00:00:00
How are you? >> Oh, you're coming out. [laughter] >> What you editing? >> Uh, I was editing Dexter.
00:00:06
>> What do you guys suspect or what do you guys know about what happened? >> Police are speaking with 13-year-old
00:00:14
Hunter and his twin brother Levi. And while they appear clueless now, one of them has just committed a gruesome
00:00:21
murder. We need to talk to uh essentially each of you and we're wondering if we can go down to the
00:00:28
police department. >> I don't know what's going on. Neither do I. >> As the weeksl long investigation
00:00:34
continues, detectives discover that these are no ordinary boys. One of them has spent years obsessively researching
00:00:43
serial killers like Ted Bundy. Now he believes he's executed the perfect murder and can outsmart police. But a
00:00:51
series of childish mistakes would cause his violent fantasies to slowly come to light, leaving his family and the entire
00:00:58
town in utter shock as the monster they feared turns out to be a 13-year-old boy.
00:01:05
>> Find that fool. >> Yes. And he needs to die. >> It's not plausible. There has to be
00:01:10
someone who flooded evidence. What happens now? He's only 13. >> That there's two types of people in this
00:01:16
world. You've got monsters. You've got people who make mistakes. If it was a murder, then it would be a monster,
00:01:23
right? >> It's 2:00 a.m. in the small village of Fairfax, Ohio, and tonight, a 13-year-old boy decides this is the
00:01:37
night he becomes a serial killer. For years, he's been obsessed with true crime content. And with his family
00:01:45
preparing to move away the following week, he's finally ready to put everything he's learned into action.
00:01:52
At 2:30 a.m., he slips out of his house and walks less than 10 ft to his neighbor's house next door. Once inside,
00:02:00
the 13-year-old [music] puts on a pair of gloves, something he learned on YouTube that would prevent him from
00:02:06
leaving behind his DNA. He moves silently through the house before approaching the bedroom of an elderly
00:02:12
woman. At 2:40, he begins strangling her. But despite months of preparation, he quickly realizes [music] this will be
00:02:20
far more difficult than he expected. Because when the woman wakes up, she fights back, punching and brutally
00:02:26
scratching the boy's face. But just minutes later, the woman is dead. Killed at the hands of a little boy. At 3:15
00:02:35
a.m., he's back in his own bed, as if nothing ever happened. It's just past 11:00 a.m. on a Sunday.
00:02:45
Many Fairfax residents are returning home from church when the Fairfax police receive a 911 call unlike anything
00:02:51
they've heard in years. >> 911. What's the location of your emergency? >> Uh 3919
00:02:57
Germaine. I think my sisters might have been murdered and it might be some blood. I I don't know. She did not
00:03:04
respond when I yelled at her. >> All right, sir. I have help coming out there for her. Okay. Do you know that
00:03:09
you might want to harm her or anything like that? >> Absolutely nobody. >> On the line is 61-year-old Daryl
00:03:16
Tenpenney, insisting his sister had been murdered, something almost unheard of in
00:03:21
this area. Moments later, first responders arrive at the house, unaware they are not only walking into a
00:03:27
carefully [music] staged crime scene, but that the killer is still nearby, watching police's every move. [snorts]
00:03:35
Yeah, we'll go ahead and get it out. We'll duplicate this confirmation stuff here. Is this confirmed? Hey, I don't
00:03:41
know if he believes this has been murdered. So, camera on. It's almost been on since I hit the
00:03:49
line. Hold trigger. Just try to touch as least as you guys can. Do what you guys got to do.
00:04:05
>> Yeah. No, I see you have blood. >> Did he Did he cover her up? >> I don't know.
00:04:11
>> The cat the dispatch said that he found her with a pillow over top of her. >> I don't know about peroxide and cleaning
00:04:18
chemicals. >> That's different. >> A lot of cleaning chemicals. >> Bismol. She drink it.
00:04:26
>> I I don't know. >> Well, let me go. You want You want the monitor? >> We have rigger. On the bed lies
00:04:33
64year-old Sheila Tenpenney, partially clothed and deceased for what appears to have been several hours. As officers
00:04:41
continue [music] to inspect the house, they notice nothing appears to be stolen, supporting their working theory
00:04:46
that Sheila may have taken her own life. And with that assumption comes the first
00:04:52
accidental success for the 13-year-old killer, convincing him he's already outsmarted the police. However, what
00:04:59
officers spot next would flip this theory upside down. >> It's just a it's a female DOA
00:05:05
undermania. Just kind of odd all over her face and some chemical. >> Blood and hair underneath your fingers.
00:05:12
>> Blood splatter around the bed. The guy that found her said the door was open and he said that he told the squad that
00:05:18
he thinks she was murdered. >> So, we'll get >> I don't see blood >> from her. >> So, that might not be confirmed.
00:05:29
Who knows? That's police work. I don't mean to overstep. >> No, you're good. I pills.
00:05:34
>> Yeah. I mean, it's possible. Yeah. >> While the blood and hair beneath Sheila's fingernails certainly raise
00:05:41
suspicions, investigators still refuse to rule out the possibility of this being self-inflicted. But before they
00:05:48
send Sheila's body for autopsy, there's still [music] something that doesn't sit
00:05:52
right with them. They're baffled by how certain the victim's brother, Daryl, seemed that his sister had been
00:05:58
assaulted before paramedics had even suggested that possibility. And with that statement alone, he has unknowingly
00:06:06
made himself their first suspect. So, they decide to ask him a few questions. How you doing, sir?
00:06:13
>> Oh, I mean, obviously not great. Um, I'm officer War Fair Police Department. When's the last time that you that you
00:06:18
do you know [music] yesterday? >> Yesterday. Do you know what time about or you talk to? Did you talk to her or
00:06:23
is this here? I seen her and actually 7:09 p.m. is the last message I got from her. Is there any Was there anything
00:06:32
that is she was she struggling with anything? I mean mentally, physically? >> No. Nothing at all? No,
00:06:38
>> she's pretty. >> Okay. Okay. So, you made a comment to these guys when they first got here that
00:06:41
you thought like she first she well she was laying on the bed with her legs spread and it looked like there was
00:06:47
blood and her head was had stuff on top of like they someone tried to splut her and she and she looked like they ripped
00:06:54
her thing open and I yelled at her and she and I didn't see no movement from her whatsoever and I just turned around
00:07:00
and walked out. I I like it. I >> Interestingly, Daryl never mentions performing CPR. And [music] while police
00:07:08
now know it likely wouldn't have saved Sheila, that's not something Daryl would have known for sure. And right here
00:07:15
comes the second lucky break for the teen killer because every good murder needs a fall guy. And the police have
00:07:22
just taken the bait with Daryl. Shortly afterwards, Daryl's interview wraps up, the scene is secured, and
00:07:29
officers return to the station to await the autopsy results. But as investigators leave the house, they
00:07:34
would overlook a crucial piece of evidence. Lying beneath Sheila Ten Penneyy's body was a men's wristwatch, a
00:07:41
seemingly insignificant detail that would later become one of the key pieces of evidence used to solve the entire
00:07:48
case. One week passes and then comes the update investigators have been waiting for. The forensic and DNA results
00:07:57
arrive, completely overturning their initial assumptions. Investigators determined that Sheila Tenpenney had
00:08:03
suffered blunt force trauma to the head and neck before ultimately being strangled to death. But they also
00:08:08
confirmed something crucial. Sheila had managed to fight back. On her hands and beneath her fingernails are traces of
00:08:15
blood and toughs of hair. DNA belonging to an unknown male. With these disturbing findings, there is no longer
00:08:22
any question. This is a homicide. So, early Monday morning, officers returned to the neighborhood, going
00:08:31
doortodoor in search of anyone Sheila may have wronged and anyone with fresh defensive wounds. But in reality, the
00:08:37
detectives couldn't be more off track. While the young killer quietly brags about the murder online, growing more
00:08:44
confident by the hour, knowing the victim had absolutely no enemies. [music] And as police begin surveying
00:08:51
the neighborhood, they have no idea which interaction will bring them face to face with Sheila's killer. So, you're
00:08:58
one of the trusted family members. What we're doing is getting elimination DNA from anybody we talk to as long as
00:09:05
you're willing. Thank you very much. And then how about your hand? Just let me double check your hands. cuz I know you
00:09:09
work with them on the air side. Yeah, that's great. >> I can't believe they haven't got a lead
00:09:14
or anything. >> Uh there's a lot going on, I'll say. Um so this is just part of the process.
00:09:21
>> Here's my card before I forget in case you have anything else or [music] >> need to reach out. I uh email and phone
00:09:27
numbers on there. >> Find that full and he needs to die. >> Yeah. Um >> capital punishment.
00:09:33
>> Well, I wish we did that more often to be honest with you. So >> I mean, you know, if he gets out, he
00:09:37
going to do it again. And you you can't you don't fix that. Yeah, >> you don't fix that.
00:09:41
>> I agree. >> Okay, you're good there. I'm going come up here soon. I know this is a pain in
00:09:46
the ass, man. But I definitely appreciate it. >> So, you guys think this is a random
00:09:51
thing or >> uh I want to say no. I I do. >> Well, but from what I've heard, you know, the guy down in that new house
00:10:00
over there and a couple others, I've been out here having my cigarette. I hear >> I think the brother did. They're going
00:10:07
to arrest him in a couple three days. I'm like, what? >> They think the brother did it, huh?
00:10:11
>> No. >> Why? Any any reason why they think that? >> I don't know. >> That's just a speculation right now.
00:10:19
>> That's interesting. >> After speaking with more than a dozen people, officers uncover a major new
00:10:25
rumor. Many in the village suspect Sheila's own brother, Daryl, is responsible. With this as their only
00:10:33
real lead, another team of officers led by special agent Richard Ward makes a surprise visit to Daryl's house less
00:10:40
than a mile away. And for the actual killer, the plan appears to be working even better than he imagined. Suspicion
00:10:46
has successfully shifted onto Sheila's own family member, pulling detectives completely off his trail as they begin
00:10:52
focusing in on Daryl. For now though, officers have just arrived at Daryl's house where it would soon become clear
00:10:58
just how lucky the kid got and why Daryl makes the perfect fall guy. >> I'm still getting a little loss of my
00:11:06
mother and I have >> I know >> straighten anything out and now this. Now I got more to deal with.
00:11:15
>> Oh, you weren't lying. >> Yeah. Well, these over here are all these boxes. Where do you hang out at?
00:11:22
Come in here. >> Oh, >> hey. I need to ask you a favor. Just I want to remember I got you swabs. I need
00:11:29
you one more thing. Could you just show me your shirt underneath your shirt that
00:11:33
you don't I just want to make sure I want to satisfy myself. >> I don't think you would ever hurt
00:11:39
anybody. >> No. >> Okay. Throw your shirt back on. >> So, you have any idea when the funeral
00:11:46
is going to be? >> They won't release the body yet. >> I don't know. Nobody's contacted us. I
00:11:53
>> was going to I was going to contact I was going to send you a message this morning to say
00:11:59
>> we are okay with that because we want this person. >> Suffice it to say, Detective Ward is
00:12:06
taken aback [music] by Daryl's unusual living situation, but still no scratches. And so the investigation
00:12:13
takes a step back. There is seemingly no one they can tie to the murder. No enemies, no leads, nothing. But that's
00:12:21
because they're looking at this crime completely the wrong way. With the investigation at a standstill,
00:12:28
officers canvasing the area continue knocking on doors until they reach the neighbor directly across the street just
00:12:34
50 ft from the victim's home. It's one of the homes where no one answered earlier. And as they approach the front
00:12:40
door, the homeowner, Rebecca, steps outside, unaware that in the next few minutes, her life is about to be turned
00:12:49
upside down. >> So, I don't know when it actually happened. I know that we saw like the
00:12:54
trucks on or cars or whatever on Sunday. So, um, and actually Sunday morning at like 6:00 a.m., um, I we had to run to
00:13:04
the ER because my son, oh, >> the cat, I guess, was sleeping on his face and they startled each other in the
00:13:11
dark. >> Oh, man. >> And it scratched him and so we were worried that it was could be bad or
00:13:15
infected and he >> Yeah, he's fine. Okay. >> It wasn't a big deal, but it was just
00:13:19
like traumatizing and I was like, "Everybody get in the car." Just a few feet away, 13-year-old Levi
00:13:26
Cart looks through the living room window and notices his mother speaking with police officers. Panicking, he
00:13:33
pauses the YouTube video he was watching, runs up to his room, and locks the door. Back outside, officers begin
00:13:40
piecing things together. The boy with fresh scratches across his body could very well be tied to Sheila's murder. In
00:13:47
a few moments, detectives will step inside to follow up on this lead. But what they will soon find will defy their
00:13:54
expectations. But before we get to that, it's worth noting that covering stories like this,
00:14:00
you've realized just how much people are forced to carry. Fear, trauma, even the
00:14:05
day-to-day burden of surviving. And sometimes that weight shows up in other ways, too, like debt. Do you feel
00:14:11
crushed by debt? Those highinterest loans, that mountain of credit card debt, or even the overwhelming medical
00:14:17
bills. All the debt that has been keeping you up at night could be gone quicker than you think. Imagine being
00:14:22
debtree, not in 10 years, but in as little as just 2 years. Think about that relief. You can finally feel free. PDS
00:14:29
[music] Debt are experts at making this happen. They know precisely how to negotiate with the companies you owe,
00:14:35
strategically working to get you a resolution where you owe them significantly less and can be relieved
00:14:40
of your debt. They listen to your unique situation to create a personalized plan
00:14:44
that works [music] regardless of your credit score. There's no minimum required to see how they can help you.
00:14:50
They tackle credit cards, personal loans, collections, medical bills. Finding the right solution to save you
00:14:55
money and get you debtree faster, putting you back in control, and their results speak for themselves. BDS Debt
00:15:01
holds an A+ Better Business Bureau rating, boasts hundreds of five-star reviews on Google and Trust Pilot.
00:15:07
That's because they've helped tens [music] of thousands of people break free of debt. Stop living in debt. Get
00:15:13
your free assessment and find the best option for you right now at pdsd.com/inssanity.
00:15:20
You're just 30 seconds away from starting to get out of debt. That's pds debt.com/inssanity.
00:15:27
With that said, let's get back to the scene where detectives are about to go inside Rebecca's house. Unknown to them,
00:15:34
what they're about to find inside will be nothing like they expect. >> Do you care if we come in or you want
00:15:40
them? Okay. Thank you. >> The only reason we're outside. >> All right. I do have two cats, though.
00:15:46
So, >> no problem. >> Come on in. >> Hey guys. >> Hello. >> Do you want to do you want to come out
00:15:56
here or No. >> Why? [snorts] Um, I haven't been really transparent about what they have across the street and
00:16:04
people who are investigating are talking to everybody and they just want me to talk to everybody who lives.
00:16:17
>> Hey bud, can I talk to you? >> Do you want to talk in the living room or do you want to talk in your room?
00:16:22
There are people who are here on the house. Um, something that happened in our tree earlier this week.
00:16:28
>> What game are you playing over there? >> Is he gaming? >> Yeah, he is. >> Dexter.
00:16:35
>> Oh, [laughter] he's uh he's cap cutting. >> Oh, hi. >> Oh, and this is cool. >> Now you are Hunter. Hunter.
00:16:42
>> You want to come sit down? >> Naturally, this is not the suspect the detectives were hoping to see. As
00:16:49
13-year-old Hunter Cart enters the room, realizing they may have jumped to conclusions, the detectives still begin
00:16:56
to question the boy. Perhaps he knows something after all. >> Um, so we're have your criminal
00:17:03
investigation and we're just talking to people to see if they might have heard or seen anything unusual that happened
00:17:08
over the weekend. >> Um, no. Uh, >> sorry. >> Would you stop me to ask? >> Yeah.
00:17:16
>> Yeah. Um, my brother got into an injury and he had to go to the ER. >> I got really sick and started vomiting
00:17:24
and stuff. >> So, >> how are you feeling? >> A lot better. But >> that's good. >> That whole day was just kind of a blur
00:17:33
for everybody. Unless it's something that happened a long time ago that's memorable. It's not really something I
00:17:40
remember unless it like is really really brought up. Although Hunter is unable to
00:17:45
provide any new details, he seems fairly cooperative and willing to help. His twin brother, Levi, on the other hand,
00:17:52
is still in his room, refusing to come out. Earlier, their mother had mentioned Levi was editing Dexter, [music]
00:17:59
a crime drama centered around a vigilante serial killer, a show both detectives are all too familiar with.
00:18:05
And it's here the detectives would begin to realize their initial hunch about Rebecca's sons may not have been a
00:18:12
coincidence after all. >> Yeah, it's usually never quick, but that's actually pretty quick.
00:18:18
>> How are you now? >> Oh, you're coming out. [laughter] >> What you editing? >> Uh, I was editing Dexter. Sometimes I
00:18:23
edit. >> Yeah, >> but >> he likes to make uh videos for Tik Tok, but >> Oh, yeah.
00:18:28
>> Oh, nice. >> Is that the cat that got you there on the nose? >> I don't know. I don't know what
00:18:34
happened. We just >> we both startled each other cuz my bed was right there. >> Yeah. His bed was out here
00:18:42
>> and >> until all the lights were off. >> Okay. >> Uh so we've been knowing for a while
00:18:48
that we needed to uh that we needed to cut their nails. Hunter's been saying that for a long time. I felt so guilty
00:18:57
when I had >> So, us moving, I mean, we know, everybody knows that cats just are
00:19:03
awkward. So, us moving, uh, Marshmallow being weird because we're moving. And >> is Marshmallow the cat?
00:19:10
>> Yes. And >> we had a uh like a play set for them >> and they we uh packed it up. So, that's
00:19:20
also probably another thing. So yeah, me and him [music] just randomly saw each other. Uh he scraped me on the neck. I'm
00:19:29
not sure if you can see. >> Okay. Where else did you get it? >> Uh he kind of scraped me on my face a
00:19:35
little bit. >> Five. >> Uh and then mainly my nose >> and I was trying to clean Yeah. I was
00:19:43
trying to clean myself up. >> Yeah. Five stitches. >> It was pretty deep. >> Pretty deep.
00:19:49
>> Uh nose there. We went back to the house after the we got out of the doctor. >> Mhm.
00:19:58
>> And then that's when we saw the ambulances. I don't know. A lot of it's a blur because I tried to clean myself
00:20:05
up. So I was distracted in the shower. >> Okay. >> Interestingly, both brothers use the
00:20:11
same word blur when recalling the incident. And while traumatic events, even something like death of a neighbor,
00:20:18
can affect memory, what catches officers attention far more is the way Levi seems
00:20:23
to overexlain what happened. [music] He claims the deep scratches came from a fight with a house cat. Something
00:20:29
officers find difficult to believe given the severity of the wounds. So with this
00:20:34
in mind, detectives believe that despite their young age, the brothers have given
00:20:38
them enough probable cause to take the next step. The detectives ask to speak with Rebecca
00:20:45
outside for a moment where they request permission to collect DNA from both of her sons. Without much hesitation, she
00:20:52
agrees. But when the three of them return, one of the brothers would have a very different reaction to being tested.
00:20:58
>> Do you mind if I come? I can explain it to you. Um, >> yeah. He's feeling a little overwhelmed
00:21:04
by this. So, >> yeah. I just feel like I don't I've been to enough doctors recently. I don't want
00:21:09
to. So, the Have you seen any like crime shows or anything? You know how how we kind of do our job. The medical stuff's
00:21:15
a little different than the law enforcement stuff, but um I don't know if she explained to you, but we're just
00:21:20
going to swab your cheek and it's not going to go into any database or anything, but we're going to compare it
00:21:25
against stuff that we have. That makes sense. >> Okay. >> And it will take 2 seconds. It's just
00:21:32
you don't have to do anything. >> [clears throat] >> But obviously we're asking everybody on
00:21:36
the street and uh it would be super helpful if you could >> Okay. >> And you're Levi, right? Or you go
00:21:48
>> by Louis. >> Louis. Okay. >> It'll be easier if you sit down >> for your legs. [music]
00:21:54
I don't have to do it first. >> I can do it first. I'll show you guys. I can be the guinea pig, too. It's what
00:22:01
I do that all the way. The detectives proceed to take DNA swabs from both brothers, though Hunter and Rebecca are
00:22:09
clearly far more willing to cooperate than Levi. But what one of the brothers doesn't seem to realize is that the more
00:22:15
he talks, the more the Cart brothers begin to look less like witnesses and more like suspects.
00:22:21
>> Louis has a few scars on his back, but it's just from my >> Oh, yeah. You could show them. Sorry.
00:22:28
>> Oh, yeah. >> It looks pretty mentally evasive. It was two years ago. Um, >> yeah, it was a lot.
00:22:36
>> It didn't look like that. >> I keep mentioning things [snorts] without your permission.
00:22:43
>> How does it feel to have any scars? >> Dr. Stevenson, it's where they go in and
00:22:47
they >> How does it feel to have nerve root that links to your leg? >> What do you guys suspect or what do you
00:22:54
guys know about what happened? >> Well, I can tell you this. it shouldn't have happened and we need to figure out
00:23:01
why it happened so that you [clears throat] know hopefully we can keep it from happening again because
00:23:06
we'd hate to miss some evidence and if you've watched any TV we don't want to be those cops that forgot to do this or
00:23:12
look into that >> plenty watching the true crimes kind of >> but it's a lot differently
00:23:20
>> me and my brother especially my brother know a lot I would say definitely my brother knows a lot about um
00:23:30
just the police in general. Um >> he wants to go into the Marines when he gets older.
00:23:36
>> Oh, nice. >> Well, recruitment >> is always there. Everybody's looking for >> Yeah,
00:23:42
>> those are hard spots to fill anymore. >> I don't get >> Yeah, there's there's a spot for
00:23:47
everybody in my opinion. >> Me and Louis have both agreed that him especially is a lot more mature than
00:23:54
most kids our age. Oh, so you can handle this news? >> You guys are handling it pretty well.
00:24:00
>> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> Strangely, Hunter continues offering interesting details without being
00:24:06
prompted, insisting that the teen brothers are far more mature than most kids their age. And when he brings up
00:24:13
Levi's injuries, Levi becomes visibly uncomfortable, giving his brother a long, chilling stare. By the end of the
00:24:22
interview, the twins no longer seem like ordinary kids to [music] the detectives.
00:24:27
Their fascination with true crime, gory shows like Dexter, foggy memory, and of course, the [music] hard to explain cat
00:24:34
scratches on Levi all point towards something deeply unsettling. With DNA collected, investigators return to the
00:24:41
station to brief the sergeant on everything they've uncovered. Now all they can do is wait for the DNA results
00:24:47
from Daryl, the Cart Twins, and several neighbors and family friends to come back the following day. Still believing
00:24:53
a deranged killer may be at work, investigators know that until he or they are caught, no one in this quiet village
00:25:00
is truly safe. The next day, the DNA results finally come in, and investigators are stunned.
00:25:11
Both of Rebecca's sons are a match, but that doesn't necessarily mean they were both at the scene. According to the
00:25:17
forensic analyst, the lab cannot tell Levi's DNA apart from Hunters because identical twins share the same STR
00:25:24
markers. Needless to say, investigators are now facing an extraordinarily rare problem. But even with these findings,
00:25:32
detectives struggle to process the fact that the suspects are only 13 years old.
00:25:37
Not only would they have to be deeply disturbed, but they would also need the physical strength to carry out a crime
00:25:42
this violent. Then again, their age could also work in the investigator's favor. Teenagers are more likely to slip
00:25:48
up, confess to friends or family, or leave evidence of their actions somewhere online. The problem is,
00:25:54
detectives have enough probable cause for a search warrant, but not enough to formally detain Rebecca or either
00:26:01
brother, something they absolutely cannot let the family realize. Nevertheless, they return to the family
00:26:07
home, hoping they can persuade Rebecca to bring her sons to the station, allowing investigators to begin
00:26:13
searching the house the moment they leave. But the situation is incredibly delicate. One wrong move could spook the
00:26:20
family and shut down the entire investigation. >> Hello back. >> Hi, we're back. Yeah.
00:26:27
>> How are you? I was >> You left your keys in the door. >> We just walked in the house.
00:26:32
>> Uh do you need to come in? What's going on? >> Yeah, that'd be great. We have a couple
00:26:36
things to talk about. >> Okay. >> Hi guys. >> We just sat down to eat. What did >> you guys get?
00:26:43
>> Thanks. >> Um, do you just need me or? >> Yeah. >> So, um, >> are all three of you here?
00:26:49
>> Are all three of you here? >> Yeah. >> You going need to be nervous? >> It's making me feel nervous.
00:26:59
>> Relax. You're okay. >> You're good. Yeah. You want to take a seat somewhere? Yeah.
00:27:04
Okay. >> It's okay. You want to go sit down so it's a little less weird? >> Yeah. Come on in. Just relax.
00:27:14
>> Yeah, you guys are good. >> Okay. Do you guys want to sit down here? You feel more comfortable?
00:27:20
>> Hey, Louis. >> Sure. >> Did you get kings, too? >> Yes. We literally just walked in the
00:27:25
door >> here. We need to talk to uh essentially each of you. >> And we're wondering if we can go down to
00:27:31
the police department. Uh just we have a a better area to talk. >> Okay. >> Okay.
00:27:37
>> So, if you guys want, let's uh put some shoes and socks on, maybe a coat, and
00:27:42
then uh we'll head head that way. >> Clearly, detectives didn't arrive with a strong plan and are instead relying
00:27:49
heavily on improvisation. Somehow though, despite not having their answers fully prepared, they appear to be
00:27:56
succeeding in getting the family to the station voluntarily. But that can only work for so long before someone catches
00:28:02
on. >> Uh, do we need to be getting lawyers or something? I'm feeling >> nervous about this. I don't
00:28:12
>> You're welcome to call an attorney. Um, >> also um like do we have to go? Is this like right now thing or is
00:28:23
>> we would like you to it would make Yeah. >> You don't have to do anything I suppose.
00:28:30
>> Right. Okay. >> I don't know. I feel uncomfortable. I'm not >> We could How about we we get there, we
00:28:37
can explain kind of what's going on, give you some more info. You can always, you know.
00:28:41
>> Okay. Well, do you want us what's going on before we head out there? And >> uh Do you mind if we do that outside?
00:28:46
>> Sure. >> Sure. >> Do you guys want to wait a second? Is that what you mean? Oh,
00:28:50
>> all three of you outside if if possible. >> Okay. We just need to we need to go over
00:28:55
some things in the neighborhood with you, ma'am. We could go back up here so we don't have to sit in the rain.
00:28:59
>> Yeah. >> And we got some some pictures I want to show you and I'll show you and your sons
00:29:05
and there's a bunch of stuff we want to talk to you about. So, >> all right. You guys good?
00:29:11
>> Are we under suspicion for something or >> We just want to talk to you. I think you
00:29:16
guys could help us clear a lot of things up around here. So, >> okay. >> All right. All right. Let's go.
00:29:25
>> Hey, John. Yes, sir. >> And he'll ride with you. >> Okay, that that works. >> All right. Before we get I just got to
00:29:35
make sure there's nothing on you that's going to stick me, poke me, cut me. Yep.
00:29:38
All right. Actually, if you want to step over there to him right there. >> All right. You can just have a seat
00:29:43
right there for me. Yeah. Do we have to put this on you for the >> whole three blocks we're driving?
00:29:58
>> Probably. So, I mean, but there's nothing that we can't talk about. >> Yeah. I don't know what's going on.
00:30:06
>> Neither do I. >> All very, very unexpected. >> My anxiety levels went through the roof.
00:30:16
Oh, >> I don't know why there's so many like police vehicles either. >> Yeah, [clears throat] that's definitely
00:30:22
what scared me. >> Seeing all the cops immediately pull up. Like one person's there, didn't see that
00:30:29
other cop got pull up and then >> I was just like, >> why are they What's the reason?
00:30:34
>> I'm sure I don't know. Maybe it's an intimidation tactic, >> I guess. But what are they trying to
00:30:40
intimidate us? Right. Miraculously, despite the detective's sloppy handling of the situation and
00:30:46
Rebecca's growing skepticism, they still managed to convince the family to come to the station. For now, they've
00:30:52
purposely [music] kept the twins together, hoping the cameras might catch something incriminating. But the
00:30:57
brothers have seen this tactic [music] before and say nothing, foolishly convinced they're outsmarting the
00:31:03
police. Investigators have also just confiscated their phones and obtained house keys from Rebecca, allowing them
00:31:09
to begin searching the home for any evidence tying the boys to the crime. But despite these small victories, this
00:31:15
is where detectives would face a major reality check about their strategy. Upon arriving at the station, the twins
00:31:23
are quietly escorted through a separate entrance and separated from their mother. The twins don't seem
00:31:29
particularly worried, calmly following detectives into the interrogation rooms. But for Rebecca, the situation is very
00:31:37
different because the moment she's finally informed that her sons are about to be questioned without her present,
00:31:44
all hell breaks loose. >> I don't want food. I want our lawyer and have my children stop being questioned
00:31:53
without a lawyer present immediately. Okay. >> So, let's make that happen. >> I don't know who you know who's doing
00:32:00
what wire. >> Nope. But I can uh >> go get that figured out for you. We need to have them right now. Okay. Yeah.
00:32:05
Okay. >> I got it. >> My slippers. We just got home from the doctor's office. >> So comfy.
00:32:12
>> They are comfy on Amazon. >> Not uh Yeah. >> On Amazon. People are so against them.
00:32:17
>> Really? I know you're being friendly. I need to know that my children are not
00:32:22
being questioned now that they have a lawyer. You didn't let us know that we're being detained.
00:32:26
>> You're not being detained. You're free to go. >> No, you didn't let us know that you were
00:32:30
detaining my children. >> They're free to leave. >> You did not right now. They're allowed
00:32:35
to leave right now. Let's go right now. Right now. You said they're allowed to leave. Yes or no?
00:32:44
>> You cannot take them. >> Clearly, this is not how detectives hoped things would go. Rebecca is
00:32:51
furious, and not without reason. The detective just admitted that the boys are free to leave, yet does nothing when
00:32:59
Rebecca demands exactly that. On top of that, her phone has been confiscated, making it impossible for her to even
00:33:06
call the lawyer. It's here that the risk behind the detective's strategy, or lack
00:33:11
thereof, becomes impossible to ignore. The advantage of this approach is that by withholding the real reason the boys
00:33:18
are there, detectives limit the information the suspects can tailor their stories to, making contradictions
00:33:24
and inconsistencies much easier to catch later. That said, when those suspects are minors and detectives need their
00:33:31
mother's cooperation, [music] this strategy can quickly backfire, undermining trust and damaging the
00:33:37
legitimacy of the entire process. And unsurprisingly, Rebecca's outrage is only beginning as she storms out of the
00:33:44
interrogation room in search of anyone willing to tell her what's really going on.
00:33:49
>> Are you accusing them of murder? >> I don't know. >> Is that why they're being detained?
00:33:55
Because they're under suspicion for murder. >> They're questioning to find out if they
00:33:58
know any additional details. >> How would they know anything unless you were accusing them of murder and you
00:34:04
think that they murdered someone? So that's >> I'm saying this whole charade, this
00:34:09
whole the way we've gone about this and approached it and slowly showed things to me because I've asked questions and
00:34:16
not because you are transparent is not okay. It literally just says we have the ability to search all of your
00:34:24
belongings. It doesn't say for what reason would they want to search the >> It says for murder
00:34:30
>> because we're investigating the murder of the neighbor. >> Yeah. And my 13-year-olds have not
00:34:34
murdered any. >> Okay. Well, we're trying to find further information that was dissolved yesterday
00:34:39
to put the pieces together. >> So, I'm not going to be told anything. >> Why am I not being questioned?
00:34:53
>> We would love to talk to you if you would be willing to talk. >> I'm literally standing here waiting.
00:34:57
>> Well, we were trying to talk to you, but you want to make phone calls and do all
00:35:00
those things. If you'd like to talk, we can talk. You're well aware >> I'm fake.
00:35:06
>> Fake. >> So >> a lot and nothing because they're not telling me anything. >> Well, I would assume because
00:35:15
>> I asked for a lawyer for the boys. He's saying because we talked yesterday. >> I'm asking him.
00:35:21
>> Sorry. I'm really worked up. I No, I understand. I understand. You have every
00:35:25
right to be worked up. I'm just trying to I'm just trying to sort it out. >> All right. I'll let you.
00:35:28
>> So, under under what grounds are they being questioned? What prompted them? There was a happened across the street.
00:35:32
>> I understand that. But what what specifically about our boys is causing you guys to bring them to the station
00:35:38
for questioning? >> Those details I don't know because those investigators know more about that than
00:35:43
I do. >> Um, >> are there other are you guys bringing in every neighbor to >> We did 25 yesterday. I know myself and
00:35:51
another agent >> in to the station. >> Well, I don't know how many people got brought here. Um, this is we're also
00:35:57
doing a search warrant at the house, too. So, a judge has granted us >> search warrant for her house and who
00:36:02
else? >> Well, the the search warrant is for the house and the vehicle on the property.
00:36:07
>> Our house and the vehicle property. [clears throat] >> Were there other search warrants for
00:36:11
otherware? >> You guys are questioning two 13year-old boys. >> Well, we're not. Someone is. You're absolutely correct.
00:36:19
But I don't know. >> You know what I'm saying? I do. >> This is why we need our lawyer down here
00:36:24
now. We need to make this happen. I don't have a phone. So, this needs to happen on your end
00:36:31
immediately, whoever we call. >> After getting little to no answers from the detectives, the twins father calls a
00:36:38
lawyer, hoping he can intervene. But even with legal counsel now on the way, detectives press forward with the
00:36:44
interviews, fully aware of the risk they're taking. At the same time, ever since the boys left with the police, a
00:36:51
search of their home has been underway. And very soon, it will begin yielding crucial evidence for the interrogations.
00:36:59
As both [music] brothers wait for their interrogations to begin, it quickly becomes clear that one of them is about
00:37:05
to be treated very differently. Because Hunter had been significantly more talkative the day before, detectives opt
00:37:11
for a more casual, friendly approach. And even his interrogation room reflects that. Levi, on the other hand, is placed
00:37:18
in a cold, cramped room, subjected to the kind of interrogation tactics typically reserved for an adult suspect.
00:37:25
Based on the scratch marks alone, detectives strongly suspect Levi is the killer. But there is still nothing
00:37:31
ruling out the possibility that Hunter may have helped him, especially after learning that Levi has significant
00:37:36
mobility issues. Now, with a lawyer on the way to the station and two furious parents pacing outside, the clock is
00:37:44
ticking. So, detectives split into two groups to question the boys simultaneously. And as the questioning
00:37:51
begins, Hunter's interview escalates far quicker than expected because there's something he needs to get off his chest.
00:37:58
>> Just so you know, I don't feel pressured doing this. I >> You don't? >> Um, of course, I feel a little pressure, but
00:38:09
I don't feel like I have to sign those. >> Okay. >> I don't know. It's more suspicion is put
00:38:14
on me if I don't answer any questions. So, >> yeah, we're here to talk, ask questions,
00:38:19
get your story. I know you told Lauren a little bit. >> Um, can I say something?
00:38:24
>> Yeah. Uh, I want to say um I don't think my brother would be able to do anything like that. But because
00:38:33
that day he got scratches on his face because of that day he it all seems like a very wide coincidence, you know, cuz
00:38:40
of course his cat was face his fat. His face was scratched by a cat. We talked about it and it certainly looks like
00:38:48
Louis has some like the coincidences are there. At this early stage of the interview,
00:38:56
Hunter, completely unprompted, begins talking about the scratch wounds, which he believes are the most concrete
00:39:03
evidence against his brother. But while he frames it as a coincidence, back at the house, police executing the search
00:39:09
warrant notice something that immediately casts doubt on the story. On Rebecca's bed, they find the family cat,
00:39:15
Marshmallow, sitting completely calm. But more importantly, the cat's claws seem far too small to match the injuries
00:39:24
on Levi. This information is relayed back to detectives at the station where Hunter and Levi are being interviewed.
00:39:30
And while Hunter appears eager to talk, Levi's interview is moving far more slowly. As detectives focus on building
00:39:37
rapport and choosing their words extremely carefully. So, seeing just how much more talkative Hunter is,
00:39:43
investigators keep their focus on him for now, hoping he can offer further insight into his brother or perhaps even
00:39:50
turn on him. >> He He had extra like red scratch marks on his face. I mean, that seems
00:39:58
obviously suspicious, but like I said, I don't think you could do something like
00:40:04
that. I'm going to keep saying this, but this makes me feel really upset because
00:40:08
a lot of evidence is piled up against him, but like I mean, I don't know if you guys suspect
00:40:14
him of anything, but I truly don't believe he he could do anything like that. Even though he has all these things,
00:40:32
>> he's never talked about anything like that with you >> because we agree >> like what
00:40:39
about hurting somebody or when he gets triggered he gets upset and acting out and just saying things or you know I
00:40:46
don't know how he behaves when he's triggered. >> No no like I said um no he doesn't
00:40:50
behave weirdly when triggered. He just doesn't he's just quiet. It's upsetting for him. Like he
00:40:59
started crying when he got back to this house cuz he he said he never gave us an explanation as to
00:41:08
why he's triggered. But >> interestingly, although Hunter describes the suspicious behavior he's noticed
00:41:15
from his brother, he continues to insist that Levi could not actually be responsible for the murder. But
00:41:21
detectives can't tell whether his reaction is genuine or part of a calculated effort to distance himself
00:41:27
from the crime. At this stage though, they're fairly certain Levi is the culprit and decide it's time to stop
00:41:34
speculating and focus on something more concrete. So, they turn to a key piece of evidence Hunter can't deny. Something
00:41:40
they had kept hidden from the twins. A watch recovered from beneath Sheila's body. One investigators initially
00:41:48
dismissed, but now strongly suspect belongs to one of the two boys. And whether he realizes it or not, what he
00:41:55
says next would seal their fate. >> Do you recognize that? >> That's Louis's far. That's Louis's
00:42:02
watch. >> Louis's watch. Yeah. >> Okay. >> All right. What do you think about that?
00:42:07
Uh, >> what do you mean about that? Okay. >> Let me widen it out. That's the picture.
00:42:13
What do you think that's a picture of? Try to take some deep breaths in there. >> We don't have any of those links,
00:42:22
>> right? >> It's not your house. >> No, I remember him saying that he lost his watch.
00:42:32
>> And when did he say that? >> After he after he got home. Also, he I'll show you one more.
00:42:46
>> He he sounded he the way he said I don't know where my watch is. I don't feel a
00:42:51
person could say that the a person say it that way knowing that you know they were their watch when
00:43:00
[music] if they did that. >> Are you saying he purposefully >> hurt? >> We don't we don't know what his you know
00:43:11
what his purpose was. We just made a mistake. >> How would he even do that? He's
00:43:18
disabled. >> How would he >> sneak out of the house, get into the house, stab somebody?
00:43:27
Is it true that he that them? >> Is that true? >> We >> Did you find DNA evidence?
00:43:36
>> We're not going to. >> Yeah. So, >> there's no way you would do that. There's some stuff that happened that we
00:43:41
can't give you details about. >> There's no way >> you have. >> There's no way. >> If he
00:43:54
There's no way. It's not plausible. There has to be someone who evidence. There has to be some misunderstanding.
00:44:12
>> At the thought of his own brother being responsible for the murder, Hunter appears to completely break down.
00:44:19
Detectives realize he's now too emotional and overwhelmed to provide any more reliable information. So, they
00:44:25
decide to end the interview. Despite failing to secure a confession and not fully ruling him out as a suspect, still
00:44:33
they've learned something important. More insight into Levi and confirmation that his watch was indeed at the scene.
00:44:41
But just outside the interrogation room, the boy's parents continue arguing with
00:44:46
deputies. And with a lawyer coming to intervene, investigators are running out of time. If they want to secure an
00:44:52
admission before the interview is shut down, they know they need to raise the [music] stakes with Levi. So, the
00:44:58
detectives interviewing him finally move on from building rapport and shifts the
00:45:02
conversation to the scratches, testing whether his explanation matches the one he gave the day before.
00:45:08
>> Do you know what we're investigating? >> M I mean, I know something happened on the
00:45:14
street. >> Across the street? >> Across the street in front of me. >> Right. A woman was murdered, right? So,
00:45:21
we're trying to find out what happened. >> I mean, I've already talked to FBI investigators. My cat had randomly woke
00:45:29
me up uh with all the lights off like sitting on my sitting on my my neck. So it like scratched my face. I felt very
00:45:42
bloody obviously. There was a lot of scratches on me. Usually because my disability as well uh I uh use like a
00:45:52
like a shower chair. >> Yeah. because I can't really stand for that long >> without getting like super fatigued and
00:45:58
falling or walking around too long. I didn't use the shower chair cuz I didn't want to make a bunch of noise and make
00:46:04
anybody up. >> Uh so I ended up literally falling uh and I fell and like hit my head on the
00:46:13
on the shower hose. >> Where'd you hit it at? >> Uh I think like around here like right
00:46:20
here. >> So I I don't know. Does that cause you to bleed more? >> Yes. Yes. >> As Levi once again overexlains the
00:46:30
incident, detectives notice he makes a point of emphasizing that the injuries became worse after he slipped in the
00:46:36
shower. But something else in Levi's account immediately stands out. After mentioning his medical condition,
00:46:42
detectives recall reviewing his records and discovering that Levi has cerebral pulsy. This brings the detectives back
00:46:49
to an earlier question. Not only is Levi just 13 years old, but his disability raises serious doubts about whether he
00:46:57
was even physically capable of carrying out such a violent attack on his own, especially considering Sheila fought
00:47:04
back. Investigators know Hunter is physically stronger, has no disability, and shares many of the same interests in
00:47:11
true crime as his brother Levi. At this point, detectives are realizing they may
00:47:15
have prematurely cleared Hunter, treating him more like a witness than a suspect. and in doing so may have lost
00:47:22
their chance to implicate him. But with the pressure mounting on Levi, this may be the perfect opportunity for him to
00:47:28
turn on his brother. [music] And for the first time during his interview, the bond between the twins is about to be
00:47:35
truly [music] tested. >> We get in and like [clears throat] 15 minutes, 15 minutes later, uh
00:47:44
mom starts seeing a bunch of sirens outside. Uh, and [clears throat] she opens the
00:47:50
window and she's like, "Oh my god, something happened to Denise." And me already in a like a panicked weird
00:47:59
state, I kind of started feeling emotionally triggered. And when she said, "Uh, there was a bunch of
00:48:04
ambulances outside." She or I, uh, I like started to freak out even more. I just felt even worse because mom had
00:48:16
said that something had happened to Denise, our neighbor, right in front of us. >> Um, and I started feeling even worse.
00:48:24
Um, just to the fact that the same night that something happened or something like that had happened that um,
00:48:35
that I had had an injury of my own. >> [clears throat] >> Although Levi never directly blames his
00:48:40
twin brother for the murder, he seems more focused on how bad the situation already looks for him. And as the
00:48:46
interview continues, it would only get worse because detectives begin receiving critical updates from the house search
00:48:53
that is still ongoing. And officers have started uncovering disturbing items. Inside Levi's bedroom, officers recover
00:49:00
a journal containing violent writing and repeated references of wanting to kill someone. They also uncover a growing
00:49:08
obsession with serial killers, books, online content, and material saved focused on infamous murderers, and in
00:49:15
particular, Ted Bundy. Detectives begin to realize this was far more than just a
00:49:21
morbid curiosity. Over time, what began as an interest in true crime had evolved
00:49:26
into something far darker for Levi. And now, detectives are left trying to determine whether this interest in
00:49:33
violence had consumed them both. Because Levi and Hunter are twins, the blood DNA recovered at the scene is
00:49:40
consistent with both of them. Something detectives choose to intentionally keep from Levi. Instead, they plan to tell
00:49:47
him that the DNA points specifically to him, hoping this pressure will make him crack. But if Levi is the criminal
00:49:55
genius he thinks he is, he will easily be able to see through the detective's bluff.
00:50:00
>> So, you said you never been in Denise's house. Never been. Okay. Do you know what DNA is?
00:50:07
>> You ever heard of it? >> I've heard of it. >> Okay. So, we're trying to figure out,
00:50:12
and I want you to help me explain this. Okay. Why your blood would be in Denise's house? That's what we're trying
00:50:20
to figure out. >> Well, I'm not sure cuz I don't know. Like, how is it my blood? Like
00:50:33
>> I That's what we're trying to find out. >> Cuz I don't know. I don't know why it
00:50:37
would be in my house. Her house. >> Yeah. We That's what we're trying to figure out. That's why we're even here
00:50:43
right now. >> Oh, >> remember we got those swabs from you. >> Mhm. >> Well, we compared that to the blood in
00:50:49
the house. And it's not only her blood, it's your blood mixed in with it. >> Wow.
00:50:54
>> Through DNA testing. >> I don't know what explanation I could give you or even come up with.
00:51:01
That would be equivalent to how that would happen. [snorts] >> There's only one person here that knows
00:51:10
and that's you. >> How do you know that? >> Because there's no other way that part
00:51:18
of you can be in that house without you never being in there. >> I can agree with that.
00:51:22
>> Right. So that's why I just need an explanation as to how I'm just trying to wrap my brain around it, you know.
00:51:31
>> Well, I have to wrap my brain around it first. >> Yeah. I So that's we need to wrap around
00:51:36
together. >> Mhm. >> You know, >> can you help me with that? >> I can't if you help me. I can help you
00:51:44
if you help me. >> How do I help you? >> By telling me the truth. >> I told you the truth, though.
00:51:49
>> I don't think you're telling me all the truth. What? But I'm not lying. >> Well, I think you have about how you got
00:51:58
hurt. >> I >> We have your blood in her house and we're trying to figure out how it got there. That's the bottom
00:52:08
line. >> Well, that's the bottom line. I mean, >> get my blood from somewhere. >> We didn't don't need your blood. We got
00:52:15
swabs. >> I just mean like did you did somebody put my blood in that house for a reason?
00:52:20
>> Oh, I don't know. What would you tell me? Would they? >> I didn't put your blood.
00:52:25
>> I don't have any enemies. >> I didn't put your blood there. >> I mean, I'm only 13. I don't know why
00:52:30
anybody would put my blood in a house, but I mean, who knows? >> Is there any more questions you have for
00:52:39
me or like what? >> Well, I just I I want to get past this and we're not getting past it. You don't
00:52:46
know? I don't know. So, we're not resolving anything. Well, I'm not sure if we can resolve it
00:52:52
if I don't know and you don't know. The human. >> I mean, listen, I I wholeheartedly
00:52:58
believe that there's two types of people in this world. You've got monsters and you've got people who make mistakes.
00:53:05
>> I think I disagree with that person. >> Help us explain this. >> What do you disagree with about that
00:53:12
state? >> I just think that, you know, there's there's a lot of different types of
00:53:18
people in the world. There's not monsters and people who commit mistakes. >> Well, I'm simplifying things in terms
00:53:23
of, you know, a crime, a murder, right? >> There's two types of people who would
00:53:27
commit a murder. >> There's a monster and there's people who make mistakes. Like his example of the
00:53:34
>> carried away. If it's a murder, then it would be a monster, right? >> Not necessarily.
00:53:41
>> You don't think so? >> No. Still believing he's in control of the situation, Levi never asks for a
00:53:47
lawyer or even his mother, and unsurprisingly fails to catch the detective's bluff about his DNA. But
00:53:54
while Levi remains convinced he's outsmarted the police, he has no idea that while the evidence uncovered in his
00:54:00
room is already damning enough, what detectives are about to find on his phone will destroy any chance of walking
00:54:06
free. Because before long, detectives would receive the final and most crucial breakthrough in the investigation.
00:54:15
After searching the brother's phones and social media activity, it begins to uncover a disturbing picture. Just one
00:54:22
day after the murder, Levi writes, "This one was a fighter." And detectives realize this wasn't a spur-of-the-
00:54:30
moment act. Levi had been planning a murder for months with searches of how to choose the perfect victim, how to
00:54:37
strangle someone, and how to defeat a police interrogation. And they would uncover even more evidence tying Levi
00:54:44
directly to the scene. Not only was the watch confirmed to be Levi's, but inside
00:54:49
his room, they discovered a shirt covered in Sheila's blood and gloves matching the ones from the crime scene.
00:54:56
Now, even without a full confession, detectives know they have enough evidence to formally charge him. With
00:55:02
this, both interrogations finally come to an end. And as a detective steps out to inform the parents that one of their
00:55:09
young sons is an alleged killer, all they can do is stand in shock, silently waiting to hear their son's fate.
00:55:18
>> Yeah, this is um their dad. >> How are you? Um, I'm special agent Ward with Beast
00:55:25
Bureau Criminal Investigation. You see two of my colleagues here, my other colleague. Now, there's some important
00:55:31
things we're going to tell you that we have that are bad. Okay. All right. That watch that we showed you
00:55:40
was under her body. >> What? >> What? Yeah. [laughter] >> No. [laughter] Okay. You have more
00:55:52
things to tell me. >> Okay. I'm I don't know what in the world happened. He's We're [music] not talking
00:56:00
to him anymore. I mean, he doesn't want to really talk anymore. Um I don't know what happened.
00:56:11
>> You can keep talking. >> Well, we have a lot of other evidence, too. I'm just trying to figure out what in
00:56:19
the world. I >> I don't know. Um, no. No. >> Okay. Sorry. What else? >> I I'm not doing this to
00:56:41
>> I don't think you are. >> I I'm just trying to do my job and my colleague. [laughter]
00:56:46
>> What happens now? Um, I'm consulting with the county prosecutor's office. >> He's only 13.
00:56:56
Oh my god. Oh my god. Oh my god. I know, honey. I know. I know. Okay. [laughter]
00:57:13
Not horrible. Not true. Oh god, I feel like such a over me so I never >> You're a mom.
00:57:26
>> There's no way you're going to know. >> After finally learning what their son
00:57:30
had done, Levi's family are left to come to terms with a devastating reality. With the overwhelming evidence against
00:57:37
him, on November 10th, 2025, Levi Cart ultimately pleads guilty to aggravated murder, aggravated burglary, and
00:57:44
strangulation in the killing of Sheila Tenpenney. And because of his age, Levi receives the maximum sentence allowed
00:57:51
under juvenile law. He will remain in a juvenile facility until he turns 21, meaning he is expected to be released in
00:57:59
2033. But for Sheila's family, the outcome still doesn't feel like justice. Under juvenile sentencing laws, Levi
00:58:07
cannot legally remain incarcerated beyond that age. And at Levi's sentencing, the lead investigator warned
00:58:14
the court, telling the judge he made a mistake. It was good luck for us that he did, but in the future, is he going to
00:58:20
learn from those mistakes? That's what I'm concerned about. For the detectives involved in the investigation, there
00:58:26
remains a terrifying possibility that Sheila was not the end of Levi's violence, but only the beginning of what
00:58:33
he could be capable of. And while this case left Ohio shaken by a killer no one ever expected, our next case unfolds
00:58:41
somewhere danger is never supposed to reach. Inside S. Vincent North Hospital, more than a dozen gunshots send patients
00:58:49
and doctors into lockdown as SWAT officers move floor by floor searching for the shooter.
00:58:56
>> Hospital way. That way. Just go that way. With one person already dead, more than
00:59:07
70 rooms, and a maze of hallways to secure, police are forced into an intense race to stop the gunman before
00:59:14
he finds another victim. To watch this exclusive Dr. Insanity episode along with three more episodes from our new
00:59:21
Tuby series.