00:00:11
thank you [Music] [Music] thank you welcome to True Crime garage wherever you are whatever you are doing thanks
00:00:44
for listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is a man who would stop the world and melt with you here is
00:00:51
the cat it's good to be seen and good to see you thanks for listening thanks for
00:00:55
telling a friend [Music] foreign this week we are featuring The Bible salesman this is an Old Ale by the
00:01:07
Shifty folks over at transplants Brewing Company this is a powerful Old Ale aged
00:01:13
in Bourbon barrels and it's nine percent alcohol by volume so please drink this one at home garage grade three and a
00:01:22
half bottle caps out of five and let's give some praise and thank you to those who helped us fill up the fridge this
00:01:29
week here in the garage first up a double fisted cheers to Charlotte and Lottie in London the UK garage granny so
00:01:37
a long distance cheers to both Charlotte and Lottie and last but not least we have our boy Thomas listening in what we
00:01:45
have to say is Parts Unknown because he says he loves checking out True Crime Garage on YouTube while his boss thinks
00:01:53
that he is busy working so cheers to the working class and cheers to everyone that helped us with this week spear run
00:02:00
yeah BWW are you in beer run yeah go over to YouTube and subscribe and that's enough of the
00:02:08
business all right everybody gather around grab a chair grab a beer let's talk some true crime
00:02:15
[Music] thank you [Music] when bad men commit acts of evil with impunity it only inspires other bad men to do the
00:02:55
same so how many bad men has the hammer man inspired this week we profile a killer who surely
00:03:06
has inspired many urban legends especially those terrifying urban legends about young women getting into
00:03:15
cars with strange men the hammer man did not care for his fellow man he did not value human life
00:03:25
and he hated women he saw women as something to be used up destroyed and discarded
00:03:33
he only valued his own life and his own Freedom so that he could take away yours
00:03:39
he was a Savage killer then he was The Hitcher and then he became the want ad killer
00:03:49
he was called so many things during his time of catching and killing many called him the devil
00:03:56
one member of law enforcement said the guy is the devil they should have fried him years ago
00:04:04
when he was dead they should have driven a stake through his heart and buried him
00:04:10
digging him up a week later to Ram another stake in just to make sure he was dead
00:04:16
that was Chief investigator Russell J Krueger Minneapolis PD this is the True Crime Story of a career
00:04:26
criminal a real life monster an American Nightmare this is the story of the hammer man and this
00:04:35
is True Crime garage [Music] foreign [Applause] [Music] it was just a little over 50 years ago
00:05:06
it was May 2nd 1973. a Wednesday evening in Seattle Washington when Mrs Miller a single
00:05:15
mother of one was starting to get worried Mrs Miller came home that Wednesday to an empty house her daughter
00:05:23
Catherine Sue Miller must have still been out with some friends it was unlike her to not be home when
00:05:30
her mother arrived but Kathy Sue was 15 years old she was growing up and she was
00:05:36
just three weeks away from her 16th birthday Mrs Miller knew Kathy Sue not only had a
00:05:43
gaggle of friends but she had a boyfriend as well this is a very innocent type of
00:05:49
relationship a very young relationship the two were really more friends than traditional boyfriend and girlfriend
00:05:56
heck the two had not even really reached the stage of puppy love yet Kathy must be out with her boyfriend mom
00:06:05
thought they were often together walking and talking in the neighborhood or perhaps
00:06:11
she was with some of the neighborhood girls but still it was unusual but nothing to be concerned with and
00:06:20
being a single mother one tends to stay busy and busy can easily distract one's heart and mind
00:06:27
Mrs Miller went about her evening preparing things for tomorrow and getting dinner ready for her and Kathy
00:06:33
but that is when it's set in the worry the not knowing maybe some mothers would be angry thinking that the teenager had
00:06:43
simply decided to not play by the household rules or was just outright defying her mother I but not Kathy Kathy
00:06:52
was a good kid who grew into a good teenager and she was no trouble at all for the single mother
00:06:59
but still it sets in Mrs Miller walked the dinner plates over to the table and sat them down
00:07:07
it was 7 p.m and there was no sign nor word of her daughter Mrs Miller didn't take a bite she didn't
00:07:16
wait for the hot dinner to get cold instead she turned from the table and walked over to the telephone hanging on
00:07:23
the kitchen wall the little notepad on the small table next to where the phone on the wall was
00:07:29
had several phone numbers for some of the other girls the same age as Kathy listed in the notepad's pages
00:07:37
Mrs Miller started calling those numbers most of the girls or at least their parents were easily reached but
00:07:45
unfortunately none had seen Kathy after school that day unsure of what to do Mrs Miller sat down
00:07:54
at the kitchen table and began to question herself should she call the police or should she just wait maybe
00:08:00
Kathy had lost track of time and would be home any minute now then Mrs Miller remembered an ongoing
00:08:08
conversation between her and her daughter a conversation that the two did not see
00:08:14
eye to eye on and it was so rare that the two did not agree that now she was starting to think
00:08:21
of course this is why she had not come home and why had she not thought of this before
00:08:28
well their disagreement was a simple one she saw one ad in the paper for a job she wanted to apply for and her mother
00:08:37
didn't want her to apply for that job that's right Kathy Sue expressed to her mother just two days prior that she
00:08:45
wanted to get a job so it's May and the school year would be out for the summer very soon and remember Kathy is just
00:08:54
three weeks from her 16th birthday and some of her 16 year old friends were starting to work at jobs this is mostly
00:09:02
stuff near their homes very part-time work Kathy's boyfriend too he had a job but he also wanted another
00:09:11
job for the summer time and the two had spent some time perusing the want ads together in the News Tribune
00:09:19
Kathy and her mother's disagreement was about a particular job opportunity Kathy's mother thought that the
00:09:25
arrangements for this job interview were not entirely kosher just a day prior Kathy showed her mother
00:09:34
a one ad for a gas station attendant job Kathy had called the number listed and spoke with the owner of the gas station
00:09:44
he said that he needed to hire someone fast and he needed Kathy to come into the gas station as soon as possible as
00:09:52
soon as she could for an interview and to fill out any tax forms that would be required
00:09:57
Kathy said that her mother wouldn't have time to take her until the weekend the owner suggested that she waited for him
00:10:06
at an intersection this would be not too far from her home and after school on that Wednesday and that he would come
00:10:15
and pick her up so that she would have a ride he's going to provide the ride to her back to the gas station where they
00:10:22
can talk they can do the interview and she can fill out any of the necessary paperwork but this is not a normal
00:10:28
request not at all and Kathy's mom was hip to that she told Kathy told her mother about the
00:10:37
arrangement and she told Kathy no she did not think that it was professional and that she is not to be getting into
00:10:44
cars with a man for which both of them had never met good advice Kathy's mom then remembering all of this Springs
00:10:51
into action jumps up from her chair at the kitchen table and she went looking through the house she's looking for
00:11:00
the old newspapers yeah the one ads and finally she located the section of the newspaper that her daughter had shown
00:11:06
her previously so she found the circled want ad for this gas station job that Kathy had
00:11:14
shown to her Mrs Miller picked up the phone she dials the number listed for the gas station
00:11:21
Mrs Miller called the phone number and a man answered she asked for her daughter
00:11:27
she told the man that she was aware of an arrangement for her daughter to be picked up by someone and she knew that
00:11:34
the meeting was to be sometime after Kathy's school day Mrs Miller asked if the man had seen her
00:11:41
daughter Kathy or perhaps even picked her up that day this man this business owner tells the mother well I did talk
00:11:51
to her but I didn't pick her up yeah he says I remember talking to the girl and he even says I wrote her name
00:11:58
down and then pauses for a second and says Catherine Miller right and she says yes that's my daughter's name have you
00:12:05
seen her and the man says that he agreed to pick her up near her home he goes on to tell Mrs Miller that he
00:12:14
drove out there however once he got to the location her daughter wasn't there he doesn't
00:12:19
know where she could be he said he waited for a few minutes but he was far too busy to be just waiting
00:12:25
around for too long and so after a short while he drove off and he hadn't seen the girl at all
00:12:33
the phone call did not last much longer okay Mrs Miller is near full panic mode now and after she hangs up the phone
00:12:42
captain the next call is going to be to Kathy's boyfriend and this is not going to make Mrs Miller
00:12:51
feel any better about her late and missing daughter so she's sitting down to dinner waiting
00:12:59
for daughter to come home she remembers this job interview and now Mrs Miller is on the phone with
00:13:05
Kathy's 15 16 year old boyfriend and this is a kid from the neighborhood that Mrs Miller is known for a long time
00:13:13
right so she trusts this kid and she asks the boy have you seen Kathy she was hoping that
00:13:22
the two were just hanging out somewhere but keep in mind when the when these two
00:13:26
hung out they were typically out in the neighborhood walking and talking together right and so just the boy being
00:13:32
home is not going to feel very good to Mrs Miller it's not a good sign no because her daughter Kathy doesn't go
00:13:38
and hang out at his house so the boy does have some information he tells Mrs Miller in a little bit
00:13:47
shamefully so because he knew that Kathy was not to take this appointment and he
00:13:54
says look I went with your daughter to stand on the corner there and wait for the guy to pick her up
00:14:01
and he tells Mrs Miller he says look Kathy knew that she wasn't to take the meeting but she really wanted the
00:14:09
job for the summer and she thought that you wouldn't be mad if I went with her however this kid had a paper route and
00:14:17
remember we've talked about this on the show plenty of times but back in the day
00:14:22
they delivered papers in the morning and oftentimes in the evening as well people
00:14:26
love their news you got to get that evening newspaper so what's the boyfriend's story to Mrs Miller
00:14:34
he says he went with Kathy to the corner and she filled him in on all the details
00:14:40
this guy's gonna pick me up remember he tells Mrs Miller that Kathy knew she wasn't to go but if he
00:14:47
went with her maybe she wouldn't be upset with her so he agrees to go with her however at some point the man's not
00:14:55
on time the car doesn't show up the vehicle doesn't show up so he says to Kathy look you should go home I have to
00:15:01
go do my paper route unfortunately man he he tells Mrs Miller that when I last saw Kathy she was still
00:15:09
standing on the corner waiting for the gas station owner to pick her up and I went off and did my
00:15:18
paper route so he's just as surprised as Mrs Miller when he gets this phone call that Kathy
00:15:25
didn't go for this job interviewer or wasn't home at least by 7 PM now we're in probably 7 30 7 45 that night
00:15:36
this makes Mrs Miller incredibly nervous remember she didn't want her daughter to
00:15:41
go meet this guy in the first place and now her daughter's not home and she's already spoke to the guy who says he's
00:15:50
the gas station owner who says yeah I went to pick her up and she wasn't there so Mrs Miller of course calls the
00:15:58
Seattle Police Department and reports her daughter as missing tells the story the Seattle Police
00:16:06
Department they do take a report now what they do with the report that evening is anyone's guess it's a mystery it's
00:16:15
not well documented what took place if they went out driving around looking for her or just put out an APB for her uh I
00:16:23
would guess that those are probably some efforts that were taken that night but what we do know is keep in mind this
00:16:31
is the 70s and where we might feel like that was not enough effort put onto this
00:16:38
scenario often in the 70s man they didn't even take a a report a missing report for a
00:16:45
teenager or a youngster until they had been gone for 24 hours some jurisdictions were
00:16:51
even doing 48 hours right because you had so many kids that just weren't where they were supposed to be they end up
00:16:56
coming home after dark they get yelled at by Mom and Dad that may be grounded for a couple of days and that's the end
00:17:03
of it and you've just wasted the police's time but in this situation at least they take
00:17:08
the report now this is going to have quite the domino effect because these reports
00:17:17
while we don't know what was done with it that evening they are handed off to the higher ups when they come in for the
00:17:24
day shift the next morning right the higher ups in this situation are Detectives
00:17:30
so now we have to introduce to everyone detectives Dwayne Holman and William Bowman Holmen and Bowman the two of them
00:17:39
read the report follow up with a call to Mrs Miller they think that it sounds suspicious enough
00:17:46
that they're going to go out and investigate they don't think that this is a a runaway situation and if it is
00:17:52
wonderful the kid comes home and everything's fine well either the businessman is lying and
00:18:00
he's responsible or the possibilities then become endless because she's at the corner of a
00:18:07
decently busy intersection exactly so they go out to the gas station to talk to the man that was on
00:18:16
the phone and when they get there they meet a person that is described as a large man
00:18:23
he's about six foot two 200 pounds and his name is Harvey Lewis kerrignon now Harvey is the gas station owner and
00:18:35
this gas station is very successful so he has attendance and cashiers working for him
00:18:41
most of them are of the teenage years a lot of you know teen boys teen girls and he tells the officers he says
00:18:50
look I was really hoping to to hire a boy but when I got the call from the girl I
00:18:57
needed the help so I told her I would take the interview he tells the officers detective Holman
00:19:03
and Bowman the same story that he told Mrs Miller the prior evening we had an arrangement for me to pick her
00:19:11
up so she could fill out the tax paperwork it it sounds like she was getting the
00:19:17
job just by calling like the the interview was more of a formality and that they would be filling out paperwork
00:19:23
so that she could start asmp and so he's telling them the story but what the detectives are noticing right
00:19:32
away Captain is that this dude does not seem to be responding very well to their
00:19:37
presence he starts sweating profusely he looks incredibly nervous oh he's a big man it's a big man and it's
00:19:46
summertime it's hot out there it's hot in the hot tub during some of the questioning and they're not even getting
00:19:51
very suspicious with they're not overly obvious with their suspicions they're not really accusing him of
00:19:58
anything at this point they're simply asking him questions and they say that not only does he appear to be sweating
00:20:05
nervous but at some of the questions he becomes angry and agitated when they're repeating their questions
00:20:13
however they see no reason to further question this man there's no indication that Kathy ever
00:20:23
was picked up by this guy they don't have any Witnesses saying that this guy picked her up they have his story the
00:20:30
same story that he said the night before they don't know that everything fully checks out but they leave the interview
00:20:38
still suspicious of this man but with nothing really to go on to finding Kathy that's that's their main number one
00:20:46
concern right now is where is this girl so this business owner Harvey he's telling her mother yes I spoke with her
00:20:54
I just never picked her up the cops go out to talk to him he becomes a sweaty mess
00:21:02
and so when they go back to the station look he he gave law enforcement some red flags so
00:21:10
what are they going to do they're going to look up his past criminal history I think we need to give a little Kudos
00:21:17
here now this seems like standard procedure today but back then 1973 not so much this guy must have appeared to
00:21:27
be nervous enough that it set off some red flags for the two detectives and as you said Captain they get to the station
00:21:34
they do a background check on Harvey kerrignon and what they see in that background check will make their blood
00:21:42
boil [Music] thank you [Music] all right we are back cheers to everybody cheers to you Colonel cheers to you
00:22:20
Captain cheers to everybody out there tuning in once again this week we are happy and lucky to have you now Captain
00:22:29
we have to go back in time here because what we have is our two detectives they just come from this meeting with the gas
00:22:38
station owner Harvey kerrignon that leaves them feeling a little unsettled they have a missing girl she's not even
00:22:46
been missing for 24 hours yet about 16 hours by this time last scene hanging out with one of her friends waiting for
00:22:55
a ride after school the previous day yeah then they go talk to this guy that claims
00:23:01
that he did talk to her on the phone and was going to pick her up but she just wasn't there and he's a little sweaty
00:23:07
he's a little sweaty so now they have to figure out okay is this guy lying to us
00:23:12
because he looks nervous when we talk to him or or does he just have a heart condition or did he do as he say went to
00:23:20
go pick her up and she's not there he doesn't know what happened to her now us the detectives got to figure out if
00:23:26
somebody else picked her up right so back at the station they decide to run a background check on Harvey
00:23:33
kerrignan now I want to point out here this guy he is kind of odd looking we already referenced that he's a larger
00:23:42
man oddly sheep feet but he's also the type that he's easy to talk to and he's a successful local businessman
00:23:53
his gas station in Seattle was a success we should point out too don't don't get
00:24:02
overly jealous here people but back then regular gas 35 cents a gallon wow the Primo stuff
00:24:11
39 cents a gallon oh Fancy Pants that's right so he's pumping more gas his gas station is selling more gas than the
00:24:19
others in town so he's a successful small business owner they don't feel other than the
00:24:27
nervousness and the sweating that he has any reason to tell them anything other than the truth but this but he is uh I'd
00:24:35
consider him to be fugly you're not the only one yeah so our friend Anne rule R.I.P
00:24:44
she described him and I like when we have a a a respected lady describing a man rather than us two garage guys I'll
00:24:53
tell you the truth I tell you I tell it like I see it she referred to him as a huge man
00:25:01
with hands like hams a brow that resembled that of a Latter Day cro magnum man which I think looking at his picture
00:25:12
that description is pretty spot on so they run a background check on Harvey kerrignon and what they find is a
00:25:21
plethora of troubling items in this dude's history yeah the ones detective asked the other
00:25:29
one does it look like he has a plethora of criminal activity he does and not not
00:25:35
any like small time crime either so let's go back in time and we're going to go back to
00:25:44
1948. so this is just a little under 25 years before 15 year old Kathy Sue Miller goes missing
00:25:55
1948 Harvey Carrington is 21 years old he's in the Army now I do want to point out here there are some sources that say
00:26:04
he was in the Air Force most say he was in the Army I could not figure out between the two which one it was my
00:26:11
guess is neither branch of our military service wants to claim this guy he stationed at Fort Richardson in
00:26:19
Anchorage Alaska now on July 31st 1949 this is this is after he's been there for some
00:26:29
time obviously there's a woman Laura Showalter 57 years old she's walking home that's a Sunday
00:26:37
night she's walking home from the theater she doesn't make it home that night the
00:26:42
next morning that Monday morning a woman's brutally beaten body was found the cause of death was due to several
00:26:51
blows to the Head Now by that Monday afternoon Captain police have a man not under arrest not
00:26:58
charged with anything but they have this man at the station and he is being questioned about his possible
00:27:05
involvement in this woman's murder the body was that of Laura Showalter it took a few days to identify her
00:27:14
but not a few days to have a suspect they very quickly land on a suspect and why how do they land on a suspect so
00:27:23
quickly well law enforcement has an eyewitness yes and this is a very odd story I think
00:27:32
so odd that the police have to believe the details of the story so they find this woman
00:27:39
unfortunately horrible situation haven't been beaten to death found in a public location right so they canvassed the
00:27:49
area and one of the persons who was walking home that night the previous night the Sunday night says to the
00:27:58
police yeah that's weird that you found that body this was like a park type setting
00:28:05
he says I was walking home last night and the same spot where she is lying where you found her body
00:28:13
I saw her lying with a with a guy and they look like they were being romantic they look like they were maybe
00:28:20
on a date and it was getting a little hot and heavy right and he goes so I kind of looked away because I didn't
00:28:26
want them to be embarrassed or think that I was peeping or anything like that but it was on my way home I saw the two
00:28:31
of them I thought they were making out I continued on and went to bed didn't think anything of it now you find a
00:28:40
woman in that same spot now he could not tell the detectives with 100 certainty that
00:28:46
the woman they found is the woman that he saw because he said he saw more of the man than the woman
00:28:54
he's kind of filling in the blanks right sometimes you see this stuff and you fill in the blanks a little bit but the
00:28:59
blanks that he was not filling in was the description that he gives of the man and he says the man clearly was a
00:29:07
younger Soldier in his early 20s um and he gave the description of this man he says he was a larger white guy
00:29:17
probably about over six feet tall around 200 pounds he had the mutton chops right
00:29:24
the very long sideburns and that's about the best description that they can get that he can provide
00:29:33
however there's some really good clues in there over six feet tall is above the average
00:29:39
height for a male back then so that shrinks your suspect pool very quickly there's shrinkage on top of that
00:29:48
he's able to say this guy's a younger man he's in his early 20s right he's a soldier
00:29:54
I Believe by the way that he was dressed that he was probably a soldier and then the mutton chops on top of that
00:30:00
so they're shrinking the the pole pretty cool very much there was significant shrinkage as they said yeah well the
00:30:08
water was cold so they go around canvassing the area and of course they're going to go to the
00:30:16
base there that Fort Richardson's right and they want to start looking for a guy
00:30:22
that would fit that description they ask around they find a guy so they bring this guy in
00:30:30
and he's very nervous sweating a lot sweaty he's answering their questions but he appears to be incredibly nervous
00:30:40
now they do the old police lineup and they bring back in the neighbor and the guy says yeah that one right there
00:30:49
that's the guy that I believe that I saw with the woman in the park the night before
00:30:55
the guy's name is Harvey kerrignon of course he is a soldier and they arrest him
00:31:03
but they don't have anything to really hold him on there's no physical evidence this is 19
00:31:11
49 so keep in mind the detectives are always behind the eight ball in these situations just
00:31:18
based off of the lack of Technology therefore the lack of physical evidence all they have is this guy saying I'm
00:31:27
pretty sure that that's the guy that I saw with that woman last night now that sounds like a good case but you
00:31:34
take that to court and you get a good defense team and they're going to present to the jury
00:31:39
well this this man can't even say that the woman that he saw was the murder victim
00:31:45
this man can't say with 100 certainty that the guy that he picked out of the police lineup is the guy that he saw
00:31:51
that night in the under the cover of Darkness so while this man Harvey kerrignon
00:31:58
remains one of those guys that we talk about so much here in the garage right Captain one of these guys where police
00:32:03
go you know what we're pretty sure we're 99.9 sure we know who did this right we just don't have the evidence to
00:32:11
lock this dude up now we need to fast forward to September 16 1949. when we have an attempted rape and a
00:32:26
horrible a brutal attack on a woman named Dorcas Callan so she's attacked and there's an
00:32:34
attempted rape assault on this young woman thankfully she is able to escape the clutches of her attacker
00:32:42
she immediately goes to police she tells the police that she was approached and attacked by a drunken Soldier early that
00:32:50
morning it's like 11 A.M and the soldier who approached her was drunk and she describes this attack as he
00:33:01
started to bring up some kind of conversation try to have conversation with her that was
00:33:07
friendly conversation however when she rejected his advances because he's wasted at 11 o'clock he's wasted at 11
00:33:16
o'clock and she's probably got places to go it's the middle of the day and so she rejects his advances and then
00:33:23
he becomes violent he just he tries to abduct her tries to attack her tries to rape her and he physically assaults her
00:33:32
now she is able to provide a description to detectives of her assailant and right
00:33:41
away ding ding light bulbs and bells are going off that description is of the same guy that
00:33:48
they talk to back in July July 31st August 1st about the woman found dead in the park
00:33:58
Laura Showalter so they very quickly go out and pick up Harvey Kerrigan and it's mostly because of two factors
00:34:09
right one the attack was so similar to the attack and murder for which Harvey was questioned that took place less than
00:34:17
77-0 days prior and the description gave to police in this latest attack where Miss Callan
00:34:25
survived after having escaped both she and then another independent witness described the man and his clothing and
00:34:33
this too matching the suspect in the July murder case so Harvey kerrignon is picked up and
00:34:40
he's questioned identified in a police lineup by both the surviving victim and the witness from the previous crime
00:34:48
and now this other independent Witness so now you have three people saying look that's the guy I think that was
00:34:56
with the murder victim in the park one person saying I was attacked by this man and the other one saying I witnessed him
00:35:04
talking to her before the attack right so they're going to arrest this Soldier Harvey and they're going to charge him
00:35:13
with murder rape and assault yes murder rape attempted rape and assault and at this time Harvey
00:35:21
Carrington is 22 years old and he is in the Army now we get to December of 1949 Anchorage Alaska
00:35:30
Harvey Carrington is found guilty and what the papers were calling a rape slaying of 57 year old Laura Showalter
00:35:39
after the trial Harvey is sentenced to death and in fact they announce during sentencing and at the the end of
00:35:48
the trial the hanging of Harvey L kerrignon age 22 will be held adjacent to the federal jail on March 3rd between
00:35:57
6 and 8 A.M 1950. that's a very quick from guilty to sentencing to death for back then if we don't experience
00:36:09
that today and I don't know if this announcement was meant for this to be a public hanging or what but
00:36:16
it sounds a little bit like that you know we're we've sentenced this man to death and oh by the way
00:36:22
mark your calendars it's going to be March 3rd between 6 and 8 A.M and here's the location so if we jump into the
00:36:30
DeLorean and go back to the future this is what the detectives are seeing when we have a missing 15 year old and
00:36:40
this guy is saying hey I I yeah I was supposed to pick her up but she never showed up
00:36:46
and this so the detectives have evidence that this guy is capable of anything and
00:36:54
everything evil but if this sentence was carried out then Harvey Carrigan would be like be
00:37:01
real says a dead man walking yeah so what happened there's much more to this story
00:37:07
so after the trial as we said he's sentenced to death now we get the guilty verdict
00:37:13
but before sentencing Harvey's defense counsel request a new trial the judge denies this in sentences
00:37:22
Harvey to hang the defense Council cited 11. grounds for asking for a new trial including an unfair and impartial jury
00:37:35
saying that the court should have granted a change of venue and because the case was well known and it was
00:37:41
publicized at the time that there was no way that you could have an impartial jury without a change of venue
00:37:48
and that Harvey was convicted mostly on him having confessed to authorities and this part of the story is rather
00:37:56
complicated but I'll do my darndest here Captain to explain it the defense cites that the confession
00:38:02
they end up charging him with the with the murder and with this other attack based off of
00:38:09
him confessing they don't have a lot of physical evidence they have these eyewitnesses who pick him out of a
00:38:15
lineup but the whole conviction and the whole sentence to death is based around his
00:38:22
confession he was brought in by the U.S Marshals interview time and time again they brought in like a psychologist and
00:38:29
doctors and surrounded by all these people and convince him to tell them what actually happened
00:38:36
how do they convince him to to tell what actually happened when he denied any wrongdoing or any involvement
00:38:44
at all initially well the defense cites that the confession was only obtained due to a quote secret
00:38:53
interrogation and promises made by persons at the interrogation to the defendant
00:39:00
and also due to psychological pressures placed upon placed upon the charged individual
00:39:07
Harvey kerrignon so what happens here captain is that they're stating that he was promised
00:39:20
Harvey Carrington was promised if look if you confess we can't sentence you to death
00:39:26
we can lock you up for life or put you away for a long time you just need to tell us what happened get this off your
00:39:32
conscious we we won't be able to kill you if you confess well he confesses they take him to court
00:39:39
and then they sentence him to die so what ultimately ends up happening here is that Harvey and his defense counsel
00:39:50
they won a new trial on this murder conviction and this new trial takes place in 1951 on the grounds that his
00:39:56
confession had been improperly obtained an officer interrogating Kerrigan as we said told him he could not would not be
00:40:04
executed if he confessed to the murder so he gets this new trial and at this trial Harvey's confession the one that
00:40:12
was used at the previous trial to secure a conviction and what would have been would have sealed Harvey's fate with his
00:40:19
death was suppressed and without the confession they didn't have enough evidence to
00:40:25
prosecute so the murder charge essentially is dismissed thus ultimately freeing Harvey of an
00:40:34
early demise right at least one other source states that the Supreme Court overruled Kerrigan's death sentence do
00:40:43
to the officers violations of the McNabb rule but he still had the rape and assault
00:40:50
charges from the September attack for which he was convicted and so he had to continue
00:40:57
to serve out his sentence minus the death penalty so he so do we know how long he ended up
00:41:03
serving well he was sentenced to 15 years before assaulting Miss Callan but of course he doesn't serve the whole
00:41:12
time does he you and I have been doing this show long enough and our listeners have been listening loyally long enough
00:41:18
to know that most cases that's a shame we're most cases at least here in Ohio you are hoping that the prisoner serves
00:41:29
out 80 percent of the sentence now keep in mind we've we've gone through time and time again
00:41:35
the problems with the overpopulation overcrowding of prisons in different states throughout the different Decades
00:41:44
of the 20th century and how it led to the early release of a lot of those inmates
00:41:51
well he's sentenced to 15 years in 1952 he's transferred to Alcatraz federal penitentiary
00:41:59
and then Harvey is paroled in 1960. so he served eight more years after he is transferred
00:42:10
to Alcatraz so old uh sweaty Harvey serves about nine years of that sentence nine years and meanwhile the police know
00:42:21
that he's a murderer so once he's paroled Harvey moves to Minnesota this is closer to where he is
00:42:28
from he he was born in North Dakota well I hope this comes out right but we see sometimes with criminals that they
00:42:36
kind of outgrow this type of behavior they can age out of violence but that's not what we're going to see with this
00:42:44
man and then on top of that keep in mind how young he is right at this time so he's in his he's 33.
00:42:54
when he's paroled he goes to Minnesota and on August 5th 1960 Harvey Carrigan is arrested in Minnesota
00:43:03
for burglary assault and attempted rape he's convicted on those charges and sentenced to
00:43:10
hold your breath don't get too excited two and a half years in a Minnesota State Prison wow
00:43:19
and then he gets unfortunately he gets another 2086 days I didn't know that they
00:43:25
sentenced you in days in some jurisdictions but he gets another 2086 days in federal prison in
00:43:33
Leavenworth Kansas from there he is released on parole and he picks up once again and moves to
00:43:40
Seattle Washington where just eight short months later Harvey Carrigan is arrested for
00:43:46
second-degree burglary and sentenced to 15 years in the Washington State Prison at Walla Walla
00:43:53
during this prison stint Harvey uses the resources provided there within to obtain a High School GED
00:44:01
diploma and he takes some college courses of note he takes some criminal psychology courses doesn't seem like a
00:44:09
good idea to offer those he is paroled four years after he gets there this takes us through 1968 captain
00:44:20
we still got five more years until detectives are talking to him about a missing little girl 15 year old Kathy
00:44:26
Sue Miller where we first started off today's episode well Harvey is going to be
00:44:31
paroled and after he is paroled he meets a lady her name is Sheila Moran yeah and they
00:44:39
strike up a relationship he eventually moves in with Sheila and Sheila's daughter
00:44:44
and the two Mary proving that there's somebody for everybody yeah and I'm guessing I'm hoping
00:44:53
and praying that Sheila was unaware of kerrignon's previous history right because nothing infuriates me more than
00:45:01
when I see a woman with a child allow somebody with a lengthy violent sexual violence too criminal history
00:45:13
into their home yeah because you're not just putting yourself at risk you're putting your children at risk as well
00:45:19
exactly you you might as well just March that child right to the front line of danger
00:45:25
so the two meet they strike strike it up they they hit it off they get married now he's living with mom and daughter
00:45:32
but during this time in 1969 he's 42 at this at this point in our timeline he's arrested for a parole violation and
00:45:41
sentenced to serve another year at Walla Walla now during this time Sheila divorces Harvey
00:45:50
Kerrigan and she states that she is seeking the divorce due to physical abuse suffered by the hands at the hands
00:45:58
of Harvey the divorce goes through he serves as year he gets out he must be one Charming fellow
00:46:09
because to look at this guy you go how would this dude get a date and then then icing on the cake his criminal history
00:46:17
but once he gets out he meets another woman Alice Johnson very fugly marries her moving in with her and her two
00:46:26
children right we have Little Billy who's 11 years old at the time in Georgia her daughter
00:46:32
Georgia who's 14. one thing we need to point out here Captain is this brings us to the latter
00:46:40
part of 1972. in our timeline and one thing that is key here and we'll come back around full circle eventually
00:46:49
is that Harvey kerrignon he receives a handful of speeding tickets during this time period
00:47:00
in October of 1972 a young woman 20 year old Laura Leslie Brock of Bellingham Washington
00:47:10
goes missing and she's found rather quickly unfortunately she's found dead her cause of death is due to several
00:47:18
blows to the Head and then this will lead us into 1973 when Kathy Sue Miller goes missing age
00:47:28
15 goes missing early May of 1973 this is The Disappearance that the police just left the gas station talking
00:47:39
to the owner of the gas station where she was going to apply for a job had an appointment arranged with the
00:47:48
owner Harvey Carrigan detectives talked to this man they get back to the station
00:47:53
they run a background check on him that's the information in story form that they find on the guy that they just
00:48:00
talked to about a missing 15 year old girl [Music] big thank you to everybody that's been
00:48:21
sharing our little garage show on social media it helps keep the lights on join us back here in the garage same bat
00:48:30
Time same bat Channel and until then be good be kind and don't live thank you foreign
00:48:58
[Music]