Search Captions & Ask AI

Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 10 - Updated Full Episode

March 16, 2022 / 42:48

This episode of Unsolved Mysteries covers a range of intriguing cases including a fake kidnapping gone wrong, a mysterious disappearance at a casino, psychic abilities following car accidents, and a buried treasure in Montana.

In Littleton, Colorado, Roger Dean was murdered during a staged kidnapping intended to extort $30,000. His wife, DJ Dean, received an anonymous letter from the killer demanding a ransom and threatening her daughter. The case took a turn in 2020 when DNA evidence linked a suspect, Michael Jefferson, to the crime.

The episode also features the disappearance of Gene Moore in Laughlin, Nevada. Her fiancé, Al Henderson, reported her missing after claiming to have dropped her off at a casino. However, surveillance footage contradicted his story, leading her family to suspect foul play.

Additionally, John Holland and Elizabeth Joyce share their experiences of gaining psychic abilities after surviving car accidents. Holland began making accurate predictions, while Joyce had visions that helped solve a missing person's case.

Finally, the episode recounts the legend of buried gold in Montana, linked to the corrupt sheriff Henry Plummer, who was hanged without revealing the treasure's location. Local treasure hunters continue to search for the gold, believing it remains hidden in the area.

TL;DR

A staged kidnapping leads to murder, a woman's casino disappearance raises suspicions, and two survivors claim psychic abilities after car accidents.

Episode

42:48
00:00:00
[Music]
00:00:04
next on unsolved mysteries
00:00:08
a man plans a fake kidnapping to extort
00:00:10
a ransom
00:00:12
but there's a hitch
00:00:13
his accomplice kills him
00:00:17
a woman disappears her fiance says that
00:00:19
he dropped her off at a casino but
00:00:22
security tapes tell a different story
00:00:26
two strangers
00:00:27
two separate car crashes both victims
00:00:30
say they became psychic after their
00:00:32
brush with death
00:00:35
a sheriff turned outward reportedly
00:00:37
buried six million dollars worth of gold
00:00:40
and the montana mountains
00:00:42
many believe that it's still there
00:00:48
you might have that one vital clue to
00:00:50
help solve one of our cases
00:00:53
i'm dennis farina and this is unsolved
00:00:56
mysteries
00:00:57
join us
00:01:10
[Music]
00:01:18
[Music]
00:01:29
[Music]
00:01:36
littleton colorado
00:01:40
it was an ordinary wednesday morning in
00:01:42
the neighborhood of roger and dj dean
00:01:45
except for the strange car parked on the
00:01:47
street
00:01:49
some remembered it was a 68 pontiac
00:01:52
others a 76 oldsmobile but everyone
00:01:56
agreed the man inside was a stranger
00:01:59
[Music]
00:02:01
at the time they thought nothing of it
00:02:03
but at the time roger dean
00:02:05
was still alive
00:02:10
roger called his wife into the bedroom
00:02:12
around seven that morning
00:02:14
jay come out here
00:02:16
what is it roger all right lady shut up
00:02:19
and get on the bed
00:02:24
the masked intruder forced roger to tie
00:02:27
and blindfold his wife
00:02:31
then he took roger into another room
00:02:34
as dj laid helplessly on her bed
00:02:37
she could hear roger and the gunman talk
00:02:39
but she couldn't tell what they were
00:02:41
saying
00:02:44
dj heard the gunman rifling through
00:02:46
drawers
00:02:58
at the front door he fired again
00:03:01
at point-blank range
00:03:04
[Music]
00:03:17
roger dean died
00:03:19
before help could arrive
00:03:23
from the beginning several aspects of
00:03:25
the case puzzled investigators
00:03:28
roger had twine marks on only one wrist
00:03:31
so it appeared that he had never
00:03:33
actually been tied up by the gunman
00:03:36
also roger was wearing contact lenses
00:03:40
when he was shot
00:03:42
yet strangely in an upstairs bedroom his
00:03:45
glasses were found covered with duct
00:03:48
tape
00:03:50
police believe that both the twine and
00:03:52
the glasses were red herrings
00:03:54
planted to give the impression that
00:03:56
roger had been blindfolded and bound
00:03:59
we believe that roger hired an
00:04:01
individual to come over to
00:04:04
basically kidnap him
00:04:06
take him to his bank withdrawal
00:04:09
thirty thousand dollars from their
00:04:11
account
00:04:12
and then obviously drop roger off some
00:04:14
place
00:04:15
so roger could report a robbery and he
00:04:18
would have that 30 000 to himself
00:04:21
during the investigation police also
00:04:24
learned that roger had taken nearly 30
00:04:27
dollars from his business and put it in
00:04:29
a secret account
00:04:33
on most weekdays roger left home before
00:04:36
6 15 a.m on the day of his murder he was
00:04:40
seen drinking coffee in his garage
00:04:42
at 7 00 a.m
00:04:46
what we make of that timing is that he
00:04:49
was waiting for
00:04:50
this individual to come and meet him at
00:04:52
his house
00:04:53
we also believe that the individual was
00:04:55
probably sitting in his car when roger
00:04:58
lifted the garage door which was a
00:05:00
signal for this individual to get out of
00:05:02
his car and walk over to roger's home
00:05:07
in my heart i cannot believe that roger
00:05:09
had anything to do with this
00:05:12
this is the man that i
00:05:15
was married to for 26 years and
00:05:18
yes there had been
00:05:20
personal problems
00:05:22
in the last few years
00:05:25
especially since the death of our son
00:05:28
but i knew the man too well
00:05:31
[Music]
00:05:35
after roger's death dj and her daughter
00:05:38
tammy tried to move on with their lives
00:05:40
but five years later they received a
00:05:43
chilling anonymous letter
00:05:46
incredibly its author claimed to be the
00:05:48
man who killed roger dean
00:05:53
the letter demanded 100 000
00:05:57
and if the money wasn't delivered he
00:05:59
threatened to kill again
00:06:01
do you know that i've met your daughter
00:06:03
tammy on a few occasions
00:06:06
do not make me kill her
00:06:09
your son is dead your husband is dead
00:06:12
do not risk your daughter she is the
00:06:14
last one left
00:06:18
i was in total shock
00:06:22
i mean this was like something that
00:06:24
doesn't happen to you this only happens
00:06:26
in the movies it makes me angry that we
00:06:28
had just started to get on with our
00:06:30
lives and put the past in the past
00:06:32
and it's all brought up to you again you
00:06:34
know this person isn't letting us
00:06:36
continue and we never did anything
00:06:38
to deserve this
00:06:42
dj and tammy called the police and the
00:06:44
fbi
00:06:45
they were convinced that the letter was
00:06:48
legitimate and that it was written by
00:06:50
roger's killer
00:06:52
dj and tammy were given round-the-clock
00:06:54
protection
00:06:55
the killer told dj that he would call
00:06:58
again
00:07:00
wait for the second ring now
00:07:04
fbi agents moved into dj's home and set
00:07:07
up a wiretap
00:07:09
hello
00:07:10
listen your husband owed me money and i
00:07:12
want my money
00:07:14
if my husband owed you money i'll pay
00:07:16
you what he owed you the fbi traced the
00:07:18
call to a phone booth in denver
00:07:21
call you tomorrow and i'll tell you
00:07:22
where to take it
00:07:23
but when they got there the killer was
00:07:25
gone
00:07:32
the killer called 12 more times
00:07:35
and then he told vijay to drive to a
00:07:37
supermarket 20 miles north of her home
00:07:40
and wait for further instructions
00:07:42
dj tried to trap the caller with the
00:07:44
help of an fbi agent hidden in her car
00:07:47
surveillance trucks and a swat team were
00:07:50
nearby
00:07:51
okay she's out of the car
00:07:53
and she's headed across the parking lot
00:07:55
now she's headed towards the phone
00:07:58
booths
00:08:01
i waited and i waited and i waited
00:08:05
i could not believe i was really having
00:08:07
to go through this chair
00:08:14
hello
00:08:17
the extortionist finally called and told
00:08:19
dj to leave one hundred thousand dollars
00:08:22
in an alley behind an apartment complex
00:08:24
in downtown denver later that evening
00:08:27
the fbi watched as dj made the drop
00:08:36
they waited until dawn
00:08:38
but no one showed up whether or not he
00:08:41
spotted something
00:08:43
whether or not he just took for
00:08:45
granted that the law enforcement was
00:08:47
involved or whether or not he got cold
00:08:51
feet and although he didn't detect any
00:08:53
type of law enforcement he just
00:08:55
was too
00:08:56
scared to actually make the pickup i
00:08:59
think all those are possibilities when
00:09:01
he didn't pick it up i was devastated
00:09:04
because i thought this is not over
00:09:09
there's nothing more that either one of
00:09:11
us want than
00:09:12
for this to be solved and now i'm gonna
00:09:14
hurt you he's still terrorizing us he is
00:09:18
still making us live a nightmare that
00:09:20
continues on and on all the time
00:09:24
in his last call the extortionist told
00:09:26
tammy he planned to kill her he said he
00:09:30
would strike when she least expected it
00:09:33
update there are new developments in
00:09:35
this case
00:09:36
and here's one of our staff with details
00:09:39
in 2020 dna evidence found on the killer
00:09:43
ski mask led investigators to a new
00:09:45
suspect michael jefferson jefferson was
00:09:49
arrested and currently faces charges for
00:09:51
first degree murder and kidnapping
00:09:55
next
00:09:56
how could a woman disappear from a busy
00:09:58
casino
00:09:59
24-hour surveillance cameras may provide
00:10:02
the answer
00:10:16
apple valley california
00:10:20
al henderson and gene moore seemed like
00:10:22
the typical couple in love
00:10:25
but they spent more than a typical
00:10:26
amount of time getting to know each
00:10:28
other
00:10:30
it took al 20 years to finally propose
00:10:33
to gene
00:10:35
she was very happy and we were making
00:10:37
plans for the wedding
00:10:39
she got more excited about it
00:10:42
with each passing day
00:10:45
however gene's children weren't nearly
00:10:47
as happy about the engagement
00:10:50
the longer i knew him the less genuine
00:10:52
he seemed i know he said that he loved
00:10:54
her many times but he also had a habit
00:10:57
of putting her down in front of other
00:10:59
people and to me that just didn't sound
00:11:01
like love
00:11:02
when your mother asked you to be nice to
00:11:05
somebody who they like
00:11:07
you go along with it even though you've
00:11:09
tried to talk like i did i tried to talk
00:11:11
my mom out of being around the guy
00:11:17
a few months after the proposal gina now
00:11:19
went on a vacation in laughlin nevada a
00:11:22
scaled down version of las vegas
00:11:25
it was there a few days later that al
00:11:28
reported jane missing
00:11:30
no one has seen or heard from her since
00:11:34
many people especially her children are
00:11:37
convinced that something bad happened to
00:11:39
gene and that her fiancee al was somehow
00:11:42
involved
00:11:43
what follows is al side of the story and
00:11:46
his account of the day that gene
00:11:48
disappeared
00:11:51
according to al they were just about to
00:11:53
check out of their hotel when jean
00:11:55
wanted to play her lucky slot machine
00:11:58
just one more time
00:11:59
he told us that he dropped her off at a
00:12:01
side entrance of a nearby casino and
00:12:04
went to find a parking place
00:12:07
when i did not find one then i returned
00:12:10
to the valet parking
00:12:12
can my wife pick up the car later thank
00:12:14
you
00:12:15
got the ticket
00:12:17
went inside the casino where gene was
00:12:20
waiting for me here's the claim check
00:12:22
for the car our plan was that we would
00:12:24
meet back at our hotel room at a quarter
00:12:27
of 12.
00:12:30
al claims that he left gene in the
00:12:32
casino at around 9 30 in the morning
00:12:35
once outside he planned to take a taxi
00:12:37
back to the hotel
00:12:40
there was no cab there
00:12:42
so after waiting a couple of minutes and
00:12:44
the cab didn't come i thought well it
00:12:46
would be nice i could go
00:12:48
play the slots with her a little bit
00:12:51
but al found somebody else playing
00:12:53
gene's favorite slot machine
00:12:56
i felt well because someone was there
00:12:58
playing it she may have decided to go
00:13:00
shopping or
00:13:02
some other thing
00:13:04
from a quarter of 10 to 10 15. i played
00:13:09
the machine that she liked hoping that
00:13:11
she would come back and i would be able
00:13:13
to get up and just say here's your
00:13:14
machine have fun
00:13:22
can you take these bags to security for
00:13:24
checking out
00:13:25
al checked out of the hotel around noon
00:13:27
and returned to the casino to look for
00:13:29
gene
00:13:30
when i saw that the car was right where
00:13:32
it had been left
00:13:34
and
00:13:35
i
00:13:36
spoke to the valet nobody had brought a
00:13:39
ticket for the car
00:13:40
then i began to become alarmed
00:13:45
al says he thoroughly searched the lobby
00:13:47
the shops and the gaming area but he
00:13:49
says he could not find gene
00:13:53
over the next few days al distributed
00:13:56
thousands of these flyers in the
00:13:58
laughlin area despite a 25 000 reward no
00:14:02
one called
00:14:03
after a certain amount of time i had to
00:14:06
figure that
00:14:09
something
00:14:10
terrible has happened
00:14:13
gene's children thought the same thing
00:14:16
but they are convinced that henderson
00:14:18
knows more than he's saying
00:14:21
the more we find out about what
00:14:23
supposedly happened
00:14:25
as compared to what can be verified the
00:14:28
less i'm inclined to believe that he's
00:14:31
telling the full truth
00:14:33
in my opinion al has not said everything
00:14:37
that had happened then
00:14:39
the reason i say that is because number
00:14:41
one the story has changed a couple of
00:14:43
times
00:14:45
al originally told police that he
00:14:47
dropped jean off in front of the casino
00:14:50
and gave her the valet ticket there
00:14:53
but al told us that he left jean at a
00:14:56
side entrance and gave her the ticket
00:14:58
inside the casino
00:15:02
within a couple of days or within the
00:15:04
day
00:15:05
you know i
00:15:06
i knew that he was involved or
00:15:09
in my heart i know he was in goal
00:15:13
police knew the casino had surveillance
00:15:15
cameras that monitored every square inch
00:15:17
of the casino 24 hours a day
00:15:20
it was time to verify al henderson's
00:15:22
story
00:15:26
al had said that a valet parked his
00:15:28
cadillac and that he entered the casino
00:15:30
a little after nine
00:15:32
surveillance tapes confirmed this
00:15:35
beyond this point henderson's story and
00:15:37
the surveillance footage do not match up
00:15:41
this tape shows two views of the area
00:15:43
where he says he gave gene the valet
00:15:45
ticket and where they supposedly walked
00:15:48
around
00:15:49
i have reviewed four of those tapes of
00:15:52
the areas that mr henderson said that
00:15:54
they were in
00:15:55
and the tapes that i have reviewed the
00:15:57
surveillance tapes that i have reviewed
00:15:58
we do not see genie
00:16:00
in any of those tapes
00:16:02
i can't really comment on that i can
00:16:04
only tell you
00:16:06
what happened i i accept no
00:16:08
responsibility for
00:16:10
what their tapes show or don't show
00:16:12
because i
00:16:14
am not an expert in that field i can
00:16:15
just tell you what happened
00:16:18
al also said that he had waited for jean
00:16:20
at her favorite slot machine
00:16:23
in examining the tapes for the time
00:16:26
frame i'll give us 9 45 to approximately
00:16:29
10 15. the machines that he told
00:16:32
security was her favorite machine we do
00:16:34
not see al playing those machines
00:16:38
eliola's response to that is that he was
00:16:41
evidently looking at the tape of the
00:16:43
wrong machine
00:16:45
i have checked with the
00:16:46
surveillance
00:16:47
personnel for the hotel and they have
00:16:50
advised me that this is the group of
00:16:52
machines that al
00:16:54
henderson told the security personnel
00:16:56
was genie's favorite machine
00:16:58
investigators began to wonder if gene
00:17:01
had been in laughlin at all eventually
00:17:04
they found a waitress who had served
00:17:06
alan gene on the day they arrived
00:17:10
other than the coffee shop we have
00:17:12
nobody uh
00:17:13
seeing
00:17:14
jeannie in the laughlin area
00:17:16
how
00:17:18
the question remained where was jane
00:17:21
between the monday saturday and thursday
00:17:23
when she disappeared
00:17:25
a few weeks later a witness came forward
00:17:27
with a possible answer
00:17:32
a friend of jeans claimed that she saw
00:17:34
the couple 150 miles away from laughlin
00:17:38
they were at a gas station in their
00:17:40
hometown of apple valley the day before
00:17:43
gene was reported missing
00:17:45
the eyewitness remembered the time
00:17:48
because they were enroute to a school
00:17:51
function that would been
00:17:53
only at that time and pinpointed the
00:17:55
time
00:17:57
and date
00:17:58
but al says they were both in laughlin
00:18:01
and there are phone records to prove it
00:18:04
i've provided several people with copies
00:18:07
of my telephone log from call usa
00:18:11
showing that i made a call from laughlin
00:18:14
to the victorville area at a little bit
00:18:16
after three on that day i had another
00:18:19
call
00:18:21
i think it was at 6 59
00:18:24
on that day so you've got
00:18:26
less than four hours and it's physically
00:18:28
impossible
00:18:30
even if all you did was drive from
00:18:32
laughlin and turn around and go back
00:18:34
you can't do it in less than six hours
00:18:38
phone records verify the calls were made
00:18:40
from laughlin on wednesday also al's
00:18:43
bookkeeper told us both he and gene
00:18:45
called from laughlin the same wednesday
00:18:47
evening
00:18:47
[Music]
00:18:49
and so we discussed various things and
00:18:51
then he says well just a minute genie
00:18:53
wants to say hi too so jeannie got on
00:18:57
the phone
00:18:58
and
00:18:59
she was just happier than happy could be
00:19:03
because she had run into a stroke of
00:19:05
luck on one of the poker machines
00:19:09
less than 24 hours later gene moore was
00:19:12
reported missing
00:19:14
unequivocally i had nothing to do with
00:19:17
the disappearance of gene moore
00:19:19
i
00:19:20
had offered the 25 000 reward i think
00:19:24
that uh
00:19:25
my net worth has gone down from around
00:19:27
two and a half million to one million
00:19:30
if i could get her back i'd give the
00:19:31
whole 1 million
00:19:33
i would do anything
00:19:35
to get her back
00:19:37
jean moore's disappearance has no
00:19:40
explanation
00:19:41
how could a woman simply vanish from a
00:19:43
crowded casino in broad daylight the
00:19:46
family says they won't stop searching
00:19:49
until they find the answer if you have
00:19:52
any information about the disappearance
00:19:54
of gene moore please log on to our
00:19:56
website at unsolved.com
00:20:03
next
00:20:04
can a traumatic car crash trigger
00:20:06
psychic powers
00:20:08
two accident victims say yes
00:20:21
can an intense trauma trigger psychic
00:20:23
powers that allow us to see things that
00:20:26
others can't
00:20:28
john holland and elizabeth joyce were
00:20:30
nearly killed in separate car accidents
00:20:33
which they say
00:20:34
left them with strange
00:20:36
psychic gifts
00:20:41
los angeles california
00:20:46
john holland's life is about to change
00:20:49
forever
00:20:52
[Applause]
00:21:06
john was dazed but not seriously injured
00:21:09
and then the following day he began to
00:21:11
feel strange
00:21:13
i started noticing
00:21:15
kind of like electricity building up in
00:21:17
my body like a i don't want to say a
00:21:18
power but it was more like a surge of
00:21:20
energy was building
00:21:23
i just felt that my body had too much
00:21:26
energy in it that's the only way i could
00:21:27
describe it
00:21:29
as a child john was interested in
00:21:31
psychic phenomena but it wasn't until
00:21:33
his accident that he knew he had a gift
00:21:40
at his work he was able to predict a
00:21:42
stranger's birthday
00:21:44
it would just come out of my mouth
00:21:46
straight out and i had to learn how to
00:21:48
stop that
00:21:49
john says his predictions became so
00:21:51
accurate that co-workers became
00:21:53
frightened of him
00:21:55
holland's boss eventually asked that he
00:21:57
stopped making predictions
00:21:59
i'm not out to prove anything okay this
00:22:02
is what happened to me this is what
00:22:04
comes out of me and this is people come
00:22:06
back and confirm
00:22:09
car accidents and other sudden events
00:22:11
that shake up a person's body and of
00:22:13
course the inner body called the aura
00:22:16
have on occasion caused that person to
00:22:18
become psychic there are a number of
00:22:20
cases on record there's also a case of a
00:22:22
man who fell off a ladder and
00:22:24
as a result became a well-known psyche
00:22:29
a few years after his accident
00:22:31
john began seeing clients professionally
00:22:34
he claims his powers intensified and
00:22:37
that he now could communicate with the
00:22:39
dead
00:22:41
a client named adrian who came to see me
00:22:44
and her dad passed away
00:22:46
sadly basically she wanted to know where
00:22:49
is he
00:22:50
what is he doing right now so what
00:22:52
happened her dad came and told me to
00:22:54
tell her to look in a book on the
00:22:56
bookshelves he wants you to be at peace
00:22:58
he described the bookcase he described
00:23:00
the location of a book and he said
00:23:02
and
00:23:04
there's going to be something a message
00:23:06
from your father in this book
00:23:08
and it
00:23:09
was unclear if he meant the book it said
00:23:11
he said no there's a message in it a
00:23:13
piece of paper a message from your
00:23:15
father that will let you know that he's
00:23:16
okay
00:23:18
it took two weeks
00:23:21
finally adrian got the courage to open
00:23:23
the book john was right inside was a
00:23:26
poem written by her father 28 years ago
00:23:32
john believes that if not for the
00:23:34
accident he would never have known that
00:23:36
the note was there
00:23:43
saddle river new jersey
00:23:49
elizabeth joyce and her son jeff
00:23:51
were badly injured in a car accident
00:23:56
elizabeth shielded jeff from the impact
00:23:59
but she suffered massive injuries
00:24:07
on the way to the hospital elizabeth's
00:24:09
heart stopped beating three times
00:24:13
and during those blackouts she says that
00:24:15
she was reunited with dead relatives
00:24:21
on the left was my stepson on the right
00:24:24
was my husband they talked to me with
00:24:26
their mind you have to go back you have
00:24:29
to go back
00:24:32
elizabeth survived the accident without
00:24:35
any permanent physical disabilities but
00:24:37
she was worried about neurological
00:24:39
damage
00:24:40
i started having a tingling sensation
00:24:43
across my shoulders and up my neck and i
00:24:45
started having blackouts
00:24:47
soon after the accident elizabeth began
00:24:50
having the same frightening dream over
00:24:53
and over again it was an explosion
00:24:58
i saw a house i saw a body i saw it go
00:25:00
out the roof i was aware of oil wells i
00:25:03
was aware of a trailer park and a fence
00:25:06
it was so real to me and in my head i
00:25:09
would hear your aunt died
00:25:11
she's in houston texas but elizabeth
00:25:13
didn't have an aunt who lived in houston
00:25:16
after having the dream every night for
00:25:18
three weeks she told her social worker
00:25:20
brenda hayes about it
00:25:23
brenda was amazed because the home
00:25:26
elizabeth was describing was actually
00:25:28
brenda's aunt's home in houston
00:25:32
and there had been an explosion there a
00:25:34
week earlier
00:25:35
[Music]
00:25:38
there was a pipeline explosion on her
00:25:40
property
00:25:42
and they haven't been able to find her
00:25:44
body
00:25:45
or find any remains
00:25:48
to identify what happened to her
00:25:52
i started to explain to her
00:25:54
what the setup was
00:25:56
and she said no wait i'll draw you a
00:25:58
picture
00:25:59
and it's uh white elizabeth drew the
00:26:02
house perfectly she then pointed to a
00:26:04
section of tall grass near an oil wall
00:26:07
where the body of brenda's aunt would be
00:26:09
found
00:26:11
jenny it's brenda
00:26:14
the houston police were called within an
00:26:16
hour they found a body it was brenda's
00:26:19
aunt
00:26:22
this wouldn't be the last time
00:26:23
elizabeth's newly discovered powers
00:26:25
would solve a mystery
00:26:27
when exxon president sydney j riso was
00:26:30
kidnapped from his home in new york
00:26:31
elizabeth joyce had a vision
00:26:34
she called the bullies
00:26:37
i'm not a fan of psychics and i've come
00:26:40
across many many psychics but
00:26:43
in this particular case with elizabeth
00:26:45
joyce i did find her to be very very
00:26:47
accurate
00:26:49
in black and white i saw a blond-haired
00:26:51
woman in a jogging suit running behind
00:26:53
the car falling and screaming for help i
00:26:56
saw the man get out of the car to go
00:26:58
over and help this woman
00:27:01
i saw a man come around from the bushes
00:27:04
i saw him grab this man that had gotten
00:27:07
out of the cadillac and put a gun to his
00:27:08
head and force him into a white van
00:27:12
i knew that it was visso
00:27:16
for six weeks elizabeth talked to the
00:27:18
fbi every day
00:27:20
giving them more information
00:27:23
i said they're putting him in a trunk
00:27:25
and they're taking him
00:27:27
off a main road and they're going to dig
00:27:29
a shallow grave and he said describe it
00:27:31
to me oh i said it's between two pine
00:27:33
trees it's in it's in the narrow space
00:27:35
between two pine trees and it's off a
00:27:37
main road either the garden state
00:27:39
parkway or the new jersey turnpike
00:27:41
the fbi won't comment on elizabeth's
00:27:43
information
00:27:44
however sydney reso's body was found
00:27:47
exactly where she predicted sydney
00:27:50
recess remains we're in a three foot
00:27:52
deep
00:27:53
sandy grave in the depths of the pine
00:27:55
barrels
00:27:57
elizabeth says that her information also
00:28:00
helped catch the killers i don't try to
00:28:02
ever convince anyone
00:28:04
that there is such a thing as psychic
00:28:06
sensitivity i let them find it for
00:28:08
themselves
00:28:10
i'm there to help others if they are
00:28:12
open to being helped if i can reach one
00:28:14
person
00:28:16
that it helps them change their life for
00:28:17
the better and they know
00:28:20
things about themselves more or if they
00:28:22
know that we all go on then i've done my
00:28:24
job
00:28:26
john holland and elizabeth joyce
00:28:28
continue to use their powers to help
00:28:30
others
00:28:31
do they really have psychic abilities
00:28:34
just ask the people they've helped they
00:28:36
certainly think so
00:28:43
coming up
00:28:44
innocent neighbors are caught in the
00:28:46
crossfire when a murderous husband
00:28:48
attacks his wife
00:29:00
talladega alabama
00:29:05
all right well thanks for the ride girl
00:29:07
give me a call early one evening
00:29:08
geraldine george a 36 year old mother of
00:29:11
two returned home from work
00:29:15
she had been separated from her abusive
00:29:17
husband larry george for six months
00:29:20
even though there was a restraining
00:29:22
order against him he continued to harass
00:29:25
her
00:29:27
that evening his obsession
00:29:30
turned deadly
00:29:36
geraldine went inside her apartment and
00:29:38
dropped her belongings off she walked
00:29:40
next door to janice morris's apartment
00:29:43
in ralph swain's apartment
00:29:49
geraldine was friendly with her next
00:29:51
door neighbor
00:29:52
janice had agreed to watch geraldine's
00:29:54
kids while she worked
00:29:59
all right say goodbye to everyone say
00:30:00
goodbye
00:30:02
she went in sent her kids home talked
00:30:04
briefly with janice
00:30:06
uh it was rather brief because janice
00:30:08
was on the telephone with her mother
00:30:11
geraldine after talking briefly with
00:30:14
janice walked back next door and as she
00:30:17
entered her apartment
00:30:18
larry george was already inside the
00:30:20
apartment talking to her kids
00:30:23
you know you're not supposed to be here
00:30:25
we've been through this before you want
00:30:26
me to call the police again
00:30:29
i want you out of my house i don't want
00:30:30
those people taking care of my kids you
00:30:32
don't tell me what to do anymore you're
00:30:34
gonna listen to me
00:30:37
put the gun away honey i want you to go
00:30:39
upstairs you call your granddaddy and
00:30:41
you tell him that larry's here come on
00:30:45
larry no now
00:30:53
[Music]
00:30:57
geraldine ran next door for help
00:31:01
janice was still talking to her mother
00:31:05
larry's next door
00:31:06
i heard a woman's voice yelling janice
00:31:10
janice
00:31:11
called the police
00:31:13
so i asked janet who was that she's that
00:31:16
girl just left out yeah what's the math
00:31:18
she said i don't know let me call you
00:31:20
back okay bye-bye and that's the last
00:31:22
time i heard her voice
00:31:29
larry george shot janice in the chest
00:31:31
before she can call the police
00:31:37
mary please stop
00:31:38
then in front of janice's two children
00:31:41
he shot geraldine as she cowered on the
00:31:43
floor
00:31:52
ralph swain heard the commotion and ran
00:31:54
downstairs
00:31:56
he was shot in the back of the head
00:32:04
then larry george calmly walked out of
00:32:07
the apartment
00:32:08
and disappeared
00:32:12
janice morris was pronounced dead at the
00:32:14
scene and ralph swain died a short time
00:32:17
later
00:32:18
this murder was stupid
00:32:20
i mean ralph or janice neither one knew
00:32:23
larry
00:32:24
they were simply in the wrong place at
00:32:27
the wrong time
00:32:29
geraldine george survived the shooting
00:32:31
but was paralyzed from the waist down
00:32:37
the next day sheriff's deputies
00:32:39
discovered a car
00:32:40
hidden in the bushes at a campsite six
00:32:42
miles out of town
00:32:45
it was registered to larry george
00:32:48
he had been living in the car there was
00:32:50
a lot of clothing in the car we found a
00:32:53
notebook where it appeared that mr
00:32:55
george had been keeping a diary as to
00:32:57
who came and went at his wife's
00:32:59
apartment and camouflaged clothing
00:33:03
i want larry joyce to pay
00:33:06
for what he did
00:33:15
update
00:33:17
after we air this story an unsolved
00:33:19
mysteries viewer claimed to have seen
00:33:21
larry george fishing on the banks of a
00:33:24
river in delaware
00:33:25
two detectives were sent to investigate
00:33:29
this is where we first encountered larry
00:33:31
george at right here we began a
00:33:33
conversation with him about fishing it
00:33:35
was at this time where myself and
00:33:37
detective pinky made eye contact and
00:33:39
identified myself as a police officer
00:33:41
larry at this time a brief struggle
00:33:44
ensued right about here we all three
00:33:46
fell to the ground here
00:33:48
we got back to our feet still struggling
00:33:50
and at that point we just turned and
00:33:52
threw lie into the water
00:33:54
george tried to run
00:33:56
but backup units quickly cornered him
00:33:59
finally he surrendered
00:34:02
at george's campsite police found a
00:34:05
generator a stove a spear gun and a
00:34:08
sawed-off shotgun
00:34:11
he knew he was wanted from her he wasn't
00:34:13
going to be taken alive if he would have
00:34:14
put himself in his hideout and if we had
00:34:16
discovered it he probably would have
00:34:19
gunfire and officers would have been
00:34:21
hurt
00:34:22
seven months after his arrest larry
00:34:25
george was tried and found guilty of
00:34:27
capital murder
00:34:28
he was sentenced to die in the electric
00:34:30
chair
00:34:33
[Music]
00:34:38
in a moment
00:34:40
the story of a fortune in stolen gold
00:34:42
hidden in the rugged hills of montana
00:34:55
we recently told you the story of an
00:34:57
escaped prisoner named robert gerald
00:34:59
watson who had been arrested for
00:35:01
kidnapping and rape
00:35:05
in tennessee's hamblin county jail
00:35:07
watson and two other inmates were
00:35:09
cleaning a common room known as the slam
00:35:12
area
00:35:14
when they were done they signaled to a
00:35:16
nearby deputy
00:35:24
during the struggle the jail's automatic
00:35:26
outside doors opened
00:35:29
one of the inmates was overpowered by
00:35:31
the deputy a second was captured later
00:35:34
that night
00:35:37
but watson made a clean giveaway
00:35:43
update
00:35:46
monroe county tennessee
00:35:49
a viewer tip led police to a remote area
00:35:52
of monroe county where they found robert
00:35:55
gerald watson he was charged with rape
00:35:58
kidnapping and assault
00:36:01
given mr watson already been on the run
00:36:03
for over two years and we've had no
00:36:04
leads on him gerald watson's arrest was
00:36:06
a direct result of the unsolved
00:36:08
mysteries program
00:36:10
when i went to knoxville to pick mr
00:36:12
watson up to bring him back he had made
00:36:14
major study but two in the car he said
00:36:16
yeah i seen you on tv he said uh i knew
00:36:19
you guys were coming in to get me
00:36:22
three months later watson was convicted
00:36:24
on all charges
00:36:29
he was given a sentence of 10 to 25
00:36:32
years in prison
00:36:38
[Music]
00:36:46
it was a legendary treasure buried in
00:36:48
the montana hills
00:36:50
or so the story goes
00:36:53
in 1863 a crooked sheriff and his gang
00:36:56
went to the gallows refusing to reveal
00:36:58
where they had hidden their stolen gold
00:37:01
it's a tale of murder
00:37:03
money
00:37:04
betrayal
00:37:08
bannock montana
00:37:14
when gold was discovered in alder gulch
00:37:16
montana hundreds of prospectors
00:37:19
descended on the town
00:37:23
riches were being made and people wanted
00:37:26
to get in on them
00:37:27
that's why
00:37:28
there was such a large gang of outlaws
00:37:31
around every mining camp
00:37:33
hey fellas we got company
00:37:45
in the spring of 1863 a group of those
00:37:48
outlaws known as the road agent gang
00:37:50
nearly wiped out the prospectors
00:37:53
it has been said they stole more than a
00:37:55
thousand pounds of gold
00:37:58
henry plummer the town sheriff was also
00:38:01
secretly the leader of the outlaws
00:38:05
henry plummer was an ex-convict
00:38:07
ironically he had just been released
00:38:09
four years earlier from a brand new
00:38:12
california prison
00:38:13
san quentin
00:38:15
henry plummer was a very pleasant
00:38:17
looking individual he was the only man
00:38:20
in bannock practically that always
00:38:22
tipped his hat to a lady when he saw her
00:38:24
on the street well you could call him
00:38:26
the consummate con man of his day
00:38:29
so he was able to con people into
00:38:33
thinking he was a confident man to be
00:38:36
the sheriff
00:38:37
and of course he knew that being a
00:38:39
sheriff
00:38:41
would give him a perfect cover
00:38:45
boys we got a stage leaving bannock in
00:38:47
two days it's full of gold and i want
00:38:49
that stage plumber and his gang targeted
00:38:52
miners trying to transport their gold to
00:38:54
a major railhead
00:39:05
it's estimated that in four months henry
00:39:08
plummer and the road agents killed more
00:39:10
than 120 miners and stole what today
00:39:13
would be six million dollars in gold
00:39:20
finally in december of 1863
00:39:23
the gang went too far
00:39:27
a local rancher found the body and
00:39:29
brought it into town
00:39:34
and that was enough for them they formed
00:39:36
a posse
00:39:38
and during the next six weeks the
00:39:39
vigilantes worked
00:39:41
picking people up giving them a trial
00:39:44
and we know they hanged about 22 men at
00:39:47
least
00:39:49
when the outlaws were caught they
00:39:51
started pointing fingers at each other
00:39:55
[Applause]
00:39:57
one road agent who was about to be
00:39:59
hanged identified henry plummer as the
00:40:02
gang's leader
00:40:03
i want you all to know that
00:40:05
henry's the one that planned all this
00:40:07
he's the one to run all the road
00:40:08
agents he's the man you want
00:40:15
[Applause]
00:40:17
the vigilante posse raced to plummer's
00:40:19
house
00:40:20
[Music]
00:40:28
plummer was marched to a scaffold that
00:40:30
ironically he built himself
00:40:32
but before he was hanged he made an
00:40:34
unusual request give me two hours and a
00:40:37
horse
00:40:39
i'll bring back my weight in gold
00:40:41
he made that mistake once
00:40:46
henry plummer died without telling
00:40:49
anyone where the treasure was buried
00:40:52
immediately after his death prospectors
00:40:55
started searching for plumbers buried
00:40:57
treasure
00:40:58
in the early 1900s two mysterious gold
00:41:01
hunters may have found it
00:41:05
they went into a local store that had a
00:41:08
vault asked if they could leave this box
00:41:10
in there all night
00:41:12
and one of the men stayed there riding
00:41:14
shotgun on the vault
00:41:16
the next morning they disappeared
00:41:19
nobody knew who they were where they
00:41:21
went or what they dug up
00:41:23
even if one box of plumber's gold was
00:41:26
found there's probably a lot more out
00:41:28
there
00:41:30
two local men scott jones and bill
00:41:32
chappie have been hunting for the
00:41:34
treasure for years
00:41:35
they're confident that plumber's gold
00:41:37
still lies buried somewhere in the area
00:41:41
nobody would bury all her eggs in one
00:41:43
basket
00:41:44
so it's understandable that he has it
00:41:45
someplace where he has access to it i
00:41:48
bet there's a thousand pounds or better
00:41:50
in different places maybe from virginia
00:41:52
city to bani
00:41:54
[Music]
00:41:57
perhaps the location of plummer's buried
00:41:59
gold will never be found if it was ever
00:42:03
there
00:42:04
at all
00:42:32
[Music]
00:42:47
you

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Most intense
  • 75
    Biggest twist
  • 70
    Most dramatic

Episode Highlights

  • A Chilling Letter
    Five years after Roger's death, DJ receives an anonymous letter from the killer.
    “Do not risk your daughter; she is the last one left.”
    @ 06m 12s
    March 16, 2022
  • The Disappearance of Gene Moore
    Gene Moore vanishes from a casino, leaving her family desperate for answers.
    “How could a woman simply vanish from a crowded casino?”
    @ 19m 43s
    March 16, 2022
  • Psychic Powers After Trauma
    Two accident victims claim their near-death experiences gave them psychic abilities.
    “Can an intense trauma trigger psychic powers?”
    @ 20m 06s
    March 16, 2022
  • Elizabeth's Psychic Predictions
    Elizabeth Joyce's visions led to crucial information in a kidnapping case. "I saw a man grab this man..."
    “I knew that it was Visso.”
    @ 27m 12s
    March 16, 2022
  • Tragic Shooting in Talladega
    Geraldine George's abusive husband attacked her, resulting in multiple fatalities. "This murder was stupid."
    “Geraldine survived but was paralyzed from the waist down.”
    @ 32m 37s
    March 16, 2022
  • The Legend of Plummer's Gold
    The tale of a crooked sheriff and his hidden treasure remains a mystery. "Nobody would bury all her eggs in one basket."
    “Perhaps the location of Plummer's buried gold will never be found.”
    @ 41m 59s
    March 16, 2022

Episode Quotes

  • This only happens in the movies.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 10 - Updated Full Episode
  • I was devastated because I thought this is not over.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 10 - Updated Full Episode
  • I would do anything to get her back.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 10 - Updated Full Episode
  • I let them find it for themselves.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 10 - Updated Full Episode
  • This murder was stupid.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 10 - Updated Full Episode
  • He wasn’t going to be taken alive.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 10 - Updated Full Episode

Key Moments

  • Murder Mystery03:17
  • Chilling Letter05:43
  • Casino Disappearance11:30
  • Psychic Awakening20:46
  • Psychic Insights26:23
  • Murderous Obsession29:17
  • Tragic Outcome32:31
  • Treasure Hunt36:46

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown

Related Episodes

Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 10
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:48
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 10
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 6, Episode 12
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:52
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 6, Episode 12
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 17
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 17
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 2 - Updated Full Episode
March 16, 2022
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
43:07
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 2 - Updated Full Episode
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 21
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 21
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 11
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 11
Unsolved Mysteries with Robert Stack - Season 1, Episode 3 - Full Episode
May 16, 2019
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
46:03
Unsolved Mysteries with Robert Stack - Season 1, Episode 3 - Full Episode
Unsolved Mysteries with Robert Stack - Season 4, Episode 8 - Updated Full Episode
March 16, 2022
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
45:17
Unsolved Mysteries with Robert Stack - Season 4, Episode 8 - Updated Full Episode
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 1, Episode 13 - Full Episode
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 1, Episode 13 - Full Episode
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 1, Episode 15 - Full Episode
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:49
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 1, Episode 15 - Full Episode
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 19
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 19
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 6, Episode 13
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 6, Episode 13