Search Captions & Ask AI

MFM Minisode 454

September 22, 2025 /

This episode of My Favorite Murder features stories about a Wisconsin hunting trip, a college stalker, and a grandmother's prank. The hosts, Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, read listener-submitted tales filled with humor and horror.

The first story recounts a Wisconsin family hunting trip where a 13-year-old boy, Uncle Gary, ends up drunk and inadvertently closes the door on a neighbor whose house is on fire. The adults, fueled by alcohol, rush to help, leading to chaotic and humorous moments.

Next, a listener shares a chilling account of a stalker targeting sorority girls at a New York college. The anonymous stalker sends threatening messages and even posts the girls' numbers online, leading to police involvement and eventual FBI tracking.

The episode also includes a heartwarming story about a grandmother who faked her death to scare off bullies, showcasing her cleverness and resilience. This story highlights the bond between the listener and her grandmother.

Throughout the episode, Karen and Georgia provide their signature banter, making light of the dark themes while engaging with the audience's stories.

TLDR

Listeners share wild stories of hunting mishaps, a college stalker, and a clever grandmother's prank.

Episode

23:53
00:00:00
This is exactly right. Isn't some far off concept? It's already here. Next starts now.
00:00:33
Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Goodbye. When a charming neurosurgeon rode into Frontier Town
00:00:39
selling a persona of confidence and care, patients trusted him. He wore cowboy boots in the operating room
00:00:45
and became sought after by patients. He promised to heal them. Instead, he left a trail of broken bodies.
00:00:51
This is a story of greed, betrayal, and a fight for justice. Listen to Dr. Death the Cowboy wherever you get your podcasts
00:00:58
or binge the entire series right now only with Audible. Goodbye. Here's another mouthwatering recipe idea
00:01:06
from Maricon, the world's finest rice vinegar. Try a Maricon hot chicken sandwich with pickled cucumbers
00:01:12
made with chilies, garlic, and the vibrant zesty flavor of Maricon Genuine Brewed Rice Vinegar.
00:01:19
Or go sweet and savory with Maricon Seasoned Gourmet, a flavor bomb for veggies and grilled proteins.
00:01:25
Get the green label for Genuine Brewed or the orange label for seasoned gourmet.
00:01:29
Then check out ricevinegar.com for more delicious recipes, because the food you love is better with Marikon.
00:01:36
Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile, with a message for everyone paying big wireless way too much.
00:01:41
Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just $15 a month.
00:01:48
Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments, but that's weird. Okay, one judgment.
00:01:52
Anyway, give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Hello and welcome to my favorite murder, the mini-sode.
00:02:27
We read you your stories. Are you ready? Begin. Should I go first? Sure. This is called Rural Wisconsin Shenanigans, Alcoholism and a Fire.
00:02:37
Perfect. Pleasantries, pleasantries. I love MFM and listening to your banter. Thank you for being a part of my life for the past eight years.
00:02:45
Let's dive in because it's long but worth it. My family is very Wisconsin, like very Wisconsin, where beer runs in our veins, our favorite hobby is fishing, and our kids grow up next to hunting rifles.
00:02:58
I heard the story after a couple of heavily poured margaritas at a family gathering.
00:03:03
My grandfather, who I nicknamed Bapa when I was little, began the story by explaining the morning ritual, a shot of Jägermeister.
00:03:11
Oh, wow. What a start. The harsh shots were taken at dawn in a forgotten cabin on a rough road before Bapa, his 13-year-old son, a.k.a. my Uncle Gary.
00:03:22
My great-uncle Bobby, Charlie, and my cousin Parker set off with loaded rifles into the forest.
00:03:28
What they were hunting has been lost to history. Sorry. They were doing Jaeger shots before they go hunting.
00:03:33
Uh-huh. That's serious. Ugh. Can you imagine? What a start. It's like swallowing your toothpaste spit and then going to kill animals.
00:03:41
Yeah. Look, no judgments. A lot of people like it, but that's what we're here for.
00:03:46
It's not for me. At this point in telling the story, my papa needed a margarita refill, so my now adult Uncle Gary took over.
00:03:53
Uncle Gary explained that the day ended with the adults handing his 13-year-old self a six-pack of beer and telling him to entertain himself and his cousin on the porch.
00:04:03
A six-pack to a 13-year-old. It's a good way to babysit kids. Yeah, right. Like, go be drunk.
00:04:10
Go be drunk. On the porch. With an incredulous laugh, my adult Uncle Gary continued to say that they finished the six-pack, but the sun hadn't set yet.
00:04:18
So he stumbled into the wooden structure to ask what to do next. Like an old 80s cliche, he was handed another six-pack and told to return when he finished it.
00:04:26
Oh, shit. It's unclear the amount of the next pack that he drank, but he remembers suddenly being inside the cabin and hearing a dreamy knock on the front door.
00:04:36
Neighbors? My uncle Gary boozily opened the door to find a middle-aged man sweating and frantically waving his hands.
00:04:42
The man at the door stated that his house was across the street and on fire. With no thoughts in his brain, my uncle blinked and then closed the door on the poor, panicked man.
00:04:53
The shit-faced 13-year-old answers the door. No, no, can't. The man continued to knock intensely on the door until one of the now-plastered adults finally noticed the disturbance.
00:05:06
Uncle Bobby and Charlie heard that the house across the street was on fire and fueled by alcohol,
00:05:11
ran into the burning building to check for animals and turn off the gas line. I'm sorry, check for animals on the weekend where they go to kill animals?
00:05:18
Pets are different, don't you know? Vicious. Vicious. True. We don't want animals to die.
00:05:24
Wait, what have you been doing all day? In real time at the margarita bar, my Uncle Gary turns to my bapa,
00:05:29
who sheepishly returned to the conversation, refill, drink in hand. My Bapa sighs but continues telling the increasingly ridiculous story.
00:05:36
My theater-inclined Bapa grabbed the neighbor by the shoulders and began to sing the first song that popped into his head at the time.
00:05:43
This little light of mine, I'm going to let it shine. So shit-faced. I mean. Imagine a strong tenor voice carrying across the street, staring at a burning house while praising the light.
00:05:53
A roaring siren interrupts the poorly chosen ballad as the fire truck appears down the road but stops short That when everyone realizes something is blocking the road My 13 Uncle Gary was lying drunkenly passed out in front of the fire truck
00:06:07
Jesus Christ. He doesn't know how he got there or anything else about that night, but he was moved, the house was put out, and no one got tickets.
00:06:16
Or killed. Or CPS called on them. Right. Somehow, all family members involved turn out to be okay human beings and productive members of society.
00:06:23
Hey. Hey. I love them all to death and will never trade their recklessness for anything.
00:06:28
Wisconsin may be rough and tough, but the beauty of Wisconsin's nature is unparalleled.
00:06:33
Bring a gun into it. I mean. Stay sexy and don't give your 13-year-old a couple of six-packs.
00:06:39
C. I mean, it is true that, like, if you're going away for a hunting weekend and that's what you're doing.
00:06:45
Yeah. And you're in nature. There's a safety to it. Yeah. You're just kind of out and about.
00:06:50
But intense. Yeah. Well, this is a bit of a left turn because this is more serious. The subject line of this email is sorority stalker. It says, Hi, Karen in Georgia and pets. I spent my freshman and sophomore years of college at a state university in upstate New York. I thought my whole life I was already living in upstate New York, apparently living two hours north of NYC does not count as upstate. I would have thought it would.
00:07:16
But then I found myself an hour away from the Canadian border in a small college town that perpetually smelled of cow shit.
00:07:23
That's how I grew up. Anyway, Greek life was a huge part of the culture there. So practically everyone was either in a frat or a sorority or knew someone who was.
00:07:32
Being such a small school, word started to travel fast my sophomore year that there was an anonymous stalker on campus who was terrorizing one group of sorority girls in particular.
00:07:42
About a dozen girls in the Sigma Kappa sorority had been receiving ominous warnings and threatening text messages from an unknown number saying things like,
00:07:52
It's not safe out there tonight, Kappas, and I'm not the threat, but harm is coming.
00:07:59
At one point, he even texted one of the girls saying, I'm in the house. Oh, my God.
00:08:04
Yeah. At the time, no one could figure out who this person was or how they found the girls' numbers.
00:08:08
but it was pretty apparent that the anonymous texter somehow knew the sorority's social calendar as well.
00:08:14
At one point, Sigma Kappa had planned a wedding with their brother frat, which as far as I can remember was just a party where the girls were all white
00:08:22
and got fake married to a guy from the brother frat. Before the wedding, one of the girls got a message from the anonymous number saying,
00:08:29
I'm excited for the wedding. Hope you don't wear anything that can stain. Please don't cancel again. I want to have fun this time.
00:08:36
Creepy. So creepy. Later, he went on to say that he wanted to cause as much harm as possible, even if that resulted in death, and that he was willing to die by the police.
00:08:47
Needless to say, everyone on campus was pretty freaked out by this point. Parties were canceled.
00:08:52
Vague emails from the university administration were sent to students to alert them to a possible threat, and the university police got involved.
00:09:01
They tried to trace the number but found it was actually registered to a fake number generator online.
00:09:06
Some students tried calling it, and eventually one person got through, but whoever picked up on the other line was using a voice-changing app,
00:09:14
so they couldn't tell if the voice was someone they knew or not. From what a news article says, the conversation was pretty bizarre,
00:09:20
with the anonymous creep saying that he knew he was unstable, his parents were divorced, and that he was also on Xanax.
00:09:26
I remember some of my roommate's sorority sisters trying to add the number on Snapchat
00:09:31
to see if the person had their snap location on. I don't remember if that worked, but my guess was it didn't because the harassment stayed anonymous and it also got worse.
00:09:41
Pretty soon after the text started, some of the girls started receiving random phone calls from around five dozen men who are trying to solicit them for sex.
00:09:50
Oh, no. Turns out the anonymous texter had posted their phone numbers to a website advertising for sex workers.
00:09:57
After a while, the harassment started to narrow down to one sorority girl in particular.
00:10:01
She received an anonymous package in the mail containing a book entitled I'm Watching You.
00:10:07
And she even started to receive drugs like cocaine and meth in the mail, which the anonymous stalker notified the school about in an email in an attempt to get her arrested.
00:10:17
Holy shit. The crazy part is at that time I was working in the university mailroom and I didn't even know that.
00:10:23
I vaguely remember the other student workers around that time talking about the police coming in to confiscate someone's package because it had drugs in it.
00:10:30
but I had just assumed some dumbass had mailed themselves weed or something like that.
00:10:35
Our boss, who was not a student, had a habit of smelling suspicious packages and then calling the police if it smelled even vaguely like weed.
00:10:42
She was lame as hell. Long story short, the FBI got involved and tracked the creep to Long Island.
00:10:48
He ended up being one of the girls controlling ex-boyfriends who just could not get over the breakup and obviously had some serious mental health issues.
00:10:59
When they arrested him, they also found an AR-15 semi-automatic rifle, which he owned legally, of course.
00:11:06
It actually was really terrifying to think about what this guy might have been capable of if he wasn't caught in time.
00:11:12
And all I can say is I'm glad I transferred shortly after that, not only because that school was the target of a crazy stalker potential murderer, but as it turns out, it was also absolutely chock full of asbestos, too.
00:11:24
Holy shit. say sexy and don't terrorize an entire group of people just because you can't handle rejection
00:11:30
abby oh my god and then abby left a note the story got picked up by page six it was so bad
00:11:38
that is before it got like really kind of personal i thought it was just going to be one of the girl
00:11:43
other girls in the sorority you know what i mean just like sending threatening texts just like being
00:11:47
an asshole to somebody yeah but that is fucking scary it also like to do it to an entire sorority is so Ted Bundy coded if I may use that language it like if I against one woman I against all women Yeah Kind of a thing Yeah It fucked up So fucked up
00:12:06
Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same premium wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying.
00:12:14
It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today.
00:12:21
I'm told it's super easy to do at MintMobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan, equivalent to $15 per month required.
00:12:30
Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra.
00:12:34
Default terms at MintMobile.com. Hi, this is Tori Spelling from Miss Spelling. Forget everything you know about hair color.
00:12:43
The mess, the smell, the damage. Madison Reed is female founded, female led and has completely transformed the hair color experience.
00:12:54
Their award winning formulas are crafted in Italy with ingredients that care for your hair, delivering rich, multidimensional results.
00:13:03
And you choose how you color. Get salon gorgeous results at home or let a pro do it for you at a Madison Reed hair color bar.
00:13:13
The future of hair color is here at Madison Reed. Try it today and get 20% off of your next order or service.
00:13:22
Go to madison-reed.com slash Tori and use code Tori20. A lot of wellness routines start with motivation and then somewhere between week two and a half-use supplement draw.
00:13:34
Gruen's was created to make daily nutrition simpler. Instead of pills or chalky green drinks, Grooms packs over 20 essential vitamins and minerals, greens and prebiotics into a snack pack of delicious gummies.
00:13:46
It feels approachable and not demanding. The convenient, comprehensive formula supports gut health, beauty, energy, immunity, recovery and cognition in one daily habit.
00:13:55
Grooms contains six grams of fiber, which is more than two cups of broccoli. And the ingredients in Grooms are backed by 35,000 research publications, which is part of what makes the formula so intentional.
00:14:06
Gruens is vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, nut-free and made without artificial colors or flavors
00:14:11
plus it's methylated so key nutrients like B12 and folate are in forms your body can actually use
00:14:17
it's comprehensive nutrition designed for routines you can actually stick with get up to 52% off
00:14:23
with code CRY at gruns.co that's code CRY at G-R-U-N-S dot C-O this one's called
00:14:32
Trash Mom? Hi all, can't think of anything witty so I'll just jump in. Back when I was seven or eight, so 94 or 95, I had been out all day with
00:14:42
my mom and on the way home, we stopped at the Safeway to grab me a Lunchable and snacks.
00:14:48
I had a field trip the next day and we had to bring our own bag lunch. Fuck yeah, Lunchables.
00:14:52
Lunchables were banned at my sister's school because there's not one ounce of protein or
00:14:57
vitamins or anything in them. It's literally like just eating something bad. Yeah, I love it on a road trip. We shopped and checked out. But on our return to the car, my mother realized that she had locked the keys inside in the ignition. Oh, remember when you used to I did that before. This was before cell phones were a big thing. So she summoned help from people in the parking lot. Hey, everyone, gather around. I really need you. Help me. They tried to jimmy the door, but were unsuccessful. So what did my mom do? Send me with the courtesy driver that was outside of the store asking people if they need to help me.
00:15:32
rides. Is that a thing? I mean, I guess. That just sounds like a stranger offering people rides.
00:15:38
A weird stranger in a car who's like, I'll be the courtesy driver at the grocery store.
00:15:42
What is a courtesy driver? Is that like a small town thing maybe? It must be. Like older people
00:15:46
that might mean if they can't drive? Yeah. That's right. She sent me with a stranger to go home and
00:15:54
get her spare keys for my grandmother, Peggy. Thank you. Peggy. Luckily, I'm able to tell this
00:16:00
story. So I didn't get kidnapped or murdered. But how crazy is that? I don't understand why we both
00:16:05
didn't ride with him. Yes. Since I had to bring the key back. Maybe she thought someone would
00:16:10
break in and steal the car since the keys were in there. But better your daughter than the car.
00:16:16
I mean, I don't know how you deal with that. The thinking. And this person's seven or eight years
00:16:21
old, by the way. This isn't a teenager. It's a second grader. Yeah. Wow. Who knows? Stay sexy
00:16:28
and don't send your daughter with a strange man. Basic parenting 101. J, she, her.
00:16:35
There's so many layers. It's so many layers of questions. Yeah, but most importantly,
00:16:40
what the hell is a courtesy driver? And do you have stories about that as well? I think the older person thing sounds right.
00:16:46
Yeah. Or like people who got drunk at the Safeway and need like a designated driver.
00:16:51
There's all these people who just go to the liquor aisle and just start cracking beers.
00:16:56
Glugging. Also, you know, there's that like thought puzzle of there's a guy and he's got a fox and a chicken and a bag of grain and he has to get them all across the river on his raft.
00:17:05
And how do you do it so that the fox doesn't eat the chicken and the chicken doesn't eat the grain combinations?
00:17:12
That's like that with a seven-year-old and a courtesy driver and a mom and some keys.
00:17:18
And the keys in the ignition. Don't eat those keys. The subject line of this email is my grandma faked her death hometown.
00:17:25
What? And then it starts, okay, so maybe she didn't create some elaborate scheme for insurance fraud, but she definitely faked her death, and it's my favorite story.
00:17:34
My Abuelita Francis was born in 1929 and grew up in rural northern Colorado. When she was about 12 years old, she used to get picked on by a group of older girls while walking home from school.
00:17:45
These girls would call her names, kick her shins, pull her hair, push her, tease her, etc.
00:17:50
They were always really mean to her. One day, my Abuelita decided she'd had enough.
00:17:54
After school one afternoon She ran ahead of everyone and laid down In a ditch and waited she took her braids out and messed up her hair she even went as far as to pick the scabs on her shins
00:18:06
and smeared the blood all over her arms and legs gross but smart for a 12 year old what
00:18:12
she closed her eyes and lay in wait as she waited for the mean girls to walk past the shallow ditch
00:18:18
knowing that she would be within eyesight of the girls sure enough the group of girls walked by
00:18:23
and saw her quote-unquote lifeless body, they screamed and panicked until my abuelita sat up
00:18:30
laughing at them hysterically. Those girls never bothered her again. Yeah, my God. She's capable of anything.
00:18:38
My abuelita always said they probably thought she was crazy after that, but she didn't care
00:18:43
because they stopped picking on her. I have plenty of other grandma stories from her,
00:18:47
but this one is my favorite. She was my best friend and I miss her dearly. She was never
00:18:52
afraid to speak what was on her mind, and she was definitely down for a prank or two.
00:18:57
She was feisty but kind, my favorite person. Thanks for the best podcast ever and for being
00:19:02
wonderful humans. Stay sexy and don't pick your scabs. You might need them to fake your own death.
00:19:07
Rachel. Oh my God, I can feel that for some reason, like the scab picky things. Yes. Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same
00:19:20
premium wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities. So
00:19:26
do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today.
00:19:31
I'm told it's super easy to do at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan equivalent to $15 per month required.
00:19:39
Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. Default terms at mintmobile.com.
00:19:46
Hi, this is Tori Spelling from Miss Spelling. Forget everything you know about hair color, the mess, the smell, the damage.
00:19:55
Madison Reed is female founded, female led and has completely transformed the hair color experience.
00:20:04
Their award winning formulas are crafted in Italy with ingredients that care for your hair,
00:20:09
delivering rich, multidimensional results. And you choose how you color. Get salon gorgeous results at home or let a pro do it for you at a Madison Reed hair color bar.
00:20:23
The future of hair color is here at Madison Reed. Try it today and get 20% off of your next order or service.
00:20:31
Go to Madison-Reed.com slash Tori and use code Tori20. This is Vardy Divaluka from A Really Good Cry.
00:20:40
A lot of wellness routines start with motivation and then somewhere between week two and a half-use supplement draw.
00:20:46
Gruen's was created to make daily nutrition simpler. Instead of pills or chalky green drinks, Gruen's packs over 20 essential vitamins and minerals, greens and prebiotics into a snack pack of delicious gummies.
00:20:57
It feels approachable and not demanding. The convenient, comprehensive formula supports gut health, beauty, energy, immunity, recovery and cognition in one daily habit.
00:21:07
Grooms contains 6 grams of fiber, which is more than 2 cups of broccoli. And the ingredients in Grooms are backed by 35,000 research publications,
00:21:15
which is part of what makes the formula so intentional. Grooms is vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, nut-free, and made without artificial colors or flavors.
00:21:23
Plus, it's methylated, so key nutrients like B12 and folate are in forms your body can actually use.
00:21:29
It's comprehensive nutrition designed for routines you can actually stick with. Get up to 52% off with code CRY at grooms.co.
00:21:38
That's code CRY at G-R-U-N-S dot C-O. Unhinged team building questions. Hey, hello and hi.
00:21:49
Like the good lesbian I am, I've spent most of my life playing and coaching softball.
00:21:54
Nice. Getting a group of 18-year-old girls to work together on and off the field has always been a challenge.
00:21:59
But post-COVID, rough. It felt like they had completely forgotten how to connect with each other, even on a surface level.
00:22:06
So I started doing a question of the day during stretch circles in practice. It began innocently enough.
00:22:12
What's your dream vacation spot? If you could have any superpower, what would it be?
00:22:16
You're on a road trip and stop at a gas station. What are you grabbing? But after a month of this, my inner murderino slash unhinged self took the wheel.
00:22:24
And that's when things got fun. Some favorites. What's your personal version of hell?
00:22:29
top answers included having to turn around and high five people after bowling like new fear unlike i get it do you know that the first time i went bowling i was very stoned
00:22:40
i went to walk up bowl as a kid no the first time you went bowling you were old enough to be stoned
00:22:45
yeah it's in college i don't know why i'm like floored by that yeah we never did it and we had
00:22:50
a wonderful bowling alley but we just never did it there's a lot of activities i did a lot of as a
00:22:54
kid because my parents were divorced so my dad had to find things to do with us on the days that he
00:22:57
Oh, so bowling was one of them. Bowling and miniature golf, I did a lot of, yeah.
00:23:02
Point being just that when I went to stand up to go bowl, it looked like there was like a spotlight.
00:23:08
Because you know how it's like all dark here and then there's light up there? Oh, God.
00:23:11
And I didn't know how to do it. So I was like, I can't do it. And my friends were like, shut up, Karen.
00:23:15
It was like, honestly, you clearly have no problem with showing off and being in the spotlight.
00:23:20
But it like all became too much pressure and like so crazy. It was hilariously weird.
00:23:26
I just, I'm, that's. Delayed bowling experience. And then, and being stuck on a never ending Zoom call where no one hangs up and you're
00:23:34
forced to small talk until the end of time. God, I agree. Absolutely chilling. So true.
00:23:38
But my all time favorite was this question. Hypothetically, if you became a serial killer and ended up with a documentary about your
00:23:45
life, what's the one thing you did as a kid that your family would say was the first sign?
00:23:50
my answer when i was five years old i stripped my cat's tail with wire strippers what the actual fuck
00:23:58
my dad worked for at the time and these were very common around the house. I swear I'm okay and so was the cat.
00:24:04
Yeah. Okay. One of my players said she used to collect roly polies, build them little families
00:24:10
and keep them as friends. She would bring them to bed, name them, feed them the whole nine yards.
00:24:15
The first sign that something is not right. Yeah. These daily questions became something we all
00:24:21
looked forward to and it helped those girls bond in the weirdest, most beautiful way. Some of them
00:24:25
are still close friends to this day. My wife and I are beyond excited to see you in Seattle for
00:24:29
both shows. Hey, thank you. Thank you. That's nice. That is nice. They're going to be different
00:24:33
stories, I swear. If you hadn't had one already, you have to try a Seattle dog while you visit.
00:24:39
A delicious blend of cream cheese, onions, and hot dog. Don't knock it until you try it.
00:24:46
Blend. So are they saying the hot dog itself is blended up? No, it can't be. No, no. Like
00:24:51
chopped hot dogs? Like creamed with cream cheese. So it's like light pink cream cheese.
00:24:58
It's like a hot dog salad, like a ham salad. I need a picture of this. SSDGM, Amanda.
00:25:04
Amanda, amazing job. And also, I think when you're little, sometimes you like, I remember I got a kitten and I washed it because I gave it a bath.
00:25:15
Yeah. Washed it. And it freaked out, hated it. And then the next day it ran away and it was really little.
00:25:22
And I felt guilty about it for years and years. And then it was just like, yeah, you were just trying to get it had fleas on it.
00:25:28
Like you're just trying to. Yeah. But that's how you learn to treat animals nicely as you see the results of what you do.
00:25:36
I whiskers. I covered whiskers in barrettes once my childhood cat. Yeah. My mom, she remembers standing in the kitchen and seeing whiskers run by covered in barrettes.
00:25:47
This is how we know. Yeah. Okay. My last email is I married an urban legend. So it says of 80s legend riding bikes until dark roller skating around the cul catching snapping turtles in the local pond and running around past sunset with no supervision
00:26:11
You know, classic 80s chaos. As a kid, I always remembered my mom telling us the story of her
00:26:16
high school friend's son, who was my age. One day, he was jumping from bed to bed,
00:26:21
and he fell and landed on a pair of scissors, which punctured his lung and nicked his heart.
00:26:26
This accident nearly killed him, but thankfully he recovered after months in the hospital.
00:26:31
My mom used this tale as a constant warning. Don't jump on the bed. Don't leave scissors out.
00:26:37
Even our babysitter told the same story to other kids. It was practically a local folktale.
00:26:42
Cut to 15 years later. I had moved from Connecticut to Oregon, and I was working as a barista while attending community college and generally trying to figure my life out.
00:26:51
That's literally what figuring your life out in the 20s looks like. Yeah, I've seen it.
00:26:54
I started working with an amazing woman and we instantly connected. We became fast friends and she introduced me to her family who made me feel like I was back home.
00:27:03
They were warm and loud and wonderful. We quickly found out why we were so connected.
00:27:08
My mom and her mom grew up together in Connecticut. Holy shit. They even double dated at senior prom when my mom was dating my dad.
00:27:17
Wow. Crazy. Yeah. After high school, her mom moved to California and eventually Oregon, which brings us to when I met them.
00:27:24
After about a year of meeting her and her family, I met her brother. He had recently moved home after serving as a Marine.
00:27:31
At first, we were both dating other people, but there was something between us. Our paths kept crossing, and eventually we started seeing each other.
00:27:39
There was something about this guy. He was kind, generous, and funny as hell. One day, we were lying around swapping childhood stories, and he started telling me about this accident he had when he was a kid.
00:27:50
He and his sisters were playing carnival and were cutting up tickets. they had left a pair of those huge steel scissors on his bed later he was jumping from bed to bed
00:27:59
and he fell and then then this is written as him talking they punctured my lung and nicked my heart
00:28:05
he said casually wait what he lifted his shirt and showed me the two scars after the accident he somehow managed to walk into the kitchen looked at his mom and said hey mom before collapsing
00:28:17
His mom threw him and his sisters into the station wagon and hauled ass to the hospital.
00:28:22
He arrived near death and spent six months in the ICU. Oh, my God. We were dating for a little over a year before I brought him back home to Connecticut to meet my family.
00:28:32
I told my siblings the story of the scissors and my brother exclaimed, you're dating an urban legend.
00:28:40
We've been together 25 years. Oh, my God. Have two amazing daughters and we're celebrating our 20th wedding anniversary this month.
00:28:47
Says, I love you, Billy Brown. That's why she wrote it in. It's their 20th anniversary.
00:28:54
I love you, Billy Brown. And I'm so glad you survived your injuries 40 something years ago.
00:29:00
Stay sexy and don't let your kids play with scissors. LB. And it says, P.S. I grew up going to Action Park every summer and definitely have a few more
00:29:08
near-death experiences to share. Stay tuned. Oh, my God. That is so cute. Oh, I love you,
00:29:15
Billy Brown. I love you, Billy. That's the cutest thing of all time. Tell us your urban legend town
00:29:21
stories. But also, I think it's really important. My favorite murder at Gmail. Tell us the one
00:29:26
thing that you did as a kid that they would say is the first time something is wrong with you.
00:29:30
Yes. And also, it should probably be something you still feel bad about to this day, which is the proof that you're not a serial killer.
00:29:37
Feel bad about or embarrassed about. I like embarrassed or like, wow, who was that?
00:29:42
Or, hey, tell us the story about your kid and what they do to my favorite murder at Gmail.
00:29:47
Narco and your children here on this podcast. Could be anonymous. That's true. Was that it?
00:29:51
That's it, I think. That was fast. Yeah. Well, you know, we've got all kinds of categories for you to write in and tell us your personal stories.
00:29:59
Yes, please do. We appreciate it so much. And, you know, if you just love Billy Brown and you want to write in about it, we'd love to hear about that, too.
00:30:06
Sure, why not? Say sexy. And don't get murdered. Goodbye. Elvis, do you want a cookie?
00:30:11
Ah! This has been an Exactly Right production Our senior producers are Alejandra Keck and Molly Smith
00:30:23
Our editor is Aristotle Acevedo. This episode was mixed by Liana Squalachi. Email your hometowns to myfavoritemurder at gmail.com.
00:30:30
And follow the show on Instagram at myfavoritemurder. Listen to My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio app,
00:30:35
Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. And now you can watch us on Exactly Right's YouTube page.
00:30:40
And while you're there, please like and subscribe. Goodbye. VitalFarms.com slash farm.
00:31:14
Look for the black carton in the egg aisle and visit VitalFarms.com to learn more.
00:31:18
Vital Farms, good eggs, no shortcuts. Goodbye. Identity theft can cost more than you think.
00:31:24
Drained investment accounts, stolen tax returns, lost wages, expenses for lawyers.
00:31:29
It's a lot. That's why LifeLock is backed by the Million Dollar Protection Package, which covers up
00:31:34
to $1 million each for stolen funds, fees for experts and lawyers, and out-of-pocket expenses.
00:31:40
don't face the burden of identity theft alone protect your future and finances with lifelock
00:31:45
join now and save up to 30 percent your first year at lifelock.com slash iheart terms apply
00:31:51
you're locked into a lot of things you can't change weather traffic hey stay in your lane
00:31:56
your wireless carrier's latest price hike but you can unlock a better way unlock the savings
00:32:01
at boost mobile and save up to 600 a year switch to the 25 a month unlimited wireless plan no
00:32:07
contracts, no price hikes, and you keep your phone. Stop being locked into their games.
00:32:11
Unlock the savings at boostmobile.com slash unlock. Based on average annual single line
00:32:15
of payment of AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile customers, compared to 12 months on the Boost
00:32:18
Mobile Unlimited Wireless plan as of January, 2026. For full offer details, visit boostmobile.com.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most chaotic
  • 70
    Most shocking
  • 70
    Funniest
  • 70
    Biggest twist

Episode Highlights

  • Dr. Death the Cowboy
    A charming neurosurgeon becomes a figure of trust, but his actions lead to tragedy.
    “He promised to heal them. Instead, he left a trail of broken bodies.”
    @ 00m 48s
    September 22, 2025
  • Sorority Stalker
    A campus stalker terrorizes a sorority with ominous messages and threats.
    “It's not safe out there tonight, Kappas, and I'm not the threat, but harm is coming.”
    @ 07m 52s
    September 22, 2025
  • Grandma's Prank
    A clever prank by a young girl puts an end to her bullying.
    “They screamed and panicked until my abuelita sat up laughing at them hysterically.”
    @ 18m 30s
    September 22, 2025
  • Bowling Spotlight Anxiety
    A hilarious recount of a delayed bowling experience filled with pressure and spotlight anxiety.
    “It was hilariously weird.”
    @ 23m 24s
    September 22, 2025
  • Childhood Guilt
    A reflection on childhood actions that lead to lasting guilt, like washing a kitten.
    “I felt guilty about it for years and years.”
    @ 25m 22s
    September 22, 2025
  • Urban Legend Love Story
    A woman discovers her boyfriend's childhood accident is a local folktale. 'You're dating an urban legend.'
    “You're dating an urban legend.”
    @ 28m 32s
    September 22, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • What a start.
    MFM Minisode 454
  • Stay sexy and don't give your 13-year-old a couple of six-packs.
    MFM Minisode 454
  • What's your personal version of hell?
    MFM Minisode 454
  • You're dating an urban legend.
    MFM Minisode 454
  • Stay sexy and don't let your kids play with scissors.
    MFM Minisode 454
  • Oh, my God. That is so cute.
    MFM Minisode 454

Key Moments

  • Goodbye00:35
  • Charming Neurosurgeon00:37
  • Sorority Stalker07:42
  • Grandma's Prank18:30
  • Superpower Question22:14
  • Road Trip Stop22:16
  • Bowling Anxiety23:11
  • Anniversary Love28:42

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown