Penn Wharton Budget Model: Reconciliation Bill Adds $3.6T to Debt, Cuts Aid to Low-Income Households

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Kent Smetters, Faculty Director of the Penn Wharton Budget Model, joins Dan Loney to break down the newly passed reconciliation bill that extends the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. They discuss the projected $3.2–$3.6 trillion increase in national debt over the next decade, minimal short-term economic impact, and long-term GDP decline of over 4.5% over 30 years. Kent Smetters talks about the effects on Medicaid, SNAP benefits, and how lower-income households may lose about $1,000 annually by 2030. The conversation also covers the limited role tariff revenues play in offsetting costs.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#TaxCuts #NationalDebt #EconomicPolicy #PublicPolicy #USEconomy #TaxPolicy ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Brief Summary

Kent Smeters analyzes the reconciliation bill's economic impact, predicting increased national debt and modest effects on GDP and household benefits.

Key points

  • Reconciliation Bill Passed. The reconciliation bill has passed through Congress, raising concerns about national debt and job impacts.
  • Debt Projections. Kent Smeters predicts an additional $3.2 trillion in debt over the next decade due to the bill.
  • Impact on Lower Income Households. The bill is expected to negatively affect the bottom 40% of households, costing them about $1,000 annually.

Transcript

Well, the reconciliation bill passed through the Senate and the House, and it helps extend the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, but there are concerns about what the bill might do to the national debt, how it will impact jobs, various other issues, and the impact it will have on the labor force. Pleasure to be joined by Kent Smeters, who's faculty director of the Pen Wharton budget model, as well as a professor of business, economics, and public policy. The Pen Wharton budget model, by the way, has done a full review of the impacts and Kent joins us to go over them. Kent, great to talk to you again. How are you, sir? Be back. Thanks for having me again. Thank you. All right, so let's dig into

the numbers right now and what we see passed and signed by the president on July 4th. What are the impacts the Pen Wharton budget model expects to occur? So, as you pointed out, debt over time, that is higher deficits uh every single year over time. And so, we're expecting about 3.2 trillion in additional debt over the next 10 years. And if you do this on what's called a dynamic basis, that is you take into account economic feedback that it actually goes up, not down. In particular, the 3.2 trillion goes up to 3.6 uh trillion. And um the main reason there is some dynamics associated with who's paying taxes as well as how some

people can re-qualify for certain benefits like Medicaid and so forth. And so we uh show that uh really the impact on the economy is basically zero um or over the first 10 years technically a slight negative by about a third of 1% of GDP over 30 years a bigger negative impact roughly about four and a half% of GDP over 30 years that this will uh reduce the economy by um the main drivers there are just continued uh increases in debt even beyond the 10-year budget window. Uh you mentioned about the healthc care potential issues. Uh a lot of conversation about that. Also conversation about SNAP things like SNAP benefits. Uh give us a sense of what

kind of impact we're going to see there. Right. Um, so our numbers are probably not quite as pessimistic as CBOS's in terms of how many people are going to lose healthcare, but um, they're, you know, around 11 12 million. We're a bit less than that, but still um, there will be some people who will have a harder time qualifying for Medicaid. Um, this is in large part undoing um, some of the expansions that happened under uh, Biden as well as Obama on the Medicaid side. um uh in terms of the impact on say by income group. So the Senate what they purposely did is they delayed some of the hit until after the midterm election. We're basically saying the

bottom 20% tile right now in uh the year 2027 are basically going to have very little impact, but they will still be net losers of about $165 per household. Um uh but by 2030, the bill would basically um reduce resources for the bottom 40% of households. Uh it it would um if you take in account both taxes saved as well as transfers reduced that is how much less they get and principally in the form of Medicaid and SNAP the bottom 40% will lose roughly about $1,000 a year and that's mostly uh from the fact that some of the tax benefits that they otherwise would have enjoyed be before 2030 such as not no tax on tips And overtime that pretty

much wears off by that point. And the bigger loss really just comes from the loss of Medicaid and SNAP. So roughly about $1,000 per uh household in the lower 40% of the income distribution. You mentioned the taxes part of the story and a lot of discussion about uh you know the extension of the tax cut and jobs act and the potential benefits and that's talked a lot about by the administration. But there are also a lot of people out there who are saying that while there may be some benefit, it may not be as strong a benefit as what maybe people would like to see. Sure. I mean, the administration really um I don't know how to say this more

politely, but they just kind of uh greatly embellished the the economic benefits of uh this particular bill. And in particular, um, they said went as far as to say not only would the economic expansion be so big that the tax bases would grow so large that they um, it would the bill would actually pay for itself. So it would grow the economy so much that the bill would actually pay for itself. it would grow so much even more than that that it would then bring down the debt GDP ratio which without this bill is already increasing and so even before this became current law um the current law be you know a minute before this was signed already had an exploding debt the

GDP ratio over time so they they're saying this is going to create so much revenue it will even turn that around so it's not going to just pay for itself up, but it's going to like doubly pay for itself. I mean, it was just over the top and there's really no rational economic model that can justify that type of conclusion. So, like you said, um most groups, including us, you know, concluded that the economic impacts are pretty modest. You could go plus or negative in the first 10 years, but it's roughly around zero. And part of the conversation also is the uh the money the revenues that would be coming in from tariffs but that has you know a a small impact on what the overall numbers

would be for the government over the next several years as well. Correct. Right. And for this particular bill they can't count that money anyway because um that money would have been attributed to what's called executive action or executive order. And so for the purpose of this bill would be ex excluded. It's already part of what we call the baseline. Um but who knows where that money is gonna come down to. I mean if we took the April 2nd you know uh a rates seriously um and that's you know almost created a meltdown of financial markets. Um that would have raised potentially four to5 trillion dollars over 10 years. um but at the same time

really crush the economy. Um but if we look at more modest rates of you know to that they're potentially looking at we're maybe talking about a couple trillion dollars over 10 years. But the problem with that is that even if you use all that money to try to pay down debt that is to reduce the budgetary impact of this bill you're also really uh playing with capital markets. you're narrowing the base of capital markets over time by which you are trying to sell all this debt into. And so on one hand you get some revenue um so that you can use it to reduce reduce debt. But we really need a really open market you know worldwide capital market to be demanding our debt. And to the extent

that a reduction in trade reduces um the demand for our debt um uh that's going to uh be much more negative than any positive income that comes from the tariff revenue. And longer term, as you said, there's an impact to the ne to the downside over the next several decades with this bill in place. Um and that would obviously mean there's a negative impact on GDP as well, right? Um so even putting the tariffs uh issues aside we're projecting that indeed this bill would now law it would reduce GDP by over 4 and a.5% in about 30 years. So it really does add a fair amount to debt because it's not only that it's bigger

than the House version that was you know previously passed on the House side. What the Senate really did is they said we're going to make a lot of these provisions permanent, you know, for what's called bird rule compliance. We'll pretend like anything that's already in the tax discussion jobs act will not cost us anything because after and so there's a little bit of an accounting game going on. But in terms of actual debt that has to be sold by the US Treasury, that's going to remain the same. And that's just it's just more things that we have to finance really using debt. So there are options out there to deal with this, you know, growing debt problem. It's just that

they're not being discussed right now in DC. Yeah. Yep. All right, Kent, great to talk to you. Thanks very much for your time, sir. Pleasure. Thank you. Ken Smeters, faculty director of the Pen Wharton budget model and professor of business, economics, and public policy at the Wharton School.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes