This episode of My Favorite Murder features stories about cold cases, hometowns, and ghostly encounters. Guests Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark read listener emails detailing chilling events from Fremont, California, and New Albany, Indiana.
The first story recounts the 1984 murder of 14-year-old Tina Fales in Pleasanton, California. The case went cold until a pregnant detective reopened it in 2007, leading to the conviction of Stephen Carlson, who had been a classmate of Tina's.
Another email highlights Lucy Nichols, a Civil War nurse, and the efforts of archivist Allison Kaye to preserve her story at the Floyd County Library in Indiana. Kaye discusses the challenges faced by libraries and museums in maintaining historical narratives.
Listeners also share ghost stories, including one about a mysterious boy named Thomas who may have been a ghost from the past. The episode wraps up with a humorous recounting of a beach trip where a group of friends encountered hammerhead sharks.
Throughout the episode, Karen and Georgia engage with the stories, adding their own commentary and humor, making for an entertaining and informative minisode.
Listeners share chilling hometown stories, including a cold case and ghostly encounters, with commentary from hosts Karen and Georgia.
This episode stands out for the following:
Pregnant detective is the coolest fucking thing I've ever heard of.MFM Minisode 443
I think I spent all summer playing with a goddamn ghost child.MFM Minisode 443
Stay sexy and make your little brother pay for your therapy.MFM Minisode 443
He's going to remember that for the rest of his life.MFM Minisode 443
Oh my God.MFM Minisode 443
Stay sexy, and know the difference between sharks and manatees?MFM Minisode 443