Search Captions & Ask AI

MFM Minisode 457

October 13, 2025 /

This episode of My Favorite Murder features stories about unexpected encounters, childhood mishaps, and the humorous side of family dynamics. Hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark share listener-submitted tales that highlight the quirks of life.

One story recounts a woman who accidentally took a neighbor's child, leading to a police response when the child went missing. The child, Jane, had wandered away from her grandmother's supervision, creating a tense but ultimately heartwarming reunion.

Another listener shares a sibling rivalry story involving a ferret and a trap set by older sisters that resulted in a fall into the basement. The humorous recounting of the incident showcases the playful yet dangerous nature of childhood antics.

A third story involves a woman who discovers a romantic connection with a man who turns out to be her cousin, linked by a flamingo figurine that belonged to his late mother. Their relationship blossoms despite the surprising familial ties.

Lastly, a listener describes a comical situation where she receives help from a cowboy, a boy scout, and a priest after a flat tire, illustrating the kindness of strangers in unexpected circumstances.

TLDR

Listeners share humorous and unexpected stories about childhood mishaps and family connections.

Episode

24:43
00:00:00
This is exactly right. Isn't some far off concept? It's already here. Next starts now.
00:00:33
Hyundai, an official partner of FIFA. Goodbye. If audiobooks are your thing, or if you've been meaning to listen to more of them,
00:00:40
you should check out a podcast called Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club, hosted by Cal Penn.
00:00:46
Each episode spotlights standout audiobooks on Audible across all kinds of genres.
00:00:51
Sci-fi, comedy, romance, thrillers, and more. With Cal talking to guests who help break down what makes each story worth listening to.
00:00:57
It's a fun, easy way to discover your next great audiobook. Check out Earsay on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:06
Goodbye. Pandora Jewelry brings the sparkle to summer, now with even better prices.
00:01:11
Shop now for up to 50% off select jewelry featuring personalized pieces to must-have summer favorites.
00:01:17
Timeless jewelry made to move with you through every moment. Shop in-store or online now through July 5th.
00:01:22
Terms and conditions apply. See pandora.net for more details. Goodbye. Goodbye. New beginnings are exciting, especially when they come with four wheels.
00:01:31
If you're shopping for your next car, start your search with Cars.com. Cars.com has the tools and expert advice to help you find exactly what you're looking for.
00:01:39
With more than 2 million new and used vehicles nationwide, it's easy to search, compare, and find the right fit for you.
00:01:45
Cars.com is there when you're dreaming, planning, or ready to embrace the new. Start your search with Cars.com.
00:01:51
Where to next? Goodbye. My favorite murder Hello! And welcome to my favorite murder.
00:02:15
The minisode. It's just a little gal. It's a secret little whisper minisode. Yeah, it'll be fun.
00:02:22
It'll be all ASMR this whole time. We promised. it's just me screaming i'm first yeah okay this one's long but it's fucking worth it okay i'm not
00:02:32
gonna read you the title hi ladies i was listening to minisode 450 and something about the lovely
00:02:37
lithuanian woman's story made me think it was time to write in do you remember that one where
00:02:42
the little girl like went on a day trip with the drug dealing lithuanian woman in a small town
00:02:47
yeah okay place it's not maybury but you can see it from here time the banging on pots and pan
00:02:55
stage of COVID. Names changed to protect the innocent. We had just bought the worst house
00:03:01
in the nicest neighborhood, and we were in the process of a full remodel. It being COVID,
00:03:06
we decided to take our golden retriever on a long walk by the creek in order to socially
00:03:10
distance ourselves from our plumber, John, who was working on the upstairs bathroom.
00:03:15
Since we live in a northern climate, the first nice day of the year, could be March, could be
00:03:19
July, everybody throws open their windows and doors. We did just that and set off. We had the
00:03:24
loveliest time by the creek and then headed home and entered on the bottom floor to give John his
00:03:28
space upstairs. Almost immediately, we heard childlike giggling above us. My husband quizzically
00:03:34
looked at me. I shrugged and I said, I assume John's wife dropped off his daughter so she can
00:03:38
run errands or something. A little blonde haired blue eyed cherub suddenly appeared and started
00:03:43
cooing and petting our dog. I, being a team player, scooped her up and took her and her new furry
00:03:49
best friend outside to play. When we had our fill of the sun, we came inside for a snack and some
00:03:54
cartoons, which led to a nice midday nap on the couch. At this point, John was about done with
00:03:59
the bathroom, so he called for me to take a look. I picked up his daughter and headed upstairs.
00:04:04
When we finished talking business, I asked John how old his daughter was. He looked at me
00:04:08
questioningly and told me that that little girl I was holding wasn't his daughter. I threw my head
00:04:14
back and laughed. Then very emphatically, he said to me, Cassie, she's blonde. John, well, he isn't.
00:04:23
We on the other hand, well, we are. I replied or shrieked. So who is she? John shrieked back. I
00:04:31
don't know. I assumed she was your niece. John, I'm about to call the cops. So you need to tell
00:04:36
me one last time that you're not kidding before I make a false report. Cassie, call 911. I called
00:04:43
911 holding onto this innocent kidnapped child for dear life. Oh my God. As soon as the operator
00:04:49
came on the line, I verbal vomited. Um, this is going to sound weird. I have no idea how this
00:04:53
happened. Um, you see, I have a little girl and at that it was time for the operator to shriek.
00:04:58
What does she look like? I gave her a description and she yelled to whoever was in the room with her.
00:05:02
We found her. We found Jane. Oh, she asked for my address and told me she was sending an officer
00:05:11
to come get the little girl. Remember the place? Mayberry adjacent? Yeah, nothing much happens
00:05:16
around here. They didn't send a police officer. They sent the three squad cars and the six cops
00:05:22
we have in town. And they followed all the protocols. All exits were blocked on either
00:05:27
side of our house. The lights were flashing and cops were in our driveway with their hands on
00:05:31
their hips. I come out with little Jane and hand her to the first officer. My brand new neighbors
00:05:37
were looking on, undoubtedly muttering, there goes the neighborhood. Turns out Jane toddled
00:05:43
out of her backyard and ended up at our house a couple blocks away while her grandmother turned
00:05:48
her back for a split second. They were searching for Jane in the opposite direction in a different
00:05:53
neighborhood the entire time we were playing with the dog having snacks and taking a nap So scary After I been interviewed by the cops Jane dad arrived to reunite with his daughter They thought she got fucking kidnapped
00:06:06
Yeah, she did. Yeah. To reunite with his daughter and walk her the couple blocks home.
00:06:11
Jane started crying. She didn't want to leave her new furry best friend behind. Her dad asked me if I and our golden wouldn't mind walking them home.
00:06:19
So we did. I hope beyond all hope that Jane's grandmother forgives me for the prolonged panic I caused her.
00:06:26
And as Jane grows up, I hope she continues her lifelong exploration of the world, but only after she tells her family where she's going.
00:06:34
Stay sexy and remember what your eighth grade teacher taught you. Making assumptions makes an ass of you and me, Cassie.
00:06:41
But Cassie, that's not fair because you didn't cause anything. You are truly just the consummate host for people old and young.
00:06:53
Yeah. And you basically, for a child who probably could have been traumatized or in a lot of strife, you like kind of gave her a nice little day and then got her delivered back to her family.
00:07:03
There was no problem. No. And she also didn't throw the first stone. Like grandma lost track of her first.
00:07:10
Grandma turned that back. You know, that's why my parents moved out of San Francisco.
00:07:13
This exact same thing happened with my mom and dad. And when my sister was like two years old, she just walked out the front yard and she basically walked into the yard of the next door neighbor and started talking to the old lady that lived next door.
00:07:27
And meanwhile, my parents are running all over. They think my sister has been stolen out of the front yard.
00:07:32
And they were like, we got to get out of San Francisco. Oh, man. You would have had such a cooler childhood in life if your sister hadn't fucking.
00:07:39
I'd still be smoking clothes right now. Damn it. Okay, here's my first one. I'm not going to read you the subject line. It says,
00:07:47
Hello, Karen, Georgia, Pets, and the entire MFM crew. I'm actually the mayor of my small...
00:07:53
What? We have a mayor? See, I told you I didn't read these. This is news to Karen.
00:08:01
We have a mayor. We have a mayor. I'm actually, capital M, I'm actually the mayor of my small
00:08:07
hometown in Idaho and have always felt it was my duty to represent my constituents with an epic
00:08:13
hometown story. But alas, I live in real life Mayberry from the Andy Griffith Show. Yeah. But
00:08:19
then I heard your requests for stories where siblings almost killed each other and I knew I
00:08:23
had my tale to tell. My dad grew up in the same small town I live in now. He was one of four
00:08:29
brothers all close in age. This was Idaho in the 60s when things were even more loosey-goosey than
00:08:34
they are currently. And I grew up hearing tales of the brothers' fights and escapades, chasing wild
00:08:40
Mustangs in the desert of southern Idaho, racing cars. There's even still a bullet lodged in the
00:08:46
wall of my grandparents' basement from an argument gone wrong. Yeah. My poor grandma tried to
00:08:52
discipline the wild boys by swinging her broom around, but nothing really stuck.
00:08:58
One day, my dad, who was one of the younger boys, picked a fight with one of his older siblings.
00:09:02
I'm not sure what started it, but I can tell you how it ended. My dad stuck his tongue out at his
00:09:07
brother and was shot with a BB gun right in the tongue. Oh, ouch. Oh, the BB was lodged too deep to easily get it out.
00:09:18
And the boys were, and the boys were too scared of my broom wielding grandma to tell anyone.
00:09:24
So my poor dad was sworn to secrecy and had to suffer through very painful dinners for a week or so until his tongue grew over the BB.
00:09:35
I am. I am I'm speechless. Hold on because here's the next sentence. It's still in his tongue to this
00:09:43
day. What the fuck? He says he has a tongue piercing. Right. Exactly. Like a tongue implant.
00:09:51
He has no problem getting through airport security, but it does really hurt when he
00:09:55
accidentally bites down on it. Oh, thank you for your entertaining podcast that I listen to
00:10:00
in earbuds on walks all around my small town to get my steps. You too. It's so funny.
00:10:06
You two are always so real and I appreciate the laughs. Also, shout out to my cousin, Rhonda, who was also a murderino and whose father shot a small piece of lead into my father for eternity.
00:10:18
So basically, Rhonda's dad is the is the culprit. I love it. Stay sexy and maybe tell someone when you've been shot.
00:10:25
Rebecca, she, her. It could have gotten infected and fallen out of his mouth. I mean, the levels of the levels, because I think they're kind of right in the way where you should.
00:10:36
your brother in the face, in the mouth, you would be in so much trouble for so long.
00:10:42
Yeah. And you know, what's crazy is that the brother, the dad who had it happen,
00:10:45
like didn't rat on him. He's like, I will take this because I know I don't want to see you get
00:10:51
in that much trouble. Yes. And you were right. I fucking stuck my tongue out at you. I shouldn't
00:10:55
have fucking done that. I bet you the older brothers that were older than the one that shot
00:10:58
him, Rhonda's dad, I'd like to call him. They were like, you have to keep your mouth shut. He will do
00:11:04
your dishes. He will do anything you want. I bet you they bribe the living shit out of him.
00:11:09
Definitely. Definitely. Also, again, I just want to underline that we just got an email from the
00:11:16
mayor of a small town in Idaho, a woman. And I would just like to also say I just saw TikTok
00:11:23
about how women need to start getting involved in politics on the local level. That's the way
00:11:28
to affect change. So thank you, Rebecca, because you're doing it. Thank you. Fuck, I'm just tickled by that, that we have a mayor.
00:11:35
It's so cool. Yeah. Someday we'll find out what the town is. Yeah. Maybe she should be the mayor of my favorite murder, too.
00:11:42
Yeah, get in here. If you spend all day waiting to take your bra off, it might be time for Third Love.
00:11:50
If you're looking for breathable, lightweight comfort this summer, you're gonna love Third Love.
00:11:54
Third Love is built around getting the fit right instead of expecting you to put up with something that doesn work And Third Love offers a full range of sizes from AA to H including their exclusive half cup sizes so you can find a fit that feels just right instead of close enough
00:12:08
Stop settling for bad bras. Whether you're looking for more lift, back smoothing, or straps
00:12:13
that stay put, Third Love can find your fit fast. Their virtual fitting room gets you in the right
00:12:18
size and matches you with the best styles for your shape. If you've ever been fitted for the
00:12:22
right size bra, you are in for a treat. It actually changes the whole game with bras. I thought I was
00:12:28
like a something, something A cup. I'm a something, something B cup. And it's just changed my bra
00:12:33
game. I thought I just hated bras, but I was wearing the wrong size. And with Third Love,
00:12:37
like they're so comfortable that it doesn't even feel like I'm wearing a bra. Use code MFM15 for $15 off your first purchase at thirdlove.com.
00:12:46
Goodbye. Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same premium wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying.
00:12:56
It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today.
00:13:03
I'm told it's super easy to do at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three month plan equivalent to $15 per month required.
00:13:12
Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra.
00:13:16
See full terms at mintmobile.com. You're locked into a lot of things you can't change.
00:13:20
weather, traffic. Hey, stay in your lane. Your wireless carrier's latest price hike,
00:13:25
but you can unlock a better way. Unlock the savings at Boost Mobile and save up to $600 a year.
00:13:30
Switch to the $25 a month unlimited wireless plan. No contracts, no price hikes, and you keep your
00:13:35
phone. Stop being locked into their games. Unlock the savings at BoostMobile.com slash unlock.
00:13:40
Based on average annual single line of payment of AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile customers compared
00:13:43
to 12 months on the Boost Mobile unlimited wireless plan as of January, 2026. For full
00:13:47
offer details, visit BoostMobile.com. Okay, this is also a sibling trying to kill siblings.
00:13:53
Okay, great. My sister tried to kill me. Hi, Karen, Georgia, and whiskered associates, including Stephen.
00:13:58
Yay. So I'm the youngest of three girls. There's five and eight years between them and me.
00:14:03
When I was about nine or 10, my eldest sister had a ferret that she wouldn't let me play with.
00:14:08
So, of course, I would sneak in her room when she wasn't home to look at the smelly creature.
00:14:13
I'm sorry. It's so greedy. It's like the ferret has nothing but love to give. And you're just going to be like, no, your sister can't see it or touch it.
00:14:20
Yeah, leave it alone. It's in the cage by itself. So leave it alone. So mean. Depressed in the cage.
00:14:26
Okay. One day after school, it appeared to me as if I beat my sister home. So I took the opportunity to go see the ferret.
00:14:32
Little did I know my sisters had removed the giant vent cover in her floor in front of the cage and replaced it with a carpet covered with clothes like Wile E. Coyote, like a Wile E. Coyote Acme trap.
00:14:44
they set a fucking trap for their sister dude they utilized the pre-existing hole in the floor
00:14:52
that's right the heating vent brilliant oh you can guess what happened next yep when i stepped
00:14:59
in front of the cage i fell through the hole and plummeted all the way down to the all caps
00:15:04
basement holy shit bouncing off a shelf in the process she could have fucking cracked her head
00:15:11
She could have absolutely died for just for wanting the love of a ferret. I mean, she didn't.
00:15:16
And so that's hilarious. Thankfully, I landed on a pile of clothes they had placed beneath the trap.
00:15:21
So at least they like, you know, they were total assholes. They planned ahead. They planned ahead.
00:15:26
Yes. Yes. I wasn't hurt except for my pride and having the breath knocked out of me.
00:15:32
My ass. She could have got a fucking concussion, like a full story. Or did you say into the basement?
00:15:37
Yes. From one story to the basement. I mean, just so dangerous. So dangerous. My asshole sisters were hiding in the basement laughing that their plan had worked.
00:15:47
My mom didn't find it so funny. Oh, no. No. I've since introduced one of my sisters to your show and she is now a murderino.
00:15:55
So, Jamie, if you're listening, you know what you did was fucking wrong. LOL. Are you reading the email?
00:16:02
Are you saying that yourself? It's the email. So, Jamie, if you're listening, you know what you did was fucking wrong.
00:16:08
LOL. My husband and I drove five hours from Delaware to see you guys in Pittsburgh,
00:16:13
and it was amazing. I hope the person in the balcony was okay. What happened in the balcony?
00:16:17
They had a seizure, I think. Oh, that's right. Oh, my God. I love that Pittsburgh show.
00:16:22
Yeah. Stay sexy and don't sneak into your sister's room. Love, Kira. I don't know if that's the lesson here.
00:16:30
Yeah, I don't. Yeah, Kira, that's very little sister of you to take that upon yourself,
00:16:35
that it's your lesson to learn. Totally. How about don't be so goddamn greedy with your ferret?
00:16:40
Yeah. How about that? Let's go to the beginning. How about there's plenty to go around with that ferret?
00:16:45
Oh, man, that's so good. People get this. People get after 10 years, people are really getting the point of the mini-sode.
00:16:53
Yeah, totally. Good job. And you know what, Jamie? Good job for you, too. Yeah. Thank you, Jamie, for the story.
00:16:58
Yeah. You have to do asshole things to get good emails for the future. So, OK. Yeah. The subject line of this email is, you didn't ask for this, but you're getting it anyway.
00:17:08
And it just starts, I recently got my dream job as a librarian in a small private school.
00:17:13
I get to read with kids and help them grow into competent, confident adults, unlike myself.
00:17:19
And then parentheses, it says, JK, I'm usually pretty competent. It says, today was the first day of school and I wanted to make a good first impression.
00:17:27
So I decided I would show up 15 minutes before school started. I've never worked in a school before, and no one told me that teachers and everybody show up way earlier than that.
00:17:37
I think I knew that, and I have never worked in a school as a lunch lady, and I knew that.
00:17:44
But you had to get there around lunch-ish, 11.30? Well, it was breakfast and lunch.
00:17:49
Did you wear a hairnet? No, but I wore gloves, like little plastic gloves. Good, good.
00:17:52
Okay. Okay so it says I pull into the parking lot I am then shepherded against my will into the drop line This was a long line and I really couldn cut out across the parking lot and risk running over any of my new students
00:18:09
I realized I would have to stay in the drop-off line and drive past nearly every single one of my new colleagues as they were standing outside to greet the students.
00:18:17
Why didn't any—someone should have said something. Right. Have you ever been in a drop-off line?
00:18:23
thank god no because i i had to go pick up nora at our old grammar school one day and there was a
00:18:30
whole my sister like had to explain it to me and she's like and you have to get there on time you
00:18:34
have to karen and i was like okay as if that's possible but people get there early and then
00:18:39
you're just locked into a single lane that they have blocked off on streets and everybody it's
00:18:46
like this pre-agreed thing where like no one else goes down those streets and they and you no one
00:18:50
honks and you just fucking i have never been in a drop-off line but i have a fear of them still
00:18:56
yeah like i understand that they are just like terrifying to everyone they become their own
00:19:01
weird machine and you have to know how the machine works so if you're the artsy aunt
00:19:06
from outside you better fucking but you better watch your what you watch your watch okay you
00:19:13
honk okay go ahead okay so it's so great too i'm just thinking because i my sister just started
00:19:18
school again, too. So it's like day three of basically her teaching kindergartners how to go
00:19:24
to school. And she's like, it's so hilarious. It's just like every year it starts over and you're
00:19:29
like, how do we do any of this? How do public schools function? It's insane. So, okay. So she
00:19:37
says, so here I am more than 20 minutes late by the time I pull up in front of the school
00:19:42
and stuck in this long ass line. I slowly inched past each one of the teachers and eventually the
00:19:47
assistant principal and the principal, who are literally doubled over in laughter.
00:19:53
Oh, good. Yeah, thank God. I was later politely informed that I should have arrived much earlier, which I had, of
00:19:58
course, already realized by then. I made a dozen more embarrassing mistakes today.
00:20:03
Oh, this was a day of email. Wow, that's right. Yes, reporting hot off the presses.
00:20:08
I made a dozen more embarrassing mistakes today, but I learned a lot, and tomorrow will be
00:20:12
better. The students were great. I was counting down the days until a kid told me something wild and it happened in my very first class.
00:20:19
In parentheses, it says a very happy and excited girl. Guess what? My grandpa got sick and he's in the hospital and he died.
00:20:28
Guess what? Guess what? That's what this whole podcast is. Yeah, seriously. Thanks for reading if you do.
00:20:34
And if any of my new co-workers are listening, feel free to stop by the library and make fun of me.
00:20:39
SSDGMK. Oh, you can feel Kay's like happiness and excitement. I mean, you got to love those people who are like, that's a good teacher because that's
00:20:48
a person who understands you are going to make mistakes and you are going to do better
00:20:52
the next day. I love that. Yeah, it's nice. If you spend all day waiting to take your bra off, it might be time for third love.
00:21:01
If you're looking for breathable, lightweight comfort this summer, you're going to love
00:21:05
third love. Third love is built around getting the fit right instead of expecting you to put up with
00:21:09
something that doesn't work. And Third Love offers a full range of sizes from AA to H, including their exclusive half cup sizes, so you can find a fit that feels just right instead of close enough.
00:21:20
Stop settling for bad bras. Whether you're looking for more lift, back smoothing, or straps that stay put, Third Love can find your fit fast.
00:21:28
Their virtual fitting room gets you in the right size and matches you with the best styles for your shape.
00:21:32
If you've ever been fitted for the right size bra, you are in for a treat. It actually changes the whole game with bras.
00:21:38
I thought I was like a something, something A cup. I'm a something, something B cup.
00:21:43
And it's just changed my bra game. I thought I just hated bras, but I was wearing the wrong size.
00:21:48
And with Third Love, like they're so comfortable that it doesn't even feel like I'm wearing a bra.
00:21:52
Use code MFM15 for $15 off your first purchase at thirdlove.com. Goodbye. Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile.
00:22:01
I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same premium wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying.
00:22:07
It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today.
00:22:14
I'm told it's super easy to do at MintMobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three month plan equivalent to $15 per month required.
00:22:23
Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. Default terms at MintMobile.com.
00:22:29
Unlock the savings at Boost Mobile and save up to $600 a year. I've been scouting these big carriers for a minute now, and I've seen them pull the same play a thousand times.
00:22:38
They promise you the world, then hit you with a price hike right when the game gets tight.
00:22:42
But Boost Mobile, their $25 a month unlimited wireless plan is the most consistent player on the floor.
00:22:47
No contracts, no price hikes. Unlock the savings today at BoostMobile.com slash unlock.
00:22:53
Based on average annual single line payment of AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile customers,
00:22:55
compared to 12 months of the Boost Mobile unlimited wireless plan as of January 2026.
00:22:58
For full offer details, visit BoostMobile.com. okay my last one is called the flamingo ghost question mark hello amazing ladies pets and
00:23:08
people i am anxious so let's just get into it i was listening to a minisode recently and you had
00:23:14
asked about meant to be stories so here's mine after a breakup and living on my own for almost
00:23:19
10 years i moved back to my parents house i am so thankful for my amazing parents they are truly
00:23:25
two of the most selfless, wonderful people out there. Yeah, I know. Lucky, lucky.
00:23:30
Sounds great. They made it easy for an almost 30-year-old to live at home. After a year of living at home, I was ready to start dating again.
00:23:37
I'm on the apps, just letting whatever come my way. I start messaging with this guy, James.
00:23:42
He was so nice and quick to ask me on a date, which I've actually, that's a positive, right?
00:23:46
It's like, let's not talk for fucking three weeks until you ask me out. Yeah. Don't waste my fucking time, essentially.
00:23:52
Yeah. First thing he says on the date is he forgot his first cousin is from my hometown.
00:23:57
I asked him their name. It was one of my close friends. in high school and our families are still friendly and see each other. That just put me at ease
00:24:04
knowing he wasn't a complete stranger and I'm safe on this date. The date goes amazingly. We
00:24:09
talked the entire time and I really hope we go out again. I could go on about how great he is,
00:24:14
but I will try to keep this short. Initially, I was like, they're going to be related. I bet.
00:24:18
Yeah, they're not. Spoiler. We fall in love and then we get the blood test. We're also cousins.
00:24:25
When I get home, I told my parents about the date and how he was my old friend's cousin. We
00:24:29
had actually met once at a birthday party. My mom puts the pieces together and realized she has
00:24:34
something of his late mother's. She goes on to explain that after James's mother had passed the
00:24:40
year before due to her long battle with cancer and cancer-related illnesses, her family was giving
00:24:46
some of her belongings to loved ones. One of the items given to James's aunt, his mom's sister,
00:24:52
was a flamingo figurine. Auntie has many things of her sister's and feels like the flamingo
00:24:57
figurine deserves a home with someone who will love it. That home being my mother's. Everyone
00:25:03
that knows my mother knows she loves flamingos. Aren't flamingos a sign of swingers? Or the
00:25:09
pineapple? Pineapple I've heard. And I think it's like an upside down pineapple. Right. Something
00:25:14
like that. Because, you know, my welcome mat in my front door has a pineapple on it. Karen,
00:25:19
that's like inviting swingers. When people go on cruises, they put a fucking like a picture or a
00:25:24
of a pineapple on their door to let everyone know to knock. I didn't know, but that's why my
00:25:30
doorbell's going off night and day. That's it. Oh my God. Okay, I'm ruining this. At a bridal
00:25:35
shower for a mutual friend that my mother and I attended, James's aunt gives my mother this
00:25:39
flamingo. She loves it. She puts it in her bathroom. I never tell James this because in my
00:25:44
head, it just sounds weird. Hey, I know we just went on a first date, but my mom was given something
00:25:48
that belonged to your deceased mom. Hope we can hang out again. Yeah, don't bring that up.
00:25:52
I'll keep that to myself for a while. A few months down the road and we're dating and it's time for
00:25:57
James to meet my parents. He comes over to our home and things are going very well. After using
00:26:02
the bathroom he comes out laughing and says to my family that is so strange I bought my mom a flamingo that looks just like that one Jaws drop Oh shit Not only was that flamingo his mom he bought it for her Oh my God Meant to be
00:26:17
We think so. Cut to three years later, James and I are now engaged and are getting married in November 2026.
00:26:24
Our families always say that his mom, Joanne, saw me and picked me out for her son.
00:26:29
I truly wish I could have met Joanne. I know she was spunky, had a huge heart, and was an extremely strong woman.
00:26:35
And I am honored that she chose me for her son. I cannot wait to see you at your late show in Boston.
00:26:42
Thank you for fostering everyone's love of true crime and giving out more knowledge on sobriety and therapy.
00:26:47
Stay sexy and don't get murdered. Angelica, Rhode Island. God, Angelica, that is wait.
00:26:53
So James now knows. When did they tell James? I think when he came out of the bathroom, they were like, oh, yeah, your mom had one exactly like that because that belonged to your mom.
00:27:02
Because it's hers. God. And also just like, you know, me and my story about the bell that my sister found, a little lady that's shaped like a bell.
00:27:11
Like, that's the kind of thing where it's like, it seems small and no big deal, but it truly is like, oh, my God, this beautiful connection.
00:27:19
Everything means something. Yeah. Or nothing means anything sometimes. I mean, I think it changes.
00:27:24
It switches back and forth. One more? Depending on the week. Yeah, I got one more.
00:27:29
And the subject line of this email says, Humanity isn't all lost. light-hearted. It says, Hi, ladies. Love you. Love what you do. Thank you. And please give your
00:27:39
critters a snuggle for me. I was leaving a small town where my family reunion is hosted every other
00:27:44
year. 100 plus Czech family members, 2.3 kegs of beer are floated by 3 p.m. when all the good kids
00:27:53
go to church, half drunk, and I go take a nap and then continue to party at my uncle's house.
00:27:58
Needless to say, I was tired. I'm almost to the interstate and my tire goes from full to
00:28:03
flat in the blink of an eye. Thankfully, I was able to roll into a gas station and call an uncle
00:28:08
to come and help. My uncle's on the way and I start trying to get the spare out from under my
00:28:12
truck. It's not going well. And overwalks a cowboy. I'm in my early 20s and exercise my
00:28:18
newfound ability from living in a major city for two years to say no thank you sir I just fine on my own and my uncle on his way And shut Mr Cowboy down Cool Independent Failing
00:28:30
at getting this tire out, but still trying. Then comes a Boy Scout. Once again, this independent
00:28:36
big city woman shuts him down and sends him away. A Boy Scout. Then, I kid you not, a priest,
00:28:43
caller and all comes over to ask if I was okay. Isn't all the same person? Just like changing outfits?
00:28:50
Just going behind the gas station, coming back out. At this point, I'm just laughing because this feels like I'm in the middle of a joke where
00:28:57
a cowboy, a boy scout, and a priest walk into a gas station and try to help this stupid,
00:29:01
stubborn woman. My uncle showed up about then and changed my tire, and I went off smiling.
00:29:06
That yes, sometimes life is a joke, but sometimes life reminds you that there is goodness in
00:29:11
the world, no matter how hard you try to shut it out. Stay sexy and try to see the good in the world.
00:29:16
Megan, she, her. P.S. I might have gotten the order wrong, but the characters are accurate.
00:29:22
A cowboy, a boy scout, and a priest. That's adorable. I would have let the cowboy help me.
00:29:29
Hell yes. Right? Yes. Let the cowboy help you. Then go to the bar with the cowboy that he will invite you to after he does that.
00:29:39
Make out with the cowboy. Make out with that cowboy. Yes. all right that was a good one thank you guys for sending your stories in have you made out with a
00:29:47
cowboy let us know yes any cowboy makeouts in detail did you go to the rodeo last year and
00:29:54
make out with a cowboy we'd love to hear about it yeah thanks for your emails stay sexy and don't
00:29:59
get murdered goodbye elvis do you want a cookie This has been an Exactly Right production.
00:30:13
Our senior producers are Alejandra Keck and Molly Smith. Our editor is Aristotle Acevedo.
00:30:18
This episode was mixed by Liana Squalachi. Email your hometowns to myfavoritemurder at gmail.com.
00:30:23
And follow the show on Instagram at myfavoritemurder. Listen to My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:30:30
And now you can watch us on Exactly Right YouTube page and while you there please like and subscribe goodbye running a business shouldn feel like surviving a software group project
00:30:46
one app for accounting another for inventory another for sales and somehow none of them talk
00:30:52
to each other that's where odoo comes in an all-in-one business management software that
00:30:57
brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing,
00:31:03
all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs. And best of all,
00:31:10
no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system.
00:31:16
Try for free today at odoo.com slash iHeartRadio. That's odoo.com slash iHeartRadio.
00:31:24
Here's the truth. You could literally be adored by everyone and then come home and still get completely ignored by your own cat.
00:31:31
It's classic cat behavior. But new Sheba Premium Puree is a lickable treat that changes all that.
00:31:37
They're protein-rich, made with bone broth, and have the smooth, creamy texture cats go crazy for,
00:31:42
especially when it's hand-fed. Yeah, it's more than a treat. It's a fast pass to favorite human status.
00:31:48
So feed your cat Sheba and go from totally ignored to truly adored in just 12 days.
00:31:54
guaranteed or your money back. Learn more at Shiba.com. It's called soccer. It's called football.
00:32:03
Uh, soccer. Football. Domino's best deal ever lets you get any pizza, including stuffed crust,
00:32:10
with any toppings for $9.99. We can agree on that. Yeah, fully. So, pineapple? Don't ruin it.
00:32:18
Get any pizza, including stuffed crust, with any toppings for $9.99. finally something everyone can get behind
00:32:24
and if the refs disagree that's between them and Domino's which means the only thing left to fight over
00:32:29
is who's ordering Domino's prices higher for some locations excludes XL and specialty pizzas
00:32:35
select this offer from 615 to 726 online only size availability varies by crust tank
00:32:40
max 7 toppings 6 for pan and New York style crust minimum purchase required for delivery
00:32:44
prices participation delivery area and charges may vary

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most heartwarming
  • 70
    Most shocking
  • 70
    Funniest
  • 70
    Biggest twist

Episode Highlights

  • Earsay Podcast
    Discover standout audiobooks with Cal Penn on Earsay, your next great listen awaits!
    “It's a fun, easy way to discover your next great audiobook.”
    @ 00m 57s
    October 13, 2025
  • Pandora Jewelry Sale
    Shop now for up to 50% off select jewelry pieces this summer!
    “Timeless jewelry made to move with you through every moment.”
    @ 01m 17s
    October 13, 2025
  • Cars.com for Your Next Car
    Start your search for your next car with Cars.com, where dreams meet reality.
    “Cars.com is there when you're dreaming, planning, or ready to embrace the new.”
    @ 01m 45s
    October 13, 2025
  • A Mayor's Tale
    A small-town mayor shares a wild childhood story involving sibling rivalry and BB guns.
    “My dad stuck his tongue out at his brother and was shot with a BB gun right in the tongue.”
    @ 09m 02s
    October 13, 2025
  • A Wild Day at School
    A new librarian shares her hilarious first day filled with embarrassing moments.
    “I made a dozen more embarrassing mistakes today.”
    @ 20m 03s
    October 13, 2025
  • Finding the Right Fit
    Discover how Third Love revolutionizes bra fitting with a range of sizes and styles.
    “Stop settling for bad bras.”
    @ 21m 20s
    October 13, 2025
  • A Surprising Family Connection
    A first date leads to an unexpected revelation about family ties and a flamingo figurine.
    “Spoiler: We fall in love and then we get the blood test. We're also cousins.”
    @ 24m 18s
    October 13, 2025
  • A Cowboy, a Boy Scout, and a Priest
    A humorous encounter at a gas station highlights the kindness of strangers.
    “Sometimes life is a joke, but sometimes life reminds you that there is goodness in the world.”
    @ 29m 11s
    October 13, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • Goodbye.
    MFM Minisode 457
  • Stay sexy and remember what your eighth grade teacher taught you.
    MFM Minisode 457
  • I thought I just hated bras, but I was wearing the wrong size.
    MFM Minisode 457
  • Stay sexy and don't sneak into your sister's room.
    MFM Minisode 457
  • Sometimes life reminds you that there is goodness in the world.
    MFM Minisode 457
  • Stay sexy and try to see the good in the world.
    MFM Minisode 457

Key Moments

  • Audiobook Discovery00:57
  • Summer Jewelry Sale01:17
  • Car Shopping01:45
  • Sibling Rivalry09:02
  • First Day of School20:03
  • Bra Fitting Revolution21:06
  • Unexpected Cousins24:18
  • Kindness of Strangers29:11

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown