Search Captions & Ask AI

Last Will & Testament ////// 263

November 16, 2023 / 48:54

This episode covers the abduction and murder of Sherry Fay Smith in 1985, the investigation that followed, and the eventual capture of her killer, Larry Jean Bell. Key discussions include the details of Sherry's last will, the phone calls from the abductor, and the evidence that led to Bell's arrest.

Sherry Fay Smith was abducted from her home in Lexington County, South Carolina, just days before her high school graduation. Her father discovered her car unattended, prompting a massive search. The investigation took a dark turn when Sherry's abductor called her family, revealing details that indicated her likely death.

The episode details the chilling phone calls made by the abductor, who claimed to have Sherry captive and later provided instructions on where to find her body. The police were able to trace some of these calls, leading them to suspect Larry Jean Bell, who had a history of attempted assaults on women.

After extensive investigation, including the analysis of a letter written by Sherry, police arrested Bell. Evidence included hair samples and a handgun found in his home. The episode discusses the psychological profile developed by the FBI, which accurately described Bell's characteristics.

Ultimately, Larry Jean Bell was convicted of Sherry's murder and sentenced to death. The episode concludes with a reflection on the case's impact and the eventual execution of Bell in 1996.

TLDR

The episode details Sherry Fay Smith's abduction and murder, the investigation, and Larry Jean Bell's eventual capture and execution.

Episode

48:54
00:00:00
this ad is about AT&T's deal on the new iPhone 15 Pro and it's real guaranteed that's not always the case with other
00:00:06
ads the view of a lifetime only with a pricey upgrade breathe in to find inner peace then pay extra to remove the ads
00:00:14
at AT&T we mean what we say learn how to get iPhone 15 Pro with Titanium on us with eligible tradein guaranteed
00:00:21
connecting changes everything AT&T c.com iPhone for details about the guarantee trade in promo for new and
00:00:27
existing customers available for limited time terms and restrictions app when it comes to Quality sleep Ashley
00:00:33
has you covered with top mattress brands at winning prices and with special financing options available you can
00:00:39
snooze now and pay later plus your mattress purchase helps give the gift of better sleep to children in need and US
00:00:47
Special Operations forces visit your local Ashley store or shop online today and make every snooze count financing is
00:00:56
subject to credit approval C store or ashley.com for [Music] [Applause] details [Music]
00:01:42
welcome to True Crime garage wherever you are whatever you are doing thanks for listening I'm your host Nick and
00:01:48
with me as always is the Master of Ceremonies in all of the reindeer games I give you the captain I don't give a
00:01:55
[ __ ] what Santa Claus says second place will still be called first losers this
00:02:01
year it's good to be seen and it's good to see you thanks for listening thanks for telling a
00:02:07
[Music] friend tonight we are drinking holy city pillner by the good people at Holy City
00:02:16
Brewing garage grade four out of five bottle caps this is the first Flagship beer in the Holy City Arsenal this is a
00:02:24
crisp and clean hopped up Bohemian style pilsner holy city will quench your thirst and please pette all in one glass
00:02:31
and today's beer was brought to us by these pleasing peeps first up we have Sam and Frasier and London England and a
00:02:39
big shout out to Lindsay in Fort Wright Kentucky next up we have Audrey from Northfolk Virginia serving this great
00:02:45
country in the Navy so Audrey thank you for your service and also in Virginia we
00:02:49
have Allen in the town of Raven and a big we like your jib to Michael in pintown South Africa and a long distance
00:02:57
cheers to Kia borin Haagen and Oslo Norway and last but not least we have Charles in bodymore murderland that was
00:03:05
my nickname in high school Captain Boyen Haagen all right well a big salute to you Captain Boyen Hagen and a big salute
00:03:12
to everybody near and far that contributed to this week's beer fund if you want to help out for next week go to
00:03:19
True Crim garage.com and click on the Donate button and we're a little behind to hold your horses and that's enough of
00:03:26
the business all right everybody gather around grab a chair grab a beer let's talk some true
00:03:33
[Music] crime [Music] June 1st 1985 3:10 a.m. I love you all last will and testament I love you mommy daddy
00:04:16
Robert Dawn and Richard and everyone else and all the other friends and relatives I'll be with my father now so
00:04:26
please please don't worry just remember my witty personality and great special times we all shared together please
00:04:34
don't ever let this ruin your lives just keep living one day at a time for Jesus
00:04:41
some good will come out of this my thoughts will always be with and in you casket
00:04:49
closed I love you all so damn much sorry Dad I had to cuss for once Jesus forgive
00:04:58
me Rich Richard sweetie I really did and always will love you and treasure our special moments I ask one thing though
00:05:08
accept Jesus as your personal savior my family has been the greatest influence on my life sorry about the
00:05:16
cruise money someday please go in my place I am sorry if I ever disappointed you in any way I only wanted to make you
00:05:26
proud of me because I have always been proud of my family mom dad Robert and Dawn there's
00:05:35
so much I want to say that I should have said before now I love you I know you all love me and will
00:05:44
miss me very much but if you all stick together like we always did you all can do
00:05:51
it please do not become hard or upset everything works out for the good for those that love the Lord all of my love
00:06:01
always I love you all with all my heart Sharon Sherry Smith P.S nana I love you so much I kind of always felt like your
00:06:14
favorite you were mine I love you a [Music] lot Friday May 31st 1985 at 3:38 p.m. Bob Smith discovered
00:06:36
his daughter Sherry's car unattended with the driver's door open in the motor running at the end of the long driveway
00:06:44
leading to the family's home he called out her name several times and got no response he checked the vehicle and
00:06:52
found Sherry's purse on the seat but where was his daughter Cherry's father started searching for her when his
00:06:59
efforts failed Mr Smith contacted the police this is just 2 days before 17-year-old Sherry fa Smith was
00:07:08
scheduled to sing the national anthem at her high school graduation so while most
00:07:13
of her friends and classmates were packing for their High School graduation trip Sherry was abducted from the
00:07:19
driveway of her Lexington County South Carolina home what followed was the largest search in South Carolina history
00:07:28
the inv investigation was Bleak they had no Witnesses and no leads Sherry is what
00:07:34
law enforcement would consider to be an extremely lowrisk victim therefore it was important to clear the family as
00:07:42
fast as possible and move on to other possibilities police very quickly ruled out any involvement by the immediate
00:07:50
family or any of the members of the immediate family they're hoping for a ransom demand so police put a trace on
00:07:58
the Smith's home home phone the next day the Smiths received a phone call on the
00:08:04
line a strangely distorted voice of a man who claims he has Sherry captive he tells Sherry's mother Hilda who answered
00:08:14
the phone so you'll know this is not a hoax Sherry had on a black and yellow bathing suit beneath her shirt and
00:08:22
shorts then the caller says you'll get a letter from Sherry later State officials
00:08:28
intercepted her letter this was entitled last will in Testament from the mail the
00:08:35
letter we read during the trailer was that exact letter apparently her abductor had Sherry drafted shortly
00:08:42
before her death this was a two-page handwritten letter and while it clearly displayed an amazing amount of strength
00:08:50
and courage on Sherry's behalf after reading the letter no one was optimistic the papers were sent for
00:08:58
fingerprint analysis local law enforcement was all over this one the FBI was very quickly sent in and
00:09:06
the FBI feared the worst their theory is that the abductor most likely killed Sherry by the time that they arrived to
00:09:13
assist in the case and the killer would now be ready to search for another victim they believe the kidnapper saw
00:09:21
Sher and her boyfriend Richard kissing at the local shopping mall and from there he followed her home she stopped
00:09:28
at the mailbox box and that's where he snatched her seems like a lot of creeps are hanging out at the local malls so
00:09:34
that was their working Theory and after this first call was received they decided to set up recording equipment at
00:09:40
the Smith home because now they're anticipating another phone call on june3rd they received a call asking if
00:09:47
they had received the letter and the caller asked do you believe me now to which Hilda this is Sherry's mother
00:09:55
replied no I have not heard from Sherry and I need to know if she is alive and well so basically if I'm following you
00:10:02
correctly this dirt bag calls the family and he says I have her mhm and then he says you're going to receive a letter
00:10:10
right but the letter is the last will in Testament so it's almost implying that she's dead and then he calls them back
00:10:18
and says do you believe me now right right he wants to know if they've received the letter
00:10:24
they as said it was intercepted by law enforcement and this this is actually a really good move by sher's mother Hilda
00:10:32
to not kind of cower to this distorted voice on the other end of the phone yeah she's saying look I've not heard from my
00:10:40
daughter I need to know if she's alive and well I don't believe anything you're saying you say you have her captive will
00:10:46
let me talk to my daughter right and so in a sense she's kind of calling his bluff right or hoping so yeah and he
00:10:55
says that when she ask him I need a know if Sherry's alive and well he then responds that you will know in 2 or 3
00:11:03
days and he hangs up the phone now later that same day he did call again this time saying Sherry was alive and he
00:11:11
would release her soon and that he wanted to tell her one thing that Sherry is now a part of him physically mentally
00:11:21
emotionally and spiritually he says our souls are now one Hilda asked again if her daughter was alive and well the man
00:11:30
said Sherry is protected and she is a part of me now and God looks after all of us okay so this guy's
00:11:39
a wacka do weirdo well these are not clear and simple answers to very clear and simple questions from Hilda and the
00:11:49
other thing too Captain using those words Sherry's now a part of me physically mentally emotionally and
00:11:56
spiritually our souls are now one I I can't feel like anybody's got any good feelings in the Smith home hearing
00:12:04
that that sounds very Bleak sounds very bad I mean it just sounds bad well on top of that you have you know her car is
00:12:15
found on mhm so the fact that this individual was able to just pull up behind her grab her take her captive and
00:12:24
now this comeb back is going to bring the Lord Jesus Christ and our savior into this so because of the first call
00:12:30
that was received they were anticipating these two phone calls and attempting to
00:12:36
trace the location of these two phone calls now they did they did have some luck with that they were able to
00:12:44
determine that these two phone calls did come from the general area you know they
00:12:48
were they local let's say right but there are some issues there were some issues with the phone trace according to
00:12:55
the FBI in 1985 it took about 15 minutes to get get a Pinpoint location of the exact phone from which the calls were
00:13:03
placed even with the strength and courage shown by Hilda Smith the caller never stayed on the phone for that
00:13:09
length of time now the man called again this time it was 4 days after the abduction and this time sher's
00:13:17
21-year-old sister Dawn answered the phone the man gave her details about the kidnapping saying he stopped his car
00:13:26
when he saw her at the mailbox he said he took a few photos of her then approached her acting friendly and when
00:13:33
he got close enough he forced her into his vehicle at gunpoint mhm he told Dawn he was regretful that the whole thing
00:13:40
got way out of hand he then went on to tell her that at 3:10 a.m. Saturday the 1st of June Sherry wrote the letter you
00:13:49
received and then at 4:58 Saturday the 1st of June we became one Soul he said don't there he goes with the weird talk
00:13:57
again right and and he says don't ask me any questions he told Don Sherry would be returned the following evening and
00:14:04
that they should have an ambulance on standby adding you'll receive instructions on where to find us well
00:14:11
and this makes you wonder because you take somebody like dmer for example and he would talk about possessing his
00:14:18
victim by eating his victim and that they would become a part of him by doing so so that's where my head goes with
00:14:25
these comments my head actually goes in two directions one what you just said there Talent one right there is is is
00:14:32
the possessing um you know we even hear zodiac wrote in his letters that they will become slaves my slaves in the
00:14:39
afterlife yeah but the weird thing that I find here is a bit of the opposite that we've seen with like when we talked
00:14:47
about keer and we talked about BTK where both of them said you know after I killed
00:14:52
somebody I just immediately went into pure paranoia where I felt the whole world knew what I just did
00:14:59
and at any second they're going to come and get me you know they're going to come and apprehend me and here you know
00:15:05
we have the FBI who stating well we believed by receiving this letter that she was probably
00:15:13
already dead before we arrived on the scene to help and this dude's probably out looking for another victim he might
00:15:20
be but he's also busy spending his time communicating with the family I wonder what happened to give them that
00:15:26
impression that he already killed her I think the letter you know the letter is weird enough that it might steer you in
00:15:32
that direction the same way that it steered us to The Possession possessing the victim MH okay they have become one
00:15:40
all of that Kookie talk right Ro could do but here's one thing I do want to point out and I I read a lot of books by
00:15:49
retired FBI agents humble brag what what what what kind of brag is that that that
00:15:54
I can read I read a lot of books no that just means nothing else to do this is after uh did
00:16:02
you start reading a lot after you studied computer well the thing that I want to point out here that I see Time
00:16:08
and Time Again by these retired FBI agents and don't get me wrong I I enjoy them very much that's why I purchased
00:16:16
their books so I can read them however they're always kind of the smartest guy in the room and I wonder a lot of times
00:16:24
like after the fact they're telling these stories 20 30 years later and they're like we knew already that uh
00:16:30
this is what was going on and it's you kind of I question it sometimes you couldn't have been right every single
00:16:37
time you know what I mean it just doesn't work out that way maybe this is why you identify with the books right
00:16:44
remember he's now telling them that they will receive instructions on where to find us more of the cookie talk and
00:16:50
letting them know that hey I'm going to let Sherry go she will be returned the following evening make sure you have an
00:16:56
ambulance on standby so to me I go on a different route thinking why is so much communication going on if you haven't
00:17:03
kept her alive the paranoia though at noon the next day the man called again and said follow these instructions
00:17:11
listen carefully he said take Highway 378 West to Traffic Circle take Prosperity exit and go 1 and A2 miles
00:17:22
turn right at the Moose Lodge sign go one4 mile and then turn left at the white building go to the backyard there
00:17:31
we will be waiting God chose us and then he hung up the phone yeah this godp is just
00:17:39
creepy well it's South Carolina and it's I I think you know it's part of that no
00:17:45
I don't mind God talk I don't mind that at all you know I'm a spiritual person what I do mind is when you kidnap a
00:17:53
person possibly have already murdered her you made her write her last will in test Testament and now you're saying
00:18:00
that you have became one and then you keep bringing God into this MH so that's uh don't like that much well and given
00:18:08
all these instructions pretty detailed instructions it's good for law enforcement that this call like the
00:18:15
others was recorded So the sheriff's department followed the directions and this led them to the body of Sheri Fay
00:18:22
Smith the decomposition of the body suggested that she had been dead for some time likely since 458 on June 1st
00:18:32
like was noted in the letter right they were pretty sure of this so she was clothed and they could tell she was once
00:18:40
bound with duct tape but the the tape had been removed so we have the residue left over from the duct tape and they
00:18:47
believed that sher's body was likely in this location since shortly after her death unfortunately by the time sher's
00:18:55
body was located due to the advanced decom the pathologist could not ascertain either the cause of death or
00:19:03
whether or not she had been sexually assaulted the pathologist believed however that Sherry either suffocated or
00:19:10
died from dehydration this resulting from a rare form of diabetes from which Sherry suffered evidence suggested she
00:19:18
was killed elsewhere investigators believed her killer placed her there and returned to visit with the corpse and it
00:19:26
was only until the body was to too far decomposed for his liking or decomposed enough to hide SL destroy evidence that
00:19:35
he told the family where to find her it's strange for me with the FBI involved you'd think that they would be
00:19:40
able to determine the cause of death well using the information that they had the FBI unit put together a profile of
00:19:48
the offender they believed that the offender was in his late 20s to early 30s probably divorced living alone or
00:19:56
with his parents white he has uh yeah that they actually will update this profile later and they didn't
00:20:06
include white as part of the first profile uh but probably divorced living alone or with his parents he has some
00:20:14
kind of criminal record this would include assaults on women or at least obscene phone calls if he has previously
00:20:21
murdered anyone the victims would be children or young girls they believed when he was on the phone was Sherry's
00:20:29
family he was reading from a script they believed the killer was rigid orderly and obsessively neat he would take notes
00:20:36
obsessively and keep many list did they say anything about possible military background uh they did not but usually
00:20:44
they will include that if they believe that he does have some type of military background and the reason why I bring
00:20:49
that up is because the neat and orderly possibly wants to create list yeah You' think that would be somebody that you
00:20:55
know had some regiment schedule at some point in their existence they believe that he owned a vehicle likely three
00:21:01
years old or newer and the vehicle is clean well-maintained and cared for outwardly he is arrogant and displays
00:21:09
contempt for the world but on the inside he is insecure and harbors strong feelings of inadequacy he possibly goes
00:21:15
around telling people he reads a lot of books yes and then and then uh doesn't speak too highly of the
00:21:22
authors they said that the man is local having lived in the area for most of his life he had access to a secluded
00:21:30
area where he knew he would have time to spend with Sher and her body they figured that the reason that the
00:21:37
caller's voice sounded distorted is because he was using some type of device to achieve this they determined the
00:21:43
caller was using something called a variable speed device they were now in the process of tracking down
00:21:51
manufacturers of these types of devices and retailers this suggested that the suspect had a background in
00:21:58
Electronics so it's it's always interesting to me Captain how they come up with this some of it more detailed
00:22:04
than other profiles that we've reviewed in the past the stuff about the books is
00:22:09
fascinating right no what gets me is when they say we believe that he has a car that's 3 years old or newer mhm like
00:22:17
that's so Random me and it's like you don't know do they have any eyewitnesses that would make them lean that way or or
00:22:28
is this just kind of a random guess according to the information I could find there was no I Witnesses mhm right
00:22:37
that's that's why it's so Random to me we believe that he has a newer three-year-old car on newer that's so
00:22:45
pinpoint I think they come up with this for a couple of reasons one I think they're working off of the idea that
00:22:52
this guy is driving a lot that he's spending a lot of time driving and they may also believe him to be careful if
00:23:00
they believe him to be careful and driving all the time they're probably going off of the thought that he would
00:23:06
prefer to drive a newer vehicle something that's well maintained and well cared for because it would be too
00:23:12
risky to spend all that time driving and he wouldn't do that because he's careful
00:23:16
or possibly the idea that this guy was married divorced so he possibly has a career is living with somebody or living
00:23:24
with his parents so therefore he has the money where he would have enough nier vehicle because that would be his only
00:23:30
opportunity to maybe impress a female also that's interesting that you picked up on that because with having a
00:23:37
background in electronics they're almost suggesting that they believe this individual has a job and like you said
00:23:44
if they believe he's living with his parents he has more money than somebody not living with their parents but the
00:23:51
obvious thing here is usually when they base off of uh the situation is this individual local or or not and that
00:23:58
seems to be pretty quick to come to that assumption and I think here really exemplifies that to Perfection you know
00:24:07
we have a situation where he gives very detailed directions to find her body and
00:24:13
I have to believe that law enforcement's working off of the thought that that's not just a place that this guy stumbled
00:24:19
upon that this is an area that he knew and knew well and therefore he's a local guy he didn't just drive in and happen
00:24:26
to see her at the mailbox and take her [Music] away this show is sponsored by better
00:24:37
help do you look forward to the holidays maybe you struggle with seasonal Blues this time of year can be a lot and it's
00:24:43
natural to feel some sadness or even anxiety about it but adding something new and positive to your life can
00:24:49
counteract some of those feelings therapy can be a bright spot something to look forward to to make you feel
00:24:56
grounded and to give you the tools to manage everything going on if you're thinking of starting therapy give better
00:25:03
help a try it's entirely online designed to be convenient flexible and suited to
00:25:08
your schedule just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist and switch therapist
00:25:14
at any time for no additional charge find your bright spot this season with betterhelp visit betterhelp.com garage
00:25:22
today to get 10% off your first month that's better help HP ./ garage dreaming of overseas Adventures
00:25:34
or connecting more deeply with family from afar Rosetta Stone Bridges the language Gap I've tried others but
00:25:40
Rosetta Stone's immersive lessons and voice feedback technology or game changers dive into 25 Languages by
00:25:47
learning intuitively just like when you were a kid and here's the holiday Sparkle grab a lifetime membership now
00:25:54
and save 50% gift yourself the world head to rosettastone.com now and save 50% you can start your day off right
00:26:05
when you find a professional on Angie to get your plumbing right first connect with skilled professionals
00:26:12
to get all your home projects done well visit angie.com you can do this when you
00:26:17
Angie [Music] that make sure you check our show off the record on Stitcher premium this week
00:26:31
it's Q&A part one the easiest way to find off the Record is to go to our website and click on the off the Record
00:26:40
link the day after they found the body of Sherry Smith the killer called the home again and this time he called
00:26:48
collect he asked to speak with Dawn he told her he would be sending the family the photos of Sherry and he asked her
00:26:57
for for forgiveness and for their prayers he said he was going to commit suicide because this thing got out of
00:27:04
hand and all he wanted to do in the beginning was to make love to Dawn and that is why he was watching her Dawn
00:27:12
startled by this interrupted the man and asked the man make love to whom then he
00:27:18
corrected himself and he said the name Sherry and he hung up the phone later that same day the killer called a local
00:27:25
TV network and asked for a specific reporter and told that reporter he planned to turn himself in at some point
00:27:32
and he would give the reporter an exclusive interview yeah this guy's changing his stories I'm going to kill
00:27:38
myself I'm going to turn myself in he should have just killed himself yeah you wonder if it's just does he need to get
00:27:45
forgiveness from the family for some reason or is this attention seeking it seems like a lot of work and a lot of
00:27:53
effort risky behavior for some attention yeah but he's a complete whacka do mhm and the FBI didn't believe or they say
00:28:05
they didn't believe the man would turn himself in or kill himself at any point they believe that the calls were in fact
00:28:12
seeking forgiveness from sher's family but also to manipulate and control the situation as much as he possibly could
00:28:20
and that this guy would eventually kill again yeah well this guy's a giant piece
00:28:25
of [ __ ] what what would have been nice though is if he would have put himself in a brown paper bag and then rang
00:28:31
somebody's doorbell and lit himself on fire okay so I do want to touch on this though because we do know from this last
00:28:38
phone call that he says that in the beginning all he wanted to do is make love to Dawn Dawn's 21 years old Sher
00:28:46
Smith is 17 and they actually you can find there's quite a bit of uh photos and images of both of them on the Internet
00:28:56
and you can see that the two of them look very much alike okay so this is when he makes this slip when he says
00:29:05
Dawn instead of Sherry when he's on the phone with Dawn I was really curious why
00:29:10
the FBI didn't update their profile because remember they said at one point that if he had killed before his victims
00:29:18
would have been children or young girls right okay well Sherry yes she's 17 and that's more closer to being an adult but
00:29:27
Dawn is absolutely an adult so you almost wonder if now at this point if you're going to say if he is killed
00:29:33
before is there a chance that Dawn was actually the intended victim you know because he he's not going to see her or
00:29:40
see a girl that he perceives to be Dawn at the mailbox and walk up and ask her if that's are you Dawn you know right
00:29:47
but he did take some pictures before so then you wander thrown and out there maybe this individual's supposed to wear
00:29:54
glasses but doesn't and so is it is it that simple of a mistake and then when he gets closer it's the wrong girl but
00:30:02
it's too late at that point I think it's I think it's very much like that I think
00:30:07
it's he the intended victim was Dawn he hoped to abduct her and do whatever he did with Sherry with her but I think at
00:30:16
some point he would accept the substitution or like you said I mean I think it's kind of too late look he
00:30:25
probably opened up the door for the person mhm and and at that point it's too late in his mind well the man called
00:30:34
Don Smith again at this time he told Don that he gave Sherry a choice of how she
00:30:40
would be killed and the choices were overdose shooting or Suffocation and Sherry chose Suffocation he told Dawn he
00:30:48
killed Sherry by placing duct tape over her mouth and nose until she died 2 weeks after the Abduction of Sherry
00:30:56
99-year-old de deorah May helck was playing with her three-year-old brother at their home in Richland County when
00:31:03
she was abducted from the front yard of the family's home a neighbor saw a vehicle pull up and a man get out of the
00:31:10
car the man spoke with Deborah then grabbed her threw the screaming girl into his car and drove off now the
00:31:18
neighbor immediately alerted Deborah's father who was inside their home they called police and after the two of them
00:31:26
jumped into a vehicle and they went speeding after the abductor car but were unable to track down the vehicle well
00:31:33
this sounds similar to is the FBI immediately thinking this is our guy in Sherry's case yeah yeah they believe the
00:31:41
offender is one and the same and with the addition of the second victim especially a younger victim the FBI
00:31:48
didn't really change their profile but they did add to the profile they added that the Killer and abductor is a white
00:31:57
man outwardly shy may be overweight but at the very least is not attractive to women so he's not Bradley Cooper those
00:32:06
close to him May notice one or more of the following the offender is experiencing weight loss drinking
00:32:13
heavily not shaving regularly and he would be eager to talk about the crimes as he is following the investigation
00:32:21
coverage on the evening news or in the papers he's also collector of pornography that likely focused on
00:32:30
bondage and or is of satom masochistic nature so not good old-fashioned Christian porn and because of the young
00:32:38
age of the second abducted victim Deborah only being 9 years old they believe the offender would be too
00:32:45
ashamed to call or correspond with Deborah's family well this turned out to be true
00:32:51
no phone calls and no letters the killer also stopped calling the Smith house the
00:32:57
the FBI believed that the phone calls would be the easiest way to trap the killer yeah I believe it would be as
00:33:03
well and since he's not calling a writing it's almost like they would want to put out a taunt to him like you know
00:33:10
he already contacted news reporters before have that same news reporter do a report on how this guy uh has become
00:33:17
weak and vulnerable because he hasn't reached out to the FBI so knowing that the Unknown Subject Was following the
00:33:24
case in the news and in the papers the FBI decided to enlist the help of a reporter of a single reporter see they
00:33:32
wanted to force this man out into the open or at the very least get him to call the Smith's home once again they
00:33:40
wanted to use Dawn Smith as bait for their trap now the Smiths begrudgingly went along with this so they held a
00:33:49
memorial service for Sherry Fay Smith they wanted the Smith family and Dawn present at this memorial service and
00:33:57
during the ceremony they had reporters Snap photos of dawn holding a stuffed animal belonging to Sherry and flowers
00:34:05
for her Memorial meanwhile undercover agents wrote down license plate numbers for all the vehicles that were present
00:34:12
in the area now this didn't seem to flush out the killer out into the open but he did once again call the Smith
00:34:20
home this time calling long distance and collect you have a collect call from a giant piece of shot well that's it's
00:34:27
interesting that you say that Captain because okay so in these collect calls you would if you were calling someone
00:34:33
collect you would be given a brief uh set of time there where you could announce who you are so it would say you
00:34:39
have a collect call from so and so and then the person receiving the call who would be paying for it can decide if
00:34:45
they're going to accept the call accept the charges or not so during this portion where the caller can announce
00:34:52
their name and who they are it's a man's voice but he says that his name is Sherry F Smith okay Dawn
00:35:00
does accept this call this time the man was not using the voice Distortion device he told Don that God wants her to
00:35:08
join Sherry Fay saying it's just a matter of time this month next month this year next year you can't be
00:35:16
protected forever then he asked Don if she had heard of Deborah May helmi Don said she
00:35:23
had to which he tells her listen carefully go One Mile West turn left at Bill's Grill go 3 and2 miles through
00:35:33
Gilbert turn right at the last dirt road before you come to Two Notch Road go through the no trespassing sign go 50
00:35:43
yards Deborah May is waiting God forgive us all yeah I don't need this turd stain
00:35:49
to be confessing for my sins the FBI is now worried and regretting the ploy of Using Dawn as bait because of the
00:35:56
received threat uh during all of this law enforcement was still submitting the letter from Sherry titled the last will
00:36:03
in Testament to every possible test the letter was drafted on yellow lined legal
00:36:10
paper from a pad so they decided to use an SD machine this device can detect even the slightest indentations on a
00:36:19
piece of paper they wanted to see if they could pull any possible information from indentations that were made from
00:36:27
writing on pieces of paper above the last will in the legal pad and they found some interesting leads they found
00:36:34
a partial grocery list and a sequence of numbers with further testing they could
00:36:40
detect nine numbers of a possible 10 digigit sequence the numbers are in this order
00:36:47
205 83713 blank 8 this was a phone number in Huntsville Alabama so working with the phone
00:36:59
company they checked all 10 possible phone numbers for a connection to Lexington County South Carolina where
00:37:06
Sherry and the Smith family lived one of the numbers in Huntsville received several calls from a residence just 15
00:37:14
miles from Sherry Fay's home the home belonged to Ellis and Sharon Shepard law enforcement went to the home
00:37:23
and interviewed Ellis and Sharon the Shepherds told police they had made phone calls to Huntsville
00:37:29
where their son was stationed in the Army but they were out of town when both of the murders were committed they
00:37:35
explained a man who worked for Ellis as an electrician Larry Jean Bell was put in charge of house sitting for the 6
00:37:43
weeks that they were away Larry was in his early 30s divorced lived with his parents he was neat and orderly and when
00:37:52
he picked them up from the airport he spoke constantly about about the unsolved murders that occurred while
00:37:58
they were away he had noticeably lost weight he was unshaven and he was irritable the sheriff asked Mr Shepard
00:38:06
to show him the room where Larry stayed while watching the home under the bed they found Mr Shephard's handgun jammed
00:38:14
in pornographic magazines featuring bondage on the cover now regarding the sequence of numbers the couple wrote
00:38:20
down the telephone number for their son and gave it to Larry Jean Bell before they left for their vacation with
00:38:27
instructions that if anything were to come up with the house to call their son the police played a portion of the last
00:38:35
call received by The Smiths this is the one where the killer did not use the voice Distortion device right and the
00:38:41
Shepherds confirmed it sounded just like Larry's voice armed with this information they did some digging and
00:38:49
they found that a vehicle registered to Bell was seen at the memorial service for Sherry Fay the office officer wrote
00:38:57
down the plate number and noted that the driver did not exit the vehicle he simply drove by the vehicle was less
00:39:04
than 3 years old early the next morning police surrounded Larry's parents home and arrested him as he was leaving their
00:39:12
home to go off to work a quick background check revealed Bell was twice arrested for attempted assaults on women
00:39:20
on both of these occasions he attempted to force a young woman into his car at knife point unsuccessfully
00:39:27
under questioning Bell admitted to nothing inside Belle's parents' home in his bedroom police found hairs on the
00:39:34
bed matching hairs from Sherry F Smith in Larry's desk they found a sheet of stamps from which the stamp used to
00:39:42
marry Sherry's last will and testament originated from the neighbor that witnessed the Abduction of Deborah May
00:39:49
told police after the arrest it was in fact Belle who he saw pulling the screaming child into his car that day
00:39:57
under further questioning Bell still admitted nothing so they played the tape of his voice from the phone calls for
00:40:05
him and still Bell admitted nothing so they brought in the FBI to further continue the questioning they took a
00:40:13
different approach rather than to continue to question him they explained to him that they had a lot of experience
00:40:20
in dealing with these types of crimes and that the perpetrator of these types of crimes never gets the opportunity to
00:40:26
explain themselves and their side of the story often the offender is too afraid and ashamed to admit what they have done
00:40:35
and once they are in court their attorney will not let them take the stand right so this individual is then
00:40:41
trapped in a nightmare that never goes away and he goes away to a lengthy prison sentence and no one understands
00:40:49
him no one knows what the hell he was going through at that time well I like their tactic here but we could always
00:40:56
employ my scary clowns where we dress up like clowns and we beat the guy to the inch of his life to get him to start
00:41:03
confessing well as they're explaining this to Larry they notice that Larry Bell is nodding his head up and down
00:41:09
he's he's agreeing with what they have to say uhhuh and seeing that he's responding they leaned in for the kill
00:41:16
and asked him when did you start to feel sorry about the crime Larry did they whisper this I don't know okay seems
00:41:24
like it' be a powerful move you know come on Larry tell us what you know we got you
00:41:32
well they asked him when he started to feel sorry about this crime and to which he says it was when he saw a photograph
00:41:39
of the Smith family right then they asked him if he could have possibly done this sort of thing and Larry told them
00:41:47
quote all I know is the Larry Jean Bell sitting here could not have done this but the bad Larry Jean Bell could have
00:41:57
so that is going to be the closest thing to a confession that Larry Jean Bell would ever give regarding both of these
00:42:04
murders so we do have a confession or a loose confession right implied confession we have some of Sherry's hair
00:42:13
is found in his room on his pillow in his bedroom okay and then we have eyewitness that saw him taking the
00:42:21
9-year-old girl away and the and and then the car registered the yeah so him driving by the memorial
00:42:29
is not really any evidence you know it's stacking pieces on the case right yeah but but there is a lot of evidence like
00:42:37
you said you not only do you have the hairs that match Sherry F Smith's hair in his bedroom I mean how the hell is
00:42:44
that going to get there two you have the sheet from which the stamp came from that the last whe in Testament was
00:42:51
mailed you also have all these little connecting factors to the letter itself you know the indentations that they
00:42:58
found using that SD machine and then you have the uh Shepherds for which he is home you know he's house sitting for and
00:43:07
they say yeah that's his voice on right right on that recording and this is the killer that's calling and taunting the
00:43:14
Smith family and that's not as good as picking them out of a lineup or anything but that's that's something right and
00:43:20
and to which I guess for the lineup purposes you have a bit of less evidence regarding the abduction and murder of
00:43:29
the little girl of Deborah May helmi yeah but you do have that eyewitness who says okay you know I see this picture of
00:43:38
Larry Jean Bell on the news and he calls up police and says that's the same guy that I saw take that little girl so we
00:43:45
have all this evidence mounting up and like you said this real Lucy goosey somewhat of a confession you know he
00:43:52
doesn't say I didn't kill these girls he says the bad Larry Jean Bell could have
00:43:59
done this would have been uh capable I guess of doing this but the good Larry you know he's serving his community and
00:44:06
he's serving God Sherry Fay Smith's older sister Dawn she was super brave and strong during the investigation into
00:44:14
her sister's abduction and murder she went on to be crowned Miss South Carolina and the following year she was
00:44:22
the runner up in the Miss America contest and Fe February of 1986 Larry Jean Bell was convicted of murdering and
00:44:30
kidnapping Sherry F Smith the jury recommended the death sentence and the trial judge imposed the sentence in
00:44:38
accordance with the jury's findings in 1987 in a separate trial Bell was convicted of murdering and kidnapping
00:44:46
Deborah May helck and again he was given a sentence of death for 9 years Larry Jean Bell filed and played the appeals
00:44:55
game trying to work the courts but on October 4th 1996 the state of South Carolina in accordance with his
00:45:04
sentences Larry Jean Bell was strapped into the electric chair and killed a large crowd cheered as the hearse
00:45:11
carrying Bell's body left the broad rer Correctional Institution one of his defense lawyers said quote we have
00:45:20
executed a sick delusional psychotic man [Music] it's beyond fascinating how correct
00:45:35
their profile was in this case now Mr I read a lot of books do we have any recommended reading for this week we do
00:45:45
and I'm happy to announce that it's not a book by a retired FBI agent so you be written on higher than a third grade
00:45:54
level you know what though captain I feel like I want to punch myself in the face for saying that during the episode
00:46:00
because that's like my favorite reading is now you know how I how I feel every episode constantly just fighting the
00:46:07
urge to attack your co-host so this week recommending a book called handsome Johnny the life and death of Johnny
00:46:15
roselli gentleman gangster Hollywood producer and CIA assassin so take a deep dive into the American underworld Johnny
00:46:25
s in handsome Johnny this book I've been looking forward to this one you don't have to write down the title right now
00:46:31
though captain or anybody out there because you can go to our website true Crim garage.com click on the recommended
00:46:37
page we have books and recommendations there for you yeah and head out to the website click on the store Page cuz
00:46:44
there's tons of shirts left uh we're running out of some of the shirts but they should if you order now they'll be
00:46:51
shipped in time for Christmas and real quick before we close out today Captain m um last week I got an email from Carly
00:46:59
she said she was listening to my favorite murder and there's an episode I guess where Georgia mentions True Crime
00:47:06
garage did a four-part series on the boys on the tracks case so Carly excited you know she listens to our show she
00:47:14
went and she tried to find the boys on the tracks and she emailed me and said I cannot find these episodes on your feed
00:47:21
So I responded to her get the Stitcher app because all of our old old episodes are on there and it's free you can
00:47:28
listen to all of our huge giant catalog that Georgia recommends so much on the Stitcher app and join us tomorrow in the
00:47:37
garage as we cover another case instead of just doing one part this week we decided to do two one parters that's
00:47:45
right we will be right back here in the garage tomorrow we expect to see you here until then be good be kind and
00:47:52
don't litter [Music] [Applause] the Angie's List you know and trust is now Angie and we're so much more than
00:48:27
just a list we still connect you with top local pros and show you ratings and reviews but now we also let you compare
00:48:34
upfront prices on hundreds of projects and book a service instantly we can even handle the rest of your project from
00:48:41
start to finish so remember Angie's List is now Angie and we're here to get your
00:48:46
job done right get started at angie.com that's AI or download the app today

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 85
    Most heartbreaking
  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Most emotional
  • 75
    Most intense

Episode Highlights

  • Sherry's Last Will
    In a heartbreaking letter, Sherry expresses her love and hopes for her family.
    “Please don't ever let this ruin your lives.”
    @ 04m 37s
    November 16, 2023
  • The Discovery of Sherry's Car
    Bob Smith finds his daughter Sherry's car abandoned, leading to a frantic search.
    @ 06m 33s
    November 16, 2023
  • The Distorted Voice
    A mysterious caller claims to have Sherry, revealing chilling details about her captivity.
    “Sherry is now a part of me physically, mentally, emotionally, and spiritually.”
    @ 11m 17s
    November 16, 2023
  • The Killer's Confession
    The killer called Dawn, claiming he would send photos and asked for forgiveness.
    “I’m going to commit suicide because this thing got out of hand.”
    @ 27m 02s
    November 16, 2023
  • Larry Jean Bell Arrested
    Larry Jean Bell was arrested after evidence linked him to the abductions and murders.
    “The bad Larry Jean Bell could have done this.”
    @ 41m 47s
    November 16, 2023
  • Dawn Smith's Bravery
    Dawn Smith, sister of Sherry, showed incredible strength during the investigation.
    “She went on to be crowned Miss South Carolina.”
    @ 44m 19s
    November 16, 2023
  • Execution of Larry Jean Bell
    Larry Jean Bell was executed in South Carolina, drawing a cheering crowd.
    “We have executed a sick delusional psychotic man.”
    @ 45m 17s
    November 16, 2023
  • Book Recommendation: Handsome Johnny
    A deep dive into the life of gangster Johnny Roselli, a Hollywood producer and CIA assassin.
    “Take a deep dive into the American underworld.”
    @ 46m 22s
    November 16, 2023
  • Next Episode Teaser
    The hosts will cover two one-parters in the next episode.
    “Join us tomorrow in the garage as we cover another case.”
    @ 47m 35s
    November 16, 2023

Episode Quotes

  • Please don't ever let this ruin your lives.
    Last Will & Testament ////// 263
  • Everything works out for the good for those that love the Lord.
    Last Will & Testament ////// 263
  • All he wanted to do in the beginning was to make love to Dawn.
    Last Will & Testament ////// 263
  • We have executed a sick delusional psychotic man.
    Last Will & Testament ////// 263
  • It's beyond fascinating how correct their profile was in this case.
    Last Will & Testament ////// 263
  • Take a deep dive into the American underworld.
    Last Will & Testament ////// 263

Key Moments

  • True Crime Garage01:42
  • Heartbreaking Letter04:13
  • Sherry's Abduction07:05
  • Discovery of Body18:22
  • Killer's Confession27:02
  • Arrest of Larry Bell41:41
  • Book Recommendation46:11
  • Closing Remarks47:52

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown