Search Captions & Ask AI

Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 18

March 09, 2017 / 42:53

This episode of Unsolved Mysteries covers the murders of two women named Mary Morris, a fraudulent car manufacturer named Liz Carmichael, a grocery store robbery in South Carolina, and a series of church arsons in Florida.

The first segment focuses on the mysterious deaths of two women named Mary Morris in Houston, Texas, occurring just three days apart. The first victim, Mary Lou Morris, was found in a burned car, while the second, Mary McGinness Morris, was brutally murdered shortly after expressing fear of a coworker. Investigators explore connections between the two cases, but the police ultimately conclude they are unrelated.

The episode then shifts to Liz Carmichael, who claimed to have invented a revolutionary three-wheel car that could achieve 60 miles per gallon. Despite raising over $3 million in pre-sales, authorities discover that Carmichael's company had no manufacturing capabilities and was a scam. After fleeing, she was later arrested and revealed to have been living under a false identity.

Next, the episode recounts a grocery store robbery in Greenville, South Carolina, where a police officer was killed. The mastermind, Sam Waty, attempted to frame his own son for the murder but was ultimately convicted himself. Waty later escaped from prison but was recaptured.

Finally, the episode discusses a series of church arsons in Florida, where nearly 30 churches were set on fire over 16 months. Authorities suspect a serial arsonist, and a man named Patrick Lee Frank is later charged but found not guilty by reason of insanity.

TL;DR

Two women named Mary Morris are murdered in Houston, Liz Carmichael commits fraud with a fake car company, and a series of church arsons occur in Florida.

Episode

42:53
00:00:00
[Music]
00:00:04
next on Unsolved
00:00:06
Mysteries two women both named Mary
00:00:09
Morris are murdered 3 days apart in the
00:00:11
same town was it a coincidence or is
00:00:14
there a
00:00:15
connection Liz carmichel claims that her
00:00:18
revolutionary three-wheel car gets 60 m
00:00:21
to the gallon but she and the car are
00:00:25
not what they appear to
00:00:27
be in South Carolina a volunt officer is
00:00:31
gunned down during a robbery his killer
00:00:34
has escaped from
00:00:36
prison and in Florida suspicious fires
00:00:39
ravage nearly 30 churches in just over a
00:00:43
year a Serial arsonist may be at
00:00:47
work join us for five cases with twists
00:00:51
and turns that you can hardly believe
00:00:54
I'm Dennis finina and this is Unsolved
00:00:57
Mysteries
00:01:09
[Music]
00:01:18
[Music]
00:01:28
he
00:01:33
Houston Texas in a remote area outside
00:01:38
the city a passer by makes a gruesome
00:01:43
Discovery inside a smoldering car he
00:01:46
finds a body burned beyond recognition
00:01:49
the CSI unit is called and begins
00:01:52
searching the area for
00:01:55
Clues the car belongs to 48-year-old
00:01:58
Mary Morris who lives only 3 miles away
00:02:01
her husband has not been able to reach
00:02:03
her since she left for work early that
00:02:07
morning I called a supervisor and found
00:02:09
out she wasn't at work that's when I
00:02:12
knew immediately that there was
00:02:13
something wrong cuz she didn't miss
00:02:15
work within a few hours detectives
00:02:18
deliver the terrible news the victim in
00:02:21
the car is Mary Morris the condition of
00:02:25
the body makes it impossible to
00:02:27
determine how she was killed nor can
00:02:30
police determine the motive Mary was a
00:02:33
bank loan officer with many friends a
00:02:35
successful career and no known
00:02:39
enemies there was no reason for it
00:02:42
whatsoever she was just a really a good
00:02:44
person you know never did anything bad
00:02:47
to
00:02:48
anybody they asked everything from
00:02:50
gambling to drugs to Affairs to anything
00:02:53
and all the answers were
00:02:56
no just 3 days after the death of mar
00:02:59
Mary Morris this case took on a very
00:03:02
strange turn not far from where Mary's
00:03:06
body was found another woman was
00:03:08
viciously murdered she too was killed in
00:03:10
her car and she too was named Mary
00:03:17
Morris two women named Mary Morris both
00:03:20
found murdered in their cars both in the
00:03:23
Houston area and just 3 days apart and
00:03:27
both had similar physical
00:03:30
descriptions coincidence in order to
00:03:33
find a possible link detectives tried to
00:03:35
piece together the events leading up to
00:03:37
the death of the second victim Mary
00:03:41
mcginness Morris was 39 years old and
00:03:44
like Mary Lou Morris she was a
00:03:46
successful professional with a lot of
00:03:49
friends Mary was like an angel she was
00:03:52
very joyful always happy making people
00:03:55
laugh not enough words really to
00:03:57
describe her I mean she was just really
00:03:59
loved by everybody call you in the
00:04:01
morning Mary Lou Morris was a nurse
00:04:03
practitioner in charge of several
00:04:05
clinics for a major Industrial
00:04:08
Corporation anything basically a doctor
00:04:11
would do Mary did she would work 14
00:04:14
hours a day not think twice go back in
00:04:16
of an evening weekends whenever she was
00:04:19
needed Mary got along well with everyone
00:04:22
on her staff except for one new employee
00:04:26
a male
00:04:27
nurse she told me that she was afraid of
00:04:30
this person that she worked with and I
00:04:32
said do you really think he could hurt
00:04:34
you and she said yes I do and I think he
00:04:37
could do
00:04:38
worse soon after that conversation Mary
00:04:42
stopped by her office one evening to
00:04:44
pick up some papers and she became
00:04:46
frightened by what she found there she
00:04:50
found things out of place on her desk
00:04:52
pictures turned to face the wrong
00:04:55
direction on his desk was written the
00:04:57
words death to her which she assumed was
00:05:00
written about
00:05:02
her she made a phone call to me on her
00:05:05
way home and uh she I could tell that
00:05:07
she was that she was shaken honey this
00:05:10
whole thing is really out of control she
00:05:13
got home and she asked me if I would
00:05:16
provide her with a gun to carry with her
00:05:18
for her own protection she asked me to
00:05:22
go over the the handling and use of the
00:05:25
gun when we were finished she asked me
00:05:28
to place the gun in her car under the
00:05:30
driver's
00:05:32
seat are you sure a few weekends later
00:05:35
Mary met her friend Lori gimel at the
00:05:37
clinic to get a flu shot Mary seemed
00:05:41
fine that Sunday and she was only going
00:05:43
to stay a couple of hours and then she
00:05:44
was going to go
00:05:46
home Lori says that she later received a
00:05:49
call from Mary who sounded
00:05:52
panicked hi it's me when she was in the
00:05:55
drugstore she saw somebody that gave her
00:05:57
the creeps she said I'm just going to
00:06:00
run across the bridge and turn off my
00:06:01
computer and sign out of the building
00:06:03
and and go
00:06:06
home 12 minutes after saying goodbye to
00:06:09
Lori Mary mcginness Morris made a
00:06:12
frantic call to 911 we're not releasing
00:06:14
the content of the tape it covers the
00:06:18
attack that happened to Mary and anybody
00:06:21
that's ever heard that tape has uh just
00:06:25
had their blood Shield listening to it
00:06:27
it's it's a very chilling disturbing
00:06:30
all the medical examiner report revealed
00:06:33
that Mary was viciously beaten and then
00:06:37
shot in the
00:06:40
head investigators focused on Mary's
00:06:42
coworker at the clinic he had quit his
00:06:45
job after allegedly trying to discredit
00:06:48
Mary detectives claim to have evidence
00:06:51
linking him to the crime and he remains
00:06:54
a
00:06:55
suspect however when investigators tried
00:06:58
to question Mary's husband Mike Morris
00:07:01
his behavior aroused suspicion he
00:07:04
wouldn't meet with us without an
00:07:06
attorney Witnesses don't need attorneys
00:07:10
suspects generally have attorneys Mike
00:07:13
Morris says that he was only following
00:07:15
the advice of some trusted friends
00:07:18
several people suggested that I'd take
00:07:21
an attorney with me not because I had
00:07:23
anything to hide but just to have
00:07:25
somebody with me that was familiar with
00:07:28
the procedures
00:07:30
next detectives asked Mike Morris to
00:07:32
take a polygraph test he refused I was
00:07:37
on anti-anxiety medications I was on
00:07:41
anti-depressants I wasn't really sure
00:07:43
that that this polygraph examination
00:07:46
that they were talking about could
00:07:48
adequately compensate for all of those
00:07:51
conditions authorities had also learn
00:07:53
that Mike and Mary Morris were having
00:07:56
serious problems with their marriage
00:07:58
when Mike heard of rumors of an alleged
00:08:01
Affair between Mary and a family friend
00:08:03
he confronted them head on I can tell
00:08:07
you that at the time that that happened
00:08:09
they both looked me in the eye and they
00:08:11
both told me that that there had been
00:08:13
nothing inappropriate in their
00:08:16
relationship and I didn't see any
00:08:18
betrayal in their eyes and then there
00:08:21
was the question of motive Mary had a
00:08:24
life insurance policy that would pay out
00:08:27
$700,000
00:08:28
[Music]
00:08:29
there was a large amount of life
00:08:31
insurance on Mary Morris which Mike
00:08:34
Morris was the beneficiary too there
00:08:36
were a lot of reasons right there for uh
00:08:39
in the way of a motive for
00:08:42
Mike but to the police the most curious
00:08:45
evidence against Mike Mars is a phone
00:08:48
call he made to Mary's cell phone 2
00:08:50
hours after detectives believed that she
00:08:54
was murdered this phone call lasted for
00:08:56
4 minutes this was by all indications of
00:09:00
the cellular telephone company a
00:09:02
completed call what you have to wonder
00:09:05
is what did that phone call either set
00:09:08
in motion or uh end
00:09:13
normally um the the cellular service
00:09:18
would have kicked in and and said that
00:09:20
the uh that the party you were calling
00:09:23
was unavailable um I didn't get that I
00:09:25
don't know why I didn't get that but as
00:09:28
long as the phone was ringing and I
00:09:30
thought that there was a possibility
00:09:32
that she would answer it I let it ring
00:09:35
but that raised yet another question
00:09:38
detectives wondered why the call showed
00:09:40
up on Mary's cell phone bill if no one
00:09:42
answered I don't accept that Mike made
00:09:45
this phone call and that the phone rang
00:09:47
for 4 minutes it's not possible the the
00:09:51
question is who answered the phone on
00:09:53
the other end that's what the big
00:09:55
question is and what did they talk about
00:09:58
for the 4 minutes
00:10:00
but Mike Morris firmly denies any
00:10:03
involvement in Mary's
00:10:05
death I had absolutely nothing to do
00:10:07
with the arrangement of Mary's murder
00:10:09
it's a hurtful insinuation it's it's
00:10:12
absolutely untrue the question remains
00:10:15
today why were Mary mcginness moris and
00:10:18
Mary Lou Morris murdered and who killed
00:10:21
them some think that a contract killer
00:10:23
was hired to murder the second Mary
00:10:26
Morris and killed the first Mary Morris
00:10:30
by mistake that theory is supported by a
00:10:33
call allegedly made to a Houston
00:10:35
newspaper A call came into the Houston
00:10:38
Chronicle and I verified this with
00:10:40
somebody at the
00:10:42
chronicle between the time the first
00:10:44
Mary Morris was killed and the time my
00:10:47
friend was killed saying something to
00:10:50
the effect that they got the wrong Mary
00:10:52
moris the first time the hit gone wrong
00:10:55
theory is also supported by the fact
00:10:58
that the wedding ring of the first Mary
00:11:00
Morris was missing from the crime scene
00:11:03
if someone had put a hit out on a person
00:11:06
that's what they take back to show that
00:11:07
they actually killed that
00:11:10
person detectives also looked at the
00:11:13
possibility that the two murders were in
00:11:16
fact connected well with the remoteness
00:11:18
of the location where the victim was
00:11:19
found as well as the effort that was
00:11:21
taken to destroy the evidence and and
00:11:23
the vehicle um that would be consistent
00:11:26
you know with a you know contract
00:11:27
killing but with the background of the
00:11:29
victim that doesn't seem likely the
00:11:32
first Mary Morris was a was a mistake it
00:11:35
was a missed hit a a bodged hit
00:11:38
something like that there's not anything
00:11:41
uh that we found that would uh support
00:11:47
that detectives continued to search for
00:11:50
any clues that might connect the two
00:11:52
merry morses but came up empty they
00:11:55
later concluded that the murders were a
00:11:58
bizarre coincidence
00:12:00
however the family and friends of both
00:12:02
Marys think that's impossible the
00:12:06
astronomical odds the two Mary mores was
00:12:08
killed 3 days apart very similar in
00:12:11
looks to me is that's what it is
00:12:15
astronomical or not connected I can't
00:12:18
help but think they have to be related I
00:12:20
can't imagine that two women with the
00:12:23
same name would be murdered within 3
00:12:26
days of each other both found in their
00:12:28
cars and not have that be
00:12:31
related according to police both the
00:12:34
coworker of Mary mcginness Morris and
00:12:37
her husband Mike Morris have not been
00:12:39
ruled out as
00:12:41
suspects if you have any information
00:12:44
about her death or the death of Mary Lou
00:12:46
Morris please log on to unsolved.com
00:12:51
next meet the woman who pulled off one
00:12:54
of the most amazing frauds we've ever
00:12:57
encountered
00:13:07
in 1973 America faced an oil crisis that
00:13:11
nearly crippled the country consumers
00:13:14
wanted cheaper gas or more fuel
00:13:16
efficient cars one Visionary claimed
00:13:20
that she had the perfect solution a
00:13:23
revolutionary three-wheel vehicle called
00:13:26
the Dale this car supposedly C cost less
00:13:29
than
00:13:30
$2,000 and got 60 m to the gallon its
00:13:34
creator claimed it could withstand an
00:13:36
impact against the brick wall at 50 mph
00:13:40
it seemed like the perfect answer to the
00:13:42
gas crunch we all heard of the gas
00:13:45
guzzlers coming from Detroit and here
00:13:47
somebody could put out an automobile
00:13:48
that could uh get 60 M to a gallon of
00:13:51
gas and travel all over the city without
00:13:53
a problem uh would have been the ideal
00:13:56
automobile we have pledges from private
00:13:59
individuals for Private Stock the
00:14:02
entrepreneur who unveiled the new car
00:14:04
was a remarkable and forceful woman
00:14:06
named Liz carmichel she had the ability
00:14:11
to incite this fire in you she's a very
00:14:14
Dynamic strong person and uh she did
00:14:17
things that that uh impressed
00:14:20
us a lowcost high mileage car was the
00:14:23
right idea at the right time Liz
00:14:26
Carmichael pulled in more than $3
00:14:28
million worth of advanced sales and this
00:14:31
was before a single car rolled off the
00:14:34
production
00:14:36
line Ino California in 1974 Liz
00:14:41
carmichel transformed herself from a
00:14:43
housewife with five children to an
00:14:46
entrepreneur she established 20th
00:14:49
century Motorcar Corporation to produce
00:14:52
her new three-wheel car I've called you
00:14:55
all together to try and give you some
00:14:56
update information on what we're doing
00:14:58
here at 20th century Motors and with the
00:15:00
Dale Liz told investors and the press
00:15:03
that her company was renting three huge
00:15:06
aircraft hangers where they would soon
00:15:08
start production first year and what
00:15:10
about the cost cost Factor any American
00:15:13
can afford our car and the questions
00:15:15
that were asked were not well if you've
00:15:17
got a manufacturing facility where is it
00:15:20
and how long you've been making cars and
00:15:21
who are your engineers and not the tough
00:15:23
questions the questions were basically
00:15:26
well Liz we're behind you and where can
00:15:27
I send my money
00:15:29
news of Carmichael and her car soon
00:15:31
spread across the country Liz was being
00:15:34
interviewed by Newsweek and People
00:15:38
magazine but back at Carmichael's
00:15:40
headquarters authorities began to
00:15:42
question her claims i' like to see Liz
00:15:47
car the California Department of
00:15:49
Corporations accused her of illegally
00:15:52
selling both dealer franchises and cars
00:15:56
that did not yet exist I have a DEC
00:15:59
refrain order issued against 20th
00:16:01
century Motorcar
00:16:05
Corporation then the Department of Motor
00:16:08
Vehicles discovered that the company had
00:16:10
no State permit to manufacture cars we
00:16:13
went to the research and development lab
00:16:15
and observed what appeared to be people
00:16:17
appearing to be busy but in wandering
00:16:19
through the lab uh I saw no evidence
00:16:22
that they were designing a vehicle or in
00:16:24
process of making a vehicle everyone in
00:16:26
the research and development lab without
00:16:29
out was sincere believed in in the car
00:16:31
and there was even talk if the company
00:16:33
should
00:16:34
fold there was a group of us that wanted
00:16:36
to get together and continue with the
00:16:38
car we believe that much in the
00:16:40
car the Department of Motor Vehicles
00:16:43
sent investigator Bill Hall to check out
00:16:45
the three hangers where Carmichael
00:16:47
claimed the cars would be
00:16:50
manufactured I went to this airport upon
00:16:53
entering I discovered the factory were
00:16:54
nothing hangers were absolutely empty no
00:16:58
tools no Machinery nothing but a little
00:17:00
dirt on the floor they had rented this
00:17:02
for only one month and the rented now
00:17:05
expired so they actually did not have a
00:17:08
factory that they were representing the
00:17:11
head with the authorities closing in
00:17:13
Carmichael decided that it was time to
00:17:16
move her headquarters to Dallas but 2
00:17:19
and 1/2 Weeks Later in Dallas the da
00:17:22
filed criminal grand theft charges
00:17:24
against Liz
00:17:26
carmichel back in California Bill Hall
00:17:29
went to the research and development lab
00:17:31
with a search W upon inspection of this
00:17:34
vehicle it was not a a viable vehicle at
00:17:37
all it had no engine 2x4s were holding
00:17:40
up the rear wheel the accelerator was
00:17:43
just sitting on the floor it wasn't even
00:17:44
attached the windows were not safety
00:17:47
glass they were Bend back and forth the
00:17:50
uh doors were put on by regular door
00:17:53
hinges like one might find on a house
00:17:55
door the vehicle just absolutely did not
00:17:57
exist
00:17:59
this Carmichael the Dallas Police also
00:18:02
searched Carmichael's house apparently
00:18:04
she and her five children had moved out
00:18:07
in a hurry but Carmichael Left Behind
00:18:11
evidence that she was not who she seemed
00:18:14
to be God what do you got there looks
00:18:17
like some kind of padded
00:18:19
girdle this this
00:18:22
Carmichael I don't
00:18:26
know okay Liz carmichel was gone but 9
00:18:30
weeks later she was found living in
00:18:32
Miami with her five children a neighbor
00:18:35
recognized her from a news photo and
00:18:37
called the police she was working for
00:18:40
dating service and was going by the name
00:18:42
of Susan Reigns they also learned that
00:18:46
Liz carmichel had another identity Liz
00:18:50
carmichel was really a
00:18:53
man Jerry Dean Michael it turned out
00:18:57
that Michael was our already wanted by
00:18:59
federal authorities for counterfeiting
00:19:02
and jumping
00:19:03
bail so was his female identity a
00:19:07
disguise Michael claimed to be in
00:19:09
preparation for a sex change
00:19:12
operation but even without it Jerry Dean
00:19:15
Michael had everyone
00:19:18
fooled we had no doubt that this was a
00:19:22
woman you just didn't question it you
00:19:25
just didn't question it I never thought
00:19:27
that Liz was a man I always thought that
00:19:30
and she is today she still lives to me
00:19:33
still a
00:19:35
female Miss
00:19:37
carmichel we have a warrant for your
00:19:39
arrest Jerry Dean Michael Alias
00:19:42
Geraldine Elizabeth carmichel was
00:19:44
arrested on April 12th
00:19:46
1975 he was extradited to Los Angeles
00:19:50
and put on trial for conspiracy grand
00:19:52
theft and
00:19:56
fraud Liz arrived in cour every day in
00:20:00
Min skirts now here somebody who's over
00:20:02
200 lb and over 6 ft tall has a uh
00:20:06
demeanor of I am a new Henry Ford it was
00:20:11
rather bizarre Liz did not give one
00:20:14
quarter in the course of the trial there
00:20:16
was never once when lesz gave up her
00:20:20
position that the people who supported
00:20:22
her would vindicate her this car is the
00:20:26
car of the future sir the idea ballot it
00:20:29
was sound it could be done today it
00:20:31
could still go back in production and
00:20:33
still be a great car there's no doubt
00:20:35
about it if you were to walk in this
00:20:36
room and say let's go again I'd go right
00:20:38
with
00:20:39
her has the jury reached its verdict yes
00:20:43
we have your honor we find a defendant
00:20:47
guilty Michael was released on $50,000
00:20:50
bail and appeal as conviction for the
00:20:53
next 4 years he lost every time but when
00:20:57
it came time for sent s Jerry Dean
00:21:00
Michael was nowhere to be
00:21:03
found update within minutes of our
00:21:07
broadcast we received a tip from a
00:21:09
viewer who recognized Jerry Dean Michael
00:21:12
as a flower vendor named Catherine
00:21:15
Elizabeth
00:21:17
Johnson Michael had chosen to live in
00:21:19
the small community of Dale Texas and
00:21:23
was arrested at his home Michael was
00:21:25
returned to California there he was
00:21:28
sentenced to 32 months on several counts
00:21:30
arising from his auto scan he was sent
00:21:34
to an all mail facility after serving
00:21:37
just over 2 years Jerry Dean Michael was
00:21:40
discharged with 3 years of
00:21:43
parole a prototype of the Dale is in the
00:21:46
permanent collection of the Peterson
00:21:48
automobile museum in Los
00:21:52
Angeles next a man facing execution for
00:21:56
murder tries to frame his own son for
00:22:00
the
00:22:01
[Applause]
00:22:05
[Music]
00:22:09
crime Greenville South Carolina the
00:22:12
night before Thanksgiving a grocery
00:22:14
store full of holiday Shoppers has
00:22:17
become a
00:22:20
Target how's a look we're going to do
00:22:22
this one let's
00:22:24
go I can't believe you brought the kid
00:22:26
don't worry about rich you'll kill car
00:22:30
Wait the thieves are career criminals
00:22:34
first inside is Rusty Corvette a
00:22:37
convicted drug
00:22:38
dealer The Mastermind is Sam waty an
00:22:42
armed robber out on parole waiting
00:22:45
nervously in the car is wat's
00:22:48
19-year-old son
00:22:54
Richard I don't write this in here right
00:22:56
now forget is your video section still
00:22:59
open I've got to get it the
00:23:01
table I turned around and that's when I
00:23:04
saw a man wearing a ski mask and holding
00:23:06
a
00:23:08
gun wait a minute you're not going
00:23:11
anywhere everybody Hit the Floor do it
00:23:14
face down
00:23:16
now I was close enough to see the color
00:23:19
of his eyes and I thought he doesn't
00:23:22
care that I can recognize him that was
00:23:25
the scariest thing of all because I
00:23:27
thought if if he doesn't care what's
00:23:29
going to happen here come on let's go
00:23:32
come on come on come on move to the back
00:23:34
of the store go go go move very cool all
00:23:37
the way back to the store all the way
00:23:40
back I said back what do you think we're
00:23:45
kidding been a
00:23:48
[Music]
00:23:51
pleasure the take is almost
00:23:54
$88,000 but the robbers do not make a
00:23:56
clean getaway he did it
00:24:00
two store employees catch the make and
00:24:03
license plate number of the
00:24:06
car behind a gray cutless it just turned
00:24:08
off a Rutherford Road on the 291 there
00:24:11
are at least two subjects in the car I
00:24:14
buys the other cars that were around me
00:24:16
a roadblock is what we were trying to do
00:24:19
and you know be able to stop him get him
00:24:21
out of the car and arrest him without
00:24:24
hopefully any uh instance of
00:24:27
injury Within minutes other units
00:24:29
Converge on the robers Charlie 29 I'm
00:24:32
heading north on Piney Mountain Officer
00:24:34
Dennis Eubanks and a volunteer Constable
00:24:36
Val and Keith move in from the opposite
00:24:39
direction head right to us Eubanks and
00:24:42
Keith swing around and get ahead of the
00:24:45
chase he's coming in right behind you
00:24:47
but before they can set up the roadblock
00:24:49
the robbers are bearing down on them Sam
00:24:53
let's run Sam let's head out get around
00:24:55
him
00:25:00
backup arrives too late 46-year-old
00:25:03
valvin Keith a father of four is dead
00:25:07
however within 48 Hours police have
00:25:10
arrested all three
00:25:14
suspects if convicted of the killing Sam
00:25:17
waty would face the death penalty while
00:25:20
in jail he talked Rusty Corvette into
00:25:23
helping him with an incredibly
00:25:26
coldblooded scheme why 's plan was to
00:25:29
identify Richard his own son as the
00:25:33
trigger man I wrote it all down for you
00:25:36
everything you need to say here take it
00:25:40
come on we're going to make Rich look
00:25:42
like one geared up Cowboy it was like it
00:25:45
was a game to him he acted like this
00:25:47
ultimate story he was going to tell was
00:25:49
the truth in the matter you know I mean
00:25:52
he he was plotting to to put his own son
00:25:54
in the electri chair is what he was
00:25:56
doing waty to insist that he was
00:26:01
innocent Sam what are you thinking it so
00:26:03
far fantastic yeah truly believe in the
00:26:07
judicial system and it's really
00:26:08
impressed me a lot the way things are
00:26:10
going in the end he was convicted of
00:26:13
murder primarily because his son and
00:26:16
Rusty Corvette testified against Sam
00:26:21
waty waty however had created just
00:26:24
enough doubt with the jury to get a life
00:26:27
sentence in instead of the death
00:26:30
penalty we were leaving the courthouse
00:26:33
and he grinned at me and and he said you
00:26:35
know he said life is nothing he said you
00:26:38
know I'm going to get out uh he was very
00:26:41
confident about
00:26:43
it it took almost eight years in several
00:26:46
botched escaped attempts but waty
00:26:49
eventually made good on his
00:26:53
threat one weekend he and another inmate
00:26:56
Danny L were assigned to an unsupervised
00:26:59
Landscaping detail on the prison grounds
00:27:03
it was a Saturday so there would be no
00:27:05
midday head
00:27:07
count let's do it the convicts used the
00:27:10
stolen hacksaw Blade with a homemade
00:27:13
handle to gain access to an underground
00:27:15
maintenance
00:27:17
tunnel waty and L had to slice through
00:27:20
three wire Gates and a steel door and
00:27:23
the rebar sandwiched between two wire
00:27:26
mesh
00:27:27
Gates it was 22 hard Cuts in all and
00:27:30
there were only 8 hours left before the
00:27:33
evening head
00:27:37
count I imagine the adrenaline was
00:27:39
pumping and nervous every sound they
00:27:41
hear they figured there's going to be a
00:27:43
guard coming to get him by 4:30 waty and
00:27:46
L had made it to the Boiler Room D hey D
00:27:51
what are you doing down here going to
00:27:52
get me the keys to that truck am I going
00:27:53
to have to get them myself I told you
00:27:55
not to come down here doing my ship Wy
00:27:57
what am I supposed to trustees who were
00:27:59
working there didn't want to get caught
00:28:01
helping them Escape 15 minutes but they
00:28:04
weren't about to get in their way get
00:28:06
some ROP so we can Haw tie
00:28:11
ourselves with barely 15 minutes left
00:28:14
watk and L drove a prison truck out the
00:28:16
main gate and
00:28:18
disappeared police caught up with L less
00:28:21
than a month later waty however had
00:28:25
disappeared saying waty is in a category
00:28:27
by himself he is I believe very
00:28:30
Psychopathic face down now it's not that
00:28:33
he enjoys killing but he'll do it an
00:28:37
instant he will do anything it takes to
00:28:40
preserve him and he won't
00:28:44
hesitate update immediately after this
00:28:48
story aired one of our viewers in
00:28:50
Colorado reported that a former coworker
00:28:53
looked exactly like waty she gave
00:28:56
authorities the man's name and and birth
00:28:58
date a database search got a hit in
00:29:02
Louisiana authorities there provided a
00:29:04
copy of his driver's license without a
00:29:07
doubt it was Sam waty he was using the
00:29:10
Alias Michael Alman and the address on
00:29:13
his driver's license LED police straight
00:29:15
to his door waty still faced a life
00:29:19
sentence he was sent back to prison and
00:29:22
that's where he eventually died of a
00:29:24
heart
00:29:25
attack Rusty Corvette served 11 years of
00:29:28
his 21-year sentence before he was
00:29:31
released Corvette was later killed in a
00:29:34
shootout with police after a botched
00:29:36
robbery
00:29:39
attempt next bill batty loved his
00:29:41
magnificent Mansion so much that he may
00:29:45
not have left when he died many claim
00:29:48
they've seen is ghost
00:29:54
[Music]
00:29:59
Basking Ridge New
00:30:01
Jersey in 1923 a wealthy executive named
00:30:05
Bill B and his wife started building a
00:30:08
17th century style Norman Castle on 150
00:30:12
acres of Woodland yeah everything's
00:30:15
coming along just fine we've completed
00:30:17
work on the kitchen and the basement how
00:30:19
far up we going to go we're going to go
00:30:21
up another foot okay and you're going to
00:30:23
have five you going to have 11 by5 in
00:30:25
1930 before construction was complete
00:30:28
the Bates moved into the castle with
00:30:30
their four children but Bill would never
00:30:32
see the completion of his
00:30:36
dream just one year later he died of the
00:30:39
flu at the age of
00:30:41
45 his castle wasn't finished for
00:30:44
another 5 years Sarah batty never
00:30:47
remarried she raised all four children
00:30:49
in the castle and lived there until
00:30:54
1941 then the castle served as a boy
00:30:57
school for several decades and finally
00:31:00
Don and Carol Berling game bought the
00:31:02
estate and began to
00:31:04
remodel Carol was really the first one
00:31:06
to feel some sort of presence and she
00:31:09
had a friend that was sort of an amateur
00:31:11
parapsychologist then she said well
00:31:13
there definitely is a presence here and
00:31:15
Carol said well maybe we should try to
00:31:17
get rid of him shouldn't we have a a
00:31:19
seance and and uh and she said no you
00:31:22
better leave things exactly the way they
00:31:23
are he's friendly he's happy uh Let It
00:31:26
Go with that
00:31:28
after Don and Carol moved in hammering
00:31:31
noises echoed through the hallways and
00:31:34
footsteps were heard going up and down
00:31:36
the
00:31:37
stairs Don and Carol started to accept
00:31:40
that they shared their home with the
00:31:42
ghost of Bill batty one time Bill
00:31:46
demonstrated just how much he really
00:31:48
cared about the castle we decided we
00:31:51
were going to go off for a little ride
00:31:53
and Carol had all the windows open in
00:31:55
the servants Wing where we were living
00:31:57
renon said said you better close all the
00:31:58
windows it's supposed to rain I said no
00:32:00
it's not going to rain don't worry about
00:32:01
it I'm leaving them all
00:32:03
open so I left them open we went out and
00:32:07
it
00:32:10
rained we came home and all of the
00:32:12
casement windows which open from the
00:32:14
inside and open to the inside were all
00:32:17
closed and latched how went did it again
00:32:19
it didn't there's no water on the floor
00:32:22
there wasn't a drop of rain in the house
00:32:24
so our only conclusion was Bill helped
00:32:26
us out when he saw the rain coming he
00:32:27
closed all the windows and gave us a
00:32:30
handing up Bill Batty's ghosts also seem
00:32:33
to have a sense of humor or maybe he
00:32:36
just likes different TV shows than Don
00:32:39
and
00:32:40
Carol what's going
00:32:42
on I don't know let me see if I can fix
00:32:46
it you just get into a movie just the
00:32:48
really interesting part and all of a
00:32:50
sudden the station would change it would
00:32:53
go from two to three to four to five and
00:32:55
it happened more than one time turning
00:32:58
back and even I knew that there was a
00:33:00
presence here but what I couldn't figure
00:33:02
out was when was he going to leave if in
00:33:06
fact was he ever going to leave um I
00:33:10
just it was something I couldn't figure
00:33:12
out the Burling games began to look into
00:33:15
the history of the castle and found
00:33:18
Eugene Melville who used to work there I
00:33:21
said to what I see in there and they
00:33:24
said they sensed something themselves
00:33:27
but they never seen him but I only seen
00:33:29
him that once I can truthfully say that
00:33:32
was the only time I ever laid eyes on
00:33:34
him was at once seem to be under here
00:33:37
Mrs B 3 years after will Batty's death
00:33:41
Eugene was helping Sarah search for a
00:33:43
bracelet that she had
00:33:45
[Music]
00:33:51
lost it's Bill my husband but it was a
00:33:56
finger of a man stand there
00:33:58
no Phill it didn't stay long before me
00:34:01
to examine it very good it was just
00:34:03
going just like that it was scary I
00:34:07
don't know about this it frightened the
00:34:10
Daylights out of me I just never wanted
00:34:11
to go in that falcony again I passed by
00:34:14
it but to get me in there to stand there
00:34:17
oh forget it I wouldn't go in there
00:34:20
apparently Bill had something of a
00:34:22
throwing arm
00:34:28
I was alone in the kitchen the bread was
00:34:30
on the counter there was no way that it
00:34:32
could have fallen off by itself and when
00:34:34
it did fall off or a fly off it it went
00:34:38
a considerable distance so I know that
00:34:40
someone had to have moved
00:34:45
it there was no one else there with me
00:34:47
at all no animals Don wasn't around
00:34:49
there was no way the bread could have
00:34:50
fallen off the counter because it was
00:34:52
set Square okay Bill that's enough knock
00:34:56
it off and that led me to believe that
00:34:58
Bill had to be there saying hi I'm here
00:35:01
there was just no way that that bread
00:35:03
could have fallen off the counter by
00:35:07
itself Don and Carol invited Dr
00:35:09
Michaeline mayor a noted Paras
00:35:11
psychologist to visit the
00:35:14
CET mayor and her assistant conducted a
00:35:17
series of tests for Paranormal
00:35:21
Activity our physical instruments were
00:35:23
not able to detect anything unusual but
00:35:26
in this particular case the sheer volume
00:35:30
of the reports adds to The credibility
00:35:32
of the
00:35:33
case one of our Witnesses in this case
00:35:36
um a particularly credible witness in
00:35:39
fact a professional person of some
00:35:40
stature reported seeing uh in the
00:35:43
driveway in front of the castle a person
00:35:47
who dissipated right in front of his
00:35:49
eyes can I help
00:35:52
you who are you
00:35:57
I think the big news here is that humans
00:36:01
can act as sensors and we find that we
00:36:05
cannot uh dismiss this evidence as
00:36:08
caused by coincidence the stair treads
00:36:10
are going up on that second floor okay
00:36:12
come on the key to existing with a ghost
00:36:15
is if you can accept it you can enjoy it
00:36:18
and when things happen you just write
00:36:21
them off as oh it must be the ghost or
00:36:23
it must be Bill if you know who it
00:36:24
happen to know who it is I firmly
00:36:26
believe he will never leave the
00:36:28
castle the love of the thing maybe got
00:36:31
the better of of his soul and I think
00:36:34
that's the thing got such power you know
00:36:37
is the soul it's
00:36:44
Eternal next prospector Dan Willams left
00:36:48
behind a huge Fortune but no
00:36:51
will then an arsonist torches almost 30
00:36:55
churches in 16
00:37:07
months Red Lake Ontario Canada on a
00:37:11
previous broadcast we told you the story
00:37:13
of Dan willins in
00:37:16
1926 Dan found gold while panning at Red
00:37:19
Lake he and his Partners staked out
00:37:21
their claim and established one of the
00:37:24
most profitable small gold mines in
00:37:26
Canadian history
00:37:28
history in
00:37:30
1936 Dan set out into the Wilderness and
00:37:33
was never seen again he left behind an
00:37:36
estate that today would be worth as much
00:37:39
as
00:37:40
$35
00:37:41
million it has remained unclaimed for
00:37:45
more than 70
00:37:47
years update within Days of our
00:37:50
broadcast Davey willins contacted us
00:37:53
claiming that he might be one of The
00:37:55
Heirs to Dan willin
00:37:58
Fortune my grandfather came from the UK
00:38:01
to Ontario in
00:38:03
1895 we believe he traveled with another
00:38:06
family member and we also have been told
00:38:09
that there was a cousin someplace up in
00:38:11
the outback of Ontario so when this
00:38:14
Unsolved Mysteries program aired and
00:38:16
this Dan willins a Bushman from Ontario
00:38:19
was was disclosed it certainly was an
00:38:21
exciting possible link for our family
00:38:24
tree searching Davey willins flew to
00:38:27
Toronto Canada to meet Joe Perkin one of
00:38:30
Dan's last surviving friends Davey
00:38:33
brought along photographs of his
00:38:34
grandfather Harold willins and his
00:38:37
great-grandfather John willins to see if
00:38:40
there was a family resemblance it was
00:38:42
uncanny uh I couldn't believe it the
00:38:45
similarity of the face the nose spacing
00:38:48
of the eyes
00:38:50
forehead I think if you took the beard
00:38:52
off the old
00:38:54
man uh they'd look like twins
00:38:58
there does seem to be a strong
00:38:59
resemblance could Davey willins be an
00:39:02
heir to Dan willins
00:39:07
Fortune now Davey plans to look for some
00:39:10
of Dan Will's old belongings he thinks
00:39:13
that they might contain traces of DNA
00:39:15
that could prove a family connection if
00:39:18
you have any information about the case
00:39:20
of Dan willins and his fortune please
00:39:23
log on to unsolved.com
00:39:31
Okala
00:39:33
Florida firefighters rush to the First
00:39:35
Baptist Church despite their efforts the
00:39:38
85-year-old Landmark is completely
00:39:41
gutted the damage is in excess of $4
00:39:46
million incredibly this is the 21st
00:39:50
suspicious fire in Florida during a
00:39:52
16-month period authorities fear that
00:39:56
they might be dealing with
00:39:57
a Serial
00:39:59
arsonist the first fire was set in
00:40:02
Jackson County Florida within a year 15
00:40:06
other churches had been
00:40:08
torched the fires mysteriously stopped
00:40:11
for 3 and 1/2 months then destruction
00:40:14
erupted again in 7 Days Seven more
00:40:18
churches went up in
00:40:22
Flames authorities formed a special
00:40:24
Joint Task Force made up of federal
00:40:26
state and local
00:40:29
investigators task force is looking at
00:40:31
all possible patterns and avenues
00:40:34
everything from profiles of possible
00:40:36
fire Setters to times of day and other
00:40:39
information regarding the churches but
00:40:43
there certainly is no specific pattern
00:40:46
that has been determined at this point
00:40:49
churches like ours like to stay open and
00:40:51
offer people a place to meditate or pray
00:40:53
and and be involved 24 hours a day and
00:40:56
it's got to the place now to where we
00:40:58
can't leave our doors open uh so someone
00:41:00
could come in and pray um you know we're
00:41:03
having to guard the church I would hope
00:41:06
that we will come to some sort of quick
00:41:08
solution however I think it should be
00:41:11
noted that we need to be prepared for
00:41:13
the long hul these are very complex
00:41:17
investigations close to 30 churches were
00:41:20
damaged or destroyed by the arson fires
00:41:23
it is sheer luck that no one has been
00:41:26
killed or seriously injured still the
00:41:29
combined property losses total more than
00:41:32
$8
00:41:33
million and money is not the only
00:41:36
measure of the destruction these are
00:41:39
very important places for us very
00:41:41
important structures they house memories
00:41:43
good feelings and they're a very vital
00:41:46
part of our community so the loss is
00:41:48
heavy for all of
00:41:52
us
00:41:53
update Patrick Lee Frank a 41-year-old
00:41:57
Drifter from Tennessee was charged in
00:42:00
connection with the church fires Frank
00:42:03
was found not guilty by reason of
00:42:06
insanity and he was sent to a federal
00:42:09
psychiatric facility for treatment
00:42:27
[Music]
00:42:42
[Music]

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most shocking
  • 70
    Biggest twist
  • 65
    Most heartbreaking
  • 65
    Most surprising

Episode Highlights

  • The Mysterious Murders of Two Mary Morrises
    Two women named Mary Morris are murdered just three days apart in Houston, raising questions about a possible connection.
    “Coincidence or is there a connection?”
    @ 00m 11s
    March 09, 2017
  • Liz Carmichel's Revolutionary Car
    In the 1970s, Liz Carmichel claims to have created a revolutionary three-wheel car, the Dale, promising incredible fuel efficiency.
    “A revolutionary three-wheel vehicle called the Dale.”
    @ 13m 20s
    March 09, 2017
  • The Unraveling of a Fraud
    Liz Carmichel's claims about her car company fall apart as authorities investigate, revealing a web of deceit.
    “The vehicle just absolutely did not exist.”
    @ 17m 59s
    March 09, 2017
  • Sam Waty's Cold-Blooded Scheme
    Sam Waty plots to frame his own son for murder, showcasing a chilling betrayal.
    “I wrote it all down for you, everything you need to say.”
    @ 25m 36s
    March 09, 2017
  • Bill Batty's Ghostly Protection
    Don and Carol discover their home is shared with the ghost of Bill Batty, who protects them.
    “Bill helped us out when he saw the rain coming.”
    @ 32m 27s
    March 09, 2017
  • Arsonist Targets Churches
    A series of suspicious fires devastate churches in Florida, raising fears of a serial arsonist.
    “It's sheer luck that no one has been killed or seriously injured.”
    @ 41m 29s
    March 09, 2017

Episode Quotes

  • She was just a really good person.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 18
  • Astronomical odds the two Marys were killed 3 days apart.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 18
  • I never thought that Liz was a man.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 18
  • Life is nothing, I'm going to get out.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 18
  • Bill helped us out when he saw the rain coming.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 18
  • The love of the thing maybe got the better of his soul.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 18

Key Moments

  • Murder Mystery00:11
  • Bizarre Coincidence12:06
  • Fraud Uncovered17:59
  • Chilling Betrayal25:36
  • Ghostly Protection32:27
  • Serial Arsonist39:59

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown

Related Episodes

Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 2
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 2
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 19
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:55
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 19
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 7
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 7
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 15
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:54
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 15
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 21
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:55
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 3, Episode 21
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 4, Episode 16
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 4, Episode 16
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 4, Episode 11 - Updated Full Episode
July 26, 2021
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:50
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 4, Episode 11 - Updated Full Episode
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 6, Episode 22
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 6, Episode 22
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 4
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 4
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 4, Episode 20
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:53
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 4, Episode 20
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 7, Episode 11
March 09, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:50
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 7, Episode 11
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 2 - Updated Full Episode
July 26, 2021
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
42:58
Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 5, Episode 2 - Updated Full Episode