Search Captions & Ask AI

Gerald Cotten ////// 524

November 04, 2022 / 54:33

This episode covers the mysterious death of cryptocurrency millionaire Gerald Cotten, the operations of his exchange Quadriga CX, and the controversies surrounding his passing. Guests include Justin from Generation Y.

The hosts discuss Cotten's background and the rise of Quadriga CX, which became the largest crypto exchange in Canada. Cotten's business model involved charging transaction fees, but as the crypto market declined, customers struggled to withdraw their funds.

After marrying Jennifer Robertson, Cotten traveled to India for their honeymoon, where he died under suspicious circumstances. The hosts question the timeline of his death and the handling of his body, which was embalmed by medical students after being moved around.

Investors became concerned when Cotten's death was announced a month later, leading to investigations into Quadriga CX's operations. The episode highlights the discovery of fake accounts and the potential for Cotten to have faked his own death.

As the investigation unfolds, the hosts speculate on the possibility of Cotten being alive and the implications for his wife and business partner. They encourage listeners to share their thoughts on the case.

TLDR

Gerald Cotten's mysterious death raises questions about his crypto exchange and potential fraud.

Episode

54:33
00:00:11
thank you [Music] [Music] thank you foreign garage wherever you are whatever you're
00:00:44
doing thanks for listening I am your host the captain and with me as always well forget about the guy that's with me
00:00:51
as always he's locked in my basement it's good to be seen it's good to see you thanks for listening thanks for
00:00:58
telling a friend [Music] and this week we're drinking Guinness Smooth Dark Stout that's creamy and
00:01:11
texture and an after bite that's both bitter and sweet it's malty chocolatey and it has a subtle punch of coffee this
00:01:20
classic Brew originates from Dublin Ireland although I'm told by the Irish that Guinness only lives up to its
00:01:28
reputation on Irish soil regardless my dad calls it adult milkshake and I give Guinness four and a half out of five
00:01:37
bottle caps to everybody that filled up the fridge this week cheers into my Irish mates I say lunch yes yes yes b
00:01:46
double e double r u n Beer Run big shout to Lisa in Pottstown PA a big we like to
00:01:55
jib to Kelly in Roseville California and Jen Lin and rivena Ohio and a big shout
00:02:01
out over the pond to Rey and Cheshire England check out the store this week for our new Halloween teacher and
00:02:08
Halloween ability and look for the Halloween posters coming to you soon and that is enough of the business grab a
00:02:15
chair grab a beer and let's talk some true crime [Music] foreign [Music] Bitcoin is a digital or cryptocurrency
00:02:59
with no Central Authority unlike with traditional government-issued currencies it was introduced in 2009
00:03:07
and there are many Mysteries surrounding the founder of the technology however it
00:03:12
seems to follow the ideas presented in a white paper by santoshi Nakamoto Bitcoin
00:03:19
is not supported by any banks or government bodies it utilizes cryptography to maintain its security
00:03:28
there are no physical coins or notes rather balances are reserved on a public Ledger with encrypted records all
00:03:36
transactions are verified by using a mass computer generated process known as mining although major and developed
00:03:44
countries including us UK and Canada allow its use official International laws regarding Bitcoin are lacking
00:03:54
and it's not considered legal tender in any country with the recent exception of
00:03:59
El Salvador join me and Justin from Generation Y as we look into the mysterious death of cryptocurrency
00:04:07
millionaire Gerald cotton this is true crime garage [Music] foreign [Music] I'm doing well
00:04:29
how are you well I'm doing okay but it's a Red Bull and Ritalin type of day I'm struggling a little
00:04:37
old R and R yes well this individual that we're going to talk about he probably took some Ritalin I'm sure he
00:04:45
did tonight's case is an interesting one would you call it a mysterious death yes or maybe a unexplained death we're
00:04:56
talking about the Unexplained death of Gerald cotton who otherwise goes by uh Gary
00:05:04
and he was running one of the or the largest crypto Exchange in Canada when somebody like that passes away it's not
00:05:15
that big of a deal but he was very young at the time so that's where some questions come in among others yes he
00:05:24
ran a crypto exchange called quadriga CX sounds like something from Star Trek yeah and for anyone that doesn't know
00:05:34
what that is I would say think of a stock exchange you know any kind of exchange where you can buy and sell some
00:05:42
type of good uh but because it's crypto people kind of their brain shuts off and
00:05:48
they don't quite understand what cryptocurrencies are I think of them as stocks but you could actually use them
00:05:56
to buy things too but do you have a better explanation Captain well his his business was a little different than
00:06:03
most because it seemed like I could go onto their website and take a hundred dollars American
00:06:09
dollars and buy a hundred dollars worth of crypto but it was not actually crypto
00:06:16
in this case for his company I could be getting this wrong but it seems to me like it was a IOU for crypto and and
00:06:24
that's not exactly out of the ordinary a lot of crypto exchanges might not be able to fill your order immediately
00:06:33
right so they will have these little tags of ious whatever you want to call them and fulfill them over the next few
00:06:41
days because they might not be able to do it immediately yeah but what's interesting about his model was that
00:06:49
their company charged you to make the transaction so once you bought the hundred dollars and whoever sold you the
00:06:58
hundred dollars both had to pay a fee so it wasn't just like some scam business the the company was making millions just
00:07:07
upon transactions and he had a pretty normal life growing up and he would end up going to school for business
00:07:17
administration at uh York University School of Business his parents were antique dealers he was just a very
00:07:26
normal nerdy guy before he started dabbling in cryptocurrencies right he had a few business ventures before
00:07:35
quadriga which we'll talk about later quadrica was as I said it it was a crypto exchange but in order
00:07:45
to become the largest crypto Exchange in Canada you have to legitimize yourself you have
00:07:54
to look like you are the real deal and he created this from the ground up with his business partner Michael Patron they
00:08:07
established a board of directors they had a small office at one point there's another way to make yourself look legit
00:08:16
and that's by creating fake user accounts to show that people are using your service and I know some podcasters will
00:08:26
purchase you know reviews or followers for themselves to make themselves appear a little bit more legitimized and I
00:08:35
personally don't care somebody does that but when it comes to a Exchange it might be a little disingenuous well
00:08:43
it goes back to a couple things in one if you want to know what which podcast we're talking about we're going to
00:08:48
reveal those in a second no we're not going to do that but if you go to iTunes and you see somebody's reviews that say
00:08:55
this podcast is nice and then the next one is nice podcast this podcast is neat like chances are those are fake reviews
00:09:07
that the podcast bought also we see it all the time where people buy followers on Instagram Facebook or whatever
00:09:18
now this practice that they're using is similar to what dating websites would use so they would get these fake
00:09:25
accounts 10 attractive females 10 attractive males and they would have these fake accounts going all the time
00:09:33
so it seemed like there was a bunch of people using their site like Justin says maybe that's okay and maybe you don't
00:09:40
frown upon on that too much on a dating site especially if it's free but on a cryptocurrency website where they're
00:09:49
charging you per transaction to me that seems a little shady up front I I agree uh because if you are legit then you
00:09:58
know maybe you can go out on Yelp or Google reviews and give yourself some good reviews but
00:10:05
some of these fake accounts were like R2D2 or Mickey Mouse I mean it was blatant that they weren't real that's a
00:10:13
that's a true crime garage's number one fan R2D2 he's partnered up with this Michael
00:10:20
guy and things are going pretty well when they first started out they were actually a like
00:10:29
over-the-counter exchange kind of like an ATM where you sh where you could like put your money in own some Bitcoin or
00:10:39
whatever cryptocurrency and then you could withdraw money but that didn't really take off so they
00:10:45
took this whole thing online which is the normal thing to do with cryptocurrencies that all happened they
00:10:52
established the company in 2013 and by 2014 it was reported that they were doing like
00:11:00
7.9 million dollars in exchanges a day and by 2017 they were doing over a billion dollars in transfers and
00:11:11
exchanges a day wow and like I said there are charging they are charging their users for every transaction and it
00:11:19
might be just fractions of pennies but still that adds up if I hadn't mentioned it Captain he's running this entire
00:11:26
thing from oh yeah MacBook Pro when you hear this it seems so made up and when you start thinking of the idea
00:11:35
of like a Ponzi scheme or something like that to me a company that is doing transactions like you said billions of
00:11:43
dollars I'm expecting them to have a campus somewhere multiple buildings tons of
00:11:50
employees once you find out that Gary is running the whole operation on his MacBook is it was it even a MacBook Pro
00:11:59
I've read it both ways I don't think it really matters though I know that to me it's like I give him a little more Kudos
00:12:07
if it's just a MacBook could you imagine if your laptop broke and you had to go to the Genius Bar and
00:12:16
deal with one of those guys to try to get your billion dollar company back up and running yeah can you could you try
00:12:22
to fix this before lunch because we're losing billions well obviously business is good uh his business partner
00:12:31
Michael he's uh got a love for expensive cars and a lot of luxurious things in life and at this time you know from 2014
00:12:41
to 2017 crypto is booming the prices are going up Bitcoin is gone from you know just thousands of dollars up to ten
00:12:52
thousand dollars for one coin right but in 2017 things start to take a hit crypto's value is tanking so business
00:13:03
investors would do they start to try to withdraw their money and normally you can just put in you know
00:13:11
sell your crypto put in the withdrawal form and within 48 hours you're going to have your money in 48 hours I would say
00:13:19
would be a long wait time right because usually at least in today's time you can
00:13:25
have it pretty instantaneously if not within hours maybe in 2017 that process wasn't quite as panned out
00:13:35
I mean when crypto first started back in the day it was hard to buy crypto there
00:13:40
wasn't all of these exchanges and apps on your phone that you could buy you had to go to some shady sites to get it so
00:13:47
investors are trying to withdraw they're not getting any response they're emailing customer service who's then
00:13:54
telling them to open a trouble ticket then their treble tickets have an SLA or a you know service agreement time
00:14:01
they're not hearing back some of them are waiting months so people are upset the investors who have
00:14:09
hundreds of thousands if not millions of dollars wrapped up in this are going online going on Reddit complaining about
00:14:17
this and even starting to file lawsuits this is one of the things I heard that was that made their company unique is
00:14:26
that it seems like other companies you would have to almost like apply to get your money out
00:14:32
and theirs were supposed to be more like readily available so the fact that once people started
00:14:39
trying to pull their money and they didn't have these stipulations in place this screwed them from the get-go they
00:14:46
had what their what we call third-party processors and the only way I can explain this is if you go to say you
00:14:55
know McDonald's or Starbucks when you pay for your coffee their Point of Sales Machine is probably owned by a third
00:15:02
party who's going to process your credit card and do all those things well they have third-party processors one's called
00:15:08
crypto Capital these processors take a fee also but with all of this legal rambling going on
00:15:18
quadrika is blaming their third-party processors and blaming some of the banks they use for the Slowdown right this is
00:15:27
just pointing the fingers and don't blame us they also have uh one of their fund holders is called custodian and
00:15:36
they had I think 28 million dollars in funds and quadraka is saying no they're they have our funds and we can't pay you
00:15:47
until they pay us right now let's go back for a second because back to these fake accounts right did you see a
00:15:56
breakdown on on how they think that the company started kind of getting upside down no go ahead and explain it yeah so
00:16:03
one of the things that they were doing is like but like we said he's running the whole company
00:16:11
from his laptop what we should say is before Gary cotton gets involved I don't like calling him Gary I'm going to call
00:16:18
him Gerald yeah that's fine old Gerald cotton gets involved they did have some buildings they did have a few employees
00:16:25
but once he got involved no offices no nothing just his laptop well he could go on in the middle of the night and just
00:16:32
basically create like a fake thousand Bitcoins and then he could start selling those to people and every
00:16:40
time he's selling you know 100 bucks here 50 bucks here their company's making money off those
00:16:46
transactions so he would do this and he actually created I think multiple fake people
00:16:53
and I don't even know if his business partners knew he was doing this but it reminds me of Shawshank Redemption when
00:16:59
you find out that Andy Dufresne created a fake guy and started funneling a bunch
00:17:04
of money to that account so but then what happens is if let's say we have a million dollars in in the pot and I
00:17:12
start adding money that was never there and now people are buying that eventually if I keep doing that once
00:17:20
people go to take their money there's not going to be enough money in the pot you have to rob Peter to pay Paul the
00:17:25
question then becomes to me for for these guys and and his you know Michael his his business partner why were they
00:17:33
doing this because they were making millions to solve transactions cryptocurrency is like
00:17:39
David Copper filled right it's like it's magic it's can't see it can't touch it but it's so
00:17:47
funny to me that these guys that are getting into these crypto currencies like you were saying Michael for example
00:17:55
had a love of expensive cars so they're using this fake entity basically and making money off this fake entity to buy
00:18:04
actual material things I just kind of find that a little ironic regardless of whether this business is
00:18:12
legitimate or not that's actually how a lot of places function it's almost like fake it till you make it right and
00:18:20
you know if he can create fake Bitcoins to sell and dump them into the pool I mean
00:18:27
that's just like the Federal Reserve just printing off more money right it's not that different to me but I could be
00:18:33
off base there well no I still think it's hilarious that they're called the Federal Reserve they're not federal at
00:18:40
all there is very clever name there is federal is Federal Express exactly at the time where these lawsuits
00:18:49
and things are happening his business partner Michael actually steps down and is just a shareholder in
00:18:58
the company at that point and Gerald is running the show Gerald at this point has his long-term girlfriend Jennifer
00:19:08
Robertson he thinks that this is a good time to marry Jennifer make her the only
00:19:16
employee listed at the company they're going to Honeymoon in India they had their eye on like uh sponsoring
00:19:25
a orphanage for children in India I think there was 12 kids at this orphanage and you know that's nice it's
00:19:34
you know they're trying to be giving and uh he walked in and he said I'll buy all 12 children yeah
00:19:42
yeah no I'll take all 12. uh but they're trying to be philanthropists with their
00:19:47
money and they get married they planned this trip to India for their honeymoon and they're going to go
00:19:56
there and adopt or you know sponsor this orphanage do you know when they got married so they end up getting married
00:20:04
June of 2018. I question that because right now the companies appears to be in turmoil and
00:20:14
legal turmoil with all these lawsuits and the inability to pay off a lot of the investors yeah but when things
00:20:22
aren't going good in life just get married it fixes everything yeah and they're going to Honeymoon in India
00:20:30
but here's what's weird though is they get married in June they're basically waiting until
00:20:36
December to Honeymoon yeah or they are they honeymooning for like months and months
00:20:44
well they they wait a little bit and you know because you know sometimes you have
00:20:48
to save up money for that honeymoon right when you're when you're running a billion dollar company off your MacBook
00:20:55
guess what I'm gonna go buy this weekend a Macbook try to figure out how to start a billion
00:21:04
dollar company yeah who's with me one of the interesting things about this case well maybe not interesting is the
00:21:13
right word but maybe confusing and maybe one of the reasons why people start questioning everything that you hear
00:21:19
about Gerald cotton is there's mixed reports just like we said they got married in June but they don't take
00:21:27
their honeymoon till a few months later and it doesn't there's conflicting stories on when their honeymoon actually
00:21:35
started and then there's conflicting stories on how many how many days was Gerald in India before he got sick and
00:21:44
went to the hospital some Reports say a week some Reports say two days now I found that he went
00:21:52
with his wife they checked in at the hotel and they went to a fondue party or a fondue restaurant now I know do you
00:22:02
fondue I don't fondue myself I'm not the biggest fan uh well maybe you'd be a happier person if you did dipping things
00:22:10
in cheese always makes them better Gerald cotton was known to have Crohn's disease okay
00:22:19
which is I guess uh really bad IBS it causes you great gastrointestinal problems it's it's not something that we
00:22:32
should take lightly it's not something that I I think oh it just had Crohn's disease that was it but
00:22:39
look it could get very bad and and depending on their the type of flare-up that the individual would have you know
00:22:46
I've had family members and stuff that have been hospitalized because of it so it's very it can be very serious I don't
00:22:54
know how deadly it is I don't know how many people will die from a flare-up Gerald
00:23:01
gets to India and some Reports say within 24 hours he's not only gone to the hospital for a
00:23:10
flare-up but he's become septic and he dies from complications you know and I guess my whole problem is
00:23:20
you know if you think okay you have Crohn's disease you're going to India maybe you go to a street vendor and you
00:23:27
order something that looks like meat on a stick and I think that stuff's great by the way I love Street vendors myself
00:23:33
I love taco trucks but the whole stereotype is he ate something bad in India and that caused him this
00:23:42
distress but if we're going off the time frame of within two days of him arriving
00:23:48
did he even have time to eat anything or was this flare-up happening on the plane
00:23:54
are you saying he he was doing a 40 hour fast no but you I get what you're saying it's
00:24:01
like saying like I have a bad stomach so when I go to Mexico the first thing I do
00:24:05
is drink a gallon of water you know we're not supposed to do that yeah so is it yeah it's very strange
00:24:13
um but here's one of the things that I kind of wonder his company's there's bad things happening in the
00:24:21
company there's illegal things now happening in the company you are doing some of those illegal
00:24:29
things you're creating fake characters and selling money that doesn't exist on in your business I wonder because of
00:24:41
the Crohn's disease if he didn't also have like some ulcers and some other stuff that was going on
00:24:49
to distress and that maybe he wasn't aware of because he's feeling like certain types of pain and certain
00:24:57
but he's he's he's dismissing that as his Crohn's disease it's very possible I agree I would be stressed out just the
00:25:05
fact that I'm running the company off of a MacBook he's at this Hospital he is declared dead
00:25:14
his wife now organizes or you know sets up transport for his body to be transported
00:25:23
I guess back to the hotel so they can find somebody to not really do an autopsy but do embalming
00:25:33
because they've already got the uh diagnosis from the doctor at the hospital that he died from like acute
00:25:41
gastrointestinal problems right so they find an embalmer they take his body there this embalmer says hey he didn't
00:25:52
come directly from the hospital he's been moved around you didn't follow protocol I'm not going to embalm him so
00:25:59
she takes his body back and they find a medical school Med students to do the embalming of his body this is
00:26:09
India maybe there is protocols and procedures there's language barriers you know maybe this is legit but it seems
00:26:19
like there's a lot of paperwork and moving around of his body at this point before she's able to get
00:26:27
him embalmed and then arrange transport for him to go back to Canada to Nova Scotia where they live and the uh 12
00:26:36
children at the orphanage they're left high and dry if I was one of those kids in that class I'd go you're a liar
00:26:42
told me I was getting new shoes I'm not and that happens on December 8th is when he goes to the hospital nobody
00:26:50
knows he's dead there's no announcements made nothing for a month quadriga is still business
00:27:00
as usual people are still depositing money into it still trying to do their exchanges
00:27:08
everything they have no clue but it's a month later that his wife posts it's a sad day
00:27:18
my husband Gerald cotton has passed away [Music] [Music] foreign [Music] we're back thanks for listening cheers
00:28:08
normally cheers to the crispy Colonel but uh I'm cheersing to you and uh this is recorded before we went to the
00:28:18
UK yes but I'm sure we're gonna have a couple drinks in the UK so I'm sure we will that's gonna be a fun time so let
00:28:26
me try to wrap my head around all this they go to India they're they're less than 48 hours he goes to the hospital
00:28:34
that's not to me that doesn't seem crazy when you find out that he has Crohn's disease
00:28:41
seems like something that's possible but then he dies and they won't embalm the body and they
00:28:50
have to do this loop around where they get some college students to do it or they actually
00:28:57
it was the little kids that they're trying to sponsor they're like we're going to have you embalm this body they
00:29:03
ship the body back to Canada and she doesn't tell any of his family members she just post it online
00:29:11
yeah Gerald had parents right have you seen any reports of them talking about his death not a lot trying
00:29:21
to find anything about it for that month period of time between his actual death
00:29:28
and her announcement I didn't find anything after that announcement you can find some some quotes
00:29:35
and whatnot but at that point it's not exactly it just doesn't seem to be known by anyone or reported by anyone
00:29:45
I'm trying to play Devil's Advocate because I'm trying to go okay well if he's the only one really running the
00:29:51
company and we announced now that he died and maybe look we don't even know at this point if she can get into his
00:29:59
computer that is running the whole company well we'll get to that okay we will get to that I'm just saying that
00:30:06
like yes it's a little fishy that she doesn't announce it for a month but you wonder is there some complications
00:30:13
because he's running this business by himself where they didn't want to that maybe they didn't want a run
00:30:19
on their server you know and and have all the money disappear yeah but one of the things
00:30:27
I don't know if you want to get to this now but they were together for a long time years before they got married but
00:30:34
before they went to India a few weeks before they went to India Gerald changes his whole will yeah he's
00:30:44
leaving a lot of his stuff to his wife they had two cute little Chihuahuas he even leaves like it's reported that he
00:30:53
leaves a hundred thousand dollars to the dogs do we know what the Chihuahua's names are I don't know wow
00:31:02
Nick would have known you can just imagine at this point this has caused complete and utter turmoil with the
00:31:10
investors yeah and they're doubling down on coming after this company and trying to get their
00:31:17
money the Canada Revenue Agency and their security and policies uh folks are now coming after this company
00:31:31
they're finding that a lot of these accounts were fake they're finding that Gerald had
00:31:41
communicated under false aliases to different organizations they're finding that
00:31:49
the hospital in India where he was declared dead well the chairman who ran that hospital
00:32:00
had actually been convicted of fraud two months prior oh surprise to Gerald's death surprise surprise
00:32:07
my first question was it was it even a real Hospital I mean I don't live there I have never
00:32:15
stepped foot in the place but according to the documents sure it's a real Hospital ran by fake doctors this
00:32:24
government agency comes after Jennifer and says all right you need to hand over his laptop you need to hand over
00:32:30
everything related to the company including all the passwords and passphrases to access it and what does
00:32:37
Jennifer say I don't have them the own the sole owner and proprietor of this company who is
00:32:44
delegated on you know he was delegated all of his stuff to his wife who is the only employee of the company right
00:32:52
he dies and she doesn't have a single password I have a hard time trusting people when I see that they have a
00:32:58
password pass code on their phone like what are you trying to hide why do you why does everybody in this world
00:33:06
need a passcode I wonder what this laptop and this makes a difference if it's a Macbook or a MacBook Pro because
00:33:13
the MacBook Pro I was like the finger identifier so they could chop his finger off
00:33:20
and she could like carry that around on a keychain and use it to unlock the laptop they
00:33:27
find that he had made several transfers or deposits of money from the company to personal accounts
00:33:38
ranging from a hundred million dollars to tens of millions of dollars right before his death
00:33:47
and it said that his laptop alone had 250 million dollars in crypto locked up on it
00:33:58
Jesus quarter trillion dollars now he was buying some stuff he I don't think he was known to buy
00:34:06
sports cars or anything like that but he he did buy some properties and he bought
00:34:13
a six hundred thousand dollar yacht like hey that's baller money right yeah I'm not real you know I'm just I'm just
00:34:24
not really into cars I buy yacht he didn't even know how to sail at the time of this purchase right he literally had
00:34:33
to take sailing lessons you know normally when you teach your kid how to drive a stick you you let them figure it
00:34:40
out on like a Honda Civic from you know the 1980s you don't get them a Ferrari to figure out how to drive a stick but
00:34:49
here he is he's got all the money in the world he can do whatever he buys a six hundred thousand dollar yacht who does
00:34:55
he think he is Conor McGregor they find out that his wife Jennifer Robinson she's changed her name four
00:35:04
times now she had been married and divorced so some of those name changes could be
00:35:12
explained but how many times was she I mean look if you're married four times and you change your name four times fine
00:35:22
right it wasn't four times but why are you just changing your name for no reason as we can assume the Canadian uh
00:35:31
government and law law enforcement is not happy with this so they get search warrants and they raid his properties
00:35:39
they're able to recover some hard drives they're able to recover some of the funds that were missing
00:35:48
Ernst young had a the ability to do you know recovery on these drives and break some of the uh
00:35:57
encryptions I guess they found that an account for someone named Chris Markay had transactions in excess of 220
00:36:10
million dollars that's a lot but who is Chris martay exactly I mean I know who he is but do
00:36:18
you want to tell the listeners oh go go ahead go ahead sorry so this is also Gerald yeah this is an alias and and so
00:36:28
you said how repeat that number again I just want that to sink in for everybody in excess of 220 million
00:36:38
dollars of cryptocurrency to a fake person that is the richest fake person I've ever I've ever heard of if you had
00:36:48
a fake person right that you're going to give millions of dollars to what would you name him
00:36:53
do you have a name you'd go by like Batman or the captain TCG Captain uh just to get you and then
00:37:03
I was arrested no I would I would go by uh Andy Kaufman that would be perfect and every now and then when I'm at a bar
00:37:10
I'll say I like to say when they go well what's your real name I say Andy Kaufman
00:37:17
or I'll say um Bond Scott they find that he didn't do his personal property tax returns for
00:37:25
2014 2015 or 2017 and in 2016 when he actually did file he showed that he didn't make any profit well In fairness
00:37:36
all that profit was going to his the fake person he created then add insult to injury they're able to recover
00:37:44
some of these funds from these hard drives but remember those third-party processors I was talking about
00:37:50
they're saying hey they still owe us money and you need to give us any of those funds recovered
00:37:59
and those third-party processes are trying to recover those funds as opposed to those funds going back to the actual
00:38:06
individuals the investors now what's what's going on with his body so he was embalmed by medical students
00:38:14
he was sent back to Nova Scotia and they buried him right away well guess what give me a shovel
00:38:23
let's dig up his dead bones and and see what he has to say for himself the investors are pressuring the
00:38:34
government to exhume his body and do a DNA test yeah there was a court hearing I believe
00:38:40
last year or two years ago now um the only thing I could find and maybe you found something better than me
00:38:50
uh it seemed as if whatever hearing that they had where it seemed like they're going to win the hearing pretty easily
00:38:59
but then that's been like delayed now because of covet so yeah I don't know actually where the
00:39:06
investors stand on the digging up the dead bones well when there's over a quarter
00:39:15
trillion dollars at hand I'm sure they're not going to give up anytime soon yeah it's sad that we you know
00:39:23
this should be a simple I wish the world worked like take any judge right and you go look what what do we know for
00:39:34
certain we know that Gerald was scamming people out of his money therefore he was doing
00:39:40
something illegal therefore he'd become a prisoner right so in a sense he becomes property of the
00:39:48
state so I do not feel bad for him his wife or any of his family members that were
00:39:56
going to dig him up to get answers you know sometimes when they want to dig somebody up I go hey hey they didn't
00:40:05
do anything wrong we should stop you know especially these cases where it's like they dig up the body multiple times
00:40:12
and do multiple autopsies and it's like by the third autopsy it's like can you even buy anything that the doctor is
00:40:19
saying because at that point the body is so mutilated but in this case we would know
00:40:27
is there is there really a person there or is this guy off somewhere else and then he becomes a fugitive we talked
00:40:36
about other partners in crime here like his uh his buddy Michael uh yeah Patron now he he and Michael claimed
00:40:49
that they'd only known each other for about five years at the time that this happened so you know if you take they
00:40:55
started the company in you know 2013 ish and then he dies in 2018. you know that's about a five-year time
00:41:05
but as further investigations into this Michael guy goes they find that Michael used to run
00:41:14
a website that was the first kind of shady crypto exchange website he created this website
00:41:23
called Talk gold and Gerald as a teenager went and joined this website that's where he met
00:41:32
Michael they would go on to create other sites I think one was called s s Investments
00:41:42
and this had a crypto I guess currency called Midas gold and it was run by a I use bank with air
00:41:55
quotes called Liberty reserve and Liberty reserve was allegedly ran by an American in Costa Rica
00:42:07
who laundered money so you take your drug money you take your human trafficking money yes you go
00:42:16
to this website you buy this Midas gold second can you tell me that website again so I can write it down
00:42:24
it's not there anymore so you're saying so now what should I do with my drug money so they go there and
00:42:32
they buy this Midas gold which think it's processed however through Liberty reserve
00:42:39
who then would turn around convert it back into Fiat cash for a fee hand it back to you
00:42:49
essentially laundering the money that's awesome now Liberty reserves like real life
00:42:55
Ozark right yeah exactly but it's all digital online digital Reserve did not keep any records
00:43:05
of their clients any kind of database so you could track who was buying this and
00:43:11
withdrawing it yeah I'm going to call my call my company Liberty Federal Financial responsibly conservative
00:43:20
Reserve Liberty reserve was reported to have over 5 million users and over 8 billion
00:43:29
in assets so this is uh so basically what you're saying is investigators have now figured out that they they this
00:43:38
scheme this was a scheme all along and that they because that they were going like no matter
00:43:46
it's almost like they came up with this scheme and they didn't expect it to blow
00:43:51
up and become somewhat legitimate and it did and that actually throws a wrench into
00:43:57
their plan of just having a a scam service because quadrica quadriga CX was platformed on Liberty reserve
00:44:11
my God wow Michael Patron I don't know what his real name was because he was actually arrested for
00:44:22
identity fraud as Omar danani what's with everybody changing their names I just don't trust people that don't use
00:44:31
their real name you know those use your real name be honest people says the captain I have a boat I have a
00:44:42
yacht 600 000 600 million dollar yacht I'll just messing with you Gerald which is using alias's creating fake accounts
00:44:54
fake people we have Michael his partner using Alias is creating fake individuals
00:45:00
we have his wife that has changed her name multiple times some like like we said if you get
00:45:07
married and divorced and you can you know change your name there and and you'll change your name coming back
00:45:12
but it's still strange that she's changed her name multiple times I think that these investors are very justified in
00:45:23
their complete and utter disbelief that Gerald cotton has died but just one more detail for you his
00:45:31
name's Gerald cotton his last name is spelled c-o-t-t-e-n on his death certificate it's spelled
00:45:38
c-o-t-t-a-n he does have stomach issues that's why I'm like it's not impossible that
00:45:44
and with the stress that he look and I don't feel bad for him because he is the one that put the
00:45:51
stress on him I wouldn't put it past him that something bad happened or or maybe
00:45:59
even like committed suicide and for whatever reason his wife is covering it up because if she if he committed
00:46:09
suicide maybe she wouldn't get certain things so I want to put it past him that the
00:46:14
the death is not real not saying it is real I'm just saying it's possible people die in their 30s people die from
00:46:24
stress related complications especially with somebody that has something look Crohn's disease disease normally
00:46:35
will not cause death but if you're super stressed out because you're creating fake people and you're
00:46:41
creating fake money and you have millions and millions of dollars that are technically not real
00:46:46
and millions and millions of dollars that you owe to people and you don't have the money to fund that
00:46:53
because you just bought a giant yacht this can cause some stress issues so it's possible that he he could have died
00:47:05
I'm leaning towards now he didn't I would but I would bet my [ __ ] my cryptocurrency on the fact that
00:47:15
he's still alive now what's interesting though is in this case as as opposed to so many other mysterious deaths or
00:47:23
Unexplained Mysteries I think we're going to get answers to this because if they
00:47:30
finally get a judge to sign off to have his body exhumed we'll know and at that point it's either a there's
00:47:42
not going to be a body in that grave B there'll be somebody else's body in that grave or nobody right you think it's or
00:47:50
now okay now if we're going to bet cryptocurrency I'm betting he's not there right
00:47:59
but I'm also betting that there's just not a body and here's where I think he's screwed up
00:48:04
I don't mind so much that the death certificate has like the name spelled wrong because he was in a different
00:48:10
country here's what gets me because Gerald doesn't seem like a dumb guy so so here's here's my issue and this is
00:48:20
the part that pulls me back and now if you said okay you have to bet right I would bet that he's not in that
00:48:29
grave but if you said well you don't have to bet all of the money there's a 10 15
00:48:35
chance that I go this is real he actually died stress whatever and the proof is he could have been cremated
00:48:46
right and I don't even know like how well like DNA tests work on ashes so as long as I think you could get like
00:48:59
human remains you could come back and go well here it is you think about how easy
00:49:04
that would be yeah like why wasn't he cremated because that would have cleared the Slate here like he was
00:49:12
buried so there's still quote unquote evidence of his existence if she would have had him cremated
00:49:18
we wouldn't really be having this conversation because I don't know if they could actually do but that's what
00:49:23
I'm saying they dig up the body he's there I think maybe that's the tell that you know and maybe his family would
00:49:33
say I don't know I'm just saying like it's not that it's not that hard for I mean
00:49:38
we haven't I mean I've never sat around and thought about faking my death but I'm going hey you go to India you die
00:49:46
from this uh this stomach issues he had me cremated but because that didn't happen like you
00:49:54
said there is evidence so that that is that that little bit that goes maybe this is just
00:50:01
what happened it's possible I wonder if uh you know his buddy Michael what if he had him killed yeah but he
00:50:12
would have to be in cahoot I mean there's the wife right you would think unless it was a
00:50:20
plan just gone horribly wrong like I'm gonna kill him and get all the crypto and then kill the wife and get the rest
00:50:26
of the stuff or just get the crypto and take off I don't know I mean there's there's some theories there of
00:50:33
what could have happened I'm more or less he did this he faked his own death and he took off or like
00:50:42
you said he actually died of natural causes like the official story says but with the totality of evidence here the
00:50:51
totality of his just criminal behavior from a teenager on and every single person he engaged with
00:51:00
in their Shady Behavior I just I can't accept that this is real because it would be the worst possible
00:51:08
timing and the worst possible planning of getting married going on a honeymoon in
00:51:15
the middle of all of this and then dying right in the middle of it it's like what
00:51:19
would the chances that you're in agreeance with me where you say the big mistake in this whole plan would
00:51:27
be not to be cremated and you and I just wonder maybe there is some kind of background with his family
00:51:34
with religious or whatever that that wasn't an option in his plan and I think that there'll be a Manhunt for him
00:51:45
on a scale that uh we've never seen before and I if I was one of those you know multi-million dollars but you're
00:51:55
just not telling them if Justin's even your real name well if yeah if if I was you bet your ass I would be
00:52:05
hiring some Headhunters to go find him and there's so much more to this case I mean we tried to fit everything we could
00:52:12
into you know an hour but you can go down the rabbit hole there is so many more details so many more schemes Ponzi
00:52:22
schemes and and criminal acts that I just didn't even feel the need to mention because I want to be surprised
00:52:30
if they don't make some kind of documentary out of this because there's enough meat on the bones
00:52:37
to to chew on this one for a long time I would love to hear what your listeners think did this guy dive natural causes
00:52:45
or do you think he's uh sitting on some beach sipping on uh an expensive Margarita yeah so tell us your thoughts
00:52:55
at truecrime garage.com click on the blog and let us know what you think Justin it's always so great to hang out
00:53:04
with you thanks so much for joining us here in the garage and I look forward to hanging out no problem
00:53:10
and London with you awesome it's been my honor thank you so much cheers [Music] thank you so much for joining us here in
00:53:32
the garage for everything True Crime Check out true crime garage.com and make sure you go and listen to Generation Y
00:53:40
this week with Nick and Aaron or the crispy Colonel and Aaron and you can check Generation Y out wherever you
00:53:50
listen to podcasts until next week be good be kind and don't litter foreign [Music]

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 75
    Biggest twist
  • 70
    Most shocking
  • 70
    Best concept / idea
  • 70
    Most unpredictable

Episode Highlights

  • Guinness: The Adult Milkshake
    Discover the unique flavors of Guinness, described as malty, chocolatey, and a subtle punch of coffee.
    “My dad calls it adult milkshake.”
    @ 01m 32s
    November 04, 2022
  • The Mysterious Death of Gerald Cotton
    Join us as we explore the enigmatic circumstances surrounding the death of cryptocurrency millionaire Gerald Cotton.
    “This is true crime garage.”
    @ 04m 05s
    November 04, 2022
  • A Wedding Amidst Turmoil
    Gerald Cotton and Jennifer Robertson marry during a time of legal chaos for their company.
    “When things aren't going good in life, just get married.”
    @ 20m 22s
    November 04, 2022
  • The Unembalmed Body
    After his death, Gerald's body was moved around, causing complications in the embalming process.
    “I'm not going to embalm him so she takes his body back.”
    @ 25m 56s
    November 04, 2022
  • A Month of Silence
    For a month after his death, Quadriga continued business as usual, with no announcements made.
    “Nobody knows he's dead; there's no announcements made, nothing.”
    @ 26m 50s
    November 04, 2022
  • The Mysterious Laptop
    Gerald's laptop held $250 million in crypto, raising questions about his financial dealings.
    “It said that his laptop alone had 250 million dollars in crypto locked up on it.”
    @ 33m 51s
    November 04, 2022
  • The Body Exhumation Debate
    Investors push for Gerald's body to be exhumed for a DNA test to confirm his death.
    “The investors are pressuring the government to exhume his body and do a DNA test.”
    @ 38m 34s
    November 04, 2022
  • The Big Mistake
    The big mistake in this whole plan would be not to be cremated.
    @ 51m 24s
    November 04, 2022
  • A Manhunt Like Never Before
    There will be a manhunt for him on a scale we've never seen before.
    @ 51m 45s
    November 04, 2022
  • So Much More to This Case
    There's so much more to this case, with many details and schemes left unmentioned.
    @ 52m 12s
    November 04, 2022
  • Join the Conversation
    Tell us your thoughts at truecrimegarage.com and let us know what you think.
    @ 52m 52s
    November 04, 2022

Episode Quotes

  • My dad calls it adult milkshake.
    Gerald Cotten ////// 524
  • I'll buy all 12 children.
    Gerald Cotten ////// 524
  • When things aren't going good in life, just get married.
    Gerald Cotten ////// 524
  • Jesus, a quarter trillion dollars?
    Gerald Cotten ////// 524
  • I wouldn't put it past him that the death is not real.
    Gerald Cotten ////// 524
  • I just I can't accept that this is real.
    Gerald Cotten ////// 524

Key Moments

  • Cheers to Guinness01:04
  • Fondue Night21:55
  • Death Announcement Delay27:13
  • Fraudulent Hospital32:00
  • Exhumation Pressure38:34
  • Worst Possible Timing51:06
  • Manhunt51:41
  • Documentary Potential52:30

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown