This episode of My Favorite Murder covers the cold case of Ada Haradine, the Susan Smith murders, and several personal stories from listeners. The hosts, Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, discuss the mysterious disappearance of Ada Haradine from Elkhart, Indiana, in 1985, and the tragic discovery of her remains three years later. They also recount the chilling case of Susan Smith, who murdered her two children in 1994, and the haunting history of John D. Long Lake.
Listeners share their own stories, including a tale of a father who found gold coins in a box of books from a dump, and a woman who had a terrifying date with a man later revealed to be a murderer. The episode highlights the emotional impact of these stories and the ongoing mysteries surrounding them.
In addition to the main stories, the hosts engage with their audience by reading listener-submitted tales, emphasizing the connection between true crime and personal experiences. The episode concludes with a reminder for listeners to stay safe and to share their own stories.
This episode features cold cases, listener stories, and chilling true crime tales.
This episode stands out for the following:
Those 10 minutes will forever be a mystery about what truly happened to Ada.MFM Minisode 186
Imagine hearing this story as a child.MFM Minisode 186
It's a full on jackpot.MFM Minisode 186
I seriously think she might have donated the damn coins to Goodwill.MFM Minisode 186
Oh my God. Yeah. This still gives me chills.MFM Minisode 186
I can never keep her out of trouble.MFM Minisode 186