Search Captions & Ask AI

214 - Live at the Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco (2018)

March 19, 2020 /

This episode features hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark performing live in San Francisco, discussing their experiences and sharing a true crime story about Dr. J. Milton Bowers, a doctor accused of murdering his wives. The episode covers topics such as the history of Alcatraz, the creative escape plans of inmates, and humorous anecdotes from the hosts' pasts.

Karen and Georgia open the show with light banter about their experiences in San Francisco, reminiscing about their past jobs and the audience's reactions. They share personal stories that lead into the main true crime narrative.

The main story revolves around Dr. J. Milton Bowers, who is suspected of poisoning his wives. The hosts detail the timeline of events, including the mysterious deaths of his spouses and the eventual investigation that led to his arrest.

Throughout the episode, the hosts maintain a comedic tone while discussing serious topics, blending humor with the dark elements of true crime. They also interact with the live audience, creating an engaging atmosphere.

The episode concludes with a hometown murder story shared by an audience member, adding a personal touch to the live performance.

TLDR

Hosts Karen and Georgia share a true crime story about Dr. J. Milton Bowers, a doctor accused of murdering his wives, during a live show in San Francisco.

Episode

1:31:49
00:00:00
This is exactly right. Why is it always chaos when we link up? Cause nobody plans anything bro.
00:00:09
Good thing the Rogue's ready like that. For real. Rain, dirt, whatever. Available all wheel drive.
00:00:15
Five modes. We still outside. And they got some kick too. That turbo? Torque is crazy.
00:00:21
The most in its class. It moves moves. Rogue doesn't mess around. And peep the space.
00:00:26
Merch on merch. Gear. Mikes. All of it fits. Load up, we out. 2026 Nissan Rogue, built for all of it.
00:00:34
Auto Pacific Segmentation, 2026 Rogue versus latest in-market competitors in the ex-SUV
00:00:40
mainstream mid-sides class, excluding electrical vehicles based on manufacturer websites.
00:00:45
Unlock the savings at Boost Mobile and save up to $600 a year. I've been scouting these big carriers for a minute now, and I've seen them pull the
00:00:52
same play a thousand times. They promise you the world, then hit you with a price hike right when the game gets tight.
00:00:58
But Boost Mobile, their $25 a month unlimited wireless plan is the most consistent player on the floor.
00:01:03
No contracts, no price hikes. Unlock the savings today at BoostMobile.com slash unlock.
00:01:09
Based on average annual single line payment of AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile customers compared to 12 months on the Boost Mobile unlimited wireless plan as of January 2026.
00:01:14
For full offer details, visit BoostMobile.com. You're listening to a podcast, so you're doing something else too, like maybe scrolling home listings on Redfin.
00:01:23
Saving places you like without thinking you'll get them. because that's what house hunting has become.
00:01:28
But Redfin isn't built for endless browsing. It's built to help you find and own a home.
00:01:35
Redfin agents close twice as many deals as other agents, which means when you find a place you love,
00:01:41
you've got a real shot at getting it. Redfin helps turn saved listings into real addresses.
00:01:47
Get started at redfin.com. Own the dream. My favorite time What's up, San Francisco?
00:02:16
San Francisco! Hello! It looks like a Lego space station in here. I love that we come out to a fully lit audience.
00:02:32
Just every single face, every smiling face that we can see. Except for that one over there that's not that cool.
00:02:43
Couple grumps in the audience tonight. I thought the symphony was playing. Season ticket holders.
00:02:51
Look out. You're not gonna like it. You're not. You're not gonna get it. Does everyone have their lid on their drink?
00:03:02
Tight. Careful. Don't. Please be careful. Mrs. Davies will be so pissed. If you spill your drinks all over her precious, precious
00:03:12
Symphony Hall. This is so exciting to be here. I don't think they've had anyone like us before.
00:03:21
No, you know what? I actually think that they had a podcast festival here last spring.
00:03:28
No. No. They don't know what podcasts are, I'm sure. Usually when we play at these venues that have bands and stuff,
00:03:38
there'll be all these signatures on the wall and Sharpie, and nobody cares, it's graffiti time.
00:03:42
Everyone, you know, there's like Long Island Medium graffiti. Yeah, sure, we had that one time.
00:03:47
And all these bands, and this time it's like really lovely frame sign photos, black and white, of people with their really expensive instruments and their years
00:03:55
and years and decades of training. Sacrifice. Sacrifice. Training. Training. Never got to go to birthday parties.
00:04:02
No. Never got to go ice skating. Yeah. Violin. Violin. Violin. That's right. And then there's us.
00:04:09
Hi. Hi. Hi. Thank you. but I did train for over a year and a half at the gap up on market and that was crazy
00:04:25
just the folding and the folding and the repetitive folding I am two blocks away I feel like this is
00:04:34
one of those we have these moments often with this podcast of that like can you believe we and now
00:04:39
we're it's like that thing and this is definitely one of them because I work two blocks away waiting
00:04:43
tables in like 2006, sometimes washing dishes when it got crazy and someone didn't show up too.
00:04:50
And a lot of the people who I would wait on is like a nice restaurant. And so a lot of them were
00:04:55
really rich stuff, the old people who were going to come to the symphony after. And so I better
00:05:00
hurry the fuck up and serve them their fucking food. Get them their gin Ricky right now. And a
00:05:08
grasshopper. Right. Drinks you've never heard of. Exactly. They all wanted aspic for some reason.
00:05:14
We don't have that here. It's not that kind of restaurant. Well, I demand beef aspic.
00:05:19
And I'd have to go make it. Yeah. Because I was also the chef now. What kind of job did you take?
00:05:24
In this story, I'm also the chef. I love this story. What kind of restaurant was it? Like,
00:05:28
what kind of food? It was like modern American cuisine. It was really fancy. It was really good.
00:05:34
So like just a ton of rosemary on everything? Everything had rosemary. There were foams, you know, flavored foams.
00:05:41
Foams? Oh yeah, that's all the rage. Just like you squirt out some lime foam and you're like, there you go, dinner.
00:05:47
It would be like some foam that's supposed to taste like a thing that you could have just like mushroom foam.
00:05:52
So you could have just put mushrooms on it. But instead you spent 18 hours making a foam that tastes like mushrooms Sorry is it like mushrooms blended into shaving cream type of thing That exactly right Unscented shaving cream with an umami
00:06:07
There's like an idea of umami, you know, like a childhood memory of umami in the food.
00:06:15
That. Yeah. And it only costs $48 for the plate. Well, then sign us all up. Right.
00:06:22
Foam. Foam. I swear to God, when she said foam, I was like, I can't hear what she's saying.
00:06:27
Something is wrong with the stage monitors. It sounds like foam. Anyway, go ahead.
00:06:32
I understand. I never waited tables. Once I worked at The Gap, I was like, I'm done with working.
00:06:39
This is bullshit. No way. It never suited me. Never suited me. I went straight to comedy.
00:06:48
The lazy man's career. just like I'm gonna not work all day and then suffer terribly for 15 minutes
00:06:54
every night and see where it gets me barely gets you to the fucking symphony that's my new
00:07:04
that's my new program at the DeVry University I'm just gonna be like so you go get a job
00:07:10
at the Gap Gap, comedy, comedy, symphony symphony and then you know whatever you want
00:07:16
you can fill in the blank success A lot of Calgary's here tonight, including Karen's dad.
00:07:24
Father. That's right. Nice, yes. He can't. Where are you looking? Yeah, you guys are all looking around.
00:07:39
They're all looking around. Whatever you're yelling, stop doing that. We're at the Davies fucking Symphony Hall.
00:07:48
Class. For Christ's sake. Be fucking classy already. Fucking be classy. Also, we can't understand anything you say anyway.
00:07:54
Yeah. Neither can her dad. Can't hear us, probably. That's why all the F's and the S's are flying so freely.
00:08:01
It's because he can't hear it. Yes, my father is a retired San Francisco fireman.
00:08:07
He dedicated his life. I'm going to really milk this. He hates shit like this so much.
00:08:15
He dedicated. he risked his life for this city on a daily basis. For every one of you.
00:08:23
Before you were born, for your parents, your parents' parents. He's very old. All throughout the 70s,
00:08:31
the man put his life on the line maybe 20 minutes a day. Much like me. And then he also,
00:08:39
they made some really nice dinners for each other and they watched movies. And that's where we found out that
00:08:44
they said, oh. You know that if you've ever, I'm sure many of you are related to San Francisco Firemen,
00:08:52
or you know one or two, they're amazing cooks, because they have to be, because the peer pressure is so bad.
00:08:56
If you make a shitty dinner, they'll beat you up. It will not fly. Wow, I didn't know there's so much aggression going on in the firefighting world.
00:09:05
Well, you know how they are with the steroids. Accusations flying. I love it. He can't answer. I have a mic, and he doesn't.
00:09:14
Yeah. And so anyway, he was a terrible steroid user for a lot of my life. But here's the thing that would happen.
00:09:23
At the firehouse, they had cable television, of course, because they're all adults and they want to enjoy themselves.
00:09:29
And that's why we never got it. We lived out in the country in Petaluma, five miles out of town,
00:09:35
where there was... Sure. They're all here. Everybody cheers for Petaluma now. No, no, no, I'm not asking you to.
00:09:44
I'm accusing you of being hypocrites. Because I remember a time when everybody laughed at Petaluma.
00:09:52
But because my dad had cable in the firehouse, when we, who got three channels, KTVU,
00:10:00
and then, right, there's only one too, and two other ones, like 10 and 5 or whatever,
00:10:07
no, 5 and 8, so we'd be like, Dad, can we please get cable? And he'd be like, no, you don't need it.
00:10:12
We have it in the firehouse. It's no good. So tonight, instead of doing the murders, we're just going to all watch cable TV together.
00:10:20
We're going to watch Cinemax. Yeah. There's someone in the audience. This might be the first time ever that I have punched before.
00:10:29
What? This is just a night of stars. It's a cavalcade of audience stars. I have two cousins here and their lovely wives who got the fuck out of L.A.
00:10:40
So smart of them. What's up, guys? and they fucking later here, love it here. Yes.
00:10:46
And one of my cousins, when I was a kid, Mitch, I'm fucking talking to you. See you.
00:10:51
Ugh, she's naming names. Mitchie, goddammit. It's so hilarious to watch everyone turn around
00:10:57
and try to figure out who they are. Mitchie was a hellion, a Vildechai, we say in Hebrew.
00:11:05
Oh, really? Yeah, in Yiddish. Vildechai? Vildechai. It's like a wild person. Wow.
00:11:10
And he was... I'm spitzing. I do love him because once he held my brother down and farted on his face.
00:11:17
Bitch. And my brother was a dick and deserved it. But once he, like at a Hanukkah party, he locked me in there.
00:11:24
You know, I was probably the most obnoxious, annoying child ever. We don't know.
00:11:28
I was. But he locked me in the shower, like the, what's it called? You know, the sliding glass shower.
00:11:34
And I was so angry and screaming. And when it opened, I just punched. Oh, wait, I just realized I punched your dad, not you.
00:11:41
What? I haven't punched you. You thought it was him. And his dad's like the sweetest man you've ever met.
00:11:49
Why did he lock you in the shower then? He didn't. He locked me in the shower and his dad opened the door.
00:11:54
I punched and hit my uncle right in the stomach And he went straight to the hospital Yeah And that was your favorite murder
00:12:05
That's right. This is my favorite murder, by the way, the two-time comedy podcast.
00:12:12
This is Karen Kilgareff. This is Georgia Hartstark. This is the symphony. We're very, very proud to be here with you.
00:12:25
When my dad got here, he goes, are they going to fill these seats up too? I was like, I don't know how it's going to work.
00:12:31
I really don't. Stephen's not here today. Oh, yeah, no Stephen. No Stephen, sorry.
00:12:36
He's home with my cats. My cats are watching Stephen. Thankfully. Otherwise, man, he would just go crazy.
00:12:44
He'd just touch all the forks and stuff. You know Stephen with the mustache and the weird behavior.
00:12:50
Oh, yeah. That's right. Should we, should you talk about your dress a little bit?
00:12:56
Oh, I guess. Yeah. Thank you. It's literally ripping off my body. It's the best.
00:13:03
This weekend. Did you bring a Kleenex out with you? I did bring a Kleenex out with me because, look it, I made a pocket on my dress.
00:13:13
See, when life gives you lemons, shove Kleenex into your dress. That's the old saying.
00:13:18
You know. What about you? Tell about your dress. Oh, well, all I have to say is it has pockets.
00:13:31
Good luck, player. Oh, no. Oh, shit. I guess, baby. She's turned into a mime. Oh, the space work is going to be off the chain tonight at Davies Symphony Hall.
00:13:43
We were like, I just need a place where I can act out some scenes and do some large gestures and really be understood.
00:13:51
and they were like, we got a place for your Davies Hall. It's going to be amazing.
00:13:54
But I want to see everyone's face in the audience while I do it. Yeah, exactly. I just want to see the disappointment on everyone's face.
00:14:01
Does the symphony play to a completely lit audience? It's so weird. I don't know how smart people do shit.
00:14:07
Maybe they want to. Maybe rich people like looking at each other a bunch. Yes. While they perform.
00:14:13
It seems weird. Like, I know that sweater costs $500, like shit like that. We're like, oh, please, that's last season Armani.
00:14:19
Anyway. doo-doo-doo-doo-doo. What's that? Vivaldi. What's that instrument you're playing?
00:14:26
Doo-doo-doo-doo-doo-doo-doo-doo-doo. Mozart. You've heard it. You know it. We know it. It's your
00:14:31
favorite song. Easy. When I was in elementary school, you had to learn an instrument. They
00:14:37
did a whole thing. Music? Yeah. You had to pick something and all the pretty little girls picked
00:14:45
the flute and the violin and all these like lovely things. And I was like a nerd already
00:14:50
and I wasn't doing great for myself. It was just kind of awkward. And for some reason,
00:14:56
I just wanted to double down on it. I picked the cello. And so it was just like,
00:15:03
my God, I have a photo somewhere of just this like tiny little thing. I was so little.
00:15:07
And I was just like, cello, this will get me popular. It didn't work. Shocking. Have you and I ever talked about the time I lost a cello?
00:15:18
I don't think so. Okay, because along the very same line of thinking, when I was in college,
00:15:25
I'd never learned how to play an instrument formally. And so I was in the theater department
00:15:32
and there was a girl, Stephanie, who was also in the theater department with me.
00:15:36
Stephanie. Stephanie was a stage manager. And she always used the word precarious.
00:15:40
Please be careful of this area of the stage. It's very precarious. And you're just like, I am going to look that up when I get home.
00:15:47
I'm going to talk to you about it tomorrow. You sound smart. And she also played the cello.
00:15:53
And so I told her at one point, I was like, I've always wanted to play the cello.
00:15:57
I don't even know if that was true. I may have been drunk. And she was like, I'd love to give you cello lessons.
00:16:03
And so she goes, you should use my practice cello. And then we'll meet. I think I had one lesson with her.
00:16:09
and then timing wise oh wait Patty Riley are you here? Are you? Yes. Maybe. I mean okay hi.
00:16:21
Why are you way up there? You're my friend. Oh you bought your own tickets. Damn Karen the truth comes out.
00:16:32
The truth comes out. She's my closest friend. I was like sorry you're on your own.
00:16:39
So Patty Riley and I live together in this very depressing apartment in Sacramento.
00:16:46
Depressing apartment! Depressing! I have one cello lesson with Stephanie. And then I take the cello and I put it in this hallway closet.
00:16:55
And then we move out from that super depressing apartment. And we clean everything up.
00:17:01
And we have one day left. And we leave a couple bags of garbage in the kitchen. And then we're like, okay, tomorrow we're going to take that.
00:17:07
We're going to dump it. I'm going to take the cello and move everything else to the eventually the haunted house that we moved into, which is the next house.
00:17:14
That's a different podcast. I'll tell you later. We go back the next day to dump the garbage.
00:17:20
The cello is gone. It's just gone. Ghost? A ghost cello player stole it? Garbage ghost?
00:17:29
I don't know what happened. And when we went to pay our final thing and talk to the person that worked there,
00:17:36
the person was just like, yeah, I don't know what to tell you. I don't know. There's no such thing as cellos.
00:17:40
There's no such thing as anybody going into your apartment a day early to clean it out
00:17:44
and just taking what was there, which is what I wanted to accuse the person of. But I was 19, and I'd already had three keystone lights that day.
00:17:52
So I didn really I wasn the best advocate for myself at the moment Fair sure So then she would call me over the summer and just be like hey can I get my cello back And I be like I am away
00:18:08
And I just kept making these weird excuses. And finally she goes, did something happen with the cello?
00:18:14
I'm honestly like over three months. I put her off. And then she was like, what's going on?
00:18:19
And I'm like, look. And this, meanwhile, cellos haunted me all through Sacramento.
00:18:25
I'm not kidding. One day we walked into the mall and there was a mannequin in like that front window for Nordstrom and the mannequin was playing a cello.
00:18:34
That sounds like a dream. Patty Riley was just like, oh my God, this is crazy. This is over the top.
00:18:39
It's playing somebody. So finally I said, I'll pay you. Yeah. I had zero dollars and 11 cents.
00:18:53
plenty of money to buy beer somehow miraculously beer money is different than money money right
00:19:00
and then uh the whole thing was just kind of unresolved never paid her never talked about it stephanie i miss you
00:19:12
sit down it's sit down time Thank you How much do you think a practice cello is worth?
00:19:23
Like $800? I don't know In today's money? $15,000? $15 million Shoot Those expensive cellos
00:19:31
I'm going to get the tissue out of my dress Yeah, you'll need it And put it here
00:19:35
Perfect Here I need tiny waters, please Very small No label We're endorsed What if we had to put a lid on it?
00:19:43
By Big Water Yeah Mine was open. It could be drugged. Yay. So crazy. So we don't have...
00:19:58
Oh, this is a true crime comedy podcast. Yeah, we told you. Oh, we like to do...
00:20:04
This is a light disclaimer that we like to do at the beginning. Most of you are here because you listen to the podcast.
00:20:09
Thank you so much. Or you're related to us and you were forced to be here. That's right.
00:20:15
Or you're a drag along, which is someone you are married or in partnership with someone who listens.
00:20:22
You do not listen. You do not care. You don't understand. But you got a really nice dinner.
00:20:26
You got a nice dinner out of it. And you're like, it can't be that bad. It's what, a murder mystery show?
00:20:31
Right. It can't be that bad. It'll be fine, but still just total and utter confusion.
00:20:36
I like NPR podcasts. Maybe I'll like this one. I don't know. I'm open-minded. I'll give it a try.
00:20:43
No, you're not. But sometimes it's difficult for people because true crime, these are horrible stories of human loss.
00:20:51
And it's stories about the worst of humankind. And so it's very awful oftentimes.
00:20:57
It's very upsetting. It's depressing. But then simultaneously, parallel to that, George and I, the way we talk to each other, is comedic.
00:21:06
and we can be jokey and lighthearted to each other conversationally while we talk about those things, not about those things necessarily,
00:21:15
but kind of during. And so that can be a very complex combination for some people.
00:21:20
It can be a challenging and maybe sometimes offensive combination to some people.
00:21:26
And so to those people, we just sincerely want to say, get the fuck out right now, please.
00:21:31
Thank you. Truly. Take a nice nap. That's fine, too. If you want to conk out for about 90 minutes, great.
00:21:44
Just overall, we don't want to hear about it. Yeah, yeah. Okay. You want to go first?
00:21:49
I think I'm going first. Okay. Yeah. Based on last night. Based on the past we've lived.
00:21:57
Sometimes we try to change it for the recordings you guys have heard, but then we're like, but we also exist in this world.
00:22:05
Do we? I mean, are we? This is a dream. Are you asleep at the gap right now? And this is all a dream?
00:22:12
I folded down a sweater wall and I fell asleep on the ground, as I was often want to do.
00:22:18
I knew I'd never be a pace setter. That's why I didn't try. Why is it always chaos when we link up?
00:22:27
Because nobody plans anything, bro. Good thing the rug's ready like that. For real.
00:22:31
Rain, dirt, whatever. Available all-wheel drive. Five modes. we still outside and they got some kick too that turbo torque is crazy the most in its class it
00:22:41
moves moves rogue doesn't mess around and peep the space merch on merch gear mics all the fits
00:22:49
load up we out 2026 nissan rogue built for all of it auto pacific segmentation 2026 rogue versus
00:22:56
latest in-market competitors in the x suv mainstream midsides class excluding electrical vehicles
00:23:02
based on manufacturer websites. NYX, that's K-N-I-X, leak-proof underwear, isn't just for one moment.
00:23:09
It's for all the everyday moments you didn't realize leak-proof underwear could make easier.
00:23:15
Maybe it's day one of your period. Maybe it's a long travel day. Maybe it's hot outside.
00:23:20
You're on the move and you just want to feel fresh. Their leak-proof underwear comes in a range of absorbencies,
00:23:26
from light to ultra, and helps protect against periods, light leaks, sweat, and everyday surprises.
00:23:33
And because they look and feel like real underwear, they're soft, invisible underclothes,
00:23:39
and machine washable. No extra hassle. No complicated routine. Just dependable protection you can wash and re-wear.
00:23:48
See why millions have made the switch to leak-proof underwear. Visit Nix.com. That's K-N-I-X dot com
00:23:55
and use code FLOW15 for 15% off. That's K-N-I-X. X.com. Code flow 15. Hey, everyone. It's Cal Penn, host of Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club.
00:24:09
This week on the podcast, I'm sitting down with Will Wheaton, who played Gordy Lachance in Stand By Me 40 years ago,
00:24:16
and now narrates Stephen King's The Body, the novella that inspired it all. We talk about what it's like to return to a story that shaped his life,
00:24:25
channeling his memories of River Phoenix and the recording booth, and why the friendships you have at 12 might be the most important ones you'll ever have.
00:24:34
I know Gordy Lachance. I am Gordy Lachance. Like, I mean, even when I was a little kid, I was Gordy Lachance when I didn't know it.
00:24:43
Listen to Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:24:50
Okay, the story I'm going to do tonight is The Phosphorescent Bride of Dr. J. Milton Bowers.
00:24:57
What's that? Spooky Halloween! Spooky Halloween! Patty Riley got a card once that said Spooky Halloween.
00:25:09
And so then that's all we would say in the holiday season is Spooky Halloween! Love it.
00:25:16
And now it's ours. Sorry, Patty. We steal everything from all of our friends. Okay, so there is a series in the Chronicle.
00:25:25
at least there was in 2015 I don't know if he's still doing it now by a writer named Gary Kamiya
00:25:31
and it was called Portals of the Past and basically he would go in and find these really cool historical stories
00:25:38
things that happened in San Francisco you know, 100 years ago or 15 years ago and basically just do these features on it
00:25:47
and it's a terasure trove of good stories seriously if you're ever looking for a murder
00:25:53
it's really good Steven mark this please copy and post this entire conversation and then email
00:26:02
it to us later so thank you Gary Camia because basically I found this story because of
00:26:08
this article that he wrote about it but then there's also a very I didn't see what year the book was
00:26:14
published it feels like the way it was written that it was like 1900 it was by or could have been
00:26:22
this week. It's a book called Celebrated Criminal Cases in America and it's by a man named Thomas Duke.
00:26:31
And so he also, it seemed like it was much more closer to the event, because there was tons more detail,
00:26:37
but it was a whole book. Gary, I'm not shitting on you. Okay. So, we start in July of 1885.
00:26:45
Ooh, that's a long time ago. Right. Over a hundred years ago. Okay. Spooky Halloween.
00:26:52
Okay. That's Vicky. The arcade house at 930 Market Street is the home and office of one Dr. J. Milton Bowers.
00:27:01
Today it's that Payless shoe source that's right by the cable car turnaround. Same spot.
00:27:08
Okay. We're all there. Everybody's like, I can see it in my mind's eye. Payless.
00:27:14
But it's not the same building as the Payless shoe source. Now it's all weird and triangular and modern.
00:27:19
Are you saying Payless is haunted? Yes. Cool. it's haunted with great prices everybody get on down truly horrifying okay
00:27:30
29 year old cecilia bowers isn't feeling well as the weeks pass she just gets worse and worse
00:27:37
she's in terrible pain her body starts to swell and her face starts to swell all over and she
00:27:43
starts having convulsions and even though her husband is a doctor as she gets sick sicker her
00:27:49
her mother shows up and insists that other doctors be brought in to see her. They believe that she has an abscessed liver,
00:27:59
but all the medicine that they're treating her with isn't working. Because it's 18-whatever and it's cocaine.
00:28:04
It's all cocaine. It's just like... They just dissolve a bunch of cocaine in water and they're like,
00:28:09
take three tinctures of this every 20. Why isn't she getting better? We're giving her so much cocaine.
00:28:15
She's just smoking and talking about opening a restaurant. Oh well. Those are the symptoms of having an abscessed liver.
00:28:26
Just playing in a jam band, whatever. Okay. So two months after, on November 1st, 1885, she dies.
00:28:37
The doctors claim there is nothing about Cecilia's death that appears to be suspicious.
00:28:42
and it's reported that at his wife's deathbed, Dr. J. Milton Bowers gives every appearance of grief and despair.
00:28:51
I love when people get credit for just doing the absolute bare minimum human response.
00:28:58
What a champion. He seems sad that his incredibly young wife died. What a saint.
00:29:05
Okay, so let's talk about Dr. J. Milton Bowers. First of all, I feel like that name tells you everything.
00:29:10
If someone has an initial first, they're a dick. It's 85% of the time. No one here.
00:29:21
Of course not hard and fast. There's always margin for error. Do you think it's because they're trying to make people curious about what the,
00:29:28
like, we don't care. Oh, what's the J stand for? And it's like, well, just change your name to J then.
00:29:32
Right. Right? Or maybe, yeah, they're lonely and they're just trying to break the ice.
00:29:35
Sure. I was like, well, my name is J. Milton Bowers, if you want to ask me about that.
00:29:40
I don't know. That must pique your curiosity, right? Right. The J stands for just so boring.
00:29:51
So anytime a married lady dies we know the husband did it So let take a look at 45 Dr J Milton Bowers He a moderately successful and they call him rather nondescript doctor
00:30:10
with, quote, no known vices, which you can translate into a shit ton of unknown vices.
00:30:17
He's good at hiding his shit, basically. Yes, exactly. As they were, I mean, everybody was back then.
00:30:22
No social media. Yeah. 1800s, he was born in Baltimore in 1843 at the age of 16.
00:30:31
He travels to Berlin to study medicine, quote, but not as a matriculated student.
00:30:37
What does that mean? He just like freelance went to Germany to be a doctor just to like
00:30:43
just collect up information on his own around town. I have no idea what it means. The first number one,
00:30:49
give cocaine for everything. Yeah, exactly. Wrap wrap people's entire heads in bandages and send them on their way.
00:30:57
Maybe it meant he audited all his classes, and they were just like, sorry, you're going to have to take some tests if you want to be a doctor.
00:31:03
And he's like, no, and get it all right up here. Don't you worry about Jay Miltie.
00:31:10
Okay. So 20 years later, in 1863, he comes on back to America to serve in the Civil War.
00:31:17
Thank you for your service, you wife-murdering bastard. I don't know if he was a doctor in the Civil War.
00:31:27
I don't know what he served as. He was undescript in the Civil War. That's right.
00:31:31
Just kind of a vague guy standing on the side, playing the banjo. So two years after that, he settles in Chicago,
00:31:39
and he marries a gal by the name of Miss Fanny Hammett. No one's named Fanny anymore.
00:31:45
No. No. They live and love together, I wrote that, in wedded bliss. for eight years
00:31:53
then in 1873 Fanny dies mysteriously oh my god that's so sad for Jay Milt now it is 1873
00:32:04
and so you have to remember this is back when you can die of like a small cut on your finger
00:32:09
or inhaling or any number of things like that truly I looked it up the life expectancy was 40 years old
00:32:18
Great. Let's get those 40 years. That sucks. Right? People lived large back then.
00:32:25
Because they were like, guys, I'm on a clock. As we all are. Anyhow. Oh, I recently saw a post on Twitter.
00:32:36
There's a Twitter account called 41 Strange that's very cool. And they just posted this thing.
00:32:40
Apparently, in the Victorian era, they used to dye dresses. If it was a green dress, they used dye that was arsenic-based.
00:32:51
Cool. And so if you bought a green dress and wore it around, you were slowly being poisoned with arsenic.
00:32:58
Man, they just loved doing stupid shit back then. Yeah, they did. Truly. They were just like, can someone invent bleach?
00:33:04
We'd love to fold that into our everyday. So that's just painting a picture of the kind of danger that's all around.
00:33:13
Directly after J. Milton Bauer's beloved wife Fanny dies, he moves to New York City and immediately marries a beautiful young actress named Teresa Shirk.
00:33:23
How did they meet? Oh, she was his patient in Chicago. We suspect a bit of overlapping there.
00:33:31
A year later, Miltie's in poor health, so they decide they're going to, as it said in the article, take a steamer to San Francisco,
00:33:40
which then I picture a boat just going straight through the Midwest. Just the hugest boat just digging through the dirt on the plains.
00:33:51
In our cartoon version of this, it's just like... Just buffalo chewing and looking like,
00:33:56
oh my God, we have to get these things out of here. We should not let them drive boats through here.
00:34:02
They're ruining this country. so they steamed over set up shop in San Fran I'm trying to find my place
00:34:12
and seven years later the second Mrs. Bowers dies mysteriously at the Palace Hotel
00:34:20
dude stopping so obvious I mean about murdering all your wives he didn't have to be
00:34:26
he was just you know he was doing it up he was a doctor everyone trusts a doctor
00:34:31
he was a doctor oh my god I bet he was also tall is one of those things where they're just like
00:34:39
oh he's got it, no whatever he says is exactly what happened probably had a monocle with the J
00:34:44
you know he had some man accessory that was like well let's see I didn't murder her and everyone's like great
00:34:50
write it down, record it as law what I kind of like though is she dies at the Palace Hotel
00:34:57
which is it's a San Francisco landmark a very beautiful place you can go there for high tea
00:35:03
and what have you. My grandmother, my grandma Grace, that was her standard of living. So like
00:35:08
when we were little, me and my sister were little, if you were doing something, like if you ate your
00:35:12
food with your hands or something, she'd look over and go, you wouldn't get away with that at the
00:35:16
Palace Hotel. Really? Yes, constantly. I love that. That's what it always was, where it was like,
00:35:21
if your clothes were kind of sloppy, she'd be like, oh, you couldn't wear that to the Palace Hotel.
00:35:26
We were always aiming for the Palace Hotel. We should have stayed there. I couldn't deal with it.
00:35:33
They wouldn't let us in anyway. Truly. I just sit in my room combing my hair over.
00:35:40
I gotta make it. The ghost of your grandma comes in just to scowl at you and be like,
00:35:45
Karen, honey. Honey. She was great. She was the one, she was a flapper in the 20s,
00:35:51
so she had all these sayings that didn't make sense. So if you were like walk by her you were wearing a red shirt she go oh red attracts But it like I five I five
00:36:05
She's like, yeah, that's how old you were to be married back then. Get ready. Get that man. Land that man, girl.
00:36:12
Also, she go, yella, yella, catch a fella. And be like, what is this about? And she never drove.
00:36:22
and if somebody asked her, oh, do you drive? She'd go, I couldn't drive a nail. It was like she had a script.
00:36:29
She just had scripted lines all the time. And she used to, when my dad would make her a drink,
00:36:35
my dad would go, Grace, what would you like to drink? And she'd go, I'll have a highball.
00:36:40
Make it light. You can't make a highball light. It's two different spirits mixed together.
00:36:46
It's impossible to do. Truly, this is what I'm striving to be one day. You can. You can.
00:36:53
In a vintage house dress. Yes. Oh, my God. Amazing. Get really good at playing old maid.
00:36:59
She'd play old maid with you and just pull the old maid all the way up and go, it's your turn.
00:37:04
And then you could just pick it and win. It was the best. A little late, I just realized she didn't want to play anymore.
00:37:13
Shoot. Oh, my God. All right. I'll work that out in therapy next week. It's fine.
00:37:19
It's fine. We're talking about the death of J. Milton Bauer's second wife, Mysterious, and at the Palace Hotel.
00:37:30
So sad. Here we are. She dies, and my grandma leans in. Oh, let's make it at the Palace Hotel.
00:37:37
Oh, we're here. I guess I was wrong. My bad. Wrong that time. Excuse me. Doesn't apply to everything.
00:37:43
So on July 18th, 1881, six months after his second wife dies mysteriously, Dr. Bowers marries his third wife,
00:37:51
Cecilia Ben-Hayon. She's the one who was dying at the beginning of the story. Oh, it all comes around.
00:37:56
Yeah, we're coming back around. So she herself had been married once before to a man named Sylvie and Levy.
00:38:01
They had a daughter named Tilly, but they got divorced. Didn't say what the circumstances were,
00:38:08
but it did, quote, cause her to earn an unenviable reputation. Oh. Oh, I'm sorry.
00:38:17
It's a lot. Um, so, so when old Jay Milton rolls up, uh, dressed like the Monopoly man, which is what I have, the picture I have in my mind, she's like, thank God, get me out of here.
00:38:34
So, one moment, please. Um, okay. So in public, Jay Milton Bowers seems to be the perfect husband.
00:38:43
He's doting. He is very, very attentive. but it turns out that at home he was actually a brutal wife beater and a total asshole as you
00:38:53
are not surprised to hear. In fact when Cecilia's mother heard that she was her daughter was going
00:39:01
to be to marry him that she was engaged and going to marry him she actually told Cecilia she forbade
00:39:07
the marriage and of course then Cecilia you know how she is she was like too bad see you later and
00:39:13
And she cuts herself off from her family. Don't do that. And goes and marries the old doctor.
00:39:18
Shit. So she hasn't seen her mother for a long time. I don't know exactly how long.
00:39:26
So I just thought I'd cover it with a very generalized representation of time. A long time.
00:39:33
Just picture calendar months falling off the calendar. January, February. Oh, my family.
00:39:43
But then when she gets really sick and she starts swelling and having convulsions, her mother shows up, of course.
00:39:50
Oh, and she was someone that's like, get this fucking husband doctor out of here.
00:39:54
Yes, she's like, you've done enough. Thank you, Milton. He's like, it's Jay Milton.
00:40:02
When her mother gets there, Cecilia is so swollen, she, that her mother doesn't recognize her.
00:40:08
She looks so bad. And the mother says to Dr. Bowers, she's clearly dying. Like, what are you doing?
00:40:18
And he was like, oh, no, she's actually on the mend. I planned a trip to the country for her next weekend.
00:40:24
Swelling is a good sign. We all know that now because it's modern times. When you swell, you're on the mend.
00:40:31
Yeah, you couldn't be healthier. So I'm sure as he told her that story, the mother's like, okay.
00:40:37
Like freaking out and so scared of him. But of course the condition worsens. They bring in a Dr. Martin of Oakland.
00:40:45
He suspects it's arsenic poison. Yes, he was there. Oakland in the 1880s. Imagine.
00:40:53
Just gorgeous fields. He says it's arsenic poison. Miltie tells him, in fact, she's suffering from an abscess of the liver.
00:41:02
And because he's a doctor, then the second doctor is like, oh, I guess the first doctor knows.
00:41:06
So then he starts giving her medicine for what you would take for abscessive liver, cocaine.
00:41:13
Thank you for pointing at me. The face of cocaine. But when Dr. Martin brings the medicine, then Dr. Bowers takes it away.
00:41:28
Magically turns into arsenic. And then comes out, and he's the only one that can actually administer it to her.
00:41:33
So on the Sunday before Cecilia dies, her aunt and cousin come over to see her. But soon after they get there, he rushes into the room yelling, get out.
00:41:41
I allow no one to see my wife and throws them out of the house. So not suspicious in any way.
00:41:47
And then they find out the family finds out that Cecilia has taken out a life insurance policy on herself As you do What that in today money You want to do a guess 1 million It half a million Damn it But look great try
00:42:05
Thank you. When her family tries to add a policy to benefit Cecilia's daughter, because they all know she's going to die,
00:42:15
and they're like, well, at least she can be covered, of course Milton refuses, because God forbid he'd do a decent human thing.
00:42:22
So Cecilia Bowers, as we know, she died on November 1st, 1885. The very next day,
00:42:28
a mysterious man goes to the coroner's office and announces that Cecilia Bowers just died at the arcade house,
00:42:34
Palosios stores, and that there are suspicious circumstances and that her death should be looked into
00:42:40
and then he just leaves and disappears. No one knows who the man was. A ghost. A different article.
00:42:47
It's a ghost this time? This time, I'm not kidding. This time it's the warning ghost?
00:42:52
Yeah, it's the Payless warning ghost. You know. The purses, they're on sale. I also read in a different article that the coroner actually received an anonymous letter,
00:43:06
but I think it's way better that a guy runs into the coroner's office like, attention, everybody, there's suspicious circumstances.
00:43:13
Well, there hasn't been suspicious circumstances around here for 25 years. And then the man goes up in smoke.
00:43:22
So, the coroner's name is Dr. C.C. O'Donnell. Now I feel bad because apparently everybody has a goddamn initial before their name.
00:43:32
He heads over to the arcade house. He finds Dr. Bowers sitting in the room with Cecilia's dead body.
00:43:38
He explains that he is there to look into the death, that he has had a report that it's a suspicious death.
00:43:44
And Dr. Bowers says to him, well, our funeral's tomorrow, and I'm not going to let your investigation interfere with the services.
00:43:51
Great. So he's like, but you have to. I'm the coroner. I don't know if that happened.
00:43:58
But what happens is Dr. Bowers buries his wife without the coroner getting to do it.
00:44:03
So then the coroner has to go and get the body exempt. He's like, I'm doing the autopsy, friend.
00:44:11
So then on November 10th, 1885, the Chronicle reports that when the autopsy is performed,
00:44:16
there is no abscess on her liver, but there is a smell of phosphorus. coming from her internal organs. So they put her stomach into a jar and then they take the jar into
00:44:29
a dark room and her stomach is glowing in the dark. What if all the lights went out right now?
00:44:40
And then a stomach rose from under the stage. Avenge my death. Oh my God. That's so creepy.
00:44:50
It's so good. Bad. It's horrible. So they conclude that Cecilia Bowers has died of phosphorus poisoning.
00:45:01
Or that her stomach's haunted. Or likes to go to raves. So Dr. J. Milton Bowers is arrested and charged with murder.
00:45:14
His trial begins in April of 1886. and the prosecutor says at the beginning that he will prove that the nurse who was brought in
00:45:23
to tend to Mrs. Bowers was actually colluding with Dr. Bowers and helping him poison her
00:45:27
and that their maid, Teresa Farrell, was also in on the act and lying for the doctor
00:45:32
and covering for the doctor. Are they all boning or something? I mean, I hate to think of a late 80s group sex situation.
00:45:39
Oh, yeah. So many undergarments to get through. It would take hours and hours. So Dr. Bowers maintains his innocence throughout.
00:45:51
He explains to the court that he's a doctor. And any doctor knows that there are so many other poisons that you can poison your wife with besides phosphorus that aren't traceable.
00:46:03
So why in the hell would he use phosphorus? For example, my other two wives before this.
00:46:07
You might want to check them, and then we can name those poisons. He also says he didn't need the insurance money, so he has no motive.
00:46:15
And you're all fools, fools, I say. and then he threw his monocle down on the ground,
00:46:18
stepped on it, crushed it, walked away. Cool. That was all off the record. The prosecution tells the jury
00:46:29
not only that Bowers is not the cool, calm professional, he appears to be, he's a wife-beater,
00:46:34
who boasted about his extramarital affairs to his wife, and when she threatened to divorce him,
00:46:41
he told her that no woman could divorce him because he was a doctor and he had ways of getting rid of her.
00:46:48
Great. He also claims that Dr. Bowers was planning on marrying a woman from San Jose
00:46:52
and that she was already... I went to court reporting school there for a minute.
00:47:09
Yeah. Did you love it so much? I loved it so much that I moved to Los Angeles. That's really saying something, San Jose.
00:47:17
Because Los Angeles sucks. Okay. They say that the proof that he was planning to marry this woman in San Jose
00:47:29
is that she was already preparing her trousseau. I didn't look it up. Under garments.
00:47:36
I pictured it as a huge headdress for some reason. But my trousseau is almost ready.
00:47:41
Don't tell me my husband's a murderer. I can't wait to play that character in the film.
00:47:50
He also told the jury that Dr. Bowers had done this before when he began courting Cecilia Bowers
00:47:56
before his second wife was even dead. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. And Bowers was ardently defended by that nurse, Mrs. Sezignig, and his maid, Teresa Farrell, the beautiful young maid, Teresa Farrell.
00:48:10
Okay, so the trial lasts six weeks. It's the longest murder trial in San Francisco to date.
00:48:16
Not today's date. The 1880s date. To that date. The jury deliberates for 35 minutes.
00:48:27
Great. And then they come back with a, you know, verdict. Thank you, a verdict of first degree, guilty of first degree murder.
00:48:34
There's literally no word there. Thank you. It's haunted. Oh my God, someone stole my word.
00:48:44
It's a ghost word. It's the stomach taking the word verdict away. So he's sentenced to hang.
00:48:52
although the judge was barely able to pronounce the sentence because he repeatedly broke into
00:48:59
uncontrollable sobs what i don't know is he okay he's not okay oh man he was just like
00:49:08
having a bad day he's really sad about having a guy hung i guess okay i looked it up i can't find
00:49:16
any information this is pre-prozac when like judges just used to start crying sorry it's
00:49:22
about something else. Just hold on one second. Three of them. This doctor? Fuck.
00:49:36
Can you imagine? Everyone's like, take that wig off. What's wrong with you? Okay.
00:49:43
So Dr. Bowers is sent to jail at the jail at Broadway and Kearney to await execution.
00:49:49
Oh, sure. We know that one. Right? Right next to the Palace Hotel. No, it's not.
00:49:54
Okay, so here's the twist. Okay. Ooh, there's a twist. Yeah, there's more of a twist.
00:49:59
Okay. A year and a half after Dr. Bowers is convicted in October of 1887, a young man goes to a boarding house at 22 Geary Street
00:50:10
and asks about renting a room. He's shown several rooms by the woman who owns the house,
00:50:17
but he only likes room 21. and she says it's not available it'll be available Saturday and so he's like sounds great and he
00:50:26
leaves so then the next day another young man shows up at that boarding house saying he heard
00:50:34
room 21 would be available and uh can he rent it and so she says sure fuck that other guy and
00:50:43
He pays $5 deposit, and he's given a key. And then a few days after that, a servant enters room 21 and finds the dead body of a young man.
00:50:55
But it's not the guy that rented room 21, and it's not the guy who asked about room 21.
00:51:01
It's Cecilia Bauer's 27-year-old brother, Henry Benhaon. So the dead, the phosphorus stomach's brother.
00:51:10
Brother. The person's brother is dead. Dead in this. In 21. Yes, in room 21. Okay.
00:51:18
They find him laid on top of the bedsheets. The bedclothes are not must in any way.
00:51:24
There's a flask of whiskey next to him, a bottle of cyanide, and three letters. One's written to the coroner, one's written to the press, and one is written to Dr. J. Milton Bowers.
00:51:33
They're all signed by him. It sounds like the beginning of one of those super irritating logic puzzles where you're just like.
00:51:39
Who was the killer. I get it. The doctor is a woman, you sexist pig. I haven't heard this in a minute.
00:51:49
But no, this really happened. So in the coroner's letter that supposedly Henry wrote,
00:51:58
he confesses to murdering his own sister. He says he planned to poison Dr. Bowers,
00:52:03
but then Cecilia found out about it and threatened to expose him. So then he was like, okay, I'll just poison you instead.
00:52:09
Great. I say, why not both? So now Dr. Bowers' attorneys are stoked, and they're like,
00:52:16
are you guys getting out of jail later days? But everybody else, the prosecutors, the press,
00:52:23
everybody who's anybody in 1880 San Francisco knows that somehow Dr. Bowers has engineered this whole thing to exonerate himself.
00:52:32
Shit. Right? So the people who knew Henry said he was a cheerful man, he did not drink,
00:52:38
and he was not suicidal in any way. In fact, he had just bought tickets to take his niece to the theater.
00:52:46
So obviously the suicide was not a plan in any way. Also, the handwriting did not match his.
00:52:53
So they end up tracking down the mysterious young man who had rented Room 21. And remember Teresa Farrell, the pretty young maid that was all up in everybody's business?
00:53:04
It's her brother, 33-year-old Thomas Dimmig. Right? Dude. Come on. Come on, Thomas.
00:53:12
Come on, don't be a dick. It's too late. He's been a dick for 150 years. He's arrested.
00:53:19
He's charged with the murder of Henry Ben-Hayon. It turns out Thomas Dimmig is a straight-up dipshit.
00:53:26
He's like, the detectives are like, is this an act? You're so stupid. It doesn't make sense.
00:53:31
We can barely talk to you. They're like actually kind of baffled by how dumb he is.
00:53:38
He tells police he rented room 21 because he has a book business and he was going to do his book business in a rooming house room for the weekend.
00:53:47
Everyone knows you do book business in a different kind of room. Yeah, that's stupid.
00:53:53
The cops are like, come on. We know Maybe a more permanent room like an office or something The cops are like dummy you lying What are you doing
00:54:06
What did you do? And then he says, okay, I didn't want to tell you because I'm married,
00:54:10
but I rented that room so I could have an affair with a woman from San Jose named Dimples.
00:54:19
That's a dog. That's not a woman. Oh, Dimples. Come to room 21. Come to room 21.
00:54:30
They don't like bestiality humor. Who cares? So, oh, later on I did find in the older and kind of
00:54:43
more thorough book, that it said in that book that her name was Timpkins, not Dimples.
00:54:51
But Dimples is so much better that I think we need to stick with that. So when the case goes to trial,
00:54:58
the prosecution shows that Thomas Deming had recently bought cyanide, that the flask found by Henry
00:55:05
matched the one that he was known to carry, and that Henry had recently, out of the blue,
00:55:10
gotten a writing job for a bookseller, even though he wasn't a good writer or smart.
00:55:17
And his own friend testified at this trial, saying, like, yeah, Henry told me he got a job writing
00:55:23
and I was super confused and it seemed really suspicious and I was upset. And it was theorized by the prosecution
00:55:34
that this was how Deming got a sample of Henry's writing to forge the letters where he confessed to the murder of his own sister.
00:55:41
After all of that proof, the jury is hopelessly deadlocked, seven voting for acquittal,
00:55:47
five for conviction. So Deming returns to jail to write a new trial. And then the state Supreme Court
00:55:55
grants Dr. Bowers a new trial. And then Dimming gets acquitted. And then eight months after that,
00:56:02
in August of 1889, the DA dismisses the murder case against Dr. Bowers in the light of the outcome
00:56:08
of the Dimming case, saying it will be impossible now to get a conviction. Wait, what?
00:56:12
So he, Dr. J. Milton Bowers, walks free from jail. Yeah? and you know what that mother bird does he moves to san jose
00:56:23
yeah he does and he marries a miss bird there someone named miss bird uh 19 years later
00:56:35
he dies in 1905 miss bird right miss bird remained alive so apparently they had a fourth one's a
00:56:45
charm. As they always say. As they say in the medical field. And the last line of Gary
00:56:54
Kamiya's article, he wrote, and so the mystery of the phosphorescent bride of Dr. Bowers
00:56:59
will never be solved. Until tonight, he fucking did it. The end. And that's the story of Dr.
00:57:08
J. Milton Bowers. Thank you. Thank you. And you know what? A special thank you to San Jose, California
00:57:18
for being there for me. You really took a hit on that one. It turns out we have a thing now
00:57:24
that the more we talk shit on your city, the more likely we're going to bring Paul Holes there.
00:57:31
Like we did for Sacramento on Friday. Sorry, he's not here. Yeah. Stephen, he's at home with Stephen taking care of the cat.
00:57:43
Um, that was amazing. I've never heard that somehow. I know it's insane. I'm going to need
00:57:47
that website. Okay. Please. www.wikipedia.net.com or .gov? .gov. Got it. .edu. Bro, from the show last night to this drive, why is it never chill? Because this is our life
00:58:04
backstage on the road it's loud messy real and that's the best part whole crew no plan just moving
00:58:13
good thing nissan builds for that kind of chaos not just test tracks real life scenes late nights
00:58:18
road trips all of it that's why it holds up nissan was ranked number one in initial quality among
00:58:24
mainstream brands by jd power yeah you can tell 2026 nissan rogue built for what really happens
00:58:31
For J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Initial Quality Study Award information, visit jdpower.com slash awards.
00:58:38
Awards based on 2025 model year, newer models may be shown. NYX, that's K-N-I-X leak-proof underwear, isn't just for one moment.
00:58:47
It's for all the everyday moments you didn't realize leak-proof underwear could make easier.
00:58:52
Maybe it's day one of your period. Maybe it's a long travel day. Maybe it's hot outside.
00:58:57
You're on the move and you just want to feel fresh. Their leak-proof underwear comes in a range of absorbencies, from light to ultra, and helps protect against periods, light leaks, sweat, and everyday surprises.
00:59:10
And because they look and feel like real underwear, they're soft, invisible underclothes, and machine washable.
00:59:17
No extra hassle. No complicated routine. Just dependable protection you can wash and re-wear.
00:59:25
See why millions have made the switch to leak-proof underwear. Visit Nix.com. That's K-N-I-X.com and use code FLOW15 for 15% off.
00:59:35
That's K-N-I-X.com. Code FLOW15. Hey, everyone. It's Cal Penn, host of Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club.
00:59:46
This week on the podcast, I'm sitting down with Will Wheaton, who played Gordie Lachance in Stand By Me 40 years ago
00:59:53
and now narrates Stephen King The Body the novella that inspired it all We talk about what it like to return to a story that shaped his life channeling his memories of River Phoenix and the recording booth
01:00:06
and why the friendships you have at 12 might be the most important ones you'll ever have.
01:00:11
I know Gordy Lachance. I am Gordy Lachance. Like, I mean, even when I was a little kid, I was Gordy Lachance when I didn't know it.
01:00:20
Listen to Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:00:27
Okay, here we go. Let's escape from Alcatraz, everyone. Okay. Now, Stephen screwed up, didn't he?
01:00:41
Yeah, he did. He forgot that I called this one last week. Then Karen called it the other night, and he forgot and told her she could do it.
01:00:50
And then he texted me and was like, I told her she could do it. And then, like, waited for me to go, okay, I'll do something else.
01:00:55
And I was like, tell her she can't fucking do it. It's only fair. It's only fair.
01:01:01
Sadly, I was in the middle of watching the Clint Eastwood movie Escape from Alcatraz,
01:01:05
and I was just like, I kind of just wanted to talk through this movie to people.
01:01:09
So please feel free to interject at any time with shit I'm leaving out. Okay. I'm forgetting because I didn't watch the film Escape from Alcatraz.
01:01:19
It was a dramatized version. Right. Yeah, so who knows? Let's get a little bit of history first.
01:01:25
75, a Spanish explorer, something something in this place, San Franciscan Bay. Yes.
01:01:33
Isle de la Alcatraz, meaning Island of the Pelicans. Oh. Over time, the official name became Alcatraz.
01:01:43
Pelican. Alcatraz Pelican. So in 1909, what was then of the fortress became demolished.
01:01:51
That had been there. A prison was built, and the prisoners had to fucking build it.
01:01:55
What a bummer that probably was, right? Yes. Like, lock me up. Writers, they put in the last brick.
01:02:02
Okay, get in. No dinner. They wall themselves in. Yeah. Oh. Bricked up. Right. They're like, we don't want to make a solitary confinement.
01:02:17
Can we just have it be an open floor plan? Yeah. No. That's right. An escape from Alcatraz was considered impossible,
01:02:26
so the U.S. government turned it into a federal penitentiary for civilians, convicts,
01:02:35
that they thought was especially dangerous, of course. So, and normally the only exit routes were death or the infirmary.
01:02:42
And you're like, pass. Pass. Or getting out, I guess. Getting released. I don't know.
01:02:49
Were there fire exits? I doubt it. So until its closing in 1963, there were only 14 escape attempts from 36 different prisoners.
01:02:59
23 were caught. Six were shot dead. Two drowned. And the remaining five are thought to have drowned, either in the bay or swept out to sea.
01:03:07
But there's also, of course, the prison's most legendary escape made famous in the film that Clint Eastwood, the 1979 film Escape from Alcatraz.
01:03:18
Let's talk about that. And that's not the one we're going to talk about tonight.
01:03:21
No, that's not true. What if it wasn't? Just a big lead up. I want to talk about this guy, Eric.
01:03:28
Who really pisses me off. Right. So let's start with the escapees. Frank Lee Morris was born in Washington, D.C. in September 1926.
01:03:37
He's abandoned by his mother and father during his childhood. He's an orphan by the time he's 11.
01:03:43
Spends most of his formative years in foster homes. He's convicted of his first crime at 13, and by his late teens,
01:03:49
he'd been arrested for crimes ranging from narcotics possession to armed robbery.
01:03:52
Wow. Super bummer. He spends most of his early years in jail serving lunch to prisoners.
01:04:00
So he's like a lunch man. Oh, that's nice. He had a love of food and cuisine. And slop.
01:04:04
And slop. And ladles. He just loved to ladle things. Love those ladles. God, I love beef stroganoff in a ladle.
01:04:12
He'd take little sips from it. Sips for me and sips for you. That's right. Shiv.
01:04:17
Okay. And a shiv. And a shiv. As he got older, he got arrested for grand larceny in Miami Beach.
01:04:27
He served time in Florida and Georgia. And then escaped. That's my name. And then he escaped from the Louisiana State Penitentiary while serving 10 years for bank robbery.
01:04:36
He was recaptured a year later while committing another burglary and sent to Alcatraz in 1960.
01:04:42
This fucking dude, though, ranked in the top 2% of the general population in intelligence with an IQ of 133.
01:04:49
Whoa. Yeah. Especially for that time. IQ of 133 nowadays is... Oh, that's 562. That's right.
01:04:58
You don't want to be anywhere near those people. No, my God. Who read your mind and steal your wallet.
01:05:04
That's right. Shiv. And a shiv. So, then there's Clarence and John Anglin, the Anglin brothers.
01:05:13
Anglin for a bruising? That's not a thing. No, it's fun. So, Clarence was 33 and John was 32.
01:05:20
They were born into a family of 13 children in Georgia. Sure. Too many children, in my humble opinion.
01:05:27
Their parents were seasonal farm workers, and in the early 1940s, they moved the family to Ruskin, Florida, 20 miles south of Tampa.
01:05:35
every June they'd go here and there I don't know, it doesn't matter you don't care about this family at all
01:05:44
it's kind of whatever, but the brothers were like inseparable, they were a year apart
01:05:49
so they were always hanging out and shit they were skilled swimmers, of course and they would be able to swim the freezing lakes
01:05:54
of Lake Michigan as ice still floated in the surface foreshadowing Foreshadowing Foreshadowing A great sign for those two Right And I bet like back then they were just these probably like muscle bound you know jokers
01:06:08
I don't know. They just sound, they sound fun. They were muscular and they always loved to shake their finger in your face.
01:06:15
We're criminals. So they were farmers and laborers. Clarence was first caught breaking into a service station when he was 14.
01:06:22
and they began robbing banks as a team in the early 1950s, usually places that were closed,
01:06:27
and when they weren't closed, they'd use a toy gun because they didn't want to hurt anyone.
01:06:30
Oh. Aw. I love when you can love the criminal. I know. Bank robbers. Fun. Cute. Good swimmers.
01:06:39
That's right. They probably had, like, their pants went up to here and they had really tough, you know, muscular bodies.
01:06:45
Yeah. They liked to shadow box a lot. Right. Put them up, see? They smoked right until they went to sleep.
01:06:52
They claim they only used a weapon once and it was a toy gun. They were arrested in 1958 after robbing a bank in Alabama
01:06:59
and both received 15 to 20 year sentences in Florida. And then they had several failed escape attempts
01:07:06
and so they were transferred to Alcatraz in 1960 and 61. So, then, and they knew our friend Smarty Pants Frank from Atlanta
01:07:18
so they were all like buddies and shit and they were like, oh my god when they got to Alcatraz
01:07:22
a high five through the bars that hadn't been invented yet but I'm sure they would have high fived
01:07:27
it was probably like a 50's wink or something oh a fake gun that's what they were all about
01:07:35
right don't be threatened no one's going to get hurt I mean it and then there was
01:07:44
so it was the three of them that did the escaping but there was a fourth dude who never
01:07:47
made it and who ratted them all out. So this, there's always that dude. Dude, this guy, he doesn't sound super smart.
01:07:55
Sorry if he is your relative. Okay. His name was Alan West and he had the education of an eighth
01:08:04
grader. Was born in New York city. And after these three dudes did their escape, he was like,
01:08:09
what's up FBI? I know everything. And like, I don't know what I'm going to tell you, like
01:08:12
immediately ratted them out. Snitch. Um, so here's what he, here's what happened. So the
01:08:19
Smarty Pants Frank is our Clint Eastwood. Clint Eastwood, that's right. He's not going to play no dummy.
01:08:26
I'd like to try the dumb guy as a role. I think I could dig into it. A really hot dumb guy with his pants up to his nipples.
01:08:34
High pants dumb guy. Yeah. I'm tired of being a cowboy with a cigar. Right. I want to be dumb for, why can't I be dumb?
01:08:44
So at Alcatraz, there were 12 head counts a day. and prison guards listening to every visitor contact
01:08:51
and metal detectors so sensitive that they were once set off by Al Capone's mother's corset lining.
01:08:57
Girl. I know. I like to picture that she looks exactly like Al Capone. But with a little gray wig.
01:09:05
Yes. Finger waves. Definitely. Why don't... It doesn't seem like they have that sensitive of metal detectors now.
01:09:12
No, they don't. The airport should get those. Yeah. But then my corset that I always wear, you know.
01:09:18
Oh, my corset. Oh, fuck that shit. Okay, so. And then they also didn't allow prisoners much exercise at all.
01:09:25
So the prison was only 1.5 miles offshore, but they were like, we're going to make you have scrawny arms so you wouldn't be able to swim anyways.
01:09:32
Oh, that's kind of smart. So what the guys did for their escape, the four men widened the vents in their 9x5 foot cells using canteen spoons.
01:09:41
So they did a count on the canteen knives after every meal, but they didn't count those old spoons.
01:09:47
Got to count those spoons. That's right. And you can rip that head off. Shiv. You know?
01:09:53
And then you just scrape the wall. And the prison had been built, like, what year did I say again?
01:09:58
It was a long time ago. 1860. 1868. And so at that point, with all the salt water and all the, you know, elements of, you know, the earth and shit.
01:10:08
Wind, fire. Everything was sort of falling apart and crumbling at that point. So they would notice these cracks in the wall,
01:10:15
and they'd stick their homemade shiv in there and be like, Oh, shiv. Holy shiv. We're getting out of here.
01:10:24
That's right. Thank you. Okay, so. And then they also found discarded saw blades
01:10:34
that they had found in the prison grounds, which I feel like should have been picked up by maintenance.
01:10:38
Absolutely. What lazy woodworker just threw his saw blades on the ground? I don't know.
01:10:45
And they had made a drill out of a broken vacuum cleaner motor. Which is like, oh, that's smart.
01:10:51
You know what? They earned it. They earned it. There's actually a lot of this story that I'm like, oh, that sounds like a fun show for like HGTV or something.
01:11:00
I would love that if it's like four college kids. Now you have to skate from Alcatraz, you dumb assholes.
01:11:07
That's right. You'll never do it. You can't walk seven feet without your phone. That's right.
01:11:12
I'm including myself. I'm including myself. And then, okay, not only is our friend Frank Morris hot and smart,
01:11:22
this fucker can play the accordion. No. Yeah. How hot is that? Yes. Lady of Spain.
01:11:34
I think that's how it goes, right? I think so. Did they let him have an accordion in jail?
01:11:41
There was a music time in jail, you guys. Oh, Alcatraz. I know. But imagine this.
01:11:48
So it was like after dinner and everyone went back to their cell and there'd be just an hour play the fuck whatever you want.
01:11:53
But nobody, I don't think anyone was playing the same thing. So it's just this cacophony of fucking music and banjos.
01:12:00
Someone keeps going, five, six, seven, eight. Seriously, pick it up. We're in G.
01:12:07
Jerry, we're in G. Yee-haw. Yee-haw, lady of Spain. The best. So they would use that time of just seizure-inducing noise to dig, right?
01:12:24
And shit. Wait, but Frank also played the accordion. So was he at music time or he was like, oh my God, my finger hurts so bad.
01:12:33
You play my accordion for me. Well, I think they were like in the same cell block, so he would play it too.
01:12:38
I don't know. Maybe they loved his music so much that they let him play at other hours of the day too.
01:12:43
Let's just say that. Okay. Let's say the guards had a soft spot for the accordion.
01:12:47
Oh, who doesn't? In our movie that we're making about this. Where there's a whole polka, intense polka nerd group in the warden's office.
01:12:57
The movie's called Holy Shiv. That's amazing. Yes, absolutely. So, okay. And then they also hid signs by making,
01:13:07
so they would take the ventilator off and dig and shit, and so they made paper mache fucking ventilators
01:13:14
that they painted in the, like, art room, I don't know, this in color, I think it's called Depressing Gray,
01:13:21
and then put the fake paper mache, like, these guys are creative. They're Martha Stewart.
01:13:25
Yes. And I don't think she fucking escaped from prison, did she? She stayed. She stayed.
01:13:31
Remember when that happened? Yeah, she was in the big house. What the fuck? But I heard that she made delicious dinners in the microwave.
01:13:39
I'm not kidding. Really? Yes. She like started doing a bunch of, she used her energy wisely while she was there.
01:13:46
Love her. She looks great in gray sweats. Depressing gray sweats. Yeah. So they made paper mache, ventilation, duct grills using magazines from the prison library and paint.
01:13:58
And then they also were like, well, they're supposed to be sleeping all night, of course.
01:14:03
And so they need to look like they're in their bed. So they made dummy heads from paper mache using a mixture of soap, toothpaste, the concrete dust that they were fucking from digging.
01:14:15
And toilet paper, which is just like, that's so creative. No, they were crafty bitches.
01:14:21
They were Etsy style. If it was today, they would have their own Etsy stores. You know when your friends are like, that's right.
01:14:28
You know when your friends are like, girls night in, like bring your favorite crafting thing and we'll craft together.
01:14:32
And they would like sit around and watch Real Housewives or whatever. That's what they were doing in my mind.
01:14:36
I bet they were best, best friends. Best friends. Such good friends. When we get out of here, guys, we're going to open our own.
01:14:43
Deli. Deli. Next to the Payless shoe store. Payless shoe store. Damn it. And we're going to have fun.
01:14:53
Hold on. Can I just say that in my, pretty much the whole reason that I wanted to do this is because the picture of the paper mache head.
01:15:02
So they have it, there's one picture where they have it like basically mocked up of what it looked like every night.
01:15:07
I don't know if it exists that way in Alctrouse now. But then they also have it when they found that they were gone.
01:15:13
It is the best. Like they really look like real heads. Because they also, they must have spent so much time on this.
01:15:19
They also got hair clippings from the barbershop and made them hair. They even gave them hair eyelashes.
01:15:26
Oh, good. Which is unnecessary, so you know they were enjoying it. Yeah. You know what I mean?
01:15:31
That's right. That's extra. Eyebrows and lashes are unnecessary. They're like, should I give mine just a five o'clock shadow?
01:15:38
Just, you know, at the end of the day. Frankie, I think that would look great. I'd love that.
01:15:44
I'd love that idea. You're really talented. Frank, I love your art, and I love your spirit.
01:15:50
Thank you. Yes. Okay, so, ba-ba-ba-ba-ba, paint, hair. They used them to convince the guards that they were sleeping,
01:16:03
but they were secretly in the workshop on the cell lock roof, which they accessed through the holes in their cells that they made,
01:16:09
an unguarded utility corridor and plumbing pipes that they used to step. So there was this whole floor above the cells that was just hanging out, ready for action.
01:16:20
Can I just make one suggestion that they can't use because it's all ended? Yeah.
01:16:25
But I got the idea that then once they, because also Clint Eastwood played the Birdman of Alcatraz.
01:16:32
So then I was thinking, what if they caught live birds and put them into the shirts so that it looked like they were breathing?
01:16:38
Oh! I wish I was at Alcatraz. Okay, anyway, sorry. I'm going to think of more craft ideas for these guys as we sit here.
01:16:50
That's beautiful. Okay, so then their next step was that on the rooftop, they secretly made life jackets.
01:16:59
They took life jackets, they made them. Excuse me. What? So the only thing that was waterproof at Alcatraz
01:17:07
were donated raincoats from the Army afterwards. They were like, ship them to Alcatraz.
01:17:13
So they got a bunch of the jackets, and they made raincoats using, or life jackets,
01:17:19
by using a 6x14, and they fucking sewed together a life raft using that. Does that make any sense?
01:17:26
You're saying they took army jackets and made life jackets and a raft? Yes, because they were waterproof.
01:17:33
Wow. Yeah. So someone knew how to sew. Frank. And then, here's my favorite part, and this is going to come back around.
01:17:42
Guess how they fucking blew up the life raft, inflated it. Okay, the accordion. Oh my god!
01:17:54
How good is that How did they do it and not make sound That a great question Okay can I just here my idea I pitch my idea One of them pretends that his girlfriend broke up with him through a letter
01:18:07
and cries really loud every night. That's it. But then they're like, okay, wrap it up.
01:18:19
If you're not that sad, they're like, just two more months of this and we'll be all...
01:18:24
I just have to cleanse the feeling from my system. And they make makeshift paddles from scrap wood and stuff.
01:18:32
And then, so on the night of June 11th, finally, they're like, this has been so much fun.
01:18:36
Let's pretend it was a montage of them crafting shit, you know? Adorable. What song would play during the montage of them crafting stuff?
01:18:45
Minute by minute. I'm not sure. I went Doobie Brothers, I don't know why. Okay. On the night of June 11th, they waited until the 9.30 p.m. head count,
01:18:57
and probably the fairy tale read by the local guard, I'm sure, that he would have before bed and making that up.
01:19:05
And then they all got arrested. Good night, everybody. Good night, everyone. Sleep, sweet dreams.
01:19:09
Sleep tight. No screaming. All night. And then all, but our friend West made it to the cell block roof.
01:19:19
they dug out. They went up. Wes didn't make it because he had widened his air vent opening
01:19:25
in his cell wall but unlike the others, he had used cement to hold the concrete that was crumbling around his exit hole
01:19:33
and on the night of the escape he discovered that his cement had set so he had just made a
01:19:37
wall. He had just basically like fixed the hole. The guard comes by and is like thank you so much for that. That was
01:19:49
nice of you. Yeah. And yeah, the others had fucking latered by the time he chipped himself
01:19:56
out of there. So sad. What a bummer, right? Wait for me, guys. Chip, chip, chip, chip.
01:20:01
No wonder they told on him. He was really so mad. Yeah. So from, but then the other three
01:20:08
accessed the higher roof through a large ventilation shaft that they had just taken out.
01:20:12
And the guards did hear a large crash as the men got out of the shaft, but they were like,
01:20:17
didn't hear anything else, went back to their poker game. What was the game your mom, your grandma played?
01:20:24
Old Maid. All the guards are sitting around with the one card pulled up. What will it be?
01:20:33
So they take their homemade raft and the three convicts shimmy down a large pipe to the ground.
01:20:39
They cut through the barbed wire at the top of the fence, 12 feet high. And then they inflate their raft, the accordion.
01:20:46
and they're in a blind spot and sometime after 10 p.m. they fucking later date off of Alcatraz.
01:20:55
In a raft made of jackets. Into the dense fog towards Angel Island two miles to the north.
01:21:01
Can you imagine the freezing? It's cold like on the street in San Francisco at night.
01:21:06
You don't want to get anywhere near that water. Oh, it's so cold. It's so cold. It's so cold.
01:21:10
It's so cold and there's so much goddamn seaweed in there. Yeah. That's what I would the whole time if I was in there, I'd just be, something touched my foot.
01:21:20
I hate it in here. Frank, calm down. It's seaweed. I hate seaweed. And then the other one's like, we could make wonderful crafts out of this seaweed.
01:21:28
Let's dry it and hang it and make it into witch's hair. Easy. You always put a good spin on everything.
01:21:36
You're such a good friend. You are. So they were going to, according to Wes, who ratted them out,
01:21:44
told them that they were going to cross to the mainland, take clothes to replace their prison uniforms,
01:21:48
and steal a car and make their getaway. And the FBI are like, oh, shit. Because A, it's like prisoners escaping,
01:21:54
even though they're toy gun users still. And also it's going to make them look really fucking stupid
01:21:58
if they can actually escape. On June 14th... That's the whole point of Alcatraz.
01:22:03
Right. You don't. Right. On June 14th, three days after the escape, the Coast Guard picked up a paddle floating about 200 yards off the southern shore of Angel Island.
01:22:12
And on the same day in general location, workers on another boat found a wallet wrapped in plastic containing names, addresses,
01:22:19
and photos of the angel of the brothers. The brothers. Friends and relatives. One's the name Clarence, I do remember that.
01:22:28
I put it here on purpose, Clarence and John. Yeah, there it is. So they find little things that they probably would have needed.
01:22:36
You know what I mean? So they're like, they're probably dead. And we don't fucking know if they are or not to this day, which is so fun, isn't it? I think they are. And I think it's your dad.
01:22:48
He just kind of rinsed off and then went right over to the fire department. He was like, you got any openings here? I can grow a mustache real fast.
01:22:58
Steroids will do that. Yeah, that's right. All the steroid use. Yeah. So basically, circumstantial evidence uncovered in the early 2010s
01:23:06
seemed to suggest that they actually survived. A raft was discovered nearby on Angel Island with footprints leading away.
01:23:14
Exciting. That's great news. And a car would have been stolen on the night of the escape.
01:23:20
And someone said that a car was stolen by three men the night of the escape. Love it.
01:23:25
What other three men are stealing cars? What are the odds? On that night. There's nothing on Angel Island.
01:23:30
Who would do it? It's our guys. It's definitely our guys. And conspiracy theorists say, you know them, they like to talk.
01:23:37
They say that there was a police cover-up because they didn't want to admit that, you know, they got duped or whatever.
01:23:44
Yeah. And there have been several reported sightings of the three men over the year, and some of them are discounted.
01:23:50
Some are taken seriously. Family members of the brothers occasionally got unsigned postcards and messages over the years Which is so cute they did it they made it I know Once a card came signed Jerry and another Jerry and Joe
01:24:05
God bless you. Scream, sneeze, or mother, brother. So loud. The family also showed everyone
01:24:16
a Christmas card that they allegedly received in the family mailbox in 1962 saying, to mother, from John,
01:24:23
Merry Christmas. What if they were Jewish? Wouldn't that be funny? That's their inside joke.
01:24:31
And the brother's mother received flowers anonymously every Mother's Day until her death.
01:24:39
You guys. They're good people. They're good people forced into a bad situation. I feel like at that point, it's like if they could get off in the most creative, clever montage way I've ever heard of,
01:24:52
and they were not in there for hurting anyone, let those fuckers live. They earned it.
01:24:57
Also, they swam the bay. They swam the bay. They swam the bay. They were going to open a nice deli.
01:25:03
Let's just let them live. Let them live. That's right. Let them craft. Exactly. And at their mother's funeral,
01:25:13
two very tall women, unusually tall women, in heavy makeup. That's me. I mean, look, that's not weird.
01:25:25
That's right. We're everywhere. And tall back then was like 5'5". Yeah. Jesus Christ, she's 5'8".
01:25:33
Showed up to the fucking funeral, which I love. And then they latered. One of the siblings also said that when their father died in 1989,
01:25:44
two strangers in probably fake-looking beards showed up. Crafted beards. Oh, what if in that one they crafted like an Orthodox Jewish, you know, with the pace and the whole thing where people are like, we'd never suspect two Orthodox Jews here at this funeral.
01:26:00
How about that? Of a strict Catholic. They showed up and wept over the casket into their beards and then snuck off.
01:26:09
So it was them, you guys. Yes. And then in 2015, a letter allegedly written by one of the escapees came to light.
01:26:15
It said, my name is John Anglin. I escaped from Alcatraz in June 1962. It's like, how much more privilege do you fucking need?
01:26:22
With my brother Clarence and Frank Morris, I'm 83 years old and in bad shape. I have cancer.
01:26:27
Yes, we all made it that night, but barely. The FBI says this piece of evidence forced the agency to reopen its cold case.
01:26:33
What if they threw him back in prison? How mad would we all be? I mean, according to the letter,
01:26:39
Frank died in 2008, and John's brother died three years later. The writer makes a deal.
01:26:44
If you announce on TV that I will be promised to first go to jail for no more than a year and get medical attention,
01:26:51
I will write back to let you know exactly where I am. This is no joke. Oh, what happened?
01:26:57
The writer of the letter says he spent many years after his escape from Alcatraz living in...
01:27:02
San Jose. No, that was a good guess. Oh. I mean, Seattle. Seattle? Yeah, which is like, cool, okay.
01:27:14
They started grunge rock? Yeah. Cool. Yes. It's Eddie about her. But then he says that he currently lives in Southern California.
01:27:28
So we could know him. Oh, my God. He could be our friend that we hang out with. It's that guy from the crafting store.
01:27:34
Yes. What if he got a job at Joanne's? That old crabby man that helps me at Joanne's.
01:27:42
Yeah. Or Joanne's, singular. What if he's like still wet with seawater and has like still has seaweed over over his shoulder?
01:27:48
It's like how we never figured this out? There's a fucking seagull perched on his shoulder
01:27:54
This guy helped me I would have never made it without Gary He's gonna befriend a seagull in our movie for sure, me and Gary. Okay.
01:28:03
Stay away! What, you're helping me? He's like right as he's going to drown and then the seagull's like no, I thought you had potato chips.
01:28:12
Fine, I'll help you since I'm here. If the men were alive today, Frank would be 90 years old, and John and Clarence would be 86 and 87, but nothing ever came of that.
01:28:26
Or maybe it did, and I just didn't look hard enough. Now that's your job to end the story yourself later tonight.
01:28:34
That's how we do it. Look, there's a restaurant here that has a beignet flight. I couldn't miss it.
01:28:40
What's up, Brenda's? So good. Okay, the only proven case of an Alcatraz inmate ever reaching shore by swimming happened on December 16, 1962 by an inmate named John Paul Scott.
01:28:52
Successfully swam the distance of 3.1 miles from Alcatraz to Fort Point. Some fucking shitty teenagers found him and turned him in.
01:29:02
But he was suffering from hypothermia and exhaustion, and he was immediately returned to Alcatraz.
01:29:07
But he fucking made it. He made it. And now it's done all the time as like fun for some of you psychopaths.
01:29:14
Disgusting lunatics. What the hell? Today, athletes swim the same Alcatraz four-point route as part of one of two annual triathlon events.
01:29:25
Have you guys heard of naps? I mean. Jesus Christ. And brunch. Bagels. Bagels. Brunch.
01:29:33
Therapy. Therapy. Get out of the bay. Yeah. Get out of that water. Anyways, that's the story of the escape from Alcatraz.
01:29:42
Yes, that was awesome. That was really good. Thank you. Do we have time for a hometown?
01:29:53
I think we do. Let's do it. Oh my God Here the thing is now this is the part where I tell you the rules of this is the part where we call someone up from the audience to tell their hometown murder
01:30:06
And this is the part where then I tell you what the rules are to qualify for doing your hometown murder.
01:30:11
And then you ignore them. And then everyone always ignores them. Fine. Do what you want. Be punk rock.
01:30:18
Last night, a girl got on stage. Heidi. And I was like, please let it be local. We're here in Oakland.
01:30:26
It would be great to hear something out of Oakland or anything nearby. Northern California would be great.
01:30:30
And she comes up. She's like, I'm from Bakersfield. I was like, Jesus Christ, here we go.
01:30:35
But she then proceeds to tell the most nutso lunatic story that was so hilarious and great.
01:30:44
And of the rules. So we'll walk through what the rules are. We want it to be local.
01:30:48
No. She said no. Bakersfield. it has to be quick it wasn't the quickest story we've ever heard although it was very engaging
01:30:55
yeah um we uh you need to have a beginning and middle and end we always love to know
01:31:00
what what really happens so there's like a little bit of a button at the end she basically tells the story like someone i can't even do it it was like somebody chasing
01:31:09
her father and breaking into her house and then merle haggard was involved it was merle haggard's
01:31:14
old house their pool was shaped like a guitar it went on and on it was insanity but it was amazing
01:31:19
somebody drove through the really long drive because it was like out on a farm somebody busted through their gate
01:31:24
and was driving up with their headlights on high and then the dad was like take this gun and you take this gun
01:31:30
and all this stuff she ran upstairs and then she just goes they never caught him
01:31:35
thanks and we were like whoa what? anyways hilarious we're giving her a podcast yeah she's the greatest
01:31:42
and we say don't be too drunk that you can't remember your story yeah also remember that if you get picked
01:31:48
everyone hates you so you have to go fast. And this time, so I have to wait to pick from the back
01:31:52
unless, yeah, no one's going to climb on this stage. Back right. Back right. So I saw Vince back there.
01:31:58
Can we get the lights up, please, so we can see this beautiful Lego land in all its glory?
01:32:04
And that's a flat no. Oh, look at it. Oh, it just takes a moment. I don't know. Because this is legit.
01:32:11
Karen, can you see anything? I can't see shit. The two of you, yeah, with your holding her wrist.
01:32:17
Yeah, yeah. Send her to Vince back there. Back that way. Turn around and then run to the exit.
01:32:22
Oh, here they are. Oh, my God. That was so fast. Hi. What's your name? Lauren. Nice to meet you.
01:32:31
Hi. Come here. This is Lauren, everybody. Lauren. I'm here. I'm standing there. That was quite a journey you made me take to get over here.
01:32:42
It was really fast. Jeez, I should have worked out before this. No. Don't be crazy.
01:32:46
I'm told I have to make this quick. Where are you from? Oh, I'm from actually Saratoga, which is right near San Jose.
01:32:51
San Jose! Who knew it was going to be such a hot topic this evening? It never is.
01:32:58
We didn't. It never is. Well, the school that I went through was a K-12 former military academy.
01:33:03
I'm sure some of you who are local can figure out which one it was. But there was this really nasty college counselor, and I feel very bad speaking ill of the dead, but here it goes.
01:33:11
Okay. Kind of the theme of the show. I literally told people who would go in with their top picks of college,
01:33:18
I want to go here, here, here, and here. And she said, you have a better chance of getting struck by lightning
01:33:23
than getting into any of these schools. You know, when you're 17, 16 years old, that's really uplifting.
01:33:29
So she did the same thing to me. I was not too thrilled, but, I mean, we move on.
01:33:33
And I heard more stories because my brother went through with her the whole nine yards,
01:33:36
and it was just a disaster. So I'm in college, and I get a call from my parents.
01:33:40
The college you wanted to go to? I went to USC, so yes. yes University of Santa Clara
01:33:46
yes right correct the fighting Piccolo Piccolo the toughest team in the Pac-10 conference
01:33:57
oh yes okay sorry nailed it nailed it okay thank you so I get a call from one of my best girlfriends
01:34:02
and she goes you are never going to believe what just happened and I was like okay tell me everything
01:34:06
I want all the details and she said well we just found out that there was a murder homicide
01:34:12
suicide at home and instantly I started going through all the people that I know back home I'm
01:34:16
like oh my god who died my year was right before the recession as we all remember that very fondly
01:34:21
my college counselor she had bragged about that she was going to retire and I was her last class
01:34:26
so I guess when the economy crashed her husband didn't really plan financially very well
01:34:31
and she blamed him and for two three years was nagging nagging complaining that she still had to
01:34:36
work. So one day he woke up, shot her in the head, and then tried to kill himself. It didn't work.
01:34:43
Oh no. So he had to go to the hospital. He held on for maybe five, six hours more.
01:34:48
But that was it. And that was the end of this very horrible woman. And oh, so sad.
01:34:54
Oh my god. Saratoga? Lauren, everybody. Lauren, she did it. Perfect. Thank you. Nice to meet you too.
01:35:06
Lauren from Saratoga. Lauren. Holy shit. She's laughing as she says it's so sad.
01:35:17
I can feel it when I hug her. I can feel her little hummingbird heart. This is hard.
01:35:22
It's terrifying. It's really hard. You guys will see. San Francisco. Thank you. You guys, thank you so much.
01:35:29
obviously the city holds a special place in both of our hearts so it's so nice to come back here
01:35:40
and not have to wait tables or work at the gap and actually i didn't have a shit ton of friends
01:35:45
when i was here i think that one of them is here we're live journal friends uh we were so to come
01:35:51
here and have a theater full of like our friends and you guys are here for us it means so much
01:35:55
to us. Thank you so much for supporting us. Thank you. And I would just like to say, you know, I started stand-up comedy here and did it, while I lived here, I did it for two years.
01:36:13
It's, you know, my lifelong dream. And that sounded sarcastic, but I meant it. I think because I meant it, I had to say it with a tone.
01:36:21
while I lived here while I was doing stand-up here one time my dad who was also at work one night
01:36:28
he just brought Station 2 Chinatown Station 2 came down to the improv right on Mason
01:36:35
and they pretended that they were doing a fire inspection and they all just stood in the back of the room
01:36:40
so my dad could watch me do stand-up comedy and isn't that the best? it was really funny
01:36:48
And then it was a showcase night so it was a bunch of local comics and it was like Patton Oswalt was here Dana Gould was here Mark Maron lived here and was doing comedy David Cross came up for a while I think Janine Garofalo may have been in town it was like star And after the show my dad said that was a great show You know who my favorite comic is Ron Lynch
01:37:14
I was just like, Dad, I was on the show. I was a choice. You could have picked me.
01:37:21
So it's an honor that I get to perform for my father in San Francisco in a situation.
01:37:28
Well, let me just say it in a situation where you guys have created this this wonder of a podcast hit.
01:37:38
You guys gave this to us. You did. So thank you for letting us be here tonight. It's amazing.
01:37:46
Thank you. We don't get we don't know what's going on most of the time. This is super crazy, but we're having the best time and we're so so grateful
01:37:59
And we love the community that you guys are creating and the friendships that you are
01:38:03
Having together and the meetups and the charity that you're giving to it's incredibly beautiful
01:38:09
Especially it such a dark time in this country You guys are really bringing a light and keep doing it It really important Yeah we honored to be a part of it We love being murderinos Thank you guys so much for supporting us
01:38:22
Thank you for everything and stay sexy. And bye San Francisco. Thank you. Bro, from the show last night to this drive, why is it never chill?
01:38:36
Because this is our life backstage on the road. It's loud, messy, real. And that's the best part. Whole crew, no plan, just moving.
01:38:45
Good thing Nissan builds for that kind of chaos. Not just test tracks, real life scenes, late nights, road trips, all of it.
01:38:52
That's why it holds up. Nissan was ranked number one in initial quality among mainstream brands by J.D. Power.
01:38:59
Yeah, you can tell. 2026 Nissan Rogue built for what really happens. For J.D. Power 2025 US Initial Quality Study Award Information, visit jdpower.com slash awards.
01:39:10
Awards based on 2025 model year, newer models may be shown. Running a business shouldn't feel like
01:39:15
surviving a software group project. One app for accounting another for inventory another for sales and somehow none of them talk to each other That where Odoo comes in an all business management software that brings every part of your business together
01:39:32
From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform.
01:39:37
No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs. And best of all, no spreadsheets.
01:39:43
Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system.
01:39:48
Try for free today at odoo.com slash iHeartRadio. That's O-D-O-O-O dot com slash iHeartRadio.
01:39:57
Big transfer news today. Who's moving? Me. To the couch. With Domino's best deal ever since they just added stuffed crust.
01:40:04
Any pizza, any toppings, now with stuffed crust for $9.99. It's a long-term contract with no release clause.
01:40:10
Only $9.99? Yeah, that sounds like the move. I'm heading straight to Domino's. The price is higher for some locations.
01:40:19
Excludes XL and specialty pizzas. Select this offer from 615 through 726. Online only.
01:40:23
Size availability varies by crust height. Max 7 toppings. 6 for pan and New York style crust.
01:40:26
Minimum purchase required for delivery. Prices, participation, delivery area, and charges may vary.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Best performance
  • 80
    Biggest crowd reaction
  • 75
    Funniest
  • 75
    Most unserious (in a good way)

Episode Highlights

  • The Cello Mystery
    A humorous story about losing a cello after a move, leading to a series of comedic events.
    “A ghost cello player stole it?”
    @ 01m 44s
    March 19, 2020
  • Podcast Festival Excitement
    The hosts express excitement about performing at the symphony, noting the unique audience atmosphere.
    “This is so exciting to be here.”
    @ 03m 15s
    March 19, 2020
  • The Mysterious Deaths of Wives
    Dr. J. Milton Bowers' wives die under suspicious circumstances, raising eyebrows about his role.
    “So obvious, I mean about murdering all your wives.”
    @ 34m 21s
    March 19, 2020
  • Phosphorus Poisoning Revealed
    Cecilia Bowers' autopsy reveals phosphorus poisoning, leading to Dr. Bowers' arrest.
    “Her stomach is glowing in the dark.”
    @ 44m 21s
    March 19, 2020
  • Dr. Bowers' Defense
    Dr. Bowers claims he is innocent, stating he had no motive to poison his wife.
    “And you're all fools, fools, I say.”
    @ 46m 11s
    March 19, 2020
  • The Verdict
    After a lengthy trial, Dr. Bowers is found guilty of first-degree murder.
    “Thank you, a verdict of first degree, guilty of first degree murder.”
    @ 48m 31s
    March 19, 2020
  • A Shocking Twist
    A year and a half after the conviction, a shocking letter reveals a confession.
    “In the coroner's letter that supposedly Henry wrote, he confesses to murdering his own sister.”
    @ 51m 58s
    March 19, 2020
  • Dr. Bowers Walks Free
    In a surprising turn, Dr. Bowers is exonerated after new evidence emerges.
    “Wait, what?”
    @ 56m 12s
    March 19, 2020
  • Creative Escape Plans
    The prisoners crafted dummy heads and made life jackets from donated raincoats.
    “They were crafty bitches.”
    @ 01h 14m 21s
    March 19, 2020
  • The Accordion Escape
    The escapees inflated their raft using an accordion, showcasing their ingenuity.
    “Guess how they fucking blew up the life raft, inflated it.”
    @ 01h 17m 42s
    March 19, 2020
  • The Mysterious Letter
    A letter allegedly from one of the escapees claims they survived and lived on.
    “I escaped from Alcatraz in June 1962.”
    @ 01h 26m 15s
    March 19, 2020
  • Emotional Stand-Up
    A comedian reflects on her journey and the impact of her hometown experiences.
    “It's terrifying. It's really hard.”
    @ 01h 35m 22s
    March 19, 2020

Episode Quotes

  • I actually think that they had a podcast festival here last spring.
    214 - Live at the Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco (2018)
  • What a champion.
    214 - Live at the Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco (2018)
  • Are they all boning or something?
    214 - Live at the Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco (2018)
  • Until tonight, he fucking did it.
    214 - Live at the Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco (2018)
  • They earned it.
    214 - Live at the Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco (2018)
  • Whoa, what?
    214 - Live at the Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco (2018)

Key Moments

  • Excitement at Symphony03:15
  • Mysterious Death28:37
  • Suspicious Circumstances42:32
  • Prosecution's Claim45:19
  • Trial Drama48:16
  • Confession Letter51:58
  • Audience Interaction1:32:20
  • Emotional Reflection1:36:13

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown