Search Captions & Ask AI

How Leaders Shape the Future

March 13, 2015 / 09:10

This episode features Shannon Burns interviewing Paul Schumacher about his book, Winning the Long Game: How Strategic Leaders Shape the Future, co-authored with Steven Kup.

The discussion covers the challenges leaders face in becoming more strategic, particularly during performance reviews where they receive feedback on their operational skills but lack guidance on strategic thinking.

Schumacher explains a questionnaire included in the book that helps readers assess their strategic leadership skills across six elements, such as anticipating changes and making tough decisions.

He provides examples of successful strategic leaders, including Elon Musk and Pope Francis, and contrasts them with companies like Kodak and Nokia that failed to adapt.

Schumacher emphasizes the importance of integrating strategy with leadership in uncertain environments and hopes readers will learn from the examples of remarkable leaders profiled in the book.

TL;DR

Paul Schumacher discusses strategic leadership and insights from his book <i>Winning the Long Game</i> with Shannon Burns.

Episode

9:10
00:00:02
I'm Shannon burning books editor for
00:00:03
knowledge of Wharton and I'm happy to be
00:00:05
here today to speak to Paul Schumacher
00:00:07
about his new book with Steven kup
00:00:09
winning the long game how strategic
00:00:11
leaders shape the
00:00:13
future Paul thank you for being here
00:00:15
today my pleasure Shannon thanks I'm so
00:00:18
curious what challenge did you see for
00:00:19
leaders that led you to WR winning the
00:00:21
long game well we deal with a lot of
00:00:24
leaders and they tell us especially
00:00:26
managers who want to be leaders that
00:00:28
they often given feedback during a
00:00:30
performance review that they're doing
00:00:32
very well operationally and their
00:00:33
execution skills are great and then at
00:00:36
the end they sort of told they should be
00:00:38
a bit more strategic because they might
00:00:40
have missed a new market development or
00:00:42
competitor entering and they then wonder
00:00:45
how do I do this and when they ask their
00:00:46
bosses what do you mean can you be more
00:00:48
specific they don't say much more than
00:00:51
you know do like Wayne Gretsky skate to
00:00:53
where the puck will be but that's often
00:00:55
not enough that's right and in the book
00:00:58
you provide a questionnaire for for the
00:01:00
readers to assess their own strategic
00:01:02
leadership yes and I think that probably
00:01:04
gets to the heart of um exactly what
00:01:06
you're talking about makes it more
00:01:07
concrete can you tell us about those
00:01:09
questions and what you what you're
00:01:10
helping uh the reader to assess yeah we
00:01:13
feel that it has to be more concrete
00:01:14
than giving very general propositions
00:01:16
such as having a vision or having
00:01:18
commitment Etc so we um in a sense
00:01:21
deconstructed strategic leadership into
00:01:23
six elements um the these would be
00:01:26
things like how to anticipate changes in
00:01:29
the external environment or internally
00:01:30
in the organization better it could be
00:01:32
the ability to challenge yourself and
00:01:34
other people's views especially in a
00:01:36
changing world and our focus is a bit on
00:01:39
how to be a speciic leader when things
00:01:40
are changing in the external environment
00:01:42
so these elements that I mentioned are
00:01:44
especially important for that for
00:01:46
example the ability to interpret things
00:01:48
that are happening not through old
00:01:50
lenses but new lenses and then in the
00:01:52
world of uncertainty the ability to make
00:01:54
tough decisions that takes some courage
00:01:56
you can't wait for all the information
00:01:58
so that's a definite leadership skill
00:02:00
the ability to align people around a
00:02:03
vision but how do you do alignment how
00:02:04
do you bridge differences how do you
00:02:06
deal with um you know conflict and
00:02:09
learning is the last so we have six
00:02:10
elements and each of these elements we
00:02:12
in this particular survey we have about
00:02:14
10 items that very behaviorally ask how
00:02:17
often do you engage in the following
00:02:18
kind of behaviors and that's what that
00:02:21
survey does so at the end the the
00:02:23
participant has a sort of a profile they
00:02:25
can draw a little hexagon as to how well
00:02:27
they score on these various dimensions
00:02:29
and focus more on the gaps and then we
00:02:31
offer specific advice on how to bridge
00:02:34
the gap the biggest gaps right in
00:02:37
particular one of the things that's so
00:02:38
interesting is that in each of these um
00:02:41
chapters you're really looking through
00:02:43
the lens of discipline as a as a
00:02:46
priority can you tell us more about that
00:02:48
yeah we thought we thought about what
00:02:49
are these skills are these abilities are
00:02:52
these competencies are these
00:02:53
orientations are they skills and it's a
00:02:55
bit of all of that so we figure it's the
00:02:57
term discipline which is a bit of an odd
00:02:59
word
00:03:00
in some in some quarters maybe but it
00:03:02
captures three key elements namely that
00:03:05
it is based on knowledge there's a
00:03:06
knowledge based underlying it so if I
00:03:08
say the the discipline of playing bridge
00:03:10
or do sport or playing the piano that
00:03:13
people associate a knowledge base that
00:03:15
is one the other is literally the
00:03:17
discipline or being disciplined that is
00:03:19
practice a stick with a program don't be
00:03:22
so easily you know distracted so that's
00:03:24
important um and the third element is
00:03:27
that you like any discipline you don't
00:03:29
master it by reading a book you master
00:03:32
it by having a framework and then
00:03:33
practicing practicing practicing just
00:03:35
like a musical instrument so we felt
00:03:37
that discipline has all of those
00:03:39
connotations but it also left uh room
00:03:41
for the notion that there is an artistic
00:03:43
element to it the art of a discipline
00:03:46
right in the martial arts or something
00:03:47
like that and I don't think we have the
00:03:49
it's not a scientific um model
00:03:52
necessarily it it it allows for um you
00:03:54
know customization and um sort of it's
00:03:57
contingent on culture and situation
00:04:00
so that's all wrapped into the idea of a
00:04:02
discipline that you know how to deal
00:04:04
with the this enormous variety of
00:04:06
situations that leaders encounter and
00:04:08
can you give us a couple examples of
00:04:10
leaders who've been very successful as
00:04:12
strategic leaders yeah well we mentioned
00:04:15
many so each chapter we start with a
00:04:17
leader that everybody recognizes so the
00:04:18
first chapter on anticipation we profile
00:04:21
Elon Musk who most people know of course
00:04:23
as having been with SpaceX a remarkable
00:04:26
inventor and PayPal he became very rich
00:04:29
and now he's pioneering the electric car
00:04:31
with a Tesla and he does approach it as
00:04:34
a discipline um when he was asked once
00:04:36
on television program how can you be so
00:04:39
creative he says well most people who
00:04:41
want to be creative don't even try he
00:04:43
says and I want my Engineers to be very
00:04:45
creative we don't people to have average
00:04:46
ideas and he says I work on this very
00:04:49
hard till my brain hurts so there's an
00:04:51
element of sort of being uh you know
00:04:55
recognizing it as something you had to
00:04:56
work on just like an an author would or
00:04:58
an athlete
00:05:00
but then other elements like challenge
00:05:02
we profile actually Pope Francis who
00:05:04
took over an somewhat dysfunctional
00:05:06
organization some would say with a lot
00:05:07
of tough issues and he may and he's
00:05:10
really you know it's a tight rope how
00:05:13
much does he really challenge there's
00:05:14
dogmas that he can't Cannons of the
00:05:16
church that he has to and he's very
00:05:18
conservative in some ways and he's very
00:05:20
liberal and very remarkable in other
00:05:22
ways so for each of these topics we kind
00:05:24
of profile leaders who we think were
00:05:26
very impressive in business we uh
00:05:29
describe um Mr holiday who was the CEO
00:05:32
of DuPont and early on in 2007 he picked
00:05:35
up weak signals that we're going to hit
00:05:37
a wall with the economy but there were
00:05:39
truly weak signals like the reservations
00:05:41
in Hotel DuPont were down he picked that
00:05:43
up on at a reception or was in Japan and
00:05:46
a Japanese customer wanted more cash you
00:05:48
know he he was short of cash so he
00:05:50
wanted to get postponements of payments
00:05:53
Etc and then the auto companies which
00:05:54
are big for dupond wouldn't share their
00:05:56
production plans and he gets his
00:05:58
information disjointed ly and he puts
00:06:01
like Sherlock Holmes kind of puts
00:06:02
together the picture and and and sees
00:06:05
what's happening before others do and
00:06:06
survived as a consequence the deep
00:06:09
depression or the recession better than
00:06:11
than others the other side of things
00:06:13
would be if you're not able to you know
00:06:15
practice this this discipline of
00:06:17
strategic leadership can you give us
00:06:18
some examples of those who uh were not
00:06:21
able to implement those
00:06:22
[Music]
00:06:24
ideas I think you can look at any of the
00:06:26
failed companies right at it's Kodak or
00:06:29
there's so many
00:06:30
um no no Nokia would be an example but
00:06:33
the ones we profile are companies like
00:06:35
Lego you know Lego the Danish company
00:06:37
that has all the lovely the lovely
00:06:39
bricks plastic bricks they really were
00:06:41
almost bankrupt after 30 or 40 Years of
00:06:44
great success and it was really their
00:06:46
inability to anticipate changes in their
00:06:48
Market in particular the video
00:06:50
Revolution the sort of the it Revolution
00:06:52
that games becoming electronic and they
00:06:55
were almost and in billand in in jetland
00:06:57
Denmark where they employed almost
00:06:59
two-thirds of the town you can imagine
00:07:01
what how devastating this was because
00:07:02
the company almost went under and then
00:07:05
they had the opportunity to kind a deal
00:07:06
with Lucas film for um you know sort of
00:07:09
a really very successful uh the force
00:07:11
you know they embraced the force and uh
00:07:15
and that that saved them but there was
00:07:16
one one leader who who who who killed
00:07:19
the deal he said we're not going to work
00:07:20
with Outsiders we've always done it
00:07:22
ourselves was very distrustful of the
00:07:24
outside world and he said Over My Dead
00:07:25
Body and it was until a senior leader
00:07:27
recognized that they were falling behind
00:07:29
the times that the world was changing
00:07:31
outside of Denmark and they needed to
00:07:32
really team up with Partners who could
00:07:34
do this much
00:07:36
better as a final question Paul can you
00:07:38
tell us uh what you hope readers will
00:07:40
take away from the book yeah for one we
00:07:43
hope that readers um who Aspire towards
00:07:45
strategic leadership start to realize
00:07:47
that you need to integrate strategy and
00:07:49
leadership in a world of uncertainty
00:07:51
much more than it's typical the typical
00:07:52
model is you know a strategy gets
00:07:54
formulated leaders are involved in that
00:07:56
process but then others often execute
00:07:58
and then of course in a world of
00:07:59
uncertainty no business plan survives
00:08:02
contact with reality so you need people
00:08:04
who are very good in picking that up
00:08:06
quickly and be able on the fly to make
00:08:08
adjustments so the tighter integration
00:08:10
that's one they will have a conceptual
00:08:12
model for what is really at the core of
00:08:14
doing this sort of rare skill very well
00:08:17
and they have some instruments but I
00:08:19
hope that they will just also learn by
00:08:20
example by just you know reading the
00:08:22
stories of leaders who were really quite
00:08:25
remarkable uh as and we it's fairly
00:08:27
International so it's not just American
00:08:29
leaders as we profile them across the
00:08:31
world um and and then also they may want
00:08:33
to Mentor other people so leaders who
00:08:35
are already strategic can use the book
00:08:37
as a guide to tell people who who they
00:08:39
feel should become more strategic how to
00:08:41
do that thank you Paul it was great to
00:08:43
speak with you it's my pleasure thanks
00:08:45
Shon appreciate it
00:08:50
[Music]

Episode Highlights

  • The Importance of Strategic Leadership
    Paul Schumacher discusses the need for leaders to anticipate changes and make tough decisions.
    “You can’t wait for all the information; that takes courage.”
    @ 01m 54s
    March 13, 2015
  • Elon Musk's Creative Discipline
    Elon Musk emphasizes the importance of hard work and creativity in leadership.
    “I work on this very hard till my brain hurts.”
    @ 04m 49s
    March 13, 2015
  • Learning from Failures
    Examining companies like Lego that struggled due to a lack of strategic foresight.
    “Their inability to anticipate changes almost led to bankruptcy.”
    @ 06m 46s
    March 13, 2015

Episode Quotes

  • You can’t wait for all the information; that takes courage.
    How Leaders Shape the Future
  • Most people who want to be creative don’t even try.
    How Leaders Shape the Future
  • You need to integrate strategy and leadership in a world of uncertainty.
    How Leaders Shape the Future

Key Moments

  • Tough Decisions01:54
  • Creative Leadership04:39
  • Learning from Failure06:46
  • Strategic Insights07:47

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown

Related Episodes

Knowledge@Wharton Interview with Sydney Finkelstein
June 29, 2020
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
29:01
Knowledge@Wharton Interview with Sydney Finkelstein
Management 101: The Marriage of Strategy and Leadership
October 11, 2016
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
25:26
Management 101: The Marriage of Strategy and Leadership
Does Your Strategy Need a Strategy Part 2
November 04, 2015
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
08:45
Does Your Strategy Need a Strategy Part 2
Leadership Strategies for Accelerating Growth
July 01, 2013
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
18:02
Leadership Strategies for Accelerating Growth
The New Rules of Leadership in an Age of Constant Disruption
March 20, 2026
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
14:23
The New Rules of Leadership in an Age of Constant Disruption
Do You Know Your Team's PWR Score?
July 24, 2015
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
31:51
Do You Know Your Team's PWR Score?
See Sooner, Act Faster
January 10, 2020
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
27:34
See Sooner, Act Faster
Why First Book Is a Model for Social Enterprises
February 15, 2017
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
23:59
Why First Book Is a Model for Social Enterprises
Leadership: Mark Shapiro, Cleveland Indians
April 10, 2013
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
15:28
Leadership: Mark Shapiro, Cleveland Indians
Why Leaders Need to Continuously Update Their Leadership Toolkit
January 13, 2026
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
18:49
Why Leaders Need to Continuously Update Their Leadership Toolkit
For the Win: Using Connected Strategies to Gain a Competitive Advantage
May 20, 2019
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
30:41
For the Win: Using Connected Strategies to Gain a Competitive Advantage
The Prepared Leader: Crisis Management w/ Erika James and Lynn Wooten – Wharton School Press Q&A
October 03, 2022
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
44:32
The Prepared Leader: Crisis Management w/ Erika James and Lynn Wooten – Wharton School Press Q&A