Search Captions & Ask AI

Did Jim Downey Write that?

June 18, 2026 / 01:18:26

This episode features Jim Downey, a former head writer for Saturday Night Live, discussing his experiences and stories from SNL, including notable cast members like Eddie Murphy and Chris Farley. Key topics include Downey's writing process, his thoughts on various sketches, and his interactions with famous comedians.

The conversation also touches on Chris Farley's outrageous antics, including a memorable incident where Farley entered a meeting completely naked. Downey describes how the team managed to keep a straight face during the unexpected moment.

TLDR

Jim Downey shares SNL stories, including Eddie Murphy's rise and Chris Farley's antics, while discussing his writing style and career.

Episode

1:18:26
00:00:00
And he I remembered he came in he came in he had seen Jaws at a theater in Time Square and he told me that his favorite
00:00:08
thing about it was there were there were guys in the audience during the the scary scenes going get him Jaws get him.
00:00:17
I was constantly encountering Eddie Murphy. This was who was a featured player and he was just going into
00:00:25
everyone's office and being hilarious. And I remember going to Jean and saying, you know, Jean, there's that that Eddie
00:00:32
Murphy guy. I mean, I don't think I'm this mad genius who's spotting something no one else can see. I think I think you
00:00:40
really you got I think you might want to put that guy on camera. >> And her attitude, I remembered, is being
00:00:47
like, uh, I think he needs a little seasoning. writer's assistant, uh, comes up to me. I'm at the head of the table
00:00:53
and and whispers to me, uh, just so you know, uh, Chris Chris Farley is out in the hallway and he's completely naked.
00:01:03
And so, and so I told everyone, okay, Farley's going to come in, you guys, and he's going to come in naked. So, it's
00:01:10
vitally important that no one give him anything. >> No one reacts. >> We just have to sort of go, oh yeah,
00:01:15
hey, Chris, what's up? Jim Downey a re our his second time with us. It's scintillating a return visit
00:01:24
with the one and only Jim Downey writer extraordinaire from Saturday night. >> We always jump into it without saying
00:01:32
too much because we just think everyone knows Downey. But he was our head writer
00:01:36
while we were at SNL. He was one of the great writers from Harvard. He did, I think, the first five years of SNL and
00:01:43
then he went and did started Letterman, the first beginnings of shaping, one of the greatest shows ever. Letterman
00:01:50
>> came back to SNL and has been dabbling ever since. >> And I think he even did
00:01:54
>> a little work on Tommy Boy. I I asked him about his rewrites and his movies and
00:02:00
>> he's a great dude. He's a funny dude and he is a one of our good buddies >> and we have a great laugh with him
00:02:08
>> and learn a lot. Yes. Please welcome James Downey. Jim Downey. >> Who's better, the Rolling Stones or the
00:02:18
Beatles? You have five seconds. >> Yeah. >> Um >> I love He seriously >> considers it. It's so funny.
00:02:27
>> It reminds It reminds me of one time I was uh >> Here we go. I >> I was I was late at night. I was
00:02:34
watching Dana Casey Kasem and it was like it was like u we're counting down the greatest bands of the rock era.
00:02:45
Number three, the Rolling Stones. Number two, the Beatles. We'll be back with the greatest band of the rock
00:02:57
to go. >> Who remembers that? What are your journey? >> Okay. So, anyway, I I was I was just
00:03:02
flipping around to go, wait a minute. Number three, >> wait a second. >> The Rolling Stones. Number two, the
00:03:08
>> number two, the Beat. >> We'll be right back around the number one band in the history of rock and
00:03:15
roll. >> What the [ __ ] would be number one? And so I waited through like 12 minutes of
00:03:20
commercials. You know, >> and then and then finally I was like, would you please [ __ ] get to the
00:03:28
[ __ ] number one? And it was like the number one. >> All right. Number three, the Rolling
00:03:34
Stones. >> Number two, the Beatles and the greatest band of the rock era, Queen.
00:03:44
>> And I was just, no. >> Was that considered a joke? >> No. I Well, I mean, >> I thought it would be like and the
00:03:52
number one band of the rock era, Golden Pony. They came out of Scotland and you know
00:03:58
>> Herman and the Hermits. >> No, but a band that doesn't ever exist. >> Yeah. >> Anyway, I love doing KCK. What a what a
00:04:05
great voice that guy had. You know, >> he's a great man. >> Did you know him? >> Let's Yeah. Are you friends with him
00:04:11
still? >> I saw him I saw him one time at the Emmys. His wife was there was a greater
00:04:17
height discrepancy between him and his wife than I've ever seen within a character.
00:04:23
>> Who was taller or shorter? two individual. >> The wife was >> probably >> close to three feet taller.
00:04:30
>> His wife, >> she was like 61 and he was like five. >> Well, actually, now that I think about
00:04:36
it, >> yeah, that she was probably only a foot taller, but still >> with heels. >> I just won a million dollars on Poly
00:04:43
Market that you would start the podcast with a Casey Kism story. >> Well, congratulations.
00:04:51
I can tell the audience Jim was my boss in case they don't recognize him from his star turn in one battle after
00:04:57
another. I recognize him. >> Well, they may not. I I put on >> Jim Downey is an actor.
00:05:07
>> Yeah, >> you're you're like a You were in the chair. You're all Paul Thomas Anderson
00:05:11
movies. I don't know what is it. You're like an actor. You're like a really funny good actor. I just thought of you
00:05:17
as a writer, but now you're fogging parts. >> I am. I'm I'm I'm denying parts to to
00:05:24
way more deserving people, and it's wrong. And um all I can say is, you know, um a lot of the people that we've
00:05:33
all worked with over the years are now like directing and writing and and things. And I guess it amuses them to
00:05:42
have me around on the set or something. >> No, no, no. I see the antedence. I think
00:05:47
that your voice work in change bank >> kind of solidified this style that you have of underplay.
00:05:58
>> Well, you underplay everything just on the edge of too much underplay but like
00:06:03
perfectly underplayed with not nothing >> and so that's its own charisma. Who's a
00:06:11
famous actor that would do that? might have been Henry Fonda. >> Furl lives. >> Well, I don't say too much.
00:06:17
>> Lives. >> People say you remind me of Fear Lives. >> That's always a good name to come up.
00:06:24
You're kind of like um You're like Brick Crawford. >> Do you ever get stopped in the street?
00:06:30
>> I'm I'm looking more and more like him all the time. >> What do you mean? You look cute.
00:06:34
>> Oh, well, thank you. >> You're You're jolly and cute. >> Adorable. Uh the thing is I mean I think
00:06:40
the underplaying thing is because >> I don't have the acting chops to overplay you know I I I do like I do dry
00:06:50
dead pan because >> dry dead >> that's sort of the the easiest thing to do >> and I think people who are capable of
00:06:59
doing more tend to do it. You know >> I'm like in in I'm idling when other people want to get out. Basically, you
00:07:08
are, and I'm not, this is exactly who you are. >> You are the modern Gary Cooper.
00:07:15
>> Discuss. >> Yeah. >> On a on a on a count of I think you're wrong. >> Um I'm trying to think. I'm trying to
00:07:25
remember. >> Come back with somebody. >> Classic Gary Coup. No. >> Well, it would be High Noon. He says
00:07:30
like three words at a time over a 20 minute span. Like he has three lines and he's very low-key. I don't think we
00:07:37
ought to >> good comedy. >> We shouldn't be going that way and then he doesn't talk for 10 minutes.
00:07:42
>> But being dry with no jokes is different than being you're doing >> right. You're doing it and it's funny.
00:07:48
Like you sent me that thing of you it was Billy Madison, right? And you gave this. So the more dry and then the
00:07:55
speech is kind of critical or aggressive. The actual words are this. You've lowered the IQ of every person
00:08:01
here but with nothing given to it is its own. I just like it. I like it. It always makes me laugh.
00:08:08
>> All right. Jim Downy's been our guest. The actor. You can always look him up on
00:08:12
Wikipedia. He wrote for some comedy show. Okay. Go ahead. What are you pondering?
00:08:19
No, I'm just I'm just listening to this and and um it it it doesn't make any sense that that all this stuff happened
00:08:29
um at the same time and none of it is related to the other, you know, the >> the um
00:08:37
>> the chair company. >> Well, the chair company is another great comedian, Tim Rob, and hilarious.
00:08:42
>> Talk to all that. talk to your late in life quote unquote acting career in film. Tell
00:08:48
>> um well the the the first thing sequentially would have been um the working with Paul Thomas Anderson you
00:08:58
know every every 20 years or so he calls me up and says I want there's something
00:09:03
very specific that I need you for. So like in 2006 I was in there Will Be Blood.
00:09:09
>> Yes, I remember. Then >> um I was out sort of hanging around on the set later for Inherent Vice, which
00:09:17
was like 2014 or 2013. >> Yeah. >> And then Yep. And then um in um and then he he um I got a call uh in early 2024
00:09:31
about um doing one battle after another, which at the time was called the the BC
00:09:37
project. And then um >> battle when you're on the set at lunch to go I got battle tomorrow.
00:09:44
>> No. Well I we we have taken a calling it OBAA. >> That's Yeah. So I was doing OBAA with PTAP.
00:09:55
>> You would have been great. One of the most disturbing movies I've ever seen and it is brilliant. But the theme of
00:10:01
the movie that PTA did called Phantom Thread. >> I loved Phantom Thread. It's meditation
00:10:08
on marriage is so uh it's dark and just uh you'd have to see the movie to understand it. But I was going to ask
00:10:17
you about one battle after another if you had that kind of subtuge theme or does it have multiple themes? What are
00:10:25
the main themes? Because it's a lot of movie >> to crunch on. >> Yeah, there are so many different things
00:10:31
going on that movie. I mean, I I guess we we the Christmas adventurers club were kind of a dry comic relief, whereas
00:10:43
>> uh Leonardo DiCaprio and Benio Del Toro were were more were a little wetter, you
00:10:50
know? I mean, I thought Benio was hilarious in that movie. >> Yes. >> Or BDT, as I call him.
00:10:58
>> Oh, yeah. Or Doro. Doro. I But he but he was just flatout funny. And what we were
00:11:06
doing was was was dry. >> Dry counter. And Leo can play white hot. >> Leo. Listen to this guy.
00:11:16
>> Yeah. Dap. >> Can call him Leo. >> Decap was >> LDC. LDC. >> Oh god dang. He's even better.
00:11:23
>> Once upon a time in Hollywood, he was a white hot mess, you know. And >> I'm in the Little Dick Club. Is that
00:11:28
what you're talking about? No, he's uh but he um >> again he he was uh he was pretty funny
00:11:36
when he was funny in the middle. >> Oh >> yeah. No, his range is enormous. He could do whatever he wants. He's you
00:11:41
know >> Were you a white supremacist? Was that sort of the uh situation? >> Well, that that was um Yeah, that was
00:11:48
the idea. I mean, um I'm not based on yourself. >> Was it based on you, Jim? The white
00:11:54
supremacy part. Was it based on you go what would it be funny if we were all white supremacists?
00:12:00
>> I went through that phase. >> Yeah, everybody does. >> That was I think everyone does. Yeah. Um
00:12:06
but you know then I I I I grew out of it and then dabbled again. >> Yeah. >> Then grew out of it the second time and
00:12:14
then it's been it's been a year and a half. >> Get caught up in a chat room. >> Yeah. You know you late at night. Um,
00:12:22
>> Sean was funny just walking crazy like this and especially toward the end when
00:12:26
he's already when he wipes out his car and he's walking back like all >> No, the his face was hilarious in the um
00:12:34
I got to see him, you know, at at at both the before and after up close. >> Oh, right.
00:12:40
>> Cuz um >> Oh, you have the ending scene. >> Most of my important work in the film
00:12:44
was >> a lot of the work is toward the end. You have to stick around. >> Well, you were at the Oscars, too,
00:12:50
right? We did that. We >> got your text. You were at the Oscars, too, right? >> Um I could have been,
00:12:59
>> but I I um >> No. Didn't you do a bit? >> Oh, yes, we shot that. We shot that.
00:13:06
>> Yeah, >> we shot that I think um couple weeks ahead. Yeah, >> I remain one of the most surprising
00:13:15
things I've ever been a part of was was the fact that that actually made it on air
00:13:21
>> because you know the the thing with the Oscars is always that the one thing everyone knows about it is how it's
00:13:27
always running long. >> They're always playing off. >> I was shocked by that. They and and I I
00:13:33
I knew this had to be the very last thing on the show and and I I said, "Look, Conan called me up, asked me to
00:13:41
come out and do it." And I said, "I'm I'm happy to do it. It it'll this will be fun, but don't kidding, don't tell me
00:13:48
that there's any possibility that >> and he said, um, well, even if it if it doesn't, um, it's going to be online and
00:13:57
probably more people will see it online." And then when I was there, there was some representative from the
00:14:04
academy there and and he said, "Oh, no, no, we're definitely doing it. This is in for sure."
00:14:09
>> So, okay. >> It is weird. It's like after the Super Bowl, the show. But actually, the
00:14:14
credits are usually here's the winning Oscar movie, everyone runs on stage. Thank you. Credits start. And it's like
00:14:22
because that's the biggest one everyone's waiting for. Sorry we ran late. Goodbye. And then it's
00:14:28
>> Jim's scene. And I'm like, "Oh, there's an added scene." I've never I don't know
00:14:32
if I've ever seen that on the Oscars. >> I don't I don't see the Oscars every single year, but um I don't I don't I
00:14:40
can't imagine there was ever like a an epilogue before. >> I enjoyed it immensely because I did not
00:14:47
expect it and it took me a minute to kind of process what it was and then I saw you and I went, "Okay, I mean and
00:14:53
you were underplaying and it was beautiful. Only thing I can do is under >> Well,
00:15:00
Spencer Tracy would kind of underplay a lot too. He was often not, you know, demonstrative. And Clint Eastwood,
00:15:08
you're like an early Clint Eastwood. But anyway, let's get back. >> There you go.
00:15:12
>> Let's get on the topic of what we're what what you've got to get in on the podcast. You had a documentary. It's on
00:15:19
Peacock. What's it called? >> It's called Downey Wrote That. >> That's right. >> Ah, that is a that is a big phrase you
00:15:26
hear. So, a highly wellreceived documentary >> um about your existence as a supreme
00:15:35
sketch comedy writer. >> Your words, >> your words, not mine. >> Um, actually, not my words there, but
00:15:42
they were the words of um >> Did I get that right? >> They're the words of Andy Breman, who
00:15:47
whose idea it was Andy Breman. >> Yeah. Andy writer >> uh was writer and I met him
00:15:56
>> at Letterman >> in in 82 83 84 and and then he went to Saturday Night Live after Letterman and um we
00:16:07
shared an office for a year there the year with Marty Short and and uh Chris Guest Larry David was there anyway his
00:16:15
Larry's Andy's wife is a documentary filmmaker and And the two of them had sort of been
00:16:23
pushing this idea for a very long time since like 2006. And then finally um um I I um I was not anxious to do it um for
00:16:35
a variety of reasons. But finally the pressure became a little too great starting around like 2020 2021.
00:16:44
So it happened. Well, I didn't ever see you as uh vain at all or a vanity. You were you were actually Sarah. You were
00:16:52
just behind the scenes. You were Jim Downey. So, this is like >> in a psychologically like all this
00:16:58
exposure >> is that was like you said there were a number of reasons. Was it energy? Was it
00:17:04
like I'd rather just let it lay and let the world discover me or what what was your push back? Um it a lot of it had to
00:17:12
do with the fact that um in the beginning the first you know 10 years it was being pushed I was working at the
00:17:18
show and I just thought it would be a really bad idea >> while you're there while I'm there with
00:17:24
the you know the and then afterwards I kind of wanted to um get away from from the thing you know the show and show biz
00:17:36
everything and then right when they really crank cranked up the pressure and basically said, "We're going to make
00:17:42
your life a living hell unless you agree to do this." I had I was one of the first people to get CO. I got I got
00:17:49
COVID in in December of 2019 and I was like a mess and I I wasn't >> your vacation in Wuhan or what what's
00:17:58
that about? Yeah, >> it actually was um I was flying back from Charleston and I was waiting on the
00:18:07
night of December 2nd, 2019 at Kennedy Airport, waiting in the rain and I was the only accidental in a group of like
00:18:17
200 people who had just gotten off a flight from Wuhan. >> For real? Serious? >> I'm absolutely because I looked it up
00:18:25
later. I just noticed it was this it was an odd thing like geez did I just walk into a a
00:18:34
like a tour group from from China and everyone was coughing and sneezing and blowing their nose everything and I'm
00:18:41
going like oh man >> I am so getting sick uh tomorrow morning and I did >> and it was only
00:18:48
>> a months later >> that because I went to a doctor like late December and he and he said I have
00:18:54
no idea what you have but you have something and then when remember it was like early February when you started to
00:19:01
hear the term Wuhan and everything >> and then I went online and discovered that there were two flights a day
00:19:08
>> from Wuhan, China >> to Kennedy airport. >> So I it wasn't just China, it was Wuhan,
00:19:15
China >> and Yeah. So that's so that's and so anyway I I I was not I was not in the
00:19:24
right frame of mind to begin with and then right you know in the in the thick of of
00:19:29
>> hey let's go >> yeah not anyway >> well my question to you is >> and we were in it I was
00:19:37
>> it's a lot easier which I'm getting to Dana it's a lot easier if they think you're going to use your connections to
00:19:45
go personally ask people to talk about you, which is an awkward situation. So, I think it's easier. They just say,
00:19:52
"We'll take care of everything." And so, Dana, me, we get a call, it's about Downey, done. So, I don't think it's
00:19:59
that hard to extract. And maybe they knew that because some documentaries are tough because I don't want to do every
00:20:04
documentary that comes my way. Now, Dana's Dr. Doc, so he does uh he's done a couple.
00:20:10
>> I I did I did POTUS. >> Oh, yeah. with with Jim. >> Yeah, I was a minor. That's it's a
00:20:19
documentary called Playing POTUS, which um >> President of the United States. >> They couldn't get Dana for the panel at
00:20:25
the premiere last Saturday, but they they snagged me and uh Robert, our friend Robert Smeiggel was there and um
00:20:34
Dana's great in the documentary. Highly recommended. >> What did I see? What did I do? I told
00:20:38
him, "You got to come to me." I told him to move the panel to where I live up in
00:20:42
the forest. You got to come. I did a good job standing in for you. >> It was hard to tell. You you It seemed
00:20:47
like a perfectly modern uh structure you were living in. >> Well, they had lights. I They were just
00:20:53
in a rented Airbnb near my house. >> But uh but you it was a very um scientific. You talked you and Daryl and
00:21:03
James Austin Johnson all talked about about constructing impressions. It was um really interesting from that
00:21:12
point of view. But you were my co-conspirator with uh with Bush one along with Al cuz I didn't have the
00:21:19
impression. >> Well, I I you were you were way too modest about that in the in that
00:21:26
documentary, but I thought I always thought your Bush was was very bushy. It it you got you got better
00:21:34
>> not better, but you got crazier with it. Yeah. as as time went on because you did
00:21:39
I don't know how many times you did Bush but it was a dozen or more anyway. >> Well more way more than a dozen. Yeah.
00:21:46
Yeah. Over four years. Yeah. Standard cold open. >> If you compared the first two to like
00:21:52
the last two, it was >> it was crazy. >> Well, the perfect thing with that, which
00:21:57
I I may have talked about, it's only interesting in that the audience took the ride with me. So as I started to do
00:22:04
what I would have done in high school, extrapolate things because I'm bored, the audience was right with me. So by
00:22:09
the end when I think I my favorite thing and it might have been your idea, but he
00:22:13
just and or Al the non sequitter of just education. That's it. You know, >> I think that was that was maybe
00:22:22
something that we kicked into it, but it was mostly just >> trying to >> uh feed you stuff that you would do in
00:22:31
the character you were already developing with. >> Yeah. It became a song, you know, it was
00:22:36
like a lot of musicality to all these different components. Bring it in here. Good. Good. That area doing that thing.
00:22:46
Got to do it, you know. So, it was fun. Anyway, look for the duck. Look for >> I did like Dana when during the week it
00:22:53
would be I was working back then I was newer and they'd say like there's no cold opening and the easiest slam dunk
00:23:01
was on Thursday to go right up a bush cold opening. So he probably did it a lot more than 12 because it was always
00:23:08
like such a good go-to that would work only use one cast member but it was easy to put up late in the week. It wasn't a
00:23:15
lot of blocking straight. >> Yeah. You you said Thursday. It seems like more Friday evening,
00:23:21
>> Saturday morning sometimes trying to >> let the audience know that. >> But but I I had so many in ones which I
00:23:28
didn't realize later how valuable that was because the studio's quiet. It's just you in the frame so you can dance
00:23:35
dance outside the lines because they're just locked on you. But now when they do
00:23:38
cold openings a lot of times it's ensemble. I don't you know it's like a a sketch with a political figure in it
00:23:46
observation I don't know yeah how they populate it different >> but that is true when you when you're
00:23:52
doing an in one there there's no such thing as a missed shot >> or or not something not being captured
00:24:00
>> and um it it is but you were one of those people that you could just send out there with often slender you know
00:24:09
material And you would you would make it work. >> I like less words. You know, I used to
00:24:16
say, can you guys take out some of these words? >> Yeah. It's too many words. I don't want
00:24:20
to feel like I'm doing a homework. I just want to be taking time. But the other thing that we worked on and Smile
00:24:25
worked on was Perau, which we didn't talk about last time, but that was just as much fun. I don't think I did it near
00:24:33
as much, but that was just as much fun uh as Bush or easier really, you know. Well, that's that I think is my favorite
00:24:41
political character you ever did and I I worked on one of them with you. I think
00:24:46
it was the time you hosted and it was the one where you were on Larry King and Will Frell was Larry King and
00:24:54
>> it was you were on uh you were it was the minor party candidates and it was the female circumcision party candidate
00:25:01
the >> uh totalitarian uh >> you know >> Chris Katan and they would do the most ornate female whatever you just said and
00:25:12
then and then Perau would always go the same old clap trap. That's what I hear all the time. And it was the weirdest
00:25:18
policy idea you could ever hear. >> That was what I loved about it was a long run from Chris Katan. Very very
00:25:24
katan was a great great sketch player. Absolutely. He had those great grounding chops and he he was doing this thing
00:25:32
about um once we um mandate and fully fund female circumcision, you'll see the economy take off like a and then you can
00:25:44
same old same old, you know, uh candycoated ice cream sundae with a cherry on top. You know, we don't have
00:25:53
the money, Larry. >> We don't have the money. Larry, can I finish one time? You can interrupt me.
00:25:58
Go ahead. >> Will was like you have the complete freedom as you need. >> Anyway,
00:26:06
>> can I finish one time? No, that was so so much fun. Still kills in my stand up.
00:26:13
>> It's the best. I I >> I think I might have voted for Perau in that election just because I I um you
00:26:20
know, he was right about NAFTA, I think. And um it would have been fun to have him as president. He was right about the
00:26:26
debt. You know, remember he had the chalkboard and the pointer. Here's our debt. Here's where it's going. We're
00:26:31
just giving the we're giving the credit card to our kids. >> Precient. >> Jim, uh, David Spade here.
00:26:40
>> Uh, can you tell me if >> you have been asked to write or rewrite some of these movies we've seen out
00:26:48
there, some of these comedies >> or punch up? >> Punch up. um you know from time to time
00:26:56
uh I have been asked to to work on stuff and I um it's not it's not my favorite thing to do. The one thing I think that
00:27:06
uh one reason that I I've been asked as as often as I have is because I I never want my name on anything which which um
00:27:15
>> why? Well, just because I I I don't particularly, you know, if it's if it's someone else's script and I'm just
00:27:22
throwing some things into it, I don't particularly need it. And >> the that's really important. It makes
00:27:29
you very popular with the other writers on the on the project, you know, because
00:27:34
most people >> uh when they do contribute something then they they off often they start sort
00:27:41
of messy fights for credit and then there's a guild. >> So, um but it's been a long time since
00:27:52
I've um >> Did you ever write scratch? >> Sorry. >> Uh well, yes, we did. I wrote I wrote
00:27:58
one with uh Tom Tom Davis and Al Franken many many years ago that that um we had
00:28:06
some funny stuff in it but it never never went anywhere. It's funny I was asked >> I was asked one time Bill Murray asked
00:28:14
me to um to take a look at a script that he was considering doing and um he said
00:28:21
I really think it it could use some some of your help with this. really >> and and it it the script was lost in
00:28:28
translation which won best script screenplay that won the best screenplay Oscar and to my credit I said I I think
00:28:38
this is a great script and I wouldn't change anything certainly I can't think of anything that I would do to change it
00:28:45
>> and so I recommended he do it and that uh it was good as it was >> it's great I'm sure Bill does go to
00:28:52
advice from a lot of people in the scene. So, it's a >> Well, Bill loves you. I've been in the
00:28:57
room with you and Bill. Bill like when you start to mention an idea, Bill gets quiet
00:29:02
>> in in a good way. He's like, "What what what what were we saying?" >> Well, you guys were, if people don't
00:29:07
know, we were either roommates or office mates at SNL or just friends, right, during the early years?
00:29:14
>> Well, we were first office mates before we became friends, but um we we yeah, we
00:29:20
were both hired um at the same time. And so we um they put us in the same office.
00:29:26
And uh over time we um we became very close and I still I talked to him just the other day.
00:29:34
>> So >> he's he's fun to talk to. >> One of the most beloved dudes out there. Not you, Bill.
00:29:39
>> Did you was it your idea? It's just kind of interesting that because people would
00:29:43
remember this at a certain age >> to for the lounge singer to sing the theme to Jaws or was it
00:29:50
>> Well, that actually the one of my earliest memories is Billy singing a fragment of that in the office
00:29:58
>> and I remembered he came in he came in he had seen Jaws at a theater in Time Square and he told me that his favorite
00:30:06
thing about it was there were there were guys in the audience during the the scary scenes going, "Get him, Jaws. Get
00:30:13
him." And so that was where >> that's funny. >> He started calling the shark Jaws. And
00:30:20
and so >> I remembered he would sing a a bit of that >> uh around the office and I and I thought
00:30:30
>> we've got to do something with that someday. And we talked about it over the years that So it goes all the way back
00:30:36
to 1976. And then when we did the 40th in 2014 or whatever it was. Yeah. >> 2015. It must have been 2015.
00:30:49
>> Anyway, um I I really I I um I added more parts to it and then uh we got together with Paul Schaefer and it
00:30:59
became a thing, a very successful thing some say in the 40th anniversary show. >> Well, no. I I was doing I was part of
00:31:08
the cutting around to music. I was doing Chant Broccoli in the piano. So I was up
00:31:12
on the stage and so I looked right on top of Bill and watching him electrify that audience with his incredible
00:31:21
commitment >> and so so you guys had to So this is for people at home. You think of an idea
00:31:29
like that and it's kind of wispy but there's something there and you're like this is how you either make it good or
00:31:35
ruin it. you say, "How do we package this into a sketch?" Like, so I think one of the first I remember he's at a
00:31:41
ski resort in a lounge and maybe the rain's there and he's going from table to table and he's maybe singing Star
00:31:48
Wars. I Yeah, I didn't work on that piece, but but that was Billy. Um he just he it
00:31:56
started with him just having uh that that kind of Vegas character that you don't see. There are no acts like that
00:32:04
anymore probably in Vegas and they haven't been for a long time. >> Lizard, >> he he was always one of the first things
00:32:11
he did around the office was that kind of cringy um uh greasy, you know, minor showbiz character. And I I'm trying to
00:32:21
remember the very first one. I think the Star Wars one at the ski lodge was the second. That was the one where people
00:32:28
really started paying attention. And then there was there was one they got we we would look for ever more uh eccentric
00:32:38
locations and there was one my favorite one was on the auto train the the Amtrak
00:32:44
train where you could drive your car onto one of the >> one of the the service cars and then
00:32:52
>> ride your train you'd ride the train down to Florida with your car >> on on the train. Right. And then off.
00:33:01
Yeah. And so I remember Billy had this great speech and there were he's doing one of his, you know, I was I was
00:33:08
thinking watching him load the the cars like and like you may drive a Dodge Comet. I may drive a a Nissan Ultima and
00:33:19
Joe over there might drive a a coupe Deville. Yet every car on the auto train is treated like every other car. And
00:33:30
then he gets kind of a and everyone starts and then he sings >> don't go changing to try to please me,
00:33:36
you know. But it was u it was early it was like early I guess what they would call cringe comedy today, right?
00:33:44
>> Maybe. Yeah. >> Yes. I mean it's not Yeah. Yeah. >> Well, I I have two questions for it. One
00:33:49
is how do you recall something like like that right now? The second one is watching all that original cast go
00:33:58
through that four or five year period. It seemed like Bill Murray I would never imagine him not being at a 10 in terms
00:34:05
of confidence but did some cast members were they all sort of fully formed or who were the ones that sort of involved
00:34:11
because just in terms of confidence because the way Bill Murray does comedy you have to be utterly committed to it.
00:34:18
You can't have any kind of fear of not getting >> too seems very like oh >> so those are two questions. Why do you
00:34:26
have a photographic memory of 50 years ago? >> I don't I don't know. I I um I but I
00:34:33
people have commented like um as though I must be forgetting more important things because I'm making
00:34:41
>> your whole life >> forgetting weddings and you >> Yeah. Um I I remember things that make
00:34:49
an impact on me and it's and it's easy to if something really makes you laugh it's it's a little easier to remember
00:34:56
that than but I would say as to your question about >> confidence all of these people had like
00:35:03
Lraine had come out of the Groundlings and and Danny Belushi Billy uh Second City. So,
00:35:11
um, they, uh, Jane had done improv stuff in up in Boston, so they were used to live audiences. And I think Dana and you
00:35:20
guys both having been touring standups, that that's the tough um, school, right,
00:35:27
is >> Oh, yeah. I had to really try to I I would look at the audience if I got a
00:35:32
laugh in a sketch. My impulse was to look at the crowd laughing, so I had to kind of go, "Oh, no. I'm in a sketch."
00:35:38
First catch I ever did that forget theater or anything on anywhere was the meteor hitting hitting Jan on the head.
00:35:47
I think it was Jack Handy. That was the cold opening. >> So I was going to ask you this question
00:35:52
for our audience. What was your first impression first? Even before we did anything, David Spade and me first
00:35:59
impressions. Don't think >> I thought you were >> losers. No, that's not losers. Exactly. I
00:36:08
thought I thought you were well-meaning. >> Uh I thought I saw you you guys auditioned. So
00:36:16
>> I I thought you were funny. So before we ever met, I had already seen you and
00:36:23
>> uh for all you know, seen hundreds of hours of tape. >> We didn't just, you know, do this stuff
00:36:29
willy-nilly. We we actually took it seriously. So, no, you guys. >> Yeah. And um
00:36:36
>> I Yeah, you guys came. You didn't need to um impress anyone. >> Okay, David, your first impression of
00:36:44
Jim Downey. >> Oh, Jesus. >> Mine was How can you get Dana out of here quicker? >> Um
00:36:53
David's on deck. Um if you should fall. >> The funny thing is he's there. D is the
00:37:00
first of all me not being aware of like you're here to like light a fire under D. I go I don't think Dana is scared of
00:37:05
me. I go I don't do these impressions. He runs this whole operation. I'm just sitting here going let me do a [ __ ]
00:37:14
update. Let me do something. Let me just get out there. And uh but everyone's just so good. It was just hard. I I
00:37:20
think I joined in a pocket when there was so many good writers and so many good performers and uh it was a little
00:37:28
harder to swim to the top. So just treading water there was good enough for me for a while, but I'm just glad I got
00:37:35
through it. And Jim was my boss for people that don't know headwriter >> came up with the idea of Thursday
00:37:41
rewrites. I didn't know that till today. Um and which were [ __ ] grueling, worse than the Green Beretss. I'm not
00:37:49
even joking. Worse, harder than the Marines. And um basically I I like Jim because he's very pleasant
00:37:57
guy, fun to hang out with, fun to walk down to dinner with. And he had a really hard job of feeding all the little birds
00:38:04
in the nest. He goes then he gives you something and then you go and then you >> Well, the great thing about Jim
00:38:11
>> I lovet often pasticated things. Jim would do this if there people around were kind of riffing on
00:38:18
ideas and then Jim would just look up not say anything and just the usually the entree was uh there's something
00:38:26
really funny about >> Yeah. >> And then and then this brilliant idea would follow it. It would be this weird
00:38:33
off-kilter. One time Jim told me, Dana, he goes, >> I think he maybe told the table, he
00:38:38
goes, or maybe just me and Schneider when we got started. He goes, >> there's sometimes you're gonna pitch an
00:38:43
idea and I'm just going to say I don't think that'll work. And I can't sometimes explain why. It's just from
00:38:51
experience. I just don't see that working. And so that was good to know because sometimes he just said, I
00:38:57
wouldn't write that up. I'd probably write up the other one. you know, because you're kind of also wanting that
00:39:01
advice before you write and everyone wants a piece of them and he'd maybe go work, not hide, but work in your office
00:39:08
and lock it. And then Schneider would sleep against the door and we'd all go in there and try to go when he comes
00:39:13
out, we got to It was just constantly on top of you. >> It's hard being headwriter of that show.
00:39:18
It's >> it it was hard to um >> I mean the part that I I you know you have to decide how much you're going to
00:39:28
uh lie to people >> to and sort of string them along and and give them false hope and and how much
00:39:37
and and but I remember the the old expression my father always used to tell me um you should always tell the truth
00:39:43
because it's the easiest thing to remember. >> Yeah. you know, and so I I very early
00:39:48
on, I think I did, I I I decided, you know what? I'm just gonna explain to people if they come in and look at the
00:39:56
board after read through >> and and on we'd have a re for you know the audience of the podcast we would
00:40:03
have our read through Wednesday and then Wednesday evening uh Lauren would would
00:40:09
slip out of the room and go to dinner and then I'd be there when when the cast and writers streamed in and looked up at
00:40:17
the board to see which >> pieces represented by little 3x5 cards, >> yeah, >> were part of the show, at least
00:40:24
>> for now, and and which weren't. And there were there were always >> outraged people like demanding to know
00:40:31
why A was in the show and and there B wasn't. And um you know I tried to um I tried to be as honest as I could but in
00:40:42
a in an encouraging way you know and and I I tried to um sometimes I actually was
00:40:51
uh the only voice in the room for a particular piece that ended up not making it.
00:40:57
>> And so I I I I tried to avoid like you know uh uh doing the chicken [ __ ] thing.
00:41:04
And so I was for it. I was >> used to tell Frank and hated it when I asked him about mine.
00:41:11
>> We all liked it. Franken hated it. I go, >> but by the way, David, you were talking
00:41:14
about the idea of of when you when you come on to the show, like looking for um a way to emerge. Yeah. You know, more
00:41:24
clearly. But the way the way we cast the show, and I'm not saying it was the necessarily the ideal way, but we're
00:41:32
like those people who like, you know, go to an antique store or something and they even though they already have a a
00:41:40
dining room table, they so fall in love with this other dining room table that they go like, I'm just going to buy it
00:41:47
and we'll figure out what to do with it later. So, if you've been in people's homes where they have like three or four
00:41:53
of everything, it's it's sort of um it wasn't well thought out. So, we just if if we saw people who were really funny,
00:42:00
if they're if someone else >> to our attention, we just we just want them here. >> Grab them, give them give them their
00:42:10
$600 a week and bring them in. >> It's only going to cost us 600 bucks a week running around.
00:42:15
>> But that was the first junior varsity era. I mean, we added Mike Myers, which
00:42:20
was incredible for us. And then we started adding more and more, and I actually did a song about it when I
00:42:25
hosted that >> 90 to 93 was very post >> because we had Sandler and Farley coming
00:42:31
up. Spay was coming up, uh, Schneider, Tim Meadows, uh, on and on. And you, we still had Phil and myself and Mike and
00:42:39
so forth. I was going to ask you this question because it's always these just fun of best cast or best cast member
00:42:47
>> but behind the scenes and I don't know if you want to answer this question when
00:42:51
was the most potent writing staff because I only know my era like was because you were there in the knots or
00:42:58
the Will Ferrell era and Amy Sure Polar all that. So do you have an answer to that or was it the original writing
00:43:04
staff or were they all just very comparable? >> Well I 5 seconds. >> Okay. I would say
00:43:13
>> and then we'll tell you the right answer. >> The the writing staff that had um you
00:43:20
know Robert Smeiggel, Jack Handy, uh Al Frank and Tom Davis um uh that that era was a pretty good writing
00:43:30
staff. >> Was that Odirk? Yeah, Con was around. I guess I guess from you know 86 to like
00:43:39
the early 90s and and it wasn't a gigantically large writing staff. I mean it was the the early writing staff
00:43:48
though was like nine people >> uh of whom like six or seven were were fairly active, you know, and nowadays I
00:43:56
mean I think they have like more than 20 writers >> and they Yeah. Sorry. Go ahead. But but
00:44:02
but I the um but there were great writers you know at every period. The other thing is a lot of the best writers
00:44:11
were performers. >> So that >> what do you mean? I mean people ask me occasionally hey who wrote that thing
00:44:18
you know that because you don't it's it I I've accepted it a long time ago but you don't get a writer's credit if
00:44:24
you're on SNL as a main cast member. If you're a feature player you get a writer's credit. So, I remember Mike
00:44:30
came on the show like in April as a feature player, writer. He soon went up to the main company, but then we won the
00:44:37
Emmy. So, on the plane ride back to New York, Mike had this giant Emmy. He'd only been there like three weeks. Yeah.
00:44:43
>> As a writer. >> That happened. >> I mean, there were we figured the longer the longer you stay at the show, it
00:44:50
comes out in the wash, you know. But it's true. There were some um um >> well it's just
00:44:57
>> there were some strange things but but yeah the the idea was I suppose that performers
00:45:04
are are going to get >> writing writing for themselves helps they help it's good for them right
00:45:12
that's its own reward >> and um if they're not paid um >> they have to they would have had to pay
00:45:19
us right because I would have taken a credit without pay but that would have been outside the
00:45:23
you know, that's writers. >> What I told Lauren just from my perception and it's not just about me,
00:45:29
but from 90 to 93 that he had a lot of weapons. Like there's not I've heard they don't do as many reoccurring
00:45:37
characters now except on update or whatever. But back then you could have a tunes or a sprockets or a Hans and
00:45:45
France or a Hollywood minute or Sandler would do sing a song, you know, his opera man. And there were so many to
00:45:53
start the show with that it just seemed like a very And then I said that to Lauren on this podcast and then I heard
00:45:59
him talking about it to the New York Times. >> The early 90s we had a lot of weapons.
00:46:06
Yeah, we had a we had a lot of um variety within we had a lot of variety within the the comedy of the show so
00:46:15
that uh distinct flavors, you know, and so a lot of people could pick, you know,
00:46:20
a dozen people would pick maybe eight different things as the best thing in the show, you know.
00:46:26
>> Yes. And we should mention, well, I want you to continue, but Bonnie and Terry
00:46:29
Turner as well because they were they could punch they could punch things up. They were really great with the church
00:46:34
slate and other things. So, go ahead. What were you >> say? I'm just saying that that that era
00:46:39
I was just identifying with with um and I know I I'm whenever I'm as asked questions like that I I I like worry
00:46:47
about is people I inadvertently leave out. >> Yeah. Accidentally we're leaving out
00:46:53
people for sure. But there have been every era of the show and and by the way I I think there were like
00:47:00
um there were like three or four distinct periods of the show where I I thought that we were doing a lot of really great
00:47:09
shows like the early years. >> Yeah. >> And the next great peri Well, the next great period was that one year with
00:47:14
Marty Short and Chris Guest. >> Yeah. >> And then and Harry Sheer did great stuff
00:47:19
that year. And um >> and then um your era which I I would make like 86 to like 93.
00:47:28
>> That was the time I was in. >> Then there was the second the Will Pharaoh era
00:47:35
>> and >> well David was overlapped with that a little bit. >> I was in there. Yeah. I was I over
00:47:40
overlapped one year with Will >> but Will Pharaoh was Yeah. >> But he was another force coming on.
00:47:45
>> Yeah. >> Right. And then and then that that that cast that sort of that Kristen Wig,
00:47:52
>> Fred Armson, Will Forte. Yeah. The Lonely Island guys. Yeah. And that So there have been there have been enough
00:48:00
of those >> uh there enough great eras. It's it's like, >> you know, it's like the Yankees or
00:48:07
something. >> Oh yeah. Lineups >> to talk about for fun. Take time to think you're good. No one really told us
00:48:15
any of us were any good until 10 years later and then Will Ferrell said they said we sucked and then 10 years later
00:48:20
they said oh they were great. So it takes a while to look back like right now you'll look back later and go oh
00:48:26
these people were really you know that's just how it works. >> Yeah. I I gave up a long time ago trying
00:48:31
to answer the question like if you had to pick like an all-star team because >> I know
00:48:36
>> it ends up being it ends up being like 25 people, you know. >> Yeah. One of the things I I really liked about
00:48:43
the 50th, I know Dana and I I'm sorry that that you know that you weren't there.
00:48:48
>> You didn't care about but there was you got so many people on camera in combinations that you'd never seen
00:48:56
before and that was that was really nice to see. Um >> you know I wanted to introduce something
00:49:04
with Eddie Murphy. I thought that'd be a perfect time for us to get together and
00:49:08
sort of address our little fake >> that spat has lasted so long, but I think is it finally done? People don't
00:49:15
know David made fun of Eddie on on weekend. Probably because of Jim. >> Probably Jim.
00:49:23
>> Yeah, >> I Eddie, if you're watching this, I bet against that. Absolutely. >> But um you know, I worked with Eddie in
00:49:31
that in a film that Andy Breckman uh it was his thing. He directed it. >> Not moving. What was it?
00:49:37
>> It was the White Like Me thing. >> Oh. Oh, yeah. Yeah. That was >> You did work on that. That was during
00:49:45
the first time >> I was ever recognized on the street in New York was just from that brief uh you
00:49:55
know exposure with the great Eddie Murphy. >> No one movie. >> It was It was a film piece and it was
00:50:01
where Eddie was in Whiteface. >> Oh yeah. Okay. And >> yeah, yeah, I remember it. Yeah,
00:50:05
>> I remember that's >> killer vision >> that Andy Andy Bregman directed. >> Oh, sorry. Andy,
00:50:12
>> the thing about uh the thing about Eddie, which now that we have 50 plus years, you know, it's kind of like um
00:50:20
how did someone get that evolved and confident? I guess at 19 he gets on the show, but he put in his dues. He started
00:50:32
at 17 and his dad would drive the car. >> But seriously, >> being I I got on at 31. I was still
00:50:40
waitering till I was 24. I mean, just Eddie is amazing how great he was. It's not a hot take. It's just interesting in
00:50:48
the context. I I to be honest with you, I remember um I had recommended when when the original writers and cast left
00:50:56
the show in May of 1980 u and Gene Demanian took over as producer. I always got along pretty well with Jean. her
00:51:03
office was directly next door to Billy and and and my office. And um so she um asked me if I had any uh advice and I
00:51:15
recommended a couple of writers um one of whom became a very valuable writer uh for the next couple years. But anyway,
00:51:23
um when I would go to visit uh these people, you know, I was I I was at Letterman at the time or I was doing
00:51:31
something else, but I would I would come by and just to to, you know, stick my head in, say hi. I was constantly
00:51:38
encountering Eddie Murphy. >> This was who was a featured player and he was just going into everyone's office
00:51:45
and being hilarious. And I remember going to Jean and saying, you know, Jean, there's the that Eddie Murphy guy.
00:51:53
I mean, I don't think I'm this mad genius who's spotting something no one else can see. I think I think you really
00:52:00
you got I think you might want to put that guy on camera. >> And her attitude, I remembered as being
00:52:06
like, uh, I think he needs a little seasoning. Um, he's got there's something there. There's something there
00:52:12
for sure, but I just think he's not ready to go up against >> I heard about him as a standup in the
00:52:18
comic strip because I was living in New York doing the Mickey Rooney show with Nathan Lane and then a friend of mine
00:52:24
was on Broadway with Mickey. He was a juggler, Michael Davies >> and he just were walking around New York
00:52:29
and he goes, "There's this comedian, young comedian at Comic Street. You should really check him out." But this
00:52:34
is why I want I just popped into my brain. There are certain things that are I just stick with me as being really
00:52:42
funny and that was just James Brown in a hot tub. I don't know why >> but that still would get me every time.
00:52:51
Do you know the bit David? >> Well, >> you can say it and it sounds funny. This a scenario
00:52:57
>> and the f the way he could do James Brown how he could hit the scream after the thing. So, it's one of those Why is
00:53:04
James Brown near a hot tub? Why does he keep sticking his foot in the hot water?
00:53:08
Why is he screaming? You know, I feel you get to five questions, it has the absurdity to last. Maybe it's a little
00:53:14
bit like chopping broccoli, like why does this exist? But that was transcendent as just a full sketch.
00:53:22
>> You guys are writer performers, but I think you'll agree with me that the show
00:53:29
really is is uh a performer show. I mean, it has more scope for writing than most shows like this do, but
00:53:37
>> um it's like they always say that in in baseball, you know, good pitching beats
00:53:42
good hitting. It's like performing trumps the writing, right? >> And that a piece like that that has a
00:53:48
great premise. I mean, I'm assuming it was Eddie, but it could easily have been >> guys who wrote with him who said like,
00:53:54
"How about James Brown in a hot tub?" I mean, but it doesn't matter. It was just
00:54:00
for the however long that piece was. It was like flat out. >> Yeah. >> Just high energy laughs. I mean, I've
00:54:07
never written anything that can compete with a piece like that for energy and laugh, you know.
00:54:13
>> Um >> I mean, you know, obviously Bob Odkirks, but Full Peak Chris Farley uh doing or something. There are those
00:54:25
kinds of things that are just uh okay that's a kind of a oneoff you know >> but also Eddie went right into movies
00:54:31
and the confidence and immediately good >> like immediate so that that was he was
00:54:37
good SNL good over there like was pretty crazy >> like I say he had he was plenty
00:54:42
confident backstage and and I'm talking about >> 198081 it's just that um he um it wasn't
00:54:51
appreciated and then when Dick Eversaw came the next season. He very quickly broke through.
00:54:57
>> Oh, so he didn't blow up the first year. I didn't >> Well, he wasn't. He didn't get a lot of
00:55:02
camera time. Um, >> his only year struggling. I love that he got a little taste of all the [ __ ] that
00:55:07
we all crazy about. >> J also Daryl Hammond calls him the world's greatest impressionist. Not that
00:55:14
he does a lot of impressions, but the ones that he did were, you know, he did his Stevie Wonder. I don't was the first
00:55:21
one to do that, you know, and he could sing like Stevie Wonder. It was like he had every metric going, you know,
00:55:27
>> like Jamie Fox also has some really good ones, too. Secretly, it's like a secret
00:55:31
weapon. >> Yeah. But I still like Hans and FRS. That's still kind of my favorite thing
00:55:38
only because um they're so insecure. They have this cable show and they're imagining people
00:55:45
denying them and then they're threatening to go to their house and do these really evil, perverse physical
00:55:52
things to them. >> I actually I actually have a very clear memory of you coming to me and pitching
00:56:00
that idea and you explaining that. But they're just incredibly abusive without actually helping their clients. So it's
00:56:09
just like humiliating They have the they have the breakdown part really well but not the buildup
00:56:17
part. >> Yeah. >> Well, because then they bring it to themselves. And if you don't think we're
00:56:21
properly pumped, let me tell you something. >> We could very easily come to your house
00:56:26
easy >> and stretch the flap of your back into the shape of a rope ladder so you could
00:56:30
crawl down in the sewer because that's where losers live. You know, it's supposed to be a Jack Lane show helping
00:56:36
people and they always turned it. >> By the way, they don't have one client. They've never showed them working
00:56:42
someone out. It's just always yelling at the camera. >> And I love that Kevin Nean when we would
00:56:48
be right before right before the camera came on, Kevin would just lower his IQ. I'd seen Will Ferrell have that trick.
00:56:54
Kevin would just make his eyes go stupid and it really made me laugh, you know, just Yeah. You know, so so Kevin and I
00:57:03
are playing a gig together and we'll come out as Hans and France. We're playing it in Seattle.
00:57:07
>> Yeah. >> So I'm already thinking Yeah. uh the Puget Sound should be called Puny Sound
00:57:14
because the jokes are so bad and they're so pleased. So anyway, I still like that
00:57:18
and you worked a lot on that. You was so so glad to have you and Smiggle come in
00:57:24
>> at a given time with Kevin and >> that was that was just you know so easy to to you know to just we were like
00:57:32
bouncing stuff off in the room. I mean, you guys had you knew what you were doing and it was another thing where it
00:57:38
was a a single shot so you could just go to town and um >> but I remember the very first time that
00:57:46
was on it was the last piece in the show. five to one. >> And um you know, it just shows if if you
00:57:56
lead the audience, you know, you bring them along, they they might not recognize at first how much they really
00:58:03
enjoy it, but if you >> Well, that's really true statement. I mean, you know, Dana, let's say
00:58:09
>> Jim was there for Cheburger, Cheburger, Cheer. I look back at Cone Head. Some
00:58:13
some of the early ones don't work at all and the audience just has to sort of absorb what's going on. And the next
00:58:19
time they do it like recurring then everyone's on to it now. >> Yes. Because I think they thought we
00:58:25
would pick up fake barbells. >> Yeah. They're figuring it out. >> You know, we're ons and frs and I think,
00:58:30
you know, we had padded things. I think that that's what they thought. >> That was never going to happen. But in
00:58:36
that case too, my character evolved because when I would look in the mirror and I was so much smaller than Kevin, it
00:58:42
just became sorry. Whoops. you know, just what do our muscles frighten you? >> Your stupid buzz cuts.
00:58:51
>> So, that made me happy, you know, because I I get bored very easily. But that was So, anyway, that was fun to
00:58:58
work on. Anything else for Jim who uh was the first five years of SNL for people don't know? First five years of
00:59:06
Letterman maybe. >> First like two. >> Yeah. >> You have Letterman and then you went
00:59:11
back. huge huge influence on the Letterman sensibility because you were right there in the beginning. He was
00:59:17
lucky to have you. I mean, >> do you see him out there anymore? You talk to him a lot or no? Well, actually,
00:59:21
yeah, we just did um I I hadn't seen very much of Dave over the years, uh except running into him now and then,
00:59:28
but um the um we did um I did his podcast, the Barbara Gaines Show, >> which is always Barbara Gaines introduces Dave
00:59:43
and his guest, and I did that back in December, and they made it a two-parter, I think. And then
00:59:51
>> um Robert um approached him about doing um >> doing Robert Smeiggel's new podcast,
00:59:58
Humor Me. >> Yeah. >> And and um and Dave said, "Let's why don't I do it with Jim again?" So we did
01:00:06
we did that thing. >> Oh, you did that? Okay. >> Yeah. I've seen a lot D a lot more Dave
01:00:09
than I have um uh in the you know, since I left the show in 1984. Um but um yeah, he was um that was a
01:00:20
real case we were talking about bringing an audience along and and sort of training them to it's like it's like the
01:00:27
first time you had sushi if you can remember that >> you know um uh it it was a little
01:00:35
>> a little you not you weren't sure about it and then um >> you know it became your favorite food.
01:00:42
Jim, I have a last story about sushi that you remind me of. So, when we were at uh I lived on the upper west side
01:00:48
when you were there and Farley, we'd never had sushi and so we someone recommended we go to this place on the
01:00:56
upper west side and so he's like, I love, you know, he's just there were probably four of us there. And then they
01:01:03
they brought us out like a dessert with sparklers and they come on, oh my go. and they call it and when he gets close
01:01:10
to Chris he GOES OH MY EYES AND THEN HE DIVES on the ground that the sparks got in his eyes and then he rolls on the
01:01:16
ground screaming and the whole place stands up and goes oh and they're like oh no they don't know what to do and
01:01:22
then he goes I'm fooling I'm fine and they're like what's going on is they still trying to get help for him and
01:01:28
he's like it was a bit they don't know you had to be very careful with Farley as to what you dared him to do because
01:01:40
it was a weighty responsibility cuz do I really want to say you don't have the nerve to pick that waitress up and carry
01:01:47
her down the stairs or something, >> put her in the fountain or poo out the window on the 17th floor.
01:01:53
>> I I was on record as opposed to that. >> What about the broomstick? >> The liability. Oh, wow. Okay.
01:02:01
>> At the rewrite table. >> That's That's for the after hours. Yeah, that's for the post.
01:02:07
>> I think that story's been told. >> I do. I do remember I do remember the time and I'm sure you guys were there in
01:02:13
the room. We were doing rewrites and um uh I think it was Tara Eli, who was the writer's assistant,
01:02:21
>> uh comes up to me. I'm at the head of the table and and whispers to me, uh just so you know, uh Chris Chris Farley
01:02:29
is out in the hallway and he's completely naked. And so, and so we had those big heavy metal doors with that,
01:02:37
you know, they're pinned in the middle, you know, and so I I told everyone, "Okay, Farley's going to come in, you
01:02:42
guys. >> And he's going to come in naked. So, it's vitally important that no one give
01:02:47
him anything. >> No one reacts. >> We just have to sort of go, oh yeah, hey, Chris, what's up? Back to our
01:02:53
work." And so Farley comes in and he had his private >> tucked between his legs and he's
01:03:00
fondling his tweaking his nipples and going like, "Do you think I'm pretty?" That kind of thing. And then we're we
01:03:08
all did the same kind of, "Oh, hey Chris. Hey, we got to talk about that update thing later." And he was so
01:03:17
serious >> that it bombed. Too bad iPhones weren't around back then because you can't it's
01:03:23
all just in. >> Was there some fake subpoena given to him at the last >> Yeah, that was that was a a um that
01:03:31
started with it was partly just a practical joke but >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. >> But but we also liked
01:03:38
>> we had been on a film shoot. It was a piece I wrote. Um it was it was do you remember the show Tales of the Highway
01:03:46
Patrol? >> Oh, Highway Patrol. It was a real It was an early reality show actually. It was
01:03:50
like cops and it was like some other network's answer to cops. And anyway, it was we we did this thing and it was like
01:03:58
1993 or something. It was tales of the Arkansas Highway Patrol. And so it was basically Bill Clinton um you know just
01:04:08
having engaging in illicit sex with various women in parked cars with guarded by Arkansas state troopers. And
01:04:17
then it ended with a scene where it's a domestic abuse case and and he's clearly
01:04:22
had the [ __ ] beat out of him by Hillary and so it's the she he's refusing to press charges and he's claiming he fell
01:04:29
down the stairs, you know, that kind of thing. Anyway, so we had to drive to the
01:04:34
shoot and and Farley was deep in character, you know, it's like, um, little lady, uh, I got a problem. See,
01:04:42
it seems they gave me an expense account. Unless I spend it all, they're liable to cut me back.
01:04:47
>> So, he was he was hitting on this this um this woman who was an extra >> and Schneider and I were in the car and
01:04:56
we finally had to like physically jump between the two of them to prevent to head off something. And so it began with
01:05:06
that, but we decided to um play a practical joke on him where we had him served with a fake subpoena and had some
01:05:13
of the writers from the Simpsons act as as process servers. And it was at the last show party and and later I was told
01:05:22
it was a cruel thing to do and and and like come on, you the poor actress who was in that car, that wasn't a, you
01:05:29
know, picnic for her. Anyway, yeah, that's a true story. He fell for that one. He flipped out.
01:05:35
>> What a character. >> Oh yeah. Anytime. You don't even know what it's for. You just think
01:05:42
>> David, you always you always did a great impression of Farley going from like
01:05:47
innocent to like barking orders to his management and everything >> in it turning. Well, it would be like uh
01:05:55
I don't know. I'm just I'm I I'm I'm not I don't I'm not really a reader. Like, listen, listen. I'm not doing it. I'm
01:06:02
not doing it for that money. That kind of thing. Yeah. >> Yeah. Tell them [ __ ] six million or
01:06:06
I'm out. >> I'll [ __ ] walk anyway. I'm from Wisconsin. Do you have a McDonald's
01:06:13
here? Is it on wheels? Because we have one. You still doing that? Yeah. I don't know. Yeah. He was uh he I like when he
01:06:22
greased his hair back like Christian Slater and wore the big glasses like Acroyd.
01:06:28
>> Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But he um uh God, he he was funny. >> God damn. >> I thought he looked cool with the hair
01:06:36
greased back. I remember me and him and Christian Slater went down to Huxley's and he's like this. Hi, Christian. You
01:06:44
grease your hair back. And he's like, "Yeah, Chris, I do." And he's like, "Yeah,
01:06:48
it was all the Chris Far when me and Dana met Ringoar and McCartney and we were It's always turns into the Chris
01:06:54
Farley show. It's the funniest thing to to to describe perfectly what you're doing. You're too giddy. You're excited.
01:07:02
Asking dumb things and just being like, "Oh, you were in the Beatles." Yeah. Yeah. That was awesome.
01:07:07
>> Don't want to make them angry is the main thing. Or or bore them, you know. Yeah.
01:07:11
>> If you're talking to a Beatle, you know, or something they've really heard. >> That was It's a skill set.
01:07:18
>> It's a dicey proposition to talk to. >> Yeah. >> Super famous. Uh Jim, uh >> Jim, anything else you want to
01:07:25
>> million things you've got going? Oneote on DVD. >> Um >> Downey wrote that which Dane and I are
01:07:32
in and we >> You're both in and thank you very much for that. I'm sorry I I wasn't looking
01:07:37
my best at the time. I was co did um a number on some of us and and I got >> I remember that. I just remember someone
01:07:46
I was in the room to get ready to come out to the patio to do the three-hour interview and I go, "Really? Three
01:07:52
hours? It's okay. We'll be hanging out." >> And a woman came up behind me with just
01:07:56
goop in her hands and just went like this. >> Oh, to your hair. >> Yeah. Without asking.
01:08:02
>> Never. >> Hey, we got something for you. >> I would have been like crack. >> Yeah. You're looking healthy. You're
01:08:11
looking good. I mean, when you turn 65 next year, that's going to be >> big milestone.
01:08:18
>> We're kind of the same age. I don't want to bring up numbers, though. >> Well, I'm older. I'm older than than
01:08:25
anybody now. >> Anybody >> in comedy? No. >> Um, >> that's active and still at the top.
01:08:32
You're at the top of your game, >> Jim. I shop at Tavern on the >> I think you are.
01:08:39
I would say I'm um I'm I'm embarking on a new career like we talked about at the
01:08:45
beginning, the um the uh >> actor performer with with limited camera presence, >> but um I can deliver I can deliver a a
01:08:57
low energy dead pan performance like nobody. >> Me too. I'll see at the auditions. You
01:09:02
accidentally every time I see something that you're in, I go, "Fuck, he stole it."
01:09:08
>> Yeah. >> He stole the whole thing. Have you >> What I am What I am is I'm I'm kind of a
01:09:13
good luck charm. I mean, if you think about it, Daniel D. Lewis, >> best actor. >> Yep.
01:09:20
>> Sean Penn supporting actor. >> Y >> What's the common denominator? Have you told PTA that maybe there's a
01:09:28
spin-off and you're not pushing it, but maybe your guy could spin off and like do a sitcom or something?
01:09:34
>> He's been made aware that I'm available. >> He's been made aware. >> You're there. You're ready to write it
01:09:40
if you >> Was this your idea? Because it didn't sound like you, but it's been floated a
01:09:44
sequel and it's going to be called one battle after another after another and I thought
01:09:49
>> 100 episodes. >> Maybe make it a streaming show. I'm not sure. battles seemed like it had your
01:09:54
fingerprints on it, but I can't really tell. One battle after another. >> It sounds like it would be a funny
01:10:00
something to do maybe on the show as a film piece. And no, it didn't come from me.
01:10:04
>> I made that up. Of course, >> I think it's in the ether like people. It's ready. People are ready.
01:10:10
>> Will there be a 60th? Last question. Will there be a 60th and will you be at it?
01:10:16
>> Eight and a half years. >> Will Dana be at it? I'm >> I'd like to think that I will definitely
01:10:21
be invited. Um, and as all of you guys will, >> uh, no post ones. >> Yeah, maybe not at that point. By the
01:10:29
way, do you realize I I asked about this cuz you know the capacity the seating capacity of Studio 8H is like if you
01:10:37
knock out every possible, you know, thing, it's it's like 300 nod seats. >> Yeah. And there are
01:10:47
at the time in February of 2025 750 people had hosted the show. >> Oh boy. >> So you kind of have to if someone hosted
01:10:57
the show you kind of have to invite them maybe hoping that they don't come >> but and then you can't exactly tell them
01:11:03
they can't bring a guest >> and then that's not involving music. And so that was a real
01:11:11
>> uh I did all of us got to be inside the studio. Well, Dana, you could have been
01:11:15
you you were not feeling well. I know. >> Well, what what did I miss? I mean, was
01:11:20
it How did it compare to the >> It was on TV. >> It was uh >> I watched it live.
01:11:26
>> I thought both of them were were actually pretty good shows. >> There's some fun stuff in them. All
01:11:30
Yeah. And you know, I gotta say, you know, really, there were little things like David, you had your that thing in
01:11:36
in the piece where you completely changed changed the energy of the piece for a minute and you just sort of said,
01:11:43
"Nope, I'm doing this then go you can guys can go back and do it." It was [ __ ] the sketch. Yeah.
01:11:49
>> And the other thing that really, this is a crazy thing because you mentioned him,
01:11:53
Nathan Lane, remember it was that piece that I think John Melany was the head writer on. It was
01:11:59
>> it was like the history of New York in in like eight minutes or something and
01:12:03
it was just Nathan Lane dancing through did the funniest impression of a guy doing blow
01:12:10
>> that really cracked me up. >> That was right next to us in that scene. >> I'll bring that up. We're gonna have
01:12:14
Nathan on here. I don't know the timeline of these releases, but yeah, we we will be talking. Uh it's always nice
01:12:21
talking headwriter >> going through that, you know, am I an actor? Am I a writer? And then Paul
01:12:29
Thomas Anderson calls. Jim, are you going to host? >> Um, I I'm taking myself out of
01:12:38
consideration for hosting. >> Okay. >> I, uh, I understand. >> I just, uh, I've just too much on my
01:12:43
plate right now. >> Plate is full. >> But, uh, I will say, um, I did want to mention, um, uh, Downey wrote that.
01:12:53
>> Downey wrote that. >> It's time. They're they're voting on Emmy nominations >> on Peacock.
01:12:58
>> I've been asked I've been asked to mention that. I want to mention um Eddie Michaels uh was great with on that
01:13:07
producer >> and everyone else who worked on it. >> Yes. >> And um >> well this is how I would do it as Hans
01:13:17
>> F. I smell an Oscar. No, I smell it. Emmy nomination. >> Here it come. >> Whoops. So long. Other docks. Fly away.
01:13:31
You no longer want it. We already have our winner. Jim's face. Jim is going, "What?"
01:13:39
>> I think I think you I think that's you made some excellent points there. And uh
01:13:47
>> you should have come on. This was I thought about randomly. Okay. I thought that Jim would come on as the head of
01:13:53
the network so-called >> and do your deadpan thing of like, you know, when you do that with the
01:14:00
audience, it doesn't really increase our numbers, you know. What do you mean? What are you talking about?
01:14:04
>> Although it's appreciated. >> Yeah. >> Uh the Billy Madison run is always on like a meme or on a good job on that
01:14:11
one. >> And uh we'll see you on the next interview. And this might be our longest
01:14:15
interview we did. It was fun. No, the last time I did what you >> I'm gonna be back, right? I'm going to
01:14:22
be back. >> Well, you know what it when you get the nomination, you should come back because
01:14:27
I I like being >> a savant. >> We'll never run out of stories to ask you about cuz it's too fun.
01:14:32
>> No, I have, you know, we did I don't think we got to any of the things we were talking about discussing. So, I I
01:14:40
don't think we got to a single one of them. >> We're the worst, dude. >> Did we talk about pus much? A little
01:14:45
bit. Not much. It's not breaking it a whole lot. >> I did I did I did want to mention your
01:14:51
um >> your Jerry Brown impression. >> Oh, that's right. That's >> was one of my favorite things ever. I
01:14:58
was proud to be one of the writers on that piece. >> Absolutely. >> I know. And I looked for it because you
01:15:05
mentioned that when we were talking on YouTube, Dana Carvey does Jerry Brown. Where is it? Because I was gonna I
01:15:11
wanted to re >> Jerry Brown now is not good. I wanted to relearn it for this podcast because it's
01:15:17
hard to remember the rhythm. I know it was and a thing and a thing, you know, was there was a thing there, but you
01:15:22
know, I I need to see it. >> I I've got to I'm going to say one last thing before we sign off. A few years
01:15:27
ago, well actually 24 years ago, I I was in San Francisco was an event for the Harvard Lampoon and and we were staying
01:15:37
at the uh home of um near the Prescidio of a very wealthy Harvard Lampoon alumnist
01:15:44
>> who was personal friends with both Jerry Brown and with Willie Brown. >> And this was at a time when Willie Brown
01:15:52
was mayor of San Francisco and Jerry Brown was mayor of Oakland. So we at the dinner we had this mayor Brown of the of
01:15:59
the month contest and we got we found another guy named Brown who was mayor of of some other town and um we had a and
01:16:07
the way we we did it was I I briefed everyone in attendance saying okay I'm introduced the three mayors they're not
01:16:13
in the room right now when I introduce you know the mayor Brown of of Vakavville or whatever he was you know I
01:16:20
want you know polite applause when I introduce Jerry Brown polite applause and When I introduce Willie Brown, I
01:16:26
want everyone going crazy like standing on your chairs like ah ah. And so we did
01:16:32
it and Willie Brown instant and then we're doing at the dinner the three of them. Willie Brown instantly starts
01:16:39
laughing because he gets a joke. Jerry Brown was very upset. >> His feelings were hurt
01:16:46
>> that he didn't get the response. Jim, I did you start the one about welcome our
01:16:51
host Tom Hanks smattering next week Sharon Stone. A huge applause. >> Well, that was a thing that Franken used
01:16:58
to used to do. >> Yeah, >> I did it immediately. Make the host feel like an [ __ ] That's [ __ ] job
01:17:07
number one at SNL. They're already nervous. They're like, "Who's next week?" And they're like, "It's going to
01:17:13
be this. Someone so much better than you." >> Funny. always funny. They always be like
01:17:18
[ __ ] Okay, thank you, Jim. >> All right, listen. If you're enjoying The Fly on the Wall, of course,
01:17:27
hopefully you are. Click follow. We don't want to be desperate, but obviously smash that goddamn button on
01:17:33
your favorite podcast app. >> Leave a review, a good one. >> Leave a fivestar rating, nothing else.
01:17:40
>> Whoops. >> And maybe even share an episode with a friend. If you're watching this episode
01:17:44
on YouTube, please subscribe. Dana, what do you think? >> I'm gonna tell you this right now. Hear
01:17:49
me now, believe me later. Fly in the Wall, believe it or not, is presented by Odyssey.
01:17:56
>> And executive produced by, hold for it, Dana Carvey and David Spade, or David
01:18:02
Spade and Dana Carvey. We don't write this stuff. Heather Santoro, Greg Holtzman, and Leah Reese Dennis. The
01:18:10
show is edited by Evan Cox with production support from Phil Sweet Tech. Talent production and booking by Sophia
01:18:18
Leapor.

Episode Highlights

  • Chris Farley's Entrance
    A humorous setup for Chris Farley's unexpected entrance.
    “Chris Farley is out in the hallway and he's completely naked.”
    @ 00m 52s
    June 18, 2026
  • Oscars Surprise
    A surprising moment during the Oscars that caught everyone off guard.
    “I was shocked by that.”
    @ 13m 15s
    June 18, 2026
  • The Perfect Thing
    The audience took the ride with me, and it was a fun experience.
    “The audience was right with me.”
    @ 22m 01s
    June 18, 2026
  • Cold Openings
    The easiest slam dunk was to go right up a bush cold opening.
    “It was always like such a good go-to that would work.”
    @ 23m 01s
    June 18, 2026
  • Bill Murray's Advice
    Bill Murray asked for help on a script that won an Oscar.
    “I wouldn't change anything, certainly I can't think of anything that I would do to change it.”
    @ 28m 38s
    June 18, 2026
  • The Best Writing Staff
    A discussion on the potency of different writing staffs over the years.
    “Was it the original writing staff or were they all just very comparable?”
    @ 43m 09s
    June 18, 2026
  • The Evolution of SNL Writers
    The writing staff of SNL has changed significantly over the years, with fewer writers in the past. The best writers were often performers themselves, creating a unique blend of talent.
    “The idea was that performers writing for themselves helps; it's good for them.”
    @ 45m 10s
    June 18, 2026
  • Eddie Murphy's Rise to Fame
    Eddie Murphy's journey from a featured player to a comedy legend is explored, highlighting his early struggles and eventual breakthrough.
    “Eddie is amazing how great he was. It's not a hot take, just interesting context.”
    @ 50m 46s
    June 18, 2026
  • The Naked Farley Incident
    A hilarious story about Chris Farley entering a meeting completely naked, showcasing his outrageous sense of humor.
    “Chris Farley is out in the hallway and he's completely naked.”
    @ 01h 02m 30s
    June 18, 2026
  • Practical Joke on Farley
    A hilarious practical joke involving a fake subpoena leaves Chris Farley flipping out.
    “He flipped out.”
    @ 01h 05m 33s
    June 18, 2026
  • Jim's Deadpan Performance
    Jim discusses his unique ability to deliver low energy performances that captivate audiences.
    “It's a skill set.”
    @ 01h 07m 11s
    June 18, 2026
  • Emmy Nomination Tease
    Jim humorously hints at an Emmy nomination, leaving listeners curious about his projects.
    “I smell an Oscar. No, I smell it. Emmy nomination.”
    @ 01h 13m 20s
    June 18, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • What the [ __ ] would be number one?
    Did Jim Downey Write that?
  • It was crazy.
    Did Jim Downey Write that?
  • I think I might have voted for Perau in that election just because...
    Did Jim Downey Write that?
  • You don't get a writer's credit if you're on SNL as a main cast member.
    Did Jim Downey Write that?
  • If you lead the audience, they might not recognize how much they enjoy it.
    Did Jim Downey Write that?
  • I smell an Oscar. No, I smell it. Emmy nomination.
    Did Jim Downey Write that?

Key Moments

  • Eddie Murphy's Talent00:42
  • Naked Farley00:52
  • Oscars Revelation13:15
  • Favorite Character24:41
  • Eddie's Early Days50:32
  • Farley's Naked Entrance1:02:30
  • Practical Joke1:05:11
  • Farley's Character1:05:35

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown