This episode of My Favorite Murder features stories about a serial killer, a nun encounter, and a personal connection to Stull Cemetery. Hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark read listener-submitted tales that highlight dark humor and unexpected twists.
One listener, Matt Goad, recounts a chilling childhood memory involving a man named James Lofton, who went on a killing spree after being baptized by his father. Lofton was later captured and sentenced to life in prison.
Another story discusses a listener's experience with a mysterious nun who appeared at their father's warehouse job, asking for help. The encounter left them questioning whether the nun was real or part of a robbery scheme.
Additionally, a listener named Lexi shares a humorous yet touching story about her best friend, Haley, who pranked her with heavy breathing phone calls for years. Now, Haley is battling leukemia, and their friendship remains strong.
Throughout the episode, the hosts engage in lively banter, touching on themes of friendship, fear, and the bizarre nature of some real-life events.
Listeners share chilling and humorous stories about a serial killer, a mysterious nun, and a prank gone wrong.
This episode stands out for the following:
Goodbye.MFM Minisode 191
He promised to heal them. Instead, he left a trail of broken bodies.MFM Minisode 191
The best parts of summer aren't just places, they're feelings.MFM Minisode 191
What if there's a person downloading from the mainframe today for the first time?MFM Minisode 191
Why did he go on a killing spree?MFM Minisode 191
Even in the darkest times, it's super fucking important to remember the good times.MFM Minisode 191