Search Captions & Ask AI

MFM Minisode 443

July 07, 2025 /

This episode of My Favorite Murder features stories about cold cases, hometowns, and ghostly encounters. Guests Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark read listener emails detailing chilling events from Fremont, California, and New Albany, Indiana.

The first story recounts the 1984 murder of 14-year-old Tina Fales in Pleasanton, California. The case went cold until a pregnant detective reopened it in 2007, leading to the conviction of Stephen Carlson, who had been a classmate of Tina's.

Another email highlights Lucy Nichols, a Civil War nurse, and the efforts of archivist Allison Kaye to preserve her story at the Floyd County Library in Indiana. Kaye discusses the challenges faced by libraries and museums in maintaining historical narratives.

Listeners also share ghost stories, including one about a mysterious boy named Thomas who may have been a ghost from the past. The episode wraps up with a humorous recounting of a beach trip where a group of friends encountered hammerhead sharks.

Throughout the episode, Karen and Georgia engage with the stories, adding their own commentary and humor, making for an entertaining and informative minisode.

TLDR

Listeners share chilling hometown stories, including a cold case and ghostly encounters, with commentary from hosts Karen and Georgia.

Episode

27:20
00:00:00
This is exactly right. Hello and welcome to My Favorite Murder, the minisode, where we read you your stories.
00:00:29
Do you like emails? Want to hear six? Did you just get off a long day of work and you want to be read more emails?
00:00:37
You're like, you know what I didn't get enough of today in my nine to five? Emails.
00:00:43
Emails. That's right. Well, here we are. Here we are. That's why our tagline of the Minnesota is, it could have been an email.
00:00:49
And it is. Here we go. I have a real hometown and it was a cold case. Should I go first with a heavy hitter?
00:00:56
Kick it off. Okay. Good evening, lovely ladies et al. Well, technically my hometown is Fremont, California.
00:01:04
It says, happiest city in the U.S. I didn't make that up. I spent well over a decade in nearby Pleasanton.
00:01:12
It's all the name implies. Also, I didn't make that up. And this is near where you grew up, right?
00:01:16
This is East Bay, yeah. These are all the suburbs. My roommate, Christy Ward, was from Fremont.
00:01:21
Okay. So I heard a lot about these places. I don't know anything about them. I just heard what she told me about them.
00:01:28
Okay. Well, then also it says, Anne Dublin, home of the federal women's prison, recently shut down due to rampant sex abuse by the staff.
00:01:36
I really can't make this stuff up. Jesus. I didn't hear about that. That's horrible.
00:01:41
It says, anywho, I'm not saying that to you. You should. Anywho, not a whole lot happens in this East Bay community.
00:01:49
However, in 1984, 14-year-old Tina Fales was murdered while walking home from Foothill High School in Pleasanton.
00:01:56
using a shortcut that ran under Interstate 680. I totally remember this forensic files.
00:02:02
She was found in a drainage culvert, having been stabbed 44 times. I know, 14. One odd piece of evidence was her purse having been tossed into a tree.
00:02:12
There were several viable suspects, including her mom's super creepy boyfriend, but nothing that panned out, and the case went cold for decades.
00:02:19
Fast forward to 2007, and a pregnant detective on light duty started taking up cold cases.
00:02:26
Pregnant detective is the coolest fucking thing I've ever heard of. That's called Fargo, baby.
00:02:31
That's like America loves a pregnant detective slash cop slash lady that's going to take care of business.
00:02:37
Yeah. It's such a like juxtaposition going on. We love it. Yes. She sent the purse for DNA testing, which wasn't available at the time of the murder,
00:02:45
and it came back to classmate Stephen Carlson. Stephen had been bullied in school, and that day was beat up and thrown into a dumpster,
00:02:52
and in a fit of rage took it out on Tina when they crossed paths. Just tragedy. That purse being tossed in the tree,
00:03:01
apparently Stephen tossed it up there to mark where her body was left as he could see the treetop from sitting on his rooftop.
00:03:09
I know, chilling. The case was depicted on a 2017 episode of Cold Case Files. He was convicted in 2014, still claiming innocence.
00:03:18
However, five years later, wrote three letters to the family admitting guilt and feigning remorse. But the family isn't buying it. Can't say I blame them.
00:03:26
They waited 30 years for justice. Yeah. Thanks for making my long East Bay commute more bearable.
00:03:32
And if you're feeling blue, come visit us in Fremont, where apparently we are overjoyed to be
00:03:37
here. Fun fact, Fremont's Niles district was Hollywood before there was a Hollywood. Shout
00:03:42
out to Charlie Chaplin and SNA Studios. Stay sexy, Becky. That is a classic hometown. And it also is
00:03:49
the hometown in the way of so many of these stories are young women being just having their
00:03:55
lives ripped away because of some angry man or man boy. And it is like the saddest part of a
00:04:01
classic hometown is just, it's always that same story. And we're not even safe walking during the
00:04:07
day. We're not even safe walking during the day. It's just, that bothers me so fucking much. Okay.
00:04:14
Self-defense class, everybody. Yeah. Okay. Here's a little nice turn. The subject line of this email
00:04:19
is I'm the archivist in Lucy Nichols' hometown. So like Lucy Nichols was a Civil War nurse
00:04:26
that I told you about that when you joined the regiment. Okay, so it says, Karen in Georgia,
00:04:32
I've been a fan of the podcast since your early days and just about lost my mind
00:04:36
when I heard you say Lucy Nichols' name. I'm the archivist for the Floyd County Library,
00:04:41
the public library system in New Albany, Indiana, where Lucy Nichols lived after the Civil War
00:04:47
and where the 21st Indiana Regiment was from. The museum where Lucy's exhibit is on display
00:04:53
is actually a branch of our library system, formerly named the Carnegie Center for Art and History,
00:04:59
now named the Cultural Arts Center. Lucy's story is a cherished part of our city's history,
00:05:05
and we're currently working on making some much-needed updates to the 13-year-old exhibit
00:05:09
to preserve the historic documents on display and tell her story in a more inclusive way.
00:05:14
If any listeners are interested in learning more, please come visit us. I'm grateful to you both and the Exactly Right team for giving this important history a broader platform,
00:05:25
especially when libraries, archives, and museums are facing increasing pressure to remove and suppress powerful stories like these.
00:05:34
I mean, you've got to be fucking kidding me. It's like they already have been suppressed.
00:05:39
Right. We can't, we're not doing it again. No, we're not doubling down. Extreme funding cuts at the federal level and at the state level in Indiana are making it more and more difficult for us to operate
00:05:49
But without these critical institutions and people who run them Lucy story and many others would have been lost to time Stay sexy and remember that black history is American history Allison Kaye And then it says P If you ever in the Louisville area I love to show you
00:06:06
some of the creepy, cool things in our archives, like our 19th century post-mortem photographs.
00:06:12
Oh, my God. From the 1800s. I can even give you a tour of the haunted old library attic. And then there's
00:06:18
the little smiley face made out of a colon. Oh, my God. BRB getting a plane ticket now.
00:06:25
I mean, here's the thing, though. This is what's beautiful. Like, if you live in Indiana, make a little weekend trip so that you can go to the Floyd
00:06:33
County Library and go support, see this stuff and support it or figure out a way to become
00:06:39
a part of it. And like, that's how we make it so that nothing disappears. That's how we fight it.
00:06:43
It's just people start showing up and repping for all these places. Love it. Okay, this one's called, well, I'm not going to read you the title.
00:06:54
Okay. No, I am because it says it immediately. Summer ghost story, you say? Ooh, great.
00:07:00
Hi, Karen in Georgia. Animals, exactly right crew, and the memory of Stephen's mustache.
00:07:05
Oh. I was listening to Minisode 441, and you asked for more summertime ghost stories.
00:07:10
I had exactly that. My dad worked for the U.S. Forest Service in the mountains of Montana when I was a kid.
00:07:16
We lived on a compound which consisted of the ranger station, fire station, and three houses available for rent by employees.
00:07:23
I mean, wow. to be a kid then, you know, like that sounds incredible. Where it's like your backyard is the forest.
00:07:29
Yeah, you're free range. It was very secluded and so far north, it was practically Canada.
00:07:34
My parents had a huge vegetable garden and my dad built a greenhouse for the tomatoes.
00:07:39
The walls were made of thick plastic nailed to a wooden frame. When I was around five,
00:07:43
I was playing with this little boy named Thomas. My mom watched him during the workday.
00:07:47
Now, Thomas was about my age, but more, shall we say, precocious than I was. And then it says he was a little shit.
00:07:53
He was always full of ideas, some good, some definitely not good. And I was already a tiny
00:08:00
people pleaser. So I usually went along with every scheme he came up with. Hi. Always full of ideas is literally how I was like described for my entire childhood.
00:08:10
She's just got a big imagination and a lot of ideas. What if we go on the roof and throw pennies down at the cat? Like it's always that shit.
00:08:19
I know they told us not to do this because this would happen, but what if that didn't happen?
00:08:22
and this happened. We go down to the store, we get a bunch of candy, we put it in a bowl.
00:08:28
Ideas. It was the early 90s when children were free roaming, so we were often outside
00:08:32
with no supervision. One day we were playing in the greenhouse because it was a very chilly morning
00:08:36
and the greenhouse was nice and warm inside. My dad had just put up the plastic for the upcoming planting season
00:08:42
and had left an old rusty can of leftover nails inside. That's on him, dude. That's on him.
00:08:49
I don't know. What should we do with these things that absolutely will give you tetanus
00:08:52
if you come anywhere near them. It's pretty much child level. Yeah. Thomas wanted to know if the nails were strong enough
00:08:58
to poke holes in the thick plastic. Turns out they sure were. And they made a super satisfying noise
00:09:04
when they poked through. I knew we were doing something naughty, but I joined anyway.
00:09:09
Together, we had a merry time poking probably hundreds of holes in the plastic. Oh my God, we drew on my neighbor's kitchen walls once.
00:09:18
My parents were rightly super mad when they saw it And I got in huge trouble. I don't remember Thomas getting in trouble,
00:09:24
but that wasn't weird to me because he wasn't their kid. We got in trouble several times that summer
00:09:29
for doing things like sneaking down to the lake without a grownup. But that moment with the greenhouse
00:09:33
is the clearest in my memory. When I was about 12, I randomly remembered Thomas.
00:09:39
As I was thinking about him, a lot of questions came up. Where were his parents?
00:09:42
How did he get to our house every day? I could picture him clearly and remember playing and talking with him,
00:09:47
but I couldn't recall any other details. So I asked my mom how we knew Thomas and why she watched him every day.
00:09:53
She had no idea what I was talking about. What? I started describing him, trying to jog her memory,
00:09:58
but she had no idea who he was and insisted we never watched a little boy named Thomas.
00:10:04
She told me it must have been a dream. That didn't feel right, but I eventually conceded
00:10:08
because what other option was there? Plus, my dad always had his giant video camera
00:10:12
out recording every moment and there was no footage of a little boy named Thomas during that time.
00:10:19
I thought about it every few years for the next couple of decades. I could still picture Thomas so clearly,
00:10:24
but then I'd shrug and repeat what my mom said. Must have been a dream. It wasn't until a few years ago that it hit me.
00:10:30
Thomas always just appeared. I never remembered him being dropped off or picked up.
00:10:34
We were always alone outside together. He never came inside the house. No one else remembers him.
00:10:40
And the detail that made my blood turn to ice was that he always wore the same old-fashioned clothes.
00:10:45
Oh, no. Brown linen overalls rolled up to his knees, a white linen shirt, a straw hat, and his feet were bare.
00:10:53
He's dressed like Tom Sawyer. Exactly. He looked like a kid who had stepped out of a Western movie set in the 1800s.
00:11:01
I whipped out my phone and sent a text to my mom. Did a friend and I ever poke holes in dad's greenhouse when I was a kid?
00:11:07
Her response gave me chills. You did, but you were by yourself. Fuck. I think I spent all summer playing with a goddamn ghost child.
00:11:15
Yeah, you did. You did. You actually did. Thank you for keeping me company as I draw or clean my house. I'm an
00:11:21
artist and author, and I can't tell you how many times I paused while writing my dark stories full
00:11:26
of trauma and violence and thought, am I okay? Then I'll listen to you two tell stories about
00:11:31
real life people doing real life things that are far worse than anything I can imagine,
00:11:36
and I feel a lot better. Stay sexy and don't get into mischief with a ghost child, Kelsey.
00:11:42
Kelsey, I have really bad news. We're not real either. Kelsey, this whole time. Call your mom. This was a dream.
00:11:50
This is a dream podcast This whole thing is of your imagination Thank you for creating us Kelsey Thank you We appreciate you It so funny Okay well I go with that theme which is also partly the theme of my last email
00:12:05
and then your last email, because it says, well, I won't read you the subject line. It just starts
00:12:10
in all caps. OMG, ladies, with four exclamation points. Still in all caps. I am going to lose my
00:12:17
mind. Four exclamation points. Then at normal writing, it says, let me start with saying y'all
00:12:22
are great and have kept me company throughout college, getting married and being an elementary
00:12:26
school teacher. Hell yes. Thank you for your service. Bless your heart. I just listened to
00:12:32
episode 438, Those Pants That Hand. Truly one of our best titles of all time. And freaked out.
00:12:41
I mean, tapping my husband's leg, pausing the episode to agree with your statements,
00:12:46
saying what you were going to say. Just imagine a man watching the Super Bowl or something like
00:12:50
that. And then all caps. Anyways, I am not only, this whole thing is all caps. I am not only from
00:12:56
and grew up in Alexander City, Alabama, but I grew up with both Willie Maxwell and Tom Radney's
00:13:02
grandkids. So that was the murderous reverend and his lawyer, and then later other people's lawyer.
00:13:10
The grandkids. Holy shit. The grandkids. So it says, but FYI, we refer to it as LX City.
00:13:16
Oh. So you know the Murdoch murders and it was Alec Murdoch, even though it looked like it said Alec.
00:13:23
Yeah. It's like the way they pronounce it, I think, in the South or there. So I should have been saying Alec City the whole time.
00:13:29
We're not in the South, though, are we? During our senior year of high school, the TV show Paranormal Witness did an episode on Willie Maxwell and his former house.
00:13:37
I think someone had moved into the house and, of course, some shit got weird. Not entirely sure the details of it, but it did air on TV.
00:13:44
Hmm. And that has four exclamation points at the end as well. That's exciting. It is exciting.
00:13:50
It was the talk of my high school. Anytime a thing happens in your town. So in Petaluma, it's a very kind of traditional lot of Victorian houses and stuff.
00:14:01
So they, when I was in high school, they filmed Peggy Sue Got Married. No way. Yeah.
00:14:06
That was one of my favorite movies as a kid. Yeah. So Laura and her friend Adrienne sat outside of Adrienne's house and watched Nicolas Cage
00:14:14
and watch them do a whole exterior scene on the street outside of like our church, essentially.
00:14:21
Amazing. That was the rage. Okay. So we're back into the email. And I'm almost certain the grandson
00:14:26
would have parties on his grandfather's old property. We don't know which grandson she means.
00:14:32
I don't think, I think it's Willie Maxwell's. Yeah, because that's what she was just talking about.
00:14:35
Okay. I never went because even as a stupid teenager, I knew not to fuck with the paranormal.
00:14:41
and all caps exclamation point my mom grew up in alexander city and all caps remembers all of this
00:14:49
happening holy shit she was 14 when harper lee moved up to ellick city and can still remember
00:14:56
the rumors that create through our small town i know it was a long read really wasn't but i have
00:15:02
thought about sending you an email about willie maxwell for so long but never had the time or a
00:15:07
researcher, and then in parentheses it says, shout out to y'alls, to put pen to paper, or I guess
00:15:13
fingers to keys. Anyways, stay sexy, and maybe don't go to a high school party that's at a former
00:15:19
alleged murderer's property. And then it just is dash J, she, her. Wow. A local. I think I'd still
00:15:27
go to the party. Would you go to the party? I would absolutely be at the party early. I'd be
00:15:32
Like, do you need me to set up the area where we do Jägermeister shots? I'll do that.
00:15:37
Can I sage the Jägermeister shots? Would we care? I want to make it all okay for everybody.
00:15:42
And I think the way we do this is Jägermeister shots. Let's have a seance around Jell-O shots.
00:15:50
My last one is not going to tell you. Hello, MFM fam. Recently on a mini-sode, you asked for childhood snake stories.
00:15:58
Okay, it's called snake story. Fuck. my 12 year old daughter who listens religiously with me too young question mark question mark
00:16:05
said mom your moment has come my fear of snakes is legendary I had night terrors for years about
00:16:13
snakes and would wake up my entire household with my psychotic shrieking I once pushed my pregnant
00:16:18
friend in front of me when I saw a baby garter snake on a hike and her children have never let
00:16:24
me live it down. Nor should they. No. You go first. You and your baby take the hit for us.
00:16:31
The first thing my own children learn from me is that if we see a snake, they better learn to take
00:16:35
care of themselves because I will be, all caps, gone. The root of this fear is no mystery at all.
00:16:42
It began with the following story. It was 1993 and I was seven years old, minding my own business, taking a bath. I was a seven-year-old minding her own business.
00:16:52
Do-do-do. Yeah. I was enjoying the silky, soft feeling of my hair under the water after using finesse
00:16:58
conditioner. Oh my God, finesse. When you said finesse conditioner, I could smell it.
00:17:04
It was pink pearlescent and it was the best smelling shampoo. It smelled so good.
00:17:09
I bet it was made of toxicity. I bet it was like lie. I bet it literally was just like the worst thing you could put on your stove.
00:17:16
Absolutely. But it smelled amazing. When I heard a soft rustling sound on the bathroom floor.
00:17:20
I hope Vince isn't listening to this. Oh, yeah, he hates snakes. I had my head in the water, so my ears were muffled.
00:17:25
And when I sat up, I could hear it more clearly. I peeked over the side of the tub to see a snake slithering on the floor a few feet away.
00:17:33
What the fuck? A real snake. This is not a ghost snake. No. The scariest of all, ghost snakes.
00:17:40
Oh, my God. When it saw me, it did that freaky-ass thing snakes do where they can rear up and lift their body off the ground.
00:17:47
Like a fucking cobra? Like a king cobra? Yeah, yeah. Fuck off. It lifted its little head up and was waving side to side and hissing It was just a garter snake and probably not that big but in my memory it was basically an anaconda Yes I absolutely lost my shit screaming and crying and all out
00:18:06
panicking because I was trapped and the door was locked and I was naked, which somehow made it seem
00:18:11
even more life-threatening. It is. It is. You're just totally like, what's the word? You're totally
00:18:16
exposed, vulnerable. Exposed, vulnerable. Yep. My mom started banging on the door asking me what
00:18:21
the actual fuck was going on and I couldn't even answer. Someone finally got one of those lock
00:18:26
picking things that you shove into the doorknob to pop the lock. Can you imagine the parents?
00:18:31
Right. Just kick the door down. Your child is screaming in a locked bathtub. Who let this child lock the fucking bath? Okay. No, there were no locked doors in my fucking house.
00:18:41
No. Don't you dare. No. But also in our house and no accusations or anything, but they were all
00:18:46
those kind of modern like empty doors. It was like a, yeah. So the locks were truly just like
00:18:52
a slit that if you stuck a butter knife in it and turned it, you could open the lock.
00:18:55
I feel some sisterly animosity going on. There was all kinds of lack of respect for our locks.
00:19:02
And my entire family rushed in to help me. The humiliation and the terror combined and absolutely
00:19:07
altered my brain chemistry. Of course. I have never been the same since. How did the snake get
00:19:13
into our second-story bathroom, you ask? My four-year-old brother thought it would be a funny
00:19:19
prank and slipped it under the door to scare me. His little self was absolutely sobbing when he
00:19:26
realized how much of a shitstorm he had caused. I almost felt bad for him. P.S., thank you for
00:19:31
getting me through nursing school during the pandemic with three small kids. You truly provided
00:19:35
my calming escape, and you inspired my daughter to start martial arts when you talked about the
00:19:41
13-year-old girl who broke her kidnapper's ankle with jujitsu. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
00:19:47
You're helping me raise the next generation to be even smarter and more badass. Thank you.
00:19:53
Stay sexy and make your little brother pay for your therapy. Shanna, like banana, she, her. Shanna, that was epic. And also,
00:20:03
what garter snake rises up like that and hisses? Yeah. The little boy had to go run into the yard
00:20:08
and find it, first of all. Yeah. Like, that is premeditated. I was kind of obsessed with this
00:20:12
when Nora was growing up, where it's like, what's the thing that's going to do this to her
00:20:16
in some way? The way it all happened to all of us. Everyone has a garter snake-like experience.
00:20:22
Oh, yeah. My nephew once closed his, Micah, when he was little, closed his little fingers
00:20:25
in like a closet thing. And I'm like, he's going to remember that for the rest of his life
00:20:29
and be afraid of like these kind of doors. And it's my fault. It was awful. He was screaming.
00:20:34
I mean. So awful. I had the same experience, only I closed Nora's fingers into a drawer like that.
00:20:40
And I like, even saying it makes me sick to my stomach the way it did at the time where it was just off.
00:20:45
And it was like being like an old drawer that we couldn't get closed. And finally I got it done.
00:20:51
She was holding us. Sam, it was like one of those like, you know, folding door, like closets.
00:20:56
And he just like, oh. Right in the fold. And he couldn't talk yet, but he knew what words were.
00:21:00
So he was just babbling nonsense words. Oh my God. Okay, wait, let me. He's fine.
00:21:06
I'll erase it. I'll erase it for you right now as you look. I'll erase it. Finesse.
00:21:10
Original finesse bottles. Blue. There we go. Beautiful. But the actual shampoo, I think, if I'm not mistaken, was pink when it came out of that
00:21:19
bottle. It smelled good no matter what. Those two finesse bottles cost $44 because it's basically like people are bidding on them.
00:21:27
Dude, estate sales are where it's at. Okay, so here's my last one. And it says, hometown, sharks are bad for business.
00:21:33
so we have now I think thematically really followed each other in this thing because we've gone
00:21:38
reptilian and now we're going to the apex predator you think snakes are bad yeah
00:21:43
let's talk about sharks okay and then it just says ladies where do I even begin maybe back in 2016
00:21:50
when I had binged cereal and needed something murdery to fill my void and boy did you deliver
00:21:56
so yes man we really got that timing right didn't we yeah we did it says so yes that would make me
00:22:03
a day one listener. Hey. Hell yeah. That said, after hearing episode 443 about the New Jersey shark attacks,
00:22:11
I knew it was time for my email to shine. In parentheses, it says, and to resend,
00:22:16
hoping this time it gets through. In the summer of 2006, my best friend and her family
00:22:21
were on our weekly beach trip to the Gulf Coast, locally known as 30A. It was the perfect summer day
00:22:28
with a slack tide. The ocean was clear blue without a single wave, So we took our gas station neon floats out to sea.
00:22:35
Oh my God. Nah, I'll be sunbathing if you need me. See you later. Good luck on your plastic floats that could get you really far
00:22:43
and then absolutely just pop and leave you there. You look sexy in your death wish.
00:22:47
Bye. Bye. The water was so perfect, in fact, that we kept making jokes about how we could see the shadows of our floats
00:22:54
on the bottom of the seafloor until... I forgot there's a shark. Fuck. Right? My friend's dad, and then in parentheses it says, who was a jokester 99.9% of the time, sternly said, girls, stop moving now.
00:23:11
We immediately pulled our limbs out of the water and peered over the edge of our floats.
00:23:16
So basically, it's like a little floating bed thing. I was thinking of the arm floaties, but actually they're on.
00:23:24
Like a chaise lap. What are those called? Yeah, yeah, I think, yeah, just like more of a chair or a bed as opposed to just the individuals.
00:23:31
Okay, got it. So they have to pull their legs up and their arms up. I don't know.
00:23:36
It should also be mentioned that my friend's little sister wasn't in a full-length float,
00:23:40
but rather in an inner tube, fully exposed. Oh, you just look like a delicious turtle to that shark.
00:23:47
Right? That's what they say. That's why you pull your limbs in. It looks like a fucking turtle and it's like, yum.
00:23:53
crunchy on the outside. Pistachio cream on the inside. Right, but it's not a turkey.
00:24:00
It's not. Okay. As we look down, a family of five hammerhead sharks are circling beneath us.
00:24:07
I think hammerheads are okay, though. I know. I was just thinking, like, at least it wasn't a real shark, but I don't know anything.
00:24:13
Same. It's like, you wouldn't care. It's a prehistoric predator that's at the top of the
00:24:20
food chain. And it looks fucking insane, so. Insane. The way their eyes are way out to the
00:24:25
It's like a nightmare. What happened? Crazy. Not to eye shame you, hammerhead shark, but God, get it together.
00:24:33
The next few minutes— Evolve already, would you? Evolve for the next 10 million years, please.
00:24:38
What if it was like a hammerhead shark, but then their eyes evolve close together?
00:24:42
Oh, no, so just still have the hammerhead, but there was no reason for that to— Okay, stop.
00:24:47
It evolves into a Phillips head. The next few minutes were in slow motion. I remember looking to the shore and seeing everyone pointing with one hand and covering their mouths with the other.
00:24:58
No, no. Worst kind of pointing. Finally, after what seemed like an eternity, the sharks moseyed on about their business, and we frantically made our way back to shore.
00:25:08
So they just had to sit there floating above. Yeah. Once we made it back, Steve, the chair and umbrella salesman, made his way through the crowd yelling,
00:25:17
whoo those manatees sure were friendly no worries folks those weren't sharks just some friendly
00:25:23
manatees he then turned to us with a wink and said sharks are bad for business keep it on the
00:25:29
down low hey steve what's up steve steve it's all on you hope your conscience is something steve
00:25:38
have you seen the film jaws because that like you are literally playing the mayor You the mayor You the villain in the Yep Let keep those beaches open this summertime
00:25:48
Okay. I think Molly just told me it's Jaws' 50th anniversary. Oh, that's right. That's right.
00:25:53
50th. Yeah. Perfect. 5-0. To this day, we are still scarred and never miss the chance to reminisce when we're all
00:26:00
together, stay sexy, and know the difference between sharks and manatees? Sam, she, her.
00:26:06
Oh, Sam, that was epic. Good one. Great one. Good one. Love a shark story. Tell us your scary ocean story or beach story.
00:26:14
We love those. Yes, perfect. Like a scary summertime story. Yeah, good one. We're getting into that summertime vibe.
00:26:20
Totally. Well, that was fun. Hey, you guys, if you like these stories and you want more of them, guess what?
00:26:27
Go to the fan cult. There are like hundreds of episodes of mini, mini-sodes where we each read one email per
00:26:34
episode. So if you're bored and you want to check that out, go to MyFavoriteMurder.com and join the fan cult.
00:26:40
Well, thank you for listening. We love you. We do. Stay sexy. And don't get murdered.
00:26:45
Goodbye. Elvis, do you want a cookie? This has been an Exactly Right production.
00:26:58
Our senior producers are Alejandra Keck and Molly Smith. Our editor is Aristotle Acevedo.
00:27:02
This episode was mixed by Liana Squalachi. Email your hometowns to myfavoritemurder at gmail.com.
00:27:08
And follow the show on Instagram at myfavoritemurder. Listen to My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:27:15
And now you can watch us on Exactly Right's YouTube page. And while you're there, please like and subscribe.
00:27:20
Goodbye.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Funniest
  • 60
    Most shocking
  • 60
    Most unserious (in a good way)

Episode Highlights

  • The Murder of Tina Fales
    In 1984, 14-year-old Tina Fales was murdered while walking home from school. The case went cold for decades until a pregnant detective reopened it in 2007, leading to a shocking revelation.
    “Just tragedy.”
    @ 02m 57s
    July 07, 2025
  • The Ghost Child
    A listener recalls a childhood friend named Thomas, who may have been a ghost. The chilling realization comes when her mother insists she was alone during their adventures.
    “I think I spent all summer playing with a goddamn ghost child.”
    @ 11m 15s
    July 07, 2025
  • The Snake Incident
    A listener shares a terrifying childhood experience involving a snake in the bathtub, orchestrated by her little brother. The incident left a lasting impact on her.
    “The humiliation and the terror combined and absolutely altered my brain chemistry.”
    @ 19m 02s
    July 07, 2025
  • Childhood Trauma
    A story about a childhood accident that left lasting memories.
    “He's going to remember that for the rest of his life.”
    @ 20m 27s
    July 07, 2025
  • Shark Encounter
    A terrifying moment at the beach when hammerhead sharks were spotted.
    “A family of five hammerhead sharks are circling beneath us.”
    @ 24m 00s
    July 07, 2025
  • Humorous Vendor
    A beach vendor reassures everyone after a shark sighting.
    “Sharks are bad for business.”
    @ 25m 29s
    July 07, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • Pregnant detective is the coolest fucking thing I've ever heard of.
    MFM Minisode 443
  • I think I spent all summer playing with a goddamn ghost child.
    MFM Minisode 443
  • Stay sexy and make your little brother pay for your therapy.
    MFM Minisode 443
  • He's going to remember that for the rest of his life.
    MFM Minisode 443
  • Oh my God.
    MFM Minisode 443
  • Stay sexy, and know the difference between sharks and manatees?
    MFM Minisode 443

Key Moments

  • Emails00:42
  • Cold Case02:26
  • Ghost Child11:15
  • Snake Incident19:02
  • Childhood Accident20:27
  • Shark Sighting24:00
  • Beach Vendor Humor25:29
  • Final Thoughts26:00

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown