00:00:00
[Music]
00:00:04
next on Unsolved
00:00:06
Mysteries a Florida Rancher is dead and
00:00:09
his girlfriend has vanished was she
00:00:12
abducted or is she the
00:00:15
killer hundreds of people see a UFO in
00:00:19
the Skies over Mexico City and there's a
00:00:22
videotape to prove
00:00:24
it a man infiltrates a nudus camp and
00:00:28
then fle when it's learned he molest Ed
00:00:30
a
00:00:32
child and a young woman's body is found
00:00:35
floating in the Chesapeake Bay she has
00:00:37
been murdered but no one knows
00:00:41
[Music]
00:00:43
why our team continues to track crimes
00:00:47
fugitives and tales of the Paranormal
00:00:50
perhaps you can help I'm Dennis finina
00:00:53
and this is Unsolved Mysteries
00:01:14
[Music]
00:01:30
Larry cin was a southern cowboy who took
00:01:32
ranching seriously he spent more than 30
00:01:36
years working with horses and cattle and
00:01:38
he was very good at it he was tough and
00:01:41
he was strong but he was no match for
00:01:44
whoever put two bullets in his
00:01:47
[Music]
00:01:49
head Lakeland
00:01:53
Florida Larry was riding a horse from
00:01:56
the time he was 2 years old he loved to
00:01:59
work
00:02:00
he left uh
00:02:02
Rodeo he was the type of person to get
00:02:05
into trouble he stayed away from trouble
00:02:07
course B came along he knows how to take
00:02:09
care of
00:02:11
himself Larry's uncle earo was the barn
00:02:14
manager for the local Livestock
00:02:19
Auction
00:02:20
are one of the employees there was
00:02:23
Melissa Joe sermons everybody called her
00:02:26
Joe Joe I'm going run these up the
00:02:28
office be back later okay I'll see you
00:02:30
later hey you ain't said nothing to him
00:02:32
about us have you ear cosin didn't know
00:02:35
that Joe and Larry were seeing each
00:02:37
other they kept their relationship a
00:02:40
secret because Joe had split up with her
00:02:42
boyfriend and Larry had just split up
00:02:44
with his
00:02:47
wife Joe's ex-boyfriend wasn't taking
00:02:50
the break up
00:02:52
well de occasions I've caught him
00:02:56
following her watching
00:02:58
her he was very upset she had left his
00:03:01
house and and he was having to live by
00:03:03
himself again he followed her
00:03:06
continuously Joe and my other daughter
00:03:08
went to the store he would follow them
00:03:10
Midnight you'd see we even caught him
00:03:12
sneaking down under the kitchen window
00:03:14
listening to their conversation one
00:03:17
night welcome ladies and gentlemen to
00:03:20
sasus arena in Florida on a Saturday
00:03:23
night in May Larry and Joe were in Dade
00:03:25
City Florida for the weekly Rodeo right
00:03:28
now
00:03:30
Larry was one of the local
00:03:32
Stars his favorite event was team
00:03:37
ring that night Joe stuck by Larry s
00:03:40
right up to the minute he and his
00:03:42
partner were called into the
00:03:47
box St out of H number one
00:03:54
right on
00:04:00
[Applause]
00:04:03
ladies and gentlemen we are looking at a
00:04:06
brand new winning
00:04:13
time Larry and his Partners split a $350
00:04:18
purse the rodeo finished late that night
00:04:22
Larry and Joe went out to breakfast
00:04:24
around 2: a.m.
00:04:28
[Music]
00:04:31
It is believed they arrived back at his
00:04:33
trailer around 4:15 Sunday
00:04:36
morning after that no one knows exactly
00:04:40
what
00:04:41
happened the next morning Joe didn't
00:04:44
show up for
00:04:45
work earo contacted the sheriff's
00:04:48
department and drove with them to
00:04:50
Larry's trailer as soon as I got to the
00:04:53
trailer a feeling came to me that I knew
00:04:56
in my mind that something bad was wrong
00:04:59
I really appreciate it
00:05:02
do Sheriff's Office is anybody
00:05:05
home when the deuty put the key in and
00:05:07
open the door the smell was
00:05:11
[Music]
00:05:14
Unreal and I knew then that Larry was
00:05:19
dead Larry cin was found nude on his
00:05:23
bedroom floor he had been shot four
00:05:25
times with a handgun twice in the
00:05:28
head his
00:05:30
had not been slept in and one of Larry's
00:05:33
guns was missing however there was no
00:05:36
sign of a struggle or robbery there was
00:05:39
also no sign of Melissa Joe's
00:05:44
sermons I felt like both of them would
00:05:46
be there when we opened the door being
00:05:49
both of them was missing at the time as
00:05:51
soon as they told ear there was only one
00:05:53
body he called us and told us at that
00:05:55
time that my daughter was missing they
00:05:56
did not know where she was
00:05:58
at some somebody watched Larry knew Joe
00:06:02
was with Larry followed Larry home and
00:06:04
was waiting for
00:06:06
him personally I feel like it was
00:06:09
somebody real jealous of his actions
00:06:11
that particular night being with job
00:06:13
spending the night with
00:06:21
job I said out didn't I tell you to stay
00:06:24
away from him I think Joe was probably
00:06:26
taking a
00:06:27
gunpoint and and at a later time
00:06:29
murdered I think Joe's
00:06:34
did the Poke County Sheriff's Department
00:06:37
launched an allout
00:06:39
investigation Joe's ex-boyfriend was the
00:06:42
Prime
00:06:43
Suspect if we want to look at Joe's
00:06:46
ex-boyfriend as a suspect in this case I
00:06:48
think that he would have probably
00:06:50
committed the offense in in a different
00:06:52
situation I don't think that it would
00:06:54
have happened in the residence I don't
00:06:55
think he would have allowed Joe and
00:06:58
Larry to spend time in residence alone
00:07:01
and also the fact that of course there's
00:07:02
no
00:07:03
struggle he was able to give us an alibi
00:07:06
for his particular time and location
00:07:08
when the actual murder occurred I don't
00:07:11
feel that the ex-boyfriend uh at this
00:07:14
time has any involvement I have no
00:07:16
evidence to indicate
00:07:18
that soon Joe herself became a suspect
00:07:23
authorities believe she may be the only
00:07:25
person who could have gotten close
00:07:27
enough to Larry to kill him without a
00:07:29
struggle but why would she kill the man
00:07:32
she
00:07:34
loved I think Larry could have made her
00:07:37
mad he can make anybody mad in a split
00:07:42
second he'll push and push and push
00:07:45
until he does make you mad they might
00:07:48
have gotten an argument and it led into
00:07:51
one thing or
00:07:53
another I mean she could have been
00:07:56
joking but it just led into to something
00:08:00
violent okay go ahead and shoot me go
00:08:08
ahead in my heart I strongly believe
00:08:12
that she is life and that she is
00:08:16
[Music]
00:08:17
hiding based on everything that I've
00:08:20
learned at this time I feel that Joe is
00:08:23
in some way involved in the murder
00:08:25
either actually committing the murder or
00:08:27
possibly a witness to it
00:08:30
uh but she has some type of involvement
00:08:32
Andor knowledge about
00:08:36
it but most people believe Joe sermans
00:08:39
was a victim I think her ex-boyfriend's
00:08:42
kidnapped
00:08:44
her I hope she I would like to think
00:08:46
she's still alive but I really don't
00:08:49
believe that they could hold her this
00:08:51
long I believe she's dead I come to
00:08:54
terms with God I just want him to help
00:08:55
me settle this case to find out who did
00:08:58
it and let them pay the penalty that
00:09:00
they should pay ever since the night
00:09:03
Larry cin was murdered there have been
00:09:05
sightings of Melissa Joe sermons at
00:09:08
truck stops in Florida Texas and Kansas
00:09:11
two witnesses had claimed they saw her
00:09:14
behind the wheel of a big rig hauling
00:09:16
livestock the authorities believe the
00:09:18
sightings are
00:09:20
reliable erlo cin does not I feel like
00:09:24
by now she'd have made a a move to come
00:09:28
back or see her mother and her sisters I
00:09:31
can't believe that
00:09:33
anybody's ever really seen her they've
00:09:36
seen people that they thought maybe was
00:09:40
her Melissa Joe sermans is 5' 10 in tall
00:09:44
blonde and blueeyed when last scene she
00:09:47
weighed 175
00:09:50
lb if you have any information about
00:09:53
this case please log on to our website
00:09:56
at unsolved.com
00:10:05
next a remarkable series of UFO
00:10:08
sightings were caught on tape in the
00:10:10
Skies over
00:10:20
Mexico when thousands of people claim to
00:10:22
have seen a UFO and hundreds provide
00:10:26
videotaped evidence even non-believers
00:10:29
have to to wonder do
00:10:31
UFOs really
00:10:35
exist Mexico City Mexico July 11th
00:10:40
1991 the last total eclipse of the sun
00:10:43
of the
00:10:45
century thousands of people stood in the
00:10:47
streets of Mexico City as it plunged
00:10:50
into total darkness in the middle of the
00:10:54
day a television executive named guo
00:10:57
aragain was videotaping ing the eclipse
00:11:00
when he noticed an unusual object
00:11:05
overhead when I saw it I said oh my God
00:11:09
this is a UFO a real UFO I mean you can
00:11:12
look at it you can look the video and be
00:11:15
absolutely convinced what are you
00:11:17
looking
00:11:19
at 8 days after the eclipse haime Maan a
00:11:23
respected television journalist
00:11:25
presented the aragen footage as part of
00:11:28
a special UFO
00:11:29
broadcast the network was flooded with
00:11:32
phone
00:11:33
calls the telephone lines blew up I mean
00:11:36
40,000 calls at the same time then the
00:11:41
the system was completely shut out we
00:11:44
received more than 15 videos and we now
00:11:47
know for sure that at least in seven of
00:11:49
them we can see the same ship that was
00:11:51
recorded by GMO
00:11:55
Arin Eric Aguilar a 19-year-old student
00:11:59
at a university in Mexico sent in one of
00:12:01
the many videos he was setting up to
00:12:04
film the eclipse from a rooftop when his
00:12:06
girlfriend spotted something unusual in
00:12:09
the
00:12:15
sky at first all we saw was a white dot
00:12:19
in the
00:12:20
sky that's all we could see in the
00:12:22
beginning later we saw that this dot was
00:12:28
shining brightly
00:12:30
it wasn't aamy it was a larger object
00:12:33
and it was giving off light it was
00:12:38
shining at about the same time 60 mi
00:12:41
from Mexico City a businessman named
00:12:44
Luis Lara videotaped a similar
00:12:50
object as I raised the camera you could
00:12:53
see something in the clouds and it was a
00:12:56
metal object
00:13:00
you can see clearly it's not a
00:13:02
star it's a UFO because it had a shadow
00:13:06
underneath if it were a star a planet
00:13:08
you would see clearly that it would be
00:13:09
completely
00:13:10
luminous but this one had a little
00:13:12
Shadow
00:13:17
underneath another video was shot by the
00:13:20
Bruton family in pbla a city 80 m east
00:13:23
of Mexico
00:13:26
City in the magnified reton video you
00:13:30
can see an odd wavelike disturbance
00:13:33
behind the pulsating disc some kind of
00:13:36
energy
00:13:38
tra hamee mosan enhanced the hour gain
00:13:42
footage and compared it to the Bruton
00:13:44
tape the objects were photographed
00:13:46
nearly 100 m apart yet they were
00:13:49
amazingly
00:13:51
similar uh the video from pbla was
00:13:55
absolutely
00:13:56
identical to the one we had seen with
00:13:59
Arin in
00:14:00
Mexico it was for the first time in
00:14:02
history never before we you had a tape
00:14:06
of two UFOs in two different places at
00:14:09
exactly the same
00:14:11
moment but there was more 2 months later
00:14:14
at a military air show in Mexico City an
00:14:18
engineer named vincenti Sanchez shot
00:14:21
this
00:14:23
[Music]
00:14:24
video I was following one of the planes
00:14:27
and I saw a shiny dot in the camera
00:14:30
it didn't fly like a plane it was
00:14:32
undulating I didn't know what it was so
00:14:35
I let the planes go off and I focused
00:14:37
more on this shiny dot in the
00:14:41
sky what I saw was a bright round object
00:14:46
about 10 m in diameter it was made of
00:14:49
silver was shining very brightly and
00:14:52
reflected the sunlight a
00:14:55
lot the object appeared undulated and
00:14:58
moved around very
00:15:01
quickly a year later the military air
00:15:04
show was staged again and again
00:15:07
Witnesses saw a mysterious flying
00:15:10
object this time the disc descended
00:15:13
rapidly and
00:15:17
vanished it is now a year later at the
00:15:20
same air show everyone anticipated
00:15:23
another sighting sure enough just as a
00:15:25
squadron of helicopters flew by the
00:15:28
familiar metallic disc
00:15:33
appeared it was traveling Against the
00:15:35
Wind so much so that had it been a
00:15:37
balloon considering the force of the
00:15:39
helicopter blades it would have crashed
00:15:42
but no it kept on its path very very
00:15:45
straight and steady till it got lost in
00:15:47
the
00:15:48
sky Optical enhancement of this video
00:15:51
seemed to reveal that the object crossed
00:15:53
in close proximity to the
00:15:57
helicopters the military hasn't make any
00:16:00
comment on that sighting or any sighting
00:16:03
and there are many more where we can
00:16:05
relate the military or military planes
00:16:09
to videos and however we haven't have
00:16:13
any kind of answer from
00:16:18
them since the eclipse there have been
00:16:21
thousands of sightings throughout Mexico
00:16:24
the witnesses range from Pilots to
00:16:26
doctors to bus drivers and even
00:16:29
school
00:16:31
children these drawings were made by a
00:16:33
class of fifth graders who say that they
00:16:36
saw the UFOs the pictures are strikingly
00:16:39
similar in detail three shining lights
00:16:42
with the brightest light in the
00:16:45
[Music]
00:16:48
center the objects were silver with red
00:16:53
one of them was coming down and the
00:16:56
other one that you could see in the sky
00:16:59
was
00:17:02
silver when they were a little lower you
00:17:04
could see the shape of the
00:17:06
objects they were like saucers with a
00:17:09
dome everything silver and though it was
00:17:12
harder to see there seemed to be a kind
00:17:15
of reddish magnetic field all around
00:17:19
it we haven't found a single reason why
00:17:22
these little kids made this story up
00:17:26
there were so many and when you talk to
00:17:29
them you can feel the honesty that they
00:17:32
transmit they're just little kids they
00:17:34
don't care about the UFO conspiracy they
00:17:37
don't care about if they are real or not
00:17:40
they saw what they
00:17:41
saw are the UFOs
00:17:45
real it's hard to deny the images
00:17:47
captured on
00:17:49
videotape a skeptic would suspect a
00:17:52
hoax but for those who have witnessed
00:17:55
the mysterious objects in the sky over
00:17:57
Mexico
00:17:59
seeing is
00:18:05
believing next viewers help capture an
00:18:08
alleged con man who infiltrated audist
00:18:12
cap and later he is known as the heart
00:18:16
attacker he's broken the hearts and bank
00:18:19
accounts of women all over the country
00:18:31
Pearson
00:18:33
Florida we recently told you the story
00:18:36
of Rusty a newcomer to the sunny Sand's
00:18:39
nudest
00:18:41
Resort as soon as he arrived Rusty
00:18:44
became a favorite among the club's
00:18:47
members he opened a video rental store
00:18:50
in a nearby town and convinced some of
00:18:52
Sunny Sand's residents to invest
00:18:54
thousands of dollars in his business
00:18:58
then just 7 months after he arrived a
00:19:02
neighbor's 11-year-old daughter accused
00:19:04
Rusty of molesting
00:19:08
her he was arrested for sexual battery
00:19:11
against a child Under 12 and the court
00:19:14
ordered him to be held without
00:19:16
[Music]
00:19:18
bail however many of Sunny Sand's
00:19:21
residents believed in Rusty they were
00:19:23
sure he was innocent they convinced the
00:19:26
judge to release him on 25 $5,000
00:19:32
bail but Rusty's supporters were wrong 2
00:19:37
Days Later Rusty disappeared taking with
00:19:40
him more than
00:19:41
$50,000 of the Investor's money as well
00:19:44
as betraying their
00:19:46
trust no matter what happens we know
00:19:48
we'll never get our money back but right
00:19:51
at this point the money is immaterial
00:19:54
right now the big thing I want Rusty CAU
00:19:56
is what he did to that child
00:19:58
police later learned that Rusty was
00:20:01
wanted in both Florida and Texas for
00:20:08
fraud
00:20:10
update within minutes of our broadcast
00:20:13
several viewers from South Carolina
00:20:15
called our teles Center to report that
00:20:17
they recognized
00:20:19
Rusty his real name is Garland Russell
00:20:23
he was living under the assumed name of
00:20:25
Ronald Edward Kent one of 38 aliens
00:20:29
he used over the
00:20:31
years Russell was arrested and
00:20:33
ultimately convicted of sexual battery
00:20:36
of a child Under
00:20:38
12 he was sentenced to life in
00:20:41
prison because his victim was so young
00:20:44
Russell is ineligible for parole he will
00:20:47
spend the rest of his days behind
00:20:51
[Music]
00:20:54
bars leis carluchi his nickname is the
00:20:58
the heart attacker he runs a con that
00:21:01
the police call a marriage
00:21:03
Swindle
00:21:04
women he
00:21:08
were Forest Hills New
00:21:12
York carluchi usually meets his prey in
00:21:15
restaurants and friendship clubs excuse
00:21:18
me hi a woman we'll call Barbara was one
00:21:22
of his many victims I was out with a
00:21:24
friend and we were sitting and having a
00:21:26
drink and he sent over drinks and and
00:21:28
got to talking and that's how we first
00:21:32
met first impression when I first saw
00:21:35
him no Style no
00:21:38
class however he was warm very friendly
00:21:42
he had a good sense of humor so I
00:21:44
started dating him I thought well he was
00:21:46
a pretty nice
00:21:49
guy the power vested in Me by the state
00:21:51
of New York I Now Pronounce You man and
00:21:54
wife you may now kiss the
00:21:56
bride after only 7 weeks Barbara married
00:22:00
Lis carluchi in a small ceremony at the
00:22:03
bar where they' first met right after
00:22:06
the wedding their relationship began to
00:22:08
fall apart he kind of jumped on me for
00:22:12
talking to other people at the wedding
00:22:15
and he got very angry about the idea
00:22:19
possibly that we even got
00:22:22
married after the honeymoon they moved
00:22:25
into an unfurnished apartment in New
00:22:27
York where they lived out of suitcase
00:22:32
cases haruchi would not let Barbara out
00:22:34
of his sight and paid for their living
00:22:37
expenses with Barbara's credit
00:22:40
card the change in his attitude and his
00:22:43
personality shocked me because there
00:22:45
were times when he was real nice and
00:22:48
then all of a sudden he'd flip and it
00:22:50
would be like black and white and then I
00:22:53
really got
00:22:55
scared I didn't have what he thought I
00:22:57
had which was money
00:22:59
the man was very physical you ever pull
00:23:03
that again I couldn't turn my head he'
00:23:06
pull my hair if I look the wrong way I'd
00:23:08
get
00:23:09
smacked of course I couldn't talk to
00:23:11
anyone at all and if we were in a
00:23:13
restaurant I couldn't even order
00:23:15
anything from the waitress because he
00:23:17
felt like I was looking at the person to
00:23:20
Signal or whatever can I get you some
00:23:22
dessert don't thank you just a check man
00:23:25
just a check carluchi maxed out
00:23:28
Barbara's credit cards emptied her bank
00:23:30
account and when they went out together
00:23:33
he used Barbara's money until it ran
00:23:37
out Barbara was
00:23:43
desperate I was just held captive let's
00:23:45
put it that way for about 6
00:23:49
months he caught me with the razor I was
00:23:51
going to cut my wrist because that was
00:23:54
the only way I could get
00:23:55
out he knew that I was going to die
00:23:58
whether I did it myself or I would just
00:24:00
waste away and die so his reaction was
00:24:03
well I may as well let you go cuz you're
00:24:05
going to
00:24:09
die 6 months after their wedding LS
00:24:12
carluchi left Barbara having spent all
00:24:14
of her money a total of
00:24:20
$20,000
00:24:23
update when this story aired viewers in
00:24:25
Nashville Tennessee identified car
00:24:29
as a local restaurant manager LS
00:24:32
Sarah the next day the police arrested
00:24:34
kuchi at his house where he was living
00:24:37
with a new wife who was
00:24:41
pregnant a viewer in Los Angeles called
00:24:43
in and told police that she too was a
00:24:46
carluchi victim while she did not marry
00:24:49
carluchi she claimed that she was
00:24:51
swindled out of
00:24:56
$65,000 LS kuchi was charged with bigamy
00:24:59
coion Larsen and fraud he was convicted
00:25:03
on all charges after serving just four
00:25:06
years in prison kuchi was released to
00:25:09
supervised
00:25:11
[Music]
00:25:16
custody next when a young woman's body
00:25:18
is found floating in the Chesapeake Bay
00:25:21
two former boyfriends emerge as Suspects
00:25:30
[Music]
00:25:35
Maryland's Chesapeake
00:25:39
Bay Coastal police on a routine Patrol
00:25:42
make a gruesome
00:25:44
find a lifeless body of a young
00:25:48
woman she was identified as a
00:25:51
33-year-old ship stward named Nancy
00:25:55
Manny Nancy Manny was one of of the few
00:25:58
female members of the seaf farers
00:26:00
international Union she had even worked
00:26:03
on giant Freighters that fed natural gas
00:26:06
all over the world but now she was dead
00:26:09
possibly murdered her two ex-boyfriends
00:26:13
became the prime
00:26:15
suspects when was the last time you saw
00:26:17
Nancy Wednesday Billy Mesmer one of
00:26:20
nany's ex-boyfriends was questioned 2
00:26:23
days after her body was found Billy had
00:26:26
written poems to nany while they were
00:26:27
like
00:26:30
now those poems aroused suspicion
00:26:32
perhaps most disturbing were these lines
00:26:36
excited breath escapes his lips while he
00:26:39
waits without the light no one will ever
00:26:42
hear your screams as the Predator begins
00:26:45
to bite the poem was signed sweet dreams
00:26:49
Billy the title
00:26:53
nightstalker I've had experts look at it
00:26:56
trying to analyze it and they have
00:26:58
concur that you know he did have an
00:27:00
obsession with Nancy at this
00:27:03
time yeah I can understand where they
00:27:05
would come up with the word uh obsessive
00:27:09
Nancy was the love of my life I wrote
00:27:12
her poetry constantly which is a very
00:27:15
obsessive thing it's full of feelings
00:27:17
and
00:27:18
emotion Billy insisted he would never
00:27:21
hurt Nancy but it was clear that she was
00:27:24
an independent woman and might not have
00:27:26
had the same passion for him that he had
00:27:29
for her she was very attractive and fun
00:27:33
she you know had a lot of boyfriends but
00:27:35
she hadn't really found a person that
00:27:37
she was destined to spend the rest of
00:27:39
her life with she left you for someone
00:27:43
else I don't understand why you keep
00:27:46
accusing me of things I really felt that
00:27:48
the investigation was going in the wrong
00:27:50
direction they were crawling all over me
00:27:52
with a microscope and I was terribly
00:27:55
frustrated that the person who actually
00:27:58
did this was going to get away she came
00:28:00
by Billy Mesmer had a plausible Alibi
00:28:03
and was cleared as a suspect but not
00:28:06
before he pointed the finger at certain
00:28:08
members of the seaf far's International
00:28:13
Union at the time of her death Nancy had
00:28:16
been studying at this Union run Training
00:28:18
Center she was dating a union member who
00:28:21
was connected to the
00:28:23
[Music]
00:28:24
school Billy says that Nancy came to his
00:28:27
apartment a few days before her
00:28:29
death hey Nancy come on in hi
00:28:34
Billy are you
00:28:36
okay Nancy had a very very bad falling
00:28:40
out with her
00:28:42
boyfriend he had told her that if she
00:28:47
didn't do things as he wanted he would
00:28:50
make things very difficult for her
00:28:51
within the union she simply said if you
00:28:56
do this then and I will expose you for
00:28:59
what you are according to Billy the
00:29:02
secret Nancy threatened to reveal may
00:29:04
have had something to do with illegal
00:29:08
drugs it's been rumored for years that
00:29:11
certain members of the Union have been
00:29:14
involved in international drug
00:29:16
trafficking not only that but possible
00:29:21
disappearances within the union and
00:29:23
within the local community I've had
00:29:25
several people come cles Rec L to me to
00:29:30
report that they suspected uh illegal
00:29:35
activity at the school was the cause of
00:29:36
Nancy's death and they fear for their
00:29:39
lives or their jobs which is why they
00:29:41
don't want to be known after her death I
00:29:45
had received some telephone calls from
00:29:48
friends of hers that were also union
00:29:50
members who had told us that they felt
00:29:53
that her death was not accidental and
00:29:56
that it was possibly linked with the
00:29:58
Union and with the
00:30:00
school for Nancy's sister Linda the
00:30:03
rumors seemed even more believable when
00:30:05
she received ny's personal effects from
00:30:08
the
00:30:10
school in going through ny's things I
00:30:12
had noticed that a lot of things were
00:30:15
missing particularly pictures of her
00:30:17
Union boyfriend and his
00:30:19
family and I know that she wouldn't have
00:30:22
thrown them away she would have kept
00:30:25
those there was more nany's camera was
00:30:29
empty and its internal mechanism jammed
00:30:32
as if someone had forcibly ripped out a
00:30:34
roll of
00:30:36
film I feel that someone had tampered
00:30:38
with her camera and so that led me to be
00:30:41
more suspicious that someone in the
00:30:42
school had obviously entered her
00:30:44
[Music]
00:30:47
room there are also suspicions about
00:30:50
nany's final work assignment before
00:30:53
entering the school nany sailed on the
00:30:55
SS myquiz a ship which employed many
00:30:58
union members she died in August in June
00:31:02
I got the slaughter from her when she
00:31:04
was working on the
00:31:06
ssmz one paragraph says things are so
00:31:10
bad on this ship that I'm getting death
00:31:13
threats
00:31:14
now and I let that go and I regret it
00:31:18
every day that I didn't demand to know
00:31:20
who exactly said that and why and what
00:31:23
exactly was said investigators also
00:31:26
thought there could be a link between
00:31:28
Nancy's death and the 1988 murder of a
00:31:31
young woman named Elizabeth Greenberg
00:31:34
like Nancy Elizabeth had the same hair
00:31:36
color same eye color and they were
00:31:39
nearly identical in height and weight
00:31:41
Elizabeth was also a ship Steward and
00:31:44
also a member of the sea farers Union
00:31:47
Elizabeth even worked the same Indonesia
00:31:49
to Japan trade route that Nancy would
00:31:52
sail a few years later both women were
00:31:55
attending the Union's training school
00:31:57
when they died and both women were found
00:32:00
floating in the Chesapeake
00:32:03
Bay it's Eerie when you look at both
00:32:07
cases the similarities in their life and
00:32:09
their Lifestyles as yet we haven't found
00:32:12
a common denominator between the two
00:32:15
boyfriends or close friends but uh
00:32:18
somewhere along the line there's got to
00:32:21
be a
00:32:22
thread I fear that Nancy's death is
00:32:24
going to be simply written off as
00:32:28
unsolved and even though everyone in the
00:32:30
county knows that something Cloak and
00:32:32
Dagger is going on they're terrified to
00:32:35
talk about it with the information that
00:32:37
has been given to me on an anonymous
00:32:39
basis over the past 2 years since
00:32:42
Nancy's death I'm beginning to fear for
00:32:44
my own
00:32:48
life
00:32:50
update more than 3 years after Nancy
00:32:53
Manny's body was found in the Chesapeake
00:32:56
Bay Police received an performance tip
00:32:58
that led to a surprising new
00:33:01
development a new suspect in the case
00:33:04
John David om Oma was serving time in
00:33:08
prison where he bragged to a fellow
00:33:10
inmate that he killed a girl featured as
00:33:13
he said on that show Unsolved Mysteries
00:33:16
when first questioned Oma said he met
00:33:18
Nancy in a bar he claimed that they had
00:33:21
gone back to the ship where she worked
00:33:23
and that she fell
00:33:24
overboard later om pleaded guilty to
00:33:27
second degree murder and was sentenced
00:33:29
to an additional 18 years he has since
00:33:33
been
00:33:35
released next a vicious sexual predator
00:33:40
abducts young girls and leaves them for
00:33:52
dead Edmonton
00:33:55
Canada mom
00:33:59
I forgot my
00:34:01
shoes three-year-old Mandy lived with
00:34:04
her aunt across the street from a
00:34:13
park Mandy spent most of her afternoons
00:34:16
at the playground which was almost like
00:34:18
her own
00:34:21
backyard come on you can do
00:34:24
it early one evening Mandy went back to
00:34:27
the park to get her shoes that she had
00:34:29
left by the
00:34:34
slide okay
00:34:38
guys she never came
00:34:54
home I got worried and I went out to go
00:34:57
and find her and when I did get out to
00:35:00
the park there was a guy out there
00:35:02
playing ball hockey with his kids he
00:35:05
said he had just seen Mandy about 5
00:35:08
minutes earlier getting her shoes but he
00:35:11
didn't see which way Mandy went Bandy
00:35:15
Audrey searched the area for two solid
00:35:17
hours finally she called the police they
00:35:20
too came up empty-handed
00:35:23
[Music]
00:35:28
19 hours later a group of horseback
00:35:30
Riders found Mandy in a remote F 9 miles
00:35:35
from her
00:35:36
home Daryl just a minute Mandy had a
00:35:39
1-in welt on her neck from being choked
00:35:42
and had been sexually assaulted she was
00:35:45
partially clothed and both of her shoes
00:35:47
were
00:35:51
missing it was quite obvious to everyone
00:35:53
involved that she would had been left
00:35:55
for dead she was injured to such an
00:35:57
extent that
00:35:58
that the perpetrator definitely wanted
00:36:00
her to be
00:36:02
dead but thankfully Mandy was still
00:36:06
alive I wouldn't have believed that she
00:36:09
could have made it out there where they
00:36:11
found her but then when when I thought
00:36:14
about it after she's she's she was a
00:36:17
miracle it was a miracle she lived
00:36:20
through
00:36:23
that apparently the as salent had driven
00:36:26
into the field and thrown Mandy from the
00:36:29
car without
00:36:31
stopping Mandy initially wasn't able to
00:36:33
tell us an awful lot she was only 3 and
00:36:36
1/2 years old however as time progresses
00:36:39
she is giving us more and more
00:36:41
information she is actually a very
00:36:43
bright young girl uh in my opinion uh if
00:36:47
she sees the person or person's
00:36:49
responsible she will be able to identify
00:36:52
them I think we have something over here
00:36:54
within 5 miles of the spot where Mandy
00:36:56
was found police discovered tattered
00:36:59
pieces of her skirt and one of her
00:37:02
sneakers they believed the as salent
00:37:05
tossed them out right after he dumped
00:37:07
Mandy by the side of the
00:37:10
road command post you send a member of
00:37:13
ID end up location the shoe was minus
00:37:15
the laces uh we're still missing at this
00:37:17
time her left shoe the person
00:37:20
responsible may be saving these items as
00:37:23
a bit of a trophy and we're hopeful as
00:37:26
well that perhaps some somebody may have
00:37:28
seen the shoe or perhaps a part of that
00:37:30
jean skirt in a person's
00:37:33
vehicle 4 months after the assault a
00:37:36
local newspaper reported that the police
00:37:38
had uncovered no further
00:37:39
[Music]
00:37:43
Clues don't fa you cheated 2 Days Later
00:37:46
another
00:37:48
abduction a 6-year-old girl and her
00:37:51
5-year-old friend were playing outside
00:37:53
their apartment building Just 4 miles
00:37:55
from where Mandy lived
00:38:00
[Music]
00:38:06
let 99
00:38:17
100 an 11-year-old boy saw a man getting
00:38:21
into a blue van with a little girl
00:38:28
it was 6-year-old coren gustaffson
00:38:31
nicknamed Punky the police immediately
00:38:35
set up a command post and launched a
00:38:37
widespread
00:38:39
search we we was just feeling sick and
00:38:42
worried what could happened to her and
00:38:45
what could you be doing to
00:38:50
her if we ever find
00:38:54
her 2 days passed then then at a
00:38:58
truckyard a driver saw what he thought
00:39:00
was a ragd
00:39:03
doll it was
00:39:11
Punky puny had been raped smothered but
00:39:15
unlike Mandy's case Clues had been left
00:39:18
at the
00:39:18
[Music]
00:39:20
scene we were able to obtain Footprints
00:39:24
and tire prints the tire prints
00:39:26
indicated that the suspect drove a
00:39:28
midsize North American front-wheel drive
00:39:30
vehicle with Goodyear invictor GLS on
00:39:33
the back with approximately 20% wear and
00:39:36
ball tires on the
00:39:41
front the footprints indicated that he
00:39:44
wore a miter type baseball cleat size 5
00:39:48
1/2 to 7 this is a patented tread design
00:39:51
manufactured in Canada we were able to
00:39:54
determine that Karine was in fact killed
00:39:56
at another location and dumped in the
00:39:58
truckyard much the same as what happened
00:40:00
to Mandy being dumped in the
00:40:03
field the distance the victims were
00:40:05
transported after
00:40:07
abduction uh what was done to the
00:40:10
victims by the
00:40:11
offender uh all facts of the case uh
00:40:15
lead me to believe that both crimes were
00:40:18
committed by the same
00:40:21
individual Ron McCay is Canada's
00:40:24
foremost criminal profiler he has
00:40:26
developed a detailed personality
00:40:29
portrait of the
00:40:31
asent in my opinion this offender is uh
00:40:34
in his lens to early 20s he probably
00:40:37
doesn't have a
00:40:38
girlfriend somewhat of a
00:40:40
loner he's a Fantasy motivated
00:40:44
individual uh and his fantasy is only
00:40:47
satisfied
00:40:48
temporarily so therefore uh after he
00:40:52
regains some confidence uh and if the
00:40:55
fantasy continues untreated
00:40:57
uh then the probability of him re
00:40:59
offending in a similar fashion is a very
00:41:02
real
00:41:04
probability someone out there knows this
00:41:07
guy our bad guy doesn't have to look
00:41:11
like any kind of a monster he could just
00:41:13
look like your boy next
00:41:15
door I know it would give our family a
00:41:18
sense of relief knowing that he's he's
00:41:20
Behind Bars and they're not somebody
00:41:23
else isn't going to have to go through
00:41:24
it what we're going through and some
00:41:26
Port of little kid isn't going to have
00:41:28
to suffer like like Corine must have and
00:41:32
as long as he's out on the streets every
00:41:34
little kid is in
00:41:40
Jeopardy
00:41:42
update 10 years after the murder of
00:41:45
Corine Punky
00:41:46
gustavson Clifford slay was identified
00:41:50
as her killer slay was already serving
00:41:52
time in a Canadian prison for an
00:41:54
unrelated sexual assault
00:41:57
DNA evidence led to his conviction in
00:42:00
the Guston case slay was sentenced to
00:42:03
life in prison for the murder he will be
00:42:05
eligible for parole in the year 2030
00:42:10
[Music]
00:42:28
[Music]
00:42:43
[Music]
