Search Captions & Ask AI

But is NOW the Right Time to Invest in the Stock Market?! - E96

December 18, 2024 / 55:44

This episode covers year-end reflections, investing strategies, and the question of whether now is the right time to invest in the stock market. Host Jesse Kramer discusses the importance of understanding market timing, diversified investing, and the implications of current market conditions.

Jesse begins with a brief year-in-review, highlighting the podcast's growth, including 51 blog posts, 46 newsletters, and 26 podcast episodes, resulting in over 41,000 downloads. He expresses gratitude for listener engagement and feedback.

The main topic addresses whether it is a good time to invest in the stock market, especially during periods of high valuations. Jesse emphasizes the significance of understanding why certain investment principles, such as dollar-cost averaging and index investing, are essential for long-term success.

He shares a listener's question about waiting to invest due to high market prices and explains the risks of market timing. Jesse discusses the historical performance of stocks versus treasury notes and the challenges of picking individual stocks, advocating for a diversified approach.

In conclusion, Jesse encourages listeners to continue investing regardless of market conditions, reinforcing that a disciplined investment strategy is often more beneficial than attempting to time the market.

TLDR

Jesse discusses year-end reflections and whether now is the right time to invest in the stock market, emphasizing disciplined investment strategies.

Episode

55:44
00:00:01
welcome to the best interest podcast where we believe Benjamin Franklin's advice that an investment in knowledge
00:00:08
pays the best interest both in finances and in your life every episode teaches you personal finance and investing in
00:00:16
simple terms now here's your host Jesse Kramer hello and welcome to episode 96
00:00:22
of the best interest podcast my name is Jesse Kramer today we've got a fun one
00:00:26
for you it's going to be a little uh end of year year in review of the podcast
00:00:30
shouldn't take us too long just a few minutes but then I'm going to dive into
00:00:34
an evergreen topic an important topic one that a lot of people ask questions about and really this is going to be an
00:00:40
episode that I hope that people can point back to and say ah there's a really comprehensive answer to the
00:00:45
question of well is now the right time to invest in the stock market whether it's because the stock market is doing
00:00:52
really well or on the opposite side of the coins there will be periods when the market will go through a bare Market
00:00:57
we'll have a a recession we'll have some of pullback and people will be fearful
00:01:02
of investing during those times is now the right time to invest in the stock market so I hope to tackle that today
00:01:08
and uh to explain a few interesting Concepts that are all interwoven into that question so that we can walk out of
00:01:14
here not only knowing the right answer of of how and when to invest but also why that's the right answer and and how
00:01:21
all these different puzzle pieces fit together before we get to that we do have a customary review of the week
00:01:26
today this one is from ljb ljb gave gave us a five-star review on Apple podcasts
00:01:32
and wrote in and said great listen this is a podcast I'm glad I finally stumbled
00:01:36
on to Jesse does a great job of taking the everyday mundane and common topics and making them applicable to his
00:01:41
listeners this is an easy add to the queue every time a new episode pops into my feed well ljb thank you for the kind
00:01:49
words feel free to reach out to me send me an email to Jesse best bestin interest. blog we'll get you hooked up
00:01:54
with a super soft t-shirt okay let's get into a little bit of a year in review
00:01:59
like I said short and sweet we had 51 new blog posts as of this recording it's
00:02:04
December 12th right now when I'm talking to you 46 weekly newsletters you know
00:02:08
since the baby was born sometimes I missed a week or I combined two weeks into one newsletter but still 46 weekly
00:02:14
newsletters you can subscribe to that on the blog homepage at bestin interest. blog about 2500 new subscribers to that
00:02:21
newsletter when this episode comes out we'll have had 26 new podcast episodes
00:02:26
every other week and total podcast downloads fantastic 41,000 downloads as of this recording we
00:02:33
only had 12,000 downloads last year so that's more than a 3X growth with dozens
00:02:38
of five-star reviews very very kind reviews uh lots of smart and exciting guests with all manner of financial
00:02:44
expertise dozens of your questions answered on our AMA episodes so thank you thank you thank you engaging with
00:02:51
you listeners that that's probably the best part about this project so please
00:02:54
keep the emails coming keep the questions coming they're great uh it gives me something fun and interesting
00:02:59
to talk about sometimes something that's fun and interesting to learn something
00:03:02
new for me that I get to dive into and learn about to preempt a common question that I get no I don't collect any
00:03:08
donations or subscriptions from you guys but instead what you can do is quite simple if someone in your life wants to
00:03:14
learn more about personal finance investing financial planning send them this podcast or send them the blog send
00:03:19
them a blog post or better yet albeit a little hypocritical of me please share my work to your network whether it's
00:03:25
social media Facebook Reddit LinkedIn whatever hypocritical cu I don't really
00:03:30
spend much time on Facebook myself or anything like that I try not to at least but if you're willing if you're so
00:03:35
inclined that's wonderful or another big source of 2024's growth here on the
00:03:40
podcast was my appearances on other Financial podcasts you know stacking Benjamin how to money choose fi catching
00:03:46
up toyi a bunch of other podcasts so if you listen to other podcasts where you think you know gez Jesse would be a
00:03:52
great resource for that audience I'd love it if you let me know about that or
00:03:56
if you recommend me to that podcast host what will next year bring here for the podcast well for starters some more of
00:04:01
the same I think a lot of the episodes are going to be you know similar I'll
00:04:04
I'll do some chitchatting I'll do some monologuing I'll explain some some
00:04:08
thoughts to you guys we'll bring on some expert guests to go deep on some things
00:04:11
that I'm less familiar with I will say though I get a solid amount of feedback
00:04:15
saying in short you know hey the more you talk Jesse the better I tend to like the episode it's very flattering thank
00:04:22
you very much I do appreciate it and so I might sprinkle in a few more solo episodes we definitely do more ask me
00:04:28
anything episodes I think those are some of the best received episodes out there
00:04:31
or at the very least I do want to make sure that the outside guests who I bring in I want to make sure they can really
00:04:36
bring the Firepower because I want to make sure that listening to this is worthwhile for you guys and hopefully
00:04:41
the the 41,000 and Counting downloads that we have so far this year will continue to grow and I do also want to
00:04:47
address one of the other goals of the podcast and that is the symbiosis with my professional life working here at a
00:04:53
fiduciary F only financial planning firm in Rochester New York in 2024 so far about 25 listeners have reached out to
00:05:00
inquire about working with me and for probably 20 of those people 20 of those families they just wanted a simple
00:05:06
review a couple hours of my time they're DIY planners they don't want any sort of
00:05:11
ongoing relationship with me they just want to pay me hourly or pay a planner hourly really just do a simple review
00:05:17
and that's about it now I don't do the hourly model I do ongoing work for an
00:05:22
annual fee with people who want an ongoing relationship with their financial planner ideally they want that
00:05:28
for years if not decades to come uh generally I work with people who understand you know a financial plan
00:05:34
isn't a static onetime thing but instead it's a dynamic plan and therefore it's
00:05:38
more than just a one-time engagement I generally work with people who either don't want to be diyers anymore you know
00:05:45
there's just twoo much for them to lose or perhaps they never really wanted to
00:05:48
be a diyer in the first place they just kind of stumbled into it I work with people who they want a third party to be
00:05:54
involved on behalf of their spouse that's a very common one one one spouse I work with will be a pretty Die Hard
00:06:00
DIY but for the sake of their potentially surviving spouse if something were to happen to them they
00:06:06
want to bring me into the relationship as far as you know the finances go I work for people who no longer want to
00:06:10
drive their own bus but instead want to focus on many of the other aspects of their life of their limited time left on
00:06:16
this Earth and so they'd rather Outsource their financial plan their Investment Management to me of course I
00:06:22
get that many people listening here probably most people listening here are diyers and I think that's wonderful I'd
00:06:28
be happy to refer you if you do want a a planner to help check your work I'd be
00:06:32
happy to refer you to one of many hourly planners who I know who I trust who do great work for their clients but
00:06:38
ultimately yes this year many of the people who approached me they wen't a good fit I was able to refer them to
00:06:43
someone who is a much better fit for me but five families this year who came through the best interest podcast they
00:06:49
did reach out to me and we started an ongoing financial planning engagement together what's interesting I think is
00:06:55
that three of those families Yep they're dedicated listeners whereas the other
00:06:58
two were referrals from listeners in other words a listener said to themselves thanks but no thanks Jesse I
00:07:03
don't need you personally but this person in my life who I know they don't
00:07:07
listen to your podcast but they do need your help and I trust you to help them so to me that's a huge win-win they're
00:07:13
getting the help they need it inspires me to keep putting this podcast out into the world you know helping people is my
00:07:19
job it puts food on my table and it proves out the business model if you will of the best interest podcast share
00:07:25
knowledge for free prove your expertise make it so valuable that people can't
00:07:29
help help but share it the audience will naturally grow as the audience grows yeah some percentage even a small
00:07:35
percentage of people might say you know what I need some professional help I trust Jesse at this point he seems to
00:07:41
know his stuff the snowball grows so thank you thank you thank you for listening thank you for your questions
00:07:46
thank you for sharing this podcast with others and helping it grow thanks for reaching out to ask for help for
00:07:51
reaching out to refer others who are seeking help one of my go-to sayings here is that a rising tide lifts All
00:07:56
Ships and I believe that the best interest is one of those Rising tides that is helping everybody involved and
00:08:02
now I want to present such a cool uh a very meaty investing financial planning topic to you today my hope is that I'm
00:08:09
able to do enough of a complete discussion on this topic today that it's going to act as an evergreen monologue
00:08:14
that will always be able to point back to and say oh you've got questions about
00:08:18
this topic well you should go listen to episode 96 of the best interest podcast and that topic is this question is now
00:08:26
the right time to invest in the stock market as I said I'm reping this you might be listening to this in December
00:08:31
of 2024 hopefully many of you are listening to this well after December of 2024 and heck for all I know the market
00:08:39
might crash next week but whether the market continues its Relentless climb or whether it crashes tomorrow what I'm
00:08:45
about to say here will still apply in other words the advice that I'm giving
00:08:49
here is if I may say so Timeless right it's going to apply it's just sound
00:08:53
investing principles that apply in a bull market and a bare market and everything in between if you're a diyer
00:08:58
you'll probably know the struggle and the complexity with this question is now
00:09:02
the right time to invest in the stock market you might have some of the answers such as well you can't time the
00:09:07
market or just lump sum your money as soon as possible or you might know that picking stocks is hard and yes all of
00:09:14
those statements are absolutely true but what I want to do today is explain and ideally explain really well why all
00:09:20
those things are true and how all those ideas fit together into one cohesive investing framework because in my
00:09:27
experience if you don't understand why the truth is the truth in financial planning or investing if you don't
00:09:32
understand the why and if you don't understand how those truthful facts all fit together like a puzzle then you
00:09:37
might be setting yourself up for a slippery situation when the world starts to cast doubt on the truth as you
00:09:42
understand it you'll be more likely to abandon your beliefs or put more directly you can say things like don't
00:09:48
time the market or diversify your Investments when the market keeps on hitting all-time highs it can cast out
00:09:54
onto that you know are you sure you want to stay invested right now despite the crazy all-time highs or when Nvidia
00:09:59
keeps on compounding higher and higher are you sure you want to diversify your assets away from Nvidia when US Stocks
00:10:06
compound higher and higher are you sure you want to own International markets when stocks in general are just crushing
00:10:11
bonds like they have been are you sure you want to own bonds understanding the why and the how Behind these types of
00:10:18
questions will make you what I believe is an invulnerable investor you know that is an investor who will not succumb
00:10:24
to fear who will not let short-term concerns overwhelm them who will not make short-sighted decisions that end up
00:10:29
causing a long-term impairment of their Capital with that Preamble I want to start with Lynn and I want to thank Lynn
00:10:36
Lynn is a dedicated listener and a reader Lynn inspired me today and kind of Lynn is one of my Muses here in 2024
00:10:44
inspiring articles about social security and the stock market and now inspiring this monologue today back in August Lynn
00:10:51
wrote to me and she said I'd like to move some of my money market funds into
00:10:55
an S&P 500 ETF but I'm waiting for the market to drop I don't want to buy in at
00:11:00
the all-time high especially because I'm earning so much in my money market fund
00:11:05
I wrote back to Lynn this is back in August I sent her some articles and just some thoughts in general and I explained
00:11:10
to her hey Lynn in short it might be correct for you to wait right now but historical probabilities dictate it's
00:11:17
probably not correct for you to wait and even getting the timing correct the gains that you're likely to make are
00:11:23
going to be probably pretty small and since that email well sure enough the S&P is up 8% not including dividends and
00:11:30
Lynn wrote to me again last week and she said Jesse it seems like you were right
00:11:34
with this market and I should have invested I'm personally against moving anything into the market right now
00:11:39
though the financial Independence Community it's all about being Frugal and buying into this super high stock
00:11:45
market feels like it's not Frugal at all for me how do you square that so that
00:11:50
sets the table for what follows here listeners in the remainder of this episode I want to explain two massively
00:11:57
important topics to you the first one is I want to explain why we invest in Diversified indexes like the S&P 500 in
00:12:03
the first place and why we try not to invest in individual stocks we'll take a
00:12:08
sidebar on the idea of beating the market and another sidebar into something called the efficient market
00:12:13
hypothesis maybe these are terms that are familiar to you but I want to go deep on them today and explain them well
00:12:19
so that you can walk away going okay now I really get it and then second I want to explain the concepts around timing
00:12:25
the market the explanation will include these little sidebar min explanations of
00:12:30
terms like Lum suum investing and dollar cost averaging and the cape ratio so first why do we invest in Diversified
00:12:37
indexes like the S&P 500 in the first place and why do we not try to invest in
00:12:41
individual stocks so one of the first lessons in long-term investing involves the challenge of picking single stocks
00:12:48
we're told to avoid searching for the needle and the Hy stack and instead just
00:12:51
buy the whole hay stack you know that's a John Bogle aism because it's amazing
00:12:56
just how rare the needles are the there's a study by uh Arizona State Professor Henrik bessom binder and it
00:13:03
perfectly illustrates the Rarity of the needles the needles being you know winning stocks and we'll cover some of
00:13:08
the highlights of that study today now we recently discussed on the best interest this idea of a risk-free rate
00:13:14
uh short-term us treasury notes provide that risk-free rate which is why T bonds
00:13:19
treasury bonds are frequently used as a benchmark against which other Investments are measured so in the study
00:13:25
that I'm going to cite here this professor Henrik bessen binder he asked himself how do individual stock returns
00:13:30
compare against treasury notes the the risk-free investment the risk-free rate and the answer is not well since 1926
00:13:38
four out of every seven stocks so over 50% four out of every seven stocks that have existed have underperformed
00:13:45
treasury notes the majority of stocks lose to the risk-free rate despite stocks having significantly more risk
00:13:51
than bonds so that's not a good thing right if we're taking on more risk in
00:13:55
stocks we sure hope to get better returns in bonds and for most stocks that simply not the case if you want to
00:14:01
outperform the risk-free rate picking individual stocks is a hard way to do so so we know that for out of every seven
00:14:07
stocks or about 57% have historically underperformed the risk-free rate and if we owned all those underperformers our
00:14:14
portfolio would look awful so let's start adding in some winners and trying to get back to even right how many
00:14:20
winners do we need to balance out all those losers that 57% of losers and the answer is well we need the next best 30
00:14:29
9% of stocks to get back to even if we take the bottom 57% which we're all losers and then we add in the next best
00:14:36
39% of the stock market then we would get to a point where stocks a diversified stock portfolio of those
00:14:42
stocks would have provided the same exact return as treasury bonds as the risk-free rate so that's 96% of the
00:14:50
total Market okay that's the bottom 57% plus the next 39% giving you 96% of the
00:14:56
total stock market for the past 100 years and you only would have received the same return as someone holding zero
00:15:03
risk treasuries so despite those sobering stats though we all know we've talked about it here many many times
00:15:10
that stocks in general the full stock market well it's crushed bonds over the
00:15:15
long run so far in this little part of the monologue we're certainly not seeing
00:15:18
it though are we well it turns out that the remaining stocks okay the top 4% of all stocks account for all of the stock
00:15:27
outperformance in the past 100 years years as compared to treasury notes if you didn't own that 4% sliver if that
00:15:34
wasn't part of your portfolio you missed out on all of the magic of the stock
00:15:39
market that 4% sliver that's the needle in the hay stack the other 96% is just
00:15:44
the hay most of which is actually rotting hay if only it was easy to identify those 4% of stocks that are
00:15:51
needles or at least maybe the the 39% of stocks that are better than the risk-free rate but it's not easy it's
00:15:57
quite hard in fact and we'll get into some this later academic studies of mutual fund performance again these are
00:16:02
professional stock Pickers those studies show that only about onethird of fund performance shows repeatability or skill
00:16:10
the rest of fun performance tends to be just luck most Professionals in other words don't necessarily discover their
00:16:16
needles it's more like they stumble upon their needles and stumbling Upon A 4%
00:16:21
needle a one in 25 stock that's improbable in and of itself the only way as far as I'm concerned to rely ibly
00:16:29
stuff your portfolio full of the valuable needles is to buy the entire Hast deack you don't necessarily need to
00:16:36
find the needles and you certainly don't hope that you accidentally stumble upon
00:16:40
them instead you need to guarantee to yourself that you own all of the needles and that's by buying a small sliver of
00:16:47
every single stock out there and yes buying that whole Hy stack does mean you'll also be buying the bottom 96% of
00:16:54
stocks too with returns only as good as the risk-free rate but you're certain to
00:16:59
capture the sought after 4% of stocks as well providing all of the outperformance
00:17:05
of the stock market and you might ask yourself like really is it that hard to find the needles well commenting on Bess
00:17:11
and biter study Jason zag of the Wall Street Journal wrote traditional advice on diversification says you should own
00:17:17
at least 15 to 30 stocks in order to reduce your risk but in a sequel to his research paper Professor Besson binder
00:17:24
found that a portfolio of 25 stocks still has a 64% chance of under performing the total Market super stocks
00:17:31
the needles are so scarce that you need to hold hundreds even thousands of companies to be near certain of matching
00:17:38
the Market's return in other words listeners small portfolios they miss too many needles the odds are stacked
00:17:44
against you you need to own hundreds or thousands of stocks to ensure you own those needles but by the time you own
00:17:51
hundreds or thousands of stocks you're essentially building your own Index Fund
00:17:55
so why bother going through the time and effort to do so when you can simply buy
00:17:59
an index fund with a single click that in short is the argument behind index investing especially in more efficient
00:18:05
markets like the US Stock Market the stock market has very few needles missing out on them negates the purpose
00:18:10
of Stock Investing in the first place your best bet literally is buying the whole hay stack here's a quick ad and
00:18:17
then we'll get back to the show did you know my written Blog the best interest
00:18:22
was nominated for 2022 personal finance blog of the year and it's been highlighted in the Wall Street Journal
00:18:27
Yahoo finance on CNBC I love writing especially when that writing is to share financial education and I usually write
00:18:35
one or two articles per week you can read them all at bestter interest. blog again the web address is bestter
00:18:43
interest. blog check it out I want to read you from an article about this phrase uh beating the market the whole
00:18:50
Hy stack that's the market and many of us have heard before that you can't beat
00:18:54
the market so I want to dive into that statement because on its face and to Fair it's a wrong statement but again
00:19:01
understanding why and how it's wrong and understanding the better ways to phrase
00:19:05
that statement is going to help each of you listening to be better long-term investors you cannot beat the market we
00:19:11
hear this warning all the time let's say it's the S&P 500 Index or the dowo index
00:19:15
or the NASDAQ or a total stock market index fund or something similar to that these people who say you can't beat the
00:19:21
market what they're saying is you cannot outperform a diversified pool of stocks
00:19:26
but if we peel back the onion on that guidance we Face two logical issues the first is there's an averaging problem
00:19:32
the Market's return is an average of many different stocks you can't have
00:19:36
every individual stock losing to an average of those stocks the logic of that just doesn't work second if my
00:19:42
stock picking strategy loses to the market as people might suggest then my anti- strategy should beat the market
00:19:49
you know if one person is losing well just do the opposite of them if they're
00:19:52
going long on certain stocks just go short on certain stocks those same stocks and voila if I lose you'll win
00:19:58
thus at least one of us has beaten the market so that was a quick little logical aside that shows that clearly
00:20:04
it's not true to say you can't beat the market it's an incomplete statement it
00:20:08
needs more details it needs more backup and it leaves people a little bit misinformed it's one thing I want to fix
00:20:13
today so yes you can beat the market but you need to understand how and when and
00:20:18
why and answering those kind of questions today will lead us to the following conclusion the question isn't
00:20:23
whether you can beat the market or not you can the question is why bother cying see thousands of people beat the market
00:20:31
every day every month every year some investors have beaten the market for decades it doesn't take prodigious
00:20:36
intelligence it only takes the right temperament so anyone who says you can't
00:20:40
beat the market they're misinformed but the first truth is it's quite hard
00:20:45
consistently beating the market is hard that's what the needle in the hay stack
00:20:48
has to do with right you need to find those 4% stocks or at the very least you need to ensure that you're in that 39%
00:20:55
part of the stock market that beats the risk-free rate and you need to really maximize your time spent there now
00:21:01
consistently beating the market though after any fees you pay well that makes it extra hard if fees aren't involved
00:21:07
it's possible to beat the market not easy but certainly possible when someone
00:21:11
else is managing money for you if they charge you a fee well that fee eat into your profits and since those profits
00:21:16
have been eaten well beating the market becomes even harder it's like in golf if
00:21:19
you begin your round with a few Strokes already on your scorecard it's still
00:21:23
possible to shoot under par but much much harder now truth number two about beating the Market is it's not 50/50 and
00:21:30
what I mean is you might think at this point so without fees 50% of stock Pickers would beat the market and 50% of
00:21:37
stock Pickers would lose to the market that is a logical conclusion assuming though that stocks performances follow a
00:21:43
normal distribution or a bell curve human height as an example forms a nice natural bell curve you get a standard
00:21:49
distribution with an average most people relatively close to the average and far
00:21:54
fewer people who are multiple standard deviations away from that average but stock performances do not follow a
00:22:00
normal distribution this is an interesting exciting and an important fact instead stock performance more
00:22:06
closely follows a longtail distribution most individual stocks perform worse than the average but a small number of
00:22:13
high performers beat the average to explain what I mean by that imagine I have 10 stocks in front of me nine of
00:22:19
those 10 stocks are worth $100 the 10th stock though it's worth $1,100 so I have nine stocks at 100 I
00:22:27
have one stock at $1 00 what's the average value of these stocks well if you followed my math the average value
00:22:33
of those stocks the total value is 2,000 and I have 10 of them so the average value is 200 nine of those 10 are only
00:22:40
worth 100 nine of those 10 are underperforming my average the one that's worth $1,100 well it's
00:22:46
outperforming my average so if I'm going to build a portfolio from those 10 stocks and I hope to quote unquote beat
00:22:52
the market I really have to hope I have some ownership of the one that's outperforming the average
00:22:59
that in a nutshell is the way that the stock market works and always has worked there's some interesting data I I cite
00:23:04
some data in this particular article from 1983 to 2006 tracking 8,000 individual stocks over that time it
00:23:11
showed that about 40% of stocks lost money over that time yikes 64% of stocks though underperformed the average okay
00:23:21
64% underperformed the index got beat by the market the remaining 36% of stocks outperformed the market so it wasn't
00:23:29
quite like my example of having nine underperformers at $100 per stock against one outperformer at 1100 per
00:23:35
stock but the same idea applies you have 64% of stocks that do pretty poorly you
00:23:40
have 36% of stocks that do so well that they bring the average up a couple other
00:23:44
interesting stats from that particular study for what it's worth is that the
00:23:47
mean average annual stock return over that period was negative 1.06% per year and that the bottom 75% of stocks had a
00:23:56
cumulative Total return of 0% in this particular study all of the positive performance from the stock market in I
00:24:02
think it was a 27 24 year period came from the top 25% of stocks okay so what does this have to do with beating the
00:24:08
market well the research tells us that beating the market is not a 50-50 proposition over this particular time
00:24:14
period a single stock only had a 36% chance of beating the market there are many bad to mediocre stocks there are
00:24:21
far fewer good to Great stocks so again if you're only picking a few stocks you're likely to miss out on the big
00:24:27
winners you're going to lose to the market if you're picking many stocks
00:24:31
well then you're simply going to mimic the average return neither beating nor
00:24:34
losing to the market you've just created your own index fund and that's why it's
00:24:38
hard to beat the market there's also a Luck versus skill problem in picking stocks the stock market as we've already
00:24:43
covered here it's a mixture of luck and skill it's notoriously difficult though
00:24:47
to discern between those two skill being a repeatable thing luck being the opposite something that's not repeatable
00:24:54
if you invest via active stock picking you'll face some scary questions like
00:24:58
have you recently beaten the market if not why are you investing in that way assuming you have beaten the market is
00:25:04
that skill or are you just lucky and then last I mean do you really have the knowledge and the skill to accurately
00:25:10
assess those other two questions it's a pretty convoluted spaghetti logical mess
00:25:15
in your head now the stock market is a notoriously efficient market and we should talk about what that means it
00:25:21
means that there are so many different investors who are armed with so much information about various companies
00:25:26
their stocks their earnings their futures that any single person cannot consistently know enough to know whether
00:25:32
today's stock prices are right or wrong whether the market is overvalued or undervalued whether today's smarter
00:25:38
decision would be to buy or sell it's just too hard to know that consistently
00:25:43
to know more than the market consistently that's what an efficient market means and thus the efficient
00:25:48
market hypothesis essentially States there's no such thing as skilled stock picking because that so-called skill
00:25:54
would suggest that someone does know more about today's prices whether they're right or wrong or at least that
00:26:00
some investor can outsmart the rest of the market with some sort of consistency now the efficient market hypothesis has
00:26:07
a lot of research behind it it's won Nobel prizes it's part of the backbone
00:26:10
of index investing that said it's not necessarily this iron law of Nature and
00:26:15
there are many smart people out there who find some pretty serious flaws in it Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger
00:26:20
perhaps most notably among them personally I think that at least here in the US Stock markets are mostly
00:26:26
efficient and that at least most of us those of us listening diyers simple investors we would do better by
00:26:33
believing that markets are efficient in other words you and I we don't have the
00:26:38
time the resources the knowledge or in other words the skill to consistently know more than the rest of the market
00:26:44
and any such skill is likely to be found in those who put in the most time in other words the 80-hour weeks of a Wall
00:26:51
Street Pro are likely to be more skilled than the 20 minutes that you spend watching my Uncle Jim Kramer on CNBC now
00:26:58
are you you sure you want to play that game against those Wall Street experts wouldn't the average return from an
00:27:02
index fund be simpler easier less stressful and more dependable to reiterate all this saying nobody can
00:27:09
beat the market is like saying nobody is taller than average it's a little bit
00:27:13
dumb but you'll notice that my tone has kind of changed over these last few minutes because yes you can beat the
00:27:19
market it's just a logical necessity but it's also complicated it happens less
00:27:23
than 50% of the time it's hard to repeat sometimes it's just luck you're invest
00:27:28
ing fees are probably going to reduce your likelihood of beating the market that's just basic math and even if you
00:27:33
do beat the market was it skillful was it just lucky if you're a DIY investor
00:27:38
is the time that you commit to that act of investing is that worthwhile and then
00:27:42
last are you smart and unbiased enough to even answer all these questions in the first place these kind of
00:27:48
complications all point in the same direction namely why bother trying to beat the market in the first place it's
00:27:54
not that you can't beat the market it's just not worth trying so one thing I
00:27:58
haven't really touched on quite yet so far in this monologue is why picking stocks is such an interestingly Hard
00:28:04
Exercise in the first place I mean it's fine and dandy to say okay most stocks
00:28:08
underperform it's fine and dandy to say only the 4% needles lead to all the outperformance over the risk-free rate
00:28:15
why is it so hard to find those 4% needles I mean surely there must be a way to do so because simply who's to say
00:28:21
whether a Stock's price is too high or too low or fair and for that we need to
00:28:25
understand how are stock prices reached in the first place they're BAS based on
00:28:28
two simple things how a company is performing its earnings and how much investors are willing to pay for those
00:28:33
earnings sometimes that's called the multiple the multiple can be thought of
00:28:37
as How likely do I believe that this company's earnings will continue into the future a simple example let's say a
00:28:42
grocery store is earning a million in profits last year how much would you pay for that store uh $3 million $5 million
00:28:49
$10 million well that's a three or a five or a 10x multiple and that number is going to be related to how confident
00:28:55
you feel that you could take over the store keep keep its earnings at a million dollars per year or ideally even
00:29:01
grow those earnings for enough years in the future so that you can get your money back and then some a Stock's price
00:29:07
works exactly the same way it's just a business just like the grocery store is
00:29:12
but it's easy to forget that fact and that leads me to a wonderful question I
00:29:15
once got from a client here who had about 20% of her money in Starbucks now 20% of your money in one company that's
00:29:22
a lot you could say it's a latte in one stock I'll see myself out after that
00:29:26
joke and for comparison Starbucks comprises about 0.20% of the S&P 500 now the S&P 500 should only be a portion of
00:29:34
an individual stock Holdings which are only a portion of an overall portfolio so to have 20% of your total assets in
00:29:40
one stock that's just way too much when I started explaining that thought process the client understandably
00:29:46
protested and she said Jesse there's a Starbucks on every corner in America why
00:29:51
would we sell it that logic totally understandable after all she's right there is a Starbucks on just about every
00:29:57
corner in America the premise is true but the client's conclusion therefore why sell Starbucks that doesn't follow
00:30:04
the premise and that's the logical misstep I'll dive into a good company
00:30:08
doesn't always make a good investment Now My Hometown Pride Kodak was once one
00:30:13
of the most visible companies in the world it would have been easy to sit there in 1985 and think man codak is
00:30:19
everywhere they own the global film Market the same way that GE owns consumer electronics and Sears owns
00:30:24
department stores why would I ever diversify out a Kodak well the share price went from $90 per share to zero in
00:30:32
about 17 years the stock market and economic history are littered with good companies going broke it's called
00:30:38
creative destruction and it's essential part of a healthy economy but it's
00:30:41
terrible if you happen to own those specific stocks now investor Peter Lynch is known for many quips but perhaps none
00:30:48
is more famous than his saying invest in what you know know what you own and know
00:30:53
why you own it unfortunately many investors interpret that quote as invest in what you've heard of and own it
00:30:59
because you've heard of it and what they've heard of naturally are popular
00:31:03
consumer Brands and companies with a high frequency in society you know those with many stores with many products with
00:31:09
long histories but what Lynch actually meant in his quote was the more familiar you are with a company the better you'll
00:31:16
understand its business and its competitive environment the better chances you'll have of finding a good
00:31:21
story that will actually come true you can't just know Starbucks because you
00:31:25
enjoy a latte or because you see it on every corner you must know its business fundamentals its competitors its
00:31:31
potential future Pathways the market doesn't care about popularity or frequency of its stores it only cares
00:31:37
about popularity and frequency in so far as those factors positively or negatively affect the objective
00:31:43
Financial fundamentals of the business riffing on that previous stanza Concepts like popularity and frequency they're
00:31:50
both Hallmarks of a company's past right the stores you see the brands standing
00:31:54
in our culture the companies here to for investment returns are all a function of
00:31:59
what the company has done in the past but the stock market is forward-looking the thousands of investors who buy and
00:32:05
sell stocks and determine their daily prices they don't care about the past they are quite literally trying to
00:32:10
predict a company's future they're pricing in that anticipated future into
00:32:14
today's fair value quite understandably most investors or at least many investors don't understand that they
00:32:20
don't do that they either shape their opinions based on the past popularity frequency past investment returns or
00:32:26
they react to current day new news and those are both mistakes the intelligent investor thinks about the future but any
00:32:32
statement akin to Well Company ABC will be great in the future that's a pretty
00:32:36
challenging statement to make accurately nothing against Peter Lynch but most of
00:32:40
you know I'm a pretty big fan of Uncle Warren Buffett who is famous for saying
00:32:44
it's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price even if
00:32:50
Starbucks is one of Buffett's wonderful companies is it trading at a fair price
00:32:55
most people including many investment professionals are terrible at determining what a fair price truly is
00:33:01
and price is a defining feature of any investment I frequently use the Honda Civic example to explain that idea is a
00:33:07
Honda Civic a fair car sure is it a good to Great car maybe would you be happy owning a new Honda Civic many of you
00:33:14
would say yeah sure I'd own a Honda Civic but would you pay $100,000 for a new Honda Civic no way it's not enough
00:33:21
to say Starbucks is a good company perhaps a great company that's a challenging enough statement on its own
00:33:26
we must go further and ask ourselves is Starbucks trading for a fair price and quite simply most of us are terrible at
00:33:33
determining what a fair price truly means at least when it comes to stocks and play along with me let's assume for
00:33:38
the sake of argument that my client was correct because Starbucks is everywhere it must be a good stock to own and it's
00:33:44
trading at a good price if that's true does it necessitate that Starbucks should still comprise 20% of their
00:33:50
portfolio or put another way is Starbucks one of the top five companies in America right 100% divided by five is
00:33:57
20 % are there only five good companies in America right I bet you could rattle off 10 equally recognizable publicly
00:34:04
traded companies in the next 30 seconds try it they're everywhere any way you
00:34:08
cut the cake or the biscotti a 20% position in one company is severely overweight in financial planning we want
00:34:15
to reduce our range of potential outcomes that's why we diversify in the first place having 20% of your money
00:34:21
tied to one single stock leads to a wide range of potential outcomes for what it's worth that client did listen to our
00:34:27
compy Council and has been divesting out of Starbucks at least as tax efficiently
00:34:31
as possible and that listeners concludes the first part of today's idea the idea
00:34:37
of why we invest in Diversified indexes like say the S&P 500 in the first place
00:34:42
and why we try not to invest in individual stocks here's a quick ad and then we'll get back to the show serious
00:34:49
question why do podcasters constantly ask for ratings and reviews yes they do help highlight our shows to new
00:34:56
listeners they help straighten just find us on Apple podcast and Spotify it's
00:35:00
totally true and a good reason to ask for ratings and reviews but I have something more important at least more
00:35:06
important to me I want to know if you like this stuff I want to know if you like my podcast episodes my monologues
00:35:12
my guests the information I share with you and the stories I tell I want to improve and make your listening more
00:35:18
enjoyable in the process so yeah I would love to read your reviews and sure if you throw a rating in there too that's
00:35:24
great if you like what I'm doing please share it with me me it's such a great
00:35:28
feeling to read your feedback I'd love to read your review or see a rating on
00:35:33
Apple podcasts or Spotify thank you now for the second part of today's idea I
00:35:39
want to explain the concepts around timing the market this explanation will include little sidebars like lump sum
00:35:45
investing dollar cost averaging the PE Ratio or the cape ratio so going back to Lynn's question Lyn's original question
00:35:52
it makes so much sense right with the market at all-time highs right now like it is here on December 12 of 2024 why is
00:36:00
right now a good time to invest right surely we should be buying low and selling high but you want me to buy High
00:36:06
you want me to buy at an all-time high okay first I want to explain the cape ratio Cape cyclically adjusted price to
00:36:13
earnings it's very much related to the price to earnings ratio which I think we
00:36:16
touched on before it's a way of measuring what stocks are selling for their price against how well those
00:36:21
companies are doing financially their earnings and the cape ratio is smoothed out over time to account for inflation
00:36:28
that's the cyclically adjusted part of it capap cyclically adjusted price to
00:36:33
earnings ratio now logically speaking Lynn has a pretty good point here we know that the S&P 500 price is at an
00:36:39
all-time high and we know that price is one of the great equalizers in determining if an investment is good or
00:36:44
not right our Honda Civic example or the hamburger example are Burgers good yeah
00:36:49
hamburgers are good would I pay $100 for a hamburger no I wouldn't price matters
00:36:54
okay quality is one thing but price is important too torically the S&P 500 Cape
00:36:59
ratio oscillates between 10 and 25 and generally though not always the lower the PE the better the forward-looking
00:37:07
investment opportunity that makes intuitive sense or at least I think it should the lower the price that I'm
00:37:13
purchasing my investment the better my long-term returns will be but does that mean that we should avoid investing in
00:37:20
any sort of stock market altogether simply because the PE the price to earnings or the cape ratio is high the
00:37:27
answer there's no not really just because the cape ratio is high it still might be smart to invest and we're going
00:37:33
to link something in the show notes an article I wrote called timing the future Market Cape versus future returns and in
00:37:40
that article you'll see some pretty interesting graphs that I put together where we could point to plenty of times
00:37:45
where the cape ratio was 25 or 30 very much on the high end and the future inflation adjusted 10 year returns or 20
00:37:52
or 30 year returns were a perfectly normal and acceptable five six 7 8% just because the cape ratio is high there is
00:38:01
no Golden Rule stating that you must avoid investing for reference right now as of this recording the cape ratio is
00:38:08
at 38 which is very very high by historical standards and again going back to Lynn's point if I'm paying a
00:38:15
very very high price for the stock market compared to historical standards surely that can't be a good thing surely
00:38:21
I must be spending $100,000 on a Honda Civic right now well I hear you Lyn now the cape ratio hasn't been below 25
00:38:30
since the year 2014 and that has some people seriously concerned are we in this massive 10-year bubble of high
00:38:37
valuations and at some point is that bubble going to pop maybe I might not know enough to have an answer that
00:38:43
question but I do know the counterargument here I think it makes a lot of sense and I'm going to try to lay
00:38:48
it out Simply 100 years ago the American economy was pretty Hands-On manufacturing production factories
00:38:55
buildings stuff that is expensive to make and expensive to scale meaning if Ford let's say Ford wanted to double its
00:39:01
car creation capacity it had to buy new land and build new factories and train new people and put in new assembly lines
00:39:09
and all of that is really expensive for a company to do and It ultimately eats into that company's earnings and growth
00:39:15
in other words it was really hard for those kind of companies to rapidly expand their profit margins but today
00:39:23
many of our biggest companies work much differently than that if Microsoft wants
00:39:27
to sell 20% more office licenses they don't need any additional Capital overhead to do so they just sell more
00:39:34
licenses many companies in today's digital age they work the same or at least very similar ways to Microsoft
00:39:41
right they don't have these massive Capital requirements to grow like the ones that existed 30 or 50 or 100 years
00:39:46
ago and as such those companies can grow their earnings much faster than historical standards and if that's true
00:39:53
maybe I am perfectly okay to pay a 38 times Cape ratio today because I believe the earnings portion of that equation is
00:40:00
likely to rapidly increase in the coming years turning today's price into quite
00:40:04
the bargain the point being that while the cape Ratio or the PE Ratio is generally helpful it's not necessarily
00:40:11
smart to believe that the PE ratios of the 1950s ought to instruct how we invest today and then going back to the
00:40:17
main point of today just because a PE ratio is high we can still have strong long-term future returns going forward
00:40:25
it's hard to time the stock market based on PE r ratio alone instead there are a
00:40:29
couple simple tried andrue techniques when it comes to investing your money into the stock market probably some
00:40:34
things that you might have heard of before to start I want to tell you a story from 2022 which was in the middle
00:40:39
of a bad year for both stocks and bonds and those kind of bare markets they make
00:40:43
you question should I just wait for the bottom before I invest and reader of the
00:40:47
blog pulson he wrote in during that year and he said Jesse I'm not tempted to
00:40:51
sell anything in my 401k or Roth IRA but I don't know why I should continue buying at least not at this point with
00:40:57
the market doing what it's doing it's not going up anytime soon can I contribute money to those accounts as
00:41:02
cash and then wait to invest once the market hits its bottom it was a great question and yeah you could try pson you
00:41:08
know that's what I responded to him but I don't think he should and there are a
00:41:11
few reasons why and these reasons apply to you listening today because timing the market in the way that pulson
00:41:16
suggested first it barely affects your future portfolio second it's really hard
00:41:21
to execute well and third it makes your life demonstrably worse along the way so
00:41:27
here's a story of three hypothetical fictional investors mostly they're identical investors we've got normal
00:41:33
Nick we've got good timing Gary we have bad timing bill normal Nick good timing
00:41:38
Gary bad timing Bill all three investors started their investing in 1985 when they were 22 years old they're now 59
00:41:45
and they're approaching retirement and some other facts about them all three of
00:41:48
them used the S&P 500 index funds for their stock Investments all three invested $200 a month in 1985 and then
00:41:55
increased their contributions by 5% per year until today so now they invest around $1,200 a month and all three
00:42:02
invest via dollar cost averaging we'll dive into that term in a couple minutes
00:42:06
the point being is they invest whether the markets are high they invest whether the markets are low and they buy in
00:42:12
between as well except for one time now during the great financial crisis that threw a small wrench into their plans
00:42:18
Nick normal Nick well he stayed the course and continued his monthly contributions but Bill and Gary they
00:42:24
wanted to try something different good time and Gary with his good timing he managed to time the market perfectly he
00:42:30
stopped investing just like Paulson wants to with the question that inspired this article Gary stopped investing at
00:42:35
the market top in 2007 he saved all his cash he then perfectly timed the market bottom in March of 2009 deploying all of
00:42:43
his cash into the stock market so he timed the market to Perfection twice he stopped investing at the perfect top and
00:42:50
then he began investing again at the perfect bottom bad timing Bill also timed the market top with Gary but when
00:42:57
the the true bottom hit in March 2009 bill was convinced that there was more room to drop so as the market recovered
00:43:02
Bill waited and waited and waited he thought a new bottom would eventually come so he didn't deploy his cash until
00:43:08
2013 when the market price had fully recovered to 2007 levels and his wise wife screamed at him to get back into
00:43:14
the market now fast forward I wrote this article in 2022 how different were Nicks
00:43:19
and Gary's and Bill's portfolio at that point well Gary was best after all he
00:43:23
timed the market perfectly twice and he had 1.46 million bill was worst after all he missed many
00:43:30
buying opportunities for about 5 years but he had $1.38 million and then Nick was right in the middle at $1.42 million
00:43:39
so again Gary with the best perfect timing 1.46 bill with the worst 1.38 and Nick in the middle at
00:43:47
1.42 the perfect Market timing around 2008 which was a huge crisis right that got Gary a 3% Edge over normal Nick and
00:43:56
Bill mess up big time yet Gary only has a 6% Edge over him in the long run Gary's perfect Market timing wasn't
00:44:04
actually that important now notably though Bill and Gary when they chose to time the market they didn't sell any of
00:44:11
their old Investments all they did was choose not to buy new Investments if they had sold their old Investments
00:44:18
though and then re-bought later our conclusion would be much different bill would have lost another 20% of his total
00:44:24
portfolio as of today despite perfectly timing the market top okay he sold at the perfect time but because he didn't
00:44:32
buy back in until it was three or four years too late his portfolio would be down about 20% today and Gary who was
00:44:39
perfect twice at the top at the bottom his portfolio would be about 50% higher today so it just goes to show if you're
00:44:46
only perfect once with Market timing you could be down 20% like bad timing bill you have to be perfect twice like Gary
00:44:56
to actually be up up a large amount and that begs a question do you feel that lucky personally I like where normal
00:45:02
Nick is at he didn't worry at all about timing the market zero skill zero luck
00:45:07
and also zero stress he just kept on buying and he's in a great place this is
00:45:11
a scenario where the juice simply isn't worth the squeeze the squeeze again is
00:45:16
double Perfection you have to be right twice if you manage to be right the first time ceasing your buys before the
00:45:22
market bottom you'll likely be plagued by bad timing bills issue when Market is
00:45:27
at Peak pessimism right when the market is truly at the bottom that's Peak pessimism do you have the skill and the
00:45:33
knowledge and the balls of steel to deploy your money into that market or are you a dumb wouldbe Market timer like
00:45:40
the rest of us are and then what's the juice you get for that squeeze well it's
00:45:44
a 3% boost on your final portfolio or maybe this time will be different maybe you'll get a five or six or a s% boost
00:45:50
on your final portfolio and while your money is out of the market sitting on the sidelines what will you be thinking
00:45:57
are you just going to be chilled out and relaxed with ice in your veins or are you going to be a nervous wreck worried
00:46:02
about when to get back into the market not only can this squeeze cost you money but its psychological cost is
00:46:07
unavoidable Gary sure he gained 3% but he also gained some white hair he was out of the market for 18 months 18
00:46:15
months is a really long time are you willing to wait 6 12 18 24 months or more for a bare Market to end now
00:46:22
personally I'm not trying to time the market over that period of time I don't
00:46:26
want to sit on my thumbs and hope that I time it perfectly who knows how long it'll take for us to return to all-time
00:46:32
highs when the next bare Market hits I don't want to test my skill with timing
00:46:36
the market I don't want to test my blood pressure by staying out of the market so
00:46:39
that story introduces an idea dollar cost averaging many of us are doing it without even realizing it that term
00:46:46
interestingly it it kind of has two definitions though they're somewhat related the first definition of dollar
00:46:51
cost averaging is to make a series of investing contributions on regular intervals such as the way that many of
00:46:57
us might contribute to our 401K accounts every two weeks $500 comes out of my paycheck into my 401k and it's invested
00:47:04
into a Target date fund that's dollar cost averaging now the second definition
00:47:08
though it involves starting with a large sum of money and then making the decision to deploy that money into an
00:47:13
investment over a specific period of time now that in my opinion is a great idea for Lynn to consider today rather
00:47:20
than dumping 100% of her new investable money into the S&P 500 today perhaps she
00:47:26
decides to contribute 10% of that money every single month for the next 10 months that way if the market does tank
00:47:33
in February or whatever some of her money will benefit from that future price drop now both of those definitions
00:47:40
of dollar cost averaging share in common the idea that you're buying assets regardless of price that you're willing
00:47:46
to accept that sometimes you might buy High other times you might buy low and in the long run it's all going to
00:47:51
average out either way you are not timing the market that all said we should cover an interesting piece of
00:47:57
math and a term called lump sump investing in short if we look back on Market history would we be better off
00:48:03
taking that Lin approach of 10 deposits over 10 months or should we invest it all at once as soon as possible looking
00:48:10
back in history about 34s of the time you would have wished you made the lump sum investment upfront that should make
00:48:17
sense I think because if we look at Market history we can easily see that it has a terrific habit of going up over
00:48:22
time as such any sort of waiting to invest that we do well historically it's
00:48:27
worked against us the market goes up and if we're waiting it's going up away from
00:48:31
us in general if I knew that regret was not a human emotion I would always always always recommend that people
00:48:38
invest their money in a lump sum as soon as possible but regret is a human emotion and we must be aware of that
00:48:44
fact and it feels pretty bad to lump suum your investment today only for the market to go down next week therefore if
00:48:51
you're worried about investing Everything at Once then dollar cost averaging can be your friend allowing
00:48:56
you to slowly but surely get your money into the market over time depending on your level of hesitancy you could dollar
00:49:02
cost average for months or even years so that's how and why we should continue
00:49:07
investing even during froy markets like this one because we don't know whether
00:49:10
it's a bubble that's about to pop or simply another stair higher on a long
00:49:14
staircase that could go on for years or decades into the future here's a fun
00:49:18
fact though you know Lyn's thoughts right now understandably is the market is so high surely it's not a good time
00:49:24
to invest but I also got messages like one from Christina in March of 22 where the major part of Christina's message
00:49:30
was the market is down should I continue investing humans are natural worriers and it's funny that whether the market
00:49:36
is up or down people will worry about whether continuing to invest is smart Behavior but if we look at the
00:49:42
Historical track record we see that continuing to plot forward in our investments is a smart thing to do and
00:49:47
the list goes on as far as reasons why not to time the market for example in General market performance comes in
00:49:53
clusters as of this recording the S&P 500 is up 28% so far in 2024 about 20%
00:50:00
of that 28% came from the best four months this year the remaining eight months account for the other 8% of the
00:50:07
28% I could point to any Year and that same pattern would exist market returns come in clumps and the more I try to
00:50:13
time the market the harder and harder it gets to make sure that I'm capturing
00:50:17
those infrequent clumps for example if I look at weeks instead of months I see that 20 of this year's 28% comes from
00:50:24
the best seven weeks in the market if I look at days instead of weeks I see that 20% of this year's 28% return comes
00:50:32
from the best 12 days in the market the more you try to play around with the perfect time to buy or sell your
00:50:37
Investments the more likely you'll be sitting on the sidelines for one of those four important months or one of
00:50:42
those seven important weeks or one of those 12 important days and to be fair because you might have heard a similar
00:50:48
stat like that one before but I've never seen anyone discussed this that losses
00:50:52
are also concentrated too for example the worst 12 days days so far in 2024 are down a combined 22% so avoiding
00:51:01
those terrible days that's a good thing too right it is except for the fact that
00:51:05
we have more good days than bad days and usually the good days are more consequential than the bad days and
00:51:11
missing out on those good days it really really hurts if you don't time the market you'll always be in the game
00:51:17
during those good months those good weeks those good days and yeah there will be bad times too but zooming out
00:51:23
that's an okay trade to take all the good days to outweigh the bad days and this final point for you listening
00:51:28
has a bit to do with the efficient market hypothesis again but I want to re-emphasize markets are inherently
00:51:34
complex and influenced by a wide range of factors that interact in unpredictable ways these factors include
00:51:40
economic data indicators like GDP growth or unemployment rates or inflation or interest rates markets often react not
00:51:47
just to the data itself but whether that data aligns with or deviates from expectations the market is a function of
00:51:53
geopolitical events political instability elections intern AAL conflicts trade policies can all cause
00:51:59
sudden and unpredictable Market swings corporate earnings and News Right company specific developments like a
00:52:04
earnings report or a product launch or a management change can lead to a sharp movement in stock prices uh natural
00:52:10
events natural disasters pandemics breakthroughs and Technology can Ripple effects across Industries and markets
00:52:16
then you just have investor sentiment Mr market right human behavior plays a really significant role in Market
00:52:21
movements fear greed herd mentality can lead to irrational buying or selling and
00:52:26
that just amps up the volatility nowadays with technology you have Market feedback loops right reactions to an
00:52:32
initial movement can trigger further buying or selling due to algorithms and margin calls investor psychology
00:52:39
compounding volatility and then you just have random noise daily Market fluctuations result from minor random
00:52:46
events a rumor a small trade that are just difficult to predict is a little bit of the butterfly effect just not
00:52:52
tied to any sort of fundamental change because those factors are interconnected and can influence each other in
00:52:57
unexpected ways accurately predicting short-term Market movements is nearly impossible even for experts and that
00:53:03
unpredictability underscores why attempting to time the market is risky and why a long-term disciplined approach
00:53:09
often yields better results going back to ly's most recent statement it seems
00:53:14
like you are right Jesse with this Market I should have invested I'm personally against moving anything into
00:53:19
the market right now the FI Community is all about being Frugal and buying into this super high Market feels like it's
00:53:24
not Frugal at all for me do you square that well Lynn I'm right for now for all
00:53:30
I know the market could crash 20% in the first quarter of 2025 wiping out all the
00:53:34
gains since August and actually proving you right for waiting but more often than not as I've talked about here today
00:53:41
waiting like you've done won't have been a smart thing to do and if you are
00:53:45
proved right let's say the market does crash next month I'm worried it might
00:53:49
teach the wrong lesson and that lesson will be when my gut tells me not to invest I won't invest and if there's
00:53:56
anything I know about this world and the stock market it's that there's always a
00:53:59
negative reason in your gut to make you hesitate from investing and looking back
00:54:03
in time those gut feelings would have led to a lot of lost compound interest so if you've made it this far I hope
00:54:10
I've done a good job explaining why we invest in Diversified indexes like the
00:54:15
S&P 500 in the first place and why we try to avoid investing in individual stocks and second I hope I've explained
00:54:23
the concepts around timing the market or not timing the market Market really including dollar cost averaging lump sum
00:54:30
investing the cape ratio and those kind of things if you ever have doubts in the
00:54:34
future about whether now is a good time to invest I hope you'll come back and
00:54:38
give this a listen and again I want to thank you all for tuning in to the best interest podcast not only today but
00:54:43
throughout 2024 making it the best year of the podcast yet this is so much fun for me thank you for all the kind
00:54:49
reviews and ratings on Apple podcast and Spotify thank you for all the emails and
00:54:54
questions please keep them coming a very happy holidays to you and here's to a
00:54:58
terrific 2025 thanks for tuning in to this episode of the best interest podcast if
00:55:05
you have a question for Jesse to answer on a future episode send him an email at
00:55:09
Jesse bestin interest. blog again that's Jesse at bestter interest. blog did you
00:55:16
enjoy the show subscribe rate and review the podcast wherever you listen this helps others find the show and invest in
00:55:23
knowledge themselves and we really appreciate it we'll catch you on the next episode of the best interest
00:55:30
[Music] podcast the best interest podcast is a personal podcast me for education and
00:55:37
entertainment it should not be taken as Financial advice and is not prescriptive
00:55:41
of your financial situation

Episode Highlights

  • Year in Review
    Jesse reflects on the podcast's growth and achievements over the past year.
    “We only had 12,000 downloads last year, so that's more than a 3X growth!”
    @ 02m 35s
    December 18, 2024
  • Listener Engagement
    Jesse emphasizes the importance of listener questions and feedback.
    “Engaging with you listeners is the best part about this project!”
    @ 02m 51s
    December 18, 2024
  • Investing Principles
    Jesse introduces key concepts about investing in the stock market.
    “The advice I’m giving here is timeless.”
    @ 08m 49s
    December 18, 2024
  • The Argument for Index Investing
    Owning hundreds or thousands of stocks is like building your own index fund.
    “Your best bet literally is buying the whole hay stack.”
    @ 18m 12s
    December 18, 2024
  • Understanding Market Efficiency
    The efficient market hypothesis suggests skilled stock picking is nearly impossible.
    “Nobody can beat the market is like saying nobody is taller than average.”
    @ 27m 09s
    December 18, 2024
  • The Challenge of Stock Picking
    Investors often mistake familiarity with a company for a good investment opportunity.
    “A good company doesn’t always make a good investment.”
    @ 30m 08s
    December 18, 2024
  • Investing in Diversified Indexes
    Explains the importance of diversification in investing, especially in high-stakes markets.
    “Having 20% of your money tied to one single stock leads to a wide range of potential outcomes.”
    @ 34m 19s
    December 18, 2024
  • The Dangers of Market Timing
    Discusses the pitfalls of trying to time the market and the benefits of consistent investing.
    “It’s hard to time the stock market based on PE ratio alone.”
    @ 40m 25s
    December 18, 2024
  • Dollar Cost Averaging Explained
    Introduces the concept of dollar cost averaging as a strategy for investing over time.
    “Dollar cost averaging can be your friend allowing you to slowly but surely get your money into the market.”
    @ 48m 55s
    December 18, 2024
  • Investor Sentiment Matters
    Human behavior, including fear and greed, significantly influences market movements.
    “Fear, greed, herd mentality can lead to irrational buying or selling.”
    @ 52m 21s
    December 18, 2024
  • Market Timing Risks
    Attempting to time the market is risky; a long-term approach often yields better results.
    “Attempting to time the market is risky.”
    @ 53m 05s
    December 18, 2024
  • The Best Interest Podcast
    Thank you for tuning in to the best interest podcast, making it the best year yet!
    “Thank you for all the kind reviews and ratings.”
    @ 54m 46s
    December 18, 2024

Episode Quotes

  • Helping people is my job; it puts food on my table.
    But is NOW the Right Time to Invest in the Stock Market?! - E96
  • Your best bet literally is buying the whole hay stack.
    But is NOW the Right Time to Invest in the Stock Market?! - E96
  • Nobody can beat the market is like saying nobody is taller than average.
    But is NOW the Right Time to Invest in the Stock Market?! - E96
  • Invest in what you know, know what you own, and know why you own it.
    But is NOW the Right Time to Invest in the Stock Market?! - E96
  • Do you feel that lucky?
    But is NOW the Right Time to Invest in the Stock Market?! - E96
  • Accurately predicting short-term market movements is nearly impossible.
    But is NOW the Right Time to Invest in the Stock Market?! - E96

Key Moments

  • Market Timing36:06
  • Investment Psychology46:06
  • Investing Strategies46:42
  • Market Performance49:51
  • Investor psychology52:39
  • Market unpredictability53:01
  • Long-term investing53:08
  • Podcast gratitude54:46

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown