00:00:00
foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] welcome to True Crime garage wherever you are whatever you are doing thanks
00:00:45
for listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is a man who was born to love volcanoes here is the captain
00:00:52
it's good to be seen and it's good to see you thanks for listening thanks for telling a friend
00:01:00
[Music] we are drinking dream pillow by the good folks over at Jackie O's this is a
00:01:07
delicious hazy double IPA that is citrusy creamy and hoppy ABV a solid nine percent you can find dream pillow
00:01:16
wrapped in purple and blue tripped out can art don't stare too long or you will be transported to another dimension now
00:01:24
let's give some garage thanks and praise first up a big cheers to Lynn in Dallas
00:01:30
Town Pennsylvania and a big we like your jib goes to Jen from New Hampshire and here's a long distance cheers to Oscar
00:01:37
in didcot United Kingdom a big shout out to AJ in Olympia Washington and here's a
00:01:44
double cheers to Greg and candy in Mesa Arizona and last but certainly not least
00:01:49
everybody we have a shout out to Rachel and San Antonio Texas everyone we just mentioned went to True Crime garage.com
00:01:57
they helped us out with this week's beer run and for that we thank you thank you
00:02:01
guys so much for filling up the fridge and when you're at the website check out our t-shirts we launched a couple new
00:02:08
ones we launched a couple old ones we have a couple hoodies in stock we have the snuggy sweaters are back we have a
00:02:16
a Frank shirt I think and if you don't know who Frank is then get out of here and that is enough of the business all
00:02:26
right everybody gather around grab a chair grab a beer let's talk some true crime
00:02:36
thank you foreign [Music] [Music] [Music] foreign this week we travel across the sea to the Emerald
00:03:27
Isle to look at an ongoing missing person's slash death investigation case in Northern Ireland
00:03:35
but this isn't your average case of someone going missing and turning up murder in this case no one is really sure what
00:03:45
happened here and the victim is a juvenile a child who simply went out for a bike
00:03:53
ride to meet friends and ended up dead in the strangest of places and in the oddest of circumstances
00:04:02
one detective called this the strangest case he'd seen in his over 30-year career
00:04:10
this is true crime garage and this is the suspicious death investigation of Noah Donahoe
00:04:20
[Music] on Sunday June 21st 2020 Noah Donahoe age 14 set off on his bike around 5 30
00:04:43
pm to meet friends at Cave Hill Country Park this is in Belfast in Northern Ireland Noah was a pupil at Saint
00:04:52
malaki's College a private Catholic boys School founded in 1833 according to the
00:05:00
Irish news Noah was meeting a group of school friends to work towards his Duke of Edinburgh award now the Duke of
00:05:07
Edinburgh award is a Civic self-improvement award given to young people who complete the requirements of
00:05:15
each level at noaa's age the four requirements would be community service mental skill building physical
00:05:22
Recreation nation and adventurous Journey this last one requires that an adventure be completed with a group of
00:05:30
kids working together which was pre-approved by an award leader when Noah left the house he had a large
00:05:39
backpack containing his laptop and some books he anticipated needing for the day's activities Noah is regularly
00:05:47
described in the media as a talented cellist at school he played rugby and basketball and sang in the choir he was
00:05:56
an exceptional student and received multiple Awards in the three years at the school including the spirit of the
00:06:02
college award the perfect attendance award and various class prizes that Sunday afternoon Noah never showed up at
00:06:11
Cave Hill Park yeah now Noah's mother is going to plead with the public for any information about her son his
00:06:18
disappearance was completely out of character for him and it seems that the police recognized right away that
00:06:24
something was wrong once they received the report that he was missing Noah was widely described as last seen wearing a
00:06:32
black skateboarding helmet a khaki green North Face jacket gray sweat shorts with an emblem on one leg a
00:06:42
tie-dye blue hoodie Nike sneakers with a bright yellow swoosh and a khaki backpack Noah's missing person's case
00:06:51
became big news in Belfast with people holding vigils and participating in searches in fact according to the
00:06:58
Belfast telegram his case became one of the biggest missing persons cases in the
00:07:04
history of Northern Ireland on the day that he disappeared on that Sunday searches Sunday night and Monday
00:07:11
focusing on the area he was believed to have been heading to Cave Hill Park came
00:07:17
up empty but on Monday night police received news that a woman named Karen Crooks called in she had heard all about
00:07:24
the missing boy as it was all over the news right she told police that on Sunday night so this was right after
00:07:32
Noah went missing he left his home at 5 30 p.m she found a black Apollo mountain
00:07:39
bike lying in the road at her North Wood Road home this is a residential area so at the
00:07:47
time you know she just assumed some neighborhood kid left his bike and would come back and get it later right she
00:07:54
left it in front of her house and went to work on Monday morning it is an odd place to find a bike maybe you'd see one
00:08:02
on the sidewalk we don't know the area so we don't know if there was sidewalks or maybe you'd find a children's bike
00:08:09
and in somebody's yard but in the street I think that's a little uh suspicious so
00:08:15
on Monday she heard about Noah from the news and the description of his bike a black Apollo mountain bike so when she
00:08:24
went home she finds that the bike is still in her yard no one's come to retrieve it
00:08:31
she called the police at 7 pm and on Tuesday police confirmed that it was in fact Noah's bike so police now
00:08:40
had an idea where Noah had gone note this Northwood Road neighborhood is totally residential and is nowhere it is
00:08:50
nowhere near the park where Noah was supposed to be going his his supposed destination yeah I wonder
00:08:57
how familiar he was with riding to the park this was actually two and a half miles away from Cave Hill and no one had
00:09:06
any idea why Noah would be in that particular area one thing that Irish crime Fighters have at their disposal
00:09:14
that is of tantamount to this case in cases like this is CCTV cameras all over the place right the Police Service of
00:09:25
Northern Ireland psni was able to put together a timeline of where Noah went and when by compiling CCTV footage from
00:09:35
businesses and homes I believe they had over 20 pieces of video footage with Noah on it yes so this was from 22
00:09:45
different sources and they were able to watch nine full minutes of Noah's Journey this was broken up footage from
00:09:52
22 different cameras that captured Noah as he went past by utilizing the time stamps on the footage they were able to
00:10:01
track his travels that Sunday evening here are their official findings one note before we get into the route Noah
00:10:09
took that day Noah's home address where he lived with his mother Fiona has not been published right media Outlets like
00:10:17
Belfast live have published maps showing the different points where Noah was seen
00:10:22
on CCTV that afternoon and they placed the starting point at the intersection of apsley Street and ormeau Avenue
00:10:32
and I'm going to spell those just in case I'm not pronouncing them correctly that's
00:10:37
a-p-s-l-e-y Street and o r m e a u Avenue the bike ride to Cave Hill from this area is 6.7 miles so it would take
00:10:51
Noah over an hour to get there and like you said he's not in the area he's supposed to be that that is one of the
00:10:59
biggest mysteries of this case yes and there's no real reporting about whether Noah had biked to this area before
00:11:09
or if he was even used to such long bike rides by himself so we don't know if he's familiar with this area where he's
00:11:18
not supposed to be right the Irish news reported that it was thought that Noah may have taken a wrong turn you know
00:11:25
simply got lost from his home in South Belfast on his way to Cave Hill and ended up in the Shore Road Northwood
00:11:34
area where his bike was found instead but how many times have you been driving or riding your bike or or whatever
00:11:41
you're doing you make a wrong turn because you think it looks familiar and then for a mile or a few miles you're
00:11:48
going okay now this doesn't look familiar right and so you just keep going like I'm going to see something
00:11:54
pretty soon that that makes me realize I'm going in the right direction but you just don't well and this is just last
00:12:02
summer when this boy vanished so keep in mind Noah had a phone with him and he's
00:12:08
a smart 14 year old if he made a wrong turn one would think he would just use a map app to obtain directions regardless
00:12:16
a wrong turn even if that's the case it's certainly logical but if that's the case it does not
00:12:23
explain him Vanishing right let's go through the timeline presented at the August and
00:12:30
November preliminary hearings okay so to be clear with everyone they have held these hearings to try to determine what
00:12:40
happened in this case this is not a trial this is simply people getting together and trying to decipher what
00:12:49
happened in this particular situation the timeline is as follows Noah left his home in
00:12:57
South Belfast on Sunday June 21st at 5 41 pm on his bike he had on his jacket and his backpack he
00:13:05
then traveled along or may you rode at 5 42 PM towards the city center before cycling through Victoria Square at 5 49
00:13:15
PM then he hit corn Market High Street and Royal Avenue this at 5 50 p.m so several different roads traveling pretty
00:13:24
fast Along on his bike covering a decent amount of ground Noah was then seen traveling alongside the art college near
00:13:32
the corner of York Street and Frederick Street at 5 53 pm CCTV footage shows Noah traveling toward
00:13:40
York gate by which stage Noah is clearly seen to no longer be carrying his backpack weird stuff he's not interacted
00:13:49
with anybody he's simply traveling on his bike and when we get to this clip we can't see a backpack he's no longer
00:13:58
carrying his backpack Noah then traveled along York Street crossing great Patrick Street and the
00:14:05
motorway which is another word for their Highway before turning left onto Brougham Street and then right along
00:14:13
North Queen Street at 5 57 pm moving toward the north of the city this part is not on CCTV but came from a witness
00:14:24
statement saying that at 6 PM as Noah cycled toward the Grove well-being Center on North Queen Street and York
00:14:33
Road he fell from his bicycle just before the junction with the Shore Road a motorist stopped at the intersection
00:14:43
witnessed this it seems she did not actually talk to Noah because Noah got back on his bicycle
00:14:53
within one minute and continued a Long Shore Road at this stage he was no longer wearing
00:15:01
his green Overcoat he continued along York Road cycling in a normal way according to the Barrister
00:15:09
presenting the timeline one minute later at just before 602 PM Noah was seen entering Northwood Crescent from skego
00:15:20
Neil Avenue he was wearing his black skate helmet blue hoodie gray shorts and black Nikes
00:15:28
then because a story involving video surveillance footage would not be complete without a glitch in the time
00:15:35
stamp there was an initial Gap in the timeline it was reported to the public that the
00:15:42
next sighting of Noah on CCTV was at 6 11 pm I think we're now a hundred percent and the cases we covered on
00:15:49
their CCTV where something is wrong there's a time stamp is normally wrong correct it would be abnormal if they're
00:15:57
a hundred percent correct so what we have here is the the initial reporting at these hearings is stating hey there's
00:16:06
nine minutes unaccounted for where Noah is not visible we don't know what he's doing who he's with if anyone at all
00:16:14
this Gap in the timeline was enough to cause all sorts of rumors conspiracy theories
00:16:21
including that Noah could have been abducted and had fallen victim to a child molester or even been kidnapped in some
00:16:30
politically motivated plot against British loyalists but this was all eventually addressed by the psni this is
00:16:40
a statement from one of the hearings says quote police have since confirmed that the 1811 timing is wrong
00:16:49
the time stamp on the actual footage is 1808. police misunderstood at the time of its retrieval that the clock on the
00:16:58
CCTV was three minutes slow and hence the reported actual timing of 1811. police Now understand the clock on the
00:17:08
CCTV to have been five minutes fast hence the new last sighting timing of 1803. these timings will be evidentially
00:17:17
verified at the full inquest but it's very strange I mean we have these gaps in time but the fact that he's leaving
00:17:25
his book bag behind the fact that he's leaving his jacket behind uh we can't say for 100 certainty that he had no
00:17:33
interaction with somebody because we don't have obviously every second of his travel that day
00:17:42
there's yeah that's correct we don't have every second of his travel however what this means per the statement is
00:17:50
that there is in fact no Gap in the footage at all the next sightings of Noah are at 603 PM why yeah and I and I
00:17:59
think what they're implying is we don't think there was any interaction because there's no time Gap showing that he
00:18:06
would have stopped to interact with somebody correct correct and again from the official statement this is for the
00:18:13
next stage in the timeline at 603 PM Noah is seeing a short distance away outside of 85 Northwood Road without any
00:18:23
close he is seen on this CCTV to go between numbers 89 and 91 Northwood Road which
00:18:32
leads to an area of waste ground behind the two houses this is a wooded area behind the neighborhood okay
00:18:41
just to recap no real Gap in the CCTV footage footage pulled from 22 cameras where we can see Noah traveling Along on
00:18:52
his bicycle however there are articles of clothing that seem to be disappearing as he continues on his Adventure so
00:19:01
that's making any sense first the backpack then his his jacket yeah and then to the point where he's he's
00:19:11
visibly naked right so he's then seen walking in this residential neighborhood naked
00:19:21
the CCTV footage that captured this was from a camera on the Northwood Road home
00:19:26
of elinda Patterson so we are at this point no possessions no clothes and his bike is gone at this point correct now
00:19:37
Linda Patterson um which her CCTV captured this footage she said that she was sitting in her living
00:19:47
room watching television when she saw Noah bike past and he was not wearing any clothes at this point she says that
00:19:55
she called to her husband but by the time he got into the room and they looked again out the window the boy was
00:20:02
gone and they saw his bike just lying in the street she said to the media quote quite a few
00:20:10
people saw him but they just saw him from the waist up and didn't think anything of it end quote Yeah they
00:20:16
didn't see his dingle dangle she also said that the boy did not seem to be in distress in any way at all but again
00:20:23
this is a very quick sighting out a window here right this is the last footage showing Noah Donahoe before he
00:20:32
vanished but here's what we do have those we do have at some point that we know that there's a mistake between law
00:20:39
enforcement and the information on the CCTV so I think some people wonder is there possibly more mistakes that law
00:20:46
enforcement just didn't catch yes uh Linda's house the eyewitness her home appears to be a condo with multiple
00:20:54
units in one larger building this is also a cul-de-sac Noah had last been seen between numbers
00:21:04
89 and 91 the address is 89 and 91 Northwood Road one of these is the home of Karen Crooks
00:21:12
she's the woman who found Noah's bike and later reported it right so Noah was there
00:21:19
biking naked this is not a situation where the child was abducted at some point and
00:21:25
somebody dumped the bike off in this neighborhood we have eyewitnesses and footage putting him there before he
00:21:33
disappears and now simply it's a bike in the street none of the footage however actually
00:21:41
shows him removing his clothing at any point it's reported that police believe Noah
00:21:47
left the area on foot they did not suspect Foul Play Because in all of the footage they reviewed which seemed to
00:21:55
account for Noah's Journey from his home to where his bike was found he was not seen interacting with a
00:22:01
single person but regardless no one knew where he went after the last sighting on Northwood
00:22:08
Road foreign [Music] [Music] we're back cheers mates cheers to you Captain I want to give a cheers out to a
00:22:44
good friend of ours Larry Finley passed away within the last week so it's with a
00:22:49
heavy heart that we we give a big cheers and a big toast to Larry Finley he joined the U.S Navy and served this
00:22:57
great country from 1959 to 1963. afterward he had a 35 year career in law enforcement where he served as a
00:23:06
patrol officer a detective and a court liaison officer and he was one of the first dare
00:23:13
officers in the state of Ohio he was my DARE officer he was the DARE officer at our school when we were kids so he was a
00:23:22
damn good guy and he will be dearly dearly missed by all so cheers to the Finn all right Captain back to the
00:23:31
information at the hearing it was reported to the court that on Wednesday Noah's helmet
00:23:39
was found by a member of the public on Northwood Road on the same day his hoodie and shoes
00:23:47
were discovered by a member of the public lying on a wall at 63 Northwood Road clearly
00:23:56
he had discarded his clothing and then gotten back on his bike and I'm saying that with a question mark
00:24:03
at the end and where were the rest of his clothes you know we we don't have his jacket his
00:24:10
shorts so now that the police knew that that Noah was biking along naked and the
00:24:17
witness had reported seeing him fall off his bike people began to speculate that
00:24:22
perhaps Noah suffered some kind of head injury during this fall you know we reported he was wearing a
00:24:28
skating helmet but regardless theories about it that perhaps he suffered some kind of
00:24:34
concussion underneath the helmet the fall from the bike and the motorist saying that he may have hit his head is
00:24:41
what led police to believe Noah might have been disoriented got lost or was simply hiding
00:24:49
the psni superintendent Clark said quote the one thing we are majoring on is that
00:24:57
he has in some way suffered a head injury which led him to being disoriented an appeal was made to the
00:25:05
public to please search their homes Gardens garages outbuildings and surrounding areas for the boy police
00:25:13
said we still believe he may have gone into an empty building or shed foot searches supported by an aerial unit
00:25:21
police dogs and a Tactical Team covered the area thoroughly as well as local volunteers but they still could not find
00:25:29
the boy they couldn't find Noah the fall from the bike could not explain one thing
00:25:35
Noah shedding his backpack and coat because this would be before the fall right and it also does not explain the
00:25:44
direction he was traveling in this is not the direction he should be going in by the time he fell off his
00:25:50
bike he was in a location he had no business being in that anyone knows of and it's far from his
00:25:58
alleged destination okay so then you asked about the backpack on Friday June 26th it was announced that police
00:26:07
recovered his backpack here's what happened a known drug addict his name is Daryl Paul age 33 found the backpack he
00:26:17
says leaning up against a wall we don't know exactly where he ransacked it and he tried to sell off some of the
00:26:26
items he found inside of the back packet like a they call it a cash converters shop but
00:26:32
I imagine it's like a pawn shop mind you there's the laptop computer inside this
00:26:36
backpack this was two days after Noah went missing on June 23rd for unknown reasons the store refused to buy it Paul
00:26:47
was arrested that week on unrelated charges and was sitting in jail meanwhile this is bizarre an anonymous call to
00:26:56
police informed them that Daryl Paul was in possession of the computer backpack and school books with missing child Noah
00:27:04
Donahue's name on them so they don't find these items on this dude when they arrest him on unrelated charges he's
00:27:14
sitting in a jail cell because of these unrelated charges as unrelated arrests and magically an anonymous phone call
00:27:22
comes in saying hey remember that missing kid that we still haven't found this dude had some of this kid's
00:27:29
belongings police are going to search his home to try to find these items or hopefully even find the boy and they did
00:27:38
recover the backpack and the books they then recovered the laptop from a friend of Paul's I guess he said that he
00:27:48
he loaned it to his friend or maybe possibly trying to sell it to the friend again we look at these cases and we say
00:27:56
if you could have just you know one question answered this case you're going to have a whole long list of them but
00:28:04
here at this point in the timeline I would be fascinated to know who called in this anonymous tip about these
00:28:12
belongings this lead is strange too because it turns out there was no possibility that Daryl Paul had anything
00:28:21
to do with what happened to Noah and this is per a police statement quote CCTV footage confirmed that the
00:28:28
individual who took the bag was a number of miles away when Noah was last seen with the bag at or about the art college
00:28:37
right this individual is being investigated for the offense under the Theft Act and the police will deal with
00:28:46
this manner separately so Paul per CCTV footage they can put this guy at a completely different
00:28:54
location miles away from where this boy was when his backpack disappears off of his body off of his person on the CCTV
00:29:04
footage right according to statements made at the preliminary hearing Noah's phone was discovered within a few days
00:29:12
of his disappearance this was near a playground on North Queen Street a citizen found the phone and turned it in
00:29:19
it was reported that both the phone and the laptop were undergoing forensic examination as one would expect although
00:29:27
initial investigation did not discover anything useful or any useful information on either of the devices
00:29:35
right we don't have any record of him making connection with somebody through these devices yeah it
00:29:42
doesn't seem to be communicating with anybody uh as far as we know he's not looking up a map app to indicate that
00:29:49
he's aware that he's lost again we also don't have any communication of why he would be in that area and not heading
00:29:58
towards the park so as you'll recall the final piece of the CCTV footage showed Noah walking naked
00:30:05
near a house on Northwood Road where his bike was found searches of the area at the time turned
00:30:13
up nothing but by Thursday police seemed to be on to something and we say that because
00:30:19
by that Thursday they are now asking everyone to stand down on their public searches remember they were asking the
00:30:26
public for help for information and for them to search their their properties right they're now asking the public to
00:30:33
stand down on Saturday June 27th six days after Noah was last seen there was news police found Noah's body at 9
00:30:45
45 a.m in a storm drain complex underneath the Shore Road area search and rescue teams had been
00:30:52
searching the complex apparently for several days captain psni superintendent Clark made a public
00:30:59
statement saying quote while we have no official identification we believe it is
00:31:04
the missing teenager Noah Donahoe Clark asked the public to stop spreading baseless rumors about Noah being
00:31:11
murdered stating that said he did not believe Foul Play to have been a factor yeah I don't think there was any uh
00:31:17
puncture wounds like bullet holes were he wasn't stabbed with a knife or anything right we do have
00:31:24
some information from the autopsy it was conducted and rumors flew that Noah had
00:31:31
been murdered placed in the storm drain system to hide the body yeah look my issue with this examiner saying people
00:31:39
shouldn't question things so much in this area they did have people that were being
00:31:46
harassed and stocked online so that's not out of the norm for the public to have some questions about that we have a
00:31:55
we have a missing child that we have on film basically um removing all his belongings it just
00:32:06
doesn't add up correct and the thing that we have going on here too is the baseless rumors that the investigators
00:32:14
are telling the public hey can you please stop with this this is not helping our investigation at all because
00:32:19
what you have here Captain is we know that his bike was found on Northwood Road and then we have the public
00:32:27
statement of well we tracked him via camera footage to where his bike went was found
00:32:34
and then about a week later we find him in the storm drain complex it's it's it will go through the storm drain
00:32:44
complex here in a little bit but we find his body in this area what you have is you have accusations by people online
00:32:52
who are saying okay well this person that lives on Northwood Road they must have killed him and abducted him and
00:32:58
killed him this person that lives on this street must have done this right and that's not helping their
00:33:05
investigation at all I I'm just saying that I I don't think it's uncalled for for the a community that knows that
00:33:13
people are being harassed online and stalked online to have questions so the autopsy again with the rumors and
00:33:22
everything like that of course they're looking for Foul Play and the police suspected that Noah may have suffered a
00:33:28
head injury resulting in this unusual behavior the coroner was also looking for any signs of head trauma or head
00:33:36
injury the results of the autopsy were startling to many it was found that the cause of death was drowning Noah had
00:33:44
drowned in the storm drain system or appears to be that way right and to make things even more puzzling it was also
00:33:51
revealed that he did not sustain any severe head injury in fact there was no detectable head injury at all according
00:33:59
to the BBC coroner Joe mccriskin said there is no evidence that Noah was attacked or that any other person was
00:34:09
involved in his death he also expressed concern about continued baseless online speculation about the incident now what
00:34:18
about uh his mental health do we know if he's on any medication or do we know if
00:34:23
he was ADHD or anything like that it does not appear that he had anything of concern because if if he had like
00:34:33
severe ADHD or something like that and they had him on a high dose of something that maybe his parents stopped giving
00:34:42
him or maybe he stopped taking he could be having symptoms of like withdrawal which would make sense on why he was
00:34:53
taking his clothes off because one of the symptoms of a of a drug withdrawal would be that you feel like your body's
00:34:59
on fire correct correct um let's go through that storm drain system here because
00:35:06
anybody that's not familiar with this case they're probably just picturing this boy being found in a ditch
00:35:14
somewhere you know a large puddle of water so to speak so the storm drain system and also let's try to figure out
00:35:23
how he got there because this is not what you're picturing if you're not familiar with this case the police
00:35:27
believe that Noah entered the storm drain of his own accord this is something he would have to physically
00:35:32
get into yeah and they say the police say that they know exactly where he went in now we don't know exactly how they
00:35:42
quote unquote know this but they figured out that he was in the drain system and
00:35:48
went into search for him and ultimately retrieved his body there's an obvious location where he could have entered if
00:35:56
you believe that he's entering the nearest to where his bike was found so that's that could be how they quote
00:36:02
unquote know that he entered the storm drain system at this location I don't think anybody knows anything in
00:36:09
this case is why I'm using air quotes there um yeah nobody nobody knows anything no
00:36:14
well nobody can see that you're making Eric quotes except for me but um I think the thing here the evidence that they're
00:36:21
just not pointing out which is obvious is that there's latches with locks on these storm drains so process of
00:36:31
elimination if all of them are locked going forward you know the next five are locked and the five behind us are locked
00:36:40
but this one isn't I think that's where they know the point of entrance yeah so remember Karen Crooks the nice lady who
00:36:48
found Noah's bike and reported it the entrance to the storm drain where it is believed that Noah went in is at the
00:36:56
bottom of her yard behind her home now this is not a manhole or one of those small under the curb openings like
00:37:05
we see in our cities here in the U.S this drainage system is massive it's a maze of underground tunnel spanning one
00:37:13
kilometer and the drains themselves are huge yeah I'm I'm not saying that looks just like
00:37:20
this but if you think of like Stephen King's It you know it's exactly what I thought of you know the dairy uh sewage
00:37:27
system that's that's what I'm imagining these have been described as culverts carrying underground waterways and the
00:37:36
entrance behind the crooks home is a very imposing looking opening photos of the access point to the storm drain
00:37:44
system it is thought that Noah entered are available online the entrance is a very large concrete opening that
00:37:53
descends into the ground almost resembling the entrance to an underground tomb or maybe a crypt
00:38:00
and the opening is topped by a very imposing iron barred grate clearly intended to keep people out
00:38:10
so the great intended to keep people from going into the drain system at first there was some question as to
00:38:17
whether Noah could fit through the bars Karen Crooks said her small boys their ages are five and seven told her when
00:38:28
they were discussing the case that they were able to squeeze through and had done so the Bars were seven and a half
00:38:35
inches apart now according that's according to the Irish news keep in mind Noah's 14 he's not five or seven so I
00:38:44
think it's highly doubtful that Noah could fit through such a small opening and as the captain pointed out I don't
00:38:50
know he's I mean he's real thin well as you pointed out we would later learn that this great
00:38:57
it was unlocked yeah so it's intended to keep people out but if you don't put a lock on it it's the same as any unlocked
00:39:04
door anybody can walk through the thing right this is could just simply be a tragic coincidence
00:39:10
I guess the complex had been inspected on June 18th just three days before Noah died but the inspection failed to note
00:39:19
that the access hatch was not locked right so on June 21st when Noah had for unknown reasons decided to enter the
00:39:29
storm drain it was unlocked the infrastructure officials placed a padlock on it on June 24th this is after
00:39:37
they discovered that the police were considering whether Noah could have gone into it yeah three days after this is
00:39:43
three days too late so again from the from the Publix perception right you had this boy who went into what should
00:39:51
appear to be a locked great and it's going to be be reported as such now you're wondering how did he
00:39:58
magically end up in there and then you find out well it was only locked just before they found him it wasn't locked
00:40:06
on the day that he went missing wait hold on did you smell that lawsuit so once it was established where
00:40:13
Noah accessed the storm drain system it took police several days to find his body the Waterway tunnels
00:40:21
were pitch black inside and it took many twists and turns the psni superintendent Clark told the media
00:40:29
that the storm drain system searches were quote extremely challenging well and what's going to be very challenging
00:40:36
here is even if they say he died from drowning again like we've talked about the case yesterday fire destroys
00:40:44
evidence water destroys evidence equally yes in the superintendent included this
00:40:50
in his statements about finding the body saying in my 30 years in the police this
00:40:57
is one of the most unusual missing person inquiries that I have dealt with at the second preliminary hearing this
00:41:06
was on August 28th the coroner addressed the court with his findings about the storm drain system and Noah's demise
00:41:13
this is quoted from the Belfast live quote today in conjunction with the police and my Council I am providing
00:41:21
some details which was which will dispel the many baseless and inaccurate rumors
00:41:27
which continue to circulate today I will set fact against fiction to me it seems
00:41:33
likely that Noah entered the storm drain to the rear of 85 Northwood Road by lifting a metal drain cover which at
00:41:41
that time was not secured I have examined the drain cover as have police officers and it seems entirely possible
00:41:48
for Noah to have been able to lift that cover and enter the drain system at that
00:41:54
location end quote the coroner described the drain as running underground from Northwood Road to Shore Road and again
00:42:03
with him being found over a kilometer away from the entrance this is a pretty big underground tunnel system yeah I
00:42:10
mean he had a you know it took him days to find him but also could he have gone down there and again we don't have
00:42:18
pictures of this location so could he have kept traveling when he got down down to the system without going through
00:42:27
all the actual points and different roads and stuff because I think it will just get confusing here in this audio
00:42:33
format that we have but there are maps online to one show you his journey that he took on his bicycle right before
00:42:42
going missing and there are also maps that will show the different entrance points to this underground Waterway
00:42:49
tunnel system I will post those on our website and also post those on social media Instagram at True Crime garage
00:42:57
Facebook at True Crime garage and Twitter at True Crime garage but something that's incredibly important to
00:43:03
understand here is the environment within the drain system itself it's described as of course challenging
00:43:10
there's a lot of twists and turns the drainage system there it it backfills with water during
00:43:17
intervals between low and high tides so what we have here is the storm drainage system is tidal the water
00:43:27
levels would ebb and flow with the tides right it would be entirely possible for
00:43:32
someone to enter the drain when the water level was low or even very low thinking that it would not pose any type
00:43:40
of danger only to get trapped down there when the tide rushed in on July 6th Fiona this is Noah's mother issued a
00:43:50
statement that read in effect at this time we are working with the psni on matters which are outstanding to
00:43:59
the investigation and we are seeking answers to questions which arise Noah's disappearance and death undoubtedly
00:44:07
raise questions however public speculation in theory is unhelpful we are dealing with the facts okay here's
00:44:15
some questions one we don't know why he was gone in the direction he was going in and not
00:44:22
towards the park that doesn't make any sense we have some time gaps but we don't think that he was communicating
00:44:29
with any individual what could happen during those time gaps we have those questions because sometimes we have
00:44:36
items missing from them but we don't have video footage of him actually discarding those items other question
00:44:43
why does he get off his bike next question he's naked why and then what was the reason for going into the drainage
00:44:53
system was that because he was naked right you know and he was looking for a place to oh I don't have any clothes I
00:45:01
need a place to hide and then like you said the the tide comes in and he he drowns or was he
00:45:09
having some kind of break was there some medical issues he was having that maybe
00:45:14
his parents didn't know about maybe classmates knew about I mean the only reason why I say that possibly a symptom
00:45:22
and we can't even say for sure that it was a symptom was like that he would feel like he was burning because why
00:45:30
else would you take off your clothes right so as far as like misdiagnose like a disease or something it is a symptom
00:45:39
uh rare symptom of Ms I think there's even some stuff to do with um diabetes and stuff but again like I
00:45:48
said did he have some kind of attention deficit disorder where they pulled him off his medication or did he have a
00:45:55
mental thing that he was on some kind of Narcotics that they pulled him off and he started going into some withdrawals
00:46:01
and just didn't know how to handle himself I mean he's only 14 years old well in some people that have never
00:46:06
heard of this case are probably asking why is the garage covering this one well first of all it's been requested highly
00:46:14
requested yeah and then second of all for a week while this child was missing it was considered by the public to be an
00:46:21
abduction and possibly a murder right then he's found then the autopsies conducted to to confirm that he drowned
00:46:29
and it's believed he drowned in this drainage system well a good amount of the public still
00:46:34
question what the hell happened here and so we have to look at this put it under
00:46:39
the garage microscope and wonder if there was a crime that was committed here now on August 9th
00:46:48
his mother put a post on to Noah's Facebook page that says why do we not all wake up my
00:46:58
son died we have no answers we have nothing please start questioning why I have no answers that same day a petition
00:47:08
was circulated on change.org and this petition was people requesting that the psni they're questioning the
00:47:19
investigation itself and psni's handling of Noah's case this petition got 22 500
00:47:27
signatures in just two days so there's a lot of people that want to know what the
00:47:34
hell happened here right because and let me put my tin hat on but the world we live in is not the
00:47:43
world in which they just tell us about and what I mean by that is just because they say that you know the walls are
00:47:49
blue sometimes you're looking at the walls and you go those damn walls are red but everybody's trying to tell me
00:47:54
they're blue and that's why I was saying it's the CCTV footage accurate and is the information that law enforcement uh
00:48:02
is putting out to the public is that accurate and if it is accurate then then there was no communication there was no
00:48:10
nobody else involved there was no Person of Interest that he came in contact with
00:48:16
but you you have to start with believing the information that has been given well
00:48:22
and many people have stated that the autopsy did not yield results um that anybody felt good about many
00:48:30
people believe that the autopsy itself which we're only able to report a little portion of it I I don't know could not
00:48:39
find what I believe believed to be the complete autopsy to have been released right so and then we've seen in multiple
00:48:46
cases hold on I smell him a little farmy Malik we know in in plenty of cases of suspicious deaths or
00:48:56
possible murders where the autopsy is they don't make a lot of sense or there's errors I mean we saw that in uh
00:49:05
Kendrick Johnson's case we see that with um like the boys on the tracks case yeah
00:49:10
but I think that's quite a accusation there to be no I'm just saying that I'm just saying that there's people in the
00:49:16
public that will question that because of those cases because of the the rumors that they've heard about other uh Foul
00:49:24
Play I'm not saying that you should assume that the autopsy wasn't done correctly or that there was some weird
00:49:31
workings of the autopsy I'm just saying that that's because of other cases people go we still don't have any
00:49:39
answers right well was this autopsy done correctly was the investigation done correctly
00:49:46
do the parents actually know but they're they're hiding something from us yeah and you're right many people have have
00:49:52
put forth the idea that the autopsy only presents more questions than it did answers
00:49:59
there was to be an inquest in the case of Noah donahoe's death that was set for this week in fact
00:50:08
it was set for Monday January 18 2021 it appears that that has been postponed because of
00:50:18
the covet situation so now what they're saying is and I'm gonna pull up this article here because
00:50:27
this is a very fluid situation again there was supposed to be a preliminary hearing
00:50:33
where they were going to go through everything all the facts of the case just earlier this week what statements
00:50:42
have come from that is that one it's to be postponed there is some type of further hearing which I don't understand
00:50:49
the difference in what these hearings are and I'm not going to pretend to uh but what I'm seeing here Captain is
00:50:57
that a further hearing will be conducted on April 12 2021 so this year however the formal
00:51:05
final inquest will be held January 10 2022 per that we're going to be left with with little in the way of answers
00:51:17
until we have that uh I guess that final formal inquest that final formal sit down yeah this is definitely a case that
00:51:27
we're going to need to revisit on off the Record and it's it's just really sad I mean you
00:51:32
got a kid a young kid that's intelligent good looking kid again it's just there's
00:51:38
so many questions why is he heading in that direction why why is he taking his clothes off why is he taking his
00:51:45
belongings and just tossing them aside all the way down to where he's not even on his bike he's on nothing and then he
00:51:51
goes into a draining system and why is that system why was it unlocked well and and I can only go what off off of what
00:52:00
I'm reading and what I'm seeing and it does not appear that anyone's denying or questioning if the grate itself was
00:52:09
unlocked it seems to be pretty understood across the board that that happens to be the situation what is
00:52:17
completely bizarre and I think you know I saw somebody post this and I think this is the the only way to describe
00:52:26
this case in this situation we we had the Chief Inspector who says this is the most bizarre missing persons inquiry
00:52:37
that I've seen in my 30 years on the force but take that a step further the best way to describe this is someone
00:52:43
said this case is a real head scratcher and that's exactly what it is this case is fascinating to me I have no freaking
00:52:51
clue what happened in this situation because we can say things like well maybe there was a mental break okay
00:52:59
there's no history there's no evidence leading up to this event of that that we've been made aware of
00:53:07
that we can say what about drugs what about a toxicology report there doesn't seem he doesn't seem to
00:53:14
have been a drug user number one and number two there is no report of of what was found or not found in the
00:53:23
boy system the thing here for me Captain is it's question after question after question
00:53:31
to get to this result there's no answer after answer after answer and this is what we have no it's he said he was
00:53:40
going one place he ended up in an entirely different place he had the means and the resources to correct his
00:53:48
route if he realized at any point he was lost right then we have his personal items and clothing seem to
00:53:56
be disappearing right before our eyes all of this stuff comes off of his person but yet at no point on any of
00:54:04
this camera footage now mind you there's tiny little breaks you know it's 22 cameras piecing together nine minutes of
00:54:11
his travels but it's boom he's fully clothed backpack helmet everything next picture
00:54:18
no backpack next picture no jacket and then to the point where he's naked his he's off of his bike none of this makes
00:54:27
any sense at all and I I can't I cannot sit here and say that I believe that a crime was committed I can say that I
00:54:36
that 100 there is a huge mystery before us I feel bad for Noah and I feel bad for his parents and the community and
00:54:45
and hopefully by April we have some more answers yeah this case is so intriguing
00:54:50
because it's it's just so bizarre it's perplexing it's tragic by all accounts Noah was a lovely boy he and his mom
00:54:59
were very close he was someone that would not be expected to behave in such a strange way
00:55:06
at least as far as the mainstream media has reported there were no background issues that would indicate that Noah was
00:55:15
anything but a normal teenager being raised in a loving household even attending a rigorous religious school
00:55:22
and working on being the best that he could be so what on Earth happened to him that day is anyone's guess at this
00:55:29
point and no Theory makes complete sense I've reviewed all the popular theories online and I can
00:55:36
poke holes in every single one of them rather quickly it is very interesting and it will be very interesting to see
00:55:42
whether the inquest is able to provide us with any answers foreign [Music] for our bonus show called off the Record
00:56:02
download the Stitcher app it's on Stitcher premium and for all of our old episodes they're free on the Stitcher
00:56:10
app thank you guys so much for listening thank you so much for telling a friend see you back here in the garage next
00:56:17
week for a new off the Record and a new case until then be good be kind and don't lose foreign
00:56:32
[Music]