Search Captions & Ask AI

Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 13

March 09, 2017 / 42:53

This episode of Unsolved Mysteries covers three intriguing stories: a man suffering from amnesia, the murder of Tony Lombardi, and an 8-year-old girl who claims to see dead people.

The first story follows a young man named Paul Beal, who was found dehydrated and disoriented in the Nevada desert. Diagnosed with total amnesia, he struggles to reclaim his identity for over eight months. After airing his story, his father from Boise, Idaho, contacts the show, leading to an emotional reunion. However, complications arise when Paul is arrested for grand larceny, raising questions about whether he faked his amnesia.

Next, the episode details the tragic case of Tony Lombardi, a 22-year-old found shot in his bedroom in Westerville, Ohio. While police initially rule his death a suicide, his family believes it was murder, citing evidence of a struggle and prior death threats. The investigation reveals conflicting theories, leaving the case unresolved.

Finally, the episode introduces Heidi Wyrick, an 8-year-old girl from Ellersly, Georgia, who claims to communicate with spirits. Heidi's encounters with friendly and violent spirits raise questions about her abilities. A psychologist investigates her experiences, leading to a deeper understanding of her perceived gift.

Throughout the episode, updates on previously solved cases are also provided, showcasing the impact of viewer involvement in solving mysteries.

TL;DR

This episode features amnesia, a murder mystery, and a girl who sees dead people.

Episode

42:53
00:00:00
[Music]
00:00:04
next on Unsolved
00:00:07
Mysteries in the Nevada desert a young
00:00:09
man is found dazed and confused he says
00:00:12
he's suffering from Amnesia the police
00:00:15
say he's
00:00:17
faking on a remote Riverbank three
00:00:19
fishermen stumble upon the body of a
00:00:22
woman wrapped in a bed sheet from her
00:00:24
own home some say her ex-husband knows
00:00:28
more than he's saying
00:00:31
meet Jean
00:00:33
Bo she draws police composits with
00:00:36
uncanny accuracy watch as she tries to
00:00:39
help solve a baffling
00:00:42
murder and this 8-year-old girl has an
00:00:45
amazing talent she sees dead
00:00:50
people join me for these intriguing
00:00:53
stories plus updates on cases solved by
00:00:56
you I'm Dennis finina and this is
00:00:59
unsolved Mysteries
00:01:12
[Music]
00:01:20
[Music]
00:01:37
Las Vegas
00:01:38
Nevada do you have any pain anywhere can
00:01:42
you wiggle your toes for me a young man
00:01:44
is rushed to a local hospital he has
00:01:47
been found in the desert outside of Las
00:01:49
Vegas dehydrated and disoriented can you
00:01:53
tell me your name he has no
00:01:55
identification and is suffering from
00:01:57
Total Amnesia the Hospital staff names
00:02:01
him Tyler you cannot have anything right
00:02:04
authorities can't find a missing
00:02:06
person's report matching Tyler's
00:02:07
description and his fingerprints are not
00:02:10
in any local or National Police
00:02:13
databases for more than 8 months Tyler
00:02:16
remains a man without a past and
00:02:18
possibly without a
00:02:21
future I can't go to work because I'm
00:02:23
not eligible for a social security
00:02:25
number I can't drive a car because I
00:02:27
don't have a Social Security number or a
00:02:29
date of birth
00:02:30
and I'm starting to feel more frustrated
00:02:34
as the days go by because I really feel
00:02:36
this needs to come to an end I do need
00:02:38
to find out who I
00:02:41
am Tyler was diagnosed as a genuine
00:02:45
victim of
00:02:46
Amnesia but when his identity was
00:02:49
discovered after we aired his story some
00:02:51
began to believe that he may not have
00:02:53
lost his memory at all Tyler sat down
00:02:57
with friends to watch Unsolved Mysteries
00:02:59
that evening our cameras were also on
00:03:02
hand but even before his story aired in
00:03:05
Las
00:03:06
Vegas a man from Boise idah contacted us
00:03:10
and said that he was Tyler's
00:03:13
father we called Tyler immediately but
00:03:16
everything that that I was looking to
00:03:18
cross referenced and we have located
00:03:20
your family for you you have yes our sta
00:03:23
told Tyler that his real name is Arthur
00:03:26
Paul Beal but he goes by Paul was 23
00:03:30
years old and before he was stricken
00:03:32
with amnesia he lived in Boise Idaho a
00:03:36
few minutes later Paul Beal called the
00:03:38
mother and stepfather he could not
00:03:41
remember hello may I speak with Mrs Beal
00:03:45
this is Mrs be this is your
00:03:49
son how are
00:03:51
you you sound
00:03:54
great I don't remember you I'll help you
00:03:58
Paul the emotional call lasted nearly 20
00:04:02
minutes you be strong okay and I'll talk
00:04:05
to you real soon okay okay honey bye bye
00:04:11
a short time later Paul's story took an
00:04:14
unexpected
00:04:19
turn I don't know you don't know you
00:04:22
don't know what your dat of birth is I
00:04:23
don't I have the Las Vegas police showed
00:04:26
up at Paul's apartment and arrested him
00:04:28
for Grand Larson it turns out that Paul
00:04:32
Beal was wanted by Boise Police for
00:04:34
stealing a shipment of frozen
00:04:37
food how long have you had Amnesia 9
00:04:41
months how do you remember that if you
00:04:43
got
00:04:45
amnesia hi I've come to get my son the
00:04:49
next night our cameras witnessed the
00:04:51
emotional reunion between Paul and his
00:04:56
mother Paul
00:05:01
ly Beal had arrived to post Paul's bail
00:05:04
but he still did not recognize I don't
00:05:08
remember you you will it's strange being
00:05:11
with Paul and his not remembering
00:05:13
anything about me not knowing who I am I
00:05:16
want to push everything into his head
00:05:18
make him remember everything I want to
00:05:20
make sure I can do things to help him
00:05:23
I'm scared I don't want to do something
00:05:25
to push it back farther I want to I just
00:05:27
want him to know I love him we all love
00:05:29
him and I'm relieved that he's safe he's
00:05:32
alive I wored so much the reunion was
00:05:35
complicated not only by Paul's Amnesia
00:05:39
but by the criminal charges against them
00:05:42
in Boise Paul had worked as a Salesman
00:05:44
for a food supply company he went to Las
00:05:47
Vegas to sell a shipment of frozen food
00:05:50
but he never returned 3 weeks later Paul
00:05:54
showed up with the empty truck in
00:05:56
Boulder City Nevada where he was
00:05:58
questioned but not arrested by local
00:06:01
police I told him when he left I
00:06:04
says boys he going to get a warrant for
00:06:06
you you know they're going to do it it's
00:06:08
going to be Gran larsy felony so it's
00:06:10
just a matter of time you better get up
00:06:12
there go back up there he said yeah I'm
00:06:14
going back now I'm going right back up
00:06:16
there and take care of the situation
00:06:17
it'll be
00:06:19
fine it was 3 days after he was
00:06:22
questioned that Paul was found wandering
00:06:25
in the desert detective Bowman wondered
00:06:28
if Paul was faking is amnesia amnesia is
00:06:32
easy I don't know who are you I don't
00:06:34
know where you from I don't know do you
00:06:37
know anything I don't know it's it's
00:06:39
easy and a guy like him he's
00:06:42
convincing is this the four of you
00:06:45
uh-huh this still isn't my son in the
00:06:48
fact that this isn't how he would react
00:06:49
to me we were very
00:06:51
close I could tell by his eyes when I
00:06:54
first saw him tonight that he really
00:06:56
didn't recognize me he was he wanted to
00:07:00
I could see it in his face he wanted to
00:07:03
do you know your name can you squeeze my
00:07:06
hand this is probably the most
00:07:08
horrifying nightmare that anybody could
00:07:10
go through losing an identity losing
00:07:12
every ounce and fiber of a person's life
00:07:16
having it pulled away then 9 months
00:07:19
later have it given back to you but you
00:07:22
still don't have
00:07:24
it and I give anything in the world to
00:07:28
remember right now
00:07:31
Paul Beal returned to Boise Idaho where
00:07:34
he served 90 days for petty theft his
00:07:37
case is now closed but one mystery
00:07:40
remains did Paul Beal fake his Amnesia
00:07:44
to avoid criminal prosecution or is he
00:07:47
truly a man without a
00:07:52
past next a 22-year-old is found shot to
00:07:57
death in his own bedroom
00:08:09
Westerville
00:08:11
Ohio an ordinary townhouse on an
00:08:14
ordinary Street home to a typical
00:08:17
middleclass family the
00:08:20
lombardis Cheryl Lombardi comes home at
00:08:23
around midnight she assumes that her
00:08:26
22-year-old son Tony will be home
00:08:28
shortly
00:08:29
[Music]
00:08:32
at around 12:45 a.m. she hears a door
00:08:35
closing and some
00:08:38
footsteps
00:08:40
son assuming it's Tony she goes to his
00:08:43
room to say good
00:08:48
night what she discovers is
00:08:52
horrifying a single gunshot wound to the
00:08:55
head has killed Tony
00:08:58
Lombardi that morning Cheryl Lombard's
00:09:00
home was swarmed by detectives as they
00:09:03
searched Tony's room for Clues they
00:09:05
began to realize that the evidence
00:09:07
pointed toward two conflicting theories
00:09:10
they were two different scenarios that
00:09:13
would pit Tony's family against the
00:09:17
police 30 minutes after Cheryl's
00:09:19
gruesome Discovery detectives were
00:09:21
investigating the scene they found a 38
00:09:24
caliber semi-automatic pistol on the
00:09:26
floor and on the bed a single spent 38
00:09:30
caliber shell in Tony's pocket they
00:09:34
found a citation he had received for
00:09:36
drunk driving 2 days earlier
00:09:39
DUI okay thanks for the info Tony faced
00:09:43
stiff fines and the suspension of his
00:09:46
driver's license the investigators
00:09:48
viewed him as someone who might have
00:09:50
been despondent over the DUI right now
00:09:54
everything that we have and the evidence
00:09:56
that we have indicates Tony's death was
00:10:01
suicide but Tony's Family believes that
00:10:03
there is evidence that his death was a
00:10:06
coldblooded
00:10:07
murder I believe that there was a
00:10:10
struggle he had an inch and a half gash
00:10:13
over his left eye he had a broken jaw he
00:10:16
had bruises uh the fact that he was
00:10:19
found nude he would never let anyone see
00:10:21
him nude those are all things that I
00:10:24
think should have been looked
00:10:26
into cherl believes Tony's killer was
00:10:29
still in the house when she got home
00:10:32
that night going up and down the steps
00:10:35
you you can see my son's room and the
00:10:38
door was closed and there was no light
00:10:41
on going up and down the steps as many
00:10:45
times as I did there is no way I could
00:10:48
have missed the light being
00:10:50
on Cheryl assumed Tony's light was
00:10:52
turned off because he wasn't
00:10:56
home 45 minutes later she heard the door
00:11:02
closing the light in Tony's room was now
00:11:05
on Cheryl again assumed that he had
00:11:09
finally come
00:11:10
home who could have turned on the
00:11:13
light well Cheryl believes it was the
00:11:16
killer who became trapped in Tony's room
00:11:19
when she arrived home I believe that I
00:11:22
surprised him and then when I went to my
00:11:24
bedroom to get ready for bed they
00:11:26
thought that was a good opportunity for
00:11:28
them to leave and I believe that's what
00:11:30
I heard was someone
00:11:33
leaving Tony's parents say there is even
00:11:36
more evidence that points to murder in
00:11:39
the week before he died Tony was the
00:11:42
target of two different death threats
00:11:44
cut me off like that again and I'll kill
00:11:46
you you hear me I hear you where do you
00:11:49
live I said where do you live right here
00:11:52
good I got it a neighbor saw the driver
00:11:55
of a white pickup truck screaming at
00:11:57
Tony
00:11:59
Tony's father overheard the second death
00:12:02
threat just a few days
00:12:04
later I was checking my messages and I
00:12:07
heard this threat on our voicemail of a
00:12:10
a gentleman a young person telling Tony
00:12:13
that he had a gun and was going to use
00:12:14
it if Tony didn't stay away from his
00:12:16
girlfriend and at that point I brought
00:12:18
that up to Tony and he said not to worry
00:12:20
about it I told Tony that I talk to the
00:12:23
guy and see what the deal was on it and
00:12:25
he said to me that uh his problem was
00:12:28
not with me it was with Tony and that he
00:12:31
would take care of it Tony would get
00:12:32
what was coming to him lead detective on
00:12:35
the case contacted as many people as he
00:12:37
could either by phone or in person and
00:12:40
attempted to question him about what
00:12:42
they had said or somebody said they had
00:12:44
said and we found no evidence that Tony
00:12:46
was under any immediate death threats
00:12:50
the police never contacted me about uh
00:12:52
Tony's death at all um I never heard
00:12:56
from
00:12:56
anybody about anything
00:12:59
the position of Tony's body and the
00:13:02
angle of the Fatal bullet were also
00:13:05
controversial her son's head was on a
00:13:08
couple of pillows and the detectives
00:13:11
removed that spent Bullet From the
00:13:13
headboard examined the angle and had
00:13:16
every indication that the trajectory of
00:13:18
that bullet was correct this was our
00:13:20
son's bed that he was actually killed in
00:13:23
and The Bullet Hole in the headboard is
00:13:25
behind the pillows and as you can see
00:13:28
it's down there and if you take a pencil
00:13:30
and you
00:13:31
insert that
00:13:33
into the headboard you can see that the
00:13:38
Bullet Hole is much lower than the way I
00:13:40
found our
00:13:42
son The Bullet Hole does not make sense
00:13:44
to me unless there was some pressure on
00:13:47
top of Tony holding him down the bullet
00:13:50
would have been much higher in the
00:13:53
headboard finally Cheryl says the county
00:13:56
Corner found bruises on t 's chest
00:14:00
directly under his clenched hands to
00:14:02
Cheryl that is proof that her son was
00:14:05
forcibly held down by an as salent Tony
00:14:09
Lombard's death remains clouded by
00:14:12
controversy the police the county Corner
00:14:15
the sheriff's department and the
00:14:16
district attorney all agree Tony's death
00:14:20
was a
00:14:21
suicide the Westerville police sure have
00:14:24
sympathy for the family they've suffered
00:14:26
a lot of
00:14:27
trauma but we have to dealing the facts
00:14:29
and the facts of this investigation
00:14:31
reveal what happened was a
00:14:34
suicide until they open our son's case
00:14:38
back up and change the cause of his
00:14:40
death I will not stop until the last
00:14:43
breath is taken from my body and if I do
00:14:46
not exceed to be able to get that done
00:14:49
till the day I die then I'll fight him
00:14:52
from
00:14:53
eternity if you have any information
00:14:55
about Tony Lombard's death please log on
00:14:58
to to our website at unsolved.com
00:15:05
coming up an 8-year-old girl claims to
00:15:09
see and talk to dead people is it her
00:15:13
imagination or does she really have a
00:15:24
gift do you remember the movie the six
00:15:27
sense and that little boy who said that
00:15:29
he could see dead people well it turns
00:15:31
out that there is a child who can do
00:15:34
just that her name is Heidi wrick and
00:15:37
she's just 8 years old and apparently
00:15:39
can communicate with people who have
00:15:41
died many many years ago hello honey hi
00:15:47
what's your name Heidi that's a pretty
00:15:50
name Heidi Heidi's family had just moved
00:15:53
to ellersly Georgia a small southern
00:15:56
town one fall day according to heidy a
00:15:59
man named KH appeared at the front door
00:16:03
and go play on that swing he had white
00:16:06
hair and he had a t-shirt on with blood
00:16:10
all over it and he had a bandage on his
00:16:14
hand with blood on
00:16:16
it Mama what hi can I go play outside
00:16:20
with the man is it Uncle Mark no what
00:16:23
man is it he has gray hair and he has BL
00:16:26
on his shirt come here are you
00:16:29
sure yeah I thought someone was trying
00:16:32
to kidnap her I don't see anyone so I
00:16:35
brought hiid in and I locked all the
00:16:36
doors and I got the butcher knife out of
00:16:38
the K you know out of the drawer and I I
00:16:41
called my husband home I said Andy you
00:16:43
have got to come home we got out and we
00:16:45
walked all up and down the street you
00:16:46
know trying to find somebody to fit that
00:16:49
description but we never you know found
00:16:52
nobody hi there Heidi hi that is your
00:16:56
name isn't it yes I'm Mr
00:16:59
shortly after her visit from Khan Heidi
00:17:02
told her mother about meeting a man she
00:17:04
called Mr gardy would you like to go
00:17:08
over and swing with me for a few minutes
00:17:12
okay I thought that Khan and Gordy was
00:17:15
the same person so I thought his name
00:17:16
was KH Gordy and that's when I started
00:17:20
asking everybody do they have they ever
00:17:21
heard of a name KH Gordy Lisa happened
00:17:24
to mention Khan and Mr Gordy to her
00:17:27
sister who had just bought the house
00:17:29
next door her sister was shocked just
00:17:33
read that right there what right here
00:17:36
look James S Gordy when I see Mr Gordy's
00:17:40
name on the deed I was terrified I
00:17:43
really was because I knew that the the
00:17:46
previous owners had was there you know
00:17:49
years and years and years back so I knew
00:17:52
that Mr Gordy I knew he had to have been
00:17:55
dead I knew Mr Gordy when I was a small
00:17:58
child
00:17:59
and um Mr Gard owned a real estate
00:18:01
company in
00:18:02
Columbus and for many many years he was
00:18:06
um Sunday School Superintendent at our
00:18:08
church up here Ells Methodist Church
00:18:11
Katherine ledford's family had owned the
00:18:13
house that Lisa's sister now lived in
00:18:16
Katherine said that James gardy was the
00:18:19
executive of her mother's will he died
00:18:22
in
00:18:24
1974 Let's see we got Catherine didn't
00:18:27
have any pictures of Mr gardy but she
00:18:29
said Heidi's description of him was dead
00:18:31
on accurate he had gray hair and always
00:18:35
wore a suit and tie and those shiny
00:18:37
black
00:18:38
shoes Catherine decided to show Heidi
00:18:41
some of her other family
00:18:43
photos I was looking through the
00:18:45
pictures and I never saw n of them
00:18:48
people and when I got to the bottom
00:18:51
there's this little bitty
00:18:54
picture that's a guy with the bandage on
00:18:57
his arm and the blood on his
00:19:00
shirt that's C Heidi had identified
00:19:04
Catherine's Uncle his name is Uncle L
00:19:06
he's my uncle L lived here when he was a
00:19:09
young man he died in
00:19:12
1957 of cancer and he lost his hand I
00:19:16
would say before he was 20 years old in
00:19:18
a cotton gin up here in Ellis why don't
00:19:21
you go ask your mom when I saw him he
00:19:23
was holding his right hand under his
00:19:26
left hand and he was doing that in the
00:19:30
picture when I found out that it was
00:19:33
Miss Kelly's uncle and his name really
00:19:34
wasn't Khan it was L it scared me to
00:19:38
death cuz I knew Heidi was really seeing
00:19:40
something for the next 4 years Heidi
00:19:44
continued to spend time with the
00:19:46
friendly spirits of James Gordy and Lon
00:19:48
Bachelor but when her mother gave birth
00:19:51
to a baby girl a nasty and violent
00:19:54
Spirit came to visit
00:20:03
[Music]
00:20:06
TTY had never been scared of anything
00:20:08
she had never been scared of of Khan she
00:20:11
had never been scared of Mr Gordy but
00:20:13
when she seen the dark figure in our
00:20:15
hallway she was
00:20:18
hysterical the new spirit became a
00:20:20
frequent and sometimes violent guest
00:20:29
[Applause]
00:20:35
[Music]
00:20:37
what is
00:20:39
it oh my God are you
00:20:43
okay oh she had just deep gashes down
00:20:46
her face and it terrified me I didn't
00:20:48
know what it was and I couldn't imagine
00:20:51
what could have scratched her that bad I
00:20:54
thought maybe she had scratched herself
00:20:55
during the night and I didn't really
00:20:57
think too much about it
00:20:59
so about two nights later I woke up my
00:21:02
side was just burning like fire listen
00:21:06
listen what is this I had three claw
00:21:10
marks going around my
00:21:12
side the next night I went to sleep and
00:21:14
I woke up and I had three claw marks
00:21:17
down my back and then it happened again
00:21:19
the next night and I woke up and had
00:21:20
three claw marks down my
00:21:22
chest I was worried to death that it was
00:21:25
going to scratch the baby and uh that's
00:21:28
when you know I was so worried I thought
00:21:30
well I've got to do something and that's
00:21:32
when I called Dr Ro noted Paris
00:21:35
psychologist Dr William R was The
00:21:38
Logical choice to investigate you were
00:21:41
standing here and and and where was M Mr
00:21:43
Gordy standing do you think she came up
00:21:45
with physical descriptions and and with
00:21:47
names that she apparently could not have
00:21:49
obtained in any ordinary way so that
00:21:52
immediately made me interested in the
00:21:54
case a couple of pictures have been
00:21:57
found of Mr gardi The Hope was that
00:22:01
Heidi would be able to identify Mr G's
00:22:04
picture uh if they were presented to her
00:22:07
with with a number of other photographs
00:22:10
in this pile of pictures we're looking
00:22:12
for somebody who looks like uh Mr
00:22:15
gardi all right
00:22:18
so what you're watching is real Heidi
00:22:22
wirick is looking through the
00:22:24
photographs for the first time
00:22:34
that one looks like
00:22:37
them that is Mr Gord you're
00:22:40
right incredibly Heidi correctly picked
00:22:43
the photograph of James Gordy twice now
00:22:47
she had correctly identified Spirits
00:22:49
from a photo
00:22:51
lineup having spoken to Heidi and and
00:22:54
and her parents I'm even more convinced
00:22:57
that we dealing with the genuine uh
00:23:01
parapsychological
00:23:03
experiences then the question comes up
00:23:07
why are these things happening to this
00:23:08
little
00:23:11
girl does Heidi possess some mysterious
00:23:14
power to communicate with the
00:23:18
dead I think hady is special I do she's
00:23:21
been seeing him for so long now and uh
00:23:24
it's just something I don't think she'll
00:23:26
ever grow out of she's just a special
00:23:28
child she's gifted so to
00:23:32
speak Heidi is now a young woman and no
00:23:36
longer lives in the old family home she
00:23:39
reports that she has not seen Mr Gordy
00:23:41
for years however she continues to see
00:23:44
the mysterious dark figure as well as
00:23:47
numerous other Spirits the sightings are
00:23:50
so frequent that Heidi now takes them in
00:23:53
stride not even that dark mysterious
00:23:56
figure scares her
00:23:59
[Music]
00:24:02
coming up a criminal composite artist
00:24:04
Jean boand draws the face of a
00:24:13
[Music]
00:24:16
killer when 12-year-old poly class was
00:24:19
abducted from her Northern California
00:24:21
home and savagely murdered police
00:24:24
distributed thousands of copies of this
00:24:27
composite sket
00:24:29
in the end its amazing accuracy helped
00:24:32
catch the killer Richard Allen
00:24:36
Davis the secret weapon in Paulie's case
00:24:39
was this woman composite artist jeie
00:24:42
boand without her sketch of Richard
00:24:44
Davis he might still be on the loose
00:24:47
these days the FBI and police
00:24:49
departments compete for her talents they
00:24:52
know that her drawings can help solve
00:24:54
the most difficult of
00:24:57
cases in the mid 70s Jean worked at a
00:25:00
sheriff's department in Oregon where she
00:25:02
saw how suspect sketches were made in
00:25:05
many cases Jean didn't like what she saw
00:25:08
was skinnier it was longer yeah it was
00:25:10
more like that more like that maybe like
00:25:12
that nuh more like that one I would hear
00:25:14
the way that investigators would
00:25:17
question Witnesses or victims and I
00:25:19
could hear that they weren't allowing
00:25:21
them to answer they would cut the
00:25:22
answers off it was kind of just the
00:25:24
facts and Uh I that that seemed to me to
00:25:27
be wrong
00:25:28
would you put any other shape around the
00:25:30
eyes Jee knew that she could do better
00:25:33
she got her chance when a supervisor
00:25:36
gave her one of his most difficult cases
00:25:39
an unsolved rap I can't remember anymore
00:25:43
it's okay and I found that if I used
00:25:45
sort of a diversionary system of
00:25:46
interviewing where we would kind of
00:25:47
circumvent the the events of the crime
00:25:49
and scenario of the crime and talk about
00:25:52
other topics and I could relax them then
00:25:55
periodically this information would
00:25:57
surface you know I just remembered
00:25:59
something he had a scar and it started
00:26:02
on his forehead and it led back into his
00:26:06
hair it's like the tip of the tongue
00:26:08
syndrome where you have somebody's name
00:26:09
that's right there and you're trying to
00:26:10
remember it you can't bring it up and
00:26:12
maybe two or 3 hours later you stop
00:26:14
trying and it just pops into your mind I
00:26:17
just remembered something else too
00:26:19
um he had a wide face I knew that the
00:26:23
drawing that had been done on that case
00:26:24
prior to the one that I was doing was
00:26:26
wrong so what we came up with was so
00:26:27
radically different that that was sort
00:26:29
of fresh hope for that
00:26:31
case a suspect was arrested and later
00:26:34
convicted because of Jean sketch more
00:26:37
cases followed and Jean's reputation
00:26:41
grew I've seen a lot of the work Jean
00:26:43
boand has done and very impressed it's
00:26:45
the best artist conceptions I've ever
00:26:48
seen Albuquerque New
00:26:51
Mexico the FBI turned to Jean in the
00:26:54
case of 16-year-old Jonathan Francia who
00:26:58
was kidnapped from behind this
00:27:00
restaurant 5 days later his body was
00:27:03
found in the trunk of his torched car
00:27:07
one of the killers known only as Jason
00:27:10
is still at
00:27:15
large investigators ask Jean to meet
00:27:18
with a key witness Scott Johnston hi
00:27:21
yeah I'm Jean Bo nice to meet you Scott
00:27:24
had innocently spent several hours with
00:27:26
the killers at his home in Winslow
00:27:29
Arizona Jean automatically sized up his
00:27:32
potential as an eyewitness visual things
00:27:35
are very important to him he takes some
00:27:37
care in the way that he looks which was
00:27:38
the first cue to me that I would be able
00:27:40
to work in a visual context with him so
00:27:44
one thing that I did was I got out some
00:27:46
Playdoh something to Anchor him in the
00:27:48
present and gave it to him to play with
00:27:50
and sort of feel to keep him in the
00:27:52
moment I shave it more in the
00:27:55
longer as Scott told his story Jean
00:27:58
began to sketch the killer named
00:28:01
Jason Scott said that he met Jason
00:28:04
through his friend Trina
00:28:06
Richardson she was staying with Scott
00:28:08
while her husband Paul was in Alabama
00:28:12
early one morning Paul returned with a
00:28:15
strange man in the
00:28:18
car Scott what's happening not much this
00:28:23
is Jason hi come in my first impression
00:28:27
of Jason was oh boy this guy dressed
00:28:30
like a cowboy he had the velvet hat the
00:28:32
long hair and the jacket and the you
00:28:34
know the jeans and kind of like worn out
00:28:37
tennies Scott noticed something strange
00:28:40
about Jason's hands but he didn't notice
00:28:43
what it was until
00:28:46
later I look down I noticed his hand was
00:28:48
kind of like red kind of clay type I
00:28:52
thought it was just you know dirt but
00:28:53
apparently it was
00:28:56
blood Jason asked to take a shower
00:28:59
shortly after he arrived that was the
00:29:02
only time that Scott saw him without a
00:29:05
hat tell me a little bit about how you
00:29:07
would put the placement of the hair I
00:29:10
place the hair kind like long and back
00:29:12
over the ears to Scott told Jean that he
00:29:15
and Trina went out to run errands around
00:29:17
9:00
00:29:18
a.m. when they returned Paul and Jason
00:29:21
were washing the car we came back pulled
00:29:24
up they saw us and they shut the trunk
00:29:29
and they act like they didn't want us to
00:29:32
see what was in it Scott later learned
00:29:35
that the body of Jonathan Francia was in
00:29:38
the trunk Scott you got a gas can no but
00:29:41
I can go borrow one okay so I went next
00:29:44
door got the gas can came back and
00:29:46
that's when Trina Paul and Jason were
00:29:48
outside
00:29:49
talking an hour later Trina and Paul
00:29:52
showed Jason the way back to the main
00:29:55
Highway that was the last time I saw
00:29:57
Jason I thought that he went back maybe
00:29:59
to Dallas or maybe somewhere else where
00:30:01
he is you know we told me he was
00:30:04
from 4 days later an eyewitness tip LED
00:30:08
police to a remote corner of the desert
00:30:11
30 m from Scott's trailer there they
00:30:14
found the burnt out car and Jonathan
00:30:17
Franc charred remains he said he was
00:30:20
from Dallas Paul Richardson was arrested
00:30:23
2 weeks later he admitted that he and
00:30:26
Jason had abducted and murdered Jonathan
00:30:30
we took
00:30:32
it 2 days after his confession
00:30:35
Richardson committed suicide by hanging
00:30:39
himself in his jail cell would you
00:30:41
create a division between the Brows
00:30:43
would you have it connected it was now
00:30:45
up to Jean to help find
00:30:49
Jason okay when I first in the composite
00:30:52
it looked pretty much like the same
00:30:54
person that I've seen in the trailer
00:30:55
pretty pretty close I was amaz
00:30:58
that's how well it you know turned out
00:31:01
okay is there anything else you'd add to
00:31:02
it I believe that Miss boand has a
00:31:05
magician's touch in dealing uh with
00:31:09
Witnesses who and has a way of just
00:31:13
extracting a photo from their mind if
00:31:15
you will Jean sketches of the man called
00:31:18
Jason have provided some hope for
00:31:21
Jonathan francia's family it would set
00:31:25
our hearts a little give us a little
00:31:27
easy in our heart can't bring our son
00:31:31
back but it'll put him where he belongs
00:31:35
and that's what we need you know if
00:31:37
there's some way that this contribution
00:31:39
can help bring some peace to them then
00:31:42
then I would I would be
00:31:46
delighted Jean Drew three portraits of
00:31:48
the Man known as
00:31:50
Jason authorities believe he has
00:31:53
relatives in either pin toop or PAC
00:31:55
Arizona and also in Dallas Texas Jason
00:32:00
is described as 5' 10 in with a medium
00:32:03
build he smokes chews tobacco and wears
00:32:07
western style clothes including a
00:32:10
horsehair
00:32:11
belt if you have any information about
00:32:14
this case please log on to our website
00:32:16
at unsolved.com
00:32:21
next Brenda and Jerry seem to be working
00:32:24
out their divorce amicably until she
00:32:37
disappeared Birmingham
00:32:39
[Music]
00:32:41
Alabama hello two of Brenda Bowen's
00:32:44
friends stop by her house they are
00:32:47
worried because she didn't show up for
00:32:49
her regular prayer meeting swee Brenda
00:32:53
but Brenda is nowhere to be found no
00:32:56
anybody home
00:32:58
within hours a Shelby County Sheriff
00:33:01
arrives to investigate Brenda's clothes
00:33:05
were laid out on her bed as if to dress
00:33:07
after her shower on her dresser was her
00:33:11
jewelry everything was laid out real
00:33:13
nice and neat her curling iron was in
00:33:16
the own position in in the bathroom but
00:33:18
there was no other signs that you know
00:33:20
Brenda was there at
00:33:22
all Brenda lived the life most With Envy
00:33:26
she was blessed with two healthy teenage
00:33:28
children a thriving real estate business
00:33:31
and a beautiful home in the Alabama
00:33:34
Countryside her friends and family
00:33:36
couldn't figure out why she would
00:33:38
suddenly vanish when Brenda went missing
00:33:42
it was devastating to us I stayed at
00:33:45
home I thought she might call you know
00:33:47
but in my heart I knew that something
00:33:50
had happened to Brenda something
00:33:53
bad the only difficulty Brenda had
00:33:55
experienced was her divorce from her her
00:33:58
ex-husband Jerry Lee Bowman 2 years
00:34:01
earlier their 19-year marriage had
00:34:04
suddenly Fallen
00:34:06
apart they were together for about 18 or
00:34:09
19 years but Jerry got out and found a
00:34:13
girlfriend and he asked her for divor
00:34:16
Jerry you've agreed to give Brenda
00:34:19
complete and uncovered use of the house
00:34:21
until your daughter turns 19 with the
00:34:24
help of a divorce attorney Jerry and
00:34:26
Brenda separated on good terms they even
00:34:30
agreed to a very unusual living
00:34:34
Arrangement Jerry would live in the
00:34:36
guest house behind the main house he
00:34:39
also gave Brenda most of the couple's
00:34:42
assets their Arrangement worked out well
00:34:44
until Jerry ran into some money problems
00:34:49
I'm asking for your help here I don't
00:34:51
know Jerry you're asking me to live a
00:34:53
life it's only a business Arrangement no
00:34:57
and he told Le he was in financial
00:34:59
trouble and they had to get back
00:35:01
together he had to have some
00:35:03
relief Bend's answer was I'd have to
00:35:07
think about that
00:35:08
Jerry
00:35:10
Jerry Jerry we can talk about it in the
00:35:16
morning I'm going to take you back to
00:35:19
court 4 days later Brenda
00:35:23
disappeared anything you'll find I want
00:35:26
baged I want it filed police began their
00:35:28
investigation at the Bowen home Jerry
00:35:31
cooperated with the police he even told
00:35:34
them what he thought had happened to
00:35:37
Brenda as I started to leave Jerry says
00:35:41
well Don what do you think happened to
00:35:43
Brenda well let's just hope she's on a
00:35:45
beach somewhere down in Florida T in her
00:35:47
buns you're
00:35:50
wrong she's
00:35:53
dead I said well if she's dead where do
00:35:55
you think we could find her and and
00:35:57
Jerry looked at me he says you could
00:35:59
find her in water somewhere you got call
00:36:02
about an abandoned vehicle that same
00:36:04
night police found Brenda's car stuck in
00:36:06
the mud 43 mil from
00:36:10
home we found her purse we uh we found a
00:36:13
cell phone there was checkbooks there so
00:36:16
that told us that this was not a
00:36:19
robbery this here's the Bowen boy
00:36:21
Brenda's son asked the troubling
00:36:23
question about the
00:36:26
car I was wondering with the position of
00:36:28
the driver's seat was in all the way
00:36:30
back right yeah it was all the way back
00:36:33
well um my mom she's only
00:36:35
5'2 with the car seat completely pushed
00:36:38
back Brenda's feet could not reach the
00:36:41
pedals but the strangest question of all
00:36:44
came from Jerry who
00:36:46
unexpectedly appeared at the crime scene
00:36:49
is that the car that belongs to the
00:36:50
woman who's
00:36:51
missing yes now this was his ex-wife's
00:36:56
car he knew whose car that was and it
00:36:59
turned out later to be a question that
00:37:01
we felt was very important to pinning
00:37:04
down as to who was responsible for
00:37:05
Brenda's
00:37:07
death Jerry was taken to the Shelby
00:37:09
County Sheriff's Office for questioning
00:37:12
his behavior continued to raise red
00:37:16
flags he was not of any help to us
00:37:18
whatsoever he showed no concern for her
00:37:22
well-being and uh during the process of
00:37:24
interview he actually went to sleep
00:37:27
remember Jerry's friends and family
00:37:29
insisted that he was just in shock and
00:37:32
devastated over Brenda's disappearance
00:37:35
Jerry was very concerned about her but
00:37:37
he was also upset that the police
00:37:40
thought it might be him he said often
00:37:43
that that he was innocent so there was
00:37:46
no way he was going to be pinned with a
00:37:48
murder they stripped him down they
00:37:51
checked him for any Cuts or bruises or
00:37:54
bites or anything they didn't find a
00:37:56
scratch on him
00:37:58
anywhere but they got in his face and
00:38:01
told him we know you did something to
00:38:03
her whatever happened to her we know you
00:38:05
did it and we will prove it and they had
00:38:09
T vision from that night
00:38:11
on Man Zero doubt in my mind that Jerry
00:38:15
Bo and killed my daughter
00:38:17
Brenda no doubt I remember but there was
00:38:21
no evidence linking Bowen to his wife's
00:38:24
disappearance so he was released several
00:38:28
months later three fishermen saw
00:38:30
something floating in the murky Waters
00:38:32
of a nearby River it was Brenda's body
00:38:36
bound and tied inside a sheet the corer
00:38:40
could not determine the cause of death
00:38:42
because the body was so badly decomposed
00:38:46
when Brenda Bowen's body surfaced she
00:38:48
was for lack of a better way of saying
00:38:50
it packaged in a certain manner we got
00:38:54
the call late this afternoon there three
00:38:55
fishermen found the body around her body
00:38:59
was a green top sheet off of a bed
00:39:04
around that was a length of nylon rope
00:39:08
the sheet was positively identified as
00:39:11
coming from the Bowen home and there
00:39:13
were two strange things about the Rope
00:39:16
first it was tied with two specific
00:39:19
knots a bow line and a slip knot and
00:39:23
second the ends had been deliberately
00:39:25
burnt the Sun asked to look at the rope
00:39:30
that was around his mother's body and he
00:39:33
looked at it and tears filled his eyes
00:39:37
he said I've seen that same combination
00:39:39
of knots from Jerry Bowen dozens of
00:39:41
times he said I've never seen anybody
00:39:43
else do it in addition to that every
00:39:46
time Jerry Bowen cut a piece of nylon
00:39:49
rope he would take a cigarette lighter
00:39:50
and burn the ends of it the knots the
00:39:54
car seat the burned ends of the Roe
00:39:58
it all starts pointing back to Jerry
00:40:00
Bowen Jerry Bowen was arrested the case
00:40:04
against him was almost entirely
00:40:06
circumstantial except for one crucial
00:40:09
element Bowen did not have an alibi for
00:40:12
the morning His Wife
00:40:14
disappeared at his trial a jury took
00:40:16
only 6 hours to convict him but the
00:40:19
bizarre story of Jerry Bowen does not
00:40:22
end with his
00:40:23
conviction while he awaited sentencing
00:40:26
Bowen was was released on bond the day
00:40:29
of his hearing his sister received a
00:40:31
goodbye letter it read this may be a
00:40:35
dumb move on my part sis but I don't
00:40:38
feel that I should serve time for a
00:40:39
crime that I didn't commit therefore I'm
00:40:43
running when Jerry was convicted my
00:40:46
thoughts was it's
00:40:48
payday when Jerry fled I felt like
00:40:51
payday
00:40:53
evaporated the FBI descended on Bowen's
00:40:56
home looking for Clues as to where he
00:40:59
might have gone they were shocked by
00:41:01
what they found on his
00:41:03
computer thousands of violent and
00:41:06
sadistic pornographic images jury is
00:41:10
very polite respectful to others but
00:41:13
when he's back in his own secret place
00:41:14
within his own residence the bizarreness
00:41:17
of his behavior starts to emerge when
00:41:20
he's visiting websites of women being
00:41:22
abused tied up uh Shackled and tortured
00:41:25
as well as a fascination for pregnant
00:41:28
women that are uh
00:41:30
naked there was no evidence recovered
00:41:32
from Jerry's home that would help
00:41:34
detectives find a convicted killer then
00:41:38
his story aired on Unsolved
00:41:42
Mysteries update after our broadcast one
00:41:46
of our viewers notified authorities that
00:41:49
a man she knew as Steven Starbucks
00:41:52
looked exactly like Bowen when police
00:41:55
arrested Starbucks he denied that he was
00:41:57
Bowen but his fingerprints confirmed his
00:42:01
identity Bowen was sentenced to life in
00:42:04
prison for the brutal murder of his wife
00:42:06
he will not be eligible for parole until
00:42:10
December 2019
00:42:12
[Music]
00:42:27
[Music]

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most heartbreaking
  • 75
    Most emotional
  • 70
    Most dramatic
  • 70
    Best performance

Episode Highlights

  • The Mystery of Tyler's Amnesia
    A young man named Tyler is found in the desert suffering from total amnesia, leading to a complex investigation into his identity.
    “I do need to find out who I am.”
    @ 02m 38s
    March 09, 2017
  • Tony Lombardi's Tragic Death
    22-year-old Tony Lombardi is found dead in his home, sparking conflicting theories of suicide versus murder.
    “I believe that there was a struggle.”
    @ 10m 10s
    March 09, 2017
  • Heidi's Gift of Seeing Spirits
    An 8-year-old girl named Heidi claims she can see and communicate with dead people, raising questions about her abilities.
    “I knew Heidi was really seeing something.”
    @ 19m 38s
    March 09, 2017
  • Jean's Breakthrough
    Jean's sketch led to the arrest of a suspect in a difficult case.
    “That was sort of fresh hope for that case”
    @ 26m 29s
    March 09, 2017
  • Brenda's Mysterious Disappearance
    Brenda Bowen vanished without a trace, leaving friends and family worried.
    “In my heart I knew that something had happened to Brenda”
    @ 33m 47s
    March 09, 2017
  • Jerry Bowen's Arrest
    Jerry Bowen was arrested for the murder of his wife, but the evidence was circumstantial.
    “The case against him was almost entirely circumstantial”
    @ 40m 06s
    March 09, 2017

Episode Quotes

  • I can't go to work because I'm not eligible for a social security number.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 13
  • I give anything in the world to remember right now.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 13
  • I will not stop until the last breath is taken from my body.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 13
  • I just remembered something else too.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 13
  • It'll put him where he belongs.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 13
  • I’ve seen that same combination of knots from Jerry Bowen dozens of times.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 13

Key Moments

  • Amnesia Mystery02:16
  • Tragic Discovery08:52
  • Spiritual Encounters15:39
  • Sketching Hope26:31
  • Vanished33:42
  • Circumstantial Evidence40:06

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown

Related Episodes

Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 1, Episode 13 - Full Episode
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 1, Episode 13 - Full Episode
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 16
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 16
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 1, Episode 10 - Full Episode
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:48
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 1, Episode 10 - Full Episode
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 19
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:55
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 19
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 6
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 6
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 8, Episode 20
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 8, Episode 20
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 6, Episode 4
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 6, Episode 4
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 7, Episode 9
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:52
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 7, Episode 9
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 4
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 4
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 8, Episode 7
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:31
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 8, Episode 7
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 7, Episode 18
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:50
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 7, Episode 18
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 11
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 11