Search Captions & Ask AI

The Bakersfield 3 /// Part 1 /// 562

October 27, 2022 / 51:26

This episode covers the case of the Bakersfield Three, focusing on the disappearances and murder of Micah Holsenbake, James Colstad, and Bailey Despot. The discussion includes details about their backgrounds, struggles with addiction, and the connections between the three individuals.

Micah Holsenbake, a father struggling with addiction, went missing in March 2018 after expressing fears for his safety. His mother, Cheryl, reported his disappearance but felt the police did not take it seriously.

James Colstad, a successful entrepreneur and father, was murdered in a drive-by shooting on April 7, 2018. He was known to Micah, and their social circles overlapped, raising questions about the connection between their cases.

Bailey Despot, a young woman with a troubled past, went missing shortly after Micah and James. Her family connected her disappearance to the other two, leading to the formation of the Bakersfield Three moniker.

The episode highlights the challenges faced by families dealing with addiction and the lack of attention given to missing persons cases involving individuals with substance abuse issues.

TLDR

The episode discusses the interconnected cases of Micah Holsenbake, James Colstad, and Bailey Despot, known as the Bakersfield Three.

Episode

51:26
00:00:11
thank you [Music] [Music] thank you welcome to True Crime garage wherever you are whatever you're doing thanks for
00:00:44
listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is a man that would like to remind us that all of mankind will kneel
00:00:51
before Zod here he is the captain it's good to be seen and good to see you thanks for listening thanks for telling
00:00:58
a friend [Music] this week we are very happy to be featuring warm hand Splash by the fine
00:01:08
folks over at dancing gnome this is a true celebration of Citra hops you'll get a citrus explosion of pungent
00:01:16
Grapefruit Tangerine and a hint of peach garage grade 4 and a half bottle caps out of five and let's give some thanks
00:01:23
and praise to our good friends for helping us fill up the fridge this week first up it cheers to Cynthia and West
00:01:29
Lafayette Indiana the Big O H goes out to Brandy from Akron Ohio here's a cheers to Amanda in O'Fallon Missouri
00:01:37
and a big we like Egypt to Susan in Carmel California next up Captain here's a cheers to Joseph in Xena Ohio or as I
00:01:46
call him Joey F and last but certainly not least we have Savannah and Kalispell Montana everyone we just mentioned well
00:01:53
they went to truecrime garage.com and they clicked on the Donate button and for that we thank you yeah we thank you
00:01:59
bwrun beer run make sure you sign up on our mailing list if you haven't then you
00:02:05
haven't been receiving the promo codes we send out every month we'll find you anyway and if you have signed up but you
00:02:11
haven't been receiving the emails that's because you put the wrong email in there
00:02:14
so you need to re-sign up and that is enough of the business all right everybody gather round grab a chair grab
00:02:21
a beer let's talk some true crime [Music] you go foreign [Music] River is a wild and Scenic River in the great
00:02:57
state of California that spans approximately 165 miles it drains an area of the Southern Sierra
00:03:05
Nevada mountains Northeast of Bakersfield fed by snowmelt near Mount Whitney the
00:03:12
river passes through Scenic canyons in the mountains and is a popular destination for white water rafting and
00:03:19
kayaking it is the southernmost major river system in the Sierra Nevada despite its remote source
00:03:28
nearly all of the river is publicly accessible in the summer of 2018 some recreational teenage swimmers in
00:03:37
the Kern River near Hart Park were met with a rather unpleasant surprise they found a duffel bag in the river
00:03:47
the bag was zipped shut and had some heft to it the weight of the bag had some of the
00:03:54
teenagers thinking that it could contain something valuable inside possibly even money
00:04:01
the teens eagerly opened the bag to investigate its contents to their disappointment the first item
00:04:09
they found in the bag was a sweatshirt well that makes sense a sweatshirt inside a duffel bag
00:04:17
s of possibly recovering jewelry or someone's lost stash of cash were fading as now it's beginning to
00:04:25
look like they simply found someone's lost gym bag but further investigation yielded a
00:04:32
rather strange find looking into the bag they could see what appeared to be raw meat
00:04:39
not a dead animal but it looked almost like something one might buy from the butcher shop
00:04:45
perhaps a raw chicken but wrong again nope boys that's not a chicken and of course here is the unpleasant
00:04:57
surprise reveal that you have been waiting for the strange item in the duffel bag was
00:05:03
actually a human limb it was a badly decomposed severed arm it was not possible to determine whether
00:05:13
the arm was cut off pre or post-mortem the arm had a black zip tie still on the wrist
00:05:21
and Marx indicating that the arm was removed with the use of a saw this horrific Discovery will not be the
00:05:30
start of our story but rather one confirmation of earlier suspicions three adults who traveled in similar
00:05:41
circles in the same town in the span of just one month were murdered or vanished
00:05:48
and feared dead those three were dubbed the Bakersfield three from a Reddit comment by Amador 9
00:05:57
a seemingly local individual sums up Baker's field and parts of Kern County California as they see it
00:06:04
and the comment reads Bakersfield is the antithesis of everybody's popular image
00:06:10
of California unlike the coastal regions Bakersfield is flat Dusty and a long way from the
00:06:18
ocean it is conservative poor and not the least bit fashionable Bakersfield was once a country music hot
00:06:27
spot but not anymore and drugs criminal activity and murder are nothing new to the region
00:06:36
exactly who was responsible for the murdered vanished and feared dead what exactly happened to them
00:06:46
this this true crime garage and this is the case of the Bakersfield three [Music]
00:07:08
at 34 years of age Micah holsen bake had lived a fairly normal and stable life he
00:07:16
was raised in Rosedale an upper middle class neighborhood of Northwest Bakersfield by parents Lance and Cheryl
00:07:23
with whom he was very close he was a normal even smarter than average kid spouting football stats and arguing on
00:07:31
the debate team a good student he graduated from high school and attended college for a year before deciding it
00:07:38
was not for him he joined the Navy but was discharged after he continued to suffer from growths in the back of his
00:07:45
throat which required surgeries he took a job as a bank teller and obtained his license to become a
00:07:53
financial advisor and was successful able to provide for his family a wife and a son
00:07:59
Micah was outgoing a bit of a jokester and generally happy but a rocky marriage and a subsequent
00:08:06
divorce contributed to a downhill spiral Micah had several throat surgeries and each time after was prescribed pain
00:08:15
pills after several Cycles through this surgery equals pain pills routine he became addicted
00:08:23
and in 2016 his life really started to change Micah's family noted a shift in his demeanor and attitude he lost not
00:08:33
only custody of his son but visitation rights as well which reportingly devastated him
00:08:40
he started to get into bar fights acting belligerent and unstable he took a leave from his job citing a
00:08:48
struggle with depression that was debilitating but eventually his employer became fed up with his absence and fired
00:08:54
him through all of this it didn't really seem to be depression that Micah may have been suffering from
00:09:01
Micah told his mom Cheryl that he was afraid he was in danger he said his mom wasn't sure of the exact cause
00:09:10
and he seemed to be suffering from paranoia but she was getting the sense that her
00:09:16
son had been threatened by someone he started to behave erratically and became unreliable and unpredictable and then
00:09:24
one day he was gone he was reported missing in March of 2018. yes on the 15th of that month Captain Cheryl his
00:09:34
mother dropped Micah in another unnamed person off in Bakersfield in a neighborhood
00:09:40
that was less than desirable in fact it was crime and Drug ridden she says that she never saw him again after that now
00:09:49
on the 17th Micah called his mom and asked or demanded for some money to help pay for a motel room for him and a
00:10:00
friend Cheryl says that she refused that they argued over the phone and eventually she
00:10:06
just hung up on him hotel motel Micah was seen on the 23rd by an extended family member crossing the street at
00:10:13
Mount Vernon Avenue and Flower Street this is near Kern Medical Center but then after that we don't have any more
00:10:21
sightings of Micah he seemed to have vanished from that point on friends started calling looking for him
00:10:29
and Cheryl and Lance's mother and father could not reach him at any attempt they
00:10:35
went to his apartment and got the landlord to let them in they say that everything was in order
00:10:41
when they went to his apartment now after about two weeks of not being able to reach him and finding that he had not
00:10:48
been in contact with anyone his parents filed a missing persons report and then unfortunately just kind of had to wait
00:10:57
and find out if the police could determine anything and they said quote we didn't hear back from anybody at the
00:11:03
police department this is what Micah's mom told bakersfield.com it seems police wrote Micah's disappearance off to him
00:11:12
skipping town to either avoid legal hot water or some other situation and after coming up with that hypothesis didn't
00:11:23
really investigate his disappearance the First Media report came out about Micah missing
00:11:32
on April 13 2018 so we already see a bit of a delay there as well the family was
00:11:39
obviously frustrated with the whole situation that they could not find their loved one and the lack of action by the
00:11:48
media by law enforcement but really this frustration Captain is just going to be
00:11:53
the beginning of the situation for Micah's family well it seems when we have somebody with some kind of mental
00:12:00
illness or drug addiction that the the media and the public they don't seem as concerned with these individuals
00:12:10
as as maybe uh just a normal person that went missing well or even let's take that a step further you say normal
00:12:18
person being missing I think we have to factor in here too this man is in his mid-30s and that probably has a lot to
00:12:26
do with law enforcement they're thinking look if he did skip town he skipped town
00:12:30
and there's probably a good reason for it so that's always a possibility here they may not have known the full extent
00:12:38
of the situation either sometimes when people were reported missing the people that report they're missing and I'm not
00:12:44
I don't know the situation here Captain so I don't want to put any blame on the family but if you are expecting action
00:12:52
make sure that you are very clear about what you believe is going on with that individual at the time of their
00:12:59
disappearance and here in this situation we have the mother who's later telling us the public that look
00:13:06
while he took a leave of absence from work citing depression maybe he was depressed maybe he wasn't
00:13:13
but he loses his job and Mom is saying I actually think that what is going on at this point is that
00:13:21
he is paranoid and we don't know if the paranoia is coming from the drugs or from him being threatened as she was
00:13:29
suspecting yeah or a combination of both yeah or a combination of mental illness
00:13:33
with drug use now we need to introduce another individual this is 38 year old James carlstad James was a successful
00:13:43
entrepreneur he opened up his own skate shop and got a patent for his torch trucks now for those of you that don't
00:13:51
know a whole lot about skateboards I know very little bit but I know that the trucks are on the bottom portion of the
00:13:57
skateboard and from what I understand here Captain this is pretty cool stuff torch trucks this patent that he he got
00:14:04
was a skateboard parts basically that enhance sparking when they're used on Rails so very cool kind of stuff there
00:14:14
kind of video game type stuff if you ask me it makes me think of Tony Hawk also he was a Bakersfield native James really
00:14:22
only worked his day job in order to afford his favorite hobby which was surfing now he also loved to gamble in
00:14:31
fact he was known to his friends as Joe Vegas yeah this year at crime con they're going to call me Captain Vegas
00:14:36
in the inflatable dates there you go Captain Vegas James has two young daughters one of them Cameron was raised
00:14:45
by her grandparents after her mom's death in a car crash when she was just 16 months old
00:14:51
but she and James were close and had sleepovers they watched movies and made cookies together they drove around
00:14:58
blasting music so even though she's being raised by grandparents it seems like the two were close and very good
00:15:06
friends but James like Micah had a problem he had broken his wrist in an accident and since 2016 was addicted to
00:15:16
prescription opioids he was given after surgery on his arm like many he quickly found that he could
00:15:24
not live without the drugs and his need for them escalated he turned to Fentanyl
00:15:30
patches and then to heroin his daughter Cameron recognized her dad's struggle with illicit substances after she saw
00:15:39
crushed up pills next to a rolled up dollar bill he started to disappear for days at a
00:15:46
time finally James did go to rehab but it didn't fully take and he continued to struggle and this has been such a
00:15:55
common sad reality for so many people and how quickly pain pill addiction can turn into heroin addiction or meth
00:16:04
addiction and this really to me is at kind of the height of all of that where you have these these pain pills in many
00:16:12
different forms and unfortunately all of them are highly addictive it's very easy
00:16:18
and very quick to get addicted to these types of drugs and then they become expensive or they're no longer available
00:16:25
to you so you start seeking out other ways to get that same feeling or to manage your addiction right and today
00:16:35
thankfully I'm of the belief that we're much more aware of this situation maybe the medical professionals should have
00:16:42
been aware of it before you think but at least today I feel like pain management
00:16:47
is structured differently than it would have been 10 years ago 15 years ago or as we're
00:16:54
seeing here even just five or six years ago now in James's situation one night that we need to talk about
00:17:03
here Captain is the night of April 7th this is when James left his mother's house his mother's Diane Burns he leaves
00:17:11
her house around 10 30. later that same night we're now talking 1 30 a.m he was in a car pulling out a driveway of a
00:17:21
residence in South Bakersfield when James crashed into a parked trailer on Cobble Mountain Road near Sandstone
00:17:31
Lane after the crash James somehow managed to stagger out of the wrecked car now this
00:17:38
is not going to be easy because he's in bad shape the car's in bad shape this is
00:17:44
one of those little Fiat cars and it's pretty smashed up too James is six foot five inches tall
00:17:51
so big boy yeah so getting a large man getting out of a small smashed up car is quite difficult from my understanding
00:17:59
Captain I believe he had to crawl or kind of squirm his way out of the passenger side door
00:18:08
to make this all the more difficult and all the more tragic the reason why he crashed his car is
00:18:16
because he was shot well that's a reasonable reason James eventually collapsed after
00:18:22
getting out of the vehicle he collapsed to the ground and his brother Ryan who was at the same house at the same
00:18:28
location that James was at earlier that he had left from he's leaving the area too same route
00:18:37
discovers his brother's car and his brother lying on the ground right and he finds his brother James basically at the
00:18:45
scene of this crash am I crazy to assume that he was shot while he was driving well there's a couple different stories
00:18:54
of this and it's been reported a little bit differently now it sounds to me I'm of that mindset that you are that he was
00:19:01
shot while driving there are some versions of the same story that he may have been parked temporarily now parked
00:19:09
temporarily does that mean that he was parked on the side of the road or at a stop sign or a stop light and somebody
00:19:15
opens fire on him but this is very much like the way that I kind of envision Biggie Smalls or Tupac right where the
00:19:25
the the car pulls up alongside of the other car and bullets are fired into the vehicle right unfortunately James
00:19:33
wouldn't make it he's not going to survive the situation in fact he bled out sadly with his brother Ryan at his side
00:19:41
who held him as he died this uh one bullet hole or multiple bullet holes I'm assuming he was shot multiple times
00:19:49
police later would call the incident a drive-by shooting now whatever vehicle that it was that fired the shots that
00:19:58
vehicle was gone so who would want to kill this mild-mannered easy-going Surfer guy Well
00:20:04
normally the the vehicle that shoots the other person they don't stick around to
00:20:09
talk to police true that uh police did not know who'd want to kill him and unfortunately no one was really talking
00:20:16
but police did catch on to something early in their investigation and what they found only raised more questions
00:20:24
the drive-by shooting victim James colstad knew the missing man Micah holsenbake
00:20:32
they ran around in the same Social Circles and James even helped Micah move residences just a few weeks before one
00:20:40
disappeared and then the other was gunned down so could The Disappearance of one young
00:20:45
father and the murder of another be connected or is it just some kind of tragic coincidence well our listeners
00:20:53
know that there are very few tragic coincidences in these true crime stories Michael went missing and was last seen
00:21:00
March 23 2018 James is murdered April 7th 2018. and now there's still another piece of
00:21:12
the puzzle that we have to introduce yeah that's correct and when we say you know there was no car the car that that
00:21:18
shot at James didn't stick around I think it's less that the car wasn't there when police showed up and more so
00:21:24
that when his brother arrives on the crash scene who's there within minutes of the
00:21:31
shooting right this car is still not there and the brother doesn't seem to know exactly what has happened to his
00:21:38
his older brother James and now we have the situation too Captain where police don't have any leads on on either
00:21:46
situation on The Disappearance of Micah or the murder of James but the one thing
00:21:52
that they can piece together and the problem with this is mainly that these two are running around in the same
00:21:57
circles and these are not the the best of circles to be in these are they're bad circles to be in my friend so yeah
00:22:04
these guys have bad jibs a lot of the people that know these two individuals and again they're adults they're in
00:22:10
their 30s so they're out living their own lives they're not under underfoot of their parents and their other loved ones
00:22:17
and they're both kind of removed from their their families you know their their children or their um in one case
00:22:25
an ex-wife so we don't have a lot of people to fill in those blank things other than possibly people that run in
00:22:31
these two circles now what we do figure out what investigators do figure out is the two know each other and that is of
00:22:38
importance because you have two situations missing murdered no one's really talking but aha at least we know
00:22:47
that they know a lot of the same people now in this third case this is going to bring us to our third person of
00:22:53
importance Bailey despot at just the age of 20 she's got her whole life ahead of her now Bailey grew
00:23:02
up in the middle class neighborhood of Rosedale we've heard that name before here's another connection her family
00:23:08
says Bailey could have done anything with her life she was beautiful smart and kind she was ambitious but also a
00:23:16
free spirit when she was young she was a member of the Future Farmers of America
00:23:21
someone who loved animals in 2016 now this is just a year after high school she ran away to Vegas and married her
00:23:33
boyfriend even though the relationship was volatile and according to some reports
00:23:38
abusive yeah so it was a relationships her parents obviously were not pleased about this marriage which predictably
00:23:47
ended quickly in 2017. Bailey however was devastated by this and things didn't seem to get
00:23:56
better for her she totaled her car and then was let go from her job and it's believed that Bailey thought that she
00:24:03
could find comfort in the arms of men and possibly drugs in early 2018 she moved in with a man that she was having
00:24:11
a relationship with a man more than twice her age he was 43 years old this man's name is Matthew Queen Bailey's Mom
00:24:21
Jane says she last saw her daughter when she stopped at the house she shared with
00:24:26
Matthew Queen to drop off some groceries this was on April 23rd but by just two days later Bailey had
00:24:37
dropped off of the face of the Earth no calls no text nothing Jane filed a missing person's Report
00:24:45
with the Kearns County Sheriff's Office but then she got a phone call it was Cheryl halsenbake Micah's mom and she
00:24:54
told her that her son too was missing Jane knew exactly who Micah was you see Bailey and Micah knew each other
00:25:04
it's hard to say exactly what their relationship was remember Micah was 14 years older than Bailey but we know that
00:25:13
Bailey started spending time in the same circles as Micah so we know that Bailey
00:25:18
knows Micah and Micah knows James correct but do we have any connection from James to Bailey well what we're
00:25:27
going to see is as we are able to find more information and continue with all three of their stories it's much like a
00:25:37
Quentin Tarantino picture man they all start to intertwine a little more as we go along well then I'll take a Royale
00:25:44
with cheese in July of 2017 we have Bailey who was actually arrested outside of Micah's house so
00:25:53
I mean just those documents that information alone proves that she knew Micah Micah knew her
00:26:00
she was charged with disorderly conduct in that situation apparently those misdemeanor charges were dismissed
00:26:07
and Micah helped Bailey file for a restraining order against an abusive new boyfriend this was in August of 2017
00:26:15
which the restraining order was granted but these incidents were just the beginning of a precipitous decline for
00:26:23
bayley a decline into drugs and unsavory company three weeks after getting that restraining order
00:26:32
she told her parents that she was drugged at a party she was drugged with a spiked drink and
00:26:38
then gang raped she started going off on multi-day Benders and resurfacing with stories of being kidnapped
00:26:48
she would call in all hours of the night pleading for help and asking to be picked up but sometimes she's calling
00:26:56
asking to be picked up and she doesn't know where she is sometimes she had no shoes or
00:27:01
possessions when her family got to her her sister recalled one night when two cars drove up
00:27:08
and picked Bailey up her sister Caitlyn said that Bailey clearly did not want to
00:27:14
go with whoever was waiting for her in the driveway as soon after that this is when she
00:27:20
ended up with that Matthew Queen in December of 2017 while out one night Matthew Queen and Bailey were pulled
00:27:29
over by police now cops found four loaded guns including an AR-15 in the car Matthew Queen was charged with six
00:27:39
counts of possession of a firearm by a felon possession of ammo by a felon and possession of an assault rifle
00:27:47
Bailey pled no contest to misdemeanor weapons charges of carrying a loaded gun and carrying
00:27:54
concealed weapons she received three years probation and then moved in with Matthew Queen and get
00:28:02
this Captain this is where it gets I mean it's a weird story already but gets a little more bizarre she moves in with
00:28:08
Matthew Queen and Matthew Queen's estranged wife and Matthew's mother they're all in one
00:28:15
house right not not weird at all ooh a new form of The Brady Bunch Matthew Queen had quite a police record
00:28:24
yeah you think including a stint in the early 2000s in federal prison on gun charges now this is from an appeals
00:28:32
court ruling quote between late December 2000 and July 2001 Queen purchased 39 firearms from federally licensed dealers
00:28:42
in the state of Indiana the guns cost more than eleven thousand dollars and at least 11 of them later were recovered at
00:28:51
crime scenes in the Detroit and Chicago areas gun sale records linked the purchases back to Queen end quote so
00:29:00
he's buying up guns in different states and then he's selling them to terrible horrible people and these guns are
00:29:08
finding their way to crime scenes and then police are able later to track these guns back to him yeah follow the
00:29:16
[ __ ] Chrome so Bailey's living with this guy who could not stay away from guns big
00:29:22
illegal ones at that and after April 25th 2018 no one could get a hold of Bailey and she was
00:29:30
reportedly pregnant at the time oh man Bailey was last seen by her mom on the 25th at a house she and Matthew Queen
00:29:39
shared this again when Jane dropped off those groceries that we already mentioned right at that time she said
00:29:47
Bailey opened the door and thanked her mother but then said that she had to go Jane never talked to her again
00:29:55
after a few days she went to the house and was told by a teenage boy who lived there that he hadn't seen Bailey so she
00:30:04
reported Bailey missing to the authorities [Music] [Music] all right we're back to the windows to
00:30:47
the walls cheers everybody cheers and if you're looking for something to do come
00:30:52
hang out with me and Barbara from truth and Justice we're going to be doing a live event and meet and greet up in
00:30:59
Grand Rapids Michigan April 16th you can find out more information on my website
00:31:05
captainfighthands.com there you go and I want to give a cheers and a my thoughts
00:31:11
and hopes and heart and prayers are going out to the people in and around Ukraine I admire your courage your
00:31:18
bravery and your resolve may God be with you all please now back to our story here Captain the first story the first
00:31:27
news story that came out about Bailey appeared on June 8th now this is after Bailey was missing for nearly six weeks
00:31:37
we have KGET which did gangbusters reporting on this case in fact such gangbusters
00:31:45
reporting that a reporter went on the Dr Phil show to talk about the Bakersfield
00:31:52
3. Now reports that Matthew Queen told police he last saw bayley at a neighborhood near Palm Avenue and Renfro
00:32:00
Road and he says she was in the company of a Hispanic male he also made multiple Facebook posts
00:32:08
saying that Bailey ran away and accusing her mom of trying to pin it on him when
00:32:14
bayley just skipped town he insinuated that perhaps she had harmed herself saying that Bailey was
00:32:21
off her meds that she was depressed and she wanted to die in one of his posts He also mentioned
00:32:29
that he knew Micah with that Cheryl holsenbake said it was very obvious this is Micah's mother it was
00:32:37
very obvious that it was not a coincidence and people out there know something definitely not a coincidence
00:32:45
and again you run in circles with people abusing drugs and you're running in circles with criminals it's a recipe for
00:32:55
disaster yeah the the situation is exactly as you said very Bleak two missing one dead and now of course with
00:33:03
the three being kind of linked together you have the fear by loved ones and and Friends searching for these other two
00:33:13
that Unfortunately they may have already succumb to the same conclusion the same
00:33:20
fate that we had in the drive-by shooting case so one month after Micah goes missing his mother Cheryl her phone
00:33:31
rings it was Diane Burns James's mom she told Cheryl her own son had been killed in April and he seemed to know
00:33:41
many of the same people as Micah who was missing the two moms realized that their
00:33:48
kids their grown children both ran in the same circles the moms formed a united front and
00:33:55
forced law enforcement to listen to their detailed connections between the children the adult children
00:34:02
Diane and Cheryl told law enforcement quote something's not right our sons knew the same people then when Bailey's
00:34:11
missing posters start going up they pulled Jane into their little ring after Lance recognized Bailey's name as
00:34:21
rumors connected to his son's disappearance well like you said I mean this is all happening within 30 days of
00:34:27
each other yes about 33 days to be exact when we from start starting point to the
00:34:35
final person of the three being reported missing so we have the family that's coming forward
00:34:43
and they're saying look person a knows person B person B knows person C that these three are all somewhat connected
00:34:51
and somehow they're connected we don't know how yet but they ran in the same circles and they're now proving to
00:34:58
police that person a does in fact know person B and something terrible happened to both of them and person B knows
00:35:05
person C and something terrible has happened to both of them and so you can see how this is kind of filling in some
00:35:12
of the blanks for law enforcement also now we have people that are are going to be come
00:35:21
into to more question here Captain right when you start to see the same names in
00:35:26
these victims lives over and over again well those people are moving up your priority list of people to interview and
00:35:33
possible suspects one also there are drug users and so they're going to be coming in contact with more people so
00:35:40
they're a little more unpredictable as far as their routines go and they're going to probably come in contact with
00:35:48
more random people than the than the average citizen would right so we have a situation where Micah knows James Micah
00:35:57
knows Bailey and now we have the family saying that look all three of these people all three of these individuals
00:36:04
knew each other it was all one big interconnected circle of people yeah the mothers the three mothers named their
00:36:13
kids Collective case the Bakersfield three that's where that name comes from and the moniker took off in the media
00:36:22
normally once there's any reporting of the victims using drugs it seems like the public and
00:36:30
the media kind of disappear from looking into those cases harder but but the three mothers in this case were
00:36:38
they're not going to let this go They're not going to just let this die out of the Public's eyes no the the three moms
00:36:46
and their families made it their quest to find their children or their children's killers they did not believe
00:36:54
that their case is all falling within one month and with all three knowing each other
00:37:00
that they could be anything other than connected Bailey's Family offered a six thousand dollar reward in Bailey's case
00:37:09
and posters plastered all over the neighborhood with photos of all three victims the Bakersfield three seeking
00:37:19
information and the moms started to compare notes Micah's mom said that before his
00:37:26
disappearance her son had become paranoid well that's definitely a red flag he said someone had threatened him
00:37:32
and he feared for his safety now his mother did too this after she learned that he was selling drugs
00:37:39
she told bakersfield.com quote my mom instinct is that he found himself in over his head she said she dropped
00:37:50
Micah off in a sketchy part of town and he vanished Cheryl started to believe he
00:37:56
had been killed James's mom felt the same way Diane told KGET that a lot of the people that were
00:38:06
hanging out with him were doing drugs and that he hung out in the same circles as Micah now she tells Dr Phil quote I
00:38:16
believe my son was set up to be murdered end quote well they're using dangerous drugs but they're also surrounding
00:38:24
themselves with dangerous people yeah Bailey's living with somebody that has has all kinds of weapons charges against
00:38:31
him now I hope nobody in the Bakersfield area needs a backiotomy because we're about to talk about one bad chiropractor
00:38:40
by September 2018 there was some news in the case the house in front of which James had been shot
00:38:49
belonged to a chiropractor his name is Dr Suki bajwa and this guy wasn't exactly the model of
00:38:59
professionalism documents filed with the Chiropractic board reflected that the doctor was in some legal trouble in fact
00:39:07
he had to surrender his license to practice because on October 7 2016 Bakersfield PD responded to a call about
00:39:18
a vehicle smashing into some parked cars they saw bajwa and a woman walking quickly from the scene walking away from
00:39:27
the scene in an alley when they stopped him Boswell denied being the driver or the owner of the car
00:39:33
that was smashing into the park cars he said he was just a passenger but the car
00:39:39
was registered in his name and seat belt burns on his body showed that he had in
00:39:44
fact been in the driver's seat and cops noted that he exhibited signs of being under the influence of a
00:39:52
controlled substance this included slurred speech bloodshot eyes droopy eyelids nodding and the
00:40:00
inability to stay alert the female passenger the unnamed female passenger did in fact tell police that bajwa was
00:40:08
driving the vehicle and that he had even asked her to lie for him well bajwa your
00:40:14
pants are on fire we're not just talking about a DUI here Captain because when cops searched the car they recovered two
00:40:23
Firearms a Smith and Wesson M and P AR-15 and a Heckler and Koch mp522 long range rifle with a faux
00:40:34
suppressor both rifles had high capacity magazines that contained live ammunition right a
00:40:42
records check revealed the Firearms were not registered and Dr bajwa was arrested
00:40:48
and then convicted of three misdemeanors in connection with the DUI crash and guns bajwa was sentenced to well 10 days
00:40:58
in jail that's what you get when you're real bad but he did get three years probation and
00:41:03
he had over two thousand dollars in fines then in May of 2017 bajwa was arrested
00:41:10
again this time police officers were dispatched to a suspicious activity incident
00:41:16
bajwa was the front passenger in a vehicle and stated that he had a loaded capped syringe in the interior of his
00:41:26
left jacket pocket police recovered a syringe filled with a dark brown liquid substance believed to
00:41:33
be liquid heroin officers also found a bottle containing several Xanax pills in addition officers located two additional
00:41:41
yellow oval shaped pills which later were identified as hydrocodone after this arrest Boswell pled guilty to
00:41:52
both selling drugs and carrying a loaded gun again another slap on the wrist 180 days in jail three years probation
00:42:01
and another five yeah it's a pretty pathetic sentencing so it was at this Shady guy's house the chiropractor's
00:42:10
house that James was cited at on the night that he was killed this was the home that he was in the process of
00:42:17
leaving when he's gunned down we know that because again remember his brother Ryan was at the same location
00:42:24
he's the one that tells that to the public and he told that to Dr Phil when he was on his show
00:42:30
now here's what he tells Dr Phil he says Ryan says that I was at Dr bajwa's house
00:42:36
that night supposedly they were eating pizza and watching some movies with a group of
00:42:41
people and Ryan said that bajwa owed James money his brother James the doctor owes
00:42:49
him money for what we don't really know but it was not a small amount of money oh probably hand
00:42:56
jobs and Cracker Jacks could be I don't know that bajwa it sounds to me like he wasn't able to practice practice at this
00:43:03
time he's already been arrested twice and again at some point his license was revoked now what we do know though
00:43:11
Captain is that Ryan tells us that his brother James was coming to bajwa's house to collect
00:43:19
that large amount of money and Bourgeois tells Ryan hey tell your brother he better not come here I'm
00:43:28
going to have my boys over and they're going to be strapped Ryan relayed the message to his brother
00:43:35
and the two have an argument Ryan then left to drive someone else home and then returns to Boswell's house
00:43:43
he says maybe approximately 90 minutes later so James was in the driveway at this
00:43:51
time when Ryan returns at this time James then pulled out and did a u-turn and pulled in behind a
00:43:58
parked car Ryan still driving toward the house here's shots here's gunshots he ran to his brother but it was too
00:44:08
late James was lying on the ground after crawling out of the vehicle bleeding Ryan maintains that all he saw was a
00:44:16
silver car he denied to Dr Phil that he knows who shot his brother he did say he
00:44:23
suspected bajwa of engineering the shooting obviously based off of the threats that bajwa told him to relay to
00:44:31
his brother earlier that night yeah a lot of bad people in this case and he can smell it yeah people who carried and
00:44:40
used guns possibly dealt guns manufactured guns and traded in guns and so the connection here is with James and
00:44:49
the story of the doctor owing him a large sum of money yeah one could easily draw a line from one dot to the other
00:44:56
and say well maybe that money was for drugs but I actually think that it was probably for guns and or maybe some
00:45:05
illegally and or maybe for some illegal gambling again we know he's Joe Vegas and then we have Micah's involvement in
00:45:20
guns and we know that they all know each other now Lance Micah's father said his
00:45:26
son had told him something before he vanished something Lance didn't believe at the time he said quote I'm putting
00:45:35
together guns I'm going here and putting together guns for people and quote Lance
00:45:41
thought his son was exaggerating and was just paranoid at that time later he's going to grow to believe that
00:45:49
this means something that this is some indication of the truth and some kind of peek into Micah's personal life Lance
00:45:58
says that when Micah told him this information again he thought he was exaggerating maybe even paranoid but he
00:46:03
also told him hey if if you're doing that kind of stuff it's easy you just stop you you can get
00:46:09
out please stop and get out and he also said if you're afraid of people then you need
00:46:14
to stop and get away from them but Micah said to his father I can't do that I'm afraid for my family
00:46:22
Lance said to KGET news quote Micah was mixed up for the first time in his life and things that were illegal so it's
00:46:31
logical for police to think he got out of town he's hiding out end quote but he wasn't Lance's younger son started
00:46:43
asking around and the name Bailey popped up yeah the holson bakes didn't recognize that name at first but then
00:46:52
within a week or so they started to see missing persons Flyers with Bailey's name and photo
00:46:59
they realize Bailey despot missing person was the same woman who was now somehow linked to Micah
00:47:08
Lance astutely said that he was pretty sure what had happened to Micah the same thing happened to Bailey because she
00:47:18
knew what happened to Micah of the Bakerfield three were put in themselves In Harm's Way by
00:47:26
one using dangerous drugs and then being around a dangerous group of people whether it's within the drug Community
00:47:34
or you know the drug Community is also connected to other criminal communities and whatever happened to these three
00:47:43
we're not saying they deserved any of this at all on any level at all what we're simply saying here is that if you
00:47:50
put yourself in a bad situation enough times it's only logical that something bad may happen to you it's not victim
00:47:57
blaming it's unfortunately the way that the world works and if you have any other beliefs other than that
00:48:04
well you're wrong all right let's Circle back to something that we talked about in the trailer here
00:48:10
Captain remember the teenage swimmers in the Kern River they find that duffel bag floating in
00:48:16
the river or somehow find it in the river thinking that it may have contained money they open it they find the
00:48:22
sweatshirt inside and unfortunately find a badly decomposed severed arm well that
00:48:28
was the summer of 2018 and we need to fast forward to December of 2018. this is when testing
00:48:37
testing revealed that the arm belonged to Mica one of our victims that we're talking about he was officially
00:48:44
classified as deceased and officially classified as the victim of a homicide it was not possible to determine whether
00:48:53
the arm was cut off pre or postmortem said the pathologist but the arm had a black zip tie still on the wrist and
00:49:02
marks that indicated that the arm had been cut off using a saw searches of five miles around the spot where the
00:49:11
arm was found this is near Highway 178 Unfortunately they were fruitless searches but police came out and said
00:49:21
that the case bore marked similarities to Bailey's disappearance definitely which is a little confusing to me but
00:49:29
we're going to continue to dive into this right now per bakersfield.com who we've continually cited here in this
00:49:36
case they State quote those similarities included they State quote those similarities
00:49:42
include Witnesses locations and evidence end quote the Bakersfield PD took over Bailey's case from the Kern County
00:49:52
Sheriff's office after the two agencies compared notes and discovered the commonalities between the two cases
00:50:00
by mid 2019 police acknowledged that all three cases making up the Bakersfield 3
00:50:08
were in fact connected foreign [Music] we have so much more to get to on episode two and if you haven't left a
00:50:30
five-star review on iTunes for the colonel and the captain then then you need to do so right now just stop
00:50:38
the episode and go over there shame on you Shame Shame yes so join us back here tomorrow for more True Crime and until
00:50:46
then be good be kind and don't [Music] thank you [Music] [Applause] foreign

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most heartbreaking
  • 70
    Most shocking
  • 70
    Biggest twist
  • 60
    Most emotional

Episode Highlights

  • Micah Holsenbake's Struggles
    Micah's life spirals after addiction and personal loss lead to his disappearance.
    “Micah told his mom he was afraid he was in danger.”
    @ 09m 04s
    October 27, 2022
  • James Carlstad's Fatal Night
    James is shot in a drive-by while leaving his mother's house, leading to tragic consequences.
    “James eventually collapsed after getting out of the vehicle.”
    @ 18m 24s
    October 27, 2022
  • The Bakersfield Three
    Three individuals connected by tragedy in Bakersfield, California, face mysterious fates.
    “Could the disappearance of one young father and the murder of another be connected?”
    @ 20m 42s
    October 27, 2022
  • Bailey Despot's Turmoil
    Bailey's life takes a dark turn after a series of personal crises and poor choices.
    “Bailey could have done anything with her life.”
    @ 23m 10s
    October 27, 2022
  • The Bakersfield Three
    Three missing individuals connected by a web of relationships and drugs.
    “Something's not right.”
    @ 34m 05s
    October 27, 2022
  • Mothers Unite
    The mothers of the missing boys form a united front to seek justice.
    “I believe my son was set up to be murdered.”
    @ 38m 16s
    October 27, 2022
  • Dangerous Connections
    Micah's involvement in illegal activities raises concerns for his safety.
    “Micah was mixed up for the first time in his life.”
    @ 46m 26s
    October 27, 2022
  • The Discovery of Mica's Arm
    Testing revealed that a severed arm belonged to Mica, a victim classified as homicide.
    “This is when testing revealed that the arm belonged to Mica.”
    @ 48m 37s
    October 27, 2022
  • Connecting the Cases
    Police found marked similarities between Mica's case and Bailey's disappearance.
    “The case bore marked similarities to Bailey's disappearance.”
    @ 49m 21s
    October 27, 2022
  • Bakersfield 3 Connection
    By mid 2019, police confirmed that all three cases were connected.
    “By mid 2019 police acknowledged that all three cases were in fact connected.”
    @ 50m 00s
    October 27, 2022

Episode Quotes

  • This horrific Discovery will not be the start of our story.
    The Bakersfield 3 /// Part 1 /// 562
  • It seems police wrote Micah's disappearance off to him skipping town.
    The Bakersfield 3 /// Part 1 /// 562
  • No one was really talking.
    The Bakersfield 3 /// Part 1 /// 562
  • Something's not right.
    The Bakersfield 3 /// Part 1 /// 562
  • I believe my son was set up to be murdered.
    The Bakersfield 3 /// Part 1 /// 562
  • Micah was mixed up for the first time in his life.
    The Bakersfield 3 /// Part 1 /// 562

Key Moments

  • Bakersfield's Reality06:33
  • James's Murder19:35
  • Missing Persons24:42
  • Drug Issues26:23
  • Unraveling Connections47:26
  • Severed Arm Discovery48:25
  • Victim Identification48:37
  • Connection Acknowledged50:00

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown