00:00:07
in October 2004 loving wife Rachel
00:00:11
O'Reilly returned home after doing the
00:00:14
school drop off less than 20 minutes
00:00:17
later she was murdered by her own
00:00:20
husband Joe Riley killed his wife in the
00:00:23
most brutal possible manner he hit her
00:00:26
across the head with a dumbbell several
00:00:28
times inflicted on unbelievable injuries
00:00:31
this was a cruel calculated model in a
00:00:34
horrific attack made to look like a
00:00:36
burglary gone wrong Joe O'Reilly killed
00:00:40
the mother of his children terrible
00:00:42
Legacy to leave those kids that's very
00:00:45
Legacy for the rest of their lives
00:00:47
mother was murdered and their father did
00:00:49
Joe O'Reiley reveled in the attention he
00:00:53
received as he paraded himself on TV he
00:00:56
went on The Late Late Show with rose to
00:00:58
make an appeal for whoever murdered his
00:01:00
wife to come forward or for people to
00:01:02
give
00:01:03
information he really was enjoying it
00:01:07
she knew the person because why else
00:01:08
would you kill her he enjoyed the
00:01:10
spotlight thank you very much as the
00:01:12
whole of Ireland watched on Joe O'Reilly
00:01:15
proved himself to be one of the world's
00:01:17
most evil killers
00:01:22
[Music]
00:01:28
[Music]
00:01:40
October 4th 2004 at around 5:20 a.m. Joe
00:01:45
O'Reilly left his home in null in the
00:01:48
north of County Dublin the married
00:01:50
father of two went to the gym before
00:01:53
heading to the outdoor advertising
00:01:55
company he worked for in the west of
00:01:57
Dublin City at 8:2 5 a.m. he left the
00:02:01
office again and arranged to meet a
00:02:03
colleague at a bus garage 5 miles away
00:02:06
in central Dublin he said they had to do
00:02:10
an inspection in Broadstone that day to
00:02:13
examine the buses and the advertisements
00:02:15
and he said he was there until 12:00 or
00:02:17
wherever he came back to his workplace
00:02:20
but O'Reilly never made it to the bus
00:02:22
garage instead he traveled 25 mil North
00:02:26
to his family home where his loving wife
00:02:29
Rachel was unaware of what her husband
00:02:32
had planned for
00:02:33
her Joe O'Reilly was an arrogant over
00:02:38
self-confident man with no
00:02:40
respect for anyone except his own
00:02:45
desires and the person who paid the
00:02:47
price for that was his wife
00:02:58
Rachel this killer Story begins in
00:03:01
County Dublin Island Joe O'Reilly was
00:03:04
born in April
00:03:06
1972 one of four children O'Reilly
00:03:09
didn't have the easiest of childhoods
00:03:12
Joe grew up in a Troublesome household
00:03:15
his father was an alcoholic and a robust
00:03:18
type of character and violent Joe would
00:03:20
have been subject to a lot of drunken
00:03:22
abuse by his father he had one other
00:03:24
brother and he had two sisters one of
00:03:27
them was very mentally handicapped and
00:03:30
physically handicapped and joah told me
00:03:32
himself my father come in and I could
00:03:34
hear him shouting downstairs where's the
00:03:36
monster where's the monster referring to
00:03:38
my handicapped sister and he come up I'm
00:03:42
going to kill that I'm going to kill it
00:03:43
I'm going to kill it now you know
00:03:45
according to O'Reilly himself he was the
00:03:48
doting Big Brother protecting his baby
00:03:51
sister from being harmed he said I'd
00:03:54
have to hop up out a bed grab the baby
00:03:57
out of the car and hide her under the
00:03:59
bed with me and he come in and he roared
00:04:02
and shouting and then he be got he says
00:04:04
that's what I had to put up with so I
00:04:07
would sympathize for Joan that you know
00:04:09
no one wants to see that type but he did
00:04:10
have a Troublesome childhood it wasn't a
00:04:13
comfortable upbringing it
00:04:15
was complicated and he did feel
00:04:18
responsible for his siblings but there
00:04:20
was also an hint of arrogance in that
00:04:26
childhood as an adult Joe O'Reilly was a
00:04:29
hard character to read with those around
00:04:32
him not knowing too much about him Joe
00:04:36
he was always very very aloof I don't
00:04:39
think any of us ever had a a
00:04:43
real understanding of him he never got
00:04:46
too close to any of us
00:04:48
um never stand offish it's just it just
00:04:53
never would have got to know him he just
00:04:56
seemed Shy Guy like
00:05:01
in 1991 O'Reilly was working in retail
00:05:05
in the center of Dublin City and this is
00:05:08
where he met 17-year-old Rachel Kali
00:05:12
Rachel and Joe met at a large department
00:05:14
store in Dublin he fancied her early on
00:05:17
and he he made several attempts to ask
00:05:19
her out but she wasn't willing at the
00:05:21
time but he he kept trying and she
00:05:23
eventually did go out room you know he
00:05:26
takes her to Paris and proposes on the
00:05:30
top of the Eiffel
00:05:31
Tower now I think that tells you an
00:05:35
awful lot about O'Reilly's vision of
00:05:39
himself and what he wanted he wanted to
00:05:42
put her on the back foot he should be
00:05:45
the great I am and I think that that's
00:05:49
the tone the background music that goes
00:05:54
through the entire
00:05:56
relationship from the outside Rachel and
00:05:59
Joe O'Reilly appeared to have the
00:06:01
perfect life they soon got married and
00:06:04
moved to the countryside in null County
00:06:07
Dublin Rachel seemed to be living the
00:06:09
life of her dreams her brother Paul
00:06:12
remembers it being a joyous time in
00:06:15
Rachel's life she loved the the country
00:06:18
living the country schools the she liked
00:06:22
walking the lane talking to neighbors
00:06:24
and stuff was a fine house and they just
00:06:28
seemed very happy out there
00:06:30
to us they had the perfect
00:06:33
marriage they were committed in many
00:06:36
ways but and here comes one of the
00:06:39
telling elements in this tragic
00:06:42
story he was an arch
00:06:46
manipulator he was one of those men who
00:06:49
turned off his affections and on at a
00:06:53
whim always putting the woman in his
00:06:55
life on the back foot it's very familiar
00:07:01
among arrogant manipulative men now did
00:07:04
that come from his childhood did it come
00:07:06
from the way he saw his mother treated
00:07:08
by his violent alcoholic father possibly
00:07:11
but certainly there's no doubt in my
00:07:13
mind that he was pretty misogynist in
00:07:17
his
00:07:18
mind there was no doubt that Joe
00:07:20
O'Reilly had little regard for women but
00:07:23
nobody could have predicted how his
00:07:26
marriage to Rachel would turn out
00:07:30
for Rachel the 4th of October started
00:07:33
out like any other day Joe had gone to
00:07:36
the gym 6:00 a.m. is and she' got up fed
00:07:41
and water the kids and dropped them off
00:07:45
to their play school in school and she
00:07:47
just came home
00:07:50
then around 1:30 p.m. Joe called
00:07:53
Rachel's family he told them Rachel
00:07:56
hadn't collected their youngest son from
00:07:59
the CEST
00:08:00
it would have been very very very odd
00:08:02
for Rachel not to her whole life was
00:08:04
based around the kids their
00:08:08
activities the thing everybody says
00:08:10
about Rachel she was a dedicated mother
00:08:13
her main goal in life was to look after
00:08:15
her children and she did that to the
00:08:17
best of ability she was a really caring
00:08:19
mother when she became a mother that was
00:08:22
her her big achievement in life although
00:08:25
she loved every other part of life I
00:08:28
think her two kids were the
00:08:30
the sort of Pinnacle of her life so it
00:08:32
was very strange when we got that phone
00:08:34
call that she had missed one of the
00:08:42
children upon receiving the phone call
00:08:44
from Joe O'Reilly Rachel's mom Rose knew
00:08:48
something wasn't right and headed
00:08:51
straight to the house to look for Rachel
00:08:54
what she discovered was horrifying the
00:08:57
back door was open the curtains were
00:09:01
drawn and she said that was very unusual
00:09:04
that they never do that and she went
00:09:06
into the house and she could see the tap
00:09:08
was running and the drawers were pulled
00:09:10
out and she could things see things
00:09:12
scattered around and she was shouting
00:09:14
for Rachel and Rachel and she made her
00:09:16
way down to the down to the bedroom
00:09:19
where she would think she would be and
00:09:21
yes Rachel was
00:09:25
there O'Reilly had encouraged Rachel's
00:09:28
mother to go to the the house for Rose
00:09:31
the devastating scene was one that no
00:09:33
parent should ever have to see she
00:09:36
couldn't even tell if Rachel was lying
00:09:40
face down on the floor or face up
00:09:42
because of the injuries inflicted on her
00:09:44
there was so much blood and her hair was
00:09:46
matted and she couldn't tell but she
00:09:49
knew she was
00:09:51
dead it wasn't long after them he mother
00:09:54
rang and
00:09:56
um we knew it was
00:09:59
it was a big
00:10:02
problem she didn't make a whole lot of
00:10:04
sense all she kept saying was she's
00:10:11
[Music]
00:10:12
dead Detective Pat marry was on duty
00:10:16
When A call came through of a violent
00:10:19
incident in null as I made my way there
00:10:21
there was messages conflicting messages
00:10:24
coming over the radio oh that lady has
00:10:26
been very badly hurt uh yeah it looked
00:10:29
looks like a burgy gone wrong then
00:10:31
someone says yeah no that lady I think
00:10:33
is dead like you know and I said my good
00:10:35
God news spread fast that something big
00:10:39
had happened and journalist Pat Flanigan
00:10:42
made his way to the scene when the crime
00:10:45
was committed the initial uh thoughts
00:10:47
were that was a burglary the house had
00:10:50
been ransacked drawers pulled out was
00:10:52
closed all over the
00:10:54
floor Detective Pat marry entered the
00:10:57
crime scene and what he discovered
00:11:00
horrified even this seasoned police
00:11:02
officer Rachel O'Reilly had been
00:11:06
barbarically killed it was really Savage
00:11:09
assault and that was shocking to me and
00:11:12
I've seen a lot of dead bodies and a lot
00:11:14
of ladies who have been murdered by
00:11:17
their husbands and in situations like
00:11:18
that but this was really horrific the
00:11:21
degree of savagery that was used to kill
00:11:23
her whoever done this to this woman
00:11:26
hated
00:11:27
her who ever did this had gone to Great
00:11:31
Lengths to cover their tracks and Stage
00:11:33
a fake
00:11:34
burglary I've been had thousands of
00:11:37
burgies and I know her a burglar and I
00:11:39
know when there's one a real one and not
00:11:40
a real one and this was not a real
00:11:44
burglar a mother of two had been
00:11:47
murdered in her own home in broad
00:11:50
daylight on the surface the crime scene
00:11:52
looked like a burglary gone wrong with
00:11:55
tragic
00:11:56
consequences but to the trained eye
00:11:59
there was something else at
00:12:04
play I know burglar I know how they
00:12:06
behave I know what to do they don't want
00:12:09
confrontation the first thing a burglar
00:12:10
will do he get into a house he go to the
00:12:12
bedroom he go to the woman's side of the
00:12:14
bed he look for all the jewelry he'll
00:12:17
separate the the uh costume jewelry take
00:12:20
the good stuff put in the pillowcase
00:12:22
gone we discovered also that there was
00:12:25
two lots of money in the house as well
00:12:28
which but now it was never taken like
00:12:31
you know so we knew that it wasn't a
00:12:33
burglary we just said like there's
00:12:35
something that right here like you know
00:12:37
Rachel has been severely attacked
00:12:40
violently blooding two skull fractures
00:12:42
many other bruises across her body this
00:12:45
is not just bang on the head and run out
00:12:47
the door if it's a burglar who's
00:12:49
frightened it's going to be one hit and
00:12:52
away this is not that this is an attack
00:12:56
which indicates rage and indicates to
00:13:01
premeditation the body was removed for a
00:13:04
postmortem at lunchtime forensic
00:13:06
examination of the house is expected to
00:13:08
last a couple of days while the Cali
00:13:11
family were hysterical with grief at
00:13:13
finding Rachel Jo o Riley seemed quite
00:13:17
the opposite it wasn't a grieving
00:13:20
husband he was just looking he was
00:13:21
taking in stuff he didn't act like a guy
00:13:25
who had just found his wife battered to
00:13:28
death and on the
00:13:30
floor Joe was standing out in the road
00:13:33
in his own he never engaged with the
00:13:35
Cali family or went up to the ambulance
00:13:38
to you know see what happened or talk
00:13:41
about the situation or give each other
00:13:44
hugs or he was just standing there like
00:13:47
a cabbo cut out standing on the road
00:13:49
there like you know and that was
00:13:53
it while the public still suspected a
00:13:56
burglary Pat Mar was looking at a
00:13:58
different line of inquiry later that day
00:14:02
he paid Joe O'Reilly a
00:14:06
visit we were wondering like what was
00:14:08
the story with Joe like he gives an
00:14:11
account of his day he said yeah I got up
00:14:12
at 5:00 in the morning he says O'Reilly
00:14:15
told the detective that he'd left the
00:14:18
house at 6:00 a.m. to head to a nearby
00:14:20
gym he was to meet a a friend a work
00:14:23
colleague there they both chatted uh
00:14:26
they showered and then went away is this
00:14:29
of course you know was to provide Joe in
00:14:31
Alibi O'Reilly who worked in advertising
00:14:35
claimed he'd then gone to a bus depot to
00:14:37
inspect some adverts and to meet another
00:14:40
colleague there he said he was there
00:14:42
until 12:00 or wherever he came back to
00:14:45
his workplace this Alibi provided Joe
00:14:48
O'Reilly with the perfect cover if true
00:14:51
he couldn't have been responsible for
00:14:53
the murder of his wife maybe uh I says
00:14:56
Rachel was having an affair and was some
00:14:59
woman got someone to give her a hide and
00:15:01
to tear her the back no no no he says
00:15:03
neither of us were having Affairs and I
00:15:05
just looked straight into his eyes and I
00:15:07
was about 2 foot away from him I said
00:15:08
Joe did you have an affair he says well
00:15:11
I did have an affair but it's all over
00:15:14
now he admitted that he had an affair
00:15:17
with a woman but he claimed it was over
00:15:21
and had been and himself and his wife
00:15:23
had SED wrote on the no back to be a
00:15:25
happy family I'd have been far more
00:15:27
surprised if he wasn't having an affair
00:15:30
given his personality and the way that
00:15:33
he liked to absolutely dominate
00:15:35
everything he would love an audience he
00:15:37
would love fans and that's how he would
00:15:39
see Affairs
00:15:44
really even after the murder Joe
00:15:48
O'Reilly maintained the facade of being
00:15:50
the loving husband regularly visiting
00:15:53
The Grieving Kali family at their home
00:15:56
every couple of days he drop in and
00:15:59
stuff me m used to make him dinners and
00:16:01
all but that didn't last very long
00:16:04
anytime he was in the house he was very
00:16:07
calculated very cautious didn't say a
00:16:09
lot just listened a lot he just wanted
00:16:12
to know information all the
00:16:21
time Rachel was buried one week after
00:16:24
her murder on the 11th of October 2004
00:16:29
Joe basically just washed his hands at
00:16:31
the funeral he he didn't want really
00:16:33
Anton to do it he didn't even want to
00:16:35
pay for his wife's
00:16:37
funeral the funeral was an opportunity
00:16:40
for the Kali family to pay their last
00:16:43
respects to their beloved Rachel the CES
00:16:47
were writing cards to put in the coffin
00:16:51
saying their last good boes and Joe was
00:16:53
in the house with them to give him a
00:16:55
card and stuff and he wrote what he
00:16:58
wrote
00:16:59
and put it in the coffin now she was
00:17:01
buried with these carrots it wasn't just
00:17:04
the family who were in mourning
00:17:06
wellwishers spread far and wide the
00:17:09
murder had sent shock waves through
00:17:11
Ireland and there was a huge public
00:17:14
interest in the case I covered the
00:17:16
funeral for the Daily Mirror at the time
00:17:18
and was quite a big funeral and very sad
00:17:21
that that the calile family were in
00:17:23
tears but Joe was uh seemed to be
00:17:27
removed from it you know as if it didn't
00:17:29
affect
00:17:31
him I suppose the day the funeral like
00:17:34
obviously it was very emotional day but
00:17:36
I think that's when he started going
00:17:38
into his kind of shiz mode it's he
00:17:43
really when he got up and did his eulogy
00:17:46
he was like it was like an Oscar speech
00:17:49
up there you know um like it was really
00:17:51
all about him you know and and he seemed
00:17:54
to love the attention and that was
00:17:57
noticeable
00:17:59
Even in our grief Joe O'Reilly was quite
00:18:02
a dominant and controlling person and
00:18:06
felt a kind of ownership over his wife
00:18:10
and over his children he certainly
00:18:12
represented himself as a family man it
00:18:15
didn't really follow that up with the
00:18:18
way he behaved in his relationship it
00:18:20
was more like well this is what I want
00:18:22
people to see me as rather than this is
00:18:24
what I really am Detective Pat marry
00:18:28
attended the funeral and had become
00:18:30
close to the Kali family over the course
00:18:33
of the
00:18:34
investigation their observations of
00:18:36
O'Reilly and the leadup to the funeral
00:18:39
had been playing on their minds I was
00:18:41
down in their house and we were talking
00:18:43
about things and they said oh yeah and
00:18:45
Joe was here sure you didn't care about
00:18:47
Rachel and we had to tell him to write
00:18:49
that note like you know and the
00:18:51
detective that was with me detector
00:18:53
Peter mcai the two of us looked around
00:18:54
at each other cuz we thought the same
00:18:56
thing what did he write in the note you
00:18:58
know you know and could it be a
00:19:00
confession there or anything like you
00:19:02
know with the Kali family's blessing
00:19:05
detectives made the difficult decision
00:19:07
to exume Rachel's body they were certain
00:19:10
that O'Reilly's note inside her coffin
00:19:13
could be the key to unlock the case
00:19:15
there was a five-page letter in it he
00:19:17
said it's the hardest letter I've ever
00:19:19
had to write in my life he asked for
00:19:21
forgiveness and he said it'll haunt me
00:19:24
for the rest of my life and uh I hope he
00:19:27
forgive me Rachel it's it's further
00:19:29
evidence that Joe
00:19:32
O'Reilly Is Not Innocent of the crime of
00:19:36
murdering his wife but at this point
00:19:39
there still isn't enough firm
00:19:43
evidence he was saying sorry for what he
00:19:45
had done and it's only him and she knew
00:19:47
about it uh but yet again it could be
00:19:50
anything else it was ambiguous and we
00:19:53
couldn't use it as you know strong
00:19:56
evidence more was needed to prove Joe
00:19:59
O'Reilly had committed the
00:20:03
crime as the investigation continued the
00:20:06
killer put on a horrifying performance
00:20:09
for Rachel's grieving family I know he
00:20:13
was given the house back after a week we
00:20:15
went out with him that day to help him
00:20:17
clean up the house and he had us listen
00:20:20
to phone messages for 20 minutes he made
00:20:24
20 different calls to her saying are you
00:20:27
dare I love you a concerned husband this
00:20:30
is not the behavior of a man with much
00:20:33
in the way of empathy it's the behavior
00:20:36
of a man who seeking to cover his
00:20:38
tracks O'Reilly then took the family to
00:20:41
the spot where his wife was murdered and
00:20:44
proceeded to act out how he thought the
00:20:47
killer might have ended Rachel's life he
00:20:50
knelt over where the body would have
00:20:51
been and reenacted how he would have
00:20:54
blud her whatever he buding her with he
00:20:57
then even Ste kept over an imaginary
00:20:59
body you know that wasn't there he also
00:21:03
went to the uh to the bathroom and said
00:21:06
explained how the the killer might have
00:21:08
washed his hands and heard her gurgling
00:21:11
and then went back to finish her
00:21:13
off Mary Cassidy who on the postmortem
00:21:17
and had viewed the
00:21:19
injuries had said to us in her report
00:21:22
and I confirmed it again with her what
00:21:24
Joe had enacted is exactly what she
00:21:28
believed the murderer would have
00:21:30
done based on the injuries of the head
00:21:33
and the body was laying it and all that
00:21:35
so here's Joe reenacted exactly what he
00:21:38
did like it was spooky not surprisingly
00:21:42
Jim and Rose are I mean literally
00:21:45
horrified how could they not have been
00:21:48
they are in the presence of someone
00:21:51
who's enacting out a murder and he's
00:21:53
only been dead a week or so for the Kali
00:21:57
family the disturbing truth about Jo o
00:22:00
royy was starting to become clear my
00:22:03
father was a little bit hesitant to to
00:22:06
jump to this conclusion but the other
00:22:08
three of us just
00:22:10
said he's just admitted
00:22:13
it we knew in our own hearts that he had
00:22:17
murdered Rachel and we just had to play
00:22:20
the waiting game then and hope to God
00:22:22
the the police could get him could catch
00:22:26
him
00:22:30
after putting on a sickening display for
00:22:32
Rachel's family O'Reilly was going to
00:22:35
take his supposed grief to a national
00:22:38
level for his next performance the
00:22:40
cameras would be rolling why go to the
00:22:43
extreme of murdering the person unless
00:22:45
they can identify him while the eyes of
00:22:48
the nation watched on Twisted Joe
00:22:51
O'Reilly was loving the
00:22:55
attention usually when someone is
00:22:57
grieving that gri they don't want
00:22:59
Limelight they don't want you know they
00:23:01
want to be left alone to grieve and
00:23:03
peace like you know members of the press
00:23:06
you know said to himself this guy is too
00:23:08
open because he was willing you know he
00:23:11
was over willing to to give his side of
00:23:13
the story gradually the tide torned and
00:23:16
you know suspicion torn on Joe just over
00:23:20
two weeks after O'Reilly murdered his
00:23:22
wife he made an appearance on one of
00:23:24
Ireland's leading chat shows with
00:23:27
Rachel's mom Kali murder happened was in
00:23:31
the bedroom which is the very last room
00:23:33
of the house so it's the room where
00:23:35
you're least likely to bring someone you
00:23:37
don't know because you're cornered he
00:23:39
went on The Late Late Show as a guest
00:23:42
with rose to make an appeal for whoever
00:23:44
murdered his wife to come forward or for
00:23:46
people to give information Rose is
00:23:49
clearly deeply upset and still grieving
00:23:52
for her daughter O'Reilly by contrast
00:23:55
seems incredibly relaxed
00:23:58
M was very uncomfortable with the whole
00:24:01
setup sitting beside him and to us was
00:24:04
very obvious at that stage that he
00:24:08
really was enjoying it like he really he
00:24:11
enjoyed the spotlight he was controlling
00:24:14
the narrative from the beginning he
00:24:17
would not have been thinking I feel
00:24:21
ashamed or I feel guilty about this he
00:24:25
would have been totally confident I can
00:24:27
tell everybody I didn't do this and they
00:24:29
will all believe me the bigger platform
00:24:32
I have to say that the more people will
00:24:35
believe me my view as well would be and
00:24:38
again it's just my view it's not a
00:24:39
police Theory it's it's just my own
00:24:40
personal belief is that she knew the
00:24:42
person because why else would you kill
00:24:44
her if it's a a violent robbery why go
00:24:47
to the extreme of murdering the person
00:24:49
if O'Reilly was hoping to put detectives
00:24:52
off the scent his Antics instead had the
00:24:55
opposite effect I can tell you now that
00:24:58
interview with Pat Kenny that night Joey
00:25:01
was suspect number one to everyone in
00:25:04
the
00:25:06
country but it was O'Reilly's Behavior
00:25:09
behind the camera that led to one of the
00:25:12
biggest breakthroughs in the case as he
00:25:14
spent a lot of time on his phone we
00:25:18
discovered the person he was on on the
00:25:19
phone was his lover and he went and met
00:25:23
her after the show and he spent a night
00:25:24
with her you know
00:25:26
after trying to be on a show to appeal
00:25:28
for information respect to the death of
00:25:31
his wife O'Reilly had told Detective Pat
00:25:34
Mary that the affair was over but it was
00:25:37
just another lie in the Killer's story
00:25:41
we had arrested the girl he was having
00:25:42
the affair with and she was in and she
00:25:45
was
00:25:46
questioned she said that they were
00:25:49
having an affair and it was a fullon
00:25:51
affair and that wasn't over having an
00:25:55
affair it's a motive
00:25:58
and was quite happy that we could
00:26:00
establish that motive so we have a man
00:26:04
who has if you like established for
00:26:06
himself the kind of perfect marriage two
00:26:10
children nice house in the countryside
00:26:12
outside Dublin good job progressing up
00:26:16
the ladder on the surfice everything is
00:26:19
fine he's got a new Lover he wants to
00:26:22
start a new life with her he wants to
00:26:25
make sure that he gets custody of his
00:26:27
children and so Rachel without knowing
00:26:31
is watching her husband plan what he
00:26:35
believes is the perfect murder the
00:26:38
murder of his
00:26:39
wife O's colleague who had provided him
00:26:43
with an alibi was arrested and
00:26:46
interrogated again about the mourning of
00:26:49
the
00:26:50
murder he was questioned at lint and he
00:26:54
eventually admitted look
00:26:58
I think I seen Joe at that stage but
00:27:00
what you're telling me I must have been
00:27:02
mistaken the colleague said he never
00:27:04
seen him at the bus garage where it was
00:27:06
supposed to
00:27:07
be Joe O'Reilly's Alibi had evaporated
00:27:12
he hadn't been at the bus depot that
00:27:14
morning the challenge now was to prove
00:27:17
he was at the murder scene instead an
00:27:20
examination of shoes O'Reilly had been
00:27:23
wearing that day led to a
00:27:26
breakthrough the Fric examin them and
00:27:30
they found dots of Blood on the inside
00:27:33
of the shoe on not along the side of the
00:27:37
shoe the drips came from above and down
00:27:41
which would have been synonymous with
00:27:42
him at the time he was standing over
00:27:45
Rachel or at the time he was killing her
00:27:47
with the weapon so we believed at that
00:27:50
stage that we had enough to arrest him
00:27:53
on suspicion of the murder of his wife
00:27:56
and which we did all the 17th of
00:27:59
November 2004 over a month after the
00:28:03
murder Joe O'Reilly was arrested and
00:28:06
taken in for questioning the arrest came
00:28:08
with something as a shock to the public
00:28:11
we questioned him and he didn't
00:28:13
cooperate he had no comment and we put
00:28:16
it about the shoes and that he had no
00:28:18
comment we put about the phone record
00:28:21
and him talking he I don't know I don't
00:28:23
get any recollection or he didn't no
00:28:26
comment to make you know so we didn't
00:28:28
have enough to charge him without a
00:28:30
confession the case against Joe O'Reilly
00:28:33
still wasn't strong enough the director
00:28:36
of public prosecutions told detectives
00:28:38
they didn't have enough to take O'Reilly
00:28:41
to trial we represented what we had to
00:28:43
the DPP and the DPP says no you're just
00:28:46
falling
00:28:48
short I thought we had enough they were
00:28:51
just a little
00:28:52
cautious O'Reilly was released without
00:28:55
charge with no new developments to rep
00:28:58
reports on public interest in the case
00:29:01
started to
00:29:04
dwindle there was a kind of dropped off
00:29:07
Sly dropped off the front pages and Joe
00:29:09
O'Reilly felt fairly secure that he had
00:29:11
got away with the perfect murder he
00:29:13
taught he was going to be a free man the
00:29:16
police carried on working quietly in the
00:29:18
background to try and prove once and for
00:29:21
all that oy was responsible for the
00:29:23
vicious murder of his wife Rachel as
00:29:27
detectives began to investigate they
00:29:29
found uh emails that that went between
00:29:32
Joe and his sister and they were very
00:29:35
very uh derogatory towards Rachel he
00:29:38
said the marriage was over Joe says I
00:29:41
can see it I'm going to be missed our
00:29:42
weekend Dad if we break up he wanted the
00:29:45
children he wanted her gone and that was
00:29:47
it and he knew the only way to get rid
00:29:49
of her was the Killer and he has to make
00:29:51
it look like a burglary he was quite
00:29:54
domineering and he did exactly what he
00:29:56
liked so I think it's fun far more
00:29:58
likely that his views on divorce were
00:30:01
you're not leaving me I will decide when
00:30:04
this marriage is over and that's exactly
00:30:07
what he did do detectives had to find
00:30:11
conclusive proof that O'Reilly had been
00:30:13
at the scene when Rachel was murdered
00:30:16
they scoured through hours of CCTV but
00:30:19
it was the cameras from the Quarry close
00:30:21
to the O'Reilly house that provided
00:30:24
valuable evidence we had Rachel she
00:30:27
drove her seen a car leaving her house
00:30:29
9:40 or something like that she was
00:30:32
coming back her car was coming back but
00:30:34
Joe O'Reilly himself drove a fat Maria
00:30:37
estate car and we had that car we
00:30:39
believed that car going up to the house
00:30:43
at 10 past 9 in the morning and it's
00:30:46
returning back at
00:30:49
9:59 so
00:30:51
between
00:30:53
945 and
00:30:56
959 that's when Rachel was murdered so
00:30:59
it sort of not ticked our box entirely
00:31:02
but it gave us reasonable suspicions to
00:31:04
believe it was Joe Riley's car you
00:31:07
know new technology was emerging cell
00:31:11
site analysis shows which nearby
00:31:13
telephone masks a mobile phone has
00:31:16
connected to every time a call or text
00:31:19
is sent or received a telecom's company
00:31:22
helped detectives analyze O'Reilly's
00:31:25
phone data from the day of the murder
00:31:28
they produced for us a a
00:31:30
map to show where Joe Riley's phone was
00:31:34
pinging off what Mass when he received
00:31:37
text messages and phone calls that
00:31:40
morning the data showed that O'Reiley
00:31:42
had left work traveled through North
00:31:45
Dublin to the house where he brutally
00:31:47
murdered his wife this was the vital
00:31:50
evidence Detective Pat Mary
00:31:52
needed so we can establish without any
00:31:55
shadow of a doubt Jo Ry had his phone
00:31:58
that morning on his person and we could
00:32:02
show 100% through the cell site analysis
00:32:06
that Jo Riley was traveling out from the
00:32:08
city out to his home at the time his
00:32:11
wife was murdered but that wasn't the
00:32:13
only breakthrough on the 14th of March
00:32:17
2006 detectives were tipped off about a
00:32:20
conversation O'Reilly had with his lover
00:32:23
When Rachel was still alive Joe had also
00:32:26
told his lover that he would kill Rachel
00:32:31
but she didn't take him seriously she
00:32:33
just start with a figure of
00:32:35
speech had Joe O'Reilly actually
00:32:38
admitted what he was going to do to
00:32:40
Rachel prior to her murder we
00:32:44
arrested Joe's lover again and brought
00:32:47
her in and questioned her and she
00:32:48
admitted that Joe said he'd kill Rachel
00:32:50
if he got away with it but I don't I
00:32:52
didn't take him
00:32:53
seriously I didn't think he'd do
00:32:54
anything like you know this when he said
00:32:56
in flipping like it wasn't anything in
00:32:59
it like you know on the 18th of June
00:33:03
2007 Joe oy appeared in court charged
00:33:07
with the murder of his wife
00:33:10
Rachel for Detective Pat marry the trial
00:33:14
had been a long time
00:33:18
coming it was quite an intense
00:33:20
investigation and there was a good team
00:33:22
of detectives on it and everyone has the
00:33:24
same agenda to get the person who did
00:33:27
this
00:33:29
it had been almost 3 years since Rachel
00:33:31
had been killed and at times the Cali
00:33:34
family had almost given up hope of Joe
00:33:37
O'Reilly ever facing Justice we always
00:33:41
knew the hardest thing was to get him
00:33:43
into court it was three years later he
00:33:45
was still walking the streets still
00:33:48
living his life still happy out um so it
00:33:51
was a huge step to get him charged the
00:33:53
trial was the final chapter in a story
00:33:56
that had from day one attracted intense
00:33:59
public interest journalist Pat Flanigan
00:34:02
covered the trial at the central
00:34:04
Criminal Court in Dublin there were cues
00:34:06
down the street for the public to get in
00:34:08
in fact I was there that morning and I
00:34:10
had difficulty getting through the
00:34:11
crowds to get into the courthouse I
00:34:13
think a lot of people thought he were
00:34:14
going to get off because of course they
00:34:16
didn't know how watertight the uh the
00:34:19
police case was against
00:34:21
them while the facts of his actions were
00:34:24
laid bare in court O'Reilly showed
00:34:27
little
00:34:29
emotion during the trial um Joe he
00:34:32
seemed very relaxed in fact he you know
00:34:34
he was looking around the court he
00:34:36
didn't seem particularly worried you
00:34:38
know at the time he had the demeanor of
00:34:40
a man who felt he was beyond the reach
00:34:43
of the
00:34:44
law the trial was especially difficult
00:34:47
for the Kali family as painful details
00:34:50
of Rachel's murder were
00:34:53
revealed as the postmortem results were
00:34:56
discussed the n ales were reminded of
00:34:59
the weeks following the murder when Joe
00:35:02
O'Reilly acted out how the murderer
00:35:04
would have likely killed Rachel you
00:35:07
might say you saw the body and know like
00:35:09
when you hear and I know he reenacted it
00:35:12
and all but it was only when we were
00:35:15
told exactly what happened that we knew
00:35:18
his reenactments are actually real but
00:35:21
um it's it's barbaric what he did it's
00:35:24
horrific so he got great joy out of doed
00:35:27
them
00:35:28
he used more violence than was necessary
00:35:31
to kill his wife there was rage in that
00:35:35
there was resentment in that but it was
00:35:37
also cold
00:35:40
blooded planned execution of his
00:35:45
wife you are in my way and I'm going to
00:35:49
get rid of you that says so much about
00:35:52
the type of person that he is
00:36:00
on the 20th of July 2007 at the end of
00:36:04
the 4-we trial the jury went out to
00:36:07
deliberate despite the prosecution
00:36:09
painting a picture of a man who had
00:36:11
reason to kill his wife there was still
00:36:14
doubt as to whether O'Reilly would be
00:36:16
punished for his
00:36:19
actions there has to be concern because
00:36:21
it's it's I think there was 11 jurors in
00:36:24
the end and it only takes a couple of
00:36:26
them and you're you're in trouble I had
00:36:30
gone over to a local pub with the guards
00:36:33
and we were chatting none of them were
00:36:36
confident you know they were all just
00:36:38
you just never know a jury so that kind
00:36:42
of diminished me a
00:36:45
littleit Detective Pat marry waited
00:36:48
anxiously with the Kali family after
00:36:51
less than 24 hours of deliberation on
00:36:55
Saturday the 21st of July
00:36:58
2007 the jury had made their decision I
00:37:02
remember being with the family we went
00:37:04
down to the pub and we were having an
00:37:05
appointed Guinness and I remember I just
00:37:07
had one called and it was sitting in
00:37:09
front of me and next people come in the
00:37:10
jury are coming back the jury are coming
00:37:13
back back in the courtroom the jury
00:37:16
delivered their verdict a unanimous
00:37:19
guilty Joe O'Reilly was finally
00:37:22
convicted for the murder of his wife
00:37:25
Rachel the whole Court just erupted the
00:37:29
judge was banging his gravel on it and
00:37:31
there was no nobody was paying any
00:37:33
attention like you know it was
00:37:35
just it was a huge release of emotion
00:37:40
that Justice had been done like you know
00:37:42
and I think the whole country were
00:37:44
shouting and I was standing there and
00:37:47
Rose G him over to me to give me a big
00:37:48
hug and I started crying as well and I
00:37:51
cried I make no bones about it well
00:37:55
thankfully he was found guilty um
00:37:58
the only way I can describe it it's it's
00:38:01
like taking the air of a balloon it it
00:38:04
just you you nearly collapse and yet you
00:38:08
nearly jump touch the sky it's an
00:38:11
amazing
00:38:12
feeling it was just it was very
00:38:14
emotional you
00:38:16
know this supremely confident indeed you
00:38:20
might say arrogant man is finally cut
00:38:23
down to size by a jury of 12 of his
00:38:28
peers who see through his Supreme
00:38:33
confidence for what it is merely that a
00:38:36
pretense a pretense that oh he couldn't
00:38:39
possibly have killed it was an outsider
00:38:41
an intruder it's one of the most cold
00:38:43
blooded of killings it's possible to
00:38:46
imagine O'Reilly is nothing more than a
00:38:49
coldblooded calculated murderer Joe
00:38:53
O'Reilly was sentenced to life
00:38:55
imprisonment and was taken f first to
00:38:57
Dublin's Mount Joy prison before
00:39:00
transferring to Midland jail to serve
00:39:03
his
00:39:04
sentence life imprisonment in Ireland is
00:39:06
anything now between 18 and 23 years but
00:39:10
people do serve a lot longer than that
00:39:11
and I suspect Joe Riley will serve maybe
00:39:16
30 years hopefully never gets
00:39:19
out but being found guilty didn't stop
00:39:22
Joe O'Reilly from appealing his
00:39:24
conviction which he did in 2009
00:39:28
Joe riy was so confident that he would
00:39:30
win his appeal that he told inmates when
00:39:32
he was in prison that he' move back into
00:39:34
the house where he moured his wife as
00:39:36
soon as he was released and bring his
00:39:38
two children with him O'Reilly lost his
00:39:41
appeal and remains in
00:39:45
prison but for the Cali family the
00:39:49
nightmare continues he was found guilty
00:39:52
he did it seven years and every two
00:39:54
years after that he's applied for role
00:39:58
what we have to do as a family then is
00:40:00
every two years when they contact us we
00:40:02
have to write letters send the in way we
00:40:05
think he should stay in jail so you know
00:40:10
it just seems a bit unfair that we're
00:40:12
not actually the guilty party here and
00:40:14
yet we' have to kind of beg to keep him
00:40:16
in
00:40:17
jail for many people in Ireland Joe
00:40:20
O'Reilly remains a threat to
00:40:23
society I believe Joe Riley is a total
00:40:26
psychopath he is no empathy for anybody
00:40:31
when he could do that to his wife he
00:40:33
could do
00:40:34
anything he was evil evil to the core
00:40:38
and if he got out could he do it again
00:40:41
yes he could joy in my mind is an evil
00:40:44
person people like Jo O'Reilly don't
00:40:48
change this is who he is he killed
00:40:53
Rachel because of the way he is the way
00:40:56
he thinks his world to view his ego his
00:41:01
entitlement that's not going anywhere
00:41:04
there's a danger that he will behave in
00:41:06
exactly the same way in future
00:41:09
relationships as he did in his past
00:41:15
relationships Rachel lost her life at
00:41:17
the hands of the evil
00:41:20
O'Reilly but she was not the only victim
00:41:23
of this devastating crime
00:41:28
your biggest hope is like the the two
00:41:31
boys had lost their mother and you just
00:41:33
hope to God it wasn't the
00:41:36
father like if it was a burglary or
00:41:41
anything else I'm not saying it would be
00:41:43
any easier but at least they'd be left
00:41:46
with their dad um so I think once that
00:41:50
realization came in that he he like he
00:41:53
didn't just take our sister he took
00:41:55
their mother which
00:41:58
which to me like I think that's
00:42:02
barbaric no matter how much you hate
00:42:05
someone it's a terrible Legacy to leave
00:42:07
those kids you know that that's their
00:42:11
legacy for the rest of their lives the
00:42:13
mother was murdered and their father
00:42:15
[Music]
00:42:24
did who knows what she would have went
00:42:26
down for a ra had Endless Possibilities
00:42:30
like she she was such a doer such a
00:42:33
giver such a great mother great sister
00:42:37
great
00:42:38
daughter she could have done an in life
00:42:41
it's just a shame he he just he just cut
00:42:46
her dead like that
00:42:48
and you know all that possibility was
00:42:52
lost he destroyed her for the years
00:42:55
leading up to her death so
00:42:58
we are the hopei ratson
00:43:01
[Music]
00:43:06
prison Joe O'Reilly fell out of love
00:43:09
with his wife and wanted to move on with
00:43:12
his lover instead of getting a divorce
00:43:15
and fighting for custody he chose to end
00:43:18
the marriage in the most final of ways
00:43:21
by brutally murdering Rachel and
00:43:23
depriving his two children of their
00:43:25
mother or was a selfish man who would
00:43:29
stop at nothing to get what he wanted
00:43:31
and he will be remembered as one of the
00:43:34
world's most evil killers
00:43:43
[Music]
