Search Captions & Ask AI

Samuel Little - Killer on the Road /// Part 2 /// 586

November 16, 2023 / 50:50

This episode of True Crime Garage discusses the case of Samuel Little, the most prolific serial killer in American history, who confessed to 93 murders. The hosts, Nick and the Captain, examine Little's methods, his victims, and the challenges investigators faced in linking him to his crimes.

Little's criminal history spans over 35 years, with many of his victims being marginalized women who were often overlooked by law enforcement. The episode highlights the difficulties in gathering evidence against him, as many victims were sex workers and their deaths were frequently misclassified.

The hosts detail how investigators began to connect Little to cold cases across multiple states after his arrest in 2012. They discuss the role of DNA evidence and the importance of witness testimonies in building a case against him.

In 2014, Little was convicted of three murders in California, and the episode covers the subsequent investigation that revealed his extensive criminal history. The hosts also talk about the interrogation techniques used to get Little to confess to his crimes.

Listeners learn about the psychological aspects of Little's confessions and how he relished the attention from law enforcement. The episode concludes with a discussion on the ongoing efforts to identify his many victims.

TLDR

Samuel Little, America's most prolific serial killer, confessed to 93 murders, revealing challenges in linking him to his extensive crimes.

Episode

50:50
00:00:00
[Music] is it possible to predict the unpredictable can 3D printed life-size organ models help to map out complex
00:00:07
surgeries ahead of time is it possible it already is right here Mayo Clinic you know where to
00:00:15
go when it comes to Quality sleep Ashley has you covered with top mattress brands
00:00:20
at winning prices and with special financing options available you can snooze now and pay later plus your
00:00:27
mattress purchase helps give the gift of better sleep to children in need and US
00:00:32
Special Operations forces visit your local Ashley store or shop online today and make every snooze count financing is
00:00:41
subject to credit approval see store or ashley.com for details [Music] [Music] welcome to True Crime garage Wherever
00:01:29
You Are whatever you are doing thanks for listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is a man with a
00:01:35
reminder that you don't bring a knife to a chainsaw fight here is the captain I can't afford to cut up people these days
00:01:42
with gas prices being so high it's good to be seen and good to see you thanks for listening thanks for telling a
00:01:48
[Music] friend today we are slow sipping some Nas feratu by the great Brewers at Great
00:01:58
Lakes Brewing company this is the beer with a bite baby it's an Imperial Red IPA 8% ABV 4 out of five bottle caps on
00:02:09
that garage grade and here's some of our friends that helped us out this week first up a cheers to Selena in stouton
00:02:16
Wisconsin big shout out to Mark in Chambersburg Pennsylvania next Captain we have a cheers to Teresa in San
00:02:25
Antonio Texas and the big we like your JP to Dana and Lafayette Indiana here's another we like your jib to Rachel and
00:02:32
Marbella Bristol United Kingdom and last but certainly not least we have Malina in Wakefield
00:02:39
Massachusetts thank you to everybody for helping us out with this week's beer fund for that we got a full garage
00:02:46
fridge and we are sending out lots of thank yous yeah BW R you in beer run if you'd like to support the garage and get
00:02:54
something in return go to our website true Crim garage.com and click on the store Page and pick you up something
00:03:01
snazzy and Colonel that is enough of the business thank you snazzy Captain all right everybody gather around grab a
00:03:08
chair grab a beer let's talk some true crime the most prolific serial killer in American
00:03:18
history Samuel little has confessed to 93 murders she fight for her ice and I'm fight for my
00:03:27
pleasure it's disturbing to listen to but investigators want to hear it all and more she was
00:03:37
laughing when I was killing the most prolific serial killer in American history I reached over I choked her and
00:03:49
once she was dead I pulled her out of the car looked around jumped back in the car little says he has a photographic
00:03:57
memory and has drawn sketches of his bronze sketches of his Bundy gasy the Green River
00:04:08
Killer all topping the list of some of the most prolific serial killers of all time but the number of victims taken by
00:04:16
each of these monsters is dwarfed by the evil work of another killer a killer who
00:04:23
was so stealthy and cunning that often not only did no one know who had committed the murder in some cases no
00:04:32
one knew that his victims had even been murdered this man stayed under the radar
00:04:39
for decades killed dozens of victims in multiple States over 35-year period the only reason that we know
00:04:49
about most of these murders is because he decided to talk this is true crime garage and this
00:04:58
is the story of Sam little the killer of [Music] women when we left off yesterday Cold
00:05:17
Case detectives in La were working on building a case of three homicides committed by Sam little and they are
00:05:24
starting to connect him to other similar Cold Case homicides in other states so now in 2013 after Sam little has
00:05:33
continually murdered America's women for roughly four decades Sam little was indicted once again and facing trial in
00:05:41
California for the 1987 and 1989 murders of Carol Guadalupe and Audrey in Mississippi investigators were going
00:05:51
back to reopen cold cases that fit Sam's M Mo and murders that occurred during the time that he lived in Mississippi
00:05:58
his first arrest there was in 1977 his last was in 1982 these arrests amongst other things teach us and tell
00:06:08
us that he was in fact in Mississippi for a period of time a Mississippi investigator told the son heral
00:06:16
newspaper quote we know he left some for dead but they survived they are good Witnesses now they remember everything
00:06:23
that happened to them like it was yesterday they have always identified Sam little as their attacker Sam little
00:06:31
is a monster there's no telling how many people he's attacked were killed now that little had finally been nailed for
00:06:38
murders that very strongly resembled Mississippi's 1982 Cold Case murder of 24-year-old Melinda lupri detectives
00:06:48
started trying to put together a case against Sam little tracking down old Witnesses and retesting physical
00:06:55
evidence in Melinda's case but of course in the interim between the murder in 1982 and
00:07:02
2013 decades had passed and little had killed many women during that time the failure of Florida and Mississippi
00:07:11
authorities to nail Sam little in the early 80s would be replicated over and over again throughout the United States
00:07:19
for decades now we know that they tried to put Sam little on trial back in San Diego but that didn't work out so this
00:07:29
be the first real investigation into Sam little and his crimes and this starts in
00:07:35
2012 2013 this will be significantly different from any other investigation that took place in Sam Little's
00:07:43
existence so this is after Little's arrest in 2012 in California and the discovery that three unsolved murders
00:07:52
could definitively be linked to him by DNA California investigators put together the other attacks he had
00:08:01
carried out on the two San Diego women back in 1984 remember Tanya and Lori that we talked about yesterday as they
00:08:08
dug into little they began to realize that this guy whose background and life history was very vague and who was
00:08:17
nomadic potentially had as many as 40 other murder victims they started reaching out across the country to try
00:08:26
to get a handle on just how widespread his crimes may be and to see if he could be conclusively linked to other murders
00:08:37
but of course Captain this is going to be quite the challenge so they started off by searching cotus until the
00:08:45
computer started smoking from so much action there were no more cases in which Little's DNA could Point them to a
00:08:52
murder and his fingerprints turned up in police files time and time again but only for lesser crimes
00:08:59
Petty crimes like theft in the murder inquiries as the LA Times put it modern forensics played no role the inquiries
00:09:08
came down to shoe leather police work interrogations and digging through Dusty files for Clues like a Western Union
00:09:17
MoneyGram from 1982 a witness who spotted a yellow El Dorado a prostitutes last meal of carrots that's what a lot
00:09:26
of these cases are going to come down to single but very specific situations and
00:09:32
items Within These individual cases throughout the United States now keep in mind we are talking about many murder
00:09:41
victims from an error before taking DNA samples on corpses was standard if little left a trail of bodies they were
00:09:50
going to have a hard time following it because the victims he was suspected of killing often preceded DNA databases if
00:09:59
they were identified by name they still were likely to have been killed long before DNA analysis so any connection to
00:10:08
little would be unknown from a physical evidence standpoint and even if the victims did have names you know many of
00:10:16
them became Jane Do's they could still have predated DNA testing or be the type of victim that no one bothers to take a
00:10:24
DNA sample from many of his victims were sex workers and performing a rape kit was deemed useless in a lot of these
00:10:32
cases that sounds horrific and that's going to be jaw-dropping to many people to hear that statement but it is in fact
00:10:41
true when you have a sex worker you can't just simply say that oh we found Seaman from Sam little on this victim
00:10:52
therefore he must have killed her it doesn't work that way because his defense could be as simple as this
00:10:59
I had consensual sex with that woman I paid her and then I left and then later somebody else came along and killed that
00:11:08
woman and left no DNA on her or no seen on her and it's that simple it's shocking but it's true I think it's hard
00:11:17
to investigate somebody like sam little because he's a criminal 100% of the time
00:11:23
if you take somebody like BTK for example he's living part of his life as a normal obst standing citizen he
00:11:30
doesn't commit crimes he has his double life as a serial killer Sam little is a criminal 100% of the time he's Street
00:11:39
Smart too and he's going to know how to talk with police he's going to know how to dodge their questions you point out a
00:11:48
very good interesting fact there Captain this is somebody that has sat across the
00:11:53
table many times or sat in the back of a cruiser many times and his existence not
00:11:58
not facing murder charges not being suspected of murder this is being picked up for other crimes he's used to talking
00:12:05
to police now there's been a lot of piling on in Sam Little's case and I get it and I've been I've been part of that
00:12:16
at times as well where I go oh the atrocities how could law enforcement let this guy kill for for decades well it's
00:12:25
not just that simple they didn't let him kill some of these cases and I think we
00:12:29
need to look at this on a caseby casee basis and throw criticism where it's due but I also think that there was a lot of
00:12:38
good detective and police work that was done in many of these cases I think in San Diego we talked about the 1984 cases
00:12:45
the attempted murder cases there was a lot of good police work on that case they had the right guy in court they
00:12:52
just couldn't get a guilty verdict from the jury let's talk about some things that were working in Sam Little's favor
00:12:59
and working very much against the investigators and the detectives looking into these homicides let's start with LA
00:13:08
because La is very intriguing here in the Sam little case in the late 80s when Sam little killed three victims that we
00:13:16
know of in Los Angeles there were several serial killers all at work at the same time so think about that you
00:13:24
have these stranger on Stranger murders which are incredibly difficult to investigate to start with with we have
00:13:30
victims living a high-risk lifestyle I'm not victim blaming it's just the truth people that makes it difficult to
00:13:37
investigate their homicides and then you have several other active unknown serial
00:13:41
killers working all in the same area and all with similar victimology to their crimes ones that I can think of for
00:13:49
instance you have Lonnie David Franklin Jr better known as the Grim sleeper killed 10 plus in Los Angeles between
00:13:57
1985 and 200 7 you want to not sleep tonight look up a picture of that guy Michael Hughes is another he was
00:14:05
convicted of killing seven females in California mainly in Culver City during the late 80s and early 90s but three of
00:14:12
his victims were killed in Los Angeles Chester Turner was convicted of 11 murders in Los Angeles over the course
00:14:19
of about 11 years in the 80s and 90s so that's three and I guarantee you there were more so the investigators had to
00:14:29
start from scratch pulling all unsolved cases from around the country in which the modus operandi fit Littles to see if
00:14:38
they could link any to him to do this they had to have a very thorough understanding of hiso so they could use
00:14:47
his methods to identify his victims so what law enforcement is going to have to do is look at Sam Little's known crimes
00:14:55
or the ones that they believe he's responsible and use that as their template yeah this will become their
00:15:01
template for looking for similar victims who were killed in a similar manner maybe left or dumped in a similar way
00:15:09
with reviewing these they start to get a clear picture of this guy's Mo and his victimology what the LA prosecutor
00:15:17
called Little's blueprint and this is what they came up with here's a quick list here Captain he cleverly and
00:15:23
deliberately selected marginalized female victims who would not be missed or were unlikely to have families with
00:15:31
resources to find them he chose women addicted to drugs Andor alcohol and then used those things to lure them he
00:15:41
preferred sex workers because they were an easy target and they would get into his car without a second thought he
00:15:49
opted for the physically vulnerable often attacking skinny weak small ill or high or inebriated women who could not
00:15:59
defend themselves could not fight him off he used his hands as his weapon of choice this is practically untraceable
00:16:09
when you compare it to things like knives and guns and he often left the victims cause of death
00:16:16
unknown sometimes they were finding these victims decomposed later and because they were strangled it was
00:16:22
difficult for them to tell that they were even a homicide victim that's part of the reason why some of these cases
00:16:28
were not even really investigated you have a drug addict that you find dead on the streets who's been dead for 2 weeks
00:16:36
or stuffed in an abandoned house somewhere and been there for months you don't find any bullets in
00:16:43
your victim or murder weapon nearby or a skull crushed or stab marks on any of the
00:16:50
bones and you go well the the the hypothesis here the Assumption here would be that this person died of a drug
00:17:00
overdose in this abandoned building and we're just now finding her unfortunately
00:17:05
well and then if the victim lives it becomes he said she said and little even though he doesn't have much of a standup
00:17:16
character he thinks he can at least win the argument well she was a drug user she attacked me or she was a sex worker
00:17:25
and she was trying to steal my money yeah as some of these survivors were not reporting some of the crimes and then
00:17:34
you have some survivors reporting them keep in mind this dude it was not uncommon for him only to be in a city
00:17:41
for 3 to 10 days he didn't have a residence if he attacks somebody and they survive or he sees a notice of
00:17:50
there's some sexual predator on the loose and it oh it looks like me or they got a match of my vehicle he just skips
00:17:56
town and goes on to the next city this is from the uh FBI a direct quote from one of their reports and this goes
00:18:04
back to the difficulties even categorizing some of his victims as homicides when they are initially found
00:18:11
and it says quote with no stab marks or bullet wounds many of these deaths were not classified as homicides but
00:18:18
attributed to drug overdoses accidents or natural causes and quote the other thing too and look I'm
00:18:27
glad to here in the garage with my my buddy the captain when I'm in the garage like to have a cold beer if I were home
00:18:34
right now I'd be eating some Honey Nut Cheerios and I only say that to tell everybody if you are if you are eating
00:18:40
something put this down step aside either hit Paws or stop eating because we're going to have to get into some
00:18:47
gross stuff with with Sam little he's a as you already know he's a Despicable disgusting human being I don't even know
00:18:55
if you can call him a human being but one of his MOS that they put in his template his blueprint if you will was
00:19:01
that he would often masturbate while strangling his victims and then dump their bodies and in fact he told
00:19:08
investigators that he could not rape would not rape the women because he struggled with erectile dysfunction old
00:19:15
Soft Cell so his victims often times are not even appearing or or would appear to
00:19:21
be like a rape victim raped and then murdered and keep in mind we touched on some of his disgusting habits the other
00:19:29
day and really how much of a monster this guy was it's not uncommon for a murderer even if it's a one-time murder
00:19:39
for a male to kill a woman to cover up a rape right leave no witness but what we have with Sam little
00:19:50
is completely different he's he's sexually assaulting because of the killing where the the killing is the
00:19:59
prime motive for his excitement right not raping and then murdering to cover up the rape this is a whole different
00:20:08
kind of monster here well he's getting off on the fact that they can't breathe exactly it's also worth noting here that
00:20:17
Sam little was 6'2 in tall and was well over 200 lbs he was trained as a boxer so these women didn't stand a chance
00:20:27
against him one once he got the victims into his vehicle he would stun or knock them out with a Punch To The Head and
00:20:35
then have his way with them and strangle or suffocate them there's not a lot of pictures of Sam little online but we'll
00:20:42
post some of those to our Instagram and Twitter Facebook all those you can find us at truecar.com but we'll we'll post
00:20:51
some of his older mug shots and you can see he's he's he's a lot different of the version of the crippled old man that
00:20:59
you see later on and and the the same little that we've all come to know this crippled old man yeah by the time we see
00:21:08
him on TV and we are able to hear of his horrible crimes that he committed he's in a wheelchair and he looks like an old
00:21:18
a sick old man by this point and you're going to go Nick you're lying there's no
00:21:21
way he was 6'2 over 200 lb but trust me he was listen to this okay investigate say we know he punched one victim with
00:21:30
such force that when he struck this victim in the abdomen he broke her spine this is from the autopsy report of
00:21:38
Audrey Nelson one of Little's 1989 LA victims quote injuries throughout her body revealed pre-death blunt force
00:21:47
trauma consistent with having been punched repeatedly in the head Nelson suffered severe bruising underneath her
00:21:54
skin this bruising extended into her chest muscles stomach and abdomen in addition the hard bone of her spine was
00:22:04
crushed during a blow to the upper Central adomen with deep bruising to the stomach itself it was a sign of
00:22:13
considerable Force like many of Little's victims Audrey's body displayed drag marks very early in Little's serial
00:22:21
killer career he stopped bothering to bury or even hide his kill just discarding the corpses on roadsides in
00:22:29
alleys ditches parking lots Ravines what have you wherever he happened to find himself think about this though too his
00:22:37
early victims and we see this a lot of times with serial killers where they will go to Great Lengths they will put a
00:22:43
a great deal of effort into concealing their crimes early on and then after a while they start to get confident they
00:22:50
start to believe you know what I can get away with this I'm smarter than the police so I think we have a little bit
00:22:55
of that going on in Sam Little's case we also have the situation of he's often high or drunk or both when he's
00:23:04
committing these horrible acts so he might not be in such a great physical state to be able to conceal the bodies
00:23:10
and then factor in the location of the murders a lot of these victims were in LA or were in bigger cities where you
00:23:19
know what driving around with the victim in your car is a risk in itself hismo which worked time and time again often
00:23:28
was get rid of the body as quick as possible and get out of Dodge get as far away from the body as I can I'm so tired
00:23:35
of these serial killers getting like really cool names Like Son of Sam or BTK Sam little should go by Soft Serve
00:23:45
because he couldn't make it hard right well they did they had a here's another disgusting uh part of the case they
00:23:52
actually called him the choke and stroke killer for you know sometimes these guys
00:23:59
get weird monikers and nicknames and and sometimes it comes from the media sometimes it comes from the general
00:24:05
public or law enforcement I don't really know where this one came from I'm guessing it's law enforcement because
00:24:12
this is something that likely the media and the general public would not know from from reading the newspaper but
00:24:20
basically what we just went through here Captain is his blueprint what they're calling the Sam little blueprint and
00:24:27
they're using Little's Mo and victimology the LA authorities are to desperately try to figure out what else
00:24:35
little had done no matter what state it took place in but again because they couldn't match anything else up on codus
00:24:41
with his DNA they're kind of blindly searching in the dark for more victims so basically they had to notify every
00:24:49
law enforcement agency around the entire country go ahead and Google that number
00:24:54
to see how many uh law enforcement agencies there there are in this country and say hey do you have any violent
00:25:02
unsolved murders of women probably sex workers drug addicts or homeless with strangulation as the cause of death
00:25:09
between the years of let's say 1960 and 2012 I mean can you imagine trying to put together this list this is an
00:25:17
enormous task it would be easier to figure out a way to get him to talk but of course we know that when he's first
00:25:26
arrested he refused to cooperate he did not even cop out to the three women with
00:25:33
whom his DNA had been found when he did talk to detectives about his history of arrest he said they were for shoplifting
00:25:41
and Petty thefts no mention of nearly 100 dead women he would eventually be linked to well and they poked and
00:25:48
prodded him but they couldn't get him aroused after he was charged with those three counts of murder for the 87 and 89
00:25:56
homicides in LA in April of 2013 La homicide detectives called in the big guns they get the FBI involved
00:26:06
and they bring in analyst Christy palazolo from the FBI's viap they wanted help compiling cases that could be
00:26:14
attributed to Sam little they wanted the FBI to do some digging into his background to try to reconstruct his
00:26:21
life which could lead to more victims so they could have kind of a road map of his life of where he was at what times
00:26:30
vicap maintains a database of known crimes and categorizes Mos and other characteristics like manner of death and
00:26:38
victimology that can help locate similar crimes and thus link perpetrators they knew little emo so palazolo started
00:26:47
digging in June of 2013 she issued a vicap alert asking detectives Across the Nation to check their files for unsolved
00:26:58
strangulation murders of vulnerable women soon her timeline of Little's life became 150 Pages she started cross
00:27:09
referencing events and locations in Little's life that overlapped with crimes in the vicap database and now
00:27:16
years later the FBI is still digging [Music] this show is sponsored by better help do
00:27:46
you look forward to the holidays maybe you struggle with seasonal Blues this time of year can be a lot and it's
00:27:52
natural to feel some sadness or even anxiety about it but adding something new and posit positive to your life can
00:27:58
counteract some of those feelings therapy can be a bright spot something to look forward to to make you feel
00:28:05
grounded and to give you the tools to manage everything going on if you're thinking of starting therapy give better
00:28:12
help a try it's entirely online designed to be convenient flexible and suited to
00:28:17
your schedule just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist and switch therapist
00:28:23
at any time for no additional charge find your bright spot this season with betterhelp visit betterhelp.com
00:28:30
garod to get 10% off your first month that's betterhelp hp.com garage is it possible to predict the
00:28:43
unpredictable could surgeons use a patient's own Anatomy to create 3D printed life-size organ models to map
00:28:51
out challenges ahead of time making surgery more precise efficient and less invasive is it possible it already is
00:29:00
because every day we're doing what's never been done learn more at mayoclinic.org
00:29:06
Sloss Mayo Clinic you know where to go dreaming of overseas Adventures or connecting more deeply with family from
00:29:16
afar Rosetta Stone Bridges the language Gap I've tried others but Rosetta Stone's immersive lessons and voice
00:29:23
feedback technology are game changers dive into 25 Languages by learning intuitively just like when you were a
00:29:29
kid and here's the holiday Sparkle grab a lifetime membership now and save 50% gift yourself the world head to
00:29:38
rosettastone.com now and save [Music] [Music] 50% all right we are back cheers mates cheers we got Colonel computer and
00:30:01
uh Sam's officer of little cheers to the people in the back those are the ones that count the most this is going to
00:30:09
take us to the 2014 trial the murder trial for the three murders that he committed in Los
00:30:16
Angeles now prosecutors arm themselves with information about possible other crimes and other jurisdictions lining up
00:30:24
witnesses to testify against Sam little such as the survivors of his attacks in Mississippi and San Diego these women
00:30:32
testified that they remembered him they remembered his large hands and how he beat and choked them investigators in
00:30:39
California were able to link Sam little to crimes in 24 States but in a 56-year life of crime he had served only about
00:30:51
10 years in prison he was suspected of multiple murders but never convicted of a Murder well good news captain that all
00:30:59
will end in 2014 well I don't want to sound like a pessimist and I guess it's better to be
00:31:06
caught late than never yes and this is one of those situations where it's going to be some kind of answer for the
00:31:16
families and we're talking about a lot of families in this case so there is some good that comes out of it you feel
00:31:23
like you're lost right I know that investigators and prosec feel like they lost all around in the Sam little case
00:31:30
but there is some good you are bringing some closure giving some answers to these many families that were just left
00:31:37
guessing for many years remember some of these victims were Jane Do's for a long
00:31:43
period of time or still are Jane do so it only took the jury two hours to convict Sam little of the murders of
00:31:51
Guadalupe Carol and Audrey he was sentenced to three life terms in prison without the Poss possibility of parole
00:31:58
as his sentence was pronounced he shouted out loud in the court that he was innocent even though they had his
00:32:05
DNA in all three of these cases well he's an idiot so yes yes he is now let's bring in a very important character a
00:32:15
very important person in this story it's Texas Ranger Jimmy Holland this is an experienced investigator with training
00:32:24
in psychopathy who specialized in interrogating techniques this did not mean that he was
00:32:30
the guy that would come into an interrogation room and physically abuse the person that he was questioning or
00:32:37
take out his service revolver and put it to the back of the the individual's head
00:32:42
or the suspect's head yeah taking his pencil and shove it in the dude's dick hole or even dropping massive folders of
00:32:49
daunting looking files on the desk and glaring at the suspect instead he had a whole different method with which I
00:32:57
think proves to be much better instead he calmly appealed to the ego and used the carrot approach bribing his suspects
00:33:08
with little concessions that would incentivize them to cooperate now let's think about Sam little he's locked up
00:33:15
for Life he's an old man three life terms in prison without the possibility of parole you are going to die in prison
00:33:23
sir now can you help us out at all do you want to sit in your cell all day long or do you want to sit in this room
00:33:29
and talk to me well in December of 2017 Jimmy Holland was teaching an interrogation class pertaining to
00:33:39
questioning of psychopaths and sociopaths at a police conference in Florida he started chatting with a crime
00:33:47
analyst this was Angela Williamson a 41-year-old Australian with a doctorate in molecular biology and expertise in
00:33:56
forensics she was employed by vicap and a justice department initiative to train and fund
00:34:03
local police and sexual assault investigations during Holland and Williamson's conversation two detectives
00:34:11
from Florida came up and asked them if they knew anything about a California serial killer who was refusing to talk
00:34:19
these detectives suspected Sam little in an unsolved Florida case maybe more than
00:34:25
one Holland was intrigued well yeah you'd be intrigued because a killer like this and a a nomad really his victim
00:34:36
list could be a significant number yes exactly you hit the nail on the head my friend and this is a situation though
00:34:44
Holland wants to get involved but he cannot without a Texas case so he started thinking about this Sam little
00:34:52
guy and the fact that he wouldn't talk and several jurisdictions seem to suspect him in many murders so then he
00:34:59
called Williamson in March of 2018 and asked if they could do something about this guy Williamson put Holland on hold
00:35:07
and asked another cubicle occupant this is our friend palazolo who we've already
00:35:13
introduced if she had heard of Sam little and of course boom she sure had palazolo said tell him about the Odessa
00:35:23
case Odessa Texas case this was a case case that she was sure would be attributed to Sam little and in fact 12
00:35:32
of the potential victims in the viap analyst had put on her list of potential Sam little murders were murders that
00:35:40
took place in the great state of Texas so Holland was definitely intrigued by the Odessa case this was 38-year-old
00:35:49
Denise Christie brothers who was found dead in 1994 now per the LA Times quote like
00:35:56
little LA victims she had been strangled and left partially clothed in a vacant lot police records showed little had
00:36:04
interaction with local police around the time of the killing end quote Holland believed that he could get Sam little to
00:36:11
talk but we we have to remind The Listener that Sam L was in prison at this point for already four years and he
00:36:20
was over 80 years old so Holland headed to California to assist in these investigations to see if he could get
00:36:29
Sam little to talk when he gets there the LA detectives inform Holland of what he was up against and they tell him that
00:36:37
Sam little despised law enforcement and that he was free to use that to his Advantage if he could the detectives
00:36:44
also said that Sam little hated being called a rapist though his seen was found on the clothing of two of his
00:36:51
victims and prosecutors labeled him a sexual predator perhaps Holland thought thought Sam little saw a distinction
00:36:59
between rape and becoming aroused during a strangulation that was something that
00:37:04
he thought he might be able to work with when interrogating Sam little now it's worth pointing out that one of the
00:37:11
detectives little despised was Mitsy Roberts who we've already talked about of the LAPD who had noted the pattern in
00:37:19
the 87 and 89 bodies found and made the codus connection to Sam little she and Beth Silver
00:37:27
the LA County Deputy district attorney were the women who finally put Sam little away so their theory was that Sam
00:37:36
little hated women of course but also hated being bested by two women and would be much more inclined to talk to a
00:37:44
man potentially about his crimes definitely seems like Sam L has some kind of intimacy issues with females and
00:37:51
so if he's going to open up and make himself vulnerable he's probably not going to do that
00:37:57
with a female well and obviously to kill this many women you have to hate women and that's what I think is part of his
00:38:04
emo here that he hates women in general it will be May of 2018 when Holland sits
00:38:11
down with Sam little of course we have the FBI listening in the Next Room now the formerly big man sam little was now
00:38:19
in a wheelchair and he's still sharp though at this time and was interested in the Texas Rangers motives for the
00:38:29
visit Holland gave little some peanut M&M's and tried to you know butter him up but little told Holland that he had
00:38:38
no interest in helping law enforcement close any cold cases because he had been convicted on fake evidence and
00:38:45
lies and so he pushed back quite a bit but we have Holland who is smart impatient and then he through
00:38:53
conversation and through this visit and other visits started to earn the trust of Sam little
00:39:01
soon they would be calling each other Sammy and Jimmy almost like their buddies this comedy duo Holland nudged
00:39:09
Sam little to take control of his story he pointed out that no one knew his name
00:39:14
but he could change that this is from the LA times has Sam little killed people yeah come on we both know that
00:39:21
Holland said the question is does Sam little want to talk about those killings and does he want to Define what really
00:39:30
happened Sam little studied the ranger quote hookers is all you are going to find Sam said Holland could
00:39:39
tell the killer was testing him Holland Shrugged do you see me tearing up see he's almost putting himself out there
00:39:48
like yeah I identify with you I agree with you that yeah you only killed people that of of a lesser value of what
00:39:56
that's what Sam Little's saying right and the detective here the Texas Ranger excuse me is smart enough to play along
00:40:03
he's playing to his ego he knows that if he can play to his ego Sam will likely open up and a whole new can of worms is
00:40:12
going to come out of every conversation that they have this is when Holland takes the chance to mention that Odessa
00:40:18
case from Texas and it seemed to motivate Sam little to start talking well don't you think a lot of these guys
00:40:25
want the truth to be out there or their truth to be out there well and he also has no more appeals at this time too so
00:40:34
it's really like he's got nothing to lose from spilling the beans he might feel like he has something to gain and
00:40:44
of course in any jailhouse snitch situation here he's telling on himself but of course you as a detective you
00:40:53
know going into that that they are only doing this for some benefit to them can I figure out what the benefit is that he
00:41:01
is seeking and kind of play to that in fact he opens up so much about this Odessa case he bluntly tells them
00:41:09
exactly what took place how he picked up this Denise Brothers what kind of car he
00:41:16
was driving what he used he used crack and black tar heroin for Denise to get him get her to join him he then pulls
00:41:26
into an alley and grabbed her by the throat and tossed her over the back seat of his vehicle like a doll where he
00:41:33
strangled her with one hand while masturbating with the other she fought back this is where one of his um
00:41:41
statements comes from that is more well known today in some of his confessions but he said that he would
00:41:50
make these encounters as long and slow as possible because the Act of Killing was
00:41:58
synonymous with sex for Sam little so he's often letting his victims repeatedly regain
00:42:06
Consciousness he said that the last time that Denise came too her head was in his
00:42:11
lap Sam little said her eyes big as marbles Sam says I told her I own you you're mine forever she cried and I
00:42:22
kissed her I kissed her tears from her face and then squeeze the life from her little knew exactly what vacant lot he
00:42:31
had dumped Denise in and they're able to take the details that he States during this interrogation during this basically
00:42:39
what's a conversation at this point and match these details up to the known information they have in the case
00:42:47
well Sam little is going to tell law enforcement that he stopped counting his killings at 84 victims and that's a very
00:42:57
large number of victims and then very oddly Captain he goes into detail about his first murder and his last murder and
00:43:07
his first murder was a woman that he met in a bar in Miami on New Year's Eve 1970
00:43:13
this was a victim that we spoke about yesterday Mary broley in our trailer for this week's episodes remember she
00:43:20
remained at Jane Doe until she was finally identified after a Florida detective had ENT Ed her information
00:43:27
into namus and got a match to a Massachusetts woman missing part of her pinky with a surgically repaired hip and
00:43:35
dyed blonde hair so even though they identified her this good detective did good work with the nameus program to
00:43:44
identify her through dental records they still had no idea who had killed her but
00:43:50
they knew it was a homicide because she was one of his victims that were buried and that it was
00:43:56
in this interview that they learned that broley was killed by Sam little well we've seen a lot of serial killers that
00:44:04
don't want to talk at all or the information that they give to law enforcement is so misleading but
00:44:11
everything that Sam is saying this is would give you hope I think as law enforcement that you're going to uncover
00:44:19
more answers for more victims and that's going to lead to closing some of these cases yes and he says that his last
00:44:27
murder victim was in 2005 this would be 7 years before he was identified by that
00:44:33
codus hit and this was a murder from Tupelo Mississippi now this is all interesting because he
00:44:42
gives detailed accounts of the first and last murders but we know that there's going to unfortunately be a whole lot of
00:44:50
Carnage between those two bookended murders now after getting him to talk of course course law enforcement's
00:44:57
confident at this point that Sam little is willing to talk about his other crimes his other murders so what they
00:45:03
end up doing here Captain is they get a letter from a Texas prosecutor pledging not to pursue the death penalty for Sam
00:45:13
little for any of the Texas murders that he confesses to and little agreed to start talking
00:45:21
about more murders but again remember he wants something in trade he wants to transfer to a Texas prison facility that
00:45:30
same day after these negotiations he confesses to 17 more murders all female victims he starts off
00:45:39
with really an emotionalist tally provided by Sam little he simply says Jackson Mississippi one victim
00:45:48
Cincinnati Ohio one victim Phoenix Arizona three Las Vegas one and so on and so on
00:45:56
most of these victims weren't on the FBI's list palazolo resorted to Google searches as they tried to keep up with
00:46:04
all of these Grim confessions coming from their prisoner well like I said law enforcement has to be optimistic because
00:46:11
they are making some Headway with this serial killer and as of mid November 2018 law enforcement has been told by
00:46:22
Sam little that he he's responsible for over 90 some homicides yeah that this was an announcement actually to the
00:46:31
general public where law enforcement is saying that Sam little is confessed to murdering dozens of women and he might
00:46:37
be linked to as many as 90 homicides this will be because they're probably going to need the Public's help at some
00:46:43
point now two weeks later the FBI announced that the vicap team have confirmed 34 of his murder
00:46:53
confessions saying that Sam little wasn't making any of this stuff up little claimed to have killed 93 women
00:47:00
between 1970 and 2005 and 18 or 19 States ranging from all the way to Florida and to California more than 30
00:47:11
of his confessions remained unmatched they have yet to be linked to any known victims this as of late last
00:47:20
year the FBI web page has a list of these and the detail and drawings which we we will get to in a minute furnished
00:47:30
by Sam little some of the confessions were no surprise whatsoever he confessed to the murder of Melinda lepri who we
00:47:38
already talked about who was murdered and he had not been indicted for after a grand jury vote he also confessed to
00:47:46
that old Gainesville case that he had eluded conviction on Patricia Mount was her name eventually Sam little admitted
00:47:54
to killing Carol gu Lupe and Audrey in LA in 87 and 89 which of course we already knew based off of DNA and other
00:48:03
circumstances that he did kill those women and then of course he confessed to 88 more little said to the LA Times that
00:48:11
he confessed in the end because he knew his time was running out and he wanted to help the families get closure and
00:48:18
perhaps exonerate someone wrongfully accused others said that little clearly wanted credit for what he had done the
00:48:27
New York Times said quote investigators who have spoken to him say he also appears to enjoy the attention he is
00:48:34
receiving as he recites details only a killer would know after Decades of discussing them with no one whatever his
00:48:43
motives Beth Silverman the LA prosecutor who locked little up for good in 2014 said that his confessions were hardly a
00:48:52
victory for law enforcement rather she said it's simply a tally of the Carnage he
00:49:01
[Music] caused so much more to get to if you need more True Crime Garage in your
00:49:14
earballs check out our bonus show called off the record you can do so by going to
00:49:19
truecrime garage.com and clicking on the off the Record link it's every other week's show $5 a month on Stitcher
00:49:27
premium I think you're going to enjoy it colonel over 100 episodes of that great
00:49:33
show in the back catalog too so check that out and check out all that Stitcher premium has to offer until tomorrow be
00:49:41
good be kind and don't L [Music] it [Music] is it possible to predict the unpredictable could surgeons use a
00:50:23
patient's own Anatomy to create 3D print life-size organ models to map out challenges ahead of time making surgery
00:50:31
more precise efficient and less invasive is it possible it already is because every day we're doing what's never been
00:50:40
done learn more at mayoclinic.org Sloss Mayo Clinic you know where to go

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Most intense
  • 70
    Most dramatic
  • 70
    Most heartbreaking

Episode Highlights

  • The Most Prolific Serial Killer
    Samuel Little confessed to 93 murders, making him the most prolific serial killer in American history.
    “The most prolific serial killer in American history.”
    @ 03m 18s
    November 16, 2023
  • Investigative Challenges
    Many of Sam Little's victims were misclassified as overdoses or accidents due to lack of evidence.
    “Many of these deaths were not classified as homicides.”
    @ 18m 11s
    November 16, 2023
  • The Choke and Stroke Killer
    Sam Little, known for his brutal methods, was dubbed the 'Choke and Stroke Killer.'
    “Sam Little should go by Soft Serve because he couldn't make it hard.”
    @ 23m 42s
    November 16, 2023
  • FBI's Involvement
    The FBI was called in to help compile cases linked to Sam Little, revealing a vast network of unsolved murders.
    @ 26m 00s
    November 16, 2023
  • Sam Little's Conviction
    After years of investigation, Sam Little was convicted of three murders in just two hours.
    “It only took the jury two hours to convict Sam Little.”
    @ 31m 47s
    November 16, 2023
  • Confessions of a Killer
    Sam Little confessed to over 90 murders, detailing his first and last victims.
    “He claimed to have killed 93 women between 1970 and 2005.”
    @ 47m 00s
    November 16, 2023
  • Sam Little's Confessions
    Sam Little confessed to multiple murders, seeking closure for families and attention for himself.
    “He confessed in the end because he knew his time was running out.”
    @ 48m 11s
    November 16, 2023
  • Prosecutor's Take on Confessions
    Beth Silverman describes Little's confessions as a grim tally rather than a victory for law enforcement.
    “It's simply a tally of the carnage he caused.”
    @ 48m 54s
    November 16, 2023

Episode Quotes

  • It's disturbing to listen to, but investigators want to hear it all.
    Samuel Little - Killer on the Road /// Part 2 /// 586
  • He was a monster. There's no telling how many people he's attacked or killed.
    Samuel Little - Killer on the Road /// Part 2 /// 586
  • He often masturbated while strangling his victims.
    Samuel Little - Killer on the Road /// Part 2 /// 586
  • It only took the jury two hours to convict Sam Little.
    Samuel Little - Killer on the Road /// Part 2 /// 586
  • I told her I own you, you're mine forever.
    Samuel Little - Killer on the Road /// Part 2 /// 586
  • He confessed in the end because he knew his time was running out.
    Samuel Little - Killer on the Road /// Part 2 /// 586

Key Moments

  • Sam Little's Confessions03:30
  • Investigation Challenges18:11
  • Sam Little's Blueprint24:25
  • FBI Collaboration26:03
  • Trial and Conviction30:14
  • Murder Admissions47:35
  • Prosecutor's Insight48:46
  • Final Thoughts49:41

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown