Search Captions & Ask AI

Adam Grant on 'How Non-Conformists Move the World': Insights from Book 'Originals'

February 02, 2016 / 30:58

This episode features Adam Grant, a management professor at Wharton, discussing his book "Originals". Key topics include entrepreneurship, risk-taking, procrastination, and fostering originality in organizations.

Grant shares his personal experience of being threatened for speaking up in a corporate environment, which inspired his research into how to effectively voice original ideas. He emphasizes that successful entrepreneurs often manage risk rather than seek it, challenging the stereotype of the risk-taking entrepreneur.

The conversation also touches on the importance of feedback in selecting ideas, citing research that shows individuals are often poor judges of their own ideas. Grant discusses examples from the business world, including the contrasting fates of the Segway and the sitcom "Seinfeld" in terms of idea validation.

Grant highlights the role of procrastination in creativity, explaining how strategic delays can lead to more innovative ideas. He also discusses how organizations can nurture originality by creating a safe environment for failure and hiring for cultural contribution.

Overall, the episode provides practical advice for individuals and organizations looking to enhance creativity and originality in their work.

TLDR

Adam Grant discusses originality, entrepreneurship, and fostering creativity in organizations based on his book "Originals".

Episode

30:58
00:00:02
Our Guest today is Adam grunt a management professor at Wharton and we're going to talk to him about his new
00:00:08
book Originals which is about how non-confirmed the world Adam welcome to knowledge at Wharton thank you so you
00:00:16
often interview authors and the authors at Wharton Series so I'm going to start
00:00:22
with a question that you usually ask them what inspired you to write this book I really want to turn the tables on
00:00:28
you on this one but I think the the inspiration for writing this book was uh twofold one uh
00:00:37
I worked as a manager for a while before I came into Academia and the one time I
00:00:42
worked up the courage to speak up uh I was actually dragged by my boss's boss
00:00:47
into the bathroom and uh I basically ended up being threatened that I would be fired if I ever spoke my mind again
00:00:54
and I really wanted to know how could I have done that more effectively and then
00:00:58
U more recently uh since my first book give and take came out people have been constantly asking if I am in a culture
00:01:05
where people are constantly selfish or toxic how do I change that and if I'm
00:01:10
facing undesirable circumstances anywhere what do I do about them and I didn't feel like I had good answers for
00:01:15
them so I started doing a lot of research and uh here we are great so you you you talk uh about entrepreneurship
00:01:22
right at the beginning of the book uh especially the company warie Parker which you know U came out of uh the
00:01:30
efforts of some Wharton students uh when typically when people think about entrepreneurs they see them as ult the
00:01:37
ultimate Risk Takers who are willing to bet the farm on their dreams uh what is your view of Entrepreneurship and the
00:01:44
relationship between entrepreneurship and risk-taking well that's what I thought too initially right when I
00:01:49
thought of an entrepreneur I thought of like you know sort of a swashbuckling pirate or a daredevil the kind of person
00:01:54
who had basically leap before he or she looked and the data tell a completely different story that entrepreneurs are
00:02:01
not necessarily more risk-taking than the rest of us um in fact they may even be more risk averse most entrepreneurs
00:02:08
hate gambling what they really enjoy is the opportunity to try something new and
00:02:13
they're typically driven not by this craving for risk but rather this desire
00:02:17
to say can I pursue a passion can I work independently can I do something where I'm really going to have an impact and
00:02:24
so what I think what mystifies a lot of us is we look at entrepreneurs and we see them taking risks and we assume
00:02:30
they're Risk Takers really what a lot of them are doing is they're managing risk
00:02:34
portfolios so think about it like a stock portfolio right if you're going to
00:02:37
make a risky investment in one realm you're supposed to offset that with a safer bet in a different stock and
00:02:43
entrepreneurs actually do the same thing with risk at least the successful ones do when they have to go out on a limb in
00:02:48
one domain they will actually be more cautious than another to cover their basis now uh you also have so many
00:02:55
interesting stories in the book uh one that I especially liked was about the internet browsers that people use does
00:03:04
that say anything about the people who use them and about their originality it says more than I initially expected uh
00:03:11
so this economist Michael hman was tracking data on customer service reps and call center employees and he found
00:03:17
that employees who use uh Chrome or Firefox actually outperformed Internet Explorer and Safari users and they also
00:03:25
stayed in their job significantly longer so I started stalking him of course to find out why why what what's going on
00:03:30
what does Chrome and Firefox do for you and it turned out it wasn't a technical
00:03:34
Advantage it was not that they were faster at typing they didn't have more computer knowledge it was about how you
00:03:40
got the browser if you were going to use Internet Explorer Safari it comes pre-installed on your computer right
00:03:46
whereas Chrome and Firefox if you want them you have to take a little bit of initiative and download a different
00:03:50
browser and that's a signal a window around what you do at work so the kinds
00:03:55
of people who had that instinct to say you know what I wonder if there's a better browser out there they were also
00:03:59
the kinds of people who looked for ways to improve their own jobs and ultimately
00:04:03
they were able to create a job where they were more effective and and more satisfied now people hear about these
00:04:08
data and sometimes they say well wait if I want to get better at my job all I have to do is upgrade to Chrome or
00:04:13
Firefox no right it's about the kind of thinking that that underlies that choice
00:04:18
not just accepting the default that's handed to you but asking is there a different or better option
00:04:24
available now in uh thinking about originality uh you said the the biggest barrier to originality is not the
00:04:32
ability to generate ideas but to select them uh how can people avoid making bad bets when it comes to idea selection I I
00:04:42
think we're all actually pretty terrible at this when it comes to our own ideas
00:04:46
right the evidence is overwhelming there you it's hard to find an entrepreneur
00:04:49
who doesn't think his or her idea is a winner um it's really other people's
00:04:54
feedback that turns out to be important so there's this brilliant research by
00:04:58
Justin Berg uh one of our former doctoral students who's now on the Stanford faculty and Justin got circus
00:05:03
artists uh to try to gauge How likely their performances were to succeed with audiences and they were terrible um they
00:05:10
overestimated the success of their own performances by a lot so then he went to managers and he showed a bunch of videos
00:05:18
so you get to see some jugglers you get to see a few clowns by the way nobody likes clowns it turns out universally
00:05:23
hated um you may get to watch a few aerial acrobatics performances and then the managers make judgments
00:05:30
and the managers are not very accurate either um you tend to be too positive on your own ideas managers tend to be too
00:05:36
negative on other people's ideas because they have a prototype about what a great
00:05:41
circus performance looks like and they're evaluating all the ideas that come out of the table in terms of does
00:05:45
that fit or not and the group that was much more effective than either people themselves or managers was pierce fellow
00:05:52
circus artists so you might not be able to judge your own ideas but you're great
00:05:56
at forecasting the success of other people's ideas because like managers as a performer you're much more willing to
00:06:02
look at an unusual act and say you know what I've never seen anything like that
00:06:06
before but that has potential but you also are willing to say you know what this is really bad so I think we could
00:06:13
all rely more on pure feedback and do a better job saying look when I've got a
00:06:18
new idea I'm not necessarily going to trust my own judgment but I'm not always
00:06:22
going to trust especially middle managers who tend to be the most risk averse and most conservative I'm going
00:06:27
to go to people who are fellow creators right and you have a couple of great examples of uh from the business world
00:06:34
uh of segue uh and Seinfeld uh in in demonstrating this can can you tell us a little bit about those examples yeah I
00:06:41
think the the segue example is is a case unfortunately of an entrepreneur being overconfident in an idea uh so the the
00:06:49
short version of the story is you have this idea for a self-balancing vehicle and you don't really go out and figure
00:06:56
out is this something people would want to drive would they trust it would they buy it whereas in Seinfeld you have the
00:07:02
exact opposite instead of a sort of a false positive it's a false negative so
00:07:07
the pilot was rated weak and it was actually initially scrapped and then this uh this movie executive excuse me
00:07:14
TV executive uh Rick lwin who doesn't even work in comedy he's from the variety and specialist Department he
00:07:20
sees the pilot and he says this is really good and he ends up finding a slot for it and using his own budget and
00:07:27
I think what what Rick did was he was able to step outside of the prototypes that a lot of us tend to use so people
00:07:33
looked at the Seinfeld pilot and they said it's a show about nothing and this
00:07:36
does not fit the mold of how a comedy or sitcom especially is supposed to run whereas Rick had come out of variety
00:07:43
specials lots of different formats and he said you know what not every plot has to be resolved not every twist needs to
00:07:50
go somewhere the point is to make people laugh and he was much more open to the potential there so does that mean that
00:07:56
when it comes to idea generation that quantity is very closely related to Quality yeah I think one of the myths
00:08:03
that people carry around if you want to be original you will think look I should
00:08:08
do less because I want to perfect my invention or my creation but again the data actually support the opposite story
00:08:16
uh Dean Simonson's a psychologist who's been studying this his whole career and
00:08:19
what he finds is one of the best predictors of how much creative productivity you will ultimately achieve
00:08:25
how much you're regarded as a genius is about the number of ideas you produce so
00:08:30
the more ideas you create the more variety you have right and some of those ideas are going to be blind alleys or
00:08:37
random walks in bad directions but you have a better shot then of stumbling upon something that's really powerful so
00:08:45
for example when you compare great composers if you look at Beethoven Bach Mozart it wasn't that their average is
00:08:51
so much better than their peers it's that they generated sometimes 600 or a thousand different compositions and a
00:08:58
few of those are considered true masterpieces you can see this not just when comparing different kinds of people
00:09:03
though you can also pick it up when you look within a person's career so creators are the most novel the most
00:09:10
original during the times when they have the most bad ideas look at Edison for example great example Edison made a
00:09:17
talking doll so creepy that it scared not only children but adults too he came up with a fruit preservation technique
00:09:23
that failed he tried to mine um in a number of ways that didn't work out and
00:09:28
it was during window where he had over aund failed ideas that he was able to perfect the light bulb and I think the
00:09:35
idea is that you have to generate a lot of garbage to reach greatness right no one of the challenges that anyone who
00:09:42
comes up with a new idea is going to face is how do you get them heard and how do you speak truth to power uh can
00:09:50
you give us some examples of uh how you can do that uh while minimizing the risk
00:09:56
of damaging your career as as as you at the start of our conversation I could have really used this advice a while
00:10:04
back I think one of the the most important things that I've learned about speaking truth to power is that when
00:10:10
we're excited about an idea we tend to make the mistake of assembling as many
00:10:15
reasons as possible to support it and by the time we pitch it it seems as if we're completely biased and blinded
00:10:23
right it's all this is a good idea and there's no balance whatsoever in the
00:10:27
pitch uh so there's an entrepreneur Rufus grisk who has a great antidote to this he starts a company called Babble
00:10:34
it's a parenting website and he goes to investors and he says these are the three reasons you should not back my
00:10:41
company and that year he walks away with over $3 million Us in funding two years
00:10:46
later he goes to Disney and says um you know I'm interested in selling this company to you here are the five reasons
00:10:52
why you should not buy it and they end up buying it for $40 million now of course part of this it's
00:10:58
a little bit of an ATT grabbing device right you don't expect an entrepreneur
00:11:01
to say here's why you should not trust me but what's interesting is when Rufus
00:11:06
acknowledges the weaknesses of his idea he looks like he's self-critical and
00:11:10
honest and he also makes it harder for people to come up with their own objections because as they're thinking
00:11:16
about their own concerns they say you know what he hit three of my four this guy must be so confident that he can
00:11:22
overcome these issues that he's willing to admit those weaknesses out loud and
00:11:26
those strengths must be powerful enough to offset them so I think we could all do a better job probably giving a more
00:11:31
balanced case for our our ideas when we speak truth to power the other thing that I would I would recommend is to
00:11:37
avoid a mistake that I made which is when I went to speak up in in my own career I looked for the friendliest most
00:11:43
agreeable person assuming that's the person who's ultimately going to be
00:11:47
supportive but it turned out that that person didn't have my back because just
00:11:52
as uh he was interested in being nice to me he also wanted to keep the peace with
00:11:56
everyone else what I should have done and what the evidence of reports is that if you go to a more disagreeable boss
00:12:02
somebody who tends to be a little bit more critical skeptical and challenging yeah that person is going to be tougher
00:12:07
on you but then they will be also more willing to rock the boat a little bit and stand up for your idea if it's
00:12:13
unpopular interesting uh when is it the right time to exit an organization rather than continuing to make the case
00:12:21
for a idea I think this is a a problem that a lot of us struggle with I don't
00:12:26
know that I have any answers to it um I do know though that if you track what happens to most people who speak up
00:12:33
usually they try voicing their idea and then if it doesn't work out they either
00:12:37
decide you know what I don't have other options and I need to keep this job or
00:12:41
they start to look elsewhere I think there are a couple of of tests though that are worth running before you decide
00:12:47
to leave the first one is have I gone to all of the potential allies that I have
00:12:51
in the organization second one is is it possible that there's a better way for
00:12:56
me to present this idea and that it's not that people are un willing to hear
00:12:59
it it's just that they they didn't see the potential because I didn't speak
00:13:02
about it effectively and then third and most importantly the question is what am
00:13:07
I ultimately trying to accomplish is this organization the best site for me to reach my goals and I think if you can
00:13:13
answer those three questions I can't succeed on any of them it's probably time to start looking
00:13:19
around a little bit well sometimes people procrastinate about some of these things uh and you have some interesting
00:13:27
ideas about procrastination in your book book do you see procrastination as a strength or as a weakness my stance on
00:13:33
this has completely changed uh part partially during the process of writing the book so I expected if you want to be
00:13:39
an original you know the kind of non-conformist who Champions new ideas and really drives creativity and change
00:13:46
in the world I thought you had to be an early bird a first mover but again the evidence proved me wrong turns out the
00:13:54
most originals are great procrastinators they're constantly putting things off
00:13:59
and I actually had a a former student G Shin who showed that if you procrastinate a little bit you will
00:14:06
generate more creative ideas than if you dive right into a task or finish it right away and the reason for this is
00:14:12
pretty simple um and I've actually been a victim of the opposite of it for a
00:14:15
while uh so I am actually a precrastinator I'm somebody who if I know I have something do in six months I
00:14:22
will feel urgent pressure to do it now and worry about it constantly until the moment that it's done and when noticed
00:14:29
as I compared that against the originals that I studied the people that I interviewed the data that I gathered was
00:14:36
a lot of them were waiting for the right time and if they put off the start or completion of the task a little bit they
00:14:42
allowed themselves to access more diverse ideas and they saw possibilities that I wouldn't have seen because our
00:14:47
first ideas are our most conventional typically right you have to sort of weed out the familiar in order to get to the
00:14:54
much more unusual and original and I wasn't doing that when I dove right into
00:14:57
a task so I've come to believe we should all procrastinate deliberately um but if
00:15:01
you push that too far of course you're just not going to have time to finish
00:15:04
your work what is strategic procrastination I think of strategic procrastination as essentially this idea
00:15:11
of waiting for the right time so as a writer for example um I have learned to leave drafts unfinished on purpose and
00:15:19
what I will do is I'll start working on a draft I really want to spend the next
00:15:22
two hours finishing it I will put it away and then 3 days later when I come back I have seven or eight new ideas
00:15:28
that I would never considered because now it's in the back of my mind we have
00:15:32
a much better memory for incomplete than complete tasks so the moment I I sort of
00:15:36
hit send on that on that draft it's out of my mind right whereas when I leave it
00:15:42
open then I'm constantly processing it I'm seeing new possibilities uh the other thing I've
00:15:48
I've learned to do over time is I'll finish a draft but I won't actually
00:15:51
submit it or ship it and I'll leave it sitting for two or three weeks by the
00:15:56
time I come back to it I have enough distance to say who wrote this driil but but I also then again I'm able
00:16:03
to approach it with a fresh perspective and for me that's what strategic procrastination is all about I mean
00:16:08
especially uh in in writing when you say something at the heat of in the in the in the Heat of the Moment In the Heat of
00:16:14
writing uh you don't have enough distance to be objective about it but exactly by waiting it uh I got very
00:16:20
similar advice from one of my early editors in my career and I've always appreciated that I think it's wonderful
00:16:26
advice as long as we find that sweet spot right of procrastinating enough to allow the ideas to incubate but not so
00:16:33
much that you run out of time and you just have to pick the simplest idea exactly now Einstein believed that uh
00:16:40
people are most creative when they are young is that true it seemed to be true for Einstein um but not for most of the
00:16:48
rest of us uh so the story of Einstein is actually pretty sad if you look at it so transforms physics not once but twice
00:16:56
with special and general relativity and then and he ends up opposing the next major revolution in physics which is
00:17:02
quantum mechanics and ironically his opposition to it is debunked because he forgot to account for his own theory of
00:17:10
relativity whoops um so Ein Einstein said reflecting on this experience that to punish him for uh for testing and
00:17:19
challenging Authority the fates made him athor an authority himself and I think that suggests that
00:17:25
at some point we are all doomed once we've inter IED ideas to essentially lose our creativity um when you study
00:17:34
though great scientists musicians poets artists what you see is that there are basically two cycles um one is basically
00:17:43
sort of the young genius and this is the Einstein somebody who comes into a field
00:17:47
accumulates knowledge really quickly but also has enough distance to not drink the Kool-Aid and that person ends up
00:17:55
with a flash of insight coming up with a wildly different way of looking at the world and yeah if that's your style
00:18:01
you're at risk for becoming too entrenched and starting to take for granted so many assumptions that you
00:18:07
can't really think differently in that field anymore but there's a second path
00:18:11
which was the old master and these are the people who tended to work much more experimentally they were doing lots of
00:18:17
little trials and errors they were doing tests they were iterating and they were
00:18:20
learning from the data as opposed to having these Eureka moments and they actually tended to Peak frequently in
00:18:26
their 40s 50s 60s even 70s and8 in some cases so I think there is hope for those
00:18:32
of us who are more tortoise than hair um how can originality be sustained over time I think one of the the challenges
00:18:44
that we all face if we want to sustain originality is we have to keep our exposure to Fresh
00:18:48
ideas and the longer you spend in a field an organization a job the more familiar certain things will become and
00:18:57
so you have to push yourself outside of that comfort zone how do you do that there's a a study I really enjoy by
00:19:02
Frederick uh Godard and his colleagues where they actually track uh fashion designers and they look at what predicts
00:19:09
which fashion houses have the most creative and original designs and it turns out one of the best predictors of
00:19:15
that is has the creative director of that fashion house lived abroad but then if you break down the data it goes
00:19:23
further living abroad alone is not enough you have to work abroad you actually have to use the ideas of the
00:19:28
the culture right not just sort of visit and enjoy it as a tour a tourist you have to internalize how that culture
00:19:34
thinks and looks at things differently and then working abroad you can break that down further and say it's more
00:19:40
beneficial for your creativity and originality if you work abroad in countries that are more different from
00:19:45
your own if you and if you stay there longer so that kind of breath is what we're looking for how do you simulate
00:19:52
that I think what a lot of us can do is we could do a much better job with the job rotation for example so in your own
00:19:58
organization and spend two days doing a job that you've never done before gives
00:20:02
you a completely fresh perspective on the work go to a site visit to a different organization or even a company
00:20:08
that's in a different field from your own different industry and all of a sudden you have lots of ideas that you
00:20:13
can apply to your own work uh what role do coalitions play in bringing original ideas to life we all
00:20:20
need allies it's very hard to be a lone original I think Dereck civer put it
00:20:25
well uh one follower is what trans forms a lone nut into a leader and you know no nobody wants to
00:20:34
be that lone nut I think many of us though assume that we need large coalitions to support our ideas but most
00:20:41
of the time researched by our own Seagal barade shows that even a single Ally a single friend is enough to make you feel
00:20:49
that you're not lonely and so I think coalitions typically are much more about
00:20:53
finding that very very small group of people who believe in you and are willing to give your ideas as a shot as
00:20:59
opposed to saying I need to get 74% of this organization on board um you also talk about something
00:21:07
called a trojan horse strategy for Coalition building what's that well this was introduced to me by Merith Perry uh
00:21:15
who's a a brilliant entrepreneur uh she's the founder of ubeam which is trying to bring Wireless power to the
00:21:20
world and when Meredith started her company she had this idea that you could actually transmit transmit electricity
00:21:27
through the air uh and and power up different kinds of devices phones computers uh without any kind of cord
00:21:33
and people didn't believe her she tried to hire the very best Engineers because
00:21:37
she couldn't build the product on her own and they said that's impossible it
00:21:40
defies the laws of physics she was convinced that they were wrong so in order to get them to come on board she
00:21:47
changed her pitch to them instead of saying I'm trying to build Wireless power can you make me this kind of
00:21:53
transducer she just said I'm trying to build a transducer can you make me this
00:21:58
part and she actually disguised her purpose because it was too radical for most people to understand and then a
00:22:03
bunch of Engineers came on board and she was able to work with them to make it happen and what she did was she smuggled
00:22:09
her real Vision in that case inside a trojan horse right she's really trying
00:22:12
to build Wireless power but she has a bunch of people working on different pieces that ultimately will come
00:22:16
together for a different outcome than they intend and I think the more radical the more original your idea is the more
00:22:23
important it is to make sure that people aren't dissuaded by the end and instead
00:22:28
Focus them on perhaps a more moderate goal that they think is plausible uh does originality have um
00:22:37
roots in family uh does for example does birth order matter in originality it matters more than I expected going in
00:22:46
there's a huge debate about birth order and I would say the jury is still out
00:22:50
overall but there is compelling evidence that firstborns on average tend to be a
00:22:54
little bit smarter and a little bit more likely to achieve convention success in
00:22:59
fields like politics and science uh we have more elected officials who are firstborn for example uh we also have
00:23:06
more Nobel prize winning scientists however when it comes to originality completely changing the way that a field
00:23:12
operates or introducing a new technology there does appear to be a later born advantage and I think there are a couple
00:23:19
of reasons for that one is that laterborns are given more freedom so by the time you know you have three or four
00:23:27
older siblings you're allowed to do a lot of things that they weren't allowed
00:23:30
to do growing up and you get to take some risks the other thing that happens is some of the more conventional
00:23:35
achievement niches are filled so you know you may have an older sibling who's
00:23:40
the academic star and one who's an athlete and you need to find other ways to differentiate yourself and one of
00:23:45
those can be creativity uh I I was interested in tracking this as you know with comedians
00:23:52
uh so I took comedy Central's list of the hundred um greatest standup comics
00:23:55
of all time which had some great Originals people like Chris Rock George Carlin Jerry Seinfeld and I studied
00:24:02
their birth order and found that they were more than twice as likely to be born last in their families as first and
00:24:08
the odds of that happening by chancel at loone are two in a million so I think there there is perhaps an advantage for
00:24:15
laterborns in originality as a firstborn I was not excited by this research but the good news is that birth order
00:24:21
effects are not set in stone right so giving children the kinds of Freedom encouraging them to find unique niches
00:24:27
to express themselves I think can push all of us even us firstborns in a more original Direction so I I I I wonder if
00:24:34
you could talk about that in a little more detail how can parents uh nurture more originality uh among their children
00:24:42
well I think Role Models play an important part of this process so what a lot of children do is they become
00:24:49
unoriginal because they've only been exposed to models or standards who are very familiar and conventional right so
00:24:57
children grow up they see lots of Engineers doctors lawyers teachers and they say that's what I want to do too as
00:25:03
parents we can open up more original niches by exposing children to a much wider variety of occupations careers
00:25:10
ideas and some of the most original possibilities are not going to exist yet which is why when you listen to what
00:25:17
some of the great Originals in the technology World say they will frequently identify their inspiration in
00:25:23
science fiction uh books like Ender Game uh now we're probably going to see more
00:25:27
Harry Potter references is when we ask the next generation of entrepreneurs what inspired you but it's amazing how
00:25:33
many inventions come out of fictional stories and I think we could do a much better job making sure that children are
00:25:39
exposed to lots of ideas that don't exist yet so that when they see for example the next generation of somebody
00:25:45
using what looks a lot like a mobile phone in a 1960s Star Trek episode they say you know what I want to go out and
00:25:51
create that you know when you consider families or even companies one of the big problem seems
00:25:59
to be group think how how does that come about and how can you prevent it a lot of people attribute group think to
00:26:07
cohesion they think that if we're too close if we trust each other too much M
00:26:11
if you and I like each other too much then we're not going to challenge each
00:26:14
other that turns out to be false um cohesive groups often make the best decisions and people frequently when
00:26:21
they trust each other are willing to challenge each other and say I know this person is not going to take this too
00:26:26
personally but if you're not careful cohesion can take you down a path toward group think when
00:26:33
people become more concerned about politics and about maintaining their relationships and reputations than about
00:26:39
speaking their minds and being honest so most leaders try to combat this by assigning Devil's Advocates right I know
00:26:47
that there's a majority preference in the room so I'm going to assign one
00:26:50
person to be the the opposite Devil's Advocates according to the research don't work very well most of the time
00:26:57
charlon neth Berkeley has been studying this for over four decades and what she shows is Devil's Advocates make two
00:27:03
mistakes one is they tend to give lip service to an idea but they don't really
00:27:06
believe in it so they don't sell it secondly when Devil's Advocates speak
00:27:11
people know they're just playing a role right I don't need to take you seriously
00:27:15
okay I pretended to advocate for this position and now we can go back to the majority preference instead of assigning
00:27:21
a devil's advocate I think what we all need to do is unearth a devil's advocate
00:27:25
genuine denters people who actually hold the minor opinion we need to find those
00:27:29
people we need to invite them into the conversation and give them a voice and what's so powerful about that is it
00:27:35
turns out minority opinions are useful even when they're wrong so let's say
00:27:39
we're going to hire one of four candidates and almost everybody in the room prefers candidate a and candidate B
00:27:47
is really the best one if someone comes in and advocates for candidate C we will
00:27:52
have a better shot at choosing ultimately the right candidate of B Because when Divergent information comes
00:27:58
to the table we're much more likely to reevaluate our assumptions consider new
00:28:01
criteria and make a better decision to to just uh conclude this fascinating conversation uh I wonder if
00:28:09
you could uh talk a little bit about how organizations can create a culture of nurturing
00:28:17
originality uh if you can offer some practical advice originality thrives as opposed to
00:28:26
being stifled there are a couple things to do one is you have to make it safe for people to fail you have to make it
00:28:33
okay for ideas to come up that don't go anywhere because if you squash all the
00:28:38
bad ideas you're going to miss out on some of your most original possibilities a second step that that
00:28:43
turns out to be really critical if you care about originality in your organization and especially if you want
00:28:48
it to be a core part of the culture is you have to think differently about hiring a lot of leaders hire on culture
00:28:54
fit they say look I want people who share our values who match the culture and that's actually a recipe for group
00:29:01
think you hire a bunch of people who look at problems in the same way who have the same opinions the same
00:29:06
principles Ideo the design firm has I think a compelling alternative to this they say look we're going to throw
00:29:12
cultural fit out the window instead we look for cultural contribution so when we hire we're not looking for people who
00:29:19
are going to replicate or clone the culture we're going to find people who enrich the culture and the test of that
00:29:25
is to figure out what's missing from your culture and then try to bring in people who can who can embody that and
00:29:31
then the I think the third thing to do if you want to build a culture of originality is you need to challenge the
00:29:36
status quo a lot you need to get people uh as Bob Sutton at Stanford would say feeling comfortable being
00:29:42
uncomfortable and one of my favorite ways of doing that is uh from Lisa bodell at Future think uh she actually
00:29:47
runs this kill the company exercise where she brings leaders together and has them spend maybe an hour or two
00:29:53
brainstorming ways to put their own company out of business now I've seen this done in um financial services and
00:29:59
pharmaceutical companies and I have never seen Executives so excited as when they finally get to to trash their own
00:30:05
employer but what's interesting about it is it shifts their mindset because they
00:30:10
start to think about instead of playing defense and protecting themselves against competitive threats they're on
00:30:15
offense and they get to try all these new possibilities and drill into them and then after that when they shift back
00:30:21
to thinking how do I defend against these threats they have much more creativity at their disposal so I think
00:30:26
that's a good example of of shaking things up a little bit Adam thanks so much for speaking with knowledge at
00:30:32
Warton today thank you [Music]

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Best concept / idea
  • 70
    Most original
  • 60
    Best overall
  • 60
    Most creative

Episode Highlights

  • The Inspiration Behind 'Originals'
    Adam shares the twofold inspiration for his book, stemming from personal experiences and cultural questions.
    “I really wanted to know how could I have done that more effectively.”
    @ 00m 33s
    February 02, 2016
  • Entrepreneurs and Risk
    Adam challenges the stereotype of entrepreneurs as risk-takers, revealing they often manage risk portfolios instead.
    “Entrepreneurs are not necessarily more risk-taking than the rest of us.”
    @ 02m 01s
    February 02, 2016
  • The Power of Procrastination
    Adam discusses how strategic procrastination can lead to more creative ideas and better outcomes.
    “Most originals are great procrastinators.”
    @ 13m 56s
    February 02, 2016
  • The Power of Originality
    Originality can be sustained by exposing ourselves to fresh ideas and experiences.
    “We have to keep our exposure to fresh ideas.”
    @ 18m 41s
    February 02, 2016
  • The Role of Coalitions
    Having allies is crucial for bringing original ideas to life.
    “Even a single ally is enough to make you feel that you're not lonely.”
    @ 20m 20s
    February 02, 2016
  • The Trojan Horse Strategy
    Disguising radical ideas can help gain support from skeptics.
    “She smuggled her real vision inside a Trojan horse.”
    @ 22m 20s
    February 02, 2016
  • Birth Order and Originality
    Later-born children may have an advantage in originality due to more freedom.
    “There does appear to be a later-born advantage in originality.”
    @ 23m 17s
    February 02, 2016
  • Creating a Culture of Originality
    Organizations must encourage failure and challenge the status quo to nurture originality.
    “You have to make it safe for people to fail.”
    @ 28m 31s
    February 02, 2016

Episode Quotes

  • I was actually dragged by my boss's boss into the bathroom.
    Adam Grant on 'How Non-Conformists Move the World': Insights from Book 'Originals'
  • When I’ve got a new idea, I’m not necessarily going to trust my own judgment.
    Adam Grant on 'How Non-Conformists Move the World': Insights from Book 'Originals'
  • You have to generate a lot of garbage to reach greatness.
    Adam Grant on 'How Non-Conformists Move the World': Insights from Book 'Originals'
  • There's hope for those of us who are more tortoise than hair.
    Adam Grant on 'How Non-Conformists Move the World': Insights from Book 'Originals'
  • The more radical your idea, the more important it is to disguise your purpose.
    Adam Grant on 'How Non-Conformists Move the World': Insights from Book 'Originals'
  • Birth order matters more than I expected going in.
    Adam Grant on 'How Non-Conformists Move the World': Insights from Book 'Originals'

Key Moments

  • Turning the Tables00:26
  • Entrepreneurship Myths01:37
  • Browser Choice Insights03:01
  • Feedback Importance04:54
  • Pushing Boundaries18:57
  • Finding Allies20:55
  • Trojan Horse Strategy22:20
  • Birth Order Insights23:17

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown