Search Captions & Ask AI

Right Wing Media Charts a New Course for Power and Influence | Pivot

November 12, 2024 / 09:03

This episode discusses the impact of right-wing media, including podcasts and social media, on political success, particularly regarding Donald Trump. Guests Mark Cuban and others analyze the effectiveness of various media platforms in shaping public opinion and influencing elections.

The conversation highlights how right-wing figures like Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan have created a powerful media ecosystem, while Democrats have been slower to adapt. Cuban emphasizes the importance of understanding social media algorithms to reach younger audiences.

They also compare the audience demographics of traditional media outlets like MSNBC with those of popular podcasts, noting the significant difference in engagement and age of listeners. The discussion touches on the challenges faced by legacy media in retaining relevance.

Additionally, the episode critiques the notion that social media users are the new media, arguing that while they can amplify messages, they do not replace traditional journalism.

Overall, the episode reflects on the evolving landscape of media and its implications for future elections, with a focus on the growing influence of podcasts.

TL;DR

Right-wing media's rise, podcast influence, and election dynamics are discussed with Mark Cuban and others.

Video

00:00:00
we've noted that Trump harness podcasts
00:00:01
YouTube and nontraditional media along
00:00:03
with the Bro vote to great success we've
00:00:05
talked about this for a long time but
00:00:07
now there's tons of pieces about there
00:00:09
one piece the new Republic argued that
00:00:10
the year it became obvious that
00:00:12
right-wing media had more power than
00:00:13
mainstream media another thing we've
00:00:15
talked about for a long time and that it
00:00:17
was Fox News Sinclair X Joe Rogan and
00:00:19
others who quote fed their audience's
00:00:21
diet of slanted and distorted
00:00:22
information made it possible for Trump
00:00:24
to win Elon Musk has been telling his
00:00:26
followers you are the media now which
00:00:28
we've heard before um again I think it's
00:00:31
getting a little overdone in my opinion
00:00:33
but it's true and it's also getting
00:00:35
overdone um that said Democrats were
00:00:37
slow to move away from Legacy Media
00:00:39
slower as they always have been because
00:00:41
they've owned Legacy Media for a long
00:00:42
time compared to the right which has
00:00:44
been dabbling in radio and everything
00:00:45
else for much because they were they
00:00:48
were kept out of the mainstream media
00:00:49
except for Fox um Mark Cuban posted a
00:00:52
podcast that he thought this this
00:00:54
explanation is only partially relevant
00:00:56
for Trump's Victory I thought this was a
00:00:57
smart observation as always he thinks
00:00:59
it's about social media Echo Chambers he
00:01:01
says that he told Harris to focus on
00:01:03
reverse engineering the algorithms for
00:01:05
each demo but the campaign was stuck in
00:01:08
2020 um it's a complex story I think
00:01:11
it's partially and I thought Mark had a
00:01:13
really good point that by just saying
00:01:16
Dems you need your own Joe Rogan it's
00:01:17
not the answer well I called you the
00:01:19
other night I'm obsessed with data and
00:01:22
also the affirmation of strangers and
00:01:24
I'm always looking at the rankings of
00:01:25
our podcast and if you type in what's
00:01:27
the most INF influential category in
00:01:29
podcast broasting as it relates to an
00:01:31
election I think it would not be
00:01:32
politics I think it would be news
00:01:33
commentary because that's where people
00:01:35
tune in to hear about the state of the
00:01:37
world and the top of the 10 top news
00:01:42
commentary podcasts which by the way I
00:01:44
would bet get dramatically more
00:01:46
listenership not only dramatically more
00:01:48
listenership but younger more valuable
00:01:52
uh consumers in terms of uh politicians
00:01:55
or people running for office or
00:01:56
advertisers sure they're much more
00:01:58
powerful than the top 10 who's in there
00:02:00
who's in that list I was I was I was
00:02:02
headed that way so eight of the 10 eight
00:02:05
of the 10 yeah are hard red Tucker
00:02:08
Carlson Megan Kelly Charlie Kirk Dan
00:02:12
Bonino I mean what a party I forget that
00:02:15
other guy a little bit older I forget
00:02:16
his name it was say John B Mark Le Mark
00:02:19
Lev the two blue the two lone islands of
00:02:22
blue are at number six is Pivot and at
00:02:25
number 10 is on with Caris swisser you
00:02:27
are literally the only islands the only
00:02:30
Sav passage of blue in the top 10 News
00:02:32
commentary of the most popular or most
00:02:35
influential medium I believe now in
00:02:37
politics don't don't crooked Medias get
00:02:39
in there don't crooked media it's
00:02:41
interesting they're C they're they're
00:02:43
they're categorized under politics and
00:02:45
they're number one or number two if they
00:02:47
were categorized under news commentary I
00:02:49
think they'd be number one or two I
00:02:50
think that's a fair point but for
00:02:52
whatever reason Apple doesn't categorize
00:02:53
him his news commentary you know what's
00:02:55
interesting what I was just thinking one
00:02:57
of the things the right-wing does do
00:02:59
better and I do think I don't know if
00:03:00
they're more powerful is they join
00:03:02
together a lot they go on each other's
00:03:03
shows they cross-promote they're always
00:03:05
you know how Rogan's doing the comics
00:03:07
that guy Tony Hinchcliffe is from a is a
00:03:10
Rogan acolyte down in Austin they all
00:03:12
work with each other as a group and and
00:03:15
I think one of the things we should do
00:03:16
is like hang with the Crooked we should
00:03:19
do something where we're always cross
00:03:20
promoting among our group they exist but
00:03:22
they're little Islands I'm up for
00:03:24
shoplifting any old idea those sons of
00:03:27
have um and so I think we should
00:03:30
start doing that but I think it's a
00:03:31
little more complex than let's make a
00:03:33
Joe Rogan you know I think it's just
00:03:35
that seems redu the me the Legacy Media
00:03:37
is just woken up to something we've
00:03:38
known all along is that we have a lot of
00:03:40
influence in the podcast space much more
00:03:43
so than they realize like your little
00:03:45
pod I always get your little podcast I'm
00:03:46
like I think we probably sold more books
00:03:48
than a Washington Post review in by far
00:03:51
or whatever it happens to be look at
00:03:54
look at okay MSNBC a million people
00:03:58
average age 70
00:04:00
uh Rogan gets 15 million downloads
00:04:03
average age
00:04:05
34 I mean where where would you rather
00:04:08
be and if you really but the reality is
00:04:10
a lot of these people okay so what do
00:04:12
Megan Kelly Tucker
00:04:14
Carlson um Glenn
00:04:17
Beck uh Bill O'Reilly I'm I'm reading
00:04:21
people in the top 15 here what are these
00:04:23
people all have in common they were
00:04:24
fired by traditional media this is
00:04:27
essentially this is this looks like the
00:04:30
outplacement office at McKenzie it's all
00:04:32
these formerly important people looking
00:04:33
for a new job and quite frankly you want
00:04:35
to talk about revenge of the formerly
00:04:37
fired or the fired from broadcast they
00:04:40
have found a home in podcasting and I
00:04:44
there's just no getting around it though
00:04:46
you have to acknowledge that traditional
00:04:48
media was missing a big these people
00:04:51
have tapped into the same strategy that
00:04:53
rer Mar tapped into 30 years ago I I
00:04:55
agree I do think the media didn't fall
00:04:57
down the job of reporting on it I just
00:04:59
don't think they're getting to people I
00:05:01
think that that's a that like
00:05:02
they ignored it I'm like no there was a
00:05:03
lot of reporting it just was how they're
00:05:05
getting to people that said the reason I
00:05:07
say it's overreach is because I think
00:05:09
they're you're the media now you're not
00:05:10
the media now followers you're just not
00:05:13
you're not going to all you can be noisy
00:05:16
you know and stuff like that but one of
00:05:17
the things that I was interesting you
00:05:20
know that constant jazz hands I don't
00:05:23
know wanker chamat poopaa who you know
00:05:26
of um Mr Spa he wrote I canceled my New
00:05:29
York Times and Washington Post
00:05:30
subscriptions just reallocated the money
00:05:32
to subscribe and follow the following
00:05:34
folks on X whom I believe help get me
00:05:37
accurate news including Michael
00:05:39
shellenberger kanoka the great the chief
00:05:41
nerd I will per I periodically publish
00:05:44
accounts I subscribe to on X and you may
00:05:46
want to consider supporting them as well
00:05:47
worst case consider following them this
00:05:50
guy I once saw him buy I was noting
00:05:53
several bottles of $10,000 wine one
00:05:55
night and now he's on a budget I mean
00:05:57
Ser yeah but I don't this we're going to
00:05:59
hear I just think what he's saying is is
00:06:01
that is that he's getting he he feels
00:06:04
like he's getting better information and
00:06:05
better follows on Twitter than he has in
00:06:07
traditional broadcast media this look
00:06:11
this is going to there's going to be a
00:06:12
lot of Naval gazing the Democratic party
00:06:14
there's going to be more Naval gazing
00:06:15
across traditional media because yes but
00:06:18
the Washington Post in the New York
00:06:20
Times does great reporting Susan Craig
00:06:22
they I'm not arguing that like to do
00:06:23
this stuff I hate but go ahead well
00:06:26
there's just no getting the most
00:06:28
influential medium in this election and
00:06:31
I think the most influential election
00:06:32
over the next or the most influential
00:06:34
medium over the next four years podcast
00:06:37
I I'm predicting next year I'm doing my
00:06:38
predictions deck I think podcast Revenue
00:06:40
next year is going to grow faster than
00:06:41
meta alphabet or Amazon and all of a
00:06:46
sudden advertisers awak up to the fact
00:06:48
that they go where attention is
00:06:49
attention money always falls attention
00:06:51
and also the Nitro meets glycerin here
00:06:54
is that advertisers of 34y old male is
00:06:57
three times as valuable if not five
00:06:59
times more valuable than a
00:07:00
seven-year-old woman because the
00:07:02
seven-year-old woman is smart she's not
00:07:04
she's not in her mating years she's not
00:07:06
spending money on stupid high margin
00:07:07
coffee and
00:07:09
SUVs and yeah I mean and you know Adidas
00:07:14
and Nike she's not doing that
00:07:16
anymore she's like okay I'm I'm only
00:07:18
going to buy money I'm only going to
00:07:19
spend money on smart things right that
00:07:21
are low margin and other than
00:07:23
pharmaceutical ads I mean basically
00:07:25
watching cable TV right now these shows
00:07:27
is a is essentially lesson in how much
00:07:30
it sucks to get old oh you have you're
00:07:32
constipated and you have restless legs
00:07:34
anyways this this medium I'm getting a
00:07:37
series of young advertising people I I
00:07:39
can't mention all of them yet because
00:07:40
they aren't up yet but suddenly I mean
00:07:43
we're sold out we're I would love to do
00:07:44
a dance how great we're doing but I
00:07:46
still just hate that they they feel the
00:07:48
need to say that New York Times and
00:07:50
Washington Post suck and they're
00:07:51
terrible they're not uh they're the best
00:07:53
of a Dying Breed and and they do a good
00:07:56
job there will always be room for them I
00:07:59
think they well the problem is you know
00:08:01
Meredith levian is doing an amazing job
00:08:04
and has figured out the business model
00:08:05
there Washington Post is important but
00:08:07
it's a shitty business okay that's two I
00:08:10
just named 10 podcasts that are making a
00:08:12
bunch of money the economics are so much
00:08:14
different well I think CNN's still
00:08:16
making money you want to well I thought
00:08:18
talk about newspapers CNN makes CNN
00:08:20
makes a lot of Mone and not only that I
00:08:23
hate to say this CNN the New York Times
00:08:25
Washington Post and pivot quite frankly
00:08:28
from just a pure economic standpoint the
00:08:30
election worked out really well for us
00:08:33
our numbers I would bet the
00:08:36
subscriptions contrarian media does
00:08:38
better when the other guy gal is in the
00:08:41
audience there's just no getting around
00:08:42
it podcasts and the medium are AM radio
00:08:46
and have definitely tapped into what a
00:08:48
lot of people are clearly was an
00:08:49
underserved market and that is people
00:08:51
who wanted to serve a longer Nuance
00:08:53
conversation with a conservative bent on
00:08:55
it and the numbers are just clear

Episode Highlights

  • The Rise of Right-Wing Media
    Right-wing media, including podcasts, have gained significant influence over mainstream narratives.
    “Right-wing media had more power than mainstream media.”
    @ 00m 12s
    November 12, 2024
  • Mark Cuban's Insight
    Mark Cuban suggests social media echo chambers played a role in Trump's victory.
    “It's about social media Echo Chambers.”
    @ 00m 54s
    November 12, 2024
  • Podcasting's Growing Influence
    Predictions indicate podcast revenue will surpass major tech companies as advertisers shift focus.
    “Podcast Revenue next year is going to grow faster than meta, alphabet or Amazon.”
    @ 06m 40s
    November 12, 2024

Episode Quotes

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown

Related Episodes