Search Captions & Ask AI

A Public School Teacher's Honest Take on Homeschooling

February 20, 2026 / 45:22

This episode features a discussion on public education with guest Amanda, a public school teacher. Topics include teaching experiences, the evolution of education, and perspectives on homeschooling.

Jacob G welcomes his cousin Amanda to the Ex Homeschoolers Club. They discuss Amanda's journey as a public school teacher, her experiences with different grade levels, and her passion for teaching second graders.

Amanda shares her educational background and how her early teachers inspired her to pursue a career in education. She highlights the independence and excitement of second graders as they transition from needing help to becoming more self-sufficient.

The conversation shifts to the challenges and changes in the public education system over the past 15 years, including funding issues and the importance of parental involvement in advocating for children's needs.

Jacob and Amanda also touch on the misconceptions surrounding homeschooling and public schooling, emphasizing the importance of being engaged in children's education, regardless of the schooling method.

TLDR

Jacob G and Amanda discuss public education, teaching experiences, and the importance of parental involvement in children's learning.

Episode

45:22
00:00:00
before I got my teaching position, I kind of was like third grade, you know, they kind of had me everywhere, [music]
00:00:06
but I really just gravitated toward those younger grades. [music] I mean, to me, I thought, oo, kinder through third,
00:00:12
I would definitely want to be in that space. And so, I think when they get to second grade [music] is a lot of
00:00:18
independence. Like, these kids are proud of everything they can do on their own,
00:00:22
they're so excited about school. So, you kind of see this shift of like, oh, they
00:00:26
need a lot of help to, oh, they're doing it on their own. That's amazing. Like
00:00:30
once you've shown [music] them, they they they go off on their own and then you start to see that growth happen in
00:00:35
second grade where [music] they really know what they they like. [music] All right, welcome welcome back my
00:00:44
fellow exhomies. It is your boy Jacob G and we are back for another week of the Ex Homeschoolers Club. The place where
00:00:49
we talk about the good, the bad, and the ugly of growing up a homeschool kid. [music] Today I've got a very special
00:00:54
guest, someone who's near and dear to my heart. my cousin Amanda is joining me
00:00:59
and uh we are going to touch on she she's a public school teacher and so we're going to talk about just public
00:01:04
school and and what it means to be an educator, what it looks like, how things have changed in her career as an
00:01:10
educator and kind of just some thoughts on the education space in general. Maybe
00:01:15
we'll we'll get her her thoughts on the homeschool experience as well. Um so
00:01:19
Amanda, welcome to the exhomeschoolers club. >> Thank you. I'm excited. I'm very
00:01:24
excited. Um, I'm so I'm so stoked to have you. We recently reconnected at a
00:01:29
family reunion and I I felt like we had a good conversation around education and
00:01:33
I was like, "Oh my gosh, I feel like this needs to be on the podcast." So, so
00:01:38
thank you for coming on. >> Yes, absolutely. >> Let's let's kick things off kind of with
00:01:42
your education background because you were not a homeschool kid. And so, were you public schoolled all the way through
00:01:48
or did you do private charter school? Anything unique or different? I was in public school throughout all my years
00:01:56
and so yeah, I no homeschooling, no charter school, no um anything other than public school.
00:02:03
>> I mean, how was that experience? I know like I I did public school for two
00:02:07
years. Like I remember somewhat of the dynamics of it a little bit, but like did you enjoy your time in school or you
00:02:14
know or would you have wished something different? >> I did enjoy school. Um, I was like
00:02:21
always just a learner. I was a reader. I I had wonderful teachers. I mean, there's like specific teachers. I can
00:02:27
like tell you their name and like things we did in their class and um so I I had
00:02:32
a great like just school um background and um so I did really enjoy it. And is that like where does your heart for
00:02:45
wanting to be a teacher like come into like how does it fit into that? Did you know go I mean you obviously went to
00:02:51
school to be an educator, went to college to be an educator, but like when did when did that light bulb click on
00:02:56
for you of like I think this might be what I want to do? >> For me it was pretty early on. I mean, I
00:03:02
specifically had like second, third grade teacher that like just really um made a big impact in my life. So, second
00:03:12
grade is like and it's just funny cuz now I teach second grade, but second grade was just like the year where I'm
00:03:17
like it's like I watched my teacher like, "Wow, you know, this is so awesome." And as I continued, a great
00:03:23
third grade teacher, a great fourth grade teacher, fifth grade teacher. And so pretty early on I knew like I think
00:03:29
I'm interested in this. I did kind of go through do I want to be a nurse or a
00:03:34
teacher? You know, I kind of debated both of those. But as the years went on, you know, I think each year just kind of
00:03:39
solidified this is what I want to do. I of course also had some background in like babysitting and like working at a
00:03:46
preschool. So I just think everything I did after that uh really solidified that
00:03:52
I think I do want to be an educator. And then of course I just continued on that
00:03:56
path. >> What's funny is like as I was kind of prepping for this conversation, I I had
00:04:00
a talk with my my mom and >> when I was a baby, we lived with your family for a few months in there and my
00:04:08
mom always was tells the story of she's like Amanda just would come home and she
00:04:13
just was like she just wanted to play with you and [laughter] and you know and that led to even when we were young
00:04:18
kids, you babysat us quite a bit and hung out with us. we would come stay with you guys and I'm sure you know
00:04:25
maybe there was some annoying times in there for from us as well but [laughter] uh but you know there's a reason that
00:04:32
the the Ortega 3 are like our favorite cousins. Um [laughter] and yes I just put that out on the
00:04:38
internet so I'm sorry I know if you guys hear this >> now all our other cousins are going to
00:04:43
hear you say that. [laughter] >> Yeah. Yeah. But um yeah, but I I have always known you as such a loving and
00:04:49
caring person. So it just makes sense that you would go into like you said either nursing or teaching or something
00:04:54
like that because I remember even as a kid you the way you played with us and the things you did with us always felt
00:04:59
like it had this >> level of like an education or a a a real life experience that kind of like
00:05:06
mattered if that makes sense. It wasn't just a like oh let's just waste time. It
00:05:10
was there was always this >> additional element to it and so I think that's really cool. So, walk me through
00:05:17
getting like a teaching degree. Is it just like a four-year program or I know some people go on to do like masters and
00:05:23
stuff, but >> Yes. >> What did that look like for you? >> Um, I I did transfer. I started out at
00:05:29
the junior college there in Ventura and then transferred to Calpali Sano. That's
00:05:33
how I landed in this area. Um, it was a 4-year program and then I continued on an extra year to do my teaching
00:05:40
credentials. So, then that's where like you start your student teaching. that's
00:05:44
where um you're working towards you know with the state to get your credentials.
00:05:49
So for me it was about 5 years. Um I did not continue on with my masters. I still
00:05:55
to this point don't have my masters and I think I'm fine with that. You know
00:05:59
some people do continue and that's awesome but um so for me it was about about five years that until I was then
00:06:06
ready to go and >> out in the real world. [laughter] >> Yeah. No, I know that that like yeah I I
00:06:14
remember having friends in college who were getting their teaching degrees and I know some of them were doing that
00:06:18
student teacher experience and I know some people now who are doing that and I think it's I think that's one of the
00:06:25
cool things about the education like degree programs >> is that you have to kind of go get this
00:06:30
like real world like lived experience almost like an internship. And >> so, um, so in those positions, are you
00:06:39
primarily like a TA, a substitute teacher? What is like, what does student teaching really look like?
00:06:47
>> Well, with student teaching, I that's where, you know, they they for me, they
00:06:52
found an assignment for me. I had two assignments and going into those, I said, I do not want kindergarten. I do
00:06:57
not want sixth grade. And those are the two that I got. I was like, oh, great. And I loved both of them. Um, I started
00:07:03
off with kindergarten. So, it's like my first assignment was I was like watching
00:07:08
the teacher. I was gradually taking over. She would say like, "Hey, maybe take over the morning routine or and
00:07:14
then uh my second assignment in sixth grade and it was a gate class. I was like, "Oh my gosh." Like I would have to
00:07:20
like study the math before I taught the math the next day cuz I was like, "Oh my
00:07:24
gosh." Uh, a great group of kids. And that was a full takeover. So, I mean, it
00:07:30
was eventually the mentor teacher in the classroom. She would just sit and watch
00:07:35
at times. Um, sometimes take breaks cuz that's what mentor teachers do, too.
00:07:39
They're like, "Oh, someone's teaching my class. I'm going to go take a break."
00:07:42
Um, but it is a full takeover and you're creating um you create an a unit within
00:07:49
your student teaching. So, it's really So, um mine was like on Greek culture
00:07:53
and so like we just did some awesome things with those sixth graders. So the second assignment is like a lot but it's
00:08:01
exciting >> because you you really do feel like ah I'm a I'm doing it like I'm a teacher
00:08:07
and I feel like that's the best learning experience. sitting at Calpali in a
00:08:12
classroom was nothing compared to being in the classroom dealing with these students
00:08:18
that are right in front of you, you know, grading paper like just it's what you're doing that I learned most when I
00:08:24
was just in the classroom and it didn't matter. Eventually from there I went on
00:08:28
to uh work in that district and it was more of like a teacher tutor position where hey kids that are struggling in
00:08:35
reading would come to me. Um even though it wasn't a credentialed teacher position. I mean I was still working
00:08:42
with what I would be doing. You know you're going to have kids that have challenges. You're going to have kids
00:08:48
that like just get it. Um so it was neat to work with, you know, all different types of backgrounds, learning
00:08:55
backgrounds. >> Yeah. I can definitely attest to like the the hands-on thing because I mean
00:08:59
one being homeschooled like got a lot of hands-on experience doing a bunch of different stuff but even in college like
00:09:05
>> the college that I chose even though I did a business degree >> my emphasis was in entertainment wanted
00:09:10
to work events and so we just did that at school we ran all kinds of events whether it was concerts or we did like
00:09:17
school events uh like we brought in a bunch of like the board members and we were like we go pick them up at the
00:09:22
airport we you know make sure they got fed into the hotels and stuff like that which, you know, not not the most
00:09:28
glamorous job, but um but like I totally relate in that aspect of like when you're actually doing it, it's like one
00:09:34
thing to >> Yeah. to talk about it in a in a classroom, but then when you're just
00:09:37
like actually living it, it's like this is way better. This is I'm I'm hooked
00:09:42
now. I want to do this. >> So, how long have you been teaching now? So I've been um in my district I've been
00:09:50
in the same district actually for about 15 years and credent like as a credential teacher 13. So I'm going on
00:09:56
my 13th year. I know you you brought up that you like are currently like second third grade teacher, but like have you
00:10:04
done all sixth grades in that span of time or have you primarily stuck in those early years?
00:10:10
>> Besides student teaching being in in sixth grade and then before I got my
00:10:16
credential, you know, before I got my teaching position, I kind of was like third grade, you know, they kind of had
00:10:21
me everywhere. Um, but I really just gravitated toward those younger grades. I mean, to me, I thought, oh, kinder
00:10:29
through third, I would definitely want to be in that space. Um, so, uh, and then I landed on second grade and I've
00:10:37
been in second grade for 13 years. So, I mean, and that's what they kind of say.
00:10:42
They said second grade teachers once you're there, they don't leave cuz it's
00:10:47
great. >> Why do you think that is? like do what is the I don't want to say like
00:10:52
attachment to it but like what I get like what is the hook there of like you know that age demographic of kids that
00:10:58
for you like just seems to like be the thing. I think when these kids are in first grade, um it's a lot of modeling,
00:11:05
a lot of, you know, they're still like little babies, you know, coming from kindergarten. And so I think when they
00:11:12
get to second grade is a lot of independence. Like these kids are proud of everything they can do on their own.
00:11:18
They're so excited about school. Um and I think I think that's what kind of
00:11:24
keeps teachers there is like, man, they're excited. They're more independent. I mean, obviously there's
00:11:29
things that we definitely have to really help them with and show them and of course a lot of modeling, but they um
00:11:37
they love that independence, like they want to do it themselves. So, you kind of see this shift of like, oh, they need
00:11:43
a lot of help to oh, they're doing it on their own. That's amazing. Like, once
00:11:46
you've shown them, they they they go off on their own. And then you start to see
00:11:50
that growth happen in second grade where everything in first grade that they've
00:11:54
learned kind of really solidifies in second grade. And you know, for the most part, you know, kids start reading and
00:12:01
they start finding like their interest and or not even just reading, like, oh, I really like science. And so, it just
00:12:08
gets really exciting. I think I think kids get to a space in second grade as seven and eight year olds where they
00:12:14
really know what they they like. They really know what they want to do. And, you know, I think it starts to shift in
00:12:20
second grade for them. >> That's like spot on. I like I I was as you were talking I was thinking about
00:12:25
like that's second grade is when I started my homeschool experience >> and I think about that first year of
00:12:31
like it was tough partly because my mom was trying to mimic like a traditional school setting and just like not very
00:12:38
successfully doing it. Um, sorry mom. Uh, she knows this. Um, [laughter] but like I remember like the things that
00:12:45
I was interested in like I loved space at that point and so like getting a telescope and like that was what I drove
00:12:53
my education in that area because I was just like this is what I'm interested in
00:12:56
and so like I'm going to just like pursue it with everything that's in me.
00:13:00
Um, but I to yeah I'm like thinking back I'm like yeah I was super proud of
00:13:05
everything I would do because it was like >> like you said you're you kind of you
00:13:09
already kind of know how to read. You kind of know some basic math and then like
00:13:13
>> yes >> you you're it's just growing like you got the you have the base layer and now
00:13:17
it's like it's just growing which like hopefully continues throughout the rest
00:13:21
the remainder of your grades. But >> yes. So, are the teachers in your district like
00:13:26
do do you guys universally agree that like second, third grade is like the best grades to teach or like do each of
00:13:32
you kind of have this like no, I just love fifth grade for some reason? >> I mean, I think it it's different
00:13:39
because if you talk to someone at my school as a fourth and fifth grade teacher, they're like, I could never do
00:13:44
second grade. You know, it's like where everyone's at is is, you know, your
00:13:52
fourth, fifth, sixth grade teachers, they more so are like, I I could go to junior high. Me, I'm like, never. I
00:13:59
could I could never go to junior high. I'm like, they would be taller than me
00:14:03
for sure, and I couldn't do that. You know, the the attitude even in fourth,
00:14:08
fifth, and sixth grade, I'm like, I see the attitude and I'm like, oh yeah, I
00:14:11
couldn't do that. I couldn't do that. And not to say in second grade we don't
00:14:15
get that with, you know, some kids that come in, but it's not the whole class,
00:14:20
you know, it's not, you know, they're just going through a lot. So it depends
00:14:24
who you talk to because if you talk to a sixth grade teacher, they're like, "Second grade, no thank you. Anything
00:14:28
lower than fourth, I'm not doing it." So [laughter] >> yeah, I always wonder that because I I I
00:14:35
obviously I've never been like a teacher teacher, but like I've taught dance
00:14:39
lessons and music lessons and those types of things. And so and and I worked at a toy store for a number of years and
00:14:44
ran birthday parties for all age gra all age ranges. >> And so my sweet spot has always been
00:14:49
like junior high boys specifically. Um I think mostly because like my maturity level matches theirs. Um [laughter] but
00:15:00
uh but I yeah I think I totally relate with that of like you put a bunch of second graders in my room I'm like ah
00:15:07
this is not this is not my thing like it's it's a little bit of torture for
00:15:10
me. Um [laughter] where yeah like that junior high level I think is just like that's my sweet spot. Um
00:15:16
>> yes >> as far as relating to kids I guess. But um I'm wondering so
00:15:23
obviously you've been an educator for a while and and um I wonder just what your
00:15:28
thoughts are on like homeschooling and the homeschool movement. Like >> you obviously
00:15:33
>> you grew up watching my sister and I be homeschooled. Like >> did you think that my mom was crazy?
00:15:39
Well, I can say it's it's interesting because you talk about um you know
00:15:45
homeschooling myths or you know kind of things how you guys view public school and you know it's like there's the other
00:15:53
side of that you know as as you know a public school like I went through public school I I'm a public school teacher and
00:16:00
how I've always viewed homeschooling and for me years ago and around you know
00:16:06
when you and Madison were being homeschooled to me I'm like are like do they have
00:16:12
friends like how you know cuz you just think of like you go to school with your friends you know and kind of observing
00:16:19
it I'm like h I don't know you know so I had all you know different thoughts then
00:16:24
like I don't know how this works you know and and um but as time has gone on
00:16:30
I've just seen how and I'm I'm surrounded by a lot of public educ um
00:16:36
you know educators But I'm also surrounded by a lot of homeschool moms and I've just seen how it can be
00:16:43
different for everyone. You know that it's not every homechool looks the same.
00:16:48
Um they kind of run it a little bit different. And then I think a lot of things have developed since you guys
00:16:53
were even homeschooled is you know all these you know cohorts that I mean kids I mean you can really tap into a kid's
00:17:01
interest and I've seen that. So, I've changed along the years with just I just
00:17:08
see it in a different light and I see how it can really benefit, you know, when kids have those certain interests.
00:17:16
Um, it can benefit kids that are in public school that are like, I just don't like this. You know, it's not for
00:17:22
everyone. I I mean, I'm sure homeschool can probably also have the clicks, too,
00:17:26
but you know, public school is so many clicks. I see it in second grade. It's
00:17:30
like you start to see the making those groups and you know not allowing others to come into your group. It's just it's
00:17:38
hard to see as the educator and a mom. I just see how maybe some kids gravitate towards homeschool. So I definitely know
00:17:45
my view has changed um for sure um about homeschooling. I'm not quite like uh I
00:17:50
don't know. It's kind of weird because that's kind of [laughter] you know kind
00:17:54
of seems a little weird. But I think when your mom and dad were doing it, you know, of course your mom's starting off
00:18:00
first. Um I I just didn't quite understand it. I think that was it too is that I didn't have quite an
00:18:06
understanding of it >> and um and know the full scoop, you know, the whole scope of it that it was,
00:18:15
you know, it was probably just not a great understanding of how it works. >> The thing is it it transitioned over
00:18:21
time, too. like we granted we got connected very early on with like co-ops and things like that. So, like we did
00:18:27
have we did have friends. Um, but it was it was hard. Like I mean those first I would say the first three years like it
00:18:36
felt a lot more isolating. And like I I mean I had gone to public school so I I was used to 15 kids in a room, you know,
00:18:46
and we ride the bus to school together. We ride the bus home, you know, a couple
00:18:50
of them lived in my neighborhood. So then we play in the afternoon, you know. I was used to that to to go from that to
00:18:55
literally like >> I mean my closest friend lived 20 30 minutes away when we started
00:19:00
homeschooling. That's a big that was a big shift and and and a struggle but definitely by the time it shifted over
00:19:06
time and by the end I mean >> helped when I got a driver's license cuz
00:19:10
then I could just go. Uh but I made more friends and you know and found those like those passion project things that I
00:19:17
was into and so I think that helped a lot. But it's it's interesting because I
00:19:22
was I'm also I think a lot about the difference of like the dynamic of who I
00:19:26
am as a person versus my sister. >> And I don't think that she would have
00:19:31
thrived in a traditional class setting. I would have been fine. >> Yeah. >> I'm the firstborn. I got like
00:19:37
>> I got the analytical brain. I just I I work well with the checklist kind of a
00:19:41
thing. And so public school to me sounds like something that would be fine for me.
00:19:46
>> She doesn't operate that way. And so she needs to be able to to bounce up and
00:19:50
down on a trampoline or knit or do something while she's listening. And that's,
00:19:55
>> you know, that's fine. And so at the time, public school just couldn't afford
00:19:58
that for her. Um, but >> I'm I'm interested to know kind of also like how you've seen now being in the
00:20:06
education space for 15 years, >> the shift in that because I think I I've
00:20:12
been hearing more and more from from parents that they're there's kind of this like I don't know
00:20:18
totally how to describe it, but there's like this hopeful >> there's like a hopefulness and like a
00:20:23
dread within the public school system of like there are services that have become
00:20:27
available for kids who have educational needs. Um, but there but there's also whether it's a lack of
00:20:34
funding, it's not available to everybody always. And so anyway, >> without feeding you too much, I mean,
00:20:41
what what has shifted in the last 15 years as you've like worked in that space and seen things evolve?
00:20:46
>> Um, it has shifted quite a bit. And you think I mean I'm going on my 13th year.
00:20:51
You think, okay, in 13 years it I mean from my first year to now, um, it's it's
00:20:57
different. And like you said, funding absolutely, you know, it depends on the district. Um, the district I work for,
00:21:04
you know, they they do receive a lot of funding and we do have a lot. Is it allocated in the correct spaces?
00:21:12
Absolutely not. And it it's hard. And it's also hard now having kids of my own because I look at
00:21:20
my class differently. I look at this class and I see students who have family support. I see students that have no
00:21:27
family support. I see students that have learning disabilities and I, you know, I
00:21:33
I see a lot in my classroom and I come from a space of like an educator but also kind of like a mama bear. Like I
00:21:40
want to help these kids, but I could only do so much, you know? And I and I feel like I really become like an
00:21:46
advocate for these kids in meetings where I have to sit and I have to sit in front of this group of people and I have
00:21:53
to tell them like they're not getting what they need and they they can only do
00:21:58
so much. It's like well this is all we have. So to say that each kid gets exactly what
00:22:06
they need, I I don't I can't say they do. And you know, if you have a kid in
00:22:12
public school and if you have like in my classroom that you know doesn't have
00:22:16
challenges, you know, they learn to read, they they can do math and, you know, it it's easier for them um because
00:22:24
they're not having to like we're not having to, you know, um put in in paperwork for hey, they, you know, need
00:22:33
to go to resource or they need speech or they need all these services, but the kids that are not there, you know, and
00:22:40
and the services take a while. It's like you put in the paperwork, you wait, but
00:22:46
then you have to have all this data for a good six months, and then once you have the data, and you're and I'm like
00:22:53
I've I really have become more bold in saying like, "No, I I know what I see.
00:23:00
Come into my classroom, sit next to this kid, watch this kid, >> and and then tell me you're going to
00:23:05
wait six months for data." It becomes quite frustrating. Like I said, I come
00:23:09
not just from educator. I come as like a mama to these kids. Like if and especially when I see that they don't
00:23:16
quite have that support at home where their parents are like fighting for, hey, some of these parents don't even
00:23:21
know what their kid is doing. They don't even quite understand what's going on
00:23:26
with their kid. And so I just feel like I have to fight harder for these kids, but then again, I can only do so much.
00:23:36
And so it's it's hard to see that. And that's where I've kind of seen the shift
00:23:39
is that, you know, sometimes we do have the money, but is it used in the right place? No. I think, you know, it's
00:23:47
shifted over here and, oh, it's, hey, let's build a new school, you know,
00:23:52
we're up to 22 schools in my district. It's like, did we really need that new
00:23:57
school, you know, or could we have used that for more services? Could we had you
00:24:01
could we have used that for more aids, more speech teachers, more resource teachers where more kids would get um
00:24:09
the help that they need? So, I I've seen a shift in that. You know, we do have um
00:24:15
full inclusion now in my district. Not all districts do. It's a district by district um decision. And it's I mean
00:24:25
we're going on probably 5 years now of inclusion, maybe four or five years. And
00:24:32
I can't say it's working well. And you know, I love having these these kiddos
00:24:37
in my class, but it's it's tough to see that um you know, they're not getting
00:24:45
the the aid that they need. you know, they're getting some of it at times and
00:24:49
then at other times I'm like, "What are we doing?" Like, "What are we doing for
00:24:54
these kids?" And it becomes quite frustrating. Um, and you, you know, you you speak up. I do speak up. I do, but
00:25:02
like I said, it's you can only do so much. >> That's that's the thing. And and really
00:25:08
quickly for anyone who doesn't know what uh incl the inclusion piece means, it's
00:25:12
basically like this special ed special ed and traditional school combined in one classroom. Correct.
00:25:19
>> Yes. >> Okay. >> Yes. >> And so yeah, I mean that can be
00:25:23
frustrating and like I I applaud you for for advocating and going before boards or you know whatever meetings you have
00:25:30
to be in because like we need people like that. Um I I live in a state where there is a lot of talk among people of
00:25:38
like the educa the public education system doesn't work. It's broken. It's
00:25:41
all these things. And it's hard because I don't I think there are broken elements like you were
00:25:47
describing of like >> do these resources go to the correct places? Those types of things. But I
00:25:52
don't think that it's broken as a whole. I just think that there are broken
00:25:57
pieces to it. And that's where people like yourself can advocate and you know
00:26:03
I know one of the things we were going to talk on too is like also how parents can get involved and be you know support
00:26:11
and then you know and even people like myself who don't have kids like where
00:26:15
what are the things that we can be doing to kind of help you um voice those concerns.
00:26:22
>> The biggest thing I think of for parents is just getting involved. You know, I
00:26:27
come from both. You know, I am a public school educator. I am a mom of three. And now, you know, I have a second
00:26:34
grader, I have a kindergartener, and then a little preschooler. So, I I am very involved. I know their teachers.
00:26:43
I'm talking to their teachers. I'm emailing their teachers. I know their
00:26:47
principal. I've set up meetings with people. I'm very involved. Now I'm in a
00:26:53
space with my own kids that, you know, they they do fairly well in school. You know, we haven't seen any like major
00:26:59
challenges. Um, and of course, if those came about, we would, you know, of course work with them. But
00:27:08
I if there was, I mean, you would best believe I would I would want to know everything. And I think that's where it
00:27:15
could be so different is that if parents were involved, if parents knew, especially like, hey, you have a kid in
00:27:20
speech and resource. Okay, what does that look like? What is he doing? Okay, maybe take a half a day from work. Go
00:27:27
sit in your kid's classroom. Watch what's happening. You know, how how is
00:27:32
my kid, you know, in class? How is my kid with this teacher? How just watching to see what your kid is doing? I would
00:27:41
do that, you know, and knowing, you know, I think parents don't know like you could walk into an office, a school
00:27:48
office and say, "I want a meeting." And they have to make a they have to give
00:27:53
you a meeting. Like you can call for meetings. You can call for um you know th those times to say, you know, I want
00:28:02
to talk about this. I want, you know, they they have to do it. It's legally they have to do it. And I think parents
00:28:07
don't know that. Um, I think sometimes parents like kind of send their kids.
00:28:12
It's like it's a teacher's job, you know? And I've seen a difference in the
00:28:16
parents that are not involved at all cuz I feel like I have to really fight, but
00:28:20
then it it's it's hard. >> I've also seen how when I'm working with
00:28:25
a parent that's fighting for their child and I'm fighting for their child, what a
00:28:29
big difference that makes. I mean, some of these kids get services that they were not getting before. If [snorts] a
00:28:36
you know if a if a school is saying they don't need speech services and you as a
00:28:39
parent are saying yes they do then you see that you see that the difference in that you see that they receive speech
00:28:48
services you see um so when we're like on the same team and I tell parents at
00:28:52
conferences like we have to work together like you have to do your part and I'll do my part and so parents
00:28:59
getting involved asking questions you know and it and it doesn't matter I'm in
00:29:03
a district where it's, you know, uh, you know, mainly Spanish speaking. We also
00:29:08
do have like a high percentage of Miksteeco, um, the Mixsteeco language. Um, and
00:29:14
that's hard, too, because some parents that speak Mikco don't speak Spanish.
00:29:18
So, there's a lot going on, but there's so much education out there. You know,
00:29:22
our district provides a lot of parent classes that you can go to in their home language. So there there's just really
00:29:29
no excuse, you know, even if you are coming over for another another country, you know, getting acclimated, but
00:29:35
knowing that this is your kid and you get one chance with your kids. So, um, and then those of you that don't have
00:29:42
kids yet, like you never know if eventually you will have kids or if you have nieces and nephews, just being
00:29:49
involved, like knowing like what kind of propositions and bonds are coming through that may eventuallyffect affect
00:29:57
you guys or affect your nieces and nephews or affect, you know, just just knowing what you're voting for is is
00:30:03
absolutely important. and um being you know going to a board meeting you know more people are showing up at board
00:30:10
meetings and you know that's where you really get to see like is that board you
00:30:15
know on board with us you know to help these kids or is it you know a job for them it's is it just something that they
00:30:23
do so and it's nice to hear people's voices you know parents are showing up
00:30:27
teachers are showing up to those board meetings and so just really being involved in that way
00:30:32
>> something that popped in my brain as you were talking too is earlier you had
00:30:36
mentioned like the myths the homeschool myths of like what we believe public school is like and I think one of the
00:30:41
big ones tends to be this thought of like well when you send your kid to public school you put them on a bus they
00:30:48
go off they come home and that's and that's that and then it's just rinse and
00:30:52
repeat 5 days a week and like you were saying I think that that's a big that's
00:30:58
a big mistake right it's like the education doesn't just stop just because
00:31:01
school is over you know it still happens at home and as parents, I mean, who better to recognize what's going on with
00:31:07
their children than than them, right? Yes. Um, >> and so I Yeah, I I agree with you. I
00:31:14
think that that's been a big shift in me too of like realizing in the last couple
00:31:18
years of like when I'm going to vote, I'm like, who am I voting for? um really
00:31:23
cuz like you know of course there's like the top tiers of like you know we're
00:31:26
voting for the president and we're voting for our senators and things like that but voting for the school board I'm
00:31:31
like I don't >> I don't know any of these people and so actually taking the time to research
00:31:36
them >> um has helped and ask questions of those people I do know who who have kids um
00:31:41
who are in school and things like that and it's just been like >> is this a good person? Should we be
00:31:46
voting for them? Is this who you like? um and what what changes do you want to see in the school districts
00:31:51
[clears throat] in our area and things like that? So, >> I I'm with you 100% on on those things
00:31:56
because >> yeah, I it takes it takes everybody to make to make a change. So,
00:32:02
>> yes, absolutely. >> I wanted to ask you this, too. Um obviously your kids are in the the early
00:32:09
ages of their career. Has homeschooling ever been something you've considered
00:32:14
doing for your kids or are you like, "No, we're doing traditional school."
00:32:18
[laughter] Um there, you know, like I've told you, it there's definitely been a
00:32:22
shift and um it's definitely something um Harvey I've really been praying on
00:32:30
because as that shift has happened as an educator, you know, I just see um a lot
00:32:35
of things happening in the classroom, but then I'm also watching my own kids
00:32:39
attend public school now and just being really involved in that. Um and then I just see I see their interest. I see the
00:32:46
things that they love to do and I think like man how and and we do expand on it.
00:32:51
My husband and I, you know, we do expand on it, you know, on the weekends, but in
00:32:56
the evenings like we do a lot here at home and we carry on that learning. Um but sometimes I think gosh to provide
00:33:06
them more. So it definitely is has been many conversations between us. um we'll
00:33:12
see what happens in the near future. But it's definitely something that we are um
00:33:17
discussing and you know kind of trying to figure out and you know and my own kids have seen like hey so and so is not
00:33:24
at school anymore because now they're being homeschooled. So, you know, my daughter Ava's like, "What's
00:33:29
homeschooling?" You know, so I'm I'm trying to explain it to her and stuff
00:33:33
and, you know, and also I'm not going into it thinking like, "Oh, then we're
00:33:38
just going to be home and together and everything's going to be peaches and cream." Um, I don't think you really
00:33:44
know until you're in it. Um, but I, you know, I've heard stories. You know, I've
00:33:48
heard your podcast and, um, you know, I've I've talked to your mom and your
00:33:53
parents and, you know, just other people. And so I I I don't go into it knowing or being like, "Oh, it's going
00:34:00
to be wonderful and we're just going to, you know, we're just going to learn
00:34:03
every day." And >> there will be days where you want to kill each other. That's just the reality
00:34:08
of the situation. But [laughter] >> yeah, I I it was funny when when CO happened. I remember I remember having a
00:34:16
conversation with my parents and being like, "Imagine if we had to homeschool
00:34:19
right now." I was like, "We would we would literally kill each other."
00:34:22
Thousand square foot home. Yes, >> on top of each other. We were already on
00:34:26
top of each other, but it was like we would have literally killed each other. Um,
00:34:30
>> yes. [laughter] >> Nobody would have come out of that scot-free. >> But um
00:34:35
>> Oh, man. But yeah, I >> And then I think what I think of also is >> if I moved into that homeschooling space
00:34:44
>> for me, it would be quite a shift because >> I teach in a traditional setting. I
00:34:49
mean, my students sit at desk. I mean I'm I try to be very like flexible like
00:34:54
hey you are just like all over the place like yeah get up like lay on the floor you know go grab a wobble chair you know
00:35:02
I'm not like one of those teachers like you have to be in your seat >> but I also have 25 students this year
00:35:09
and so I can't always have you just be wherever you want in the classroom. So
00:35:15
for me it would be quite a shift because I'm so used to that traditional setting
00:35:20
whereas that's probably not what we would do for homeschool you know I don't
00:35:24
think and I don't think even my own kids I don't you know they would be like no I
00:35:28
don't want to do this you know this is where we were at you know um so that would be quite a shift.
00:35:35
>> Yeah. What one of the things that's come up on this show a couple times too is
00:35:38
this >> kind of separation of like teacher mother and how like >> it gets really blurry when you
00:35:48
homeschool because you know I mean >> there were days I would do school till
00:35:53
10:30 at night and you know but I wasn't I wasn't doing school for the first four
00:35:57
or five hours of the day >> and so it was very interesting to try to get to a balance place where it was like
00:36:03
okay mom is taking the teacher your hat off, she's putting the mom hat back on.
00:36:07
And you know, same with dad eventually is like those types of things. And and so it's interesting to talk to some of
00:36:12
my friends because their parents very much struggled. I think my parents did too, but they really struggled with
00:36:17
that. Like how do you find that balance between the two because currently for even though like you were saying you and
00:36:25
Harvey educate your kids at home still to some degree? >> Yes. >> You still are putting on you're just mom
00:36:30
and dad to them. And so >> Exactly. You know, it is a it is a shift to think like all of a sudden they're
00:36:36
going to have to be like, "Oh, mom is my teacher and my mom." That's okay.
00:36:41
[laughter] >> It's a little different. >> Yeah, exactly. >> I was going to ask you too just about
00:36:48
>> kind of the curriculum building at in like a public school setting. You
00:36:51
mentioned earlier that when you were student teaching, you got to build like a unit around uh Greek history. And so
00:36:57
[clears throat] I was wondering because I think another misconception that a lot
00:37:01
of homeschoolers have is this this like well public school teachers are just they're told everything that they have.
00:37:07
You know they're given all the resources and they're kind of told this is what
00:37:10
you have to teach and and yada yada yada. And so I'm wondering like is there
00:37:14
a degree to customization in the public school system of like teachers being able to like you know switch in and out
00:37:22
of stuff or how does that look? I mean, we definitely have to follow state standards. You know, we have we're going
00:37:29
over those all the time. And, you know, like for second grade has a specific set
00:37:33
of state standards that um, you know, that we do have to follow. Um, our district also has somewhat of a pacing
00:37:41
guide, you know, to kind of so you're not, you know, already on unit four and
00:37:46
you're supposed to be on unit two, you know. So um there there is definitely
00:37:50
and we're given textbooks you know we do have to more so follow them but we adjust them. I mean we we can you know
00:38:00
you know change and kind of gear them towards our class. You know if if I'm given a very dry you know story
00:38:10
I'll find the real you know they also like chop up stories. That's I always
00:38:14
tell my students I said I I don't like this because they give you a portion of
00:38:18
the story but there's this whole story with like details and you know so I go
00:38:23
by the the the full novel you know the story that we're reading and so we'll
00:38:29
read the one that they've given us through curriculum but then I'll read
00:38:33
like the actual story you know and the kids are always like oh that one's way
00:38:36
better. I'm like, "Yeah, right." Because it's like it gives you more, you know,
00:38:41
they just chop it up. So, you know, things like that. Yes, you can adjust. Uh, of course, you know, as um there's
00:38:47
five of us second grade teachers on my team and, you know, we try to take things that can be kind of dry and make
00:38:54
it more exciting, you know, maybe do a project with it. So, there's definitely
00:38:58
room for um, you know, changing it in that way. But I mean, of course, you can't change what you're teaching. You
00:39:08
know, you have to really stick to, okay, we're learning about fantasy right now.
00:39:12
We have to stick to fantasy or we're learning about, you know, you know, the
00:39:18
three states of matter, you know? So, you really have to like stick with what you're teaching like as the basis, but
00:39:24
how you teach it can pretty much become your own. the ability to add that secondary level like like storytelling
00:39:31
for instance like like I think about like I read Robert Sin Caruso the a bridged version when I was a young kid
00:39:37
and then I read the full version which if anyone's read that book you know that
00:39:40
that book is a grammatical nightmare um just run on sentence after run on sentence after run on sentence. I think
00:39:46
there's a point where there's like four pages of just one sentence um kind of a
00:39:50
deal but [laughter] >> I'm like this this needs a little bit of editing. Um, but the the the full
00:39:56
version is like such a richer story like you were saying. It tells, you know, it
00:40:01
is and and there's so many books like that. Um, >> yes. >> And I was thinking about too like
00:40:05
>> I remember being in public school and there being >> I I want I think we were learning about
00:40:10
like uh the states of water, right? So like vapor, liquid, >> and solid. And I remember I I don't
00:40:17
remember exactly what we did, but I just remember her giving showing us something. And I don't remember what
00:40:23
exactly it was, but it was just this like activity that we got to do. And like >> again, like I don't remember the
00:40:29
activity. So obviously, how hard did it stick? But like I remember the day though and I remember the excitement
00:40:33
around it because it was like, okay, we're not just reading a textbook and learning about this thing. We're
00:40:37
actually like >> seeing it play out in real life. And I think >> in my experience that's where that's
00:40:42
where education in general just like it actually like hooks into you is just that like you know it's one thing to
00:40:48
read it but then to see it to touch it to feel it it's like >> whoa you know it becomes a whole another
00:40:55
solidified thing in the brain. So >> yes, and that's true what you say. It's
00:40:58
like that's what kids remember. Like kids are not going to remember if I taught them standard S.14
00:41:06
dot, you know, and that's where, you know, education can get frustrating is like that's not what what do I remember
00:41:13
about my second grade teacher? I remember that she said if you read a hundred books this year that she would
00:41:21
take a group of us um to go have dinner with her family. Uh, I ended up getting I was like so motivated that year and
00:41:28
you could see the process. You would have it on the wall and four of us got to go ride in her car like how cool
00:41:35
you're in your teacher's car. We got to go have ice cream and then we had dinner
00:41:40
with her family, her husband and her son. That's what I remember. I remember
00:41:45
reading a hundred books in second grade and h getting that experience. Like that's what I remember. Do I remember
00:41:51
the lesson she taught? No, I don't. >> Yeah. you know, it's what what do I
00:41:56
remember about those times and it's like I don't remember those times. You know,
00:42:00
they had to you had to take a test for the state. Like kids don't remember that
00:42:04
stuff. That's not what sticks in their mind. That's not what's solidified. You
00:42:08
know, they do remember like you said, the hands-on, the you know, doing those projects. Like that's what that's what
00:42:14
they stick with. That's what the one thing they'll remember about second
00:42:17
grade or whatever grade it is. So, >> I don't know. This is making me long for
00:42:21
second grade again. Um [laughter] an easier time in life. Um, but >> yeah, exactly.
00:42:29
>> Amanda, this has been this has been super fun. Is there anything else we
00:42:32
haven't touched on in the education space that you feel we've missed? >> I think whatever it is, however it is
00:42:39
that you whether you're in public school, homechool, charter, um like you've kind of mentioned all all
00:42:45
different um aspects of learning, education is like whatever works best for you. And
00:42:51
and there's always a shift like education is always shifting like you know it it's always changing and and
00:43:00
like I've told you my different views on on homeschooling because I've learned
00:43:05
more you know it's I see and I get one chance with my kiddos. You know I think
00:43:10
of my own kiddos at home. I get one we get one chance with our kids and I just want to give them the best. Um, but it's
00:43:19
like when if public school works for people, yes, but get involved, you know, don't ever ever just send your kids
00:43:28
somewhere and just, well, I hope I pray, you know, no, you have to be involved. Like, you have to know what your child
00:43:36
is doing, you know, wherever it is they're going and whatever, you know, aspect of education that your child's
00:43:43
involved in, you know, just get involved. You know, that's my biggest thing. Um, you know, I just wish more
00:43:49
parents would do it. You know, I it's it's sad to see that part of it. >> No, I think that's a great kind of
00:43:55
message to end on is like just get involved. Like >> it it's timeconuming, but it's worth it.
00:44:00
It it pays off in the end. And so, >> and I think that's it, too. You know,
00:44:04
parents are tired, people are tired, everyone, whether you have kids or not. We're busy and we're tired.
00:44:10
>> We're busy. We're exhausted. Yeah. >> Yes. But in the long run, you'll, you
00:44:15
know, you'll pat yourself on the back for it. Absolutely. You know. >> Yeah. I mean, hey, we're talking about
00:44:20
the next generation of humans. Some point they're going to run this place. >> Yes.
00:44:24
>> We got to make sure they're the smartest they possibly can be, you know.
00:44:27
>> Yes. Yes. Absolutely. >> Well, Amanda, once again, thank you so much for coming on and uh and sharing
00:44:34
about the public school experience. >> Maybe, who knows, maybe we'll maybe
00:44:38
you'll be a homeschool parent at some point. Come back on. We'll talk about
00:44:41
that experience for you. We'll see. [laughter] And um yeah, and to my audience, I hope
00:44:46
you guys enjoyed this one. If you did, do all of the internet things you know how to do. Leave a comment, like,
00:44:51
subscribe, all that stuff. Share it with a friend. Uh if you got anything meaningful out of this, please like, let
00:44:57
me know. I I want to know. I want to know what you liked about it. And uh yeah, with that, we'll see you next
00:45:04
week. All right. [music] Peace. >> [music] [music]

Episode Highlights

  • Welcome to the Ex Homeschoolers Club
    Jacob introduces Amanda, a public school teacher, to discuss education experiences.
    “Today I’ve got a very special guest, my cousin Amanda.”
    @ 00m 54s
    February 20, 2026
  • Amanda's Teaching Journey
    Amanda shares her path to becoming a teacher and her experiences in student teaching.
    “I think each year just kind of solidified this is what I want to do.”
    @ 03m 39s
    February 20, 2026
  • The Shift in Second Graders
    Amanda describes the transition from needing help to gaining independence in second grade.
    “They’re doing it on their own. That’s amazing.”
    @ 11m 45s
    February 20, 2026
  • The Shift in Education
    A discussion on the evolving landscape of public education and parental involvement.
    “There’s a hopefulness and dread within the public school system.”
    @ 20m 21s
    February 20, 2026
  • Advocating for Kids
    The importance of parental involvement in advocating for children's educational needs.
    “When parents are involved, kids get services they weren’t getting before.”
    @ 28m 32s
    February 20, 2026
  • Homeschooling Considerations
    Exploring the potential shift to homeschooling and its challenges.
    “I don’t think you really know until you’re in it.”
    @ 33m 44s
    February 20, 2026
  • Hands-On Learning Sticks
    Experiential learning creates lasting memories for students.
    “It’s one thing to read it but then to see it...”
    @ 40m 48s
    February 20, 2026
  • Education is Always Changing
    The landscape of education is continuously evolving, requiring adaptability.
    “Education is always shifting.”
    @ 42m 53s
    February 20, 2026
  • The Importance of Parental Involvement
    Parents must engage with their child's education to ensure success.
    “You have to know what your child is doing.”
    @ 43m 36s
    February 20, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • I have always known you as such a loving and caring person.
    A Public School Teacher's Honest Take on Homeschooling
  • That's amazing. Like once you've shown them, they go off on their own.
    A Public School Teacher's Honest Take on Homeschooling
  • I just see how it can really benefit when kids have those certain interests.
    A Public School Teacher's Honest Take on Homeschooling
  • It’s hard to see that they’re not getting the aid that they need.
    A Public School Teacher's Honest Take on Homeschooling
  • I would have literally killed each other.
    A Public School Teacher's Honest Take on Homeschooling
  • Education is always shifting.
    A Public School Teacher's Honest Take on Homeschooling

Key Moments

  • Homeschooling Perspectives17:41
  • Isolation in Homeschooling18:34
  • Shifting Educational Needs20:04
  • Advocacy in Education21:46
  • Parental Involvement26:24
  • Nostalgia for Second Grade42:21
  • Evolving Education42:53
  • Future Generations44:25

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown