Search Captions & Ask AI

I Kissed Dating Goodbye Part 2: The Harmful Heart of Purity Culture | #43

July 10, 2025 / 01:05:01

This episode discusses the book I Kiss Dating Goodbye by Josh Harris, focusing on chapters 4 through 7. Topics include Christian love versus worldly love, the implications of dating, and the concept of purity.

The host, Jacob Gooden, begins by summarizing the influence of Harris's book on modern purity culture, noting its publication history from 1996 to 2019. He emphasizes the significance of understanding the differences between true love and selfish love as defined by Harris.

In chapter 4, Harris shares a story about his friend Jeff and a girl named Gloria, illustrating the conflict between worldly love and the Christian perspective on love. Jacob critiques Harris's views, arguing that love should not be solely equated with selfishness.

Chapter 5 introduces the idea of the right thing at the wrong time, with Harris using a parable about a magic thread to discuss the importance of patience during singleness. Jacob expresses disagreement with Harris's assertion that dating detracts from personal growth.

In chapters 6 and 7, Harris discusses purity and redemption, sharing personal stories and biblical references. Jacob critiques the portrayal of women in biblical narratives and the implications of purity culture on personal relationships, advocating for a more balanced view of love and dating.

TLDR

Jacob Gooden critiques Josh Harris's <i>I Kiss Dating Goodbye</i>, discussing love, dating, and purity culture in chapters 4-7.

Episode

1:05:01
00:00:00
What happens when you put a 19-year-old in charge of setting the standard for Christian dating? Well, you get this
00:00:05
book. That's right. I Kiss Dating Goodbye by Josh Harris. That's what we're talking about today. I'm Jacob
00:00:10
Gooden and this is the Exhomeschoolers Club. [Music] So, let's kick this thing off. This is
00:00:19
part two of the I Kiss Dating Goodbye series. Uh if you missed part one, go back. It's only a few episodes ago,
00:00:26
okay? And uh and it'll be linked in the show notes. I'll do that for you as
00:00:29
well. But um we talked last week on kind of what this book stems out of. We talked about the history of the Harris
00:00:36
family, their involvement in like the Christian homeschool world. So why it plays a significant role to a lot of us
00:00:42
homeschoolers. Um because even if you didn't read this book, this book came out, the quick history is this book came
00:00:48
out in 1996, the year I was born. Okay? It didn't cease to be published until
00:00:54
2019. So, this book has had an influence on what is today modern-day purity culture. Okay.
00:01:02
Last time we talked about part one of the book um and that section was called I kissing goodbye. We talked on chapters
00:01:08
1 through three and we talked about a bunch of different stuff in there, but it was kind of setting the stage for
00:01:14
what is what is the alternative uh to modern day dating. This week we're going
00:01:21
to look at part two which is called, let me pull it up here, the heart of the matter, and it's chapters 4 through 7.
00:01:29
This week is going to touch more on like Harris's definitions of of like Christian love, right? Of true love uh
00:01:36
versus like worldly love. Okay? And he kind of brought this up in in the earlier chapters where he he said talked
00:01:44
a lot about how, you know, Christ love is like this unselfish thing and it it's always
00:01:50
giving and it's it's all of these things, right? And that that then worldly love is
00:01:58
is the opposite. It's selfish. It takes um and it and it considers nothing of
00:02:04
the other people involved. Um and so we're going to see that. So, I mean, right off the rip, right? We're going to
00:02:09
just let's get into it. Okay, chapter 4. Right off the rip, like many of the
00:02:13
chapters in this book, he kicks it off with a story. And he tells this story of driving around with his buddy Jeff. Uh,
00:02:20
it's summer. He's in the car with his buddy Jeff. They're driving around and
00:02:25
Jeff is telling him like, "Oh, yeah. I've been going out with this girl
00:02:27
Gloria." And, um, Josh is like, "Oh, yeah. I know her. You know, we're all
00:02:31
friends, whatever." And um and Jeff basically confides in him like, "Hey, we
00:02:36
like we really like each other and we just had sex kind of a deal." And he's
00:02:41
kind of looking for this like pat on the back like, you know, like, you know, add
00:02:45
a boy kind of a deal, like get some kind of a thing. And Josh does not give that
00:02:51
to him. He's like the polar opposite. He's like, "Well, that's not really like
00:02:55
I don't think that's the right way to do things." And they kind of get in a
00:02:59
little tiff about it, but nothing too serious. And then like they just part ways. Okay. But at the end of telling
00:03:05
the story, Josh talks about, you know, I come home, uh, I'm visiting from out of
00:03:12
town and he's like, I run into Jeff. And Jeff is now engaged to a totally different girl. Uh, some girl named
00:03:18
Debbie, right? So Gloria is long gone at this point. And Josh responds with, "That's great." I said, "My
00:03:24
congratulations sounded hollow. I couldn't help it. I was thinking of Gloria. I hadn't seen her in a long
00:03:30
time. What was she now? Three or four girlfriends back? Love, huh? And I read this and I was just like
00:03:38
bothered by this, right? You should always be happy for your friends, right? Even if you don't agree
00:03:45
maybe with their with their love choices, cuz I've had a few friends like that. But but you should be happy that
00:03:52
they're happy, right? You should want them to be happy. And but the fact is we're years removed from the situation
00:03:59
with Gloria and Josh is still hung up and can't even be happy for his friend
00:04:04
who has moved on. Let alone the fact that like Josh is this big advocate, right, for doing it Christ way, doing it
00:04:10
like the right way, which is get married, have sex. And his buddy Jeff is like going down that path. He's getting
00:04:16
married. And Josh can't even like just reconcile in his brain like that maybe this dude
00:04:22
has grown up. Maybe this guy has evolved and changed, right? So, just this weird really arguably like
00:04:31
terrible friend behavior, let alone just like you're obsessing over something that is
00:04:37
not your business whatsoever. We flash forward like a couple more pages. Okay. So he talks about
00:04:45
the he he calls it in the section he calls it Aphrodite or Christ. And he says I cannot overemphasize the
00:04:51
importance of gaining God's perspective on love. We can link all the negative
00:04:56
habits of dating to adopting a fallen world's attitude towards love. And the
00:05:01
conflict between God's definition of love and the world is not new. Christians have always had a choice to
00:05:08
either imitate the master or slip into the more enticing pattern of love provided by the world. But again, Josh
00:05:15
is equating like love as this like purely selfish thing. He's equating it to like
00:05:23
basically sex always. Uh he he basically is like if you're not a Christian, love is only selfish. It is only self-
00:05:32
serving. Uh he later goes on to talk about this on page 62 and he says first we must understand that all of the
00:05:41
world's deceptions flow from the belief that love is primarily for the fulfillment and comfort of self. The
00:05:47
world poisons love by focusing on meeting one's own needs first and foremost. We witness this poison in the
00:05:54
boyfriend or girlfriend who pressures their partner into sex. You've heard the
00:05:59
line, "If you really loved me, you do it." In other words, I don't care about
00:06:03
you or your convictions um or how this could damage you emotionally. Meet my needs. Or what about the person who
00:06:11
dates someone because it will boost his or her popularity but then dumps that person when someone of a higher social
00:06:17
sta status comes along? Again, there are people like this. People will do these things. People are
00:06:24
shitty. Okay? It it happens. But I would argue that most people if you ask them about what love is and what
00:06:33
real love is, they would not say this. They would not say this selfishness of throwing aside one's own needs uh to
00:06:44
meet the needs of other like only being selfish, right? We would talk about true
00:06:48
love has this aspect of give and take, right? Like we do have things, we do have needs as humans. Um, Christians
00:06:55
might not know that because we are told consistently that like not to listen to our bodies. Uh, that our bodies are
00:07:03
wicked and evil things and that like the wants and desires of man are like awful,
00:07:08
right? And and it leads to this weird mentality. I talked about it in the previous episode, but like for me it led
00:07:16
to this weird I still struggle with what pleasure is to me, right? And doing things that make me happy. uh whether
00:07:23
it's sexual, whether it's just like like actually like fun things of like playing
00:07:29
a video game or reading a book or like taking time for myself, things that I need to recharge.
00:07:35
Um I struggle to register when my body is telling me those things and I've gotten better at it, but it's it's a
00:07:41
slow unlearning process. Okay. It's so strange to me like this like selfish like love thing because I
00:07:54
remember hearing that as a kid. I do. I remember hearing about like that people outside of God's love really couldn't
00:08:02
have rich fulfilling relationships and love because they didn't know what it
00:08:07
was to love. They didn't know what it was to like sacrifice and give up themselves. Later in the in the chapter,
00:08:12
he has a section called true love nullifies dating and he has this quote in here that
00:08:20
um or he says a few things in here. He goes back to his Jeff and Gloria explanation and he says that they uh
00:08:28
they often uh they unfortunately they often subscribed to the world's definition of love. First, their
00:08:35
motivation was self-centered. Jeff went out with Gloria because she was pretty to all the other guys uh or she was
00:08:42
pretty. All the other guys liked her and she satisfied him sexually. His criteria
00:08:46
for pursuing a relationship with her compares to his criteria for choosing a pair of jeans. They make him feel good.
00:08:53
They make him look good. Gloria wasn't much better. So on the other hand, she
00:08:58
liked Jeff because he was a prize. He was good-looking, athletic, and he owned a nice car. They met each other's
00:09:04
emotional and physical needs and helped each other's image. Self-centered, right? As he goes on, our entire motive
00:09:13
is transformed when we extract the poison of self-love. Now, I want to say this because this was a note I wrote
00:09:19
down. I read this book as if I was like 14, 15, okay? Peak puberty, sexual feelings are awakening in you.
00:09:30
If I had read this and seen poison next to self-love, again, it feeds into this whole
00:09:37
narrative that like because we view self- loveve as selfishness, right? Now, I view it much more as like self-care,
00:09:44
right? Listening to our bodies. Sometimes you just got to take a spa day. You just got to do a facial mask.
00:09:49
You just got to pamper yourself a little bit, right? But I would have I would have only ever
00:09:57
seen those words in a very negative context if this is the book I was going off of.
00:10:03
All right, we are moving right along into chapter 5 of this book. It's called
00:10:07
The Right Thing at the Wrong Time is the Wrong Thing and uh subtitle is how to keep impatience from robbing you of the
00:10:15
gift of singleness. Now, the story that starts out this whole thing is he tells this parable of uh the magic thread and
00:10:22
how this uh this kid named Peter gets this magic ball of of thread, okay? Or this magic spool of thread or something
00:10:30
like that. And the way the thread works is that it Peter can go forward in time by pulling the thread and it will
00:10:38
advance him in time. Okay? And so the parable goes that, you know, he goes to class one day and he's in school and
00:10:45
he's bored out of his mind because he doesn't want to be in school. So he tugs
00:10:47
the thread just a little bit and he flashes forward and he's not in school anymore. And as his life goes on, he
00:10:54
continues to pull on this thread anytime there's anything boring. He just wants
00:10:57
the excitement. He just wants the the enticing parts of life. And so he pulls the thread and before he knows it, he's
00:11:04
pulled all the way through his life. He's pulled the thread to the very end.
00:11:08
Now, the thing about the thread is there's no respspooling it and going back, right? It only works one way. And
00:11:14
uh Josh uses this like as an example, right? To be like, we often young people often give up their
00:11:24
like their singleness in pursuit of a relationship, in pursuit of this this adult thing. um and how sometimes it's
00:11:34
actually good to sit in the like monotonous life, the monotonous day-to-day stuff. And um and I was like
00:11:43
interesting. I don't totally disagree with him on this. Um, I think his some of the arguments for it are a
00:11:54
little bit dumb, but I do understand that like idea of like life is a series of excitement and kind of some boring
00:12:03
times and it it's this weird up and down roller coaster, right? Um, so I'm not
00:12:09
going to totally disagree with the guy on all of it, but I do disagree with him on some of it. And uh specifically this
00:12:19
he talks later in the book or talks later in this chapter about seasons and he says uh just as spring's role is
00:12:29
different from that of fall so each of the seasons of our lives has a different emphasis focus and beauty. Totally with
00:12:36
you right life is seasons. We cannot skip ahead or experience the riches of another life season any more
00:12:44
than a farmer can rush the spring. Each season builds on the one before it. God has many wonderful experiences he wants
00:12:52
to give us. He also assigns those experiences to particular seasons of our lives. In our humanness, we often make
00:12:59
the mistake of taking good things out of its appropriate season to enjoy it when
00:13:04
we want it. Premarital sex is a prime example of this principle. Sex in itself is a wonderful experience and he has in
00:13:10
parenthesis from what I've from what my married friends have told me. But if we
00:13:15
indulge in the outside of God's plan, indulge in it outside of God's plan, we
00:13:20
sin. Like a fruit picked green or a flower plucked before it blossoms. Our attempts to rush God's timing can spoil
00:13:27
the beauty of his plan for our lives. Just because something is good doesn't
00:13:31
mean we should pursue it right now. We have to remember that the right thing at the wrong time is the wrong thing. One
00:13:38
of the things that I struggled with growing up was God's will was talked a lot about when I was a
00:13:47
kid. And I think I've brought it up on the podcast before, but I had kind of a different view of God's
00:13:56
will than most of my friends did. A lot of them would they would pray a lot. They would read
00:14:02
the Bible a lot and basically be asking God for this very definitive answer of like do this, do that. And sometimes it
00:14:12
was for very arbitrary stuff that I was like this is a waste of God's time. And
00:14:21
let me give you an example. Like it would be like should I join this club or that club? And now if I still believed
00:14:31
that, you know, God was master of the universe, of course, you know, if I believed all the Bible stuff, I would
00:14:36
still believe that, you know, God even cares about those little details. My difference of opinion came from uh
00:14:45
when I was young, my mom had me read the Westminster Catechism, and one of the first sections of that book, it was
00:14:53
basically these teachings on the Bible. Um but one of the first sections and themes of that book was this idea that
00:15:02
in order to do the will of God, what is the will of God? The will of God is that
00:15:06
you glorify and honor him. And in doing that, you get to you get to spend eternity with him.
00:15:14
And I was like, interesting. Okay. And so from then on, I kind of had this different view of like I don't really
00:15:22
need to bother God with all of the questions of all of the like, should I do this club over that club? I should
00:15:29
just make a decision. And if I'm doing it and I'm honoring God while doing it
00:15:34
and I'm being in a light to the world, I'm doing the will of God. And how does this fit into what I'm talking
00:15:43
about here? I think so many people waited for this like God to tell them now is the time to date, right? Now is
00:15:53
the is the time to do this thing. And I think Josh pushes this a lot too because
00:15:56
he pushes this certainty within dating. And we're going to get we're going to
00:16:00
see more of it as we go further in the book, but he pushes this certainty of like dating
00:16:06
is bad because like you should be the person that you pursue, you should want to like pursue them for marriage and be
00:16:12
like kind of almost certain about it. And I remember there just kind of being this because broken hearts are bad,
00:16:18
right? Getting hurt is bad and hurting other people is bad. But that's just not how life always
00:16:24
works, right? We get hurt, we get knocked down. And so I think I viewed dating in a different way because I
00:16:29
viewed it as like I'm interested in this person. Let me date them. Let me meet
00:16:34
them. Let me experience them. And Josh is going to argue you do this as friends without the romantic stuff. But I I
00:16:40
disagree. I've always disagreed on that. I think that the romantic stuff can add
00:16:46
a seriousness to it. Um like let me give you this example. When I dated my wife, pretty early on in
00:16:56
our relationship, we were friends before we were lovers. Uh, but when we were friends, we talked a lot
00:17:04
about like what we want out of life. We hung out with a lot of different people.
00:17:09
And then as we started dating, one of the things that I told her very quickly was that I was not dating to just have a
00:17:18
girlfriend. I had an intention behind it. I wanted to get married. I wanted or I wanted to find a partner. It wasn't It
00:17:25
was less about getting married. It was more about I wanted to find someone that I wanted to do life with.
00:17:31
And I set that intention very early in our relationship. And it didn't scare
00:17:35
her off. She was like, I'm interested in that, too. Now, we also added all of the handholding and
00:17:43
the kissing and that was an aspect of figuring out if this was the person that I was compatible with. Again, I think
00:17:50
Christians got it wrong. They got scared of someone along the line was like sex equals bad. And I think Josh is one
00:18:02
of these people where we even see in the in the first chapters and and I I read his follow-up book to this as well. I
00:18:09
think Josh got hurt while dating because even though he doesn't talk about it a
00:18:15
whole heck of a lot in the books, Josh does mention the fact that he dated a lot of girls. He kissed a lot of girls.
00:18:22
He never uh was he never uh lost his virginity, which I even hate that term, but
00:18:30
but he he was not like a pure guy. like he he had done the thing and then he got
00:18:36
frustrated with it. And I think part of that is just the fact that like I think he got hurt one too
00:18:43
many times and he was like there has to be a better way instead of just actively pursuing
00:18:53
more out of it, right? And like actually I don't know maybe looking at the situation differently. And this is a
00:18:59
little bit of an aside. This is not in my notes, but I'm I'm realizing as I'm
00:19:03
talking about this that I'm like there's so many things and Josh, I would love to
00:19:07
have you on and maybe I could just ask you this question, but was it that you got hurt and you were
00:19:14
like, okay, screw this, I'm going to figure out a better way, which was like,
00:19:17
I'm going to make it look cool to be single, or was it an unwillingness to learn that
00:19:27
maybe you were the problem in a lot of these relationships? Did you have areas that you needed to
00:19:32
grow as a person to to fulfill whatever it was you were going to get to? I don't think it's a bad thing to
00:19:41
want to date somebody with the intention of marriage, with the intention of finding a life partner. I also don't
00:19:47
think it's bad to date people with the intention of I like having somebody to
00:19:52
go get drinks with, to go to the movies with, to have like a partner in crime kind of person. and maybe they're not my
00:19:58
forever person, but they're just somebody I'm vibing with currently. I don't think that any of that's bad. I
00:20:05
just think it's all about like the intention and the communication of those things right off the rip so people don't
00:20:11
get injured. Does that make sense? Anyway, I could ramble on this for a long time, but let's let's move on.
00:20:19
Okay, a few pages more. He says, "While you're single, dating not only keeps us
00:20:24
from preparing for marriage, but it can quite possibly rob us of the gift of singleness. Dating can tie us down in a
00:20:29
series of pseudo relationships, but God wants us to maximize our freedom and flexibility to serve him. Any season of
00:20:37
singleness, whether you're 16 or 26, is a gift. You might uh you just might do
00:20:42
God a disservice by wasting its potential on a lifestyle of short-term dating." I talked about this in the last
00:20:49
episode, but this idea that like when you're in a relationship, you can't like
00:20:58
be serving God, right? Like you can't or you can't be preparing for marriage.
00:21:04
It's like really [ __ ] weird. And I'm sorry I cursed, but like it's really
00:21:09
weird, right? There's a lot that goes into marriage. There's a lot of things I
00:21:13
didn't know that I was going to need to do as a husband that I that I had to
00:21:18
learn, but some of them I learned beforehand. Okay. I learned about like the difference of personality, right? I
00:21:27
learned about I need to do certain things. I need to take care of my partner in certain ways that I had
00:21:37
not ever thought of before. I learned about the fact that like my words held different meaning or the tone of my
00:21:44
voice held different meaning than maybe I intended. I still learn this on the daily. Um and it maybe hurt feelings or
00:21:51
made people feel a certain way. And I don't think I would have learned those things if I wasn't
00:21:58
I mean like I said I'm still learning those today but like I learned a lot of
00:22:02
them while I was dating while I was like exploring a romantic partner was like the way that we interacted and the way
00:22:10
we like learned how to take care of each other and what we needed. Right. I brought up in my last episode that like
00:22:16
I had surgery while I was dating my my wife. We were not even close to being engaged. Like I had surgery. I couldn't
00:22:23
take care of myself. It was in an awkward part of my back, my lower back, and like I couldn't replace the gauze on
00:22:31
my own. I needed help and I needed her help cuz I had nobody else. My family didn't live nearby. Nothing.
00:22:39
And she could have easily been like, "Nah, don't do that. That's like not the level
00:22:45
of our relationship." But she cared about me and she said, "No, I'm going to
00:22:49
take care of you and I'm going to like do this for you." And she would push me to when I wanted
00:22:56
to just kind of be like, you know, do things that were, you know, the doctor was telling me, "You got to take it
00:23:01
easy." She helped hold me accountable to following doctor's orders as opposed to
00:23:07
me and myself. I would have been like, "No, I can do XYZ and I can do this on
00:23:11
my own and I don't need anybody." I would have had this very independent
00:23:14
streak inside of me. And she didn't have to do that. But but I learned to accept
00:23:21
that and I learned to communicate better when I'm sick what I need. And I'm a super needy patient, by
00:23:29
the way. Um, but I don't like this argument that he continues to make that like when you when you're in a
00:23:36
relationship, you then like are like losing out on this opportunity to like learn how to be a spouse. Like I just
00:23:44
think that that's like I think it's just like flipped to be honest. Like like you
00:23:49
actually can't really learn how to be a spouse until you're in a relationship
00:23:52
and you're actually having to like you're closing that intimacy gap, right?
00:23:58
You're closing that gap of like it looks different to be intimate with friends
00:24:04
than it does with a partner than it even does with a spouse. Like it's just very
00:24:10
very different and that's okay. Like it just and it's okay to explore that. I also
00:24:18
wanted to bring this up because I put this in my notes again. Early on in this book, he was talking about how he wanted
00:24:23
to go back to dating as if it was in the 1800s. Now, if we look at historically like
00:24:31
dating and we look at dating even within the Bible, one of the reasons I think the Bible doesn't talk a lot about
00:24:37
dating is because at the time women were like bought and sold, right? They came with dowies. They like it was a lot of
00:24:47
times it was these plays within families to strengthen themselves. Talk about selfish love, man. It was families plays
00:24:54
to like strengthen their their worth, their their value, their standing in society. And it's like
00:25:03
Josh, why are we going back to that? Because now we're coming out of that and
00:25:08
we're coming into a place where women can have a say. Women can have a voice
00:25:14
and they can say, you know, I value these things in a partner. Before they couldn't do that, it was just like, you
00:25:19
know, dad would arrange something. mom and dad would arrange something or you know you hear about arranged marriages
00:25:24
people still to this day have arranged marriages I'm not totally knocking that
00:25:28
just FYI but I think it's interesting this push within Christianity specifically in this book
00:25:38
but I think by so many to kind of go back to this like maledominated 1800's view of of romance
00:25:48
as opposed to we're in a different place now. We've evolved as a society. We've
00:25:54
changed the rules. We evolve, we change, we grow, we become better. And um yeah, it just honestly
00:26:04
feels very like patriarchical um and nasty to be quite honest. So that's chapter five. We're going to move
00:26:14
on to chapter six because I mean I could talk about every paragraph of this book
00:26:19
and my disagreement or agreement with it. Uh most of it's disagreement. Um but yeah,
00:26:26
let's jump in. Chapter six, the direction of purity. Subtitle, how to get on the road of righteousness.
00:26:35
This book, this chapter, man, kicks off with a disgusting story again. But this story, he talks about, so he talks about
00:26:46
going to church camp and he talks about the pastor that was leading the thing saying, "Hey, we're going to fill out
00:26:52
these anonymous note cards and we're going to rank where you sit on the um the levels of physical intimacy um and
00:27:02
their seriousness kind of a deal." And so he's like, "Hey, if you've ever like
00:27:05
kissed somebody, so it's like a 0 to 10 system is the way he outlines it. So,
00:27:11
you know, zero would be nothing, right? Done nothing. One is like like kissing and then 10 would be sexual intercourse.
00:27:19
And so Josh is like, "Okay, so we fill them all out. We drop them in the thing,
00:27:24
you know, and we leave." It was like the end of a service and then they were
00:27:28
going to talk about it uh in a different in a future thing. And he's like, "As
00:27:33
I'm walking out, like some of the guys are all chatting about like, "Oh, what'd
00:27:36
you score?" And you know, and they're like, "Oh, I got to like a six, but like
00:27:41
almost a seven kind of a deal." And I'm like, I'm sitting here going, "Weird weirdo
00:27:49
behavior." Again, this is the kind of stuff if you never went to church youth group, if you never
00:27:55
did like the summer camps and things like that, these are the types of things that would happen at places like that
00:28:00
where it's like this weird like telling of things to the adults in the room, but
00:28:07
then ultimately it's going to come down to them shaming us into feeling like wicked people,
00:28:17
resulting in us repenting of our sins. and asking God into our hearts, right? Asking for forgiveness, asking God to
00:28:24
come live inside of us so that they can report their numbers back to the church when we get back and say, "Hey, 150
00:28:30
students committed their lives to Christ or something like that." But anyway,
00:28:34
these are like just weird controlling church behavior that is just like Anyway, I wanted to also talk about this. He
00:28:46
says, "Like countless Christians, my two friends foolishly viewed purity and
00:28:50
impurity as separated by a fixed point. As long as you didn't cross the line and
00:28:55
go all the way, they believed they were still pure." True purity, however, is a
00:29:01
direction, a persistent, determined pursuit of righteousness. This direction starts in the heart and we express it in
00:29:08
a lifestyle that flees the opportunities of compromise. I grew up believing the same thing that
00:29:14
like purity was kind of this like fixed thing, right? So, I talked last time about like sexual sin not being
00:29:21
classified, right? Like of like what is too far and everybody's definition is
00:29:26
slightly different, but we can all agree that having premarital sex is like that
00:29:29
is way beyond the line and nobody should be going there. Um kind of a deal. And then on the lower half of it would be
00:29:38
the kissing. I personally probably would have ranked like masturbation down on the lower part. Um maybe even some like
00:29:45
pornography. Um I don't know. People would probably disagree with me. They'd probably be
00:29:51
like porn and masturbation go higher on the list. But like I know that for me I viewed it very much in that fixed
00:29:59
point of like until I had sex I was like I'm good. I'm good. I got this. Now,
00:30:11
mentally, I had decided in my brain, I had determined that I was like, I think that the Bible's views on sex are wrong
00:30:20
or the things that I had attributed to biblical standards of sex were wrong. And I had determined that
00:30:28
I was like, I don't think that premarital sex is sinful. Disagree, agree with me, whatever you
00:30:34
want. I don't really give a [ __ ] That was what I had determined. But my body was so used to being told
00:30:42
that sex equals bad that when I did have sex that was outside of marriage, it was
00:30:49
great in the moment. But the shame and the guilt that came after were awful. And so even though in my brain I was
00:30:58
like telling myself I was like no, this is okay. Like this is fine. Like you should not feel guilty for this. This is
00:31:02
like normal natural you know like you're learning. You're exploring. this is a
00:31:06
part of the human experience like you should you know be enjoying it all these types of things because my body had been
00:31:13
told so for so long that like this is bad this is bad this is bad I just had so many issues with it
00:31:20
but when it came to anything else I was like well that's not crossing that line
00:31:28
I knew that like watching porn maybe masturbating was sinful but it was not like at this definitive
00:31:35
Like it it almost felt like having premarital sex was like you it's an instant go to hell card, right? Like in
00:31:41
Monopoly you get the like go to jail, go directly to jail, do not pass. Like it felt like maybe that was like the case.
00:31:47
Like and I've only ever really felt that way about two things inside of Christianity.
00:31:52
One, sex is like the instant go to hell card and homosexuality is the instant go
00:31:59
to hell card. And it's just wrong. It's just wrong. It's like it's just a [ __ ] up belief to be
00:32:07
quite honest. And um it doesn't make you less of a person. It doesn't like
00:32:13
dehumanize you. It's it I I I don't even know like I can't even the words aren't
00:32:21
even there to express my feelings on this. But I just agree with the idea that that was what we were being taught
00:32:29
of like purity sits within these fixed points of like you're either all the way
00:32:36
at a zero where you are like extremely pure um because you've done nothing physical or you're all the way over here
00:32:44
and then there yeah there's all this stuff in in the middle but it's all like
00:32:48
redeemable. You can be saved from that. So, without further ado, I'm not going
00:32:53
to I'm not going to ramble too much longer on that. I do want to jump ahead a few more pages uh to page 89. And he
00:33:01
starts talking about good old King David. And one of the things I'm just going to say
00:33:08
this now because I'm going to bring this up again later, but the the story of
00:33:12
King David, this particular story with him at Ba Sheba is from 2 Samuel chapters uh 11 and 12. If you're not
00:33:19
familiar with it, here's the cliffnotes version. Okay. King David, king of Israel, goes out on his rooftop, sees a
00:33:26
beautiful woman taking a bath on her rooftop in all of her nakedness, is like, "I want that woman." So, even
00:33:33
though he's a married man, uh has multiple wives cuz he's king uh of Israel. Um he sends his guards to go get
00:33:42
her, bring her to him. He seduces her, they sleep together, she gets pregnant. What he doesn't know at the time is that
00:33:48
she is the wife of one of the generals of his army. And uh what ends up like happening is that he ends up killing her
00:33:56
husband so that he can be with her. But the reason I bring up this story is is one I want to highlight something. You
00:34:04
know, Christians will always say like God uses imperfect people. They'll use
00:34:08
that as an argument. David is considered by the church as one of like the guys. He is one of like the ultimate god
00:34:15
followers and he's a man to be respected. He's a man to be uh admired, to to imitate, all these types of
00:34:24
things. And I was rereading this story cuz I read it the more than just in this book. I actually opened my Bible and
00:34:31
read this story and I was reminded that I'm like, this is a man who does everything that you guys disagree with.
00:34:40
Not only does he have multiple wives, which a lot of Christians would argue is bad, he has an affair with a married
00:34:50
woman. He gets her pregnant and then he kills a guy as a result of it. I just don't understand the justification for
00:34:57
King David. To be honest, I think that's the main p pull from there that it just
00:35:03
always irks me that I'm like, why are we talking about this guy? Because I'm not going to get political. I'm just
00:35:10
going to leave it at that. But why why why do we do that? It just seems dumb to me. Okay. There's plenty of other people
00:35:17
in the Bible who are better examples, more faithful examples of of their faith than King David. That's all I got. I'm
00:35:25
going to leave it at that. I want to point out this other part of this book. Um it's always interesting to me. He says
00:35:34
this in the in the book of Proverbs, the seductive spirit of impurity and compromise is symbolized by a weward
00:35:39
adulteress. We are warned that many are the victims uh many are the victims she has brought down. Her slain are a mighty
00:35:48
throg. And then he goes on. He says, "Though King Solomon wrote these words
00:35:52
hundreds of years ago, this woman continues to lurk all around us today. She snares the innocent with promises of
00:35:57
pleasure, but she truly desires nothing but her victim's destruction. She has
00:36:02
ruined countless lives, both male and female, with her treachery. And I just wrote this in my notes. I said, "Why
00:36:09
does the Bible always portray like the bad guy as like a woman? Like, why is it never why is it never a
00:36:18
guy? It's always like a woman." Um, I don't know. Something to think about.
00:36:23
That's all I got to say there. Next up, page 93. We're moving. We're moving.
00:36:30
Purity and action is what this section is called. I'm just going to read this.
00:36:35
It has a a bit in here. It says, "Respect the deep significance of physical intimacy. Many non-Christians
00:36:41
view sex as bodily as a bodily function on the level of scratching your back. They engage in sex whenever and with
00:36:49
whomever they want. While this lifestyle is an affront to biblical values, many Christians treat lesser expressions of
00:36:56
physical intimacy with the same lack of respect. They view kissing, holding, fondling uh as no big deal. While you
00:37:04
may hold higher standards uh while we may hold higher standards than our pagan neighbors, I'm afraid we too have lost
00:37:11
sight of the deeper significance of sexual intimacy. I wrote in my notes, I said viewing sex as the same as
00:37:18
scratching someone's back is like a wild thing to say. Like that's how he views
00:37:24
the world's idea of like love and sex, right? It's like we we don't differentiate between like scratching
00:37:31
your back or having sex with someone. It's all just bodily, you know, our body
00:37:35
is telling us we need something, so we just fulfill it. There's so much more to
00:37:38
it than just that. Like sex is so much of a bigger thing than just scratching your back. Like
00:37:45
I would just I would argue that people don't view they view sex as a special
00:37:50
connection between two people. And I don't think they would put it on the same level as scratching the back. Like
00:37:58
also he mentions in here that he says later in this chapter he says physical intimacy is much more than two bodies
00:38:06
colliding. God designed our sexuality as a physical expression of the oneness of
00:38:11
marriage. God guards it carefully and places many stipulations on it because he considers it extremely precious. He
00:38:18
doesn't back up this statement with any Bible verses. I mean, this whole page
00:38:23
right here, both these pages, I mean, there's one little Bible scripture here
00:38:26
that says, "Do not let your heart uh turn to her ways or stray from her paths."
00:38:33
But there's no other scripture in here that's backing up these stipulations
00:38:37
that supposedly God has. That's why I said earlier, uh, you know, where the bi
00:38:42
where the story of King David is. If you want to check it out, second 2 Samuel chapters 11 and 12.
00:38:51
Where where is your proof? Where is your backup? That is something that I realized as I read this book.
00:38:59
Many Christian books bet on you already having an understanding of the Bible, having
00:39:06
already been to church, having already have this knowledge in place to just then go along
00:39:13
with them saying stuff like, "Well, we all know that this is the way God views
00:39:17
it. We all know that this is in the Bible. Where? Tell me where. Show me where."
00:39:27
Okay, I didn't think much of these types of things until I read um When Religion
00:39:33
Hurts You. And as I was reading it, one of the notes I took on that book was I was like, everything is cited. There's
00:39:40
links to everything. There's references to books and all these things. They're
00:39:44
all listed, not only in the actual writing, but there are annotations in the corners to say, "Hey, you know, go."
00:39:51
And in the back there's an entire reference sheet of everything that's referenced throughout the whole thing.
00:39:58
I would respect this book, I think, a lot more if he actually had sources to back it up and maybe sources more than
00:40:07
just the Bible. Even though this is a Christian book, of course, the Bible is the whole truth. Nothing but the truth.
00:40:15
So help me, right? Like I get it. But like the more you just rely only on the Bible for
00:40:25
everything. As a non-believer, it gets harder and harder to like kind of buy into the [ __ ] so to
00:40:33
speak, because if I don't believe it, you got to hit me with other sources that maybe I respect more. That's all
00:40:39
I'm going to say about that. Moving on, he brings up Billy Graham. Thought this
00:40:43
was interesting. My family has a connection to Billy Graham. My grandfather used to work for Billy
00:40:47
Graham organization. One of the things that Billy Graham historically did, and I saw this play
00:40:53
out in my own lives as well, but in the early days of his ministry, Billy Graham
00:40:58
experienced deep concern over the public's distrust of evangelists. How could he preach the gospel to people who
00:41:04
assumed he was fake? As he considered this question, he realized that most people who distrusted evangelists did so
00:41:11
because these evangelists lacked integrity, particularly in the area of sexuality. To combat this, he and his
00:41:18
close circle of men who ran the crusades avoided opportunities to be alone with women who weren't their wives. Now, I
00:41:25
grew up in a household and with people in my life who kind of lived by similar principles, who would leave the doors
00:41:32
open. I had a grandfather, like I said, who worked for the Billy Graham organization. He had to follow some of
00:41:37
these rules. Here's what I understand about this that I can kind of get behind. I understand the wanting to to
00:41:46
for there to never be a question about what happens behind closed doors. I I get that. Here's where I kind of
00:41:55
disagree. I believe that this perpetuates the idea that men are uncontrollable hormone
00:42:03
monsters. The way that purity culture is set up is so that men don't have to take
00:42:11
accountability for their actions. And that's a really dangerous message to tell young boys specifically
00:42:21
that we get to blame. We get to put we get to shift blame to to women a lot of times for well they wore this thing
00:42:31
which results in us being like well they were asking for it. They you know said or did this thing or
00:42:37
they gave me this look and and you know whatever. It's their fault not mine.
00:42:45
And so we're teaching these young men that like they have no self-control, right? It's unavoidable.
00:42:55
I get really irritated by this because I know that I was that way for a long [ __ ] time. I thought that I was just
00:43:08
uncontrollable. And I'm thankful. I I said it in episode one. I'm going to say it again. My dad
00:43:16
had told me that there is a time and a place for sexual things. We grew up in California. We go to the beach. you're
00:43:22
going to see women in bikinis. He's like, "The beach ain't a sexual place.
00:43:25
We're not here to be hooking up. We're not here to be ugly. We're not here to do it's not sexy
00:43:32
time." And that helped. I'm not going to lie. I think it I think it gave me a breadcrumb
00:43:40
of learning about self-control and learning to like harness that. One of the things that I chose to do, and I'm
00:43:48
just going to take ownership for all of this, is that I masturbated a lot as a teenager. I did. It's disgusting.
00:43:56
Trigger warning if that grosses you out. I get it. It grosses me out sometimes, too.
00:44:03
I did that because the alternative was popping a boner left and right for any little thing. the wind would blow,
00:44:13
I'd have a boner. Doing that early in the day, kind of taking care of myself, so to speak, it
00:44:21
alleviated sometimes the embarrassment of that happening when I was with other people.
00:44:29
And so, even though I felt a lot of guilt and shame about it, right, I felt like I was on the spectrum, right? We
00:44:34
talked earlier about the 0 to 10. Even though I felt like I was sitting in there and I was doing something I
00:44:39
shouldn't have been doing, I like I chose to do that because I was like, I would rather that happened than me be
00:44:50
embarrassed when I'm with my friends and someone comment on it or just feel a
00:44:56
certain way or feel awkward because there I am. Like men can't hide it, right? we get a boner. It It's external,
00:45:07
right? Women get turned on. You guys can hide it a little bit more, right? So, I just like I chose to do that. I ch
00:45:19
that was a self-control thing for me. Now, of course, I had problems with pornography.
00:45:26
I had I had some issues with some of that. Uh but it kind of helped. Like in a weird way
00:45:34
it kind of helped because when I did get to the point where I no longer viewed masturbation as bad, right? And I no
00:45:42
longer viewed premarital sex as bad. Um I had learned that I also needed to have
00:45:49
self-control. I had learned that like sex is not going to happen all the time. Anytime the wind blows and I'm like
00:45:57
wanting it, right? It it's it's a partnered thing. It happens between two
00:46:01
consensual people. What I started to realize was that other guys I knew were not that way. They were pressuring women
00:46:11
into having sex. They were pressuring women into uh giving them hand jobs and [ __ ] and like getting them off. They
00:46:18
were like uncontrollable and they would like like I said, we would be at things and like it was just whatever. But they
00:46:26
were they wrote it off as like well that's just me. that's just guys being
00:46:32
guys and you know and then making gross comments about things that women would wear and
00:46:38
like all of these things and they would write it off as like that's just dudes
00:46:41
being dudes and that's like what we're supposed to do. It's like no it's not
00:46:44
[ __ ] what we're supposed to do. Like we are supposed to be gentlemen. We are
00:46:50
supposed to know the time and the place the appropriate measures to take in these circumstances. And
00:46:58
it just irks me when I see these things. And we're going to get into it even more because I mean the
00:47:06
next section of this book is like guys versus girls responsibilities. And like I mean literally he lists all these
00:47:14
things that are like the guy's responsibility, right? He's like, "Guys,
00:47:17
it's time we stood up to defend the honor and righteousness of our sisters. We need to stop acting like hunters
00:47:21
trying to catch girls and begin seeing ourselves as warriors standing guard over them. How do we do this? We must
00:47:26
first realize that girls don't struggle with the same temptations we struggle
00:47:29
with. We wrestle more with our sex drives while girls struggle more with their emotions. We can help guard their
00:47:35
hearts by being sincere and honest in our communication. We need to swear off flirtation and refuse to play games that
00:47:42
lead them on. We have to go out of our way to make sure nothing we say or do stirs up inappropriate feelings or
00:47:48
expectations. Few things I want to say on this one. Of course, I would argue it's a good thing
00:47:58
to be a man that's willing to stand up for a woman. I think most I'm not going to say everybody, but I
00:48:06
think most people would argue that that is a good thing. The thing that I disagree with is like down here it talks
00:48:14
about we wrestle more with sex drives while girls struggle more with their emotions. I don't I don't think that's
00:48:19
true. I think that we are at a point where men have been programmed for so long that our emotions are like negative
00:48:27
things and we shove them deep down inside. Like we don't cry, we don't show
00:48:32
weakness. Our emotions are weakness, right? We've been told that lie for centuries at this point and it's just
00:48:40
programmed into us that like emotions equal weak and and thus because women are emotional and women tend to be more
00:48:50
in touch with their emotions. They're the weaker species. I think it's the polar opposite. Like I
00:48:56
I genuinely am at a point in my life where I'm like I think it's the polar
00:48:59
opposite because like I will be burning up inside with emotions and unable to cry, unable to do things because I just
00:49:07
haven't gotten there yet in my therapy and and growing as a human being because
00:49:13
I struggle to do those things. I struggled to show emotion because it still registers in my brain as weakness.
00:49:20
So even though again mentally I can tell myself it's okay you can cry, it's okay
00:49:25
to be sad, it's okay to feel this emotion, there's a part of me that's like but
00:49:30
that's not manly that's like weakness kind of a thing. What he doesn't mention
00:49:36
in this section is dressing appropriately. He mentions nothing about clothes for the men. But
00:49:45
yet when we get to the girl section says girls you have an equally important role. Remember the weward woman we
00:49:51
discussed earlier. Your job is to keep your brothers from being led astray by her charms.
00:49:57
Please be aware of how easily your actions and glances can stir up lust in a guy's mind.
00:50:03
You must realize that guys most commonly struggle with our eyes. I think many girls are innocently unaware of the
00:50:10
difficulty of a guy that a guy has uh to remain pure when looking at a girl who is dressed immodestly.
00:50:18
Now, I don't want to dictate your wardrobe, but honestly speaking, I would be blessed if girls considered more than
00:50:25
fashion when shopping for clothes. Bro wants girls to dress like they're in the
00:50:29
1800s. Like, what the [ __ ] is wrong with you, Josh Harris? You're going to sit
00:50:34
here and you're going to be like, one, you're going to spew off [ __ ] about women being more emotional than
00:50:40
men when that's just programming that needs to be broken down. And then you're going to say that men
00:50:46
struggle more with their sex drive than women do. I've talked to enough girls at
00:50:49
this point about about their [ __ ] teenage years and being horny all the time and whatever. Like again, as men,
00:50:58
we can't hide it. We have an exterior appendage, right? As penis hvers, we have an exterior appendage, right? For
00:51:05
the vagina havers, you guys can hide it. Like you like but you put everything on the girls of
00:51:13
like you you know when you dress a certain way and you act a certain way and you flirt a certain way it makes
00:51:19
guys fall into temptation into lust. And yet the guys take no responsibility of this. I mean like
00:51:32
we're taught that like we have two options in those circumstances. We either give in to that emotion of like
00:51:41
lusting after a woman or we run like extremely far away. And I I just think that there's a weird I think that
00:51:49
there's a middle ground in there where it's learning to like accept the situ
00:51:55
that the situation isn't sexual. And that's not running away. It's not
00:51:59
removing yourself from the situation. It's a it's recognizing. It's a
00:52:02
recognition as men, as penis hammers, that like this is not a sexual situation and I'm not going to make it that. Okay,
00:52:12
women, you are allowed to wear what you want. Okay, you like dress how you want.
00:52:18
Like, just do it. He also doesn't talk about the fact that like as guys, we wear clothes that maybe turn girls on,
00:52:27
right? I could go on and on and on about this. I don't have the time to do that.
00:52:33
Okay, so we're going to move on. Chapter 7, last chapter. It's called a cleansed
00:52:38
past, the room, how Jesus can redeem your past. He kicks it off talking again in a
00:52:48
story. He talks about the room. This is where the title comes from. And he shares kind of
00:52:54
having a dream. And he wakes up in this room. And in this room, there's all these um kind of like mini file cabinets
00:53:00
for index cards. Okay. And uh and each one is labeled, right? And so there's
00:53:06
different things in there like uh like one says friends, and then the next one too, it says like friends I've betrayed,
00:53:11
and he's got other stuff that's like books I've read, lies I've told, comfort
00:53:15
I've given, yada yada yada. And then he gets to one that's called songs I've
00:53:19
listened to. And this is what he says. I realized that when you pull it out that
00:53:25
it would expand uh to to meet like however many cards were in there, right? And so uh the cards were packed so
00:53:34
tightly and yet after two to three yards I hadn't found the end of the file. I
00:53:39
shut it shamed not so much at the quality of music but more by the vast amount of time I knew that that file
00:53:45
represented. He feels shame for time spent listening to music because you know what that time could
00:53:53
have been spent preparing for marriage or could have been spent glorifying God in some way or could have been spent
00:54:00
like that's his argument as he gets down here. That's his argument is that what
00:54:06
if I what if I hadn't have wasted all of this time on all this other stuff on
00:54:11
living life, right? Living just living life, being a normal human being. What if I had not wasted all my time on these
00:54:17
things and instead I had just solely focused on God? I'm sorry, but what a boring life it's going to be if all you
00:54:24
ever do is read the Bible, pray to God. Like, I'm sorry. That's not exciting. We
00:54:30
are meant to do so much more than that. We set the intention of what we want our
00:54:34
life to be. We set value to things. We set intentions of the things we want to accomplish and do and whether we what
00:54:41
the impact is that we want to make in life and the messaging that we want to leave behind for the next generation of
00:54:47
people. And as I read this, it made me really upset because it reminded me so much of
00:54:58
my relationship with my grandfather and how, like I said, my grandfather worked for
00:55:04
the Graham organization. He had uh some seminary degrees or had gone to seminary
00:55:09
multiple times. He was a chaplain. He was never a pastor as far as I know, but he was a chaplain. And so when I
00:55:16
graduated high school and I went to college, I went to a Christian college, uh, but I was not studying religion. And
00:55:23
he would always tell me when I would talk to him, you should consider getting a minor in religion or you should just
00:55:29
double major. And then he's like, when you're done, you should go to Asbury
00:55:32
Seminary and get, you know, a full seminary degree. And I was like, that's not really what I want to do, Grandpa.
00:55:40
Like that's not intriguing to me. It's not interesting to me. And he's like,
00:55:44
"Yeah, but it's like a good thing to have in your back pocket so when you
00:55:47
like become a pastor or you, you know, whatever." And I was like, "I don't want
00:55:50
to be a pastor. I don't want to do that." So the value there was just not
00:55:55
there for me. Um but also one of the things that we disagreed on so so adamantly was the idea of what
00:56:04
evangelism looked like. And he would talk about going out and preaching to the people and all of these types of
00:56:12
things. and standing on stages and and shouting, you know, the words of God and whatever. And my view on it has always
00:56:19
been relationship based. It's always been about meeting people where they're
00:56:23
at, not pushing God down their throat. And this is still, I think, how I live my life, too, of just like you can't
00:56:32
always just start the relationship with like, well, what do you believe? Well, this is what I believe. Like, it takes a
00:56:38
while. You got to ask dumb questions. You got to ask the like, what's your favorite color? What's your favorite
00:56:42
movie? What's your favorite day of the week? Like, you got to get through those
00:56:46
questions, the dumbass questions, to get to know somebody. And and to get to have
00:56:51
a relationship with that person. That's why I think Josh's take on this is so
00:56:56
garbage, right? He's sitting there pulling out this box and it's all the
00:57:00
songs he's ever listened to and he's upset because he's like, I could have
00:57:02
spent this time doing something so much greater for God. What if those songs come up in having these conversations
00:57:09
with people, right? you meet somebody who is a music afficionado, right? And you can list off all these bands you've
00:57:15
listened to. You can list out all these things, you know, who produced and who did that and yada yada yada, right? All
00:57:21
of these things, right? You can have a conversation with people. And that's why
00:57:25
I'm so like I'm such a big advocate for like have the things that you're
00:57:30
passionate about and like learn them and learn them really well. And like uh I talk about this all the time within the
00:57:37
homeschooling world of just like my parents knew that I loved pirates and they built a whole curriculum around me
00:57:42
loving pirates and they pushed me to learn that. Right. When I got really into music, I learned a ton about music.
00:57:49
They allowed me to listen to like Eric Clapton and BB King and all these guys that they might not have agreed with
00:57:56
everything they did. I mean, are you kidding me? Eric Clapton has a song called Cocaine that's about doing
00:58:00
cocaine. Like I just I'm so sick and tired of this like thought process of like it's such a
00:58:08
waste of time to do anything outside of basically like study the Bible because like I'm at a point in my life
00:58:15
where like I think I view a lot of evangelism as somewhat of a pyramid scheme. Now I'm
00:58:25
saying evangelism and not Christianity because I think they can be separate things. Okay, they go hand in hand, but
00:58:31
I think they can be separate things. So I just want to say that I want to clarify that. So when I talk about
00:58:36
evangelism, I view it now more as a pyramid scheme a lot of times because I think of it as this person shares the
00:58:44
gospel with these people who get saved who then go share the gospel with these people who then it's a pyramid scheme.
00:58:50
It's like Lulao, right? It's like any of these knockoff pyramid scheme companies
00:58:55
where you know you you sell this product and you you get all these other people to start selling that product and you
00:59:02
get a commission off of it and then yada yada and it goes all the way down, right? And then it implodes because it's
00:59:06
not a system that works. Like I said, my idea of building relationship with people and now as someone who's not a
00:59:16
religious person, I would classify myself as more spiritual person. My view of building relationships
00:59:26
before entering into like the spiritual conversations has paid off so much more.
00:59:30
It allows me to be friends with people of all different denominations. It allows me to have conversations with
00:59:35
people of all kinds of different walks of life. and like to ask stupid questions, but to be knowledgeable in
00:59:42
things that like are interesting and whatever. And we can have relationships that don't revolve around religion. We
00:59:47
can have relationships that revolve around our interest in music, our interest in books, our interest in
00:59:51
movies, our interest in podcasting, like whatever it is. Like I could build relationship on those things.
01:00:00
And I think so much of what I saw growing up was building relationship on just Christianity being the thing. And I
01:00:09
don't know that that's enough of an interest to really build solid relationships on
01:00:15
any longer. So, oh my gosh, I think we made it. Let me see if I have any other notes. Any other
01:00:24
little tabies in here? No, that's it. We made it to part three. The next part is
01:00:30
going to be called building a new lifestyle. It's going to be a few more chapters. This has been interesting.
01:00:36
This doing this um series has been so interesting for me because I read this book and I read it a while ago
01:00:48
and I really sat with it and I I took notes while I read and then now it's been a reflecting on those notes and
01:00:54
figuring out what I really think and feel about those things. And boy oh boy, um, I don't know how
01:01:05
much got left in, but I definitely can get pretty heated about some of that stuff. I know that getting through the
01:01:12
rest of this is going to be tough, and that's part of why I kind of have split
01:01:16
them up a little bit where there's maybe a gap in between. So, if you don't like
01:01:20
this content and you're just like, I just want the interviews with people, it's okay. That that content is going to
01:01:26
be coming in between. um episodes kind of a uh a pallet cleanser, so to speak. But I have so much more to say about
01:01:36
this stupid book. And I know that this next section we're going to start getting
01:01:42
into, I think, more of the practical applications of how he views how he sees things like courtship starting to work
01:01:49
out and how relationships actually will get formed and things like that. So, it's going to be interesting. Um stay
01:01:54
tuned for that. Um, you know, if you're listening from way in the future and
01:01:58
it's already out, you know, just click over to that new episode. But, um, I appreciate you guys and I appreciate
01:02:05
you guys listening to me rant and rave about my experience reading this book and my experience within purity culture
01:02:13
and where I am today. And I know that I'm probably not, no, not probably. I know that I'm not a perfect person and I
01:02:22
know that I'm continuing to grow and that's something I want to remain committed to is growing and evolving and
01:02:28
changing and being better as time goes on. And that's why I make stuff like this because I want to talk about the
01:02:35
people that we used to be the people the person that I used to be um and how we can change and evolve and be better uh
01:02:43
and and be stronger. And that's not scary, right? It's a good thing. Um it's
01:02:48
a good thing to change. It's a good thing to like evolve and we can allow our thinking to change. We can allow our
01:02:55
ideas to change. We can allow our beliefs to change and it's okay. There's
01:02:59
nothing wrong with that. So, with that being said, one of the great things that came out of episode one of this series
01:03:07
was that a couple of you reached out to me. You sent me messages on whether it was a DM, whether it was an email and we
01:03:13
talked about things and I would love that again for this episode. So, if you have purity culture stories, if you've
01:03:20
got stuff to say about Josh Harris, if you've got stuff to talk about with church drama or just with homeschooling
01:03:28
drama or whatever you want to chat about, uh, I want I want to talk to you. So, couple ways you could do that. Shoot
01:03:35
me an email, [email protected]. Shoot me a DM. Uh, exhsclub on uh I'm on Tik Tok, threads,
01:03:44
Instagram. I think that's about it, but uh yeah, or go down in the show notes
01:03:49
and there's links to all that stuff as well. And um yeah, I want to I want to
01:03:53
hear from you. In addition, if you're listening to this, whatever platform, whether you're watching, whether you're
01:03:58
listening, whatever you're doing, do all the internet things that you pretty much
01:04:02
should already know how to do. Like this episode, leave it a review, leave a comment in the description, share it
01:04:07
with a friend, do what you got to do um to get this out to more people. I appreciate that. The show appreciates
01:04:14
that. It's so much bigger than I would have ever hoped. We're almost a year in.
01:04:18
I think we are a year at this point in to this podcast and uh it's been incredible. It's been an incredible
01:04:23
journey. I'm so stoked for what's coming down the line. Uh and we're just going
01:04:28
to keep going. We're going to keep sharing stories. We're going to keep doing stuff like this, hanging out,
01:04:33
getting to know each other, and uh yeah. All right. Till next time, this has been
01:04:37
Jake. Peace. [Music] [Laughter] [Music]

Episode Highlights

  • The Heart of the Matter
    Exploring chapters 4-7, focusing on definitions of Christian love versus worldly love.
    “We're going to look at part two which is called, the heart of the matter.”
    @ 01m 24s
    July 10, 2025
  • The Right Thing at the Wrong Time
    Josh discusses the importance of timing in relationships and the gift of singleness.
    “The right thing at the wrong time is the wrong thing.”
    @ 13m 35s
    July 10, 2025
  • The Importance of Learning in Relationships
    Being in a relationship teaches you how to be a better partner and spouse.
    “You can't really learn how to be a spouse until you're in a relationship.”
    @ 23m 44s
    July 10, 2025
  • Historical Context of Dating
    Dating has evolved from a patriarchal system to one where women have a voice.
    “We've evolved as a society. We've changed the rules.”
    @ 25m 57s
    July 10, 2025
  • Purity and Impurity
    Purity is a direction, not a fixed point, challenging traditional views.
    “True purity, however, is a direction, a persistent, determined pursuit of righteousness.”
    @ 29m 01s
    July 10, 2025
  • King David's Flawed Legacy
    King David's actions raise questions about the justification of his legacy in Christianity.
    “Why are we talking about this guy?”
    @ 35m 05s
    July 10, 2025
  • The Need for Evidence in Faith
    A call for more sources and evidence in Christian teachings beyond the Bible.
    “Show me where. Tell me where.”
    @ 39m 27s
    July 10, 2025
  • The Dangers of Purity Culture
    Purity culture teaches men to avoid accountability, perpetuating harmful stereotypes about self-control.
    “This perpetuates the idea that men are uncontrollable hormone monsters.”
    @ 42m 01s
    July 10, 2025
  • A New Perspective on Relationships
    Building relationships based on shared interests rather than solely on religion can be more fulfilling.
    “We can have relationships that revolve around our interest in music, our interest in books.”
    @ 59m 45s
    July 10, 2025
  • Embracing Change
    The speaker reflects on personal growth and the importance of evolving beliefs.
    “It's a good thing to change.”
    @ 01h 02m 48s
    July 10, 2025
  • Call for Stories
    Listeners are encouraged to share their experiences with purity culture and more.
    “I want to hear from you.”
    @ 01h 03m 53s
    July 10, 2025
  • Podcast Milestone
    Celebrating nearly a year of the podcast and looking forward to the future.
    “It's been an incredible journey.”
    @ 01h 04m 22s
    July 10, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • You should always be happy for your friends, right?
    I Kissed Dating Goodbye Part 2: The Harmful Heart of Purity Culture | #43
  • The right thing at the wrong time is the wrong thing.
    I Kissed Dating Goodbye Part 2: The Harmful Heart of Purity Culture | #43
  • I learned to accept that and I learned to communicate better when I'm sick.
    I Kissed Dating Goodbye Part 2: The Harmful Heart of Purity Culture | #43
  • Men are uncontrollable hormone monsters.
    I Kissed Dating Goodbye Part 2: The Harmful Heart of Purity Culture | #43
  • I think it’s the polar opposite.
    I Kissed Dating Goodbye Part 2: The Harmful Heart of Purity Culture | #43
  • I view evangelism now more as a pyramid scheme.
    I Kissed Dating Goodbye Part 2: The Harmful Heart of Purity Culture | #43

Key Moments

  • Friendship Tensions03:42
  • Historical Dating Practices25:57
  • Purity as a Direction29:01
  • King David's Controversy35:05
  • Emotional Programming48:25
  • Personal Growth1:02:26
  • Listener Engagement1:03:15
  • Podcast Celebration1:04:22

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown