00:00:00
Sword and Scale contains adult themes and violence, and is not intended for all audiences.
00:00:06
Listener discretion is advised. She couldn't even defend herself. Look how big he was.
00:00:17
Alright, don't get used to this. This isn't going to be the new norm. We aren't going to do two episodes a week, every week, forever.
00:00:23
I mean, do you want to kill me? This is Season 12, Episode 290 of Sword and Scale, a show that reveals that the worst monsters
00:00:29
ah I missed it dammit alright let me try that again this is season 12 episode 290
00:00:35
of Sword and Scale a show that reveals that the worst monsters are real It was a cold January in Cleveland, Ohio.
00:01:06
Then again, isn't every January cold in Cleveland, Ohio? A thick layer of snow covered the ground and the sky was gray.
00:01:16
Inside the modest downstairs apartment of a turn-of-the-century house, 35-year-old Denisha Cooper was pacing through her living room.
00:01:25
Her hands were shaking as she called 911. Cleveland 911, Dispatch Malave, do you mean please fire ambulance?
00:01:31
Please. What's going on over there in 149 Tarnisha? I want to report a missing child.
00:01:37
How old is the child? 14. What's the child's name? Aliana Dupree. Okay, has she ever done this before?
00:01:47
No, I put her on the RTA this morning because they gave her bus tickets and she knows to
00:01:54
She put her right down the street from the police station. And I gave her, I put her on the bus and she just gets on the 10th at the school.
00:02:02
And I called the school because I had a parent-teacher conference and they said she never checked in to school.
00:02:09
Donisha's 14-year-old daughter, Aliana, had not returned home from school. Aliana took the RTA bus every day.
00:02:17
RTA stands for Regional Transit Authority, and it's basically a city bus. Even though Denisha was weary of sending her daughter to school this way,
00:02:27
it had never been a problem before. What time did you put her on the RTA? It was about 6.38 when the bus turned out.
00:02:36
You know, you know, Yana said. You said it's 6.30 this morning? Yes. What school did she go to?
00:02:44
Ypres. Every weekday morning, Aliana would get on the bus at 6.45 a.m. and ride halfway to school to 93rd Street and Kinsman.
00:02:54
Then she would transfer onto another bus, which would take her all the way to school.
00:02:58
And she never made it to school this morning at all? No. And they usually give out a phone call if the child doesn't come to school, but I didn't get a phone call.
00:03:08
Dinesha never heard anything from Aliana's school about her not showing up. Normally, they would send her a text message through the school's messaging service,
00:03:17
but Denisha received no notifications or telephone calls. So she assumed her child was safe in her classroom with her teacher and peers.
00:03:27
But then Aliana never returned home. Denisha called the school to check to see if her daughter was still there.
00:03:34
She had a parent-teacher conference scheduled for 5 p.m. that evening. Maybe Aliana had decided to stick around for some reason.
00:03:42
That's why I didn't call until just now. Okay. All right. She's trying to get his own car over to you now. What was she wearing when you last seen her?
00:03:52
Brown coat and her E-print uniform. Brown coat, black sweater, black pants? Yes.
00:03:58
Okay. Has she ever done this before? No. She's never ran away before? Did it say nothing like this before?
00:04:05
No. Okay. She's trying to get his own car over to you now. If anything happens or if you hear back, give us a call back because we're going to have an officer come make a report for you, okay?
00:04:14
Okay. Thank you. Denisha was sick of worry. This was not like Aliana. Her daughter was a good kid.
00:04:23
She was sweet, shy, and young for her age. She still liked Disney movies and dolls.
00:04:31
She was innocent and inexperienced. The panic of where Aliana could be did set in.
00:04:39
Here's one of the administrators at the E-Prep. Like I mentioned, I opened the door.
00:04:45
to school every day for my students. I greeted everyone by name. I was in and out of classrooms
00:04:50
every day coaching teachers, and so I had a lot of interactions with students in the lunchroom.
00:04:57
Aliana, because I was her first point of contact at EGREP, she felt comfortable coming to me often.
00:05:03
This administrator had a special relationship with Aliana. She was never absent, and she was the type of student that loved coming to school, so
00:05:12
So I don't have the data in front of me, but I know she was at school all the time.
00:05:20
So when she heard she was missing, she sprung into action. I put my coat on, and my director of curriculum and instruction went out to the library to see if she was there.
00:05:32
My first instinct was maybe she just didn't come to school in case she was at the library.
00:05:36
I don't know. That was my instinct. She checked the library, but no Aliana. However, there were other places and other libraries that she might be at.
00:05:46
We got in my car and we drove to the library at our first bus stop on Kinsman to see if
00:05:53
she was there. That was all that was happening I was on the phone with Mrs Cooper while also calling the police to follow up At that point the police were at EFREP so I went back to school to talk with the officer
00:06:10
Back at the school, the staff talked with the police as concern grew. Everyone who knew Aliana could tell something was very wrong.
00:06:18
The police officer was there. He wanted to take my statement and learn more about Aliana.
00:06:25
At the time, the officer felt like maybe she was just a typical kid and run away.
00:06:32
And I had told the officer that that was in my gut. I knew Aliana. That was not something she would do.
00:06:39
And so he told me that he would go back out to the community. And myself and three of my staff members continued to call parents and call students to find out if anyone had any understanding of where she was.
00:06:55
I go home. I call Mrs. Cooper to let, you know, stay on the phone that entire night.
00:07:01
I remember Mrs. Cooper calling me around midnight that night, just keeping in touch.
00:07:06
Nobody slept that night. Not Denisha Cooper, not any of the school staff, not any of her friends or extended family.
00:07:14
Everyone was busy making a plan for how to find her. And the next day, they got to work.
00:07:20
The next morning, we set up a system where my school and a few of our other schools
00:07:26
brought teachers and staff over and we canvassed the area with flyers. And we divided the city up.
00:07:33
So myself and my director of curriculum instruction, we went as far as Tower City.
00:07:37
We had folks up and down, 9th, up and down, all the neighborhood. We were there all day.
00:07:42
That evening, I went to a community event with the Peacekeepers and Aliana's family.
00:07:52
There was news media there. We wanted to do a call to the community to find out if anyone had any information about her.
00:07:59
We prayed that night. That was the end of that night. The community rallied together in search of Aliana, and the faculty at E-PREP took charge.
00:08:10
Meanwhile, the police were starting their investigation, retracing their steps. Every weekday morning, Aliana would catch the number 14 bus and ride it to 93rd and Kinsman.
00:08:21
Then she'd transfer to another bus, which took her down 93rd to her school. This was not the best area.
00:08:31
Between Kinsman and E-Prep, 93rd Street was home to a few churches, auto shops, vacant lots, and some houses.
00:08:40
The officers searched every location for Aliana and took note of where they could collect surveillance footage along her bus route.
00:08:48
But they started with the video footage from the bus she got on the day she went missing.
00:08:54
At that point, I did review the video, and there was a couple of things that we saw on the video.
00:08:59
We saw Aliana talking to a younger age kid, possibly her age, high school age kid,
00:09:07
that, you know, peaked our interest, but she was having a further conversation with him.
00:09:12
And then there was also another adult male that was seen on that video who was seen exiting the bus,
00:09:19
and Aliana did exit the bus that peaked our interest as well. The man in the video footage
00:09:24
did more than just talk to Aliana on the bus. He had gotten off the bus, fallen on the same path that Aliana was going where she was crossed on East 93rd Street to the other side.
00:09:37
And that male in that video appeared to reach out and say something to her in the crosswalk.
00:09:43
That kind of peaked our interest. It was an older adult male. They had no conversation with her whatsoever on the bus, but reached out and it appeared to have said something to her in that crosswalk.
00:09:52
The man in the RTA bus footage sat facing the front with his white hoodie pulled up.
00:09:59
As Aliana exits the bus, he looks up, grabs his two bags, and gets off the bus behind her.
00:10:07
He yells something as they both cross the busy intersection, but Aliana keeps walking until she gets to the other side of the street.
00:10:15
That's when the footage ends. The bus continues its route. But what do you do next?
00:10:22
At that point, I started to check vacant lots in the area of 93rd and Kinsman, also on the path of Kinsman to Union, which would be the school room.
00:10:39
So they kept searching. Soon the FBI got involved. Denisha handed over her daughter's phone just in case there was something on it,
00:10:48
which she'd found in her bedroom dresser. anything on there could help still no Aliana
00:10:55
the whole neighborhood was on high alert in search of this beloved teenager it felt like she had just vanished
00:11:04
into thin air then police found a body police have more questions than answers after they discovered the body of a female
00:11:13
inside an abandoned home late last night and while investigators wait for a positive ID
00:11:18
there is concern tonight that it could be that of a missing 14-year-old Cleveland girl.
00:11:24
On Sunday, January 29th, 2017, only three days after she'd been reported missing,
00:11:32
officers searched an abandoned house just off 93rd Street. Inside the cold and crumbling home,
00:11:40
the police used their flashlights to follow bloody footprints and smears towards a room.
00:11:45
inside they found a training bra some clothes a ripped condom wrapper and the body of a young black female she was naked except for a pair of socks on the built window bench next to her was an assortment of torture tools a drill a Phillips head screwdriver a nut driver
00:12:11
and a box cutter. There has not been a positive identification of the victim found in that house
00:12:18
on Sunday night. And until there's positive scientific evidence, we're not going to announce
00:12:25
who that person is. We have a very strong idea based on evidence and things like that of who
00:12:31
that person is. And we've talked to that family. We're in constant contact with that family.
00:12:36
But until the medical examiner makes that positive identification, we don't have an
00:12:41
announcement for that. The body looked like Aliana, but there had been several missing
00:12:47
women reported in the area, so they had to be sure. After securing her dental records,
00:12:53
it was confirmed. I went home. I went home and then a few hours later, I got a call from my boss to let me
00:13:02
know what had happened. I had to call all her teachers. I had to call everyone and tell
00:13:12
I don't know if anyone has it. It's my school. She's my student. It's our community.
00:13:18
I just felt like everyone had been putting so much time and effort into finding her that we needed,
00:13:23
everyone needed to know what had happened. As far as anyone could tell, Aliana had been mercilessly tortured and killed in this terrifying house,
00:13:34
with its cracked door frames, scurrying rats, and peeling wallpaper. Now, the police had to follow the breadcrumbs of video footage to find the person who killed her.
00:14:09
14-year-old Aliana DeFries had mysteriously disappeared one January afternoon on her bus ride to school.
00:14:26
The entire community had banded together to find her, but it was the police who eventually discovered the dead body of Aliana in an abandoned home just off her bus route on 93rd Street.
00:14:40
This area of Cleveland, Ohio, was littered with abandoned and crumbling homes. Over the past few years, five women had gone missing near 93rd Street, their bodies mutilated and dumped like trash.
00:14:56
All the murders had remained unsolved. Like we said before, this was not a safe area.
00:15:03
Crime had started to fester there among the abandoned homes, and the women who were killed before Aliana were adults caught up in that dark world.
00:15:12
But after what happened to Aliana, an innocent school kid, officials started to perk up.
00:15:19
Some members of the city council feared the worst. This is not a coincidence to me that now this is the fifth young lady that in less than a mile, whose body has been dumped on 93rd and either in a vacant lot or a vacant house.
00:15:36
This city councilman was convinced a serial killer could be targeting the Eastside neighborhood.
00:15:42
But the cops didn't agree. Every time I bring it up, they tell me that I don't know what the hell I'm talking about, that these aren't connected.
00:15:50
Well, like I said, I just want them to prove me wrong. Meanwhile, Aliana's family grieved publicly, and the entire community decided enough was enough.
00:16:00
This was a teenager who had been taken from her family, and residents who rode the bus every day with Aliana and kids like her decided to take turns guarding the last place she had been seen, her bus stop.
00:16:14
All we're doing is watching, just making sure that they get from one bus to another.
00:16:17
I'll be out here every day to the end of the school year until they find some other way to get those babies to school safe.
00:16:23
As much as it was about preventing future tragedies, this was also a way to honor Aliana.
00:16:30
Community is out here and we didn't forget about you. We're sorry that this happened on our watch and we don't want this to happen again.
00:16:36
Police continued pulling surveillance footage from around her first bus transfer,
00:16:41
where the man in the white hoodie had followed Aliana across the street. At that point, after seeing that video there, and you can tell that the video of the RTA bus ends after the bus keeps moving along,
00:16:54
I responded to the Shell Gas Station, which is right on that corner where that bus passes.
00:17:01
I went inside there to check to see what kind of video was available there, and they two only had interior video.
00:17:08
So I did watch a little bit of the video. There was nothing on the video that indicated we had a good gun in the store.
00:17:14
The detectives continued pulling video from businesses and churches all up and down Aliana's bus route.
00:17:21
They kept thinking they would see the man in the white hoodie again. But then something strange happened.
00:17:28
Another man appeared in the surveillance footage from her second bus stop. And it was not the man in the white hoodie.
00:17:35
Outside the True Gospel Mission Baptist Church on East 93rd and Fuller, only a few blocks away from where she was murdered
00:17:44
camera footage showed a black male pacing back and forth across the parking lot at around 7 a.m.
00:17:52
then Aliana gets off her bus and crosses the street towards the church the black male then goes up to Aliana and starts talking to her She takes a cautious step back Even from the grainy video you can sense the fear
00:18:07
in her body language. Then she scurries away. A few seconds later, the video catches him following
00:18:15
her up the street. It's chilling. Meanwhile, the community continued to make sure Aliana was not
00:18:23
forgotten, like the other murdered women before her. The church video was released to the public
00:18:42
and tips soon came flooding in, but they would prove unnecessary because the killer
00:18:49
had left his DNA all over the crime scene. In that cold, disgusting house, Aliana had not only been viciously murdered,
00:19:01
tortured with tools, but also raped. The killer's DNA was like a white flag all over the abandoned house.
00:19:10
When the police sent what they had out for forensic testing, they found the culprit was already in the system.
00:19:17
His name was Christopher Whitaker. He wasn't hard to find, either. 44-year-old Christopher was an ex-con who'd been living and working in the 93rd Street area.
00:19:31
He had a 19-year-old daughter to himself, but he was a negligent father. You know, being in and out of jail and all.
00:19:40
Can't be a good father if you're locked up, you know? Anyway, Christopher had listed his aunt's house as his last known address.
00:19:47
But he was staying with a girlfriend while he worked when he could. And when I say he worked, I mean he did random construction-like tasks on homes for a buddy.
00:20:01
I'll explain in a sec. Anyway, he couldn't do much else given the lengthy criminal history.
00:20:07
Do you know, um, have you seen the news or anything recently in the past week or so?
00:20:12
You know what's going on in that area? Yeah. So then you know why I'm asking all these questions?
00:20:16
I know. Are you familiar with the girl that went missing? I do not know anything.
00:20:22
You don't know her? When you were over there working or anything, did you ever see her?
00:20:25
Never. I wasn't even out that early in the morning. First, we heard about it. I was in the car with Ray's brother, T.
00:20:35
We were going to move a friend of his, and we saw a lady passing out flyers. and we stopped and he grabbed two flyers
00:20:43
and he was reading the flyers first. We heard about it. What day was that? Do you know?
00:20:50
That was like a... Yeah, I did go back over there that Friday because I went and had to move.
00:20:57
Okay, so Friday you were on Fuller. Yeah, and I went back home, yeah. And people were passing out flyers?
00:21:03
Yeah, it was... I don't know if she was white or Puerto Rican or something. She was standing right there at 93rd,
00:21:08
Some females passing out flyers. Some females passing out flyers. So nothing about her looks familiar.
00:21:13
You don't know her. Not at all. You have no information as to her whereabouts or what happened to her.
00:21:20
What's the next thing that you heard about what was going on over there? I mean, what I heard on the news.
00:21:26
What did you hear on the news? They discovered the body. They weren't releasing much information.
00:21:32
I mean, I don't know. Just basically what I heard on the news. Christopher said that the only thing he knew about Aliana was the same thing anyone else did.
00:21:42
But the police knew that he was involved. His DNA was literally everywhere. Instead of bashing him with the cold, hard evidence right away,
00:21:52
they wanted to see him squirm a bit. It's fun. And cops need to have fun, too, sometimes.
00:21:59
Were you ever in that house? I'm not going to lie. Yeah, we went in the house, me, T, and what's the other guy's name?
00:22:09
What do they call him? What is his nickname? They call him Boogie. Call him what?
00:22:15
Boogie. Boogie? Yeah. I mean, we went and we took the hot water heater and the furnace out.
00:22:20
T and Boogie? And we took a couple pieces of some wiring, some, you know, little metal stuff connected to the furnace.
00:22:29
Took that out. So you're talking about the piping and wiring? Yeah, took a test card door.
00:22:34
How long ago was that? It's like Monday Tuesday when we were there. Oh, and by construction work, I also mean that Christopher and his friends would go into abandoned houses
00:22:46
and dismantle whatever parts they could use, like hot water heaters, sinks, pipes, or scrap metal.
00:22:55
They were scrounging. You know, like rats. Like vermin. Where did you guys park the vehicle to load all this stuff up?
00:23:02
We just put it on like a cart, a shopping cart, and took it up the street. And the next morning we put it in the van and took it to the scrapyard.
00:23:14
Do you know how much you got for it? Not much. It was like $37 split between three people.
00:23:24
$37? Right. Just three grown men stealing metal from abandoned houses and lugging it out in a also-stolen shopping cart.
00:23:33
Then trading it in at a scrapyard for a measly $37 to split three ways. Instead of just, oh, I don't know, flipping a burger or maybe even delivering a burger these days.
00:23:46
For way more. But nah, nah, just keep doing what you're doing. Why would anyone resort to such a low-level cash grab?
00:23:54
Oh, right, right, right. His criminal record keeps coming back to the Doesn't it?
00:24:01
Let's just keep all of this in mind while we listen to Christopher spin his little web.
00:24:06
Well, if I was to tell you that we found your DNA inside the house in the upstairs, would that surprise you?
00:24:14
Probably through the kitchen, maybe. I can tell you that we didn't find your DNA in the kitchen.
00:24:19
That's not the room that we found your DNA in. That's the reason I'm asking you if you went into any other part of the house.
00:24:25
You know your DNA is on file. Yeah, I mean I had a case back in 04. The kitchen isn't where we found it because there was nothing in the kitchen. The kitchen was empty. The dining room is where we found your DNA.
00:24:42
Do you want to think about whether or not you were in that room at all? What? How do you explain your DNA and actually your print in the dining room?
00:24:55
We walked around the house, but we just didn't walk. I mean, it's like we didn't focus in there like we in here trying to see what's in here.
00:25:02
We just looked around. I mean, I'm not saying the basement and the dining room is the only thing we looked at.
00:25:09
I mean, we looked around the house, but I didn't go around the house like just trying to see what's all in here we can take.
00:25:17
Did you find anything in any of the other rooms that you guys took or touched or made a try to remove?
00:25:24
I did go upstairs because we went to see if they had a cast iron tub up there. Because cast iron tubs.
00:25:29
You're talking about the second floor? Yeah, we went up to the bathroom, looked, came back down.
00:25:34
Christopher said that they walked around poking their heads in each dilapidated room,
00:25:39
trying to salvage anything of value that someone else hadn't already ripped from the home's carcass.
00:25:45
but he was jittery as he spoke a little nervous what's wrong chris i'm trying to get it right
00:25:54
when i'm sitting here i'm nervous because i'm actually in the house that this girl's body
00:25:57
was found yeah so i'm like that's understanding i want to get this right yeah and i understand that
00:26:03
getting back to her now now that we've got the house down pat you've never met her you've never
00:26:10
seen her before you didn't recognize her when you saw the flyer okay she's not a friend of yours or
00:26:17
somebody that you talked to on the street when you were working on the street i would have no reason to speak to a 14 year old girl well sure she's a 14 year old girl i can
00:26:25
understand that so then then my next question would be can you explain how your dna your semen
00:26:32
would have ended up inside her i don't know anything about that you don't know anything about
00:26:39
that? I mean, I wasn't even over there on that day. Okay, you weren't over there. Then I got to
00:26:48
wonder how your semen could have ended up inside of her. So now we have your DNA inside the house.
00:26:54
We have your fingerprints inside the house. And now, now we have your DNA inside of her.
00:27:01
Christopher sat there across from the detective with his broad shoulders slumped forward.
00:27:06
He looked like a gigantic toddler being punished in his naughty chair. The flyer of Aliana was on the table in front of him,
00:27:16
her smiling, innocent face looking in his direction. But instead, he just stared at his hands.
00:27:23
There's going to be more things that are going to come up once they're finished testing it.
00:27:27
So I'm asking you this now. You can get in front of this, straighten this out, tell your side of the story,
00:27:34
or you can just let us assume whatever we want to. It's up to you, all right? You want to explain to us what happened?
00:27:45
Yeah, I must explain to you for real. Well, sure you do. How did you meet her? How did you get to talking to her?
00:27:53
Did you see her before that day? Never. Never? Well, then how did you get talking to her?
00:28:00
Tell us what happened. Christopher refused to look up. The detective pushed the picture of Aliana closer to him and tapped her pen on it.
00:28:10
So why don't you just tell us how you came upon Aliana, that's her name, how you came upon her, how you got to talking to her.
00:28:20
How did that come about? What happened? Crazy. What did you say? It's crazy. What did you run into?
00:28:29
I'm a crackhead. I get high and I do stupid shit for people for money. Okay. The scrap metal scrounging makes a little more sense now, doesn't it?
00:28:42
Everybody you hang with, that you smoke with or get high with, you don't know everybody you deal with.
00:28:49
Sure. You don't know everybody's situation or how everybody got in that situation.
00:28:55
So, I mean, for me to sit and try to put names or faces to everything that went on that night or that morning, it's probably impossible because I was high.
00:29:13
So you're telling me there was more than just you there. Is that what you're saying, Chris?
00:29:18
By the time I realized how old this girl was, I left. Okay. I left. And there was other smokers around.
00:29:32
Yeah, I mean, like, late at night, you're trying to find out. You don't know who to ask.
00:29:37
So, I mean, smokers come together to get high, whatever, whatnot. You don't even know.
00:29:42
It's like, I might not know you if you were getting high. And I'm like, you know where to get something at?
00:29:47
Yeah, you're going to look out for me? Yeah, whatever. How this little girl got involved I do not know and if I could go back to this day and prevent what happened from happening I would
00:30:08
Had I been in the house for the remainder of that day, I probably would have never let anything happen.
00:30:14
As a taxpayer, aren't you sick of this shit? Just asking. You do pay your taxes, right?
00:30:21
Christopher tried to say that this all happened because of his addiction to crack.
00:30:28
He was out looking for drugs when he met some guys who took him back to the house.
00:30:32
It was someone else, not him. Aliana was already there, naked. He was being very vague about the whole thing.
00:30:41
How did she get into the house? Start with that. That part I can't tell you. I was invited in.
00:30:48
Okay, who invited you? I don't know the name of somebody I was smoking with. Male?
00:30:57
Male. Despite the video evidence of Christopher stalking Aliana near the church on 93rd Street,
00:31:04
he tried to tell the police that two strangers invited him into the abandoned house and Aliana was already inside.
00:31:10
He just happened to be cruising around town looking for drugs on, yep, you guessed it, a stolen bicycle.
00:31:18
And what bike were you riding? I was riding a blue and green mountain bike. Whose bike is that?
00:31:29
It was a bike laying around in the backyard down on 84th. Chris went on for a long time, spinning a story about two random men who he described in great detail.
00:31:43
They were the ones who had done this, not him. he just happened to be there and yes sure he had sex with her i mean why not you know she was there
00:31:54
and she also wanted to get high and you know she's naked and stuff so whatever imagine being so stupid
00:32:01
that you think other people are this stupid the whole thing was completely unbelievable to anyone
00:32:07
who knew aliana actually it was completely unbelievable to anyone with a brain but aliana
00:32:13
was a good kid. The detectives knew this, yet they sat and listened as Chris went on and on.
00:32:21
As far as hurting her, no, I had nothing to do with that. I'm going to give you the honest to God truth.
00:32:27
They told me that she was somebody that was getting hot or whatever. And now when I see,
00:32:34
hear the news and they say she was slow, I understand why she was going along with what
00:32:41
they was saying. She was probably scared or whatever. I had no idea. I'm high. I'm just,
00:32:46
you get high. Thinking is cool. I mean, there's women out there that sell their body for dope.
00:32:55
What room of the house did you have sex with her in? On the carpet, on the little bundle right there.
00:33:04
Which room? I think it was the little room closer to the door. Do you recall what she was wearing?
00:33:13
No, she was naked when I got there. Well, you were there on Wednesday night. She wasn't picked up until Thursday morning.
00:33:20
When I went there Wednesday, we was just smoking. We was just getting high. I went and got some more dope, came back, and she was already there naked.
00:33:31
I don't know how they got her naked, how they got her in there. Okay. She was already naked.
00:33:38
and so I'm taking this to party. Can you imagine what a piece of shit you have to be
00:33:44
to show up at an abandoned house, see a naked teenage girl, and think, this is a party?
00:33:51
I mean, that's some straight-up ditty shit. I mean, you're basically Ashton Kutcher at that point.
00:33:56
This man is so beyond scum of the earth that this is the story he's willing to admit.
00:34:02
This is what he thinks is acceptable to tell detectives. And she was already inside the house, naked.
00:34:11
In what room? In the living room. She was just sitting here quiet. She had like a black hat on.
00:34:19
Black hat? The only thing she had on was like a black hat. I don't know if it was one of theirs or if it was hers that she had worn.
00:34:27
It was basically like, it was like, man, just look out for me. And she gonna look out for you, whatever, whatever.
00:34:33
Like, lay down and open your legs. Go on there and give my double sign. Oh, so they offered her up to you.
00:34:39
I'm just wondering if you had any conversation with her. No, I never talked to her.
00:34:43
Was she crying, emotional? No, she wasn't crying. Not at all? No. That's surprising.
00:34:50
I mean, it's surprising to me now that I look at this and I see what I saw on the news and I saw the flyers.
00:34:57
And I'm like, well. So it was just the three of you inside this house? and basically it's like
00:35:05
I really didn't even fit inside her so it was basically me just sitting there and I jacked
00:35:12
myself off basically did you use a condom or anything? no I gave the condom to somebody
00:35:19
you gave the condom to somebody well there's only two other guys there I gave it to one of them
00:35:25
I opened it up and I was about to use it but I just jacked myself off and I rubbed up against her
00:35:32
as I was coming. So your DNA on the condom wrapper that was in the living room would explain?
00:35:39
It was on my hands. You touched it, you opened it, and then you handed the open condom
00:35:44
to the other guy? So this is how 44-year-old Christopher had been living his life.
00:35:52
He stole scrap metal for crack cocaine, he worked random drywall jobs and his only mode of transportation was with friends or on stolen bikes Quite frankly his life wasn worth living and it hadn been for some time
00:36:10
A long, long, long time. Chris grew up the youngest of seven kids. His father was not around when Christopher was eight years old.
00:36:22
His mother died of kidney failure. Fearing the state would try to separate the kids into foster care, Christopher's eldest sister moved the family to Cleveland to be closer to their aunt.
00:36:34
Christopher grew up and, like his older brothers, turned to drugs and petty crime.
00:36:39
So you're telling me the Nancy Reagan say no to drugs thing didn't work? Weird. Christopher was arrested throughout the late 90s and early 2000s for burglary, felonious assault, and other drug-related crimes.
00:36:53
years went by he stayed in the drug world and had a daughter of his own but by the time his little
00:37:00
girl turned six chris would be behind bars when he was 32 years old christopher attacked a female
00:37:08
friend when she came over to use his bathroom he sprang open the door stabbed her in the neck with
00:37:14
a pair of scissors and then strangled her then he grabbed me around my neck and was choking me
00:37:20
and I passed out. Then he raped her repeatedly. When she woke up, she was naked and bleeding out.
00:37:30
She barely survived. Chris was charged with third degree felonious sexual assault and attempted
00:37:36
murder, but he pleaded down the murder charge. He only got four years in prison. Four. I mean,
00:37:46
what kind of judges are we putting on the bench? Four years for a violent rape and attempted murder?
00:37:57
Makes you wonder what the fuck is going on in Ohio. Christopher has been a registered sex
00:38:03
offender since his release in 2009. On post-release control, he offended again, but managed to slip
00:38:11
through the cracks of the legal system for some reason. The sexual assault case was closed.
00:38:17
His sentencing was over. And so that could not be used as a reason to put him back into prison.
00:38:22
The process did what it's supposed to do. It doesn't make us completely safe. It never can.
00:38:28
Even Christopher's former victim knew he killed Aliana. And a person can go out and sell drugs and get more time than they gave him.
00:38:36
And now look what he done came back and did. When they found her body, it was like something came over me and said, Chris did that.
00:38:43
Her death was so violent and sick, her throat had been slashed with a box cutter.
00:38:49
Her face had been stabbed with a screwdriver. Then he had wedged her eyeball out of its socket.
00:38:56
Then he left the tools on display on the windowsill before discarding her body like trash in the corner of the room.
00:39:04
Now here Chris was, his DNA all over the place, his criminal history chock full of violence and rape.
00:39:12
And he was still trying to convince the detectives that he did nothing wrong to hurt Aliana.
00:39:19
Sure, Chris. Sure. There's only one problem with your story, Chris. The footprints in the house.
00:39:28
There's only one said. They're yours. There's only one said. There's only one set.
00:39:34
Three people went in there scrapping and then two people was in the house with me.
00:39:40
I'm not lying to you. I can show you the pictures. There's only one set of footprints in there.
00:39:44
Oh, did you believe Chris? You should probably rethink some things. A lot of stuff.
00:39:51
There were more problems with this story than just the footprints, though. I believe that you were high on drugs. I believe that you were out of your mind.
00:39:59
I can believe that point, but I don't believe that two unknown strangers that you've never met before in your life bring you to this house that you've already been to a couple of times, just decide to go to the same house that you've already been to, and then you leave.
00:40:20
and surprisingly in a matter of 10 minutes they find her bring her into the house get her naked
00:40:28
and then you return it doesn't match up chris so you're you're like halfway there you're halfway
00:40:36
to accepting responsibility but you're still trying to you're still trying to blame other people
00:40:41
no i'm not trying to blame other people i'm trying to tell you exactly what happened
00:40:45
Now, you're trying to lessen your responsibility for what happened. Christopher, there were two people in the house.
00:40:54
You and Aliana. That's it. There weren't two other people in that house. Those two other guys.
00:41:00
It was just you, wasn't it? No. I swear on my mom. I'm not going to... Don't do that.
00:41:05
Please don't do that. The prints that you left behind were bloody prints. They could only have gotten bloody if she was bloody.
00:41:16
Do you understand what I'm saying? You couldn't have just jacked off on her and then left and she was fine
00:41:23
if you have bloody prints left in the dining room. Chris had been caught, literally red-handed and red-footed.
00:41:31
It was almost as though he had no foresight at all when he killed Aliana. I guess crack does that to you.
00:41:39
it was almost as though the slap on the wrist he had received for raping a woman and stabbing her in the neck
00:41:45
enabled him the power to do this again except get it right this time this wasn about drugs this was about the fact that his urges of torture and rape were bubbling up to the surface yet again and he was powerless to stop them
00:42:25
44-year-old convicted sex offender, rapist, drug dealer, and user, Christopher Whitaker,
00:42:38
had been taken into custody for the heinous murder of 14-year-old Aliana DeVries.
00:42:45
Despite the overwhelming DNA evidence at the scene and on her body, Christopher continued to try to blame the crime on other men,
00:42:54
and, of course, his disgusting drug habit. Maybe his mind was so warped from decades of crack use
00:43:01
that he thought there were two other men with him. Or maybe he was just a seedy, worthless rapist and murderer,
00:43:08
lying his ass off to try and get away with it yet again. Which bus stop were you standing at?
00:43:13
Right there at the corner of Fuller by the church. Okay. Because we was trying to decide where we was going to get the dope from.
00:43:20
That's what I was trying to get at, get you to the church. Everybody that we was calling either wasn't even answering the phone or didn't have nothing.
00:43:30
So the video from the church is going to show us all this? The video from the church is going to show.
00:43:40
I'm standing there. My dude will walk by the show. Here I'm walking down, talking with Aliana.
00:43:49
She's probably walking a few steps behind him. and I'm still standing here. But the surveillance video from the church
00:43:56
showed Christopher pacing back and forth, confronting a timid Aliana and then stalking her as she walked away.
00:44:04
Christopher then changed his story and said two guys didn't actually go into the house with him.
00:44:10
They just helped walk her to the house. He'd gone through about four different versions of the events
00:44:16
at this point. Once you got inside to get high, what happened? Did you get high?
00:44:23
Actually, I stood, like, in the little storm thing and got high just so the wind wouldn't blow my lighter.
00:44:29
You're talking about the storm door? Is that what you're talking about? Yeah, that leads to the basement.
00:44:33
Okay. Where's she at? She's, like, standing right there by the door, back door, if you mean it.
00:44:43
What happened then? And I came through the house and said, dear, she was like, she just looked at me crazy.
00:44:52
Like, what does that make you feel like? And I said, I said, make me horny. I said, I asked her if we could get naked and do something.
00:45:03
She was like, it's cold. And she took her backpack and her jacket off anyway. and I'm thinking it's okay.
00:45:15
Sometimes his delusions are so unbelievable that it does seem like the drugs removed him from reality.
00:45:22
Christopher said it was all consensual, but then Aliana flipped on him. I don't know exactly what happened at that moment.
00:45:29
Like she attacked me or whatever. Like if she suddenly realized I was wrong and I need to get away from here,
00:45:37
but I was high and it scared me. I turned around and it's like I punched her, but then it's like after that, it's like a blur.
00:45:48
It's like I almost blacked out or something. I don't know. Okay. Where'd you punch her?
00:45:54
I really can't say. I don't know if it's in her left side or the right side of her face.
00:46:00
But in her face? Is it with a closed fist or an open hand? It might have been a closed fist, but after that, I just blacked out.
00:46:08
I just was like, fuck. When you said you punched her, did she like fall back or something like that?
00:46:16
I don't remember. Like I said, when I turned around and went into that rage, it's like I blacked out.
00:46:26
Did you have those tools with you when you went to the house? Was that something you were carrying around?
00:46:32
No. Whose backpack is that? Actually, those tools was there. They were there at the house?
00:46:39
I remember seeing them there. Where did you see them in the house? Sitting on the ledge by the window.
00:46:44
Did you use any of those tools? I don't remember what I picked up. I'm telling you that I'm still got through.
00:46:51
I don't remember what I did. I just remember when I came through that it had happened and I just discussed it right now with myself.
00:47:01
Look, yeah, Chris, there's just one more question that we have for you as far as that's concerned,
00:47:05
because I can see this is uncomfortable for you. I appreciate you telling us what happened, but there's one thing that's not.
00:47:12
I've got to get it out because I swear. After you dragged Aliana into that bedroom,
00:47:17
there's evidence that you then did something to her before you left. Do you recall that?
00:47:25
I'm being honest with you. I don't remember your name, but I'm being absolutely honest with you.
00:47:31
Okay. there's indications based on the condition of the room that you then cut her one more time at least.
00:47:40
Do you recall that? Of course, he would not recall. Christopher was selectively forgetting everything
00:47:47
about the gruesome butchery he committed with those drywall tools. But Aliana's corpse told a different story.
00:47:56
Her body told the detectives what a vile monster killer really was. Before throwing him in jail, the detectives asked him about five other missing
00:48:06
women from 93rd Street. He admitted he knew one of them and said they used to get high together.
00:48:13
She was, quote, good people. I just regret getting high. And if I was in my right state of mind and
00:48:21
their child would still be here. It's like, I mean, a lot of things get blamed on drugs, but
00:48:27
Like I told him, I was clean for three years, and then it's like when I started getting high again, I don't know what happened.
00:48:33
It just turned on a monster inside of me, I guess. I don't know, and I just hated myself so much.
00:48:39
With Christopher behind bars, Aliana's family felt a little relief. But this tragedy was far from over.
00:48:48
Here's Aliana's father. Please watch your children. There's a lot of Christopher Whitakers out here.
00:48:54
There's a lot of Christopher Whitakers out here. They're watching as I speak. Aliana's mother was determined to stand strong when the court proceeding started.
00:49:03
I'm going to go to every pretrial, every trial, everything. So he sees my face, but I want him to suffer.
00:49:12
Like, you know, he made my daughter suffer. But I also don't feel like he deserves to live for taking my daughter away from me.
00:49:22
Christopher was given 10 charges, including aggravated murder, rape, kidnapping, abuse of a corpse, and tampering with evidence.
00:49:31
He admitted that he was involved, but his defense argued that it was crack cocaine that actually caused the crime.
00:49:39
Not Christopher. Isn't it funny how you can just skate responsibility like that?
00:49:44
Just point at another thing and go, no, that did it, not me. so everyone who loved Aliana
00:49:50
including her family, her friends and teachers had to endure a very public trial
00:49:56
they had to sit there and watch CCTV footage of Aliana on a bus smiling her last smile
00:50:03
as she exited onto 93rd street they had to watch Christopher stalk her outside the church
00:50:10
they had to look at pictures of the crime scene and the unthinkable ways she had been tortured
00:50:17
They had to hear the medical examiner explain how it was most likely that she was in fact alive when Christopher stabbed her face with a screwdriver and plucked her eye out of its socket.
00:50:32
They had to hear how after he murdered Aliana, Christopher went to a local church and helped a pastor unload food pantry items with a calm smile on his face.
00:50:47
the jury found him guilty on all charges. They recommended the death penalty. The judge agreed.
00:50:58
Christopher Whitaker was sent to death row. Finally, where he belongs. Before he was locked away, Christopher told the judge he wanted to say something to Aliana's family.
00:51:10
I never wanted this to happen. Ever since that day I been in field with great remorse Through the year I made a lot of phone calls and in those calls I said things a lot of things in order to protect my family feelings
00:51:24
I've admitted to my guilt, to the detectives and to my lawyers. I asked my lawyers not to contest or challenge anything in this case because I really want
00:51:32
to freeze family to have closure. I will not try to hide behind drugs or alcohol.
00:51:40
I will not pretend or lie because it wouldn't be fair to the family. I apologize to the family and the community for my actions.
00:51:47
There is no excuse for what I've done. I can't imagine the pain the family feels, but I know the pain I felt when I had to look at what I did.
00:51:56
Outside, the media buzzed, and Aliana's family stood strong. What do you think of the death penalty recommendation?
00:52:03
I wanted life without the possibility of parole, but I respect whatever the jury and the judge has come up with.
00:52:11
I prefer him to sit there forever. You can sit on death row forever, but you're isolated.
00:52:15
I want this man to experience hell on earth before he experiences hell and afterlife.
00:52:20
Aliana DeFries' family did not stop fighting, even after the trial. Her father and stepmom made it their mission
00:52:29
to see that the house she was killed in be torn down. This cluster of forgotten homes attracted seedy activity, drug use, and crime.
00:52:40
Five women had been killed there already, and Aliana was the last girl the city was willing to lose.
00:52:47
Standing outside in the rain, Aliana's father spoke to a crowd. To our understanding, this building, this house, needed to remain standing for legal purposes.
00:52:59
But now that we have a conviction of the man that took our baby away, this house can be torn down.
00:53:08
We want to bring light to the other women that were found within a mile of this house.
00:53:15
And we want to send our condolences to their families. We have to get these eyesores and these safe havens for crime because that's what they are.
00:53:26
You have individuals that seek out these places and beforehand they come by and they replay in their mind what they plan to do later.
00:53:38
So we have to bring awareness to the dangers that lurk in these abandoned structures.
00:53:44
The house was destroyed on December 2018. Aliana's family felt that her death was preventable.
00:53:52
I think they're right. I think it was. The school she attended had an alert system in place where a text message could go out to a parent whose child didn't show up to school.
00:54:03
But on the day Aliana was murdered, Denisha received no text message. No phone call. Nothing.
00:54:10
Remember, the only reason she found out her daughter was absent was when she called the school office.
00:54:17
Aliana's family sued the school and the city. after a lot of back and forth the case was finally settled
00:54:25
and the DeFries family was given a one million dollar settlement not much if you ask me for a life taken Aliana family took it a step further and advocated for a new law to be put in place that required schools to make contact with parents
00:54:42
if their child is absent from the school within the first two hours of the school day starting.
00:54:48
This bill was brought to the House of Representatives in early 2019, and it was promptly signed and passed.
00:54:56
It's called, of course, the Aliana Alert Law. This year, Aliana DeVries would have been 21 years old.
00:55:06
She had so much ahead of her. The way she was taken from this earth is the kind of tragedy that makes your heart hurt.
00:55:15
It makes you worry about the future. Hell, it makes you worry about the present.
00:55:21
To die alone in that freezing house, in the dark and snow, with a sexually depraved monster plucking her apart as she lay there dying.
00:55:32
It's just too awful to think about. You can't let it sit in your head too long without doing some damage.
00:55:39
She was an innocent, beautiful child who was beloved by so many. Her family did everything they could to make sure her death served a higher purpose
00:55:49
for the community at large. but like Aliana's father said monsters like Christopher Whitaker
00:55:56
are out there we hear about them every day they slip through the cracks of the legal system
00:56:02
and often blame drugs for their actions but I think we all know better we've talked about so many
00:56:09
of these monsters these former human beings they're all cut from the same cloth narcissism
00:56:17
sociopathy psychopathy the inability to empathize with the pain of others, and the uncontrollable need to satisfy one's own carnal gratification above all else.
00:56:35
Christopher blamed drugs for what he did to Aliana and his other previous victim.
00:56:41
But it had little to do with drugs. Christopher had depraved urges inside of him, and he spent most of his adult life repressing them.
00:56:51
He pushed them deep, deep down inside. The deviant killer in Christopher came out when he was 32, when he stabbed and raped a woman in his bathroom.
00:57:03
Who knows what set him off then? He was able to keep his urges at bay for another 12 years until the day that he murdered Aliana.
00:57:13
Like an aerosol can near a fire, he finally exploded. This time, he couldn't stop it, just one stab to the neck.
00:57:21
He had to keep going. After he raped Aliana, he treated her like she was a dead animal in a science lab.
00:57:31
I think Christopher willingly gave up his self-control that cold January morning.
00:57:36
He wanted to do this. He got sexual gratification from not only the rape, but also the torture, the murder.
00:57:47
It made him come to be frank about it He is one of the most wicked and vile men that exist but certainly not the only one There is no forgiveness for this type of crime There is no forgiveness for what Christopher
00:58:06
has done here. No sentence suitable to fit his crime. Only Christopher knows what's waiting for
00:58:13
him when he finally crosses over to the other side for all eternity, if you believe in that
00:58:19
sort of thing. I hope he does, and I hope that his final days on Earth are filled with fear
00:58:25
as to what's coming. I hope he's a man of faith, and I hope he believes in eternal damnation
00:58:33
and hellfire. Because I think that if he's right about that, there may be a very warm
00:58:39
future waiting for him. A future much warmer, nay, hotter, than the freezing cold house
00:58:49
Aliana died in. I'm sure this will come across as bitching, but it's just me explaining to you
00:59:07
why there are so many episodes all of a sudden. I don't want you to get used to it
00:59:12
and think it's going to be the normal schedule. You see, we make our money by selling advertising or premium subs.
00:59:22
And if there are fewer of you coming in the door than there are leaving, then we can't really do that anymore, can we?
00:59:29
And Apple loves to hide us, even though we've been a top premium channel ever since they launched their premium channels.
00:59:37
service. So we're going to just put out a shitload of episodes and try to capture more eyeballs that
00:59:44
way for the time being to see if we can turn around this trend and get some more people coming in
00:59:50
the front door. I'm only telling you this because you're going to complain eventually,
00:59:54
and I'd rather just deal with it now. Stay safe. Thank you. Thank you. you