
This episode covers the mysterious disappearances of Tom Young and Keith Reinhard from Silver Plume, Colorado, in the late 1980s. The discussion focuses on the circumstances surrounding their vanishings, the impact on the small community, and the eerie similarities between the two cases.
Tom Young, a 47-year-old man, disappeared in September 1987 while living in Silver Plume, a town with a population of fewer than 200 residents. His disappearance shocked the community, which was already grappling with the loss of a familiar face.
In August 1988, Keith Reinhard, approaching 50 years of age, retraced Young's steps to investigate the mystery but also vanished without a trace. The episode highlights the profound effects these events had on the close-knit town.
The hosts discuss the odds of two similar disappearances occurring in such a small town and the lasting grief felt by the residents. The narrative emphasizes the chilling nature of these cases and the unanswered questions that remain.
Two men vanish from a small Colorado town under similar circumstances, leaving the community in shock.

This episode stands out for the following:
The odds of this happening seem frankly astronomical.Dark Side of the Mountain // Episodes 882-883 /// True Crime Garage.
It isn't difficult to imagine the shock and grief.Dark Side of the Mountain // Episodes 882-883 /// True Crime Garage.
This is the true crime story of Tom Young.Dark Side of the Mountain // Episodes 882-883 /// True Crime Garage.