Search Captions & Ask AI

The Impact of Referral Coupons

July 06, 2016 / 06:04

This episode features Wharton marketing professor Raghu Iyengar discussing his research on referral coupons and their impact on customer behavior and firm revenues.

Iyengar explains that his research involved a field experiment with an international beauty company that implemented referral coupons, which can be shared among customers. Contrary to expectations, the findings revealed that referral coupons did not perform better than traditional coupons.

Key takeaways include the importance of customer loyalty in the effectiveness of referral coupons. Iyengar notes that high loyalty customers tend to be better brand ambassadors, while low loyalty customers may feel skeptical about sharing coupons.

He emphasizes the need for customization in marketing strategies, suggesting that companies should tailor their approaches rather than using a one-size-fits-all method. Transparency about customer importance can also enhance coupon redemption and sharing.

Looking ahead, Iyengar expresses interest in combining field experiments with big data, particularly in the context of Internet of Things products and their effects on consumer behavior.

TLDR

Raghu Iyengar discusses his research on referral coupons, revealing they may not be effective for all customer types and emphasizing the need for customization.

Episode

6:04
00:00:01
today we're speaking with Wharton marketing professor Raghu iyengar about his research that looks at the impact of
00:00:07
referral coupons on customer behavior and firm revenues thanks for joining us Raghu thank you very much d for having
00:00:13
me can you give us a brief overview of your research sure so this research was a field experiment that we conducted in
00:00:19
collaboration with an international beauty company so this company like many other companies was taking inspiration
00:00:24
from a lot of interesting things that are going on in the couponing world so if you look at what's really hot these
00:00:29
days it's about referrals many companies are doing it especially tech companies
00:00:33
Airbnb does it uber does it draw bak was doing it you know PayPal was doing it many companies do it so this company
00:00:41
decided that they wanted route referral coupons and the idea of reference who pawns is the following let's say I send
00:00:46
you Steve as a customer a coupon if you can use it yourself that's great but
00:00:50
wouldn't it be great if you can share that coupon with your friends that's
00:00:54
what we're calling referral coupon a coupon that is redeemed by the person who receives it but also can be shared
00:00:59
with other customers so on the surface you might imagine referal coupons are better than typical coupons or the
00:01:04
traditional ones which cannot be shared what did we find well in fact they were not that better in fact they were worse
00:01:10
so does that was very surprised and what were the key takeaways from the research
00:01:15
so the big takeaway I think for us is while referrals clearly are a practice which is very mainstream one should take
00:01:22
a little pause it might not be the case that referrals are always good in fact it is the case that customers who come
00:01:28
from referrals one of my colleagues at Wharton christoph vanden bolter has found that customers were coming from
00:01:34
referrals are better than other customers / / about the sender's the sender's who have to make those
00:01:39
referrals they are not that easy to do you have to think about who is going to be better off from getting this referral
00:01:44
so a big takeaway was that don't ask for referrals from all of your customers in
00:01:49
fact what we found was customers who are high Lowell T customers these are people
00:01:54
who are committed to the brand these are people who bought from you quite a lot these people turn into brand ambassadors
00:02:00
they not only redeem a lot on their own they share that coupon with many other people but what happens for the low
00:02:07
loyalty customers these are customers who occasionally buy from you they're not frequent purchases they in fact are
00:02:12
not very happy getting that coupon why because in some sense you're asking them to do the job for you they might be
00:02:19
skeptical as to why is this firm wanting us to do the job for them and why do they want my network so what do we find
00:02:25
these low loyalty customers in fact redeem a lot less when they're given refuge upon as a course to standard good
00:02:32
and did any of these findings are surprised here I think you know when you think about referrals it's a big
00:02:38
practice you know the typical notion is that referals work I think what we found
00:02:43
was it doesn't work for everyone even a practice like sending out raffle coupons
00:02:47
should be customized I think that was a bit surprising to us because on the surface it looks like something that
00:02:52
shouldn't change people's behavior whether they get a referral coupon or a
00:02:56
regular coupon but what we found time and again and we did a bunch of field experiments in this paper we found time
00:03:01
and again it's a very robust finding in fact exposing people to referral coupons
00:03:05
even if they don't share themselves it actually changes their own behavior so
00:03:09
you mentioned customization so what are the key for practical implications for marketers so I think customization of
00:03:16
the bat is very important you know what it looks like is many practices which might seem as it might work in mass you
00:03:24
send everyone a coupon that's not to be the case I think you should even think
00:03:28
about customization right tail another thing that we found which was also managed really interesting as part of
00:03:32
the study was in one of the conditions we sent a referent coupon along with a value of how important the customer is
00:03:39
for example I'll send referral coupon to Steve and say well Steve here's a coupon
00:03:44
for you that you can share with your friends but also note to see that you're
00:03:47
a very important customer for us just a very fact that the company is being transparent they be upfront about how
00:03:54
important you are actually change people to become even better brand ambassadors
00:03:58
they redeemed a lot more they shared it with their friends a lot more they shared it with friends who bought a lot
00:04:04
more custom lot more products from the comfortable and what sets your research apart from other research in this area
00:04:10
so much work typically in referrals first of all it's quite limited and what
00:04:15
is present there is typically based on secondary data this is data based on historical purchases so what we wanted
00:04:22
to do was to work closely with the company with a forward-looking approach in the sense why don't we do a field
00:04:27
experiment which can help us asli look at the impact of ruffle coupons on future
00:04:32
behavior so if the most important part of the research is looking at causal impact doing a field experiment is a
00:04:40
gold standard so I think what sets this research apart is the ability to collaborate closely with the company and
00:04:46
doing a field experiment and what do you think you're going to look at next so I
00:04:51
think I really enjoy the idea of doing field experiments together with big data I think to me that alliance or that
00:04:58
Nexus is going to be very fruitful later on so one of the things that I'm very
00:05:02
interested in this idea of Internet of Things of course there are many companies out there there are you know
00:05:07
coming up with different products for example home automation products home monitoring products do these really help
00:05:13
how much do they help what what do consumers learn from these products so we are working very closely with a
00:05:19
company in Austin that is doing a lot of these internet of things in terms of electricity savings they are actually
00:05:25
doing a lot of experiments informing people how much electricity they are using sending out text messages using
00:05:31
smart thermostats to see whether they're able to regulate their usage that's the
00:05:37
next thing great thanks so much for joining us today thank you very much Steve you

Episode Highlights

  • The Surprising Truth About Referral Coupons
    Raghu Iyengar reveals that referral coupons may not be as effective as expected.
    “In fact, they were worse.”
    @ 01m 08s
    July 06, 2016
  • The Importance of Customer Loyalty
    High loyalty customers make better brand ambassadors compared to low loyalty customers.
    “These people turn into brand ambassadors.”
    @ 02m 00s
    July 06, 2016
  • Field Experiments vs. Historical Data
    Raghu explains how their research stands out by using field experiments instead of secondary data.
    “Doing a field experiment is a gold standard.”
    @ 04m 40s
    July 06, 2016

Episode Quotes

  • Referrals might not always be good.
    The Impact of Referral Coupons
  • Don't ask for referrals from all of your customers.
    The Impact of Referral Coupons
  • Customization is very important.
    The Impact of Referral Coupons

Key Moments

  • Referral Coupons Research00:07
  • Unexpected Findings01:08
  • Customer Loyalty Insights02:00
  • Field Experiment Approach04:28
  • Future Research Directions04:51

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown