Search Captions & Ask AI

483 - Those Pants, That Hand

June 05, 2025 /

This episode of My Favorite Murder covers the story of Reverend Willie Maxwell, a preacher linked to a series of suspicious deaths in Alexander City, Alabama. Hosts Georgia Hartstark and Karen Kilgariff discuss the case, including the mysterious deaths of Maxwell's family members and his eventual murder at a funeral. The episode also touches on Harper Lee's interest in the case and her attempts to write about it.

Georgia and Karen begin by introducing the episode and sharing their thoughts on the film Pride and Prejudice. They discuss their favorite scenes and characters, particularly the dynamics between Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy. They express their enjoyment of the film and recommend watching different adaptations.

The main story revolves around Reverend Willie Maxwell, whose wife Mary Lou was found dead under suspicious circumstances. The hosts detail the investigation, including Maxwell's attempts to cash in on life insurance policies taken out on his wife just before her death. They highlight the community's growing suspicion of Maxwell as more deaths occur in his family.

As the narrative unfolds, the hosts recount how Maxwell continued to evade justice despite mounting evidence against him. They discuss the eventual murder of Maxwell by Robert Burns, a relative of one of his victims, during Maxwell's funeral, which shocked the community.

The episode concludes with reflections on Harper Lee's interest in the case and her efforts to document it, ultimately leaving listeners with lingering questions about her unpublished work.

TLDR

Reverend Willie Maxwell's suspicious family deaths lead to his murder at a funeral, with Harper Lee's unwritten account of the case discussed.

Episode

46:23
00:00:00
This is exactly right. Isn't some far off concept? It's already here. Next starts now.
00:00:33
Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Goodbye. Pandora jewelry brings the sparkle to summer, now with even better prices.
00:00:41
Shop now for up to 50% off select jewelry featuring personalized pieces to must have summer favorites.
00:00:46
Timeless jewelry made to move with you through every moment. Shop in store or online now through July 5th.
00:00:52
Terms and conditions apply. See Pandora.net for more details. Goodbye. Goodbye. If audiobooks are your thing, or if you've been meaning to listen to more of them,
00:01:00
you should check out a podcast called Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club, hosted by Cal Penn.
00:01:07
Each episode spotlights standout audiobooks on Audible across all kinds of genres.
00:01:11
Sci-fi, comedy, romance, thrillers, and more. With Cal talking to guests who help break down what makes each story worth listening to.
00:01:18
It's a fun, easy way to discover your next great audiobook. Check out Earsay on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:26
Goodbye. Hello and welcome to My Favorite Murder. That's Georgia Hartstark. That's Karen Kilgariff.
00:01:49
And we're here to podcast for you once again. We're going to do it every week if we can, if the mood strikes us.
00:01:55
If we have the sweaters with the colors that are needed to combine and be together.
00:02:00
Magenta and lime green. What would you call this? Lime green? Yeah. Right? Yeah.
00:02:05
With a little forest? Yeah. It's loud. It's very loud. Well, it looks like a nice 60s polyester blouse.
00:02:13
Okay. No? No. It's fucking fast fashion. Is it? No. I mean, no. Fast fashion with a retro bent?
00:02:21
Yeah. Yeah. Speaking of retro and bent, I finally did it. I watched Pride and Prejudice.
00:02:28
Oh, wow. How'd it go? It went great. Vince was at a wrestling show. I was alone on like a Saturday night with my wine.
00:02:36
What do I do? I had caught up with the Valley. And so I was like, oh, holy shit. I'm going to do this.
00:02:43
I, there was not a moment I was bored. Right. Not a fucking moment. Right. Yes. Which is like, that's all I ask for in a movie.
00:02:49
Yep. You know? Yes. I wanted more. I fucking loved it. So good. It was really fucking good.
00:02:55
Right? Yeah. It just really gets undersold as like a chick flick or like a Jane Austen award. It's like,
00:03:04
it's such a gorgeous unfurling of a film in front of you. I know Vince would have loved it if you were home. I didn't need to watch it without him at all.
00:03:12
So good. In fact, it probably would have been better with him. I don't know. What was your favorite part?
00:03:18
The first dance, dance party. When he slams her and then she slams him back. When they first go in.
00:03:24
Yeah. And it's like, and then it's also like, I know that actress. I know that actress.
00:03:28
I think every actress that's famous today. Yes. You know them. Yeah. The mom could have done without her.
00:03:34
Brenda Blethlin. Well, that was the idea. I know. I know. That's like the point.
00:03:37
Worst mom ever. Yeah. Yes. It was. Oh, and then like I got choked up. Actually got me like, you know, I don't cry.
00:03:43
But when she fucking told him off when they were on the cliff or whatever. Yeah.
00:03:48
I got like emotional. When she was like, and your dad, that was I was supposed to take it as a compliment.
00:03:54
You hate my family and think I'm shit. I can't believe I love you. Well, fuck you.
00:03:58
You know, it was very, it was good. That's Elizabeth Bennett. She does that in every circumstance.
00:04:03
My favorite is also the first dance when she, because I'm always like, how does one meet that type of rejection, which everybody fears it?
00:04:13
Yeah. How would you do that with a smile on your face and be like, even if their partner was a little plain or whatever the line is, and then walk away where it's just like you.
00:04:24
Devastating. Especially if it was Matthew McFadden. You'd just be like, how come I'm not doing that?
00:04:29
Devastating. Devastating. She's kind of like. Whatever. Yeah. She has so many good lines.
00:04:34
Wait, here's my other best favorite part. Okay. Because also, you should watch Vera, the British detective show, because the mother plays a detective.
00:04:43
Okay. And I also need to watch the other versions of Pride and Prejudice. Because everyone had a fucking opinion.
00:04:49
Yep. I'm not mad at them about this, I guess, for once in my life. Oh, okay. Got it.
00:04:52
So I want to watch the other versions and find out. For sure. This series is great because it's a binge that then lasts.
00:04:59
It's not just an hour and a half. It's like however many episodes. I can't remember.
00:05:02
And that's the great one with Colin Firth. Sure. He plays a different kind of Mr. Darcy, though.
00:05:06
I don't know if I'd be attracted to Colin Firth. Yeah, that's my feeling. Right.
00:05:11
But Matthew McFadden's coming across that field at you. I didn't think I'd be attracted to him ever.
00:05:15
And then. Oh, yeah. Those pants. Fucking. Those pants. That hand. Yeah. But how about Dame Judi Dench's star turn?
00:05:25
Yeah. I mean, when she comes to that house to be like, you tell me if you are marrying my nephew.
00:05:31
It can't be born. It can't be born. And she's just like, I've got this. It's a perfect movie.
00:05:36
Yeah, it's good. I enjoyed it. I'm so glad. So we're here. So here we are. Well stop acting mad because I so glad I so excited Also it one of those ones where like it a go back to because there things you missed Oh also we not even mentioning what perfectly prepared potatoes That part where the priest cousin comes Yes the weird cousin was so good And do you remember do you know he was from season two White Lotus the bad gay that Jennifer Coolidge
00:06:05
was hanging out with. Oh my God. Same actor. He's an 80s actor too though, isn't he?
00:06:09
He's been around for a long time, but he is like one of the best of the best. Oh my God.
00:06:13
He's the bad gay. Yes. Tom. These bad gays, that's a line from it. We're not fucking.
00:06:18
Yes, that's Jennifer Coolidge. Yeah. Being quoted. These gays are going to kill me.
00:06:22
Oh, that's good. Oh, I'm overjoyed. Okay, good. But let's, what do you have? What have you got?
00:06:30
Let's move on from it. Perfectly prepared potatoes. I won't. I'm just going to keep misquoting the movie, which driving people who really know every word of the movie.
00:06:38
But people on TikTok have made T-shirts with him on it. And then it says what perfectly prepared potatoes.
00:06:47
I wish I could remember it. But it's like, it says what perfectly prepared potatoes.
00:06:51
And it's just like him looking down. Like it's a fan shirt. Yeah, I love it. So good.
00:06:55
Can I just let you know real quick? Yeah. What excellent boiled potatoes is the phrase, and it's Tom Hollander.
00:07:01
Thank you, Molly. Molly, thank you. Wait, did you know what excellent boiled potatoes off the dome?
00:07:06
I had to Google if I am going to be clean about this. Please always be clean. There's no reason not to.
00:07:11
Thank you for that info. There's no shame. I just did it wrong eight times in a row.
00:07:14
You get to do it wrong if you want to. What excellent boiled potatoes and what a perfectly appointed room.
00:07:21
Something like that. Yeah. Just like bad small talk. That's good. So good. Okay.
00:07:25
I'm so glad. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you guys for fucking yelling at me until I did it.
00:07:31
It was for my own good. Right. It was for my own good. Do you feel different? I feel more open-minded to movies like that.
00:07:38
Okay. Then I have a recommendation. Okay. There's another one and there's a couple versions of it and it's called Persuasion.
00:07:45
Okay. Someone else mentioned that in the comments. The original Persuasion is so good.
00:07:50
Okay. And it is one of those love stories of like, it's too late. She made the wrong call and she lost him forever.
00:07:56
Devastating. Okay. But did she? Our Jane Austen doesn't devastate permanently. Okay.
00:08:02
And it is so beautifully acted. And it's the same thing where you're in this place.
00:08:06
It's so real. These houses, these estates they live on, whatever. And like what it does to people, what people are like.
00:08:14
I don't know. It's great. Vera and persuasion. I will do that. And you don't have to watch.
00:08:18
You don't have to go all the way into Vera. You'll just be blown away at what an amazing actress Brenda Blathen is because she's like a completely different person and not.
00:08:27
That mother is like the kind of mother that would say a thing that would humiliate you and the whole family in front of as many people as possible.
00:08:34
Oh, I have one of those. It's hard. Oh, I've met one of those before. It's painful.
00:08:39
And not even on purpose. I feel like I have to say that. Like, not on purpose. No.
00:08:44
Just that's your personality. Right. It's tough. Yeah. Yeah. She's a little, she's squeamish.
00:08:49
Yeah. Okay. Well, should we talk about merch for one second? Oh, sure. Okay. Because it's fucking hilarious this week.
00:08:57
Well, this is very exciting. So we each got to design our own merch. Didn't get to.
00:09:02
We just fucking did it. And then Nicole was like, that should be real merch. And we were like, okay.
00:09:07
So I designed. My pitch was, hello, my name is. And then the name would be Supped because that's the one I got superintendent.
00:09:18
I got it wrong. It was episode 465. You're kidding yourself, Supped. So Hello, My Name is Supped is now available as a mug and a koozie. And I have both right here with me.
00:09:32
Hello, my name is Supped with my terrible handwriting. That's Georgia's script. My actual scrawl.
00:09:38
Truly her design. So then I also designed some merch. And essentially, people were saying that after the election, me quoting my dad, who said we just have to sally forth, was people were really liking that online. So Nicole suggested we make shirts of it. And she's like, what do you want the shirt to look like? And so I picked up a tiny legal pad and just very quickly sketched it and said, what if it was something like this, just like a little cartoon head of my dad saying that.
00:10:07
And then she was like, sounds good. What if we just do it exactly the way you wrote it?
00:10:12
So in the same vein and in the same spirit of George's merch, we have T-shirts that are my hand-drawn picture of my dad.
00:10:20
So good. Which literally looks exactly like him. It does. It totally does. Saying we're going to sally forth.
00:10:25
Yeah. That's a perfect shirt. That's pretty great. I feel like for us and merch.
00:10:30
Yeah. This is where we want to be. Yeah. Like this strikes a good balance, I think.
00:10:35
I think so. So this is your summer merch, guys. Bring this to the beach? I don't know.
00:10:39
I mean, you could. Do you want it on a towel? Do you go to the beach? Hello, my name is supped on a towel.
00:10:43
That's fun. Great idea. I actually love that. Do you go to the beach? Do you go?
00:10:49
Do you like sand in your toes and in your car and in everywhere? Everywhere? Everywhere.
00:10:55
Purse. People are like, we do. Yeah, people do. All summer long. Should we do the rest of the exactly right updates while we're here?
00:11:03
Sure, we should. We have a network and it's called the Exactly Right Podcast Network.
00:11:08
And here are some of the updates. Well, this is a big one. MFM Animated is brand new.
00:11:13
Nick Terry brings us the story of Peachy, the bitter little bird. It's my favorite.
00:11:18
I say that every fucking time. It's my favorite. Yeah. This one is beautiful. It has so many.
00:11:22
I get Peachy pulls a switchblade on me. Yeah. It's great. I'm honored. No spoilers.
00:11:29
But George is physically threatened by a small bird. I am honored to be physically threatened by Peachy.
00:11:33
So you can go find it on YouTube right now. It's at youtube.com slash exactly right media. And there are also 70 other episodes of MFM animated. So if you like this one, you might like the other ones, too.
00:11:45
Yes please follow us on YouTube It very helpful And while you there on YouTube we also got full episodes of Buried Bones This podcast will kill you and the little podcast called My Favorite Murder There tons of videos guys We making them for you Please go check that out YouTube slash exactly right media Thank you The end
00:12:05
If you spend all day waiting to take your bra off, it might be time for Third Love.
00:12:09
If you're looking for breathable, lightweight comfort this summer, you're gonna love Third Love.
00:12:14
Third Love is built around getting the fit right instead of expecting you to put up
00:12:17
with something that doesn't work. And Third Love offers a full range of sizes from AA to H,
00:12:22
including their exclusive half cup sizes so you can find a fit that feels just right instead of close enough.
00:12:28
Stop settling for bad bras. Whether you're looking for more lift, back smoothing, or straps that stay put,
00:12:34
Third Love can find your fit fast. Their virtual fitting room gets you in the right size
00:12:38
and matches you with the best styles for your shape. If you've ever been fitted for the right size bra, you are in for a treat.
00:12:44
It actually changes the whole game with bras. I thought I was like a something-something A cup.
00:12:49
I'm a something-something B cup, and it's just changed my bra game. I thought I just hated bras, but I was wearing the wrong size.
00:12:56
And with Third Love, like they're so comfortable that it doesn't even feel like I'm wearing a bra.
00:13:00
Use code MFM15 for $15 off your first purchase at thirdlove.com. Goodbye. While the world watches the stars at the FIFA World Cup this summer, Hyundai has its eyes on the next generation of talent.
00:13:13
The future soccer stars who are already turning heads at age 14. Making plays that end up on everyone's feed, scoring from angles that don't make sense,
00:13:20
rewriting record books that barely had time to gather dust. Because Next doesn't wait for an invitation, and Hyundai doesn't either.
00:13:27
Hyundai has always moved the future within reach. Hyundai did it by making advanced safety standard on every vehicle.
00:13:33
Hyundai did it by engineering EVs with ultra-fast charging capability. And Hyundai continues doing it every day.
00:13:39
From robotics that change how people live to young athletes changing the game, the future isn't some far-off concept.
00:13:45
It's already here. Next starts now. Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Goodbye.
00:13:51
Cheap Caribbean Summer Savings Event is here. Right now, get $100 instant savings on vacation packages to Cancun, Jamaica, and the Dominican Republic.
00:14:00
Whether you're chasing poolside drinks, white sand beaches, or endless all-inclusive fun,
00:14:05
Cheap Caribbean helps you get more beach for less money. Book your summer vacay today at CheapCaribbean.com.
00:14:11
Goodbye. All right, so it's summer. We need some mental health time off. And so Karen is going to tell you a story this episode.
00:14:21
Yeah, we're going to do some solo episodes, get our homework done and go on vacation.
00:14:26
I have a story for you that the book that was written about this story, I have recommended on this show so many times.
00:14:35
It was one of those things where I was like, well, I just read the one book and I like the one book.
00:14:38
I did a similar thing with The Man from the Train, which I love so much. But I also did this with Casey Sepp's book, Furious Hours, Murder, Fraud and the Last Trial of Harper Lee.
00:14:50
So today I'm going to tell you about that, the case behind that book. So it starts off in the late 70s in the small town of Alexander City, Alabama, and a local literary icon has just moved to town.
00:15:03
It's none other than an Alabama native and world famous author of To Kill a Mockingbird, Harper Lee.
00:15:08
At this point, Lee has won the 1961 Pulitzer for that book, which quickly became an American classic, and Harper Lee became a household name.
00:15:18
But instead of embracing that celebrity, she became even more private, and she bucked the literary world's expectations.
00:15:26
She didn't capitalize off the immense success of her book and immediately cranked out a second novel.
00:15:31
She just kind of, like, receded. So basically now, 20 years have passed since To Kill a Mockingbird's publication.
00:15:38
and Harper Lee has never indicated that she's doing anything else until now. Because Lee has come to Alexander City on a mission.
00:15:48
She's setting up interviews throughout town and scribbling down notes all about a string of suspicious deaths and a particularly sensational murder trial
00:15:56
that took place there in Alexander City. Harper Lee has been transfixed by this case.
00:16:01
She tells her friends it might be the story that pulls her out of her hiatus. She's even come up with a title for the book that she plans to write about it.
00:16:11
It's called The Reverend. This is the story of Reverend Willie Maxwell, a black Alabama preacher whose family members keep dying under mysterious circumstances.
00:16:21
Wow. I totally downloaded the audiobook and then didn't listen to it. So this is good for me.
00:16:28
This is a vacation listen. We build and build on these recommendations. Right. So, of course, Casey Sepp's Furious Hours, the book all about this case, is the main source.
00:16:39
Please order it from your local independent bookstore. Hey, or get it from the library, everyone.
00:16:44
Sure. Check it out. And the rest of the sources are in our show notes if you want to see what else.
00:16:48
Are you quoting the poster in the library that says, check it out? And it has like the stack of books.
00:16:54
Were you doing that on purpose or did that just happen? It probably came out of my childhood memory because it's like a stack of books.
00:16:59
Is there a checkmark anywhere on there? Yeah, I think at the top. But it's like because you check out books, it's like a winky thing.
00:17:06
Yeah. I think a book is flying open. A winky thing. Just a little winky thing. Hey, librarians, if you have a good check it out poster at your library, will you send us a picture of it?
00:17:17
Oh, my gosh. Post your photos of check it out and tag us. And if you think you have the oldest check it out poster, like the most vintage, please let us see it.
00:17:26
Yes. Please let us have our childhood memories come back to us. Okay, nice one. Okay.
00:17:31
Side content. Okay, so we begin in the summer of 1970, seven years before Harper Lee arrives in Alexander City.
00:17:38
It is the 3rd of August, and the body of Mary Lou Maxwell, a woman in her early 40s, has just been found in her car on the side of a rural two-lane road called Highway 22, and that's just outside of Alexander City.
00:17:52
Mary Lou husband of 20 years is a man named Willie Maxwell a sharply dressed captivating man in his mid who often described as being elegant He also a reverend Willie preaches at various churches and revivals throughout the area
00:18:07
And author Casey Sepp writes in Furious Hours that, quote, there wouldn't be anybody nicer to you conversation-wise.
00:18:14
People said of him, you'd think that man came from heaven. He was so smooth. So when Mary Lou is found dead, the Reverend's reputation takes a huge hit.
00:18:25
And for good reason. Her death is as suspicious as Willie's behavior. So, for example, the night Mary Lou is found dead, Willie calls the police and claims that he's worried she might have been in an accident.
00:18:37
He then directs the police straight to her car broken down on the side of Highway 22.
00:18:43
So not just a theory. Yeah. When the police arrive, it's obvious that Mary Lou was not in a car accident.
00:18:49
Her vehicle shows no signs of damage. The surrounding trees are untouched, and it looks like the car has simply pulled off the highway and been parked by the side of the road.
00:18:58
But Mary Lou's body has clearly been brutally attacked and strangled. There's blood everywhere, including on the outside of the car, which is hard to explain in a supposed crash.
00:19:09
Right. Plus, rope is found on the ground nearby, which may have been used as the murder weapon.
00:19:14
It then comes to light that things were tense between Willie and Mary Lou. He'd been cheating on her with lots of different women.
00:19:21
And at the time of her death, the Maxwells were in tens of thousands of dollars of debt.
00:19:26
Then investigators get bombshell information from the couple's neighbor. Her name is Dorcas Anderson.
00:19:31
She's in her late 20s. So Dorcas tells police around 10 p.m. on August 3rd, Mary Lou had stopped by in a panic saying she just received a call that Willie was involved in a bad car accident.
00:19:42
coming home from a preaching gig and that he'd crashed somewhere off of Highway 22.
00:19:48
So Mary Lou says to Dorcas, I'm on my way to go get him. But suspiciously, about an hour after this, Willie comes home in a car with no visible damage.
00:19:58
Mary Lou is not with him and Mary Lou never comes back. So all of that looks bad for Willie, but it gets even worse when he immediately tries to cash in
00:20:07
on several of the life insurance policies that he had taken out on her. At that time, it was very easy to take out life insurance policies.
00:20:16
All you needed was a name, a birthday, a social security number, and a talent for forgery if you're doing it behind someone's back.
00:20:24
They had machines, like cigarette machines for life insurance at the airport back then.
00:20:29
Like you just put a quarter in. The worst feeling. Also, what a brilliant person to think of those machines where it's like, you know, where you get real anxious.
00:20:41
about life and death. Horrible. Okay. So most of these policies were very cheap for Willie to file,
00:20:48
yet they promised to pay out thousands of dollars in the event of Mary Lou's death,
00:20:52
and some had been taken out on her right before the day she died. So before long,
00:20:58
Willie Maxwell is charged in his wife's murder. He hires a white attorney named Tom Ratney to
00:21:02
defend him. Despite the overwhelming circumstantial evidence against Willie, he winds up being acquitted after the prosecution's key witness, who is Dorcas Anderson, changes her testimony.
00:21:14
Suddenly, Dorcas claims she can no longer remember what happened the night that Mary Lou was killed.
00:21:19
So now, even though the people of Alexander City are deeply suspicious of him, Willie Maxwell walks away a free man.
00:21:26
And with Tom Radney's help, he also becomes a rich man because he is able to cash in on his dead wife's insurance policies.
00:21:33
Wow. The insurers fully believe that Willie killed Mary Lou, so they are reluctant to pay.
00:21:39
But when they don't, Rodney files civil suits against them and ultimately forces their hand.
00:21:44
It's unclear exactly how much Willie makes off these policies, but we do know that he gets a handful of checks that add up to thousands of dollars.
00:21:52
And then he splits the money 50-50 with his attorney. so then like a twist from a soap opera dorcas anderson's husband dies and she becomes the
00:22:04
next mrs willie maxwell okay see where this is going not great so even after the mysterious death
00:22:12
of his wife and the suspicion he's involved willie maxwell somehow manages to keep on preaching
00:22:17
but he has to do it out of town where the congregants are not aware of the story
00:22:21
Then in February of 1972, about a year and a half after Mary Lou's death, Willie's 52-year-old brother John is found dead on the side of the road about 10 miles outside of Alexandra City.
00:22:33
And according to Casey Sepp, John's cause of death is officially listed as a heart attack due to overconsumption of alcohol.
00:22:42
But when it comes to light that Willie has taken out life insurance policies on his brother as well, locals begin to theorize that Willie forced his brother John to drink a lethal amount of alcohol and then left him for dead.
00:22:56
Oh, my God. That's how do you. Yeah. It would be so long and like horrible. Yeah.
00:23:03
So the problem is that police can never prove that Willie Maxwell is involved. They simply don't have the evidence, which is something that the reverend's attorney hammers home when his client is taken in for questioning.
00:23:14
All good things most of the time. If people were, like, fighting for people where it's like, hey, if you don't have evidence.
00:23:21
Yeah. No, but it's like, but there is evidence. Right. Just not. Yeah. So Willie is never charged with any wrongdoing.
00:23:28
And because of that, the insurance companies have no choice but to, again, pay him out.
00:23:32
and they are not happy about it you don't want the insurance companies mad at you i just you can't
00:23:38
take insurance out for whomever you want it just feels weird it was the 70s early 70s yeah man
00:23:45
might as well been the 1720 i don't know what i'm talking about i was only two okay so then a few
00:23:52
months later in september of 1972 off a highway called route 9 the new mrs reverend willie maxwell
00:23:59
dorcas Anderson is found dead in her car. Oh, dear. In an eerily similar way to how Mary Lou Maxwell was found.
00:24:06
Dorcas is only 29 years old at the time, and by all accounts, she was a very healthy woman.
00:24:12
Her autopsy notes bruises on her shoulders and elbows, as well as a cut above one of her eyes,
00:24:18
and twigs and leaves stuck in her shoes, which could point to some sort of violence or struggle,
00:24:23
but her death is deemed a natural one. So even though Dorcas and the Reverend had only been married for about a year,
00:24:30
Willie had taken out about 20 life insurance policies on his new wife, all of which were almost certainly done behind her back.
00:24:38
Yeah, okay, he's just... 20. Gangbusters here. So Dorcas' loved ones are certain
00:24:44
that the Reverend is responsible for her death, but because it's not deemed a homicide,
00:24:49
and with the case against Willie being entirely circumstantial, no charges are ever filed.
00:24:55
So for a few years, things are quiet. the reverend winds up marrying for a third time
00:24:59
and this time to a woman named Ophelia. But little more than three years after Dorcas' death
00:25:05
in February of 1976 Willie's 22-year-old nephew James Hicks is found dead in his car off of Route 9.
00:25:12
What the fuck? The same highway where Dorcas was found. Authorities to this day have never determined
00:25:18
James' cause of death. His car and the area around it don't have any signs of damage
00:25:23
and an autopsy will show that James only has a tiny bit of alcohol and caffeine in his system.
00:25:29
He has a few small cuts on his arms, legs, and chest, and one on the inside of his mouth,
00:25:34
but they aren't the types of injuries that would kill someone. James's widow, Mary, tells investigators
00:25:39
she is certain Willie Maxwell is responsible. She even claims that his new wife, Ophelia, had been calling,
00:25:46
trying to get James's social security number before he died. Come on. So police track down the two local men who tell them
00:25:53
about their very damning interactions with the reverend. One claims Willie tried to recruit him into committing a murder.
00:25:59
The other claims that Willie admitted to killing people with pills, containing some sort of poison that he would dissolve into whiskey.
00:26:07
So the police collect all that information about Willie Maxwell's activities, but they don't arrest him,
00:26:12
probably because they would need harder evidence than just hearsay, and they know this lawyer is going to be waiting right there.
00:26:19
But until then, increasingly horrified locals fear that Willie Maxwell is going to keep on getting away with murder.
00:26:25
And then one year later, in mid-1977, Willie's 16-year-old stepdaughter, Shirley Ann Ellington,
00:26:33
Ophelia's child, is found along a nearby highway near Willie's car. At some point, the evidence is that everyone you freaking know dies.
00:26:43
Yes. That's the evidence. Your immediate family keeps being killed. Yeah. But unlike the other suspicious deaths,
00:26:51
Shirley Ann is not discovered inside the car. She's actually been crushed underneath it.
00:26:57
So the police think this scene is staged because it's supposed to look like Shirley Ann died in a terrible accident while changing a tire.
00:27:04
But none of the tires on the car are flat. And Shirley Ann's hands are very clean while the tools she would have been using are very dirty.
00:27:11
That's the kind of stuff that's insulting where it's like you're not going to even stage this with any energy.
00:27:17
You're just going to put all the things together and be like, it'll work again. You don't even, yeah, because you know you can get away with it.
00:27:23
Yeah. On top of that, Shirley is found about a mile from her house. It wouldn't make sense that she wouldn't just walk home instead of attempting to change a car tire.
00:27:33
So this is now the fifth suspicious death of someone connected to and actively insured by Reverend Willie Maxwell.
00:27:40
By this point, the Reverend has collected around $90,000 from insurers. Oh, my God.
00:27:45
Would you like to guess how much money that is? This is 1977. And it's how much?
00:27:51
90. It's accrued. It's $90,000 accrued from 1972 to 1970. In today's money, I'm going to guess that is 210?
00:28:01
What? 750,000. Almost a million dollars. Wow. Yeah. Okay, that's way off. I know. When I looked at that number, I was like, whoa, but it's the 70s, which I want to tell myself was 20 years ago.
00:28:12
It was not one. So at this point, the Reverend's reputation is fully in the gutter. He is now basically his name is like he's the local boogeyman. Everyone who knows about him can't stop talking about how he is just actively getting away with murder scot-free. Many people see him as a criminal, working the system in such a way that he's able to evade the consequences for murder, and he's making money. Others need a better explanation, so they start blaming voodoo and hoodoo.
00:28:39
There's some overlap, but they are essentially different things. In popular culture, they have been conflated for years because it's from back in the 70s.
00:28:49
These two terms are used interchangeably in most of the reporting that Maren found.
00:28:54
But it is worth noting that these have been extremely misrepresented in popular culture for a long time.
00:29:01
Voodoo is a formal religion. It blends traditional West African religious practices with Catholicism.
00:29:07
Whereas hoodoo is the African-American tradition of folk magic and medicine strongly associated with the South.
00:29:15
So we don't know if Willie practices either hoodoo or voodoo. But as author Casey Sepp explains in Furious Hours, historically, it wouldn't have been that unusual for a black Christian preacher in the rural South to be echoing elements of voodoo in his ministry.
00:29:31
In these same rural areas, folk medicine associated with hoodoo, like herbal remedies and poultices, often filled in critical health care gaps for both black and white clientele.
00:29:42
So by the 1970s, voodoo and hoodoo have been derided and condemned by racist whites for so long, the popular culture comes to misunderstand them as just creepy and nefarious.
00:29:53
All that trickles down to the people in Willie Maxwell world So they start making all kinds of wild claims about the reverend having supernatural powers one rumor claimed that he could turn into a black cat at will
00:30:07
they're just trying to explain how somebody could be getting away with this and just like basically
00:30:12
kind of scamming the justice system yeah but ultimately it's because the insurance policies
00:30:17
give him money to pay for a lawyer that's fighting for him it's like that's how the rich always never
00:30:24
go to jail. Totally. I'll tell you a thing or two about it. So in June of 1977, Willie Maxwell makes
00:30:33
the bold choice of attending his stepdaughter, Shirley Ann Ellington's funeral. About 300 people
00:30:40
attend this ceremony. One of the mourners is Shirley Ann's 36-year-old uncle, a man named
00:30:44
Robert Burns. Robert Burns is known as a very decent man. He's a loving dad. He is a veteran
00:30:51
from the Vietnam War. He's a very hardworking, long-haul trucker, a very loyal husband to his wife of eight years, Vera.
00:30:59
But Robert is also very close with his niece, Shirley Ann. So during this funeral,
00:31:04
he stuns everyone in attendance by pulling out a gun and in front of hundreds of witnesses
00:31:09
shooting 52-year-old Reverend Willie Maxwell in the head, killing him. What? At the funeral.
00:31:17
Oh, man. I wasn't expecting that. Right? It's a real turn midpoint. Yeah. Oh, my God.
00:31:25
So the reverend's buried one week later. Casey Sepp reports, quote, his funeral was one of the most well attended in this part of Alabama.
00:31:33
What people say about why they went is to make sure that he was really dead. So they could see him in the casket and verify that he was actually dead because they didn't think he could be killed.
00:31:45
Holy shit. Yeah. I mean, that's just wow. Imagine your beloved niece and you just know who did it and you know he's going to get away with it.
00:31:54
And you saw it coming. Yeah. And he did it to those other women where it's like Dorcas was just a witness and suddenly she's probably got love bombed and pulled in.
00:32:03
Yeah. Yeah. Horrible. So now in death, Reverend Willie Maxwell's notoriety has expanded far beyond Alabama, attracting reporters from all over the country.
00:32:11
And this is when Harper Lee reads about the reverend's murder in the newspaper and, of course, immediately is like, what is going on? I have to know more.
00:32:20
So it's a well-established fact that Harper Lee is a true crime fanatic. Casey Sepp mentions a quote Lee once gave about the infamous axe murderer Lizzie Borden, where she jokingly empathizes with her, saying, quote, I know exactly why she did it.
00:32:36
anyone burdened with long petticoats and having had mutton soup for breakfast on a day like that
00:32:41
was bound to have murdered somebody before sundown. Yikes. That's our girl. That's our
00:32:46
Harper Lee. She's just like, got it. Salty. She's a little salty. She's a salty lady played by Sandra
00:32:51
Bullock in the movie, the Truman Capote movie. All right. Interesting. So we know Harper Lee
00:32:57
is deeply interested in the themes that lie at the heart of the Reverend story. Things like
00:33:01
southerness, race, vigilantism, and the American justice system, all those themes that ran through
00:33:08
to kill a mockingbird. So it's not too surprising that she decides to move down to the Alexander
00:33:13
City area so that she can immerse herself in the reverend's world. While living there,
00:33:18
Lee interviews several people close to the case. She even develops a friendship with Willie's
00:33:23
longtime attorney, Tom Radney, who in another surprising turn in this saga, winds up defending
00:33:29
Robert Burns after he's charged with the Reverend's murder. Oh man, this guy's just like,
00:33:34
I'll take anyone. Well, I think it's like, is he the only lawyer for a thousand miles?
00:33:38
Maybe. Is it that feeling? He's the only one to take black clients, maybe. Maybe. Could it be that he was like, I was a part of this and this horrible thing happened and now
00:33:47
I need to be a part of this? Yeah, like atonement kind of? Yeah, maybe. Balance the scales. Although
00:33:51
his client is the one that got murdered, but it's an interesting turn. Yeah. So Tom Radney exchanges
00:33:58
extensive notes with Harper Lee, likely with the hopes that she'll write another bestseller that
00:34:03
highlights him as a particularly savvy lawyer. They also have some fun together. Years later,
00:34:09
Tom Rodney's wife, Madeline, will describe Harper Lee this way. She'll say, quote,
00:34:14
I didn't spend nearly as much time with her as the men did. Harper Lee smoked and drank,
00:34:18
and she had several four-letter words she'd contribute to any conversation. I love that
00:34:24
and these are like southern women who like we will go out on the porch while you men talk
00:34:30
and happily I guess you stay there too sorry mid quote but she had this really cute wit about her
00:34:37
she was smart and I enjoyed just listening to her just sitting back and listening to the conversation
00:34:42
so she liked it she was a fan so when Robert Byrne's trial kicks off in September of 77
00:34:48
he pleads not guilty by reason of insanity So Tom Radney is now tasked with one of the most difficult jobs an attorney can have.
00:34:57
He not only has to prove Robert's insanity at the time of the reverend's death, which is very hard to do in court, but he also has to defend a client who killed his victim in front of 300 witnesses.
00:35:10
Right. Like that's not in question. Right. So there's no denying that part. But Radney is, of course, a very good lawyer, even though PTSD isn't something most people understood at the time, like in the 70s. He relates Robert Burns' temporary insanity in the courtroom to the trauma he endured while serving in Vietnam.
00:35:29
At the same time, Rodney plays on the public's anxieties around the power of voodoo, and he uses it to paint the reverend as basically Robert's complete opposite.
00:35:39
As Casey Sepp puts it, Rodney establishes Willie Maxwell as, quote, the witchiest witch doctor and the voodooiest voodoo priest the South has ever known,
00:35:49
a man so mysteriously powerful that no force of law could touch him and so feared that no neighbor would look him in the eye So reporting from this time seems to take Tom Radney narrative here and run with it with Willie Maxwell becoming known as quote the voodoo priest in some faraway newspapers
00:36:08
Okay. So it's a bit hypocritical. Yeah. Yeah. To take a turn like that. It is. But maybe it's like, hey, I was there in the front lines
00:36:18
and, like, got involved with this guy. I don't know. Totally. So the trial lasts two days.
00:36:23
Robert Burns is acquitted of the reverend's murder. Wow. Because the jury ultimately accepts his insanity defense.
00:36:29
The courtroom reportedly bursts into applause at the verdict. Yeah. And that same year, the town of Alexander City names Tom Radney the man of the year.
00:36:39
Yep. And just so you get a full sense of Tom Radney, because this is like, we're just making comments on this kind of singular thing where it's like, he, of course, probably had 100 other clients and was, you know, whatever.
00:36:51
so everyone knows attorney tom radney went on to serve in the alabama state legislature
00:36:56
and he was a vocal advocate for civil rights he passed in 2011 at age 79 after a long illness
00:37:03
so he was the real deal in that way of like you said the only lawyer to represent black people at
00:37:09
that time or whatever it was he was doing he kept doing it after all of this okay which is good to
00:37:15
know yeah and apparently robert burns is still alive and in his 80s no way yeah and he talked
00:37:20
to Casey Sepp as she wrote her book, and he's been quoted by reporters a few times over the past
00:37:25
decade. That's so interesting. So with that, the story of Reverend Willie Maxwell comes to a close,
00:37:30
but we're still not at the end of our story because the enduring mystery here involves Harper
00:37:35
Lee, who despite all evidence suggesting that she was writing a book on this case,
00:37:40
never publishes one. In fact, nothing she wrote in this era has ever surfaced, at least not publicly. So while she was in Alexander City, Harper Lee conducted interviews,
00:37:52
including with Robert Burns after his acquittal, which imagine what that must have been like.
00:37:56
She took copious notes. She even sent pages of writing to Tom Radney for him to review.
00:38:02
And later, Harper Lee's sister Louise will claim that she read the entire manuscript
00:38:07
of the book about this case. And Louise reportedly declared that book to be, quote,
00:38:13
Better Than In Cold Blood. So it was written. Yeah. Oh, my God. I mean, would her sister lie?
00:38:19
Probably not. No. Because she'd want her sister to get the credit of like, oh, no, she did it.
00:38:23
Yeah. And it was better than in cold blood. Which, speaking of, we know Harper Lee was a very skilled reporter, and she proved this
00:38:31
when she helped Truman Capote, her childhood friend from Monroeville, Alabama, report on
00:38:36
the death of the Clutter family in 1950s Kansas, the subject of the book In Cold Blood.
00:38:40
And that book is a hugely important piece of American literature that helped legitimize true crime as a genre. But we also know Harper Lee's feelings about it were very complicated, mostly because of how close Truman Capote got with one of the murders in that case.
00:38:56
And so author Casey Sepp noted, quote, while on the one hand, Harper Lee seems to have been out to write her own in cold blood.
00:39:03
There were very distinct ways in which she was trying to do something different.
00:39:07
She had real concerns about Capote's book, about journalistic ethics, the role of the reporter and the way true crime writers can come to sympathize with their subjects.
00:39:16
Interesting. So Harper Lee once even wrote to Truman Capote's Fact Checker at The New Yorker, expressing her fears that while they were working on In Cold Blood, it was, in Harper Lee's words, quote, more novelistic than nonfiction.
00:39:32
She'd also written a letter to Gregory Peck, who played Atticus Finch in the movie version of To Kill a Mockingbird.
00:39:38
And she said to him, quote, my agent wants pure gore and autopsies. My publisher wants another bestseller.
00:39:44
And I want a clear conscience in that I haven't defrauded the reader. Wow. Yeah.
00:39:50
Chutzpah and what's the word I'm looking for? Character? Yep. Yeah. Good standards.
00:39:57
Like actually trying to stand for something. Yeah. Also, it makes it a little easier. She'd already gone through something before where it's like probably as they went through the in cold blood process, it was like, is this right or wrong?
00:40:08
Right. This doesn't feel good, but I didn't say anything at the time. Yeah. She's the researcher. She doesn't get to tell the author what to do.
00:40:14
Totally. But then but she gets to make her own adjustments. Yeah. Okay, so there's theories on why her book never saw the light of day. That's one of them, that she liked the ethics of it. Some have also speculated she might have been hamstrung by the fear of having to follow up to kill a mockingbird, which, good Lord.
00:40:33
I mean, stay sexy and don't get murdered. How do we follow that up? We haven't and we don't.
00:40:37
Others think she may have had really bad writer's block or that her publishers didn't like the idea of a book that centered around the lives of black people.
00:40:45
Right. Ultimately, we don't know what happened to Harper Lee's writing about the Reverend Willie Maxwell case, and she will never get a chance to show us or tell us herself. In 2016, at the age of 89, Harper Lee passed away in her sleep. Someday, someone could discover Harper Lee's work from Alexander City.
00:41:04
After all, many thought that she'd never publish anything after To Kill a Mockingbird, but then her book, Gossetta Watchman, was released shortly before her death.
00:41:14
In the meantime, if you live in or near Alexander City, please go check the dusty corners of your grandparents' attics because in 2009, a local man bought an encyclopedia from a Salvation Army and he found a handwritten note from Harper Lee buried inside.
00:41:33
We don't know who the note was written to. It's dated June 11th, 1978. And it says this, quote,
00:41:40
You simply can't beat the people in Alexander City for their warmth, kindness and hospitality.
00:41:46
If I fall flat on my face with this book I won be terribly disappointed because of knowing that the time I spent with you was not time lost but friends gained This is not remotely goodbye because I be coming back until doomsday And that is the story of the alleged murders and murder of Willie Maxwell and the lingering mystery around Harper Lee The Reverend
00:42:09
Wow. Okay, now I fucking know that story. Thank you. What happened to the book? The idea that she left a note in an encyclopedia for somebody to discover 40 years later is so badass of her.
00:42:25
She knew. That feeling. Yeah. She's like, I need to write a love letter to the city, but if I do it officially, they'll try to give me something and make it about me.
00:42:33
Right. And I just want the actual people to know. Yeah. So here. Oh, God. So good.
00:42:40
That's so good. Yeah. She wants a reader to know. Yeah. And they found treasure.
00:42:43
Yeah. ever look in your attics and go buy things at garage sales. If you live in Alexander City,
00:42:50
will you please send us any of your theorized Harper Lee treasure? It's like I found this manuscript in my grandma's nightstand.
00:42:59
That was an incredible great job for a solo. It had everything you'd want and more.
00:43:06
That's how we do these solo episodes. We provide, provide, provide, and we get the hell out.
00:43:10
Because we fucking sometimes need a moment. Do you understand this? I don't understand why it's been nine and a half years.
00:43:17
It's nonstop podcasting. It's a lot. A lot of podcasting. We love it. We're not complaining.
00:43:23
We do love it. We're so grateful. But man, it's nice to just have like two weeks, not worry about stuff.
00:43:30
You know, you do it from your job. Right? So we're doing it from our job. I mean, look, people, we just took a week off.
00:43:38
I mean, we do this sometimes. Yeah. But definitely, any complaints, please write to...
00:43:43
Get that out! Can you bleep that? My real email address? While the world watches the stars at the FIFA World Cup this summer,
00:43:55
Hyundai has its eyes on the next generation of talent. The future soccer stars who are already turning heads at age 14.
00:44:01
Making plays that end up on everyone's feed, scoring from angles that don't make sense,
00:44:05
rewriting record books that barely had time to gather dust. Because Next doesn't wait for an invitation, and Hyundai doesn't either.
00:44:11
Hyundai has always moved the future within reach. Hyundai did it by making advanced safety standard on every vehicle.
00:44:18
Hyundai did it by engineering EVs with ultra fast charging capability. And Hyundai continues doing it every day.
00:44:24
From robotics that change how people live to young athletes changing the game, the future isn't some far off concept.
00:44:30
It's already here. Next starts now. Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Goodbye.
00:44:36
Cheap Caribbean Summer Savings Event is here. Right now, get $100 instant savings on vacation packages to Cancun, Jamaica, and the Dominican Republic.
00:44:44
Whether you're chasing poolside drinks, white sand beaches, or endless all-inclusive fun, Cheap Caribbean helps you get more beach for less money.
00:44:52
Book your summer vacay today at CheapCaribbean.com. Goodbye. This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace.
00:44:59
It's 2026, and if you have an alternative career like food photography or professional mixtape making or witchcraft, you're going to need an online presence.
00:45:07
Whatever your thing is, Squarespace helps you build a website that's as unique as you are.
00:45:12
Squarespace provides you everything you need to offer services and get paid all in one place.
00:45:16
From consultations to events and experiences, you can showcase your offerings with a customizable
00:45:21
website designed to attract clients and grow your business. Get paid on time with professional invoices and online payments.
00:45:28
Plus, streamline your workflow with built-in appointment scheduling and email marketing tools.
00:45:32
With Squarespace's collection of cutting-edge design tools, anyone can build a beautiful professional online presence that perfectly fits their brand or
00:45:39
business. Head to squarespace.com slash murder for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch,
00:45:43
use offer code murder to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Goodbye.
00:45:58
Okay, well, this is a special occasion because we're starting to do this thing. We've been doing our hurrays where everybody writes them in on the show.
00:46:05
But now, today, we're doing it in the car. We're doing the honking hurrays. That's right.
00:46:10
So this is presented by Hyundai. We really appreciate you bringing us here and giving us this lush car to sit in.
00:46:17
The gorgeous Ioniq 5. Here we go. I drive this. This is actually Karen's car. Do you want to go for a second?
00:46:22
Sure. Okay. My hurray is that today is my one year sober anniversary. Wow. It's been pretty hard given the state of things,
00:46:30
but facing it sober means I can do the work that needs to be done. Wow. That's from Instagram from at Avon Gale.
00:46:37
Avon Gale's doing it even in the midst of full global meltdown. That's right. That's important work.
00:46:43
That's true. It's a hard time to be doing it, but you're doing it. Good work. So the subject line of this email is hooray.
00:46:49
I'm a PI. Okay. Okay. It says my hooray is that I just completed my associate's degree in
00:46:54
biology and got a job as a private investigator. Those are different. That's so cool though.
00:47:00
It is very, this is a person who's living the full range of life. Multifaceted. I've been listening since I was 14.
00:47:06
I'm now 21. What? How? Why? Is that math right? And working, it's like liar. And working on my bachelor's degree in forensic science.
00:47:16
Oh my God. Thank you for helping me find my future career, hopefully working in DNA testing.
00:47:22
There was no name signed on this, but Molly, our producer Molly, has a theory that they
00:47:28
left their name off because they're a PI. Ooh. Yeah. They're smart. That is so badass. Yeah.
00:47:34
Amazing job. Good job. Very cool. Okay. This is an email. It says tonight I'm sitting crisscross
00:47:40
applesauce on the floor of my new home folding laundry while my future husband and the love of
00:47:45
my life is putting our baby girl to sleep. Two different people. No questions. Sorry. Sorry.
00:47:52
So many people have thanked you over the years for your kindness and your advocacy and your
00:47:56
and their willingness to talk about mental health. So I am just another one in the book
00:48:00
But it's a large part because of you and because of this community that I made it here and that my children are here.
00:48:07
Hooray. Melanie, heart emoji. And then it says, P.S. My husband suggested naming our next child son after his father, Gary.
00:48:17
Baby Gary. Baby Gary. It says, I simply cannot. LOL. I think if you name your child Gary, we have merch for you.
00:48:25
We do. There is merch waiting for you. So you send us the birth certificate and proof.
00:48:29
Yes. That you named your child Gary. We need pictures of the face. Yeah. We need pictures of the feet.
00:48:34
And the birth. Okay. This email, the subject line is hooray, a dog, a dude, an England.
00:48:41
And it says, hiya. After 33 years of being a hopeless non-romantic, last year against all odds, I somehow met and fell for a sweet, charmingly befuddled Englishman and fellow teacher living in Tucson, Arizona.
00:48:55
Wow. So naturally, after only a few months of dating, he told me he decided to move back to the UK at the end of the school year.
00:49:02
Well, cut to the hooray. I packed up most of my life and moved to England this past New Year's Eve.
00:49:07
While it turns out that teaching is brutally hard on both sides of the Atlantic,
00:49:11
I'm loving building a little British life with this kind and unexpected man. But the real hooray?
00:49:17
I'm writing this from the airport on my way back to the States to reunite with my dog,
00:49:21
my best friend of nearly nine years to finally bring him back across the pond with me.
00:49:26
You not believe the hoops required to move a dog to the UK But I endlessly grateful to my wonderful sister for taking care of my Henry while I figured it all out Stay sexy and choose adventure over pragmatism every now and then
00:49:40
Katie. I love that. I want to have a little British life. I know. Build that British life.
00:49:45
Fill it with scones and befuddlement. Okay, this is from her email. Hi, my MFM queens.
00:49:52
My hooray is that March marked four years being a registered nurse. Wow. Before my nursing career, I was a teacher for four years and slowly fell into a deep depression.
00:50:01
In 2018, I made the decision to go back to school for nursing, and I haven't looked back since.
00:50:07
Now I have four years in as an RN, and I'm happier than ever. It's never too late to change your life around.
00:50:14
Hooray, Christina. Yes, Christina. Yeah. That's so true. Yeah. Never too late. Also, if she just becomes a stand-up comedian now, she's done every job in my family.
00:50:23
Oh, yeah. Oh, and fireman. Right. Okay. This is a combo because it's a comment on episode 479, No Bangs.
00:50:31
They also fold a hooray in here. It's from Instagram, and it says, Going through a really hard phase of life, but the joy from my kids is getting me through it.
00:50:39
I got them new PJs the other day, and my two-year-old goes, Dinosaurs! Yay! I could have cried.
00:50:47
So hooray for dinosaurs and amazing little humans. And that's at dshively07. That's so sweet.
00:50:54
That's so sweet. I know. Imagine having little children that bring you joy. What's that like?
00:50:59
What are we talking about Is that it That it We done it Alright well thank you Hyundai And thank you listeners for sending in your hoorays Stay sexy And don get murdered
00:51:10
Goodbye. Elvis, do you want a cookie? Ah! This has been an Exactly Right production.
00:51:22
Our senior producers are Alejandra Keck and Molly Smith. Our editor is Aristotle Acevedo.
00:51:27
This episode was mixed by Liana Squalachi. Our researchers are Maren McGlashan and Allie Elkin.
00:51:32
Email your hometowns to myfavoritemurder at gmail.com. Follow the show on Instagram at myfavoritemurder.
00:51:37
Listen to My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:51:42
And now you can watch us on Exactly Right's YouTube page. While you're there, please like and subscribe.
00:51:47
Goodbye. Bye. Vacation planning should feel like a breeze, not a deep dive into countless travel sites searching for the best deal.
00:52:01
With Cheap Caribbean's Budget Beach Finder, you can search every destination and every date all in one search.
00:52:06
You'll save time and money with the Budget Beach Finder. Say goodbye to endless scrolling and tab hopping
00:52:11
and hello to Budget Beach Bliss at your fingertips. Go to cheapcaribbean.com to try out the Budget Beach Finder
00:52:17
and see just how stress-free vacation planning should be. Goodbye. Each episode spotlights standout audiobooks on Audible across all kinds of genres.
00:52:36
Sci-fi, comedy, romance, thrillers, and more. With Cal talking to guests who help break down what makes each story worth listening to.
00:52:43
It's a fun, easy way to discover your next great audiobook. Check out Earsay on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:52:51
Goodbye. You know that fantasy where you run into your ex while looking impossibly cute and wildly unbothered?
00:52:58
Hill House makes the perfect dress for that moment. or if you're just running errands.
00:53:03
Hill House Home is the brand behind the viral nap dress, known for its signature smocking, ultra flattering fit,
00:53:09
and comfort that makes it a favorite for just about everyone. Celebrities like Taylor Swift, Olivia Rodrigo, Anne Hathaway,
00:53:16
and Mindy Kaling have all been spotted in Hill House. These dresses are the definition of versatile,
00:53:21
perfect for running errands in the morning and stylish enough for dinner or a party that night.
00:53:26
And it's not all they carry. They started with bedding back in 2016, and now you'll find bathrobes, pajamas,
00:53:32
children's clothes, and maternity, all with the cutest prints. And it's so true, the hardest time picking out one nap dress
00:53:38
because the prints are so dreamy and beautiful. But now that I have it, I'm going to wear it all day, every day.
00:53:44
I'm going to throw on my leather jacket at night and look like a total badass. Cowboy boots or cute heels, whatever it is,
00:53:49
this nap dress can make it look classy. You look like that classy lady you see at the airport.
00:53:54
Hill House makes fun fashion that makes you feel good. Get 15% off your first order of $100 or more at hillhousehome.com with code MURDER15.
00:54:04
That's MURDER15 for 15% off at hillhousehome.com. Goodbye.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 90
    Most shocking
  • 90
    Biggest twist
  • 85
    Most intense
  • 80
    Most dramatic

Episode Highlights

  • Earsay Podcast Introduction
    Check out Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club, hosted by Cal Penn.
    “It's a fun, easy way to discover your next great audiobook.”
    @ 00m 57s
    June 05, 2025
  • My Favorite Murder Hosts
    Georgia Hartstark and Karen Kilgariff welcome listeners back to their podcast.
    “We're going to do it every week if we can, if the mood strikes us.”
    @ 01m 43s
    June 05, 2025
  • Harper Lee's New Mission
    Harper Lee returns to writing, inspired by a sensational murder trial.
    “She's setting up interviews throughout town and scribbling down notes.”
    @ 15m 48s
    June 05, 2025
  • Willie Maxwell's Suspicious Policies
    Willie takes out multiple life insurance policies on his wife just before her death.
    “They promised to pay out thousands of dollars in the event of Mary Lou's death.”
    @ 20m 48s
    June 05, 2025
  • Dorcas Anderson's Testimony Changes
    Key witness changes her story, leading to Willie's acquittal.
    “Suddenly, Dorcas claims she can no longer remember what happened.”
    @ 21m 14s
    June 05, 2025
  • Mysterious Deaths Continue
    Willie's brother and new wife die under suspicious circumstances, raising eyebrows.
    “Locals begin to theorize that Willie forced his brother John to drink a lethal amount of alcohol.”
    @ 22m 42s
    June 05, 2025
  • Funeral Shooting
    At his stepdaughter's funeral, Robert Burns shoots Willie Maxwell in front of hundreds.
    “He stuns everyone in attendance by pulling out a gun and shooting Reverend Willie Maxwell in the head.”
    @ 31m 07s
    June 05, 2025
  • Harper Lee's Interest
    Harper Lee becomes intrigued by the case and moves to Alexander City to investigate.
    “Harper Lee reads about the reverend's murder and immediately is like, what is going on?”
    @ 32m 11s
    June 05, 2025
  • A Note from the Past
    A note discovered in an encyclopedia sparks a connection across decades.
    “The idea that she left a note in an encyclopedia for somebody to discover 40 years later is so badass of her.”
    @ 42m 16s
    June 05, 2025
  • Celebrating Sobriety
    A listener shares their one year sober anniversary amidst global challenges.
    “Facing it sober means I can do the work that needs to be done.”
    @ 46m 24s
    June 05, 2025
  • A New Life in England
    A woman moves to England for love and plans to reunite with her dog.
    “I'm loving building a little British life with this kind and unexpected man.”
    @ 49m 11s
    June 05, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • Devastating.
    483 - Those Pants, That Hand
  • Oh, my God.
    483 - Those Pants, That Hand
  • Oh, dear.
    483 - Those Pants, That Hand
  • What the fuck?
    483 - Those Pants, That Hand
  • You simply can't beat the people in Alexander City for their warmth, kindness and hospitality.
    483 - Those Pants, That Hand
  • It's never too late to change your life around.
    483 - Those Pants, That Hand

Key Moments

  • Next starts now00:32
  • Goodbye00:35
  • Podcast introduction01:43
  • Funeral Shooting31:07
  • Harper Lee Investigates32:11
  • Harper Lee Treasure42:50
  • Sober Anniversary46:24
  • Nursing Career Change50:01

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown