Search Captions & Ask AI

122 - Surprise! It’s Paul Holes

May 24, 2018 /

This episode features a recap of the Golden State Killer case with special guests Billy Johnson and Paul Holes. Topics include the investigation's timeline, the importance of familial DNA, and updates on the case since the arrest.

Hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark welcome Billy Johnson, who discusses the developments in the Golden State Killer case since the arrest. He shares insights about tracking the suspect's history and the challenges faced during the investigation.

Paul Holes joins the conversation, revealing details about the DNA evidence that led to the suspect's identification. He emphasizes the significance of familial DNA in solving cold cases and discusses the emotional impact on victims and their families.

The episode highlights the collaboration between law enforcement and the true crime community, showcasing how public interest can aid investigations. The hosts and guests reflect on the societal changes surrounding discussions of sexual assault and the justice system.

Listeners gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of the case and the ongoing efforts to bring justice to victims. The episode concludes with a call to action for listeners to support initiatives aimed at solving cold cases.

TLDR

Billy Johnson and Paul Holes recap the Golden State Killer case, discussing investigation updates and the role of familial DNA in solving cold cases.

Episode

1:27:15
00:00:00
This is exactly right. Isn't some far off concept? It's already here. Next starts now.
00:00:33
Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Goodbye. If audiobooks are your thing, or if you've been meaning to listen to more of them,
00:00:40
you should check out a podcast called Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club, hosted by Cal Penn.
00:00:46
Each episode spotlights standout audiobooks on Audible across all kinds of genres.
00:00:51
Sci-fi, comedy, romance, thrillers, and more. With Cal talking to guests who help break down what makes each story worth listening to.
00:00:57
It's a fun, easy way to discover your next great audiobook. Check out Earsay on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:06
Goodbye! The best parts of summer aren't just places. They're feelings. It's the scent of fresh ocean air, sun-warmed skin, and long evenings outside.
00:01:15
Pure's new summer collection is designed to capture those fleeting moments and make them last.
00:01:20
Restore your sense of place with clean, premium fragrances you control from your phone.
00:01:24
Bring the feeling of summer home. Discover the collection at Pura.com. Goodbye. Okay.
00:01:47
Okay, well then, maybe we should start this very special episode. This is the most special episode.
00:01:53
Welcome to my favorite murder. the podcast where we go to a studio that we never go to and record there where it feels really weird
00:02:03
and professional and there's no cats uh we're wearing headphones which is odd yeah well here
00:02:10
we are um but we have special guests yeah we have special guests today plural when have we had guests
00:02:17
not a lot i think guy brandon's been a guest and that's it and that's and our guest today has been
00:02:24
I guess. Which is about to happen now. Now it is. Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome Mr. Billy
00:02:29
Johnson. Hello, ladies. How you doing? And hello, all you murderinos out there. Hi, thanks for being
00:02:34
here. This is a special episode. This is a special episode. You guys are definitely still jet lag.
00:02:41
It's special because it's the first one we're recording back from our European 2018 European
00:02:48
tour. That's right. Which was very exciting. Oh, the choir's here. Hold on a second.
00:02:54
Hang on. Close that door. We left the back door open. That's how much we're not used to recording in the studio. Doors are
00:03:02
open. Thanks. Okay. Thanks. So, we're back from Europe. Back from Europe. We have jet lag.
00:03:08
We have jet lag. Georgia has a cold. I'm cold. I'm going to repeat everything you say. But
00:03:13
the fun part is this is we finally get to do the episode where we like recap and go back over the golden state killer case arrest and um and then we
00:03:27
have a very special call-in uh guest yeah surprise right yeah we keep you in a surprise it's a
00:03:33
surprise yeah it's a surprise we'll keep a surprise oh i might i might when we introduce him i'll
00:03:37
oh i already said it was a him um oh shit oh now they all know it's paul holes oh shit
00:03:44
I wanted it to be Carol Daly. God damn it. Where's Erica Hutchcraft when you do it?
00:03:51
All right. So, well, Billy, what, since this is your show, what is the foremost kind of update piece of information of this case since,
00:04:05
I guess since the press conference is when we last talked to you? There's not. One thing is that this guy really didn't have a lot of friends.
00:04:12
He was not, you know, and what I did is it was so strange when as soon as it happened, and you guys are some of the first that I was talking to when it was happening, when I found out at one o'clock in the morning in the bed in Chicago, a flip switched in my head and it was all about, okay, everything went away.
00:04:28
Everything about the homework evidence and his shoe patterns and all that, that all went away and it was all about build a timeline and it was all about what other crimes has he done.
00:04:38
So I've been reaching out and trying to find anybody that might know this guy to build a timeline of where he's been and then also what other crimes that he's been that he could be involved with.
00:04:48
And, you know, there's not a lot of people that were friendly with him. We already we know from the people in Exeter that he was kind of he very much kept to himself on the police force.
00:04:59
Everybody would joke around, pal around. And he was kind of like very serious, very serious.
00:05:03
and uh you know we're trying to track down his navy people obviously can't you know ken and all
00:05:09
the people in the um in the the sack police department they're trying to track down all
00:05:13
these people one of the things that i've been doing just via twitter and via a couple facebook
00:05:17
pages that i had launched when the book started is having anybody reach out to me before it happened
00:05:24
before he was caught i had two people reach out to me and say that they were actually they
00:05:30
encountered him at one point and one woman said that he broke into her house it was right around
00:05:35
the same time period he saw that she was there and and heard that there was somebody else in there
00:05:41
and he decided not to do anything because it sounded like he didn't realize somebody was in
00:05:44
the house and he just said to her you really need to fix your screen door and then walked out
00:05:50
so i had that information i said well can i give that to the police because did you file a police report she said yes i did i was like well there might be something in that police report because we had none of it Me and Paul Haynes looked in Michelle hard drive We had none of that
00:06:05
So we said, well, maybe they don't know about it either. Maybe it just slid under the radar.
00:06:08
Maybe there might be something in there that, oh, a neighbor saw this kind of car
00:06:11
and then it could lead to something. So that was like three weeks before he was caught.
00:06:15
It had nothing to do with it because we all know what happened. but since I got I've gotten a couple of tweets at me and I've talked to people and and and
00:06:26
interviewed them and realized that this guy very well might have attacked people before
00:06:31
he started everyone is kind of like there's no way he started at 30 years old right yeah and
00:06:38
he you know it's a very easy narrative and it's a very convenient narrative to say okay he started
00:06:44
as the ransacker. He probably started as a peeper. Then he started going into people's houses and
00:06:49
ransacking. Then he decided to go on and rape people inside the houses, then rape a person with
00:06:56
a couple, and then ended up killing. That makes sense to people because there's that escalation.
00:07:03
But what if he was attacking people before that? A guy texted me, and we got into this conversation.
00:07:09
I talked to him every day now, and his mother was attacked on the street. She was hitchhiking.
00:07:15
Her mother was attacked on the street. And he showed her, you know, she was raped, and it was a possible murder.
00:07:23
It was an attempted murder. He actually drove over her with his car. Wow. Wait, sorry.
00:07:26
Was this in Visalia? No, this wasn't in Visalia. But this was in, I don't want to exactly say where it was, but it was in a town that he's been in.
00:07:33
Okay. And it was before everything had happened that we knew about. but it was around the time of the ransackers actually it's like right before it and um she
00:07:44
had never seen uh they never solved it they never had any you know they had one suspect but he didn't
00:07:50
pan out her she's had tons of surgeries you know it's really affected her and she he showed her the
00:07:58
the picture and she started to shake and she really thinks that she had 100 id on this guy
00:08:06
now that could be it i don't want to mention any names or names or anything like that so you know
00:08:12
i hooked him up with the da i don't i want to whether it was him or not i just want i want to
00:08:16
get this guy justice because it was a horrible story and i'm going to get it out there and if
00:08:21
it wasn't him it was obviously somebody else we're going to try and work on that whether they kept
00:08:26
the rape kit is the question because we know that sacramento threw away the rape kits thank god for
00:08:33
Paul and Contra Costa that they kept those rape kits. Yeah. Because they used to just throw stuff away because the statute of limitations was up.
00:08:40
I've been thinking a lot about the statute of limitations from this case. Yeah. All these cases and them throwing the rape kits away because of the statute of limitations
00:08:49
and how now we're all testing these old backlog rape kits. And, you know, everyone wants to fucking strangle the statute of limitations.
00:08:58
I wonder if there's someone out there, there's some way we can make it so that if you hadn't
00:09:01
tested it before the statute of limitations was up, you know, it can be extended somehow
00:09:07
because it's not on you that the fucking rape kit wasn't tested and run through the
00:09:11
system. Yeah. Like the normal rules shouldn't apply. Right. Because the normal rules didn't apply.
00:09:18
Right. Because the due diligence wasn't done. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, the fact that we now know that now that the floodgates are open and we've been
00:09:26
screaming from the rooftops that we should be doing familial DNA and doing it this way
00:09:29
for a while. Which we'll get into. But the fact that there are still rape kits that haven't been tested, and now that they've been tested and profiles have been made, but what are they doing with those profiles and where are they putting them?
00:09:41
And it's the biggest travesty for me in American justice system is that the trauma that somebody goes through from a sexual assault and then the trauma that you have to go through for actually telling somebody and then on top of that going through the exam and then having somebody just put it in a locker for years and years.
00:09:58
Not only that and that person's justice, but it's the next person's justice. It's the next woman or the next male's justice.
00:10:05
So every one of those rape kits should be running through Familia right now, in my opinion.
00:10:10
And also for the other reason, we actually just talked about this in some city we were in on the tour.
00:10:16
Because it also is keeping free somebody who should not be free. The justice should be executed on that rapist because that idea that this – well, this happened, but it's not a priority or it doesn't matter that much.
00:10:31
It absolutely should be just as much of a priority as murder. Right. I mean the idea that that has somehow – that the way people look at it is like it's a lesser crime or that it's less than anything.
00:10:47
that's kind of the cool part about this story really coming to the fore so much is like
00:10:51
people hearing 50 rapes in the 70s and i think it's that you know it's like it was a time where
00:10:57
it was okay it's calm down it's not that big of a deal yeah and think about how many i mean we
00:11:04
still hear so much about how many sexual assaults are not reported right about how many sexual
00:11:08
reports were not reported back then yeah yeah and the the police officers and we've talked about
00:11:14
that certain police officers that don't, you know, are not good with sexual assaults,
00:11:18
especially back then when they were being reported. Yeah, and there's no training.
00:11:22
There was no, the idea of sensitivity training was a joke. Right. And, yeah. Right advocates, no such fucking thing.
00:11:28
Yeah. Also, that makes me think of the fact that it's, you know, the bone chilling reveal that
00:11:35
he was a policeman in Auburn. Then you think, what if that fucking guy was the guy that came to your house after you were
00:11:43
attacked? I mean like yeah it opens that door It just like horror after horror with this with this case But like the idea that he was a person that that had that much authority and power as an Auburn policeman and that he was living this double life Once again this whole case is so cinematically dramatic and insane
00:12:05
It's almost too over the top. It's over the top. Is the estranged wife coming forward at all, or is she not speaking?
00:12:14
She is not speaking now. To anyone? Neither is Bonnie. To the cops? I don't know if she's speaking to the cops or not.
00:12:21
We can talk about that. Is she our surprise guest? I was right with that. You know, so, yeah, we might as well call him now.
00:12:30
But, you know, so I had the opportunity. He was going to come to CrimeCon anyway.
00:12:35
We were doing, you know, CrimeCon is like Comic-Con for crime. It was in Nashville.
00:12:39
We had two presentations about the Golden State Killer, which we had to completely tear up.
00:12:47
We do. And I really wanted to, you know, and we moved. The first one was going to be just a deep dive into the evidence.
00:12:54
And me and Paul Haynes were going to go through and we're going to do this and that.
00:12:57
And we're going to say, like, you know, what about this piece of evidence? No, that's junk.
00:13:00
And this looks like the best sketch and everything. So obviously that went to hell.
00:13:03
But it was going to be in a small room. He said, no, we've got to move you into the bigger room.
00:13:06
Yeah. So we go in, we look out. There's like 2,500 people in this room. Holy shit.
00:13:10
And I wanted to give Paul his due, you know, because Paul didn't get to speak at the press conference.
00:13:15
And it was just sort of leaking out that he was the guy that really solved this thing.
00:13:19
and Paul was you know Paul very much you know because we were talking about the book
00:13:24
and we were there because it was for Michelle's book you know Paul would say that he felt that Michelle
00:13:28
was his partner so you know it made sense for him to come out so we brought him out
00:13:34
and it was like Beatlemania I love it it was like nothing you've ever seen he gets a standing ovation
00:13:42
and then after everybody is trying to take selfies with him and he can't walk five feet
00:13:47
without somebody grabbing him and you know it made me smile just because and the reason why i was very upset that they didn't put
00:13:54
him or put anybody else of the real investigators that were in the trenches at that press conference
00:13:58
they wouldn't put him on the screen is that what i want to see is in true crime when you work in
00:14:03
true crime for so long the biggest thing that comes to you is that there's so many super villains
00:14:07
we're surrounded by super villains manson bundy gacy dommer name the superheroes and you can't
00:14:15
You know, you might say John Walsh or you might say, you know, this person or that person or maybe like a local policeman.
00:14:21
But we don't put them out there. And, you know, I was thinking about Paul. It's like if we're going to get a superhero out of any of this, it's going to be Paul.
00:14:29
And Paul is going to be somebody that – listen, if he's going to have the hot for holes hashtag and he's going to be this.
00:14:36
And he's going to be this. I did not start that, by the way. You did not start the hot for holes.
00:14:39
I did not. No, I think I started it. But if you – you know, if he's going to be a hard thrower, then so be it.
00:14:45
Because what I want is I want a little kid to be watching the screen the way that they did back in the day when they would see Jack Webb or FBI guys up on the screen and say, I want to be like that guy.
00:14:55
Yes, exactly. Or a little girl seeing Erica Hutchcraft or Carol Daly and be like, I want to be like her.
00:15:02
Yeah. And those are the heroes that we need to be pushing in front of the camera just because we have such this imbalance in this explosion that we've seen with true crime.
00:15:09
And you know that the kind of people that will take this, you know, ridiculous, funny hashtag power and use it for good.
00:15:15
Yes, exactly. And if it puts it out there and then, you know, this case and the legacy of this case is all about not only solving this case, but solving so many other cases.
00:15:25
And we've already seen it. The floodgates are open. We've already seen cases are going down.
00:15:29
And there's so many cases now that we can solve based on this one. And thank God it was a big one.
00:15:34
Because if it was a smaller one or if it was a sort of nebulous one, you might get people saying, oh, you know, and we had that a little bit where people were saying there's privacy laws, there's this or that.
00:15:43
But nobody is really defending this guy and defending someone that had at least 50 rapes and 12 murders.
00:15:51
I want to talk about this. Should we bring out our special surprise guest? Well, here's what I was thinking.
00:15:57
you know he he needs his he he he is the superhero of this story and we were going to have him on the
00:16:05
phone but oh no no what's about to happen that door is open oh no billy just went somewhere
00:16:19
Billy stepped out Oh no Paul Holes is in the building everyone Paul Holes is hugging Karen
00:16:38
He's in the building I thought Billy just walked off the podcast I thought he got pissed and was gone
00:16:46
Oh my god ladies and gentlemen And it's Paul Holes. Hi. Hi, Georgia. Hi, Karen. Hi, Paul.
00:16:54
Hi, Paul Holes. Paul Holes. Billy, thanks for doing this. You're welcome. As I'm driving up to Sacramento, hitting him on his head, putting him in my truck,
00:17:02
dropping him back down. It was a long night, but he's here. Oh, my God. This is a surprise to Karen.
00:17:09
I knew it was happening, but I'm still up. You knew it was happening? Oh, yeah. Oh, I read it through.
00:17:13
I made sure I read it through, Georgia. I texted her and I said, does she like surprises?
00:17:19
I was like, no. She doesn't hate surprises. Okay, can I just say this in my own defense, Paul Holes?
00:17:26
First of all, I don't know if you heard that, but I did not start the hot for holes hashtag.
00:17:29
That was not me. No. It's not my style. No. But as we were just saying, I think that a lot of this excitement, and we were just talking about like crime con and stuff.
00:17:40
I think a lot of this excitement is kind of like an overly simplistic way of kind of giving you
00:17:46
like a ticker tape parade in a way that you can't do anymore it's like we're doing it
00:17:51
social media style we doing it murderino style but like you know you were the lighthouse keeper for decades on a case that that should have or you know for whatever reason ended up not getting solved for so long and was so horrible
00:18:07
And like, we've talked about it, like watching you talk about it on that ID special where you know, every single fact, you know, every single path.
00:18:17
You seem as passionate as us. You're not detached from it. And you give Michelle, who is one of us, so much credit, which means so much to us.
00:18:27
Well, and when the cameras weren't on, when she first came to you, you welcomed her with open arms.
00:18:31
I mean, you just could not have done it better. So I think there's a lot of this is stupid.
00:18:36
Like, it's very stupid and incredibly embarrassing. It's funny and silly and fun way.
00:18:42
Just saying it's just a humongous thank you. Yeah. Oh, well, you know, it's been just a surreal experience.
00:18:49
Yeah, tell us about this experience. What's it been like? Well, after the press conference when D'Angelo was announced, you know, I had with Jane Carson and Debbie Domingo, they had convinced me to go to CrimeCon about a month prior.
00:19:03
And so as we were marching down with D'Angelo, I didn't think there was any way I'd be able to make it out to Nashville.
00:19:09
I had no idea what I was walking into. and it was great but my first uh i guess experience was i was walking in the hallway
00:19:18
and it was late at night on a thursday evening and this mother and daughter passed me by
00:19:22
didn't pay any attention to them and all of a sudden i hear this paul and i look around and they're looking at me and that's the first time i've ever been
00:19:31
recognized by somebody i have no idea who they are and then for the course of the next two days
00:19:37
It was amazing in terms of all these murderinos coming up to me and getting pictures.
00:19:43
I didn't have a Twitter account, but my wife's friends were all of a sudden saying,
00:19:49
Hey, Paul's getting pictures of all these women. Where is he at? What is going on?
00:19:53
Can we talk about that for one second? Because, first of all, the sincerest of apologies to Mrs. Holes.
00:20:01
All of this is so out of control. Does she like it? Is she pissed? Oh, no. She's been a great sport about it.
00:20:08
Okay, good. You know, she's the one that's actually watching and letting me know.
00:20:12
Because I'm so afraid to go on and Google myself because I don't want to see what exactly is out there.
00:20:18
But she's been great about it. You don't. Take it from us. But, you know, at the same time, she didn't know what was going on at a crime con either.
00:20:25
And then so I get the phone call. She's going, what is going on out there? She didn't know you'd have fangirls.
00:20:31
So many. Well, it's so many women. Fangirls. But it's like 90% women. And also, 90% of women who have been watching you be a talking head on these shows for years.
00:20:42
Yeah. You know? We've seen the screen grabs from 10 years ago. Oh, yeah. I know.
00:20:48
I'm learning that what gets out there on the internet stays out there forever. It's forever.
00:20:52
It's forever. It is. It's horrifying. And since I've gotten a Twitter account, it's been one of those things where I've probably posted a couple things going, oh, what did I just do?
00:21:03
You never delete it. That's just it. um so wait then at crime con because we had a couple friends who were there that was the most
00:21:11
exciting thing i was like the um my friend katie reif who's a reporter for the av club was there
00:21:16
and i was like you need to tell me every single thing that happens because she was in the room too
00:21:20
and she was just like the whole room just went insane and then i got the report from billy also
00:21:25
when it was over but it was like it was because i was i just wanted it to be what we thought it
00:21:31
you deserve. And what we wanted to see at the news conference, what's it called? Press conference.
00:21:37
We wanted to see, which is like, you guys, which I know isn't professional, but in the background,
00:21:43
seeing you there being like, you should just get up there. Well, you know, at CrimeCon, when Billy
00:21:48
pulled me out onto the stage, that was such a humbling experience. And yes, in many ways,
00:21:54
I've been the face of the investigation. But really, I think everybody was applauding
00:21:58
everybody that's been involved in the investigation. So that's the thing that needs to get out there
00:22:05
is that there's men and women that are still actively investigating the case. They have been
00:22:11
on this case for, in some instances, decades. And they don't have the opportunity I have in order
00:22:18
to be able to come out and be a public figure at this point. So I think that applause, I mean,
00:22:24
And it sent just chills up my spine when I got it because I never thought I'd be in front of that many people in a standing ovation.
00:22:34
But again, I think that was an ovation for the team. Absolutely. I'm going to say this right now because I'm sitting right next to him.
00:22:39
Paul has goosebumps right now. I did too. It's so exciting. Well, because as you both know, this – and as they said in that press conference or whatever, but this doesn't happen that often.
00:22:52
And so the idea that it just happened. We get to applaud the solving of a case. The trajectory all of it took.
00:22:58
It was just like. Can you tell us like the phone call that you got that the DNA was a match?
00:23:04
Can you, I bet that was insane. So that was, it was, I was out of state, you know, shopping for a house because I'm in the process of moving out of California and at a restaurant at P.F. Chang's.
00:23:16
Oh, plug. That was a plug. We'll make a lot of money off that. Thank you. Sesame chicken.
00:23:22
So I had just finished eating, and I get a call from Lieutenant Kirk Campbell, who's one of the investigators from Sacramento DA's office.
00:23:32
And I see that he's calling, and we had had D'Angelo under surveillance, so I knew, okay, this call is an important phone call.
00:23:40
So I go out, and Kirk says, okay, you can't tell anybody about this. Except for Karen and Georgia.
00:23:48
And he said the initial DNA results, because we had gotten a surreptitious sample,
00:23:56
SACSO had gotten a surreptitious sample from D'Angelo, came back. And though it's a low-level profile, which means it was not a complete DNA profile,
00:24:05
but the lab is really excited with what they see. And, you know, with my background, I'm saying, what exactly do they have?
00:24:12
And once he told me, I knew it was the guy. And then I walk back in, and we're getting our fortune cookies.
00:24:18
Oh, my God. My wife is opening up her fortune cookie and all excited about what it says.
00:24:22
You know, I could care less about what the fortune cookie says at that point. And you literally and truly can't tell your wife.
00:24:27
Like, that's a secret that you have to keep. I can't tell you. Come on. I told her.
00:24:33
But she read it on my face. Yeah. I'm sure. And I wasn't going to tell her in the restaurant because I knew what the reaction would be.
00:24:40
And so I'm trying to not tell her. And she knew who had called. And next thing you know, she's like pushing me out the restaurant wanting to know what's going on.
00:24:47
And you still owe that PF Chang $62. They're also the surprise guy. The manager from that PF Chang.
00:24:55
Everyone may be. I love it. While the world watches the stars at the FIFA World Cup this summer, Hyundai has its eyes on the next generation of talent.
00:25:04
The future soccer stars who are already turning heads at age 14. Making plays that end up on everyone's feed, scoring from angles that don't make sense, rewriting record books that barely had time to gather dust.
00:25:15
Because Next doesn't wait for an invitation, and Hyundai doesn't either. Hyundai has always moved the future within reach.
00:25:20
Hyundai did it by making advanced safety standard on every vehicle. Hyundai did it by engineering EVs with ultra-fast charging capability.
00:25:28
And Hyundai continues doing it every day. From robotics that change how people live to young athletes changing the game,
00:25:34
the future isn't some far-off concept. It's already here. Next starts now. Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA.
00:25:41
Goodbye. Pandora Jewelry brings the sparkle to summer, now with even better prices.
00:25:46
Shop now for up to 50% off select jewelry featuring personalized pieces to must-have summer favorites.
00:25:52
Timeless jewelry made to move with you through every moment. Shop in-store or online now through July 5th.
00:25:57
Terms and conditions apply. See pandora.net for more details. Goodbye. This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace.
00:26:05
It's 2026. And if you have an alternative career like food photography or professional mixtape making or witchcraft, you're going to need an online presence.
00:26:13
Whatever your thing is, Squarespace helps you build a website that's as unique as you are.
00:26:17
Squarespace provides you everything you need to offer services and get paid all in one place.
00:26:22
From consultations to events and experiences, you can showcase your offerings with a customizable website designed to attract clients and grow your business.
00:26:30
Get paid on time with professional invoices and online payments. Plus, streamline your workflow with built-in appointment scheduling and email marketing tools.
00:26:38
With Squarespace's collection of cutting-edge design tools, anyone can build a beautiful professional online presence that perfectly fits their brand or business.
00:26:45
Head to squarespace.com slash murder for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use offer code murder to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
00:26:53
Goodbye. Do you still, sorry, do you talk to Carol Daly or do you like? Carol Daly and I communicated, but believe it or not, we had not met or even communicated up until about a couple months ago.
00:27:07
Wow. So that was one of those things in this case where, I mean, she is somebody that deserves so much credit for the work she did with the victims up in Sacramento.
00:27:18
And if you ever got to see her reports, it was cutting edge in terms of recording all the victimology, not only the circumstances of what happened, you know, what the offender did, what he said, which gave us insight into who this guy was, but also who the victims were.
00:27:35
And that's very important when you're dealing with a fantasy-motivated type of crime.
00:27:40
So she did an amazing job. And I always was like, wow, this is an amazing woman in terms of what she was doing back in the 1970s.
00:27:48
And then I finally got to talk to her on the phone once some of the media attention was coming out before we had even identified D'Angelo as being a person.
00:27:58
And then afterwards, I got to meet her in person for the first time. And that was a great experience.
00:28:02
Yeah, she seems amazing. I just re-watched the IDC special to do the before the arrest, after the arrest.
00:28:09
What was it called? There's still more to tell. We don't know who it is. What is it?
00:28:14
It's Unanswered Questions? Yeah, it's called Unanswered Questions, the Golden State Killer.
00:28:19
There's more to come. But, I mean, it's really fascinating, like you're saying, the comprehensive job that she did.
00:28:26
But also just like she's just so on point to this day. And then back then when you see those pictures and you see the video of her.
00:28:36
Like, don't be polite. Her don't be polite speech and all that stuff where you're just like this.
00:28:41
She must have been one of a handful of women in that Sacramento County Sheriff's Department.
00:28:45
A real victims advocate. Not only that, just across the country. Think about how many sexual assaults that had happened that didn't have a Carol Daly there.
00:28:52
Totally. What she was doing, like you said, was so groundbreaking. Well, and I believe she was the first female assigned to investigations for Sac Sheriff's Office.
00:29:00
So, you know, she was cutting edge. She blazed a trail. Yeah. The 70s sucked. It's very cool, though, that she is kind of like one of those lights that comes up in the story, too.
00:29:12
And, you know, I don't know. We should hear from her more, I think. That makes me – can I ask a couple specific questions that you probably can't answer, Mr. Paul Hulls, but you probably can, about speaking of her speaking at the town halls.
00:29:27
Was he there at any of them? Do we know? You know, that is something that I think we're still trying to figure out.
00:29:40
You know, Carol has a memory of one of the victims standing up and speaking in front of the town hall.
00:29:48
And he does, him and his wife, do become victims later on. Now her memory has somewhat changed over time which you would expect after four years So that is going to be one of those questions as to was he in the audience saw this man and decided I will show you who I am How dare you speak
00:30:09
against what I am doing? Which I believe absolutely this offender would do. He's very vindictive.
00:30:16
I believe some of the cases that involve males were selected based on who the males were and
00:30:21
what they had done to him, either directly or indirectly. Which ones of those victims?
00:30:26
At this point, I don't know. And he very well could be in other town hall meetings.
00:30:33
But right now, it's speculation. But it does make sense with who he is. So does that mean that he might have actually known some of the victims?
00:30:43
I know you can't answer any of this. Well, the reality is, I don't know. And that's one of the big questions that I have is,
00:30:51
I always, marching down and investigating this case, I truly felt that the victim selection, he was multimodal.
00:30:58
There are victims that he absolutely just followed home. There are victims that while he's out prowling a neighborhood, he stumbled across.
00:31:05
He likes a certain neighborhood and picks the right victim. Absolutely. It's a neighborhood that is conducive to him.
00:31:10
Yeah, and he had a lot of potential spots in each neighborhood. You can choose any neighborhood and find a victim.
00:31:16
And so in many ways, he may have employed that strategy where he goes, I know how to get in.
00:31:21
I know how to get out of this neighborhood. They're all single-story houses. I don't have to worry about witnesses in the second floor seeing me hopping fences.
00:31:30
So it's very possible he could have just chosen a neighborhood and then found somebody that met his criteria and the opportunity presented itself.
00:31:39
But I do think it is possible that he has had interaction with some of these victims ahead of time, both females and males.
00:31:47
And that was one of the things I was trying to do, in particular, try to identify the males to see if there was maybe a business setting or some other type of sporting activity that they could have interfaced with at some point.
00:32:00
Yeah, I mean, even Jane says the story about how during the attack, he said, you looked really good at the O Club.
00:32:07
and he didn't use the term officers club he said oh you had to be she she thought he was definitely
00:32:13
in the military because whether he had seen her at the officers club or not but the fact that he
00:32:17
used the term oh club meant that he was in the military so she wondered if he may have seen her
00:32:22
at some point yeah and we did see you know this this offender was very much into trying to put
00:32:30
to the victims on edge, and he would look at the victims' lifestyles and make comments
00:32:37
to try to make them think that he had seen them or they knew him. In the San Ramon attack, he tells that victim, I've seen you at the lake.
00:32:49
Well, on her driveway was a boat. So it's sort of one of those things. He's spried enough to go, okay, she's probably been to the lake at some point, and so I'm
00:32:57
going to use that against her just to kind of get her on edge. Well, and I was talking to my sister about it because my sister can't deal with any true crime anything.
00:33:05
But she was asking me questions. And I'm like, okay, but I'll answer this for you.
00:33:09
But then you're going to know. But she was saying it doesn't make sense why the victims didn't call the police.
00:33:15
And I'm like, okay, I'm about to tell you something you're not going to like. And it's going to keep you up.
00:33:19
The way he would wait there and it would be dead silent. They would think he was gone.
00:33:25
They would move. And then he would threaten them again. Like that idea, so then they would end up just laying there, like stock still till the morning came.
00:33:33
Because they didn't know if he was still there, so he'd have hours of getaway. It's so, like, deviously brilliant in that way of keeping that time frame so that he has so much time to get as far away as he can.
00:33:46
Absolutely. And, in fact, in attack number 13 up in Sacramento, you have a mother and daughter laying side by side in the bed.
00:33:54
And he was somebody that was able to move through the house silently. That's one of the things that the victims were commenting on.
00:34:01
And at a certain point, it's been quiet for a long time. And so the mother asks the daughter, are you okay?
00:34:08
And the daughter responds, shh, mommy. And all of a sudden, he pushes down on the bed right next to the mother's head.
00:34:14
That's what's so, I think that that is what is so, that draws us in about this case is what a, it wasn't just about rape for him.
00:34:23
and murder, it's so much more like of a head fuck. Absolutely. And just conniving and cunning and terrifying.
00:34:32
Terrorizing. He's a psychological sadist. So his big thing was the fear he was instilling in the victims.
00:34:40
So when you read the actual sexual assaults, and they did vary. Some of the sexual assaults were almost styled like a consensual type of interaction
00:34:51
where he had obviously been fantasizing about that female. Then you have some of the sexual assaults were much more violent.
00:34:59
But many of the victims were commenting in terms, especially later on in the East Area Rapist phase,
00:35:05
he did not seem to be getting what he wanted from the sex. And that's when you start to see this, you know, uh-oh,
00:35:13
he's feeling internally he needs more. And then down in the first attack in Galita, Santa Barbara,
00:35:19
when he's got them separated and bound, the two, the male and female victims. He's pacing back and forth saying, I'm going to kill him.
00:35:25
I'm going to kill him this time. I'm going to kill him. He obviously realized he had to take the next step to satisfy that inner compulsion.
00:35:32
And then in all the Goleta attacks, he fails because the victims fight back, right?
00:35:37
So it is interesting in that, yes, you can make that argument. Most certainly in the first two, which were within a few months of each other,
00:35:46
right at the end of 1979 with what could have been a double homicide and the victims end up
00:35:54
running away from him and then he has to bail and then FBI agent chases him Two months later with Dr Offerman and Dr Manning Dr Offerman slips his bindings and gets up and charges him and gets shot
00:36:07
He's killed, and he goes over and shoots Dr. Manning. And then a year and a half later, he's back in basically the same area with Sherry Domingo and Gregory Sanchez,
00:36:18
and he gets into a physical fight with Gregory Sanchez. it doesn't go the way he wants but he does leave dna evidence in that scene so he at least got to
00:36:28
the point where he's leaving dna evidence right and was the mandyori double shooting before all
00:36:35
of those murders that was in february 78 yes it was do you think it could have been because there
00:36:41
is the talk that that was could have been a thing where maybe um uh the guy recognized him or there
00:36:47
was some reason why he had to shoot that couple that maybe the it was accidental being forced to
00:36:53
murder and then suddenly he's got a taste for murder in a way that he hasn't before well i think
00:36:59
when you look at the entirety of the series because right now it really is looking like
00:37:03
d'angelo is also the visalia ransacker right and you do have the homicide of claude snelling
00:37:09
so he has a taste of of murder at that point of the maggiore case the predominant theory right now
00:37:17
with Maggiore is Brian and Katie were out walking their dog. Brian being a military police officer known to have an aggressive personality, they stumble
00:37:26
across a guy that's out prowling. And Brian puts his cop hat on, confronts the guy, possibly chases the guy until the guy
00:37:34
decides he's going to catch me and pulls a gun. Which he's done twice before, besides the Snelling.
00:37:40
Didn't he shoot the... You have the Rodney Miller case. Right, and the kid who chased him, and then the cop.
00:37:46
I know a lot of us. We're about specifics on the show. Okay, yeah. So, you know, in that particular instance, it may have been, even though it was most likely a defensive type shooting, you know, he has power and control over those victims.
00:38:05
He took their lives. He made that decision. And that's what this guy is all about.
00:38:08
And I think also, and we know that he changed tactics again when somebody, you know, even though he didn't, you know, he knew he almost got caught and then he moved.
00:38:17
He moved areas. He didn't attack in that area again. He was very, almost one of his signatures was his, not only his ability to escape really, and his ability to know all the different escape routes, which leads you to believe that maybe one of those escape routes when he was walking around when he was prowling was whipping out his badge when he did have the badge.
00:38:36
or whether he kept the badge and saying, oh, no, I'm just, you know, I'm a police officer
00:38:40
and using the police vernacular. You know, he knew all of these different ways. The reason why he chose that neighborhood is because he grew up, not necessarily in that
00:38:48
exact neighborhood, but he grew up near that neighborhood in Branch of Cordova. And he knew that all of those escape routes, you know.
00:38:55
And I think that's very much, and when something went south for him, he would say, I've got
00:39:00
to go someplace else. And one of the things that we were talking, I was talking about this with another investigator
00:39:04
involved in the case, who we both know, but I won't mention his name because he doesn't like
00:39:09
the spotlight. But he was saying how, you know, I was talking before about this other case that
00:39:16
somebody had told me about. The son had told me about this, his mom, and his mom very well might
00:39:21
have been one of his victims, but it was early on in the case. And the investigator told me,
00:39:26
you know, we've seen this guy at his best. We saw him when he got away with 50 rapes and 12 murders.
00:39:31
we didn't see him in the minor leagues we didn't see him when he was coming up and he was making
00:39:37
mistakes really we don't really have that and you know what he was doing or potentially doing before
00:39:43
that when he was even a teenager what he was doing you know and that's one of the things that i'm
00:39:47
trying to do is create that timeline to figure out all right did he ever go to summer camp did
00:39:51
he ever go on a on a work trip or whatever uh did he ever in korea when he was visiting his dad did
00:39:56
he ever go off and say you know any furloughs that he might have had in the in the navy any of those
00:40:00
those deals, you know, what he might have done, you know, gone on vacation and said,
00:40:05
I'm going for a walk. And then what did he do then? Yeah, he, there's so much that's out there.
00:40:11
And we really didn't know what he was doing before he really got it because he became an
00:40:15
expert at doing what he was doing. He did, though, I would say Visalia, he was in the minor leagues.
00:40:21
Visalia Ransacker was not a very good burglar, struggled to get inside houses, even though he
00:40:27
did get in many, many houses. He was constantly being seen by neighbors, by victims.
00:40:36
And when you look at after that series stopped six months later, now you have somebody who
00:40:44
all of a sudden has more advanced skill sets being able to break inside houses. Nobody sees East Area Rapist. And East Area Rapist is now doing everything he can from
00:40:55
getting from being seen even by the victims by wearing a mask shining flashlights in their eyes
00:41:00
even even with those precautions he's telling the victims don't look at me or i'll kill you
00:41:05
he recognized in visalia he made a mistake he left a trail and he changed he learned and that's the
00:41:13
evolution of d'angelo and he also changed so much that he was a cop in exeter and he sees that you
00:41:20
know i probably need to leave exeter because someone might recognize me and then he goes up
00:41:24
Maybe he saw that, you know, when we were doing the newspaper archive searches, you see the ad for, hey, Auburn's looking for police officers.
00:41:31
He sees that. He goes up there and decides, I'm going to go back to my hometown and do it.
00:41:36
And was he, when he was a cop in Exeter, was he heavy like the Visalia Ransacker was?
00:41:41
Like, that was one thing we talked about when we talked, we had the book episode and this was all pre-arrest.
00:41:50
But it truly looks like two different people. The descriptions are completely different.
00:41:54
Yeah. And I know there was a lot of active rapists at that time unfortunately there But it almost like he did a kind of like a PX90 thing
00:42:05
Like he did a makeover and like a workout thing where suddenly he's super agile and silent.
00:42:10
Are you saying he invented PX90? I'm saying let's take a look at that guy before we go any further.
00:42:17
I mean, if you take a look, and I've actually got him right there, you know, how heavy his face was.
00:42:22
And that was always the stumbling block that Paul had and I had and Michelle had and Paul Haynes had was whether this guy who was being described as being kind of stocky with these heavy, heavy legs and this face that was like a baby's face, whether he could have been this kind of swimmer's body, Spider-Man that's jumping over all this stuff and made that switch, you know, just a couple of years later.
00:42:46
And it turns out that he did. And I think he probably purposefully altered his physique because there was a composite of him in Visalia that was very good when you started looking on.
00:42:57
So he had to change, but in order to continue doing what he wanted to do. So the homework evidence, was that red herring?
00:43:07
I don't know right now. I had high confidence that that was from him. You were really into that homework evidence.
00:43:13
I was really into that homework evidence. and at this point in time, my confidence has been shaken.
00:43:19
However, based on what I saw inside D'Angelo's house. Oh, my God, he went in there.
00:43:24
Oh, my God. Yeah, go on. I do think that there is still the possibility. The writing is very consistent with who this offender is, you know, that scrawled punishment.
00:43:35
Punishment. You know, everyone writes that on their homework. Oh, yeah, exactly.
00:43:38
It's really common. Casual. The mad is the word essay. That psychologically is so much with who it fits with who this offender is.
00:43:47
I do believe and had said that I believed it was an old spiral that he had because I'm fully confident.
00:43:54
D'Angelo is a guy that was out there taking notes as he's prowling. We have two pens that were dropped up in Sacramento.
00:44:00
So I do think he had an old spiral with him where I'm a little bit stumped right now is the diagram because, you know, I did a lot of work on that diagram.
00:44:10
I had people saying, this is a guy that is familiar with the development industry.
00:44:14
Looks like he's a practitioner using industry-specific symbols. And right now with D'Angelo, he's a cop.
00:44:21
Yeah. You know? And then some kind of just blue, yeah. I'm with you, Paul Holes, on that whole thing.
00:44:27
Because when you first, the night of the arrest, when you sent us that old article that you'd found where it said in high school he'd worked for a winch and crane company.
00:44:38
A crane hoisting company. And in my mind, I was like, he was the guy that went out there and pulled the trees out before they paved out all of these housing complexes.
00:44:48
Like it made perfect sense to me. It's still a planned community drawing. It is.
00:44:53
I do believe when you look at in the military where he did receive carpentry training, so he understands how to frame houses.
00:45:01
once i don't know what kinds of classes he took at sierra college or sac state but it's going to
00:45:10
be more than just criminal justice because you do take additional courses and they have courses
00:45:14
of drafting landscape architecture so maybe this is just an exercise that he did however
00:45:20
it's also possible that i had a guy online who's been 45 years in law enforcement he said you know
00:45:28
back in the day, we weren't paid very good. We often took second jobs, and often those second
00:45:33
jobs were security guards on job sites. And that resonates with me based on the pattern that I saw
00:45:39
within Sacramento a little bit. Once he moves outside of Sacramento, you see a prevalence of
00:45:46
attacks occurring either in or immediately adjacent to active construction. So I could see
00:45:52
where maybe that's what he's doing, and that's what's pulling him out all over Northern California
00:45:57
because he's moonlighting, and while he's out in San Jose, he's taking the opportunity to attack.
00:46:03
Well, and Dana, point two, he got into a gated community. Getting into that community wouldn't have been very hard,
00:46:09
but you look at that community, they had security guards at the gates, they had roving security guards, so it's a higher-risk attack.
00:46:17
So he is choosing to go there versus maybe going to where someplace it's not so high-risk.
00:46:24
So that's something that I look at going, maybe there's a reason he's drawing to Harrington more so because he could have chosen a different neighborhood.
00:46:35
Was there anything when you were – I can't believe you were in that house. What I would fucking pay.
00:46:40
Just as an estate sale fanatic alone. And also just little things like the fact that he took so many trophies and that they were just anything with initials on it.
00:46:50
It's just like all that stuff that it's just so weird to be on this side of this part of the story where for so long, like Michelle and those cufflinks for so long, people have been taking these tiny things and just trying to do whatever they can with tiny bits of information.
00:47:07
And now there's households of information. And is there anything in the house? And I know you can't give us specifics that made you kind of do a happy dance or gave you chills or gave you any kind of feeling.
00:47:18
So, I think the most, the thing that I observed that left the biggest impression on me,
00:47:29
and this probably isn't very well known in the series, but one of the aspects that the East Area Rapist would do
00:47:39
is when he would take the female out, and typically it's a family room, to separate her from the husband
00:47:44
and lay her down and she's bound. He would turn the TV on and he would keep the sound off
00:47:49
and then put a towel over the TV so he'd have this glow so he could see her. Walk into D'Angelo's room
00:47:57
and he has a computer there And he's got a towel over the monitor. And I'm looking at that going, well, is that just a dust cover?
00:48:05
Or is he reminiscing? No one does that. He wants a glow. Is he pulling out any of those souvenirs and replicating the glowing environment from back in the 1970s?
00:48:20
So that was something that struck me. And then he likes peanut butter. He's eating peanut butter off a spoon.
00:48:25
And that's what I do. He's still a human. He's still human. Do you think he's going to talk or explain any of this?
00:48:36
I really don't think so. Before he was identified, I judged this offender as being all about self-preservation.
00:48:45
He didn't want to get caught. He has never demonstrated the Zodiac or BTK ego of wanting to say, hey, look at me.
00:48:54
And so I felt that if he was caught, he's not going to sit there and self-incriminate.
00:49:00
After seeing how he responded during the first, you know, I watched seven hours worth of the interviews, and I just don't see him talking.
00:49:10
But you never know. He may have a change of heart at some point. Is he speaking to his family, his daughters?
00:49:17
I can't comment on that. Are they okay, those poor girls? I know. It's so horrible.
00:49:22
I mean, it tore my heart seeing the two youngest daughters there. And I said this at CrimeCon.
00:49:29
And in my opinion, those two, actually all three of the daughters are really his last victims.
00:49:34
They're suffering now from what he did. Absolutely. One of the things that, and this is a story that, I don't know if you told it at CrimeCon, but you told it to me,
00:49:45
was the, I think it was maybe the night or a couple nights before you retired when you were outside of his house.
00:49:52
Right. And you were thinking about getting the swab. Can you walk us through that?
00:49:57
This is one more movie-like aspect of the story. Of course, you're retiring in a couple days.
00:50:02
Yeah, exactly. Well, that's the thing. You're retiring in a couple days. Your partner, Michelle, died in her sleep tragically two years ago,
00:50:11
and you're retiring in a couple days, and you've got one last suspect to check out,
00:50:15
and you're right outside of his house, and you're wondering, you know what? I'd really like to just go in and get a swab.
00:50:20
And what was going through your mind? And at any point, did you say, I'm too old for this shit?
00:50:24
Because that would be the most cinematic thing that you could possibly do. Can your partner be a dog?
00:50:29
Yeah. Like a lab? That would be great. Or a child. Yeah. No, you know, that, in leading up, we had kind of, we had about, I would say, four to five males from the genealogy search.
00:50:44
That caught our interest because they had California connections. And then two that had Sacramento connections, one through extended family and then D'Angelo.
00:50:54
And after we were able to eliminate the one, and it was marching down on DeAngelo saying, well, what's about this guy?
00:51:02
You know, on paper, you start finding out his connection to Sacramento was he had some family attending school in Rancho Cordova.
00:51:12
He was a Folsom High School student in the 60s. Auburn PD, you know, I kind of did not like that.
00:51:19
I was going, ah, up in Auburn, and how's he doing all these attacks? But it wasn't until I spoke with the boss that fired him from Auburn, the chief.
00:51:29
And the chief is relaying some of the behaviors that he experienced and observed.
00:51:34
And, of course, we've got the engagement to Bonnie in 1970. And we have our offender making the statement, I hate you, Bonnie.
00:51:41
I hate you, Bonnie, in one of the Davis attacks. There was enough churn that it was, I need to see where this guy lives.
00:51:48
Had you seen the story about the shoplifting? Yes. You did? Yes. So the timing of me driving up to his house was my last day before I literally turned in my badge and gun.
00:52:02
Ridiculous. And I was sitting there going, well, I need to go see. That's what I always do is now once I've identified somebody, I just need to start looking at them.
00:52:13
And so I drive up from Martinez, which is in the Bay Area, up to Citrus Heights.
00:52:18
And that's about an hour and a half drive. I get up there and I just park in front of his house.
00:52:23
And you have to understand, at this point, it wasn't, this is the guy. He was just starting to get interesting.
00:52:28
And I'm sitting there, and I'm looking, and there's a car parked in the driveway, and I'm looking to see if there's any activity in the house.
00:52:35
I don't see any activity, but I was pretty confident that he was there. And in my position, it was just like, you know, this is my last day.
00:52:46
What's the chances that this is actually the guy? I should just go knock on the door, introduce myself like I've done time and time again, and just say, hey, I'm looking into an old case.
00:52:56
Can we chat a little bit and eventually establish a rapport and then ultimately ask, do you mind giving a DNA sample?
00:53:04
And I thought about it and with what I'd heard from the chief and the Bonnie and some of the other aspects about him, I just don't know enough about him to do that yet.
00:53:14
And that's when I decided to drive away. And this story initially got out when a local Bay Area news person was kind of asking me
00:53:22
I said, well, I really, really was gunning to solve this case before I retired And I didn't
00:53:28
But at least I can take solace in that I was within 50 feet of the guy I've been looking for for 24 years
00:53:34
And that was it And all of a sudden it's this big, oh my god, he was right there right before
00:53:40
And I wasn't feeling that type of thing at all In fact, the local magazine writer that wrote an article on me, he emailed me after that story got out.
00:53:51
It was like oh that like Jodie Foster going into Buffalo Bill house in Silence of the Lambs It was like no I wasn feeling that at all I was just kind of I guess I better drive off here You know when I told that story to Pete Headley who we both talked to and who I working with on that Allentown 4 case and chasing another serial killer that I putting a Rasmus in this other serial killer but I putting another timeline for and figure out where he been
00:54:15
He said, that makes me so happy that he didn't go in that house. He just said, I'm so happy he didn't go in that house.
00:54:22
You know, in retrospect, when you learn about who D'Angelo is, you know, during surveillance, he was, the guys watching him were saying, this guy is not moving around like a 72-year-old man.
00:54:35
He's like a 50-year-old man, like me. You know, he's moving around. He's on his motorcycle.
00:54:41
He's got high rates of speed on his motorcycle on the freeway. The way he drives, I mean, stop signs are optional.
00:54:49
Puttering around the house, in the yard. He's basically just showing that he's a physically capable individual.
00:54:56
And we knew that he had lots of guns registered to him. And, of course, he had both the military and law enforcement training when it comes to firearms.
00:55:03
The front of his house, that front door, it's a funnel of death. It really is a kind of enclosed area that you have to walk through in order to get that front door.
00:55:13
So in retrospect, me knocking there, and I had been on TV enough, we could have looked through a peephole or a window and seen, oh, I know who that is.
00:55:20
and he could have gotten a gun and things could have been very bad. Do you think that he watched and he kept up on the news of his own?
00:55:28
I absolutely think that. And also I think what would have been so disappointing,
00:55:33
let's say he hadn't killed you, but if he'd killed himself, it would have, you know, to that last couple days,
00:55:40
being so close and he's on to it and kills himself. And that was part of the concern.
00:55:46
You know, I could have contacted him. It could have been suicide. It could have been violence between him and me.
00:55:52
It could have been he flees, you know, or he takes hostages. You know, lots of things could have gone bad.
00:55:59
So whatever made me drive away, you know, that instinct, that intuition, you know, thank God I followed that.
00:56:06
It's because you're Paul Holes, American goddamn hero. That's why. So speaking of DNA, which part?
00:56:14
That you're not Paul Holes? You already did it. It's too late. You're on the record.
00:56:18
Can we talk about – so now everyone – can you tell us – everyone's talking about the DNA aspect of it and how it's unfair and all this bullshit and unconstitutional.
00:56:31
How close of a match can you find based off of someone else's DNA that they turn into a website?
00:56:38
I mean he wasn't – From the genealogy side? Well, when you do that kind of search, of course you're hoping to find somebody as close as possible.
00:56:46
Right. And that makes things easy. If you find a sibling or a first cousin, it's very, very easy to identify the offender from that.
00:56:56
When you start getting out to the second cousin, it's a very doable thing, but it takes a little bit more effort.
00:57:01
Third cousin, it's doable like what we had, but it's four months worth of very, very hard work.
00:57:07
That's what it ended up being, his third cousin. We were dealing predominantly with third cousins.
00:57:13
we ended up getting somebody who was on the order of a second cousin at one point and that was
00:57:17
one of the you know the turning points in terms of getting us into the right branch
00:57:21
but the thing that i keep telling people is of course there's a stigma law enforcement is
00:57:29
is got our dna or accessing our dna i can't see that person to the up in the genealogy websites
00:57:37
those people's DNA profile. I can't download those profiles. For me to see their genetic information,
00:57:44
I have to be able to do that. The websites don't allow that, and I don't care about that.
00:57:48
All I'm looking for is how much DNA these people share with my offender's DNA. And then those people I know aren't
00:57:56
my person of interest, right? They don't even know who this guy is. I mean, do you know who your second cousins are?
00:58:03
Do you know who your third cousins are? They're kind of pushy, but it's a bad account.
00:58:07
You know, you're starting to get too far away in the family for people to really know who they are.
00:58:13
But they're a starting data point. And when you have multiple starting data points that you can track back in time and find a commonality, then you have something to work with.
00:58:22
So your offender is likely a descendant from there. This might sound stupid, but then do you reach out to those second and third cousins and kind of get a family treat?
00:58:30
No, you don't even need that. No reason to. It's traditional genealogy work that you do online.
00:58:34
Okay. It's very easy. And there's other things. But when you start getting down into people that are alive today, you know, the genealogy websites anonymize that automatically.
00:58:43
But us in law enforcement, that's what we excel at is identifying those people. And so when we get down into the people that are born that are still alive, then we resort to traditional law enforcement investigations, accessing the databases that we can access to identify who they are and start evaluating them.
00:59:02
Are they people that we should consider? and then eventually at some point you start going well maybe this person i need to get some dna from
00:59:10
just to help see it am i close enough or have i stepped further away yeah because i think there's
00:59:16
a lot of people who are trying to frame it and i think they were probably trying to do that too
00:59:19
because it's a story it's just another angle on it's a story on the story but it uh like when you
00:59:24
were on the daily that new york times podcast and that guy was kind of he was kind of seemed like he
00:59:29
was trying to hammer you on that or whatever and then you were like yeah but also your aunt could
00:59:33
call you in just directly to the police department and say, take a look at my nephew.
00:59:37
He seems suspicious. And then we're on to you that way. Like, you're just picking and choosing why you don't like the way we find the person.
00:59:45
In many ways. And people are concerned. I've heard the term, well, an extended family member is basically being used as a genetic
00:59:52
witness against me. I have no control over that person putting their DNA up in the system And I have a common shared DNA with them And I can kind of understand that but you have to understand what really happens in all these investigations As you said we get tips typically from ex ex are going I didn like him
01:00:11
I think he's a Golden State Killer. Sometimes they really believe it, and sometimes they just want to throw their ex under the
01:00:17
bus and be, oh, you know, let's have law enforcement rain down on his head. In many ways, I liken this to a form of swatting, you know, that thing where they call up and say there's an hostage at this house.
01:00:27
Next thing you know, you have a swat team going in. People do do that. So at least with the DNA, it's a precision tool.
01:00:39
And we contacted, once we started this particular aspect of the genealogy using the autosomal DNA and the GEDmatch,
01:00:47
we contacted one person and got DNA from that person. and she was very, very helpful.
01:00:54
That saved hundreds of people who the public had called in from us going and knocking on the doors
01:01:00
and having that fear of all of a sudden law enforcement is investigating them and then asking them for their DNA sample.
01:01:08
So in many ways, it was better for those people's privacy because they weren't being invaded.
01:01:16
And their pot stashes. And not to mention that. They were all flushing down the toilet.
01:01:20
The tax dollars that are being wasted by the time that would have been spent getting those hundreds.
01:01:25
Well, and I've pointed this out. For 44 years, with more resources than any other law enforcement investigation that I can think of, we did not solve this case.
01:01:39
Once we started this process with five people plus two outside experts, it took us four months.
01:01:46
So it really shows the power of the technology. And then since that, we've seen a double homicide up in Washington be solved.
01:01:54
I fully expect to see additional cases start to fall. The dominoes are all falling.
01:01:59
There's so many. I think this is the biggest single, since DNA was actually used in a criminal case, this is the next biggest break in terms of solving cold cases is using familial DNA.
01:02:13
and it's going to be a matter of resources. We were talking about this before, that there's all of the rape kits that are out there
01:02:20
and how many of those people did evolve into murderers or did evolve into serial rapists.
01:02:26
And it's going to be a matter of, and I've spoken about this on the show right after the press conference,
01:02:31
is that they're going to need genealogists. They're going to need volunteers. Not everybody had the resources that you had
01:02:39
and you were able to have those resources, but the small police departments and the thousands of police departments that we have across the country.
01:02:45
And there is a group of people right now, all of the baby boomers who have a ton of experience
01:02:51
and it's the most educated and most skilled workforce that we've ever seen retiring.
01:02:57
There really is a chance right now to utilize those people as well as the Gen Xers and also
01:03:02
the millennials who want to do, want a hobby with purpose and, you know, deputize them in a
01:03:08
in a meaningful way, uh, using liaisons and stuff. That's what I've been doing. And actually,
01:03:13
after my, after I said that on the podcast, I won't mention the state, but somebody called me
01:03:17
from the legislation of the state and said, I want to do this. So that might, that might actually
01:03:22
happen. That's so exciting. Well, it does seem like, and you know, and more credit to you,
01:03:28
Paul Holes, but like, it is that thing of the police that open their arms to talking to,
01:03:34
you know writers journalists or just the the online investigators or whatever where that idea
01:03:41
that it's to pool the information and to pool what the information you can pool it can only benefit
01:03:47
right if more people are working on something or is that not right no very much so now there there's
01:03:54
there's pros and cons and and obviously like my partnership with michelle was very much a positive
01:04:01
experience. And, you know, we, I would say it was symbiotic. We were able to just help each other,
01:04:07
and it was truly a public-private partnership. And the online sleuthing community, there's a lot
01:04:15
of very bright and capable people out there that have capabilities that far exceed mine in certain
01:04:23
ways or expertise that lends itself to being able to provide information. But what you do see, though, is you have the other side.
01:04:33
And the other side is what weighs down the investigation because now you have these people that are calling in tips that have no nexus.
01:04:42
They get very belligerent. In fact, they start looking at me as their private investigator.
01:04:48
And I was like, no, that's not how this works. There needs to be a code of conduct.
01:04:52
There needs to be a filter, a filter that everything goes through. And I'm actually writing this code of conduct up right now.
01:05:00
And one of the things is after the biggest thing, which is don't name names in public, don't say, hey, this is the guy.
01:05:07
Is this the guy? Hey, I think this is the guy. You can never do it then. Which is what you saw in the Boston bombing, which set crowdsourcing back years.
01:05:15
The second thing after that is be safe. And the third thing is that you have to have that kind of code of conduct.
01:05:22
You can't just go off. And especially if you're dealing with victims' families. Right. Yeah. You have to you have to just maintain a positive outlook and not just, you know, crap all over anybody.
01:05:32
And you're not going to get credit. A lot of times you're not going to get credit.
01:05:35
And there's a lot of people, oh, I found this guy, found this guy. You just have to say, listen, if you're working with the victims, families, the victims, families know.
01:05:42
But it's going to be few and far between that a police officer or a detective is going to go and say this.
01:05:48
And I've had it happen myself. And I was amazed when they did it. And they invited me to the press conference for something that I helped solve.
01:05:52
it very rarely happens you know it like i think it happened maybe 20 of the ones that i been able to help with so you know always going to get that but you need that code Yeah and that would be helpful as long as they abide by it
01:06:09
But there's also kind of having respect that there are going to be aspects of the investigation that have to be closed.
01:06:15
And that is very, very real, and some people have a hard time understanding that.
01:06:20
those of us that have experienced this over the decades realize that there are people out there
01:06:27
you know for example there are people that will confess to these types of crimes and they have no
01:06:34
involvement and that's one of the reasons you know if we don't have a case that has such strong dna
01:06:40
evidence and we have to rely on the circumstances of how that crime was committed there is going to
01:06:45
be details that have to be held back from the public otherwise we're going to have these people
01:06:49
coming in and just confessing and laying out how it happened because they read about it in the
01:06:54
newspaper. And we can't really sort them out from the actual guy that did it. How do you decide
01:06:59
what of that evidence to keep behind and what of it would be helpful for the public to know to help
01:07:08
solve it? It's case by case. And most certainly it's assessing what only the offender would know.
01:07:17
And that's what we would hold back. There's also things that we hold back just out of sensitivity to the family, you know,
01:07:26
because they don't want to necessarily hear the horrors that their family member went through.
01:07:31
So, you know, there's lots of decisions that are made, and it has to be made very early on.
01:07:37
You know, for example, a coroner's report, the medical examiner's report, when all the information that's in there is technically public record.
01:07:43
So we have to recognize very early on at that point in time to seal that record or redact specific information out of that report that we do not want to let the public know about.
01:07:57
That was actually one of the cool things, too, about the ID Channel special is how many victims spoke on camera, talked about their experience.
01:08:07
Like, I think that that part of the Golden State Killer, it's knowing how many victims there are and what a horrible time that was for so many people in Sacramento in the 70s.
01:08:21
And then just to see these amazing women who were just like, well, this is what happened and walking you through it where it's like they were the victims of this crime.
01:08:30
But they're also very strong women who are leading their lives and seeing them also at CrimeCon with you guys.
01:08:35
Jane and Margaret are just ridiculously amazing. It's so cool. And Jane's sense of humor and coming up with quip after quip, you know, of first, you know, with his small member and having, you know, the conversations about that, but also just, you know, wanting to hit him in the head with the roast that he had in the oven and all that.
01:08:54
Oh, God! She's so fantastic. Are there any cases that really you'd want people to focus on now that this one is off of our web sleuth plates?
01:09:05
Yeah, look up Allentown 4. That's the one that I'm, you know, as far as like the, and I was actually working on the Allentown 4 case right when I learned that Michelle died.
01:09:14
I had just gotten back from being in the woods and walking that area when I was in a bar and found out that she had passed.
01:09:21
So I kind of linked these two, and these two were actually kind of linked in a weird way too because Paul knew about that case and had talked to some of the same investigators about DNA way back in the day about that.
01:09:33
Well, the interesting thing, I didn't know about the Allentown 4 case at all. Billy brought that to my attention a few years ago when we first met at Michelle's memorial.
01:09:47
And so I kind of looked at that online and said that looks like a very interesting case.
01:09:51
I had a case that I went out on in 2002, a homicide of an Asian female. and it turns out that that guy, Larry Vanner, who killed his live-in girlfriend,
01:10:05
we couldn't have identified Larry. We didn't know who he was, and he had abandoned a child back in 1986.
01:10:12
Oh, I've been reading about this one. Lisa Jensen. And we were sure, once we determined he was not the biological father of Lisa,
01:10:20
that we thought that she was an abducted child from somewhere. and using traditional law enforcement methods we could never identify who lisa was and i just
01:10:29
happened to get into a conference call february of 2017 with peter hedley from san bernardino and
01:10:37
a captain from my sheriff's office who was the lead investigator on the 2002 homicide and that's
01:10:44
when i first found out that lisa jensen had been identified as don bodin a missing girl out of
01:10:50
Canada. And eventually that ended up linking this 2002 case out of Contra Costa County
01:10:58
to the Allenstown case out of New Hampshire that Billy had told me about, but I couldn't tell Billy
01:11:05
at that point in time. Yeah, I know, I know. But, and the crazy thing about that case is that we
01:11:12
still, you know, the girls in the barrels, which is a woman and three females, we still don't know
01:11:19
their identities, but we know who killed them, which very rarely happens. You know, it's always the other way around.
01:11:25
So that's the case that I'm very deep into right now and working on a special on.
01:11:31
And also, you know, it's going to be in my book at some point. But there's so many crazy twists and turns.
01:11:36
And we talk about this guy being, you know, we talk about the Golden State Killer and being
01:11:41
so evil. I really think Rasmussen slash Bob Evans slash Larry Vanner, he had tons of different names,
01:11:47
was even more evil because his M.O. was this. He would sidle up to a woman who had kids.
01:11:53
He would take that woman sort of away from her family and move her away, and then he would molest the kids
01:12:00
kill the woman and then use those kids to attract another woman that he's like this poor
01:12:06
single father once he got that other woman with other kids he would kill the kids that he got
01:12:11
with the other one once they were ready to talk and then start that whole cycle all over again
01:12:15
and he did this a lot and we're still trying to figure out where else he's been so it's right now
01:12:22
i'm delving into these two backgrounds of these guys that weren't necessarily super nice guys
01:12:28
The difference is that one of them is dead, and he liked to talk a lot because he really was a master manipulator, this guy Rasmussen.
01:12:34
You can look up his stuff, his interrogations, and he really thinks he's going to get out of it, whereas D'Angelo is a completely different cat, and he's just obviously spending seven hours just staring at the wall.
01:12:46
Do you think that's because he's a cop too? He's already seen what can happen if you start talking?
01:12:52
No question about it. The law enforcement training is most certainly – he's been on the other side talking to suspects.
01:13:00
He understands what it means to incriminate yourself with statements. And he was married to an attorney.
01:13:08
Oh, right. Do you think it will go to trial? Do you think he'll have the balls to go to trial on this?
01:13:15
I think it will eventually go to trial, but don't expect that trial to happen anytime soon.
01:13:19
I think the trial is probably going to be five years or more out. These cases, I mean, it takes a long time to get a case, especially of this magnitude, to trial.
01:13:30
Yeah. And he's looking for an escape route again. So he's going to do everything in his power to either potentially go spend time in a hospital as opposed to spending time in a prison or a jail and just do anything he can in terms of, all right, we're going to try to do delays and delays and delays.
01:13:48
How much did it piss you off when you saw him in a wheelchair in the courtroom? That was just a bunch of BS.
01:13:54
And that's where, in many ways, here he is. He's trying to portray himself as a Golden State Killer back in the day as just this master criminal mind.
01:14:07
And then he's doing this wimpy wheelchair thing. At this point, he just needs to man up.
01:14:11
He needs to basically take accountability for these crimes, tell us everything. if he wants any type of recognition, so to speak, do like the BTK did.
01:14:25
Just stand up there and say, I did this. This is how I did it. This is who I self-identify as.
01:14:31
And unfortunately, right now, he's taking the cowardly way out. Sorry, go ahead.
01:14:38
No, I was thinking maybe part of that and the difficulty of that is that judge recently deciding
01:14:45
that they can publicly talk about the size of his penis, which I'm sure has a lot to do with all of it, really.
01:14:55
Don't you think, at the end of the day? Like there's the part of the rage and part of all that stuff.
01:15:00
I just think it's like there's a real humiliation level that's not just he got caught.
01:15:04
Right. That's possible, maybe. Yeah, definitely. It's so frustrating. Well, it's not only they talk about it,
01:15:10
they actually can take a picture of it. Right. And they have. We've got the GSK dick pic.
01:15:14
that's there. And we'll be putting it up on the Instagram, my favorite murder Instagram account.
01:15:19
There's a brand new hashtag waiting to happen. We're talking about the single sock, Billy.
01:15:24
Yes. Oh, yeah, yeah. So this week, I don't know how early you guys are going to get this on,
01:15:28
but NICMEC, which is National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, they do Rock One Sock,
01:15:33
which is to raise awareness for all of the missing children that are out there. So I'm going to be asking everybody in this room
01:15:40
to be taking off one shoe and one sock and rocking one sock. And we'll take pictures of it and put it up on social media.
01:15:47
But, you know, NCMEC is great. They're a fantastic organization, and they do a lot with them.
01:15:53
And it really is. It's the clearinghouse for finding missing children. And I actually was at NCMEC right before, the day before I went up to Allenstown, which the day before I found out about Michelle.
01:16:06
I was actually interviewing I was at knickmeck interviewing the guy that had done the
01:16:11
the um the facial reconstructions of the four victims in the barrels and it was fascinating and
01:16:18
he was turning turning the heads around on the on the screen and then the showing and you saw this
01:16:22
giant hole in the back of their heads and this is what this guy did he had he you know took a rock
01:16:28
or a brick and then just did this to these three little girls and this woman and that's his earmark
01:16:33
And that's what we've been looking for, me and Headley, across the country and seeing other places that he did that because obviously that was his way of getting rid of somebody was hitting them in the back of the head.
01:16:41
And we found a couple. And one of those little girls was his own daughter. Yes. Amazing.
01:16:46
Which is how they found him. Horrible. That's insane. Karen, you look shook when the sock thing.
01:16:52
Yeah, we've been on a European tour for several weeks. I don't remember the last time I had a pedicure.
01:16:58
I going to have to send mine in after I go to the foot doctor Like just the idea of that Well I was going to yes Don make me do this today I kept two secrets from you
01:17:11
It was that. And it was not, it was having Paul actually here. So I understand if you're one of the other ones.
01:17:16
This is like my humiliation birthday, basically. Why do you hate me this much? I thought we were friends.
01:17:21
Oh, I love you, Karen. Right under the bus. So unfair. I love it. The one thing I did want to say, Paul Holes,
01:17:27
is when I was listening to The Daily, at the very end of that interview, and he kind of weirdly abruptly ended it
01:17:34
where he suddenly was like, well, thanks for doing this interview. The way you said to him,
01:17:39
I think you said it was great to be here or it was great to talk to you or something.
01:17:44
The sound of your voice, and maybe this is just my, I think I can read your mind,
01:17:48
but it sounded like what you were saying is, thank God this is the story I'm finally getting to tell.
01:17:54
There was such a relief in your voice and almost like a happiness the way you said, like, it was great to be here.
01:18:01
It was just so exciting that the story finally changed. Yeah, and I can't say that at that moment in time that's what I was thinking.
01:18:12
I don't remember. God damn it. It absolutely is great to be able to at least start talking about who the East Area Rapist.
01:18:20
That's how I've known this guy. This was the East Area Rapist or the Ear to Me for decades before Michelle named him the Golden State Killer.
01:18:26
to finally see who he was after all these years, to see that face that all I've seen in my mind when I read the case files is a masked man.
01:18:35
So now I could see basically the mask has been taken off. So it is kind of very nice to get to this point.
01:18:44
And as I've mentioned, I have a story to tell that's never been told. And now I have the opportunity to be able to tell it, and I'm working on that.
01:18:52
And we heard that there's going to be an addendum to I'll Be Gone in the Dark. Am I allowed to say that?
01:18:59
Yeah, I think so. No, we're working on that. Really? Because I've been telling everyone across the globe.
01:19:06
Because people have actually been bringing copies of the book to the meet and greets at our live shows.
01:19:11
For us designing, we're like, we had nothing to do. Yeah, just to go like, you know, well, and I sent you the picture, but there were two murderers who were from France who just said,
01:19:20
We brought you this because we figured you'd want to see it, the French version of it, which, of course, I immediately started crying.
01:19:26
I was like, I really did want to see this. I didn't realize it. But, you know, just that there's now an ending.
01:19:34
Like that it was there was something very sad and, of course, unsatisfying about how it was.
01:19:41
And going through her notes and while we were putting the book together and finding that coda, finding the letter to the old man.
01:19:48
And it was amazing. You know, my jaw dropped when I first saw that and I was just and the way that she wrote it and it really did play out exactly how she said.
01:19:58
And I that was one of the first things I thought about when I heard the news. I was like, I wonder if it was just like that, you know, and it turns out it was.
01:20:06
But finding that it was it was almost like she knew she knew that if something ever bad happened to her, this is how the book is going to end if we didn't catch him.
01:20:14
And again, she just wanted him caught more than anything else. So, yeah, that'll it'll end there.
01:20:18
And then we'll attack something else on the end. It's very cool. And what's next for Paul Holes?
01:20:23
Are you going to go Hollywood, Paul Holes? So I am, you know, of course, I am going to write a book about my story.
01:20:30
I am exploring TV opportunities to see what's there. You know, I've got many, many cases that I've worked.
01:20:38
And one of the things, you know, though GSK is my biggest case, I want to make sure people understand that I'm not just GSK.
01:20:45
That wasn't your only case? That wasn't my only case. You didn't just hold that one file on your desk for 30 years?
01:20:51
Wait. I will say for the better part of the last 10 years, I really tunnel visioned on that case, especially in the last two years.
01:20:58
And in some ways, as Billy was the one that said, oh, you need to open a Twitter account.
01:21:04
I have been like an incarcerated man. I have just been so tunnel visioned on the case that a whole world has kind of grown out there.
01:21:11
And now that the case is behind me and I'm retired, I'm now, what is this? It sucks.
01:21:18
I go online. It's crazy. It's a nightmare. But it's very fun at the same time. So, you know, I am exploring things.
01:21:26
I am helping other agencies out. And it's not just the genealogy side. I bring other aspects of expertise that I can lend to a case.
01:21:34
You're a science dude. I have a science background. I have an investigative background.
01:21:38
I have a behavioral background. And I think that's my strength is I can walk between those disciplines and be able to piece together stuff that maybe an investigator who doesn't understand the forensics and is looking at a report that's just a bunch of scientific gibberish.
01:21:53
I can talk in that investigator's language and say, this is what you've got. This is the direction you need to go.
01:22:00
Same thing if you have a profiler coming in. I can be able to help bridge these people that don necessarily walk in each other worlds And so that my strength and that what I hoping to be able to do and help other law enforcement agencies Cut to the Paul Holes Lifeguard Show
01:22:17
What? Can't be the show, Paul. I think on that note, what's a really important question is,
01:22:23
are you going to take advantage of all the fucking puns you can use with your last name?
01:22:28
If not, I will be very disappointed. You know, growing up with the last name, the Holes, I heard it all.
01:22:35
I've been referred to every body orifice. Not fair. Yeah, yeah. And you see some of the hashtags.
01:22:41
And it's just the way it is. Oh, yeah. But it's all fun. Listen, I got hard fart.
01:22:45
I understand. Yeah. People like to have fun. And I think everybody, especially on Twitter, people just go a little crazy.
01:22:52
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because they're just everybody's – I think for us at least, the newness of how many true crime fans are out there, how passionate they are,
01:23:03
And how we've all basically, like I said, we've all been watching the same TV shows for 20 years.
01:23:08
We've all, well, you know, I remember the episode of whatever the show was, Dateline or 2020, when they were like, the Erons is the original Night Stalker.
01:23:17
You know, whatever, 2001, whenever that happened, like all those things. We've been telling people about, I mean, I've been anecdotally telling people the story of how he must have been at one of the town halls because of this thing without even really knowing what the case was for years.
01:23:32
And it turns out it might not be true, but it's a great story to tell at parties.
01:23:35
Well, it's amazing. And that the Golden State Killer is up there with the worst of the worst.
01:23:44
So those stories fit, even if they're not totally accurate. That's how bad this guy is.
01:23:49
I mean, he really is that awful as a person. So, yeah, it's just there's a whole true crime world waiting for you, Paul Holes.
01:23:57
Well, I hope to be able to walk into that world. A whole new world. Down the rabbit holes.
01:24:05
Yeah. Because me and Michelle used to always talk about, oh, I'm going down this rabbit hole.
01:24:11
Like when we were doing, when we had entered it into Y-Search, entered his DNA, when we only had a little bit of the markers, not as many as you had later on.
01:24:19
But going down that rabbit hole of that one name we won't mention and going through 18th century census reports from Britain and three weeks of that going like, what am I doing with my life?
01:24:33
This is ridiculous and thinking like we can get them. But it was 10 generations ago and it just wasn't working.
01:24:39
Do you call up the guy that you were sure it was and you were hounding and apologize to him?
01:24:45
Well, there's been multiple guys like that, and I have gone and spoken with them,
01:24:50
and they have no idea that I investigated them as a suspect. So it was, you know, in fact, one guy I spent a year on,
01:24:59
and after I got his DNA surreptitiously and eliminated him, I spent three hours in his dining room talking to him because I thought he was close enough
01:25:06
that maybe the East Area Rapist was somebody he knew. Wow, wow. That was just part of the typical investigation.
01:25:14
You march down this path. You get excited about somebody. You see all the circumstantial evidence.
01:25:18
The DNA eliminates, and you're going. You should have just arrested him. He probably did something wrong.
01:25:23
Well, that's a show right there. Other reasons to arrest someone, even though they're not the serial killer.
01:25:30
Really quick, did they not let you talk at that press conference? Is that a political thing?
01:25:35
Is that that kind of like the DA speaks, and then this person speaks, and it's. Well, most certainly, you know, with the press conference, you do have the elected officials.
01:25:44
They're coming up on their campaign cycle, so they're going to want to get that attention.
01:25:50
I had told DA and Marie Schubert, because they did not want to get into the details about the genealogy at that press conference.
01:25:59
The focus was on D'Angelo. I had gone up to her before, and I said, you know what?
01:26:04
If the press starts asking questions about the technical aspects, don't turn it over to me,
01:26:08
because then I'm going to be answering, and then you are going to be answering questions about the genealogy side.
01:26:13
so I did back away from being somebody who could have been up there at that podium in fact I had
01:26:19
victims I had to go call and so I slipped out you know as it was dragging on and on in order to start
01:26:25
calling these victims yeah okay well we still wanted you to cool this is amazing thank you so much great thank you both for being here yeah well it's
01:26:38
been my pleasure and you know and one of the things that you said you talked about Michelle's
01:26:41
contribution to the Golden State Killer case, and absolutely she had a contribution. But you take a look at
01:26:47
what you two are doing in the true crime space. You are bringing attention to these
01:26:51
cases, and that is just as significant. So you are having a role, so understand that.
01:26:57
Stop it. Thanks, Paul. I'm going to cry. Well, we're definitely having a good time. Yeah.
01:27:03
We feel lucky to be involved any way we can. With the thing that, you know, as all of us say,
01:27:09
it used to make us feel weird to be so interested in stuff like this And it used to be a thing that we all kept to ourselves And now it you know there like it a new day And everyone gets to go yeah I into that too I love that I know all about that There more than enough unsolved murders out there This was only
01:27:25
you know, really a handful in the grand scheme of things. There's 215,000 unsolved murders since
01:27:30
1980 in America. And, you know, you guys can shine the light because you guys are the biggest
01:27:36
superstars right now in in true crime that that true crime has seen in a while uh really long time
01:27:43
i mean you had you had john walsh and then you had nancy grace but nancy grace is a very polarizing
01:27:47
character any of you guys and the fact that you know you've got 3 000 people showing up at your
01:27:52
at your events and and going crazy and and all of the etsy stuff and all the crafts and everything
01:27:58
i mean it really is amazing and i think that there's a lot of great that can be done from
01:28:02
all the murderinos out there yeah that's true i think that's only happening because we we also
01:28:06
constantly hear when we meet people at the meet and greet, people saying either they're going
01:28:12
back to college to study forensics, or they are switching their majors. I mean, we hear things
01:28:19
all the time. And we're like, I'm like, I've just been reading Wikipedia pages. I'm not.
01:28:24
But it's people are so excited that they have this interest that they know they share,
01:28:29
that's popular and interesting. And, and I love the idea that there could be this wave of women
01:28:35
getting into police work and really being, you know, the next Carol Daly so that that's,
01:28:41
that isn't an odd thing. And that there is that, the female perspective, I think,
01:28:46
is kind of crucial. It absolutely is. And I've experienced that firsthand where you work
01:28:52
a case and you're working it from a male perspective, and then the female is seeing
01:28:57
it from a different side. And it definitely is an additive when you go, huh, you know,
01:29:02
that is not how I perceived this at all. So that is very valuable. And there are a lot of amazing
01:29:08
women in law enforcement today. Yeah. Yeah. Well, that's an incredible community, this little
01:29:14
murderino community, and we're lucky to be part of it. And it also isn't just going back to school.
01:29:18
It's voting. Remember that. If you don't want to go back to school, if you've got a good job,
01:29:23
and you're just saying, all right, I just like reading about this stuff and listening to it,
01:29:27
it's voting. And we need to get loud, and we need to get loud now. As much as we were getting loud
01:29:32
and starting to get loud with the backlog and ending the backlog. And we need to start getting loud on all of these,
01:29:38
even the remains that are sitting in police lockers of people. We need to start figuring out who those people are,
01:29:44
start figuring out not only running the rape kits, but then running them through familial DNA and solving these crimes.
01:29:49
And that's going to be through the murderinos getting loud along with everybody else
01:29:54
and just trying to make that stuff happen. Okay. Are there any resources people can look into online to kind of find?
01:30:00
I would say let's start with End the Backlog. Just do a search for End the Backlog and you can find it.
01:30:05
Mariska Hargitay is doing great work there. Yeah, we've talked about that a lot.
01:30:08
The cool thing is sometimes murderinos will get together just to drink together.
01:30:12
And then they'll be like, we raised $250 for End the Backlog. It's very cool. Everybody's very proactive and excited.
01:30:22
It's cool. Yay. Thanks, you guys. Thank you, guys. Thank you, guys. Thanks for listening, everyone.
01:30:27
Fuck. This is so rad that we're going to do this. This is a show and its own fucking hooray.
01:30:32
It's all one thing. That's right. Yeah. Steven. Wait, you have to say the thing.
01:30:37
Oh, stay sexy. I forgot my line. Stay sexy. Don't get murdered. Bye. Vacation planning should feel like a breeze.
01:30:44
Not a deep dive into countless travel sites searching for the best deal. With Cheap Caribbean's Budget Beach Finder, you can search every destination and every date all in one search.
01:30:53
You'll save time and money with the Budget Beach Finder. Say goodbye to endless scrolling and tab hopping and hello to Budget Beach Bliss at your fingertips.
01:31:01
Go to CheapCaribbean.com to try out the Budget Beach Finder and see just how stress-free vacation planning should be.
01:31:07
Goodbye. Pandora Jewelry brings the sparkle to summer, now with even better prices.
01:31:13
Shop now for up to 50% off select jewelry featuring personalized pieces to must-have summer favorites.
01:31:18
Timeless jewelry made to move with you through every moment. Shop in-store or online now through July 5th.
01:31:24
Terms and conditions apply. See pandora.net for more details. Goodbye. Clothes shopping? Not as easy or fun as it sounds. You just want to feel confident in your clothes.
01:31:34
You can spend hours scrolling, zooming in, reading reviews, only to end up with a cart full of nothing that feels or fits right and a bunch of returns to do.
01:31:43
Stitch Fix makes it so much easier. A personal stylist sends pieces that match your size, style, and everything's in your budget. No guesswork, no stress, and your guaranteed compliments.
01:31:52
Here's how Stitch Fix works. Take a quick style quiz, share your size, style and budget and get matched with a real human stylist who gets your vibe.
01:32:00
It's no risk. All style. Get a personalized fix box straight to your door and try it all on in the comfort of your home.
01:32:07
Shipping and returns are always free and there's no subscription required. Plus, get a free try on for your first fix.
01:32:13
Get started today at stitchfix.com slash murder to get $20 off your first order.
01:32:18
That's stitchfix.com slash murder. Goodbye.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most intense
  • 80
    Most talked-about
  • 75
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Best overall

Episode Highlights

  • Special Episode Announcement
    This is the most special episode, welcoming special guests and recapping the Golden State Killer case.
    “This is a special episode.”
    @ 01m 47s
    May 24, 2018
  • Justice for Victims
    Discussion on the importance of testing old rape kits and the impact on justice.
    “Every one of those rape kits should be running through Familia right now, in my opinion.”
    @ 10m 10s
    May 24, 2018
  • Surprise Guest Reveal
    Paul Holes makes a surprise appearance, much to the excitement of the hosts.
    “Oh my God, ladies and gentlemen, And it's Paul Holes.”
    @ 16m 51s
    May 24, 2018
  • The Call That Changed Everything
    Receiving a crucial call about DNA results while out of state leads to a significant breakthrough.
    “I knew it was the guy.”
    @ 24m 12s
    May 24, 2018
  • The Evolution of D'Angelo
    Exploring how the offender changed tactics over time, becoming more skilled and elusive.
    “He recognized in Visalia he made a mistake he left a trail and he changed.”
    @ 41m 13s
    May 24, 2018
  • D'Angelo's Altered Physique
    The discussion reveals how D'Angelo may have purposefully changed his appearance over time.
    “And I think he probably purposefully altered his physique...”
    @ 42m 47s
    May 24, 2018
  • The Towel Over the Monitor
    A chilling observation about D'Angelo's computer setup raises questions about his past actions.
    “He wants a glow.”
    @ 48m 09s
    May 24, 2018
  • The Last Day Before Retirement
    A tense moment unfolds as an investigator reflects on being so close to the suspect before retiring.
    “I was within 50 feet of the guy I've been looking for for 24 years.”
    @ 53m 26s
    May 24, 2018
  • The Emotional Weight of Cases
    Reflecting on the emotional toll of working on sensitive investigations.
    “You have to maintain a positive outlook.”
    @ 01h 05m 25s
    May 24, 2018
  • The Golden State Killer's Evil
    Exploring the disturbing methods of a notorious criminal.
    “I really think Rasmussen was even more evil.”
    @ 01h 11m 42s
    May 24, 2018
  • A New Chapter for Paul Holes
    Paul discusses his future endeavors in writing and television.
    “I am exploring TV opportunities to see what's there.”
    @ 01h 20m 35s
    May 24, 2018
  • The Power of True Crime
    Exploring how true crime enthusiasts are making a difference in solving cases.
    “You guys can shine the light because you guys are the biggest superstars right now in true crime.”
    @ 01h 27m 30s
    May 24, 2018

Episode Quotes

  • It's almost too over the top.
    122 - Surprise! It’s Paul Holes
  • It's so exciting.
    122 - Surprise! It’s Paul Holes
  • It's so, like, deviously brilliant in that way of keeping that time frame.
    122 - Surprise! It’s Paul Holes
  • I think those two, actually all three of the daughters are really his last victims.
    122 - Surprise! It’s Paul Holes
  • You can't just go off.
    122 - Surprise! It’s Paul Holes
  • Stop it. Thanks, Paul. I'm going to cry.
    122 - Surprise! It’s Paul Holes

Key Moments

  • Justice Discussion10:10
  • Standing Ovation22:24
  • The Call24:12
  • Chilling Computer Setup48:09
  • Familial DNA Breakthrough1:02:01
  • Emotional Toll1:05:25
  • Golden State Killer1:11:42
  • Emotional Connection1:26:57

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown