Search Captions & Ask AI

Heated Rivalry Producers: How We Made a Hit

February 07, 2026 / 39:26

This episode features a discussion about the hit show "Heated Rivalry" with creator Jacob Tierney and executive producer Brendan Brady. Topics include queer representation, the show's success, and production challenges.

Jacob and Brendan discuss the importance of portraying queer joy in media, emphasizing that many queer stories focus on trauma rather than happiness. They believe that the show's romantic elements resonate with audiences, particularly women.

The conversation touches on the Canadian film and TV production system, highlighting how it differs from the U.S. model. They explain the funding structure and the benefits of retaining intellectual property.

Brendan shares insights on the show's unexpected success and the reactions from industry executives who initially rejected it. Both guests express gratitude for the positive impact the show has had on viewers.

They conclude by discussing future projects, including a comedy series about Indigenous characters, and the importance of maintaining creative control in the industry.

TLDR

Jacob Tierney and Brendan Brady discuss the success of "Heated Rivalry" and its impact on queer representation in media.

Episode

39:26
00:00:06
Hi everyone, this is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisser. Today we've
00:00:11
got a special bonus episode and it's not about anything terrifying or depressing.
00:00:16
It's about the most addictive, delightful, surprise cultural phenomena of the decade, heated rivalry. I'm
00:00:21
joined today by the show's creator, Jacob Tierney, and executive producer Brendan Brady. Uh, welcome you two. You
00:00:28
guys are in mood already. I already >> Thanks, Cara. >> We've been beset by some tech issues,
00:00:33
but nonetheless, the gays will prevail. Um, the success of the show is about so many things. Queer joy, uh, uh, sex,
00:00:40
inclusion. It's amazing business story, and that's really what I wanted to talk
00:00:44
about. Um, but first for the fans, are we getting a standalone episode before season 2?
00:00:49
>> Um, I love saying now this is Brendan. So, um, uh, I would say that like much
00:00:55
like the best parts of this show, just enjoy the year. >> Enjoy the year. Is that on your t-shirt?
00:01:05
>> Oh, no. Soon. Trademark. Trademark. We trademarked it. >> Yeah. Okay. Because that means no.
00:01:10
That's a no. >> That's We'll see here. This is Jacob speaking now. Uh, that's a here's the
00:01:16
here's the truth and that nobody actually wants to hear is that we just don't know yet. We are, you know, we we
00:01:22
actually only finished this show basically a week before episode 6 aired and so this has been a a massive uh
00:01:31
surprise and endeavor and endeavor and we didn't really have a moment to catch
00:01:35
our breaths before answering questions like this. So the truth is we're getting
00:01:39
a plan in place. We will have more information for folks soon. Uh we understand that there's an appetite for
00:01:44
a lot of this and we're just trying to figure out what we can physically accomplish in in in the next year
00:01:50
>> in the next year. So one thing this show has been a giant PR boost to the entire
00:01:54
your entire country. Here's Prime Minister Mark Carney at a recent media event. You had to speaking of Feel the
00:01:59
Year, but go ahead. >> The world knows that Shane and Ilia are rising hockey stars who fall for each
00:02:06
other as they face off in one of the greatest rivalries the game has ever known.
00:02:11
But they're also two young men who are terrified of being their fullest self.
00:02:19
And we live in an increasingly dangerous, divided, and intolerant world. A fundamental Canadian value is
00:02:29
that people should be able to be whoever they want to be, to love whoever they want to love. So uh the narrative has
00:02:41
become that it was a little show out of Canada obviously made in Canada because American disturbers were afraid of the
00:02:45
sex content. Why don't you start Jacob the reaction first of all and the kind
00:02:49
of what you think is happening here from I mean I'm sure you've answered this
00:02:53
question but he sort of articulates it rather well is that people are are upset and divided and this brings a respit but
00:03:01
I think it's more than that in my in my opinion but why don't you start Jacob
00:03:05
then you Brendan >> I mean I think that there's I I think that what the show did
00:03:12
in an in a kind of an unpreachy un trying to teach you a lesson way is just present queer joy. And I think that
00:03:21
that's its soft power. You know, that's the thing that I think people are
00:03:25
surprised by and and that that is hit people, at least from what what I'm getting. And I think that while there
00:03:33
are queer stories out there, I don't think there's a lot of joy. And I don't
00:03:37
think that the the the the kind of profound joy that you only find in romance really that kind of
00:03:43
heartfilling, fantasy fulfilling, desireful things that that you get to see don't happen to
00:03:50
queer people in media. And I think that that is the kind of whoosh of it all, >> especially men. There's a lot of lesbian
00:03:58
content out there. I can tell you the L word. >> I think especially men. And I and I
00:04:02
think that um yeah, we just don't to have a story that chooses to not and you
00:04:09
know there are obviously our queer lives are filled with trauma and and I get that and we I think we all
00:04:15
know that but I think that this this show's desire to not focus on that to focus on other parts of the queer
00:04:21
experience as fantasy and I fully admit it's a romance. It's from a romance
00:04:26
romance. um that that I think that that's the partly the reaction to it. Um there's a lot I don't pretend I can
00:04:34
explain, but I do that it is that >> that is kind of that's the big difference.
00:04:39
>> Yeah, it's different experience for gay people versus straight people, I think.
00:04:42
And because I was always waiting for the hit. >> Yeah. I think we all are. And I think
00:04:45
especially because they have sex so early and we are trained that if we have sex, we will be punished. So if we can
00:04:51
not have sex, we might be able to be happy. But we can't do both. You don't
00:04:55
get to have a sex life and be happy. If you want to have a sex life, get ready to die. And if you want to be happy, get
00:05:01
ready to not have sex. >> I I think like the other part of this uh which Jacob has talked about a lot and
00:05:07
it was kind of how we were pitching this when we were going out to people, which
00:05:10
is this is a story written by women and it's consumed primarily by women and we
00:05:16
don't take female uh desire and stories seriously in media a lot of the times.
00:05:23
Um, I think a show uh like this that came out of nowhere is kind of we were when we were pitching it, we were really
00:05:29
crossing our fingers hoping that we were right. We were like there is a built-in
00:05:33
audience there. The these books are consumed. So there's so many readers of all types of romance novels. They're
00:05:40
there and they are yearning for uh for these stories to be told. So, I think that was the other like secret sauce in
00:05:48
this is just like this is a massive fan base that have not had their stories taken seriously and they got to see it
00:05:55
taken seriously and they loved it. >> We'll talk about that because romance I
00:05:59
always say everyone's like why it's so popular. I'm like it's a romance novel.
00:06:02
It's from romance novels are pop. It's one of those genres that people don't
00:06:05
realize how big it is, how big >> and genre it's been around since the
00:06:09
dawn of time. Like it's as old as a detective story, you know? It's as old
00:06:12
as all of like romance is there would have been a time when when Jane Austin would have been considered romance. I
00:06:19
mean that's these are and it's dismissed. >> I think to Brendan's point, it's
00:06:23
dismissed despite the fact that it it the romance genre carries the publishing industry in terms of fiction.
00:06:30
>> Um and I think it's dismissed because um of the misogyny that we all endlessly
00:06:35
live with because it's something that appeals to women, is often written by women and consumed by women. And so why
00:06:41
would any I've said this before I was like if this show was about a boy with a
00:06:45
gun somebody would have optioned this book 10 years ago you know >> well a hockey player with a gun
00:06:51
>> anyway talk about this but getting it made like we talked on this success on
00:06:55
on on what it symbolizes the difference between Canada and the US though even how these productions are funded um let
00:07:03
me talk about this idea of was made in Canada because American distributors and let me play very quickly a part Mark
00:07:10
Carney's speech about that and how it was funded >> on behalf of Canada's new government.
00:07:17
Look, I'm a politician. I'm not above taking credit for the Canadian funding
00:07:22
that helped you share this story with the world. I might not have been here when the decision was made, but I'm here
00:07:28
now. So, uh, yeah, I made I green lit this thing. I stood up to the Americans. >> Oh, that's amazing.
00:07:36
>> That was an amazing speech. >> Yeah. So I I think that um like you know
00:07:42
this speech that he gave was at an event uh called prime time which is hosted by
00:07:47
the producers uh Canadian producer of media association like the Canadian version of the PGA and the point of this
00:07:54
was to raise awareness of what's going on in our industry because uh the entertainment landscape is under attack
00:08:02
right now. We've been trying to update our systems. Um, and because of Koosma,
00:08:08
because of uh the US's um, you know, wanting to come in and tell us how to run our country and how our cultural
00:08:16
sector needs to be dictated. There's a lot of concern about whether or not we're going to have a system in place
00:08:22
that has cultural sovereignty for Canada. And so for us, what was so amazing about this experience and
00:08:28
getting to see Mark Carney there is our show was made in the Canadian system and
00:08:33
it is very different from the US. We >> Well, explain it. Explain it for people
00:08:37
who don't understand. >> So basically the Canadian uh film and TV system has subsidies and equity and
00:08:44
grant systems that are propped up by the Canadian government. So we, you know, when you go to a broadcaster like we did
00:08:51
with Crave, which is the streaming platform in Canada that um commissioned the show, uh they go and say, "Okay,
00:08:58
great. Here is a license fee." Typically, it'll run between 20 to 30% of the budget. Then we have a tax
00:09:05
credit, both provincial and federal, and that brings another 20 to 30% of the budget. And then it's always that last
00:09:12
little piece that you're looking for, right? So the benefit to us in uh Canada
00:09:17
as producers is it's unfortunate that we don't get necessarily the whole budget
00:09:23
out of our uh broadcasters but we as the producers own all the underlying IP. >> So that is a big
00:09:31
>> you don't sell it to a studio in the system >> but the the you know the limitations on
00:09:38
that are you have to go then raise money. So, how we did this with our show is we ended up talking to a couple of uh
00:09:46
studios, some of them American, some of them Canadian, and ultimately it wasn't
00:09:51
the right fit from a creative perspective. And, you know, we've we understand where everybody was coming
00:09:57
from. It is a this was, you know, on paper didn't seem like a an amazing massive hit right out the gate. Um, and
00:10:05
so luckily when we were going through this process, uh, Crave's parent company, which is Bell Media, Bell Media
00:10:12
is like if Comcast and Disney were merged into one in our country. They own everything from telecommunications to
00:10:19
internet to sports >> and they have divisions like Craig, which is their only streaming platform. They have
00:10:26
others, right? Yes, it's their only streaming platform. >> So, it's like a Disney Hulu or whatever.
00:10:32
>> Exactly. But they're also it's like and and they have CTV which is their ABC. So
00:10:36
they have a terrestrial they have a terrestrial channel and they have streaming.
00:10:40
>> They have cable channels, they have a streaming platform. Um and they had just
00:10:44
acquired a distribution company called Sphere Abacus uh out of the UK. And so we were looking for that last 30% of the
00:10:53
budget and um they came in for 20 more% on a distribution advance. So the last 10% was Jacob and I putting our producer
00:11:02
fees and we put in almost all of our producer fees less what we had to keep back because you still have to pay for
00:11:08
taxes. So it was a big gamble for us but ultimately I can I >> So what you would have earned for this
00:11:14
the fees that are standard right when you when you what was the total budget here?
00:11:20
>> So we were just under 3 million Canadian an episode. >> Amazing. That's pretty low. Which is
00:11:27
what >> I don't know if you know what a big deal this is, but Brendan is telling the
00:11:30
truth. >> Yeah, we've been >> Cara Swisser gets >> She gets the truth. This is exclusive.
00:11:37
>> So, we were uh we were just under three uh per episode >> per episode Canadian,
00:11:43
>> right? Because it looks great, by the way. It didn't look on the cheap or
00:11:46
anything else cuz >> that's also that speaks to Jacob and his amazing abilities. He's directed over a
00:11:52
100 episodes of television. So he knows what he's doing and also speaks to a way
00:11:56
in which we like to work uh which we feel really is is different than the US system or typical
00:12:02
>> is an enormously low amount of for people who don't know it's it's very low
00:12:06
for a reg television shows I mean the salary >> it's low for a sitcom it's deeply low
00:12:10
for a 1-hour drama. Yeah. >> Deeply low for most those are the salaries of certain people depending.
00:12:17
So, um, talk, you know, obviously these were not well-known people, but still it's still an expensive thing. I think
00:12:23
most US ones, I feel like 10 million is the lowest they make, right? >> It can, it depends. It's like between
00:12:29
six to four to$10 million an episode US is typical. Uh, depending on what your level is, but yeah, I mean, costs have
00:12:37
really skyrocketed over the last decade. >> Is it less expensive to make this in
00:12:42
Canada from a production perspective? >> No, we have an efficient model. Um, and
00:12:46
I mean, yes, it is because we don't have the same level of money that is being
00:12:51
thrown around. So, we by necessity have to spend less. Um, but we also like did something here where we shot all six
00:12:59
episodes in 36 days. Jacob shot shot Jacob directed all six of them. We block shot them like one giant movie. Um, we
00:13:09
talk about this when studios, especially US studios, come and say, "How do you
00:13:13
guys do this?" And we go, "It's crazy." You have all of your episodes written
00:13:18
before you go into prep. And that's typically when we lose people and they don't understand,
00:13:22
>> right? Because they write it through. They although that's changing in the US
00:13:26
actually. >> It's crazy to do it the other way. It's especially when you're not doing 22
00:13:30
episodes anymore. Like back in the old model when you're doing this volume of
00:13:33
episodes where it's not possible to have them all ready. >> Well, you have writers on staff.
00:13:36
>> Well, you have to just be writing all the time. But if you're doing if the new
00:13:39
model is 8 to 10 episodes, there's almost no reason why this can't be accomplished before you start shooting.
00:13:44
So, you start shooting. Go ahead. Go ahead. >> Yeah, we start shooting and then we do
00:13:48
10-hour shoot days primarily. Like, I'm not going to say it's not every day, but
00:13:52
we try to keep our hours low. And there's a couple of reasons for this. A, as soon as you get into 12, 13 hours
00:13:59
with crews, you end up paying for an additional day by virtue of the overtime. Uh, but we also just feel that
00:14:06
like, you know, my wife is an assistant costume designer. She was the assistant costume designer on this show. She's 5
00:14:12
months pregnant. Uh the departments that Thank you. The departments that get hooped are hair, makeup, wardrobe with
00:14:20
these precalls a lot of the time. Who are those departments run by? Primarily women. And so we also just feel that
00:14:28
like there in our business we need to change this mentality of endlessly shooting 15 16 hour days which is where
00:14:35
the costs balloon. >> Right. Right. What are you a lesbian? What's happening here? Anyway, so but
00:14:40
but Jacob talk about your production style. you you besides being you know truncated like making it tight you keep
00:14:46
it keep it tight kind of thing you call it anti-fascist explain what you mean by
00:14:51
that >> well I mean I guess what I what I mean about that is there's a desire often for
00:15:00
perfection that is I think not only unachievable but also uh insane and cruel to be even attempting. There's no
00:15:10
reason to do if you're doing 25 takes of a scene because you don't like the
00:15:13
performance of the actor. I I'm an actor. I've been doing this since I was
00:15:16
four years old. The problem is the scene. It's not the actor. You haven't
00:15:19
written it properly. If you're not accomplishing what you need to accomplish, there's a fundamental issue.
00:15:23
And by torturing people into repeating and repeating and repeating, I don't know what you're gaining. And so that's
00:15:29
kind of >> I just did I just did a it was all day. I was like, why? I kept saying why is it
00:15:35
all day? >> To do nine different sizes on a closeup is insane. All of this stuff is crazy.
00:15:39
It's just like it doesn't add to anything except exhaustion and to overworking people. I would and what I
00:15:46
like to say is I would rather be surprised by an offering from an actor than control every last aspect of their
00:15:52
performance. And I've used the a scene as an example like on the day when we
00:15:56
were shooting. There's a scene in the sixth episode in the cottage after the
00:16:00
boys have been caught by Shane's dad where Hudson and Connor have a scene together and they essentially he decides
00:16:06
that he's going to go talk to his parents. Ilia's going to come with him.
00:16:09
And when we were shooting it, I thought I I wasn't convinced that I was going to
00:16:14
use what Hudson was doing in that scene. I thought it might be too much. He was reacting. He had a big reaction which is
00:16:20
interesting for Hudson because he's a very internal actor especially when he's
00:16:22
playing Shane and I didn't say anything and I just kind of watched it and I was
00:16:26
like this is interesting. I think I can cut around this. I think I can figure out how to get what I want out of this
00:16:31
scene. And then when I got to the editing room and my editor put the scene together, she loved what he had done.
00:16:38
And I looked at it again with new eyes and I was like, "Oh, I actually love
00:16:41
this too." And I'm so glad I didn't insist on some idea that I had in my
00:16:45
head because what he brought to the table was more interesting and it was surprising and it was full of life and
00:16:51
it wasn't part of some insane jigsaw plan that I had in my head that needs to
00:16:56
fit together or everything falls apart. >> And I >> Well, it's a different way of creating,
00:17:00
right? >> It is a different way of creating, but also I I do believe fundamentally that
00:17:04
film and TV is an ensemble process. It is. Otherwise, go write a book, you know, go paint a picture. There's lots
00:17:09
of ways to be in total control, but as soon as you invite other talents in, as soon as you invite, you're in a medium
00:17:16
in which that is a part of how it's going to have to happen to ask these brilliant people to work with you and
00:17:21
then not listen to them or not use their skill. >> Although that's sort of the director
00:17:25
genre, right? Like the director gets to run everything gets to run. >> And I think it's a crazy system, you
00:17:30
know, like I want to work with talented people and I want to what are they doing
00:17:34
here if I'm not going to listen to them? if I'm not going to incorporate their
00:17:36
ideas, if I'm not going to incorporate what makes them so talented, why I wanted to work with them in the first
00:17:41
place. And so, you know, anti-fascist might be a big statement, but it is kind of it's a rejection of an idea that
00:17:47
everything has to come from one person and like what you know, the the brilliant idea is very top.
00:17:53
>> Yeah, I've had I've had very little experience, but I've been on several
00:17:56
sets. I mean, the idea of somebody taking your cell phone from you when you get to work because they want you
00:18:02
focused on their art is so pardon, my friend. So [ __ ] male and boring and stupid to me. Why does the girl can't he
00:18:09
can't text his wife about dinner because your genius extends that? I It's just
00:18:14
exhausting. It's >> Yeah. Yeah. It's also long. It's long. >> It's torture.
00:18:19
>> I I kept saying to people, I got things to do. This is a job. So when you talk
00:18:24
about owning this intellectual property, what does that mean now for you all? Because I own all my intellectual
00:18:29
property just so you know and I think it's important. Explain why it is for you especially in this space because
00:18:34
that's something that's been an anathema to the industry. Well, I'll tell you
00:18:38
what it means is like Jacob and I uh you know worked on a show called Letter Kenny and Shy and the producers of that
00:18:45
show made it in Canada as well and they had a robust merchandise business and when we were in post-prouction we
00:18:53
decided because we have we you know retained all the intellectual property behind the series that we wanted to take
00:19:00
advantage of that and make a line of merchandise which we're doing which is now incredibly uh like it's It's become
00:19:07
this amazing part of our business that we're super excited about. But it also
00:19:12
means that ultimately like when we we made the decision to reinvest our fees, it was because we knew that if this goes
00:19:20
really well, we're going to benefit for the next 25 years off of this. And that
00:19:26
is the difference. And I think like what you know people always ask about or I guess you look at the Canadian system
00:19:33
versus the American system. the Canadian system. You as the producers, if you want to take advantage of being a really
00:19:40
truly Canadian show, part of the G like the offering is the broadcasters can't
00:19:46
own the IP. The producers get to and some people will look at that, you know, the but the flip side in the US is
00:19:54
you're making way more money upfront. I don't think that either is right and the
00:19:59
other is wrong. I just think that our system uh is something to protect because what's happening in the US you
00:20:07
can kind of look to and say I mean is this fully working right now like can we really argue that this system is better
00:20:14
than ours? No. But I can say that for a hundred years this business was run on the idea that creators and the people
00:20:22
who made it got to own and benefit from what they did did for their entire lives. And I think that that's something
00:20:30
worth fighting for. >> I I think so completely. At some point, I wasn't gonna make something for
00:20:35
someone and I said, "You just have to give me IP." And they said, "Why do you
00:20:38
have to have it?" I said, "None of your business." Cuz I want it.
00:20:41
>> Yeah. >> Cuz it's mine. It's not yours. >> It's like the old musician, right? It
00:20:45
was like own your own publishing, right? Because why would you let somebody else
00:20:48
administer your work and take all the profit from it? >> That's correct.
00:20:51
>> And like we're going to we have opportunities and we will work in this
00:20:55
system that doesn't have that and it'll be fine as well. But I just think that
00:20:59
like when we talk about, you know, there's so many reasons why budgets have exploded. You know, the economy
00:21:05
of scale on on TV has just completely fallen out because we don't make episode
00:21:11
enough episodes. We don't contain them into certain locations. But also, it doesn't matter if you have a massive hit
00:21:18
or kind of a middling hit, you seem to win no matter what at that level. So I think that there is something to look at
00:21:25
as we move forward in these systems of like giving people back end again like these these old ideas should be new
00:21:32
>> right which they which they have changed. So we're going to take a quick
00:21:35
break when we come back we'll have a question from a big fan. We're back with
00:21:39
Rob's executive producer Jacob Dier and Brendan Brady uh who are behind the the
00:21:45
people behind this huge hit heated rivalry. I'm friends with Eileen Chaen, the executive producer of the L- Word,
00:21:50
Handmaid's Tale, and many other shows. And of course, the groundbreaking sort
00:21:54
of gay show in the United States was this one, uh, which was many moons ago. She had a question we're going to play
00:22:00
for you right now, Jacob. I love your show. Absolutely love it. Congratulations. Here's my question. Our
00:22:07
mutual friend, colleague, agent, ally, Matt Felker, shared with me the outlandish and stupidly familiar story
00:22:14
of getting heated rivalry on the air. all the rejections that preceded your fabulous and well-deserved massive
00:22:21
success. So, do you feel vindicated, pissed, annoyed, smuggly satisfied, grateful, just enjoying the process,
00:22:30
more determined than ever to tell sexy queer human stories, some other emotion that I didn't describe or perhaps
00:22:37
haven't yet even experienced? >> That's a um that's a great question. I
00:22:43
>> She's great. For people that don't know, Lord really >> brilliant show,
00:22:46
>> groundbreaking at the time. Um, was shocking and showed people happy. >> Yes, it did. It showed a lot of
00:22:54
complexity. I mean, yeah, it was a Yeah, that's a real Thank you, um, for the
00:22:59
question and thank you for being a fan of the show. That's so cool. And I'm
00:23:03
sorry that Matt Felker is both of our agents. Um, it's a joke. I love Matt Felker, but um you know uh uh I can't
00:23:10
pretend there isn't a part of me that's slightly smug. I mean, you know,
00:23:15
a show like this we're experiencing here with this show is so like beyond the
00:23:20
beyond in the land of you can have a successful show as I did with Letter Kenny previously and it does not explode
00:23:27
in this way and this this level of attention. Um, I, you know, I I try to not I I'm in therapy and I try to not be
00:23:36
I try to not be toxic exteriorly. And I think that the lesson that I want to take away from this experience is to
00:23:42
continue to trust myself creatively because that is the thing that paid off is that I felt very strongly and I
00:23:49
luckily had enough backing and support Brendan primarily obviously and then my my creative crave family all these
00:23:56
executives there and and I did trust something inside me that was like I'm not doing that. I'm not doing what these
00:24:02
folks want me to do. And I just to be very clear it wasn't just Americans it
00:24:05
was other Canadians too. It was a lot of people like this. They all like the lean-in like, "Oh, you have a gay hockey
00:24:10
show with sex." And they were like, "That's not what we meant. Too much sex,
00:24:13
too much hockey, too little hockey, too little sex." Whatever it was, it was all
00:24:17
like, "Why is it like this? Can it be different?" And I really was like, "I
00:24:21
don't think it should be. I think it should be what it >> What was the craziest thing?" Um, my
00:24:25
ex-wife started Planet Out and then and they merged with Gay.com and one of the venture capitalists said, "Couldn't they
00:24:32
just be hip people versus gay people?" I mean, listen. And she said she said I
00:24:36
she was like what? Like >> I think the thing that didn't the thing that was the most you don't get this
00:24:42
note that we got I think was the idea of needing a female entry point into the show because women wouldn't watch this
00:24:48
show if there wasn't a woman protagonist. And I was like you know women read these books women write these
00:24:54
book gay men don't even know these books exist. Like these are for women. And so
00:24:59
the miss that gap in understanding u and I do think there's a thing with TV you know a lot of executives they get it
00:25:07
feels like they get paid by the note and so if they are not coming in with a big
00:25:10
thought what are they even doing in the room the most of the best executives that I know are the people that actually
00:25:15
speak the least and that kind of trusting creators and then when they do give a note uh I take it because this is
00:25:21
somebody that is rowing in the same direction as me. This is somebody trying to make the same show as me. So in
00:25:27
general they call it drive by editing. >> Yeah. There you go. Yeah. And so I I
00:25:31
think that there was such a misunderstanding of who the what the audience wanted out of this and what I
00:25:37
chose to trust was my gut and the IP and the audience that was already enjoying it. And I was like why would you change
00:25:45
this when it's already being consumed and obsessed over to this degree? Why do
00:25:49
you think you know more? >> What about you Brendon? Oh, um I've also listen there the best thing that
00:25:56
happened was we we are friends with a couple of folks who ended up passing because their their bosses wouldn't get
00:26:03
on board and getting them letting them come to us and be like I told my boss look what you missed out that is the fun
00:26:10
part of the like kind of smuggness I think you know but to be honest um this has been absolutely nuts Cara like we're
00:26:19
this has been so crazy it's so much bigger than we ever thought. I think the
00:26:24
>> now everybody's your friend, right? >> Yeah. But also I just feel that I'm
00:26:28
going to sound a little polyianish here, but I mean it. We are trying to also stay grounded by being of service to
00:26:36
people. Part of the reason why we were at the CMPA thing with uh Mark Carney was to kind of raise awareness for our
00:26:44
industry and we're just trying to figure out ways to to stay grounded with the
00:26:49
people and the things that make uh you know we've got this incredible platform.
00:26:52
We want to use it to to actually promote positive issues. Um and we're we're
00:26:58
hoping that that's what we can kind of do. And that's been the most fun thing
00:27:02
that we've gotten to to experience right now is like hearing from people how
00:27:07
their lives are being changed and how we are now able to actually affect a modicum of change. Even if it's just
00:27:13
pushing everything in the right direction, we're not going to change the entire universe here.
00:27:18
>> No, of course not. But but the specificity of the things we are able to
00:27:21
change has been really positive and lovely. So in that genre, I want to play something Matt Damon said on Joe Rogan
00:27:27
last month about how streaming has impacted the creative process because a lot of it part of it are people breaking
00:27:32
free, right? Like myself many years ago or I have a lot of people coming to me. I'm like it's great out here. Like you
00:27:38
don't need all that stuff. But let's talk let's hear what he had to say. And
00:27:41
this is a very successful actor and producer. >> Sorry. You said Matt Damon. Matt Damon.
00:27:45
Oh, okay. Interesting. >> He's talking about the the business. >> I've heard of him. I think I've heard of
00:27:49
him. You've heard of him. Like for instance, Netflix um you know standard way to make an action movie that we
00:27:57
learned was you know you usually have like three set pieces, one in the first act, one in the second, one in the third
00:28:02
and you know you kind of ramp up and the big one with all the explosions and you
00:28:06
spend most of your money on that one in the third act that's your kind of finale. Um and now they're, you know,
00:28:11
they're like can we get a big one in the first five minutes to get somebody, you
00:28:15
know, we want people to stay >> Yeah. tuned in and and can and you know it wouldn't be terrible if you
00:28:21
reiterated the plot three or four times in the dialogue because people are on their phones while they're watching. You
00:28:27
know what I mean? >> So talk about that. He would, by the way, would make an excellent gay hockey
00:28:31
player. But um >> too old an old gay hockey >> a retired one. Sure. >> Listen, I should be clear. I love Matt
00:28:39
Damon. I've always loved Matt Damon. >> So what talk about that? What's
00:28:42
happening now in in the creation? Do you either of you feel pressure? >> We have yet to really experience that if
00:28:49
I'm being perfectly honest, Crave was not like that. Um, and I will say that
00:28:54
part of what the reaction to the show that has been so kind of interesting to me is people saying like this is a show
00:29:01
you have to pay attention to. If you're on your phone, you're not going to get
00:29:03
it because it's so much about what is not being said, about catching looks between people. It is dialogue as
00:29:09
avoidance and obiscation. And the story line is actually really simple. They're
00:29:14
in love. they can't admit it. So like it's actually not a super complicated
00:29:17
plot in that way, but so much of it is about the ways in which they're avoiding
00:29:21
each other, the ways in which they cannot speak. That's why the sex is so important because that's when they're
00:29:27
being honest. And so I think there is definitely a move towards oversimplification.
00:29:33
That being said, you know, I I don't I wouldn't want to make too much of a big
00:29:37
deal about this. Like everybody wants an opening that captures you. Like that's
00:29:40
not new. like that that that's been a note since the dawn of time with stories
00:29:44
like let me in what's the first scene why are you capturing my attention I don't think that's insane and I think
00:29:51
that like I think that that's you know I think that this thing you can see it I
00:29:55
think in a lot of streamers you know where you're like oh boy you've just
00:29:58
explained a thing to me that I already know I get I get that that can be frustrating but I would also add I am on
00:30:04
my phone when I look up and realize you've said it to me this for the third time and I'm like yeah you're not wrong
00:30:10
I did drip Right. >> But and I think that there can be room for both. You know, entertainment and
00:30:15
popcorny fun stuff that like I kind of don't care. And then every once in a while something comes along and you need
00:30:20
to pay attention and that's okay too. And then and then it's up to you to
00:30:23
choose. Do you is that too much for you? That's okay. Move it along. >> Yeah. I actually didn't look at my I I
00:30:28
have a rule like how many how many text looks isn't in a movie? How good is it
00:30:32
if I don't pick it up at all? >> We have shows in my household with my
00:30:36
boyfriend that we put on to be on our phones with. We're aware of this and we
00:30:40
think of them as like visual podcast. The >> Grammys Grammys was a good one. When you have
00:30:45
the the Netflix acquisition of Warner, does that affect it? >> Yeah. Yeah. Well, yeah, we don't I think
00:30:53
we don't, you know, we have no uh actual information on that. I would say um
00:30:58
again, we just want more competition in the marketplace and I think that this this
00:31:05
is part in Canada in everywhere everywhere really. But I think, you know, it's kind of to the point I was
00:31:12
making about like, is this system in the US working really well right now? I don't know. Is that good? Is this going
00:31:18
to be good for creators? Um, it's really hard to tell at this point, but I would
00:31:23
say like I don't love that there's less places to go cuz in Canada what we have
00:31:28
like the reason why we ended up on HBO uh around the world is because Crave and uh Bell Media have the exclusive rights
00:31:38
to all of HBO's uh catalog in Canada. >> Um and so if we don't have HBO, you have
00:31:46
Crave and that has HBO on it. And so like if we don't have that on Crave, does that
00:31:54
affect Crave? What happens to them? That's a big part of why people go there. I mean, now in now in heated
00:32:00
rivalry, obviously, but um but yeah, like I think that it's a scary time as we see more and more mergers happening.
00:32:08
And I for one would love to see uh just more competition because I think it's
00:32:13
way better when we have more. But what I would say too, I just that because we're
00:32:17
an acquisition, you know, HBO is not actually creatively involved in the show. I think they like they they say
00:32:23
nice things about it, which is great. Exactly. So, we're not like I think that
00:32:27
that that part is not really going to change uh at least in the foreseeable future.
00:32:32
>> Mhm. So, but now now that the show's blown up, they're not suddenly have an
00:32:36
opinion about >> No, they're still getting it for the same price. I think it's worked out
00:32:39
great for them. It's worked out really well for them. Like, this is a very successful acquisition. And I mean it's
00:32:44
clearly working well enough that I don't think they feel the you know yeah I I
00:32:48
think that this is just like keep doing it guys. That's the that's at least what
00:32:51
Casey has explicitly quite said to us is like keep going >> but it can go elsewhere right around the
00:32:57
world. >> Correct. >> So it's been sold territory by terri or chunk of territory by territory in
00:33:03
general p picked up by HBO outlets Sky in the UK and Ireland and in New Zealand. a couple of other exceptions to
00:33:09
that rule, but basically what they do is they buy it for and then they have an option on the second season and
00:33:15
potentially third season. So they get it's like a kind of a right of first refusal. So with with an increase they
00:33:20
get it. So it's not really even to be renegotiated. It's just kind of like you
00:33:24
either want this or you don't. There's no input into the content. >> Right. Right. Um I have a couple more
00:33:29
quick question quick questions. One is about obviously everyone here in the entertainment industry in LA seems to be
00:33:34
in despair in many ways in terms of what's happening and including with competition with AI and stuff. Do you do
00:33:40
you is there a big fear from you all about AI because this is the some of the big hits this year have been the most
00:33:46
nonI type of content like sinners weapons yours you know I think that yeah >> I want each of you to talk about
00:33:54
>> has more thoughts on this than I do. >> Okay. Uh yeah, I think that listen there
00:33:59
is going to be a place for AI in how we work in this business. I actually think that there are a lot of opportunities
00:34:07
but I think it is in that tool for creators not as the creative engine behind >> costumeuming.
00:34:15
>> I think like even scheduling, budgeting and prepping like those kinds of things
00:34:20
where you take an immense amount of time trying to just input data. So much of our jobs are data driven like just
00:34:26
trying to get information and I do think exactly I think that those are the opportunities right away that we will
00:34:34
see and where I would love for people to focus their attention because we were experiencing this and I'm sure Cara you
00:34:40
can you have had this with your team those moments of friction when you're trying to explain something to someone
00:34:49
and they don't get it that is hard to replicate that is hard to do with AI in
00:34:55
a way that actually gets you to a place where you're like, "Okay, cool. We have
00:34:59
now communicated together and we are on the aligned and you're now going to >> speaking of friction, your whole show is
00:35:05
about friction." >> Hell yeah. Hell yeah. But yeah, I think that I think it's hard. I think we
00:35:10
underestimate the importance of friction in the creative experience. >> Yep. I would agree. That's that's
00:35:16
exactly how I say it. I I talk about it. I the the words tech people use are always seamless, frictionless,
00:35:22
convenient. You know, they're always using those words. I'm like, "No,
00:35:25
friction's critical for you being here." >> Yeah. What about you, Jacob? Do you
00:35:30
think about it all? >> Uh, it confuses me. Uh, no. Is the answer. Like, I don't think like I again
00:35:37
like the way that the way that Brendon speaks about it is like that makes sense to him. I'm like, I can imagine it
00:35:41
helping me with some stuff, but like it's not going to write for me. Like I don't I don't want that either. I love
00:35:47
what I do. I don't want to I don't want someone I don't need that kind of help
00:35:52
is the way I would say. Yeah. >> So, before we go, what would you uh want to do if you could do anything? Like you
00:35:58
guys are now the world is your oyster kind of thing. Like you can do obviously you're going to do another season of
00:36:02
this, maybe two, three, whatever. Um because there's lots of books for people
00:36:07
don't realize. Um what what would you want to make? Would you direct say a pointed point break remake with your
00:36:14
heated survival stars? another one before they finally [ __ ] the game. >> Where they finally [ __ ]
00:36:23
that I'm very open to a father son story with Hudson Williams and Keanu Reeves.
00:36:28
However, I would >> um you know >> they do look alike. >> They do. They really do. And Keanu is
00:36:33
Canadian. He can come home. We can do a fun thing together. Um, you know, we are being we I'm certainly
00:36:40
being offered a lot of things and uh uh and uh yeah, I'm very excited about what's next. And I
00:36:46
>> Is there anything you're like, God, >> I can't really say, but I can tell you
00:36:50
that once I can talk about >> a couple of things. They are one of which in particular is a dream uh come
00:36:59
true. Uh so yeah, I I'm I'm excited to be able to eventually talk about it, but
00:37:03
I I can't at this point. We've got also Yeah. And we also we have a whole
00:37:08
productions company that we're running with a like a lot in development. So,
00:37:13
it's about getting these projects. The projects that, you know, from a producer
00:37:17
standpoint, what we really want to get made um are we have a number of shows. The one that is about to go out is
00:37:24
called The King is Dead. And I'm going to plug it right here because it's from
00:37:27
an amazing amazing indigenous writer out of Canada named Tim Fontaine. Crave is already signed on for development. We're
00:37:35
looking for that other partner because it's basically a uh uh it's a com action
00:37:42
adventure comedy set in the 1700s. I know. Bear with us. >> Hello, Outlander.
00:37:48
>> Yeah, 100%. But it's a comedy about a group of indigenous folks uh tired of
00:37:53
all these white people coming to North America. They take a boat, traverse back to England, uh, in an attempt to kill
00:38:03
King George III. >> Oh my god. History. >> It's like Monty Python energy. It's very
00:38:09
funny and we're very excited about that show. >> Yeah. So, that's in development with
00:38:14
Crave right now and we're very excited about that one. >> All right. Well, everybody loves you.
00:38:18
All the boys are getting a lot of attention, which they must be having a ball, it looks like, but you guys
00:38:22
deserve equal amounts of attention. We think what you make is amazing. and and in this time in the United States, it
00:38:29
was just what was needed for. So, get that episode out. Get that special episode.
00:38:35
>> We will. We will do our best. And thank you for having us on. We really
00:38:38
appreciate it. Thank you, Cara. >> Thank you, Jacob. And thank you, uh, Brendan. Um, thanks to the audience for
00:38:43
listening to our special bonus episode of Pivot. You'll be back in our fe will
00:38:47
be back in our feeds on Tuesday, and I will read us out. Today's show was produced by Larara Neon, Zoe Marcus, and
00:38:54
Taylor Griffin. Brandon McFarland engineered this episode. Jim Mle edited the video. Nishad Kerwa is Vox Media's
00:39:01
executive producer podcast. Make sure to follow Pivot on your favorite podcast platform. Thanks for listening to Pivot
00:39:07
from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com/pod.
00:39:13
We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. And Scott, eat your heart out.
00:39:18
I got the heat of rivalry, guys.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 75
    Best concept / idea
  • 70
    Best overall
  • 70
    Best direction
  • 70
    Most original

Episode Highlights

  • Cultural Sovereignty in Canada
    The creators discuss the unique Canadian production model and its significance.
    “This show was made in Canada because American distributors were afraid of the sex content.”
    @ 02m 44s
    February 07, 2026
  • The Power of Queer Joy
    Jacob Tierney discusses how the show presents queer joy as a powerful narrative.
    “Queer joy is its soft power.”
    @ 03m 21s
    February 07, 2026
  • Romance Genre's Popularity
    Exploring the overlooked significance of romance novels in media.
    “It's a romance novel; it's from romance novels that are popular.”
    @ 06m 01s
    February 07, 2026
  • Intellectual Property Ownership
    Owning intellectual property is crucial for creators, allowing long-term benefits from their work.
    “It's something worth fighting for.”
    @ 20m 30s
    February 07, 2026
  • The Importance of Attention
    The show's complexity requires viewers to pay attention, as much is unsaid.
    “You have to pay attention to this show.”
    @ 28m 58s
    February 07, 2026
  • The Role of AI in Entertainment
    AI can assist in production but should not replace the creative process.
    “AI is a tool for creators, not a creative engine.”
    @ 34m 04s
    February 07, 2026
  • The King is Dead
    A comedy about indigenous folks aiming to kill King George III, set in the 1700s.
    “It's like Monty Python energy. It's very funny!”
    @ 38m 06s
    February 07, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • Queer joy is its soft power.
    Heated Rivalry Producers: How We Made a Hit
  • It's a romance novel; it's from romance novels that are popular.
    Heated Rivalry Producers: How We Made a Hit
  • It's exhausting.
    Heated Rivalry Producers: How We Made a Hit
  • Cuz it's mine. It's not yours.
    Heated Rivalry Producers: How We Made a Hit
  • You have to pay attention to this show.
    Heated Rivalry Producers: How We Made a Hit
  • Friction's critical for you being here.
    Heated Rivalry Producers: How We Made a Hit

Key Moments

  • Introduction00:06
  • Tech Issues00:31
  • Cultural Commentary02:44
  • Queer Joy03:21
  • Production Insights08:41
  • Audience Engagement28:58
  • Exciting Projects36:45
  • Comedy Development38:14

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown