Search Captions & Ask AI

MFM Minisode 452

September 08, 2025 /

This episode of My Favorite Murder features stories about cults, family dynamics, and unexpected encounters with animals. The hosts, Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, read listener submissions that include a near-recruitment by a cult, a family bat incident, and a chaotic horse camp experience.

One listener shares a chilling tale about almost being recruited by a cult called God the Mother while attending college in San Diego. She describes how a seemingly friendly encounter turned into a frightening situation when she realized the group had ties to human trafficking.

Another story involves a listener recalling a childhood experience with a bat that flew into her home, which her siblings refused to believe until they witnessed it themselves. This humorous yet eerie account highlights the dynamics of sibling relationships.

The episode also includes a story about a horse camp that turned out to be run by drug dealers, where the listener learned valuable lessons about horses and trust. This anecdote adds a layer of absurdity to the overall theme of unexpected revelations.

Listeners are encouraged to share their own stories, emphasizing the podcast's community aspect and the variety of experiences that can be both humorous and unsettling.

TLDR

Listeners share chilling and humorous stories about cults, bats, and chaotic horse camps.

Episode

26:48
00:00:00
This is exactly right. Isn't some far off concept? It's already here. Next starts now.
00:00:33
Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Goodbye. When a charming neurosurgeon rode into Frontier Town
00:00:39
selling a persona of confidence and care, patients trusted him. He wore cowboy boots in the operating room
00:00:45
and became sought after by patients. He promised to heal them. Instead, he left a trail of broken bodies.
00:00:51
This is a story of greed, betrayal, and a fight for justice. Listen to Dr. Death the Cowboy wherever you get your podcasts
00:00:58
or binge the entire series right now only with Audible. Goodbye. This is Kristen Davis from Are You a Charlotte?
00:01:06
Forget everything you know about hair color, the mess, the smell, the damage. Madison Reed is female-founded, female-led,
00:01:15
and has completely transformed the hair color experience. Their award-winning formulas are crafted in Italy
00:01:21
with ingredients that care for your hair, delivering rich, multi-dimensional results.
00:01:27
and you choose how you color. Get salon gorgeous results at home or let a pro do it for you
00:01:34
at a Madison Reed hair color bar. The future of hair color is here at Madison Reed.
00:01:40
Try it today and get 20% off your first order or service. Go to www.madison-reed.com forward slash Charlotte
00:01:50
and use code Charlotte. For 20% off your first order or service, visit www.madison-reed.com forward slash Charlotte and use code Charlotte.
00:02:04
There's a difference between liking a house and actually getting it. Redfin is built to make up that difference and close the gap between finding and owning the home for you.
00:02:14
Redfin agents close twice as many deals as other agents. So when you find a home you love, you're not a step behind when it comes to making an offer.
00:02:22
That means less watching great homes disappear and more focus on the one you'll call home.
00:02:28
Redfin helps turn saved listings into real addresses. Get started at redfin.com.
00:02:34
Own the dream. Hello and welcome to My Favorite Murder, the mini-sode. We read you your stories and now we update you about your stories and their responses.
00:03:03
That's right. When we do a minisode that is so compelling that Nick Terry doesn't animated about it.
00:03:10
Go to the Exactly Right Media YouTube to watch. To watch and then go ahead and read those comments under the baboon animated.
00:03:16
We did and there's a lot happening. Do you want to just kind of like tell people the story if they don't know it?
00:03:23
Just real quick. Basically, the MFM animated that was a hometown was a little girl who they went into like a safari drive through.
00:03:30
and the mother made the little girl get out and face down the baboons to get their side mirror
00:03:37
back. How was that? That was perfect. And then the people spoke and not only did the people speak
00:03:45
in these YouTube comments, Diane's daughter came to defend her honor. The mother of the daughter
00:03:51
who was the little girl was with, it wasn't her kid. She kicked someone else's kid out of the car
00:03:56
yes to square off with baboons diane was like hey emily you get out and go get that mirror
00:04:02
but that's emily's side of the story the plot thickens because diane's daughter showed up to
00:04:08
say emily didn't really tell that story accurately um i'm sorry she came around to say hot tea coming
00:04:16
in really quick should we say this shit people were saying in the comments were like peak 90s
00:04:22
parenting there. All kids were safe. No thanks to Diane. You know, Diane didn't watch the Omen,
00:04:28
question mark. Right. There was a lot of Diane shit talking. Yes. So here's a comment from Diane's
00:04:33
literal daughter. Hi, all. Diane's daughter here. I need to make some corrections to this story as
00:04:37
to vindicate Diane. I have taken this recording to my sister and mother, and we all agree that
00:04:42
Emily has misremembered a few key facts here. The first and most important is that my mom asked me,
00:04:48
her daughter to open the door and retrieve the mirror that was sitting directly next to the car
00:04:52
door on the ground. That's another little, it wasn't that far away. Yes. I refused as we were
00:04:56
being swarmed and attacked by baboons. Yes, we know that. Secondly, Emily absolutely volunteered
00:05:02
to slither out the door to grab it. The baboons did charge and Emily did not get the mirror.
00:05:08
Diane eventually drove to the end of the safari and a ranger did grab one mirror that was duct
00:05:12
taped to the car for the ride home to PA. Despite the fact that my mom did ask a literal child to
00:05:18
fight for the mirror, she asked her child to do so. She sacrificed her own child. Yeah. Whose side
00:05:24
are you on? Yeah. Are you on the initial daughter or the main girl, Emily, who did the slithering?
00:05:29
Who was not the daughter. Who told the story like she was sent out into a safari park as a child.
00:05:36
Well, clearly we need Diane's side of the story. So she needs to write in. Diane, if you could send
00:05:40
a video in, we would love to be able to throw to you. And then maybe we talk to you live.
00:05:45
All right. So that's the update on hometown. That's right. Send us your updates for hometown or your side of the story. We want to know.
00:05:51
I mean if your hometown has gotten all the way to Nick Terry level and you would like to make a correction or talk about what real we here to entertain any version of reality That true That what we do Okay let do hometowns You want to go first
00:06:05
Sure. The subject line of this email is God the mother almost got me. Hi, Karen, Georgia and
00:06:11
fellow murderinos. I've been a listener since day one. My little sister introduced me to my
00:06:16
favorite murder back when we were both working in a plastic factory trying to save up for college
00:06:21
tuition. That's about as American as you can get. I'm so proud. 1930s. I mean, hell yes. Did you have
00:06:30
to wear those things on your hair? Yeah. Did you have to wear protective goggles? I hope you were
00:06:34
a mess because breathing in those particles can't be good for you. No. And also, were you assembling
00:06:38
like a little toy? Oh, okay. Okay. Okay. Right back in and answer all those questions. Your podcast
00:06:45
got me through long shifts and hard days and I've been hooked ever since. After listening to episode
00:06:50
490, I wanted to share a story that still gives me chills. The time I was almost recruited by a cult
00:06:55
known as God the Mother. I remember that documentary. Picture this. It's 2018. I'm a
00:07:01
senior at the University of San Diego trying to survive my core curriculum. So that means that
00:07:06
she made it to college. She got that plastic money and she got her college tuition. Amazing.
00:07:12
Good job. One requirement was to take three theology or religion courses. That's a lot.
00:07:17
What the fuck? The Jesuits will get you. Growing up culturally Catholic, didn't exactly prepare me for what those professors were throwing at us, and I was desperate to form a study group so I wouldn't totally bomb the class.
00:07:29
I was walking alone one evening after dance practice trying to get home when a girl about my age smiled and waved me over. She asked, have you heard of God the Mother? At first, I was curious, even a little relieved. I'd been actively looking for a group of study buddies to help me survive this class, and this sounded promising.
00:07:47
She explained that the group of mostly women met off campus to discuss matriarchal themes and religion.
00:07:52
All right. Sounded kind of cool, right? But something felt dot, dot, dot. Oh, fake smile plastered to your face.
00:07:59
Do you want to hear about God the Mother? Have you met God the Mother? Now try to smile but not use your eyes.
00:08:05
Have you met God the Mother? Can't do it. The more she spoke, the more uneasy I became.
00:08:13
The vibe turned from friendly to weirdly intense. I tried to excuse myself, but she started following me around campus.
00:08:20
Oh, no. That's when I decided to fuck politeness and embarrassment. I spotted a cute guy coming out of the campus store and ran up to him, pretending we know each other.
00:08:29
Genius. Best thing to do. Thankfully, he caught on immediately and played along.
00:08:32
The girl eventually backed off, and he stayed with me until campus police arrived and gave me a ride home.
00:08:38
Man, that is how you hit on someone. So good. It doesn't matter if there's no one following you.
00:08:44
Hey, sir. Right? Oh, my God. There's someone following me. Can you protect me? Hey, will you shop with me at this Marshalls?
00:08:50
There's someone following me. There's someone following me through this Marshalls.
00:08:53
Can you sit on my side? I stuffed a shirt in my purse earlier. The next day in class, everyone was talking about the news.
00:09:00
Apparently, this God the Mother group, as seen on USD's campus, had ties to human trafficking.
00:09:05
Oh, fuck. They were targeting local college students, especially women, through those supposed study groups that were actually fronts for kidnapping.
00:09:13
Holy shit. What? To this day, I think about how close I might have come to becoming one of those stories we all talk about.
00:09:19
I've never forgotten a student who helped me or that gut feeling that told me something was wrong.
00:09:25
What if it had been him who was the problem and she got in his car? I'm sorry, but you just can't trust anyone.
00:09:30
He's like, I'll help you, little girl. I am God. I'm also God the mother. Stay sexy and if something seems too good to be true, it probably is XOXO, Debbie.
00:09:40
Nice. That's good. Good escape. I'm not going to read you the title of this one.
00:09:44
Okay. It just starts. Hi, big fan. My incredible grandma who passed. I'm so sorry, but we didn't explain why we're so glammed up right now.
00:09:54
If you're going to watch us on YouTube, now's the time to start because we look fucking glam and flawless.
00:10:00
I'm wearing fake eyelashes. I am too. We had a photo shoot just now and we were like, let's film now because we're never going to look better.
00:10:06
I thought that'd be a little bread crumbing for people to come over to the video part.
00:10:10
To the exactly right media. my favorite murder YouTube. Join the fan cult. Join the fan cult. Whatever. Get your tour tickets.
00:10:17
My incredible grandma who passed away in 2022 had the most incredible stories. As she got older,
00:10:22
she lost her filter and got progressively sassier. She also had a hard time finding
00:10:27
doctors that she liked. Okay, we're set up. After years of looking, she finally found someone that
00:10:32
she trusted and could also get along with. What do you think she was like? I mean, how long are you
00:10:36
in a doctor's appointment that you're not getting along with people? Immediately. He took her
00:10:40
arthritis seriously, and she finally felt like she was making progress. One day, he was just no
00:10:45
longer available, not on the clinic website, canceled appointments, and no one at the clinic
00:10:49
would talk about him. Finally, my mom, who was accompanying my grandma to all her appointments,
00:10:54
decided to Google him, and she found that he had lost his license for, all caps, experimenting with
00:11:01
animal-grade Botox, meant for like dogs with arthritis, in his own face and also his mom's
00:11:08
face. No, what? Who are you mad at in this story? They did it to themselves. Anyway, I don't know
00:11:16
that my grandma ever really trusted another medical professional again, but it was a great
00:11:19
addition to the arsenal of incredible stories from my grandparents, unseating the time my grandpa got
00:11:25
kicked out of the McDonald's because one of his friends, they were all over 80 at the time,
00:11:29
tried to throw a chair at one of the other friends. Oh, shit. Oh, they were like the old
00:11:34
man coffee group at McDonald's. Talking shit. Aren't their chairs bolted to the ground for
00:11:39
that reason? Probably. Yeah. Where are their loose chairs at McDonald's? This is a questionable
00:11:44
story. Your grandpa lies. My grandparents were the coolest. Hannah. Hannah, I'm so sorry
00:11:50
what I said about your grandpa I was I was lying I the liar here Wow I love Botox animal in your face in your mom face Just get little whiskers Can I have it here here here and here And in my pupils
00:12:05
Hi, this is Tori Spelling from Miss Spelling. Forget everything you know about hair color.
00:12:12
The mess, the smell, the damage. Madison Reed is female founded, female led, and has completely transformed the hair color experience.
00:12:22
Their award-winning formulas are crafted in Italy with ingredients that care for your hair, delivering rich, multidimensional results.
00:12:32
And you choose how you color. Get salon gorgeous results at home or let a pro do it for you at a Madison Reed Hair Color Bar.
00:12:42
The future of hair color is here at Madison Reed. Try it today and get 20% off of your next order or service.
00:12:51
Go to madison-reed.com slash Tori and use code Tori20. Hey, everyone. It's Cal Penn, host of Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club.
00:13:04
This week on the podcast, I'm sitting down with Will Wheaton, who played Gordy Lachance in Stand By Me 40 years ago
00:13:11
and now narrates Stephen King's The Body, the novella that inspired it all. We talk about what it's like to return to a story that shaped his life,
00:13:19
channeling his memories of River Phoenix in the recording booth and why the friendships you have at 12
00:13:25
might be the most important ones you'll ever have. I know Gordy Lachiance. I am Gordy Lachiance.
00:13:33
Like, I mean, even when I was a little kid, I was Gordy Lachiance when I didn't know it.
00:13:38
Listen to Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:13:44
The following ad is sponsored by Pets Best Insurance Services. you knew right away he's perfect the one for you those puppy dog eyes that cute little button nose
00:13:54
you don't even mind the drool when you find your perfect match in a dog or cat the love is
00:14:00
unconditional your budget on the other hand has realistic limits help protect your heart and your
00:14:05
wallet with pet insurance from pets best with plans starting from less than a dollar a day
00:14:09
you can get up to 90 cash back on eligible vet bills pets best makes it easy to pick a plan that
00:14:15
works for you and your bank account. Find the perfect match for your perfect match at PetsBest.com.
00:14:21
Pet insurance products offered and administered by PetsBest Insurance Services, LLC are underwritten
00:14:24
by American Pet Insurance Company or Independence American Insurance Company. For terms and
00:14:27
conditions, visit www.petsbest.com backslash policy. Products are underwritten by American
00:14:32
Pet Insurance Company, Independence American Insurance Company, or MS Transverse Insurance
00:14:35
Company and administered by PetsBest Insurance Services, LLC. One dollar a day premium based
00:14:39
on 2024 average new policyholder data for accident and illness plans. Pets age zero to 10.
00:14:45
The subject line of this email is horse camp run by drug dealers. Perfect. So it just starts so period.
00:14:53
I'm a city girl from Queens, New York, who had spent summers in the Catskills visiting my mom's family and generally annoying my father by fighting with my sister.
00:15:02
Our usual sibling bonding, but with a forest aesthetic. My sister was obsessed with horses and I was still undecided with them at that point.
00:15:10
My dad would take us to a place that claimed to be a ranch when it really was a bar with some horses out back.
00:15:17
I want to go there. Lying to kids just to get them to a bar. You love it here. Go over there.
00:15:22
Dad, it's a parking lot. I'm sure this was his place of choice because it was cheap.
00:15:28
This summer I was 10. We went on a ride early enough in July for my sister to see their camp flyer, a week-long camp where one could learn horsemanship skills.
00:15:38
My parents caved to my sister. And of course, if one of us was going, both of us were going.
00:15:42
Horse camp was, in fact, just a bunch of girls cleaning the stables and running around unsupervised for four hours a day with horses.
00:15:50
As a 10-year-old, I learned two things. Number one, horses are dicks. Very true.
00:15:55
Very true. They're like worse than cats. They're so tense and strong and finicky.
00:16:01
Not in a bad way. Like, good for them. But like, what are we trying to do? Well, and also bad for nine-year-old girls who think that they're going to walk up and touch their cheek and make friends forever.
00:16:10
No, horses don't fucking play that way. And then they put their head back and they show those huge veneers.
00:16:15
I have those. And they eat your apple. I do too. As a 10-year-old, I learned two things.
00:16:20
One, horses are dicks. Two, it's not called horse camp. Did you know that horses...
00:16:25
It's not called horse camp. Did you know that horses who don't like saddles will bloat out their stomachs when you're putting them on?
00:16:33
Cool. I've told you that story of my cousin Stevie and I riding his horse lady who just walked around in a field.
00:16:40
Yeah. Free and easy. Free range. She's like, fuck these kids. Stevie put a saddle on her one day and she blowed it out like this.
00:16:46
So I was riding behind him and we just very slowly went all the way over to the side and then fell on the ground.
00:16:52
That horse was laughing so hard in its horse language at you. Do not try me. Yeah.
00:16:56
I'm not doing this with you. I learned this on day two when trotting and suddenly my whole saddle went sliding sideways on the horse.
00:17:03
Shit. The amazing part is your feet are in the stirrups. Right. So you're going with it.
00:17:08
Crash. I wish that was the worst of it, but two days later when on a trail, my horse was bitten by the horse behind me.
00:17:14
Horses apparently do this when they have beef and took off into the woods at high speeds.
00:17:20
What I had learned at horse camp was echoing through my brain. The lead expert said day one, if anything happens on your horse and you are scared, all caps, do not scream.
00:17:30
If you scream, it will make things worse, which is why as I pulled the reins over my head and prayed to the horse gods to make this animal stop, I did not let out a squeak.
00:17:39
I waited 20 minutes to be found and jumped off the horse to let out a string of profanities, quite impressive for a 10-year-old, and refused to get back on, stating, I hate horse camp.
00:17:51
Only to be told horses don go to camp This is equestrian riding camp I literally like drop the reins and walk into the river Float away See on the flip motherfucker
00:18:05
Now I'm going to rafting camp. Once I got home, I learned the next important lesson.
00:18:10
Whatever the camp is called, if my dad paid for a full week, I was going back for the full week.
00:18:15
After finishing out the week, I in fact found a great respect for horses and the knowledge I never wanted to ride one again.
00:18:21
And my sister went back to this place for years until it was finally shut down because the owners were arrested for selling meth out of the bar.
00:18:31
Apparently, the side hustle of horse camp wasn't enough for them. So remember, always check your horse's saddle before getting on and maybe check that the camp that you're sending your kids to isn't run by drug dealers.
00:18:43
Wow. And that's just signed C. Great story because you could have just told us about the meth dealers.
00:18:48
That's a great story. Yeah. That was great. All of it. I'll never get on a horse.
00:18:52
I'm personally like I have a healthy fear of horses and I think people should for their children too.
00:18:57
Yeah. Like it takes one gardener snake to fucking spook a horse. The problem is with us farm people.
00:19:02
We fucking love being on horses. And I went to horse camp with my friend Jennifer Gearing and most of those things happened to me.
00:19:09
And we were taught vaulting, which is when you run beside the horse and jump onto it.
00:19:15
Don't do that. And like we had to do a show at the end to show people we could do it.
00:19:20
Book camp. book and cat camp sounds great they must have that they must that's called the public library
00:19:26
okay get a library card grandma's house get a library card here is a 30 plus year old summer
00:19:33
ghost story oh hey karen in georgia not a day one listener but so glad i found you when i did
00:19:39
the sound of your voices keeps me sane on a daily basis an escape from the shit show we call reality
00:19:45
in 2025. Fuck yeah, baby. Stay sane. Today I was listening to Minisode 441 and you asked for
00:19:50
summer ghost stories. Yes, because we're like, anyone can tell a winter ghost story.
00:19:55
We're like, is Arizona haunted? Because it's hot. Oh, right. So there must not be ghosts there.
00:20:00
Do you have a summer? We did that. I thought about sending this story in several times before,
00:20:05
but your specific call for summer ghost stories finally gave me the kick in the ass. I needed to
00:20:09
write this all down. Finally. Every summer as a kid, we would do a two week family vacation on
00:20:14
Cape Cod. Sounds amazing. Rich. We rented various houses over the years, but there was one in
00:20:20
particular that we returned to several years in a row, starting in the summer of 1991 when I was 12.
00:20:26
Built in 1826 as a Methodist church, the house was essentially one cavernous open space with a few
00:20:33
flimsy half walls added in to create bedroom areas. The worst. Because if those walls don't go all the
00:20:39
way up to the ceiling, you can hear your parents fucking. I mean, or just anybody farting. I mean,
00:20:44
It's the worst. Okay. Above the living space was the kind of attic that just gives you the chills the moment you put your foot on the stairs.
00:20:51
Yeah. Cape Cod's probably so haunted. So it's all those sailors and seamen. Yes.
00:20:57
Pirates. The attic was set up as an artist studio. From what I understood, the artist had died and his children wanted it to remain completely untouched.
00:21:05
Paintbrushes and canvases were still laid out as if he would return at any moment.
00:21:10
Most nights, my sister and I would hear noises coming from the attic. It sounded like heavy footsteps and creaking floorboards.
00:21:16
I tried to never be the last one awake at night, but sometimes all I could do was lay there waiting for the first terrifying creek.
00:21:23
Were you trying to rush off to sleep? Yeah, you're like, ambient, ambient, ambient.
00:21:26
Get me out of here. I got to go. Sometimes the footsteps would wake me up at midnight.
00:21:33
My sister and I would often run to each other's beds, and she's seven years older than I am, so I knew I wasn't crazy, or wake our parents when we got too freaked out.
00:21:41
my way too chill dad would always explain it away as probably a squirrel in the walls they never heard
00:21:48
a thing and i don't think they believe us to this day i thought of the house often since then last
00:21:52
december after a visit with my parents who eventually bought a house not that one thank god
00:21:57
and retired to cape cod i started doing a deep dive on the history of the house no one remembered
00:22:02
the address but i found it by digging through google maps and online historical archives so
00:22:07
satisfying. In 1925, an artist named C. Arnold Slade purchased the abandoned 1826 Methodist
00:22:14
Meeting House and had it dismantled and reconstructed on Savage Point, the blustery
00:22:19
hilltop location of his home and compound of cottages. He took basically a Methodist church
00:22:25
and moved it and rebuilt it somewhere else. Put it back up. Yeah, that's like begging to be haunted.
00:22:32
The church was turned into a studio and exhibition space where Slade displayed copies of his
00:22:36
iconic war paintings, as well as his current portraits and New England landscapes. Slade's
00:22:42
summer rental cottages and quirky church studio became known as Sladeville. When Slade died in
00:22:47
1961, his wife sold Sladeville to an artist, Peter Hooven. Hooven lived in the house and used the
00:22:54
attic as his studio in his death. Do you want to guess what year? Yep, you guessed it. 1991,
00:23:00
the summer we started renting there. So the second artist died the year they started,
00:23:05
and then they were like, whoop, let's bring in this family for a vacay. They were the next ones in.
00:23:09
Yeah, and he died there. He died young, only 57 years old, and all of my internet sleuthing
00:23:14
has brought zero answers about how he passed. I now have no doubt that there was at least one,
00:23:20
if not two, spirits inhabiting the space above us all those nights, plus churches in Massachusetts in the 1820s,
00:23:26
probably lots more spooky shit there. Yeah. Stay sexy and don't vacation in super haunted,
00:23:31
abandoned churches turned deceased artist studios. I can't believe I got that. elona she her it's really creepy that only the kids heard it oh for sure that's like well now
00:23:43
we know we're dealing with ghosts yeah hello beautiful i'm amy eric founder of madison reed
00:23:50
a hair color company i named after my daughter forget everything you know about hair color the mess the smell the hassle the damage we're female
00:24:00
and female-led, we've transformed the hair color experience with ingredients that care for your hair
00:24:05
and award-winning color on your terms at home or at our hair color bars. The future of hair color is here at Madison Reed.
00:24:18
Hey everyone, it's Cal Penn, host of Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club.
00:24:24
This week on the podcast, I'm sitting down with Will Wheaton, who played Gordy Lachance in Stand By Me 40 years ago
00:24:31
and now narrates Stephen King's The Body, the novella that inspired it all. We talk about what it's like to return to a story that shaped his life,
00:24:40
channeling his memories of River Phoenix and the recording booth, and why the friendships you have at 12 might be the most important ones you'll ever have.
00:24:49
I know Gordy Lachance. I am Gordy Lachance. Like, I mean, even when I was a little kid, I was Gordy Lachance.
00:24:56
when I didn't know it. Listen to Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club on the iHeart Radio app
00:25:02
or wherever you get your podcasts. Protect your pet with insurance from PetsBest.
00:25:07
Plans start from less than a dollar a day. Visit PetsBest.com. Pet insurance products
00:25:12
offered and administered by PetsBest Insurance Services, LLC, are underwritten by American Pet Insurance Company
00:25:16
or Independence American Insurance Company. For terms and conditions, visit www.petsbest.com
00:25:21
backslash policy. Products are underwritten by American Pet Insurance Company, Independence American Insurance Company
00:25:25
or MS Transverse Insurance Company and administered by Pets Best Insurance Services, LLC.
00:25:29
One dollar a day premium based on 2024 average new policyholder data for accident and illness plans
00:25:33
Pets age zero to ten. The subject line of my last email is welcome to Squirrel Town, USA. Hi, friends.
00:25:41
Is that too presumptuous? It feels right. That's in parentheses. And then it says Olean, New York is about 1.5
00:25:49
hours south of Buffalo and for some reason believes it has the most squirrels in the world. There's absolutely no way they could know this.
00:25:57
Just one squirrel running. He's just everywhere all at once. He's so busy. He's amped up. Yeah. There's absolutely no way that they could know this,
00:26:05
but I think they needed something to cling on to so that they could feel important.
00:26:09
For whatever reason, squirrels were the answer. We all need something. Yeah. And squirrels work. This got extremely out of hand when one day I was in high school
00:26:17
and I awoke to the news that someone had planted 28 four foot tall concrete statues of squirrels around the city. And then all caps, 28. Each
00:26:28
was painted differently to represent either where it was placed or just whatever the hell the artist
00:26:33
felt like doing. For example, there was a Ronald McDonald one outside of McDonald's.
00:26:39
A Ronald McDonald squirrel. There was a banker outside the bank until someone stole the concrete
00:26:45
sack of money it was holding and then they had to move it inside A Starry Night one for shits and gigs oh it vink a starry night squirrel a wizard of oz one and one just titled hey mom guess what that dedicated to the troops that might be a reference
00:27:04
that might be personal yeah true our chamber of commerce had everything when it came to squirrel
00:27:10
swag including t-shirts that said peace love squirrels ornaments card games maps on where
00:27:16
you find all of them and you guessed it a squirrel calendar wow since it's a small town and people
00:27:22
got bored a lot of these have been vandalized or stolen of course i love an artist blitz can we get
00:27:29
artist blitz emails in your small town where artists just fucking do a thing overnight and
00:27:34
you're like that felt like it was like city hall commissioned like they've kind of forced it i hope
00:27:38
they asked for the public to vote on the month how much did that cost okay go on i don't know i
00:27:43
Yeah, we'd like a full cost report, please. Immediately. So lost or stolen, vandalized or stolen, which honestly good for them for running off with those because they probably were heavy as fuck.
00:27:53
But we definitely still have enough to live up to our name. To this day, I have no idea who Greenland's this project or if they're now gallivanting around to other towns pitching these ideas.
00:28:03
I escaped Squirrel Hell, USA and now live in Denver with my husband and dog, Butter.
00:28:08
Aww. Butter's a good dog, man. I turned my husband into a murderino early on. And now almost every time we're in the car, he says, can we listen to murder?
00:28:16
And I turn on the most recent episode of MFM. Oh, that's beautiful. A drag along.
00:28:22
Stay sexy and don't steal concrete money from a squirrel. Taylor. Wow. She did it.
00:28:28
She did it. I love that report. Also, because that's a little bit of like, it feels like the Circleville Pumpkin Festival vibe.
00:28:35
That, yeah, for sure. Or the cocaine bear. You know what I mean? Yeah, we want to know what's going on in your town.
00:28:40
This is our thing. Yeah, we love it. Leave us alone. Or come by and say hi. Or come by.
00:28:44
My last one is a trash siblings story, but it's so, so funny. Hi, I just listened to Minisode 443 about the snake in the bathroom.
00:28:53
Remember the little kid put the snake in his sister's bathroom when she was in the bathroom?
00:28:57
And remember that I, too, have experienced a snake in the bathroom. But that's not what this story is about.
00:29:01
Because when the writer said that her four-year-old brother put the snake in the bathroom,
00:29:05
I immediately murmured trash siblings. And it's the quotes are like this where ones up, you know, siblings.
00:29:11
Sure. To myself. And it unlocked a long forgotten memory like open sesame. So here we go.
00:29:18
This is such a good idea. Trash siblings. I just want to say this. And my sister loves to tell the story.
00:29:24
I used to have this magical gift when I was like around five or six of my parents would be like at a restaurant with their friends.
00:29:30
And we had to entertain ourselves in basically like an old Italian dark restaurant.
00:29:35
In the like entryway. In the entryway. Stay out of everyone's way. play with the cigarette machine every time I pulled I would get a pack of cigarettes every single time that to me is a good trash sibling story where my sister had to take me to the bathroom It like well I take you by to play the cigarette machine and see what happens You scored big on the cigarette machine
00:29:51
So here we go. I am the youngest of five siblings all born three years apart in the 70s and 80s.
00:29:56
You can make your own assumptions about my parents' parenting style. Was I forgotten at the grocery store more than once?
00:30:02
Absolutely. Did I sit in the way, way back at the station wagon without a seatbelt?
00:30:07
Sure did. Yeah. As the youngest of five, I was generally expected to tag along and try not to get myself killed.
00:30:13
So when I woke up one morning and told my family that a bat attacked me in my sleep,
00:30:18
they immediately brushed it off. When I insisted that, all caps, a bat was in my room, it flew down, landed on my head,
00:30:26
and flew away, they simply gaslit me and told me that I was dreaming. This went on for weeks, and not a single sibling believed me.
00:30:33
Trash! Well, what do you know? a few weeks later while we were all in the family room watching a movie a fucking bat flew in hell
00:30:42
yeah finally he's making his fucking entrance yeah letting everyone know he's not a ghost bat and i'm
00:30:47
not i love it it's like everybody else is gonna have their bat reaction right and they're just
00:30:52
like oh we're friends already this old thing that you said didn't exist danny he and i are friends
00:30:57
yeah and you guys are so scared danny the bat and i go way back and i've literally been telling you
00:31:02
about it that's right no no you're dreaming i wish i had a better name than danny oh well just
00:31:06
Just try it again. What about like Herbert? Herbert the bat. What about something would it be?
00:31:10
Oh, because it would be Bert the bat. There we go. You see how it just puts it right up there?
00:31:15
Bert the bat. There we go. We did it. Yeah. I like that we were talking like that, like it's going to get cut out or something.
00:31:21
Never. Okay. A fucking bat fluid. My dad immediately tried to catch it while we all squealed and my mom looked for something
00:31:27
to put it in if my dad, in fact, did catch it. And me, I just sat there like the smug little kid I was because I fucking told you so.
00:31:35
Yes. We never did catch the bat and assumed it eventually died in the attic or flew out one of the windows.
00:31:41
Gross. To this day, my siblings still say that there was never a bat, even though they saw it with their own eyes.
00:31:48
Yep. I'm now in my late 30s and what I would consider to be a full grown adult. But to my siblings, I will always be the baby.
00:31:54
Sigh. Thank you for being the soundtrack to my life. I've been listening since the very beginning and I'm so grateful to have your steady voices in my life.
00:32:01
Stay sexy and just accept being the youngest. We can't. No, we won't. We can't. Emily.
00:32:07
Hi from Germany. P.S. The snake in my bathroom was a water moccasin. Pretty dangerous and scary.
00:32:13
Weeks of sleep was lost until the snake was found by a drunken friend who grabbed it and threw it in the pillowcase.
00:32:19
Oh, to be young and dumb. So we got snakes. We got bats. That whole bat story. And then they just touch a water moccasin story and leave?
00:32:26
Are they bad? Emily. I don't know water moccasins. Oh, they're completely poisonous.
00:32:30
They kill you. Oh, shit. Yeah, those are bad ones. Jesus, Emily. Well. Victory What a victorious email that was Send us your trash sibling stories whatever you think that means whatever it means to your heart and to your soul And I think the burden of being the youngest sibling stories can go on forever
00:32:46
We need them. I mean, I got used to being like tied up in a sleeping bag to be tortured.
00:32:53
But I was like, I'm going to like it. And I just sit in the sleeping bag in the dark.
00:32:56
Like I can breathe. I'm fine. I never thought of that twist-a-roo of like, I'm enjoying myself.
00:33:02
Yeah. That's the only way you can get them. Well, thanks for enjoying yourself, everyone, for listening.
00:33:06
Yeah, and stay sexy. And don't get murdered. Goodbye. Elvis, do you want a cookie?
00:33:13
This has been an Exactly Right production. Our senior producers are Alejandra Keck and Molly Smith.
00:33:23
Our editor is Aristotle Acevedo. This episode was mixed by Liana Squalachi. Email your hometowns to myfavoritemurder at gmail.com.
00:33:31
And follow the show on Instagram at myfavoritemurder. Listen to My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:33:38
And now you can watch us on Exactly Right's YouTube page. And while you're there, please like and subscribe.
00:33:43
Goodbye. Goodbye. Hey everyone, it's Cal Penn. I'm inviting you to join the best sounding book club you've ever heard with my podcast, Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club.
00:34:00
Every episode I nerd out with amazing guests and dive into the best new audiobooks available on Audible.
00:34:07
It's the book club for your ears. Listen to Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:34:20
Paramount Plus is now the home of all your BET favorites. What? With all new episodes of Tyler Perry's Divorce Sisters.
00:34:28
You've always liked a little drama. Plus a whole new world of movies like Gladiator 2.
00:34:32
Now I will control an empire. Original series like The Chi. Just make sure we protect each other.
00:34:38
And live sports like UFC. Welcome to the history books. New home, same family. Your BET favorites are now on Paramount+.
00:34:47
Subscribe now. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project.
00:34:54
One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales. and somehow none of them talk to each other.
00:35:01
That's where Odoo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together.
00:35:08
From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all-in-one powerful platform.
00:35:13
No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs. And best of all, no spreadsheets.
00:35:19
Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system.
00:35:24
Try for free today at odoo.com slash iHeartRadio. That's O-D-O-O-O dot com slash iHeartRadio.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most chaotic
  • 60
    Most shocking
  • 60
    Most surprising

Episode Highlights

  • Dr. Death the Cowboy
    A charming neurosurgeon leaves a trail of broken bodies instead of healing.
    “He promised to heal them. Instead, he left a trail of broken bodies.”
    @ 00m 48s
    September 08, 2025
  • God the Mother Cult Encounter
    A college student narrowly escapes a cult with ties to human trafficking.
    “Apparently, this God the Mother group had ties to human trafficking.”
    @ 09m 00s
    September 08, 2025
  • Horse Camp Run by Drug Dealers
    A girl learns the hard way that her horse camp was a front for drug dealing.
    “Always check that the camp isn't run by drug dealers.”
    @ 18m 43s
    September 08, 2025
  • Haunted History
    An artist's studio turned haunted house reveals chilling secrets from the past.
    “Yeah, that's like begging to be haunted.”
    @ 22m 25s
    September 08, 2025
  • Squirrel Town, USA
    A small town's obsession with squirrels leads to a bizarre art installation.
    “28 four foot tall concrete statues of squirrels around the city.”
    @ 26m 12s
    September 08, 2025
  • The Bat Incident
    A childhood tale of disbelief turns into a shocking revelation when a bat appears.
    “They simply gaslit me and told me that I was dreaming.”
    @ 30m 20s
    September 08, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • He promised to heal them. Instead, he left a trail of broken bodies.
    MFM Minisode 452
  • Stay sexy and if something seems too good to be true, it probably is.
    MFM Minisode 452
  • Horses are dicks.
    MFM Minisode 452
  • Stay sexy and don't vacation in super haunted, abandoned churches turned deceased artist studios.
    MFM Minisode 452
  • Stay sexy and don't steal concrete money from a squirrel.
    MFM Minisode 452
  • I love that report.
    MFM Minisode 452

Key Moments

  • Greed and Betrayal00:51
  • Cult Encounter09:00
  • Horse Camp Reality16:21
  • Drug Dealer Revelation18:36
  • Haunted House21:05
  • Artist's Legacy22:02
  • Squirrel Statues26:12
  • Unexpected Bat30:13

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown