00:00:00
They've come from
countries where they speak
00:00:01
Spanish, they're adults, they do
not know very much about our
00:00:05
financial system because they
just got here. And a lot of them
00:00:08
have had negative experiences
with the financial systems in
00:00:12
the countries where they came
from. And so material that is aimed
00:00:16
at that community, helping them
plug in to our financial system
00:00:21
as soon as possible and not get
ripped off and be able to send
00:00:24
money back to their own
countries, to remit money with—
00:00:28
once again, without getting
ripped off— this is a community
00:00:30
that has very specific needs,
00:00:32
and we want to
address those needs.
00:00:34
Welcome to The Ripple Effect, the
podcast that takes you on a
00:00:38
journey through the minds of
Wharton faculty. I'm your host,
00:00:41
Dan Loney. And in each episode,
we'll be diving deep into the
00:00:44
inspiration behind the
groundbreaking research that
00:00:47
Wharton professors have
conducted, and exploring how
00:00:50
their findings resonate with the
world today.
00:00:53
Well, financial literacy is receiving greater
attention these days, as
00:00:57
educators look at new and
innovative ways to improve the
00:01:01
knowledge, especially for
younger individuals, as we move
00:01:04
forward. Pleasure to be joined
here in studio by David Musto,
00:01:07
Professor of Finance here at the
Wharton School, who is involved
00:01:10
in a lot of these areas
right now.
00:01:12
David, great to see you again.
Thanks for your time.
00:01:13
Nice to be back.
Nice to be back.
00:01:14
Let's start with just, I guess,
your general thoughts about
00:01:17
where financial literacy stands
at the moment, kind of in our
00:01:21
culture, what it's missing, where
we need to go moving forward.
00:01:25
When you think about today's
high school student—which is
00:01:28
what we're focusing on a lot, and we
can talk about that— they
00:01:31
haven't had a lot of
opportunities to make financial
00:01:34
decisions. And they haven't had
to think, to some extent, about
00:01:38
things that you and I had to
think about a lot when we were
00:01:41
kids, like inflation, until
recently. Right? It didn't even come
00:01:44
up. And yet they have so many
big financial decisions ahead of
00:01:47
them. Not just student loans
that loom very soon in their
00:01:51
lives, but also responsibility
for their own retirement,
00:01:56
election campaigns that hinge on
financial issues that are hard
00:02:01
to understand. The demands on
them to understand finance are
00:02:04
greater than ever, so maybe
literacy might not be lower than
00:02:08
it was 40, 50, 100 years ago. But
the demands to be adept are
00:02:15
much higher than they used to
be.
00:02:16
And it seems like in many cases,
the resources to be able to
00:02:19
provide that information are not
there as much as they probably
00:02:23
should be. Hopefully, they will
increase in the years ahead,
00:02:25
but still a ways to go.
00:02:27
I've been involved in developing a
financial literacy course for
00:02:31
high school students, and it has
been an education to see how
00:02:36
little they've already seen, and
how little is already out there.
00:02:41
So it's been a great opportunity
for us to go in and— and really
00:02:45
be helpful and add some value to
their lives at a key
00:02:47
moment, too, when— when all these
decisions are just
00:02:50
about to come
up in their lives.
00:02:51
So tell us about what the course
entails and— and at what—
00:02:55
how you've been able to develop the
relationships with a lot of
00:02:58
these schools in order to
provide this information.
00:03:00
Okay, so the course that I'm
talking about is Essentials of
00:03:04
Personal Finance. Penn calls it
Finance 2, and that's
00:03:09
important. It's actually a Penn
class. These students are taking
00:03:12
it. 500 students are taking this
class right now, at schools all
00:03:16
around the country. And they are
getting Penn course credit. They
00:03:19
get a transcript from Penn
showing this course on it. It
00:03:23
covers the whole range of
financial issues that are
00:03:27
relevant in their lives right now.
Like if you are working at
00:03:32
checkout at a store, what's
coming out of your paycheck and
00:03:35
why? What does that get you?
Where's that going? And then
00:03:39
student loans, which are coming
up for a lot of these students
00:03:42
right away. Well, how do those
work? And it also covers some
00:03:46
topics that really are about
being an educated voter. So
00:03:49
when people say the Social Security
Trust Fund is running out. Well,
00:03:54
what is that? What exactly is
that? It's not a stack of
00:03:56
dollars somewhere that's running
out. But it— but it does mean
00:04:00
something, and it is running out
soon. So what does— what does that
00:04:03
mean? And the different
candidates say different things
00:04:05
about that. Well, what do you
like? What— what does that mean
00:04:08
for you? A lot of low hanging
fruit there that we are going
00:04:12
out there and providing. And the kids
not only get a chance to learn
00:04:16
this material, they get Penn
course credit. And I should add
00:04:19
that what's really made this
work for us is a partnership
00:04:22
between my center, the Stevens
Center, our global youth program
00:04:27
that— that reaches out to high
school students, and a nonprofit
00:04:31
in New York called the National
Education Equity Lab, which has
00:04:35
a lot of that last mile outreach
to these Title 1 high schools
00:04:40
around the country. So that
teamwork between my— the two centers
00:04:44
here at Wharton, and this New
York nonprofit is what's made
00:04:48
this work. So we have students
thousands of miles away from each
00:04:51
other taking the same course.
- Now it feels
00:04:53
like maybe in the past, maybe
we've underestimated the
00:04:57
importance and the value of
having this type of education,
00:05:01
and the understanding and having
all of this kind of in their
00:05:04
lives at a younger age, so they
can be better prepared when they
00:05:07
leave high school.
00:05:08
Oh, for sure, yeah. And I— we
noticed that specifically, in
00:05:11
the case of student loans. Kids
are 17 years old, having made
00:05:15
almost no financial decision in
their lives. And here's this
00:05:17
enormous financial decision to
make, borrowing tens of thousands of
00:05:22
dollars, when they've never
borrowed anything, and having to
00:05:25
deal with all the different nuts
and bolts of that. They're at a
00:05:28
perilous moment there and ripe
for being taken advantage of
00:05:33
too. And so just to make them
astute and adept is very
00:05:37
rewarding. I should say, also,
for our Wharton students, who
00:05:40
are the synchronous instructors
for this class, too— I made the
00:05:45
videos, but we have our Wharton
students who are actually the in-
00:05:48
class, over— you know, over the
internet— instructors to these
00:05:51
students all the way from
California to Florida.
00:05:54
So I understand one of the other
areas that you focused on is
00:05:58
the development of an app
00:05:59
that can help this process
out as well.
00:06:02
Yes. When we started the Center
five years ago, and were
00:06:05
looking around for, what's a way
we can reach out to the Penn
00:06:08
community that's grounded in
finance, and that would mean a
00:06:12
lot to the Penn community? And
we thought: student loans. For the
00:06:14
same reasons I just gave. Huge
decision, very early age. And so
00:06:18
we thought, what people could
use is an app to help them think
00:06:22
about taking out a student loan.
And not only that, what would be
00:06:25
really terrific is to bring high
school students here to Wharton
00:06:30
and have them build the app. So
they not only learn the finance
00:06:35
involved in student loans by
building the app, but they'd learn
00:06:38
everything else having to do
with essentially a little
00:06:42
startup company. We have a very
clear goal of what we want to
00:06:44
deliver, and different pieces of
the project. And different teams
00:06:48
of students are working on
different elements. And it's all
00:06:52
coming together. In fact, we're
having a launch on April 19, of
00:06:55
this app, trying to get it into
the hands of students as soon as
00:06:58
possible. So the students are
learning finance, and they're
00:07:01
also learning about
entrepreneurship, building a
00:07:04
company, getting it done.
00:07:07
It's just been a great experience.
00:07:08
Larger scale, how important
can technology be, do you think,
00:07:12
to enhancing the level of financial literacy
that we have in our kids?
00:07:17
I think it's a huge impact. And
specifically— and this is what's
00:07:21
come up in the student loan app—
financial decisions are decisions
00:07:23
you're making under uncertainty.
Right? You're taking out a loan,
00:07:27
you're gonna have to pay it
back. You don't know what your
00:07:30
circumstances are going to be in
the future. You have a hope, you
00:07:33
have an aspiration for what
you're doing with this money and
00:07:36
how it's going to pay off, but
you don't know for sure. And so
00:07:40
then trying to visualize, "I'm
taking out this loan, the
00:07:43
consequences include" — you know,
think of a bell curve. A left
00:07:46
tail, where things have not
worked out, and now what? And a
00:07:50
right tail where my aspirations
have come true. And everything
00:07:54
did work out. That kind of
scenario analysis is what you
00:07:57
have to do in your mind somehow,
when you take out the loan in
00:08:00
the first place. And I think
technology can have a great
00:08:04
effect in helping people do that
scenario analysis, think about
00:08:07
the diversity of consequences
that could follow from a
00:08:11
decision, and then make the
decision that's best for them.
00:08:14
Longer term, what do you hope is
the impact that the app has on
00:08:19
these kids in their lives?
00:08:20
Well, I think there are several
moments where the app could add
00:08:24
a lot of value. Naturally, the
number one scenario we picture
00:08:28
is you've gotten into a college,
you get a letter just spelling out
00:08:31
your financial aid, where they
say, "Well, here's our sticker
00:08:34
price for the college, here's
what we're actually going to
00:08:36
charge you. And here's what you—
what we expect you to borrow and
00:08:39
your parents to pay," and all
that. And you look at that.
00:08:42
You get that from one school,
and then you get that from
00:08:44
another school. And you think
about "Well, I could go to this
00:08:48
school and finance it that way,
I can go to this school, finance
00:08:50
it this way, what should I do?"
And we would help you think
00:08:54
through, you know, the consequences of
those different paths, at least
00:08:57
the diversity of consequences
that could come out of either
00:09:00
decision and help you think about
that and make the decision
00:09:03
that's best for yourself. So
that's one scenario. Another
00:09:05
scenario is, you're applying to
college in the first place, you
00:09:08
haven't even applied yet. And
you're thinking about where
00:09:11
should I apply? And if you know
more about the actual net cost
00:09:15
of colleges— and sitting here at
Penn, I should say that Penn has
00:09:18
a very high sticker price. But
for many students, an extremely
00:09:22
low net price to many students.
And a lot of them don't even
00:09:26
know that when they're applying.
And Penn is not the only school
00:09:29
like that. And the more you know
about that, the more you
00:09:32
understand where would be a good
place to apply. And then once
00:09:35
you've gotten in, then— and this
is something we talk about in
00:09:38
our financial literacy class—
you are in a position to bargain
00:09:42
between these schools. When
you've gotten into several
00:09:44
schools. And we have some
students we've worked with who
00:09:47
have bargained very successfully
with a terrific outcome.
00:09:50
I understand you're also looking
at the issue of financial
00:09:53
literacy from the perspective of
other cultures as well, for
00:09:56
people that are here in the
United States thinking about
00:09:58
things like the Spanish-speaking
community as well.
00:10:01
Yes. Well, this is something that was
inspired actually by a financial
00:10:05
services provider who contacted
the Center, saying, "Well, I see you
00:10:09
have English language material,
but I have potential clients,
00:10:13
they've come from countries
where they speak Spanish,
00:10:16
they're adults, they do not know
very much about our financial
00:10:20
system, because they just got
here. And a lot of them have had
00:10:22
negative experiences with the
financial systems in the
00:10:26
countries where they came from.
And so material that is aimed at
00:10:31
that community, helping them
plug in to our financial system
00:10:35
as soon as possible and not get
ripped off, and be able to send
00:10:38
money back to their own
countries, to remit money—
00:10:41
once again, without getting
ripped off— this could be
00:10:45
tremendously valuable." And at
first, we thought, "Oh, well, we
00:10:47
could just put captions on the
material we already have." I
00:10:50
thought, "No, that's not right.
This is a community that has
00:10:52
very specific needs. And we want
to address those needs." And so
00:10:56
we are now working with our
Wharton Latin American Students
00:10:59
Association, to develop the
courses that we're going to
00:11:03
offer. And then they can be the
onscreen talent. They can be— it's a
00:11:07
joint project with them.
And, you know, hopefully, by the
00:11:11
end of this calendar year, we
can roll it out and then make
00:11:14
this available to new arrivals
in our country.
00:11:17
Safe to say that it also
potentially opens the door to
00:11:21
looking at the banking industry,
and the changes that it may need
00:11:25
to be to be more inclusive and
more— more well-rounded in terms
00:11:29
of the information and how they
present it to all types of
00:11:32
individuals?
- Yeah,
00:11:33
well, certainly there are some—
if you just look across the big
00:11:37
banks in the country, some of
them make a big effort to reach
00:11:40
out to immigrant communities and
other underserved communities
00:11:43
and others don't. But it would
certainly help to have material
00:11:47
they could provide that would
just be— you know, it's not
00:11:51
marketing for their bank. It's
just, this is what it's like in
00:11:54
the US. Here are the
opportunities. Here are the
00:11:57
risks. Here are the safeguards.
And sort of introduce them to
00:12:01
our financial system. And then
they can make financial
00:12:04
decisions, which once again, are
both astute and adept. We can
00:12:07
bring people to that point, then
hopefully, you know, every bank
00:12:11
would feel comfortable doing
business with them.
00:12:13
We're obviously— it feels like
we're in a better situation
00:12:15
right now around financial
literacy than maybe we were a
00:12:18
decade, two decades ago. But are
we at a point where we have
00:12:24
reached the level of recognition
where we understand how
00:12:27
important having these elements
of education are going to be for
00:12:31
kids, as they continue on down
the line? Not just this
00:12:34
generation of kids in high
school now, but the next several
00:12:37
generations as well?
- Yeah, well, I
00:12:39
think that we look at our own
lives and see how much
00:12:43
responsibility we have for our
own financial well-being. Far
00:12:48
more responsibility than people
had many years ago. And even
00:12:52
though there's so much to learn
in high school— so much that you
00:12:55
need to boot up on to enter
society— finance just has to be
00:13:00
part of that. You know, it's how
you save up what you've produced
00:13:05
at one time in your life, to be
able to spend at another time of
00:13:07
your life. Or to borrow against
your future production to get
00:13:10
something you need now. It's
just fundamental to life to make
00:13:14
financial decisions. And, you
know, the sooner you can do that
00:13:18
with a clear mind and
understanding the consequences
00:13:21
and own your financial decisions,
the better for everybody.
00:13:24
David, great to see you again. Thanks
very much.
00:13:25
Great to be back.
00:13:26
Thank you. David Musto, Finance
Professor here at the Wharton School.
00:13:30
Thank you for listening
to The Ripple Effect. We hope
00:13:32
you found this episode
informative and engaging. Don't
00:13:35
forget to subscribe and leave us
a review so that we can continue
00:13:39
to bring you the best insight
from the Wharton School.
