00:00:07
[Music] thank you [Music] [Music] thank you foreign garage wherever you are whatever you're
00:00:43
doing thanks for listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is a man who
00:00:47
is 100 concentrated no pulp here is the captain it's good to be seen good to see
00:00:54
you thanks for listening thanks for telling a friend [Music] this week we are excited to be featuring
00:01:04
a beer from one of the great brewing companies and this beer is called Nosferatu by the really good Folks at
00:01:11
Great Lakes Brewing Company don't be afraid of things that go hop in the night this is a scary good Imperial Red
00:01:18
Ale ABV 8 garage grade 4 out of five bottle caps and let's give some praise and cheers to our friends that helped us
00:01:26
out this week first up a big shout out to Patty Callahan for always picking up cheers to you Patty the big we like to
00:01:33
jib to Catherine in Wheeling West Virginia next a big Midwestern shout out to Rebecca from Ankeny Iowa and a big
00:01:40
shout out to Michael in Piedmont South Carolina next we have Jeffrey and Amesbury Massachusetts and last but
00:01:46
certainly not least we have Jessica and Plymouth Meeting Pennsylvania everyone we mentioned they went to our website
00:01:53
that's true crime garage.com clicked on the Donate button which helped us out with this week's beer run and for that
00:02:00
we thank you yeah e double r-u-n Beer Run only a few tickets left to our July 9th event at Fat Bottom Brewing Company
00:02:10
in Nashville so get those tickets you can get those at true crime garage.com or if you want to come hang out with the
00:02:17
captain July 14th at brewdog in Cleveland you can find tickets at my website captions.com that is enough of the
00:02:27
business all right everybody gather around grab a chair grab a beer let's talk some true crime
00:02:35
[Music] the most prolific serial killer in American history Samuel little has confessed to 93
00:02:45
murders [Music] it's disturbing to listen to but investigators want to hear it all and
00:02:57
more laughing while I was killing them the most prolific serial killer in American history
00:03:16
[Music] little says he has a photographic memory and has drawn sketches of his victims
00:03:24
bronze sketches Mary brasley was a woman that intimately knew the real life meaning of the word
00:03:33
struggle sadly she had first-hand knowledge of what it meant to struggle and she fully understood the continued
00:03:41
Battle of struggling for Mary life was far from Easy her childhood was difficult
00:03:49
and her early adult years were far worse she kept finding herself falling into the arms of abusive and uncaring Men
00:03:57
[Music] falling for and falling in love with men that just beneath the surface or anything but desirable
00:04:06
they say that life is a journey and not a destination and for Mary it was a journey of
00:04:12
hardships and strife the road map of that Journey was not an easy one for Mary to navigate
00:04:19
she was broken by the husband and boyfriend that abused her and through injury ailment and addiction found
00:04:26
herself unable to care for her children Mary's roads on her life's road map if there ever were such a thing had
00:04:35
collapsed to a single dark and damp tunnel the light at the end of that tunnel was
00:04:40
so dim that she was convinced that the fairy man blew out the flame on his Lantern when she wasn't looking
00:04:47
she had many physical complications and challenges a physically abusive boyfriend injured
00:04:53
her so badly that she had to have hip surgery which left her with metal Parts in her body in a limp
00:05:01
there was also a self-inflicted injury from a kitchen accident when Mary nearly cut off her finger
00:05:07
while chopping vegetables and then refused to have it treated she let the severed portion dangle until
00:05:14
it eventually fell off leaving her with a stump at the end of the digit by 1970 Mary brasley was 33 years old and she
00:05:25
was struggling not struggling to make it she was struggling to exist [Music] some of her troubles were roadblocks set
00:05:36
up by others and some were obstacles that she created herself [Music] by now she was a severe alcoholic
00:05:44
she suffered from cirrhosis of the liver it was nearly anorexic standing five foot four inches tall and weighing a
00:05:52
very unhealthy 80 pounds she was pretty much estranged from her family sometime in June of 1970
00:06:02
Mary walked away from her life in Massachusetts without so much as a single goodbye to anyone
00:06:09
her kids were already in foster care and she didn't care for any of the men in her life
00:06:16
the last reported sighting of Mary is from a story that came from a family member
00:06:21
one of the very few who had not turned their back on Mary this was Mary's sister Claire
00:06:28
Claire says that on June 12 1970 she was told that the night before police picked
00:06:35
Mary up walking along a highway told police she was walking the highway because two men had pushed her out of
00:06:42
their car in Palmer Massachusetts and she hurt her shoulder it's unclear where Mary slept that night
00:06:50
but her family was told that she was planning to take a bus back to Boston where she was staying with her parents
00:06:58
Mary never showed up in Boston she never returned to her parents home Claire later told the media that Mary
00:07:06
would often rely on and get around by taking rides with strangers and Mary could often be found in the company of
00:07:13
anyone that would provide her with alcohol Mary's family never heard from her again
00:07:19
roughly seven months later on January 24 1971. a father and son were out on a Hunting
00:07:27
Expedition what they will find certainly is not what they went out looking for one of the two spotted a leg sticking
00:07:36
out of the ground they reported this immediately to the authorities and as you guessed it the leg was
00:07:42
attached to the rest of the body buried in a shallow six-inch deep makeshift grave
00:07:49
but the Father and Son were not hunting in Massachusetts no they were in the Florida Everglades
00:07:54
one thousand miles away from where Mary was last seen the body was badly decomposed and
00:08:02
detectives could locate no form of identification from the body recovery site this was a homicide
00:08:10
the victim was a female with highly probable sexual assault suspected based on the fact that the body was
00:08:18
found with both legs through one leg hole of the victim's panties detectives believed that Mary's killer
00:08:24
dressed her after the assault and murder before burying her body since investigators could not identify
00:08:31
the victim the county gave the victim a new name one that no one wants in 1971 Mary became another Jane Doe
00:08:42
Mary simply disappeared and decades passed with not one indication of her faith life moved on
00:08:50
children grew up and the body remained at Jane Doe for 47 years but thankfully one day this Jane Doe
00:08:59
would get her birth name back and sadly her family would learn what they may have feared all along
00:09:06
Mary didn't just disappear she was taken taken far away and killed Mary brosly was located after all of
00:09:16
these years and her killer was too Mary might have been this killer of women's first kill
00:09:22
but she was far from his last this is true crime garage oh foreign [Music] San Diego California Thursday September
00:09:48
27 1984. San Diego PD received a complaint of a violent crime Lori Barros called
00:09:57
9-1-1 from her sister's house she told police that a man whom she did not know beat her up raped her and strangled her
00:10:06
and then left her for dead on the side of the road she was able to provide police with a detailed description of
00:10:12
the events that took place as well as the assailant and the vehicle he was driving at the time
00:10:18
according to the report Laurie told police that the man abducted her she was walking and this man pulled up in a
00:10:25
large American car he got out ran up to her and he pulled her by the throw into his car
00:10:33
once inside the vehicle the man threatened her repeatedly all the while driving to a more secluded location once
00:10:41
he arrived at a spot that he found to be satisfactory for whatever it is that he
00:10:46
planned to do he put the vehicle in park and then proceeded to brutalize the woman choking and punching her the LA
00:10:53
Times described portions of the attacks as follows quote with his arm still wrapped around her neck he drove to a
00:11:00
deserted trash strewn lot at the top of a steep hill he pulled her into the back
00:11:06
seat and tied her hands behind her back with her nylons he tried to kiss her and
00:11:12
when she tried to shove him off he began choking her he asked her to swallow he did this over and over again Captain
00:11:19
Lori finally played dead and the man opened the car door and dumped her out onto a pile of garbage
00:11:28
she believes that the man intended to kill her and that he actually thought that he had succeeded when he discarded
00:11:34
her she was not dead however but she lay right where he dumped her She lays still
00:11:40
taking extremely short breaths even though she wanted to gasp for air and fill her lungs with the oxygen that he
00:11:47
had just denied her she laid there not moving a muscle she was afraid he was watching
00:11:55
as the minutes passed she started to convince herself that he had gone but she laid there
00:12:01
still because now the fear was that he would return and find her alive and if so he would most certainly finish the
00:12:08
job Lori believes that she laid there for over 30 minutes or so before she finally
00:12:15
got up stumbled to the nearest pay phone there she called her sister who immediately rushed out to get her
00:12:23
once she finally felt safe when she was back at her sister's house she called the police and reported that she was
00:12:30
attacked and luckily she was able to provide police with a detailed description of the vehicle and her
00:12:37
attacker that's correct a good amount of detail in fact in regard to the events the attack
00:12:44
that took place the attacker and his vehicle or the vehicle he was driving at the time
00:12:49
the man that she described to police she described him as African-American approximately 40 years of age about six
00:12:57
foot one inches tall 230 to 240 pounds with a dark complexion dirty unshaven and he had a gold pinky ring with two
00:13:09
diamonds in it now she said that the attacker was driving a two-door large American-made car with a maroon colored
00:13:16
interior the passenger side window of this vehicle was broken and there was white tape on the window
00:13:25
so this making this vehicle very distinct and possibly easy for police to spot he had foam dice hanging from the rear
00:13:34
view mirror she said the vehicle did not run well so that's a pretty good description of
00:13:40
everything right Captain well the key thing there is the broken window with the white tape well that description
00:13:46
from Lori will in fact lead us to this later event the following month on Wednesday October
00:13:54
24th San Diego Patrol officers happened upon a black Thunderbird parked on a street this was in an area of the city
00:14:03
known for stolen vehicles sex workers and drugs the Thunderbird fit the description of
00:14:10
the car reported by the victim of the September attack the one that we just covered so of course they stopped to
00:14:16
check it out the police now as the officers were shining their lights on the T-bird a black man emerged from the
00:14:24
car zipping up his trousers flicky flicky hands are sticky according to the officer's statements the man quote
00:14:32
appeared to be very nervous one officer said of the man he kept looking at us kept looking at the car then looking at
00:14:40
us and then looking at the car they approached him and asked him what he was doing
00:14:45
the story he gave was that he had had a fight with his wife but they had now made up and they were making love in the
00:14:52
back of that car but the cops could see bloody scratch marks on the man's neck right they took
00:15:00
a look inside the vehicle and saw his I'm using air quotes here Captain wife she was stuffed on her back behind the
00:15:09
driver's seat leg splayed on the back seat naked her eyes rolled back in her head bleeding and bruised the officer
00:15:20
thought the woman was dead at first but then she started gasping for air so the officer could see fresh choke marks on
00:15:28
the woman's throat and remember he saw the scratch marks on the man you don't have to be on the job
00:15:36
too long to have a good idea what you think took place so obviously this guy's lying and obviously he's trying to choke
00:15:43
this lady to death and good thing they were there to stop it and arrest him yeah there's a few things that work out
00:15:51
here in our favor right first we have the great detailed description given by the first victim we have the good police
00:15:59
work by these two officers by spotting this car in a area that it sounds to me like if you're looking to bust somebody
00:16:06
or issue a ticket you can just drive to this area any time of day and find somebody to put the back of your car
00:16:13
somebody that's up to no good but they check on this vehicle and like you said they they see that there's
00:16:19
something strange going on here this woman appears to have been assaulted very badly this man's story doesn't make
00:16:28
sense of course they arrest him and they are told by the man that his name is Samuel McDowell
00:16:35
so Sam's story well his original story will start to fall apart very quickly and he started to admit some truths to
00:16:45
the officers although of course he was not going to be entirely truthful Sam said that he was angry because he
00:16:53
had not gotten his money's worth from his victim So This Woman's name is Tanya Jackson and she is a sex worker at this
00:17:02
time Sam said that he met Tanya at a bar in downtown San Diego where the two of them
00:17:09
agreed that she would perform a sex act for him for twenty dollars he said she directed him to the location
00:17:16
where the officers would later discover the two and his vehicle he says they got
00:17:22
into the back seat of his car and Tanya started fooling around with him Sam says
00:17:28
that he wanted more but then she started to refuse this upset Sam so Sam says that he threatened her and told Tanya
00:17:36
that she wasn't going anywhere until he got what he wanted Sam says Tanya attacked him
00:17:42
and he grabbed her around the throat in self-defense and he's telling the officers this is why the officers are
00:17:50
driving him back to the station after they arrested him they're still asking him what happened back there it's
00:17:57
hard to believe him on anything when he said when he said the victim was his wife and not a sex worker well and then
00:18:05
you have the situation of he's saying now yeah I grabbed her by the throat yeah I was choking her but this was in
00:18:12
self-defense and he's I mean he's not making any buts about it he's telling the officers I did this and you know
00:18:18
what she deserved it so while the officers are driving him back to jail Sam asked them several times quote how's
00:18:27
the [ __ ] is she going to make it with a douchebag then they accused him of raping Tanya
00:18:35
Sam continued to deny raping her but admitted that quote I did kick the [ __ ] out of her he also told police I should
00:18:43
have killed that [ __ ] in both of these cases the September case and the October
00:18:48
case rape exams and kits were conducted this included collecting Sam McDowell's DNA
00:18:56
so Sam was quickly connected to the attack on Lori Barros the previous month because their findings are going to
00:19:03
match up in both of these cases and this is back in the day when police officers
00:19:08
have billy clubs it'd be nice if they would have just pulled over on the side of the road and he never made it back to
00:19:13
the station for the attacks on Lori and Tanya Sam McDowell was charged with several charges including attempted
00:19:20
murder in both cases the state's best evidence in these cases were the two victims themselves of course right their
00:19:28
statements to the police and then later what would be their testimony in front of a jury
00:19:35
but Sam ended up only being convicted on lesser crimes this is due to some complications with
00:19:42
the trial the two victims were both sex workers that complicated things and we'll get into that here in a minute
00:19:49
and little argued that his only crime was hitting one of them in a payment dispute after she tried to
00:19:56
cheat him now this Sam McDowell in court also produced an alibi witness this was a
00:20:03
respectable looking woman carrying a Bible who said that the two of them were out of town on the night of one of the
00:20:10
attacks so the one where he's caught red-handed he can't do much about other than to to claim that he was acting in
00:20:16
self-defense but the one where he wasn't caught he's able to produce an alibi for
00:20:21
right so what we have here Captain is the situation yes those rape kits and exams were conducted in both of these
00:20:29
cases they also connect they also collected this Sam McDowell's DNA but keep in mind
00:20:36
this is 1984. they're not able to go oh well this is the same guy in both of these cases
00:20:42
so he can come up with a defense for the first one saying that one wasn't me even
00:20:49
though you picked me up a month later for about the same thing and now this Lori Boris is picking me out of a lineup
00:20:56
I'm telling you I'm not this guy and on top of that I have a witness who comes in she's carrying a Bible saying you
00:21:04
know what the two of us we are together we're in a relationship and we were both
00:21:09
out of town on the night of the September attack so he's got a somewhat decent defense
00:21:16
here for what should be an easy conviction of two accounts of attempted rape well and also you can make an
00:21:24
argument that the second attack that he's caught red-handed that that's an attempted murder charge yeah but in both
00:21:31
cases he was charged with attempted murder now per the Washington Post uh it says that this Sam McDowell was
00:21:39
convicted of falsely imprisoning the second victim but acquitted of kidnapping and sexually assaulting the
00:21:45
woman in the first attack and the jurors were deadlocked on a host of other charges
00:21:52
so this trial all of a sudden it looked like a slam dunk wasn't going so well for the prosecution
00:22:00
so prosecutors were not very anxious to retry Sam so they allowed him to plead guilty to
00:22:08
two counts of assault with great bodily injury and one count of false imprisonment now I want to read to you a
00:22:16
portion of Lori bars's testimony this will kind of describe our attacker here and his method and what he was like in
00:22:26
that attacking situation her testimony says quote he liked to feel me swallow with his thumb on my
00:22:33
neck it became a game right before I'd go unconscious as my eyes started rolling
00:22:40
back he'd let go and asked me to swallow again he loved when I swallowed it excited him
00:22:46
and he had a smile on his face so she's talking about while this man is choking her strangling her to death
00:22:54
that when she would start to black out he's letting go so she can breathe and come too so he can do it again to her
00:23:01
and going so far that she says that he had his thumb right on the portion of my neck where he could feel me swallow and
00:23:11
wanted to feel me kind of swallow and gag and try to gasp for air this guy is an absolute creep it's sad but the
00:23:20
reality is especially in these types of crimes that the surviving victim is your
00:23:25
best evidence this is often your best tool if you will for apprehending your unknown perpetrator in these crimes and
00:23:33
the victim's stories and Reporting these crimes they did get this monster off of
00:23:37
the streets but not terribly long so unfortunately the way that this plays out in court again we said that it
00:23:47
should have been a slam dunk and it should have been but I I'm not trying to blame this on
00:23:51
any one or two people here but the victims themselves just kind of fell apart in the courtroom
00:23:59
so the October victim who had an addiction problem was drunk and clearly drunk in front of the jury when she was
00:24:08
at trial and when she was giving her testimony this could be from her addiction this could be from the terror
00:24:14
that this man brutalized her and now she's got to sit in front of him just feet from this guy
00:24:22
the woman from the September attack the problem ended up being with her situation is she started to lose
00:24:28
credibility with the jury when she first starts off her complaint to the police and then her testimony to the court
00:24:37
was that she was just walking along the street this guy pulls up jumps out of his car grabs or throws her into his
00:24:44
vehicle and he's abducted her and off they go to a secluded location where he tries to kill her
00:24:50
well very quickly it's figured out that she wasn't just walking on the side of the street she's
00:24:57
a sex worker and she has an addiction problem this caused her to lose credibility with
00:25:04
the jury and now the first attack he's not looking so guilty in and the second attack they're a little confused as to
00:25:11
what's going on because he's saying look I yeah I did fight with this woman I did
00:25:16
assault her but I didn't try to kill her what we end up with here is Sam McDowell most certainly attacked
00:25:24
both of these women he most certainly tried to kill both of them but unfortunately because it fell apart
00:25:34
at court for this he only serves two years in a California prison and then he's released on parole
00:25:41
and once he's released on parole within months of Sam McDowell's release women in South Los Angeles started dying
00:25:56
oh foreign [Music] [Music] [Music] we are back cheers mates cheers to you Colonel cheers to you Captain tall cans
00:26:31
in the air everybody out there listening thanks for joining us this week now we're going to move on here to a couple
00:26:37
of other cases and this takes place in 1987 and then 1989 in and around the Los Angeles area so we're going to go back
00:26:46
starting in July of 1987 where we have the first of three bodies that were found that all
00:26:54
displayed similar characteristics they were all found within a few miles of each other the three bodies were dumped
00:27:01
like trash now I know that that is a rather overused statement in True Crime but in this case these three bodies were
00:27:10
actually dumped along actual refuse the first victim was 41 year old Carol Alford her body was found on July 13
00:27:19
1987. the other two homicide victims that were found were Audrey Nelson age 35 and Guadalupe abadaka age 46.
00:27:29
they were found in August and September of 1989 respectively this killer though unknown at the time
00:27:39
to police his identity let's think about what we know here in the garage as we review those attacks that took place in
00:27:47
San Diego he gets locked up and then he's out he's released and we have these three murders that take place and you go
00:27:57
you know what this guy is he's escalating he's increasing his frequency of attacks but not necessarily this guy
00:28:05
already has escalated to this level of frequency because in 1984 those two attacks took place one month apart
00:28:16
just like here where we have two victims that take place just one month apart this guy whatever he's into he requires
00:28:24
this type of stimulation so much that he's to the point where he's going out and attacking women killing them or in
00:28:33
the 84 cases believing he had killed them within a month of one another obviously
00:28:39
his crimes are sexually motivated yes now for a little more of the Grim details of each of the body recovery
00:28:47
scenes all of these victims were found in the same Central Avenue Alameda street
00:28:53
Corridor near downtown Los Angeles So within five miles of each other Carol was in a back alley against a
00:29:02
fence Audrey was found in a dumpster which was located in a nightclub parking lot
00:29:08
Guadalupe was found in an abandoned creepy old commercial garage structure all three had been manually strangled
00:29:17
and it was determined that all three were dead when they were dumped all had been brutally beaten with blows or
00:29:24
punches to the head all were nude below the waist all had crack in their systems
00:29:31
one victim had mailed DNA under her fingernails two victims had semen stains on their shirts
00:29:39
but in the 80s before CODIS this was a very little help to the murder investigations
00:29:45
and so the three dead women remained victims of a nameless faceless Predator their deaths not linked together until
00:29:53
much much later these attacks seemed similar to me of that of like Ted Bundy but again we're gonna have another
00:30:02
Survivor from these attacks and this is believed to be an attack connected to these others because it's so similar in
00:30:11
nature or similar in belief as to what we think happened to the other three victims it did not survive so another La
00:30:19
woman who narrowly escaped the same fate comes forward and reports the assault and per the Los Angeles Times
00:30:29
we learn some details of that attack and the times reported that the woman reported to the city's police that a man
00:30:38
had pulled her into his black Thunderbird here we see that similar vehicle again
00:30:43
sexually assaulted her then repeatedly choked her unconscious she awoke to find herself lying Left for
00:30:51
Dead amid trash and broken glass with bruising on her neck and popped blood vessels in her eyes but she couldn't
00:30:59
name her attacker when she reported this to police and so just like the three dead victims this case too would go
00:31:07
nowhere this investigation really had nowhere to go so now we're going to skip ahead to over two decades later
00:31:15
this is going to bring us 2012. now in 2012 homicide detective Mitzi Roberts was assigned to the lapd's
00:31:27
Cold Case special section which was funded by a grant from the National Institute of Justice to try to solve the
00:31:34
9000 La murders that remained open after five years her job was screening DNA evidence from cases long since
00:31:45
considered lost causes many of these cases were murders of women that dated back to the 80s the height of the
00:31:52
cocaine epidemic in the city good thing she gets involved because she's going to
00:31:56
come across a CODIS search for two of these crimes that happened in 1989. yeah so she's worked in this case in April of
00:32:05
2012. and Mitzi runs across a CODIS search on the DNA that was found on the two women murdered in Los Angeles in
00:32:13
1989. this is the Audrey case and Guadalupe's case now keep in mind mitzi's working with resources that the
00:32:21
investigators just did not have in 1989. Mitzi arranged for the DNA testing on swabs and items found from those two
00:32:31
victims bodies now in both cases she got a hit to a man who had been arrested and
00:32:38
required to give a DNA sample in connection with a previous arrest and this man's name was Samuel little yes
00:32:45
and the officer Captain she was horrified at what she found when she started reviewing his
00:32:51
record so this man had a rap sheet 100 pages long detailing approximately 100 arrests
00:32:59
this from an article in New York Magazine by Jillian Lauren quote over six decades
00:33:06
he was repeatedly arrested in Ohio Maryland Florida Maine Connecticut Oregon Colorado Pennsylvania New Jersey
00:33:14
Arizona Georgia Illinois Missouri California and the list goes on charges include burglary breaking and entering
00:33:23
assault and battery assault with the intent to Rob assault with a firearm armed robbery assault on a police
00:33:30
officer solicitation of prostitution DUI shoplifting Theft Grand Theft possession of marijuana unlawful flight
00:33:39
to avoid prosecution resisting arrest battery false imprisonment assault with great bodily injury robbery rape and
00:33:49
sodomy end quote and he left out being a huge douchebag yeah that's quite the rap sheet there
00:33:56
Captain yeah scary individual scary individual not only that we didn't even name all of the states
00:34:04
that would have been listed there and so this guy is up to no good frequently up
00:34:09
to no good he's got all kinds of nasty horrible hobbies and he's fine doing them in your neighborhood my
00:34:15
neighborhood and everybody else's all in all this Samuel little had served less than 10 years in prison in total
00:34:23
despite repeated brutal and sexually motivated attacks on and attempted murders of multiple female victims
00:34:31
so of course Mitzi Roberts reviews this information and she freaks out right why
00:34:37
on God's name was this guy on the streets so she decided she was going to be the
00:34:44
one to put an end to this dude to stop him and put him away for good when others could not now the Samuel little
00:34:52
had an outstanding Los Angeles bench warrant for a 2007 narcotics violation so that's good news for us in our
00:35:01
investigation right we got this really bad guy here he's got this lesser charge but it's an outstanding warrant that's a
00:35:08
good excuse for us to go pick this guy up and have a long talk with him not only are you going to be able to talk to
00:35:13
this creep but you're probably going to be able to put him away for at least a short amount of time you're hoping so
00:35:19
now Roberts officer Roberts decided to in fact use that warrant to bring him in but the problem's going to be that she
00:35:29
couldn't locate him from her information he didn't appear to be in California any longer and she
00:35:35
discovered that this Samuel little who was transient moving from place to place well there's some of you out there
00:35:43
scratching your heads going wait didn't you say Samuel McDowell earlier now you're saying Samuel a little well
00:35:49
that's because this guy he's got a list of aliases almost as long as the list of crimes that he's
00:35:55
been connected to and convicted of so he uses aliases like Samuel McDaniel Samuel McDowell Willie Mae Clifton and
00:36:05
Willie Lewis and the list goes on he was nearly impossible to locate and officer Roberts and her team spent weeks
00:36:15
dashing from town to town across the southern U.S as they got hits on a usage of a prepaid Walmart card to which
00:36:23
little Social Security Disability Benefits were being paid so this is one of those situations where
00:36:30
boom they get these hits on these this Walmart credit card that's directly tied to the individual that they're looking
00:36:37
for and we're only dashing from town to town or state to state looking for this guy
00:36:43
or through the snow because we're convinced that he's guilty of all kinds of other stuff in fact we've already
00:36:49
connected him to two homicides you're always a day late and a dollar short because you're you're always
00:36:55
chasing this guy and you're getting your information days after he's probably already left that town
00:37:02
so they're running about looking for this individual they were always about two days behind
00:37:09
him she said Samuel little had been arrested in Kentucky for possession of a crack pipe so they knew that he had been
00:37:17
in the Bluegrass State recently finally in early September of 2012 he used that Walmart card as some Mini Mart in
00:37:27
Louisville Kentucky and the Sheriff's Office was notified and in turn notified the LA authorities Roberts contacted the
00:37:36
U.S Marshals and gave them the address of the homeless shelter that this man was registered at this was the Wayside
00:37:43
Christian Mission they had him in custody within hours this is after 60 years of committing
00:37:50
crimes well once they arrest him they're able to get a DNA swab from him so they
00:37:56
could do a DNA test against the evidence they have in these other crimes yes this
00:38:01
DNA swab the DNA test it absolutely links this man Samuel little to the unknown male profile that
00:38:10
was found on two of our victims this is from 1989 the victims Audrey and Guadalupe so Samuel little was
00:38:18
extradited to California on the outstanding warrant for the narcotics charge and he was sentenced in November of 2012
00:38:26
to three years for that crime but soon he would be termed a serial killer for the murders of Audrey and Guadalupe and
00:38:36
Carol who was the 1987 victim that was found in the same location as Audrey in Guadalupe and yes and quickly they'll be
00:38:46
able to charge him with three murder charges to Samuel little this again from Jillian
00:38:52
Lauren who we will be citing quite a bit in these episodes as she's done gangbusters work on these cases and
00:38:59
spent a lot of time working on these cases she says quote Little's genetic material had been detected on the bra
00:39:08
and fingernail kit of 41 year old Carol Alford who had been found strangled in a
00:39:14
residential South Central Alleyway in July of 1987. it was the Tipping Point in January of
00:39:22
2013 assistant district attorney Beth Silverman filed three charges of murder against Samuel little end quote now at
00:39:32
that time California investigators had no idea that the three murders they were charging Samuel little with were only
00:39:41
and this is a horrible horrible statistic 3.22 percent of his actual murder count
00:39:49
but once they started digging into him they noted a very disturbing pattern just in his known crimes well when you
00:39:58
see crimes like this that are so vicious and you see multiple Crimes by the same
00:40:04
disgusting individual it has to come to mind what other crimes is he involved in
00:40:10
that's correct in the situation that you have here Captain is you look at this and you go okay well
00:40:16
we have DNA evidence connecting him to these three murders that took place one in 87 two in 1989 but prior to that
00:40:25
this dude had been locked up for a couple years on those two attempted murder charges
00:40:31
and once you've secured the arrest on him and he's facing three murder charges in January of 2013.
00:40:40
this is no young man he's no spring chicken at this point this is an older dude with a 100 page rap sheet
00:40:51
two attempted murder charges that he somehow dodged he got off light three pending murder charges and you're
00:41:01
going what else could this guy have been doing two turtle doves he's been out running the streets and running and
00:41:07
hopping from state to state all of his life what else has he what else has he done
00:41:14
who else has he killed yeah because you have to look at a bunch of different crimes that you know he's capable of
00:41:20
attempting murders rape murders this is going to take us to the great states of Florida and
00:41:28
Mississippi so Mitzi Roberts to her horror to everyone's horror actually the records
00:41:36
she says reflected that Samuel Little's name had come up in connection with two murders and two attempted murders of
00:41:43
women in the Gainesville Florida and Mississippi areas in the early 80s it's amazing how much
00:41:51
area that Sam little has covered but again we've we've seen this with other Killers like Ted Bundy well on these
00:42:00
cases Captain this Samuel little was never brought to trial on three Mississippi cases
00:42:06
which were as follows one is from the summer of 1980 this is a sex worker named Hilda who met little at
00:42:14
a club the two agreed on a 50 service fee and went back to her apartment as soon as the door closed he punched
00:42:23
her in the head knocking her out she awoke on her bed naked with Little's hands around her throat she passed out
00:42:32
again he then attempted to drown her in the bathtub using a scarf wrapped around her
00:42:39
neck for leverage she passed out and woke up only to have him choke her out again this goes on
00:42:47
several times luckily Hilda had a pact with another worker Dolores that if either them left with a John and weren't
00:42:58
back in 20 minutes then the other one would come looking for their friend right Dolores knocked on the door of her
00:43:08
apartment of her friend's apartment and then yelled through the window and little let Hilda go and he took off
00:43:17
Hilda woke up in the hospital somehow she survived this brutal attack she didn't bother to report the incident
00:43:25
though even though she spent three days under the care of medical Physicians and
00:43:31
staff in 1981 Samuel little hired a 20 year old sex worker named Leela McLean who had three kids
00:43:42
when she got in his car Sam little cold copter while he was still clutching the steering wheel with
00:43:50
his left hand he then punched her between the eyes he beat her so badly blood ran from her
00:43:57
eyes like tears each time she tried to escape he grabbed her and threw her back in the car
00:44:04
I mean just if you just close your eyes and try to picture this how it's playing
00:44:09
out what this woman is saying was done to her it's horrifying it's absolutely horrifying this guy is like something
00:44:15
out of a horror movie each time she tries to escape he gets out of the car he's throwing her back in
00:44:21
the car finally she's able to get out and she ran half naked across a highway so
00:44:31
she could get help so some Good Samaritans pick her up and take her to the hospital
00:44:36
saving her life then police did not talk to her about the incident at the time basically no one in a position of
00:44:46
authority at this time seemed to care about what happened to Hilda or Leela it's sad
00:44:53
we've seen so many cases where the victims are sex workers and doesn't seem like law enforcement works the case as
00:45:00
hard as they should I I do want to defend law enforcement a little bit here in these situations because it's unclear
00:45:06
if with the first attack it's clearly stated that this was never reported right to authorities and
00:45:15
unfortunately when you have the situation we've talked about this before uh we've talked about this when we first
00:45:21
started up the garage that you if you were to decriminalize prostitution or sex work or whatever you want to call
00:45:28
those titles or or escorts or what have you a lot of the time the victims will not report the crime because they
00:45:40
are committing crimes themselves and so you get into this really dicey area of we want these things to be
00:45:49
reported because the men that are up to this kind of behavior are the absolute worst these are monsters these are
00:45:56
individuals the guy we are describing to you right now will stop at nothing to choke a loud breath and choke again
00:46:05
until the person blacks out who knows how many times before he is done and actually kills the individual and then
00:46:12
dumps them on the side of the road so luckily in these two situations he was not successful and I think that you
00:46:21
know you have to question two this is 1981. things are different we do learn from our mistakes right and I do know
00:46:29
that in most locations if a woman shows up beaten and battered like this near death to the hospital
00:46:38
in a lot of locations I don't know if it's every state but I believe that the doctor has an obligation to report this
00:46:45
to police whether the where whether the person in his care or her care wants to report this or not this is a matter that
00:46:53
needs to be investigated well in this episode we've already talked about so many
00:46:58
crimes but we have to finish off because we haven't got to the third attack in the Mississippi cases yes and
00:47:07
unfortunately this case here the victim does not survive the attack and this took place in September of 1982
00:47:16
we have a 24 year old victim her name is Melinda lapree she was a young mother she unfortunately
00:47:24
was working as a sex worker at this time similar situation to what we've seen at
00:47:30
other attacks yeah a man drives up to the King William Motel this is where lupri was living at the time and also
00:47:38
working and Melinda gets into this man's car well she's never seen alive again in fact her nude body was found on
00:47:49
October 4th dumped in a cemetery ditch her death was ruled a homicide the there was another sex worker that
00:47:58
was at the motel as well that was able to tell police that Melinda got into a pinto Woody with
00:48:07
Alabama tags so now we're getting some good information right the last time that
00:48:12
she's seen this is the kind of vehicle that Melinda was getting into and by the way it has out-of-state plates on it
00:48:20
that car attracted attention of police when it broke down in the area on November 24th
00:48:27
and three occupants were suspected of shoplifting turkeys from a local grocer the cops put together that the pinto was
00:48:37
in fact the same one seen at the King William motel and there they arrested a Samuel McDowell on suspicion of murder
00:48:46
and like we know Samuel McDowell is Samuel little but he's going to get some breaks again in these cases where his
00:48:54
victims aren't so lucky he is having some luck with the criminal justice system unfortunately it always seems to
00:49:02
play out that way right if anybody's going to get lucky in one of these situations it's almost always the
00:49:07
murderer the murder victim is never lucky because of course they lost their life yeah soj about it the investigators
00:49:15
in Mississippi started to put together a case against Samuel little slash Samuel
00:49:20
McDowell bringing Hilda and Leela to in to testify these were the two surviving victims
00:49:29
we have a grand jury that's put together but unfortunately for whatever reason and you'd have to ask these people I
00:49:37
don't know but this grand jury that they put together didn't seem to take any stock in what the two female sex
00:49:46
workers had to say after all I guess you know they agreed to go with Samuel little we know that
00:49:53
unfortunately there was no physical evidence linking Samuel little to the murder case Melinda
00:50:02
lupree the only witness who saw them together was another sex worker so this goes to
00:50:09
the grand jury but it does not get an indictment and because of this since they're not
00:50:16
going to charge him with murder or attempted murder or assault or anything Samuel little Samuel McDowell was free
00:50:23
to go and this pattern happened over and over again except that it almost never got as
00:50:30
far as a grand jury I guess prosecutors knowing that their only Witnesses were sex workers or
00:50:36
addicts what seems to happen here Captain is that they cut deals or reduced Sam Little's charges and he walked after
00:50:44
doing little to no time at all [Music] so much more to get to thanks for joining us here in the garage
00:51:05
thanks for telling a friend until tomorrow be good be kind and don't litter [Music]
00:51:40
thank you