00:00:00
[Music]
00:00:04
next on Unsolved
00:00:06
Mysteries in the ashes of a garage fire
00:00:09
police find a body of Clarence rockets
00:00:12
and then 10 years later another fire
00:00:15
kills his wife and the body of Clarence
00:00:18
Roberts is found again how can one man
00:00:22
die
00:00:24
twice few people know that Elvis Presley
00:00:27
had a twin brother who died at Birth
00:00:30
some believe that the tragic loss
00:00:32
inspired Elvis to
00:00:35
greatest the heartbreaking death of a
00:00:37
six-year-old girl remains a mystery that
00:00:40
her family and friends still want to
00:00:43
solve and police and California need
00:00:46
your help to track down a doctor who
00:00:49
sexually assaulted his trusting
00:00:53
patients murder missing persons wanted
00:00:58
fugitives and the parent
00:01:00
normal I'm Dennis finina and this is
00:01:03
Unsolved Mysteries
00:01:16
[Music]
00:01:25
[Music]
00:01:40
in Nashville Indiana two of the most
00:01:43
respected residents were Clarence and
00:01:45
Geneva
00:01:47
Roberts that is until they became the
00:01:49
center of a local
00:01:52
controversy a tangled mystery of lies
00:01:56
and
00:01:57
deception one winter night a fire raged
00:02:00
out of control behind the Robert's home
00:02:03
when the ashes cooled firefighters
00:02:05
discovered a body it was soon identified
00:02:08
as Clarence Roberts 10 years later there
00:02:12
was another fire two more bodies were
00:02:15
discovered the first was Geneva Roberts
00:02:18
the second was none other than Clarence
00:02:24
Roberts how could the same man die twice
00:02:27
it was just one more question about the
00:02:30
mysterious Clarence Roberts I talked to
00:02:33
both detectives that was on the second
00:02:35
fire and from what they told me I'd say
00:02:37
it was definitely Clarence I still think
00:02:40
Clarence died in the first far I don't
00:02:41
think Clarence Roberts died in the
00:02:43
second far I I just don't believe that I
00:02:46
think Clarence is still
00:02:49
alive I sure
00:02:51
do people in Nashville are still
00:02:54
wondering about Clarence Roberts he was
00:02:56
a businessman a former sheriff and a
00:02:59
board member of of the local bank it was
00:03:01
hard to imagine anyone more successful
00:03:04
and yet somewhere along the way a
00:03:06
different side of Clarence Roberts began
00:03:08
to
00:03:10
emerge before his troubles began
00:03:13
Clarence owned the thriving hardware
00:03:15
store with his brother Carson he and I
00:03:18
worked together for about 22 years
00:03:20
Clarence always seemed to be pretty
00:03:22
happy he enjoyed working Clarence was
00:03:24
outgoing he was friendly and always made
00:03:26
friends with people and always got along
00:03:28
with people
00:03:30
what Clarence and his wife Geneva had
00:03:33
been married 20 years Geneva came from a
00:03:36
poor family but together she and
00:03:39
Clarence made a good life for
00:03:42
themselves then Clarence began spending
00:03:45
money more money than he had he
00:03:49
purchased three luxury cars and a home
00:03:53
he could not
00:03:56
afford to finance his extravagant
00:03:58
lifestyle Clarence sold the hardware
00:04:01
store and put everything he had into
00:04:04
real estate Investments those Ventures
00:04:06
failed and Clarence found himself in
00:04:09
serious financial trouble for all the
00:04:12
money that he was losing everything
00:04:15
going down the drain he was going for a
00:04:17
millionaire or broke and he was ending
00:04:20
up broke he was trying to pull out of
00:04:24
it finally even Clarence and Geneva's
00:04:28
cars were repossessed
00:04:31
they were deeply in debt with nowhere to
00:04:34
turn he wasn't the clearance that I had
00:04:37
always been used to being around he was
00:04:39
down he was really depressed and I feel
00:04:43
that he was
00:04:45
suicidal and then the fire one month
00:04:49
after the Robert's cars were taken
00:04:51
firefighters arrived to discover the
00:04:53
garage of their home engulfed in flames
00:04:56
there the heat was so intense that they
00:04:58
can only stand by helplessly while the
00:05:01
structure burned to the
00:05:03
ground once the fire had cooled they
00:05:06
made a gruesome Discovery Chief come
00:05:09
back here I think we got a body a body
00:05:11
in the ashes was burned beyond
00:05:13
recognition a half melted Shotgun by its
00:05:17
side the coroner feared that Clarence
00:05:19
had finally escaped his deaths by taking
00:05:23
his
00:05:24
own we thought it shot himself there
00:05:27
wasn't much doubt in our mind that he
00:05:30
just got too many warriors ahead of him
00:05:32
and he' committed suicide so when we got
00:05:35
back down to the funeral home we started
00:05:37
looking for
00:05:38
shots and U we couldn't find
00:05:43
any questions began to surface the
00:05:47
coroner wondered how Clarence could have
00:05:49
taken his own life without firing a
00:05:51
single shot when detective Don kuster
00:05:54
carefully sifted through the ashes he
00:05:57
found a ring that had belonged to
00:05:58
Clarence despite the intense heat the
00:06:01
ring was not
00:06:04
damaged there's no way that ring could
00:06:06
have withstood the heat of that far like
00:06:09
it did and not even have a damage port
00:06:12
on it at
00:06:13
all I definitely think the ring was a
00:06:16
plant uh it just it had to be it was the
00:06:21
first of many Clues suggesting the fire
00:06:23
was not what it seemed police learned
00:06:26
that a few months before the fire
00:06:29
Clarence had taken out several life
00:06:30
insurance policies totaling close to a
00:06:33
million do a test of the body found in
00:06:36
the ashes showed type AB blood Clarence
00:06:40
had type B blood if it wasn't the body
00:06:44
of Clarence Roberts then who was it
00:06:47
eyewitnesses provide a possible
00:06:51
answer just 2 days before the blaze
00:06:54
Clarence had been spotted in a bar
00:06:56
buying drinks for a homeless man
00:07:00
according to the eyewitnesses as he and
00:07:02
Clarence were leaving the bar The
00:07:05
Drifter passed out and collapsed
00:07:08
Clarence said he'd take him to the
00:07:10
hospital and Clarence left with him and
00:07:13
later on I checked the hospitals within
00:07:16
a 300 mile radius and this man was not
00:07:18
admitted to a hospital
00:07:21
anymore now there were two theories
00:07:23
about Clarence one scenario was that he
00:07:27
had killed himself
00:07:29
the other that Clarence Roberts had
00:07:32
murdered the transient then staged his
00:07:34
own fiery death in order to collect the
00:07:38
insurance money suicidal yes that to
00:07:41
commit murder no way I can't believe he
00:07:44
could have been any part of that it
00:07:45
would be hard be beyond my wildest
00:07:50
imagination to think that Clarence
00:07:51
robers could ever been involved with
00:07:53
anything like
00:07:55
that
00:07:57
definitely definitely he was capable of
00:08:00
[Music]
00:08:02
it Clarence was either dead or missing
00:08:05
and Geneva was definitely alone with no
00:08:09
money and no Clarance she was forced to
00:08:11
move back to the wrong side of the
00:08:13
tracks her claims to the insurance money
00:08:16
were
00:08:18
denied the financial setbacks took their
00:08:21
toll on Geneva she avoided her friends
00:08:24
and neighbors eventually becoming the
00:08:26
target of local gossip shopkeepers said
00:08:29
that Geneva began buying a lot of beer
00:08:32
that was surprising as she was a
00:08:34
diabetic and almost never drank beer
00:08:37
reports began to surface that someone
00:08:39
else was hanging around Geneva's
00:08:43
house we had developed information that
00:08:47
a man had been seen behind Geneva's
00:08:53
residence the man acted very strangely
00:08:56
he would never let anyone get close to
00:08:58
him and he always seemed to duck away
00:09:00
from them and head back toward the house
00:09:02
immediately I'm sure that was probably
00:09:04
Clarence I think he had perhaps run out
00:09:08
of places to go you know and he had come
00:09:11
back uh to staying with Geneva he was
00:09:14
the mysterious man that was seen behind
00:09:16
her house Geneva was able to keep the
00:09:19
identity of the mysterious man a secret
00:09:23
at least until the night of the second
00:09:25
fire
00:09:30
[Music]
00:09:33
when my office
00:09:35
called and explained that it was
00:09:37
Geneva's house on
00:09:39
fire and that they thought Geneva was
00:09:41
still inside the house I went right to
00:09:44
the fire scene and the fire was still
00:09:48
burning very intensely at that
00:09:51
time after the fire was extinguished why
00:09:54
we just stayed behind and I'm not even
00:09:57
sure why um I just just wanted to look
00:10:01
further sifting through the ashes
00:10:03
Searchers found the charred body of
00:10:06
Geneva Roberts hours later they made
00:10:09
another startling
00:10:12
Discovery Geneva's body had been removed
00:10:16
to the funeral
00:10:17
home and the fire had been extinguished
00:10:20
the house was totally
00:10:22
demolished so we'd gone through the
00:10:23
reubel and a fireman had located a
00:10:26
second body in another part of the house
00:10:29
and I was just so certain that it would
00:10:33
be that of
00:10:35
Clarence I recognized him immediately by
00:10:38
his chest
00:10:41
x-ray now I knew that I was going to
00:10:44
have a difficult time to
00:10:46
tell uh all of my friends and Neighbors
00:10:48
in the world that Clarence was dead for
00:10:53
the second
00:10:54
time it just
00:10:57
um turned out to be Clarence and I I was
00:11:00
very pleased with that uh that this
00:11:02
might be coming to an
00:11:04
end little did I know that it was just
00:11:08
starting it looks like someone just came
00:11:10
in the back door and poured all the way
00:11:13
around the walls the second fire was a
00:11:16
clear cut case of arson we could follow
00:11:19
very clearly these burn patterns from
00:11:23
Geneva's bed into the adjacent room
00:11:26
where clarence's body was located
00:11:29
and then down a hallway and out the back
00:11:32
door of that
00:11:33
house so we determined right there that
00:11:38
at least Geneva had been
00:11:41
murdered we're sure that turpentine was
00:11:45
used to ignite this
00:11:48
fire we know that we simply don't know
00:11:51
who started
00:11:53
it whether it was clearance that started
00:11:55
the fire or that of a third party
00:11:59
I subscribe to the the theory of a third
00:12:02
party police have no clue as to who set
00:12:06
the second fire but they believe they
00:12:08
have identified the second victim so I'm
00:12:12
absolutely convinced that the second
00:12:15
victim the victim in the second fire is
00:12:18
that of Clarence Roberts there's just no
00:12:19
doubt in my mind there's not a doubt in
00:12:22
my mind at all I'm absolutely convinced
00:12:25
that Clarence Roberts died in the second
00:12:27
fire and that some person possibly a
00:12:30
derel uh died in in the first fire and
00:12:34
when I say absolutely I mean that this
00:12:36
is
00:12:38
uh not only a reasonable medical
00:12:41
certainty uh but we beyond a shadow of a
00:12:45
doubt the mystery of Clarence Roberts
00:12:48
lies buried in this small Cemetery in
00:12:50
Nashville Indiana but the questions
00:12:53
remain who was the man in the first fire
00:12:56
who set the second fire and why and and
00:12:59
the key questions where is Clarence
00:13:01
Roberts and is he even buried in his own
00:13:06
grave police believe that there is
00:13:08
someone who knows the truth about
00:13:10
Clarence and Geneva Roberts if you have
00:13:13
any information about this case please
00:13:16
log on to our website at
00:13:18
unsolved.com
00:13:22
next few people know that Alvis Presley
00:13:25
had a twin brother who died at Birth
00:13:28
some believe that his twin inspired his
00:13:31
legendary
00:13:32
[Music]
00:13:43
F Memphis
00:13:45
Tennessee Elvis Presley the king of rock
00:13:48
and roll his life story is a classic a
00:13:51
shy teenager from the wrong side of town
00:13:54
becomes a superstar but what few people
00:13:57
know about Elvis is that he was haunted
00:14:00
his entire life by the death of his twin
00:14:02
brother Jesse
00:14:04
[Music]
00:14:06
Garen Elvis was born in this Shack in
00:14:09
East Tupelo Mississippi records show
00:14:12
that his twin brother was born first
00:14:15
more than a half hour before Elvis but
00:14:18
by the time Elvis was born Jesse Garen
00:14:21
Presley had already been declared dead
00:14:25
Jesse was buried in an unmarked grave in
00:14:27
this nearby Cemetery
00:14:29
today many believe his death had
00:14:31
profound emotional consequences for
00:14:34
Elvis some say that it was the driving
00:14:37
force behind both his creative genius
00:14:39
and his
00:14:42
self-destruction when Elvis was a child
00:14:45
5 6 years old he used to tell me that he
00:14:48
used to hear a voice inside of his head
00:14:50
and he used to confuse him and he used
00:14:52
to scare him a little bit and he was
00:14:54
afraid to mention it to anyone he
00:14:56
thought perhaps it was his brother Jesse
00:14:59
communicating to him telling him what to
00:15:02
do music was Elvis's way of
00:15:05
communicating with Jesse the two had
00:15:07
been bonded before they were born inter
00:15:09
utterly with the Rhythm and the voice of
00:15:13
the fundamentalist Assembly of God
00:15:14
Church a very important Cornerstone for
00:15:17
understanding
00:15:18
Elin Dr Peter Whitmer has devoted years
00:15:22
to studying the psychology of twins
00:15:25
especially those who have been separated
00:15:27
by Death the surviving child is often
00:15:30
referred to as a twinless
00:15:34
twin many twinless twins including Elvis
00:15:37
tend to become should we say
00:15:41
superstitious Elvis would look to his
00:15:44
twin for signs of guidance for signs of
00:15:47
strength Elvis also felt that Jesse was
00:15:49
his Compass was a sign of direction that
00:15:53
Elvis should in fact do great things
00:15:56
that had the two of them been United
00:15:58
they would have been able to do great
00:15:59
things that they were separated Elvis
00:16:02
alone had to be the Creator the
00:16:06
perfectionist there are more than a half
00:16:08
a million twinless twins in the world
00:16:10
today like Elvis Presley they're United
00:16:14
by a common but unusual Bond a strange
00:16:18
belief that the spirit of the dead twin
00:16:21
lives on I do feel the presence of
00:16:23
someone else in my life I've um again I
00:16:27
it's only been recently that I've
00:16:28
thought thought to put it in that
00:16:29
framework of the twin I've thought of it
00:16:32
more as a guardian angel or a or a
00:16:35
spiritual presence for some of Dr
00:16:37
Raymond brand coined the term twinless
00:16:39
twin and founded a nationwide support
00:16:42
group for them twins are unique because
00:16:47
there's one thing that a twin a multiple
00:16:50
has that single birth people do not and
00:16:52
that's called unal bonding of course
00:16:55
today with ultrasounds and
00:16:57
studying behavor
00:16:59
in uteral and we realize that they hug
00:17:02
and what appears to be kissing and even
00:17:04
perhaps slugging or pushing at each
00:17:06
other we understand and accept today
00:17:09
that uteral bonding begins at the moment
00:17:12
of
00:17:13
conception consider the case of Dean
00:17:16
sites born an identical twin Deanne
00:17:19
became twinless when her sister Shannon
00:17:22
died just 5 hours after birth she may
00:17:25
have died 22 years ago but I can feel
00:17:27
her presence all the time Shannon's my
00:17:30
guardian angel she watches over
00:17:33
me you know she kind of makes sure
00:17:35
nothing really bad happens to me or my
00:17:38
family the aunt says that while she was
00:17:40
on her way to work she had a dramatic
00:17:42
psychic experience with her lost twin
00:17:45
theanne believes her sister saved her
00:17:48
life it was about 9:00 in the
00:17:51
morning and I was going down the offramp
00:17:54
and this feeling came over me I could
00:17:58
feel Shannon's presence really strong
00:18:01
next to me and then almost like her
00:18:05
presence came over me and had me pull
00:18:07
over to the right and then
00:18:09
stop and then not even 5 seconds
00:18:14
later Shan was telling me to pull
00:18:18
over before I got
00:18:20
hit it wasn't as if she said you know
00:18:23
hello I'm here it's just the feeling the
00:18:26
security of her being around
00:18:30
because my twin died in the womb I lived
00:18:34
and she died there's a sense that I've
00:18:36
carried with me forever that somehow I
00:18:39
took too much for example I must have
00:18:41
eaten all the food or uh you know I was
00:18:43
the one who lived and uh I carried a a
00:18:46
deep sense of guilt about being here not
00:18:49
until we find that's the downside the
00:18:51
guilt another many people believe it is
00:18:54
guilt that drives twinless twins to
00:18:57
Great Heights or the depth
00:18:59
of self-destruction some say the root
00:19:01
cause of Elvis Presley's emotional
00:19:03
torment was his sadness and feeling of
00:19:06
responsibility for his twin brother's
00:19:09
death Elvis's friend Larry Geller
00:19:12
recalls a conversation that took place a
00:19:15
year before Elvis died he said man I had
00:19:19
a dream the other night I can't get it
00:19:21
out of my head I got to tell
00:19:23
you there I was with my twin brother
00:19:26
Jesse he had the same hairstyle The
00:19:29
Sideburns the same eyes one Spotlight on
00:19:32
him one Spotlight on
00:19:35
me but Larry the strangest thing I
00:19:39
started to feel
00:19:41
guilty I I felt like like I did
00:19:44
something wrong and I don't know why
00:19:45
it's the weirdest feeling and I I said
00:19:48
well maybe it's kind of simple you lived
00:19:51
and he
00:19:53
didn't Elvis never was able to resolve
00:19:56
his psychological HST over the death of
00:19:59
Jesse it was something that was at the
00:20:02
core of all of his behavior from my
00:20:05
perspective his substance abuse his
00:20:08
self-abuse in general his working
00:20:10
himself to death was the desire to
00:20:13
reunite with
00:20:14
Jesse I remember one time we were
00:20:17
talking and he was telling me about his
00:20:19
mother he used to question her about his
00:20:23
twin brother Jesse
00:20:25
Garen and she said to him Elvis God took
00:20:29
your twin brother back home to heaven
00:20:32
and someday we'll all be together again
00:20:36
and Ela said to me
00:20:38
Lawrence I believe that we're all going
00:20:41
home someday I'm going to be with my
00:20:43
twin brother
00:20:44
[Music]
00:20:45
again for now medical science cannot
00:20:48
explain the psychic connections of
00:20:50
twinless twins and though some might
00:20:53
think they lead troubled lives the twins
00:20:55
themselves believe that they have been
00:20:58
gifted
00:20:58
[Music]
00:21:03
next the search for a young woman who
00:21:05
disappeared near a lake in
00:21:17
Alabama Lake Guntersville Alabama early
00:21:20
morning wond Betty Dorman tries to wake
00:21:24
up her 26-year-old niece Wanda Jean
00:21:27
maize
00:21:30
Wanda Wanda but Wanda doesn't answer
00:21:33
Betty calls her grandson John for help
00:21:37
get out of the
00:21:49
way Wanda Wanda's Uncle ran down to the
00:21:53
lake and saw a piece of clothing on the
00:21:56
duck it was Wanda torn and bloody night
00:22:00
gown his first thought was that Wanda
00:22:02
had fallen into the water and
00:22:05
[Music]
00:22:07
drowned the Alabama State Rescue Squad
00:22:10
began dragging the lake searching for
00:22:12
clues or a body they found
00:22:16
nothing Wanda's parents couldn't do
00:22:19
anything but wait I never fought for a
00:22:23
minute Wanda was in the water Wanda is
00:22:26
an excellent swimmer and a
00:22:29
Survivor she's always been a
00:22:32
Survivor within a few hours the rescue
00:22:35
squad found an abandoned canoe and towed
00:22:38
it to shore inside were traces of
00:22:42
blood after seeing the the blood in the
00:22:45
boat I knew that she was alone and hurt
00:22:47
and needed medical attention the thing
00:22:50
that you feel inside when you have the
00:22:53
possibility of losing a daughter is
00:22:57
Indescribable I never be the
00:22:59
same until I know what happened to
00:23:04
one homicide investigators were called
00:23:06
in detective Ed teal took charge of the
00:23:10
investigation when we arrived We
00:23:13
examined the canoe blood samples taken
00:23:16
from that all this Blood was sent to the
00:23:19
lab and came back to being her type of
00:23:21
blood like a little blood stain in this
00:23:24
canoe this is the most mysterious case
00:23:27
that I've ever worked
00:23:29
I've never worked a case in 10 years
00:23:33
where someone just
00:23:36
vanished when I came into the room I
00:23:39
noticed that the bed the cover had been
00:23:42
turned back but no one had never slept
00:23:45
in the bed appearance of what was
00:23:48
identified as her clothing was lying in
00:23:50
a chair her purse her identification
00:23:54
checkbooks Rings watch everything was
00:23:57
laying on the the
00:23:59
nightstand I got to looking at the wall
00:24:03
here the glass that was broke
00:24:05
out there are two panes of glass that
00:24:08
was
00:24:10
broken the thing that baffles me the
00:24:12
most about this is that no one in the
00:24:15
house heard the breaking of the glass or
00:24:19
the beating of the venician blinds
00:24:21
that's a lot of
00:24:23
Racket more than a few questions remain
00:24:27
unanswered how could Wanda's aunt and
00:24:29
uncle have slept through the sound of
00:24:31
the window being broken if Wanda was the
00:24:34
victim of Foul Play Why was the bedroom
00:24:36
window broken from the inside why would
00:24:39
Wanda take off her night gown and leave
00:24:42
it on the dock and why were there blood
00:24:45
stains in the canoe there were no
00:24:48
answers and Wanda Jean ma herself seemed
00:24:51
to have vanished into the Alabama
00:24:55
night
00:24:57
update 18 years after Wanda disappeared
00:25:00
the remains of a body were discovered in
00:25:03
a remote area 2 mi from the lake we're
00:25:06
sad to say they were Wanda jeans however
00:25:09
there were no signs of Foul Play and
00:25:12
police now believe that Wanda was
00:25:14
disoriented by the darkness and fell to
00:25:16
her death in the Rocky terrain the case
00:25:19
is now
00:25:21
closed next a 6-year-old girl is found
00:25:24
dead less than a block from her house
00:25:27
what happened to Catherine corzilius
00:25:35
[Music]
00:25:41
Boston
00:25:47
Texas at the age of six Katherine
00:25:50
corzilius seemed to be leading a Charmed
00:25:53
Life she lived in a good neighborhood
00:25:55
with her loving parents Nancy and Paul
00:25:58
and her brother Chris her father was
00:26:00
personal manager for Rockstar John
00:26:05
bonjovi when Catherine played her first
00:26:08
piano recital no one imagined that she
00:26:10
would never live to see the first grade
00:26:14
her untimely death would be memorialized
00:26:17
by family friend John
00:26:21
[Music]
00:26:23
Banji August 7th
00:26:26
4:15 that's when Nancy and Paul's world
00:26:29
came crashing
00:26:31
down it was Paul's birthday he was
00:26:34
working at his office in New York City
00:26:36
Nancy and the kids had spent the day
00:26:38
running errands around Austin picking
00:26:41
out gifts for
00:26:43
him it uh was very quiet here in our
00:26:47
neighborhood as it usually is in fact I
00:26:50
I can remark that it it was
00:26:51
exceptionally quiet that
00:26:53
day on the way home they stopped to pick
00:26:56
up the mail it was a ritual Catherine
00:26:58
looked forward
00:26:59
[Music]
00:27:01
to Nancy knew what would happen next
00:27:05
mommy may I want come sure I'll see you
00:27:08
when you get there okay it was
00:27:10
Catherine's way of saying that she was a
00:27:12
big girl I allowed Catherine to do that
00:27:15
because I knew she was ready to be more
00:27:16
independent and she had done it before
00:27:19
Nancy and Chris drove home one way while
00:27:22
Catherine walked home in the opposite
00:27:24
direction the shorter way home the
00:27:27
corzilius family lives here on elders
00:27:30
Circle the community mailboxes are
00:27:33
located here Nancy and Chris drove home
00:27:36
in this direction Catherine apparently
00:27:39
followed this
00:27:42
route both of my children had walked
00:27:44
home together and separately from the
00:27:47
mailboxes it's a short walk
00:27:52
probably less than a quar of a
00:27:56
mile when Chris and I got home we
00:27:59
unloaded our car and started putting our
00:28:01
packages away mom what Catherine's not
00:28:04
back she tried to stop somewhere along
00:28:06
the way go back up on the road see if
00:28:08
you can find her all
00:28:11
right he came back in just a very short
00:28:14
period of time a few minutes and he was
00:28:16
crying and he said she's not there Mom
00:28:19
we got in the car and drove right next
00:28:21
door to our neighbors I ran down the
00:28:23
steps to their front door knocked on the
00:28:25
door their son answered
00:28:27
[Applause]
00:28:29
hi is Catherine here no ma'am she hasn't
00:28:31
been by here at
00:28:33
all I believe uh at that moment Chris
00:28:36
and I knew that something terrible had
00:28:38
happened minutes later Nancy would find
00:28:41
out just how
00:28:56
terrible I could take fell that she was
00:28:59
unconscious but she was breathing and I
00:29:01
knew it was too hot to leave her on the
00:29:06
pavement I know that it's never a good
00:29:09
idea to move somebody if you don't know
00:29:11
what their injuries are but I just
00:29:13
couldn't leave her there and I think
00:29:15
having driven her to the emergency
00:29:17
before knowing the way very well I felt
00:29:20
confident that I was able to to drive
00:29:22
that
00:29:23
drive Catherine suffered a fractured
00:29:25
skull she never regained the conscious
00:29:29
Catherine was on a ventilator to keep
00:29:31
her breathing but she was brain dead it
00:29:35
wasn't a matter of her being in a coma
00:29:37
or being
00:29:38
unconscious uh her brain had died I
00:29:42
arranged for a charter aircraft so that
00:29:44
could come directly home but in the end
00:29:47
it was too late anyway I arrived at
00:29:49
12:30 in the morning and I believe she
00:29:51
was pronounced dead at 11:30 that night
00:29:54
hour before my
00:29:57
arrival from the start everyone just
00:29:59
assumed that Catherine had been the
00:30:01
victim of a hit and run driver however
00:30:04
as police searched for the suspect other
00:30:07
disturbing theories began to surface
00:30:10
Catherine left her mother's car here and
00:30:13
head it in this direction less than 10
00:30:16
minutes later she was found here on the
00:30:19
opposite side of the circle half a mile
00:30:22
away the medical examiner's report only
00:30:26
deepened the mystery he determined that
00:30:29
Catherine had not died from a hit-and
00:30:31
run accident dangerous that Catherine
00:30:34
sustain could have been the result of
00:30:36
either uh jumping from a moving vehicle
00:30:39
uh being thrown from a moving vehicle or
00:30:42
falling from a moving vehicle the type
00:30:45
of injuries that we expect expect in
00:30:47
these circumstances would have been the
00:30:49
same if Catherine did Tumble from a
00:30:52
moving vehicle whose vehicle was it and
00:30:56
was she pushed or did she fall one of
00:30:59
the theories that investigators proposed
00:31:02
was that indeed somehow Catherine had
00:31:04
jumped on the back of our vehicle
00:31:07
without nany's knowledge and uh as the
00:31:10
vehicle drove around ear Circle she had
00:31:12
fallen off which was uh a way to explain
00:31:15
where she was found in El Circle which
00:31:16
is completely opposite of where she
00:31:18
would have been on her normal
00:31:21
route the corzilius family was stunned
00:31:25
was it possible that Nancy was respons
00:31:27
responsible for her daughter's death
00:31:30
Paul and Nancy hired their own private
00:31:33
investigator Barbara O'Brien she found
00:31:36
the scenario hard to believe Hot August
00:31:39
day this whole car would have been very
00:31:41
very hot there's only one place to hold
00:31:43
on to all the way up here and the door
00:31:47
is the only other place down here to
00:31:49
hold on to and it opens when you get a
00:31:53
hold of it she also had a broken left
00:31:56
thumb and she had a splin on her thumb
00:31:59
so it would have been extremely
00:32:00
difficult for her to get a hold on
00:32:02
anything and her mother would have seen
00:32:05
her in the rear view
00:32:07
mirror the corzilius family has their
00:32:09
own Theory they believe their daughter
00:32:12
was abducted and murdered a search of a
00:32:15
vacant overgrown lot just 30 yard from
00:32:18
the mailboxes may have provided a
00:32:21
crucial clue a few days after
00:32:24
Catherine's uh death the investigators
00:32:27
did bring in the can9 unit and search
00:32:31
the area they did pick up her scent over
00:32:34
in this vacant lot which would indicate
00:32:38
that she was coming in this direction
00:32:40
from the
00:32:41
mailboxes taking the most direct route
00:32:43
home the scent was lost however which
00:32:46
tells us that this may have been the
00:32:48
point where she was abducted or the
00:32:50
injury took place but she was then later
00:32:53
moved where she was found by her mother
00:32:56
she looked like she'd been laid out
00:32:58
there for me to find her hair was smooth
00:33:02
down her shirt was straight her shorts
00:33:05
were straight her toes were pointed
00:33:07
straight her sandals were on I know
00:33:10
someone moved her and I know someone
00:33:12
laid her there for me to
00:33:16
find after all the investigations and
00:33:19
speculation the cause of Catherine's
00:33:21
death remains a mystery in the quiet
00:33:24
neighborhood on Elder Circle her memory
00:33:27
lives on
00:33:28
Catherine's neighbors have planted a
00:33:30
tree and placed a plaque in her
00:33:35
name I think if Paul and Nancy's parents
00:33:40
knew how it happened perhaps it could
00:33:42
help them with the closure of this
00:33:45
tragic event nothing that anyone can say
00:33:49
or do is ever going to bring their
00:33:50
daughter back to him but it's twice as
00:33:53
hard not knowing what
00:33:56
happened I think of
00:33:58
uh families of people who are missing an
00:34:00
action well they're not here but what
00:34:03
happened to them and that's exactly to a
00:34:06
certain extent how I feel about our
00:34:08
daughter I had Catherine's body but
00:34:11
something happened in the last 15
00:34:12
minutes of her life then I I don't know
00:34:15
what that
00:34:17
was the investigation in the Catherine's
00:34:19
death has ground to a halt if you have
00:34:22
any information that might help resolve
00:34:24
this case please log on to our website
00:34:27
at
00:34:28
unsolved.com
00:34:31
next a family doctor is on the Run
00:34:35
charged with the brutal rape of a
00:34:47
patient San Diego
00:34:51
California hi we will call this young
00:34:54
woman
00:34:55
Patricia when she was 19 years old
00:34:58
Patricia went to a clinic complaining of
00:35:00
flu symptoms you know what if you just
00:35:03
take a seat it'll just be a few minutes
00:35:05
Patricia had no way of knowing that the
00:35:07
doctor who was about to see her had
00:35:10
recently been forced to resign from
00:35:11
another clinic four different complaints
00:35:14
of sexual misconduct had been filed
00:35:16
against them each by a young woman in
00:35:19
her
00:35:20
20s the doctor's name was Arvin son the
00:35:24
California State Medical Board ruled
00:35:26
that son could keep his license because
00:35:29
there were no witnesses to the assaults
00:35:32
it was the patient word against the
00:35:35
doctors Dr shha right now shha hi he kep
00:35:40
asking me questions about family about
00:35:43
um having a boyfriend and I was really
00:35:46
sick I had a fever I wasn't feeling well
00:35:49
this combined with um all the
00:35:51
questioning it really just threw me off
00:35:53
you know I just figured that he was just
00:35:56
trying to be more help F and
00:35:58
caring Patricia says that once the nurse
00:36:01
left Dr son's examination quickly became
00:36:05
a sexual assault he manipulated me into
00:36:09
a position where I couldn't even see
00:36:11
what he was
00:36:12
doing and I didn't even know what he was
00:36:15
doing or trying to do until I'd finally
00:36:19
realized that he had raped
00:36:23
me after he had left the room I just
00:36:26
started crying
00:36:28
I knew what had happened but I just
00:36:29
could not believe that that had happened
00:36:32
to
00:36:33
me I'm okay Patricia was afraid to let
00:36:36
anyone at the clinic know what happened
00:36:39
a short time later Patricia's parents
00:36:42
took her to another hospital and local
00:36:44
police were notified after a week-long
00:36:48
investigation Arvin was
00:36:50
arrested he had no reaction he kept
00:36:53
repeating after I told him what she was
00:36:56
alleging he said oh how interesting and
00:36:59
throughout the interview he repeated how
00:37:01
interesting no emotion no reaction just
00:37:05
uh he said he didn't do it that he might
00:37:07
have been frame but uh I would have
00:37:09
expected a little reaction out of an
00:37:11
innocent
00:37:12
person the next day Arvin posted
00:37:16
$175,000 bail within a month he had
00:37:20
disappeared later his medical license
00:37:22
was revoked by the state of California
00:37:25
Every Woman he's around is in danger
00:37:28
he's not going to
00:37:29
stop he had four warnings and lost a job
00:37:32
and then he came back and raped Patricia
00:37:34
he's not going to
00:37:35
stop the only two places I really felt
00:37:38
safe was at church or at the doctor's
00:37:40
office you know and now you know I don't
00:37:45
have that trust for anybody
00:37:48
anywhere Arvin Sona is 5' 6 in tall with
00:37:52
dark hair and dark eyes he graduated
00:37:55
from medical school in his native India
00:37:57
and completed his residency in Dayton
00:38:02
Ohio authorities believe that Arvin
00:38:04
sinhal is still working in the medical
00:38:06
profession somewhere in the United
00:38:09
States possibly in a small town he is
00:38:12
wanted on 13 counts of rape and three
00:38:15
counts of sexual battery if you have any
00:38:18
information that could help lead to his
00:38:20
arrest please log on to our website at
00:38:23
unsolved.com
00:38:32
Daytona
00:38:34
Florida teenagers have a reputation for
00:38:37
being moody but by all accounts the case
00:38:40
of 19-year-old Tim molner was extreme
00:38:44
without warning Tim simply drove away
00:38:47
from home one day and out of his
00:38:49
family's
00:38:52
life Tim was a rather quiet uh sensitive
00:38:57
type of a person but he was always very
00:39:00
polite and well-mannered and he was
00:39:03
doing well in school was on the dean
00:39:06
list in fact and uh he was a very
00:39:09
likable
00:39:10
person on the day Tim left his parents
00:39:13
grew more and more frightened with each
00:39:15
passing hour his 14-year-old brother
00:39:18
Frank had been the last family member to
00:39:21
see Tim said to have a nice day there's
00:39:25
a pretty good age difference between us
00:39:27
but we still hung out a lot cuz you know
00:39:28
we got along real good and pretty open
00:39:30
relationship and um I could just tell
00:39:33
something was something was bothering
00:39:34
him why it wasn't really saying seemed
00:39:36
like there was a lot going on in his
00:39:40
mind two weeks passed with no word from
00:39:43
Tim the Muller's first clue came from a
00:39:45
gas station in Lake City Florida 150 Mi
00:39:49
North on the day he disappeared Tim paid
00:39:52
for a tank of gas with his parents'
00:39:55
credit card the recall that Tim had been
00:39:58
traveling alone but traveling
00:40:02
where his family could only guess until
00:40:05
they received the notice from a car
00:40:07
impound yard in Georgia that is the
00:40:12
molers learned that 6 days after Tim
00:40:14
left home his car was found abandoned in
00:40:17
a parking lot just the block from the
00:40:20
Atlanta bus
00:40:21
terminal when we went to inspect the car
00:40:24
we did find his driver's license and
00:40:26
wallet
00:40:28
and um some identification in our credit
00:40:31
card which indicated to me that he
00:40:35
changed his identity and in other words
00:40:37
he wanted to start a new life from there
00:40:39
on I worried mostly about Foul Play and
00:40:43
was afraid that something happened to
00:40:45
him because we have no proof that he
00:40:47
drove his car from Lake City Florida to
00:40:51
Atlanta Tim molner left behind a tangle
00:40:54
of conflicting Clues on one hand he
00:40:57
didn't take any clothes with him perhaps
00:40:59
he had never really intended to stay
00:41:01
away and yet just before leaving Tim
00:41:05
withdrew nearly all the money from his
00:41:07
savings account he did however leave a
00:41:09
balance of $10 as though to say he might
00:41:13
someday
00:41:15
return I mean no matter where he is or
00:41:18
what he's up to it'd be great to see him
00:41:20
and just you know tell we miss him and
00:41:23
um you know kind of curious why he left
00:41:26
what have you I'm sure you know I don't
00:41:27
know what the circumstances were but uh
00:41:30
you know it' be great to see
00:41:33
him
00:41:35
update when this story first aired a
00:41:38
viewer recognized the clothing that Tim
00:41:40
was wearing when he
00:41:42
disappeared 10 years earlier the viewer
00:41:45
had discovered a body in the woods near
00:41:47
meron Wisconsin with similar clothing
00:41:51
DNA tests confirmed that the body was
00:41:54
that of Tim Muller police have no idea
00:41:57
what Tim was doing in Wisconsin or how
00:42:00
he died if you have any information
00:42:03
about the death of Tim mulner please log
00:42:06
on to our website at UNS south.com
00:42:28
[Music]
00:42:42
[Music]
