00:00:07
[Music] welcome to true crime garage wherever you are whatever you were doing thanks
00:00:45
for listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is a man that just can't be stopped when you Zig he zags
00:00:51
he's all shimmy and no shake he is the Kappa thank you thank you thank you it's good to be seen and it's
00:00:57
good to see you thanks for listening thanks for Tama friend today we are drinking speed wobbles from Key Brewing
00:01:09
Company garage grade four and a quarter bottle caps out of five this is the first beer in a series of customized
00:01:16
batches the busting boards crew and the key Brewers dropped a gnarly combo of hops to land this very satisfying IPA
00:01:24
that you can ride all day remember hoppiness breeds happiness and today we are getting happy thanks to our good
00:01:31
Garage friends first up way high up in the 21st century tower we have May listening in Dubai and a big shout-out
00:01:38
to Emma and Windsor Ontario and a small shout-out to Emily in Charleston West Virginia and next we have one of our
00:01:47
Instagram followers Jessica and northern speed in and a big shout out to Paula and Reading
00:01:53
Pennsylvania alright next up we have Molly and beautiful Austin Texas and last but certainly not least we have two
00:02:00
great gents at a Boston Mass we have Theo and his father Ted big cheers to Theo and Ted hopefully they are drinking
00:02:08
beers and listening to this episode together thank you all for going to true crime
00:02:12
garage comm and clicking on the donate button and filling up the fridge for this week's show yeah make sure you
00:02:19
subscribe to the podcast and if you haven't take a second give us a five star review and that's enough of the
00:02:26
beers all right everybody gather round grab a chair grab a beer let's talk some true
00:02:32
crime after a night of drinks and dancing on August 22nd 2009 29 year old mother and nurse
00:02:54
Tony Sharples disappears after leaving a party in the early morning hours of August 23rd now let's get back to the
00:03:02
house where Tony was last seen the people whom we know to be at the home that night according to crystal Jones
00:03:09
who was with her at the party police lieutenant Frank Higgins said that they interviewed all the people at the house
00:03:17
that night and I believe he said that all of them were cooperative as well so this included Willie green remember he's
00:03:25
the owner of the house right and they all seemed to back up Crystal's story that Tony left the home under her own
00:03:33
power the police stated publicly that there was no indication whatsoever of foul
00:03:38
play no one at the party was a suspect and there were no persons of interest that they had uncovered in their
00:03:46
investigation I wonder if they let them search the property from everything that
00:03:52
I have seen there was never a search of the property or the house specifically lieutenant Higgins said quote nothing
00:04:00
took place there that would lead us to believe that something happened there and quote so we don't know how in-depth
00:04:09
any of these quote-unquote interviews with the people at the house were it was Elaine law a private investigator on
00:04:19
this case whom we discussed we'll discuss her more in a bit she is under the impression that Willie green
00:04:26
basically told the cops that it was mostly just his family there that night and that they didn't really know
00:04:35
anything and she says they weren't really questioned in this case to be clear as we pointed
00:04:43
out just a minute ago Willie Greene's home was not subject to any kind of search and none of the people at his
00:04:50
house that night aside from crystal have spoken about the events of that evening publicly which is
00:04:57
I find ridiculous because this is our last night and we're about so searched the property yeah so for
00:05:06
many people interested in this case the quick dismissal of the partygoers as potentially involved parties does not
00:05:16
sit well in the failure to investigate a possible crime scene is I think inexcusable
00:05:23
Willie Greene we are told as you said he fully cooperated it does seem that the fact that a woman went missing after
00:05:33
being at his home in a compromised state should warrant further investigation long there was a conflict as well right
00:05:43
I always wondered if that conflict had truth or merit to it or if it was something that that everybody was making
00:05:49
up to cover up something else yeah so Tony's friend Gigi haze right she's the one who organized the Texas Equusearch
00:05:57
search of the river yeah she regularly contacted the police demanding that Willie green and all the others be
00:06:06
formally questioned she is under the impression that Matt green somebody else who was at the party and the uncle of
00:06:17
Willie and Matt green both have criminal histories and she says these two should
00:06:23
have been looked into very closely repeated attempts by private investigator Elaine law to contact
00:06:31
Willie green have been completely disregarded she did not even get a return call from his attorney if he is
00:06:41
at all concerned about the fact that a woman disappeared from his home he certainly is not showing it so now let's
00:06:49
ask the question captain is crystal telling the truth she's the only one that we've heard speak publicly about
00:06:59
what happened that night why I think like you said earlier she's been pretty cooperative and she's also been very
00:07:06
eager to talk and to get the story out there and as the years go by she's kind of now more reluctant to to talk about
00:07:17
the case is that fair to say Oh agreed 100% and and here's here's the problem with crystal it's hard for me to really
00:07:29
get a fix on her I can't I can't figure her out because we have the situation as
00:07:36
you said where early on in this case I mean we're coming up on ten years now she was at one point talking and very
00:07:43
active and vocal about what happened that night and about her missing friend and yes that has tapered off over the
00:07:52
years some of that might not be because she is hiding anything or because she isn't telling the truth she has taken a
00:08:01
lot of flack on the Internet a lot of people have gone after her yeah and it could just be for that I mean at
00:08:09
some point when you're trying to help a situation you know you and I jokingly say it sometimes no good deed goes
00:08:16
unpunished right if she in fact is out there trying to help find her friend and she's getting [ __ ] on for it one can
00:08:27
only take that one can only take that for so long it only takes so much [ __ ] and here's
00:08:34
the other thing that makes it hard for me to get a real good handle on her is that in the beginning not only is she
00:08:41
talking but she seems to be doing things that are helpful to the search for Tony
00:08:48
Sharples she is one that is reported to have called and report Tony is missing she is one that is reported to have
00:08:56
helped the family print flyers and distribute flyers looking for Tony right and this is also your with your friend
00:09:05
she might not even a known that Tony was going through these battles with her mental illness
00:09:11
switching up medications she might not have known any of that well according to crystal she said she did not know any of
00:09:19
them but he didn't know that Tony was not supposed to be drinking and crystal almost gives the suggestion that had she
00:09:26
known had she been aware of what was going on in Tony's life that she likely wouldn't have asked her to go out
00:09:33
dancing and drinking and partying with her that yes you probably want to ask that and then when you go back to this
00:09:39
party and there was a confrontation that's probably seems a little strange but again she's probably just going okay
00:09:46
well we had a couple drinks but you would have way more knowledge about this situation then you get into the car with
00:09:53
her and you get in our argument and she tells you to leave one you're probably not gonna be let in our drive to you're
00:10:00
not getting out of that car and let's be clear if you're drunk at a party or not
00:10:07
drunk let's say you're tipsy at a party and you guys decide to leave but you're forty minutes away from where you know
00:10:14
your safe area and your friend drops you off and they don't come back to get you
00:10:19
you're gonna be pissed and you have every right to be pissed and she she hasn't been and she's been champion to
00:10:26
go hey we want to figure out what happened to my friend and she probably feels a little bit responsible because
00:10:31
she didn't know about these things like you said she invited her out probably one enough and probably would have
00:10:38
invited to hang out with her but one enough went to a party went to a club so she's been a champion to keep the story
00:10:46
and the limelight but you see this with like when Brian Schaeffer went missing last person one of the last people to be
00:10:54
with him is Clint he gets thrown under the bus in the Tyler Davis case you know his wife and his friend are now being
00:11:01
thrown under the bus so you just become that part of the story so crystals being
00:11:06
thrown under the bus and again how much [ __ ] can you take well and then you have
00:11:12
the flip side of that same coin and on the flip side of that coin what do we see we see people that say
00:11:20
Christel went out of her way to make sure that she was one of the people that reported Tony missing that she helped
00:11:29
create the story and helped to give credence to that story by making two phone calls to Tony's phone so you're
00:11:38
saying that people are saying that she's creating the narrative correct and Tony's friends
00:11:46
Tony's longtime friends they say they believe crystal is lying and they believe it's very strange that the
00:11:54
police have put all of their trust into Crystal's story about what happened right but one of the reasons why they
00:12:01
put their trust into her stories because she did something that we never advised
00:12:06
and that is to ask for a polygraph so she takes a polygraph which I don't think any lawyer wouldn't tell you to do
00:12:17
but I think she was pretty adamant on trying to clear her name yes I have that she offered to take a polygraph did so
00:12:26
and passed the polygraph test the polygraph examination the the other thing too is there are questions about
00:12:39
what her relationship is with Matt green and there's still questions about what exactly went down at the party even if
00:12:47
you believe crystal or not that's just my opinion she was the first to call police
00:12:52
when Tony failed to show up the next day as I pointed out she did help in the searches for Tony putting up the fliers
00:12:59
she did talk to media I have a question for you I don't know if you can answer this because I couldn't figure it out
00:13:07
are the initial reports when when they're talking about the events of that night are the initial reports are they
00:13:15
talking about the conflict that happened at the house and why they left the house
00:13:21
because it doesn't seem that clear and I always wondered what you know which came
00:13:26
first you know dude that did they not talk about why they left and then once crystal figures out that
00:13:35
her friend was dealing with some mental issues is that when the story of the conflict came out because I just think
00:13:42
that would be kind of telling know the story of the conflict that the house came out once it was known that the
00:13:52
otoni was missing right so it came out right away it came out fairly early yeah yes not to
00:13:59
the general public but to the enforcement the people searching for Tony but you know here's the thing while
00:14:07
crystal has put up publicly anyway put up a good front as being a concerned friend and maybe she is legitimately a
00:14:15
concerned friend as you pointed out she did pass that polygraph and she has generally stuck to her story again it's
00:14:23
the it goes back to social media and things that I've seen on the Internet she clearly has not come out smelling
00:14:29
like a rose during this whole thing Elaine law the private investigator who is searching for Tony
00:14:37
she says she interviewed Krystal for four hours and her statement is is this she feels that while Krystal was not
00:14:47
straight up lying about the situation she says that she believes that she is not being fully truthful either and
00:14:56
missing because he could take a polygraph test and tell the truth but but be omitting things so the right and
00:15:07
the thing here is that the private investigator basically believes that Krystal knows more than what she is
00:15:14
saying to law enforcement and to the public and she cites that she really does not like the fact that Krystal
00:15:21
refused to show her her phone records from that time period yeah the private investigators looking
00:15:27
for confirmation of the two calls correct she wants to line those up with what she
00:15:33
knows about Tony's phone why not and I would also want to know who she called after that because he she claimed that
00:15:40
she calls Tony's phone twice doesn't get a reply then she is calling multiple people to get a ride I want to
00:15:50
know who's calling after that did she call Matt green I'd be interested in that but also maybe those two calls
00:15:57
never happened but wouldn't they be able to get Tony's cell phone records at some
00:16:03
point oh they do have them the private investigator has them and so that's where I question are they only
00:16:10
simply coming up as incoming calls right I doubt that I'm guessing that part of the reason why maybe police are really
00:16:19
going on crystals story is two reasons one the other people at the party that night
00:16:24
according to here's the other thing we don't really fully know a full list of the people at the party right all we
00:16:32
have is the people that that law enforcement spoke to saying yeah but this is it this is all the people that
00:16:38
were there that night and then on top of that they they may have Tony's records saying that it was in fact crystal that
00:16:46
called her on those two times six minutes apart around the time that she vanished and so
00:16:53
that kind of backs up crystals story as well I think what a lane law is saying here is exactly what you just said she
00:17:00
wants to know what other activity was going on with crystals phone before those calls between those calls and
00:17:07
afterwards who is she talking to and one thing that would would cause a big shake-up and a big wrinkle in her story
00:17:15
would be if in fact she did phone anybody that was still at that party at that time her or believed to be at
00:17:23
Willie Greene's house at that time because that doesn't seem to gel with with her actions of what she said to the
00:17:31
public you know that I called I called my friends my family looking for a ride home because I was dumped on the side of
00:17:37
the road well again it's strange though too because we have the last person supposedly with her you wonder how much
00:17:44
she was questioned when they when people are people are questioning how much people were questioning at the party how
00:17:52
much was crystal questioned and she was the one that came forward and said I'll take a polygraph test
00:17:57
they didn't ask her to she was the one willing to so then you wonder if they even how much they've checked her phone
00:18:03
records or did they just go while we we talked to the cousin so we know that the
00:18:08
cousin came and picked her up so I know that we're kind of spinning our tires on
00:18:14
this here a bit but before do whatever we want I want to make sure that everyone has their seats in the full
00:18:20
upright position because this is where the story starts to get weird okay on September 14th this is about
00:18:31
three weeks after Tony disappear authorities in Pennsylvania got word that the New Jersey State Police had a
00:18:37
possible hit on Tony's car on September 8th a stationary New Jersey State Police
00:18:44
vehicle parked in Camden had seen something an automated license plate reader mounted in the police car
00:18:52
recorded the plate number on each car passing it a car bearing plate number DND seven seven seven two passed and was
00:19:03
recorded the automated plate reader ran the plate and because Tony's car was listed as missing remember they reported
00:19:12
it as missing it would have notified the officer Manning the vehicle that it was
00:19:18
possibly her car but the police car was parked and no one was in it so no one noticed the license plate number hit
00:19:26
until a week later right now it's worth noting that I have read that these license plate readers are not 100% 100%
00:19:39
of the time I've seen some people point out things that they're more likely closer to 90% accurate the other thing
00:19:48
that we got to keep in mind too is it's possible that it was not Tony's car that
00:19:55
was seen but simply a car with the license plate number DND 777 to Wright was in Camden on September 8th that the
00:20:05
plate was on a different vehicle now private and ball where you have that idea but you
00:20:11
serve the other idea that you can have the same license-plate number but a different state hmm so-so
00:20:19
Elaine law who is working on this case the private investigator yeah and who I spoke with briefly for this episode she
00:20:30
actually is the one that told me to cover this case I approached her about a different case that she was working
00:20:37
there there's a case out there and I won't go into specifics specifics about it because the family asks that we not
00:20:45
cover it the victim's family it was a case that I had wanted to cover for some time
00:20:50
there's very little information out there in the newspapers and in the public about it and I saw Elaine law's
00:20:58
name in one of the newspaper articles so I contacted her thinking well if we're gonna learn anything about that case we
00:21:05
need to get it from her to which she says look the family doesn't really want it to be covered why don't you take a
00:21:11
look at and she tossed out a few other cases that she had been working on that really need the public's help and and
00:21:19
really need a voice thrown out there and the story told one more time in hopes that it hits the right ears so she told
00:21:29
us that a Camden police officer this is a little this is a little off the record
00:21:35
here then a Camden police officer told her that a car with Toni's plate number also got a parking ticket in the city
00:21:43
around that same time period but he didn't go into further detail about that whole situation I could not find that
00:21:53
anywhere so it seems like at least that plate number has popped up twice on Camden police radar so the New Jersey
00:22:03
State Police says both that they and the Camden police scoured the area but never
00:22:08
found any other trace of the car with that plate on it now lieutenant Higgins of Lower Merion Township Police
00:22:17
Department says quote cars don't usually disappear entirely at some point in the
00:22:22
future they turn up whether it's a junkyard or somewhere else and quote but we know Tony's car has never turned up
00:22:30
and the idea that her car may have been in Camden in an area riddled with drugs prostitution and crime has led to a
00:22:40
predominant theory of what possibly could have happened to Tony now we also have private investigator Elaine law she
00:22:52
talked about tips that came in and also about possible sightings of Tony so about a month after well six weeks a
00:23:02
month and a half after Tony vanished yeah a former detective private investigator
00:23:09
Elaine law offered her services to the family for $1 she saw Tony's case on the news and felt that it was something that
00:23:20
there was possibility based on the amount of sex trafficking in the area and tips about possible sightings of
00:23:27
tony that tony was still alive and possibly either involved in drugs and prostitution or she had been trafficked
00:23:35
so Elaine started a website to gather tips she met with both Krystle and the family tried to contact Willy green held
00:23:45
a town meeting about the case she kept Tony's picture in the media even going around Camden with a picture of Tony
00:23:52
asking pimps dealers working girls and residents if they had seen her right because you have a individual that again
00:24:01
is struggling with mental illness shouldn't be drinking but was drinking has had some struggles with addiction in
00:24:09
the past is it possible that this she gets in this conflict that kind of pushes her over the edge and when she
00:24:17
leaves her friend she doesn't really know where she's at but then she goes hey you know maybe I can get some drugs
00:24:24
by going to Camden and if you go there then who knows what bad things could happen Elaine says that she has gathered
00:24:33
50 plus tips to track Tony from initial sightings near or in Lancaster where she worked to
00:24:42
Camden and then to Philly saying it's almost as if Tony was being moved around some of these tips placed Tony in the
00:24:52
presence of a large black man and a skinny Hispanic man with a goatee and there was a sighting of a woman having
00:25:00
very dark under eye circles almost raccoon eyes something that apparently Tony struggled with since her teen years
00:25:07
and then one guy said he had seen Tony four times in candid and that they had the same heroin dealer
00:25:15
another tip came from a security guard that placed an abandoned dirty scraped up black sedan with tinted windows so a
00:25:25
vehicle matching a similar description to Tony's under the Ben Franklin Bridge between Philly and Camden shortly after
00:25:33
she went missing it had no plates in the Camden police never disclosed whether they followed up
00:25:39
on that vehicle sighting or the sightings of possibly Tony now of course we also have no idea whether any of
00:25:50
these tips are correct and if Tony was actually seen and many of these tips do come from people that I would consider
00:25:58
to be less than reliable and if it was Tony that was seen then you have other things to wonder about was she abducted
00:26:08
or did she go willingly yeah it's and it's very hard to I feel for this whole situation because of her struggles with
00:26:20
the mental illness if she hits a point of a manic state and then she's using drugs the drugs could can you know have
00:26:34
her continue to stay in a manic state and and and who knows where she's at so one thing I do know though too is that
00:26:43
police they say that they looked into whether Tony ever purchased drugs in Camden they came up with nothing
00:26:51
regarding that and they also said that there is actually no evidence at all that she even knew anyone in that area
00:27:00
the other thing too if it was drugs that she went after that night or or if that's the reason that kept her away it
00:27:10
seems a little strange to me it seems like there would have been a lot of other places closer to home to make that
00:27:16
score the case did start to grow cold after these tips were coming in these were pretty early in the investigation
00:27:25
pretty early in Elaine laws investigation I do want to get to some other interesting tips in this case okay
00:27:33
a call that was made to West Brandywine Township Police Department this is a call where a man claimed to be from the
00:27:41
Canadian Security Intelligence Service this is an agency similar to the CIA in Toronto
00:27:48
the man said agents found a car parked on their lot and traced the car to Tony and the agents also found someone who
00:27:57
they believed to be Tony matching her description the man provided an email address and a phone number where he
00:28:04
could be reached and requested photos of Tony the address and phone number however turned out to be a fake Chief
00:28:14
Warner said police called the Toronto Police Department and was told the call must have been faked
00:28:20
chief Warner said that the caller was quote the guy had all the right answers he was talking the police lingo and he
00:28:30
knew what to say and quote several days later an officer in West Brandywine Police Department's radio room took a
00:28:39
call from a sheriff's deputy in South Dakota the deputy claimed the officers found Tony's car there the man promised
00:28:47
to fax information over but never did officers contacted the man's alleged department but personnel there had no
00:28:56
knowledge of the vehicle or of the man who made the call we have chief Warner again who says look we got
00:29:03
a copy of that recording and he says it was the exact same guy that he talked to
00:29:09
the the guy that claimed to be from Toronto he said that the reason why he could identify the caller as being the
00:29:16
same is he described this man as having an interesting voice it was something about the way that this man sounded the
00:29:24
chief Werner was able to believe that the caller was in fact the same the thing though that's weird
00:29:33
here and just kind of really blows my mind is why would somebody bother to stage these two hoaxes this is four
00:29:44
years after Tony went missing [Music] [Music] joy bird empowers you to create the
00:29:57
furniture and space that brings you joy and keeps those summer vibes flowing all
00:30:02
year long over a year ago I ordered two Soto apartment chairs from joy Bird and they have been fantastic super
00:30:10
comfortable super durable and they look beautiful in fact I was sitting in one watching a movie last night and I was on
00:30:17
joy Bird calm this morning shopping I got my eye on the Hughes swivel chair with joy Bird you get one-of-a-kind
00:30:25
furniture crafted to your unique taste one a sofa and aqua blue or indigo a loveseat in the hottest red if you can
00:30:33
dream it joy bird can make it a reality from rich buttery leather to the plushies velvet that you ever felt find
00:30:41
the fabric and texture that's right for you joy Barrett even offers a range of kid and pet friendly upholstery options
00:30:49
that stay in the test of time plus they have free personal design consultants to
00:30:54
help you nail down your perfect design trust me next chair zooss 'im see how joy bird can help you design your dream
00:31:01
space make furniture your own at joy bird comm slash garage create the furniture that brings you joy today at
00:31:09
joy bird comm garage go to joy bird comm / garage and receive an exclusive offer
00:31:16
for 25% off your first order by using code garage that's joy bird comm / garage to get exclusive 25% off your
00:31:26
first order credit card bills every month you get them with multiple payments and multiple due dates wouldn't
00:31:34
it be easier just to have one payment at a lower rate you can with a credit card
00:31:38
consolidation loan from my friends at light stream get a rate as low as five point nine five percent APR with Auto
00:31:46
pay plus the rate is fixed so will never go up over the life of the loan you can
00:31:51
get a loan from $5,000 to $100,000 with no fees and you can even get your money as soon as the day you apply you will
00:32:00
want to check out their website light stream calm it's easy it's simple it's fast they're
00:32:06
gonna help you save money and save a lot of time and just for our listeners apply
00:32:11
now to get a special interest rate discount the only way to get this discount is to go to light stream comm
00:32:18
slash TCG that's lig HT s TR e a.m. dot-com / TC G subject to credit approval rate includes 0.5% auto pay
00:32:31
discount terms and conditions apply and offers are subject to change without notice
00:32:36
visit light stream comm slash TCG for more information if there's something interfering with your happiness or
00:32:43
preventing you from achieving your goals better help online counseling can help better help offers licensed professional
00:32:50
counselors who are specialized in issues such as depression anxiety relationships
00:32:55
trauma anger grief self esteem and much more connect with your professional counselor in a safe and private online
00:33:02
environment and get help at your own time and at your own pace anything you share is confidential and
00:33:09
it's so convenient you can schedule secure video or phone sessions as well as chat and text with your therapist and
00:33:16
for some reason you are not happy with your counselor you can request a new one at any time for no additional charge
00:33:22
best of all it's a truly affordable option our listeners even get 10% off your first month with the discount code
00:33:29
garage so why not get started today go to better help calm slash garage then simply fill out a questionnaire to help
00:33:37
them assess your needs and get matched with the counselor you'll love that's better help.com slash garage
00:33:42
that's better help calm slash garage [Music] all right we're back you filthy animals
00:33:55
stay filthy you Annalee he filtered well you know we were talking about this on Saturday at our presentation meetup
00:34:04
whatever you want to call it is being a true crime lover is becoming a little more acceptable in society so we're
00:34:13
becoming less filthy animals of the true crime kingdom it ain't easy being greasy
00:34:19
yes or cheesy in late 2013 something happened that could give us a significant clue into Tony's
00:34:31
disappearance private investigator Elaine law received a letter at her office the one paged unsigned letter
00:34:39
postmarked in Trenton New Jersey on November 29th arrived in her mail December 1st
00:34:46
she didn't initially notice the letter in the pile of mail and she was shocked when she observed the return address it
00:34:55
was from Toni Sharples now toni is typically spelled t o n I was T ony Sharples now here is the text of the
00:35:12
letter dear Elaine law the police and PA do not have a tip line I tried calling the Philly police where I live but they
00:35:23
said it was not in their jurisdiction one of the detectives pulled me aside and gave me your name and address in the
00:35:32
last few days of September 2009 a friend in Camden called me and offered me money
00:35:39
to move a car from Brooklyn New Jersey to Boston Massachusetts he told me he would pay me $5,000 cash plus I could
00:35:49
have the plates he asked if I knew anyone 27 or 29 that wanted to pay per trip so he gave me a social security
00:35:59
card I drove the car a black four-door pontiac grand prix and drove to an auto body shop outside of boston
00:36:07
massachusetts i took off the plates and with a black magic marker wrote down the
00:36:14
last five digits of the VIN number and cleared out the glovebox I came back to Camden a day later and he told me that
00:36:24
the car was not stolen but missing he said a friend of his a cop in Camden got into a fight with a girl she died and he
00:36:33
needed to get the car out of Jersey about a month ago my daughter was playing in the garage and found the box
00:36:40
with the plates and social security card I had forgotten all about it the plates are DND seven seven seven two
00:36:50
the social security card and this is where Sharples his cell phone number was written in this spot and the last five
00:37:00
digits of the VIN are the person wrote the last five digits of Sharples vehicle's identification number in this
00:37:08
mine no I think some of this stuff was actually reported or public knowledge but I think it's definitely that VIN
00:37:16
number would be hard to get the writer goes on to say because of Hurricane sandy I had to visit Jersey to help
00:37:23
friends clean up I decided to drop you this letter what happened to Tony I don't really know all I know is that she
00:37:32
had a run-in with the police and I was paid much-needed cash to get the car to a shop in Boston again the the letter is
00:37:41
not signed it's a one-page letter and as you said captain yes the we do know that
00:37:47
the plate number was readily available this was not only I mean it was on the internet plus it was on flyers looking
00:37:56
for for Tony because her vehicle was missing as well the difficult thing as you said are the
00:38:03
five digits of the VIN number and we could speculate day and night how difficult it could have been or how easy
00:38:10
it could have been to get Tony's cell phone number that may have been difficult we do know that it was
00:38:16
a relatively new phone I don't know if that came with a new number but we should point out the VIN number and the
00:38:24
cell phone number were both correct they were tony's now Alain turned over the letter to the West Brandywine police
00:38:34
and also notified the New Jersey State Police and the New Jersey Attorney General's Office she also gave the
00:38:41
letter to the media in hopes that it would keep Tony's case alive later she learned that police believe
00:38:49
the letter to be a hoax probably because it was sent in close proximity to the to
00:38:55
hoax phone calls she's not certain why they came to this conclusion but that's what they have said publicly that this
00:39:03
letter is is a hoax what are you feeling about this letter because you're your captain letter man we will cover every
00:39:13
case that involves a strange letter yeah so I have a lot of questions about this
00:39:20
letter I think that most of the information in so this is not the same as like the zodiac who who kills Paul
00:39:29
Stine and then provides you a bloody torn off piece of his shirt right in a letter this is very different this is
00:39:37
somebody who is claiming to have done something been paid by somebody else possibly limiting their involvement
00:39:44
limiting their involvement and then my proof of you to believe my word is I'm gonna provide you with these three
00:39:53
things these three pieces of information and they could have obtained these in the exact manner that they said that
00:40:01
they took the plates they wrote down the VIN number they cleared out the glovebox
00:40:04
that easily could have obtained all these things from that exact action however I believe that somebody could
00:40:14
have got this information if they looked and spent a little bit of time on it I don't think it would have been extremely
00:40:21
difficult to find all three of these things and provide it one thing that I find interesting is that when with the
00:40:29
claim of having the Social Security card this individual then provides her cell phone number in
00:40:36
place of what what he or she probably should have put the social security number brilliant so that makes me wonder
00:40:45
well why have a hoax why write this letter well those are things that point to me point to me that it could be a
00:40:53
hoax okay before we move on I do want to clear one thing up because some people might be asking themselves this of some
00:41:00
of the wording in the letter when he says that he was asked if anyone if I knew anyone 27 or 29 that wanted to pay
00:41:10
per trip so he gave me a social security card what they mean by this is somebody
00:41:17
that wants to steal an identity to to take somebody else's information all right yeah that's that that's the paper
00:41:24
trip that he's talking about or she so here's where I have a different issue with it where I questioned the validity
00:41:35
of of the letter I'm also a bit horrified and terrified by the letter there's something very strange going on
00:41:48
here if there were to be three hoaxes and then we had the the one of the police officers the chief of police
00:41:57
saying he believes just by listening with his own ears that that the the caller of those two calls were one in
00:42:07
fact the same so if though if the two calls that come in that are hoaxes that try to put Tony in her vehicle in
00:42:14
Toronto and then the other call tries to put Tony's vehicle somewhere in South Dakota and now this letter is stating
00:42:24
that hey I live in Philadelphia right somebody from Camden hired me to do this I had to move the car from Brooklyn
00:42:32
Brooklyn New Jersey to Boston Massachusetts we have six different cities named in three different hoaxes
00:42:40
and then on top of that if it's not that big of a leap to go okay well if the same person made those phone calls did
00:42:47
then the same person write this letter and that's where I get horrified and terrified at the same time there's
00:42:55
there's something very strange there if one person is responsible for all of these communications yeah but to me it's
00:43:05
like what is the hoax trying to prove it's trying to prove that she left the area that she was last seen by her
00:43:13
friend that's to me what these are trying to prove so that he's trying to steer the direction of the investigation
00:43:23
like throwing them off the trail if they were in fact that's that's the other problem I have with this whole thought
00:43:30
it's four years later the only conceivable reason that I can come up with this somebody would would make
00:43:37
these communications would be just that to throw them off the trail but but we're under the belief that the case had
00:43:45
gone cold by this time so there is no trail what trail are they on were they even on a trail at the time right but
00:43:52
maybe I'm just saying if something happened bad at that party that they're still you know they feel guilty they
00:44:06
feel paranoid maybe they're creating this hopes for that reason let's keep you away from thinking about that party
00:44:16
unless you cuz they don't know the leads but again that doesn't make a lot of sense to me because you'd think unless
00:44:25
the cops were constantly beating down their door and asking for information why would you involve yourself anymore
00:44:34
why not just stay away right and if you had nothing to do with it why involve yourself at all that's why I'm saying
00:44:41
this it's all weird man it's all weird and and then then you are if you weren't involved you I don't think you would
00:44:47
create the hoax I'm saying but again that the other possibility that I haven't really thought about till now is
00:44:55
the idea of when when she says crystal said while she I thought she would come back for me and
00:45:02
it's like what if at some point Tony did come back and she went back to the party
00:45:08
without crystal hmm you know this is not you know we're just basing off of if the
00:45:16
cops might believe crystal and she might be telling the truth about that but that
00:45:20
does not mean that Tony didn't go back to the party yeah and but you know if we haven't done any search of this property
00:45:29
III just don't know how again and we also don't know how many individuals were at that house so is it there were
00:45:38
but I do know there was enough individuals that something bad could have happened and somebody could have
00:45:42
disposed of her car it would appear that something happened to this car in actually Tony's car going to a Chop Shop
00:45:50
out of state makes some sense why her car has never been located you know after this point I I do want to throw
00:46:01
this information out there and I have names here but I've I've purposely removed them because I question how how
00:46:13
true this this information is this is but but it does cite several of the things in the letter that we just talked
00:46:23
about so an estranged wife of an ex Camden police officer okay remember in the letter the the letter writer claimed
00:46:33
to have been paid by somebody that said that that Tony had a run-in with a police officer right so an estranged
00:46:42
wife of an ex Camden police officer who was fired after falsifying reports in order to get this estranged wife
00:46:52
arrested this wife comes forward talks with the private investigator Elaine and tells her that her ex who lived in
00:47:02
Brooklyn I keep wanting to say Brooklyn it's Brooklyn New Jersey right again the
00:47:08
town mentioned in the letter also ran an auto business where he would repo cars and resell them including the
00:47:19
area of Boston she claims that at one point she saw a black four-door Pontiac with tinted windows in their driveway
00:47:29
one day and assumed it to be one of these vehicles one of his cars that he repossessed or that took possession of
00:47:37
to resell so again that's information that was provided to us yeah it's it's always difficult when you have these
00:47:48
these marriages that go south that go away bad what the hell go south it's tough to whether or not you get a
00:47:57
divorce that's a different thing but they all go south it seems like he was definitely up to no good because we do
00:48:03
have the Camden police department who claims he was fired for falsifying reports now you're a liar right I mean
00:48:10
that's in I want to believe the letter it seems like it makes sense it seems like just with the VIN number it's not
00:48:19
the full VIN number rights as part of the VIN number five numbers the last file but it's enough for me to go okay
00:48:25
that's information that's not easy to get my issue with it is if you're gonna come forward with this letter why not
00:48:38
just come forward altogether because you see I mean like I feel like by sending this letter whoever paid you could come
00:48:53
after you could come after you and if you don't go and tell them your full story then you've offered yourself no
00:48:59
protection from that person right it's not only you know it's like oh yeah well they but they didn't put their
00:49:04
identification in the letter well no but no but the person of the person that real the person that paid this person
00:49:11
like well where you are according to the letter it was like a person that there was a middleman right
00:49:19
so right so the police officer if in fact the letters correct may not exactly know who
00:49:27
ultimately was paid to move the vehicle who ultimately wrote the letter right but it it's but some it won't work that
00:49:35
hard for him to figure it out right it wouldn't be that hard for him to figure that out so I are you ready for another
00:49:45
twist here captain sure all right on May 15th 2014 Tony's mother Donna received a
00:49:52
check in the mail from the Department of Revenue state of Indiana for jest it was
00:49:59
a little over a thousand dollars this check this was a tax refund check what's notable is that the check was made
00:50:08
payable to Tony Lee Sharples and Robert E Morales husband and wife this Tony and
00:50:18
robber apparently filed joint state returns on earnings of forty six thousand six hundred and twenty five
00:50:26
dollars from Johns Hopkins University Tony's occupation was listed as a nurse and Roberts as a doctor a bogus phone
00:50:37
number was on the return now this is mind-boggling for many reasons but mainly because a man named Robert E
00:50:47
Morales went missing from Phoenix Arizona two weeks before Tony did on August 8th
00:50:53
2009 he is still missing to this day you can see his Charley project page on their website I wonder if somebody is
00:51:04
trying to scam the system and going hey let's put these two missing people together you know but how would you file
00:51:13
a tax return so the the private investigator Elaine contacted the Department of Revenue in Indiana and she
00:51:22
said that she learned it was a legitimate refund check and that the tax returns Antoni and Roberts joint names had been
00:51:29
filed electronically as for why the check was sent to Tony's old address instead of the address listed on the
00:51:38
turn Elaine said she was told that whenever the address is less than one year old that they just send it to the
00:51:48
former address who knows how this happened but significantly someone had stolen Toni's identity and yeah but they
00:51:59
could have nothing to do with her disappear you could have nothing to do with the case but then you also wonder
00:52:04
if in fact that person had access to her social security card and we know that the anonymous letter writer mentioned
00:52:12
that he had the card Donna her mother believes that Toni kept her Social Security card in her wallet which of
00:52:21
course has never been found but this is what drives me just absolutely insane about these missing
00:52:29
person cases the investigation should have been harder on these people at the party they should investigated that
00:52:37
property period did the cops know did law enforcement know that should be going missing for the rest of her life
00:52:43
that would be sitting here ten years later wondering where she's at no but you got
00:52:50
to start by assuming that you need to assume that the worst case scenario is going to happen and you need to make
00:52:55
sure that you do your due diligence don't be a piece of [ __ ] right well here's here's the thing I see two things
00:53:05
kind of going on here there are points in this investigation where me on the outside looking in it appears to me that
00:53:12
they are doing their due diligence that they are working the case hard but there
00:53:19
are other times where I have a completely different feeling and this is not a small case this is an
00:53:25
investigation that's been 10 years now how many how long and good have they worked on it through the course of that
00:53:32
time is certainly up for the for debate and and my own opinion is at times it was not good on their end that could be
00:53:42
that we have multiple jurisdictions involved in this I will say that the local police investigating the case gave
00:53:50
the impression pretty early in what I would consider to be a very unprofessional manner that they believed
00:53:57
Tony was simply on drugs and/or crazy so when you have that coming out of their department you really have to wander and
00:54:07
I'm sure a lot of people close to Tony are wondering the same thing is in fact if they were investigating the case
00:54:15
thoroughly if they were giving her disappearance the appropriate due diligence as you were saying law it's
00:54:22
pathetic that they would call her crazy because look if you break your arm what do you do you go to a doctor got
00:54:29
something broken in your brain you go get help for that so that to me that's a sign of somebody trying to get help I
00:54:38
think my gut is telling me that this there's more truth to this letter than not and and I couldn't tell you why but
00:54:49
it's like yeah I'm not ready to dismiss it as quickly as what it appears law enforcement has yeah the VIN number I
00:54:59
can't get over that and then also I don't know how much I buy the the ex-wife of the cop coming forward and
00:55:10
saying hey I saw a car similar to this I don't know but but those are two things
00:55:17
that line up mm-hmm and and that needs to be followed and it's sad because like you said this car
00:55:24
probably went to a chop shop there was probably evidence of there's probably evidence of what happened to
00:55:31
her and and that's gone forever and I I do know that some of that for her daughter
00:55:38
I do know that some of Tony's friends absolutely believe that Tony never left Willie Greene's house that night that
00:55:45
something happened to her there and it could be any number of things an overdose died in an accident was killed
00:55:54
as the result of some kind of physical altercation there was a pool there maybe maybe she drowned in the pool but you
00:56:02
know their belief is that in order to protect Willie Greene MBA salary and reputation that she and
00:56:09
her car were later disposed of and that's and we don't have the whole story there
00:56:16
well like Forrest Gump said it maybe it's both happening at the same time hmm is there a possibility that something
00:56:24
happens at this party they know a shady cop they call the shady cop hey we need your help
00:56:31
right or they call their lawyer their lawyer knows a shady comp that could shop the cop comes the cop that knows
00:56:39
some bad people that can help take care of this problem it could be both happening at the same time is anybody
00:56:46
there that night in some shape or form of a police officer right even from another city we again we don't have the
00:56:54
full list of names we actually had two people that were unnamed in our list and we're going off and saying that that is
00:57:02
an accurate list of people there could be additional people that were there that were conveniently left off of the
00:57:08
list provided to law enforcement my only issue with all that it's like I said she
00:57:14
would have had to drop her friend off and somehow circle back around because I do think that her friend started out
00:57:22
being a champion for finding her friend and so that's the part that doesn't line
00:57:30
up and unless possibly unless she drops her off and circles back round but you'd
00:57:35
have to obviously it would not be that hard to fabricate and manufacture the story of of Tony leaving ditching her
00:57:45
friend and her phone conveniently being off all at the same time right and and to work that into her story but to be
00:57:54
the one to come forward and ask for a polygraph test again I I we don't know what questions were on that test we hear
00:58:04
from law enforcement that she passed but we don't know what questions it's just a
00:58:09
sad scenario for for whatever reason once you put mental health in it it's I think people I think people were a
00:58:19
little too dismissive of of things regarding the private investigator Elaine law she is no longer so certain
00:58:26
that Tony is still alive she does still believe that Tony was that something happened to her and she was trafficked
00:58:34
she does believe that the sightings of Tony in the area were legitimate she does continue to follow up on leads and
00:58:42
tips to this day speaking there are there is some movement on this case as far as the private investigator is
00:58:51
concerned there are still some leads that she is working on it would be it wouldn't be appropriate to discuss those
00:59:00
here today because it's not something that we have a lot of information on but regarding Tony's parents her mother and
00:59:08
her stepfather they say they don't know what to think quote it's like a rollercoaster of
00:59:15
emotion Donna told one reporter they aren't sure that Krystle is telling the truth and they say that they have had no
00:59:23
contact with her but they also know that Tony should not have been drinking and could have been disoriented and gotten
00:59:30
lost and ended up in the river or elsewhere okay both of them feel strongly that it's a that a search of
00:59:39
Willie Greene's home should have been conducted when asked if she believes that her if her daughter is still alive
00:59:45
Donna says honestly no Tony would have called by now she always did well my granddaughter is the same way if she
00:59:56
doesn't call me I know something is wrong no one knows a child like a mother Tony stepfather agrees with his wife and
01:00:05
he has also stated that someone must know what occurred the night of August 23 2009 and he adds that she didn't just
01:00:15
vanish into thin air that there must be more to this story now Tony is still listed as a missing person the 10th
01:00:23
anniversary of her disappearance is next week we will have a photo of Tony on the
01:00:29
blog at true-crime garage dot-com tony's DNA has been entered into a national database so if at some point a body is
01:00:38
found she will be identified hats go off to her our friends and family and and then her parents you know now looking
01:00:47
after her her child and and and then also what an awesome individual to take on their case
01:00:57
the private investigator taken on their case for $1 and trying to make a difference
01:01:03
in this world that's pretty amazing [Music] whatever struggles you are facing from
01:01:15
depression and anxiety to trauma and grief but our help can connect you with a professional counselor and a safe and
01:01:22
private online environment it's so convenient you can even schedule secure video or phone sessions as well as chat
01:01:29
and text with your therapists and anything that you share is completely confidential best of all it's a truly
01:01:35
affordable option our listeners even get 10% off your first month with discount code garage so why not get started
01:01:43
simply go to better help calm slash garage and fill out a questionnaire to get match with the counselor you'll love
01:01:49
today that's better help calm slash garage how about a little recommended listening for
01:01:55
everybody this week this week I want to recommend the stitcher app you've heard it before it's free it's amazing it has
01:02:01
all of our old episodes on there to listen to and you can check out our other show our wonderful show that
01:02:08
everybody loves off the record it's available on stitcher premium I bring up the recommended listening captain
01:02:15
because this last weekend we were at the Ohio History Center and a lot of you came out and joined us there and we did
01:02:21
a discussion on Ohio cold cases which we've covered so many of them check those out on the stitcher app we will
01:02:28
see all of you back here in the garage next week until then be good be kind and don't live
01:02:34
[Music] [Applause] [Music]