
This episode discusses the Rollins Rodeo murders, featuring listener emails that share personal connections to the victims, including Carlen Brown and Christy Gross.
The hosts read an email from a listener who grew up in Rollins, Wyoming, detailing her mother's acquaintance with Carlen Brown, one of the victims. The email highlights the small-town dynamics and the lack of information surrounding the case.
Another email mentions other abductions in Rollins, including Renee Davidson and Lisa Marie Peterson, emphasizing the fear that gripped the community during those years.
The hosts reflect on the challenges of researching these cases, particularly the lack of accessible information on victims like Deborah Meyer, and discuss the importance of local knowledge in uncovering the truth.
Throughout the episode, the hosts share their own experiences and memories related to the Al Rosa Villa shooting, connecting it to the broader themes of tragedy and community response.
Listener emails reveal personal connections to the Rollins Rodeo murders and discuss the challenges of uncovering local crime history.

This episode stands out for the following:
That's a lot of girls murdered from one tiny little town.Rawlins Rodeo Murders /// True Crime Garage
You make a lot of assumptions to fill in the gaps.Rawlins Rodeo Murders /// True Crime Garage
It just seems very strange and fishy to me.Rawlins Rodeo Murders /// True Crime Garage
What a tragedy of uh Columbus, Ohio.Rawlins Rodeo Murders /// True Crime Garage
Sometimes things hit you real hard; you're just not ready to deal with it.Rawlins Rodeo Murders /// True Crime Garage
Thank God it wasn't worse than what it could have been.Rawlins Rodeo Murders /// True Crime Garage