Search Captions & Ask AI

Princess Doe ////// 594

November 16, 2023 / 01:05:20

This episode covers the unsolved case of Princess Doe, a young woman found murdered in Blairstown, New Jersey, in 1982. The hosts, Nick and the Captain, discuss the details surrounding her discovery, the investigation, and the various theories about her identity and circumstances of her death.

Princess Doe was discovered on July 15, 1982, by a gravedigger named George Crease. She was found in a wooded area near Cedar Ridge Cemetery, wearing distinctive clothing. The hosts describe her injuries and the autopsy findings, noting that she had been beaten and had died from blunt force trauma.

Throughout the episode, they highlight the community's efforts to give her a proper burial and the ongoing investigation involving multiple law enforcement agencies. They mention the facial reconstructions and the various theories about her identity, including a possible connection to a missing girl named Diane Die.

The discussion also touches on the confessions of Donna and Arthur Krenlaw, who claimed responsibility for her murder but whose statements did not align with the known facts of the case. The hosts emphasize the lack of leads and the importance of public awareness in potentially identifying Princess Doe.

Listeners are encouraged to share information and images related to the case, as the investigation remains active and unsolved nearly 40 years later.

TLDR

The episode discusses the unsolved murder of Princess Doe and ongoing efforts to identify her.

Episode

1:05:20
00:00:00
[Music] is it possible to predict the unpredictable can 3D printed life-size organ models help to map out complex
00:00:07
surgeries ahead of time is it possible it already is right here Mayo Clinic you know where to
00:00:15
go when it comes to Quality sleep Ashley has you covered with top mattress brands
00:00:20
at winning prices and with special financing options available you can snooze now and pay later plus your
00:00:27
mattress purchase helps give the gift of better sleep to children in need and US
00:00:32
Special Operations forces visit your local Ashley store or shop online today and make every snooze count financing is
00:00:41
subject to credit approval see store or ashley.com for details [Music] [Music] welcome to True Crime garage Wherever
00:01:29
You Are whatever you are doing thanks for listening I'm your host Nick and with me as always is a man who knows
00:01:35
that at any moment a $20 scratch off could dramatically change his life here is the captain yeah flicky flicky on my
00:01:43
way to thousands and thousands of dollars it's good to be seen and good to see you thanks for listening thanks for
00:01:49
telling a [Music] friend this week I am chair dancing because we are featuring a beer by one
00:02:00
of my absolute favorite producers of beer today we are drinking hazy Heights IPA tropical smooth This Is by The Brew
00:02:09
Masters over at Highland Brewing Company in beautiful Asheville North Carolina this baby is plump with hazy notes
00:02:17
tropical fruits like pineapple and mango which smooth out the bitterness of this
00:02:22
IPA which features five different kinds of hops 7.5% ABV available in cans and kegs garage grade four and a half bottle
00:02:34
caps out of five and here is a shout out to some of our garage friends who I hope
00:02:39
are listening in and chair dancing to the captain's latest Music Creation first up a big cheers to Kimberly in
00:02:46
Lewis Center Ohio a big shout out to Wendy and Star Idaho next up here's a cheers to Brandy from Pittsburgh PA and
00:02:55
a big shout out to an in Tucson Arizona next up we have a cheers to Thomas and chapen South Carolina and last but
00:03:02
certainly not least we have Ryan and Boise Idaho everyone we just mentioned well they went to our website which is
00:03:10
true Crim garage.com clicked on the little tip button the Donate button the beer fund button and helped us out with
00:03:18
this week's beer run and for that we thank you yeah BW R you in beer run if you need more True Crime garage for your
00:03:25
earballs do it right now stop what you're doing cuz I'm about to ruin the True Crime podcast that you're used to
00:03:32
check out our show cut off the Record and you can do so at True Crime garage.com there's a link right there
00:03:39
Colonel that's enough of the be all right everybody gather around grab a chair grab a beer let's talk some true
00:03:49
[Music] [Music] crime [Music] princess doe was found July 15th 1982 in Blairstown New Jersey she was
00:04:26
given the name of Princess so she would not be just another Jane Doe next week will be 40 years since her
00:04:37
body was discovered and there are so many out there that still hope and pray that one day her headstone will bear her
00:04:46
real name after the gruesome discovery of her body and as time marched on in 1982 princess doe remained unclaimed in
00:04:55
the morg for 6 months the good people of Blairstown pulled together their financial
00:05:02
resources for a proper burial for the girl today she lies in Eternal rest in the
00:05:10
Cedar Ridge Cemetery steps away from where her half clothed body was found down a wooded embankment on that muggy
00:05:21
summer day to this day princess Doe's true identity Still Remains unknown her name forever imprinted in cyberspace on
00:05:33
the Warren County prosecutor's office cold cases website The Headstone placed at her current resting spot was paid for
00:05:43
by local donated funds The Headstone simply reads princess Dove missing from home dead
00:05:52
among strangers remembered by all born question mark found July 15 1982 this is drwr
00:06:12
[Music] garage there are several law enforcement agencies involved in the investigation
00:06:26
into figuring out who princess Doe is who princess doe was and who is the perpetrator of her murder I will read
00:06:36
directly from the prosecutors website so that we don't misconstrue any of the facts here and from the Warren County
00:06:45
prosecutor's website it states unidentified female known as Princess doe a deceased female was found on July
00:06:52
15th 1982 in waren County New Jersey her body was found behind Cedar Ridge Cemetery
00:06:59
on Highway 94 located in Blairstown the female had been deceased for less than a week prior to being
00:07:07
found she is 15 to 20 years old she was petite standing approximately 5'2 in tall and weighing 110 lb now keep in
00:07:19
mind those are both approximate numbers on the weight and the height her left earlobe was double pierced but no
00:07:26
earrings were found it is unknown if if her right ear was pierced or not the female had been treated by a dentist at
00:07:34
one point in her life as a few Dental fillings were observed in her teeth she was found wearing a red v-neck short
00:07:42
sleeve shirt and a long red wraparound skirt that had peacocks pictured around the lower hem border she was also
00:07:51
wearing a gold chain necklace that had white beads along the chain and an ornate cross pendant images of the skirt
00:08:01
and cross are featured on the prosecutor's website and we will put that on our social media the thing that
00:08:08
we need to point out here too Captain is that facial reconstruction was completed
00:08:13
by the national Center for missing and exploited children forensic artist and depicts what the female or princess doe
00:08:22
may have looked like in life so we have those sketches we have those artist renderings of what they believe princess
00:08:31
do may have looked like another interesting thing is that she had red nail polish on her right hand only and
00:08:38
that she had no known surgical scars or distinguished birth marks or tattoos well at least this is what we know of
00:08:47
her body we don't know if there were scars or any marks on her face because she was so badly beaten in the face I
00:08:54
want to cite a wonderful story that was put together by a Natasha Mullins on the
00:09:00
website medium.com and Natasha titled her article about the princess do case she
00:09:08
titled it the woman who lies dead among strangers it's a really good read I recommend that everybody check that out
00:09:15
on medium.com I'll read a portion of it here which gives a little more description on the discovery of the body
00:09:23
of the remains and this is titled a brutal discovery which it exactly that's exactly what it was and it reads Cedar
00:09:33
Ridge Cemetery is a small Cemetery nestled in the forest of Blairstown New Jersey off of Highway 94 Blairstown was
00:09:41
a farming Community home to just over 5,000 permanent residents in 1982 and was a quiet little town without
00:09:50
many disturbances on July 15th 1982 George crease a Gravedigger for Cedar Ridge Cemetery was walking through
00:10:01
a wooded area towards the rear of the cemetery when he came across a horrific Discovery lying face up on the bank of a
00:10:10
creek bed was the decomposing body of a young woman she was wearing a red t-shirt and a red peasant skirt was
00:10:18
folded across her legs her face had been bludgeon to the point that it was unrecognizable and a gold cross necklace
00:10:27
was Tangled in her hair Cree notified the police immediately and an investigation began no identifying
00:10:34
possessions were found on the body of the woman and because of how she was found the case was immediately
00:10:40
considered a homicide an autopsy concluded that she had died of blunt force trauma to her head but the weapon
00:10:47
use could not be determined she was found without undergarments but no evidence of sexual assault could be
00:10:53
confirmed because of the state of the decomposition so the killer unfortunately did did not leave any
00:11:00
collectible DNA behind at the crime scene there was no evidence of drugs in Jane Doe's system but the medical
00:11:08
examiner initially reported that there was alcohol in her system it was later discovered that decomposition had made
00:11:16
her blood ferment which made it impossible to determine if she was intoxicated at the time of her death
00:11:23
however it was clear that she wasn't incapacitated during the attack because there were defensive wounds to her arms
00:11:31
and hands she had fought back against whoever attacked her it was initially estimated that Jane Doe later named
00:11:39
princess doe had been in the graveyard for two weeks but later investigators have changed this number to just a few
00:11:46
days I guess the moist air around the creek likely sped up the decomposition and as well as the hot muggy days making
00:11:54
it appear as though she had been there for a longer period of time what we have stated here in this article Captain is
00:12:02
that July 11 July 11th is the approximate date of Princess Doe's death although it is uncertain as to what the
00:12:12
exact day is the other thing that complicates this thing of coming up with the time of death or the date of death
00:12:19
here for princess doe is the article points out that moist air around the creek the location of the cemetery where
00:12:26
she's found plus it's hot muggy days it's July this all kinds of speeds up the process the decomposition process so
00:12:35
while we know that that would speed it up it gets difficult to even determine when she was placed there MH so we don't
00:12:43
know how much of the decomposition was actually sped up in her situation I mean we could be talking about any number of
00:12:51
situations going on here it's a real mystery and and unfortunately there's not a whole lot of breadcrumbs to lead
00:12:58
us anywhere here in this case I mean we could be talking about think about what we spent
00:13:03
so much time talking about here in the garage recently the America's Highway serial killers some of these victims
00:13:10
were transported hundreds of miles if not a thousand miles away from where they were abducted we don't know where
00:13:17
she was killed but we do have investigators who have been on the record saying we believe she was killed
00:13:23
elsewhere and then eventually placed in the cemetery where she was found well because it was such a remote location
00:13:31
too we don't know if she was found within a day or so of being dumped there or a week or more right and so I I think
00:13:39
that I would be hesitant to put July 11 as the approximate date of death I think
00:13:46
that it's interesting that they give us one they provide us with one but I would
00:13:50
if that were my job I would not be wanting to put my stamp on that I think there's too many factors and variables
00:13:57
to consider when trying to come up with that that window and again I keep going back to our America Highway serial
00:14:06
killer episodes and thinking she's found right off of Highway 94 there's a chance that that's not a
00:14:14
coincidence that somebody drove this person drove this victim killed them elsewhere days before and then
00:14:21
transported them and and placed her there where she was ultimately found well the other problem in this case is
00:14:27
going to be because she is so badly beaten in the face that they're not able to figure out what her eye color would
00:14:34
be so another identifier that we just don't have the information for and weirdly
00:14:42
enough man we have a situation here where she's found in a cemetery and then later buried in the same Cemetery so the
00:14:49
the town's people of the good people of Blairstown New Jersey they pulled together their funds and they decided to
00:14:57
give her a proper burial with with a headstone but to me it's a little creepy she's being found in this cemetery and
00:15:03
then later buried there as well I'm guessing here captain that there I don't know what this Creek is like in this
00:15:13
location it's likely that it's not big enough or powerful enough for her to have been deposited by the creek you
00:15:21
know that she was dumped in a in a larger body of water or and somehow the water carried her here it doesn't seem
00:15:28
like any of the investigators believe that to be a scenario worth considering so I'm going to have to go off of the
00:15:36
fact that they've never mentioned that plus there would there should be more evidence of her being in a river or
00:15:43
being in water for a considerable amount of time before she's found in this location one item of concern to me and
00:15:51
this would be very helpful to our little armchair investigation here Captain our
00:15:55
little garage investigation if you will I would like to know from this George crease and I hope that I'm saying his
00:16:02
name correctly he's a Gravedigger a caretaker for this Cedar Ridge Cemetery he's the one that found her body on July
00:16:11
15th 1982 I would like to know from him if he could tell us when he believed the last
00:16:19
time he was in that exact location of the cemetery right because then we could probably narrow it down a little bit
00:16:25
better as to when she was placed there and maybe that's information that the medical examiner has and the
00:16:31
investigators have and they are taking that into consideration when they provide us with this date of approximate
00:16:39
death of July 11 and if you look at the Cedar Ridge Cemetery on a map an aerial view of the cemetery will show you that
00:16:51
the location where she is found is is rather on the fringes of the cemetery itself like I wouldn't even consider
00:16:58
that to be it's probably belongs to the cemetery but it's so close to the creek and in in the start of this wooded area
00:17:10
that I would like to know you know if George could recall one what days of the week is he there is he there by
00:17:17
appointment only it doesn't sound to me like this is a job that he's there Monday through Friday every week but
00:17:24
also taken to factor when were you in this location of the cemetery because her body's found in a spot where you
00:17:33
could be there you could be working you could be there visiting a past family member and not see it wouldn't be
00:17:42
obvious that there was a body there it was somewhat concealed to concealed from State Route 94 anyway and there's
00:17:49
several reconstruction images the one that's in color by the ncmec to me she looks like Kat Von D remember
00:18:03
that tattoo artist that had a show a tattoo show she I do not Kat Von D she also was famously uh dated Nikki 6 I
00:18:17
think she also dated um Jesse James so but but looks very similar to to this uh artist ring and
00:18:29
there are so many different agencies as we pointed out earlier that have been involved at times with this
00:18:34
investigation I've been told that the proper people to contact should you have any information would be the New Jersey
00:18:41
State Police but we also referenced the Warren County prosecutor's office and Nick Mech they've worked with the
00:18:49
national Center for missing and exploited children as well and then we have the do Network so there's a lot of
00:18:55
information on this case even though we don't know who she was or have very little clue as to who she could have
00:19:03
been but I do want to point out that depending on which Outlet you get your news from or your information from I
00:19:12
should say the information is a little different on each of these websites so if we're looking at princessd do.org
00:19:21
which is a very comprehensive right website it's it's substantial there's a lot of stuff going on there a lot of
00:19:29
good information I don't know when the last time it was updated it looks like it may have been a couple years since it
00:19:35
was last updated but on that website we get a little bit of different information that we want to point out
00:19:43
because the best chance of figuring out who she was would be to crowdsource this
00:19:49
thing and this is something that they've been trying to do since the 80s to crowdsource this to figure out who she
00:19:54
could have been and on the princess do.org site it says the victim was found with red nail polish on the right hand
00:20:02
only as the captain pointed out but here it says both ears were pierced where on
00:20:09
the waren County website it states that they could not determine this says both ears were pierced the left ear twice so
00:20:18
some some differing information here well the information I found is that they found two earrings in her left ear
00:20:26
and then they go on to State this seems to be pretty hardcore fact here uh and everybody seems to be agreeing on this
00:20:33
information no known surgical scars birth marks or tattoos were found on her person scars or marks on the head face
00:20:42
area would not be known due to the condition of the body it also goes on to state that the the front two teeth are
00:20:49
slightly darker than the other teeth dental records are available for comparison so that's good they have some
00:20:57
dental records which has come to help clear other potential persons that could be princess doe that they've determined
00:21:06
based off of dental records that the person is not princess do well another identifying factor is that this victim
00:21:15
has never given birth nor been pregnant so she wasn't pregnant at the time and she's never given birth before so this
00:21:23
is when they start trying to age her and that's they're putting her between you know 14 to 18 years old yeah that varies
00:21:33
Again by website I've seen 14 to 18 that seems to be the majority consensus but I've also seen 15 to 20 on
00:21:42
other websites I think just to play it safe let's say 14 to 20 here based off of everybody's speculation what's really
00:21:50
frustrating to me again is these images you can find a lot of these if you just Google search princess D online but to
00:22:00
me a lot of the images just look like completely different people so it kind of throws
00:22:06
you it'd be really hard to compare and contrast you know a photograph of somebody with these drawings well and
00:22:15
the other thing that we need to keep in mind and I want everybody to to remember
00:22:19
this at all times when you're when you're thinking of possible theories when we're going through some other
00:22:24
situations here trying to fill in the blank keep in mind no one has come forward to
00:22:31
identify her or to claim her that's a big part of this mystery and to me I think that that is what likely holds the
00:22:39
key the answer to this mystery but let's go through some of the timeline here and
00:22:46
this is based off of the timeline from Princess doe.org July 15th 1982 is when the unidentified body is found who she
00:22:55
would later be known as Princess Doe she's laid to rest 6 months later so January 22nd
00:23:04
1983 is when she is laid to rest in a grave not far from the location where her body was originally discovered at
00:23:12
the Cedar Ridge Cemetery now she's named princess Doe by the investigators and by
00:23:18
the good people of Blairstown New Jersey because they didn't want her to just be
00:23:24
another Jane Doe so this is a way to distinguish her from other Jane doees part of that being her young age you
00:23:32
know they believe that she could possibly be a child we said it earlier as young as 14 maybe as old as 20 right
00:23:39
but she was also somebody that was in good health and well taken care of or took care of herself leading up to her
00:23:47
death so this wasn't somebody that was malnourished or uh never been to the dentist or anything like that some
00:23:54
situations that we have covered in other cases and 1983 HBO airs a special about
00:24:00
unidentified human remains and features the princess doe case this is also the same year when Princess do becomes the
00:24:09
first unidentified person case entered into the ncic computer database by the FBI the next month in July of 83 is when
00:24:21
we have the unveiling of a lifelike bust of Princess doe based off of the inter ations of the remains so as the captain
00:24:30
pointed out over the years we will have different sketches different computer composits of the victim and also we have
00:24:38
this lifelike bust that is put together right now in 1985 something really interesting
00:24:45
happens in this case and and something that that really I think still we sit here and we're we're 40 years later
00:24:53
we're one week from being 40 years to the date of when Princess do was found but this is something that
00:25:00
also needs cleared up even though it took place in 1985 so starting in 1985 investigators in New Jersey became
00:25:09
convinced that princess doe was Diane die a teenager who went missing from San Jose California in
00:25:18
1979 so Diane Dy ran away from home there were problems at home and she decided to take off now they are
00:25:28
believing that 3 years later she's found unidentified Beat to Death blooded to death in New Jersey and she could be
00:25:38
princess doe now Diane d was 13 at the time of her disappearance so she would have fallen kind of perfectly into that
00:25:47
age range and the height and weight range of Princess doe so this was a bit of a debate right we had the D family
00:25:57
that says no we don't believe that that princess doe is our missing little girl we believe that she's probably still
00:26:06
alive and well and just doesn't want to come home we don't believe or have any reason to suspect that she made it all
00:26:13
the way to New Jersey but see then you have to argue what we were just talking about
00:26:19
earlier this is right next to Highway 94 right is it a possibility that she was killed hundreds of miles away that she
00:26:26
didn't make her own way to New Jersey the person responsible for her murder made her way to New Jersey my big issue
00:26:35
with this whole concept though is that Diane D's family doesn't believe that princess doe is her yes and there was as
00:26:46
said a lot of debate there was not just debate between the die family and law enforcement there was debate
00:26:52
within law enforcement itself well law enforcement made an announcement public publicly I mean I I think that's very
00:27:00
irresponsible well right and we should point out that that was one person decided to do that that kind of went off
00:27:09
on their own yeah one dumbass without permission without proper evidence without anything kind of sealing the
00:27:15
deal here because what we would later learn in 2003 they were able to make a DNA
00:27:25
comparison from the die family to princess doe and it was determined that the two were completely unrelated right
00:27:33
so no chance that Diane Dy is Princess doe what what boggles my mind is that that was left
00:27:43
open-ended for so long from 1985 to 2003 before they could determine that it was in fact not Dian
00:27:52
die and as you stated Captain some someone in law enforcement says publicly that princess doe was Diane
00:28:01
die it still remains to this day that there are a lot of people out here and out there that once knew of this case
00:28:08
and believed that at least the identity portion of it is solved and still believe that princess doe is or was
00:28:17
Diane d and we're here to tell you that is not the case at all this these are scientific facts that prove that D and
00:28:24
die is not princess du [Music] this show is sponsored by better help do you look forward to the holidays maybe
00:28:46
you struggle with seasonal Blues this time of year can be a lot and it's natural to feel some sadness or even
00:28:52
anxiety about it but adding something new and positive to your life can counteract some of those feelings
00:28:58
therapy can be a bright spot something to look forward to to make you feel grounded and to give you the tools to
00:29:06
manage everything going on if you're thinking of starting therapy give better help a try it's entirely online designed
00:29:13
to be convenient flexible and suited to your schedule just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a
00:29:18
licensed therapist and switch therapist at any time for no additional charge find your bright spot this season with
00:29:25
better help visit better help.com Garay to get 10% off your first month that's betterhelp
00:29:34
hp.com garage is it possible to predict the unpredictable can 3D printed life-size
00:29:44
organ models help to map out complex surgeries ahead of time is it possible it already is right here Mayo Clinic you
00:29:53
know where to go dreaming of overseas Adventures or connecting more deeply with family from
00:29:59
afar Rosetta Stone Bridges the language Gap I've tried others but Rosetta Stone's immersive lessons and voice
00:30:06
feedback technology are game changers dive into 25 Languages by learning intuitively just like when you were a
00:30:12
kid and here's the holiday Sparkle grab a lifetime membership now and save 50% gift yourself the world head to
00:30:21
rosettastone.com now and save 50% and we are back can't wait to head to Nash Vegas yes we will be in Nashville this
00:30:50
weekend at the wonderful fat bottom Brewing Company drinking beers shaking hands talking to the people
00:30:59
M fun times a real quick thing too if you want to check out that missing the HBO documentary fascinating information
00:31:07
on this case but also on the Johnny gosh case now that we've cleared up the whole
00:31:12
Dian die angle of this investigation let's jump back in time two years prior to 1983 this is when police released photos
00:31:23
of the clothing that princess doe was wearing at the time of her death uh that she was found still wearing when her
00:31:30
body was discovered this is because they believe that the clothing was somewhat unique and hoping that somebody would
00:31:38
recognize the clothing and then come forward with information about who princess doe could have been now we
00:31:46
should also point out that initially and this makes sense anybody that's reviewed
00:31:52
any murder case will know that initially the Blairstown police they believed that
00:31:58
it was going to be a local girl when she was first discovered but then very quickly after a couple of days of nobody
00:32:05
coming forward to identify her now they start going well we're going to have to expand our our thoughts and
00:32:11
considerations here on who this could be it could be somebody from a nearby Town
00:32:17
nearby City or even out of state I wish that they would have I understand holding on to this information I
00:32:25
understand not wanting to release it until you feel like you have to but I also look on these things with hindsight
00:32:32
and I say I think that you waited too long you know we we do in this case have people coming forward saying oh that
00:32:40
clothing well that that reminds me of something here's some information for you but I'm wondering what kind of
00:32:46
information and how much better could the information have been had You released these photographs earlier you
00:32:52
know people forget stuff things get lost in people's memories things get lost in
00:32:57
time but they do have people that come forward after they release the photos of this clothing that princess do was
00:33:05
wearing one of the witnesses claimed that she had seen a woman the woman princess doe at a store near the
00:33:12
cemetery right another set of witnesses confirm this saying that they had seen a
00:33:19
woman at a grocery store two days before the murder so I'm guessing this is before July 11th 1982
00:33:27
they're saying that she was wearing her hair in a bun at the time and reportedly
00:33:32
had a stoic expression like him GK unfortunately none of these Witnesses said that they spoke with the woman but
00:33:40
they did they were all certain that it was Princess doe that they had seen based off of this unique clothing now
00:33:48
another witness revealed that she had seen very similar clothing to what Jane Doe princess doe was wearing in a
00:33:55
clothing sore on Long Island the witness was certain that her clothing had been bought in Long Island
00:34:02
and so police began investigating disappearances in that area they also checked school records for a girl
00:34:08
matching the princess Doe's description but no further leads were found there were some eyewitnesses that believe that
00:34:15
princess doe was working at a motel yes one of these Witnesses state that this was a motel near Blairstown New Jersey
00:34:25
this witness said that they actually spoke to the woman and said that they were told by her that she was a runaway
00:34:32
from Florida and that her father was a dentist and that she was looking for work and that she's also anti-dentite
00:34:41
well and then we have others that come forward from various Motel over in New York also in New Jersey and in
00:34:50
Maryland that are coming forward saying that we think that we saw her working at
00:34:56
motel over over there if in fact this was Princess doe it sounds to me Captain like she must have been living under
00:35:03
some different aliases at the time because this information while we only have bits and pieces of it I'm sure law
00:35:10
enforcement have a significant amount more and they've not been able to tie this information to an identification of
00:35:18
Princess doe yeah we don't know for sure if it was a hoel motel Holiday Yen well
00:35:25
so it wasn't like there was no press or nobody talking about this case but it had its es and flows but we're going to
00:35:33
have some significant break or at least some significant information in this case 17 years later in
00:35:40
1999 yeah so this is when we have an arrest that that would seemingly be unrelated to our case and the arrest is
00:35:48
of a Donna kren law and so she is arrested for fraud she's committing fraud and she's a bit of a career
00:35:55
criminal well her husband Arthur who's a few years older than her is a bit of a career criminal as well now from my
00:36:03
understanding here Captain Donna was picked up in California I believe but was originally from New Jersey or from
00:36:10
the New Jersey area and she's stating that they had committed some crimes in that area before she left and was
00:36:19
committing fraud in California and they were running I say they her and her husband according to
00:36:25
Donna were running a sex trafficking operation or a sex ring where they had working girls sex
00:36:35
workers that were either employed by them or forced into working for them it's a little
00:36:43
unclear and I think you'll understand why once we start going through some of this
00:36:48
information but Donna is telling law enforcement that she believes that her husband is the one that killed princess
00:36:57
doe that was responsible for her murder stating that he was a [ __ ] princess at
00:37:03
the time of her arrest she's stating that the couple was angered when the woman now known as Princess doe refused
00:37:10
to work for them as a prostitute and she said that her husband left with the girl and didn't come back
00:37:19
with her now why would she suspect that he had killed her well because she had witnessed or been a part of
00:37:27
her husband Arthur killing two other girls and now these other victims one is known as
00:37:36
Linda but again that's Linda with quotation marks so they don't know that Linda was her actual first name and
00:37:46
their other victim is believed to be suffk County Jane do so let's point out something here Captain that's rather
00:37:54
obvious first off we have this couple that confesses first the wife confesses and then the husband
00:38:01
confesses to being the the perpetrator of the murder of Princess doe this is going to be highly debated
00:38:10
amongst law enforcement what is in their favor for them telling the truth in this situation
00:38:17
would be that their other victims still remain unidentified they were unidentified at the time that they were
00:38:23
found right and the other victim share similar injuries that we have with Princess do so that is in their favor of
00:38:34
them telling the truth however we have investigators who are on the record that state that they don't believe that the
00:38:41
kren laws killed princess doe based off of the confession that they received it it doesn't align with the facts of the
00:38:50
case the facts that they know about the case the other thing too that I want to point out here as well is if our
00:38:58
princess doe was killed by a stranger or somebody that wanted to harm her what I
00:39:05
would suspect I'm not saying it would have to happen or be 100% but I would suspect that somebody that knew her that
00:39:13
loved her or even once knew her or once loved her would have come forward by now
00:39:19
and said hey I think that that is my missing daughter or my missing niece or my missing right sister anybody like
00:39:28
that I think would have come forward and because we have no one coming forward to
00:39:33
claim princess do as being somebody to me where I think the suspicion lies is that very likely somebody that was very
00:39:42
close to her is responsible for her murder and we've seen this with some other cases that we've reviewed here in
00:39:49
the garage where you get somebody that's estranged from their family and they're
00:39:53
killed by a husband or a boyfriend or a fiance right and placed out somewhere if
00:39:59
they're not identified that these family members aren't coming forward she may have already been estranged from her
00:40:05
family maybe even a runaway yeah or running from an abusive situation but we've reviewed plenty of cases where a
00:40:12
husband boyfriend or fiance who lives states away from the victim's family will even contact the victim's family at
00:40:20
some point maybe months later and say yeah yeah she uh she took off she started running around on me she took
00:40:26
off last time I I was aware she was in Maryland or she was in Michigan and they start throwing out these different
00:40:32
states of where this person could be now I am in agreeance with the speculation against the Crim laws Arthur and Donna
00:40:41
because the the injuries to their other victims are damn near spoton to what we have
00:40:48
with Princess doe but again we have investigators saying that they don't know the facts of the case their
00:40:54
confessions don't align with the facts of the case their confessions only align with the publicly known knowledge the
00:41:02
publicly known information that has been released in her case and keep in mind too I think with Princess do we're
00:41:09
probably talking about the likelihood of some kind of sexual assault is I would put it on the high probability
00:41:17
end of the spectrum here of our investigation based off of the fact that she's not found with any undergarments
00:41:25
on her person even though they could not determine that because of the decomposition I think that that is
00:41:32
probably the case and probably the situation here but Again difficult thing here is because some people confess to
00:41:40
crimes they don't commit and they have other victims that they don't have the identities for so it's possible that
00:41:47
this guy did kill somebody in a cemetery it's just not princess do it's possible
00:41:52
the kren law is killed more than just the two people that they are Donna KRW is out last time I checked she
00:42:00
was still she's out on the street she's a free woman at this point but the Arthur kren law remains in prison to
00:42:07
this day I'm guessing based off of the two murders that he's locked up for that it's very likely that he has committed
00:42:15
more murders and I think where we probably have some disconnect could be that donin law the wife could be
00:42:25
confusing Prince do with another woman who her husband killed I think with his confession the problem becomes you know
00:42:35
did he kill some other girl somewhere in a cemetery again the investigators are stating that they do not believe that
00:42:42
she was killed in the cemetery they believe she was killed elsewhere in the place there and then on top of that we
00:42:49
have him saying that I killed her and and placed her in that Blairstown Cemetery so it would be difficult to
00:42:57
believe that that he's confusing one victim with another here when we have this specificity of his statements of
00:43:05
that Blairstown Cemetery interestingly enough it's believed that it was the potential Fame that they might have been
00:43:14
seeking with being connected to the princess doe case that we already have a situation where they've murdered where
00:43:22
he's going to be locked up for at least two homicides and their homicides are somewhat similar to what they've read
00:43:30
coming out of New Jersey and that is if he's going to be locked up for two anyway he might as well get some Fame
00:43:37
and notoriety from being connected to what is a famous victim with this princess doe yeah it's sad when these
00:43:46
[ __ ] bags will confess to a crime that they might have had nothing to do with just so it's it's almost like they're
00:43:52
getting a trophy and look at me look at me give me attention now now some of the
00:43:57
identifiers or possible identifiers on princess de are really interesting to me I'm wondering here like with the
00:44:05
fingernail polish on one hand but not on the other hand right is this something that was deliberate you know I've heard
00:44:12
it suggested that well maybe maybe the killer put nail polish on one hand for whatever weird reason or maybe she
00:44:19
removed nail polish but I know several women that will purposely wear nail polish that doesn't match you know maybe
00:44:28
the the toenails are done different than the fingernails or they'll do multiple colors on different fingernails and so I
00:44:36
wonder if it was just simply a style thing for this young woman that she preferred to paint only one hand if that
00:44:45
was something that she commonly did that would be a little unique that would be a
00:44:49
way to potentially identify her if anybody was friends with with a girl at one time that that was known to have
00:44:56
done that only paint one hand well we know the location that she was found I think this is definitely a case that if
00:45:05
the True Crime Community got behind and and shared her picture enough that maybe
00:45:10
we could could get somebody to come forward and say that that was my sister or that was my cousin or or or something
00:45:19
well and we talk about possible identifiers and I know we've ruled out the Diane die connection here but but
00:45:26
what's weird to me man if you look at the Dian die picture and one of the pictures that was generated by Nick Mech
00:45:35
the national Center for missing and exploited children of Princess doe they're eerily similar they're eily
00:45:42
similar so I can see why somebody started to put that together but again we know that to be not the case but you
00:45:50
think with the advancements and technology for DNA that we'd be able to at least link this princess do back to a
00:45:59
family right and you wonder if that's how we're going to end up solving this thing because again I really think that
00:46:07
I think that her not being all right she's not connected to any missing person if she was we would
00:46:14
be having a whole different conversation there is a chance that whoever she was she was actually
00:46:20
reported to be missing but on the flip side of that coin there's also the possib
00:46:26
that she's never been reported missing to anyone and therefore if that ends up being the case I would have to strongly
00:46:35
suspect the person closest to her that being a father a mother a brother a a husband a boyfriend a fiance fancy the
00:46:45
person closest to her is probably responsible for I agree for her murder would be my
00:46:52
belief now there is some interesting things here though still and some potential leads with this isotope
00:47:00
testing and we've seen this in some other cases in the barrel dough cases that we've talked about where they do
00:47:08
testing on the remains and based off of chemicals and other sorts of things they
00:47:13
can determine or take an educated guess as to where the person may have lived for an extended period of time right and
00:47:22
when they do the isotope testing on princess doe what they come up with is that she likely lived for a considerable
00:47:30
amount of time in the state of Arizona so that information that they come up with actually puts her in multiple
00:47:36
States but with them saying that the the strongly most suspected state would be that she lived for an extended period of
00:47:45
time in Arizona the other thing though too is I don't think we can discount these possible sightings of her living
00:47:53
in the area right we have mult multiple witnesses that come forward after seeing
00:47:57
the clothing saying that oh I spoke with a a young woman that worked at a motel that worked in the New Jersey area New
00:48:05
York area Ocean City is strongly mentioned so is Long Island and those locations are really interesting to me
00:48:14
too for several reasons one part of the kren Law's confession states that they meet this
00:48:21
woman that wanted some work and so they're going to try to make her a sex worker and she threatens to rat them out
00:48:30
to police and that is what pissed off Arthur to the point that he kills this young woman the thing the thing that's
00:48:37
interesting to me about the kren law confession though is that it does coincide with some of these possible
00:48:44
eyewitnesses who said that they saw and spoke with somebody leading up to the discovery of Princess doe that they may
00:48:51
have spoke to princess doe so that that story kind of goes along with it now the
00:48:58
strong suspicions to this day Captain are that the kren laws were not involved in Princess Doe's murder right that
00:49:06
princess doe likely lived for a considerable amount of time in the state of Arizona may have been a runaway from
00:49:14
the state of Florida and her father may have been a dentist all based off of these eyewitness statements and some
00:49:21
information that they've collected over the years but we have law enforcement who are on record saying we don't
00:49:28
believe the kren Law's confession however we believe and we have reason to believe that princess doe may have lived
00:49:39
or worked on Long Island in New York which does go along with part of kren Law's confession but again law
00:49:49
enforcement stating everything in kren law's confession is based off of public knowledge public information
00:49:56
stuff they could have read in the newspapers what is weird to me here Captain is 1982 you're weird to me still
00:50:04
unidentified right is this I like the idea of linking this to somebody else right like someone like
00:50:13
kren law who's killed other people in similar Fashions and disposed of the bodies in similar
00:50:19
manners I like connecting it to somebody else I also I I cannot shake the idea that it could a trucker who was
00:50:27
traveling the region or even cross country and that is the reason why we have we've got a disconnect between
00:50:34
linking victim to who she actually was the unidentified remains to the missing person I think that's a strong
00:50:41
possibility the other thing that keeps nagging at me your mother is the Long Island serial killer Yes we have Long
00:50:49
Island serial killer victims that are still unidentified to this day the way that the remains were found in the Long
00:50:57
Island case would suggest that they were killed these victims were killed in a a manner other
00:51:04
than bludgeon to death from everything I read that would be the suspicion I don't
00:51:08
think they've come right out and said how exactly how these victims were killed but I find it interesting that
00:51:16
this happens in 82 we still have some unidentified persons in the Lisk case the Long Island serial killer case
00:51:26
Blairstown New Jersey not terribly far away they believe that there's a connection to Long Island or to Ocean
00:51:34
City I think Ocean City is in Maryland so in that general area there are people that have also suggested that maybe this
00:51:42
might be one of Joel rifkin's earlier kills that could make some sense Joel riffkin is a weird one for me because he
00:51:50
doesn't seem to he he will confess to some things but I also believe that that he's holding a lot back I think there's
00:51:57
other people that he has killed and has held back that information and and chose
00:52:02
not to confess to an extra murder or two than what we know him to be responsible
00:52:07
for well it'll makes sense if this victim is as young as 14 right and he's not willing to confess to certain things
00:52:14
so uh do we have a situation where she's found in New Jersey and he doesn't want
00:52:19
to be prosecuted or charged by a different jurisdiction than his other crimes took place
00:52:25
I have this I'm not saying that that I think that it's connected but I have this nagging sneaky sneaking suspicion
00:52:34
that that Long Island serial killer someone some type of serial killer that was active in this general area in this
00:52:43
region you said region at one point or another is responsible for this princess do it could be could be their first
00:52:51
kill or could be one of their earlier kills that's not been connected the other thought too is that and this is a
00:52:58
strong theory in this case is that whoever is responsible for this is already locked up for another crime
00:53:06
potentially another murder yeah the problem with riffkin too is and and again he could have more more
00:53:15
victims but it seems like he didn't start killing until the late 80s and obviously princess doe is a early 80s
00:53:24
victim on the princess doe website the website dedicated to her case and to helping determine her
00:53:33
identity they got a couple of interesting pages on there Captain one is a theories page and one is a
00:53:40
questions and answers page and I'm not going to go through everything on both of those pages because we've kind of
00:53:46
discussed some of those just in in our general discussion here today but some of the unsubstantiated
00:53:55
prevailing theories in this case are again that she's a a possible runaway that was known to have worked in Ocean
00:54:05
City Maryland again this is inconclusive but it's a it's a a theory that remains
00:54:12
strong to this day at least amongst some and there are other theories that she was uh run away from Florida estranged
00:54:22
from her family again this is based off of those eyewitness statements that came
00:54:27
forward in 1983 there is OB unsubstantiated claims that maybe she was a local sex worker
00:54:37
that worked at the truck stop uh or at local businesses again not confirmed just a theory this one seems
00:54:48
interesting to me though I I tend to believe that she's probably not does not have deep roots in this general area or
00:54:56
any general area nearby where she was eventually found I think if that were the case that we probably wouldn't be
00:55:03
sitting here almost 40 years later still wondering about the identity of our victim and one of the questions
00:55:11
on the website is who is currently handling this investigation and is it still active answer that they provide
00:55:20
again this would be from I believe 2017 so we're going a little little bit back here but according to the information
00:55:28
that they have on their site Captain it says the Warren County prosecutor's office is currently handling this case
00:55:34
and yes the case is active and being investigated and pursued now that would still coincide with the information that
00:55:41
we found on the Warren County prosecutor's office website and then a great question that is asked on this
00:55:49
case what forensic evidence is available and the answer that they provide is hair
00:55:55
fingernails fingerprints DNA and teeth have all been collected into evidence the DNA has been entered into the
00:56:02
Nationwide codus database one of the other questions that's interesting to me here captain and I I referenced earlier
00:56:10
that maybe this could be tied to a person who has killed other female victims is the question that says does
00:56:18
the princess do case have anything to do with the tiger lady question mark so the
00:56:24
answer is the tiger lady a is a woman who is unidentified a bangal tattoo was found
00:56:31
on her calf uh so that is how she gets this name of the nickname of tiger lady she
00:56:39
was found nearby uh I guess this is Nolton Township in 1991 now law enforcement has stated that
00:56:50
they do not believe that the cases are related but there is this strong strong suspicion because you have these two
00:56:56
victims yes found mind you 9 years apart but relatively close to one another in the same county of Warren County New
00:57:05
Jersey and we have two of them who are still unidentified I think it's pretty simple
00:57:11
to me again if we could do some DNA testing and and connect her to a family because the other problem too
00:57:20
is the person that could identify her is possibly also the person responsible for
00:57:25
her death and that's why they haven't came came forward to identify her and that is my strong belief my my strong
00:57:32
suspicion there and I think you're exactly right here Captain let's get some DNA testing some familial DNA uh
00:57:39
genealogy work detective work going on this look there's there's several agencies out there there's several of
00:57:47
these Labs out there that that can do all of this work inhouse from start to finish for you and we already referenced
00:57:54
that this case is well known you know it's it's a it it was known Nationwide HBO covered it uh America's Most Wanted
00:58:02
cover it several outlets have covered it over the years and if you want to get your name in the papers for solving a
00:58:11
big case and and pointing out that hey this is a service and a technology that we offer that we can sell to people this
00:58:18
is a great way to get your name out there and I'm hoping that there are these Labs that are coming forward and
00:58:24
offering their services to the great state of New Jersey now from the Warren County prosecutor's office website and I
00:58:33
know that this is a problem in a lot of counties we talked about this in our Sam
00:58:38
little case we talked about it in our America's Highway serial killer cases that we
00:58:45
covered four-part series but for Warren County they seem to have a bit of a problem with unidentified remains we
00:58:54
know that they have princess doe who was found July 15th 1982 in Warren County New Jersey found behind the Cedar Ridge
00:59:03
Cemetery on Highway 94 located in Blairstown New Jersey we also reference tiger lady who was recently identified
00:59:13
and this is interesting too here Captain because this is a a laboratory that's more than capable of coming up with some
00:59:21
answers in our princess do case so in July of 2021 bod Laboratories in Virginia was able to locate family
00:59:30
members of the deceased victim known as tiger lady uh using genealogy the deceased female was positively
00:59:38
identified as Wendy Lise Baker Wendy Baker traveled through multiple States prior to being found in the gravel
00:59:47
parking lot area along Route 94 in Nolton Township waren County I would like to know what states she was known
00:59:57
to have been traveling through because I I get it that it's 9 years later but is
01:00:03
that the problem that we have in identifying princess doe was she from another state could she be from one of
01:00:11
the states that Wendy Baker was known to have traveled through and then in 2017 we had some human remains that were
01:00:21
discovered by law enforcement as well this was freaky stuff here man the police responded to a call that somebody had
01:00:31
discovered a shoe that still had a foot in it so this was a woman's size seven reebox sneaker
01:00:40
that contained a grayc colored crew sock and exposed lower leg bones was recovered by the
01:00:49
uh sorry recovered May 2007 and again there's additional information on the Warren County prosecutor's
01:01:00
website but what can we do other than shine some light on this case here in the garage what what what we can do is
01:01:09
share these images with people on social media asking for help there there'll be
01:01:15
images on our website at true garage.com and also hopefully we can put some pressure on law enforcement to do
01:01:22
these tests to identify this victim and hopefully bod or somebody like bod Technologies bod Laboratories will reach
01:01:31
out to Warren County and offer their services free of charge and the captain's exactly right we need to we
01:01:39
need to share we need to view and share the images of Princess doe but what's also very important is that we view
01:01:50
share and review and share the information in princess Doe's case because again because of how badly this
01:01:58
victim was beaten we're they're kind of guessing as to what she looked like so that might be part of the problem too
01:02:06
just based off of off of looking at our victim or what she may have looked like nobody's connected any dots I think that
01:02:13
the information of the items the clothing that was found on her and where she was found the time frame all of that
01:02:22
is just as important if not might be more important in this case than the actual composite sketches of Princess
01:02:30
doe now if anybody does have any information out there again it's Warren County who is actively pursuing this
01:02:40
case so you're going to want to get in touch with the Warren County prosecutor's office and their phone
01:02:45
number is 998475 6275 or you can email at cold case at C.W warren. nj. us thank you so much for joining us here
01:03:11
in the garage we're excited to be heading down to Nashville and you can hear all about it if you're subscribed
01:03:18
to off the Record we'll be talking about it next week Colonel do we have any recommended reading for the Beautiful
01:03:24
List yes we do Captain and that's right down in Nashville we're going to turn that mother out this week we are
01:03:30
recommending hi your children HDE your wife this week we are recommending ruse lying the American dream from Hollywood
01:03:38
to Wall Street this is a memoir from the man who lived this wild ride called his
01:03:43
job just to get by and then to thrive Robert kck's juicy Memoir tells all and with a bit of a spy novel type of thrill
01:03:54
Beck bears and shares all of his wild business Secrets within the world of corporate Espionage check out ruse lying
01:04:03
The American Dream by Robert kbec you can find that great title and many more wonderful recommendations on our
01:04:11
recommended page at true Crim garage.com want to thank you all for the continued
01:04:16
support and make sure you share our show with your buddies on social media it means a lot keeps the show plugging
01:04:22
along until next week be good be kind and don't [Music] litter is it possible to predict the
01:05:05
unpredictable can 3D printed life-size organ models help to map out complex surgeries ahead of time is it possible
01:05:13
it already is right here Mayo Clinic you know where to go

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most heartbreaking
  • 60
    Most shocking
  • 60
    Most unpredictable

Episode Highlights

  • Community Support for Burial
    The community of Blairstown came together to give Princess Doe a proper burial after her tragic discovery.
    “The good people of Blairstown pulled together their financial resources for a proper burial.”
    @ 05m 02s
    November 16, 2023
  • The Mystery of Princess Doe
    Princess Doe was found in 1982, and her true identity remains a mystery to this day.
    “Her name forever imprinted in cyberspace on the Warren County prosecutor's office cold cases website.”
    @ 05m 33s
    November 16, 2023
  • Princess Doe's Discovery
    Princess Doe was discovered on July 15, 1982, in Blairstown, New Jersey, with no identification.
    “She was found wearing a red v-neck short sleeve shirt and a long red wraparound skirt.”
    @ 07m 42s
    November 16, 2023
  • The Mystery of Princess Doe
    Investigators believed Princess Doe was Diane Dy, a missing teenager from California. However, DNA evidence later proved they were unrelated.
    “No chance that Diane Dy is Princess Doe.”
    @ 27m 33s
    November 16, 2023
  • Confessions and Controversies
    Donna Krenlaw confessed that her husband killed Princess Doe, but investigators doubt their claims align with the facts.
    “Their confessions only align with publicly known information.”
    @ 40m 57s
    November 16, 2023
  • Princess Doe's Origins
    Evidence suggests she lived in Arizona for a significant time, possibly as a runaway.
    “She likely lived for a considerable amount of time in Arizona.”
    @ 47m 27s
    November 16, 2023
  • Possible Serial Killer Connections
    Theories arise linking Princess Doe to other unidentified victims and serial killers.
    “I have this nagging sneaky suspicion that the Long Island serial killer...”
    @ 52m 34s
    November 16, 2023

Episode Quotes

  • The good people of Blairstown pulled together their financial resources for a proper burial.
    Princess Doe ////// 594
  • To this day, Princess Doe's true identity still remains unknown.
    Princess Doe ////// 594
  • What boggles my mind is that was left open-ended for so long.
    Princess Doe ////// 594
  • She likely lived for a considerable amount of time in Arizona.
    Princess Doe ////// 594
  • I like the idea of linking this to somebody else.
    Princess Doe ////// 594
  • I have this nagging sneaky suspicion that the Long Island serial killer...
    Princess Doe ////// 594

Key Moments

  • Princess Doe Found04:18
  • Community Burial05:05
  • Unresolved Identity27:41
  • Confession Controversy36:51
  • Isotope Testing47:00
  • Eyewitness Accounts47:55
  • Long Island Connection50:42
  • Unidentified Remains58:56

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown