RETURN TO CHANNEL

Search Captions & Ask AI

Ashley Okland /// True Crime Garage

April 02, 2026 / 01:00

This episode covers the tragic case of realtor Charlotte Fimiano, who was murdered in Pennsylvania while meeting a potential buyer. The discussion references previous episodes 698 and 699 of True Crime Garage, which also focused on a similar true crime story.

Charlotte Fimiano was a successful realtor who met a buyer at a vacant home on Chelsea Lane. The episode highlights the circumstances surrounding her violent murder.

The hosts express their frustration with the case, emphasizing the eerie similarities to other true crime stories they have covered.

TLDR

Charlotte Fimiano, a realtor, was murdered in Pennsylvania during a showing, echoing a similar true crime case previously discussed.

Episode

1:00

00:00:00

I first became aware of this case just shy of 3 years ago at CrimeCon in Orlando, Florida.

00:00:08

Just days prior to the weekend event, we released two episodes about a very eerily similar true crime story.

00:00:16

In September of 2023, True Crime Garage featured an incredibly frightening story

00:00:21

about a very successful realtor in Pennsylvania named Charlotte Fimiano. Charlotte, responding to a showing, left

00:00:31

her office to meet a potential buyer at a home that sat vacant and silent at the

00:00:37

dead end of Chelsea Lane. Charlotte was violently murdered inside that home. You can do a full review of that case.

00:00:47

That true crime story is episodes 698 and 699 on your garage radio dial. In fact, that is one of the most

00:00:56

frustrating cases that I have reviewed.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

70
Most heartbreaking
60
Most shocking

Episode Highlights

The Case of Charlotte Fimiano
A successful realtor was violently murdered in Pennsylvania, shocking the community.
“Charlotte was violently murdered inside that home.”
@ 00m 40s
April 02, 2026

Episode Quotes

That is one of the most frustrating cases that I have reviewed.
Ashley Okland /// True Crime Garage

Key Moments

Frustrating Case00:56