00:00:00
when it comes to Quality sleep Ashley has you covered with top mattress brands at winning prices and with special
00:00:06
financing options available you can snooze now and pay later plus your mattress purchase helps give the gift of
00:00:13
better sleep to children in need and US Special Operations forces visit your local Ashley store or shop online today
00:00:22
and make every snooze count financing is subject to credit approval C store or ashley.com for d details dreaming of
00:00:31
overseas Adventures or connecting more deeply with family from afar Rosetta Stone Bridges the language Gap I've
00:00:38
tried others but Rosetta Stone's immersive lessons and voice feedback technology are gamechangers dive into 25
00:00:45
Languages by learning intuitively just like when you were a kid and here's the holiday Sparkle grab a lifetime
00:00:52
membership now and save 50% gift yourself the world head to rosettastone.com now and save 50%
00:01:08
[Music] [Music] % [Music] welcome to True Crime garage wherever you are whatever you are doing thanks
00:01:45
for listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is a man who once worked for NASA and he knows there's a
00:01:52
lot that they are not telling you here is the captain yeah but I had to quit when I saw Ur anus it's good to be seen
00:01:59
and good to see see you thanks for listening thanks for telling a [Music] friend this week we are featuring the
00:02:09
$50 million man by the great folks over at three Floyd's Brewing this is an imperial India Pale Ale $50 million man
00:02:20
has a little something for everyone it's a little dank with some Haze and a touch
00:02:24
of pine all held together with tropical fruit watch out evildoers Gra grade four
00:02:30
out of five bottle caps and beer can art Three Floyds Brewing always gets five bottle caps let's give some praise and
00:02:38
cheers to our friends that helped us out this week first up a big cheers goes out
00:02:43
to Janet skull from Reading Pennsylvania and a big we like your jib to Kristen Dewey from Toledo Ohio next up we have
00:02:51
Christine and her crew at Glow Tanning spa and Williston North Dakota everyone we just mentioned well they went to
00:02:59
website True Crime garage.com and helped us fill up the fridge for this week's shows yeah BW R and beer run you need
00:03:09
you want a band the van t-shirt we have a couple new stock shirts ban the van and creepy camper redesigned a little
00:03:19
bit so check those out in the store Page and Colonel that's enough of the business all right everybody gather
00:03:25
around grab a chair grab a beer let's talk some true crime [Applause] [Music] for most and in suar
00:04:00
Wisconsin June 16th 2020 was shaping up to be just another ordinary day another regular
00:04:10
Tuesday in a small town in the heartland of the good old us OFA but tragically it would not end up
00:04:20
as just another ordinary day no June 16th as far as one man was concerned was going to go out with a
00:04:30
bang and not just one this evening we'll be filled with fire gunshots Bloodshed and
00:04:40
tears one vengeful man with murder on his mind and blood in his eyes was going to rule the
00:04:48
day and unfortunately he got just what he wanted for the man with the gun in his
00:04:56
hand no longer cared about what is right and what is wrong he sought revenge and in its wake he left blood on
00:05:06
his father's farmland and when he was done he burned the whole thing down this is true crime
00:05:14
garage and this is the homicide case of Jim and Nedra lmy in the search for the man that killed
00:05:23
[Applause] them [Music] a 911 call comes in so many times these true crime stories start off with a 911
00:05:46
call but this 911 call is quite different than what we typically have yes the call was to 911 emergency
00:05:54
services but this was not the panicked voice the caller screaming into the phone or even a murderous boyfriend or
00:06:04
husband calling in and doing his best acting performance attempting to sound like a frightened or grief stricken
00:06:11
loving partner concerned when he found his much better half unresponsive and bloodied nope our real life True Crime
00:06:20
Story for today starts off with one of the most calm and reasonable voices I have ever heard on a 911 call at a
00:06:29
approximately 5:48 p.m. on a Tuesday this is June 16th 2020 in Sumer Wisconsin the Jefferson
00:06:41
County Sheriff's Office received a 911 call from a female caller the caller is so nice in considerate that when the
00:06:50
responder picks up the phone and says Jefferson County 911 the nice lady says calmly this is
00:06:57
not an emergency but I I am taking care of my parents' house and there's Windows
00:07:02
broken and we had locked the house down so our caller is calling in what sounds like a possible b& she states that there
00:07:11
are two broken out windows on the second floor of her parents' home now before we
00:07:18
get into this call any further we need to provide some background information here the house is a nice farmhouse on a
00:07:25
very large plot of Farmland lots of acreage the house appears to be a two-story home and while this is a very
00:07:34
large property the home is situated right near the street right near the road which is County Highway a in suar
00:07:41
Wisconsin when our story picks up the farm and the house up until very recently was owned by an elderly couple
00:07:51
the Andersons they had owned the farm for many years likely decades but both had passed away of natural cause prior
00:07:59
to this day verdal Anderson Mr Anderson passed away just 11 days prior to this 911 call verdal Anderson passed away on
00:08:10
June 5th the property was in Probate at this time his children and their spouses
00:08:18
helped to take care of him and the property before his passing his daughter and her husband were taking care of the
00:08:25
house and the property after he died the 911 caller was his daughter the one taking care of the home she identifies
00:08:33
herself to Jefferson County Sheriff's Office as 57 yearold Nedra lmy she's calling reporting a potential Breakin at
00:08:42
her deceased father's home located at North 1941 County Highway a this is just off of State Highway
00:08:52
106 Nedra told the dispatcher that when she and her husband his name is Jim lmy or James limy arrived at the property
00:09:03
they noticed that some windows on the home were broken out and they were concerned that there might have been a
00:09:08
Breakin well this location of the farm it's in a very rural area yes so this will be Jefferson County deputies
00:09:16
responding to the call and a Breakin may make some sense especially for these deputies because this is suar Wisconsin
00:09:24
a very small rural community as of the last census there were less than a thousand residents of suner so when
00:09:34
Jefferson County Sheriff's Office thinks of crime and crime Trends in this small
00:09:39
community we are talking about mainly property crimes things like vandalism stolen property breaking and entering
00:09:47
not violent crimes and not murder well and think about this as a small community you find out that this guy
00:09:54
passed away and that there's nobody living on the property the caller as said is Nedra she's very calm the call
00:10:02
is rather short and sweet but the first responder on the other end says to Nedra
00:10:07
you know just stay where you are we'll send somebody out you don't want to go into the property or into the house
00:10:14
because it there could still be somebody in there likely most of the time we're talking about a property that's for the
00:10:22
most part unoccupied right you have the children of the deceased coming by to take care of the place from to time but
00:10:30
there's nobody staying there night after night so we could have a situation where
00:10:34
somebody broke in or this is simply vandalism and whoever's responsible they moved on and they ain't there anymore
00:10:41
just for safety precautions you don't want to go into the house yeah definitely better safe than sorry so
00:10:47
it's recorded that the 911 call from Nedra lmy comes in at 5:48 p.m. remember she is calm and collected when she calls
00:10:56
that potential Breakin she's calm we have a Jefferson County Deputy arriving on the scene approximately 12 minutes
00:11:04
after receiving the call so now we are roughly at 6:00 p.m. pretty fast response when he arrives he finds a
00:11:12
scene that he describes as calm he Parks his Patrol vehicle and approaches a vehicle that he sees parked in the
00:11:21
driveway now he's met with some confusion here at what he discovers this is because when he gets near the vehicle
00:11:30
he sees a woman lying on the ground she's right next to the vehicle which is an SUV that's parked in that driveway
00:11:37
the deputy at first he's thinking the lady is injured perhaps she appears to have fallen just outside of the vehicle
00:11:46
she's laying right next to the vehicle the first clue that this is not the case is the woman is not moving at
00:11:53
all and the deputy is now speaking to her she is not responding to anything that he's saying she's not reacting not
00:12:01
verbal and not moving then he spots what appears to be a gunshot wound on this poor lady according to police and court
00:12:11
documents the deputy sees an individual sitting in the back seat of the vehicle he asked this man who was later
00:12:19
identified as nedra's brother Kirk Anderson this man is non-verbal due to mental and physical limitations so the
00:12:29
deputy says to the person that he does not know in the back seat of this vehicle are you okay and he gets no
00:12:37
response which we now know is what is to be expected right this is when our calm
00:12:43
scene changes dramatically because this is when gunfire starts the deputy takes cover
00:12:51
behind his squad car the deputy calls into his Department that shots are fired it's the it's the dreaded shots fired
00:13:00
call then the shots start up again the deputy is quick to figure out that the shots the gunshots being fired in his
00:13:09
direction are coming from a second story window inside the home and I hate to be
00:13:15
Capp and reca but just so that I'm fallowing you Nedra calls 911 says there's a possible Breakin to the
00:13:22
property the property was owned by her father that recently deceased mhm so the deputy shows up he thinks he's going to
00:13:30
be finding that caller but he finds Nedra laying down by the truck she's been shot her brother is in the back
00:13:38
seat of the truck but he is non-verbal yes and when we have the shots that are fired at this Deputy so think about this
00:13:45
he's arriving on the scene of this very large property lots of acreage and when he gets there there's nobody to bring
00:13:52
him up to speed on the situation being anything but calm right right when the call came in
00:13:59
and all of a sudden he's out of nowhere he hears gunshots and then realizes these shots are being fired in
00:14:06
his Direction he takes cover behind his squad car calls in shots fired shots fired well with the possibility of there
00:14:13
being a Breakin you're coming to that scene at least on some high alert but now that you have this victim laying
00:14:19
down by the truck now shots are being fired at you I mean this is not your typical call that law enforcement has to
00:14:28
deal with with especially in this area and good for him and lucky for him in some ways to realize very quickly that
00:14:36
the shots are being fired from a second story window coming from that house well
00:14:41
like you said there's a house on this property but there's multiple barns so just the fact that you're able to figure
00:14:47
out where these shots are coming from well and anybody that's served this great country and and and done an actual
00:14:56
Tour of Duty where they saw action will tell you that you are at a huge disadvantage when the shooter or the
00:15:06
person that you may be in a gunfight with when they are elevated when they are above you you have a lot less cover
00:15:14
and really almost no safe place to go to when they have that vantage point over you of being elevated so good for him to
00:15:25
notice right away hey these are coming from the Second Story window even though I'm trying to hunker down behind my
00:15:31
squad car I still likely am not very safe here so what he does is he decides to fire some shots back in the direction
00:15:41
of that window now of course you're hoping maybe you get lucky and you hit the the person that's firing at you but
00:15:49
in all likelihood he's just hoping to force whoever that shooter is to take cover and also just having arrived on
00:15:56
the scene shortly before the gunfire starts and not really knowing the lay of the land he also may not be aware of how
00:16:05
many people are actually firing at him so he decides to make a very smart move to fire some shots back this is likely
00:16:14
going to force the shooter to take cover giving him the opportunity to flee because he's got to get out of there
00:16:20
right and so he does he he fires the deputy says he fired four shots in retaliation and then he runs out of
00:16:30
there retreating down the driveway and he runs across the road and jumps down into the ditch you
00:16:38
know you drive those Country Roads you see those deep ditches on on both sides of the road often he's diving down into
00:16:45
one of those ditches to take cover getting himself further from the home I mean that'd be intense then he's gonna
00:16:52
start crawling through this ditch to get even further from the home he's already
00:16:57
called him backup and the backup arrives it's believed it was approximately 3 or 4 minutes later
00:17:05
when a second Deputy arrives on the scene but if you're the deputy that is you know running for safety and you
00:17:11
called backup you you're probably a little worried too that you're not bringing other law enforcement agents
00:17:19
into a situation where they become Sitting Ducks the problem for the deputy is going to be that this is clearly a
00:17:25
scene and a situation that is being beyond control right well again like you said we don't know if there's one
00:17:32
shooter or multiple Shooters especially for a deputy by himself and so even when
00:17:37
the backup arrives again this is about 3 or 4 minutes after he's in the ditch well he gets in the car with the other
00:17:45
deputy and they're going to back up to kind of assess the situation we have an active shooter now we have to figure out
00:17:51
what are we going to do are we going to set up a perimeter we have a person that
00:17:56
is alive in the truck in the vehicle that we're concerned about we have a person who appears to be
00:18:04
DOA next to the truck we don't really know what's going on we do not know how dangerous the situation can be and this
00:18:13
is when they back up it's within about five six minutes that they start seeing lots of dark smoke and now visible
00:18:22
Flames that are coming from that house the same house where the gunfire was coming from so now we have what's going
00:18:30
to end up being a standoff of Epic Proportions yeah what a crazy scene that is going down yes we have gunfire and
00:18:37
now black billowing smoke and large Flames coming from the house so the sheriff's department is in full force at
00:18:45
some point you know they're calling in everybody they're in full force on the scene but they are limited by the sheer
00:18:51
danger of the situation so they are back away from the house on both directions but they are almost watching this in a
00:19:00
way that I'm sure they probably felt a little helpless about the manner and controlling the situation using a drone
00:19:10
they are going to start searching the scene this might help them to determine where the shooters located how many
00:19:17
shooters they have and also how many other people that do we have that we need to be concerned about that are in
00:19:25
danger themselves use the Drone they fly over the property and when they get near the
00:19:32
home and near that vehicle that was parked on the driveway there the Drone spots another body this time it's the
00:19:42
body of a man they could tell that it was a man that is lying in front of the SUV this drone will give them the
00:19:51
opportunity to send in a SWAT team but here's the problem Captain by the time we get the SWAT team in
00:20:00
there the house is burned nearly to the ground sending them up to I mean there's
00:20:07
there's practically no building left by the time they are there and then we are finding two dead
00:20:17
bodies the woman's body that was found earlier by the deputy the man's body that was discovered using the
00:20:25
Drone and here's the thing we don't have any shoes or Shooters found on that property and the structure that the
00:20:35
shooter was in is now burned to the [Music] ground this show is sponsored by better
00:20:55
help do you look forward to the holidays maybe you struggle with seasonal Blues this time of year can be a lot and it's
00:21:02
natural to feel some sadness or even anxiety about it but adding something new and positive to your life can
00:21:08
counteract some of those feelings therapy can be a bright spot something to look forward to to make you feel
00:21:14
grounded and to give you the tools to manage everything going on if you're thinking of starting therapy give better
00:21:22
help a try it's entirely online designed to be convenient flexible and suited to
00:21:27
your schedule just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist and switch therapist
00:21:33
at any time for no additional charge find your bright spot this season with betterhelp visit betterhelp.com garag
00:21:40
toay to get 10% off your first month that's betterhelp hp.com garage dreaming of overseas Adventures
00:21:52
or connecting more deeply with family from afar Rosetta Stone Bridges the language Gap I've tried others but
00:21:59
Rosetta Stone's immersive lessons and voice feedback technology are game changers dive into 25 Languages by
00:22:05
learning intuitively just like when you were a kid and here's the holiday Sparkle grab a lifetime membership now
00:22:12
and save 50% gift yourself the world head to rosettastone.com now and save 50% hey parents Greenlight is here to
00:22:23
take one big thing off your to-do list teaching your kids about money with a Greenlight debit card and money app of
00:22:29
their own kids and teens Learn to Earn save and invest you can send money instantly set flexible controls and get
00:22:36
real-time notifications of your kids money Activity Set up chores and put allowance on autopilot to reward them
00:22:42
for their hard work then learn about the world of money together get one month free when you sign up at greenlight.com
00:22:49
slmp podcast at Consumer Cellular you get the same exact coverage as the largest
00:22:56
carriers but for up to half the cost cost same thing up to half the cost up to half the cost for the same thing 50%
00:23:02
the money for 100% the same thing I hope I'm making myself clear Consumer Cellular when Freedom calls we're here
00:23:10
to answer call us at 1888 Freedom half the cost savings based on cost of consumer cellular single line 5 GB data
00:23:16
plan with unlimited talk and text compared to lowest cost single line postpaid unlimited talk text and data
00:23:19
plan offered by T-Mobile in Verizon May 2023 all right we are back cheers mates thanks for joining us thanks for telling
00:23:36
a friend cheers to you Colonel cheers captain now we have a very dangerous situation but in the aftermath it
00:23:43
quickly turns to a very sad sad situation the victims that they found on the property that the deputies found and
00:23:52
the Sheriff's Office found on the property are later identified as Jim and Nedra lmy yeah they were the owners of J
00:24:02
and L root iron company and active members of the Faith Community Church which is in nearby Fort Atkinson they
00:24:13
were fatally shot to death at their late father's County Highway a farm this is nedra's Father's Farm now
00:24:26
these two individuals have been described as incredibly wonderful caring people and of course I didn't meet
00:24:35
either one of them don't have any personal direct information or relationship with either of them but
00:24:42
what was telling to me Captain was hearing nedra's voice on that 911 call and just hearing that the first thing
00:24:50
that she says to the first responder is this is not an emergency that tells me this person is caring like
00:24:59
if you have if you have other problems going on or you have something that you think is an emergency person who's
00:25:06
answering the phone please address that first before you get to my problem they are described as down toe people her
00:25:14
friend describes the couple as the couple that made everything fun and they were known for being very helpful in the
00:25:22
community and if they saw a problem they would jump in and they would help out so
00:25:28
now what we have here Captain is this horrible situation the burned down house two dead victims and we have to figure
00:25:35
out a couple things why did this all happen who's responsible and who was the shooter that
00:25:43
was inside of that house and how many shooters do we have the first thing that I wondered in
00:25:50
the autopsy report the information that's come out about that report is not super detailed which I don't know how
00:26:00
much that's going to help the public here or help us in looking at this case and
00:26:07
investigation simply put the news reports say that both died from multiple gunshot wounds the question I have here
00:26:14
is were they shot at close range or were they sniped we do know that the deputy himself when he is approaching the
00:26:23
property and approaching the house it was more of a sniper type situation for the gunfire that was heading in his
00:26:30
Direction well like you said the reason why NRI called in the first place is they saw these broken out windows and so
00:26:37
it makes you wonder how premeditated this was but we are going to get our first very big clue very quickly in this
00:26:47
case so in the aftermath and in the rubble we are now searching the property looking for answers and I'm sure
00:26:54
searching this property very cautiously very carefully because they would expect
00:27:01
to find the shooter yeah we already have a like like you said we have this psychopath at least one maybe multiple
00:27:09
shooters that were already firing at a deputy I mean this person or persons is looking to kill according to documents
00:27:20
the officers the SWAT team and now the Sheriff's Office they're searching the property they find they quickly locate a
00:27:28
black Dodge Ram truck this is a Dodge Ram 1500 the vehicle is registered to Lynn
00:27:37
Anderson they find the truck in an out building and the doors are closed to this out building so they need to figure
00:27:47
out why this truck is there so Lynn Anderson is contacted by the Sheriff's Office what are they say we found your
00:27:55
truck this is the situation why would we find your truck on this property Lynn Anderson explains
00:28:03
to them well that's my husband's truck it's registered to me but he drives it all the time and he drives it and uses
00:28:10
it for work and transportation and that property is his father's property so it wouldn't be totally out of the question
00:28:19
to find his truck there but the interesting thing is that her husband Kevin Anderson does not keep his truck
00:28:28
there his truck goes where he goes right so one would expect to find the truck with Kevin Anderson they've searched the
00:28:36
property high and low and they've not found any additional victims so now we need to figure out why is Kevin
00:28:44
Anderson's truck parked in this out building concealed in this out building if you will yet we don't know where
00:28:52
Kevin Anderson is well like we said we have two dead family members to the deceased owners of the property now we
00:29:00
have another family member that we can't find so is Kevin a victim of this shooter or shooters or is he the shooter
00:29:12
is he the killer you're starting to see a hypothesis take shape here Captain because following up on that vehicle
00:29:19
information after they've identified who the vehicle should belong to and why it
00:29:25
may be there now they want to know well what is Kevin Anderson's relationship to Nedra and her
00:29:35
husband James or he went by Jim right Kevin is nedra's brother Lynn Anderson explains to the Sheriff's Office that
00:29:44
the two of them have not been getting along very well lately and a lot of that had to do with the recent passing of
00:29:52
their father the father according to Lynn Anderson Kevin believed that the father was going to leave Kevin Anderson
00:30:02
as the executive of the will now from my understanding Captain this is what I find to be incredibly
00:30:11
weird there's three kids for my understanding and they were all left equal portions of inheritance right
00:30:21
according to Lynn Anderson Kevin Anderson was extremely upset and angry that the father made Nedra the executor
00:30:31
of the will yeah this works different in different states and different depending
00:30:37
on how you set it up sometimes when you're awarded or not awarded when you're appointed the executive you're
00:30:47
just making sure you're the one responsible for making sure all these things happen in the will and you're
00:30:54
basically the contact person probably for the attorney now sometimes the executive if
00:31:02
they do a lot of work they'll get maybe a little bit of a more percentage for doing that work but everything I see in
00:31:12
this case was she was appointed the executive but everybody was still going to get a equal slice of the pie yeah and
00:31:20
we've seen and I'm thankful that I've not seen this in my immediate family or any of the family's closest to me but
00:31:30
I'm sure a lot of the listeners out there have seen this as well this inheritance situation can rip families
00:31:36
apart and can cause Big Time disputes amongst those receiving an inheritance and those not receiving an
00:31:46
inheritance here what I think the the major problem is is simply the executive status but I
00:31:56
think that goes deep deeper because I think what is not in these reports what's what's not direct and clear in
00:32:03
these reports is sounds to me Captain like Kevin Anderson had one idea for what they should be doing with the house
00:32:12
and the property the the large Farmland that was owned by his parents and Nedra and her husband Jim who are the
00:32:21
executors of the will had a whole different idea I think that Nedra was going to sell the home and the property
00:32:29
and likely share the profits with all of her siblings and Kevin may have wanted to keep the house or keep the property
00:32:40
or believe that it should have been willed to him individually yeah these situations
00:32:46
become difficult CU normally if you have a piece of property then the way it goes
00:32:51
down is you go okay well we have this piece of property and we're all entitled to onethird of the pie
00:32:57
so if Nedra says look I don't want to keep the property it's going to be too much work then it it becomes an option
00:33:05
for somebody like Kevin to buy the property but if you don't have the means to buy that property because he would
00:33:13
have to then pay for 2third of the property for him to own it yeah and again we don't know the exact details of
00:33:21
their will or how everything was broken down so we could have some of that wrong
00:33:24
we're just trying to make some inferences here because of this incredibly tragic and dramatic
00:33:30
situation that has played out well and whether he wanted to keep it or whether she wanted to keep it or sell it that
00:33:36
really doesn't matter what really matters is that there was a dispute about what was going to happen and very
00:33:42
quickly Kevin Anderson becomes the prime suspect for the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office one they find his
00:33:50
vehicle there but two more importantly they don't find Kevin they don't find his remain in the burned out house they
00:33:59
don't find Kevin coming back home that night or returning to work the next day Kevin is Mia and his sister and
00:34:10
brother-in-law have been murdered well good for law enforcement for one finding Kevin's vehicle and now they're getting
00:34:17
some information from Kevin's wife on who Kevin is but what else do we know about
00:34:24
Kevin Anderson well we know this that 10 days after the shooting and after the fire we're not jumping to any
00:34:33
conclusions here Captain because the sheriff's department announces that they that
00:34:40
Kevin Anderson is wanted for homicide and arson charges so they issue a warrant for his
00:34:47
arrest on June 26 2020 now Anderson himself has been referred to as the Black Sheep of the
00:34:57
family he wasn't somebody he was somebody that lived nearby lived by his parents but he wasn't always visible and
00:35:07
in attendance of a lot of family activities and so his the children of Nedra and Jim have said that well they
00:35:17
would see him maybe once or twice a year this would be primarily at like Christmas time or a larger family event
00:35:26
he wasn't somebody that was around it he wasn't somebody that seemed to have a very good or close relationship with his
00:35:33
family so referred to as the black sheep of the family and part of this could be
00:35:39
his personality uh part of this could be his alcoholism there are reports that he had
00:35:46
bouts of alcoholism throughout his adulthood my guess is it's probably a combination of both and we talked about
00:35:56
family disputes especially the disputes after the father passed away but it sounds like there were some family
00:36:03
disputes with Kevin Anderson before the father passed away and we know that he was upset about the will and the
00:36:12
executive status but what's interesting is when the sheriff's department goes to talk to
00:36:19
or to find Kevin Anderson hoping to find him at his home and speaking to his wife
00:36:24
Lynn not only does the wife backup this idea that he's mad about the will they find the will on his kitchen table like
00:36:32
he's been pouring over and and reading through it for days well cuz just to be clear we have his vehicle but we have
00:36:41
nobody that have seen Kevin Anderson on this property there's nobody that saw Kevin Anderson and said I could identify
00:36:49
Kevin Anderson and I know for a fact he was the shooter and we know that he had access to the property and may have had
00:36:57
access to the house and I say may have had access to the house because of some strange things that were going on so
00:37:04
after his father passed away there are plenty of reports out there from Jim and Nedra that say that
00:37:12
they believe somebody was tampering with the property so the locks on the house at
00:37:20
some point had been changed keep in mind Nedra is the executive of the will and of the estate she didn't change the
00:37:29
locks so the locks had been changed somebody set up a trail camera near the home trying to I guess record the
00:37:38
comings and goings of people I can get that like for security purposes but this was something that was unbeknownst to
00:37:45
Nedra and Jim they find the trail camera there and they're like okay who set this
00:37:50
up right they're probably not scratching their heads for very long they probably
00:37:55
know that it's their brother Kevin that set it up and they also told several people that when they would return to
00:38:02
the property the next day or after a couple days that there would be a light or lights on that they did not leave on
00:38:10
when they left so somebody's accessing the house somebody's accessing the property and somebody's changing the
00:38:19
game there at the house and at the property changing the locks setting up the trail camera leaving lights on and
00:38:25
they we do know that when Nedra and Jim came to the house that day on the day in
00:38:31
question she reported at least two broken out windows that her report on the 911 call States was the second floor
00:38:39
of the home well see this what makes me wonder how how premeditated this was because if they have these arguments we
00:38:47
have escalation as far as the property be being tampered with and maybe Kevin knowing that this is going to come to a
00:38:56
head he goes to the house and for whatever reason instead of opening up Windows he just bust out those windows
00:39:03
cuz he's going to use those as a way to essentially kill his family members I'm glad that
00:39:11
you hit on this because a lot of the early reports that were coming out back in 2020 Captain were stating that they
00:39:18
believe that an argument led to the death and the murder of Jim and Nedra and I look at this situ ation and
00:39:26
the more and more I look at it I don't think we had so much of an argument maybe that's a blanketed statement that
00:39:32
this was an ongoing argument but what I see here is a lot of premeditation now listeners out there in listener land all
00:39:42
of you beautiful people out there this case is extremely important even though we have the Sheriff's Office telling us
00:39:50
who committed these murders it's incredibly important because this man Kevin Anderson
00:39:57
is still on the Run we are coming up on 3 years now and they've not located or apprehended this
00:40:05
individual that they have said is responsible for a double homicide the attempted murder of a deputy an arson
00:40:13
burning down a home of supposedly somebody he loved and cared about and he's also wanted on weapons
00:40:22
charges and the reason why Kevin Anderson is wanted on weapons charges is this ain't this dude's first
00:40:29
rodeo he's got prior convictions this comes from when he was a young man so when he was a younger man
00:40:38
him and a friend were and it's described two different ways okay in the reports that I've read uhhuh were vandalizing
00:40:47
some cars or breaking into some cars my guess is they were probably breaking into the cars and if they got caught
00:40:54
they might get lucky if somebody if the officer or a judge saw it as potential vandalism but it doesn't end there they
00:41:01
were inside drinking in this bar all night long getting nice and toasted and then they go out and they're doing
00:41:07
whatever to these vehicles well these vehicles belong to the patrons of that bar right so somebody eventually comes
00:41:15
out and says hey what are you doing to my vehicle and then goes in and tells the
00:41:20
other patrons oh you know uh so and so's out there Kevin and his buddy are out there they breaking into cars so the
00:41:28
patrons come running out of the bar ready to take these two guys down unfortunately
00:41:36
Kevin pulls a gun and starts firing shots at the people running out of the bar yeah but just to be clear this is
00:41:44
this is Kevin when he's in his 20s but he's at this present time of the the murder of his sister and his
00:41:53
brother-in-law he's in his 60s yes I believe he was 61 years of age when his sister and brother-in-law were murdered
00:42:01
but what's so crazy too is if you see uh this property and there's actually a individual on YouTube I I probably
00:42:11
should try to find his information but there was a guy on YouTube that visited the faces of the Forgotten is what I
00:42:19
have written down here for for the YouTube gentleman Yeah so basically what he did was he just goes to the the the
00:42:26
crime scene basically and it's it's modern day so the house has been de demolished show so he just shows you the
00:42:33
property shows you where the house was and then uh I believe he actually visits the graves of the victims to pay respect
00:42:43
um very nice little video but it gives you a very good sense of this property and what this deputy and what the SWAT
00:42:50
team and what all law enforcement was dealing with that day what's so crazy about it
00:42:57
is it's not like there's a bunch of properties like right beside this house like no he basically vanished Into Thin
00:43:06
Air it's very weird because looking at the property and the cool thing is from this faces of the Forgotten guy on
00:43:14
YouTube you can see how it looks roughly today I think this was probably about a
00:43:18
year ago or something since his video came out but you have grass there where the house once was there's still a shed
00:43:26
kind of a larger shed and I don't know if that there's a barn too yeah I don't know which one of those buildings is
00:43:33
where Kevin Anderson concealed his vehicle because that's what I believe that whole intention was was to hide his
00:43:40
vehicle and we'll get into that in a minute but but the crazy thing is one you get to see it's it's very much like
00:43:47
those old Farms where it's a lot of Acres huge property there's no house next door there's no house to the left
00:43:56
to the right or across the street but their home is very close to the the road itself right and then you have two at
00:44:06
least two out buildings I only saw two maybe three there's not much SP there's not
00:44:12
much opportunity for anybody to take any cover right you have the house and it's
00:44:17
not like there's a lot of trees or anything like that however the hell Kevin Anderson got out of there he got
00:44:26
lucky because well he didn't get lucky I shouldn't call it that his gunfire shooting at that Deputy forced them to
00:44:35
retreat yeah and force them to go back far from the house and he probably slipped out the back door and ran in
00:44:43
some Direction but also made me wonder if there was some kind of accelerate and is is it possible that he actually died
00:44:51
in the house and they just never recovered his remains that's interesting because the warrant
00:44:59
as it states is on June 16 2020 Kevin Anderson is alleged to have shot and killed his sister and brother-in-law at
00:45:10
their family farm in rural je Jefferson County Kevin Anderson then proceeded to burn The Farmhouse down and shot at a
00:45:19
sheriff's deputy responding to the farm Kevin Anderson is believed to have fled the area as no remains were found in The
00:45:28
Farmhouse right so let's give a quick description of Kevin Anderson because that's what we are here for you know the
00:45:35
True Crime Community often talks about things like crowd sourcing well there's no bigger or
00:45:43
better job for the True Crime community in the crowdsourcing Arena than apprehending these wanted individuals
00:45:53
these very dangerous indiv indviduals that are still at large so Kevin Anderson would be 64 years
00:46:02
old in 2023 he is a Caucasian male 6ot tall approximately 200 lb with blue eyes and
00:46:12
brown hair he's one of these guys though Captain I saw multiple pictures of him and he his hair is thinning and receding
00:46:21
but he's one of these guys that can look very different to me from picture to picture
00:46:26
he has sometimes the Fu Manchu type of mustache and other times he has a large goatee oh yeah sometimes
00:46:36
he has the old 70s porn stash and sometimes he's clean shaven to me with his facial hair I think he looks
00:46:45
dramatically different with the different types of facial hair or no facial hair yeah and we'll post pictures
00:46:51
of him on our social media but I agree with you if you see him with the porn stash he looks like one individual you
00:46:59
see him with the goatee almost looks like a whole different guy but even more so when he's clean shaving and he puts
00:47:06
on his glasses and I hate to judge a book by its cover but do you get the same vibe
00:47:13
that I get and I know part of that is layered with we know what he's being charged with right and we know about his
00:47:19
previous crimes but isn't he one of those dudes that you just look at him and you get the oh this guy's probably a
00:47:27
jerk this guy's probably he's not this guy's probably a jerk face you know what I mean like he gives you he has the the
00:47:34
appearance of the guy that's probably not a lot of fun to be around he's not a big bag of laughs this guy he looks when
00:47:42
he has his glasses and he's clean shaving and he's and he's partly bald to me he looks like one of those just
00:47:48
grumpy College professors but when you see him with a porn stash or you see him with a go
00:47:57
the the pictures I've seen remember how we've talked to individuals that have come in contact with uh serial killers
00:48:05
or killers and they talk about once they got an attitude once they rubed this murderer the wrong way how their eyes
00:48:16
became like black as coal there's a couple pictures of Kevin that I just think he looks evil
00:48:26
he I'm having a hard time seeing the blue in his eyes as they're described that's what I'm saying there's like it's
00:48:33
like there's there's something um there's something evil when you see these pictures and again we we we know
00:48:44
the story but uh there's something off and you can tell that just by these pictures but like I said that when he's
00:48:52
clean shaven with the glasses he just kind of looks like a a grumpy old college professor and Kevin Anderson is
00:48:59
not a prime suspect make no mistakes about it he's well beyond Prime Suspect status to the point where Kevin Anderson
00:49:07
has been officially charged with homicide charges so Kevin Anderson is facing a class a felony two of them for
00:49:17
homicide carrying a sentence of life in prison he's also facing an additional attempted homicide charge which is a
00:49:24
class B felony with a maximum sentence if convicted of 60 years in prison that arson charge a maximum sentence of
00:49:33
$1,000 40 years in prison and the illegal possession of a firearm by a felon charge which carries a maximum
00:49:42
sentence of $25,000 and 10 years in prison and we have some more detailed information to
00:49:49
get into to get to in a followup episode but it would be incredibly irres responsible
00:49:56
of us to delay until then to get to this very important information it's the reminder of crowdsourcing this is where
00:50:03
you The Listener can help law enforcement authorities are requesting the Public's assistance and the search
00:50:10
for Kevin P Anderson from Fort ainson Wisconsin again Kevin P Anderson is described as a 6 foot tall Caucasian
00:50:19
male who weighs about 200 lb and has blue eyes and balding brown hair we will post photos of Kevin Anderson on
00:50:28
our social Accounts at true Crim garage.com at tcgn on Twitter Anderson should be
00:50:36
considered to be armed likely at all times and it should go without saying that he is extremely dangerous
00:50:44
authorities strongly caution the public and anyone who sees Kevin Anderson do not approach him do not confront
00:50:53
Anderson rather call Authority immediately if in Wisconsin please get in touch with the Jefferson County
00:51:00
Sheriff's office by using one of these two numbers 1 1920 674 7310 or call we tip at 1
00:51:13
80078 crime if outside of the great state of Wisconsin please call the United States Marshalls Service
00:51:21
headquarters at 1877 92 6 8332 these telephone numbers will be listed in this week's show
00:51:32
[Music] notes so much more to get to join us back here in the garage same bat time
00:51:46
and same bat Channel and until then be good be kind and don't litter [Music] [Applause]
00:52:13
[Music] hey parents greenl is here to take one big thing off your to-do list teaching
00:52:32
your kids about money with a Greenlight debit card and money app of their own kids and teens Learn to Earn save and
00:52:38
invest you can send money instantly set flexible controls and get real-time notifications of your kids money
00:52:45
Activity Set up chores and put allowance on autopilot to reward them for their hard work then learn about the world of
00:52:51
money together get one month free when you sign up at Green