This episode of My Favorite Murder features stories about hometown crimes, survival, and personal anecdotes. Guests Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark read listener-submitted emails detailing true crime tales.
The first story discusses the murder of Jesse Keith in 1894, a case that shocked the small town of Listowel, Ontario. The gruesome details of her death led to the belief that Jack the Ripper was in Canada. The accused, Almeid Chattel, was later hanged for the crime.
Another email recounts the survival story of Susan Shuneman, who was kidnapped and assaulted in Savannah, Georgia in 1985. Despite the trauma, she became a director at the Piedmont Rape Crisis Center, advocating for survivors.
Listeners also share humorous anecdotes, including a tale of a kitchen fire caused by a distracted father and a drug smuggler posing as a granite installer. The episode highlights the blend of humor and horror in true crime storytelling.
Finally, the episode touches on a tragic plane crash in Monroe County, Michigan, where all 29 passengers died. The impact of the crash still resonates in the community, with memorials honoring the victims.
Listeners share chilling hometown crime stories and survival tales, blending humor and horror in true crime storytelling.
This episode stands out for the following:
He promised to heal them. Instead, he left a trail of broken bodies.MFM Minisode 215
Stay sexy and pitter patter.MFM Minisode 215
Oh, my God.MFM Minisode 215
I like to think of her as undercover in the movie Blow.MFM Minisode 215
My mom then, quote, ran faster than she has ever ran in her life.MFM Minisode 215
I feel like that winery was like another baby.MFM Minisode 215