Search Captions & Ask AI

MFM Minisode 183

July 13, 2020 /

This episode of My Favorite Murder features stories about a man living in a bunker, a flash flood, and a grandfather's dark past. Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark share listener-submitted tales that highlight bizarre and chilling events.

The first story recounts the tale of Jeremiah Button, who lived in a bunker in Wisconsin for three years after being charged with sexual assault. He hid from authorities until a hiker discovered him in 2019.

Another listener shares a flash flood incident involving their grandparents in Colorado, where they had to escape a storm that caused significant destruction and loss of life.

Additionally, a story about a grandfather who accidentally killed his best friend while driving drunk adds a somber note, revealing the long-lasting guilt he carried.

Throughout the episode, Karen and Georgia maintain their signature humor while addressing these serious topics, engaging with their audience and sharing personal anecdotes.

TLDR

This episode features stories of a man in a bunker, a flash flood, and a grandfather's tragic past.

Episode

28:56
00:00:00
This is exactly right. Why is it always chaos when we link up? Cause nobody plans anything bro.
00:00:09
Good thing the Rogue's ready like that. For real. Rain, dirt, whatever. Available all wheel drive.
00:00:15
Five modes. We still outside. And they got some kick too. That turbo? Torque is crazy.
00:00:21
The most in its class. It moves moves. Rogue doesn't mess around. And peep the space.
00:00:26
Merch on merch. Gear. Mikes. All of it fits. Load up, we out. 2026 Nissan Rogue, built for all of it.
00:00:34
Auto Pacific Segmentation, 2026 Rogue versus latest in-market competitors in the ex-SUV
00:00:40
mainstream mid-sides class, excluding electrical vehicles based on manufacturer websites.
00:00:45
Unlock the savings at Boost Mobile and save up to $600 a year. I've been scouting these big carriers for a minute now, and I've seen them pull the
00:00:52
same play a thousand times. They promise you the world, then hit you with a price hike right when the game gets tight.
00:00:58
But Boost Mobile, their $25 a month unlimited wireless plan is the most consistent player on the floor.
00:01:03
No contracts, no price hikes. Unlock the savings today at BoostMobile.com slash unlock.
00:01:09
Based on average annual single line payment of AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile customers,
00:01:11
compared to 12 months on the Boost Mobile unlimited wireless plan as of January 2026.
00:01:14
For full offer details, visit BoostMobile.com. Introducing Taco Bell's new jalapeno citrus salsa.
00:01:19
With bright citrus, real red jalapenos, guajillo chiles. Usually, you add sauce to the food.
00:01:25
But when the sauce is this good, the food is just there to get the sauce to your mouth.
00:01:30
That rolled quesadilla, not a rolled quesadilla anymore. Now it's a sauce shovel.
00:01:35
Taco Bell's jalapeno citrus salsa. Get it with any item on the cantina chicken menu while it's here.
00:01:41
The participating U.S. Taco Bell locations for a limited time only. While supplies last, contact store for availability.
00:01:45
Hello and welcome to My Favorite Murder. The mini-sode. It's so teeny tiny. Look how cute it is.
00:02:11
Oh my god, it's just, it's like it goes right on the top of your pencil. I was trying to make, Georgia, I was trying to make your picture bigger on the Zoom, and instead it looks like I'm trying to start a chat.
00:02:22
I'm still like someone's old aunt. Oh, it's impossible. And now I just need to close it.
00:02:27
Now close it. Press on mute. Press on mute. What was that thing, the Grandmaster Flash thing?
00:02:33
Love Grandmaster Flash. And it was on Facebook when people would tag pictures. Grandma.
00:02:39
Grandma, but they wouldn't see that it actually auto-filled Grandmaster Flash. So many grandmas tagged themselves as grandmasters.
00:02:46
The most amazing thing that's ever happened. Do you know the one guy who like changed his mom's autofilf?
00:02:53
So anytime she wrote, I love you, it said like, I shit you. So love was changed to shit.
00:03:00
And then it kept going, love, shit, shit, shit, over and over. There's nothing better because I'm right on the precipice of being totally in the mom's camp of just like, I don't know how these machines work.
00:03:13
there's a lot of blind faith involved yeah and at this point in our lives I refuse to learn
00:03:17
look if aim was good enough for us kids hey I'll go back to angel fire any fucking day of the week tell me and I'll
00:03:25
go you want to go first yes I do okay but I did make this way too big and now get away
00:03:35
both of you here we go I'm so excited about this a hometown dump story I got one of those
00:03:42
I got a few of them. I've never been more excited about it. Hey, MFM fam. I live in NYC, but have been staying with my parents in Wisconsin since March,
00:03:54
waiting to see if I have a job when my restaurant reopens. I went with my dad to drop off some stuff at the dump when he casually said,
00:04:00
did you hear about the man they found last summer who lived in a bunker behind here for three years?
00:04:06
To which I replied, tell me everything. I just love the idea of someone doing that to their dad.
00:04:13
Tell me everything. Girl, open your mouth. Spill it. In 2014, a man from Stevens Point, Wisconsin, which is very strange because my friend Bradford is from Stevens Point, Wisconsin.
00:04:27
It's not a big town. It's very northern Wisconsin. 2014, a man from Stevens Point, Wisconsin named Jeremiah Button was arrested for sexual assault of a child and child pornography.
00:04:38
Realizing he faced decades in prison, he decided it was time to move. While out on bail, he biked 30 miles north to a rustic wooded area close to Marathon County's landfill.
00:04:49
He dug out a bunker, lining the walls with tarps and cardboard, and brought in food and supplies one backpack load at a time.
00:04:56
In 2016, right before his court date, Button left his car, wallet, and a note saying he was moving to Florida.
00:05:03
For the next three years, Button hid in that hole in the ground, getting all of his necessities from the landfill nearby.
00:05:10
Ew. Can you smell? It would be, I mean. And the food, like what are you eating? Like it's never.
00:05:18
It's all pine cones and peanut butter. You're just like a bird. You're a bird boy scout project is what you are, friend.
00:05:25
You can just eat bird seed off a pine cone for all I care. Okay. He dug a well in a wet area of the woods
00:05:33
And he had a fire pit with a tin can chimney for warmth Button even attached an antenna to a tree
00:05:40
And used a system of eight solar panels And numerous car batteries To power a TV, lights, and fans
00:05:46
Holy shit Yeah, this is insanity Oh wait, we can't leave this out He planted marijuana in the woods
00:05:53
Harvesting up to a pound a year Jesus If he was not a fucking pedophile I would be in awe of this person But I hate him It like If you only had put your energy toward good
00:06:07
You could have been like the greatest camping dude Totally But instead you're just a coward
00:06:12
But all this came to an end when a hiker Came upon the well concealed door of the bunker
00:06:17
And curiously went inside To find Button Could you imagine? Don't open the door in the woods
00:06:23
Don't open a door in the fucking woods. If you see a door and it's been well concealed,
00:06:30
get the fuck away from the door. Don't open. There's a reason. That is not a murdering out right fucking there, I'll tell you what.
00:06:35
And there's not a cute bear in a ballet tutu inside. It's a well concealed door.
00:06:41
It's a well concealed pedophile. Not a fucking dancing bear. That's pretty much one of two choices you have of what's
00:06:49
behind a well concealed door. It's either that or the what's in from The Princess Bride?
00:06:55
The machine of something pain. God damn it. It's like the apocalypse machine. It's been too long.
00:07:07
Anyhow, don't say who cares, Stephen. There's nothing I care more about than the movie The Princess Bride.
00:07:13
Me too. It's the greatest thing of all time. It's the greatest. Those scenes with Peter Falk and Fred Savage
00:07:20
are so perfectly executed family film. A child being actually a very realistic child for the 80s especially.
00:07:31
Touch bratty. Bratty at first, broken down by the grandfather who's seen it all. Seems like a goofball
00:07:38
but actually is telling the greatest story anyone's ever heard. It's one of my favorite movies.
00:07:42
And the turn of when he's like, it's okay, you can tell me the kissing part at the end is the
00:07:47
best thing that's ever happened to America. Grandpa, will you come over and read it to me again tomorrow?
00:07:52
Oh, it's the cutest. Also, I just have to say, I met Fred Savage when I worked in episodic sitcom television.
00:07:59
He's everything you want him to be and more. Thank God. He's exactly the same looking and sounding.
00:08:04
The first time I heard his voice, I got weird, like, chills. Dude, wonder he grew up with you.
00:08:09
Yeah, right. And he's super nice. It's like he knows the responsibility on his shoulders of being Fred Savage, and he's delivering just hand over fist.
00:08:19
Love it, and has great taste in comedy. He's like so talented. Very talented. And now very, very hilarious, of course.
00:08:28
And like doing it. Been great since he was eight years old. But then also now can direct like three camera television, which is very difficult.
00:08:36
This took a weird turn. Okay. Guys, we're still in the middle of this. Can you please shut up so I can read the rest of it?
00:08:41
We're still in the first story, guys. Stop it. It's just the door in the forest.
00:08:49
is just beyond. I had to talk my way out of the panic of that. Okay. So this hiker went inside, curiously,
00:09:00
and found Button sleeping on a cot. So the hiker called 911, and after a standoff with police,
00:09:06
Button finally came out and stated, I'm a wanted man, and remarked that it was, quote,
00:09:10
nice to talk to human beings. Last October, Button received 30 years in prison for his crimes,
00:09:16
but the judge gave him a bonus to 230 days already served for his life on the lamb.
00:09:22
Thank you ladies for keeping me sane through this pandemic. My mom is now a big fan.
00:09:26
Hi, despite all the swearing. Sorry, mom. Sorry. In front of me, this says, Oh, well,
00:09:33
she says the same thing to me. I look forward to the day that I can bring her to a live show.
00:09:40
Oh, so do we stay sexy. And for the love of God, stay out of the forest. Marie. Absolutely.
00:09:46
Okay, all three of mine this week are grandparent stories, which we always love.
00:09:53
Dear Karen, Georgia, and Co., this isn't a murder story, but does fall under some of your categories of interest, namely badass grandparents, survival stories, and flash floods.
00:10:03
Great. All our favorites. Did you know flash floods are our interest? They are now.
00:10:10
They are now. No, it's true. It's just one more thing to put on the dating profile.
00:10:16
In the summer of 1976, my grandparents, who, by the way, Karen, she gave us their names and they live up to the hype.
00:10:25
Irvin and Nancy. Irvin. Yes. Not enough Irvins anymore. Wait, is this story about Magic Johnson?
00:10:33
All right. They had driven up to Estes Park, a small mountain town in Colorado, to go to their regular square dancing group.
00:10:41
Of course. I know. The way my grandpa used to tell it, on the way home, a huge thunderstorm developed over the mountains and the night was, quote, blacker than the inside of a cow.
00:10:54
Irvin, you old bullshit, are you? It was the kind of Western state summer thunderstorms that are so intense that windshield wipers can't move fast enough to see clearly out of the windshield.
00:11:07
Eventually, they had to pull over. They stayed in the car until a man started banging on their window and yelling at them to get out of their car and head for higher ground.
00:11:15
Oh, shit. My grandparents ended up having to climb the steep canyon walls in their square dancing outfits in the pitch dark and pouring rain.
00:11:23
I can fucking picture it now. Shit. Yeah. Swinger partner up the hill. And do-si-do.
00:11:31
And do-si-do. As they climbed, a huge wall of water came down the canyon and swept away cars, houses, and parts of the road.
00:11:40
Eventually, they had found a group of other people who had climbed up the canyon and took shelter in a van.
00:11:45
They spent the night that way, stranded and waiting for the morning to be rescued.
00:11:50
Down on the plains, my 19-year-old mom and her older brother had no idea what happened,
00:11:54
except that their parents were supposed to be driving back through the flash canyon and they hadn arrived home They waited out most of the night with their own grandmother until finally getting a call late the next morning that their parents had been rescued by a helicopter and taken to one of the local high schools
00:12:09
The Big Thompson flood was one of the worst natural disasters in Colorado history.
00:12:14
The storm that caused it dumped 12 inches of rain over the canyon in four hours.
00:12:20
That's a foot. Huh? That's a foot. you're fucking right 12 inches that's not right 12 inches as a foot did she mean 12 feet
00:12:33
she had to me i don't know that's almost that's almost the yearly total of rain i don't think
00:12:38
they could i don't think it could rain 12 feet in four hours i don't think but 12 inches of rain is
00:12:43
like up to your ink you're like calf well i bet it's enough we're from california you guys we
00:12:50
We don't. Rain is cute here. Listen, you can do a flood. I think of 12 inches of rain is plenty to do a flood.
00:12:58
Well, a flood doctor, please email us and tell us what is a lot of rain. Yeah, that seems like a ton.
00:13:05
Great. But they do say that that's almost a yearly total of rain for the area that they got it all in one night.
00:13:12
Oh, shit. So they weren't able to handle it. No. On top of that, in the steep canyon, all of the water that fell on the hillsides collected in the Big Thompson River, which is why the flood was so swift and devastating.
00:13:24
143 people died and many homes were destroyed. Some of the cars were washed down the river with were only identifiable by their VIN number.
00:13:33
The sediment in the water had completely stripped off the paint. Wow. My grandparents' car was never found.
00:13:40
In 2006, three years before she died, my grandma got to meet the man who saved their lives, the guy who banged on the window.
00:13:47
Really? Butch Hutchins. Of course, that's his name. He said he had stayed away from the flood memorials because he was afraid to learn that he could have done more.
00:13:57
But it's because of him that I got to meet both my grandparents. SSDGM, Maya. Wow.
00:14:04
Butch Hutchins. Was that the name? Butch Hutchins? Butch Hutchins and Nancy and Irvin.
00:14:08
our best friends. See, you know what? It's true. We don't take like because flooding doesn't
00:14:15
affect us that much. It is hard to imagine. But like the idea that cars were like unrecognizable
00:14:21
and like that's I mean, that's don't make me say that's the power of water. You don't need you don't need 12
00:14:28
feet. So you're the water doctor. That's what you're saying. It's me. Ask me. AMA water.
00:14:37
My Do you know my first boyfriend died in a flash flood? No. Yeah. That's real sad.
00:14:42
That's horrible. I know. Well, he was, we were, we weren't together. I was, you know, I was like young at the time when we dated, but then we got older as you
00:14:50
do. And he went off to go to college and he and his best friend just got caught up in a flash
00:14:55
flood, swept under a fucking semi. Oh my God. And he died. He was such a wonderful person.
00:15:01
It's really tragic. That's horrible. Mike Lewis, we met at Jewish camp. oh no oh it's so sad
00:15:09
when people die young I know okay okay ready for more bad stuff always cool this is
00:15:17
New Jersey's Bermuda Triangle underwater ghost town yep there we go hey you did you did Lady of the Lake
00:15:24
at a live show right I believe so is that the is that in one of the Carolinas yeah
00:15:31
maybe oh maybe Elena I did like LaLanne, but that's not Lady of the Lakes. Right. Okay. It is a haunted lake, though.
00:15:39
I got sent that, but I thought you did it. I think I did, but I can check for you.
00:15:44
Okay, it says, this title is intriguing enough. After hearing about a fellow murderino's
00:15:50
underwater ghost town in Minnesota 181, I immediately thought of a similar underwater ghost town
00:15:56
near my hometown that is also referred to as New Jersey's Bermuda Triangle. Round Valley Reservoir was built in the
00:16:02
1960s in the small town of Lebanon New Jersey, the state built two dams and flooded the small farming community that once existed at
00:16:10
the bottom of the Cushetunk Valley. This included an old schoolhouse and several homes. As water
00:16:16
poured in, the remains of the town sank more than 150 feet to the bottom of the reservoir
00:16:20
to be forever lost, or so many thoughts. In the 70s, the reservoir and surrounding area became
00:16:27
a peaceful place for boating, fishing, swimming, hiking, and scuba diving. There are videos from
00:16:33
divers that have gone to the bottom of the reservoir and filmed the old building foundations
00:16:37
that still exist below the surface. As many have enjoyed the waters, boaters began to go missing.
00:16:43
Over the past 50 years, more than two dozen people, that's 24 people, have gone missing and
00:16:49
have died while boating and fishing in the reservoir. Oh my god. That's a lot. I know.
00:16:56
I believe the first disappearance was in the early 70s when two men and their boat went missing.
00:17:01
All of them. Everything goes down together. Their bodies were never found again, but their boat hit the shore a few days after.
00:17:09
Four years later, two friends that went fishing were reported missing by their families.
00:17:13
They were last seen sailing on the northern shore of the park when their empty canoe came to shore a few days after they were reported missing.
00:17:22
The oddest story from the reservoir happened in the late 1980s. Two friends vanished on a fishing trip on March 18th, 1989.
00:17:30
After submarine searches of the water, neither of the men were found. Flash forward to 1993, so like four years later,
00:17:39
and the body of one of the men was found preserved, still fully dressed with boots on when a fisherman caught the body with his hook.
00:17:47
Although it's believed that most of the deaths were from drowning, locals suspected a wind vortex or bad energy from the former farm town
00:17:54
are responsible for the strange deaths pulling boats under the water There are still bodies and boats that have yet to be found Mystery of the reservoir still remains when a human foot without an owner was found in 2012
00:18:09
The FBI and the New Jersey State Police have scraped the bottom of the reservoir
00:18:12
looking for human remains of the many who have perished there with no results. Growing up, my friends and I would go to this park all the time
00:18:19
and often to do the nefarious activities that high schoolers do. Fun! Meaning to have fun.
00:18:29
Just like hanging upside down like bats in trees and stuff. Boating, hiking, and camping around the reservoir myself,
00:18:36
I was constantly on the lookout for ghost canoes or body parts. Sadly, nothing that crazy has ever happened to me there.
00:18:42
My sister lived down the hill from the reservoir for a few years and said it became quite annoying when she would hear helicopters
00:18:48
hovering over the park constantly. You would think they wouldn't allow boating anymore.
00:18:53
Thank you for being two voices that I listen to. I'm in the midst of anxiety attacks
00:18:57
and I need to calm myself down or hey, or accompanying me on a long drive. Despite a pandemic,
00:19:03
my partner and I are moving from NYC to Los Angeles and I will need you to go across the country.
00:19:10
Stay out of the forest, but also stay out of the water. Bree. That's crazy to me
00:19:15
because I feel like people who fish regularly and people who boat are pretty like experienced you know what i mean like they're
00:19:22
not just gonna like tip out of their boat like probably you and i would do they're like they
00:19:27
know the rules and they know what to do and what not to do and the you know the aka the rules and
00:19:33
so that's just creepier you know what i mean it's yes and it's also when you think of like if two
00:19:40
um fishermen go out uh in the really early morning something could happen and it's like
00:19:46
Just say it's a rogue wave on a lake, which I don't even know if that's possible.
00:19:50
Rogue wave on a lake. Boom. They're in the water. It's over. And no one saw it or heard it.
00:19:55
Like that idea. And I won't even get into the reality of the Loch Ness Monster absolutely coming up and
00:20:01
knocking you out of your house. Totally. I mean, that's what I thought. Lake experts.
00:20:07
Lake doctors. Is a rogue wave possible? Lake exports. Experts. Exports. Jesus, I can't speak today.
00:20:16
All right. This is another grandpa story. And it starts, hey, sexy ladies, mustache and pets.
00:20:26
Kind of reductive, but I like it. I like it. I recently got hooked on your podcast after my baby sister bought me an MFM logo pin, the proceeds of which go to Beam.
00:20:36
My story has to do with the day I found out that my grandfather killed a man. Grandpa was born in 1929 in a tiny town in Kentucky and dropped out of school in seventh grade because back then it was a totally legit thing to do.
00:20:49
From what I know of my grandpa, he was a hands on learner who could do just about any job you threw at him.
00:20:55
This man taught himself how to repair lawnmowers. Who even does that these days?
00:21:00
Amen. Yeah. He worked hard his whole life and had some amazing stories about being a ranch hand for a bit.
00:21:06
And I will never tire of repeating his quote. you could get yourself a quarter and buy a Coke and a bag of peanuts and see a movie stories.
00:21:15
Simpler times. Anyway, in 2009, my grandpa had a sudden decline in health and needed hospice care.
00:21:21
Our family had been at his house for the past several days, keeping my grandmother company
00:21:25
as my grandpa passed and when my dad suggested we'd go to lunch. While at lunch, my dad somewhat
00:21:30
casually mentioned that my grandpa had accidentally killed his best friend when they were young
00:21:34
adults. Apparently my grandpa and his friend would run moonshine because of, because of
00:21:40
fucking course they did. It was Kentucky. And on one such run, my grandpa was driving
00:21:45
after drinking some of their product. He crashed the truck and ended up killing his friend
00:21:50
in the accident. Oh no. I know. My dad told me that grandpa never drank again and was
00:21:55
of course heartbroken over his friend's death. Hours after my dad told me this tale, my grandpa
00:22:00
ended his time on this earth. It was a totally wild experience for me to hear that my sweet grandpa had lived with this
00:22:06
guilt and pain for 60 plus years. I was a sophomore in college when he passed in this family story directly influenced my
00:22:13
strong stance on drinking responsibly. Stay sexy and for the love of God, don't drink and drive.
00:22:19
S. Oh, wow. I know. So I thought of carrying that with you your whole life. Horrible.
00:22:25
Sad thing. Because of what? I mean, we used to talk about that all the time. And then I made so many incredibly irresponsible decisions in the 90s.
00:22:33
And I could have very easily killed someone with my car. Very easily. Totally. So many times.
00:22:40
Or even just gotten a DUI. You ruined your own life. Yeah. I was trying my hardest.
00:22:47
You're not special. You're not going to get away with something like that if you chance it.
00:22:52
It's crazy. And sometimes if you do get away with it, you live with that horrible feeling of like,
00:22:57
Jesus Christ, it's so irresponsible. All right. I'm sorry I said that you're not special, everyone.
00:23:04
You're all special to me. It hurt me deeply. Bro, from the show last night to this drive, why is it never chill?
00:23:12
Because this is our life. Backstage, on the road, it's loud, messy, real. And that's the best part.
00:23:19
Whole crew, no plan, just moving. Good thing Nissan builds for that kind of chaos.
00:23:24
Not just test tracks, real life scenes. Late nights, road trips, all of it. That's why it holds up.
00:23:30
Nissan was ranked number one in initial quality among mainstream brands by J.D. Power.
00:23:35
Yeah, you can tell. 2026 Nissan Rogue built for what really happens. For J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Initial Quality Study Award information, visit jdpower.com slash awards.
00:23:47
Awards based on 2025 model year, newer models may be shown. NYX, that's K-N-I-X leak-proof underwear, isn't just for one moment.
00:23:55
It's for all the everyday moments you didn't realize leak-proof underwear could make
00:24:00
Maybe it's day one of your period. Maybe it's a long travel day. Maybe it's hot outside. You're on the move and you just want to feel fresh.
00:24:09
Their leak-proof underwear comes in a range of absorbencies, from light to ultra, and helps protect against periods, light leaks, sweat, and everyday surprises.
00:24:19
And because they look and feel like real underwear, they're soft, invisible underclothes, and machine washable.
00:24:26
No extra hassle. No complicated routine. Just dependable protection you can wash and re-wear.
00:24:33
See why millions have made the switch to leak-proof underwear. Visit Nix.com. That's K-N-I-X dot com and use code FLOW15 for 15% off.
00:24:44
That's K-N-I-X dot com. Code FLOW15. Hey everyone, it's Cal Penn, host of Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club.
00:24:54
This week on the podcast, I'm sitting down with Lily Chu, the author of the Audible original romantic comedy Just Kiss Already.
00:25:03
It's a story about a forensic anthropologist who secretly writes mystery novels, an actress who adapts his book into a film, and what happens when a meme and a media tour collide with a slow burn romance.
00:25:16
It's performed by Simu Liu and Philippa Su, and it is an absolute blast. When you actually hear the performance, you realize that other people are taking your words and what you thought was kind of a straightforward sentence like the cat in the corner is black.
00:25:33
In my head, it's the cat in the corner is black, not the dog, not the gerbil. But someone else might say it. The cat in the corner is black.
00:25:41
That's always fascinating to me. How they just bring in all these different nuances and really make it fun and interesting and distinctive.
00:25:49
Listen to Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:26:03
Okay, well, this is a Grandpa one, too. And we're going back to Wisconsin. Okay, ready?
00:26:07
Hello, all, human and animal. This isn't so much a hometown murder, but a connection to a serial killer.
00:26:13
First, a little background. I grew up in a small town in rural southwest Wisconsin.
00:26:18
and my grandpa is a funeral director. Growing up in a funeral home is probably what made me the murderino I am today.
00:26:24
I swear it's not really as weird as it sounds. One day when I was at home for a visit,
00:26:28
my mom and I started talking about true crime, as one does. I asked her if grandpa had ever dealt with any murders in our town.
00:26:35
She paused for a moment and then proceeded to tell me the best story I've heard about my grandpa.
00:26:39
When my grandpa was in mortuary school, he and his classmate were called out to a crime scene to help with some bodies.
00:26:45
That crime scene was none other than Ed Gein house What Holy shit Right My grandpa was there when they arrested ed gein what he says he remembers most of the house was that the normalness of the scene there was a pot boiling
00:27:02
on the stove like he was getting ready for lunch super creepy no that's not the creepiest
00:27:08
wasn't he boiling a head or something i mean that's i don't know he could have all they could
00:27:14
have been like top ramen in one pot and then his mother's skull in another. I can't remember.
00:27:19
Now, because my grandpa was in mortuary school, he was there to deal with any dead bodies.
00:27:25
He and his classmate had to collect and bag all the body parts that were found in Ed Gein's home,
00:27:31
including the skin lamp and the nipple belt. To make it worse, they found the body of his last
00:27:37
victim. Yeah, that's the one I was thinking of, which is the woman that was in that out in the
00:27:41
garage. To make it worse, they found the body of his last victim, Bernice Warden, but had not found
00:27:46
her head. Again, my grandpa had to help search the whole house for her head. Eventually, they found
00:27:52
it wrapped up in a sailor, a wool sailor coat in a trunk. My grandpa still has a scrapbook of all
00:27:58
the news clippings of Ed Gein's case and arrest. If you ask him, he'll tell you about it. Holy
00:28:03
shit. My grandpa, my grandpa is such a sweet, quiet, kind man. Hearing this story about him
00:28:08
just makes me love him all that much more. Anyway, I love you and your podcast. It helps me through times of depression
00:28:13
and makes me feel like I wasn't a weirdo for liking crime. Thanks for all you do.
00:28:19
A bonus story. There was once a farmer that came into the funeral home having died of a supposed heart attack.
00:28:24
When they were preparing the body, my grandpa found that there was actually a bullet in the man's heart.
00:28:30
The police investigated and discovered the hired man that worked on the farm had actually shot the farmer.
00:28:36
I can't remember the motivation, But he would have gotten away with it if it wasn't for my dad.
00:28:40
That was from EJ. Thank you. Wow. Unbelievable. Horrible. I mean, like, I don't care what business you decided you wanted to go into.
00:28:51
Nobody was like, and this is where I'd like to end up. Totally. Ed Gein's house.
00:28:56
Ed Gein's mental meltdown home. Yeah, there's nothing that prepares you no matter how much, like, how comfortable you are working with dead bodies.
00:29:04
There's nothing that's going to like mentally prepare you for that. Probably. Hopefully.
00:29:08
Because you you're supposed to work with dead bodies. Some guy on a farm is not supposed to have a house full of dead bodies.
00:29:15
That's look, I'm going to go out on a limb and say it. It was wrong. I think that was from Buddha who said that it was wrong.
00:29:22
It was wrong. What Ed Gein did slash Buddha. Strong stance by Karen Kilgareth. Dash Osho.
00:29:30
That's the old quote. OK, here's another dumpster. Interest quote. What? I said that's my Pinterest quote.
00:29:36
Oh, got it. OK. This one a grandparent story and a dumpster treasure story This is full circle Hello friendos Thank you We sound like a cereal I love it
00:29:52
I just listened to Minnesota 182, where y'all asked for dumpster treasure stories,
00:29:56
and I had to write in. My grandfather was the most influential person in my life
00:30:00
and was such a steadfast source of advice and support during my challenging high school and college years.
00:30:06
When he died two years ago, after a two-year battle with ALS, I asked my grandmother if I could take his favorite blue cardigan, and she said yes, and then asked if I knew the story behind it.
00:30:16
When her grandfather, my great-grandfather, was dropping off their garbage at the local dump in Wakefield, Michigan, he came across a box filled to the brim with old clothes.
00:30:26
He dug through it and found the blue cardigan. After trying it on, he decided to keep it.
00:30:31
My great-grandmother was appalled that he would take home a, quote, dumpster sweater and insisted that he get rid of it.
00:30:38
However, my incredibly strong-willed Finnish great-grandfather decided to keep it and only wear it when he went to work.
00:30:45
A couple years later, my great-grandmother found the cardigan sitting in his work case, and she tried to get rid of it again, but he found out and told her that he would give it away instead.
00:30:55
And I could fucking picture this grandfather cardigan, blue cardigan, can't you?
00:30:59
Yep. Oh, yeah. We probably have had it in our closets at some point in our lives.
00:31:03
Like the oyster shell button. Uh-huh. Four of them. Maybe there's like a little bottom V crocodile or on the lapel.
00:31:12
My grandmother had just met my grandfather a few months prior and they had just started dating.
00:31:17
My great grandfather loved my grandfather and decided to give him the cardigan. My grandfather came from a very, very poor family and decided to take it because most of his clothes were filled with holes and old.
00:31:31
Fast forward 60 years and that same blue cardigan is now sitting in my closet. I love that he gave it to somewhere like that.
00:31:37
The great grandmother would have to see regularly. It's pretty great. Also, it's like a gift until you go like, I got that at the dump.
00:31:47
Here, take this gift. You thought it was a wonderful gift. It's crazy to think that my favorite blue cardigan was discovered in the early 1950s at a dump in Wakefield, Michigan.
00:31:57
But I'm so glad I have it now. It makes me feel so much more connected to my grandfather and even my great grandfather who passed away a few weeks before I was born.
00:32:05
Thank you guys for all you do. I am going on to school to get my master's in nursing, and I wouldn't be where I am today without you both normalizing getting help for my crippling anxiety and depression.
00:32:15
Yay. Oh, nice. Y'all rock. Stay sexy and socially distance, y'all. Kindly live. Amazing story.
00:32:24
Yay. Oh, I love it. I miss thrifting so much. It's very sad. I miss thrifting in the late 80s 90s when there was actually true treasure to discover Before eBay Yeah I mean you had to do it yourself yeah and all they like all the old stuff was there yeah and you could really find treasure
00:32:46
treasure treasure true look sometimes it smelled sometimes you brought moths home to your
00:32:53
look sometimes you were genuinely poor and just needed a shirt 50 cents for a shirt sometimes
00:32:59
You weren't being cute No You needed it But you also looked cute While you did it
00:33:04
But you looked cute Because you were young You could make cute choices Because you were young
00:33:08
And you have no idea Send us any story Complimentary At this point Yeah You know what's good
00:33:14
Yeah You know what's compelling Right Myfavoritemurder at Gmail Or you can go on our website
00:33:19
Myfavoritemurder.com There's a place to send in your hometowns Or there's like a forum
00:33:23
On the fan cult too Where everyone just shares Each other's stories It's cool Stay sexy
00:33:28
And don't get murdered. Goodbye. Elvis, do you want a cookie? Why is it always chaos when we link up?
00:33:36
Because nobody plans anything, bro. Good thing the Rogue's ready like that. For real.
00:33:41
Rain, dirt, whatever. Available all-wheel drive. Five modes. We still outside. And they got some kick, too.
00:33:47
That turbo? Torque is crazy. The most in its class. It moves, moves. Rogue doesn't mess around.
00:33:54
And peep the space. Merch on merch. Gear. Mikes. All of it fits. Load up, we out.
00:34:00
2026 Nissan Rogue, built for all of it. Auto Pacific Segmentation, 2026 Rogue versus latest in-market competitors in the ex-SUV
00:34:09
mainstream mid-sites class, excluding electrical vehicles based on manufacturer websites.
00:34:14
Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales.
00:34:22
And somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odoo comes in. An all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together.
00:34:32
From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all-in-one powerful platform.
00:34:38
No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs. And best of all, no spreadsheets.
00:34:43
Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system.
00:34:48
Try for free today at odoo.com slash iHeartRadio. That's odoo.com slash iHeartRadio.
00:34:56
Here's the truth. You could literally be adored by everyone and then come home and still get completely ignored by your own cat.
00:35:03
It's classic cat behavior. But new Shiba Premium Puree is a lickable treat that changes all that.
00:35:09
They're protein-rich, made with bone broth, and have the smooth, creamy texture cats go crazy for,
00:35:14
especially when it's hand-fed. Yeah, it's more than a treat. It's a fast pass to favorite human status.
00:35:20
So feed your cat Sheba and go from totally ignored to truly adored in just 12 days, guaranteed, or your money back.
00:35:28
Learn more at Sheba.com.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Most heartbreaking
  • 75
    Most chaotic
  • 75
    Biggest twist

Episode Highlights

  • 2026 Nissan Rogue: Built for All of It
    The 2026 Nissan Rogue offers five modes and all-wheel drive, ready for any adventure.
    “Rogue doesn't mess around.”
    @ 00m 23s
    July 13, 2020
  • The Bunker Man
    Jeremiah Button lived in a bunker for three years after committing serious crimes.
    “He dug out a bunker, lining the walls with tarps and cardboard.”
    @ 04m 49s
    July 13, 2020
  • The Big Thompson Flood
    A devastating flood in Colorado claimed 143 lives, affecting many families.
    “The Big Thompson flood was one of the worst natural disasters in Colorado history.”
    @ 12m 09s
    July 13, 2020
  • New Jersey's Underwater Ghost Town
    Round Valley Reservoir is home to an underwater ghost town with numerous mysterious disappearances.
    “Over the past 50 years, more than two dozen people have gone missing.”
    @ 16m 43s
    July 13, 2020
  • Grandpa's Dark Secret
    A listener shares a shocking story about their grandfather who killed a man.
    “My grandfather killed a man.”
    @ 20m 40s
    July 13, 2020
  • Grandpa's Dark Secret
    A shocking family story reveals the guilt my grandpa carried for decades after a tragic accident.
    “My grandpa had accidentally killed his best friend when they were young adults.”
    @ 21m 30s
    July 13, 2020
  • A Cardigan's Journey
    A treasured blue cardigan connects generations, found in a dumpster and passed down with love.
    “It's crazy to think that my favorite blue cardigan was discovered in the early 1950s at a dump.”
    @ 31m 50s
    July 13, 2020

Episode Quotes

  • Why is it always chaos when we link up?
    MFM Minisode 183
  • You could have been like the greatest camping dude.
    MFM Minisode 183
  • I'm a wanted man, and it's nice to talk to human beings.
    MFM Minisode 183
  • Stay sexy and for the love of God, don't drink and drive.
    MFM Minisode 183

Key Moments

  • Turbo Power00:19
  • Bunker Life04:49
  • Flood Disaster12:09
  • Ghost Town Mystery16:43
  • Grandpa's Secret20:40
  • Grandpa's Guilt22:06
  • Ed Gein Connection26:10
  • Cardigan Discovery30:26

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown