
This episode covers the murder of Amy Blumberg, a 20-year-old student at Eastern Illinois University, on New Year's Eve 1999. The hosts discuss the timeline of events leading to her death, the investigation that followed, and the eventual arrest of Edward Scott Phillips.
Amy was working alone at her aunt and uncle's dance apparel store when she was murdered. Her parents became concerned after failing to reach her and found her body upon arriving at the store. The police discovered a significant amount of blood and evidence suggesting a violent struggle.
Investigators initially struggled to find leads, but a composite sketch of a suspicious customer was released. The case drew parallels to the I-70 killer, a serial killer who targeted store clerks. Despite numerous interviews and tips, the case went cold for years.
After four years, a tip from Phillips' ex-wife led to his arrest. He had been in the store on the day of the murder and had blood on his clothes when he returned home. The trial revealed circumstantial evidence linking him to the crime, and he was ultimately convicted of first-degree murder.
The episode concludes with updates on the I-70 killer case and the ongoing investigation into similar murders, highlighting the complexities of solving such crimes.
The episode details the murder of Amy Blumberg and the investigation leading to Edward Scott Phillips' conviction.

This episode stands out for the following:
This is something that's not terribly uncommon.Amy Blumberg ////// 639
The dance apparel store was relatively new.Amy Blumberg ////// 639
Amy was the owner's niece.Amy Blumberg ////// 639
Why would somebody do this to a person they don't even know?Amy Blumberg ////// 639
It's personal now.Amy Blumberg ////// 639
Winner winner chicken dinner!Amy Blumberg ////// 639