Search Captions & Ask AI

Roth Steve SF

February 25, 2016 / 06:12

This episode discusses forecasting, decision-making, and risk-taking with insights from the Good Judgment Project. The conversation features experiences of becoming a super forecaster and the importance of adapting forecasts based on new information.

The guest shares how attending an event in New York City with Phil Tetlock and Bob Mellers inspired him to join the Good Judgment Project as a forecaster. He reflects on his journey from being a novice to achieving super forecaster status.

Key discussions include the significance of historical information in forecasting, the necessity of adjusting forecasts with new data, and the value of considering diverse perspectives.

The guest also contrasts his investment philosophy with that of his wife, highlighting differing approaches to risk and decision-making in their personal lives.

Overall, the episode emphasizes the continuous learning process in forecasting and the impact of collaborative information sharing on improving decision-making skills.

TL;DR

The episode covers forecasting, decision-making, and risk-taking insights from the Good Judgment Project.

Episode

6:12
00:00:09
my professional life has involved 4k
00:00:12
have what I do or have done to help
00:00:15
other people make better decisions
00:00:17
hopefully but several years ago I
00:00:20
attended a pen engaging minds event in
00:00:25
New York City and Phil tetlock and Bob
00:00:29
meddlers were speaking about the good
00:00:31
judgment project which was very
00:00:33
intriguing to me and so I inquired about
00:00:36
joining as a forecaster and several
00:00:40
months later when positions opened up I
00:00:43
became a forecaster
00:00:50
that and in a very humbling way that I
00:00:54
knew a lot less about the world than I
00:00:56
thought I knew and so that to begin with
00:00:59
spurred by thirst for knowledge and
00:01:02
information it also gave me a
00:01:05
perspective about risk-taking because in
00:01:08
my first year I was not a super
00:01:10
forecaster I had to earn that status and
00:01:13
I was involved in in a marketplace which
00:01:16
involved essentially trading and I
00:01:20
learned a lot about risk-taking and how
00:01:22
much I was either risk-averse or overly
00:01:27
overly risky learning about things from
00:01:32
a perspective of other information has
00:01:35
been very important but once i became a
00:01:38
super forecaster in particular what was
00:01:40
helpful to me was a perspective of
00:01:43
others the sharing of information and
00:01:45
the ability to test your own beliefs and
00:01:49
hypotheses for bias by taking into
00:01:53
account what others have said or
00:01:56
analyzed as well as information that
00:01:58
contradicts your own has been very
00:02:00
valuable to me
00:02:06
the process evolved over time for me and
00:02:10
one of the things that is important to
00:02:12
me is to use historical information but
00:02:15
not to be over Alliant on it if there is
00:02:18
the ability to compare against similar
00:02:22
situations in the past I'm very
00:02:25
cognizant of using that information but
00:02:28
only to the extent that it is truly
00:02:30
relevant to the current circumstances
00:02:34
beyond that frequently adjusting my own
00:02:39
forecast based upon new information and
00:02:42
new perspectives of others is extremely
00:02:45
valuable it's very easy to take a
00:02:48
position and sit back and say that's it
00:02:51
however the real world is a very active
00:02:54
one and often things change and
00:02:58
forecasts should change based upon the
00:03:01
events and the happenings of the world
00:03:04
and I found it's extremely useful to pay
00:03:06
a lot of attention to those events and
00:03:09
frequently re-examine my own forecasts
00:03:13
and see if they need to be updated
00:03:19
I think that one of the things that
00:03:22
would be extremely useful would be to
00:03:23
participate in good judgments open
00:03:25
forecasting competition because you can
00:03:29
test your own abilities and learn about
00:03:31
the things that that both limit your
00:03:35
ability to forecast and make you a
00:03:37
better forecaster and through that
00:03:41
process become somebody who is more
00:03:47
adept at forecasting the good judgement
00:03:53
incorporated itself has put together
00:03:56
various training methods which have been
00:03:59
very useful to me as a super forecaster
00:04:01
and I'm sure to others but as an
00:04:03
individual just forecasting and and
00:04:08
using that forecasting experience can be
00:04:11
a very valuable thing to learn about
00:04:14
yourself and the process of forecasting
00:04:18
what and and what you do well in what
00:04:21
you do less well and then to seek ways
00:04:23
of improving upon those weaknesses
00:04:29
my wife and I have two different
00:04:31
philosophies of investment she has been
00:04:35
involved over the years as a partner and
00:04:37
an investment firm that does alternative
00:04:39
investments which are allegedly less
00:04:43
risky but by my lights carry a risk that
00:04:46
is sometimes more than what I like I on
00:04:49
the other hand and much more risk averse
00:04:51
and although less risk-averse then i was
00:04:55
when i first started participating a
00:04:59
good judgment project my professional
00:05:04
career has been oriented towards
00:05:06
reducing the risk that decision makers
00:05:09
have and perhaps i've taken that point
00:05:13
of view in my own approach to investing
00:05:16
which my wife feels is overly
00:05:19
conservative i think that that the
00:05:22
forecast thing as part of the good
00:05:25
judgment project has given me a window
00:05:28
into my own risk taking perspective and
00:05:32
move me at least somewhat closer to my
00:05:34
wife's point of view and and i think
00:05:39
that that's a very useful thing in real
00:05:41
life as well as you know from the
00:05:44
standpoint of participating as a super
00:05:46
forecasting
00:06:03
you

Episode Highlights

  • Becoming a Super Forecaster
    The journey from novice to super forecaster reveals the importance of perspective and information sharing.
    “I had to earn that status and learned a lot about risk-taking.”
    @ 01m 10s
    February 25, 2016
  • The Importance of Adaptability
    Adjusting forecasts based on new information is crucial in a changing world.
    “It's extremely useful to pay a lot of attention to those events.”
    @ 03m 06s
    February 25, 2016
  • Investment Philosophies
    Different investment strategies can reflect personal risk perspectives, as seen in a couple's contrasting approaches.
    “My wife and I have two different philosophies of investment.”
    @ 04m 29s
    February 25, 2016

Episode Quotes

  • I knew a lot less about the world than I thought I knew.
    Roth Steve SF
  • The real world is a very active one and often things change.
    Roth Steve SF
  • Forecasting can be a very valuable thing to learn about yourself.
    Roth Steve SF

Key Moments

  • Journey to Forecasting00:43
  • Learning from Others01:45
  • Risk Perspectives04:49

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown

Related Episodes

Superforecaster Full Video
February 26, 2016
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
01:01:33
Superforecaster Full Video
Chang Welton SF
February 25, 2016
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
08:57
Chang Welton SF
Adams Karen SF
February 25, 2016
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
06:58
Adams Karen SF
Rogg David SF
February 25, 2016
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
08:15
Rogg David SF
Rich Elaine SF
February 25, 2016
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
06:53
Rich Elaine SF
Why an Open Mind Is Key to Making Better Predictions
October 02, 2015
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
26:30
Why an Open Mind Is Key to Making Better Predictions
Building Better Forecasters
May 18, 2015
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
12:14
Building Better Forecasters
Untangling Skill and Luck in Business
March 06, 2013
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
21:21
Untangling Skill and Luck in Business
Beugoms, Jean Pierre
February 26, 2016
Captions not detected. You can watch the video, but not search it. If you think this is an error, contact support.
11:26
Beugoms, Jean Pierre