Search Captions & Ask AI

The I-5 Killer /// Part 2 /// 314

June 26, 2019 / 47:50

This episode covers the case of Randy Woodfield, known as the I-5 Killer, discussing his background, criminal activities, and the investigation into the murder of Julie Wright.

The hosts, Nick and the Captain, introduce Randy Woodfield, detailing his early life in Oregon, his athletic prowess, and his troubling behavior that began in junior high. They highlight his expunged criminal record and his brief stint in the NFL with the Green Bay Packers.

Woodfield's criminal activities escalate after he is arrested for robbery and sexual assault in Portland. The hosts discuss the sting operation that led to his arrest and the psychological evaluations that suggested a sexual motive behind his crimes.

As the investigation into Julie Wright's murder unfolds, Woodfield becomes a prime suspect. The hosts detail the police interrogation, his evasive answers, and the evidence found in his apartment that links him to multiple crimes.

The episode concludes with Woodfield's trial, his conviction for murder and attempted murder, and the ongoing mystery surrounding his potential additional victims, with estimates ranging from 12 to 44.

TLDR

Randy Woodfield, the I-5 Killer, is discussed, detailing his crimes, investigation, and conviction for multiple murders and assaults.

Episode

47:50
00:00:07
[Music] [Applause] [Music] welcome to true crime garage wherever you are whatever you are doing thanks
00:00:45
for listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always as a man that is living on spongecake
00:00:50
and Corona Rita's he is the captain why my nickname was the Papa to civ Love it's good to be seen and it's good to
00:00:58
see you thanks for listening thanks for telling a friend today we are drinking DDH noise pollution by the good folks at
00:01:10
southern grist this double IPA featuring calypso Citra and vicked secret this beer packs a soft mouth feel low
00:01:17
bitterness and explosive hop profile ABV 7.5% garage grade 5 out of 5 bottle caps
00:01:25
and today we are giving thanks and praise to some of our very best listeners first up we have beth in
00:01:31
memphis and a big shout out to Adam in Athens Georgia and here's the cheers the candy and quill acum Beach British
00:01:38
Columbia a big shout out so Ray J and parts unknown and here's a Cheers to Michelle in Solebury Pennsylvania and
00:01:46
last but not least sending love we have Wendy aka the British lady on a scooter so thanks to everybody for going to our
00:01:53
website and helping out with this week's beer fund if you want to fill up the fridge for next week's show go to true
00:01:59
crime garage comm and click on the donate button yes thank you so much for the support thanks for selling out the
00:02:06
sticker packages two days in a row we sold them out then we put them back up and sold out again so be patient we're
00:02:16
working on getting another package together if you'd like to support the garage and get something in return go to
00:02:21
true crime garage calm and click on the store page and that is enough of the business
00:02:27
alright everybody gather round grab a chair grab a beer let's talk some true crime
00:02:32
[Music] when we left off yesterday captain we were introducing to everyone an individual by the name of Randy
00:02:50
Woodfield and he came to the attention of police because they were investigating a homicide that took place
00:02:58
his name was connected to the victim they were able to prove through witnesses that Randy Woodfield knew the
00:03:05
victim and they strongly believed that whoever killed Julie Reitz knew her right so he worked with her at a bar at
00:03:14
some point and it also believed that he possibly went on a date or at least pursued her was interested in dating her
00:03:22
and police found several pieces of evidence at the crime scene itself at the murder scene to suggest that whoever
00:03:30
killed Julie writes she let the killer into her home and spent some time speaking and spending time with this
00:03:38
individual before the murder occurred now he is put himself in the hot seat because when they go to interview Randy
00:03:45
and talk to him at his apartment he says he did not know her mm-hm and they have
00:03:51
proof of otherwise so now they're very interested in taking him down to the department where they can further
00:03:58
question him and maybe turn the heat up a little bit on this guy so let's find out more about Randy Woodfield real
00:04:07
quick he was born in December of 1950 in Salem Oregon he grew up in Auto Rock Oregon he is the third child of a
00:04:17
upper-middle class family so we're on last week's episode we were talking about children growing up with
00:04:24
disadvantages this is not that situation this guy he had every advantage out there going for him he was an upper
00:04:33
middle class family he had a good family and then on top of that he was the he was a gifted athlete oh yeah he was a
00:04:40
white male yeah and he was a football star at the Newport high school now he was also a basketball star he played
00:04:48
baseball he was on the track team this was the athletic darling of the high school now he did have some
00:04:57
problems and these were problems that he caused himself Woodfield began to exhibit sexual dysfunctional behaviors
00:05:05
during junior high school this is because he was exposing himself in public and this can go and tell ya or
00:05:15
show no tell ya this continued when he went to high school as well but there there are different variations of the
00:05:25
following statement depending on who you talk to but it's believed that that there may have been football coaches or
00:05:34
maybe even his parents or people in the community that tried to conceal these incidences after he got caught they
00:05:42
didn't want him to be ousted or removed from the football team yeah which is pathetic well it's absolutely pathetic
00:05:49
but the reason why I wanted to point out that there's different variations of that is I don't know one which is true
00:05:57
and two a lot of times especially back way back then this was not it was not uncommon for something like this to be
00:06:08
committed by a minor to be swept under the rug and not necessarily just for the sake of this kid to play football after
00:06:17
graduating high school Woodfields criminal record was expunged so he did get brought to charges on some of this
00:06:24
his parents on the record state that they forced him to attend therapy over the incident that he was convicted of I
00:06:33
wonder if there was some kind of trauma in his childhood or something like this you know do we know his religious
00:06:42
background was he raised Catholic was just there's something where it's like him exposing himself and middle school
00:06:51
in high school where is that coming from it may not have to stem from anything that happened to him he could just be
00:06:58
sexually dysfunctional right correct yeah after graduating high school whatever criminal record he had at the time was
00:07:05
expunged he went on to attend Portland State University in Portland in 1970 this is where he played for the Portland
00:07:14
State Vikings and he played wide receiver he was an offensive football player this would carry him to the NFL
00:07:23
he was that talented of a receiver do we know what team he played for once he made it to the NFL he he was drafted by
00:07:32
the Green Bay Packers so he was drafted in the 1974 NFL Draft by the Green Bay Packers he chose to drop out of college
00:07:41
this is just shortly before graduating he was attending school seeking a degree in physical education but when offered
00:07:51
the position in the National Football League he dropped out of school is there any record of him pulling out his dingy
00:07:58
poison then I fell well his career did not last very long so he was drafted in the 17th round with
00:08:08
the 428 sick yeah well we got to keep in mind you know I'm a die-hard NFL guy the
00:08:15
NFL back then in the 70s was not what it is today right one you didn't have the number of teams that we currently have
00:08:23
so they had they that alone made them have a lot more rounds for drafting and this too because believe it or not they
00:08:33
didn't pay extremely well it wasn't like he went to the NFL and you were a millionaire like you are today
00:08:40
that was not a guarantee and people that were were drafted later and just not as
00:08:46
good they made about as much money as people that had regular jobs or regular you know if you went to college and had
00:08:53
a degree probably make more money you might make a little more so we already said that 1980 the national average
00:09:01
salary was roughly thirteen to fourteen thousand so when he signed with the Green Bay Packers he did sign a contract
00:09:09
his contract was for sixteen thousand dollars and this is 1974 now this did allow for some incentives
00:09:18
should he perform extremely well so he had the opportunity to make more money but on top of that - I think that they
00:09:27
were having so many rounds for drafting these players I believed it in 73 74 there may have been a strike as well so
00:09:36
now they need to fill rosters because people players are saying we're not going to play for any number of reasons
00:09:45
his I have a scouting report here which I find interesting so they Randy Woodfield wide receiver he's listed
00:09:55
depending on where you look at six foot or six foot one 170 pounds played for Portland State born December 26 1950 he
00:10:06
was timed at four point seven in the 40-yard dash notes on player cuts on a dime has good hands and catches well in
00:10:15
crowd fluid and smooth hustles and is a good jumper he pulls out his provided yogurt slinger faster than anybody well
00:10:25
in that is it's generally believed that that's why he was cut from the team that
00:10:32
these these incidences where he's exposing himself or allegations of such continued even once he joined the Green
00:10:41
Bay Packers he technically did not ever play a game for them he was signed to a contract and eventually cut I believe
00:10:50
that the Green Bay Packers official stance on this and statement on this is that he just was not good enough to make
00:10:56
the team right I don't know if this is another situation and I'm not I want to be very very clear I'm not accusing the
00:11:03
Green Bay Packers of anything I don't know if this is another situation where maybe there were others somebody
00:11:10
somewhere covering up or not reporting these these you know incidences because he was an NFL player well it's a great
00:11:20
way not to get tackled though this is true this is true so he was in the NFL and for any number of
00:11:30
reasons that you choose to believe he was cut from the team personally I believe it probably included some of
00:11:36
these flashing incidences one thing that I found interesting regarding his short
00:11:43
time with the team is they offered him a flight a paid flight to get to their training camp to which he turned down
00:11:54
and chose to drive and make his own way there and I'm not know don't want to suggest anything but go ahead and
00:12:01
suggest it I just I just wonder if he chose that because he intended on exposing himself for committing any type
00:12:09
of crimes along the way it just or he could just been afraid of flying I don't know but I found that I found that to be
00:12:16
interesting now after he was let go from the team he did stick around a little bit and played on their farm team but
00:12:24
ultimately he's let go and he returns home back to Portland this is where Randy's going to get into more trouble
00:12:32
in early 1965 there were several Portland women who were basically attacked while they were in a park and
00:12:41
the way that these attacks would go down is it would start off as a robbery the offender would find an individual a
00:12:48
female walking by herself approached them with a knife threatened them take their pocketbook during the
00:12:56
course of the attack there was some type of sexual assault this went on long enough and there were
00:13:02
enough of these attacks that police decided hey we're gonna have to figure out who this guy is and we're gonna have
00:13:10
to come up with some good strategy to do something about it you know so they come
00:13:15
up with a sting operation and they take a female police officer put her in plainclothes
00:13:21
she signs up for this and god bless her because you have to be brave to do this first of all you know that the person
00:13:28
committing this crime is threatening and bringing a weapon to the attack oh yeah
00:13:34
on top of that you're out there by yourself and the other officers that are going to assist you in the
00:13:40
sting operation they have to be a good deal of a ways away right because they can't risk being seen by the potential
00:13:47
attacker so this is a very brave officer who puts herself in harm's way potentially goes out into these parks
00:13:56
and walks alone and it doesn't take very long until she is robbed and attacked I
00:14:03
don't know 100 percent of the details of the attack or if it was if she was able
00:14:10
to thwart the attack and just put it to an end right but one interesting thing that they did was when she would go out
00:14:17
there remember robbery was a big part of these attacks so they put numbered bills
00:14:24
they issued numbered bills and put him in her pocketbook each time that way even if the attacker got away yeah they
00:14:32
could trace the bill and then maybe try to figure out who this individual is this sting operation results in the
00:14:41
arrest of Randy Woodfield so he is charged with not only robberies but he's charged with sexual assaults as well no
00:14:52
Creepo he ultimately pled guilty to reduce charges of second degree robbery and Woodfield was sentenced to ten years
00:15:00
in prison he did he served five of those years or four and a half somewhere in that ballpark but he didn't do the full
00:15:10
ten years here was the problem that we have psychologists that were making suggestions regarding the charges for
00:15:19
Randy Woodfield at least the charges he was facing not what he pled guilty to but the sexual aspect of those crimes
00:15:27
the psychologists were pointing out that that was the driving force they believed
00:15:31
that was the driving force for the way that Randy Woodfield was acting out right before the actual robbery so the
00:15:37
driving force is sexual not the actual robbery correct that that just goes along with the whole rest of the attack
00:15:45
mind you especially in the in the mid 70s in our country one thing we were really big on trying to do was
00:15:54
rehabilitating offenders and treating criminals to try to make them not be criminals and make them be good citizens
00:16:04
and a lot of that reason is one the mindset at the time is that a lot of people they just need to be
00:16:11
rehabilitated they just need treatment they don't need prison bars they don't know the prison
00:16:15
walls opportunities as well right but on top of that you have an extenuating circumstance of a lot of these prisons
00:16:24
where were full there's no more room left so you have to really push the angle of trying to treat and
00:16:32
rehabilitate these individuals to try to lessen the population lessen the prison
00:16:37
population and why he's in prison I wonder how many times he's you know pulling it out I from all four and a
00:16:47
half years that's a lot of pulling it out well from all of the records that I could find he was a he had a good record
00:16:55
he was a good model inmate let's say he had some infractions the flapping in the
00:17:02
wind the one infraction that stands out is he had illegal shoes then somebody had sent him basketball shoes now in the
00:17:10
prison where he was housed at the time they were to be in prison uniform right from head to toe he chose to not wear
00:17:19
the issued shoes and he had shoes brought in this he says because he had bad ankles and he he needed he required
00:17:28
basketball type or tennis shoes to wear so that was his only infraction he was a
00:17:35
bit of a jerk about some of the the prison rules like he one thing that didn't make sense to him was why should
00:17:42
he get penalized for bringing in the illegal shoes when you have other inmates that are that are getting away
00:17:50
with bringing in drugs right to the prison so he had a big problem with that I don't know that he would have had to
00:17:57
expose himself to get any kind of satisfaction or whatever the hell he was looking for when he started doing that
00:18:03
in the first place one the population is May and that doesn't seem to be his victim
00:18:09
type right but to his other complaint about prison was that there were female employees that worked at the prison and
00:18:17
he said sometimes these employees were in a position where they would see inmates showering or using the restroom
00:18:26
and we're on the outside he would tell us that he has a big problem with that that doesn't seem to go along with
00:18:33
flashing your junk off a bridge to some some girls in the park right it just doesn't does not add up Hey look
00:18:41
at my potato so now we are questioning Randy Woodfield about this murder that took place of Julie rights yeah so they
00:18:51
want to know everything they know that he knows or everything that could possibly link him to their case he does
00:19:00
seem somewhat cooperative once he's back at police headquarters answering their questions where he starts to waffle on
00:19:09
being cooperative is when they say look this is very easy we just need a blood sample hair sample and take a polygraph
00:19:19
test and we can just clear you and we'll move on with our investigation so this he says you know what before we do any
00:19:28
of that jazz let's I think I need to call my attorney yeah these detectives are not idiots they're
00:19:36
going to call Randy's bluff they save no problem what's his name what's his number we will call him for you
00:19:43
to which he says maybe I don't maybe we don't need to involve my attorney and they continue on with their questioning
00:19:52
they want to know how well he knew Julie rights because eventually he does admit
00:19:58
to knowing her so now we're going down the path a little further right no but how does that work I mean maybe you
00:20:05
don't know but it's say how does he backtrack on that one Oh wily oh yeah I know Julie I'm
00:20:15
guessing that he would feel like he was backed in a corner at the and he has to offer them up something
00:20:21
because now they're not he's on their turf now and they're not gonna they're not gonna back off until he like so you
00:20:27
see what I mean like there's a there's a big difference between somebody coming to the revelation themselves or getting
00:20:34
backed into the corner where now the law enforcement officers know that he was lying about something right and he cut
00:20:41
he does try to present this in some form that could be perceived as believable he
00:20:46
doesn't admit to knowing her until he is shown a picture of Julie okay and he's going to add to that that yeah he knew
00:20:55
her but not very well and that I think he even said that he was unaware of her last name right which is very possible
00:21:04
if you work in a bar or a social setting where you might not interact with your coworkers really well he's also going to
00:21:12
provide an alibi for the night that Julie Wright's was murdered he was somewhat in the area and they were able
00:21:19
to determine that because he stayed or at least booked a hotel room that was a few towns away let's say so he wasn't
00:21:29
terribly far but his alibi is look I went out I went to this bar this bar this bar this bar went to bar hopping
00:21:36
and I met a girl along the way and she tagged along with me for the rest of the night he never really puts himself much
00:21:45
closer the need be with with this very flimsy alibi he's unable to provide them with the full name of the girl that was
00:21:56
tagging along with him on his adventure I think her name was Sarah maybe was Katie I don't know Olivia well
00:22:04
when they're trying to figure out what kind of relationship acquaintances or otherwise did Randy and Julie have one
00:22:15
question they want to know is did the two of you ever have intercourse did you ever have sex together to which he says
00:22:21
no now we're going to circle back around to we want your hair we want your blood
00:22:28
and we want to do a polygraph and we want your fake hair as well and he is going to play along with this for a
00:22:34
while and pretend that he is going to do that mm-hmm here is where things take a
00:22:41
turn they contact his parole officer because after they after he comes in they already knew he had a record but
00:22:50
this record states that it was for a robbery remember he pled guilty to second-degree robbery right when they
00:22:57
contact his parole officer they learned a couple of things that are very interesting one the parole officer
00:23:04
informs them that yes he he did confess to second-degree robbery but these crimes all had a sexual aspect to him
00:23:12
and then secondly they figure out that he's not living where he was where he told his parole officer that he was to
00:23:21
be living he had not informed the parole officer that he had moved right so now he's already in violation of said parole
00:23:30
and he's playing from behind the eight-ball at this point the parole officer also informs the officers that
00:23:38
Randy Woodfield was a suspect in in a couple of other homicides that took place just months before really these
00:23:46
were women that he knew at one time in his life and he was questioned in both of those incidences so one of the crimes
00:23:57
took place this was the murder of sherry Ayers this took place and then you have
00:24:02
a month later the murder of Darci fix and her boyfriend now that both of these attacks and murders occurred in the
00:24:10
homes of the victims this is why these crimes would not immediately be tied to who they are looking for as far as the
00:24:20
i-5 killer goes because the i-5 killer goes into a business and attacks and kills their yeah this is what's so
00:24:29
interesting about this case and about this good detective work we have two detectives that are looking to solve the
00:24:35
murder of Julie rights they are speaking to Randy Woodfield regarding the murder
00:24:42
of Julie rights their whole intent at this point is to I their connect him to the murder of Julie
00:24:49
rights or to clear him and move on and try to find a better suspect right the problem here though is they get this
00:24:57
information from the parole officer now there's so much more intrigued with this
00:25:02
guy they don't believe him to be truthful they believe that his answers are evasive and now he's not cooperating
00:25:08
he doesn't want to submit blood hair or to the polygraph then upon further questioning now we have a very nervous
00:25:16
and a very scared Randy Woodfield he's starting to show the officers that he's nervous he's starting to show them that
00:25:23
he is afraid of their questions rather than showing as Peter now being backed into a corner
00:25:28
he points out to them look I'm not going to give you the polygraph I'm not going
00:25:33
to give you hair I'm not going to give you blood I didn't even know that Julie Wright's was murdered and tool you guys
00:25:40
came here and told me and into which he follows up with just because I had sex with her does not mean that I killed her
00:25:52
[Music] find the full archive of true-crime garage when you download the free stitcher app and get exclusive bonus
00:26:04
episodes of true-crime garage off the record only on stitcher premium for a free month of listening goto stitcher
00:26:11
premium dot-com slash true-crime garage and use promo code garage or you can go to our website true crime garage comm
00:26:20
and click on off the record while you're at our website visit the store page that's where you get all of the very
00:26:27
cool garage gear download the free stitcher app and check out our website true crime garage com
00:26:37
[Music] all right we're back cheers mate cheers to you captain what we are seeing here is what we've
00:26:47
seen in other cases that we've discussed before when pushed into the corner when
00:26:52
backed into the corner we have individuals where their story starts to change and maybe you're getting a little
00:26:59
more of the truth or you're getting a bunch of more lies so in this situation Randy is now
00:27:07
changing his story the investigators are telling him your story is not adding up
00:27:13
you said one thing here and another thing there and then on top of that you are in a minor it is a minor violation
00:27:22
of his parole but he is in violation of that parole to which they are going to really push the issue of the test they
00:27:31
want the blood test the hair test in the polygraph test mm-hmm Randy Woodfield and forms the officers that he would
00:27:39
prefer to go back to prison than to submit and subject himself to those tests that seems like an odd thing to
00:27:46
say no if you're innocent and these three tests can clear you of this murder why would you go yeah I'll just go back
00:27:55
to prison yeah doesn't seem doesn't seem to make any sense where if they convict you that's where
00:28:02
you're going anyways it's very strange well all of this weirdness and then him not being cooperative will ultimately
00:28:10
lead to a search warrant and I believe that I said earlier that he may have been living in Eugene Oregon he did move
00:28:17
around a little bit but by the time of the questioning he had an apartment in Springfield Oregon and this is where
00:28:24
they are going to serve this search warrant and find some items inside that apartment what they discovered is a
00:28:32
spent 32 caliber shell casing they found this inside of a racquetball bag remember this matches the caliber of
00:28:42
some of our crimes that we've discussed yeah the other thing here too is when we
00:28:47
were discussing the offender or the profile that was put together of the offender
00:28:52
they had mentioned that he was wearing driving gloves they open up in the back they did confiscate some racquetball
00:29:00
gloves from his apartment that were similar in description right to what they had probably the most interesting
00:29:08
thing that they found in his apartment was a roll of tape this was actually a box there was a box that contained
00:29:17
several rolls of adhesive tape some of the rolls were used and a couple of the rolls were missing from the box what
00:29:25
kind of tape was as I now that we know that he was an athlete I kind of wondered if this was some kind of tape
00:29:32
that was used to like back in the 70s and 80s a lot of people that played football with like tape their fingers up
00:29:39
taped their hands up my guess I've never seen the tape and throughout some of the
00:29:46
different attacks and murders it's described differently you know sometimes a band-aid sometimes surgical tape
00:29:53
sometimes adhesive tape yeah when it's confiscated and rule simply describes it in her book the i-5 killer as adhesive
00:30:02
tape what I'm envisioning is what you just said that white tape that strong white tape that you see football players
00:30:10
wrapping around their ankles it's almost like electrical tape boxers wrapping it
00:30:15
around their their knuckles mm-hmm so yes that's what I'm picturing the the great thing here for the detectives it
00:30:24
seems they were they were ultimately searching for a gun they did find evidence that Randy Woodfield had guns
00:30:32
or had access to guns but they never found a gun in his apartment they found like a receipt for a gun purchase the
00:30:40
caliber didn't match any from the attacks and they found a gun cleaning kit yeah but see here's what I wonder if
00:30:48
you find a receipt for a gun but you can't find that gun does that prove to you on some level that this guy
00:30:54
purchases guns then gets rid of them well that would be your suspicion but you're looking for the gun that matches
00:31:00
the description in the caliber and the ballistics for the crimes that you know were committed again I want everybody to
00:31:09
keep in mind when they serve this search warrant these two detectives are not looking for the i-5 killer
00:31:17
they are looking for whoever killed Julie Wright's right it was not until they found the box of the adhesive tape
00:31:24
that the alarm bell started going off because the detectives were well aware of the search for the i5 bandit in the
00:31:33
i-5 killer but they had never linked that individual to the murder of Julie rights
00:31:39
it seems different right it seems 100% different the cool thing here is Randy Woodfield seems very concerned why they
00:31:47
want that tape why would you bother out of all the things to take from my apartment why do you bother taking tape
00:31:54
from my apartment mm-hmm this is going to lead to a domino effect that all of this is happening very quickly but they
00:32:04
are able to they have his mugshot Randy Woodfield smoke shot they already know all these jurisdictions that are looking
00:32:12
for the i5 bandit or the i-5 killer or both so now they're going to send out their information that they have on
00:32:19
Randy Woodfield with a picture of of his mug shot from the first time he served in prison as well as some general
00:32:26
information that they know about him mind you what was he driving at the time a VW Bug they send out this information
00:32:35
and what we have is lisa garcia she will positively identify Randy Woodfield in a
00:32:44
photo lineup Lisa Garcia is somebody that was robbed by the i5 bandit mm-hmm so shortly after the search of his
00:32:52
apartment Randy Woodfield is taken into custody this is depending on where you read and look into this case you're
00:33:00
gonna get some variations of why they took him in I'll cut I'll cut out all the crap here they took him in simply
00:33:07
because they knew he violated his parole that's what we're gonna bring you in on
00:33:10
that's what we're gonna hold you on all this stuff that we collected from your apartment could just be a coincidence we
00:33:17
have to prove that it is some type of evidence then once he is in their custody this is
00:33:23
when we get lisa garcia that comes forward and positively identifies him as the robber as the person that robbed her
00:33:30
this is also compounded with several other organ robbery victims coming forward positively identifying Randy
00:33:39
Woodfield as their attacker so this is not just one witness now we have multiple victims coming forward the
00:33:48
other thing that they're going to figure out through the course of their investigation and evidence that was
00:33:52
collected at Randy Woodfields apartment there was a roll of tape that they found
00:33:57
that matched tape that was found on the victims not only did it match by how it was made the materials used to make it
00:34:06
it also lined up to the point where some of the tear marks met up with the tear marks on a piece that was found on one
00:34:14
of the victims so what we out of here is yeah we have a guiding situation guiding
00:34:20
he is taken into custody custody on March 7th and it's just nine days later on March 16th that indictments for
00:34:30
murder rape sodomy attempted kidnapping armed robbery and illegal possession of firearms are initiated this from
00:34:38
multiple jurisdictions in both of the states of Washington and Oregon so how does his trial pan out the trial takes
00:34:48
place in the summer of 1981 and ultimately Randy Woodfield was tried for murder and attempted murder
00:34:56
this is stemming from the TransAmerican tidal building attack that we discussed in which Sherri Hall was murdered and
00:35:04
Beth Wilmont survived the problem for Randy here is they do have some evidence linking him
00:35:11
to this crime but what's going to really seal the deal is Beth Wilmont survived the attack yeah and she was also able to
00:35:21
sit in front of the jury describe the attack to the jury and points a Randy Woodfield as being the assailant and
00:35:29
being the murderer of her friend yeah on June 26 six 1989 it took about three and a half
00:35:36
hours of deliberation but what field was convicted on all counts and he was sentenced to life in prison plus 90
00:35:44
years a few months later there was a second trial that was being held this was in relation to the sexual assault
00:35:52
charge from the drive-in restaurant where he walked into the restroom and locked the door behind him yell in this
00:36:01
trial he you know there is some evidence again but mainly it's the living witness
00:36:07
that comes forward that helps the prosecution get Randy the conviction for which he receives an additional 35 years
00:36:16
that is added on to his already and stated sentence so he so he got life plus 90 plus 35 plus 35 and but that I
00:36:27
see or what it's claiming on the interwebs is a life imprisonment plus 165 so I wonder if there was another
00:36:39
case brought against him the thing here to that's a little weird is and you will
00:36:46
find this in several parts of the country especially during this time frame mmm but they really have trouble
00:36:56
narrowing down how many potential victims murder victims Randy Woodfield could have mmm the big problem with him
00:37:06
is he he struck so fast his his he was so rapid between attacks there was a very short cooling-off period for this
00:37:16
serial killer mm-hmm I've seen numbers anywhere from 12 possible victims all the way up to 44 yeah I've seen the 8 18
00:37:26
to 44 and despite the apparent links with countless other crimes and which include homicides what field would
00:37:36
actually not be prosecuted for the majority of the crimes that it is believed that he may have committed
00:37:42
right and this is because he's not getting out of prison you've already discussed
00:37:48
lengthy prison sentence and the state was unable to afford these additional trials for what are crimes that are
00:37:57
generally considered by victims families and law enforcement to be closed cases yeah and I think law enforcement can
00:38:06
close them on some level and I think as long as that's you know because you don't want to have all these trials and
00:38:14
give this guy more attention than he deserves and then spend more money on then on these trials than he deserves
00:38:23
and I think as long as the detectives could come to a consensus of here's the evidence and we can prove it to the
00:38:31
family and that gives the family closure on that level a hypothetical question for you okay
00:38:40
so you you're on trial it doesn't matter if you're innocent or guilty right but you're on trial and you get sentenced to
00:38:49
life imprisonment plus 165 what's your reaction what's my it is going to matter if I'm
00:39:02
guilty or innocent my reaction okay if I'm guilty you kind of right you're like okay yeah I did this [ __ ] okay if you're
00:39:10
anis if I'm innocent I'm I'm outraged you're you're in hell any statement given to the courtroom no I know because
00:39:22
you you're hoping and you're betting on some Appeals during that you know to to right the wrong if you are in fact
00:39:31
innocent yeah so I would refrain from acting like a jackass in the court which is going to be brought up time and time
00:39:39
again which would also that be law enforcement the prosecutors pointing out look at the temper
00:39:47
how can you not but look how he behaved how can you not believe that he would be
00:39:53
a violent individual or murder people so so now you're the judge right and I want
00:39:59
you to sentence me to life imprisonment plus 65 years scene go I hereby sentence you to life
00:40:09
imprisonment plus a hundred and sixty five years so you're saying there's a chance
00:40:15
that's that would be my reply whether I was innocent or guilty that would be my reply
00:40:21
well Randy Woodfield has never confessed to any crimes okay and he has he's even
00:40:30
gone as far to proclaim his innocence yeah there's a book out there called the serial killer letters a penetrating look
00:40:37
inside the minds of murderers and this is where several serial killers or alleged serial killers depending on how
00:40:46
you want to look at it share letters become pen pals with the author and in some of Randy Woodfields letters to the
00:40:56
author he states that not only is he not guilty but he he's innocent and furthermore he has a suspect in mind for
00:41:05
these crimes and he says that Larry more likely committed one or many of these murders the letters themselves you can
00:41:17
actually find some of them on the internet because I think for whatever reason after the author was done with
00:41:24
these letters somehow they ended up being sold on the internet I don't know how that came about but so these are not
00:41:30
super uncommon letters there is one that stands out more than others and that's the one where he outrightly names Larry
00:41:39
Moore as being the i-5 killer or who he suspects of being the i-5 killer I've read all these letters in this
00:41:47
correspondence and not all of them have to do with him proclaiming his innocence
00:41:51
but within some of those letters it seems weird because it seems at times like he's willing to say that maybe his
00:41:59
general theory mm-hmm and it's tough to to to deduce this just from the letters because he doesn't out rightly say this
00:42:08
is what actually happened but you can pull bits and pieces from it and it appears to me
00:42:15
like he is willing to admit to being the i-5 bandit to which he is actually saying that the i-5 bandit in the i-5
00:42:23
killer are two separate criminals right and that he might be good for some of these i5 bandit cases but he's not good
00:42:32
for any of these i-5 killer cases so which he points out that Larry Moore would be a better suspect to be the i-5
00:42:41
killer well who is Larry Moore why would he suggest that Larry Moore could be the
00:42:48
i-5 killer Larry Moore was convicted of the Oregon Museum Tavern shooting which took place on may 7th 1981 so it's all
00:42:59
about the same time period right in this case we have Larry Moore who basically walks into a bar with a rabbi and a
00:43:07
priest pulls a gun on the bartender shoots at the bartender and then turns the gun on several of the patrons at the
00:43:15
tavern he shoots multiple people this is a mass shooting really is what it is now
00:43:22
thankfully for a lot of the people there or at least some of the people there he
00:43:28
has a handgun that at some point he has to reload and the patrons that were being fired upon realized once he had to
00:43:36
reload that gun let's get this guy and they charged him and they take him down he's arrested on the scene unfortunately
00:43:44
the killing spree ended with three people dying at the scene it also injured 20 others one of these people
00:43:53
died in the hospital later that night and then there was a gentleman that he died nearly thirty two years later from
00:44:00
injuries that he suffered on that day so you have Randy Woodfield who is going to
00:44:08
point to this other killer as being the actual killer there is some problems with that though because we do know that
00:44:17
in 2001 and in 2006 Randy Woodfield was linked by DNA we don't need your confession buddy he was linked by DNA
00:44:27
test - two additional murders in Oregon that occurred in 1980 and 1981 I think that
00:44:37
it's fair to put his number somewhere around that 12 marker seems appropriate it but the scary thing here is it almost
00:44:47
seems like that might be a very conservative number we have a gentleman from the Portland Police Bureau this is
00:44:57
Jim Lawrence he's a cold-case detective when asked to describe the i-5 killer he says he
00:45:05
killed and then five weeks later he killed again then it was three weeks then two weeks I believe that it would
00:45:12
have soon been every few days he was like the boogeyman in April of 1987 Randy Woodfield filed a 12
00:45:23
million-dollar libel suit against author and rule the true crime author who had written the i-5 killer which is the
00:45:32
account of Randy Woodfields life and crime spree which became a best-selling book in 1984 the federal court and
00:45:41
Oregon dismissed the lawsuit in January of 1988 thankfully Randy Woodfield is serving his sentences at the Oregon
00:45:52
State Penitentiary Airy and Salem and he is never ever getting out of prison [Music]
00:46:03
all right thank you guys so much for joining us another week in the garage and thank you so much for telling a
00:46:09
friend and sharing on social media I want to pay tribute to the late great and role if anyone would like to look
00:46:16
further into this case the source everyone goes to is the true crime book the i-5 killer by anne rule that will be
00:46:24
our recommended reading for this week and you can find that title as well as others listed on our recommended page at
00:46:30
true crime garage calm and rule is one of the best true crime authors of the last 50 years when she started out
00:46:38
captain writing true crime books way back in 1969 editors and publishers told her that no one wants to read true crime
00:46:46
written by a female author so for years she was published using the pen name andy stack so they told her she couldn't
00:46:55
be a successful female true crime author and by god she did it as well as any and
00:47:01
better than most so cheers to the late great Andrew land cheers to all of you out there until next time be good be
00:47:09
kind and don't live [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music]

Episode Highlights

  • Welcome to True Crime Garage
    Nick welcomes listeners and introduces the episode's theme.
    “It's good to be seen and it's good to see you.”
    @ 00m 56s
    June 26, 2019
  • Randy Woodfield's Background
    Exploring the life of Randy Woodfield, a gifted athlete with a troubled past.
    “This guy had every advantage out there going for him.”
    @ 04m 28s
    June 26, 2019
  • The Sting Operation
    A brave female officer goes undercover to catch a serial attacker.
    “This is a very brave officer who puts herself in harm's way.”
    @ 13m 51s
    June 26, 2019
  • Woodfield's Legal Troubles
    Randy Woodfield pleads guilty to reduced charges after a series of crimes.
    “He pled guilty to reduced charges of second-degree robbery.”
    @ 14m 55s
    June 26, 2019
  • Randy Woodfield's Arrest
    After a series of investigations, Randy Woodfield is taken into custody for violating parole.
    “They took him in simply because they knew he violated his parole.”
    @ 33m 07s
    June 26, 2019
  • Conviction and Sentencing
    Randy Woodfield is convicted of murder and sentenced to life in prison plus 90 years.
    “It took about three and a half hours of deliberation, but Woodfield was convicted on all counts.”
    @ 35m 36s
    June 26, 2019
  • The I-5 Killer's Legacy
    Despite being linked to multiple murders, Woodfield's trial focused on a few key cases.
    “The scary thing here is it almost seems like that might be a very conservative number.”
    @ 44m 39s
    June 26, 2019

Episode Quotes

  • This guy had every advantage out there going for him.
    The I-5 Killer /// Part 2 /// 314
  • He was cut from the team for exposing himself.
    The I-5 Killer /// Part 2 /// 314
  • He pled guilty to reduced charges of second-degree robbery.
    The I-5 Killer /// Part 2 /// 314
  • He was a good model inmate, let's say.
    The I-5 Killer /// Part 2 /// 314
  • Why would you bother taking tape from my apartment?
    The I-5 Killer /// Part 2 /// 314
  • He was like the boogeyman.
    The I-5 Killer /// Part 2 /// 314

Key Moments

  • Welcome00:40
  • Randy Woodfield02:46
  • Cover-Up Attempts05:40
  • Murder of Sherry23:57
  • Evidence Found28:30
  • Tape Discovery31:22
  • Witness Identification32:40
  • Trial Begins34:48

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown