Search Captions & Ask AI

How AI, Consumer Shifts, and Cultural Marketing Are Reshaping the Future of Brands

November 24, 2025 / 28:30

This episode covers marketing trends, the impact of AI on consumer behavior, holiday marketing strategies, and insights from Advertising Week in New York. Guest Peter Adams discusses the challenges marketers face due to economic shifts, the vanishing middle class, and evolving consumer preferences.

Peter shares insights from Advertising Week, highlighting the uncertainty in the marketing industry, including layoffs and the focus on AI and influencer marketing. He notes how the conference was well-attended, indicating a demand for guidance amidst these changes.

The discussion touches on the vanishing middle class and its effects on marketing strategies, with a shift towards targeting wealthier consumers and emphasizing value in messaging. Peter explains how this affects loyalty and customer lifetime value.

AI's role in marketing is examined, particularly how it influences consumer decision-making and job dynamics within agencies. Peter mentions the growing reliance on AI tools and the potential for larger companies to dominate the market.

Finally, the episode discusses Walmart's holiday marketing campaign featuring the Grinch, showcasing a blend of nostalgia and value messaging. Peter emphasizes the importance of storytelling in current marketing strategies.

TLDR

Peter Adams discusses marketing trends, AI's impact, and Walmart's holiday campaign featuring the Grinch.

Episode

28:30
00:00:00
Hello and welcome. You're listening to Marketing Matters on the Wharton podcast
00:00:05
network. This is our weekly podcast where we analyze the latest in marketing, advertising, customer
00:00:12
behavior, branding, new product launches, retail specialties. I'm Barbara Khan, the Patty and JH Baker
00:00:19
Professor of Marketing, and my co-host, Professor Americus Reed, is out of town today, so I'm doing it by myself, which
00:00:28
is sad. However, I am welcoming a terrific guest, a person we've had before, and who knows quite a lot about
00:00:36
everything that's happening in marketing. So, it's very exciting to have him here. So, I'd like to say hello
00:00:42
to Peter Adams, who's the dive. Hello, Peter. >> Hi, Barbara. Thanks so much for having
00:00:50
me on and I'm happy to be on the show now that it's in a podcast format.
00:00:55
>> Yeah, it should be fun. Um, we we put it out to our huge Wharton Network and all
00:01:00
Wharton Network friends. So, we have a very intelligent, interested audience who are very concerned about the latest
00:01:08
things in marketing. And that's what's great to talk to you about because you
00:01:12
often talk about marketing trends and you talk about how marketers are adapting to um or adapting to economic
00:01:19
shifts to AI to changing consumer behavior and all those kind of topics. And of course, you also talk about
00:01:26
state-of-the-art new marketing campaigns, the holiday campaigns that every marketing reporter seems to have
00:01:32
to do at this time of year. Uh what's happening in holiday marketing? But before we get to that, I know that you
00:01:39
recently went to um a conference sponsored I think by or it was called advertising week conference or something
00:01:47
like that. I forget exactly what it's called. War something like that. >> Uh advertising week in New York. Yes.
00:01:53
>> Oh, okay. That's a pretty descriptive name. [laughter] So, advertising week in
00:01:58
New York. And you get like some pretty high up marketers discussing some of the latest trends. And so I thought maybe
00:02:05
we'd start there. Um and you can maybe tell us some of the things that you've
00:02:10
talked about in thinking about what's going on in marketing. >> Yeah. So for advertising week um you
00:02:17
know it was an interesting time for the conference to happen. Uh obviously there's quite a bit of uncertainty
00:02:24
affecting uh multiple aspects of the industry right now with uh tariffs with the conference landing right as holidays
00:02:31
are ramping up and then you know on an individual company basis there's quite a
00:02:35
bit of consolidation uh advertising week draws a lot of folks from the ad agency
00:02:40
world and is actually in the same office space as some of the IPG agencies which
00:02:45
are getting acquired by um Omnicom. So uh a little bit of a harried conference this year. I think people are a little
00:02:53
jumpy uh but also very well attended which I think speaks to the fact that people are looking for uh kind of
00:03:00
guidance and how >> and networking for the next job. [laughter] >> Sure. Definitely. I mean I mean you've
00:03:06
seen um just in the past few months the number of layoffs uh some of them affecting marketing uh pretty intensely.
00:03:15
Um, so yeah, definitely uh a lot of interesting off-site happening to complement the main sort of
00:03:22
agenda that's put on by advertising week itself. Um, and yeah, many of the typical topics you would expect as well.
00:03:29
Uh, AI, uh, creator and influencer marketing. I moderated a panel that was about uh local marketing strategies but
00:03:37
ended up actually intersecting with a couple of those topics as well because that is another area uh that is being uh
00:03:44
disrupted and evolving very quickly right now. >> So there's a couple big themes that
00:03:49
maybe we can dig into a little bit that I saw in some of your writing. One of them was this interesting idea, you
00:03:55
know, on the vanishing middle class. So and I've seen a little as some some changes on that too. It seems like the
00:04:02
rich are getting richer and the poorer are getting poorer and there's nothing
00:04:05
in the middle and obviously a lot of marketing is being generated to those, you know, 1% rich people. So, you're
00:04:12
seeing a lot of emphasis on new luxury and things like that. Um, but how does that affect in general? Not everybody's
00:04:20
going to be able to focus on the 1%. So, how does what's what's the big effect of
00:04:24
this vanishing middle class? Yeah, I mean it's it's for for years or for
00:04:30
decades, uh marketing, broad-based marketing has focused on, you know, the middle class folks, uh people who can be
00:04:38
regular repeat purchasers. You think of categories like packaged goods, stuff like that. Um even stuff like more
00:04:44
premium food and beverage brands. This has always been a big opportunity, but as you pointed out, there's been um some
00:04:50
research that was put together by War. Uh also other companies like McKenzie have sort of identified some of these
00:04:56
patterns where uh it's just an increasingly bifurcated bifurcated market. That's a fun thing to say out
00:05:04
loud. Um but yeah, there's there's incredibly welloff people uh who have,
00:05:10
you know, continued to prop up the economy. If you look at the share of how consumer spending hasn't maybe tapered
00:05:16
off as much as some people expected it to given tariffs and things like that, a decent amount of it is propelled by um
00:05:23
you know very welloff upper middle class uh and higher uh consumers. But yeah, then there's the other end of the
00:05:29
spectrum and um it affects marketing strategies because marketers now need to factor
00:05:37
value and affordability into their messaging more even if they aren't necessarily budget brands. They have to
00:05:43
acknowledge that things that used to be maybe regular or repeat purchases are are maybe a little bit of an extra ask.
00:05:51
I mean, you think about categories like groceries. That's where a lot of people
00:05:55
express the most frustration with prices rising. Um, but it also changes what these researchers call kind of consumer
00:06:03
milestones. I mean, fewer people are buying a house or having kids. Conventionally, those events happening
00:06:11
is a big spending trigger for brands. They go, "This is now an opportunity for
00:06:16
us." But if those people are no longer doing that, and they're no longer doing
00:06:19
that in greater numbers with young consumers, that poses a real problem. Yeah, the housing market is particularly
00:06:25
interesting. People have a little bit of golden handcuffs because they a lot of them bought property or starter houses
00:06:31
when the loans were really cheap and they're locked in. They can't get that
00:06:34
loan again. And so they're kind of locked in and I think that's stagnating
00:06:38
the housing market a little too. Then of course on the other end there's these
00:06:42
people who have just way too much money. And so some of the industry that's developing around that ultra luxury is
00:06:49
is an interesting kind of marketing situation. And I I'm looking a little bit about that and like branded
00:06:55
residences and use of of luxury brand names on condominiums like MercedesBenz or Aston Martin condos [clears throat]
00:07:03
and this idea that's really catering to the super wealthy but that's a very very
00:07:08
small percentage of the overall population. So not clearly not what's driving most marketing. Um, and so I
00:07:16
guess you know along the lines of what you're saying is if you if the marketers
00:07:20
are going after not the ultra wealthy but every you know the other the other part and they're focusing on value.
00:07:27
What's your take on what that does to loyalty? Um, you know, I mean, a lot of
00:07:32
what we're talking about when we talk about marketing in our marketing classes
00:07:35
now is the importance of customer lifetime value and building picking the right customers and then, you know, like
00:07:42
subscription models and retaining customers and things like that. But if you're really focusing on price and
00:07:48
value, that's almost the antithesis of loyalty in some sense, unless they're
00:07:52
making some of this value contingent on relationship. >> Yeah. it it the I mean I think the
00:07:58
loyalty question is it gets challenged a lot. Um I I think depending on the category marketers now have the benefit
00:08:06
of having a lot more granular data. Um you think about um places like retail and um even restaurant uh QSR brands,
00:08:16
you know, they've they've had loyalty as part of a playbook for a while, but
00:08:19
especially now with some of these factors we're talking about knowing when people are buying them, what's pushing
00:08:24
them to buy, and being able to leverage that um to not only inform their own marketing strategies, but in
00:08:31
the case of retail, now monetizing those capabilities to sell to other brands that are also struggling with the same
00:08:36
problems. retail media networks. >> Yeah, exactly. Um, but the loyalty thing, I I read an interesting report
00:08:43
from this agency called Razerfish the other day and it goes back to that sort of milestone um question we were talking
00:08:50
about uh just now. Uh there's a really interesting insight there in there. I
00:08:54
forget the specific share of consumers, but the consumers were basically saying,
00:08:58
I would rather receive these sort of bespoke promotions that recognize frustrating points in life. like if I
00:09:07
take a redeye flight, I want early check-in at a hotel. And I would prefer that over getting an upgrade to the
00:09:13
suite on my honeymoon. So again, you think of honeymoon, that is a traditional consumer milestone, things
00:09:18
that marketers maybe try to usually add a little more white glove service around, but more people are kind of
00:09:24
saying, you know, there's so many aspects of day-to-day life that are frustrating. If you can alleviate that
00:09:28
in any way, that fosters loyalty. Um, and yeah, I know, you know, pricing and value and promotions are seen as sort of
00:09:37
lowhanging fruit in the loyalty space right now, but I do think there are a lot of loyalty strategies kind of being
00:09:43
driven on deal right now. Um, yeah. >> Yeah. My problem is whenever you do it
00:09:49
on deal that just I don't know but you know I don't think of it I think of that
00:09:53
as a fight to the bottom and typically you want to build it more on what you were saying earlier understanding what
00:10:00
the customer is buying looking at data and then maybe alleviating pain points as you suggested or maybe finding new
00:10:06
opportunities to delight whichever way but still it is contingent on understanding the data and that brings
00:10:14
us to another big issue that you wrote about and I'm sure was discussed a lot
00:10:18
is how AI is changing both customer behavior and marketing response and to your initial point like jobs and things
00:10:25
like that. So I mean maybe you can speak to each one of those buckets. First one
00:10:30
that I'm interested in is I don't know how much they talked about from the
00:10:33
customer point of view, but not only are marketers using AI to look at the data to build the models that you're talking
00:10:40
about and to identify some of those opportunities, you know, to customize to a customer, but a customer is now
00:10:47
looking to AI to tell them what to buy. And was there any conversation on how that's changing customer decision making
00:10:55
this focus on you know chachi bt to help you make a decision on what to buy >> to the extent that everyone is obsessed
00:11:02
with the sort of the agentic question um right now you know definitely is a word
00:11:07
that was top of mind during a lot of the AI talks at advertising week and continues to be as people start to think
00:11:13
ahead to the holidays in 2026. I mean, you know, Amazon and their earnings boasting about how much their assistant
00:11:20
is being used. Um, you know, it only went national, I think, within the past, you know, year or so. Uh, but, you know,
00:11:27
they've got the muscle to kind of push people towards features like that. And
00:11:32
Walmart, you know, the biggest retailer in the traditional sense, also working with, you know, the chat GBTs of the
00:11:37
world to develop similar capabilities. Um, and yeah, I mean I think for marketers thinking in the long term, you
00:11:45
know, it's a potentially exciting channel. Um, but you know, for right now it's, you know, sort of the large
00:11:52
companies with the capabilities to invest in this stuff will probably have the first mover advantage. Um, and for
00:11:58
others who don't have the sophistication, um, you know, it it'll potentially sort
00:12:03
of, uh, be a disadvantage in some ways. you know, Amazon has already eaten up so
00:12:08
much share of e-commerce and things like that by just being the most technologically sophisticated and
00:12:13
convenient. You know, do they further grab more share if they've got the best
00:12:17
shopping assistant or what have you. >> Yeah. I mean, your answer to the question, you you flipped the question
00:12:22
to what I asked, but in answering your question, you probably answered it also. I was thinking about how it changed the
00:12:29
um actually the mindset of the consumer. But what you're suggesting is these
00:12:34
agents really exist for some of the big players. And so clearly they're going to
00:12:40
be programmed to give the big players more advantage. So uh perhaps what's happening is the more you depend on
00:12:48
these agents, the more you kind of narrow the playing field because only the big guys are having
00:12:55
them. I guess that's what you were saying. Um I was just wondering like if it changes how I make decisions. Do
00:13:01
people just listen to what the agents say and do that and then so there so that who has the agents really are is
00:13:09
going to frame where purchases are being made? I guess that's what your answer
00:13:13
was. And do you believe that? I think consumers I mean you know there's still
00:13:18
areas where AI falls short but purely anecdotally know that um yeah people when they're struggling to think of
00:13:25
something like a holiday gift idea will prompt chap GBT like this person likes X
00:13:30
and Y what's a sort of you know a potentially surprising or thoughtful gift I could get them that that that's
00:13:37
how people plan uh you know everything from vacations now and yeah holidays for sure. Um I'm not sure you know like the
00:13:44
the adoption of these uh individual chatouts kind of at the consumer level is quite high and um continues to be
00:13:52
very engaged and you know just speaking from personal experience right now every
00:13:56
year my family does a secret Santa uh drawing through a platform that also doubles as serving gift recommendations.
00:14:04
And I noticed for the first time this year it has an AI thing. So if you're drawing up a wish list for your secret
00:14:08
Santa, it'll you can plug some prompts in and it'll recommend them to you. So
00:14:13
um it's definitely informing Yeah. consumer shopping behavior. >> Yeah. Yeah. And so therefore, the people
00:14:17
who control those agents and control those platforms are obviously doing it in their own best interest. And so
00:14:23
you're going to see the big get bigger in that kind of thing because the smaller ones can't afford it. Um, so the
00:14:30
other thing that people are talking about with AI and it sounds like, you know, was a topic there was how much
00:14:36
it's replacing jobs or how much at these advertising um, agencies or whatever
00:14:41
these marketing situations, a lot of the work that used to be done by people is now being done by AI. Was that a concern
00:14:48
or >> I I mean I think that the idea that AI is wholesale replacing roles at agencies
00:14:55
is um you know maybe a little overstated sometimes. Uh there's no doubt that you
00:15:03
know agencies are investing very heavily in this but I read an interesting article the other day that was talking
00:15:08
about this AI washing. Um obviously the economy is not in a very good spot right
00:15:12
now. ad agencies in particular, the publicly traded holding companies have not been a in a good spot for a long
00:15:18
time. I mean, they're financially mostly financially pretty distressed companies
00:15:22
that are now looking to break apart and sell stuff off. Um, you know, I think if
00:15:27
they can sell their layoff story as, you know, AI is replacing jobs, it looks better for them um in public. But the
00:15:35
the thing that's more interesting for me with the agencies is how it's starting
00:15:39
to switch up how they approach their services models. Um, so WPP, the largest ad agency, um, last month introduced
00:15:48
this new offering where basically, uh, the their clients don't even need to hire an agency anymore. They can
00:15:55
basically just make use of WPP's AI technology for their campaigns. So, um, they've gotten a lot of questions. Does
00:16:04
this cannibalize agency work? You're basically saying, you don't need to hire
00:16:08
people anymore. You can just borrow our tech. Um, and it'll be interesting to
00:16:12
see if sort of their competitors also adopt this. Um, cuz it's the type of thing that, yeah, definitely disrupts
00:16:19
sort of the traditional agency model, but might also be kind of necessary as this is what clients are sort of
00:16:24
demanding and they value the ability to have technology partners who can help them execute their marketing.
00:16:31
>> Yeah. Well, that'll be interesting. Well, given that we have you now and it
00:16:35
is Christmas, I see that you have written on a number of these new holiday stories and what's happening. So, we
00:16:42
might as well dig in and see if there's anything interesting. Let me This one
00:16:47
isn't a holiday story, but I'm since you wrote about it, let me just ask. Pepsi
00:16:52
has been changing all their logos. I mean, every year there's a new logo change for them. Last year was Mountain
00:16:57
Dew. This year they overdid their corporate branding. Did you have a takeaway on like how important that is
00:17:04
or like you know I know they think it's important they spend a lot of a lot of
00:17:10
time on it but did did what was your reaction to the importance of overhauling this and
00:17:18
what you know I don't know what what did you take of that when you wrote that
00:17:21
article? >> Yeah I mean they're a business that's under quite a lot of pressure right now.
00:17:26
um they have an activist uh investor campaign that they're sort of contending
00:17:31
with that's pushing them to shed some lower performing aspects of the business. And you know it's right there
00:17:37
in the name PepsiCo. Pepsi for a long time was you know kind of the big focus. They're a food and beverage company but
00:17:43
Pepsi is the flagship and at least when it comes to traditional full sugar Pepsi
00:17:48
is a brand that has been in pretty serious decline in recent years. has dropped in just a few years from being
00:17:53
the number two soda in the US to number four. Um, and the PepsiCo corporate branding for a long time sort of
00:18:01
mirrored the Pepsi branding. It was similar color schemes and sort of visual motifs, but this new overhaul
00:18:08
um moves Azure. It is the most dramatic change away from that yet. So, um, what they're trying to do is highlight we're
00:18:17
not just Pepsi. We own 500 brands and we own cool new growing brands. I mean, they recently acquired Ciiete, uh, the
00:18:26
Mexican food company. Uh, they bought Poppy, which is obviously their big response to this prebiotic cola
00:18:32
disruption. Um, so this overhaul is sort of, yeah, positioning them as more than
00:18:37
just Pepsi and being a kind of well-rounded food and beverage business. Uh, and yeah, the the visual identity
00:18:43
looks nothing like what they've done before. >> Nothing. Yeah, I'm just looking at it
00:18:46
now. I mean, I know we're not showing it, but it is radically different from
00:18:50
the past where it really did focus on Pepsi and and what that meant. And now it's, you know, the red and blue is
00:18:57
gone. It's more like uh natural colors, organic kind of feel, definitely to food
00:19:02
and well, we'll see how that happens. And now Todd Kaplan used to be at Pepsi,
00:19:08
but then he moved to Craft, I think. >> And I think you wrote an article about
00:19:13
that, too. Did you write something about Craft? I thought I saw something on that.
00:19:17
>> Yeah, he he had a big presence at advertising week. Um, and was >> he's a cool guy. We had him on the
00:19:22
podcast and like I don't know why he left Pepsi. I don't know what but he had
00:19:27
been at Pepsi for a really long time and I I guess he left a few years ago for the opportunity at Craft. So yeah, what
00:19:33
was your take from what he's been doing? Uh well so his talk at advertising week
00:19:38
touched on a thing that I think is affecting a lot of legacy marketers right now is um he has always been a big
00:19:44
champion or I shouldn't say always but in recent years has been a very big champion of this idea of um you know
00:19:51
thinking past traditional media strategies toward earned media. Um you know how do you get your brands being
00:19:58
talked about in culture in ways that extend beyond paid advertising. And so basically in his first you know year
00:20:04
plus at craft he has been um just sort of peppering uh the industry with like these little and large activations that
00:20:14
are very kind of culturally oriented. Um Hines Mustard did a collaboration with Mustard the DJ behind the Kendrick Lamar
00:20:21
songs. Um, and so he spoke at advertising week just sort of about how to identify those moments and kind of
00:20:29
keep pace with the sort of churn of mostly social mediadriven content. You know, these memes emerge overnight and
00:20:37
it presents brands a small window of opportunity to kind of go viral and attach themselves to those. Um, but you
00:20:43
know, how do you identify them? How do you make the most of them and make sure they're the right fit for your brand?
00:20:47
Was a lot of what he was talking about. And this is a change we see taking hold all across the board of this kind of
00:20:53
pivot away from traditional kind of paid national advertising to this very socially uh organic contentoriented
00:21:01
approach. Um and it's led to some interesting results for sure. I mean Craft Hinds has um you know managed to
00:21:07
keep its brands a little more on the pulse of culture. Uh but you know the larger business obviously um you know is
00:21:13
struggling with what a lot of other kind of large packaged foods companies are right now. Yeah, that's an interesting
00:21:18
thing. Um because it it's a different tool set than than people have. And it
00:21:22
sounds like he's somebody who has the traditional one and is in the new world
00:21:26
because now you're looking for these cultural moments. You got to do them fast because they they change. So you
00:21:31
don't have a lot of time to test everything. And if you don't do it through the lens of your brand, you can
00:21:37
get into trouble. I mean the famous one a couple years ago was Bud Light and Target and all of them. they responded
00:21:43
to something that would seemed perhaps in the on the drawing board to be a no-brainer and then they release it and
00:21:50
they get this really negative response and see a huge effect on sales like it's
00:21:54
not small effects on this and yet if you're doing that kind of marketing where you're looking for the cultural
00:22:00
moment or the opportunity I could imagine it's it's tough to know at really quickly whether or not it's
00:22:08
the right move for your brand to discuss it. Uh, so you I guess you have to have
00:22:13
some kind of blueprint as to what is in the brand's DNA and what isn't and
00:22:18
things like that. Did he talk about something along those lines like how to know it and how to know it fast?
00:22:23
>> Yeah, I mean I think I I think you've kind of you know I don't know how much
00:22:29
you know a specific criteria is employed but I think yeah very much understanding
00:22:33
the sort of brand values and where they come from. Does this make sense with our
00:22:37
narrative? Um, and you know, this is a case where, you know, we just talked a little bit about how agencies are being
00:22:43
disrupted, but this is a case where kind of like partners can help. Um, there was
00:22:47
a separate talk I went to that was with PepsiCo and their CMO was saying or their beverages CMO was saying, um, you
00:22:55
know, we've got some of the most experienced marketers, the most talented marketers, but we don't get the
00:23:00
algorithms like our agency does. So they've developed this new partnership model where they've put their social
00:23:06
agency much closer to their internal teams to kind of keep a pulse on these things that we're talking about, making
00:23:12
sure they're aligned with the brand values and things like that, but also that they can be reactive in the way
00:23:18
that we're talking about. So it's definitely causing a lot of these traditional large marketing
00:23:22
organizations to kind of switch up how they think about everything from agencies to CMO roles and things like
00:23:28
that as well. You know, you think about like these companies that are great and then all of a sudden they make a misstep
00:23:34
like a Dolingo or something like that was like that everybody thought they were terrific and then I forgot what it
00:23:39
was but they made some misstep. And so I would imagine part of what you're doing
00:23:43
with this is not only learning to figure out which ones you respond to and which
00:23:49
ones you don't and then when you do, how you make sure it's through the brand's
00:23:52
lens, but you got to also figure what do you do when you made a mistake? How fast
00:23:57
do you get out of it? you know, because it is a very fast window. So, if you make the mistake quickly and maybe own
00:24:04
it quickly, it might go you might not have to deal with it for too long. Yeah. I mean, it's like anything else. I
00:24:11
I think the decision-m needs to be um fast, but unfortunately, you know, we were just talking about the
00:24:19
cultural relevance brands can find in responding quickly to social stuff. I mean, social stuff can also quickly bury
00:24:26
brands. I mean, uh, good example of this recently was Cracker Barrel, uh, >> made a fairly innocuous update to their
00:24:36
logo. There's been a good deal of reporting, including in the Wall Street Journal about how basically, you know,
00:24:41
even bots sort of seized on this as a contentious topic, and they're still trying to kind of claw their way out of
00:24:47
something that I I've never really understood why that was such a flash point. I mean, you can say what you want
00:24:52
about the logo, but I didn't think it should be as controversial as it ended
00:24:55
up being. So, um, yeah, I think staying really reactive and being able to pivot quickly is super important. Not waiting
00:25:02
weeks on it, not going through, you know, multiple different agencies and crisis PR firms, you know, you got to
00:25:08
kind of maybe go with your gut a little bit more on some of this stuff. Um, you know, the Duolinga case is one of these
00:25:13
things where I think the leaderships at the company just sort of misread the rumor and AI. Um, you know, they started
00:25:19
talking so much about AI and how great AI is. And um the thing people loved about their marketing was it's you know
00:25:25
it was very focused on their mascot but it was very human in a way. It was very humorous. It was their mascot reacting
00:25:31
to things in culture. And then for the the company leadership to say AI is all that matters and and things like that. I
00:25:37
think you know there's a it's a really testy sub subject still. Um >> and uh yeah was obviously very
00:25:43
alienating to some of their user base. >> Yeah. I mean it's interesting how this
00:25:48
but anyway let's end. And I know we don't have that much time left, but it
00:25:51
is Christmas. So, let's go to the biggest retailer and the story you wrote on Walmart and the Grinch. Uh, what was
00:25:57
your take on all of that? >> Yes. So, Walmart for the past couple years um has really embraced uh this
00:26:05
very pop culture forward messaging strategy. I mean, last year for the holidays, they ran an ad that featured,
00:26:11
you know, Gilmore Girls and all these kind of famous uh sort of seasonal touchstones. And this year they're kind
00:26:17
of returning to a similar playbook, but focusing on one kind of cultural property, which is the Grinch. And
00:26:24
they've basically built this whole kind of world where they're tying um kind of
00:26:29
their product assortment and services into the world of the Dr. Seuss uh Dr. Dr. Seuss is how the Grinch Stole
00:26:36
Christmas. And um they've recently updated it. Walton Gogggins, who previously appeared in their ads that
00:26:41
they started running this summer, is now playing the Grinch. So, um, you know, I
00:26:46
think in times like this, we we we were having the conversation earlier about like kind of value and promotions, what
00:26:51
a weird holiday period it is, um, and and why that, you know, could potentially lead more people to kind of
00:26:57
focus on on messages of value. But, you know, Walmart is historically known for value, but they're leaning into a very
00:27:03
kind of storytelling first approach, which I think might actually end up working pretty well for them. I think
00:27:08
people are looking for a sense of escapism uh and nostalgia. Um and it gives them a chance to also, you know,
00:27:15
they they are highlighting their product assortment as well. But I think it's a
00:27:18
pretty savvy campaign. >> It's so funny because it's like that sounds so much like traditional
00:27:24
marketing, you know, going to Dr. Seuss and the Grinch and Christmas and nostalgia. I mean, those are things we
00:27:30
were teaching 25 years ago. So you start from culturally forward and AI and social media and you end up with Walmart
00:27:38
and the Grinch. Kind of interesting what happens in marketing. Anyway, we are out
00:27:43
of time. So Peter, thank you so much for joining us today. And where can listeners go to read up with your
00:27:47
stories and keeping up with the times? >> Sure. Uh you can always check out uh
00:27:52
marketingdive.com. Uh we also have a daily newsletter and two weekly newsletters focused on
00:27:58
agencies and mobile marketing. Uh, and I post about my stuff on LinkedIn as well.
00:28:03
So, uh, give me a look there. >> Thanks a lot. Thank you. That's all we
00:28:08
have time for today. I'd like to thank our producers, Dion Simkins and Marissa
00:28:12
Remma. And thank you all for listening. We'll be back next week. Till then, this
00:28:16
has been Marketing Matters on the Wharton Podcast Network. I'm Barbara Khan here without America's Reed.

Episode Highlights

  • The Vanishing Middle Class
    Marketing strategies are shifting as the middle class disappears, impacting consumer behavior.
    “The rich are getting richer and the poorer are getting poorer.”
    @ 04m 03s
    November 24, 2025
  • AI's Role in Marketing
    AI is transforming how consumers make decisions and how marketers respond.
    “AI is changing both customer behavior and marketing response.”
    @ 10m 21s
    November 24, 2025
  • Walmart's Grinch Campaign
    Walmart embraces pop culture with a Grinch-themed holiday campaign, blending nostalgia and value messaging.
    “It's a pretty savvy campaign.”
    @ 27m 15s
    November 24, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • There's quite a bit of uncertainty affecting the industry right now.
    How AI, Consumer Shifts, and Cultural Marketing Are Reshaping the Future of Brands
  • Fewer people are buying a house or having kids.
    How AI, Consumer Shifts, and Cultural Marketing Are Reshaping the Future of Brands
  • AI is changing both customer behavior and marketing response.
    How AI, Consumer Shifts, and Cultural Marketing Are Reshaping the Future of Brands
  • It's a different tool set than people have.
    How AI, Consumer Shifts, and Cultural Marketing Are Reshaping the Future of Brands
  • Social stuff can also quickly bury brands.
    How AI, Consumer Shifts, and Cultural Marketing Are Reshaping the Future of Brands
  • Staying reactive and pivoting quickly is super important.
    How AI, Consumer Shifts, and Cultural Marketing Are Reshaping the Future of Brands

Key Moments

  • Solo Hosting00:25
  • Economic Uncertainty02:24
  • Vanishing Middle Class04:03
  • AI Influence10:21
  • Cultural Marketing Shift19:51
  • Agility in Marketing24:57
  • Walmart's Nostalgic Approach27:05

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown