Search Captions & Ask AI

MFM Minisode 127

June 17, 2019 /

This episode covers hometown murder stories, including a chilling tale from Westchester, Virginia, and a bizarre incident involving an alligator at a Wendy's drive-thru.

Listeners share their hometown murder stories, starting with a murder in Westchester, Virginia, where a mother arranged for her boyfriend to kill her husband. The story highlights the shocking details of the crime and its aftermath.

Another story involves a CPS worker in South Texas who was murdered, with the investigation leading to a surprising twist involving the boyfriend's son as the killer. The narrative emphasizes the unexpected connections between the storyteller and the case.

A humorous yet alarming account describes a man throwing an alligator through a Wendy's drive-thru window in Florida, showcasing the absurdity of modern prank culture.

Lastly, a listener recounts a camping trip that took a scary turn when they heard voices outside their tent, prompting a frantic call for help. The episode concludes with light-hearted stories and advice about staying safe.

TLDR

This episode features chilling hometown murder stories and bizarre incidents, including an alligator thrown at a Wendy's drive-thru.

Episode

27:11
00:00:00
This is exactly right. Isn't some far off concept? It's already here. Next starts now.
00:00:33
Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Goodbye. When a charming neurosurgeon rode into Frontier Town
00:00:39
selling a persona of confidence and care, patients trusted him. He wore cowboy boots in the operating room
00:00:45
and became sought after by patients. He promised to heal them. Instead, he left a trail of broken bodies.
00:00:51
This is a story of greed, betrayal, and a fight for justice. Listen to Dr. Death the Cowboy wherever you get your podcasts
00:00:58
or binge the entire series right now only with Audible. Goodbye. Pandora Jewelry brings the sparkle to summer, now with even better prices.
00:01:07
Shop now for up to 50% off select jewelry featuring personalized pieces to must-have summer favorites.
00:01:13
Timeless jewelry made to move with you through every moment. Shop in-store or online now through July 5th.
00:01:18
Terms and conditions apply. See Pandora.net for more details. Goodbye. My favorite murder
00:01:58
our fucking incredible assistant picked out the most, I mean I can't, there's so many good ones.
00:02:04
It's a plethora of riches over here at the old Exactly Right Studios. That's right.
00:02:10
Let us tell you them. I go first? Sure. This just the subject line is regular old hometown.
00:02:16
Oh great. Nice. Dear MFM crew, my hometown murder is from Westchester, Virginia. It is a small town
00:02:22
known for their annual Apple Blossom Festival and not much else. Our story begins in my son's kindergarten class
00:02:28
My son had made his first best friend, James And James invited him to a birthday party at his house
00:02:34
I brought him to the party along with four other parents James is a wonderful kid, but his family members were a little less than savory
00:02:41
His mother, Lisa, had removed the screen from the front door So she could hang out the door frame and smoke
00:02:47
Instead of going all the way outside Like one of those double, half split doors?
00:02:53
Yeah, she turned it into like a Mr. Ed horse door but for smoking. It's kind of brilliant.
00:02:58
That's epic. That's like a fucking 80s mom right there. For real, because she's being considerate
00:03:03
and not getting that smoke into the pancakes as she makes them. Oof. Uncle Billy belonged to a motorcycle gang,
00:03:10
the Warlocks, and gave each child a dollar in between pounding Keystone Lights. Yes.
00:03:16
A real favorite of mine in my 20s, Keystone Lights, at 10 a.m. at a child's birthday party.
00:03:22
Ooh. Parties. where more do you need a keystone light than at a child's birthday party?
00:03:28
It's called brunch. You call it brunch? Don't act like... Or a child's birthday party.
00:03:32
It's so much fun with the screaming. The dad, James Sr., had the longest pinky nail I've ever seen.
00:03:38
What the fuck? It was a real work of art. As a parting gift to this lovely party,
00:03:43
Grandpa made sure to show each child how he could make his false teeth move up and down
00:03:47
while still in his mouth. I mean, what else are Grandpas for? That's amazing. I would be at these people's house every weekend.
00:03:52
Absolutely. I'd be like, when are you going to start showing us the guns? Right, you adopted me.
00:03:55
Guess what? Guess what? I'm here for the month. I want to be here when you go four-wheeling.
00:04:00
Yeah. I want to be here when you all start a weird fight over a fire. Okay. Fast forward a year later, James and my son are still good friends at school, when one day my neighbor told me about a murder in our subdivision.
00:04:11
Turns out Lisa had arranged to have her current boyfriend, Chris, and an accomplice murder James Sr.
00:04:18
According to our local newspaper, James Sr. and Lisa were in the middle of a split because she'd recently gotten back together with Chris.
00:04:25
So James Sr. went to stay with his cousin. God, I hope all these names have been changed to protect the innocent.
00:04:31
Are there any innocents in the story, aside from the children? Who knows? Think of the children.
00:04:36
Only the children. So James Sr. went to stay with his cousin, who lived in my subdivision.
00:04:41
James Sr. roomed in the basement there, and Chris and his accomplice broke in, stabbed him multiple times, and ended up slitting his throat.
00:04:49
Oh, God. It's horrifying. James Sr.'s cousins were upstairs asleep. James Sr. is the pinky guy, right?
00:04:55
Or the Keystone guy? No, I think he was just the dad. Got it. Yeah. I don't think James got mentioned in the kind of character.
00:05:02
He wasn't interesting enough. Sorry, you were exactly right. James Sr. had the long pinky nail.
00:05:06
Thank you. I apologize. Thank you. I apologize, and I apologize. Thank you. Okay, so James Sr.'s cousins were asleep upstairs.
00:05:15
They heard nothing, but when they didn't see him the next morning, they went down to check on him and discovered his body.
00:05:21
It's horrifying. Once the body was discovered, the first place the police headed was Lisa's house.
00:05:26
They found her and Chris asleep in a shed behind the property. Okay. Why? Is that like me falling asleep on the couch because I'm watching TV?
00:05:34
What were they doing in that shed? Yeah, that's a good question. They were watching British procedurals.
00:05:40
God, if I had gotten that out, it would have been funny. Because everyone else in the family would give them too much shit, so they have to watch them in the shed.
00:05:45
They don't get us. Okay. Okay, go. He was arrested immediately Chris was convicted to murder and received two life sentences plus 25 years Much later Lisa was convicted of being an accessory to murder and sentenced to 10 years The motive was murder was quicker and easier than divorce Oh it horrible James still went to school with my son until third grade
00:06:07
I don't know what happened to that poor little boy, but I can't help but think that he's
00:06:10
probably better off not being under the care of his mother. Stay sexy and don't let a drunken warlock give your son money at a children's birthday
00:06:17
party. A beautifully done. That person makes themselves completely anonymous. Yeah.
00:06:23
But then everybody else. Just look up those names. Yeah. Okay. This one's called Cigarettes Kill, but can also find a killer.
00:06:29
Ooh. Okay. Hey, gang. So I've had a couple of crazy fucked up things happen in my small South Texas town.
00:06:35
I fucking bet you did. I bet you did. But feel the closest connection to this one.
00:06:39
So here we go with periods. That wasn't my emphasis. Love it. Back in the spring of 2006, a local CPS worker, which we all know is Child Protective Services.
00:06:49
That's right. Who was 53 at the time, disappeared from her home. The next day, her body was found still in her pajamas in a field, still in her pajamas,
00:06:58
and she had ligature marks on her neck and wrist. There were also signs of sexual assault.
00:07:03
Immediately, the person of interest was, you guessed it, her boyfriend. She had been dating a pretty well-known business owner in town on and off for the past several years.
00:07:11
He also happened to be the father of a guy I went to school with. We weren't super close, but we had mutual friends, and he had come to some of my parties back in high school.
00:07:19
The boyfriend admitted that she had come by his house earlier that night to discuss rekindling the relationship, but claimed to have no connection to the murder.
00:07:25
Right. The cops weren't able to link him to it either. People then started wondering if the murder could be related to one of her CPS cases that she had worked on.
00:07:33
Oh, yeah. The case seemed to go silent, at least in the media, until five months later when I was home for summer break at my parents' house and news broke that there had been an arrest.
00:07:42
Apparently, when the piece of shit dumped her body in the field, he had flicked out a cigarette butt next to her.
00:07:48
And then it says, what is this, amateur hour? The cops had been surveilling their suspect, not sure why they decided to focus on him.
00:07:54
When one day, while following him, they were able to scoop up a cig he had thrown out the window, and it was a match to the butt found at the crime scene.
00:08:01
Wow. Ready for this? Turns out, the killer was, then it says, drumroll please, the motherfucking son of the boyfriend.
00:08:10
What? What? Yep, the guy who used to come to my parties at my house. Oh, my God. This is like the best written one, because like casually mentioned, like, oh, this is my connection to it.
00:08:18
And then it's like, boom. Yes. Well done. He tried to claim that they were having an affair and were having rough sex and it was an accident.
00:08:26
But everyone thinks that's bullshit. It is. To avoid a possibility of the death sentence, he took a plea deal and is currently serving 20 years for kidnapping and a life sentence for the murder.
00:08:35
So thankfully, he will never be able to attend one of my epic ragers again. thanks for all your hard work ladies you've provided me with countless hours of entertainment
00:08:43
during work traffic and community service don't drink and drive people yeah that's right wow
00:08:48
hoping to catch a live show the next time you make it to texas until then stay sexy and don't
00:08:52
smoke cigs jay jay wow jay you gave it you gave that one you're all yeah and then you left a
00:08:58
little something of humility at the end humility and great advice great advice drunk driving
00:09:03
I've talked about this before. It shouldn't even exist anymore. There's Lyft. There's all kinds of ways you can pay people to give you a ride.
00:09:11
Don't take your Vince and I like we're going to dinner. We won't take our car anymore.
00:09:14
Right. It's like we're going to have two drinks. That's too many for me to drive or for him to drive.
00:09:18
It's not worth it. It's not. It's not. And but also good to mention because there's the there's there's all the repercussions
00:09:25
afterwards. Like you could hurt somebody badly. You could kill somebody. It's going to cost you a shit ton of money.
00:09:31
Like 10 grand or something. So much money. you could go to jail which is then there's the emotional effects yeah but then also i bet
00:09:37
community service isn't that fun i've had to do it have you really yeah i did community service
00:09:41
for what for shoplifting no i think it was the drug one did you have to wear a reflective vest
00:09:48
no i had a i had to work at this fucking creepy dudes like um like metal yard what's it like
00:09:55
scrap yard yeah yeah and he like was he was a creep but like all my friends had gone to him
00:10:00
when they had community service. Yeah. I had great friends. That's where all the girls went for community service.
00:10:07
That's where all they went. And so I was there and he was hammering something and the hammer slipped out of his hand.
00:10:12
He was probably drunk. It hit me in the toe. And he was like, good thing you have steel toe boots on.
00:10:17
And I fucking didn't. And I was like, uh-huh. Okay, that's it. This isn't about me.
00:10:22
Stay safe and sane. Okay. This just says hometown story. Great. We're getting back to basics on the minisodes.
00:10:29
Hi, Karen, Georgia, Stephen, Petz, and anyone else I missed. Well done. I'm a new murderino thanks to my girlfriend, who is a huge fan of you guys.
00:10:37
I always racked my brain for hometowns to send in, but growing up sheltered in South Orange County led me to not being very exposed to any crime happening in my area.
00:10:47
Are you familiar with South Orange County? I'm from South Orange County, technically.
00:10:50
Is that your spot? It's like Irvine is like the beginning of South Orange County up to like the San Diego line.
00:10:57
Oh, so we're talking the La Jolla area. We're talking San Clemente, Laguna Beach.
00:11:02
Is that Richie, Richie, Richie? Some, and then there's also meth. Like, it's just like, there's a little of everything there.
00:11:07
Okay. At least when I live there. Okay. Okay. When I told my parents about your podcast, I asked them if they had any hometown crime
00:11:13
stories they could think of, both of them growing up in Southern California and being
00:11:17
children of the 60s and 70s. My mom remembered the Hillside Strangler fears when she was at LA Valley College in the 70s.
00:11:23
Wow, that's right there. Yeah. She said that she was very aware of the story, but didn't know many of the details.
00:11:29
One night when she'd come back to her home in Burbank, she'd seen a car waiting in front of her house with someone inside.
00:11:35
She waited in her car for 15 minutes with the doors locked to see if they would leave, but they wouldn't.
00:11:40
Worried, she honked the car horn so her parents knew she was home and so they might come outside.
00:11:45
They did, and my mom ran past the car to the front door. Good for her. So smart.
00:11:50
Such a smart person. She remembers watching outside to see what the car was doing.
00:11:53
it would just move to across the street down the road one house and then back to the front of her house just periodically moving their parking spot They called the police because my mom was freaked out When sirens could be heard down the street the car bolted
00:12:06
No! She doesn't remember how many people were inside or what kind of car it was,
00:12:10
so I don't know if there were two people or if the car was the two-toned sedan, like you mentioned in episode 114.
00:12:17
But she definitely remembers it happening at the same time and being totally freaked out.
00:12:21
That's my hometown. thank god nothing happened but still think it's a fun scary story stay sexy and don't get kidnapped
00:12:27
right in front of your house johnny from california p.s congrats on the new book oh that's nice one of
00:12:33
my best friends shout out abigail ervin has one of her pieces of art in it thanks for supporting
00:12:39
artists hey abigail it's the ones that the long stick figure so talented what's her instagram
00:12:46
account is it just abigail she her art is beautiful and like moody the first time i saw it
00:12:53
it was the one of the three of us standing together with the butterfly it's abigail and then ervin
00:12:58
a butterfly and the cats and it's so cute but you know what i was gonna say like one of the main
00:13:03
reasons i read this one because it is like oh sorry because i did this story so knowing that
00:13:08
was a thing they did they would they would basically surveil women that they would follow
00:13:13
home. I mean, if it's not them, it's some other fucking creep. So like the idea that
00:13:17
she was smart enough as like, you know, a young college student to just be like, no, I'm not just going to
00:13:23
get a, I'm not going to tell myself I'm wrong to be weirded out by this. I'm going to sit in my car and make my parents come out.
00:13:29
Like, don't be a hero. Do that. And trust your gut. Trust your instinct because so many of us are like, that's crazy.
00:13:35
You're not going to get kidnapped. While the world watches the stars at the FIFA World Cup
00:13:39
this summer, Hyundai has its eyes on the next generation of talent. The future soccer stars
00:13:43
who are already turning heads at age 14. Making plays that end up on everyone's feed,
00:13:48
scoring from angles that don't make sense, rewriting record books that barely had time to gather dust.
00:13:53
Because Next doesn't wait for an invitation, and Hyundai doesn't either. Hyundai has always moved the future within reach.
00:13:58
Hyundai did it by making advanced safety standard on every vehicle. Hyundai did it by engineering EVs with ultra-fast charging capability.
00:14:06
And Hyundai continues doing it every day. From robotics that change how people live
00:14:10
to young athletes changing the game, the future isn't some far-off concept. It's already here. Next starts now. Hyundai,
00:14:17
an official partner of FIFA. Goodbye. This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace.
00:14:22
It's 2026, and if you have an alternative career like food photography or professional mixtape
00:14:28
making or witchcraft, you're going to need an online presence. Whatever your thing is,
00:14:32
Squarespace helps you build a website that's as unique as you are. Squarespace provides you
00:14:36
everything you need to offer services and get paid all in one place. From consultations to
00:14:41
events and experiences, you can showcase your offerings with a customizable website designed
00:14:46
to attract clients and grow your business. Get paid on time with professional invoices
00:14:50
and online payments. Plus, streamline your workflow with built-in appointment scheduling
00:14:54
and email marketing tools. With Squarespace's collection of cutting-edge design tools,
00:14:59
anyone can build a beautiful professional online presence that perfectly fits their brand or
00:15:02
business. Head to squarespace.com slash murder for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch,
00:15:07
use offer code murder to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
00:15:11
Goodbye. If you spend all day waiting to take your bra off, it might be time for Third Love.
00:15:17
If you're looking for breathable, lightweight comfort this summer, you're gonna love Third
00:15:21
Love. Third Love is built around getting the fit right instead of expecting you to put up with
00:15:25
something that doesn't work. And Third Love offers a full range of sizes from AA to H, including their exclusive half
00:15:31
cup sizes so you can find a fit that feels just right instead of close enough. Stop settling for bad bras.
00:15:37
Whether you're looking for more lift, back smoothing, or straps that stay put, Third Love
00:15:42
can find your fit fast. Their virtual fitting room gets you in the right size and matches you with the best styles
00:15:47
for your shape. If you've ever been fitted for the right size bra, you are in for a treat.
00:15:52
It actually changes the whole game with bras. I thought I was like a something, something A cup.
00:15:57
I'm a something, something B cup. And it's just changed my bra game. I thought I just hated bras, but I was wearing the wrong size.
00:16:04
And with Third Love, like they're so comfortable that it doesn't even feel like I'm wearing a bra.
00:16:08
Use code MFM15 for $15 off your first purchase at thirdlove.com. Goodbye. Okay. This is called, well, this is a drive-thru story and hometown murder.
00:16:22
Yeah. To whom it may concern. You asked for drive-thru stories. And while this didn't happen to me, it was in my hometown.
00:16:28
in 2016 a guy threw a live three and a half foot alligator through a wendy's drive-through window
00:16:34
and it says of course this is in florida apparently at 1 30 in the morning he ordered
00:16:43
food at the speaker drove up to the window and when the employee went to hand him his drink
00:16:47
he threw a gator inside and drove away this is look at three feet that people put three feet up
00:16:54
in front of you. Put your hands just outside of your shoulders. Yeah. And then put sharp fucking
00:16:59
teeth coming out of one end of it. And like a yellow eye with a split down the middle like the
00:17:04
devil himself. That's right. Oh my God. And he drove away. He claimed it was a prank? Question
00:17:09
mark. I thought the person working in the window was the guy's friend, but I looked up articles on
00:17:14
it just now and it turns out no. The poor fast food worker was just trying to make it through
00:17:18
the night shift. He was a swift. Oh my God. Oh my God. Let me see. Let me see. There's the okay.
00:17:23
It's bigger than three feet. There's no way that's three feet. Steven just held up the picture from Facebook.
00:17:28
And he looks pissed. He's pissed. But this is the problem with the modern prank culture.
00:17:36
Pranks are for friends and people you know and people that understand and are into it.
00:17:42
You throwing an alligator at a fast food worker is a full-on assault. And unnecessarily bizarre.
00:17:50
Did he order his fries without assault? No. No, no, no, no. No you cut that Stephen you fired But it wasn great I liked it Thank you
00:18:05
Thank you. Also, the shame is a good part of puns. That's true. That's part of the experience.
00:18:10
I can't stop my mouth from saying that. Yep. Listen to what I just thought up. Can you put that photo in Instagram as well?
00:18:15
Because also, he didn't care about that alligator. I know. He just threw it and left it behind.
00:18:20
I don't love alligators, but don't be a dick to them. Yeah. Okay. I thought the person working the window was the guy's friend, but I looked at the articles on it just now, and it turns out that no, the poor fast food worker was trying to make it through the night shift was a stranger.
00:18:33
Bullshit. The judge sentenced this doofus to 75 hours of community service. Ooh, theme.
00:18:38
Didn't do that on purpose. And a $500 fine and gave us this quote. In my view, there is absolutely no excuse for taking an animal, particularly an alligator, and throwing it through a window at a total stranger.
00:18:50
And then it says, amen, judge. Hold on. Now, if I was in front of that judge, I'd be like, but.
00:18:57
However. If you saw that fast food worker and they were wearing crocodile shoes.
00:19:03
Yeah, yeah. And then you were from PETA. Yeah. So you're already kind of on the edge.
00:19:08
Your Honor. And you go and you're like, is this how you feel about alligators and crocodiles?
00:19:12
Your Honor. I'm trying to lighten the world a little with love and joy and funny stories.
00:19:17
Could you imagine? I'm just saying picture in your mind. Yeah. This guy looked bored.
00:19:20
Okay. Thankfully, no one was hurt, including the gator, which was released back into the wild.
00:19:25
Oh, good. Yeah. Okay. As for my hometown. That gator, like to all his friends, is just like, I think I was kidnapped by aliens.
00:19:32
You won't believe this. It was really disturbing and it smelled like french fries.
00:19:35
And they're like, Chuck, we don't believe in aliens. Chuck, you're crazy. Chuck, don't be crazy.
00:19:39
And they all look exactly like the alien from Alien. Oh, that's cute. Okay. As for my hometown, I grew up down the street from a cemetery and with a mom who was a murderino
00:19:49
since before I was born. We went to the cemetery a lot, despite not knowing anyone buried there personally, because it was a quiet place to ride our bikes and rollerblade.
00:19:58
Sure. My mom would always point out. Your mom sounds amazing. My mom would always point out the graves that she knew the stories behind, which rubbed off on me.
00:20:06
When I first started dating my now fiance, I gave her the murder tour of my town.
00:20:11
Thanks for not running away, sweetheart. The one I remember the most was the grave of a teenage girl named Rachel Hurley.
00:20:18
On March 17, 1990, Rachel was out boating with her friends and was supposed to meet her mom in the parking lot of a nearby beach.
00:20:25
She never showed up. Her family and friends searched for her for hours in the rain, and they finally found her that evening in the woods on the shore.
00:20:32
She had been raped and strangled, and she was just 14 years old. The 30th anniversary of her death is coming up, and her case is still unsolved.
00:20:40
Oh, no. I know. The local sheriff's office made a Twitter account for her at Rachel Hurley 90.
00:20:46
Will you spell that? R-A-C-H-E-L-H-U-R-L-E-Y and then the number 90. I hope that the online community of Sluice
00:20:53
can help finally crack her case. Yeah. Mom used that story as a warning for me and always told me to stay away from the woods.
00:20:59
I'm fucking telling you guys. At the beach, no matter how fun they looked, I'm 33 now and still look at them with suspicion.
00:21:05
Anyway, thank you for putting into audio form the conversations I've been having with my mom
00:21:09
since childhood. Stay out of the forest, Sarah. Yeah, Sarah. Sarah. Wow, that was great.
00:21:15
Thank you. Yeah, great job. So much. God, that would be amazing if Citizen Sluice, who are solving cases left, right, and center every day,
00:21:24
would take up, because it's the 30th anniversary, would take that up and see. It's just a 14-year-old girl's rape and murder unsolved for that long.
00:21:33
It's just, there's no reason aside from not having evidence, you know. But now there is. DNA.
00:21:40
Because I've been watching, since we're off the road, I really miss Forensic Files.
00:21:44
and so I went to Netflix and just started just watching it that way. But it's so funny
00:21:51
because it sounds like that's right in that time where it was like just beginning.
00:21:55
The DNA thing was just beginning. And there was little bits and then they destroyed
00:21:58
like evidence trying to get that. Yes, right. So it's like the re-approach and retesting stuff.
00:22:05
I wonder if that could really make a difference. Let's do it. Will you say the name one more time?
00:22:09
Rachel Hurley 90. Okay, great. On Twitter. On Twitter. Awesome. Now listen to this subject line.
00:22:15
We didn't stay out of the forest and we almost got murdered. What is happening? This is meant to be.
00:22:21
It just says yellow. Love it. But like the color. I know one of the first rules is to stay out of the forest.
00:22:29
And of course, SSDGM. But when I was a junior in high school about 10 years ago, my friend and I may have broken the staying out of the forest rule.
00:22:37
And I'm so happy we stayed sexy and in fact did not get murdered. So it was a weekend on an early summer day, and I was on my way to my friend Chloe's house.
00:22:45
We were planning on camping out in her backyard and having a fun girls' night with high schoolers' essentials,
00:22:51
shady weed, and a handle of $10 vodka. Oh, God. Can I just say this about the bad vodka?
00:22:58
Yeah. Whatever you need to do, whether it be just save for another week or steal $10 out of your mom's purse,
00:23:04
which I'm not advocating yet at the same time. You just said it. You don't have to bottom shelf the vodka.
00:23:10
Yes, you do. Get up out of the winner's cup area and get into some decent brand.
00:23:17
It'll kill you. I feel like my years of hangovers from shitty alcohol has made me drink less in general.
00:23:24
You know, like even now when I can afford a Tito's, let's say. Oh, I see. You know what I mean?
00:23:28
Like I don't overdo it because that one night on my 21st birthday when I drank just the absolute fucking bottom trash covered in dust in the back of the fucking shelves at the liquor store.
00:23:38
and vomited in the gutter. Yeah. So don't do that again, Georgia. Okay. You know what?
00:23:42
You're right. These are guardrails that in high school we put up for ourselves where it's like, yeah,
00:23:46
I will never drink gin again. Well, I won't drink anything again, but I really, if I had to go back, I would never
00:23:52
go back to gin. Just don't buy the shitty whiskey because that'll give you a fucking hangover.
00:23:56
Buy the shitty vodka. What are we talking about? The shitty vodka is better. whiskey. I'm just saying you deserve better than the shitty vodka. No, you don't. Not if
00:24:04
you're 20. John Karen does his thing. You mess it up with pink lemonade. That's right.
00:24:10
You mess it up with pink lemonade. Okay. It was midday and we were having some lunch before
00:24:19
we were going to pitch the tent. That's also smart. Put down that base layer of food. Oh,
00:24:23
100%. If you're going to drink $10 vodka. There you go. Chloe, being a year younger
00:24:29
than me and not quite as rebellious as myself, was worried that her parents were going to
00:24:33
smell the weed because our tent was going to be so close to the house. They would have.
00:24:37
Yeah. I told her not to worry, but if it made her feel better, we could move further back into
00:24:41
the yard. That's when Chloe had the bright idea of camping in the unoccupied summer camp campgrounds
00:24:46
that the entrance was right next to her house. Have you never seen a horror movie?
00:24:50
I mean, they were like, do you want to stay here in the safety zone or do you want to go
00:24:53
into the living horror movie? Oh, my. Love it. Okay. Amazing. Of course, I obliged.
00:24:59
I was used to camping in the woods. I was a Boy Scout at the time. In parentheses, I'm a girl.
00:25:04
I love it. So we told her mother our plans, and we loaded the tent in the back of my truck and drove down the long camp driveway deep into the forest.
00:25:13
Horrifying. This really is the beginning of a horror movie. For being in a summer camp, there weren't many open spaces, and it was quite wooded.
00:25:21
We found the most open area we could near a cabin and set up camp. before long it was getting dark so i'd started a fire and chloe and myself had started our night
00:25:29
of doing bad things like that high schoolers shouldn't do after a few hours we were drunk
00:25:34
and high and decided it was time to go into the tent and fall asleep i doused the fire pretty well
00:25:39
leaving a small small flame so we didn't uh so we had a little light don't worry i'm from new
00:25:44
england everything is wet and i wasn't worried about wildfire i trust you thank you you know
00:25:49
more than us thank you if you can start a fucking fire in the woods then you know enough about it
00:25:54
to take care of it. Yeah. I couldn't start a fire and I shouldn't be left alone with a fire that someone else started.
00:25:58
Yeah. Therefore. Therefore. Look, you can rely on a girl boy scout to get in there and handle shit.
00:26:04
Clearly that's what she's about. That's right. She has a truck for fuck's sake. Yeah.
00:26:07
Hell. Come on. Okay. So we were laying down for a few minutes still laughing and giggling
00:26:12
when we heard a stick break like something or someone was walking outside. That when we noticed See this is when vodka does not help you That right That when we noticed the fire was much bigger than it had been after i threw water on it i told chloe not
00:26:27
to worry that it probably just relit itself like fires do sometimes which that never happens um
00:26:33
but when i peeked out of the tent i noticed two or three new logs had been placed on the fire
00:26:39
and then 25 exclamation points chloe and i started to panic and my truck was as good it was a good
00:26:46
50 feet away and we were not about to sprint that far with someone outside our tent then we heard
00:26:51
fucking laughing and at least two male voices um chloe was crying at this point and i told her we
00:26:57
had to get out of there as fucking soon as possible all caps thank the good lord i had one bar of
00:27:03
service on my phone and we were able to call her mom to come and get us oh thank god longest five
00:27:08
minutes of my life waiting for her car to pull up we grabbed our backpacks threw all of the water
00:27:13
on the fire, hopped in Chloe's mom's car and noped the fuck out of there. We then came back the next morning
00:27:19
to get the tent and my truck. And as I was too fucked up to drive the five minutes down the trail
00:27:25
back to Chloe's house the night before. Stay safe and sane. Yes, that was a really good call.
00:27:30
We never found out who it was or what their intentions were, but I will absolutely never camp in the forest again
00:27:37
unless there is at least 10 people. Stay sexy and fucking just stay out of the forest
00:27:42
to avoid potential murder. bales hilarious great job really good epic story it was so good um okay here's my last one okay
00:27:51
i'm not going to tell you the name of it okay but it's light-hearted hey georgia karen steven and
00:27:56
all furry associates i've been listening to your podcast since january and have now completed all
00:28:01
the current episodes i'm obsessed i don't have a hometown to share but i figured you two would
00:28:06
love to hear about the time my older sister and i's dress up went horribly wrong yes we are
00:28:11
Originally from NYC, but we moved upstate when I was nine and my sister was 12 so we can have a better life, a.k.a. my parents didn't have to worry about us being kidnapped when we walked home alone from schools.
00:28:21
Yes, they do. Yeah. Both of my parents are in the NYPD, and all we knew about their jobs at that time was that they were basic cops, and sometimes we would be left alone in the house while they worked overnight.
00:28:33
On to the story. My sister and I were home alone during the first few weeks we had moved into our new house.
00:28:37
Since we had come from an apartment we were fascinated by all the closets in our new home that my parents were using for box storage till they could unpack Like what a thing that you don think about that you like I from an apartment and then suddenly you have closets
00:28:51
Closet space. Why are there so many doors? Yeah. Being the nosy little shits we were, we snuck into our parents' room to go through the three closets they had.
00:28:59
While going through my mom's single closet, my sister had come across a bag we had never seen before.
00:29:03
upon further inspection we realized the bag was filled with all caps wigs so many colorful wigs
00:29:11
obviously this revelation meant one thing all caps fashion show night and 12 how fun like you
00:29:20
stop fighting for 10 minutes so you can fucking have a fashion show so you can do a full-on wig
00:29:23
show that's right we got all dialed up in our sunday best with neon wigs and danced through
00:29:28
the house to old JLo songs. Hell yeah. It was magical. Until my mother came home early to find
00:29:34
my sister and I not in bed and each sporting a three foot long blonde wig. How fun. Like I want
00:29:39
to do that now as an adult. We should. Wig party. Let's do it. We thought she would be mad but she
00:29:44
burst into laughter and took a million embarrassing pictures. Okay please send us one of those and
00:29:49
we'll post it. We'd love it. After she calmed down she sat my sister and I down to explain where the
00:29:53
wigs had come from. It was then that we learned that my mom was no basic cop. She was an undercover
00:29:58
narcotics detective. Hell yeah, she was. She used the wigs to go undercover to clubs and gang parties
00:30:05
to burst. Nope. Yeah, to burst drug dealers, it says. And she meant boss. I think so too.
00:30:12
Or burst them like balloons. Yeah, burst their egos. Both low level and kingpins.
00:30:18
Wow. I always knew my mom was a badass, but I had no idea she was out in the streets keeping us safe
00:30:23
while also rocking the perfect lavender bob cut. Stay sexy and maybe don't go through your mom's closet
00:30:30
and play with wigs that most definitely have gunpowder on them. K. Oh, my God. I love it.
00:30:37
So many good ones this week. So many good ones. You guys, first of all, please, if you have a wig party this week
00:30:43
because of that email that we just read you, please send us pictures. Yeah, please do.
00:30:48
Wigs. Wig party. Thanks for listening, you guys. Send your shit to my favorite murder Gmail
00:30:52
and also our brand new beautiful website myfavoritemurder.com you can submit your stories there
00:30:56
and it's so gorgeous take a look at what we're doing over there there's some polls
00:31:00
you might want to take there some there some fan cults you might want to join the fan cult is so much better Yeah It awesome It so exciting Thanks guys Stay sexy And don get murdered Goodbye Elvis you want a cookie
00:31:13
Vacation planning should feel like a breeze, not a deep dive into countless travel sites
00:31:17
searching for the best deal. With Cheap Caribbean's Budget Beach Finder, you can search
00:31:21
every destination and every date all in one search. You'll save time and money with the
00:31:25
Budget Beach Finder. Say goodbye to endless scrolling and tab hopping and hello to Budget
00:31:30
beach bliss at your fingertips. Go to cheapcaribbean.com to try out the budget beach finder
00:31:35
and see just how stress-free vacation planning should be. Goodbye. You know that fantasy where
00:31:40
you run into your ex while looking impossibly cute and wildly unbothered? Hill House makes the
00:31:46
perfect dress for that moment. Or if you're just running errands, Hill House Home is the brand
00:31:51
behind the viral nap dress, known for its signature smocking, ultra flattering fit,
00:31:56
and comfort that makes it a favorite for just about everyone. Celebrities like Taylor Swift, Olivia Rodrigo, Anne Hathaway,
00:32:03
and Mindy Kaling have all been spotted in Hill House. These dresses are the definition of versatile.
00:32:08
Perfect for running errands in the morning and stylish enough for dinner or a party that night.
00:32:13
And it's not all they carry. They started with bedding back in 2016. And now you'll find bathrobes, pajamas, children's clothes, and maternity,
00:32:20
all with the cutest prints. And it's so true, the hardest time picking out one nap dress
00:32:25
because the prints are so dreamy and beautiful. But now that I have it, I'm going to wear it all day, every day.
00:32:31
I'm going to throw on my leather jacket at night and look like a total badass. Cowboy boots or cute heels,
00:32:36
whatever it is, this nap dress can make it look classy. You look like that classy lady you see at the airport.
00:32:41
Hill House makes fun fashion that makes you feel good. Get 15% off your first order of $100 or more
00:32:47
at hillhousehome.com with code MURDER15. That's MURDER15 for 15% off at hillhousehome.com.
00:32:55
Goodbye. If audiobooks are your thing, or if you've been meaning to listen to more of them,
00:32:59
you should check out a podcast called Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club, hosted by Cal Penn.
00:33:06
Each episode spotlights standout audiobooks on Audible across all kinds of genres,
00:33:10
sci-fi, comedy, romance, thrillers, and more, with Cal talking to guests who help break down what makes each story worth listening to.
00:33:17
It's a fun, easy way to discover your next great audiobook. Check out Earsay on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:33:25
Goodbye.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Biggest twist
  • 70
    Most dramatic
  • 70
    Most surprising

Episode Highlights

  • A Charming Neurosurgeon Turned Villain
    A neurosurgeon known for his confidence left a trail of broken bodies instead of healing.
    “This is a story of greed, betrayal, and a fight for justice.”
    @ 00m 51s
    June 17, 2019
  • Murder in a Small Town
    A mother orchestrates her husband's murder, leading to a shocking revelation.
    “Turns out Lisa had arranged to have her current boyfriend, Chris, and an accomplice murder James Sr.”
    @ 04m 18s
    June 17, 2019
  • The Alligator Prank
    A bizarre prank involves throwing an alligator through a fast-food drive-thru window.
    “In my view, there is absolutely no excuse for taking an animal, particularly an alligator, and throwing it through a window at a total stran”
    @ 18m 42s
    June 17, 2019
  • The Gator's Alien Abduction
    A gator's humorous perspective on its experience of being captured.
    “I think I was kidnapped by aliens.”
    @ 19m 27s
    June 17, 2019
  • Rachel Hurley's Unsolved Case
    The tragic story of a young girl whose murder remains unsolved after 30 years.
    “The 30th anniversary of her death is coming up, and her case is still unsolved.”
    @ 20m 36s
    June 17, 2019
  • Camping Horror Story
    A chilling tale of a camping trip that took a terrifying turn.
    “We never found out who it was or what their intentions were.”
    @ 27m 32s
    June 17, 2019
  • Wig Party Gone Wrong
    A fun childhood memory turns into a surprising discovery about their mother.
    “We thought she would be mad but she burst into laughter.”
    @ 29m 34s
    June 17, 2019
  • Mom's Secret Life
    A surprising revelation about a mother's undercover work as a narcotics detective.
    “I always knew my mom was a badass, but I had no idea she was out in the streets.”
    @ 30m 23s
    June 17, 2019

Episode Quotes

  • It's horrifying.
    MFM Minisode 127
  • What? Yep, the guy who used to come to my parties at my house.
    MFM Minisode 127
  • I think I was kidnapped by aliens.
    MFM Minisode 127
  • Your mom sounds amazing.
    MFM Minisode 127
  • Stay sexy and fucking just stay out of the forest to avoid potential murder.
    MFM Minisode 127
  • I always knew my mom was a badass.
    MFM Minisode 127

Key Moments

  • Greed and Betrayal00:51
  • Horrifying Discovery05:21
  • Shocking Connection08:10
  • Bizarre Prank16:34
  • Gator's Perspective19:27
  • Rachel's Tragic Story20:36
  • Camping Incident27:34
  • Mom's Revelation30:23

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown