Search Captions & Ask AI

How being contrarian created Kill Tony: "Everybody was telling me to do a podcast"

December 30, 2025 / 01:35

This episode discusses the 12-year journey of the podcast Kill Tony, hosted by Tony Hinchcliffe and co-hosted by Brian Redban. Key topics include the origins of the show, the format of open mic nights, and the unique approach to comedy.

Tony Hinchcliffe shares his experience hosting open mics at the Comedy Store, where he would critique comedians after their sets. He reflects on the fun he had with friends while watching these performances and how their humorous commentary inspired the podcast.

The conversation highlights the initial skepticism from others, including co-host Brian Redban, about the appeal of an open mic podcast. Despite doubts, Tony believed in the concept and pursued it, leading to the show's eventual success.

TLDR

Tony Hinchcliffe discusses the origins and success of Kill Tony, highlighting its unique open mic format and initial skepticism.

Episode

1:35
00:00:00
Tell me a little bit about the unbelievable 12-year overnight success that is Kill Tony.
00:00:05
>> I just built the show that I wanted to do. You know, I was very lucky early on
00:00:11
at the comedy store to get to host the open mics there, which are 3 minute long sets on Sundays and Mondays with 40
00:00:19
comedians in a row doing 3 minutes, 3 minutes, 3 minutes, 3 minutes. And I would go up after each comedian did 3
00:00:26
minutes and make fun of them. and every once in a while afterwards go up to them
00:00:30
personally and say, "Hey, you know, if you took a breath sometimes or, you know, used pauses or sped up or got the
00:00:38
mic closer to your mouth, little advice here and there." And me and my friends
00:00:42
would always have so much fun sitting in the back of the room watching these open
00:00:45
mics and the things that we would whisper into each other's ears I thought were so funny. We'd be in the back of
00:00:51
the room. Sometimes we'd be the only people laughing at the open mic because
00:00:55
of what we're saying to each other. And I thought to myself during this time in
00:00:59
which everyone was saying, Tony, you have to do a podcast. You got to do a podcast. Everyone has a podcast. It was
00:01:06
completely unheard of at the time. But I thought, why not show how crazy an open
00:01:12
mic can be and the ideas that me and whatever comedian buddies were sitting next to me if we shared what we were
00:01:18
laughing about with the people, I think it could be a hit. And even the co-host Redband at the time goes, "Wait, what?
00:01:25
Who the is going to want to watch an open mic? And I kind of thought everybody would. Turns out worked out
00:01:32
pretty well. >> Yeah.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Best concept / idea
  • 60
    Best overall

Episode Highlights

Episode Quotes

  • I just built the show that I wanted to do.
    How being contrarian created Kill Tony: "Everybody was telling me to do a podcast"
  • Wait, what? Who the is going to want to watch an open mic?
    How being contrarian created Kill Tony: "Everybody was telling me to do a podcast"
  • Turns out it worked out pretty well.
    How being contrarian created Kill Tony: "Everybody was telling me to do a podcast"

Key Moments

  • Podcast Idea00:59
  • Surprising Success01:32