Search Captions & Ask AI

Darlie Routier /// Part 2 /// 490

November 07, 2022 / 01:12:37

This episode covers the case of Darlie Routier, who was convicted of murdering her two sons, Devon and Damon, in 1996. Key topics include the evidence presented at trial, the role of the knife used in the murders, and the controversial silly string incident that influenced public perception.

The hosts discuss the timeline of events leading to Darlie's arrest on June 18, 1996, and the evidence found at the crime scene, including the bloody knife and the sock discovered two houses away. They analyze expert testimonies regarding blood evidence and injuries sustained by Darlie compared to her sons.

They also address the prosecution's arguments about Darlie's possible motives, including financial issues and unhappiness in her marriage. The hosts highlight the significance of the silly string video taken shortly after the murders, which portrayed Darlie in a way that led some jurors to believe she was guilty.

Throughout the discussion, they consider alternative suspects, including a potential intruder and a serial killer active in the area at the time. The episode concludes with a reflection on the complexities of the case and the lack of definitive evidence against Darlie.

Listeners are encouraged to share their opinions on the case and to check out the bonus show for updates on ongoing true crime stories.

TLDR

Darlie Routier was convicted of murdering her sons; evidence and public perception played crucial roles in her trial.

Episode

1:12:37
00:00:05
[Music] [Applause] [Music] welcome to True Crime garage wherever you are whatever you doing thanks for
00:00:44
listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is a man who when he was five
00:00:48
imagined that there was a such thing as a unicorn and this was before he had ever heard of one or saw one here is the
00:00:56
captain that's cuz there was a giant horn growing in my pants it's good to be seen and good to see you thanks for
00:01:02
listening thanks for telling a [Music] friend today we are getting down with purple Puffs by Angry Chair Brewing now
00:01:14
that it's summertime and it's warming up outside it's time to try this fruited sour with marshmallows black currant and
00:01:21
blackberries it's the one with the evil looking purple peep on the can garage grade four and a quarter bottle caps out
00:01:28
of five and here's some cheers to our peeps right here first up a cheers to an in Houston Texas and a big shout out to
00:01:37
Lori and South Ben Oh Lordy next up we have Nicole and Beaver Dam Wisconsin and a big we like your jib goes to Brooke
00:01:45
and Baytown Texas and we have a shout to Elliot listening in Marietta Georgia and
00:01:51
last but certainly not least we have a big shout out in much love to Barb Edwards listening in the Greater
00:01:57
Columbus area thanks to everyone for helping us out with this week's beer fund yeah bwe r n beer run if you'd like
00:02:07
to support the show big way to do it tell a friend just grab their phone pull out their podcast app subscribe to the
00:02:15
show and tell them you must listen to this or we're not going to be friends no more just look at him and say you're
00:02:20
welcome yeah you're welcome now give the phone back gather around grab a chair grab a beer let's
00:02:30
talk some true [Music] crime on June 6th 1996 Devon ag6 Damon age5 were murdered
00:02:53
their mother darly roer is taken directly to the hospital less than 2 Days Later on June 8th darly gives a
00:03:01
written statement to police on June 14th darly family and friends celebrate Devon's birthday and that is certainly
00:03:11
an event that we will get into when we get into the trial portion of Today's Show 4 days later captain on June 18th
00:03:19
darly is arrested and charged with capital murder with the murder of her two sons we have discussed a good deal
00:03:27
of the crime scene and evidence found at the crime scene but we need to go through that a bit more in some strong
00:03:36
details here right so let's get into some things regarding items found at the crime scene that point toward darly
00:03:44
being guilty and in some opinions maybe even innocent first is the knife the knife that was used in the course of the
00:03:54
murders was determined to have come from the home it was a knife that came from a
00:03:59
set from a butcher block that was kept on the kitchen counter in the rer home officer David main testified that the
00:04:06
butcher knife that match the set with blood on the blade and handle was found on the kitchen counter one knife was
00:04:14
missing from the knife block and this knife fit into that slot perfectly Bob P an analyst with the southwestern
00:04:23
Institute of forensic Sciences in Dallas testified about this knife that quote I
00:04:29
was not able to to determine conclusively that this knife made the wound on Devon's chest but my opinion is
00:04:35
that a knife with similar characteristics made the wound Judith Floyd a DNA analyst with genan screen
00:04:42
labs in Dallas testified that traces of both Damon and dar's blood were found on
00:04:48
this knife she did not receive the entire knife just some samples taken from it Dr Joanie mlan testified that
00:04:57
the stab wounds to Devon were in fact consistent with that blade and the knife was still sitting there bloody when the
00:05:05
officers arrived on the scene there's really no question in my opinion captain that this was the knife that was used to
00:05:12
kill Devon and Damon and it came from within the roer's own home whether or not the knife came from inside the house
00:05:20
or from outside the house doesn't point in my opinion towards her being more guilty or more innocent that's correct
00:05:30
it does not tell us who was using the knife during the course of the attacks what we do know is it was used on Darley
00:05:38
as well if we are to believe the blood evidence now darly claimed that the killer or the Intruder threw the bloody
00:05:45
knife down on the floor of her utility room but multiple experts this is law enforcement and crime scene analysis
00:05:52
testified that this story was not consistent with the evidence they stated that there basically would have been
00:05:59
blood splatter or other marks left on the floor by the knife cluttered clattering to the tiles instead in the
00:06:08
utility room there were some blood drips and I'm going to break this down because
00:06:13
there are multiple experts that come in and testify as to the blood evidence but
00:06:20
to rather than go through each one of them I can collectively report what they are generally saying here they're saying
00:06:29
about the blood evidence a couple of things one they're not seeing blood evidence that suggests that whoever was
00:06:37
carrying the bloody knife that they were running and fleeing from the home okay again this could have been an intruder
00:06:45
this could be darly running around with a bloody knife what they're saying that it's
00:06:51
consistent with is somebody walking slowly throughout the home that the way that the blood is dripping from the
00:06:56
knife and onto the floor would be that of someone walking at a slower Pace not speeding not jogging not sprinting
00:07:05
through the house yeah but if you just stabbed all three people and for all you know those are the only people in the
00:07:11
house why are you going to run away why not just walk away well I I'm not trying
00:07:18
to get into the mind of the potential Intruder here I'm just using this and cross referencing it against dar's
00:07:25
account of what went down that night Tom Beville a retired Oklahoma City Police Captain who was the owner and teacher at
00:07:34
a forensic School testified about an experiment that he conducted he dropped and threw a bloody butcher knife six or
00:07:42
seven times onto the floor and said that he could not duplicate the blood spatters found on the utility room floor
00:07:50
it was his opinion his conclusion that no knife had ever been thrown down at that
00:07:57
location James KW testified that there was no evidence that the knife had been thrown down anywhere the blood in the
00:08:05
utility room was from someone slowly dripping the places where the knife had been according to the experts like the
00:08:12
kitchen counter showed patterns left on the surface by the bloody blade there were some indication that the knife had
00:08:20
been laid down in a few places on a table on the carpet in the family room marks on the floor and rug
00:08:30
where it had been Tom Beville testified these findings are inconsistent with dar's story and then you have to wonder
00:08:38
why the Intruder would have taken the time to put the knife down pick it back up again in various spots around the
00:08:45
home I find some things troubling with this quote unquote blood evidence and I'm not meaning to question these
00:08:52
experts or really even put together anything that's just kind of convenient to go along with my own personal Theory
00:09:01
but I question one the placement of this knife you know we do have evidence I don't doubt this evidence that the knife
00:09:09
was set down on different locations throughout the downstairs of that home what I'm questioning is is there a
00:09:16
possibility that darly did this and also did not kill her sons we know she readily admits that she picked up the
00:09:24
knife anybody that's listened to the 911 call I hope they would agree with me and
00:09:30
hear the amount of chaos going on within a short 5 to six minute window mhm I think that there is a potential maybe
00:09:40
small chance but a chance that maybe she picked it up and then it was moved more
00:09:46
than one time by her herself and again doesn't have to mean that she is in fact guilty correct the other thing that I
00:09:54
question too here Captain is look I'm sure this Tom bevel's a great guy uh Oklahoma City Police Captain he's a
00:10:01
owner and teacher at a forensic School his opinion that the knife was never on the floor in the utility room
00:10:09
because he ran these experiments conducted these tests threw it down six or seven times this is his testimony
00:10:17
when we are charging a person with capital murder and we intend as the state to execute her if we find her to
00:10:27
be guilty yeah I would hope that somebody would conduct that test more than six or seven times it seems a
00:10:34
little yeah we're convicting somebody on a sixth grade science experiment right right even my science fair experiments
00:10:42
had I would run the test more than six or seven times and so I I question that that what
00:10:50
doesn't seem to be something that I'm able to question is the fact that she says that the Intruder seems to be
00:10:56
fleeing he would have been by her own admission carrying the knife at that time there's no indication that the man
00:11:03
was running from the scene I don't have any reason to think that otherwise that he wouldn't be
00:11:09
running it seems like a good idea to get the hell out of there to me if you were
00:11:15
in fact the attacker uh question for you is there blood evidence on the window screen or the window ledge yeah so this
00:11:25
is a little tricky for the window where the Intruder came in or came out of or was staged to have come in or out of I
00:11:37
found a few places that state that there was like a bloodied fingerprint a smudged blooded fingerprint and there's
00:11:46
a couple of them that were unidentified in the home not a lot I think it's only three and we'll get into that more as we
00:11:55
carry on here but if in fact there was blood on the window sill it would have been in the form of a smudged
00:12:03
fingerprint let's go back and talk about the screen once again my friend because
00:12:07
the screen is an interesting part of this case to me because darly tells us that an intruder must
00:12:17
have cut into this screen opened up the window came through the garage then the utility room walked into the kitchen and
00:12:25
then came into the family room attacked and killed both boys and attempted to kill her before she fights him off wakes
00:12:34
up whatever screams and then he turns and fleas drops the knife and then goes back out that same window in the garage
00:12:41
that he came in the police and the prosecution will tell you that no that darly attacked and killed her sons and
00:12:52
attempt to Stage the scene that she cut the screen one issue I believe against the prosecution in the police's
00:13:02
theories here Captain is that it seems readily agreed upon by everyone that the screen they have evidence to believe
00:13:09
that the screen was cut from the outside and I think that if someone In the Heat of the Moment trying to Stage a
00:13:16
scene might not be clever enough to think that through but her husband went to bed roughly an hour before the
00:13:25
murders took place so is it possible that she went outside and and started staging the scene before she would
00:13:34
attack her children I guess that would be that's certainly a possibility yeah that's a good point you make there
00:13:39
because he says that both of them say that between 12:30 and 1 is when they parted ways they don't know the exact
00:13:46
time but between 12:31 they parted ways he went upstairs to go to bed she starts
00:13:50
to fall asleep the call comes in to 911 at 2:31 a.m. and if it's 1:00 then yeah you're right if she was really
00:14:03
planning this stuff in advance then she could start to Stage some things beforehand now the screen covering an
00:14:12
open window in the roer's garage was found to have been cut vertically and horizontally as we said yesterday in a
00:14:19
t-shape from the outside the screen was cut with a sharp implement this is all per the evidence
00:14:29
and forensics that we can see that it was cut using a sharp instrument one thing that's tricky and goes against
00:14:38
dar's Case is that law enforcement state that they believe that another knife a large bread knife with a sharp point
00:14:47
that was found in the same Butcher Block that the murder weapon came from right they believed that this was the knife
00:14:56
that was used to cut the tea into this screen and they say that because on its blade they found microscopic traces of
00:15:06
fiberglass rods and rubber polymer dust indistinguishable in color size and composition from the screen's components
00:15:15
so they can't say 100% that this this microscopic debris if you will yeah came from that screen but they're saying that
00:15:23
there's nothing when you compare the two together there's nothing that disting ises it from being from anywhere else
00:15:32
than that screen yeah my problem with that though is there's a bunch of different knives in a butcher
00:15:39
box and how many times do you use that knife for something else other than cutting like meat or something you might
00:15:49
use it to open up mail or you might use it as a sometimes I'll use a knife as a screwdriver so I I I don't know I get
00:16:01
what you're saying but I think it's a little more intricate than that I mean when you're
00:16:06
comparing the the debris that would be created from cutting the screen to this microscopic debris that's found on this
00:16:14
one particular knife right not found on any of the other knives in the Block it's definitely damning yeah I to me
00:16:22
it's actually more damning than the murder weapon knife because as you pointed out correct just because it came
00:16:28
from that that butcher block inside the house does not mean we know whose hand was using it to stab people so the
00:16:35
defense does argue a point here on this knife and saying why okay one you cannot
00:16:45
there's no expert saying 100% that this debris came from that screen we just have nothing in its
00:16:52
makeup to declare that it didn't come from the screen and we didn't find it anywhere
00:16:57
else when when looking the argument that the defense raises and this is a good one I think they're saying look the same
00:17:08
brush that you were using to dust for fingerprints and such on the the window that could have been accessed by an
00:17:19
intruder MH is the same brush that you were using when you were checking all these knives so it stands somewhat of a
00:17:28
reasonable EXP explanation that there was carryover yeah you'd think you'd find a little bit of debris on all the
00:17:34
knives well and that's the the prosecution's argument back that's a rebuttal well we only found it on this
00:17:40
one knife wouldn't if if that stands to be true what you're arguing wouldn't we find it on all of
00:17:46
them look I don't know I mean does it matter that if you what order you're checking these knives in with this brush
00:17:55
so yeah you should have been more careful because this it it B basically makes your point invalid you're exactly
00:18:02
right and if you're going to bring it up at the trial as evidence against and there's an argument against your
00:18:08
argument then expect that argument to be you know you're bringing this into question yeah if I'm on the jury right
00:18:15
and people were going look this is a damning piece of evidence I'm going you have to throw this evidence
00:18:21
out because it makes sense either way but I think technically by the way the way you're instructed in court to be on
00:18:30
the jury if something weighs equally for innocence or guilt you have to have it go towards innocence well and one thing
00:18:40
that you know a lot of people will bring up in this case is that okay the the wounds the injuries the attack on the
00:18:47
boys was enough to kill them to end their lives that's how severe it was and the injuries to darly who is being
00:18:55
accused of their murder well they're not as severe she survived she didn't have as many wounds they weren't as deep and
00:19:04
it goes on and on but this is another situation where we could spend a whole hour on her injuries I won't waste
00:19:13
anyone's time because my general thought about her injuries is this they marched a lot of quote unquote
00:19:20
experts in and out of that courtroom that said that her injuries were superficial that she did them to to
00:19:27
herself and they were superficial for every expert that they marched in that said her injuries were minor and
00:19:34
superficial the defense marched in an expert that said she almost died they were severe she could have died she was
00:19:41
within 2 millimet of dying well let me ask you a question what do your eyeballs tell you what my eyeballs tell me
00:19:50
is reviewing some photographs that belong to this case and her injuries that are seen in a lot of
00:19:59
these photographs one thing that I think the the defense I think the defense screwed
00:20:05
up a little bit in this case and one thing that they screwed up on is I've seen a picture that was taken of her in
00:20:12
her hospital bed where she does not appear to be awake this must be shortly after surgery mhm she looks freaking
00:20:19
terrible man like she looks to me like she's knocked out and lucky to be alive from what I've reviewed and
00:20:29
everything I've been told about this case and could find that photograph was not shown to the jurors not presented in
00:20:36
court that day I think it's a powerful photograph what was shown to the jury and shown in court during
00:20:45
the proceedings was what the prosecution presented and these would have been pictures and photographs of her injuries
00:20:54
and they would have been days afterward this would be you know when when she came into the police station and when
00:21:01
she was eventually arrested so those ones don't look bad at all but I think the one that shows to me what I think is
00:21:08
the real severity of her injuries is the one where she appears to be knocked out
00:21:13
in that hospital bed yeah I mean I think when I look at her stitches I mean number one word I think is oh that's
00:21:21
nasty yeah that's a real nasty uh but it reminds me a little bit and and do you want to guess what I'm
00:21:30
thinking of a case that we covered I believe it was Chicago uh Lulu Lemon mhm reminds me of
00:21:39
that case where you have a victim supposed victim which is actually the murderer going to create self-inflicted
00:21:50
wounds those wounds were minor these to me not so much two millimeters away from
00:21:59
basically killing yourself very quickly and all the other wounds pretty deep again enough to have stitches on
00:22:10
multiple parts of her body not just on her neck but the neck is probably the worst one of the
00:22:16
bunch yeah but anywhere she has staples it's nasty well and the neck would be if you believe the Intruder
00:22:26
theory if you believe darly that would be the wound that would be the injury the attack portion that the
00:22:34
Intruder is trying to use that would be the the Fatal blow right there the attempt at taking her life yeah and
00:22:43
again her injuries you have experts arguing it both sides well the injuries to her arm are not indicative of
00:22:51
defensive wounds and then another expert tells you they are exactly defensive wounds every case that that we've
00:22:57
reviewed here captain and we're coming up on 500 episodes so we've reviewed uh what two three couple four million yeah
00:23:05
we've we've reviewed quite a bit her the the wounds to her arms they're in the exact spot that I
00:23:14
would think that that's how you defend yourself you put your arms up you put your arms between you and your attacker
00:23:20
MH so I don't know how anybody could say oh we can prove that these are not defensive
00:23:27
wounds I'm not saying that they are I'm just saying I don't know how anybody could stand up there and look 12 people
00:23:33
in the eye and say these were not defensive wounds so I don't think the injuries to
00:23:40
her tell us a lot not when you have experts arguing both sides of the coin right again it's like I said if
00:23:47
something leans towards well it it doesn't make her look innocent or guilty then you have to view on the side of
00:23:55
innocent and then they point to the kitchen sink where there's proof that someone had cleaned up around the
00:24:03
kitchen sink cleaned up some blood around the kitchen sink okay that's great it doesn't look
00:24:09
good for darly in my opinion but we have Darren Darley and people arriving at the
00:24:15
crime scene that are saying we saw her holding towels well she put a towel on herself and she put a towel on her her
00:24:22
son correct and so it's so nobody's disputing that there there wasn't tals being used right right and I'm I'm just
00:24:30
saying it could be another part that's just kind of gotten lost in there did she clean up I don't think it points to
00:24:37
guilt 100% or innocence it certainly doesn't Point towards innocence either well again I want to go back to what her
00:24:43
husband said is when he woke up before she called 911 both boys were alive so if she is guilty of this she was giving
00:24:53
the opportunity for both of those kids to say we know who did it and it was it was Mom yeah that's interesting because
00:25:01
the information I have actually it's unclear if both boys were alive but one was most certainly alive when Darren
00:25:09
found the boy and was still clinging to life when First Responders showed up on the scene and there were doctors that
00:25:17
testified to that boy's injury saying one he couldn't have survived very long after after sustaining those injuries
00:25:25
okay so a matter of minutes is as long as he would be alive that to me actually backs up
00:25:35
dar's timeline of the events right she wakes up after the boys are attack chases the guy or runs for whatever
00:25:43
reason into the kitchen and then very quickly immediately calls 911 and the police we know are on the scene before
00:25:51
the end of the call which is only 5 minutes and 44 seconds long so that actually goes along with dar's timeline
00:26:00
and it doesn't have to be something that she had to make it fit it just is and Darren comes down the steps he's still
00:26:08
alive the doctors also testified that the the boy would have been able to make a noise that's their exact statement I
00:26:16
don't know that that means that they could talk but it seems to me if he could make noises again there's a chance
00:26:23
that he could have survived the paramedics believed that there was a chance they could revive this kid that's
00:26:28
their words as you pointed out this kid could have told us what happened at this
00:26:34
attack who attacked him and again I don't think she has any type of expertise to know like well I stabbed
00:26:42
him enough that he's only going to live for a couple more minutes and he's not going to be able to say my name or he's
00:26:48
not going to be able to tell his dad that his mom killed him yeah she has no expertise on that I don't know I think
00:26:55
very few people would and then then there's the sock okay I'm sure there's somebody out there in their car
00:27:01
screaming at the at the radio going when are you guys going to talk about the sock well let's get to the sock right
00:27:08
after this quick beer break [Music] [Music] welcome back cheers to everybody in the
00:27:42
front and everybody in the back especially the people in the back here we go Captain let's talk about the
00:27:50
sock all right the sock evidence and this is evidence that's found at the crime scene the problem is this sock is
00:27:57
not found inside the rer home it's not even found on the rer property it's found two houses away near a trash can
00:28:10
in someone's yard so how do we know that this sock actually belongs to this case
00:28:16
that it's important to this case well it had blood on it and it had a some of both of the boys blood was found on the
00:28:26
sock now there was no blood found anywhere else around this sock you know there wasn't a puddle of blood blood
00:28:35
drippings nothing of that just this bloodied sock that has it's not even a whole lot of blood on the sock itself
00:28:42
but think about the location of where it was found it's found two homes away near
00:28:49
the trash can on someone else's property the thing with this sock and with the blood evidence on this sock to me this
00:28:57
is the one one thing that strongly points toward darly being innocent in this case the murder weapon the knife
00:29:09
bread knife that may or may not have been used on the screen mhm the cut screen itself some of the blood evidence found
00:29:18
inside the home dar's injuries compared to the boy's injuries I think anyone could make a strong argument for or
00:29:27
against using I any of that evidence for or against darly and I say that with a lot of confidence because that's what
00:29:35
happened at the trial right the cleaning of the sink is a little more damning against Darley again I don't think so
00:29:44
because she brought up the fact that she had these towels that she used to try to
00:29:50
help her kid out and help herself out right and it's one of those situations though I wish that the there were
00:29:58
someone to have seen her doing this or at the very least she says that she cleaned up around the sink for whatever
00:30:05
reason we don't have that and that's why I I call that more into question but the
00:30:12
whole weight of everything I really look at this sock as being completely against
00:30:17
darly being guilty and I say that because there is in fact blood from both of the the deceased victims found on
00:30:26
this sock and and then we cross reference that with the information that we receive from the doctors at trial
00:30:35
that state that the the boy that died in the presence of Darren and in the presence of First
00:30:43
Responders who if he would have been revived could have told us what exactly went down that mommy attacked me or a
00:30:51
strange man attacked me or whatever the amount of time that it would have taken for him to expire does not leave a lot
00:30:58
of room for someone to Stage a ton of things at this crime scene right the sock in particular because the sock is a
00:31:07
big problem for a lot of things one whoever placed it where it was found and it was found by crime scene TCH so
00:31:16
this is not something that just magically appeared later but whoever placed it where it was found or dropped
00:31:22
it where it was found no one was seen so darly wasn't seen running out outside of
00:31:28
the home and then coming back into the home there was no strange man unidentified man who was seen dropping
00:31:35
it or in the area of where it was dropped but again it has both of the children's blood on it so it was there
00:31:43
when the the the boy that we know only had a short window from Attack to death it was there after he was attacked it
00:31:51
was inside the rer home after the attack yeah and then found outside and the other thing too if if one were to Stage
00:32:00
a crime scene it seems like a really bizarre place to place this random bloody sock if you wanted to point and make
00:32:11
evidence and create evidence that there was an intruder that fled the scene you would drop this sock in the roer's
00:32:20
backyard in your own backyard or at the bottom of your driveway somewhere where you you would want the crime scene text
00:32:27
to find now they did find it but again it was several homes away it's not in a spot
00:32:34
that's going to be super obvious for the crime scene text to find this and what about DNA why didn't they test this sock
00:32:40
for DNA well they they did find some DNA and they found dar's D DNA inside the sock but they didn't find any other DNA
00:32:50
on the sock from my no they did not find any other DNA on the sock now there are
00:32:56
future test that are scheduled for some of the items at the home but all the tests that have been conducted on I love
00:33:04
this this I I love our justice system there's future test on a crime that happened in
00:33:10
1996 well but that's I mean that's not like something like oh we have this we're just waiting around to do it it's
00:33:18
it's at the appeals of dar's Defense oh that these tests were granted her DNA is
00:33:25
found I don't know that that proves again that doesn't prove anything to me it just proves to me that at some point
00:33:32
and probably recently she may have worn that sock and looking at this utility room is it also
00:33:40
is it a laundry room I'm just wondering how this killer got the sock okay so it does look to me like there's
00:33:49
a I only have a drawing of the ground level of the road to your home like a floor
00:33:57
plan and so there are two rectangle square shaped items in the utility room which
00:34:04
could be washer drver that would make the most sense and according to darly and Darren they kept a
00:34:15
basket of items that were used as Rags so like this sock it's it's mate you know they you buy them in pairs right
00:34:25
it's mate was never found not inside the home not outside the home I lost my meate years ago so that to me stands to
00:34:34
go along with this thought that it's a it's now become a rag at its you know at this point in its sock life YOLO and so
00:34:44
yes the they kept a basket of rags and items that were to be used as Rags inside this utility room so again if a
00:34:55
criminal entered the home through that window in the garage they would come in the only room that it's accessible to
00:35:02
the home is then the utility room they could have quickly just grabbed that sock and placed it over their hand or or
00:35:12
or used it in some manner to try to you know go in and then pick up a knife with
00:35:18
it the thing is if if you're criminal if you're Intruder is in fact a sophisticated criminal he's got gloves
00:35:26
on his hands there's a good strong chance he's not leaving his DNA inside that sock right again the issue becomes
00:35:34
how does that sock get to where it is and darly remains inside the home calling 911 all at the same time that that
00:35:42
doesn't leave a whole lot of time for darly to Stage all of these items yes there's some time for her to Stage some
00:35:49
of them I will admit that I don't see enough time to Stage all of these items especially the sock yeah I agree and
00:35:57
that was something that was presented at the trial and something that the prosecution they just didn't address
00:36:03
because they didn't have an answer for it mhm well again to it it's 1996 so DNA testing and hard our
00:36:13
knowledge of DNA was not the greatest so I'm certain even if there was even traces of touch
00:36:23
DNA that they wouldn't have been able to get that off the sock that seems correct
00:36:28
to me the again they do have dar's DNA from that and of course they have both boys because they have blood evidence
00:36:35
from both boys on that sock as well I do want to point out something too that I failed to mention when discussing the
00:36:43
screen so the windows in this garage you would only see these windows from the back of the home okay you
00:36:52
wouldn't see these out front and these windows only look to be about 8 maybe 9 in off of the ground off of concrete I'm
00:37:03
pointing that out because if I were an intruder if I were looking for a way into this
00:37:09
home I have to say captain that's the same window I would pick I would pick one of these two windows in that
00:37:15
location yeah makes the most sense and it would not be hard to climb in and out of this window you would slice the
00:37:23
screen open up the window put your foot your left foot or right foot put in and then you bend down and boom you're in
00:37:29
the garage well and if you're a neighbor you could sneak into their garage when their garage door was open and unlock
00:37:36
those windows well and that's you bring up a fine point there my friend something we mentioned time and time
00:37:43
again in previous episodes uh in particular the Aurora Hammer Slayer episodes make sure your windows are
00:37:51
locked people and then take it a step further like we said in the Aurora case lock the door from your garage to your
00:37:59
home mhm because if there was an intruder in this case Captain that's how they got to into and exited the home in
00:38:09
this case so what we're saying is lock your [ __ ] up lock that [ __ ] up tight there was a vacuum that was also called
00:38:17
into evidence and this is because they it was found tipped over and the prosecution in law enforcement stated
00:38:26
that this vacuum was tipped over and they could prove that this was further sign that
00:38:34
someone was staging the scene because underneath the tipped over vacuum they found debris and blood meaning that the
00:38:44
vacuum was tipped over not during the course of a scuffle or someone fleeing the home but it was tipped over
00:38:51
afterwards to make it look like there was a scuffle that the blood was in a location where it could not have been if
00:38:58
the vacuum was already tipped over yeah but you could bump a vacuum and it it tips over I don't know if it necessarily
00:39:08
proves that somebody was trying to Stage uh a scuffle you know I agree with you and we don't need to argue this
00:39:15
point I'm just pointing out that the their argument was that the blood was in a location that if the vacuum was
00:39:22
already tipped over the the the scuffle was already over at that point the the attack had already happened the
00:39:29
stabbings had already happened right we don't need to argue it any further because this actually was later proved
00:39:35
to have been moved by crime scene tax so great right so what you're saying is that now we have proof that crime
00:39:47
scene texts messed with the crime scene yeah and and not a positive way no they either bumped it over or or moved it
00:39:57
during the course of of their work there I mean they were they crime scene techs
00:40:02
were at this scene for nine straight hours after arriving on the scene and probably several visits after that as
00:40:12
well so this is a lot of work a lot of moving pieces and parts I'm pointing this out to go well if we can prove that
00:40:19
this is the case with the vacuum what does it say to us about the sink area and some of the other things
00:40:27
that we call into question inside the home what we can't what I think we cannot call into question is this sock I
00:40:34
think this sock it's to me it's not 100% definitive proof that that darly is Innocent but to me it it strongly
00:40:43
suggest given the timeline that we have to work within we we cannot change the timeline it is what it is those are the
00:40:51
hardcore facts of this case there does not seem to me to be enough time to kill both children
00:41:00
administer my own injuries stage all these things get the sock two doors down outside without
00:41:09
being seen cut the screen alarm and awake my husband call 911 and then the First Responders are on the scene before
00:41:18
the 911 call is over well again I think they came to a conclusion way too early and I think if if they would have
00:41:25
started questioning people in that neighborhood they would have found somebody that knew a little bit too much
00:41:31
about Darling right a little bit too much liked her a little bit too much knew a little bit too much about her
00:41:38
schedule knew a little bit too much about her family cuz it seems to it seems to me if you're finding this sock
00:41:45
yes you could park a car far away and you're going to I guess run to your car to get away
00:41:52
but with the sock being found if it's an intruder I would say that points more to
00:41:59
somebody that lives in the neighborhood could be I just think that if it were somebody that had good knowledge of the
00:42:05
victim and using victimology it seems like there would have been a more optimal time to to plan your attack
00:42:13
that's true that's true I mean you know that there that Darren lives there if you know a good deal about darly you
00:42:19
just and from everything we see they're operating with one vehicle at this time at this stage in their lives you yeah
00:42:27
that's an interesting fact too because it's like I wonder what you could see into the garage from those outside
00:42:35
windows well the car was parked out front in the driveway right but either way you'd be able to see if there's a
00:42:41
second car correct and if you didn't know much about them and you just saw one car you the perpetrator might
00:42:48
assumed oh well I see her laying down on the couch and there's only one car here
00:42:54
her husband must be at work or you know he must work third shift I'm just saying
00:42:59
if the perpetrator didn't know much about her yeah that's a good call and then I take it a step further if in fact
00:43:05
it were a stranger that that broke into the home stranger danger I keep going back to the idea captain that somebody
00:43:13
could have seen her the vantage point would not have been great but somebody could have seen her through one of the
00:43:19
windows in the family room sleeping on the couch and maybe not have seen the two boys sleeping on the floor and even
00:43:28
with the chance of a husband being upstairs some of these guys will take that risk right you go in your I your
00:43:39
goal would be to sneak in undetected to the point where maybe she doesn't wake up until you already have hands on her
00:43:48
till you're already threatening her because we've seen this with the uh Golden State killer with with serial
00:43:55
rapist and time and again the idea is they're they're not waking up until until the point where the threat is
00:44:03
already there so you can silence them so that they're silenced and then whomever's upstairs is not a key factor
00:44:10
in in the course of your attack what becomes really screwed up real quickly if you are an intruder is stumbling upon
00:44:19
these these kids sleeping on the floor and Damon was actually in a position which doesn't make a whole lot of sense
00:44:25
of why he would be sleeping there uh where he was found but if he was in fact sleeping in the position where he was
00:44:33
later found there's a chance that if that if those rooms were dark enough remember
00:44:39
dar's words in her written statement is that she flipped on a couple of lights after this attack and that the TV was
00:44:48
turned off at some point mhm there's a chance that the Intruder may not have known that that child was sleeping on
00:44:55
that floor until he stepped on them or stumbled over them yeah by this point gloved hands he's come in he's put the
00:45:04
put the sock over his gloved hand pulled a knife out of the Butcher Block that's
00:45:09
on the counter in the kitchen which he would have walked past that through the kitchen anyway on his way into the
00:45:15
living room now the short of it here Captain we won't continue along too much on this trial but the short of it is
00:45:22
that on January 6th 1997 this is just 2 days after dar's 20 7th birthday that's when the trial began on February 1st
00:45:30
darly was convicted of murdering Damon she was only charged with well only taken to trial for the one
00:45:38
murder the thought being a couple reasons why he was young enough that it was an automatic capital murder case
00:45:47
right they they were getting the death penalty if they got a conviction in that case and if they were to lose that case
00:45:55
there's a good chance that at a later date they would have charged her she was charged with both murders but actually
00:46:00
taken her to trial for the murder of Devon uh 3 days later she was sentenced to death by lethal injection by the
00:46:08
state of Texas now we talked a lot about motive what would be the possible motive
00:46:13
well if she were in fact the killer of these two children the state points to a few different things as being possible
00:46:21
motive one depression that she was depressed two that the family was having money problems again the money problems
00:46:28
are certainly in dispute for everybody that says they were having money problems there's also evidence that they
00:46:33
weren't having money problems we'll Circle back to that and then the other one was that she was unhappy in life and
00:46:40
did not want to be married anymore did not want to be a mother anymore the money problem thing is certainly a weird
00:46:47
one here because if you look at the life insurance policies on the members of the
00:46:52
roer family they did not have a whole lot of insurance on the two murdered boys mhm they didn't even have enough to
00:47:02
cover their funerals right so so they went if if money was a problem and she's killing to get out of that problem well
00:47:10
they they became more in debt because of the murders right from my from what I could find here Captain it was $5,000 on
00:47:19
each child and they spent approximately $14,000 total on the funeral services now now if money is what darly
00:47:29
was seeking there was a huge life insurance policy on Darren why not just kill him yeah the
00:47:37
husband is big money I mean we're talking $5,000 a kid compared to it was like $250,000 life insurance on Darren it is
00:47:48
my belief captain that en large part darly roer was convicted not so much on the evidence
00:47:56
because I think we've done a good job of pointing out that a lot of the evidence
00:48:00
could be argued either way for innocence or guilty however one thing that really
00:48:06
stood out was this silly string incident okay so darly and her whole family participated in a birthday party for
00:48:15
Devon this was days after he was killed they were doing their best to mark this special occasion with joy instead of
00:48:24
sadness and but hold on a second th this doesn't make sense to me maybe it's cuz
00:48:29
I don't have my own biological kids but if my kid died or my kid was murdered I don't think I would go to his
00:48:40
grave site and celebrate his birthday I think I would you could maybe do something at home you know to think
00:48:48
about him and maybe even have a cake there or something but but to go to the grave site I don't know I guess that's a
00:48:55
little strange but that's that's just my thoughts I agree with you and I bet you if darly were here with us
00:49:02
today she would agree with you as well because I think I found her having a statement somewhere at a much later date
00:49:10
that says you know looking back it might have been a bad idea but she says look my my son was turning seven we would
00:49:17
already planned some of his birthday before he was killed and he was very much looking forward to being seven and
00:49:23
we wanted to have some kind of celebration for him some kind of birthday party for him now in dar's
00:49:32
defense it was her sister's idea uh for portions of this event it wasn't just her idea but the reason why we're
00:49:42
discussing this is because the police department took video of this event okay and they showed it over and over again
00:49:53
to the jury well what was the jury seeing they were seeing darly smiling laughing having a good time shooting
00:50:01
Silly String all around Devon's and Damon's grave yeah she looks like she's not even out a grave she
00:50:10
looks happy in the video we' you know anybody familiar with this case has seen this video she looks as if her kids have
00:50:17
not just recently been murdered so they showed this video at the trial and I know of at least one juror that says
00:50:26
that this video is what sealed the deal for him that she was guilty of killing these boys I for the life of me cannot
00:50:37
figure out what the hell the defense was thinking Captain duh but what happened here is the prosecution actually had a
00:50:47
video that was hours long it was hours long the second half of the video shows a whole bunch of happy people roer
00:50:54
family and friends happy celebrating this birthday party the first half of the video shows a very sad
00:51:05
gravide service and Gathering of these friends and family where darly is crying I mean crying out loud it's not
00:51:17
just weeping silently to herself and we're talking almost 2 hours of crying and praying and crying
00:51:26
and praying together with all these other people that portion of course the prosecution's not going to show and I've
00:51:32
seen some people that say that's unfair that the prosecution didn't show that portion they want to win the case yeah
00:51:39
their job they didn't show up to lose yeah their job is to get a conviction yeah you think you think Michael Jordan
00:51:44
shows up and goes you know what let's spot the other team 30 points let just tie my hand behind I'm the best yeah I'm
00:51:50
the best spot him 30 points give him a shot well I mean OJ's prosecutors did this you know well the only thing that
00:52:00
the prosecution has to do legally is say to the court look this this videotape that we have this we consider this to be
00:52:09
evidence can will you allow us to submit it as evidence yes we will okay well then that means everything from start to
00:52:14
finish on that that cassette is evidence and their only job at that point is to turn it over to the defense and say
00:52:23
we've seen it all you should see it all as well and then you can decide defense what portions of the video you want to
00:52:29
use in your defense of your client but this stuff I hate and I hate arguing about this stuff when people will say to
00:52:37
you well look uh she shouldn't have been smiling at their grave sight that's proof that she's guilty we don't know
00:52:46
how you don't know how you'd react to these things just like the 911 call I don't know how I'd react uh to seeing my
00:52:54
kids and puddles of blood would I be even able to talk would I even be able to call
00:53:01
911 I I I don't know so I think these times where people want to point this as some kind of evidence look I think it
00:53:10
makes her look bad and that's probably one of the reasons she got convicted but it's not evidence it's not evidence but
00:53:18
again the defense had access to this and I will read you what happened and what went down at the trial the defense
00:53:25
decided that they did not need to insist that the remainder of the Silly String video be shown that means after the
00:53:32
Silly String portion was shown where everybody's laughing and having a good time and darly looks like a horrible mom
00:53:38
who's not remorseful or regretful or in mouring at all after that's shown the defense made a conscious decision to not
00:53:47
show the other portion not showing the long terribly sad prayer service and memorial for the two boys this in my
00:53:56
opinion was an enormous mistake after the trial juror Charles Sanford said in an affidavit that quote had we been
00:54:05
shown this other tape so that we had been able to see the whole picture of what happened that day I believe I would
00:54:14
not have voted to convict Mrs rotier wow take this a step further this was a big reason to find
00:54:24
her guilty from these jur this was something that when they were back behind the scenes when they're
00:54:30
deliberating when they're when they're when they're trying to come to their conclusion guilty or
00:54:35
innocent they played that Silly String video I have seen that they played it five six seven maybe a dozen times yeah
00:54:45
behind closed doors not inside the courtroom just where the 12 of them could view it and watched it over and
00:54:53
over and over again and I'm sure every single time they hit play they became a little more convinced At This Woman's
00:55:00
guilt so I think this was a huge mistake on the part of the defense well yeah but
00:55:06
it's also as far as public opinion goes because we know that sometimes the the hands of Justice move very slowly but if
00:55:14
she gets convicted because of this I think one of the reasons by having this shown also to the public like on news
00:55:23
channels and stuff like that they go look at this Monster look at this woman she she must be responsible we got a
00:55:31
conviction and she must be responsible and that's why I think a I think this clip itself is the reason why there
00:55:38
hasn't been this crazy movement to I mean there has been a movement but a crazy overwhelming amount of people that
00:55:45
say this doesn't make any sense why she is convicted we also referenced earlier Captain some unidentified fingerprints
00:55:54
there were some unidentified prints in the house they have never to this day been identified there were prints found
00:56:02
on the garage window which housed the slashed screen the exact location the base of the window this would be where
00:56:11
you would think that the Intruder or maybe even darly herself trying to Stage the scene would have touched right it's
00:56:18
been stated that these fingerprints do not do not belong to darly Darren or law enforcement officials investigating the
00:56:27
case also a fingerprint found in blood on the coffee table was too smudged to identify we have one expert that says
00:56:36
that it is his opinion that the this fingerprint appeared to belong to a child the defense put forth a witness
00:56:46
that said that it could be that of an adult another bloody fingerprint found on the door out to the garage from the
00:56:55
utility room to the garage was too smeared to be useful at all so someone with bloody hands touched the coffee
00:57:03
table near the boys and the door handle to the garage and someone touched the garage window whose fingerprints are
00:57:13
these we don't we can't match them to anybody known to be inside that home that night yeah I do want to point out
00:57:21
something too A lot of times when you have smudged fingerprints and look I don't know the size of this
00:57:28
and I'm I'm guessing that's what this expert's saying well it probably belonged to one of the boys that was may
00:57:33
have been a smaller fingerprint again an expert saying well it could have belonged to an adult but smudged
00:57:39
fingerprints that are found in blood they're usually smudged and have no actual fingerprint because the person that left
00:57:47
that smudge was wearing gloves that it comes from a gloved hand yeah or if he's wearing one glove and it's glittered
00:57:55
then we know who it is and I do want to point out here captain and I'm not saying that these persons make better
00:58:03
suspects than darly I'm not saying that uh I'm just saying that I'm pointing out
00:58:08
that there are other avenues that could have been taken with this investigation there are other things to have been
00:58:14
considered here she wasn't the Standalone suspect in my mind one we have a black car that was seen casing
00:58:22
the roers neighborhood street and even some witnesses say home home this would have been weeks before the attack so we
00:58:29
have multiple eyewitnesses multiple people living in the neighborhood that they say they spotted at one time during
00:58:36
the nighttime weeks before the attack a suspicious black vehicle next we have this one I think is really alarming we
00:58:44
have two men that try to enter a home in the same neighborhood in the 1:00 a.m. hour that same night oh my God yeah so
00:58:54
some woman she saying that she fell asleep on her couch she was either reading or watching TV she falls asleep
00:59:02
on her couch she hears someone attempting to open her front door you know just using the handle and so she
00:59:09
got up and looked through the peephole and said that she saw two men standing on her front porch who then fled once
00:59:17
they couldn't get in the door that's the same night and we talked about what time
00:59:23
Darren and darly say that they went to sleep that's in the same time frame how can you lose this case well
00:59:33
and here's one that I can Name by name and I don't think that they would have there would have been and hold on a
00:59:38
second cuz we also don't know the person that was casing their house weeks earlier we we possibly casing the home
00:59:47
possibly casing their house weeks earlier the neighborhood the street it's not that hard to go okay but we also
00:59:52
have these two guys that were trying to break into another house it's not too far to I'm just saying like they always
01:00:00
say to win a defense or to win a case you just have to have a better story or a more logical story or present enough
01:00:09
doubt yeah I mean you could say well maybe the guys that broke into that house were the same people casing their
01:00:16
house earlier or maybe they weren't but maybe they weren't they just tried another house right and that means
01:00:22
there's multiple people trying to break into houses in this area what I find highly alarming about that
01:00:28
witness's uh statements is think about it she's saying I was asleep on my couch there's I'm not saying this happened but
01:00:37
is there a chance that one or both of those guys looked through a window saw this woman by herself sleeping on a
01:00:42
couch and said H let's try the door and see if it opens yeah this is this is our
01:00:47
house this is our victim it's not too damn hard to believe that they went throughout you know went to different
01:00:53
parts of the neighborhood and continued to look in Windows and maybe spotted another young attractive woman sleeping
01:00:59
on her couch and decided you know what yeah the door doesn't work and we may have woke the person up at the last one
01:01:08
let's see if we can find a window that's open or a window that's unlocked and also they wouldn't be that afraid of if
01:01:15
there is a maleo home because there's two of us right and again the chance that you could silence your potential
01:01:22
victim before they could alarm anybody that you are even even in the home here's one and again police and
01:01:31
investigators would have had no way of knowing this individual's name at the time we know this guy and actually when
01:01:37
I was reviewing this case here Captain this is bizarre to me because I thought well when I first looked into it I
01:01:46
thought This Woman's guilty as hell and as I started looking more and more into it I started thinking uh maybe she
01:01:51
didn't do it well if she didn't do it then somebody else did is there an alternative yeah and the first person
01:01:58
that jumped to my mind was Michael Jackson Tommy ly cells he is a serial killer he was active at the time he was
01:02:06
active as far as we know from 1980 to the year 2000 he was active in the states of Missouri New York Illinois
01:02:15
Texas and Kentucky probably others as well he earned the nickname Coast to Coast or the cross country killer yeah
01:02:23
yeah I know this guy um but the reason why jumped to mind to me was he actually committed crimes that were very similar
01:02:32
to this case and as we already pointed out he committed murders in the state of Texas so one one to just give you a
01:02:41
little taste of it because I don't want to go too far into Tommy lindel's because there would be a lot to talk
01:02:46
about but just to prove that he did similar types of crimes in 2004 Tommy lenells confessed that on October 13th
01:02:57
1997 he broke into a home took a knife from a butcher block in the kitchen stabbed a little boy to death and
01:03:05
scuffled with a woman that he found inside the residence this was Julie Ray Harper and her son Joel Harper Joel was
01:03:15
killed Julie survived the attack and she was later charged with Joel's murder and
01:03:22
convicted of killing her son then years later Tommy lyells confesses to this attack on this boy but
01:03:31
he only has one conviction and they say what 22 suspected murders yeah the words
01:03:37
that we have are retired Texas Ranger John Allen said quote we did confirm 22 murders I know there's more I know
01:03:45
there's a lot more obviously we won't ever know he's been executed he was executed by the state of Texas well got
01:03:54
him well real quick to if this photo is correct of one of his victims that I think got
01:04:01
away this younger victim it looks like her one of her wounds is in the exact same spot on the body as the neck wound
01:04:14
on Darlene yeah so that's why I mean his attacks were very similar he was known to break into a home and then he would
01:04:23
often kill as many people as he could but in most cases he only ended up killing the children and would attack
01:04:30
somebody else or scuffle with them fight with them attempt to kill them and flee
01:04:34
the scene and he did this in multiple States what a [ __ ] princess a couple of other possibilities and here's one that
01:04:41
seems a little obvious and and we just didn't get to it but would be Darren roer yeah now I do want to point out and
01:04:50
I'm not going to go too far down this road because we have darly who is said from day one and still to this day even
01:04:58
after they have scheduled her her her date of execution has not been scheduled but she's been that's her
01:05:06
punishment she said all along all this time Darren was not the guy that I saw that night Darren could never have done
01:05:12
this on the reverse Darren has always said that he never believed darly killed the kids yeah he stood by her he still
01:05:20
stands by her to this day well and I know there's a camp of people that believe it's possible that they're both
01:05:27
responsible and they're both covering for each other I just don't see the evidence to say that he was involved at
01:05:34
all I find it hard to believe that darly would stand by him all these years after
01:05:40
she's been sentenced to be executed right at some point you walk away from that and you say all right this guy was
01:05:47
involved as well there are several other things here too captain at some point darly said that she suspected one or
01:05:54
possibly even two men that lived in her neighborhood I don't know the details of
01:05:59
that but that's something she has said over the years I don't know who these men are why she would suspect them skip
01:06:06
hollandsworth one of my favorite True Crime writers that writes for Texas monthly he referenced something that he
01:06:12
had seen elsewhere that at one time there was some suspicion surrounding a local police officer's son um I'm
01:06:20
guessing this would be a grown man son and then also one thing that is brought up in this case and it's kind of an
01:06:28
aside I couldn't find any real information on it but it was super bizarre to to find out was that there
01:06:37
was an active serial rapist that was active in the Greater Dallas area at the time of these murders again like we said
01:06:46
the the most logical motive for us if it's an intruder would be sexual sexual would be
01:06:55
a stranger attack would be my my opinion for for the most part but one thing that
01:06:59
I found interesting about this serial rapist that's referenced in this story again couldn't find information if this
01:07:08
rapist ever escalated to murder or committed murders in the course of his other crimes I couldn't find if the the
01:07:15
person was ever caught but one thing that they did state is that this serial rapist at the time was known to use
01:07:23
items found inside the victim's home during his attack the sock the knife that's what we have here in dar's
01:07:34
case well no and also like you said this um seral rapist that's in the area could
01:07:40
have been these two men that the eyewitness saw those that night it could have been the black car that people saw
01:07:48
uh in the neighborhood they all could be connected and personally if you if you wanted to sit down and asked the colonel
01:07:57
what do you think happened here look this might piss off a lot of people I don't know but I actually lean
01:08:05
toward her being better to be pissed off than pissed on I lean toward her being innocent I'm not 100% convinced either
01:08:14
way I'm putting a lot of weight into other people's thoughts and theories one being the juror that we already
01:08:22
referenced and talked about saying that I think this could have gone the other way had we had more information and seen
01:08:30
this other video I also take a lot of stock and put a lot of stock into Darren roer himself yes standing by and saying
01:08:38
that she's innocent all these years again it's the behavior of this woman there were some people that questioned
01:08:46
her behavior and there were other people that said she was like the the greatest
01:08:49
Mom you know she would she loved these kids she would do anything for her children yeah and I don't see a history
01:08:58
there I don't see a History of Violence there's nobody that's come forward that said hey there was bruises on these kids
01:09:05
all the time or that she was a violent person or an angry person again there there seemed to be no mention of a fight
01:09:14
that night between even her and her husband and also I think if she had any of those traits or if she had anything
01:09:22
that would trigger her husband to not believe her I don't think he would believe her
01:09:29
and I don't think he would stand by her because you you just murdered two of my kids I could see why they came up with
01:09:35
the theory but I think this is a situation where law enforcement came up with the theory and then they triy to
01:09:41
put the pieces we'll make them work we'll we'll make the pieces fit again that's the prosecution's job to get the
01:09:49
conviction it's the defense to obviously get her acquitted I don't think she should have been maybe you
01:09:58
charge her maybe there's enough to charge her I don't think there's enough to convict her so whether you think that
01:10:03
she's innocent or guilty I don't think there's enough to convict her and I think the defense should have had an
01:10:11
easy day in court of Defending any piece of evidence thrown at her and I'm also putting a lot of stock into this next
01:10:21
bit here captain in 1999 there was a book that came out on this case and it was called Precious Angels a true story
01:10:29
of two slain children and a mother convicted of murder By Barbara Davis this book accounts for roer's
01:10:39
Guilt for darly roer's Guilt the author was convinced at the time of writing the
01:10:44
book researching the book and releasing it that darly was 100% guilty Barbara Davis has since changed her mind and now
01:10:53
supports darly rotier by donating all of the income from her book to dar's [Music]
01:11:13
family very interesting case one that you could go back and forth on depending on what side you're hearing the evidence
01:11:22
from would like to hear your opinion on this case go to True Crime garage.com and click on the blog and let us know
01:11:31
what you think and if you need more trr garage for your earballs check out our bonus show called off the Record we do a
01:11:38
lot of case updates so if you're going hey I know you guys covered this but this was in the news you should do an
01:11:45
update we probably already have on off the Record that's right join us back here in the garage next week for a new
01:11:53
episode of off the Record and and a new case on True Crime garage until then be good be kind and don't litter
01:12:09
[Music] [Applause] [Music]

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most controversial
  • 70
    Most heartbreaking
  • 70
    Most polarizing
  • 60
    Most shocking

Episode Highlights

  • The Unicorn Dream
    Nick shares a childhood memory about believing in unicorns, adding a light-hearted touch to the show.
    “This was before he had ever heard of one or saw one.”
    @ 00m 48s
    November 07, 2022
  • Cheers to Our Peeps
    The hosts toast to listeners from various locations, creating a sense of community.
    “Here's some cheers to our peeps right here!”
    @ 01m 28s
    November 07, 2022
  • The Crime Scene Evidence
    Discussion on the knife found at the crime scene and its implications for Darley's guilt or innocence.
    “There’s really no question in my opinion that this was the knife that was used to kill Devon and Damon.”
    @ 05m 10s
    November 07, 2022
  • The Sock Evidence
    A bloody sock found two houses away raises questions about the crime scene.
    “This sock is a big problem for a lot of things.”
    @ 31m 10s
    November 07, 2022
  • Timeline of Events
    The timeline suggests Darly had no time to stage the scene after the attack.
    “There does not seem to be enough time to kill both children and stage all these things.”
    @ 40m 55s
    November 07, 2022
  • Trial and Conviction
    Darly was convicted of murdering her son Damon and sentenced to death.
    “On January 6th 1997, just two days after Darly's birthday, the trial began.”
    @ 45m 22s
    November 07, 2022
  • The Silly String Incident
    Darly celebrated her son's birthday days after his murder, leading to public outrage.
    “She looks happy in the video, as if her kids have not just recently been murdered.”
    @ 50m 17s
    November 07, 2022
  • Unidentified Fingerprints
    Unmatched fingerprints found at the crime scene raise questions about the investigation.
    “Whose fingerprints are these? We can't match them to anybody known to be inside that home.”
    @ 57m 13s
    November 07, 2022
  • Darren's Support
    Darren Roer has always stood by Darly, claiming she didn't kill their children.
    “Darren has always said that he never believed Darly killed the kids.”
    @ 01h 05m 15s
    November 07, 2022
  • Darly's Defense
    The defense argues there's insufficient evidence to convict Darly, raising questions about the prosecution's theory.
    “I don't think there's enough to convict her.”
    @ 01h 10m 05s
    November 07, 2022
  • Barbara Davis's Change of Heart
    The author of a book on the case now supports Darly, donating proceeds to her family.
    “Barbara Davis has since changed her mind and now supports Darly.”
    @ 01h 10m 53s
    November 07, 2022
  • Complex Case Discussion
    The case presents conflicting evidence, leading to varied opinions on Darly's guilt.
    “Very interesting case, one that you could go back and forth on.”
    @ 01h 11m 13s
    November 07, 2022

Episode Quotes

  • I think that there is a potential maybe small chance...
    Darlie Routier /// Part 2 /// 490
  • This kid could have told us what happened.
    Darlie Routier /// Part 2 /// 490
  • The sock is a big problem for a lot of things.
    Darlie Routier /// Part 2 /// 490
  • I think this sock strongly suggests Darly is innocent.
    Darlie Routier /// Part 2 /// 490
  • If my kid was murdered, I wouldn't celebrate his birthday.
    Darlie Routier /// Part 2 /// 490
  • I actually lean toward her being innocent.
    Darlie Routier /// Part 2 /// 490

Key Moments

  • Welcome to True Crime00:40
  • Crime Scene Analysis03:39
  • Evidence Discussion05:30
  • Innocence Questioned09:40
  • Trial Begins45:22
  • Questionable Evidence1:10:00
  • Community Engagement1:11:25
  • Final Thoughts1:11:58

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown